I use to live just down the road from John in Manchester in the late 80's and early 90's, along from the Southern Cemetery, you'd see him walking about with his guitar over his shoulder even after they got big, and the paint shop they got their ammo from when they made their famous attack on the Revolver records owner was just round the corner in Northenden, I was at Spike Island, though I don't remember that much!, and TBH I don't remember it being that good either, it's funny how it's become an iconic gig now, I was 21 and still one of the oldest there lol, but as a Stone Roses fan back in the day you felt a massive loyalty to the band, like they were part of your family, I remember defending them to my mates and then going back home a year later and everyone was dressed like them & danced like Ian and loved them, at the time I hated that more than when everyone hated them, it seems like yesterday but another lifetime ago, and I know that doesn't make sense, but it's hard to explain, it's like a dream now, but it was the best time of my life
He used to get some stick back in the day but he always reminded me of Keith Moon as a player.. Powerful and inventive, though technically fairly simple.. ( Though a lot of Reni's grooves are deceptively intricate really.) It's good to ear them on less drugs and a better monitor system!
@@JesusHChrist-q9d Did he?! I was only about 4 when the first record came out so I wasn't aware of that. He sounds rock solid to me. Great rhythm. Holding it all together.
@@jasonmfzb I think he’s the best musician in the band, John squire is insane, like 9.8 out of 10, but reni is on a completely different level, he’s the backbone of this wonderful band
There are plenty of drummers out there who are technically 'better' than Reni, but surely there's never been any drummer who's been so instrumental in elevating the musical output of a band. The Roses without Reni would have been very good, with him they were... well, just listen.
When was guitar culture not cool? It was tough to make it big back then, but think about the last 20 years!! You can't just be a good interpreter of ideas, you need to have great ideas, and John has them in spades!!
@@swingersonian He’s referring to the Second Coming era..which is kind of true. Obviously guitars were still prominent in Grunge and Britpop…but the guitar hero/balls to the wall playing approach was seen as “uncool” in the 90’s. Squire was one of the only players embracing it.
Some have referred to Squire as the first "Non-Heavy Metal Guitar Hero," although I can think of several guys (Johnny Marr, the Edge, Billy Duffy, just to name a few) who arrived earlier. Point is, he carved out a niche where his amazing skills were able to shine through and be prominent without being in a Metal band. Then came the Led Zeppelin obsession, which I cannot fault him for one bit. It happened to me too. Many disliked that era of the Roses and Squire's playing, but as a Classic Rock fan first, and an 80s alternative Rock fan second, I thought it was amazing. As close as anyone has gotten to the mystique and majesty of Jimmy Page without getting stuck squarely in Metal-Land. The last couple minutes of "Breaking Into Heaven" still take my breath away. Love ya John.
@swingersonian The roses peaked at exactly the same time as acid house, warehouse raves etc. I was at Spike Island 1990, it was an all day rave before these fellas come on, very unique. The North West of UK United, Liverpool, Manchester (traditional enemies) laid down their arms. We could go the hacienda n the Mancs cane to Quadrant pk, all the same movement, the roses predated britpop and were unique in that period.
I walked into my mate's bedroom and he was playing This Is The One. I took some acid, listened to the whole album. Tried to get my sister to lend me her album so I could copy it to tape. She wouldn't let me. I stole it from her. I still have it over 30 years later, perfect condition. I will give her back one day.
My sister was the same way, but if I stole it from her, she would have called the fricken police on me. No lie. My sisters are both worthless. I have 2 unfortunately.
@Mrs Brady Believe me she had her moments, from constant Shakin' Stevens playing, through to Johnny Hates Jazz and Duran Duran. This was the first album I ever wanted a copy of :D
As a massive fan in the early 90s, first in Turkey and then in the US, this was a band I thought I was never going to get to see live. I usually don't care for reunion gigs, but this concert in 2016 was something else.
i had a staring out contest with Ian Brown at Liverpool Uni. in 1989.I was a wide eyed teenager and in awe.I only won because he had to start singing.The contest lasted pretty much for the whole intro of adored. i turn 50 next week and it seems like a lifetime ago.
Reni, Mani and Squire have that rare talent. They sound like they're playing a different song and the same song at the same exact time. Also I'll never not be able to love Ian Brown.
I love the comment mate. They have something no other band has for me and that comes from rhe 4 of them together. The poster with the rock, rock, funk and soul kinda the same thing you are saying.
@@iansmith8263 never has been ... I don't know how the hell he did it so well in the recording studios ... they didn't have autotune back then ... so he can sing in tune,, but I've not witnessed it live or on live footage ever ...
@@mrlsms In the studio (certainly for the 'Stone Roses' album) he sings in almost a whisper most of the time, really breathy. So it's easier for him to hold the tune. The producer can compress it and raise it in the mix. You can actually hear him start 'I Wanna Be Adored' in that hushed style and it sounds good. He can't get away with that for the most part live because it's such a dynamic soundscape. He has to sing above the band.
Waited years to c them. Heaton park manchester,T IN THE PARK saw them my home town twice glasgow green ,hampden stadium the last gig they done.id do it all again. Do agree with his singing. But if you c him do his solo stuff its the same.
I am from Manchester the Stone Roses are a way of life for us their music pours out of every car every kitchen window and every kids ipod we sing the songs to our kids who in turn sing to their kids the music of all generations. The band that inspireds generations!
The roses have an affliction with Scottish/Greenock folk, Hence why they loved Us Scots, The music department at our local college was named after Ian, he even opened it as he was friends with one of the lectures that put on gigs locally, Ian played our town hall along with a few other known faces over the years, another being the seahorses,although they might have actually played there gig in Rico’s 🤟❤️✌️
This is the band music fans are most thankful for. They sum up an era. They made music that means so much to so many people. And they are incredible musicians. Who can begrudge them their day in the sun and the chance to make money from that? That Ian Brown can't really sing is totally irrelevant - his persona is the Stone Roses and people sing their hearts out anyway. It's like going to church. Though I have heard them countless times, these songs still send a shiver down my spine and put a tear in my eye. Fucking magic.
Perfect description mate. But I'd take ians voice over modern singers with falsetto and good technique any day. His voice had attitude and he meant it.
@@stephenhillman Great point. He did & still does. He’s my absolute hero as a human being who never compromised. I’m like that, though I have no public talent!
This edit is fantastic. The greatest thing about it is how seamless it is even though it’s culled from multiple sources. Great work, great tribute to a great band. The first Roses album was the soundtrack of my teens. Came at a time when GnR, Def Leppard and U2 ruled the airwaves. The Roses were something totally new and beautiful. One of the few albums I still listen to front to back. Not one mediocre song in the lot. I told myself in high school that the girl I would marry one day would have to be a big Stone Roses fan for the union to work. I married a girl into country music so you know how the Storey ends. It wasn’t a love song. Oh well, there’s still hope to find another Stone Roses fan out there.
It can work the other way around, too. My girl was into Neil Young, Bowie, Bread., hugely pre-dating the Roses. 40 years later next summer, we both love Stone Roses & Ian Brown. If we got married again, we’d choose Ten Story Love Song as one of our renewal of vows tracks. And Heroes.
What made The Stone Roses & their songs so special was that they were 4 equal parts of talent, given equal attention in the playing & recording; no turning down one to favour another. Bands and producers would do well to follow that example today. Phenomenal.
@j.harrison6744 He's not great live, but they knew how to get the most out of his voice in recordings. And he's vocally unique; you know it's him from the first couple lyrics sung.
"The candle that burns twice as bright, burns half as long". Glad to see them burning again. Music that sounds like everything and anything is possible - the last sound of the 80s and the first sound of the 90s. Long live the Roses. 🍋🍋🍋
They came ,they went away ,they came again ,,went away ,came again and sounded like they never been away ,the stone roses ,,maybe had only two albums but they were second to none,,,pure class,,,,the tunes will live on ,,,,,,,,,,,thanks for the great music lads and great times,,,,,,
At this show especially, Reni is John Bohnam and Buddy Rich at the same time. He's a world class athlete at his craft and is playing so hard and fast that it makes sense that this was essentially it. Boy, did he show it in this performance. A ridiculous talent. Don't worry, fellow drummers in the biz definitely know of Reni.
Excellent observations. I would also throw John Densmore of the Doors in there, based on how masterfully Reni's patterns and fills not only often match the melody lines but enhance and enforce them. He's playing the SONG, not just the drums. Densmore was a master of this as well. Brilliant, brilliant stuff.
@@andrewconrad2859 Throw Clem Burke from Blondie into the mix too, oh and Jeff Pocaro from Toto in there as well. Its a simplified term but I call them song drummers, they play for the song and not for themselves. Too many drummers play for themselves, and overcomplicate things, Neil Peart and Ginger Baker spring to mind! Great drummers but they often played for themselves and the audience, instead of playing in the song. Ringo and Mick Fleetwood were also great at doing exactly what the song called for.
Makes me wanna jump on a plane and head to rainy Manchester to enjoy tea, coffee, or beer. All equally satisfying! Cheers from sunny LaLa Land. I♡UK 🇺🇸❤ 🇬🇧
It's not raining today!! We have a saying here in Manchester...If we can see the hills - it's going to rain. If we CAN'T see the hills - it IS raining.
Great live in sync & time with each other, even on Bye Bye Badman when Ian ends up a Bar ahead, Reni and the rest of the band manage to pull it back without losing time or major fuck up! For me that’s the beauty of being in a band and playing live, no matter how good you are we will all make mistakes from time to time, it proves we’re all human and how as musicians you can retrieve and how well you can play your way out of a mistake.
Fucking awesome the played "Don't Stop" which is 'Waterfall" played backwards note for note and they nailed it both backwards and forwards. That's fucking hard to do.
@@thomasedmundrichards this is quite an unpleasant comment with zero basis. Two things - firstly check my profile photo for Stone Roses credentials secondly find me any best drummers list with Reni in it. Come back when you have done both
Ian brown is a very lucky man,had an awesome drummer a cracking bass player and a truly phenomenal guitar player this band will be forever etched in my memory.a great gig at a great venue.ian brown what a fantastic frontman.knows how to get a crowd hyped and dancing
The late 80's - what a time to be a teenager. The Stone Roses music defined that period for me, never to be repeated. I feel sorry for the current generation who won't see the emergence of bands like this. Woolworths on a Saturday morning to get the latest records. Wonderful memories.
THANK YOU TO EVERYONE INVOLVED IN THIS FANTASTIC PRODUCTION. There’s John, Paul, George and Ringo... and there is also Ian, John, Mani and Reni. One Love. 🍋
@@paulcollins5586 True, but at least the Roses wrote their own music. The Beatles were allegedly assisted. Their output is considered by some professionals to have been literally impossible. Way too many songs in the time available.
@@GT380man What the heck are you talking about? George Martin, like any producer, surely lent a hand, but aside from that, it was all talent (or more likely genius) of J, P, G and R. That is why musicologists consider the Beatles as a lightning in a bottle; what they accomplished is almost other-worldly. Don't get me wrong, I love the Stone Roses, but they are definitely not in the same league as the fab four. Oh, another important fact, the Beatles are the pioneer band in writing, playing, singing and recording their own music.
yeah, those looks between them for that gig say a thousand words, feel privileged to have witnessed each connection and tried to prioritise those moments in the edit.
I waited 25 years to see the Roses perform live then finally saw them live at an outdoor gig in Belfast in August 2012. To say it was like a religious experience doesn't even come close, I stood utterly mesmerised from the opening bass rumble of Adored right through until the 8 minute frenzy at the finale of Resurrection. If ever there was a band of brothers, the Roses are it. Their musical legacy may not be a large one but it will live on for as long as humanity exists. Truly a band like no other. I'm sad that it's over but I'm ecstatic that I lived in the time of the Stone Roses. One Love 🍋🍋🍋
I waited a bit less but finally i've been there that day. Tennents Vital Festival with Foo Fighters day before or after, dont remember. Both fantastic gigs but Roses was pure magic. I feel goose bumps watching NY concert and remind myself Belfast show. Dont be sad its over, be happy its happend 🙋♂️
They always wanted to break America and be the biggest band in the world so it was fantastic for them to feel the love in NYC. Back in the day my brother saw the Mondays play there (think there was a video of the concert also) with Shaun's giving his 'manchester in the area!' shout. Performing over there always meant a lot to the manc heavyweights and resulted in special performances! Covid luv to the Rose's! Also check out the Bridewell Taxis, the manc crew (proper boys who followed these bands) had a lot of luv for this band back in the day and their sound seems really relevant at the mo! Forget any City rivalry we were with the Rose's and their Mersey Paradise vibe!
Lucky enough to see them at Wembley and the Etihad shows in 2016. They were epic. EPIC. Reni never plays anything the same way twice. They are and will always be icons.
Yo bro, that comment ya just sent, is like listening to my thoughts!!, I grew up in Manchester and in the late 80,s - early 90,s I was a teenager who was looking for a scene to be into ! AND BANG !!! the roses ,the coolest, the freshest, greatest fukin bunch of kids from my manor, came along and changed everything, loved em then ,and adore them still!!!
Brilliant. That guy on the guitar is pretty good. Never seen each member of the band go round and hug each other at the end like that. These guys were special.
Please excuse my ignorance guys but is John Squire the hairier guitarist on our right & this is their original line up ? I date back a bit further to the likes of Chris Squire from the ‘ 70s and all that Prog stuff but did appreciate their work back in 1989 along with James , The Chameleons, Charlatans , Inspiral Carpets , Mock Turtles . I did buy She Bangs the Drums mind you which was Phenomenally loud & clear on a 12” single 👍😁
Great to see such a large audience for one of their North America gigs, especially at the legendary square gardens. Didn't realise they had any kind of following in the states.
I was at the show. I hate MSG. Way too big but sometimes you have to just deal with it. I love the small venues because I get right in front. I will only see those I truly love at MSG. Feels like sitting a mile away. This was an awesome show.
@@tripface78 same with me. This is the only MSG concert that I actually thought was awesome. Of course it's the Roses, but it's also the energy of thousands of fans who finally got to see live, a band they had adored from far away for 27 years.
They sound brilliant at this gig and Ian’s voice is spot on. Much better than the Heaton Park gigs and Glasgow Green which I went to. Saw em in 95 at Bridlington Spa and Sheffield
Seen them in Dublin and Belfast, so pleased I saw them before they packed it in again. Edit.. Spike Island is a great little movie for any Roses fans. lol
Was it sold out?!! I heard not quite, but still ppl to the rafters, probably 15,000-16,000 ppl there, they guessed. Certainly a triumph for the Roses, especially considering the incredible potential they had to be "the next legitimate big deal," if ya like, in America. Oasis has had, probably, the best sustained success in America of any of the distinctly English bands IMO. But yeah, this is one enthusiastic fuckin crowd!! It's like a bunch of Englishmen came w/them😉
It really gets me in the feels every time I see Stone Roses live concerts and see that there are stadiums full of fans that know the words to their songs and sing them back to Ian in synchronicity with him!!!
I’m sitting here in Scotland first night of second lockdown wondering what to watch and I stumble across this... WOW!!! Thanks man. Absolutely outstanding effort. 🤟🏼🔥
Literally exactly the same mate lol! Snuck in to see Ian Brown at TITP back in the day but would've gave that day to see the Roses live - outstanding gig! Decent footage and sound too!
I cannot get enough of this concert! I have viewed this fan edit 1 million times!! I am thankful to Stephen Hillman and Company for bringing this concert back to me in 2020. It was fantastic at MSG live in 2016, but even better now that so much time has passed. Magical!
@@ritaraymsnrn7294 i watched it about 3 times since i found it this week. i never thought i would see them live. they surpass any expectation. what a band
Wow. Next to the outstanding musicality, can we also please talk about how good Ian Brown sounded? I haven't heard him this good in any other reunion video.
@@nicktaylor684 If I was to guess, he’s got the best fold back ever, so he can actually hear what he’s singing….he looks well, doesn’t he? Always into fitness.
What a geezer Browny is. Always in rare , quality clobber. Adidas trainers that are made just for him. Top frontman. Gotta love Mani. Saw them at Leeds in 2017 I think the year was at 02. Unbelievable night.
At 56 it's a blessing to enjoy this and see others catch on to one fine band....in 1989 I turned all my friends onto this newly discovered group I read about....the album played on for several years afterwards..... friggin UK love from a Montreal born and raised genxer.
@@JOHNROBBofficial thank you. Means a lot. Happy it's free for everyone to enjoy. Imagine having access to the on stage camera footage and close mics! Although I love that it's the real sound of that bsnd in that venue, no digital effects, auto tune or overdubs. Happy new year to you.
Hello John! Fancy seeing you here! Agreed, this is most excellent Stephen, and the audio sounds great considering its all from the phone recordings, almost as good as I used to make Gold Blade sound!!
Absolutely brilliant mate. Goosebumps. Well done. I'll never forget the girl I saw standing at the bus stop in 1988 with an Elephant Stone t-shirt on, and being instantly converted on the spot.
Brilliant. I have a similar story. The guy playing football in the park in 1988 had the elephant stone t shirt on and thsts all they talked about. I was 11 they were 16/18. I asked what the stone roses were. The guy said come round tonight and I'll let you hear them. I went. I heard. I went home and asked for a guitar. 20 yrs later I got to record with John Leckie. Everyday he would tell me something new. I've subsequently met all the band on many occasions but never as the roses. They are the greatest group ever. The playing on this show and that leg of the tour in particular is stunning. Mani, Reni and John can't be out classed by anyone.
similar story about a bus stop but diffrent band. stood waiting for the bus (probaly 1979/80 ish) and the bus stops in Hull at the time used to have a little yellow rubbish bins strapped to the pole. someone had written 'adam and the ants' on the bin. next day i remember going to the record shop to discover who adam and the ants were ...happy memories
@@martinl2325 I have a similar story about a bus stop in Leeds and this here car pulls up and asks if i remembered my stop, look and listen. He says he clunk clicks on every trip, could hardly make out what he was saying for the jingle jangle of his gold chains but was well impressed by his Madchester baggy shell suit. Asked if i fancied a trip with him to see round the local hospital, guided tour like. Never forgot it well apart from the blackout bit. Fixed it for me.
@@GT380man Hadn't even got to the bit where i backpacking round Thailand and i went to a ping pong game with this fella called Paul Gadd, nice fella, bad beard
I met mani and ian ian comes from my home town but it was an absolute privalge to be taken to Rockfield to see the kids record well not actually record the 2nd coming 95 I was in heaven on earth thanks to dub war from newport
I only got into the stone roses after seeing ian brown supporting manic street preachers a few years ago . Someone in the crowd shouted ian brown your shit and he instantly replied youre the c##t that paid 16 quid to watch me the place was in uproar . Been a fan of his ever since
If I see Stone Roses and Oasis getting back together my life is complete. So gutted I didn’t have a chance to go to these gigs the Roses played few years ago.
Was at the show as a stupid 13 year old kid and I totally took for granted the greatness I was witnessing, became a proper fan later and it’s always been one of my biggest regrets, what I would give to go back and experience this as a proper fan, it’s almost worse to know I was there and didn’t soak it
@@leightonbond3336 Aye. Fair play. They were really good that nite too. American hipsters, especially at shit like Coachella, gettin "up for it" ain't really their bag, n the low audience participation leads to a dull show. We Americans are brutal, especially in NYC, though... N the Roses, as you see, blow em the fuck away!😉 Well done, fellas.
@@matthewrider6456 coming from a Brit, the MSG crowd were fantastic, I can feel the love through my laptop screen. Maybe I'm biased though, let's go Rangers
@@Shaunography You're spot on! I thought it came across that way too. Oasis MSG sell-out show from 2005's DBTT tour (NOT the more prevalent MSG '08 footage!) is also that way. Liam's actually up for it, being their first-ever MSG gig, & a sell-out at that, and he sounds pretty great too, given the state of his voice at that time, & the crowd sing every, single, solitary song so loudly, it's hard to hear Liam or Noel properly through the majority of the gig anyhow! The full show is on UA-cam, though.
![Radiohead - 7/27/16 - MSG - [Full Show Multicam+Taper-Audio] - Madison Square Garden - N2](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/t94FTibEgYQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Me and my wife got engaged at the top of the Empire State Building the day before this show. We were of course there. Best week of my entire life.
Now that's a plan!
She was the one 🤣😍
When was it mate ?..
were the Roses big in the States then,..??
To british for the americans
And that, ladies and gentlemen, is why The Stone Roses are the best band Britain ever produced.
❤👍👍👍👍 period
Bar The Smiths obv.
This concert made me come alive again. It’s fantastic surely I am not too old at 75 to love Ian Brown. Thanks for this I am jumping up and down.
Yo girl, you is jammin
Never too old to love the stone roses. Just proud.
Right on!!👍👍👍👍👍
Be Rude Not Too
How cant you love him & his music. God like genius 🙌 you keep truckin
I use to live just down the road from John in Manchester in the late 80's and early 90's, along from the Southern Cemetery, you'd see him walking about with his guitar over his shoulder even after they got big, and the paint shop they got their ammo from when they made their famous attack on the Revolver records owner was just round the corner in Northenden, I was at Spike Island, though I don't remember that much!, and TBH I don't remember it being that good either, it's funny how it's become an iconic gig now, I was 21 and still one of the oldest there lol, but as a Stone Roses fan back in the day you felt a massive loyalty to the band, like they were part of your family, I remember defending them to my mates and then going back home a year later and everyone was dressed like them & danced like Ian and loved them, at the time I hated that more than when everyone hated them, it seems like yesterday but another lifetime ago, and I know that doesn't make sense, but it's hard to explain, it's like a dream now, but it was the best time of my life
Nice story cheers. Hope you enjoyed the video
Beautiful
Totally get it chief! Remember being outside Glasgow green gig and realising how important it was 🫶 one love 🍋
I was around at that time also. Our band rehearsed at Chorlton behind Sale Cycles. Roses used to rehearse there also. Yeah, Spike Island was shit!
Yeah man !! ❤ Buzzing !!
Reni really is a fucking great drummer.
He used to get some stick back in the day but he always reminded me of Keith Moon as a player.. Powerful and inventive, though technically fairly simple.. ( Though a lot of Reni's grooves are deceptively intricate really.)
It's good to ear them on less drugs and a better monitor system!
@@JesusHChrist-q9d Did he?! I was only about 4 when the first record came out so I wasn't aware of that. He sounds rock solid to me. Great rhythm. Holding it all together.
More than that. He does great harmonics too
Probably the best of a generation and up there with the best ever 😊
@@jasonmfzb I think he’s the best musician in the band, John squire is insane, like 9.8 out of 10, but reni is on a completely different level, he’s the backbone of this wonderful band
Reni should be in every conversation when discussing the greatest drummers of all time. He’s ‘otherworldly’ good!
There are plenty of drummers out there who are technically 'better' than Reni, but surely there's never been any drummer who's been so instrumental in elevating the musical output of a band. The Roses without Reni would have been very good, with him they were... well, just listen.
The best make it look unattainable but effortless, greatest of our generation for sure...
👏👏👏
I agree, I remember when I was a kid thinking how does he dance with the drum kit, hold amazing rhythm and sing at the same time 🤯
@@cdogensis6392 who
John Squire rescued Guitar culture when it wasn't cool. More power to his elbow, been listening to this a lot through lockdown.
When was guitar culture not cool? It was tough to make it big back then, but think about the last 20 years!! You can't just be a good interpreter of ideas, you need to have great ideas, and John has them in spades!!
@@swingersonian He’s referring to the Second Coming era..which is kind of true. Obviously guitars were still prominent in Grunge and Britpop…but the guitar hero/balls to the wall playing approach was seen as “uncool” in the 90’s. Squire was one of the only players embracing it.
Who said it wasn't cool?
Bands like guns n roses, bon jovi, judas priest, iron maiden, Metallica and def leppard were still mega huge back then.
Some have referred to Squire as the first "Non-Heavy Metal Guitar Hero," although I can think of several guys (Johnny Marr, the Edge, Billy Duffy, just to name a few) who arrived earlier. Point is, he carved out a niche where his amazing skills were able to shine through and be prominent without being in a Metal
band. Then came the Led Zeppelin obsession, which I cannot fault him for one bit. It happened to me too. Many disliked that era of the Roses and Squire's playing, but as a Classic Rock fan first, and an 80s alternative Rock fan second, I thought it was amazing. As close as anyone has gotten to the mystique and majesty of Jimmy Page without getting stuck squarely in Metal-Land. The last couple minutes of "Breaking Into Heaven" still take my breath away. Love ya John.
@swingersonian The roses peaked at exactly the same time as acid house, warehouse raves etc. I was at Spike Island 1990, it was an all day rave before these fellas come on, very unique. The North West of UK United, Liverpool, Manchester (traditional enemies) laid down their arms. We could go the hacienda n the Mancs cane to Quadrant pk, all the same movement, the roses predated britpop and were unique in that period.
I walked into my mate's bedroom and he was playing This Is The One.
I took some acid, listened to the whole album.
Tried to get my sister to lend me her album so I could copy it to tape. She wouldn't let me.
I stole it from her.
I still have it over 30 years later, perfect condition.
I will give her back one day.
My sister was the same way, but if I stole it from her, she would have called the fricken police on me. No lie. My sisters are both worthless. I have 2 unfortunately.
@@JamieLeeKnoxville only 2? i have 4 older sisters so grew up with double your nightmare lol.
I temporarily "Borrowed" it from my older Brother. I got a bloody hiding but it was worth it. 👍 😅😊
Family love.
@Mrs Brady Believe me she had her moments, from constant Shakin' Stevens playing, through to Johnny Hates Jazz and Duran Duran. This was the first album I ever wanted a copy of :D
ほんまにローゼズ最高！レニのドラムはマジでいいよ！信じられないほど時間を越えてマジックを再現してる。このビートがローゼズを蘇らせる鼓動。
Big thank you to Stephen Hillman for the incredible job. A super production that will bring tears to the eyes of every fan.
Thanks. Glad you enjoyed
As a massive fan in the early 90s, first in Turkey and then in the US, this was a band I thought I was never going to get to see live. I usually don't care for reunion gigs, but this concert in 2016 was something else.
If they didn't sell it out, they came damned close. And whoever was there really got a special treat. Cheers, from America
#MadFerItAmerican🇺🇲🇬🇧
Dear Steve Hillman, on behalf of all Roses fans, thank you!!!
i had a staring out contest with Ian Brown at Liverpool Uni. in 1989.I was a wide eyed teenager and in awe.I only won because he had to start singing.The contest lasted pretty much for the whole intro of adored. i turn 50 next week and it seems like a lifetime ago.
I had with with Johnny rotten in Manchester during there last reunion. Epic night
All the best Gray
Reni, Mani and Squire have that rare talent. They sound like they're playing a different song and the same song at the same exact time. Also I'll never not be able to love Ian Brown.
I love the comment mate. They have something no other band has for me and that comes from rhe 4 of them together. The poster with the rock, rock, funk and soul kinda the same thing you are saying.
Ian is on form here
He has sounded appalling in the past but he’s spot on here
It’ll be a long time before a band comes along to match the roses
Agreed. I saw them at ethiad at a similar time - they were way better than Eaton park (particularly ians singing)
I'm delighted for them that they were able to do this and secure themselves financially. They deserved it.
yeah what a swizz; he can't even sing in tune
@@iansmith8263 never has been ... I don't know how the hell he did it so well in the recording studios ... they didn't have autotune back then ... so he can sing in tune,, but I've not witnessed it live or on live footage ever ...
@@mrlsms In the studio (certainly for the 'Stone Roses' album) he sings in almost a whisper most of the time, really breathy. So it's easier for him to hold the tune. The producer can compress it and raise it in the mix. You can actually hear him start 'I Wanna Be Adored' in that hushed style and it sounds good. He can't get away with that for the most part live because it's such a dynamic soundscape. He has to sing above the band.
I agree completely. They made a pretty, pretty penny from 2012 to 2017.
Waited years to c them. Heaton park manchester,T IN THE PARK saw them my home town twice glasgow green ,hampden stadium the last gig they done.id do it all again. Do agree with his singing. But if you c him do his solo stuff its the same.
John is so fluid and flawless and musical love his approach to the guitar
Waterfall into Don't Stop was sublime!
I am from Manchester the Stone Roses are a way of life for us their music pours out of every car every kitchen window and every kids ipod we sing the songs to our kids who in turn sing to their kids the music of all generations. The band that inspireds generations!
Mate you forget about the best band to come out of manchester The smiths.
@@rrickey360 Heaven knows am miserable now 😉
The roses have an affliction with Scottish/Greenock folk, Hence why they loved Us Scots, The music department at our local college was named after Ian, he even opened it as he was friends with one of the lectures that put on gigs locally, Ian played our town hall along with a few other known faces over the years, another being the seahorses,although they might have actually played there gig in Rico’s 🤟❤️✌️
@@Floydy affiliation?😄I remember being jealous as a paisley buddy-mon the greenockians
@@nolanlamond2439 magic m8
This is the band music fans are most thankful for. They sum up an era. They made music that means so much to so many people. And they are incredible musicians. Who can begrudge them their day in the sun and the chance to make money from that? That Ian Brown can't really sing is totally irrelevant - his persona is the Stone Roses and people sing their hearts out anyway. It's like going to church. Though I have heard them countless times, these songs still send a shiver down my spine and put a tear in my eye. Fucking magic.
Lovingly put together also, thanks!
Perfect description mate. But I'd take ians voice over modern singers with falsetto and good technique any day. His voice had attitude and he meant it.
Fucking well said! Thank you. ✨ ✨
@@stephenhillman Great point. He did & still does. He’s my absolute hero as a human being who never compromised. I’m like that, though I have no public talent!
Say no more👍
I was there. Right in front. It was a mind blowing show. I was worried as they are a bit hit and Miss. But this was other worldly.
Thank you for creating this. It’s a master piece.
Jeff, when did this gig take place? Dec 2020?
@@stevejen3416 it says in the title 30/06/2016
This edit is fantastic. The greatest thing about it is how seamless it is even though it’s culled from multiple sources. Great work, great tribute to a great band. The first Roses album was the soundtrack of my teens. Came at a time when GnR, Def Leppard and U2 ruled the airwaves. The Roses were something totally new and beautiful. One of the few albums I still listen to front to back. Not one mediocre song in the lot. I told myself in high school that the girl I would marry one day would have to be a big Stone Roses fan for the union to work. I married a girl into country music so you know how the Storey ends. It wasn’t a love song. Oh well, there’s still hope to find another Stone Roses fan out there.
All the English girls love Roses
@@comebackwimeapplepie Then to England I will go.
It can work the other way around, too. My girl was into Neil Young, Bowie, Bread., hugely pre-dating the Roses.
40 years later next summer, we both love Stone Roses & Ian Brown. If we got married again, we’d choose Ten Story Love Song as one of our renewal of vows tracks. And Heroes.
who in gods name clicks on a stone roses concert and gives it a thumbs down.....your day must have been real bad if this doesn't make you happy dance
Sean Ryder!! 😂😂
What made The Stone Roses & their songs so special was that they were 4 equal parts of talent, given equal attention in the playing & recording; no turning down one to favour another. Bands and producers would do well to follow that example today. Phenomenal.
Three parts. Ian is flatter than roadkill.
@j.harrison6744 He's not great live, but they knew how to get the most out of his voice in recordings. And he's vocally unique; you know it's him from the first couple lyrics sung.
never knew that the USA loved them, It makes me so happy to hear you sing along.
"The candle that burns twice as bright, burns half as long". Glad to see them burning again. Music that sounds like everything and anything is possible - the last sound of the 80s and the first sound of the 90s. Long live the Roses. 🍋🍋🍋
Beautifully put 😌
I love that. Just reaching back into the 80s just connects with my youth (was 20 in 1980).
Reni......an original, with great backing harmonies! Excellent
They came ,they went away ,they came again ,,went away ,came again and sounded like they never been away ,the stone roses ,,maybe had only two albums but they were second to none,,,pure class,,,,the tunes will live on ,,,,,,,,,,,thanks for the great music lads and great times,,,,,,
At this show especially, Reni is John Bohnam and Buddy Rich at the same time. He's a world class athlete at his craft and is playing so hard and fast that it makes sense that this was essentially it. Boy, did he show it in this performance. A ridiculous talent. Don't worry, fellow drummers in the biz definitely know of Reni.
Excellent observations. I would also throw John Densmore of the Doors in there, based on how masterfully Reni's patterns and fills not only often match the melody lines but enhance and enforce them. He's playing the SONG, not just the drums. Densmore was a master of this as well. Brilliant, brilliant stuff.
@@andrewconrad2859 Throw Clem Burke from Blondie into the mix too, oh and Jeff Pocaro from Toto in there as well. Its a simplified term but I call them song drummers, they play for the song and not for themselves. Too many drummers play for themselves, and overcomplicate things, Neil Peart and Ginger Baker spring to mind! Great drummers but they often played for themselves and the audience, instead of playing in the song. Ringo and Mick Fleetwood were also great at doing exactly what the song called for.
Makes me wanna jump on a plane and head to rainy Manchester to enjoy tea, coffee, or beer. All equally satisfying! Cheers from sunny LaLa Land. I♡UK 🇺🇸❤ 🇬🇧
It's not raining today!! We have a saying here in Manchester...If we can see the hills - it's going to rain. If we CAN'T see the hills - it IS raining.
Let's go now!! I'm in LALA Land too- We can charter a jet!
Long Beach here 👍
This was fantastic. Thanks so much for putting it together!
Not forgetting how Amazing a bass player Mani is Love to the Gods.💗💗💗
Squire hits every note. For me his fret wankin is up there with the best. So good to hear them so in sync with each other. Tears of joy.🤟🤟🤟🤟
"You and Me Both" bro! (Yazoo, 1984)
Sharing those tears!
Fret wanking? Harsh. I know he could be a real pain to work with……🤔
Love his playing but he messes up within the first 5 notes haha
Great live in sync & time with each other, even on Bye Bye Badman when Ian ends up a Bar ahead, Reni and the rest of the band manage to pull it back without losing time or major fuck up! For me that’s the beauty of being in a band and playing live, no matter how good you are we will all make mistakes from time to time, it proves we’re all human and how as musicians you can retrieve and how well you can play your way out of a mistake.
That performance of "Don't Stop" was mesmerizing.
It was incredible~
It was the one that really brought me back~
Then ‘Made of Stone’ blew the roof/my head off~~
Fucking awesome the played "Don't Stop" which is 'Waterfall" played backwards note for note and they nailed it both backwards and forwards. That's fucking hard to do.
We know....
fucking sublime.
They are Legends!
@@michaeldaly6662 🧡 that word. It's rare to find an occasion to use it, but you nailed it bro.
@@cujowayI didn't know. Now I do
Best live fools gold so far!!
Best lots of songs on this gig for me.
No Reni no Roses - he is immense. Completely underrated drummer. And just a cool bastard
👍
All cool ya know especially squire
Sadly, but the time I saw them in LA at the Palladium in 1995, Reni had already taken leave. Reni is so fun to watch.
He is anything but under rated. Most mis used term used on you tube by idiots with no clue
@@thomasedmundrichards this is quite an unpleasant comment with zero basis. Two things - firstly check my profile photo for Stone Roses credentials secondly find me any best drummers list with Reni in it. Come back when you have done both
Reni is the greatest drummer of all time. Amazing touch. Pure class. Great singer too 😎
Thank you for saying that, Agreed Totally! 🥁✨🎵🥁
Absoluts legend him and john carry thr band
One of the best bands and musicians of ALL TIME! One Love to the Mancs xxx
Legendary! I have goose pimples!
"Iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii'm gonna break right into heaven"
Superb. Reni is the glue to this band.
Ian brown is a very lucky man,had an awesome drummer a cracking bass player and a truly phenomenal guitar player this band will be forever etched in my memory.a great gig at a great venue.ian brown what a fantastic frontman.knows how to get a crowd hyped and dancing
The fab four
Yep. Jim Morrison kind of luck, as far as being surrounded by amazing musicians.
The late 80's - what a time to be a teenager. The Stone Roses music defined that period for me, never to be repeated. I feel sorry for the current generation who won't see the emergence of bands like this. Woolworths on a Saturday morning to get the latest records. Wonderful memories.
THANK YOU TO EVERYONE INVOLVED IN THIS FANTASTIC PRODUCTION.
There’s John, Paul, George and Ringo... and there is also Ian, John, Mani and Reni.
One Love. 🍋
Not even close.
@@paulcollins5586 The Stone Roses are the best band since The Beatles, indeed
@@paulcollins5586 True, but at least the Roses wrote their own music.
The Beatles were allegedly assisted. Their output is considered by some professionals to have been literally impossible. Way too many songs in the time available.
@@GT380man What the heck are you talking about? George Martin, like any producer, surely lent a hand, but aside from that, it was all talent (or more likely genius) of J, P, G and R. That is why musicologists consider the Beatles as a lightning in a bottle; what they accomplished is almost other-worldly. Don't get me wrong, I love the Stone Roses, but they are definitely not in the same league as the fab four. Oh, another important fact, the Beatles are the pioneer band in writing, playing, singing and recording their own music.
Absolutely top of their game….. and all mates again. Sublime performance by the Stone Roses.
yeah, those looks between them for that gig say a thousand words, feel privileged to have witnessed each connection and tried to prioritise those moments in the edit.
WOW. I was there, it was magic. And so is this.
I waited 25 years to see the Roses perform live then finally saw them live at an outdoor gig in Belfast in August 2012. To say it was like a religious experience doesn't even come close, I stood utterly mesmerised from the opening bass rumble of Adored right through until the 8 minute frenzy at the finale of Resurrection. If ever there was a band of brothers, the Roses are it. Their musical legacy may not be a large one but it will live on for as long as humanity exists. Truly a band like no other. I'm sad that it's over but I'm ecstatic that I lived in the time of the Stone Roses. One Love 🍋🍋🍋
Saw em three times, Scotland, Wembley and Halifax for pre gig, people who say Ian’s vocals are awful haven’t seen him live, he’s mega
I waited a bit less but finally i've been there that day. Tennents Vital Festival with Foo Fighters day before or after, dont remember. Both fantastic gigs but Roses was pure magic. I feel goose bumps watching NY concert and remind myself Belfast show.
Dont be sad its over, be happy its happend 🙋♂️
How incomprehensibly majestic.
They always wanted
to break America and be the biggest band in the world so it was fantastic for them to feel the love in NYC. Back in the day my brother saw the Mondays play there (think there was a video of the concert also) with Shaun's giving his 'manchester in the area!' shout. Performing over there always meant a lot to the manc heavyweights and resulted in special performances! Covid luv to the Rose's! Also check out the Bridewell Taxis, the manc crew (proper boys who followed these bands) had a lot of luv for this band back in the day and their sound seems really relevant at the mo! Forget any City rivalry we were with the Rose's and their Mersey Paradise vibe!
Travelled from sydney australia for this haha worth every cent
Wow that's committed. You picked a good one!
But The Stone Roses did make it to Australia, didn't they?
Even Coldplay posted a photo of that show in Australia.
Lucky enough to see them at Wembley and the Etihad shows in 2016. They were epic. EPIC. Reni never plays anything the same way twice. They are and will always be icons.
Heaton Park and Etihad. Two of the best days of my life! ✌️✨✨✨✨
That drummer has unshackled his limbs from each other. Those are just mad polyrhythms.
Man, this is superb. Late teens in NW England '87 onwards was a very special time for me.
Blackburn and raves at Sett End!
Yo bro, that comment ya just sent, is like listening to my thoughts!!, I grew up in Manchester and in the late 80,s - early 90,s I was a teenager who was looking for a scene to be into ! AND BANG !!! the roses ,the coolest, the freshest, greatest fukin bunch of kids from my manor, came along and changed everything, loved em then ,and adore them still!!!
This sounds amazing! The vibe is TOP! Even One For All sounds good!
Never been into the Roses. But oh my god I am now. Outstanding
Some gig aye!
Incredible. I flew out from L.A. for this show and can now relive it. Thanks a million!
I flew from Canada, Totally worth it!
Yeah same I flew out from SF ... incredible.
I lived in NYC at the time and didn't bother getting off the couch for this. Can't adequately convey my regret.
Y'all keep winning at life!
The best hour and a half I've ever spent on UA-cam 🔥
Brilliant. That guy on the guitar is pretty good. Never seen each member of the band go round and hug each other at the end like that. These guys were special.
I think they knew that was a special night and they played a blinder!
Guy on guitar is Squire
@@parker11965 haha yeah i know, was trying to be slightly funny!
Please excuse my ignorance guys but is John Squire the hairier guitarist on our right & this is their original line up ? I date back a bit further to the likes of Chris Squire from the ‘ 70s and all that Prog stuff but did appreciate their work back in 1989 along with James , The Chameleons, Charlatans , Inspiral Carpets , Mock Turtles . I did buy She Bangs the Drums mind you which was Phenomenally loud & clear on a 12” single 👍😁
@@newforestpixie5297 yes thats Squire and yes original line up.
Shoot You Down is that perfect song. Gets me every time.
Great to see such a large audience for one of their North America gigs, especially at the legendary square gardens. Didn't realise they had any kind of following in the states.
I was at the show. I hate MSG. Way too big but sometimes you have to just deal with it. I love the small venues because I get right in front. I will only see those I truly love at MSG. Feels like sitting a mile away. This was an awesome show.
@@tripface78 same with me. This is the only MSG concert that I actually thought was awesome. Of course it's the Roses, but it's also the energy of thousands of fans who finally got to see live, a band they had adored from far away for 27 years.
What a guitarist John Squire is, his 70's flavoured playing gave The Roses an edge their contemporaries could only dream of possessing.
I love the way Reni plays, no filler all killer!
They sound brilliant at this gig and Ian’s voice is spot on.
Much better than the Heaton Park gigs and Glasgow Green which I went to.
Saw em in 95 at Bridlington Spa and Sheffield
Seen them in Dublin and Belfast, so pleased I saw them before they packed it in again.
Edit.. Spike Island is a great little movie for any Roses fans. lol
I was there. One of the BEST shows I've ever attended.
Was it sold out?!! I heard not quite, but still ppl to the rafters, probably 15,000-16,000 ppl there, they guessed. Certainly a triumph for the Roses, especially considering the incredible potential they had to be "the next legitimate big deal," if ya like, in America. Oasis has had, probably, the best sustained success in America of any of the distinctly English bands IMO. But yeah, this is one enthusiastic fuckin crowd!! It's like a bunch of Englishmen came w/them😉
I could watch Reni all day on a drum kit! They seemed to be enjoying themselves - fabulous!!
Great to see them loved in the USA finally! 👍😁👍
Glad to see these guys playing after all this time.
Had no idea of their popularity in the US..... This makes me happy 😊
I was there on the floor near the front and I’m a Brit living in Chicago, 70%+ who were there were British. Best concert EVER!!
Ahhhh... Should av known
@@richardfielding6058 Brit living in Montreal here - we drove down for it. Couldn't move for the Brits and Irish! Such an incredible night
I think the audience was mostly Europeans (specially Brits).
It's safe to say that their musical aptitude has increased exponentially over the years. Well played!!!
It really gets me in the feels every time I see Stone Roses live concerts and see that there are stadiums full of fans that know the words to their songs and sing them back to Ian in synchronicity with him!!!
New York waited a long time for a Stone Roses show, but by god they finally gave us one. This was a fantastic show.
The country, the world is missing bands like these. Long live the Roses
Thank fuk for UA-cam and people like you.
I’m sitting here in Scotland first night of second lockdown wondering what to watch and I stumble across this... WOW!!! Thanks man. Absolutely outstanding effort. 🤟🏼🔥
Class mate 🍋
Literally exactly the same mate lol! Snuck in to see Ian Brown at TITP back in the day but would've gave that day to see the Roses live - outstanding gig! Decent footage and sound too!
@@The.Dulcet.Toned.Scotsman I hear ya man. We just gotta enjoy footage like this. Their music never ages.
@@mikeymckinnon5778 saw them at The Barras in '95 then twice in Japan 2012---FujiRock was tremendous.
it's truly grand
Even though he isn't the original Stone Roses' drummer, Reni is THE Stone Roses' drummer -- no one else can fill his shoes!!!
I cannot get enough of this concert! I have viewed this fan edit 1 million times!! I am thankful to Stephen Hillman and Company for bringing this concert back to me in 2020. It was fantastic at MSG live in 2016, but even better now that so much time has passed. Magical!
Yes, I'm watching it again!!! Best Valentine's gift!
@@ritaraymsnrn7294 i watched it about 3 times since i found it this week. i never thought i would see them live. they surpass any expectation. what a band
STONE ROSES !!!The best bandof there time by MILES!!!
Wow. Next to the outstanding musicality, can we also please talk about how good Ian Brown sounded? I haven't heard him this good in any other reunion video.
he's amazing here
Best he’s ever sounded - reckon something to do with the mic though
He often struggled live, especially if John had his guitar way too loud, which he usually did.
@@nicktaylor684 If I was to guess, he’s got the best fold back ever, so he can actually hear what he’s singing….he looks well, doesn’t he? Always into fitness.
Same for John 😎
Love this band.
What a geezer Browny is. Always in rare , quality clobber. Adidas trainers that are made just for him. Top frontman. Gotta love Mani. Saw them at Leeds in 2017 I think the year was at 02. Unbelievable night.
At 56 it's a blessing to enjoy this and see others catch on to one fine band....in 1989 I turned all my friends onto this newly discovered group I read about....the album played on for several years afterwards..... friggin UK love from a Montreal born and raised genxer.
Wow - that’s great
Thsnks John. My love letter to the Rose's for sure. This gig was something special.
@@stephenhillman would be great if they released this - you’ve done a great job putting that together. A reminder of their greatness. Happy new year.
@@JOHNROBBofficial thank you. Means a lot. Happy it's free for everyone to enjoy. Imagine having access to the on stage camera footage and close mics! Although I love that it's the real sound of that bsnd in that venue, no digital effects, auto tune or overdubs. Happy new year to you.
Hello John! Fancy seeing you here! Agreed, this is most excellent Stephen, and the audio sounds great considering its all from the phone recordings, almost as good as I used to make Gold Blade sound!!
This was amazing show!!! Was there.
What a night! What an amazing upload! Thank you - Don't be sad because it's over, Be happy because it happened!
I have a feeling that the Stones Roses 🌹 🌹 🌹 🌹 will tour again once the pandemic is over , in support of a new album 🍋 Shhh...
Totally agree, absolutely outstanding. Oh and that's what "Loop" is for - it's never over! 😍
ps - that transition into I Am The Resurrection!!! I Remember it like it was yesterday
Absolutely brilliant mate. Goosebumps. Well done. I'll never forget the girl I saw standing at the bus stop in 1988 with an Elephant Stone t-shirt on, and being instantly converted on the spot.
Brilliant. I have a similar story. The guy playing football in the park in 1988 had the elephant stone t shirt on and thsts all they talked about. I was 11 they were 16/18. I asked what the stone roses were. The guy said come round tonight and I'll let you hear them. I went. I heard. I went home and asked for a guitar. 20 yrs later I got to record with John Leckie. Everyday he would tell me something new. I've subsequently met all the band on many occasions but never as the roses. They are the greatest group ever. The playing on this show and that leg of the tour in particular is stunning. Mani, Reni and John can't be out classed by anyone.
similar story about a bus stop but diffrent band. stood waiting for the bus (probaly 1979/80 ish) and the bus stops in Hull at the time used to have a little yellow rubbish bins strapped to the pole. someone had written 'adam and the ants' on the bin. next day i remember going to the record shop to discover who adam and the ants were ...happy memories
@@martinl2325 I have a similar story about a bus stop in Leeds and this here car pulls up and asks if i remembered my stop, look and listen. He says he clunk clicks on every trip, could hardly make out what he was saying for the jingle jangle of his gold chains but was well impressed by his Madchester baggy shell suit. Asked if i fancied a trip with him to see round the local hospital, guided tour like. Never forgot it well apart from the blackout bit. Fixed it for me.
@@mysecretworld6603 Excellent. Hope your ring recovered.
@@GT380man Hadn't even got to the bit where i backpacking round Thailand and i went to a ping pong game with this fella called Paul Gadd, nice fella, bad beard
I met mani and ian ian comes from my home town but it was an absolute privalge to be taken to Rockfield to see the kids record well not actually record the 2nd coming 95 I was in heaven on earth thanks to dub war from newport
I only got into the stone roses after seeing ian brown supporting manic street preachers a few years ago . Someone in the crowd shouted ian brown your shit and he instantly replied youre the c##t that paid 16 quid to watch me the place was in uproar . Been a fan of his ever since
If I see Stone Roses and Oasis getting back together my life is complete. So gutted I didn’t have a chance to go to these gigs the Roses played few years ago.
One of the best bands to ever do it. Ian Browns songwriting,Mani's bass ,Reni drums and John Squire guitar . AMAZING 🙏
Was at the show as a stupid 13 year old kid and I totally took for granted the greatness I was witnessing, became a proper fan later and it’s always been one of my biggest regrets, what I would give to go back and experience this as a proper fan, it’s almost worse to know I was there and didn’t soak it
You were there mate
Thats enough. Ive beem too pissed to remember some good gigs as well. No regrets just keep learning and growing.
This is class, as close as we'll get to a proper live film of an entire gig from the reunion, well done to the uploader!
And the only American show of the reunion!
@@matthewrider6456 Coachella too.
@@leightonbond3336 Aye. Fair play. They were really good that nite too. American hipsters, especially at shit like Coachella, gettin "up for it" ain't really their bag, n the low audience participation leads to a dull show. We Americans are brutal, especially in NYC, though... N the Roses, as you see, blow em the fuck away!😉 Well done, fellas.
@@matthewrider6456 coming from a Brit, the MSG crowd were fantastic, I can feel the love through my laptop screen. Maybe I'm biased though, let's go Rangers
@@Shaunography You're spot on! I thought it came across that way too. Oasis MSG sell-out show from 2005's DBTT tour (NOT the more prevalent MSG '08 footage!) is also that way. Liam's actually up for it, being their first-ever MSG gig, & a sell-out at that, and he sounds pretty great too, given the state of his voice at that time, & the crowd sing every, single, solitary song so loudly, it's hard to hear Liam or Noel properly through the majority of the gig anyhow! The full show is on UA-cam, though.
A MASSIVE THANKS TO ALL THE GUYS WHO MADE THIS POSSIBLE
🎥
THIS SHOULD GET A DVD RELEASE WITH A PRO SOUND QUALITY AUDIO, IT'D BE MEGA.
King Monkey and his never ending supply of maracas! What a band! Fantastic upload!
thanks for making this, saw them in Jakarta 2013, one of the best band of all time... and they only put out 2 albums...
Glad you enjoyed it. Thanks
Stephen Hillman you are the best So many thanks
what a band our band my heart breaks thinking they are gone best thing ive watched in this whole fucked up year hope it is comming to the big screen
lol. Not sure it would stand up to a big screen unless they edit the footage they have. Love that though 'our band'. Mean so much to so many.
It was a great gig even from the back !
Cheers for uploading. That was an hour an half of sheer joy.