Why is China punishing Australia? The human impact of the trade war | Four Corners
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 тра 2024
- Over the last twelve months, China has launched a wave of trade sanctions against Australia.
Industry after industry has been hit with a range of punishing measures, from massive new taxes to import restrictions.
As a result, many Australian products have effectively been banned from entering China, leaving the businesses that rely on this trade in peril.
But why is China punishing Australia and who is at risk?
From the barley fields of WA’s salt lake country to the lobster trawlers of Hobart, Four Corners reveals the human and financial cost of the ongoing dispute.
Read the story in English: www.abc.net.au/news/2021-04-2....
Read the story in Chinese: www.abc.net.au/chinese/2021-0....
_________
Watch more Four Corners investigations here: bit.ly/2JbpMkf
You can also like us on Facebook: / abc4corners
Follow us on Twitter: / 4corners
And sign up for our newsletter: www.abc.net.au/4corners/newsl...
_____________
Australia was siding with America with politics, unease about China's rise, and yet expecting China not punching back, what a joke!
errr i think it all started because china released a plague on the world again. I think China bought a gun into a punch up
@@millennium677 you doing alot of bad thinking aren't you😂😂
@@ionly6805 am I?
@@millennium677 Come on you guys still on to that fake news??! International scientists have already made it very clear it isn't from a lab. You guys just eat up every single Western propaganda produced without questioning anything and never even looking at opposing sources. The difference is that people on our side know both sides(not our choice since Western propaganda is so ubiquitous and has such great distribution worldwide) and looked at facts whereas people on your side simply are mindless bots eating up every single Western propaganda vomited out by Western news.
@@sleepyhead6468 I never said it was from a lab LOL it undoubtedly came from China same us most plagues have Bubonic Plague, Spanish flu all came from China and were the most fatal viruses in history, its due to humans being too populated in a small area surrounded by animals, its basic virology heavily dense populations of people surrounded by animals causes viruses
Australia: *talks shit about china every chance, bans huawei and tech companies, talks about decoupling
China: *starts the decoupling
Australia: why is china punishing me???!!! Economic bullying!!!!
Banning Huawei was in the interest of the aussies
@@laurafulop2486 I believe it was America who banned Huawei..
A would love to see a meteor hit China.. holy shit that'll make every country's day
@@ZeeLover123 I can not believe I'd see some one so cruel and heartless as a fellow human beings!
@@AihuaWestwood boohoo, world isn't sunshine and rainbows. Especially in a communist country where they kill their own. The world is better off without China.
It seems China has learned from the US in terms of applying sanctions as a form of a promoting “Free trade practices”!
China has been doing sanctions before anyone else
The CCP has been doing it to Korea before Trump. We know who the real bully is.
@@pgood7266 You're joking right ! Sanctions has always been the tool of USA ever since the USD became the worlds reserved currency, total abuse of that privelidge.
America egged the Australian government on, who then poked China in the eye, and now Australians are paying the price and telling the government they understand and that they did the right thing, in a perfect world they did, in a business world they got a bit cheeky, bet it really chaps their ass that after instigating alot of it - America picked up 30% of their wine exports
Australian politicians, playing politics with people's livelihoods, in order to please their master.
It's simple you cannot depend largely on China's huge import of Aust exports and yet on the other hand you are following America's anti-China policy.
…..seems you can
@@Droo75 australia doesn't... we trade with them (a lot) but that is because they are willing to pay....
we may trade with them - doesn't mean we trust them.....
@@albertbresca8904 that’s exactly what I was saying 🤯
@@Droo75 and who do they in fact trust? no one it seems....
and they make enemies of their neighbors (India) who are a similar size population wise.....
US's words: We stand with you Australia, don't crack under pressure!
US's actions: hey China, I can sell you Maine lobster, california wines, iron ore and everything that you don't want from Australia!
truckers thought they're selling something unique. 😁😁😁
To add to your comment, Trump made the comment, we stand with you Australia - Geriatric Joe made the “Hey China” move after the Democrats fraudulently removed him from office....
@@majoysuico Biden kept everything Trump levied against China, so what are you complaining about?
just shut up with your left right political nonsense man people like you just bizarre
@@abdiganiaden stop for being so rude... Mind your words
the us is a bad guy . they sell everything to china while the guy puts a wedge in relations between you and china. and bad guys in your goverment are foolish enough to stand with the us . they should be blamed . you australian traders have fallen into victims of the aus foreign policies towords china. it is not too late to turn around for australia now.
I don't think "China punishing Australia", I think "Australia seeks punishing from China" on behalf of USA. Current Australia administration's only foreign policy is blindly following US.
That’s what exactly I am thinking 🤔
Australia chose wrong enemy... Donald trump trade war with China, how about the result? Australia IQ and EQ really has problem.
china has screwed us the same in the past for no reason... so it was not unexpected ... and only was a matter of time..
nothing to do with the US.... as it was going to happen sooner or later anyway....
@@user-il8bv4fg7p china stopped trade a few times in the past decades before trump...
and for no apparent reason (than china trying to bring us to our knees... worked so well then...lol) ....
we knew this was coming sooner or later... why not give china a reason and see how they react .. well see if they will seem to think about it or get pretend offended again (stop eating bats!!!)
@@albertbresca8904 yes Dont get oN your knees, hold oN 🤣
The title should be "Why is Australia committing economic suicide?"
Not even one interviewee says anything like " Aussie government should change their way towards china".
It's as if things just happen out of nowhere. And also, it's not a trade war. It's soft sanctions
Just the wine ppl. They can go to China and cry about it
Funny even if that sentence is said, it won't show up on the creen for you. This is not politicallly correct. I can see them all expecting Au goverment to do something but couldn't let the words out. "Australia's trade amount with China is almost nothing to China and losing it wouldn't hurt China at all. All the bad results will only hurt Australia." - according to a Chinese professional on youtube.
That's 'cause were sick and tired of the stand over tactics of communist China, not just with Australia but many other countries as well. If they had the guts to allow other freedom of politics instead of bashing in the heads of anyone who dissents then we would be prepared to take a look at how Aussie government should change. Just look at HK.
@@LuiBei1994 : The wine went to Hong Kong. Now, the lobster went there too. China is cracking down on that.
"why is Australia punishing China ?"
If the concern is human rights then worry about the Aboriginals
👍👍👍
@Handsome Hobo Has they been sterilized? Its a long story white Aussie have long done to the native.
It's not about human rights, its because Australia called for an investigation into the origins of the corvid virus .
@@byroneckhardt4131 No, its not relate. WHO already investigated it.
@Handsome Hobo make your complaints to the government who let Chinese buy our lands. Chinese simply following Australian law and you can’t accept their cash then complaining they buy too much. Vote the government out and change the law.
Mr C: I’m your biggest customer.
Mr A: So what? I still don’t like you. You are a culprit to me. Whatever you do offended me.
Mr C: I don’t want to buy from you.
Mr A: How dare you? Are you trying to bully me?
Mr C: I’m buying from your competitors.
Mr A: You are such an ungrateful. I’ll never compromise on my values & rights. You are trampling on my freedom & I’ll practice self defense with my friends in front of your house.
Mr C:......silent
Mr A: How dare you ignore me!!
And then Daddy Sam shows up.
@@nomad7381 Daddy Sam to Australia dying in a ditch : bless you , son .
@Mark Wellington jesus save you .
@Mark Wellington you are in China now ? My prayer for you .
Geo-politics aside. I feel bad for the men and women working in the agricultural industry especially those affected by sanctions.
That's Canberra's fault
@Citizen of the DPRK: When politicians play game, people usually get the shorter end of the stick. Vote them out . . . simple.
Sanctions vs a shut down that ruined then global economy.
Asking for independent investigation into corona virus was enough to see China have a hissy fit.
Stand strong Australia. Dirty communist China owes the world trillions in reparations for the damage done through corona .
feel bad for the 300 million chinese who are running on their chinese banks, waiting in line from 3 am and told they can withdraw a $100 a day. LMAO. Save your feelings for those truly hurting. Like Jack Ma. No lights on at home there anymore.
@@josephlee7054 Follow up the story. Every bank insured half a million currency for each bank account. International practice.
This is the consequence of being a puppy of US instead being the president of your people's interest.
China has banned Australian wheat, barley, red wine, and coal, but the United States has increased its exports to China. The United States thanks Australia for its generosity.
@bronzed Aussie No you guys are fakes and hypocrites look how australian military used Afghanistan innocent to train your coward soldier. This is parfait double standard of Aussies to preach humain rights to attack the others countries.
Gong fei
Got back stabbed by US and still thinks US is a friend??
It's simple....stop buying cheap chinese products stop supporting communists....... that's the only way you can hurt china and make them learn...support other democratic countries and your own
@@marsroma3668 stop selling rare earth to USA military is the best way to save innocent people in the World
In 1950, we bombed North Korea/China, 1954 bombed Guatemala, 1958 bombed Indonesia,1959 bombed Cuba, 1960 bombed Guatemala, 1964 bombed Kongo, 1964 bombed Laos, 1961 bombed Vietnam, 1969 bombed Cambodia, 1967 bombed Guatemala, 1982, Granada, 1983 bombed Lebanon, 1986 bombed Libya, 1980 bombed Ecuador, 1980 bombed Nicaragua, 1987 bombed Iran, 1989 bombed Panama, 1991 bombed Iraq, 1991 bombed Kuwait, 1993 bombed Somalia, 1994 bombed Bosnia, 1998 bombed Sudan, 1998 bombed Afghan, 1990 bombed Yugoslavia, 2002 bombed Yemen, 1991 bombed Iraq, 2003 bombed Iraq, 2011 bombed Afghan, 2007 bombed Pakistan, 2008 bombed Somalia, 2009 bombed Yemen, 2011 bombed Libya, 2014 bombed Syria.
But we are very concerned about China threatening the world.
Jahangeer Khan - It is beyond unbelievable that there are still brainwashed sheep who cannot see through the west propaganda.
Australians say; Do as I say, don't do as I do.
Damn, what did Guatemala do to deserve this?
When governments and businesses stop making money out of peddling death and destruction will this nonsense stop, but of course it won't. Yes, we should be concerned about China's current political trajectory. China's government is rubbish. It doesn't act in the best interest of its own people or the world. It wants to be a world power, but what does it have to offer? I don't see anything coming out of China that inspires, evokes confidence or optimism. Here we have another totalitarian regime grasping for wealth and power. The only thing close to the heart of China's Communist Party is its own survival at all cost.
@@bannol1 your comment is straight out of western fear mongering media.
Ok. You win. White is might.
Moral of story, You cant fight war while having business with each other.
It is now 2024 now. The result of China's trade tariffs has proven "China has no power over Australia". Just stating the facts.
The problem is that Australia and other countries put all their eggs in one basket which is utterly stupid and short sighted. At least you allowed resources in the ocean, land to recover.
Actually it's very simple, if KFC accusing their customers for being chicken abusers, they will stop eating KFC fried chicken.
@bronzed Aussie you have been blinded by your politicians from seeing the facts.
@@b00tysmith racist
@bronzed Aussie come on mate don't spoil my business.
Every one can try our tasty bat soup for 2$ /bowl. We are specialized in every animal soups and we even take party orders. Our Popular items from the menu below
1957-1958 - H2N2 soup.
1968-1969 - H3N2 soup.
1997-2004 - H5N1 soup.
2003 - SARS soup.
2006 - Bird Flu soup.
2009 - Swine Flu noodles.
2013 - Porcine Pestivirus fried noodles. 2019 - Covid-19 special bat soup.
Pls order us through only or call she sing pig for further queries.
Conditions applied: the livestock we use are may be infected, as a traditional Chinese culinary we eat them alive. Pls feel comfortable to order and new recipes are on the way.
@bronzed Aussie Right on, now you can stay home and enjoy the below cost wine and beef, really happy for you!
@@RahulGupta-db3yj Definitely want to try Kuwalla soup, and wonder how kangaroo taste like, but people said actually lots beef they ate is kangaroo or horse meat.
“Don’t you stand up to the bullies?”funny, isn’t Australia standing WITH the biggest bully on this planet? Sadly, that big bully does not care about his ass-kisser.
Exactly right. The US will use Aus, and Aus will be punished for it's anti-China moves. As China is the future, why not try to make friends?
If you dont treat your customers friendly, then there is no reason they will be back shopping.
Australia is not anti China , we are just pro Australian. Australia is just exercising its soverignity by not giving China the right to decide what Australia can do. Australia is not part of China. It's our country.
Why still sell iron ore to China? Why not simply stop all trade with China?
Make up your mind and come clean on sovereignty.
Perhaps now an Aussie can buy one of its own lobsters for the realistic price of AUD$20 per kilo.
It is simple,you will not buy any thing from a shop who insult you every day.Don't insult your customer is the first rule in business.
cannot agree more
When the customer fabricated images of you solders killing children what do you want them to do. Let that slide and not caution them
@@noahbrown8275 Who told you your cutomer is killing children?Have found any evidence or original footage for that,have you realized tha all you heared is just fake story?You can find footage taken in world war II,have you found any evidence you called today?
@@noahbrown8275 Australian soldiers (note the correct spelling) killing Afghanistan civilians including children was reported by BBC/CNN etc., not the Chinese media, and it wasn't fabricated, the footage was from the soldiers' bodycams, the acts were confirmed by the Australian military. China did the right thing by cutting ties with such a savage country so undeveloped at the human rights level. If Australia believes the Chinese government has wrongdoings, it should've stopped trading with China in the first place, like China, instead of whining about China stopped trading with Australia.
@@pinkcichlid Australia is a morally far superior trading partner compared to China. The labor camps in China are a systematic attempt to eradicate an entire culture. This is far worse, than a few soldiers disobeying their orders and being needlessly cruel. In one case it's an ongoing political agenda, in the other case there were single perpetrators without any political backing. Also, if you want proof of the labor camps: there is plenty, reaching from satellite pictures to witness testimonies. Just use your favorite search engine and if your internet is not being censored, you will certainly find all the proof you need in less than an hour.
Australia has joined the US and its allies in declaring a Cold War on China, and China has responded accordingly.
@Al Pacino yes china are very much clear of the virus while the west is still scratching it's balls thinking what to do.
@@vpatron8085 the arsonist inadvertently burned down his own house.
THIS IS THE PRICE YOU PAY FOR BEING A PAWN AND VASSAL STATE TO THE US. IN CHILE WE ARE SELLING OUR WINE AS NEVER BEFORE...
LOL other way around, Xi has been waging a Cold War on America from within and without since 2012!
@Al Pacino Well, the Wuhan Institute of Virology, China, doing the bat virus experimentation was interestingly funded by US National Institute of Health, as the conduct of such experiments was made illegal in the American soil and was only lifted by Trump administration in 2017. Not saying the virus is of Lab origin as there are no evidences to prove yet, but the whole connections to that lab that everyone is curious about is interesting.
Definitely self-inflicted wounds. Stop hurting yourself, and treat your trade partners with respect. Stand up to the bullying US and UK.
LOL.
AU and UK are puppets of the U.S
@@Teolulz What's so funny about the whole lame puppet/lapdog name calling is that it's aimed at whatever country has refused to do what China wants. It appears that being obedient is just fine and dandy as long as you are being obedient to China. Displease China and suddenly you are a puppet of the US (which is apparently not fine and dandy).
@@45641560456405640563 hahahaha you got hurt for being called a lapdog? In most of Australia's history, they were a lapdog of world power ( UK and US )
@@roanlancephil9915 Errr, no. I was merely making an observation. Well done on completely missing the point.
Talk about killing the goose that laid the golden eggs: 30:38 "Without China a catch that used to fetch $80 a kilo is getting as little as $25.00". I think that is supply and demand in free trade. So it seems from this that the Chinese got tired of being taken? $80 for a $25 dollar product.
stop with the supply and demand. selling arms to terrorists is supply and demand in free trade. grow a brain
Donald Trump: " American First."
Scott Morrison: "Yes. American First."
@fred james native american : "you're right, we simply not allowed to breathe anymore" 😂😂
Nice try Prongalong. Now go have fifty cents worth of noodles.
@@kenbellchambers4577 I could only buy your brain with that amount of money lmaoo🤣🤣
Of late Australia PM is acting like a child crying wolf beating WAR DRUM like China is planning to invade Australia like what US army supported by Australia invaded Iraq based on WMD lie. Australia echos whatever US leader barks without thinking of repercussion on Australian farmers , traders, businessman & universities. Only N.Z. pm shows better maturity in dealing relation with China.
@bronzed Aussie if America is first, Australia must be second
Australian politicians are not decided by Australian but by Americans. Maybe it is the reason.
Some Americans are Australian citizens. So based on that I would agree.
If it feels clever to say so...
You mean Australian foreign policies are decided by America, don't you? I fully agree with you.
@Richard Prat Russia is also a democratic country but she does not follow US policy. Iran and Pakistan are also democratic countries but they do not follow US foreign policies. The same is true of many African countries! Australia is just like an adolescent that is still tied to her mother's apron strings. She is not yet fully independent. Queen Elizabeth techincally still has the power to fire your PM. Australia looks up to the UK and the US as her masters and surrenders her sovereignty over foreign policy to these two countries. Unfortunately Biden is still following the policy of America first (though more subtly) and Australia is only a pawn to be used. All your farm produce which you used to export to China are now supplied by the US who will not hesitate to replace Australia to make money from the China trade.
Why not Australian do the export to American and economically strongest link with American? When American invaded Iraq , why Australian do not say anything on this tragedy. It is not difficult to think and figure out.
THIS is an excellent, comprehensive explanation of the on-going (and worsening) quarrel/conflict, something that I was seeking to grab a more comprehensive understanding of. Many THNX for a job well done.
just showing a few businesses hurt by this .. when they should have known as china has done this to us a few times in the past (not honoured contracts... turned back ships... things like that ) for no reason.....
most people here are not affected
I feel really bad for the hardworking Australians, but let's get this straight: the Australian government is to be blamed here.
Your government has chosen to fight other's war instead of putting your well being as priority. If they really care about human rights record, they would have never dealt with both US and China (and I'd argue that the US has done worse).
It's not about human rights, it's plain politics for the benefits of those on top.
To add, the overall export to China from Australia has increased because of iron ore. So essentially your government is still dealing with China with or without your (ordinary Australians) support.
Now who owns these iron ore businesses? Not ordinary Australians for sure. So ask yourself this: "why are you being asked to sacrifice your livelihood when those on top are making money with China?"
Duh, in democracy, they choose those leaders to form the government to represent them . Hell as guilty....
Asking for independent investigation into Corona was what triggered the Chinese.
China is to blame. You can scapegoat the politicians in Australia but won’t change reality and what China created ……
China placed the tariffs and China is the one leaving Australian imports like Lobster to rot with pathetic excuses of "anti-dumping" among others. Australia thankfully has proven to develop their exports to other regions and most industries are nowhere near as deeply impacted as China's own industries that so heavily relied on cheap imports from the close at hand Australia including vital key resources like meat, grains, iron ore, and coal. Power to the Australian people and power to their continued growth despite China's underhanded efforts to force submission.
@@franciosdauteuil4626 Australians who treated their natives as animals?..
if Australian government doesn't care about China's interest, why should Chinese care about Australia's? my only question.
all australians have been heavily brainwashed, reading through the comments section it is sad to see how deteriorated their mental state is.
@fred james The whole world knows you have been heavily brainwashed, all you said is pure garbage,
@@zharkoo Yes indeed they Australian themself that become communist. They are prey of MSM deep state controlled media to act against others and got severe damage.
@@julielumsden397 sent warships in south china sea to threaten the Chinese with war, criticized China on Hong Kong and the Muslim minority, banned Huawei products
@@julielumsden397 I frankly don't know why, all I am doing is following the news, not that I have any more information than that :-) My best guess is exactly what they say in the video: "Australian government displayed repeated unfriendly behavior and we decided to fire back", that seems pretty honest statement from CCP. Perhaps to add to that they know that Australia unlike other countries depends on China (40% of all exports from Australia go to China), so that pissed them off, on the one hand they feed Australia on the other hand they are biting them... If China imposed tariffs on other countries it would not hurt them as much. I come from a western country, and I am shocked that everyone is so vigorously blaming China for everything while totally ignoring our rotten behavior. The massive propaganda and brainwashing is staggering. It's not China, WE are the problem, perhaps China is a problem as well but not nearly as large as the western leadership. I don't like China, but I definitely hate the western establishment - collection of psychopathic murderers.
This story tells us “if you want an enemy, you will have an enemy”.
And China is our enemy.
What does China gain by making enermies with all countries around the world? Is there any country that China is a friend with or does it want to try enslave and abuse everyone? Australia has lots of friends from all over the world because we love to help the under dog, the down trodden, lift up the weak and make them strong.
Yunjuan Feng Pet dogs cannot declare war. Their masters can.
@@yunjuanfeng591 Barking dogs seldom bites, moreover, when it comes to a lap dog.
@@venderstrat america is behind all these
It seems China is starting to follow our pioneered & accepted international practice of applying “Maximum Pressure” without humanitarian accountability?
Yes indeed they are learning fast isn't it?.
Very true when the west doing this for centuries no one is complaining and those countries kneel, now China did it to them it’s a suppression of freedom of expression. Lol… heck even USA is smart enough not to do bad move on economic trade wars, they know that imagine if all electronic manufacturing stops in china what will happen to it
You are bias
The irony is that US beef exporters have replaced Aussie exporters!
40% of Australian export went to China and Australia went to pick a fight with them. What to do.
USA for rescue
@@philipjfry4465 China has bought over 23 billion worth of agricultural goods from US, about 70% of Phase 1 of the trade agreement.
Let them starve then...China has to buy their food from somewhere. They can’t trade war their way into power
China has far more land and can eat something else but dogs
@@CRAZYCR1T1C Er, China produces more food than any other country in the world. Meanwhile, Australia's not even in the global top 20 food producing countries. Even countries like Turkey, Italy and Thailand produce more food than today's Australia. China really, seriously doesn't need our food.
PS - "Let them starve", nice sentiment - not.
Economic decoupling with China...isn’t it what the Australians wished for?
Engage your brain for a change.
@Reido Astria As in I'm telling the person to use their brain.
@Reido Astria It's very important. The original post seems to be from a fairly brainwashed individual. Basically as soon as you see a comment like that you know they haven't thought things through.
@Reido Astria Generally it's only the more brainwashed types that stagger about the internet declaring Australia wanted to 'decouple'. Oh sure it probably feels empowering for them and gets some flippant 'likes' but it has little to do with the reality of the situation. Anyone who'd thought things through wouldn't make that sort of comment. It's just knee-jerk waffle.
@Reido Astria LOL. If only you were genuine in your line of questioning. Alas of course you are barking up a tangent, so to speak. And no doubt doing so knowingly.
It's observational. If a person says something that shows they've not thought things through then chances are they haven't. So either probably not a deep thinker or brainwashed to parrot certain platitudes. If it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck and walks like a duck it's probably a ????
Some things are self-evident. Not everything is shown by a link to a text book or similar. Some things are obvious merely by observation. Like the woman who used to live in the same building as my family who used to screech and scream nonsense and who would bark at passing cars. I didn't need proof she was disturbed, it was self-evident from her actions.
I see the stupidity. Why did you antagonize your biggest customer? My business will be dead in 2 months if antagonized my customers.
In the late 1990's the executives of most companies outsourced their manufacturing to China to cut costs, boost profits, increase executive bonuses and shareholders profits. At the cost of jobs and manufacturing.
If not to China..they do it in another country...this is capitalism...you cannot blame China..if they offers the most attractive base for msnufacturing ???
Psst, Psst.
Sell your lobsters to America, they can print lots of dollars to pay you. What ? The Americans are supplying China with their Boston lobsters. Hahaha, Australians, you have been properly shafted by the Americans.
USA picked up all the trade that Australian government missed out on.
Morrison is a smart ass, he should kick US butt 😤
Not true .
America farmer's as always are getting there asses handed to them.
I still think that Aussie will beat the Un-United states in their race to the bottom by a country mile + some!
Every day these Aussie guys are proving that the ole Funnell Web Spider is the most intelligent species on the Australian Continent!
Very true...
Watchmaker Charlie likes hamburgers made by Adam and visits his stall regularly. One day Adam questions about the design of Charlie's watches. Charlie continues to visit Adam's stall. Then Adam starts to tell everybody how bad the watches are. Charlie still buys burgers from Adam. Next he ridicules at Charlie's accent. Charlie starts to feel uneasy and starts buying his lunch from other stalls at times. Later on, Charlie has a quarrel with his wife and Adam encourages Charlie's wife to divorce him. Charlie stops visiting Adam's stall. Adam starts telling everybody how unfair Charlie is to him, maintaining that it's his freedom to say and do as he wishes. So freedom he keeps as he wishes but the business is gone.
Best comment I seemed for a while! Politician friendly! Lol thanks man
Lesson learned. Don't do business with China.
Australia - Welcome to the same economic coercion your allies - US- has been using on other countries for decades.
South America has been exploited for more than 100 years by the US, i came from there...................
@ユジン USA will slap down and up and coming economy. Remember the Plaza accord shafted down Japan's throat. Jailing of Alstom managers to destroy France telecom leading position. Banning Huawei and ZTC .
@ユジン free Gaza, payback reparations to African Americans and Muslim Middle East. No payment, no peace
Beef from Austrilia is now very cheap in Singapore. I have never seen Austrilian beef that cheap since I moved here in 2007.
I bet it's delicious too!!
Should be... why pay more than necessary?
@@Chris-vq5vr brand effect
@@MrBlinder514 brand effect? Wtf is that ?!
You should thank China 😂
For decades We don't like things australia is doing but we don't interfere with Australia's internal affairs... Just kept silence.
There is no need "to lay down in a foetal position to kicked to death, but choosing to poke the dragon before the dragon turns back and blows fire at us in a pretty painful way" as quoted by two different viewed Australians. China had been painfully humiliated in the past and enough is enough.
China has underestimated how Australians value their liberty and democracy.
@@lachlansydney2149 It should be the other way round - respect China's sovereignty.
@@hankxu3457 Perhaps China could respect a few things....
@@hankxu3457 respect is earned, not commanded. Hard to respect one that only cares about face.
Huawei was the easiest one to avoid: they should have allowed Huawei to tender, and just not chosen them (this is precisely what Singapore did). It's called diplomacy. Banning Huawei outright in March 2019 is what started the war. The other easy issue to stay right out of is Hong Kong: for 155 years the British stole Hong Kong from China at gun point. It makes absolutely zero sense to interfere there: the British 100% caused that one, not China. If the Australian government had remained rational and acted diplomatically on these two issues then China would still be friends. If you want to claim the moral high ground, you first need to actually have the moral high ground.
An honest man! Very few of them these days.
Huawei is the 1 that couldn't avoid, because it's trump's main target at that time, but other else were pure stupid
@@hunterxhunter5287 As I highlighted: Singapore are a US ally, they allowed Huawei to tender for their 5G network and then simply didn't choose them. It's very simple. Whereas an overt outright ban based on bigotry is an act of war.
@@pianowhizz I think Huawei is still involved in Singapore but on a small telco network.
@@dimsumden5745 on 5G?
Australia has Rudolph Murdoch and Sky News to thank in part for this current situation.
Thank CGTN.
when Newt Gingrich fast-tracked Rupert Murdoch's citizenship. that's the beginning of the Divided States of America.
Rudolph Murdoch is comrade Murdoch... you have been conned. Thanks comrade 🤣🤣🤣
Yuppers! BIG TIME!
I suspect Rupert Murdoch's true identify is Satan's envoy. He is here to sow the discord among our human race.
am i the only indian worried about this ? australians and americans come trade with india we can produce all the goods china can
Live and learn... Stupidity have no place. For every Action, there's ALWAYS an EQUAL and OPPOSITE reaction.
China has underestimated how Australians value their liberty and democracy.
@@lachlansydney2149 wishful thinking...
You're right, and China is starting to learn that. If China continues to behave like an asshole, more and more countries will treat it as an asshole.
A positive outcome of this is Australians can now eat lobsters for breakfast, lunch and dinner.
yes great
🤣😂😂🤣😂🤣
A glut now. No market. Price dropped from 100 to 20....
Weird thing is that I don't know any Australians that really eat them. Quite apart from the price being stupidly inflated Australians have such a wide choice of food there just isn't a massive market for lobster (as we call it).
I should travel to Aussie to enjoy lobsters lol
Put it another way: will you buy from a rude butcher, when there are polite ones around?
Put it another way, if the customer continually acts like a jerk surely the butcher eventually asks the customer to stop acting like a jerk?
Australia and other nations need to stop buying cheap chinese products & stop supporting communists....... that's the only way you can hurt china and make them learn...support other democratic countries and your own
@@45641560456405640563 you need to see who started all this first.
@@brnzhut Outside of China pretty much everyone knows apart from a few benighted souls who choose to be wrong for the sake of being different.
@@marsroma3668 Nothing can hurt China in this day and age. They are already 20 steps ahead of everyone else in the globe. They have captured the biggest source of raw materials Africa and the biggest market Africa. 1.2 billion Africans plus 1.3 billion Chinese is enough for them. Africa and China will be filthy rich and no trade war can stop them, did you know 2 in every 4 people is either Chinese or African?
You're not even supposed to be in Australia give the natives back their land
Feel very sorry for the business people caught in the political cross fire. I have many good friends and colleagues in AU and i love them. However it's their government provoking China and harming Chinese people's interests. I think they should talk to their own politicians about their hustle attitude towards China.
I share your sentiments on the people as well, but to suggest this all Australian government and the CCP is pure and innocent is pretty arrogant.
i buy coffee only from customer-friendly shops.
Because Australia lies to frame China. It gets punished for its crimes.
@Confidential Name you are born to be a judge
@Confidential Name Who cares about where you buy from.
As in ones that don't call you out for kicking people on your way into their shop?
Support fair-trade.
Support free market.
Support democracy.
Buy where YOU want.
Aren't we lucky to have a choice?
Clearly some people don't have a choice...
It was Australia who began this trade war by supporting the American trade war on Huawei.
lol... hardly dude... china has done this to us a few times before for no reason....
so trying to slip spies into our country and then trying to give us all the KUNG FLU didn't work as we are doing quite well....
@@albertbresca8904 loll KUNG FLU is kicking your ass now? Hope your grandparents are well. hahahaha
@@spencerlee7603 they died years ago but thanks for your comment thought i think you think i am quite young....
funny we didn't have people welded into their apartments ...
@@albertbresca8904 from a infectious disease point of view. people getting welded in apartment for a couple of weeks works, and it can save millions of people getting infected and die from it. Why not?....you have your “freedom”. More of you people die.
@@albertbresca8904 After seeing your reply implying that people getting welded in their apartment is the worse thing ever than millions could get infected and tens of thousand could die.....I don’t think you are quite young. I think you are quite stupid.
You can’t make friends with someone meanwhile you are treating him as enemy!
So now Australia must learn we need each others to live
Yes and China go whole world africa, sea, central asia, sri lanka, asia pacific island and beware debt trap
Australia pokes china,
China pokes back,
Australia surprised pikachu face 😂
China pokes the world, Australia pokes back. China cries and breaks trade deals.
@@adztronomical Pretty much.
LoL! You are laughing now but Australia is just waiting for the WTO decision. After that decision (whether it favors Australia or not) expect Australia to start banning Chinese products too. And this type of banning is more effective because it went through proper framework. And we will see whether you will be laughing after that.
@@angeloevangel8079 yes we are waiting for that as well. Fyi im pushing for a full decoupling with australia. Tho its not likely to happen still i hope one day it can be achieved. I for one will not touch any single australia product
@@adztronomical USA pokes the world. Australia dont poke back.
China is not punishing australia
China is ignoring australia
Of course it is. Trade stopped. What more evidence do you need? to be hit over the head by them while they ignore us? lol
@@Ignirium they just returned the favour for what you have been doing to them for a very long time.
@@karrole88 Me? Sounds like you have a lot more to say
Says all the Australian iron ore ships docked in China lol
@@IgniriumLOL... trade stopped. Honestly grow a few brain cells before commenting...
100% Zero Sympathy for Australian Crayfish Licence holders.
You sold out on Australia years ago, but selling a tightly regulated Australian natural resource to China and making the price unaffordable for local Aussie purchasers.
And now you cry....
And sell a Cray for $80 locally....
Disgusting behaviour in the first place
Here's my gripe there's enough natural resources for everyone to live happily ever after...but that's a dream because of greed and control
Imagine putting your eggs in one basket and then tearing that basket apart simply because Uncle Sam tells you to
Been their done that. My state put all it's egg's in the auto industry basket. More and more we have nothing as GM, Ford, Chrysler move production to China, Mexico, Canada, Brazil, Argentina etc.....The Austrialian government did nothing wrong. China just does not like their media or government not towing the CCP's Propaganda! China is the one in the wrong and they are making AU hurt in every place they can with out hurting themselves too much. Funny how iron ore is no being targeted by China! It is not being targeted because that would hurt the CCP and their plans more than it would hurt AU.
Bow to your Chinese overlords
Some cleric trained in the USA by the Americans themselves, along with their friends, the Israelis and Saudis.
@@guyarrol582 no, I hate China aswell
better 25 million people suffer I guess than 300 mill...
sadly I guess it needed to be said...
you might say why AUstralia? same argument could be used for any country....
yes in the short term it will hurt incredibly badly.... but like other disasters I guess we'll get over it (as if we have a choice....sigh)
Have you ever seen sales men curses their customers and wondering why they don't get any sales. XD
Your 50c is on its way
Agree 100%. You are genius,my parents used to own a candy factory,the idea is don't bite the hands that feed you,all will be well.
Chinese government needs respect from hiding evidence of Wuhan virus, otherwise refuse to be a good customer.
😅😅 T.S.G.H
It is Australia being pressured by USA and WEST to boycott China. So please don't spin and bias here.
Blame the president of Australia for all this. He shouldn't follow the United States like a pug to ban Huawei. Australians should not sacrifice for Americans to maintain their hegemony.
Never should we have put all of our eggs in China,
We have did this to ourselves what dont kill you will make you stronger Australia.
One thing I see here most of these farmers are not blaming their own government
Do you know that there's such a thing call editing?
@@user-lb7if9ec5q 農夫们沒在視頻对澳政府表示不滿因为視頻把它edit掉的意思。
Meanwhile indian farmers , why is my wife pregnant.. the government is to be blamed 😡😡
It's simple....stop buying cheap chinese products.... that's the only way you can hurt china
@@marsroma3668 Supply chains are leaving China. It's understood that there is no stability. It will probably take a matter of 3-5years, but China will be on its own.
Trade is a two way street . If you sanction someone. What makes you think they do not have the right to sanction you back...
Because Australia lies to frame China. It gets punished for its crimes.
@@Runner-do1sg 😂 right pity the best of the world agrees with Australia. China is going to be taken down and it's kidding itself if it thinks it can bully the entire world.
@@Notthetimeforit what about westerners killed million chinese and set fire to royal garden in beijing?
@@josephguo6256 go collect you're fifty cents from your CCP masters like a good little troll
@@Notthetimeforit getting angry because the historic facts revealed?
Mutual respect would have prevented the unnecessary sufferings. Politicians must be astute to know when to pull the handbrake.
"Don't interfere in our affairs and also, don't have laws against foreign interference in your affairs!"
Pretty much....
imagine if you have a business partner who willing to do business with you ...buy everything you wanted to sell....he is no,enemy to you..yet just because you are 5 eyes and anglo,saxon...you kept smearing, demonising,fabricate fake news and hurl defamatory words to him...you still expect him to be nice to you and say thank you for everything you have done.?? put yourself in his shoes..what will you do?
Even Dogs know- they don't bite the hand that feeds them ... 😁
It wasn’t too long ago that our prime minister was posturing aggressively towards China now for some mysterious reason our politicians can’t understand why China should bet choosing to behave as it is ! Have we as a nation developed a collective amnesia ?
Please give specific examples of this "aggressive posturing" and contrast this with China's wolf warrior diplomacy, political interference and economic coercion.
@@blimpusa so what you are saying is you guys do have collective amnesia
shut up troll
This is a bad argument for defending China's actions. Have you ever heard of "proportional response"? For example, If I said bad things about you and then you shot me in the foot for it and threatened to shoot the other foot unless I apologized then that's not really a proportional response to my actions is it? You would be seen as psychotic. This is the same situation.
Sure, I don't think aggressive rhetoric from the PM actually accomplishes anything, but China has wanted to use more aggressive coercion for a while now. Not because Australia's PM said something they didn't like, but because Australia holds completely different governance, economic prospect and values. Although most importantly because those structures align us with the USA, their direct competition. A structure that threatens the CCP's existence. So why I do believe Morrison deserves some blame for his dumb rhetoric. I similarly believe it is ignorant to the understanding of geopolitical prospects to think he is the reason this is happening in entirety. It was coming eventually with or without someone like Morrison.
@@arcdraconis9579 enlighten us
when the world only talks about china, you know they made it.
food for thought....
THey punishing themselves now. Can't keep the lights on, coal shortage, iron ore shortage, wheat shortage, cotton shortage. Aussies are resourceful, resilient and most importantly prudent, alternative markets have been found, net export loss is very low now.
America knows where and when to use her friends.
Australia got problem with usa only othere was china and Australia both are good do business
For their own advantage and self interest🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
@@balajielumalai7980 Australia is friendly with the US so no wonder she decoupled from China out of clear reasons (human rights abuses and opacity). Guess what? China threw a tantrum and sent armies of trolls to attack in free speech bastions.
Your a fool we love Australia .
So true, US is using Australia without them realizing. China will never interferes in other country internal affairs unlike the US
Treat others like how you wish to be treated, simple as that.
Yes, seize back the port of Darwin, just for starters. Then go after other Chinese owned assets in compensation until the full losses from the Wuhan virus are covered.
When China has no overseas assets left, the bill will maybe have covered the first year's interest on the debt.
Phil Lee how about send in your troops to occupy China like you did 100years ago, kill a few million of the Chinese, would that be even more satisfying to you and make you proud to be an Aussie?
@@jdc3636 Why? Blockade is cheaper and has no real risk associated with it.
I guess your masters in the CCP have forgotten what their ancestors knew about walls.
Phil Lee go ahead and do it, stoping being a keyboard warrior .
@@jdc3636 I'll leave the deyboard warrior role to you, since your apparently so practiced at it. In the meantime isis over a year since I knowingly bought anything made in CCP occupied China.
Back in April, on the radio, all the "allies" vowed to drink more Australian wine and don't care about the Chinese market, I guess that is working out fine?
Astralia should ban coal sales to China for two years. The coal prices would soar and help Australia.
Australia is the one who started all this ... isn't it?
i think China started it in 1949. You cant trust commuists ever!
@@KevinSwan10200 Ask your master to trickle down money on your under class.
@@KevinSwan10200 Jesus Morrison has been in power for that long..
What did Australia do to start this? They gave China covid-19?
@@KevinSwan10200 sorry, Chinese is mostly Confucius-ist /Buddhist not communist
The door swings both ways. You've only told one side of the story
Libs own the abc fundamentally now
Totalitarian dystopian regimes do not get to tell their side of the story because we already know their side of the story.
Poor China. /s
@@geraldmaxwell3277 so they just actioned
Australia is a democracy and one of the most open and freeest economies on the planet.
It enjoys freedom of speech, freedom of association and last I checked, has no labor camps , does not execute people nor does it stifle dissent .
China is a totalitarian regime. Everyone knows that .And no one will ever change our view of China as long as the CCP holds monopoly power. Ever.
"We all in survival mode."
I can't buy any lobster for less than $60 a pound
Imagine getting worked up because a customer stoped buying from you in a free market and making it sound like their fault.
“If you pray for rain, be prepared to deal with the mud”
Damn this documentary really brings out the proverbs in people :)
@@jimmash9353 but they didn’t bring out their hypocrites politicians making millions by selling out theirs citizens !!!
That post was sponsored by the CCP Wu mao army.
Can't agree more!
@@nickvdk11 your country make a fuss first with the dragon. So accept your consequences.
“Mind your own business"
"Nobody likes a busybody"
"Don't bite the hand that feeds you"
"Don't start nothing, won't be nothing"
Pretty much sums up the entire current Australia/China relationship? Lol
Australia doesn’t feed China, those are called exports. Australia has benefited greatly from China economically that can’t be denied... if australia really does want to part relations with China they better look for an alternative market FAST!
@@artofthedeal4637 Tf are you even talking about? Lol 😂
Add "Between a rock and a hard place"
As described in Charles Dickens novel "Great Expectations," England shipped its jailed inmates of debtors and criminals to settle Australia, but in Dickens novel, some of these people wanted to return to England for various reasons, specially after these debtors and criminals became very rich and successful developing the lands of Australia. Later, Australia was part of the British Commonwealth. It can be guessed that the Queen of England rather wishes England can regain Hong Kong back, while China believes that England took Hong Kong by unfair force during the Opium War, when the English forced the Chinese to become addicted to the drug opium, and when the Chinese tried to block the opium importation, England sent its naval forces to start the Opium War that ended with England getting Hong Kong. Guess that Australia still feels affiliations toward its old mother country of England, like in Dickens novel "Great Expectations" so that some of its politicians may side with England concerning Hong Kong. This creates the "between a rock and a hard place" issue. Another saying is "One cannot have the cake and eat it too." Another saying is "Seven years of feast are followed by seven years of famine (and drought,) specially if runaway global warming occurs. And, Joseph advised to the king of Egypt to build huge grain storages, and the king placed a tax on the farmers to set aside 20 percent of the harvest during the feast years to fill up the huge grain storages to prepare for the following famine, when the Earth becaome bone dry, and nothing grew. And, in the Book of Revelations, after the white horse appears on the scene with a loud noise (like the iron horse appearing on the scene with a cloud of white steam about a couple of hundred years ago) announcing the beginning of the End Times, the earth will become hot and dry with nothing growing, and all of the grasses are burnt in wild fires.
@bronzed Aussie Dude what are you talking about? You are just rambling and saying random things. I read everything you wrote 3 times and I couldn't find a single thesis. What point are you trying to make??? LMAO
@@artofthedeal4637 ummm, very noisy aren't you? Sounds you are very rich, do you own everything in Australia?
Why don't you tell this such good ideas to Australia governor/that foreign minister? Telling them:' Now is time to keep all of the products which you mentioned earlier' , and tell them: 'don't selling anything to China'. I hope they wouldn't kick your ass🤭.
I'll pray for you before you become a street-beggar...
God bless you too!
Don’t take a dump where you eat 🙄
My question is, has Australia seen it is coming since they banned Huawei products in 2015 and kept treating China as a enemy after that? If not, it is just stupid, isn't it?
@@artofthedeal4637 oh camon
Australia banned Hauwei bacuse they are pets of USA
They banned it claiming it wansnt escurre despite de fact that even European countryes spy each others
@@artofthedeal4637 Before Australia turned against China, do you have any evidence of China intent to cause harm to Australia. I don't think you do. Australia can trade with any country it wants, China can do that too. Australia treats China as enemy, China just do what Australia wants to achieve! China is not punisching Australia, China is defending itself!
Why are people so shocked? How many people have been warning about it. People are to caught up in believing Our politicians are making deals for the Australian people. Lower your over priced products and I am pretty confident Australian people will buy it.
Most producers would go bankrupt.
Even though prices are lower, people have no money to buy them.
company's should allow for this instead of grab grab when its going good always a slump after good. should know better .
why do you think it is overpriced? is it the producers are making tons of money? or is it the salaries are going up and up? guess what now? cut pay to survive and accept a lower QOL standard from now on.
@@johntse8655 where is your proof?
Australia gov has seen this coming. This is not punishment, this is revenge.
Both, revenge for deciding to be the lackey of the US, and punishment for sucking up to the Chinese economically without paying any attention at all to their business philosophy.
Sell to daddy trump then
Michael Celente said: "The business of America is War -- the business of China is Business". We chose the War Party.
whether you kick the dog or not, depends on who owns the dog. 😊😊
Weren't the ignorant politicians and the manipulative media hell bent on decoupling? Hardly anyone spoke up for the exporters, the chest thumpers and the paranoid ruled Australian media. It's not punishment, it's granting your wish.
Believing that China is punishing Australia is like if mr. A is treated badly by everyone at McDonald’s ( hamburger restaurant), and if he refused to going back to it, he’s being prejudice? Is mr. A punishing McDonald? Or is he just simply taking his food safety seriously and go somewhere else ? Obviously McDonald didn’t want his businesses . Sometimes it’s just that simple to fix things. Improve your services, your customers will return. They too miss your nicety.
Hahaha, If the boss of the supermarket where you used to shop scold you every time when you went there, do you still want to shop at that place? So, we just want cut the link with Australia, you find your new customers, we find our own new supermarkets(e.g. the US), let’s forget each other
Australia is not anti China , we are just pro Australian. Australia is just exercising its soverignity by not giving China the right to decide what Australia can do. Australia is not part of China. It's our country.
@@lachlansydney2149 we don’t want decide what Australia can do, just want cut the link, no offense
Boston lobster very good👍
Well you could always stop the uncool stuff you are doing that's getting you scolded.....
Farmer and fisher man: I can’t making a living because the trade war.
Politician: that’s fine we are selling more iron ore.🤷🏻♂️
1 fisherman...1 farmer.... media did NOT present much more than that ....
small business is always a risk.... maybe you woudl understand if you had tat small; thing called freedom..??
@@albertbresca8904 dude I live in the US…
@@iwenyou dude I live in Australia.. interesting that you speak in favour of china.... you still have relatives in china you don't want harassed by the police ?
@@iwenyou so..if living in the US you should understand about small businesses .. and how they are risky....
some fail... some succeed.... actually a lot fail sadly....
and if you look closely at this show you will see how these farmer or fisher seem to have the LATEST equipment and invested big to (I guess) make money fast.. before china stops trade (again) as they have no the past for no reason... we knew it was only a matter of time before they did it to us again )trying to bring us to our knees.. again..) ..
we are still selling things - maybe not to china but to other countries, but yes there will be some bad times... short term pain, long term gain....
@@albertbresca8904 I wasn’t speaking in favor of China… I am speaking in favor of those small businesses who were hurt by the trade war. The politicians simply ignore them and seeing these people as numbers and willing to keep hurting them for more votes. Creating a fake enemy is best way to do that.
Great, the Australian way is to poke it's fingers into it's customers' eyes and expect them to come for more.
When the customer spreads a deadly virus across the world then it's ok to ask why LoL
@@kerokero3082 youtube deleted my reply.
Sure you can stop trading with them. Stop crying.
@bronzed Aussie great, buy South African products, just as good
@Max St Arlyn yes, the link was deleted
@Max St Arlyn so much for freedom of speech and information.
Australia has declared a Cold War on China - what did you THINK would happen Australia?!?!
I see comments where they are pointing fingers at USA. But I mean the Australian Economy was relying to much on China I feel like they should have found new customers to export
On the bright side our marine life gets a rest.
and the bat population
@@HalloweenH-ij5rn What did you use to do with your bat population? 😅
Dont worry our corporate fishermen and farmers will still find away to exploit our environment
The Chinese poach it.
Go rest for a decade or two.
Keep your customers happy and they will keep coming back. WTO doesn’t have any power, EU and USA have just pretty much ignored their decisions when it suited them.
@bronzed Aussie Then enjoy the poverty that will ensue mate ;)
@bronzed Aussie "bubbling cesspools and toxic sludge" lol sounds like India to me mate ;) The fact that Australia is so reliant on primary sector of the economy means that Australia is finished the minute China has no need for its resources, you guys are basically the Saudi Arabia of Iron ore ;) Enjoy the coming poverty mate ;)
@bronzed Aussie You do realise China also has one of the worlds largest iron reserves, they are just buying from Australia to preserve their supply for the future. Mate I would stfu if I were you, your stupid comments bring shame to Australians.
Sell it to the big brother who conn you to do it....
@@sharkb8754 Better to be poor than to become a satelite state of the new chinese empire. You cannot put a price on dignity.
If you think China are committing 'genocide' why would you want to do business with them anyway?
This documentary is so idiotic, look at how your prime minister trashes China, so what do you expect when you trash talk your number 1 customer ? All they need to do is to take their business somewhere else. I feel bad for the everyday Aussie who got caught in between the geopolitics.
US to Australia: when i say jump you jump ok!
Morrison actually asks the U.S. "How high do you want me to jump, sir?"
you are here assuming china hasn't done this to us before - for little to no reason....
so .. we gave them a reason this time... and we feel good about it...
so a little money loss (in the short term) - china thinks it is all about money... some things not so much....
@@albertbresca8904 It is not money. China does not want to be bullied by western imperialism
@@albertbresca8904 A little money? I don't think more than 4 billion dollars in exports is little money.
@@isurumw6119 where did you get that small amount from? I can only find trade exports from australia around 250 billion with china 40%....
How much does Australia export a year?
With annual product exports of $248 billion, Australia is the 24th largest export economy in the world.6 Nov 2020
Our trade minister should talk to our foreign minister for what happened, not china
And what should China do? Grab its petticoat and blush?
If the Aussies are dumping then one might say that they have started a trade war
Stop insulting China is the key