Why any religion gets so upset by questioning any aspect of its basis? I am a great admirer of Salman . He is a brave man to stand up to the mindless thugs. We must be able to question anything without fearing death.
@@NextStepEdificationhere you are wrong bro, we are angry upon seeing how they are filming such great gods of sanatana Dharma religion. If they really want to give religion an artistic view, they should do something better, bacho vaali movie mat bnayie pls, questioning not only the holiness of our gods but also the wisdom of our great great and the greatest director who have made this movie.... Hat's off to him
@@gtt_dikshashahi8054 , many thugs stood against Swamy Periyar who wrote ," Sachchi Ramayan ". But Periyar is right . See Jago Panch and Science Journey.
Islam is very clear that's why appeals to mind no gol mol stories Ask any question Zakir nair will give u answer, that's why u ppl don't like him . May almighty grant you wisdom.
Mahound does recognize that these verses about goddesses are devilish ---- and Mahound rejects these Satanic Verses------ so all this is not insult against Mohammad--- this may even be considered a tribute to Mohammad, ----- that Muhammad does reject satanic verses. So I do not see any insult against Islam or Mohammad!
यह समरी सुनने के बाद मुझे तो समझ में नहीं आया कि इनके खिलाफ फतवा क्यों दिया गया। इस समरी में तो मुझे नहीं लगा कि किसी रिलीजन के लिए कुछ गलत बोला गया। यह तो सिर्फ एक काल्पनिक कहानी है। इसे सिर्फ एक काल्पनिक कहानी की तरह ही लिया जाना चाहिए। बाकी कहानियों की तरह।
नाम क्यों क्यों रखा जिब्रील और आयशा तथा मोहम्मद से मिलता जुलता और बहुत कुछ सांकेतिक कुरान से संबंधित घटनाएँ भी! जबकि ये तो कुरान और हदीसों में कही बात के दोहराने पर भी सर तन से जुदा पर पहुंच जाते हैं! इसे ही चोर की दाढ़ी में तिनका, चोर मचाये शोर, चोरी और सीनाजोरी आदि कहते हैं! इसी बदमाशी के कारण सभ्य देश और इनसे परहेज करते हैं!
@@Platonism474 aise ghatiye channel share mat kro. We want a book summary not a defence of islam. It's funny that your God's religion need a defender😂. Science does not need a defender.
Muhammad saheb recited this but 200 years after him Muslim caliphate denounced and said that when Mohammed said he was possessed by shaitan ( Satan) and that’s why he praised the three female deities of Arabia
Ya hazart Muhammad ka character pa baat kar raha ha or aik jootha waqiya bayan kar raha jis ko Muslim Sahi nahi manta or hadees ma usa jootha kaha gaya ha. Ya waqiya log Muhammad peace upon him ka bara ma kahta hala ka ya aik jootha waqiya ha jisa is na apni book ma use kar ka aik jooth ko phalana ki Koshish ki ha or prophet ki toheen
@@unknown-vn6bqShi baat hai jhoota vakiya ku likhna shi shi vakiye likhne they jaise ki pedophile - 9 saal ki bacchi ke saath intercourse, rape of slaves and justifying it and killing innocent just because they are not following his relegion, calling women idiots, aasmaan pillar par tika hai joki dikhai nhi dete, earth flat hai, vo saari ghtiya chize or neech harkate jannat mai Jake pure ho jayegi Jo earth par kroge to jahanum mai jaogey, and list goes on
Is anyone muslim here,,, to tell me the exact thing,,, that why are the Muslims of whole world angry upon rushdie,, google says there is hate things about the prophet of mohamad,,,, but in this summary I don't anything related toh this much hate....... Can anyone please clear the thing?????? Bacz i will have a viva upon this satanic verses,, on 24th of this month.
All characters name and story are related to muslim history and very pathetically recreated. Only a muslim can understand what he did and how he is insulting the religious personalities via his satanic mind.
@@dinkuabc I haven’t read it. I’m not Muslim, but respect all religions, and don’t enjoy anything bad about any religion, so why should I do something I don’t enjoy. I do know that this book was written with intent to be offensive.
बांग्लादेश की लेखिका तसरीन नसरीन ने लज्जा नाम की किताब लिखी थी राजीव गांधी ने बिना पढ़े वो किताब पर प्रतिबंध लगा दिया था लेकिन वो किताब में ऐसा कुछ नहीं था केवल कट्टर मुल्लो के बारे में लिखा था.
अगर यही समरी है इस उपन्यास की तो बहुत ही वाहियात उपन्यास है यह और हां यही कहानी है इस उपन्यास की तो इस पर किसी को मारने का फतवा क्यों जारी हुआ है बात कुछ समझ में नहीं आ रही है जरूर कुछ ऐसी बात है जिसको आपने समरी में छोड़ दिया है
سر میں درد ہوگیا میں بچپن سے سنتا آرہا ہوں کہ یہ ہے وہ ہے ۔😂یہ تو کسی ہالی وڈ فلم کی اسٹوری لگ رہی ہے شاید یہ لوگ فلم بنانے سے ڈر رہے ہیں تبھی کتاب شکل دے کر دیکھنا چاہتے ہیں کہ مسلمان غصہ کرتے ہیں ۔۔یہ کتاب صرف اگر اردو میں یا ہندی میں ہوتی تو کسی کی سمجھ میں نہیں آتی۔😂😂😂دنیا آج بھی نا سمجھ ہیں ایک نفسیاتی مریض کو اتنی اہمیت دے رے ہیں
Ye kitab english me thi. Urdu ya hindi me nahi. Aur ye kitab kisi Hollywood film ki story nhi h. Tumhare nasamazhpn ke waja se hi tum log easily brainwashed ho jate ho 😂.
It is easier for a writer like Rushdie to attack any religion and become famous.Even if U read his Midnight Children,he depicts Saleem Sanai the protagonist as if he alone represents India.Ithink Gabriel Garcia Marquez has used Magic Realism in a better manner.
This novel is merely a complex fictional story and nothing else. It doesn't attack on any religion. I personally feel that characters and fictional parts of the story are extracted from old Grecian and Egyptian goddess and gods.Low standard of fiction.
This story and characters are match with kuran. This all shows that Muhammad was lier about allah and he was not a prophet but regular man. Muslims do feel insulted on this.
Congratulations on reading the novel and comprehending the story. I gave up after making several attempts. I found it very uninteresting and idiotic. What is the point or moral of the story. No one would've read it , had it not been for the controversy.
It's not a smooth story.Why did the author used the dreams,what did he want to express,what is the message of this novel! the author supported monotheist religion,opposed polythesism and matriarchy....does he express his disbelief in pilgrimage?At last the feresta or angel is nothing but a common man who doesn't have solution for earthly problems.
Publicity stunt is western means to make money like sex and religion, your freedom doesn't allow to insult, Among the believer's of Naipaul and Mokhtara mai, The sword of Islam are few examples.
It's a fictitous drama with him that people wud be confussed lack of understanding the Quran Regarding Gibreel and Muhammad there's something wrong to understand the Meaning of Gubreel and Quranic Muhammad. Note According to Quran Gibril is not a farishtey and Quit different between Historical and Quranic Muhammad.
No madam, no , you are probably right. But first of all this fiction book is a perfectly written TRILOGY. Perhaps you have no experience of reading a trilogy. Actually 3 stories are expounded in this book. Secondly, if anyone has knowledge of the background Islamic subjective history only he/she can understand that what/where he ( the author) is talking about. Or anyone who masters the subject literature he/she can understand it. As somebody commented, very complex or a difficult novel. ( Because actually a trilogy) . Sir Rushdie actually underestimated the capacity of understanding of the Muslim educated youth of that times ( 1988) . He wanted to inspire the world of English literature only. Technically of course it is the best ever trilogy written in English. But he couldn't estimate its reaction on the mindsets of the Muslims. Unfortunately one part of this trilogy proved to be absolutely absurd with respect to the muslim's fundamental belief system. And the muslim scholars interpreted Mahound for the prophet Muhammad ( salallahu we Alaisalam) , Ayesha, the wife of prophet, and the Immame , the Immam Khomeini himself...and all his characters some substitute of the character in islamic history. For example the town of Jahilia , substitute of the Mecca town 1400 years ago. He ( auther ) took it easy, same like editor of the magazine Charlie Habdo . But the Muslims and Immame Khomeini took it seriously, as he ( auther ) has tried to alter the muslim history and that also making the mockery of it . And then power is always the power whatever the Russian, American, or Iranian. And he got the hard time , which everyone knows. And you our dear UA-camr firstly try to understand all three portions of the trilogy separately. Then comment on them also separating them from eachother. Otherwise this is a very difficult book even the masters in English literature avoid to talk about it. Because of political reasons this book couldn't obtain the Nobel prize , otherwise technically it was of that level. And miraculous about this book is, it got sold millions of copies because of the Immame Khomeini's verdict ( Fatwa). That also is a truth about this book .
m proud to be kafir and sanathani my dharm always stands on adhyayana(study) manana(memorisation , thinking ), mandana(analysing and argumentation) and khandana (criticisim) any of its sect and aspects jai shri ram
This information is spot on! The word "Iqra" indeed has multiple meanings, including "read", "learn", and "recite". This is a beautiful example of the Quran's linguistic and semantic depth. When Jibreel (Gabriel) said "Iqra" to the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), it was a deliberate choice of word, encompassing all three meanings. The Prophet's responses, "I cannot read", highlight the gradual revelation of the word's meanings. 1. "Iqra" as "read" - The Prophet was initially hesitant, feeling unable to read. 2. "Iqra" as "learn" - Jibreel's persistence encouraged the Prophet to learn and understand. 3. "Iqra" as "recite" - Finally, the Prophet recited the words of Surah Al-'Alaq (96:1-5), marking the beginning of his prophetic mission. This nuanced understanding of "Iqra" underscores the Quran's emphasis on knowledge, learning, and the transmission of divine guidance. This theory beautifully captures the essence of this pivotal moment in Islamic history! While yall being dramatic cringes Btw iam all aware how yall not so whitewashed hindus call non hindus as mleccas and also ruling on how to treat mleccas 😂😂😂
Here are Quranic verses mentioning "Darul-Al-Bab" (People of Logical Thinking) and emphasizing rational thinking: *Darul-Al-Bab (People of Logical Thinking)* 1. Quran 38:29: "This is a Book which We have revealed unto thee, full of blessings, that they may ponder over its verses, and that Darul-Al-Bab (people of understanding) may reflect." 2. Quran 40:54: "And thus We have revealed it as a clear Arabic Quran, that you may understand, and [so that] Darul-Al-Bab (people of understanding) may take heed." *Rational Thinking and Logic* 1. Quran 8:22: "And indeed, the worst of living creatures in the sight of Allah are the deaf and dumb who do not use their intellect." 2. Quran 7:179: "And indeed, We have created many of the jinn and mankind for Hell. They have hearts wherewith they understand not, and they have eyes wherewith they see not, and they have ears wherewith they hear not." *Intellectual Discourse and Debate* 1. Quran 16:125: "Invite to the way of your Lord with wisdom and good instruction, and argue with them in a way that is best." 2. Quran 29:46: "And argue not with the People of the Scripture except by the way which is best." *Critical Thinking and Reflection* 1. Quran 47:24: "Do they not ponder over the Quran, or are there locks upon their hearts?" 2. Quran 23:68: "Now have they not pondered over the Word, or has there come to them what came not to their fathers of old?" *Ulul-Al-Bab (People of Understanding)* 1. Quran 3:190: "Indeed, in the creation of the heavens and the earth and the alternation of the night and the day are signs for Ulul-Al-Bab (people of understanding)." 2. Quran 39:9: "Are those who know equal to those who know not? Only Ulul-Al-Bab (people of understanding) take heed." These verses emphasize the importance of: 1. Logical thinking and rational understanding. 2. Intellectual discourse and debate. 3. Critical thinking and reflection. 4. Seeking knowledge and wisdom. Would you like more verses or explanations? And all humanity are equal in the sight of god no arab or non arab is over each other Allahu akbar !!! 🏴🏳✨️
टीवी डिबेट में भी अपना आपा खो बैठते है भले ही सामने वाला जो किताब में लिखा है वहीं बात करता है वो ये लिखा हुवा सत्य भी स्वीकारने के लिए तैयार नहीं होता और गाली गलौज पर आ जाते है यही हालत जाकिर नायक की है वो भी सामनेवाले की कोई बात स्वीकारने के लिए तैयार नहीं होता और कह देता है में आप को सुनने के लिए तैयार नहीं हु मेरा दस लाख फॉलोवर्स है क्या आप इतने लोग इकठ्ठा कर सकते हो यही साबित करता है आप मुझे से मुकाबला करने बिल्कुल लाइक नहीं है!!!!
शांत सौम्य श्री इरफान जी दूरदर्शन के राज्य सभा टीबी के शो में सीमा चिश्ती इसे इस किताब को कूड़ा कहती हैं, जो कि उन दिनों बीबीसी को प्रतिनिधित्व को करती थी, और इस किताब की बीबीसी , श्रेष्ठ मानवों का समूह जो किताब को लेकर इस्लाम और इस्लामिक देशों के सामने सही समीक्षा विश्लेषण नहीं कर सकी। सामान्यत किसी समूह के सदस्य के द्वारा भी उस समूह का या उसके मंच से कहा जाना उसका ही कहना ही है। वर्षों तक यह शोर क्यों चलता रहा हैं
@@tsering5709 , if you don't know anything better keep quiet, don't jump in anything and anywhere, first get knowledge then speak. Narrow minded person you are
Achhi to hai. Isme aisa kuchh nhi hai jo ki kisi religion k against ho. Kuchh logo ka dimag kharab hota hai. Isaliye kisi bhi chij ko kahi bhi add krk Politics Card khelate hai.
@@tsering5709 Yes my mind is small because it has no capacity for the bigotry which western powers wanted to infuse in the ignorant people. Dear Tsering if I verbally abuse you and your father with the religion which you are subscribing to, then you would also have become a small minded person.
Sapne to Mohammed Sahab Ko Aate the lekin Salman Rusi Sahab Ne jibreel ko Chuna Kuchh Maut Se Pahle ke Sapnon Mein jite Hain Kuchh Maut Ke bad ke Sapnon Mein Yahi line Manavta ke liye Ghatak hai
Sapne tu sabhi dekhte lekin kuch maut se pahle ke sapno main jite hai aur kuch maut ke baad ke sapno main aur yahi aksar manavta keliye ghatak ho jati hai Kya deep line boli hai yaar tum ne sach sach bolo kaha se churaya
Ager koe pavitr kitab aap ke bhalae ke baat kerte ho r aap usme ghaltiya nikaloge to bura kiska hoga ? Na dharm ka hoga na kitab ka hoga bura hoga manavta ka. Andhkar me doob jaoge. Aaj kaha jaye apne bahu betiyo ko sati karo ,to karoge ? Nahi , lekin pehle to kerte the r yehi dharm tha.
I don't mean to hurt your feelings, but I am sorry to say the style of your narrative delivery is not really inspiring for the listener, rather repetitive and monotonic. You need to work on your speach and speed skills , learn to give credit to the listeners' common senses and not keep repeating things - it makes the listener lose interest. I hope you will take this as a positive feedback to improve, and grow upon
मुझे तो नही लगा कि इसमें पैगंबर मोहम्माद या कुरान के विषय में कुछ अपमान जनक हैं! तीन देवियो का जिक्र कुरान में भी हैं और बाद में इन्हे शैतान की आयत कहा गया हैं! ये विषय क्यों चुना! इस दोष के कारण उन्हे दंड मिला!
Muslim itane chote hogaye hai injise tusche writer se dar lagta hai ,nabi ki saan me ye kuch bhi lekh de kay farak padta hai ye hame ulzana cahate hai taki muslim school bank stock market college engineering medical College hospital khol na sake ,in nafti logo ko bolne do aachi baat hai ,jo nabi se allha ki chahat ho ye duniya ki insan jinki age 50 saal hai who kay Jane allha our mohammad martaba
Why any religion gets so upset by questioning any aspect of its basis? I am a great admirer of Salman . He is a brave man to stand up to the mindless thugs. We must be able to question anything without fearing death.
@@NextStepEdificationhere you are wrong bro, we are angry upon seeing how they are filming such great gods of sanatana Dharma religion. If they really want to give religion an artistic view, they should do something better, bacho vaali movie mat bnayie pls, questioning not only the holiness of our gods but also the wisdom of our great great and the greatest director who have made this movie.... Hat's off to him
@@gtt_dikshashahi8054 , many thugs stood against Swamy Periyar who wrote ," Sachchi Ramayan ".
But Periyar is right .
See Jago Panch and Science Journey.
Islam is very clear that's why appeals to mind no gol mol stories
Ask any question Zakir nair will give u answer, that's why u ppl don't like him .
May almighty grant you wisdom.
@@vinodtohani9577 because they belive they need to protect their GOD who dont have the power to self protect
@@sabasami1454 you are half brained according to Islam so shut up
Truth is bitter, followers have not digested the revelation by Rushdi
ayatollah gave his fatwa without reading it .just like some Indian muslims
Even I haven't red it but he has given a very dirty title, one should never play with such things it's very sensitive.
Correct.
@@sabasami1454 YT cancelled my reply .YT defends the "immoral beduin"in Kemal ataturk words .
@@sabasami1454 when mohamed started his religion he shouldnt be questioning others too
Mahound does recognize that these verses about goddesses are devilish ---- and Mahound rejects these Satanic Verses------ so all this is not insult against Mohammad--- this may even be considered a tribute to Mohammad, ----- that Muhammad does reject satanic verses. So I do not see any insult against Islam or Mohammad!
यह समरी सुनने के बाद मुझे तो समझ में नहीं आया कि इनके खिलाफ फतवा क्यों दिया गया। इस समरी में तो मुझे नहीं लगा कि किसी रिलीजन के लिए कुछ गलत बोला गया। यह तो सिर्फ एक काल्पनिक कहानी है। इसे सिर्फ एक काल्पनिक कहानी की तरह ही लिया जाना चाहिए। बाकी कहानियों की तरह।
Yes
नाम क्यों क्यों रखा जिब्रील और आयशा तथा मोहम्मद से मिलता जुलता और बहुत कुछ सांकेतिक कुरान से संबंधित घटनाएँ भी!
जबकि ये तो कुरान और हदीसों में कही बात के दोहराने पर भी सर तन से जुदा पर पहुंच जाते हैं! इसे ही चोर की दाढ़ी में तिनका, चोर मचाये शोर, चोरी और सीनाजोरी आदि कहते हैं!
इसी बदमाशी के कारण सभ्य देश और इनसे परहेज करते हैं!
She has just picked burning topic. She is not either dare to present topic clearely or simply need get view becuz of incident that happend
Strongly agree. 👍
@@Platonism474 aise ghatiye channel share mat kro. We want a book summary not a defence of islam. It's funny that your God's religion need a defender😂. Science does not need a defender.
Muhammad saheb recited this but 200 years after him Muslim caliphate denounced and said that when Mohammed said he was possessed by shaitan ( Satan) and that’s why he praised the three female deities of Arabia
Praised my foot !!!
Read surah najm !! For easy refute of ur propaganda fallacy
U wannabe cringe!!!!
@@syedbasheeruddin6934 truth hurts
This novel has a very complex fictional story. It is not any insult against Islam or Prophet. Why Muslims are upset about this book.
Because they are illerate uneducated
Ya hazart Muhammad ka character pa baat kar raha ha or aik jootha waqiya bayan kar raha jis ko Muslim Sahi nahi manta or hadees ma usa jootha kaha gaya ha. Ya waqiya log Muhammad peace upon him ka bara ma kahta hala ka ya aik jootha waqiya ha jisa is na apni book ma use kar ka aik jooth ko phalana ki Koshish ki ha or prophet ki toheen
@@unknown-vn6bq मादृचोद्व को xpose कर रहा हराम के😂😂
@@unknown-vn6bqShi baat hai jhoota vakiya ku likhna shi shi vakiye likhne they jaise ki pedophile - 9 saal ki bacchi ke saath intercourse, rape of slaves and justifying it and killing innocent just because they are not following his relegion, calling women idiots, aasmaan pillar par tika hai joki dikhai nhi dete, earth flat hai, vo saari ghtiya chize or neech harkate jannat mai Jake pure ho jayegi Jo earth par kroge to jahanum mai jaogey, and list goes on
The reason they are upset about it is written in first sentence of your comment, and that is “a very complex fictional story”.
Classic work of Salman Rushdi....
Is anyone muslim here,,, to tell me the exact thing,,, that why are the Muslims of whole world angry upon rushdie,, google says there is hate things about the prophet of mohamad,,,, but in this summary I don't anything related toh this much hate....... Can anyone please clear the thing?????? Bacz i will have a viva upon this satanic verses,, on 24th of this month.
All characters name and story are related to muslim history and very pathetically recreated. Only a muslim can understand what he did and how he is insulting the religious personalities via his satanic mind.
Nice explanation....Even in India it is ban..
Indian government's from 1947 was/is against Non Muslims..
& It is till now in 2022.
Koi ban nahi haa bhai. Har jagah mil jata haa.
Why Congress banned this super book
Vote bank ka chakkar babu bhaiya😂
मोदी ने बैंड क्यू नही हटाए 😂😂😂😂
It's essentially Indian Muslim Congress
😂😂😂😂 hat gya @@478patel
By hearing the story... One thing is clear...those who oppose They don't know their book and didnt read saitanic verses
Did you read it, or are you judging by this video?
@@Nozarks1 i didnt read but...know the story... If you read it tell me whats ofending you in that
@@dinkuabc I haven’t read it. I’m not Muslim, but respect all religions, and don’t enjoy anything bad about any religion, so why should I do something I don’t enjoy. I do know that this book was written with intent to be offensive.
I can't respect all religions but If masses of people starts to worship a demon or a rapist, such religion should not be respected .
Bahut bahut dhanyvaad 🌈🙏🌸 kahaani sunaane ka apka ye initiative bahut achha laga 👍
Praying for Salman rushdie, who is admitted in New York after stabbing incident
No religion tolerates questioning, It only wants obedience, faith - have faith!
except hindiusm ok!!!! hindiusm stands only adhyayana(study) manana(memorisation), mandana(argumentation) and khandana (criticisim)
Shashtrart/debates ki freedom har religion nhi deta, kai to khulke bolte hai, akal ka dakhal nhi😂
बांग्लादेश की लेखिका तसरीन नसरीन ने लज्जा नाम की किताब लिखी थी राजीव गांधी ने बिना पढ़े वो किताब पर प्रतिबंध लगा दिया था लेकिन वो किताब में ऐसा कुछ नहीं था केवल कट्टर मुल्लो के बारे में लिखा था.
Itni bakwas kahani aur uske upar yah log mare ja rahe Hain murkhon ki puri ek jamaat hai
Kahani ke peeche maqsad ko samajna zroori hai.
@@smshafique9873 tmne samjha h kya ?
@@brijmohanyadavsriganganaga7883 Bilkul.
In fact mere bas mein hota toh mai bhi fatwa jaari karta taaki koi aage aisi bakwaas novel likh kar bakwaas logon ke celebrity banne se baaz aaye.
What is the problem?
Where does it insult Islam.?
It is fictional , does not criticize any religion.
अगर यही समरी है इस उपन्यास की तो बहुत ही
वाहियात उपन्यास है यह
और हां यही कहानी है इस उपन्यास की तो इस पर किसी को मारने का फतवा क्यों जारी हुआ है
बात कुछ समझ में नहीं आ रही है
जरूर कुछ ऐसी बात है जिसको आपने समरी में
छोड़ दिया है
Yes, as per summary, the novel has no purpose or magical powers.
Nor any money charms seem hidden in it.
SriRam.
One must read this fiction,before they die. Salman is a intelligent writer, jai hind ...
What say and what intension by That Controversial story anyone tell me
Muslims should not have protested over this garbage. Muslims themselves made this book famous.
You are right
Kitab bananewala sabse bada c
Padhnewale usse bade c
Bann kernewale toh c++ 😂😂😂😂
Ruushdi didnot Express any wrong idea against Islam. I don't understand why Khomaini gave fatwa?
Bahut ummid se is ko suna lekin dimagh ka dahi hogya...
😂😂😂
Happy that you narrated this story.
Thank you so much.
People should be aware of this narrative by Islamists
Just because a book has been written on imaginary characters , it it does not mean that the author should be attacked .
Everyone can share a bad message for a definite religion. But, this shouldn't right.
سر میں درد ہوگیا میں بچپن سے سنتا آرہا ہوں کہ یہ ہے وہ ہے ۔😂یہ تو کسی ہالی وڈ فلم کی اسٹوری لگ رہی ہے شاید یہ لوگ فلم بنانے سے ڈر رہے ہیں تبھی کتاب شکل دے کر دیکھنا چاہتے ہیں کہ مسلمان غصہ کرتے ہیں ۔۔یہ کتاب صرف اگر اردو میں یا ہندی میں ہوتی تو کسی کی سمجھ میں نہیں آتی۔😂😂😂دنیا آج بھی نا سمجھ ہیں ایک نفسیاتی مریض کو اتنی اہمیت دے رے ہیں
Ye kitab english me thi. Urdu ya hindi me nahi. Aur ye kitab kisi Hollywood film ki story nhi h. Tumhare nasamazhpn ke waja se hi tum log easily brainwashed ho jate ho 😂.
Will definitely read it..
Yah to bataayi nhi ki muslims kis baat par naaraz hue . Story to bilkul useless lagati hai . Kuchh mtlb hi nhi nikalata .
Rushdhi sahb get well soon
ua-cam.com/video/Rq0vqMYNK54/v-deo.html
Mam 3 September MEG4(ASPECTS OF LANGUAGE) Exam hai.....please ek last minute Suggestion de dijiye.... please mam
It is easier for a writer like Rushdie to attack any religion and become famous.Even if U read his Midnight Children,he depicts Saleem Sanai the protagonist as if he alone represents India.Ithink Gabriel Garcia Marquez has used Magic Realism in a better manner.
Good.... The while book should be uploaded on net as audio book..... so that people can know what it contains.....
This novel is merely a complex fictional story and nothing else. It doesn't attack on any religion. I personally feel that characters and fictional parts of the story are extracted from old Grecian and Egyptian goddess and gods.Low standard of fiction.
Gibril is there in yehudis also
इसका मतलब है की सच का एन्काऊंटर
Es story me controversy kya hai mujhe to kuch nhi pta chla
This story and characters are match with kuran. This all shows that Muhammad was lier about allah and he was not a prophet but regular man. Muslims do feel insulted on this.
@@RajeshPatel-fk2os accha 👍
Congratulations on reading the novel and comprehending the story. I gave up after making several attempts. I found it very uninteresting and idiotic. What is the point or moral of the story.
No one would've read it , had it not been for the controversy.
Muslim made this famous
Jahalat is the hallmark of muz la 😊
It's not a smooth story.Why did the author used the dreams,what did he want to express,what is the message of this novel! the author supported monotheist religion,opposed polythesism and matriarchy....does he express his disbelief in pilgrimage?At last the feresta or angel is nothing but a common man who doesn't have solution for earthly problems.
I Also Didn't Understood Any Logic Behind It. Although I Am Hindu
Misinterpretation leads to all these issues 😢
Time pass Kids Stories... From U K..😅😅😅
Publicity stunt is western means to make money like sex and religion, your freedom doesn't allow to insult, Among the believer's of Naipaul and Mokhtara mai, The sword of Islam are few examples.
I have subscribed your channel,and I appreciate your your.yoy have described in Hindi language in good manners.Once again thankyou
ISLAM MAI AUR MOHAMMAD SAAB NE KABHI KHOON KARNE KI BAAT NAHI KAHI TO HUM KON HOTE HAI ❤
Bhai kis se jhuth bol rahe ho, yeh internet wala generation hai sab ko sab kuchh pata hai..😅😅😅
this novel made Salman rushdie rich and famous 😅
It's a fictitous drama with him that people wud be confussed lack of understanding the Quran
Regarding Gibreel and Muhammad there's something wrong to understand the Meaning of Gubreel and Quranic Muhammad.
Note According to Quran Gibril is not a farishtey and Quit different between Historical and Quranic Muhammad.
No madam, no , you are probably right. But first of all this fiction book is a perfectly written TRILOGY. Perhaps you have no experience of reading a trilogy. Actually 3 stories are expounded in this book. Secondly, if anyone has knowledge of the background Islamic subjective history only he/she can understand that what/where he ( the author) is talking about. Or anyone who masters the subject literature he/she can understand it. As somebody commented, very complex or a difficult novel. ( Because actually a trilogy) . Sir Rushdie actually underestimated the capacity of understanding of the Muslim educated youth of that times ( 1988) . He wanted to inspire the world of English literature only. Technically of course it is the best ever trilogy written in English. But he couldn't estimate its reaction on the mindsets of the Muslims. Unfortunately one part of this trilogy proved to be absolutely absurd with respect to the muslim's fundamental belief system. And the muslim scholars interpreted Mahound for the prophet Muhammad ( salallahu we Alaisalam) , Ayesha, the wife of prophet, and the Immame , the Immam Khomeini himself...and all his characters some substitute of the character in islamic history. For example the town of Jahilia , substitute of the Mecca town 1400 years ago. He ( auther ) took it easy, same like editor of the magazine Charlie Habdo . But the Muslims and Immame Khomeini took it seriously, as he ( auther ) has tried to alter the muslim history and that also making the mockery of it . And then power is always the power whatever the Russian, American, or Iranian. And he got the hard time , which everyone knows. And you our dear UA-camr firstly try to understand all three portions of the trilogy separately. Then comment on them also separating them from eachother. Otherwise this is a very difficult book even the masters in English literature avoid to talk about it. Because of political reasons this book couldn't obtain the Nobel prize , otherwise technically it was of that level. And miraculous about this book is, it got sold millions of copies because of the Immame Khomeini's verdict ( Fatwa). That also is a truth about this book .
यह आश्चर्य की बात है कि कोई इतनी मूर्खतापूर्ण उपन्यास लिख सकता है, कोई छाप सकता है और लोग पढ़ भी लेते हैं🐒🐒🐒
Usse se murkhtapurn ye hai jo is pustak ko padhne wale ko murkh khta hai chutiya sala Sandeep nam rkhne se tu bidwan ho jayega.
Tumhara comment suggest karta h ki tum se bada moorkh koi nahi ho sakta
m proud to be kafir and sanathani my dharm always stands on adhyayana(study) manana(memorisation , thinking ), mandana(analysing and argumentation) and khandana (criticisim) any of its sect and aspects jai shri ram
This information is spot on! The word "Iqra" indeed has multiple meanings, including "read", "learn", and "recite". This is a beautiful example of the Quran's linguistic and semantic depth.
When Jibreel (Gabriel) said "Iqra" to the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), it was a deliberate choice of word, encompassing all three meanings. The Prophet's responses, "I cannot read", highlight the gradual revelation of the word's meanings.
1. "Iqra" as "read" - The Prophet was initially hesitant, feeling unable to read.
2. "Iqra" as "learn" - Jibreel's persistence encouraged the Prophet to learn and understand.
3. "Iqra" as "recite" - Finally, the Prophet recited the words of Surah Al-'Alaq (96:1-5), marking the beginning of his prophetic mission.
This nuanced understanding of "Iqra" underscores the Quran's emphasis on knowledge, learning, and the transmission of divine guidance. This theory beautifully captures the essence of this pivotal moment in Islamic history!
While yall being dramatic cringes
Btw iam all aware how yall not so whitewashed hindus call non hindus as mleccas and also ruling on how to treat mleccas
😂😂😂
Here are Quranic verses mentioning "Darul-Al-Bab" (People of Logical Thinking) and emphasizing rational thinking:
*Darul-Al-Bab (People of Logical Thinking)*
1. Quran 38:29: "This is a Book which We have revealed unto thee, full of blessings, that they may ponder over its verses, and that Darul-Al-Bab (people of understanding) may reflect."
2. Quran 40:54: "And thus We have revealed it as a clear Arabic Quran, that you may understand, and [so that] Darul-Al-Bab (people of understanding) may take heed."
*Rational Thinking and Logic*
1. Quran 8:22: "And indeed, the worst of living creatures in the sight of Allah are the deaf and dumb who do not use their intellect."
2. Quran 7:179: "And indeed, We have created many of the jinn and mankind for Hell. They have hearts wherewith they understand not, and they have eyes wherewith they see not, and they have ears wherewith they hear not."
*Intellectual Discourse and Debate*
1. Quran 16:125: "Invite to the way of your Lord with wisdom and good instruction, and argue with them in a way that is best."
2. Quran 29:46: "And argue not with the People of the Scripture except by the way which is best."
*Critical Thinking and Reflection*
1. Quran 47:24: "Do they not ponder over the Quran, or are there locks upon their hearts?"
2. Quran 23:68: "Now have they not pondered over the Word, or has there come to them what came not to their fathers of old?"
*Ulul-Al-Bab (People of Understanding)*
1. Quran 3:190: "Indeed, in the creation of the heavens and the earth and the alternation of the night and the day are signs for Ulul-Al-Bab (people of understanding)."
2. Quran 39:9: "Are those who know equal to those who know not? Only Ulul-Al-Bab (people of understanding) take heed."
These verses emphasize the importance of:
1. Logical thinking and rational understanding.
2. Intellectual discourse and debate.
3. Critical thinking and reflection.
4. Seeking knowledge and wisdom.
Would you like more verses or explanations?
And all humanity are equal in the sight of god no arab or non arab is over each other
Allahu akbar !!!
🏴🏳✨️
टीवी डिबेट में भी अपना आपा खो बैठते है भले ही सामने वाला जो किताब में लिखा है वहीं बात करता है वो ये लिखा हुवा सत्य भी स्वीकारने के लिए तैयार नहीं होता और गाली गलौज पर आ जाते है यही हालत जाकिर नायक की है वो भी सामनेवाले की कोई बात स्वीकारने के लिए तैयार नहीं होता और कह देता है में आप को सुनने के लिए तैयार नहीं हु मेरा दस लाख फॉलोवर्स है क्या आप इतने लोग इकठ्ठा कर सकते हो यही साबित करता है आप मुझे से मुकाबला करने बिल्कुल लाइक नहीं है!!!!
Thank you Salmon
Only one mistake id in this novel is, used some neme, s as jibreal, lath, manath, uzza, are taken from islamic or Quran.
I couldn't understand details. As I listened i think It is simply a story like Ramayan & Mahabharat
Thanks for informatve video.👍
शांत सौम्य श्री इरफान जी दूरदर्शन के राज्य सभा टीबी के शो में सीमा चिश्ती इसे इस किताब को कूड़ा कहती हैं, जो कि उन दिनों बीबीसी को प्रतिनिधित्व को करती थी, और इस किताब की बीबीसी , श्रेष्ठ मानवों का समूह जो किताब को लेकर इस्लाम और इस्लामिक देशों के सामने सही समीक्षा विश्लेषण नहीं कर सकी। सामान्यत किसी समूह के सदस्य के द्वारा भी उस समूह का या उसके मंच से कहा जाना उसका ही कहना ही है। वर्षों तक यह शोर क्यों चलता रहा हैं
Aapne bahut acchhe se present kii hai storyko
Thank you very much mam 😊
खोमेनी अब तक जिंदा है?
Meg 7-10-14 kya ye IGNOU k easy subject bataiyega plz??😊
Nabi nhi rangila tha😂
Nothing objectionable why muslims are beating their chest ,it is a fictional drama and nothing like blasphemy .
This novel doesn't make any sense.The plot of the novel fails.the characters of the novel are not fictional but They have been taken deliberately.
Vultures monsters sick Shameful
@@tsering5709 😊
It seems like a shahrukh khan and karan johar story... What a fun
Do u know madam, this book is banned in India
Madam,it is banned in India,I should keep in mind.
The midnight children wrote by Salman rushdie
Dedicated to all the duplicate converteds in Kerala .....enjoy
I also pray that he get
Wors place in Jahanum.
Amin
I pray diminish theses Vultures monsters killing innocents in the name of religion shameful ..Speedy recovery Prayers
@@saniaaa321 straight to hell the criminals murderers
@@tsering5709 , if you don't know anything better keep quiet, don't jump in anything and anywhere, first get knowledge then speak. Narrow minded person you are
If this is what is written in Salman Rushdie's book, then there is no need to kill him, he is a psychopath, he needs a doctor
If this is a lie why everyone want him d ?
He chanted satanic verses, fir to nabi ke against hi fatwa jari hona chaiye tha
आपकी आवाज कंगना से मिलती है।
Madam this book is banned in India
Achhi to hai. Isme aisa kuchh nhi hai jo ki kisi religion k against ho. Kuchh logo ka dimag kharab hota hai. Isaliye kisi bhi chij ko kahi bhi add krk Politics Card khelate hai.
You are telling old story that we know
Have you read the novel
I fear not
If you have tell us about its contents and literary appraisal
कोई नही बचेगा। 😂😄😉😃😉😃😙
Salman Rushdie is a great bigot.
small minded elements
@@tsering5709 Yes my mind is small because it has no capacity for the bigotry which western powers wanted to infuse in the ignorant people.
Dear Tsering if I verbally abuse you and your father with the religion which you are subscribing to, then you would also have become a small minded person.
Presentation is not satisfactory."Hai" ka ❤❤❤p❤❤ra❤❤❤❤yo❤❤g❤❤❤
A overrated book with ordinary story. the book gets hyped because govt banned it.
चोर की ढाड़ी में तिनका है
Sapne to Mohammed Sahab Ko Aate the lekin Salman Rusi Sahab Ne jibreel ko Chuna Kuchh Maut Se Pahle ke Sapnon Mein jite Hain Kuchh Maut Ke bad ke Sapnon Mein Yahi line Manavta ke liye Ghatak hai
Sapne tu sabhi dekhte lekin kuch maut se pahle ke sapno main jite hai aur kuch maut ke baad ke sapno main aur yahi aksar manavta keliye ghatak ho jati hai
Kya deep line boli hai yaar tum ne sach sach bolo kaha se churaya
@@TrinityKnot88 tauqir हुसैन I know you know this, 72hoor ,kayamat ka din aur maut से pahle khushhal parivaar के sapne
@@0Bharat main tu humour mean bola bhai tum etna kyon bhadak rahe ho
@@0Bharat aur mere naam ki spelling bhi tum ne galat likhi hai
@@TrinityKnot88 😄no mention
All are mad . Christian or Muslim both are same religious story. 🙏
They worship two different Gods.
Isme fatwa kyu lagaya lekin ?????
Very nice story... thanks maam for telling this story...
Thank you
@@Ashwajitpalande9162 welcome
Ager koe pavitr kitab aap ke bhalae ke baat kerte ho r aap usme ghaltiya nikaloge to bura kiska hoga ? Na dharm ka hoga na kitab ka hoga bura hoga manavta ka. Andhkar me doob jaoge.
Aaj kaha jaye apne bahu betiyo ko sati karo ,to karoge ? Nahi , lekin pehle to kerte the r yehi dharm tha.
I don't mean to hurt your feelings, but I am sorry to say the style of your narrative delivery is not really inspiring for the listener, rather repetitive and monotonic. You need to work on your speach and speed skills , learn to give credit to the listeners' common senses and not keep repeating things - it makes the listener lose interest. I hope you will take this as a positive feedback to improve, and grow upon
Only names se pareshani hai
😔😔😔Most bored Faaaaaaltu item.. confused.. Kids story.. Ever heared... 😔😔😔
This community gets offended by everything, ashamed of nothing
Says a hindu the irony
मुझे तो नही लगा कि इसमें पैगंबर मोहम्माद या कुरान के विषय में कुछ अपमान जनक हैं! तीन देवियो का जिक्र कुरान में भी हैं और बाद में इन्हे शैतान की आयत कहा गया हैं!
ये विषय क्यों चुना! इस दोष के कारण उन्हे दंड मिला!
Thanks
Congress raaj ke under hum n is kitab mein kya likha hai ye batein krnne ki himmat kishi left gadu ne dikhayi.
rushdi sahab great man
❤
ua-cam.com/video/Rq0vqMYNK54/v-deo.html
ua-cam.com/video/Rq0vqMYNK54/v-deo.html
Rasgulla hi saitan tha,
Oh Ye bach gya
tera जीजाजी tha
Pr tu nhi bachega😁
Muslim itane chote hogaye hai injise tusche writer se dar lagta hai ,nabi ki saan me ye kuch bhi lekh de kay farak padta hai ye hame ulzana cahate hai taki muslim school bank stock market college engineering medical College hospital khol na sake ,in nafti logo ko bolne do aachi baat hai ,jo nabi se allha ki chahat ho ye duniya ki insan jinki age 50 saal hai who kay Jane allha our mohammad martaba
I need the book.
दीदी पहले बोलने का अभ्यास कीजिये। बार बार जो है, शब्द का उच्चारण मत कीजिये। इरिटेड करता है।
Great presentation 👏