Logitech Z623 vs Edifier R1700BT || 6-Track Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 лип 2024
- Edifier on bhphotovideo: bhpho.to/2CR4oLK
Edifier on amazon DE: amzn.to/33Vblan
Logitech on amazon DE: amzn.to/2URvitY
Logitech on amazon UK: amzn.to/2UNP7Cj
------------------------------
Follow me on instagram at / digitalstereophony for the latest updates and behind the scene look
----------------------------
All the tracks used in this video can be found here:
• Test Tracks
----------------------------
Sound recorded using Zoom H6 recorder. Levels matched using SPL meter. All tone controls set to neutral - Наука та технологія
Been waiting on this comparison forever. Thank you so much!!
Have you been thinking about making a blog with your personal ranking about sound quality of speakers you are testing?
I'm a bass pleb and still got the Edifiers because sound quality is better at mids and highs, you get BT connection and they look great. You can also dial in some more bass if you need to and still connect a subwoofer later for some extra punch (BTs version). Still, if you like a separate subwoofer for the same base price, the Logitech might be a better budget choice.
.
Also, I'm subscribing because this is the most non-BS speaker review I've ever seen
wow. Adding the source track makes a huge difference. You get a much better sense of what the speakers are not reproducing accurately, and sometimes it seems like what they're not reproducing at all. Fabulous video. How are you recording the sound in the room?
GREAT JOB! very usefull content. Thank you
Can I have the tittle of the Retro Wave music used in the video? Unable to find it. Thank you
Please compare Logitech Z623 with Edifier R2000DB need it so much thanks!
I like this channel, right down to business.
With SupremeFX, you might can use Z623 as if you had a Combo of both.
is it possible if you could even test HiVi D300 (Swans), please? Even Googe couldn't provide enough review. Thank you in advance.
thx for the vids. ill go 4 R1700BT 🔥
Hi. Can You compare Scansonic S5 BT and Heco Ascada 2.0?
Jesus them 1700's are good! So much missing in between on the z623
I love that full speed st
Which one plays better on higher volumes? Edifier or Logitech? I do not worry about subwoofer as I have good floor speakers that give good low BASS. I want quadro speakers and I wonder if it will be better to get Edifier or Logitech and use subwoofer as just extra speaker. Edifier in this comparison have better highs. But can it play loud as Logitech?
Please do comparison for Edifier 3600D vs Logitech Z623.
Thank u so much , I bought a R1700BT :)
Edifier doesn't need a sub. Those things have a really good and punchy bass. Unless you're using them outside or in an open space the bass is more than you need. I move mine from the living to my room and since my room is a small space I need to lower down the bass or it makes everything vibrating. Don't go with the impression than Logitech is better just because it has a sub. Edifier doesn't have a sub because this model doesn't need to. The bass can be so hard and really have a good punch. Also it has a really good definition and fidelity. I'd go with Edifier all the way, they're perfect as they are
Your saying that. But if you put a really decent sub with them you would disagree with your comment.
I was between these two and still got the Edifiers because sound quality is better on mids and highs, and you can still get a subwoofer on the BTs version if you feel you need it later on
As someone who owned both yes I can agree to this.
Edifier sounds very clean and crystal.. Also balanced for those punchy bass songs.. The best way to listen Classical Music
Playing both simultaneously through a y splitter and enjoying
I really enjoyed this comparison video! I own the Logitech Z623 and have been looking for a better alternative away from the wires. If the R1700BT sounds like this in person I'll be very happy!
bro? this battle was epic. the edifier is best in voice and the logitech with the bass. epic too the tracks you select.
My Chinese Edifier beg to differ. Vocal had a screen over it and not sounding as clear as i expected.
@@happybuggy1582 They are all Chinese. It is a Chinese brand AFAIK
very usefull ... thanks buddy
I bought Edifier 1700BT based on some of previous hearing session on your channel. And I have to say that they sounds incredibly nice. "Nice" is the best word that describes 1700BT. Bass is very soft and strong... very nice to listen to. The 1700BT set sounds best between 30%-60% percent of volume power ( I have maxed Trebles and +40% of the Bass ). In real BT1700 sounds better that in your comparison (I think it depends also on the room shape ... My room is small, full of obstacles that disperse the sound).
Edifier has beauty in sound. Definitely more high end..
is the difference between sound quality alot different in real life rather than just headphones, (im using sennheiser hd569) because i can tell a difference but not much
I hear a fairly notable difference on my 58X Jubilees.
Happy owner of the Edifier R1700BT thanks to this site. BT is actually a nice extra. For the price, it seemed like the best of the bunch. Light EQ to up the mids and you're good to go. Very fully sounding.
What is the bass like? Thinking of buying the 1850db (1700bt with optical and subwoofer ports) with a Yamaha sub I have collecting dust since I upgraded my home theatre. Is the bass good for movies and games? Can you feel it in the ground?
Does it lack bass?
Exactly I eq up the mids too and they are perfect
Please lay out the audio track in a separate file without pressing UA-cam. We will download and build with mkvmerge. So it will be clearer that sounds better. Thank.
the soundquality from youtube is in comparison with soundcloud, spotify and another company so worst, i nover hear music over yt but for comparison and hear the different is that ok. i am webdesigner, when
Digital Stereophony needs a little page i can help.
@@jenshuxley you are right, we aren't here to see exactly how these sound, more to see the comparison in the lows/mids/highs. For that you don't need super high quality. Also, Spotify is much higher quality than UA-cam unless you are playing on low-normal quality which I doubt many people do
for me is a comparison from non studio monitors so difficult. to feel music, maybe edifer, for fun and dance music logitech, for movie and gaming(needs good bass) logitech... edifer is easier to installation... i dont know, i dont like logitech mouse/keyboard(bad experience) but for gaming/movie is the bigger bass good and with a EQ i can set less bass and give a bit more high frequences and have a good and cheap setup, but logitech looks veary cheep... not easy!
after 623 edifier sound like bass free sound system. i have 623 for its size bass is superb.
Can you please do a Rockville APM6W 6.5 inch please!! I need to buy some monitors but I need to know if they are better than the Edifier r1700bt.
do one with the Tascam vl-s5 please
edifier soun looks amazing on my logitech z625
Logitech Z623 got harmony sounds from the subwoofer and sounds more alive
Edifier R1700BT stands in clearity and easy listening
Hello guys, I wanted to ask which is better for youtube, movies and gaming between logitech z625 and edifier 1700bts, I am really confused as to which one to get
I have Logitech Z533. Are Edifier R1700DB better?
Love ping pong party music for testing
Me too haha epic
Heh
why was the intro SO LOUD?
Which speaker sounds better than you ?
Edifier more bright... Love
Logitech Z623 looks quite good. Bass isn't bad.
Edifier ❤️
i own both speaker, logitech is perfect for gaming superb bass, best with fps game like COD, and edifier is all rounder crisp high, great mid, and good bass..
Thanks!!...
Ping pong, orleans jazz, deep
Those 3 should applied to all test...
Sad there is no deep here
But thank you for the review!
I personally go for logitech z623, test with my Moondrop Blessing 2 (350 $
Edifier R1700BT sound more clarty. Thanks for all compare.
The Logitech's lack of tweeters is killing off all the detail, though at least the subwoofer gives it more bass volume bad sadly, the extension isn't enough for reasonably accurate audio reproduction, hence the boominess wihout the actual punch.
In short, it's a case of clarity detail with a lack of bass vs. more boomy bass with a lack of detail.
What not so many people know is that carefully designed full range speakers can be more accurate in detail than average 2 or 3 way systems. A good full range speaker really can sound incredibly clear. There is no crossover problem with full range speakers. The Z623 has those carefully designed full range speakers with also a huge magnet (common in all good full range speakers). I have the Z623 and continuously amazed how well they sound in such a small case. The detail is really great which explains why they are THX certified and I think is well deserved.
@@simondovinsky2734 while that may be true, you aren't getting the same exact details as say: Klipsch Promedia 2.1 THX. So I'd say they failed on the top end side of things because it's really difficult to supplement highs on par with a 2 way. I have both systems to say this confidently
Edifier R1700bt nice bass,...
Sir, do you know to connect edifier r1700 to subwoofer?
google and you will find the answer. Parallel wiring with channels on the sub bridged looping back . The have diagrams on forums you can find through google.
Or u could just buy a r1850db with a dedicated subwoofer port...
I just returned my Z623, it's crap! The satellites sound like tinny phone speakers! It's only good for heavy bass and volume, and would drive my neighbors mad. I live in a one bedroom apartment with a lounge of 4 by 5 meters. I'm considering the R1700BT. It will be my only sound system, hooked up to the PC and TV. Will they be good enough for that?
The Z623 has more volume, but the sound image becomes very spongy with bass-heavy music, so that the highs and mids of the small satellites are almost completely lost.
U can reduce the bass and increase the treble than it sounds really close to the edifier i mean in clearity
@@sizzy7549 impossible. Turning up the treble just means boosting a certain higher frequency. A whole chunk of frequency is missing!
@@AbsoluteFidelity i know that logitech is bass heavy but i have experienced that biggers subwoofers are about the quality of bass not the quantity of bass but logitech can't win on high end it is just good for low end
@@sizzy7549 in no way shape or form the logitech's bass is high quality. Quantity yes, but 0 quality. Have you heard how good subs sound, even good budget subs? The speed, accuracy and low rumble are what is missing on the logitech's sub. That sub cant even play deep, it has an obnoxious 60hz boost that makes it sound more 'powerful' but in reality that is all it does. From bass to mids to highs, the logitech fails badly. Its only good at one thing, its cheap.
@@AbsoluteFidelityIt's funny how audiophile "experts" often don't even bother to listen to something cheaper without negative prejudices. No, it's not top quality, but definitely above average. Why do i think that? Yes, the bass is loud, but it still has resolution, the notes are audible. The satellites do not have a recessed midrange - very good for home cinema, which is probably the main use of these speakers, after all, they are THX certified.. Each class has its own standards..
Well there are some reasons to not buy logitech speakers. The Satelites are made of plastic and are 1 way speakers (no mid/tweeter setup). They can’t be sounding that great. I bought the RT1280DBs + Edifier T5 subwoofer, i’m sure it will do a great job
sub would be cool for video games and explosions so i think ill go for z623 but the 1700 are very clear hmm its tough
The edifier would be better with a sub. The Logitech isn't very hi-end sounding, at least, through my earbuds. In other words, I'd prefer the edifier with the addition of a sub.
Its the mids that are missing with the Logitechs and making the massive difference
i went from z623 to edifier r1850db + wharfedale diamond sw150 and it is great night and day difference
Edifier it's not Hi end at all
@@ernestopablo3026 well the S3000PRO certainly are ! ua-cam.com/video/WSp30KG-jp0/v-deo.html
@@ellisfletcher3491 Hi Ellis! Lol!
much more details on the edifier
J’ai le logitech et je constate qu’il n’est pas fait pour de la musique. Le bass enveloppe tout; les deux satellites ne suivent pas; Ils ont un médium très plat et des aigus indescriptibles. Du coup, pour écouter de la musique, je préfere la TDK trek A25.
Logitech more bass, Edifier more crisp sound.
Edifier BTs gets the option for adding a subwoofer....separately
Body and weight of logitech's bass is obvious. It is up to user. If u want that bass, logitech is way to go.
Edifier sounds cleaner
Are you using a special soundcard or interface which is affecting the Soundquality?
Sound was sourced from laptop via Behringer Monitors2USB interface for this video
@@DSAUDIOreview So is this thing affecting the quality much? I am asking because I am thinking about an soundcard for my r1280t
It sounds quite transparent, but is not really necessary, it is there more for the convinience of switching between the monitors on the fly. For R1280T I would not spend any extra on interface as there will be no audible improvemnt in sound quality. Just use Your headphone jack in Your laptop or PC and You will be fine
@@maxr3653
For this speakers go for XFI Extreme Gamer/Music good card for low price, if you have integrated sound card like alc 887/892 etc.
I change first alc 887 to audigy SE (huge difference), and next audigy se to xfi gamer (another level up of quality) on my r1600tIII.
There is list of good ones www.audiofanatyk.pl/polecane-daci-i-karty-dzwiekowe/
any recommendation a subwoofer for Edifier R1700BT?
there is no subwoofer out. maybe you can split out the base from a component that wouldn't be redundant with the active speaker? I have these and the bass is pretty good though, will shake the room a bit.
Edifier T5
Try ths sub
Mivoc Hype 10 G2
Edifier T5 8" 70W Powered Subwoofer
Edifiers with logitech sub 🔥😂
to much to muddy, boomy and slow, no thx to this logitech sub.
I want to buy speakers for my Samsung TV kindly guide me bro Edifier r1700bt Vs Logitech z337. Which is better in sound quality and bass?
slight win for the Z333/7 in the bass department, the small sub kicks well and goes deep enuff for its size and power.
but the R1700BT take it away in general overall soundquality and detail and the bass is not bad either, not exactly sub levels, but you can get more out of them as you can hear right now in this vid.
check the Edifier S3000PRO here's a demo ua-cam.com/video/WSp30KG-jp0/v-deo.html
Can logitech sub be used with 1790bt??
Nope, there are custom connections on the logitech like a 15 pins VGA type connector between the satellite (right channel) and the subwoofer.
I don't get why Edifier doesn't have a bookshelf/computer system with Sub to compete in this segment.
They do. S350DB
ua-cam.com/video/LoUt487ttgc/v-deo.html
@@st0rm617 I’m going to have to take a look at those!
Z623 vrs klipsch pro media 2.1
Yesss
I'm kind of amazed by the fact that R1700BT only has one drive and sounds better than most hi-fi speakers I've heard.
Then you haven't actually heard any "hi-fi" speakers.
Not saying the edifiers are bad! For the price they're actually great.
@@JaygeLP Arrogant assumption there
EDIT: There are some trashy hi-fi speakers out there
@@HBMHD I bought some r1700bts for my mother last year and they're amazing for the price.
They're great budget speakers but they definitely don't compare to proper Hi-Fi speakers.
I have Dali Zensor 1s myself and once you've heard some actual HiFi speakers like some KEF R3s or something you know that both of these just aren't Hi-Fi. Nothing arrogant about it.
@@JaygeLP I'm not calling you arrogant, I'm calling your assumption arrogant
in short just teill me which one to buy?
Logitech, since you sound like you don't know anything about sound quality, you'll probably be able to appreciate the Logitech subwoofer thump but not so much the clarity of the edifier
EDM and Gaming definitely go for Logitech（more punchier bass）
Vocal and Pop Songs go for Edifier（more crispier treble）
**But for competitive gaming， headphones are more recommended**
Logitech 2.1 vs edifier 2.0. Can you disable the logitech subwoofer?
Yes
That's an unfair comparison. The Edifier have woofers built in but the Logitech are just single drivers. It'll be Edifier easy then
I can't fit that sub on my desk....
HappyBuggy it would be better to put it under if possible 😅
Edifier is best
Much better Logitech Z623 has more harmony on the bass and it is not bad in the mids, for the highs you can work with the equalizer, ... while Edifier R1700BT you cannot work much on the bass with an equalizer !
Wdym? you can't work on highs too well for Logitech due to no tweeter
@@DarkwareTNP Yup I just returned my Z623, it's crap! The satellites sound like tinny phone speakers! It's only good for heavy bass and volume, and would drive my neighbors mad. I live in a one bedroom apartment with a lounge of 4 by 5 meters. I'm considering the R1700BT. It will be my only sound system, hooked up to the PC and TV. Will they be good enough?
The Z623 satellites sound muddy as fuck. I've been using them for over 2yrs. I also enjoy classical music. So the disappointing mids and highs are that much more noticable. My EQ settings are ridiculous just to get anywhere near decent sounding mids. The sub is ok but after awhile you notice its just boomy and not very accurate. Needless, to say I'm going to be upgrading very soon.
What did u upgrade to?
The Z623 are not suitable for classical music. However for modern music and movies they are great. Since I have the Z623 I can now hear how bad some productions are of several songs which I could not hear with ordinary speakers. That's a bit of a disadvantage, you really can distinguish good and bad productions. Example of a good production: ua-cam.com/video/GiIdnJ-PNhg/v-deo.html
logitech sound are more similar to the sound of source track. edifier is more high in treble and less in low.
Due to that thx certification.
It's delivering the original audio
Probably adding a sub to edifier makes is superior to Logitech
I dont think like that because it is depend on your speaker that u are listening too. My side edifer is better.
The logitechs sound awful I bought them when the first came out and returned them the next say the bass is so muddy and drowns out the already lackluster highs and mids just plastic trash not well built like the edifires about six months or so afo i bout the edifire 1700bts and so far I'm impressed with the sound quality
Kesimpulan ku yang edifier menang di clarity kejenihan
Dan Logitech menang di bass nya sebagian clarity juga mantap untuk speaker 2.1 pas gak berlebihan seperti yang lain contoh altec
Edifier has much crisper highs than the logitech.
I bought z623 for $65 and I aint complaining.
a 2.1 system vs a 2.0 system... of course the logitech will have better bass with that subwoofer...
I am sad because edifier has no sub output
Much more dynamic in the Logitech especially in the low end. Although the Edifier has more clarity the Logitech is more enjoyable .
Which one is better ?
Logitech z623 is okay for parties and such. The mids are terrible and tinny.
R1700BT
Logitech Z623 sounds better dynamically, but other songs play better with the Edifier R1700BT.
I choose Edifier R1700BT.
Edifier sounds better
I can't help to wonder if many of the people saying Edifier have enough bass were listening without a subwoofer.
It's night and day.
Don't get me wrong, the r1700 sounds noticeable better in almost everything else, but once you got a subwoofer, is hard to go back.
@@lexluthor4156 Fully agree, there is no substitute for subwoofers and you only need one.
the problem with logitech's is that after using them for over a year, you get a terrible coal whining high pitched noise from the subs when the unit is idling or in low volume. I ve used their most expensive speakers such as Z5500 and some budget ones; each and every one of them developed this very same annoying problem, so I m not buying any sound equipment from logitech. Yes they do sound really good in the beginning but , because they re built with such low quality, they wont last long...
Microlab solo 7c vs Logitech z623
Z623 vs Solo 6C is coming, Solo 7C vs Z623 is not
@@DSAUDIOreview ok
даже без саба, Эдифайр звучит лучше.. в том числе и бас передает естественней..
Edifier all day long
I haven't read any comments yet. Listening with a nice set of headphones, the Logitech sound much better to me. They're far closer to the source track. I find the high end to be present and accurate, noting the hi-hat in particular. I find the edifier to be missing low end almost entirely in some tracks and it's too shrill and tinny in the highs.
Logitech z623 lack of treble. Because it dont have tweeter. Only full mid range.
My experience is that the Z623 have very good full range speakers up until about 14 kHz or so, for younger people this is maybe a bit too low but for a little bit older people high enough.
I'm in the 50s and very happy with the Z623. The bass is really great, well balanced and with good connection to the satellite speakers.
Is it just my ears that hears these Logitechs as far less accurate and less balanced in the low, mid and high sound spectrum compared to the Edifiers' performance next to each other?? This video made me realise that Logitech 2.1 speaker sets are simply student dorm value computer speakers..
Edifier 6 Logitech 5
Edifier has more body in the sound.
logitech rules
Logitech je delanej na moderni hudbu s bassama, proto ma silny woofer a ostatni uz neni nic moc. Ale pri dobry zdroji zvuku umi i Logitech (Tang Band) zahrat slusne za ty prachy.
Kazdopadne Woofer patri na zem, takhle to vic zkresluje.
Nelze hodnotit kvalitu zvuku, kdyz mate "vyskovy repro" vedle wooferu.
The difference on bass quality is huge between those two. Edifier is way better. Sadly the driver cant reach too low frequences due its size.
so the edifier loses then? you just said "bass quality" and "cant reach too low" lmao
@@puresesh7985 , he s right, logitech can only play one kind of sound
@@oliviu11119 one kind of sound? wym speakers play all kinds of sounds idiot.
@@oliviu11119 Late here, but holy fuck that took a turn
I think my R101V sound better than any Logitech that were recommended honestly no offence though I really like their mouses but speaker no at the moment.
Again the edifier is noticeably thin and tinny even against the Logitech