What are the Satanic Verses? | Dr. Shabir Ally
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 тра 2024
- The Satanic Verses is a term used in academic literature to refer to purported verses of the Quran which, according to some narratives, were once recited by Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) and taken to be a part of the Quran, but soon after denounced by the Prophet as having a Satanic origin and removed, leaving behind a strict monotheistic text. It became infamous because from a non-Muslim point of view, it would seem that the Prophet could not distinguish between what is Satanic and what is from God. Dr. Shabir Ally explains that the story doesn't arise from the most authentic narratives of the Prophet's life, and he shares John Burton's theory about how the story was concocted and why Muslims embraced it.
If you enjoy this video, please support our work financially by visiting our website www.quranspeaks.com OR sending an etransfer to igive@quranspeaks.com OR subscribing monthly at patreon.com/quranspeaks
► DONATE: www.quranspeaks.com/
► SUBSCRIBE: ua-cam.com/users/subscription_...
COMMENT, LIKE and SHARE
Facebook: / letthequranspeak
Instagram: / quranspeaks.tv
Twitter: / quran_speaks
How is it possible that the prophet didn't recognise Satan and he thought it was Gabriel??
Perhaps he was not perfect.
Because he was human and human make mistakes all the time.
The truth
Many modern Muslim scholars have rejected the story. Arguments for rejection are found in Muhammad Abduh's article "Masʾalat al-gharānīq wa-tafsīr al-āyāt",[year needed] Muhammad Husayn Haykal's Hayat Muhammad (1933), Sayyid Qutb's Fi Zilal al-Quran (1965), Abul Ala Maududi's Tafhim-ul-Quran (1972) and Muhammad Nasiruddin al-Albani's Nasb al-majānīq li-nasf al-gharānīq.
Haykal (1933) points out the many forms and versions of the story and their inconsistencies and argues that "the contextual flow of Surah 'al Najm' does not allow at all the inclusion of such verses as the story claims". Haykal quotes Muhammad Abduh who pointed out that the "Arabs have nowhere described their gods in such terms as 'al gharaniq'. Neither in their poetry nor in their speeches or traditions do we find their gods or goddesses described in such terms. Rather, the word 'al ghurnuq' or 'al gharniq' was the name of a black or white water bird, sometimes given figuratively to the handsome blond youth." Lastly, Haykal argues that the story is inconsistent with Muhammad's personal life and is completely against the spirit of the Islamic message.
Aqa Mahdi Puya has said that these fake verses were shouted out by the Meccans to make it appear that it was Muhammad who had spoken them; he writes:
"Some pagans and hypocrites planned secretly to recite words praising idolatry alongside the recitation of the Holy Prophet, while he was praying, in such a way that the people would think as if they were recited by him. Once when the Holy Prophet was reciting verses 19 and 20 of Najm one of the pagans recited: "Tilkal gharani-ul ula wa inna shafa-atahuma laturja"-(These are the lofty (idols), verily their intercession is sought after.) As soon as this was recited the conspirators shouted in delight to make the people believe that it was the Holy Prophet who said these words. Here, the Quran is stating the general pattern the enemies of the messengers of Allah followed when they were positively convinced that the people were paying attention to the teachings of the messengers of Allah and sincerely believing in them. They would mix their false doctrines with the original teachings so as to make the divine message a bundle of contradictions. This kind of satanic insertions are referred to in thus verse, and it is supported by Ha Mim: 26. It is sheer blasphemy to say that satanic forces can influence the messengers of Allah.
He didn't mention that it took 8 years for Mohammad to recite the verses that were canceling the satanic ones. Why so long ?
Thanks for the explanation ❤
Very True.
because it's not true
where did you find this out?
Source please?
If the verses are fakes, there is no point in killing anyone over them. If they are authentic, they expose Moh as a false prophet. If they are authentic, Moh worshipped idols.
Precise and exact words of yours that need to be carved in stone. Till now no debate on this subject says Mohammed was an illeterate and only was a business man who could count money. The whole incident and the second coming of Satanic Verses to make a fiction close to reality is what pains this Desert tribe and their cousins.
Prophet Mohammed (saw) was true leader and last prophet.he worship Allah the one God and teaches us also to worship Allah ,Allah is the creator of univers , mankind , jinn and angles.
@@dr.starbright143your muhamad declares that he believes and followed what satan said to him, your muhamad can’t tell between allah and satan, the fact that it’s right in front of you, the evidence that muhamad worships satan and you still follow and believe him, that some brainwashing and indoctrination happening in your brain..
@@dr.starbright143I am interested in prophets biography. He had a terrible lifestyle
@@NILWALyou will have to read three types of biographies. One from who are anti islam one who believe in Islam and one who are neutral .
Then I hope if you are not prejudiced you will have the real story.
I know a muslim who read the book. He said that everything he heard about this book from other muslims was wrong. But the only way to proove that for yourself is to read it yourself.
Yeah you are right, The prophet Muhammad was bewitched and kept imagine himself having S*X But in fact he did not 👍👍👍
They are embarrassing us, in our Religion you can't go to conclusion without a Fact etc
Are you trying to sell some books? Point to us if a fully free copy of the book or a pdf is available. I am not wasting any money on this.
@@rooblez9005 I have read a hadith which rememered me of one narration in Rushdies book (with the hillarious story about how Moses made just 5 out of 50 prayers). Sorry about that "fact" and that you feel ambarassed. You should be more ambarasses about your cluelessness.
You should start with yourself, then, to lead what you're preaching by example, instead of telling us what the Muslim you know told you.
😬so we have a prophet with no single prophesy and now he is being influenced by the devil😭
The whole story is not authentic that like my quoting from gospel of Jacob
@@killerbee6484the man are all trustwhorty by the satanic verses?
no single prophecy? you havent even googled it to test that claim, thats pathetic.
No prophecy? Do ur research akhi
No prophecy lol do your homework son and come with a different arguments.. too many to mention but 1 that you see with your own eyes right now is how the prophet prophecyed Arab people in competing in tall buildings lol how would a man in the 7th century even utter such words?? Unless he prophesied it coz his a prophet? 🤔
As I said do your homework son,
So these verses were present at some point but where removed during the time the text was being written?
No, he is saying the story was made up to support the theory or doctrine of abrogation. However, the story does not make sense since, the Meccan Arabs would have taken advantage of this event and use it to undermine his claim to Prophet-hood and nobody would have believed in him. But, this never occurred during the lifetime of the Prophet (s).
this was a very clear explanation for what has been troubling me... now, what about Salman Rushdie?
According to what you said, how can you be sure that the rest of the Quran is not from Satan?
If you paid any attention to the video, the angel Gabriel was there to help correct Muhammad in distinguishing which were the correct verses.
the Quran keeps dissing Satan, saying Satan is the enemy. Why would Satan want to spread that message??
The Quran is definitely not from YHWH and what is not from YHWH is from the devil ...
Exactly 💯 I have the same question.
@@Winterheart786have you ever heard of the trojan horse? Is the same here
The question now is that since Muhammad couldn't discern if this message was from satan or God , how can we be sure that the rest of his messages were from God and not satan .
One would expect that God would make sure that his prophets never give a wrong message to his people and this is not impossible for God to do as He is all seeing and all knowing .
And yet this false message was given once , it is highly unlikely that prophets of God will not be able to differentiate between their God and satan .
Many modern Muslim scholars have rejected the story. Arguments for rejection are found in Muhammad Abduh's article "Masʾalat al-gharānīq wa-tafsīr al-āyāt",[year needed] Muhammad Husayn Haykal's Hayat Muhammad (1933), Sayyid Qutb's Fi Zilal al-Quran (1965), Abul Ala Maududi's Tafhim-ul-Quran (1972) and Muhammad Nasiruddin al-Albani's Nasb al-majānīq li-nasf al-gharānīq.
Haykal (1933) points out the many forms and versions of the story and their inconsistencies and argues that "the contextual flow of Surah 'al Najm' does not allow at all the inclusion of such verses as the story claims". Haykal quotes Muhammad Abduh who pointed out that the "Arabs have nowhere described their gods in such terms as 'al gharaniq'. Neither in their poetry nor in their speeches or traditions do we find their gods or goddesses described in such terms. Rather, the word 'al ghurnuq' or 'al gharniq' was the name of a black or white water bird, sometimes given figuratively to the handsome blond youth." Lastly, Haykal argues that the story is inconsistent with Muhammad's personal life and is completely against the spirit of the Islamic message.
Aqa Mahdi Puya has said that these fake verses were shouted out by the Meccans to make it appear that it was Muhammad who had spoken them; he writes:
"Some pagans and hypocrites planned secretly to recite words praising idolatry alongside the recitation of the Holy Prophet, while he was praying, in such a way that the people would think as if they were recited by him. Once when the Holy Prophet was reciting verses 19 and 20 of Najm one of the pagans recited: "Tilkal gharani-ul ula wa inna shafa-atahuma laturja"-(These are the lofty (idols), verily their intercession is sought after.) As soon as this was recited the conspirators shouted in delight to make the people believe that it was the Holy Prophet who said these words. Here, the Quran is stating the general pattern the enemies of the messengers of Allah followed when they were positively convinced that the people were paying attention to the teachings of the messengers of Allah and sincerely believing in them. They would mix their false doctrines with the original teachings so as to make the divine message a bundle of contradictions. This kind of satanic insertions are referred to in thus verse, and it is supported by Ha Mim: 26. It is sheer blasphemy to say that satanic forces can influence the messengers of Allah.
Even if it is accepted that he did a mistake...He got it corrected by Allah(swt)...So if there were other mistakes..they would also be corrected..
But this never happened and it is just a story..
No witnesses
How long after the satanic verses were abrogated. Instantly or after 8 years by Surah Al Hajj verse 52 ?!
Please reply Thanks
After 8 years
@@smruthimurali850 Very Suspicious!!
@@Reverted2006 exactly 😂 and people don't use their brain to think about it.
@@smruthimurali850any proof
"eventually" to be exact
Assalamualaikum Tuan Haji. Thanks for sharing. Sharing is caring for the well being of one another. Well explain. Jazak Allahu Khayran. From Malaysia.
😁😁😁 He explain nothing, your prophet Muhammad was bewitched after all 🤭🤭
@@kamekameha721 After all the Quraan didn't mention the Prophet pbuh was bewitched 🤔
True love = the love of God!
*God himself went to the cross for you out of love for you as a human being*
Philippians 2:5-8
Nice to see someone talk so sanely and explain both sides.
Shabir’s lips moved but he made no sense none whatsoever!
There was a lot said but made no sense.
Muhammad was influenced by the devil to recite verses that were in contradiction to what he claimed to preach (monotheism) and he went on further to prostrate in worship of the three (3) goddesses (Al’Lat, Al’Uzzah, & Mannat).
Muhammad committed shrik along with the Quraysh.
Allah supposedly abrogated the “Satanic Verses” but didn’t reprimand Muhammad.
Could this be the reason why Muhammad is in hell???
@@NathanKwadade there is no evidence that this happened. This is a fabricated, unfounded story that keeps getting said over and over. It is a concoction.
@@NathanKwadade I hope so. And I hope his legacy makes it worser and worser for him there.
@@theunknownexplorer1944
This is evidenced in the Quran Surah An’Najm.
Sura an-Najm (Star) 53:19-22
If it didn’t happen then why is this reported in the Quran in a Surah?
If the Quran is inspired by Allah and this incident is stated and revealed then it certainly happened as stated.
Muslims always try to hide and lie about things that make Islam ☪️ look bad.
@@NathanKwadade you dont undestand Quran by simply qouting critics or toilering to seem as you wish.
The Quran says Allah will remove what Satan casts in and if he cast nothing in there is nothing to remove. However, there are two issues with this the Quran says Satan has no authority over his followers except for the ones that follow thee. Secondly, if Muhammad could not tell the difference between satanic verses and one's from Allah then how do you know that Jibreel telling him what have you done and this being from Satan is not also from Satan and subsequently all the verses after that.
@UC0ncJaFosqsuqNUH3rWPpFQ Allah protected the Quran? So why is the Quran today out of order from the original order he supposedly "revealed" it to Muhammad in. In fact the first verse revealed to Muhammad is now aaaalllll thr way in chapter 96 when there is zero authority from Allah to do that. In fact the Quran falsely accuses the Jews of moving verses out of place but that is exactly what happened to the Quran. Your god protected the Quran? So how come he says he causes it to be changed or forgotten! Quran 2:106 "We do not abrogate a verse or cause it to be forgotten except that We bring forth better than it or similar to it. Do you not know that Allāh is over all things competent?
Quran 6:112 explains Quran 22:52 as the devil (being from mankind or jin) heckling the words of the prophet while reciting the Quran, notice that Quran 22:52 never says anything about Satan dictating a recitation it only says "يلقي الشيطان في امنيتة" Satan throws in his recitation, which is what heckling is.
Apply the historical criteria, you will drive to the conclusion of Sean Anthony who is more qualified than you with all due respect and he rejects its historicity.
READ : The Satanic Verses in Early Shiʿite Literature, Page 141-145
@@Sheragust if He is once influence by Satan..we don't know what he could recite..you will never know cause he doesn't even know the difference..and your very verses could also be written under Satan influence..who knows
@@aguimaiabonmai1970 no because if it really was satan, quran wouldnt continue to call satan a loser and evil of mankind.
The fact that Muhammad immediately revoked his recitation because Gabriel called him out shows his transparency.
Its well known Muhammad would go over the quran with Gabriel often because he would tell him the proper order of the quran and also teach him extra ways of recitation for the people.
Constant review of the quran, making sure its perfectly revealed until he died.
@ that argument isn't very good because Satan is the best of the deceivers and could just be saying that..... oh wait the Quran calls Allah the best of the deceivers.
Just to add a bit of info - it was claimed that the particular shaitan/shaitan/satan in question was able to take the guise of hazrat jibreel alaihis salam - kinda reminds me of the term - "You Cunning Devil"
imho Quran & Hadiths gives guidance so followers should try to grasp the meaning/interpretation: instead of being like sheep to the slaughter literally.
When our journey is ended on this earth we will know the consequences of our actions that's why it's imperative to seek guidance/help from ALLAH (SWT).
i've realized i'm nothing special in comparison to all of the countless creations in the heavens, earth, other worlds & beyond dimensions. so pray for & help the suffering of creation if one seeks anything of the Lord our Rabbil Alamin
Qadi Iyad (r) has an almost perfect explanation of it in his Masterpiece „Al-Shifa“ where he showed also the opinion of several high ranked Ulama of his time
Asalam Alaikum we rahmatullah we barakatu and thank you for the insight into this topic, which has caused and still causes so much trouble, and unfortunately also nurishes the widely spread misinformation and negative attitudes against Islam.
A late convert to Islam from Germany.
Asalam alaikum and response means assimulation, simulation
Lucifer=Jesus=Muhammad=Messiah=Qiyamah=Nuclear=74
As the Singularity emerges, arithmetic intelligence, shall paint a congruent picture. I find it so funny when people claim to talk to some algorithm referred to as Satan. Allah"Halla" would make no conundrum. In fact God+Alla=Devil. Essentially Devil means Double. Islam is second to Christianity. The name islam means "is Lamb" in reference to Christ as Lamb. Humans are incapable of being negative. Only positive and antipositve exist giving a wealth of direction for understanding.
good luck to have 72 houris in heaven
Alaikum Salam warahmatullah brother, this story is totally fabricated by Hypocrites to degrade Prophet (PBUH & HF). If that is the case than it will contradict the Quran, few verses before this alleged setanic verses Quran it self clearly rubukes the claim of corruption - >Chap53,verses 3&4: it translates that prophet never spoke out of his own desire rather he spoke the revelation only. Also in Chap38, V-82&83 Setan himself confirm that he can not influence prophets. Further more there is Hadith: the Setan runs away when Umar (2nd Caliph) is present so how is that possible Setan can influence his master Prophet (PBUH & HF)?
@@arcadegamer5059 🔥 🔥 😂😂😂
@@BabbanCarbonate 🤣🤣
I am not a Muslim, but I find these interviews intelligent and help me to understand Islam's teachings.
Your profile name is very disgusting. Please change it.
cmon whitepanties. ive actually heard Mr ally claim that paracletes means muhammad. what do you think?
Intelligence leads to truth.
Ignorance leads astray.
He is not intelligent.
@@trutherasitis2109
Thanks 🙏 for pointing this out!
Shabir’s lips moved but he made no sense none whatsoever!
There was a lot said but made no sense.
Muhammad was influenced by the devil to recite verses that were in contradiction to what he claimed to preach (monotheism) and he went on further to prostrate in worship of the three (3) goddesses (Al’Lat, Al’Uzzah, & Mannat).
Muhammad committed shrik along with the Quraysh.
Allah supposedly abrogated the “Satanic Verses” but didn’t reprimand Muhammad.
Could this be the reason why Muhammad is in hell???
This just shows to me that our beloved Prophet SAW never narrated the Quran based on his own, and it also proofs to me that Allah protects the Quran as per what Allah promised.
We are in mental prison are we?. Swallowing a sugar coated cynide capsule to justify an embarrassing exposure. The holes and leaks are just too many.
@@theoracleofthenorth2870 which holes are you referring to? pls do elaborate. Unless you don’t have knowledge and only attack with what you hear from Fox news or western stupidity.
It proves to me that Kentucky Fried Chicken is the best chicken.
You see in this what you already believe. It's nonsense.
@@ahudspith look, it is not like is a blind believe for me at least. I’m a born muslim, wasn’t a practicing muslim until about 2yrs back, i was raised muslim hence knowing the basics of Islam, so all the islamophobic and western believe regarding muslim i already know for it not to be true. So it was easy for me to get to know regarding my religion (no negative believe from the start) and educating myself in the Quran, starts praying and etc.
My point is, the statement i made in the above, is not a blind believe there is a reason for me to say it, and one can only know once you have read the Quran, get to know the miracles within in it, such as scientific accuracy, the logic that God had laid within it, the impossible arrangement of the text itself within the Quran.
So yeah, if i believe the color of our blood is red and people trying to convince or saying it is blue, offcourse i will reject it.
@@GarudaAlfa Show me the verse where it says Muhammed was visited by Angel Jibreel 🤔
I have heard something about this before. But this is a very interesting lecture. I'm Christian and I'm always interested in understanding other religions. Certainly explains the different views on this subject.
What would you like to know ?
@@Skyone7thcentury you have a very little knowledge. In the Quran , you can see that Quraish has been islam's enemy at first because they do not want to accept the God is One concept. Later on, they accepted it and left Paganism.
@@Skyone7thcentury its not copying , its continuation.
The Kaaba was part of prophet Abraham's life. It is a prayer house where too many Idols were displayed on his lifetime and he fixed this. The iconic circling around the Kaaba is done by Hagar prior the renovation of Kaaba. The believers commemorate the circling around the area because of miracle sent to Hagar and Ishmael, the son of Abraham. Do you not have Bible? Just like Muhammad saws, Abraham preached that God is One. People were angered and did not believe as it was already tradition to have idols and many gods.
After Abraham , of course hundreds of years passed and another situation where people forgot about the real God again. Paganism is everywhere just like before. The kaaba was in the same state again where a lot of idols were displayed. Some caretakers of kaaba do it for money.
Muhammad preached the same message "God is One" but mostly the elders does not accept them. The youngsters were the first believers of Muhammad saws and it is causing conflicts between parents vs their children. They fled out of Mecca as Quraish tribe is torturing them. They are enemies at first.
@@Skyone7thcentury well it is part of his life, if you do not know. Also, if you speak to a Christian Arab they also call God as Allah. In their Bible, it is written. Don't make up stories boy.
@@Skyone7thcentury Allah literally means God. The God of Abraham was worshipped even before Paganism. Pagans did not accuse Muhammad pbuh of preaching another God. His message is that, There is Only One God. God is One, not many. So what is the problem about the name "servant of God"? Even Jesus pbuh was called slave/servant of God in your Bible.
Acts 16:30-31 Bible
“Sirs, what must I do to be saved?” And they said, “Believe in the Lord Jesus, and you will be saved, you and your household.”
John 17:3
@@Ahmad-oo5qi John 17:1 has Jesus clearly saying He is Gods Son, why did you leave that verse out?
It's incredible how whichever surah you pick, all the Qur'an has to offer to women is contempt
Assalamualaikum! I remember when the book first came out! I thought, " How many protesters actually read the book?"🤔 Thanks for explaining it.
I’d say to this day, 99.99% of Muslims have never read it. It’s sad when people act like mindless zombies.
The shaykh is talking about the verses in the Quran. He is not talking about the Rushdie book
Quite a few actually! It's why they burned the book!
@@wolfgang7812 They burned the book because they were told to. They got upset and rioted because they were told to. They do what they are told to. Barely any of them read the book, including Muslim scholars and leaders. They are nothing but mindless zombies who deserve zero respect in a civilised society.
@@wolfgang7812 It is just a book. Art. And has nothing to do with the koran or hadith. Rushdie plays with figures, is inspired by the old testament, islam and ancient gods. In this book a indian movie-actor is playing so many gods, that he gets psychosis by/after lefting islam and is DREAMING that he is an angel giving Mahound (!) this "satanic advicec". What should this have to do with islam? IT IS ART, imagination. And in the end "Mahound" (who is INSPIRED by the descriptions of Mohammed) is just a small part in this whole 700 sites book.
What is wrong with seeking wisdom from the three goddesses Al-uzza, Al-lat and Manat. I am a Pagan and I seek wisdom and inspiration from them.
They dont exist. They are false gods.
Really from idols
People, not Mohammed turned them into “Satanic” verses. Mohammed knew the truth about our Divine Mother. Idol worshipping is not what religious people think which why they are so ignorant on idol worship interpretation. Keep in mind- Mohammed didn’t read or write so although someone next to him was always writing it doesn’t mean they could interpret to people the wisdom that Mohammed had. I hate when Muslims call Mohammed illiterate because he was the opposite- reading and writing is actually beneath someone that has divine wisdom. They don’t need to read or write to attain such wisdom as these were the ways of the ancients. Lastly, can you imagine trying to have a simple conversation with Mohammed or any other divine being and always saying “Peace be upon Him” after you say his name. I know Mohammed wouldn’t even listen to what you’d have to say after hearing it every time you say his name. It’s like you’re not sure that Peace is actually upon him or you’re just trying to look like your Holy. Get over yourselves! May the true Mohammed be revealed to those that seek and may the beloved Mother be merciful when she judges the Earth. ❤💕❤️💕
Dr Shabir, why are you never condemning the killings and stabbings in this interview. Considering your explanation.
I think one of the strongest pieces of evidence in the Quran about how these satanic verses don’t exist is when you look at the revelation order, the surrah that was brought to the Prophet, peace be upon him, right before An Najam is Al Ikhlas. The same surrah that states Allah is one and does not beget children. Allat, Uzza, and Manat were believed to have been daughters of Allah, and while An Najm denounces them specifically, Al Ikhlas denounced them and ALL other idols worshipped.
So if the satanic verses truly did exist as many try to push, why aren’t there hadith of people asking the prophet “hey wait a minute you revealed just the other day we shouldn’t worship anyone else.”? If we can record everything about the prophet, even fabrications, you would think at least ONE person would question the Prophet on this issue. Not to mention the leader Idol of Mecca’s 360 idols was Hubal, someone that was not recognized by these satanic verses. You really think the Meccan leaders would be like “ahhh, at least we have Allat, Manat, and Uzza!”? Hubal is the idol they went into battle with! You would think someone would be upset about this, no? But no, this hadith claims everyone was happy, from the muslims to the pagans, until the correction.
I refuse to believe that this hadith is true. Even without going into how God will forever preserve the message of the Quran and would correct the Prophets if they ever erred, it just doesn’t make sense.
Questioning wether the verses exist or not is like taking us into the bush after the very learned Islamic scholar ,Dr Shabir has given us the needed enlightenment.
All i want to know is that how many days or months later did the correction came from Angel Gabriel.
Salaam.
Absolutely incredible refutation
well i thought the quran cannot be corrupted
The correction came almost 8 years after the satanic verses.
@@ademolaadelakun9241
I don’t believe this theory because there’s no “authentic” documentation on this. Any one can make up stories, it’s up to us believe what’s true and what’s not. The Sahara’s were wise and not just blind.
To sum it all up, there would be no way a group of 313 men can defeat 700 men.
Let’s use our brain. Islam is the only monotheistic religion that’s keeping the tradition of all abrahamic religions alive.
Watching from Liberia, West Africa.. Thanks so much Dr Shabir Ally for your clear explanation on the subject…..
how would you like your lie served sir?
I am a Liberian too, let me ask you something...so muhammad received revelations from gabriel who received them from allah. If gabriel didnt know what muhammad had recited where was muhammad getting the revelations from before satan threw in the verses?
@@phyrestarter If you have a copy of the Quran please read Sura 5:48 it clearly answers your question.. Thank you for asking, Happy Flag Day…
@@albertwlehnah4492 I read it thank you. hmmm so Allah while giving the quaran to gabriel, gaved him the wrong one then gabriel gaved it to muhammad....to test who? Muhammad, Gabriel, or muslims?
@@albertwlehnah4492 side note....flag day?
The present quoran was written in 1860. The quoran and the hadith has changed many many times; the translation of the oldest quoran is forbidden; translation by Luxembourg
LOL sure 😂 Delusions
Beautiful take on such intricate subject, jajakallah
It was corrected after 8 years and the verse is removed from Quran.
👉Allah almighty our creator says,
*And this(Quran) is not the word of an accursed satan. Whither then are you going? This is an Admonition to all the people of the world, to each one of you, who wishes to follow the Straight Path. But your willing is of no avail unless Allah, Lord of the worlds, wills so.*
Qur'an 81 (25-29)
Nice comment! The "Muslim scholars; imams and sheiks" who have gone along with the rubbish discussed in this video ought to be taken to account!
No responsible Muslim Scholar Imam Hafiz etc would ever go along with this filth!
Ha ha ha.
I am Allah I didn't sent any Gabriel to Muhammad. You muslims are fooled by mullah. Ha ha ha
@@wolfgang7812
*"In the name of Allah the Beneficent, the Merciful."*
I invite you to Islam, and if you become a Muslim you will be safe, and Allah will double your reward, and if you reject this invitation of Islam you will be committing a sin.
(And I recite to you Allah's Statement:)
👉Allah almighty our creator says,
*Say, "O people of the Book! Come to what is common between us and you, that we worship none but Allah; that we associate nothing with Him and that none of us shall make as our Lord any other than Allah."*
*If they reject your invitation, then tell them plainly, "Bear witness that we are Muslims (who worship and surrender to Allah alone)."*
Qur'an (3:64)
👉Allah almighty says,
*Your real Deity is but One. He Who is Lord of the earth and the heavens and of all that is between them, and Lord of all Easts.*
Qur'an (37:5)
Once we die our creator will again resurrect us on the Judgment day.And on that day if you have believed in Allah and have followed his book Quran then you will be succeed in the hereafter life.
Hereafter life is the eternal life either in Paradise or hellfire depending upon the good amd bad deeds you did in this world.
👉God Almighty says to the Mankind,
Say(O Prophet),
*“Allah gives you life, then causes you to die, then He will assemble you on the Day of Resurrection about which there is no doubt.”*
Quran (45:26)
@@sanjayrawal2258
*All Hindus must read*
Allah almighty our creator says,
*“If anyone desires a religion other than Islam (submission to Allah), Never will it be accepted of him; and in the Hereafter he will be in the ranks of those who have lost (their selves in the Hellfire).”*
Qur'an 3 (85)
"Ma chidanyadvi shansata"
*O friends, do not worship anybody but Him, the Divine One.*
[Rigveda Book 8 :1:1]10
Similar message is in the Qur'an which is Final revelation from God almighty.
God Almighty says to the Mankind,
*This then is, Allah, your Lord; there is no deity but He is the Creator of everything : so worship Him alone, for He is the Guardian of all things, No sight can comprehend Him but He comprehends all sorts of sight, for He is All-Comprehensive and All-Aware.*
Quran 6 (102-103)
Brahma Sutra of Hindu Vedanta:
"Ekam Brahm, dvitiya naste neh na naste kinchan"
*"There is only one God, not the second; not at all, not at all, not in the least bit".*
God almighty says in Qur'an,
*Your real Deity is but One. He Who is Lord of the earth and the heavens and of all that is between them, and Lord of all Easts.*
Qur'an (37:5)
"Na tasya Pratima asti"
*There is no image of Him.*
[Yajur Ved 32 : 3]
So its not allowed for you all to make idols of God. Because Idol worshiping is prohibited in your scripture.
Allah almighty our creator says,
*But those ˹idols˺ they invoke besides Allah cannot create anything-they themselves are created.*
*They are dead, not alive-not even knowing when their followers will be resurrected.*
*Your God is ˹only˺ One God. As for those who do not believe in the Hereafter, their hearts are in denial, and they are too proud.*
Qur'an 16(20:22)
"Ekam evaditiyam"
*"He is One only without a second."*
[Chandogya Upanishad 6:2:1]
Its clear from above verse that there was a messanger sent by Allah to the people who are worshipping idols meaning Hindus.
In Qur’an Allah Almighty says,
Accordingly, we sent to every community a Messenger, saying,
*"Worship Allah and keep away from the taghut(False Gods)."*
Will someone tell me which Surah and Ayat no of Quran reference he is giving I am trying to fund out this Ayah by name of Surah Tks
Just Google it, with key-word satanic verses.
And good on you Dr Ally for condemning the attack on Sir Rushdie….
*Can you explain why your Prophet prayed to 4 gods. Allah, Al Lat, Al Uzza and Manat. And can you tell me if that is SHIRK ?*
(Ibn Ishaq, Sirat Rasul Allah, translated as, The Life of Muhammad, (translator: A. Guillaume), Karachi: Oxford University Press, 1998, pp. 165-167)
Now the apostle was anxious for the welfare of his people [the Quraysh], wishing to attract them as far as he could. It has been mentioned that he longed for a way to attract them, and the method he adopted is what Ibn Hamid told me that Salama said M. b. Ishaq told him from Yazid b. Ziyad of Medina from M. b. Ka`b al-Qurazi: When the apostle saw that his people turned their backs on him and he was pained by their estrangement from what he brought them from God he longed that there should come to him from God a message that would reconcile his people to him. Because of his love for his people and his anxiety over them it would delight him if the obstacle that made his task so difficult could be removed; so that he meditated on the project and longed for it and it was dear to him. Then God sent down "By the star when it sets your comrade errs not and is not deceived, he speaks not from his own desire,"[Q. 53:1-3] and when he reached His words "Have you thought of al-Lat and al-`Uzza and Manat the third, the others"[Q. 53:19-20], Satan, when he was meditating upon it, and desiring to bring it (sc. reconciliation) to his people, put upon his tongue "these are the exalted Gharaniq [a high flying crane] whose intercession is approved". When the Quraysh heard that, they were delighted and greatly pleased at the way in which he spoke of their gods and they listened to him; while the believers were holding that what their prophet brought from their Lord was true, not suspecting a mistake or a vain desire or slip, and when he reached the prostration and the end of the Sura in which he prostrated himself the Muslims prostrated themselves when their prophet prostrated confirming what he brought and obeying his command, and the polytheists of the Quraysh and others who were in the mosque prostrated when they heard the mention of their gods, so that everyone in the mosque believer and unbeliever prostrated, except al-Walid b. al-Mughira who was an old man who could not do so, so he took a handful of dirt from the valley and bent over it. Then the people dispersed and the Quraysh went out, delighted at what had been said about their gods, saying, "Muhammad has spoken of our gods in splendid fashion. He alleged in what he read that they are the exalted Gharaniq whose intercession is approved".
lets not act asif satan hasnt approached previous prophets before. Take Ibrahim (AS), khalil Allah. Satan approached him, did he not?
DE- BUNKED. I didnt even have to read it all
@@Ahmad-oo5qi Agreed your prophet has been debunked. Yet you gullibly continue to follow.
😂
The fake that it had to be changed is crazy enough and y’all say it was perfect etc etc. anyways.
This is a test for everyone of us as for those who are willing to believe in these fakes story to reject Allah’s guidance and find false excuses not to follow it or they literally believe in it and are being misguided because of them being at a stage of blind following.
Thank you for your intervention! May Allah bless you all. And also keep in guiding those that are willing to.
لِّیَجۡعَلَ مَا یُلۡقِی ٱلشَّیۡطَـٰنُ فِتۡنَةࣰ لِّلَّذِینَ فِی قُلُوبِهِم مَّرَضࣱ وَٱلۡقَاسِیَةِ قُلُوبُهُمۡۗ وَإِنَّ ٱلظَّـٰلِمِینَ لَفِی شِقَاقِۭ بَعِیدࣲ﴿ ٥٣ ﴾
Al-Hajj, Ayah 53
I swear i saw a video of a fake "muslim" acting worried and stuff just made me worried for my faith too , but all i had was to reaserch on my own and then ask multiple different sources , the fake muslim just twisted things for his own narritive to make the viewer worried , he had correct spellings too which made him look more authentic but turned out he was hebrew which is basically the same family language as arabic so they can easily say arabic words
He is interpreting the Quran using the Hadith, and it's wrong. The correct interpretation of those verses (22:52-54) is that Allah allows the Devil to TEMPT the messengers and Prophets, by interfering with their wishes, however, it doesn't say that they were added in the form of verses of the Quran, but something else (opinions, ideas etc.). Then that something else is nullified by the Quran (or the Revelation given to a Prophet, in general) however those whose hearts are hardened/sealed will follow those deviant suggestions instead of following the Revelation of God, that is the fitnah/trial.
An example we have today is the Halal/Haram food debate. The Quran (6:145) CLEARLY says that ALL good food is HALAL except: what is killed in the name of other gods, what is already dead, blood, and the meat of pigs. What do the majority of Muslims follow? They have a whole list of more haram animals that are in fact halal. When confronted by this fitnah in the form of doubt, the hypocrites will choose to follow the opinions of the sheikhs (who are following the opinions of those before), while the true believers will choose to follow the direct message of God.
Also when the Quran (41:41-42) says that it's an invincible book, and falsehood cannot approach it from before it or from behind it, this is what it means, that whatever argument we bring against it, the Quran itself has a counterargument inside it hidden somewhere, waiting for a believer to understand it. The Quran (25:33) also says "whatever argument they put forth, we give you a better argument and explanation"
@@magicianslucky602 never risk your faith brother
Quran is an issue based revelation.
Quran is an guidance for prophet and his companions lived in 6th century. Almost every Verse in Qur'an has situation background.
“Whenever We sent any messenger or Prophet before you, and he recited anything (of Our revelation), Satan tampered with it. But God abrogates Satan’s interjections and then He firmly reaffirms His revelations. God is all knowing, all wise.” (Holy Qur’an: 22:52)
“He makes Satan’s suggestions a trial for those whose hearts are diseased or hardened - and surely, the wrongdoers are far gone in error, astray.” (Holy Qur’an: 22:53)
They are self explanatory verses' no room for any doubt.
The first one means after the rasools (peace be upon them) the shaytaan deviated the people, so they were sent ambiyah (peace be upon them) to clear up things or rasools (peace be upon them) with a modifed message.
Second point, Satan can't tempt Prophets (peace be upon them) or interfere.
Allah sent The Qur’an as the last revelation of Truth, Al-Haqq. Shaytan can never tamper with it. It is only man whose heart is deviated by Shaytan that is being tampered with. Not the Holy Qur’an.
@@MAH-tu1xz 🤭🤭🤭🤭 This is the most hilarious statement I ever heard 🤭😁😁
Your holey Qur'an is not even preserved by allah 😁😁😁🤭😁
@@kamekameha721 is it that you read and still do not understand? Even with all these explanation you still talk like this. Sometimes, the problem isnt about what is made explicitly clear it's about what you already have stored in you which makes whatever you have read not to have any meaningful delivery. Try to have a clear mind now and read the verses again, then you will understand what the poster meant. Have a nice day
"Indeed, God does not forgive association with Him, and He forgives what is less than that for whom He wills ۚ And whoever associates with God has strayed far astray." Quran:Anisaa, verse 48.
Medinian verses. Muhammad used to worship idol in Mecca times
So did Allah forgive Muhammad for shirk.,
Oh wait, all of Muhammed sins are forgiven even when he contradicts the Quran
@@ThatisnotHairIdiot
This story if true it actually proves the sincerity of the prophet because why would he not exploit the pagans through verses like these when according to the story they believed in him after the verse ?
Why would he chose to remain on monotheism when he and his companions would be persecuted ?
This was to be the peak of his power why would he give that power up for monotheism ?
Looting is very lucrative, and lucrative is always tempting, and tempting is always justifiable, and justifiable is always narcissistic.
@@caseyrudd8441 how ignorant you are
He gave up on Satanic verses only after 8 years. Tells you by that point he did not need the idolators politically.
he himself was an idolator thats why, he added it in there without understanding monotheism and took him 8 years to realise the blunder.
Erh.. he was using violence?
Like he took his adopted son wife as his wife and claimed Allah mandated it. I am sure his son gave willingly.
Oh the son was soon sent in dangerous war raid and got kill coincidentally….
You didn't read the book, the book is a fictional account about a fictional person receiving words from an angel and the receiver changing the message
How can someone read this book ????
What Shabir saying is that Salman Rusdie said nothing different from his understanding of the satanic verses.
Yep, but he was attacked. Also, he wrote that as a Muslim, later he became I think atheist.
If I understand it correctly, Muslims have the greatest respect for their Prophet. More than that, I understand that disrespecting the Prophet is punishable by death. So what I don't understand is this: Why would Muslims disrespect their Prophet so badly as to invent a story of him supporting idolatry and worshipping idols? More than that, why would other Muslims accept these stories and put them in their religious books (I understand there are more than 37 sources for this story). More than that, why have there always been Muslims, even scholars, who accept this story as genuine?
Most scholars of Hadith like Bukhara and sahih muslim said it’s a fabrication. We have isnad system and a grading system for Hadith. People invent these type of stories against the prophet because they are either enemies or just simply misheard or misunderstood something.
Non of the true Muslim enlighten by Quran can believe such trash.
By studying Quran, one can clearly see that the Person who taught this book to his followers can never indulge in idolatry. Quran is very very clear in the matter of Monotheism, no other religion can compete Islam in the teachings of Monotheism.
The story came from Biographies and unauthentic Hadiths, written after more than 100 years of the death of the Prophet Muhammad s.a.w and were written by the people far from the centre of Islam I.e Macca and Madina, forefathers of these writers were generally hard opponents of Islam. Therefore they were not able to fully grasp the clarity of Prophet Muhammad s.a.w and Quran regarding the concept of Monotheism.
To become true Muslim, one have to believe in Quran as the final revelation from the Lord,
all other books and writings may be correct or wrong, so we don't have to believe them all.
@@quest...6246 The events in Torah are all confirmed in archeology. Mnt Sinai has been found in Saudi Arabia. Did Islam borrow God of Israel?
@@keepthechange2811
Prophet of Islam Muhammad p.b.u.h never claimed Islam as a new religion, according to Quran Islam is what earlier Prophets, like Ibraham, Isaac, Ishmael, Moses, Jesus and all other prophets taught the humanity before prophet Muhammad.
Quran define true Muslims as,
" They ˹all˺ believe in Allah, His angels, His Books, and His messengers.
˹They proclaim,
“We make no distinction between any of His messengers.” 2/285.
Quran consider all those on the Quranic path,
"Those who believe (in the Qur'an), and those who follow the Jewish (scriptures), and the Christians and the Sabians,- any who believe in Allah and the Last Day, and work righteousness, shall have their reward with their Lord; on them shall be no fear, nor shall they grieve". 2/62
Prophet Muhammad clearly says that we the Muslims are on the right path of Ibraham,
"Who turned away from all that is false, and ascribed divinity to none but the One True God."
@@quest...6246 My question is: WHY? Why would Muslims invent such 'trash' as you call it about their Prophet? This story is recorded in 37 Islamic sources. Why would other Muslims record this story if it were not true? They risked being killed by recording this story. Why?
I'm scared to say publicly a comment on this. Is there an e mail I could ask my question?? InshaAllah
Dr. Shabir, is bending the truth, your prophet got a revelation that there are partners to your Allah, also why is no one mentioning that it took 8 years for your prophet to correct this, so for 8 years your people were worshipping partners to your god, but never have I ever heard any muslim scholars stating how long this process was....It took 8 years... a lot happened in 8 years
How can there be purported verses of the Qur'an that were taken out if it is law that the Qur'an is perfect and has never been altered?
Because there were no verses removed from Qur'an Kerim.
These verses have never existed.
what about the verses that the goat ate? The verse of stoning and breast feeding an adult 10 times.
@@jesuschristtheonlyhopeofth429 That hadith is weak, muslims don't follow weak hadiths lol
Thanks so much for such a concise and easy to understand explanation of Satanic Verses. I was never able to understand it until I saw this video. May Allah gives you Jaza e kathira for your efforts. Ameen summa Ameen
All he did was admit there indeed are Satanic verses in the Quran and he also admitted Mohammed was a false prophet who Al-Lah allowed Satan to use as he willed.
Question. What proof do the Muslims have that Satan didn't continue to use Mohammed? Even if Mohammed denies Satan continues to be under his spell, how can u justify the rest of the Quran isn't from Satan??
LMAO!!! Its truely fun exposing false Islam.
This story if true it actually proves the sincerity of the prophet because why would he not exploit the pagans through verses like these when according to the story they believed in him after the verse ?
Why would he chose to remain on monotheism when he and his companions would be persecuted ?
This was to be the peak of his power why would he give that power up for monotheism ?
Either way this story is even rejected by most academic historians specialized in early Islamic studies like Sean Anthony.
Source: The Satanic Verses in Early Shiʿite Literature, Page 141-145
@@Sheragust either way? this is typical of the islamic narrative. always hopping from tree to tree. becuase now if you and i have a conversation and you see the problem in that incident, youll just revert back to "its actually rejected by..."
@@tomasashenafi882 I'm not sure why you are being aggressive with your language, but the story is not historical not just according to Muslims but also non Muslim academics specialized in the subject and I gave the reference, someone like Sean Anthony is more qualified on this subject than Salman Rushdie or what not.
@@Sheragust apologies if i sounded aggressive. but often i notice that pattern of conversing in my Muslim brothers and sisters.
but for your question as to "why wouldn't he keep his polytheistic view",
if you follow muhamad's story, whenever he finds it convenient the amazing law of abrogation takes full effect to track back and change stories. like with his interaction with Jews and Christians.
-----------------------------------------
in this case my guess judging by his selfish character is that if he kept these godesses as part of the belief system, then other prophets may show up claiming to be sent by those godesses and then he wouldnt be the only voice of authority
A succinct explanation. Thank you. I’ve just started reading the Quran after meeting so many wise and relaxed Muslim men over many years. It’s surprising what one finds when one’s mind is uncluttered by prejudice and hearsay.
If Mohamed couldn’t differentiate between Allah and Satan , How did he know it was Gabriel who told him to remove the verses?..
Obviously it would have been Gabriel, because why would Satan want his own verse from the quran to be removed. On top of that, in the 23rd ayah of surah An-Najm (53:23), it is mentioned that Allah has never authorized worshipping them, and that these are names that the disbelievers forefathers have made up.
@@anuboy8046 that makes no sense..
There are overwhelming contradictions with this alleged story. *Nor does he speak from [his own] inclination, It is not but a revelation revealed, to him* 53:3-4
I mean Surat Al-Najm begins, by these blessed verses, as to draw our attention, to any future fabricated claims, such as 'the Satanic Verses.'
*No falsehood can approach it from the front, nor from the rear (i.e. neither directly nor indirectly). It is sent-down from Allah the All-Wise, the All-Praiseworthy.* Quran 41:42 Can it be any clearer?
*If he (Messenger) were to invent any saying in Our Name, We would certainly have seized him by the right hand and We would then have surely cut off the artery of his heart.* Qur’an 69:44-46 In other words, the Messenger wasn't able to say anything from his own whims and desires, yet Satan was allowed and able to interject with verses? lol
*Say, "If mankind and the jinn gathered in order to produce the like of this Qur'an, they could not produce the like of it, even if they were to each other assistants."* 17:88
*“We indeed have sent down the recital (the Qur’an) and indeed We are its Protector (from any corruption or interference).”* 15:9
Even the heavens were sealed shut for the jinn during the revelation of the Quran, and to this day.
*And we have sought to reach the heaven; but found it filled with stern guards and flaming fires.* 72:8
People want to discuss everything, including fabricated stories, yet they don't want to reflect on the Quran. Discuss away.
Goodly explained
Because sadly many of our scholars are people pleasers and they don’t want to offend or give room to anyone to doubt Hadith. They always tip-toe around claiming false Hadith.
It really sounds like the leaders of the Caliphate were really trying to cover Muhammad’s and the early Islamic scholars’ tracks on this one.
@@brotherben4357 Whatever you think there Ben. But do get yourself mentally prepared, for the Hellfire, you're going to need every last atom's weight of preparedness. And it doesn't start at the Hellfire, no, it starts with 2 angels that are eager to meet you, once your soul returns to its rightful owner. Now back to your Satanic human blood sacrifice whims, and desires.
@@Free-Palestine I’m not sure if threatening someone with hellfire is a very kind thing to do, mate.
Why do you feel the need to use your religion (hiding behind it) to do that to a stranger?
There are those who say that the Prophet never did anything of his own free will or volition and that everything he did, including his marriages (including to the clearly very young Aisha), was commanded upon him by Allah. This is a general 'get out clause' to any possible attack or criticism on him. Clearly, unless a person is a Robot, he/she MUST be acting in accordance with his/her own head, willingly or unwillingly. The Prophet DEFINITELY was not a Robot. Hence, he must take ownership of his actions.
The age of Aisha was about 18, there is so much disinformation floating around.
@@JohnSmith-tn9ll Oh yes. If you add 10 + 9, as the Arabic figures were always 10 less, you do get 19 which is very close to 18 as you suggest. Unfortunately, that is wishful thinking. Aisha herself said she was 9 when the Prophet consummated the marriage with her.
@@dollishillwork Except you are mistaken, as it was not reported by Aisha (ra) herself, but reported through her nephew in Iraq, who passed away at 80 and spent the last 10 years of his life in Iraq, and all commentators say his Iraq narrations are not to be taken as authentic, as he was known to mix hadeeth during this time as he was ageing. And her age of 9 goes against multiple authenticated hadeeth. So its not wishful thinking, it just requires delving deeper into the knowledge than at face value.
Technically Muhammad was a robot when it came to revelation. He would have gabriel appear in front of him in the middle of the street. He gets an episode and memorises the revealed verses. He then would immediately or the next day if it was late repeat exactly what he heard.
Verily versions exist thereof in multiple having among them contradictions.
Hafs: تَعْمَلُونَ ‘you do’ vs Warsh: يَعْمَلُونَ ‘they do‘ (Al-Baqara 2:85)
Hafs: يُدْخِلْهُ ‘He makes him enter’ vs Warsh: نُدْخِلْهُ ‘We make him enter’ (Al-Fatḥ 48:17)
Hafs: فَبِمَا ‘then it is what’ vs Warsh بِمَا ‘it is what’ (Al-Shura 42:30)
Will you not then doubt?
I thought the Quran is authentic ?
Page to page ??
So hmmm they decided what goes in and what stays out?
So the Prophet couldn’t distinguish between satan and Allah s voice ?
How reliable are the Prophet Mohamed’s claims then with regards to Allah s messages to him?
Allah has very clearly said in the first five verses of chapter 53 under discussion- that the Holy Prophet Saww speaks what is revealed and does not speak out of by his whim. and is neither misguided or astray. He speaks what Allah inspires him. The revealed Quran is the book from GOD and mankind has been openly challenged to produce the like of it or even a single sura. So far as traditions and collections of background is concerned it needs to be based on sound and tested premises. Many stories or statements do appear but then all are not authentic. Other Gods have been mentioned in all literature like the Cow worshipped by the Israelites or the idols confronting Moses etc. The main theme from Adam to Prophet Mohamed has always been One God. And even that message was eclipsed. The fact is the message was conveyed, the values and the objectives of life have been conveyed. And yes deception and falsehood will also raise its head as if it’s true. Mankind still has to sift through this mix to discover truth and will continue to face falsehood masquerading as truth.
And the final truth is that there is one GOD and he sent down the revelations for his creation. The sum total of these Revelation s and instruction is Guidance to achieve the Noble status which a human has been designed for and can become.
Someone clearly stating through another how believable lol.
He should have aligned the story by revealing it to another not the same person
Supported my brother
It's very simple
You have said it all
In first aiahs of the same surah
That he cannot speak by himself but with waha-yu
where its said jesus is god?
biggest error? jesus as god in quran!
٣١ اتَّخَذُوا أَحْبَارَهُمْ وَرُهْبَانَهُمْ أَرْبَابًا مِنْ دُونِ اللَّهِ وَالْمَسِيحَ ابْنَ مَرْيَمَ وَمَا أُمِرُوا إِلَّا لِيَعْبُدُوا إِلَٰهًا وَاحِدًا ۖ لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا هُوَ ۚ سُبْحَانَهُ عَمَّا يُشْرِكُونَ
s 9:31 They have taken their scholars and monks as lords besides Allah, and [also] the Messiah, the son of Mary. And they were not commanded except to worship one God; there is no deity except Him. Exalted is He above whatever they associate with Him.
Jesus is God in Quran you have to worship him
@@kelechukwuonyegbu4470
Shabir’s lips moved but he made no sense none whatsoever!
There was a lot said but made no sense.
Muhammad was influenced by the devil to recite verses that were in contradiction to what he claimed to preach (monotheism) and he went on further to prostrate in worship of the three (3) goddesses (Al’Lat, Al’Uzzah, & Mannat).
Muhammad committed shrik along with the Quraysh.
Allah supposedly abrogated the “Satanic Verses” but didn’t reprimand Muhammad.
Could this be the reason why Muhammad is in hell???
Yeah, whatever, it is embarrassing that Iblis was able to do that to the Prophet…no matter how you purposefully try to explain to turn it into a legit matter…it is not.
Dr Ally makes it clear this is ‘purported’ and not from the most authentic hadeeths and Ibn Katheer in his tafseer says the report is fabricated. May Allah swt enable us to see the truth as truth and falsehood as false and keep our imaan strong -Ameen.
Right. This story would be exactly what enemies of Allah would make up
6.385 Narrated Ibn Abbas:
The Prophet performed a prostration when he finished reciting Surat an-Najm, and all the Muslims and pagans and Jinns and human beings prostrated along with him.
Our LORD,GOD AND SAVIOUR,HIS BOW IS A RIVER. AS IT IS WRITTEN IN HOLY BIBLE (HABAKKUK 3:9) 🙏
السلام عليكم. عندي سؤال، اسمحوا أن أطرحه. هو بدون ازدراء. هل يخذوا القرآن نصاً؟ مثلما حق تاريخي؟ أو مثلما رسالة روحية؟
Out of mere curiosity due to recent attack on Mr. Rushdi, I bought cheap kindle version of this book. I just ended up reading about first 25 pages of this book. It was as if they were written by absolute lunatics. I have never read a book / part of a book that is so much convoluted, disgusting and ridiculous. Absolutely bored and disgusted. Why Muslims made famous this crazy lunatic by becoming so angry. It was a total wastage of money of my time. Do not waste your money - just borrow it and you will know.
Islamists didn’t make Rushdie famous, at least not initially. This book received wide critical acclaim, won the Whitbread award for best novel, and was on the New York Times Best Seller List for almost 8 weeks in 1989. Rushdie made himself famous for his writing and plot building skill. Islamists reacted to this fame and perhaps only brought him more notoriety. But he’d still be famous regardless of their attention.
Agreed
Rushdie is knighted by the Queen. Why was he given such privileges
Agree
"I have never read a book thay is so much convoluted, disgusting, and ridiculous."
Seems like holey quran to me
In academia things are heating up,as a Muslim scholar once said"there are holes in the narrative),kalif ousmane did order copies of the Quran to be burned...there are just too many contradictions,it explains the "avalanche" of apostates.
Good luck
lets not act asif satan hasnt approached previous prophets before. Take Ibrahim (AS), khalil Allah. Satan approached him, did he not?
Paul Williams Blogging Theology channel has a good video about this with Ali Atae, refuting the satanic verses story.
Quranic verses not recorded in "louh'im mahfool'u" before creation of "assamahu walarl'u" ?
How can Shaitan cast new verses?
Confusing
Dr. Shabir, thank you sir for your calmness to explain one of the most difficult question ever asked, if most Islamic school were like you most persons would have seen the beauty of your reliion. God bless you always
Ameen
He is interpreting the Quran using the Hadith, and it's wrong. The correct interpretation of those verses (22:52-54) is that Allah allows the Devil to TEMPT the messengers and Prophets, by interfering with their wishes, however, it doesn't say that they were added in the form of verses of the Quran, but something else (opinions, ideas etc.). Then that something else is nullified by the Quran (or the Revelation given to a Prophet, in general) however those whose hearts are hardened/sealed will follow those deviant suggestions instead of following the Revelation of God, that is the fitnah/trial.
An example we have today is the Halal/Haram food debate. The Quran (6:145) CLEARLY says that ALL good food is HALAL except: what is killed in the name of other gods, what is already dead, blood, and the meat of pigs. What do the majority of Muslims follow? They have a whole list of more haram animals that are in fact halal. When confronted by this fitnah in the form of doubt, the hypocrites will choose to follow the opinions of the sheikhs (who are following the opinions of those before), while the true believers will choose to follow the direct message of God.
Also when the Quran (41:41-42) says that it's an invincible book, and falsehood cannot approach it from before it or from behind it, this is what it means, that whatever argument we bring against it, the Quran itself has a counterargument inside it hidden somewhere, waiting for a believer to understand it. The Quran (25:33) also says "whatever argument they put forth, we give you a better argument and explanation"
this is a dumb explaination from a dr. Dr. Shabir and other islam followers so ignorant that self proclaimed prophet muhammad received words from satan. Not even a single word from God. How can satan insert a satan verse into a a koran or his recitation if he is a Godly man or a chosen prophet. How did the pervert prophet did not realize this was satan? its a joke... stubborn and ignorant mulims please come back to the Book this is where the truth is.
Mr Rushdie was completely wrong to call them the Satanic Verses. He should have called his book "The False Verses".
Both the Bible and Quran contain a fundamental lie, which proves that they were written by men, and that 'god' is not real. At the time of writing, men did not know how man was created. A real 'god' would have known about evolution.
Why did 'god' create two totally different books when he had only one message? They were written by men who wished to inflict their different rules on their own people.
The same applies to the creation of the universe. Men 'guessed' it must have been created by something they couldn't see, so they wrote it into the Bible and Quran to help convince people that a 'god' existed.
The origins of the universe are, as yet, unknown, but to think it was a 'god', shows a very primitive mind.
There is ample information on the internet to prove evolution is the absolute truth, but the primitive mind may not understand it.
Religions are still debating evolution because they are 100 years out of date and they want to maintain a belief in a 'God'.
Evolution has been proved by REAL scientists to be the absolute truth, so a 'GOD' did NOT create 'MAN'.
@@Stiffytheenlightenedguess we will all know the truth in short anyways ! Try and think science changes its theories now and then allways ... and trust me ik science ..plus death will reveal the truth to u anyways ... just wait for it to arrive..
Allah swt sent the quran to prophet Muhammad s.a.w for guidance for mankind with wisdom and knowledge and this brother explained it in such a way masha Allah very beautiful
The quran says that allah has sent the Torah, Psalms, and Gospels. In fact the Gospels are called guidance and light by allah and muhammad is told to go to the Christians and Jews if he has any doubts about the quran. Certainly allah's not sending his final and best prophet to a people who have corrupted their book. As modern muslims say.
The satanic verses are clear proof muhammad is a prophet of satan.
Pbup? , use saw which is more accurate
@@magicianslucky602 yh I changed it
@@kraja2510 adding "saws" for Muhammad and "as" for other prophets is a direct violation of Quran verses 2:136 and 3:84
We should either always use "as" or nothing
PBUH (Peace be upon him) for all prophet is appropriate, because it translates to AS (alayihi Salam). But if you say SAWS you're breaking 3:84
Surah Al-Hijr - Verse 9
إِنَّا نَحْنُ نَزَّلْنَا الذِّكْرَ وَإِنَّا لَهُ لَحَافِظُونَ
9. “Verily, We Ourself have sent down the Reminder (the Qur’an) and verily We, (Ourself) will be its Guardian”.
Exactly, how can a prophet of God be influenced or possessed by Satan or Demons? That doesn’t add up. Muhammad is a false prophet
I still don't understand HOW those verses were even recited by the Prophet? I had the understanding that Angel Gibril revealed the entire Qur'an to the Prophet. Did shaitan sound exactly like the angel Gabril? Now I'm confused!!!
Yes. I don't belive in the incident. It has been concocted by narratives. Impossible that prophet recited anything other than the true revelation of God. Its beyond logic.
Depends on which Quran you are talking about. The current Hafs Quran was written haphazardly in 1924. As per the earliest scholars, it contains verses from both. Scientifically it was written by - Mu'awiya.
اللَّهُمَّ اغْفِرْ لِي ذَنْبِي كُلّهُ ، دِقَّهُ وَجُلَّهُ ، وَأَوَّلَهُ وَآخِرَهَ ، وَعَلاَنِيَتَهَ وَسِرَّهُ.اللَّهُمَّ إِنَّ ذُنُوبِي عِظَامٌ وَهِي صِغَارٌ فِي جَنْبِ عَفْوِكَ يَا كَرِيمُ ، فَاغْفِرْهَا لِي
My favourite book is satanic verses of Salman Rushdie. It is a greater than quran coz many evil persons have burnt it coz it is sooooo good 😃
@@noorjahan1333 so ,you are a atheist?
@@incredibleislam7943 i am slave to none and master of my life.
@@noorjahan1333 What make you to not believe in god
@@incredibleislam7943 god is man-made phantom 👻
If Gabriel corrected Prophet Muhammad how could such verses once became the part of Quran?! ،
🤔
This question deserves an answer. Anyone??
Every verse that is ever uttered by Muhammed had to be part of Quran. Many abrogated verses are also part of the Quran.
@@vinamrasinghai2339 Let me know which verses are abrogated thanks
Thankyou for your video. I have wondered this myself.
Maybe Im mistaken, but didnt the Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings be upon his name) say that the ways of Allah are hidden, and no man knows the ways of Allah, and anyone who says he knows the ways of Allah is a liar? So what are we arguing about here?
So I have a question. So arabs were worshiping Allah and his daughters? So Allah already existed as a pagan God's name? Please I hope someone answers this question. Because it seems like the person in tje video is agreeing that thr pagans we're giving daughters to Allah 😮
Here’s a basic explanation:
The Satanic Verses refer to an event in Muhammad's life which Muslim scholars call The Story of the Cranes. It is a time when Muhammad recited, as part of the Qur’an, that the polytheistic gods of Mecca were valid. Some time after saying this he withdrew these verses from the Qur'an and said they were inspired by Satan.
This event is recorded and accepted as authentic by the earliest Islamic biographers: Ibn Ishaq[1] and Ibn Sa'd[2]. It was a standard part of how the early Muslims told the life of Muhammad. Al-Tabari[3] records several accounts of the event, Ibn Taymiyyah[4] accepts it as authentic, and Imam al-Bukhari[5] gives a partial account. However, Orthodox Islam now rejects the event.
there no point of accepting a weak hadith, the source should be athentic as Quran 22:52 mentions this may be an attempt. not an actual event.
@@somgalaxy4445 quite strange that you have a different criteria to Muslims of the earlier centuries. Early Classical scholars accept the story as authentic.
@@manulajo1803 its an attempt as Quran 22:52 mentions.
@@somgalaxy4445 it's a successful attempt as recorded by the earliest sources
@ali The early Islamic scholars accepted it, no?
Ibn Ishaq lived only a generation after Muhammad.
What was the duration which PBUH Mohammed took to give counter verses condemning them ? I guess 8 years is that right ?
Why we are not allowed to critique the prophet of Islam the sa.e way we critique bible, Jesus etc??
"Peace be upon him" gets me every time 😂😂😂😂
After reading the sunnah (the Good, the Bad and the Ugly) I know understand why the guy really needs a lot of peace to be upon him!
Oh God!! I've been Googling and searching for videos explaining this satanic verses and I was really waiting for Dr. Shabir. Thank Goodness!
Dr Ali Atai did it on Blogging Theology recently.
are you Muslim
Yes. What makes it hard to search for is the title. Early Islamic scholars referred to the verse as ‘The Story of the Cranes’, rather than ‘the Satanic Versus’ which is later became known as.
You ever try Dr Daniel Shayesteh?
@@caseyrudd8441 He’s a Christian apologist, no?
Did you know or figured out by now there is marvelous quran channel on the youtube.
The question that rises is that Quran says bring a chapter like it if you can. If prophet Muhammad (saw) couldn’t differentiate between false and authentic revelation, who on earth today will be able to if someone makes a chapter like Quran?
Respectfully the elusive Satan has no power to enter anybody's mind unless allowed by that person. One cannot evade personal accountability by reciting the mantra, " Devil made me do it".
That's why we should pray 5 times a day
*Fajr* - to get ready for the day
*Zuhar (Duhr)* - to give thanks for everything you have and received from God.
*Asar* - to end your daily dealings well without cheating or other temptations from Devil.
*Maghrib* - to get ready for the night, as temptations get stronger by this time.
*Isha* - to get a good sleep, having God sending angels to guard your dreams (no nightmares nor "prophesies").
The Beloved Prophet of Allah Sallahu alaihi wassallam would not allow Satan the cursed one to ever influence him! Our beloved Prophet of Allah sallahu alaihi wassallam was protected by Allah azzwajal from the afflictions of Satan the cursed. What was being discussed in the video is suggestive that our Beloved Prophet Sallalahu alaihi Wassallam was inflicted by Satan the cursed; which is why the cursed book of this cursed author was burned on publication in 1980s!
@@wolfgang7812 So can you tell us How allah prophet Muhammad was bewitched then.
@@madjames1134 That routine did not help Prophet. How that is going to help you?
@@wolfgang7812 This is what Quean says. So you don't agree with Quran?
Comprehensively and eloquently explained, as ever, by the good doctor...
how can a prophet of God be influenced or possessed by Satan or Demons? That doesn’t add up. Muhammad is a false prophet
I can't believe comment section is ON. Atleast this man is honest unlike other apologists
One thing that is hidden from this narrative of satanic verses is the time between the revelation of the satanic verses until the revelation of the verses canceling them (Al Hajj 56). And which verses of the Quran were revealed during that duration. That is 8 years. Then that Muhammad during that period of time prostrated himself to the idols of the Quraysh.
There are only 2-3 books i have read about 2 times, one of them is 'The Old mand and the Sea' by Ernest Hemmingway. I read Satanic Verses in 1998, when i was in US, and forgot about it. Now is the time to read it again. It is the curiosity that kindles intellect in the man. This explanation by the scholar was very clear.
how can a prophet of God be influenced or possessed by Satan or Demons? That doesn’t add up. Muhammad is a false prophet
I haven't read Salman Rushdie’s “The Satanic Verses”, but I will read the book soon.
"The book topped Amazon’s bestseller lists on Tuesday [16.08.2022], days after Salman Rushdie sustained serious injuries in a stabbing at a lecture in New York.
The book had come in as the #1 Best Seller in Amazon’s Literary Satire Fiction list and in the Contemporary British & Irish Literature list. It also claimed 11th place in the overall Amazon Best Sellers list."
The Quran is more knowledgeable.
It's an encyclopedia of our past, present and current world we live in and it's free.
My favourite book is satanic verses of Salman Rushdie. It is a greater than quran coz many evil persons have burnt it coz it is sooooo good 😃
@@DaTruth1017 My favourite book is satanic verses of Salman Rushdie. It is a greater than quran coz many evil persons have burnt it coz it is sooooo good 😃
@@DaTruth1017 😀 what exactly does the Quran say about our world? There things in the bible that have not even happened yet. Imagine that.
@@m77ast Bro that is the bible we are here talking about The Quran which contains scientific evidences.
If someone is claimed as a prophet, one would expect that they know good from evil, God from Satan, if not then one must be extremely careful what you believe of anything they say. If what they say is so complicated that someone else must explain what is really meant, then what they say is not for you either unless your learning and understanding is equal or above the original claim.
I think it is a big mistake Dr.Shabir made when he first assumed that the Prophet spoke those words praising idols. Many scholars reject the whole story as fake and concocted, while those who -for the sake of argument- accept some sort of it say, it was satan who threw his words into the ears / the hearing of pagans, not that the prophet himself ever pronounced thoses "satanic verses". If we read the actual surah of Quran An-Najm( i.e. chapter53), we find it coherent in its context by rebuking Arab pagans about their following to idolatry and prejudices, speaking about Allah's dominion over heavens and earth, His reward, punishment, forgiveness, mentions Moses and Abraham,God's signs and creation, and finally, an order to prostrate to God and to worship Him. In all that context it is just impossible to fit in the so called satanic verses, and most important the Prophet PBUH is infallible when he conveys the message of God, thus can never pronounce something like that as Allah's word.
Thanks may Allaah bless you, you're the only one here making this story much clearer, in coherent with all the verses of Qur'an saying the Prophet pbuh, can't speak on His own and the Qur'an isn't the satanic words.
People can hear many things but before they would have reflected on what they hear or read, shaytan would have come their ways in order to hinder whatever good result they could get from their Creator Who's directing and guiding their thinking. May Allaah continue to guide us aright.
Here’s a Hadith from Sahih…..that matches the stories from early Muslims at the time……. 6.385 Narrated Ibn Abbas:
The Prophet performed a prostration when he finished reciting Surat an-Najm, and all the Muslims and pagans and Jinns and human beings prostrated along with him.
@@Investors_Consigliere Yes of course, They all prostrated To God, and that was their reaction to the command of the last verse in Surah An-Najm which tell them to prostrate to Allah and to worship Him. If you understood differently then you are wrong!
@@alphabeginna3823 explain the early Islamic sources that also told this story but in greater detail? TABARI volume 6, page 107 and IBN Ishaq’s documentation
@@alphabeginna3823 explain Surah Al-Hajj Ayat 52
“And We did not send before you any messenger or prophet except that when he spoke [or recited], Satan threw into it [some misunderstanding]. But Allah abolishes that which Satan throws in; then Allah makes precise His verses. And Allah is Knowing and Wise.”
I didn't even know about this until now. Thank you sir, may Allah bless you
C P
I believe you. You said it all.
what if satan went to bless Dr Ally? how would he know the difference if even muhammad (SAW) couldnt tell
May God give you peace that the world cannot understand. A peace that the world cannot understand, yes a peace left to us by Christ Jesus our Lord and Saviour🙏
@@tomasashenafi882 this is why it appears that prophet Muhammad was often possessed by bipolar spirit.
This totally make sense that if the Prophet (pbuh) preaching a pristine monotheism then reneging on that to compromise and then going back to the pristine monotheism, he wouldn't be able to convince people that he's genuine, either to Muslims or non Muslims. This certainly proves the whole story to be false.
And we should keep in mind, Al Tabari wrote on the preface of his book “Hence, if I mention in this book a report about some men of the past, which the reader of listener finds objectionable or worthy of censure because he can see no aspect of truth nor any factual substance therein, let him know that this is not to be attributed to us but to those who transmitted it to us and we have merely passed this on as it has been passed on to us."
So, He literally opt out from any responsibility in regards to the authenticity of the matter instead simply kept himself as a narrator of the information in question. Same applies to Ibn Saad.
😄😄😄😄
Who is to be worshipped in life naturally mother and father . But mother role is bigger than father in raising a human life . Lets start respecting mothers .
Islam is to humanity what clipping wings is to a bird
Thank you for the explanation. This is my first time hearing this story. May Allah reward you.
where its said jesus is god?
biggest error? jesus as god in quran!
٣١ اتَّخَذُوا أَحْبَارَهُمْ وَرُهْبَانَهُمْ أَرْبَابًا مِنْ دُونِ اللَّهِ وَالْمَسِيحَ ابْنَ مَرْيَمَ وَمَا أُمِرُوا إِلَّا لِيَعْبُدُوا إِلَٰهًا وَاحِدًا ۖ لَا إِلَٰهَ إِلَّا هُوَ ۚ سُبْحَانَهُ عَمَّا يُشْرِكُونَ
s 9:31 They have taken their scholars and monks as lords besides Allah, and [also] the Messiah, the son of Mary. And they were not commanded except to worship one God; there is no deity except Him. Exalted is He above whatever they associate with Him.
Jesus is God in Quran you have to worship him
@@seeki3315 this verse already proves that jesus is NOT god.
@@seeki3315 the verse is talking about people like you (and criticizing then) who consider their scholars (aka the church) and Jesus (peace be upon him) gods when in fact they were not ordered to worship any god but One God [Allah].
Do not be a fool. Read the next verse after it.
@@theunknownexplorer1944 remove this verse from your quran and hadith first, my friend
The Qur'an calls Christians and Jews "the worst of creatures" (98:6) and commands you to violently subjugate us (9:29). Christians are being mercilessly persecuted in Muslim lands by your brothers and sisters. And you ask why we bother to respond? It's all out of hatred, right?
Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) as saying:
The last hour would not come unless the Muslims will fight against the Jews and the Muslims would kill them until the Jews would hide themselves behind a stone or a tree and a stone or a tree would say: Muslim, or the servant of Allah, there is a Jew behind me; come and kill him; but the tree Gharqad would not say, for it is the tree of the Jews.
But you don't see anything hateful in what the Qur'an says about non-Muslims (for instance, when Allah says that he has no love for non-Muslims in 3:32)? And you have no objections to 4:34, 4:24, 5:51, etc.?
if you do not agree with me, then you are terrorist,
go in peace, my friend
from peace nobleist
Rremove these verses first, my friend then u can cry
Your fake god did reward all of u with death and hell
Very queer that he couldn't tell the difference, since he was so wonderful and everything.🤔
It's almost as of he was just a human😱😱😱
The more I learn I'm not even sure he qualifies as that.@@Tesseractimus
Bro the prophet was a human being too u know
@@mohameddioum305 I know. And he was a delusional mental invalid too. Free yourself from his spell.
@@mohameddioum305 And he liked little girls.
Regardless of whether the satanic verses in the end removed from the Quran or not, was teaching the satanic verses, before being corrected, a big sin?
Exactly, how can a prophet of God be influenced or possessed by Satan or Demons? That doesn’t add up. Muhammad is a false prophet
Verses are still in Quran.
And so why would someone be killed or stabbed for commenting about this. Since you are so peaceful
islam - the only religion that has to constantly explain itself 😂
Trinity?😮
Trinity is very well understood . Its jusy one of tha talking ppint that these maulanas keep repeating like "where did jesus said he is god" just talking points
@@Devrajsingh-vc1hq no, christians fail to explain the trinity. Why do 3 entities have to ‘communicate’ if they are the same person by soul? Get ur head out the sand, your lord will ask these same wuestions and we will both be scared shitless but inshallah i will have hundreds and thousands of prayers inshallahh!
@@Devrajsingh-vc1hq the romans came to all these lands and fucked all the women and killed all the men and now everyone says jesus is god😂😂😂. Its a big test but when u really oearn and research the religions and the people behind them and the fact that muhammeds enemies knew him as ‘the trustworthy’. Its a brilliant story line from our maker, one that only those who Allah elects will choose correctly. Surely you are of the loosers
@@Ahmad-oo5qi The fact that the trinity is what confuses you is hilarious. What confuses me about Islam is why do some mercilessly kill others for not being muslim (even though the Quran says everyone is born muslim and will revert at some point) and others don’t?
Just a thought, how can a man who says that he got revelations from both God and satan be trusted. Then which one is from satan and which one is from God. And when he had received the satanic verses from satan directly why did he not receive the verses directly from God and why only through jibriel. Why hasn't he seen God all this while but for so many other prophets in the Bible GOD has visited them🤔
You’re focusing on inauthentic narration.
There’re a lot of authentic narratives about prophet Muhammad which needs your focus if you’re not biased person.
@@islanmohamed390 Which one says specifically that Jibreel visited him? And when did Jibreel identify himself as an Angel of YHWH?
@@fotochick4 Islam is revealed in Arabic therefore yhwh is not Arabic word.
If you tell what yhwh means may be I’ll give you a word that may be similar to it if yhwh is really Gods name.
@@fotochick4 يَـٰمُوسَىٰٓ إِنَّهُۥٓ أَنَا ٱللَّهُ ٱلْعَزِيزُ ٱلْحَكِيمُ ٩
O Moses! It is truly I. I AM Allah-the Almighty, All-Wise. 27:9
28:30 But when he came to it, he was called from the bush in the sacred ground to the right side of the valley: “O Moses! It is truly I. I AM Allah-the Lord of all worlds.
20:11-12 But when he approached it, he was called, “O Moses!
It is truly I. I AM your Lord! So take off your sandals, for you are in the sacred valley of Ṭuwa.
SO if yhwh means ‘I AM’ Then Quran has many I AM said by Allah!
Wow never thought of this...true
“So that’s how the verse reads now” “that chapter as it is now”
The story comes from the early Muslim biographer Ibn Ishaq. The approving of these goddesses is just a human impulse to make alliance with powerful groups that the Prophet Muhammad changed his mind about and realised the error or inconsistencies of his compromises. Feel forgivingly about him if you see in him a person wanting to be good
Really? What about abrogation in the Quran....the sure sign that Muhammad was a fraud.
What do you mean that's how the verses read now? I thought the Qur'an couldn't be changed? I apologise for my ignorance. I'm trying to read the Qur'an at the moment.
What prophet (sm) got through Gabriel(As) is still unchanged. So, Qur'an is unchanged. Don't worry
@@MdIrfan-fl4wq Aha, got it! Many thanks for explaining that. I really appreciate it.
this story of satanic verses is fake, nothing was ever added or replaced in the quran
@@elorebenyame2016 I've no idea about the Bible. It never made sense to me how Jesus was God and the holy spirit. Also we know for certain that a lot of it has been changed and mistranslated. Which is why I've chosen to read the Qur'an first.
@@Tip_Top If a lot has been changed in the bible, doesn't that prove to you that your god cannot be God? I mean, according to him, he revealed the Torah and the ingeel didn't he? Open your eyes bro, please.
The entire narrative behind the gharaniq story can only make sense if the story were true, I’ve studied it myself.
Apparently muslims still defending gharaniq and every scholars responsible of it in the first place, regardless they claimed it as false narration
This story is rejected by most academic historians like Sean Anthony.
Source: The Satanic Verses in Early Shiʿite Literature, Page 141-145
It's an apocryphal story started circulating only 100 years after the fact, Muslims don't take it as canonical and actual historians specialized in early Islamic studies even doubt its historicity.
I have no idea why would anyone believe that this story happened with how much evidence it lacks.
@@Sheragust what evidence does it lack? The story came from different independent sources, No credible historian will undermine multiple independent sources no matter how contradictory they may seem to be.
Secondly the strongest link to the gharaniq story is from said ibn jubayr who lived in 7thCE close to the time of Muhammad, So the notion that the story started circulating a 100 yrs after Muhammad is false.
Using historical chronology why the first Muslim immigrants to Ethopia returned two months later after hearing rumors that the Meccans has become Muslims and the fact the Meccans prostrated with Muhammad after reciting the Surah indicates the satanic verses likely happened than it didn’t.
Can you give exegesis on the historical context of Surah 22:52?
Why must we accept Sean Anthony hypothesis? What evidences that led to his conclusion?
@@Sheragust That's the whole point!
Even if we both agree this story is rejected and non canon, why does muslim scholars put it in the hadiths and tafsirs in the first place.
Salman Rushdie was not the first man who mention satanic verses as a FICTIONS, muslims scholars were the one did it. Yet nobody denounce sahih al bukhari, tafsir ath thabari, tafsir al jalalayn, sirah nabawiyah, tafsir muqatil, ibnu katsir as blasphemer for mentioning that story.
@@julianhansen3717 muslims have the ability to pick and choose hadiths. It's part of their taqiya.
Even shahih hadits could be dhaif if it's not good enough to hold on to
Bro Shabir is like the most understanding human being
How do we know that rest of the Quran is also not from Satan??
Exactly, how can a prophet of God be influenced or possessed by Satan or Demons? That doesn’t add up. Muhammad is a false prophet
You cannot. That is why Muslim scholars don't talk about satanic verses even though it is part of the Quran.