Logitech Z623 vs Edifier R1280T || 6-Track Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 жов 2024
- Edifier on amazon DE: amzn.to/2BZ5YuM
Edifier on bhphotovideo: bhpho.to/2OgmT1r
Edifier on amazon UK: amzn.to/2Ejm5E4
Logitech on amazon DE: amzn.to/2XtLJi8
Logitech on amazon UK: amzn.to/2BXsnJ4
-----------------------
Follow me on instagram at / digitalstereophony for the latest updates and behind the scene look
----------------------------
All the tracks used in this video can be found here:
• Test Tracks
----------------------------
Sound recorded using Zoom H6 recorder. Levels matched using SPL meter. All tone controls set to neutral
Not completely on topic: I own both the Z623 and got the 1280DB yesterday. The 1280 DBs are much more defined, wider and crisp then the logitechs. The bass on the 1280DB is really good. Not wall shaking as the Z623, but for music it goes deep and has a good rollover. I have the Z623 for my computer which is good for games and some shows/movies, but for music the edifiers win hands down.
thanks for your comment man. good stuff bro
I just got the 1280T and there is really no bass to speak of, even with the bass dial turned all the way up, it just doesn't put out lower frequencies. Full bass sounds a bit muddy or muffled. They are very crisp and detailed, otherwise, but if someone wants any amount of decent bass, even from songs that aren't totally bass heavy, like "Don't Panic" by Coldplay, you won't get it with 1280 Edifiers, they're not full range. Vocals don't sound like they're coming out of the speakers, though, they're very clear and sound like there's a center channel.
@@barfo281 have you tried adding the t5 edifier sub?
@@ssing4345 Nope. Wasn't even aware of it.
@@barfo281 Yup, Edifier lists their frequency response as 75Hz-18KHz (+/-9dB) which means they produce no deep bass at all, whereas the Logitech's frequency response is 35hz-20khz which means they produce deep bass
Great job man! Just ordered the Edifier R1280DB based on this. The bass on the edifiers is so much more effortless, its there but its lighter and more balanced! Thank you!
do you recommend them?
@@florider2904 I do, you get a surprising rumble if you're going to watch movies and tv shows, even at low volume.
For music, if it's a low quality audio it might not be as loud as you want them, but the quality never ceases to impress. Very clear, warm sound.
I have been looking for this comparison, because I want to buy the Edifier one for my parents home speaker. This is really good comparison because it compare my current speaker system with the Edifier one. My dad is fan of crystal sound so I think he will love the Edifier.
Really depends on what you like, more bass go for logitech, clear sound go for edifier.
Yeah but you can just turn the base up on the edifiers
@@BigTim.05 on the Logitech too, you have a knob for increasing or lowering the bass.
@@BigTim.05 Yes, but it doesn't matter how much you turn up the bass if the speaker can't produce deep bass, it won't and the Edifier's produce no deep bass. Not only that but the Logitech's are louder too
@@carewser the logitechs have horrible sats that are horrible if it’s louder than 50%
@@hyphinxThat's not true, i've had them at full volume and they're still pretty clear
Dont forget that the logitech only provides a good stereo image when you have the subwoofer at the same level as the satelites, when you put the subwoofer on the ground under your desk there wil be a big hole in stereo image
Because the logitechs amp only send above 150hz to the satelites, and the edifier is stereo all down to around 50hz
Basicly the edifier wins in stereo imaging sound quality etc, but it lacks the deep bass from a subwoofer.
Paring the edifiers with a cheap subwoofer wil easily outperform the logitech speakers with ease
Only way for the logitech speakers to sound on their best is setting them up in your tv room where the subwoofer is still in a direct path with your ears
Putting the subwoofer under your desk wil fk up the sound to much,getting a decent enough stereo image is only possible by turning up the subwoofer volume
what results in overpowerd boomy bass, anyway a subwoofer should not play above 100hz subwoofers arent meant to play so high, everything above 100hz wil just sound muddy
I wish that logitech finally stopped with cheaping out on their satelites and enclosures, and set their crossover from the sub to 100hz and make the satelites play atleast as low as 100hz/80hz
A 4/5inch satelite driver wil do the trick
What sub would u recommend? Wish I knew as much
@@ah-ui7yh depends on the room size , placement,budget, the rest of your setup etc, i cant just name any decent brand and make u happy.
Even if i had all that info i still would recommend going to a local dealer and test them out in real for yourself, even if you buy the best subwoofer out there on the market you might not like the sound, everybodys ears are different
@@cybernaab Im lost again but will rely on your advice to find a way out.
The Logitech is much closer to the original track. The highs on the Logitech aren't as piercing as the Edifiers but they're accurate to the original track. The Edifier is too tinny to my ear.
Listening with a JBL Charge 3, The Z625 sounds great, both have potential, the Edifier are great because they have twitters. I believe you can improve the sound with an equalizer, I did it with the JBL I have and they sound amazing.
Trust me the Logitech is ok if you want boomy bass that lacks definition. Unless you have a DSP source that you can adjust, don't bother.
I own a pair of logitech z623's, and z906's. Both are great speakers for what they are advertised for, and music is not one of them. They have a frequency response of 20khz-35hz, and they do shake the house. Both of them hooked up together, they can be overwhelming in a small room. I recently bought a pair of sterling mx5's, and Ik those are on a different level of these edifiers, but they are so worth a mention. Picked them up 79$ a speaker from guitar center, and they smash either of these out of the water. Get yourself a sterling h224 if you dont already have a audio dac, this thing blows the focusrite out of the water price to performance wise.
Just like High Framerate Monitor,
Once you taste Good Audio setup,
You can never go back
Be careful
I have the Logitech Z533 (one step down the ones on video) bought after that my Edifier R1000T4 burned themselves for no reason.
Personally i preferred the Edifier sound, but after tweaking the Z533 with the software equalizer that comes with my motherboard (Asus Z390-E Gaming) i can say that they sound pretty similar…
Maybe with the Logitech there isn’t the same comfort because you have a very strange sub, with the connection panel on the side and not on the rear, but after all it’s satisfying
Many thanks for this. Just a couple of days ago I purchased the Z533 and I was disappointed on the treble, sounded muddy and without clarity. So I adjusted the sound with the DTS and the quality significantly increased. I owe you a beer.
Best channel for speaker comparisson
I want to love the Edifier R1280s --- but I think I like the way the Logitech z623s sound. I hate the Logitech's GIANT woofer though. I want one of them for a 60" TV.
Bobzeda just don't. Logitech doesn't has a midrange..
@@11Modern11 I know....I want a sub though!!! If the Edifiers just had a subwoofer option!!!
@@bobzeda edifier m3600d?
Please do Edifier S350DB vs Klipsch Promedia 2.1. Thanks.
Listening to this on my Logitech Z625 😌🙌🙌
Can do once 1280 + t5 subwoofer vs z623 again???
im gonna buy both. i have z623, and i will but r1580mb
I already have the Logitech Z623 and I find they've got way too much bass. I am upgrading them to the edifier R1280T soon. I love music and the edifier has clearer audio and less of a punch like the Logitech Z623 does.
If I had Z623 I'd stick with them. You can at least turn the bass down. You can't get more bass out of 1280T, it's just not there.
@@barfo281 Not just bass, i have the z623 and they sound meh if thats all you're used to but they are muffled when compared to these edifiers and the edifiers are cheaper, ill be upgrading soon.
@@whitegoodman7465 I went with Edifier 1280T over Z623. Not saying I regret it, but they don't really wow me.
@@soylentgreen8795 Hey SG, fancy seeing you here.
@@barfo281 1280 by themselves are not great. Add a good sub and watch them bloom, the Z623 will start to cry
Can you hook Up THE edifiers to THE Logitech subwoofer and see what happens?
I have the Logitech system and dont Want to loose that Extras deep
use an eguqlizer and you can extract the same clear sound from logitech + with bass
what equalizer would you recomend
@david Boeta APO equalizer is very good and with z623 you really need an eq to tune the upper mids and highs
Either I’m just a total casual when it comes to audio or this is exhibit A for why UA-cam sound tests don’t reflect the real world experience, because I feel like I can’t tell the difference between these speakers, just from listening to the comparison
What are you listening through?
@Andrew Weber quote: "Either I’m just a total casual when it comes to audio or this is exhibit A for why UA-cam sound tests don’t reflect the real world experience, because I feel like I can’t tell the difference between these speakers, just from listening to the comparison"
Most likely it's the gear (if you're listening to it with your TV speakers, computer speakers, cheap soundbar, entry level computer speakers, bluetooth speakers, etc) you're using at the time of listening to this video. My advice get a good pair of wired headphones/ear buds first (like Beyerdynamics, Audio-Technica, Sennheiser, Etymotic research, etc) because it's a good way to isolate your various background noises and you'll realize sounds you may have never heard before from what you normally listen too. I also recommend a decent DAC, (even a cheap USB external DACs usually sound better than most computer's built in audio chipset/card) this way you will have better sound processing that what's built into your phone, computer, TV, etc) but still get the headphones/ear buds first over this. Now when you listen to some of these youtube sound comparison videos you will easily tell the difference (unless you're hearing impaired). From here try a few speakers, only buy from outlets with easy return policies, and pick the speakers based on what you intend to listen the most (Rock/techno/edm/rap budget for a sub sat or add a sub if budget allows. Classical/jazz/dialog consider going 2.0 since this genre tends to only go down to about 40hz so popular audiophile monitors is the way to go).
Thanks a lot , now I know which to purchase, I had Z906 so get 1289 for my room.
Logitech Z623 does not have tweeter drivers so don't expect high tones from this device.
I have z623 amazing sound has good treble and good bass
Nice mids
@@@necor3088 Yes it's a bass heavy system. You need well balanced highs, mids and lows if you are looking for a decent sound system. Anything heavy will ruin it. Since the device in question does not have tweeters it cannot produce good highs. It's just an average sound system as far as music is concern. With overpowering bass Z623 is good for games and movies though.
I know...it's missing mids too.
@@necor3088 the z623 has bass, thats all it has. It has shit mids and highs.
Based on what I heard from my iPhone 13 Pro Max, and my Edifier MR4. The R1280T sounds harsher on the high frequencies, meaning they are tuned to be higher response on the high frequencies. That is to say the vocals could sound too sharp than the original song, but people somehow perceive it to be clearer... Z623 sounds to be more balanced on the vocals for me. Harsher high frequencies hurt my ears. But anyways, could be just my preference
you HAVE to listen through headphones because the mr4 dont give the sound as it is and cant make the overpowered z623 bass
This begs the question if the Logitech's bass was turned down, would the system sound more detailed and clear?
nope, there is no tweeter on logitech one. thus it wont go as detailed as edifier in high frequencies, also mids
I have both connected to Chromecast audio (multiroom) 😀
RedTony I think they sound good edifier is the Living room and Logi in my room & I like how they sound Together, I equalize them with the home app.
to use an equalizer if your playing from a phone you can use musi you can pick settings like more bass, less bass
You know both speakers have that built in?
@@hyphinx yep this was a year ago when i was first starting to learn about speakers (as you can clearly tell), now i know more or less everything about them
@@k0zmix114 ah okay makes sense
May God be with you all. very helpful thank you!
I have Logitech Z533. Are Edifier R1700DB better?
Why are you not comparing edifier t5 and Logitech z623?
I have r1280t + Modecom mc-2110 sub (5,25") and it's sounding very good, lows/mids/highs, hybrid setup :)
Which one is better? Edifier r1280db or logitech z333
I own the Z906 and recommend that hands down over both of these. But that's unfair to say that because this is a comparison between the z623 and the R1280T being roughly the same price. That being said i would recommend buying the edifier because of the inputs and build quality that the z623 lacks.
Another important thing to mention is that the logitech lacks a center speaker which is a must if you use it for movies because it will be hard to understand conversation/discussions in movies when people are speaking. Thats why the z906 has more speakers for clarity.
But for music id personality buy whatever based on your taste of music as the subwoofer will mean alot for some people but overall i think the edifier would be the more sensible choice.
Btw if you go to a store and listen to both and feel having a bigger subwoofer is better over clarity but bothered by the fact that there is no Bluetooth on the logitech they sell a Bluetooth adaptor separately.
The Edifier can be louder than the Logitech?
Hello guys, I wanted to ask which is better for youtube, movies and gaming between logitech z625 and edifier 1700bts, I am really confused as to which one to get
absolutely 1700bts
We need a review of someone reviewing these with comments
2.1 speaker always bad in the real world. You really to put the sub precisely or it will be boomy and not blending with the satelit sound. The mid always loses its richness. If you hear it was good at the showroom doesn't mean it will be good in your home. But 2.0 small speaker will be consistent everywhere. Especially for desk speaker.
Not to mention not all recordings are the same, and some will have such boomy bass you can't stand it and others will be so anemic, well, lets just say a remote for your sub is a must! Or you'll be getting up to change the settings every time you change genres, "headslap!"
A system like the Logitech is perfect for television
Which one for retrowave and space ambient music?
I'd say Edifier, they are super crisp...........but if you want ANY amount of bass, Z623, because 1280T just doesn't have it. I just got them and I'm a bit disappointed - I wasn't looking for room shaking bass, which is why I went 1280T over Z623 (which are only $20USD more at time of this post), but 1280T have no detectable bass to my ears.
I d say the Edifier are too "airy" for my teastes and the Logitech too boomy. I prefer the Logitech slightly more but i believe they exagerate so i wouldn't get them either. I ll give a thumbs up though cause it was a nice comparison.
i play r1280t using galaxy young poweramp player and sound not like this.. bad dynamic, not clear and bad bass plus slow bass response. what player u use? TASCAM player 😭😕? and MY friend use fio x5 to cheap speaker 10$ they sound close like this . why this demo sound so real? room? so great room can make sound dynamic? clear ? help
U need a better phone
Yes but if I'm only using the speakers for gaming, would the logitech be better
Quality price yeah. If Subwoofer is not in your plans then a CREATIVE PEBBLE V3 should be fine
we might disagree but Logitech are very FLAT for mediume and high frequencies because of THX certification. I tried many times to listen Jazz, Funky, Rock but never made it. I have agreed with many sound engineers about that reason. For bass kicks or the pseudo feeling of warm low freq music its because of powerfull subwoofer.
original the best😁
logitech z625 or presonus e 3.5?? suggestions plz
JBL 1 405>presonus e 3.5. If you're bass head then logi
Waduh speaker aktif 2.0 tanpa sub awan speaker aktif 2.1 yang ada sub
Jelas kalah soal deep bass nya gan
Kecuali clarity dan detail nya masih bisa diterima
I want both. The edifer is too big for my desk. and I have limited space below by my long legs.. ARG
I've use Logitech z623 for some time.. The bass ain't worth the crappy satellite sounds. Invest more, or wisely.
So youll say the edifier is better?
@@denisnatera3633 with a good sub, its superior in every way.
AUDIONERD: "I cant hear the xylophone at 2:45! This speaker is trash!"
TEST PSY TRANCE PLEASE Sound
Artist of long drive
I plan to buy r1280t. I heard that the bass can't go deep. I'm not really fan of bass (especially mid bass), but i love when bass can go deeper with natural sound. So I also plan to buy replacement rca to 3.5mm cable (because many said the original cable is sucks). Will the new replacement cable fix the problem?
@Orav A. is edifier m3600d better than this logitech?
I added to r1280t subwoofer 5,25" for cheap and now this play very good all frequencies.
Hello I'd like to know who plays the song "Long drive" please tell me.
Can I connect the 1280db to my z623 subwoofer?? I
With your version probably not, but you can connect a sub to the new r1280dbs!
Логитеч за 16 к, против эндифаера за 6, к
Хммм, интересно что же будет звучать лучше, 2.1 система, или 2.0
В 2.1 системе басов по больше, но это не удивительно, в остальном могу сказать что 2.0 держалась не плохо в сердних-высоких частотах.
Original track is being played out of what?
Your speaker, lol.
Yeah tannoy M1s sound better XD
Non of these is good enough for me but i prefer r1280 'cause it sounds a way more closely to good home speakers
thank you. great video
I’m listening to the comparison on edifiers and the original sounds better LOL
The fact that I can hear a clear difference between them even on my phone says alot.
The Logitech just sounds kinda tinny in comparison
Really happy with my own Edifiers in the two years I had them so far
what???????
Dude, They sound tinny because your phone can't reproduce deep bass 😐 the edifiers only stand out because they have great mids
I own the Logitech. Muddy sound, boomy bass, very dark sound. Don't buy it for music.
why not if one is looking for exactly that
Andy Luong do your Logitech’s satellites distort after 65 percent volume?
Z623 is a disappointing buy for me, don't get it if you listen to music.
@@jamesrotunno6911 This speaker is very loud. I never turn it up to much
@Calamity I think I won't help much. The quality of the speaker has limited, the clarity is not there. Plus I am a simple user, use it as it is. Sold it after 3-4 months.
Ya jelas memang z263 karena itu subwoofer kalau r1280t wofer bookshleft
what the heck? only based on subwoofer and you think edifier is bad?
*If you listen to this test from the logitech Z623 on the headphones you will have a headache*
The lack of bass on the Edifier is horrible IMO
I think the model 1280 that ends "DB" fixes that but it's 50 box more or so.
@@absgames9425 The DB version just has bluetooth and additional input options, otherwise they are identical speakers.
@@barfo281 not according to the frequency response printed in the specs
Buy r1280ts + subwoofer maybe 🤔
I purchased the r1280ts, I don't plan on purchasing a sub as I live in a duplex and do not want to disrupt the neighbors have u heard them will I be satisfied with the bass I am not looking to shake my walls but I want to hear the bass.
THX certification is enough to say which one sounds best. Logitech always yeah.
THX certificación is like hi-res is pure marketing doesnt Say anything
But I trust on thx certification.
THX is owned my Razer the mice company.
To get THX certification it only needs to be a certain percent loud. Plus a healthy license fee paid to THX. It's all marketing and here it's clearly worked.
Hmm my logitch z263 sounded like cheap laptop speakers when I tried them
Check your ears
Unfortunately it's true. Just try the speakers without the sub and you'll see what he means. The woofer must be handling a lot of the mids.
ABS GAMES they are still fairly loud and have bass without the woofer but yes the woofer is mostly what puts them together
@@predispose no bass in those without the sub
HONDA RULES well yea no low frequency bass but that’s what the sub is for
Logitech win blu four many
Me listening with 20$ speakers : hmmm, yeahh both good speakers 🤣🤣
🤎🔊Videos! - GJK ↑ TAW!
- Questions Pls?
- What R The Bass & Treble Settings Set @ On Both?
- When U Screen Fade - Indicative Of Both Systems Playing(?) "Thnx!''
El logitech
edifier sound like coming from bucket🤔
That logitech looks fugly
Hi
Logitech is a cheap company ...
What you mean "Cheap"? I don't think so, bro
@@dariuss7923 It is cheap indeed, it aims at making profit while using cheap materials like plastic. Tell me one single 2.0 made out of wood from Logitech. Even better, tell me one single 2.1, 5.1 or 7.1 made out of wood from Logitech. Just because you're using a Logitech doesn't make it expensive or hi-fi and you'd understand that by using actually higher grade speakers. Logitech is simply an affordable company that makes PC speakers and pheripherals.
so true but people won't realise this until they try other quality brands like Edifier and Audioengine.
Logitech is not only one company using cheap plastic
You people don’t get it... Logitech is meant for people who want to play games or watch movies... Is not for music... If you want a perfect music then get a amp and 2.0 bookshelves speakers...
Edifier is a joke😂 too costly as compare the sound.
edifier sounds tiny.
На Man on fire обе системы сосут с проглотом. Просто невероятно ужасное звучание.
Debilni srovnani 🙈 srovnavejte 2.1 vs 2.1
A produkty se stejnou cilovou skupinou.
Logitech ma sice full range satelity, ale je urceny predevsim na elektronickou hudbu
Logitech is more like trash bass
Is the bass worse than the edifier's ? Im trying to buy a speaker between these two