As an American I must say I am extremely disappointed in the deadness of the audience. If SR was playing that song almost anywhere in Europe the entire crowd would dancing and singing along.
I was at this gig and the crowd was very small. The crowd that was there was very dedicated though but Coachella mainly caters to people in their twenties and as such most attendees were incredibly young when the band broke up, and as a result they hadn't heard of The Stone Roses. Even when they were popular they didn't make much of a splash over here. Sometimes that just happens. Kudos to the Coachella organizers that decided to bill them as headliners despite the fact that they were never popular over here. There's not one major festival over here that would've paid them that respect, let alone booked them in the first place. So stop trashing American's for not going apeshit during this set. As far as bands go this was by far the best sounding band I heard all weekend. The main stage a Coachella has one of the best sound systems out there and they lifted the band up to the next level. They were absolutely spot on and completely blew me away.....but Ian Brown sounded really bad. I know he was never a fantastic vocalist to begin with, but this was the worst I've ever heard him. Still, it wasn't enough to take away from how good the set was as a whole. I really hope the poor attendance for their sets at Coachella doesn't discourage them from ever coming back here, because they have a lot of dedicated fans here and I imagine they could have a pretty successful tour in the US if they played in some 2000-3000 person venues.
Interesting, my friend said he was going to see them and was really stoked to finally see them after all these years. I didn't have the heart to tell him that they were going to be shit live because... Ian Brown. He came back from the festival quite disappointed at how bad they were. He said Blur completely blew them away.
I agree the crowd does not realize the glorious performance they are seeing but at the same time thank God these guys even got back together to do this performance.
You don't have to sing well to be a good singer eg: Bob Dylan, Leonard Cohen, Johnny Cash etc,,,,,.....I agree that in Ian's case, as in the singers I mentioned, it's about the "attitude & character" in his/their voice than the actual pitch but tbh this performance is shocking.
Music can be whatever the listener wants it to be or mean, any song can be interpreted in a million ways. The stone roses weren't perfect they were fucked up but guess what, so is this country and there for The Stone Roses fitted in just right and expressed the nations feelings in every chord they played. As above, some of arguably the best musicians throughout the decades couldn't sing or even play there instruments that well. This performance isn't great but not many bands can jump on a world wide tour after 20 years of silence.
Jack Morris Some singers can't cut it live: I understand. Your are competing with other frequencies. Brownie sounded great on L.p., even Leckie confirmed it. Bit flat here. But Brownie brought swagger.
I would've given my right arm to see them at Coachella (or anywhere for that matter)! It kills me to think of all the kids out there who wouldn't have the faintest of who the Stone Roses are and what they did for rock-n-roll. They changed my life when I was 13.
I remember staying up all night to buy tickets when they first went on sale for the Phoenix Park, Dublin gig when the Roses got back together + going absolutely crazy at the gig itself, digging every minute of it, jumping around, singing every word along with everyone else there. I see thi vid and think there's something deadly wrong in some parts of the world...
I've seen ian Brown in interviews..and to be honest, he's the roses weakest link...he's got a shocking voice..he must of thought his birthday and Christmas had come together when the other 3 musicians play...reni mani and squire are brilliant
Mani loves playing with the Roses they all do take one of them away it aint the Roses great band changed alot of things after one album always be remembered
now lets not argue with our American cousins. Unfortunately the Roses weren't promoted in the US when they first hit the scene. The second coming did ok in America but the whole "scene" was wasted. Thanks to the internet we can all enjoy this unbelievably amazing band !!! I'm seeing them in June. BRING IT ON !!
To all the people that think this was a “Bad Live Performance” - note that they do not have sound check at coachella. I would have done anything to see this live! Brilliant
You should have been there with me on the 19th June for the 4th sell out night at Man City's stadium Best gig of my life...and I've seen a lot of bands. Incredible. What's with the crowd here? Not ONE person appears to be into it. What a waste.
As an Englishman I have to agree that the British bands have led the way since the sixties. However, don't beat yourselves up over it Emma Mullins. Everyone draws their inspiration from somewhere and the early Brit bands like the Beatles and Rolling Stones were heavily influenced and born out of the American scene of the mid to late 50's. The likes of Eddie Cochran, Buddy Holly, Chuck Berry, Elvis Presley, Little Richard, Jerry Lee Lewis and others were all American and started the whole rock scene. Without them crossing over to our little island, where would we be now? So thank you America for rock n roll.
Here in Brazil, SP and Dublin/ Ireland! Come to SP you will see thr biggest fans from '80 years, since of beggining... passion for the documentary that boys shows up from Manchester!😍😘
this is the one im waiting for!!this is the one this is the one shes waiting for!!! fuck!!!!the best simple and amazing lyrics!!!!!!!!!!!! thank you ian!!!!!!!
blakefish80, Fuckin Right Man!!!! It's..? The Stone (Fuckin) Roses... Right IN Front OF YOU!!! Typical Yank "OK Whatever... Where's Gun's & Rose's!?" lol
apparently he refused to wear an in ear monitor for this show. this means it is unlikely he was able to hear what key the band were playing in. a real shame - because on the second weekend he did. and man does he sound good.
everyone bashing on american crowds. its coachella. your average american knows the crowds are shit at that festival as we openly make fun of that festival. lol.
+dna598 No, only Brown benefits from getting his copious musical fuckups cleaned up in the studio. And no, I don't want to get into a debate about Brown = "But...but...attitude, man! He's the soul of the band." Don't even want to argue that, pro or con. Just love the Roses, but not blindly. They sound great live on any decent live recording. But true, haven't been able to actually see them live-live.
+notmyspleen this is what it's all about man, Facebook is a pile of crap, this is where the real people come to talk, I spend hours on here talking about music to art to religion and politics, soon as anyone starts slagging off I'm outta there to some more interesting people.
People can't seem to get that. 'He's out of tune often.' Yeah, well there's a million in tune amazing singers that are never involved in anything of any worth. They need to get onto watching X-Factor.
Yeah, attitude can only get you so far though. Even as a roses fan, I have to admit that he sucks as a singer. He is out of tune as often as he is in tune.
trust me- I was- but I was stuck behind the 1st barriers they have set up at Coachella. It separates the crowd up into sections. For weekend 2 I made my way up around the stupid barrier walls and into the pit. The crowd for weekend 2 was much more rowdy!! Seeing these guys twice here will always be a great Coachella memory for me.
I can only imagine this crowd are stunned rigid by actually being able to watch the Stone Roses live. It's hardly The International, with everyone jumping, singing, swaying, fists in the air, sweat dripping off the ceiling. But then, these people probably weren't even born then.
I'm American. I was tempted to blow the whole weekend's entry fee just so that I could see the Roses. Unfortunately, had other obligations for my time and money.
As an American I apologize for missing this band originally. They didn't get any notice in the New England area that I know of. I sort of heard of them when I discovered the La's a couple years ago. (yeah I know .....late on that too). The Stone Roses are an " if only band". If only only they had made more than 2 albums and perhaps a little more normally spaced out. Most big groups had an lp every 12 to 18 months. That being said I think the first album is quite possibly the best album ever. Almost every song is perfect. Just the opinion of a 67 year old fart.
They couldn't legally release anything after the 1st album for 5 yesrs. It was a famous court case at the time and basically ended their career at its peak.
@@mrdarren1045 That was tough, yes. But they also had 5 years to write songs with no distractions. If they even wrote 6 decent songs a year, that would have been 30 songs - 3 albums worth of material which could have kept them going for another 6 years or so. Basically, they got lazy and let their heads drop. Such a shame...
@@brians132 but the zeitgeist was gone by then. If they hadn't had the interruption of the court case etc I think they would have been able to maybe keep it going longer. Also after 5 years the expectations were way too high to live up to. But they'll forever be remembered for that first album and the fools gold single. No sound takes me back to being 16/17 like those records... along with Voodoo Ray.
***** : No doubt I agree with that notion. I would consider myself the exception to the rule. The majority of 'yanks' don't know the art of 'chant' due to their affection for the apathetic sport known as American Football, which I can't understand (a very boring visual sport with far too many breaks). Any British or Argentine crowd are tip top when it comes to audience participation probably due to their great passion for true 'football,' which is openly manifested in concert.
+Brongaene Griffin Poor guy always looks like he's trying to solve an algebra problem in his head at the same time he's playing. Sounds great, though, but what a dichotomy between how it looks and how it sounds with him.
Saturday night at The Etihad was even better than Hearing Park! Heating Park was so special as they were back together but the Etihad was even more amazing!
We didn't deserve Oasis either, Oasis was too good when all US radio wanted was a bad of sad whiney shitty post grunge...remember...Kurt Cobain's death spawned Bush and Puddle of Mudd, and Seether.
i was expecting a big roar when Ian said THIS IS THE ONE! wow these fellows here -.- some random 3rd division football club gets more support than the stones had from this audience
It must be occasionally great to play for an audience who has no interest in your music - you can still collect your performance fee without having to really care less.
Reunió a la banda cuando le pareció para hacer varias giras y sacar una pasta y luego los volvió a dejar tirados como en los 90 cuando traía aquellos colocones encima del escenario, que bue amigo!!!
![[Pro-Shot] The Stone Roses Coachella Festival 2013 [Full webcast]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1kTeJgv7sOA/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Pro-Shot] The Stone Roses Coachella Festival 2013 [Full webcast]](/img/tr.png)
John Squire was an absolute genius....One of the best guitarists the UK ever produced!
I agree with you
Still is!! Check out the new LG JS album...freaking brilliant
Agree!!!!
The crowd acts like they don't know who is performing right in front of them.....I would have died to see them
Probably because most Americans never heard of Stone Roses for obvious reasons as their music has never made it in the states.
Freedom Of Nomad What? The festivals or Stone Roses. Are the American Festivals got Maximum security or what?
Sadly this will go down as one of the worst Roses live performances, if you watch the full set it was truly dreadful, especially when Ian was singing.
Freedom Of Nomad how many amazing, but obscure in the UK market, American bands have you never heard of?
Freedom Of Nomad American crowds are crazy. They just don't give a **** about 1980s British bands who never had a hit in the USA.
I don’t think the crowd realises the greatness in front of them
this generation doesn't know much about bands.
I was there they didn't
Right? Ian says, "This is the One" and there's a smattering of claps. I'd have been losing my freaking mind.
septics man
@@philipmoylan992Not surprised
As an American I must say I am extremely disappointed in the deadness of the audience. If SR was playing that song almost anywhere in Europe the entire crowd would dancing and singing along.
Agreed. In Europe everybody would be going absolutely batshit.
Says a lot about America ... but hey you have Taylor Swift
@@dannyx2197we don’t claim her crazy ass
This is the best Stone Roses track!
The most important thing of the world 1989: The fall of Berlin Wall and The Stone Roses! This is the One! Greetings from Mar del Plata, Argentina
The band that changed everything, One Love
I'm American and Stone Roses in 1995 was my favorite rock show I've ever seen (out of many). Such amazing talents.
I was at this gig and the crowd was very small. The crowd that was there was very dedicated though but Coachella mainly caters to people in their twenties and as such most attendees were incredibly young when the band broke up, and as a result they hadn't heard of The Stone Roses. Even when they were popular they didn't make much of a splash over here. Sometimes that just happens. Kudos to the Coachella organizers that decided to bill them as headliners despite the fact that they were never popular over here. There's not one major festival over here that would've paid them that respect, let alone booked them in the first place. So stop trashing American's for not going apeshit during this set. As far as bands go this was by far the best sounding band I heard all weekend. The main stage a Coachella has one of the best sound systems out there and they lifted the band up to the next level. They were absolutely spot on and completely blew me away.....but Ian Brown sounded really bad. I know he was never a fantastic vocalist to begin with, but this was the worst I've ever heard him. Still, it wasn't enough to take away from how good the set was as a whole. I really hope the poor attendance for their sets at Coachella doesn't discourage them from ever coming back here, because they have a lot of dedicated fans here and I imagine they could have a pretty successful tour in the US if they played in some 2000-3000 person venues.
Great comment. Very interesting. Thanks for sharing mate.
It was great to see them without 50K mouthing the guitar chords so you can't properly hear the band.
@@jamesaudiffred1140 Not many bands have a guitarist who plays in such a lyrical fashion. It’s really unusual actually
Interesting, my friend said he was going to see them and was really stoked to finally see them after all these years. I didn't have the heart to tell him that they were going to be shit live because... Ian Brown. He came back from the festival quite disappointed at how bad they were. He said Blur completely blew them away.
I agree the crowd does not realize the glorious performance they are seeing but at the same time thank God these guys even got back together to do this performance.
Anyone who moans about Ian's vocals just doesn't get it. It was never about being able to sing and it was never about being perfect.
You don't have to sing well to be a good singer eg: Bob Dylan, Leonard Cohen, Johnny Cash etc,,,,,.....I agree that in Ian's case, as in the singers I mentioned, it's about the "attitude & character" in his/their voice than the actual pitch but tbh this performance is shocking.
That's an excuse. Music is always about those things.
Music can be whatever the listener wants it to be or mean, any song can be interpreted in a million ways. The stone roses weren't perfect they were fucked up but guess what, so is this country and there for The Stone Roses fitted in just right and expressed the nations feelings in every chord they played. As above, some of arguably the best musicians throughout the decades couldn't sing or even play there instruments that well. This performance isn't great but not many bands can jump on a world wide tour after 20 years of silence.
As long as it is musical. i.e. in tune
Jack Morris Some singers can't cut it live: I understand. Your are competing with other frequencies. Brownie sounded great on L.p., even Leckie confirmed it. Bit flat here. But Brownie brought swagger.
I would've given my right arm to see them at Coachella (or anywhere for that matter)! It kills me to think of all the kids out there who wouldn't have the faintest of who the Stone Roses are and what they did for rock-n-roll. They changed my life when I was 13.
Only thing better than this is hearing it over the PA at Old Trafford Manchester 0161✌🏼
I remember staying up all night to buy tickets when they first went on sale for the Phoenix Park, Dublin gig when the Roses got back together + going absolutely crazy at the gig itself, digging every minute of it, jumping around, singing every word along with everyone else there. I see thi vid and think there's something deadly wrong in some parts of the world...
I've seen ian Brown in interviews..and to be honest, he's the roses weakest link...he's got a shocking voice..he must of thought his birthday and Christmas had come together when the other 3 musicians play...reni mani and squire are brilliant
We are United ........... #GGMU
best ryhthm section around!
Mani loves playing with the Roses they all do take one of them away it aint the Roses great band changed alot of things after one album always be remembered
Absolutely brilliant love this band thanks for uploading :)
The best drummer since keith Moon
Pete Townshend's sentiments exactly. Said Reni was the most naturally gifted he'd seen since Keith Moon.
John Bonham is the best drummer ever...
Damn right, sir!
Remi’s warm ups were legendary.
fantastic performance Ian is in great voice. Impressive. Should never of split.
This is the one is a great song , John squire My favorite guitar is a genius
This is the one I´ve been waiting for ...
Lovely! Amazing band, the four of them.
now lets not argue with our American cousins. Unfortunately the Roses weren't promoted in the US when they first hit the scene. The second coming did ok in America but the whole "scene" was wasted. Thanks to the internet we can all enjoy this unbelievably amazing band !!! I'm seeing them in June. BRING IT ON !!
A perfect song 🙏🏻
One of the best day of entiry my life! What a groovy with those boys! 😻
I love this song so much and playing on guitar is such a joy. Shame Ian really cannot sing that well XD. Oh well still the Stone Roses either way!
Well Mexico's concert was amazing and the crowd was fantastic!
To all the people that think this was a “Bad Live Performance” - note that they do not have sound check at coachella. I would have done anything to see this live! Brilliant
No one else drums like Reni.. Fucking genius.
Old Trafford... This, is the Theatre of dreams...
I hate being american sometimes, our music just sucks. I belong in Manchester man
Totally agree. British music is so much better than ours (yeah, a few exceptions, blah blah ...).
You should have been there with me on the 19th June for the 4th sell out night at Man City's stadium Best gig of my life...and I've seen a lot of bands. Incredible. What's with the crowd here? Not ONE person appears to be into it. What a waste.
As an Englishman I have to agree that the British bands have led the way since the sixties. However, don't beat yourselves up over it Emma Mullins. Everyone draws their inspiration from somewhere and the early Brit bands like the Beatles and Rolling Stones were heavily influenced and born out of the American scene of the mid to late 50's. The likes of Eddie Cochran, Buddy Holly, Chuck Berry, Elvis Presley, Little Richard, Jerry Lee Lewis and others were all American and started the whole rock scene. Without them crossing over to our little island, where would we be now? So thank you America for rock n roll.
Merry Christmas Billy what bout solo Iggy pop......
Nirvana and The Strokes
Freaking Epic performance by one of THE finest bands...what is it about that Island Nation? 😮
I love the loud verses and the quieter chorus, and Ian singing in a hushed manner.
The best 5 minutes and 37 seconds you'll ever find on you tube.
love these guys
Here in Brazil, SP and Dublin/ Ireland! Come to SP you will see thr biggest fans from '80 years, since of beggining... passion for the documentary that boys shows up from Manchester!😍😘
this is the one im waiting for!!this is the one this is the one shes waiting for!!!
fuck!!!!the best simple and amazing lyrics!!!!!!!!!!!!
thank you ian!!!!!!!
Rode a cloud of innocent feeling and understanding when I heard this song while a child
Them there yanks are like "This is NOT Bon Jovi... Abort, Abort!" 🤣
blakefish80, Fuckin Right Man!!!! It's..? The Stone (Fuckin) Roses... Right IN Front OF YOU!!! Typical Yank "OK Whatever... Where's Gun's & Rose's!?" lol
Stone Roses one of the best ever..never got to see them live..This band got the screws from their record company back in the day..
Ian was great that whole tour then the biggest showcase and he bombs, think the nerves must get him on big shows.
apparently he refused to wear an in ear monitor for this show. this means it is unlikely he was able to hear what key the band were playing in. a real shame - because on the second weekend he did. and man does he sound good.
Havent evan heard it yet and I know its excellent
IB stone Roses, LG ,RA U changed my life and help me track On 😎 💞 xx from Australia 🤘
thanks for this Christopher really enjoyed it,,squire is God,,
everyone bashing on american crowds.
its coachella. your average american knows the crowds are shit at that festival as we openly make fun of that festival. lol.
Pocos ejemplos hay de una banda que haya hecho tantas buenas canciones en tan pocos discos (2 si no me equivoco). Que buenos son!!!
crowd looks totally mesmerised
かっこよ！
ようこそ夢の劇場へ
THIS IS THE ONE!
legends that should stay in the studio.
to true....
+dna598 No, only Brown benefits from getting his copious musical fuckups cleaned up in the studio. And no, I don't want to get into a debate about Brown = "But...but...attitude, man! He's the soul of the band." Don't even want to argue that, pro or con. Just love the Roses, but not blindly. They sound great live on any decent live recording. But true, haven't been able to actually see them live-live.
no debate needed
+dna598 Thank you for restoring my faith in comments sections in general. No rancor, no dick-waving, just some people talking. Refreshing.
+notmyspleen this is what it's all about man, Facebook is a pile of crap, this is where the real people come to talk, I spend hours on here talking about music to art to religion and politics, soon as anyone starts slagging off I'm outta there to some more interesting people.
TOUGH CROWD ! We've all had em! dx
John Squire is amazing.
Awesome sauce from L.A California.
Summer music, perfect
Burn the town that i was bornnnnn!!!!
I've waited for 👌
Come play in france and you' d have a fucking well deserved audience who' d go crazy.
Love you guyz
Vocals sound fine to me
United!!!
They are the resurrection.
Ian Brown's got soul.
I'd pick that over a pro vocalist, any fucking day.
People can't seem to get that. 'He's out of tune often.' Yeah, well there's a million in tune amazing singers that are never involved in anything of any worth. They need to get onto watching X-Factor.
Yeah, attitude can only get you so far though. Even as a roses fan, I have to admit that he sucks as a singer. He is out of tune as often as he is in tune.
trust me- I was- but I was stuck behind the 1st barriers they have set up at Coachella. It separates the crowd up into sections. For weekend 2 I made my way up around the stupid barrier walls and into the pit. The crowd for weekend 2 was much more rowdy!! Seeing these guys twice here will always be a great Coachella memory for me.
What a feckin band...brilliant
Why do people like to shit on Ian’s vocals? They’re not the greatest but they’re also not horrible
I've heard wayyyy worst and nobody says chit.
Roses, One Love.
John Squire's tone is so good!
I love em
best member best song best band ever.....
I can only imagine this crowd are stunned rigid by actually being able to watch the Stone Roses live. It's hardly The International, with everyone jumping, singing, swaying, fists in the air, sweat dripping off the ceiling. But then, these people probably weren't even born then.
brilliant.
De otra Galaxia está banda
I'm American. I was tempted to blow the whole weekend's entry fee just so that I could see the Roses. Unfortunately, had other obligations for my time and money.
Una banda del carajo! Ese bajo Mani Diosssssssssssss
Crazy drum.... fucking amazing
As an American I apologize for missing this band originally. They didn't get any notice in the New England area that I know of. I sort of heard of them when I discovered the La's a couple years ago. (yeah I know .....late on that too). The Stone Roses are an " if only band". If only only they had made more than 2 albums and perhaps a little more normally spaced out. Most big groups had an lp every 12 to 18 months. That being said I think the first album is quite possibly the best album ever. Almost every song is perfect. Just the opinion of a 67 year old fart.
They couldn't legally release anything after the 1st album for 5 yesrs. It was a famous court case at the time and basically ended their career at its peak.
@@mrdarren1045
That was tough, yes. But they also had 5 years to write songs with no distractions. If they even wrote 6 decent songs a year, that would have been 30 songs - 3 albums worth of material which could have kept them going for another 6 years or so. Basically, they got lazy and let their heads drop. Such a shame...
@@brians132 but the zeitgeist was gone by then. If they hadn't had the interruption of the court case etc I think they would have been able to maybe keep it going longer. Also after 5 years the expectations were way too high to live up to. But they'll forever be remembered for that first album and the fools gold single. No sound takes me back to being 16/17 like those records... along with Voodoo Ray.
Is there any crowd worse than a Coachella one???
***** and...no excuse for a crowd this shit
***** : No doubt I agree with that notion. I would consider myself the exception to the rule. The majority of 'yanks' don't know the art of 'chant' due to their affection for the apathetic sport known as American Football, which I can't understand (a very boring visual sport with far too many breaks). Any British or Argentine crowd are tip top when it comes to audience participation probably due to their great passion for true 'football,' which is openly manifested in concert.
+John Noon yep - people who go to the Glastonbury festival (and not just the ones with their iphones) !
@@Lunatic4Bizcas Great point mate. Art of the chant - haha love it.
John Noon nope
The best
Good memories the best
Come and do some more gigs in England please. No other country appreciates you like we do. Believe the hype!
Manny is just so adorable it hurts.
+Brongaene Griffin Poor guy always looks like he's trying to solve an algebra problem in his head at the same time he's playing. Sounds great, though, but what a dichotomy between how it looks and how it sounds with him.
Deep concentration I guess,?
Perfeito!
perfect.....love them😈
This isn't the one! Saturday at Heaton Park was the ONE!! Look at that crowd like..
Saturday night at The Etihad was even better than Hearing Park!
Heating Park was so special as they were back together but the Etihad was even more amazing!
Yeah, it’s called beauty mate. You’ll understand one day.
Am seeing them at Finsbury Park in London in June!
Ian Brown ( el rey de los monos) , John shire y maní los mejores the stone roses , largA vida a los reyes del pop rock inglés !!!!
America never deserved the stone roses
We didn't deserve Oasis either, Oasis was too good when all US radio wanted was a bad of sad whiney shitty post grunge...remember...Kurt Cobain's death spawned Bush and Puddle of Mudd, and Seether.
i was expecting a big roar when Ian said THIS IS THE ONE!
wow these fellows here -.-
some random 3rd division football club gets more support than the stones had from this audience
Lemsip crowd. :). Watching THE best band in the effing universe.
fucking shit crowd the best band in the world and they just stand there
Dat opening bassline and guitar solo...
Stone Roses are too good for Coachella audiences.
But Mani Is loving it!!!!!
fans are acting like they are watchin sharknado
+rhys innes fans???
make that crowd
rhys innes lol watching Beady Eye
Reni is an amazing drummer
Best crowd in the world
Said no one ever
It must be occasionally great to play for an audience who has no interest in your music - you can still collect your performance fee without having to really care less.
rare proof ian can sing live....even if reni is holding the real notes while being a legend on drums.
Reunió a la banda cuando le pareció para hacer varias giras y sacar una pasta y luego los volvió a dejar tirados como en los 90 cuando traía aquellos colocones encima del escenario, que bue amigo!!!