The Real Losers Of The US-China Trade War | When Titans Clash | Ep 2/4 | CNA Documentary
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 вер 2024
- A 3 year trade war has created corporate casualties in both US and China. In China, a dual circulation model is now underway to mitigate the effects of US protectionism. In the US, a Biden administration mulls new economic measures against China, even as industry groups lobby for tariffs to be lifted. Both countries also brace for what used to be unthinkable- the possibility of a financial war.
Continue watching When Titans Clash: • When Titans Clash | Fu...
=======
About When Titans Clash: There are historical forces at play in ongoing US-China tensions. How do sentiments of pride and shame fuel the rivalry? And how might a Biden administration confront Beijing?
===========
#CNAInsider #WhenTitansClashCNA #USChina #TradeWar
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER!
cna.asia/insid...
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnain...
What are the roots of US-China tensions? And will Southeast Asia be forced to take a side? Continue watching When Titans Clash: ua-cam.com/play/PLkMf14VQEvTbTGw6gbmIHoWz4nmolfkpU.html
STOP COMUNIST PARTY CHINA INFUNCE IN ALL THE WORLD IIDEOLIGY OF DARK
ENDCCP.COM
War mongering Trump and his stupid ilk
Imho, it's mainly geopolitical. Because US is not comfortable of 'losing' to China. Even if China is a democracy, the difference would be akin to sino Soviet split.
@@willliam1420 Communism is GREAT!!!!
One day America might leave. China Still around but still a one party state with another Name ; using American models How many Senators and congress persons China need They would take turn to screw peoples but with a bigger number to mess with 1500 millions
When it comes to China, it's almost impossible to find unbiased documentaries on UA-cam. Thank you CNA for your great work!
The problem is the interpretation of unbiased "reporting". How will people understand either side, unless we learn to read between the lines, and trust what we learn.
@@davidcadman4468 agree with you my friend.
Chinese is a difficult language
@Jason Fuller What has CCP done to you?
@Jason Fuller hostage ? you mean US citizen?
Xi Jinping visited more ordinary American people than trump did in 4 years😂😂😂😂😂
@@hen4055 No, Chinese actually likes him hhhhhhhhhh because he is so funny
Name one US President who had visited ordinary Americans. I know they are friends with deep pockets donors, can’t remember they have ordinary people as friends.
Oh you mean Winnie the Pooh? I love that guy!!!!!!!
yeah
@@sz5263 when they need votes, they will hug a baby and take a photo
The real losers of a trade war are the same people who lose at everything else. We the people
well said
The loser is the greedy peoples who was rich and want more more rich in China and america . For people like us , nothing!
Heyyyy guys pls relax. Lets just look at the brighter side. Well at least we r still free to live freely. Things gonna get ugly if i became the chinese president. Air isnt gonna b free anymore. Ohh yes...also tax included
@@tartibroucke6110 Not really，things are getting more expensive because the trade war，inflation is out of control
America is rich. It's just around 90% of money belongs to 1% of American. This is not China's problem. Government should have protect jobs instead of blaming.
Exactly. Finally a smart American.
They should solve the 90% and 1% first otherwise, no matter what done the china is meaningless, because it still 90% to 1%
All belongs to CCP in China.😲😲😲😲
@@AmethystNote CCP global times franchise.🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@sitarampradhan8488 India loser
Since China entered WTO, the GDP of China grows 13 Trillion, the GDP of the USA grows 11 Trillion. Both have benefitted a lot. The problem of US is not baking the cakes, the problem is how the extra cakes are distributed.
And
The USA has,
only 350M people
While there are 1400M in China.
Yet according to American people they had a worse 20-year than ever...
Why?
@@betteryou3860 In an economy, we don't look at what they have now, but we look at what they have made so far, the rate of increase of wages in China is huge compared to the US, although they still have a very little amount of average salaries, the potential is huge there. That is why all the companies want to share a market in China, because of the profit they can get in the future. 13 trillion is a huge jump in the GDP for China, but 11 trillion, though it is only 2 trillion less, is not a huge jump in the GDP for the US considering the GDP was already high before China entered WTO.
@@betteryou3860 US had a GDP that is 10 times China's GDP in 2000, but now China has 2/3 of the US's GDP, only 6 trillion behind us. the growth rate is enormous. It has only been 20 years and they have 2/3 of what we have now. That's why people say 2030 will be the time when China out-compete the US.
The problem of US is not cutting the pie to its rest of 90%of people.
don't foget a few of those Trillions were (10-30%) and are always gonna be used to bail out Wallstreet who's gambling on other people's money (their client and otherwise)
while 90% of it goes to 1% of Corporate Elites and Oligarchs,
so nett is actually (minus) -10 to -20%, simple math, there's your answer
which translates to your jobs, your houses, and your retirement funds
The lady in the beginning who hosted Xi Jinping said that "he read Mark Twain". Let that sentence sink in slowly. 1. How many millenials in the USA have actually read or remember Mark Twain. 2. Can you name or know of any US president the last 30 years who has read any great literature in Chinese history, I highly doubt it. What does it mean for the future...think about it.
Xi's a pretty impressive guy.
What book u suggest? I'm not from US but interesed
I am pretty sure they read Art of war
Art Of War, Know Thy Enemy And Know Thyself And You Shall Win A Hundred Battles. The same applies to Putin. Smart Leaders are curious and willing to listen but are final in their decisions.
@@weilee1155 ty. Have to search it from Turku library
America can't blame China for its problems. Businessmen will relocate their businesses to other countries where they can make more profits, it's natural. American workers demand shorter working hours, more pay, fewer working days and more benefits. Chinese workers are hardworking, loyal, disciplined and resilient. Which do you prefer?
I wouldn't say Chinese workers are all those things you mentioned as their main draw. At the end, they're cheap labor, and everyone prefers cheap labor lol. You trying to conflate the main reason why people moved their business to another country with those characteristics of that working population is just patently false and misleading. Big business desire cheap labor, this is the basis of capitalism, the owning class wants to purchase the cheapest labor with the highest skill, while the working class would like to do the least amount of work for the most pay. That is the basis of the capitalism. You're an idiot if you think the chinese workers would put up with their working condition for a long time, in the short-run it works, but not in the long run. Why do you think they have suicide nets at at the Foxconn factory? That isn't a result of a hardworking, loyal, disciplined and resilient work force, that's a sign of the owner class extracting as much productivity from their mule.
@@henrytep8884 No, they're not. Chinese build crap and would sell it to their own mothers. When they're not ripping each other off, they'll take from anyone. Chinese opening free trade with the world saved China. The U.S.A. buying all that cheap crap made China rich.
why US castrated Japan with the Plaza Accord? Japan never fully recovered from the lost decade even to this day. and Japan supposed be US ally? US wants to remain the top dog forever.
@@henrytep8884 u can have cheap and good labor u can also have cheap and crap labor. China is definitely cheap and good but I agree that they won't remain cheap for long. As with all things as their standard of living rises, so will the national wages. But if you think for a second that US companies will relocate back to US soil because of that then u are sorely mistaken. They will keep looking for other countries with cheap labor to produce their products, and what will America do then? Continue to sanction any country that offers cheaper production or come up with ridiculous excuses to wage another trade war?
@@ripp846 i dont agreed as two company made amazing product such DJI and Huawei where drone made by USA by gopro sank. So not everything made in China is bad. Chinese porcelain was so wanted by British colonist. Everything have a give and take. All our product are made there like Apple. Most your thing is made there so what would you have us do.
This is one of the best documentaries in recent years, unbiased, comprehensive, hit the nail in the head. Good job, CNA.
idd, I am deeply impressed
Maybe added interviews of a few ppl who don’t favours china may be better… but really have to say CNA does a much better job then Bloomberg. It is gives simple explanation of the digital currency and reason why the Chinese are pushing it hard instead of just saying China is pushing it so it can do bad things without being punished. And also they interview both Americans and Chinese instead of just let one side talk
@@class6aa This video does a great disservice to establishing the truth. It helps make a case for laying the blame for the pain some Americans are experiencing on China. In truth, America benefited tremendously from trade with China. As proof, one just needs to point to the tremendous number of new American billionaires created during the two decades between 2000 to 2020. It is the American government which failed Americans who lost out during the course of bilateral trade.
How? By keeping taxes on the rich low, and protecting industries that burdened the poor. and the middle class. By protecting the healthcare industry and allowing them to charge exorbitant fees and drug costs, they aided US healthcare capitalists on the sick. Almost two thirds of those in the middle class who slipped into poverty cited a health crisis as the factor responsible.
Blackrock, armed with funds placed in their hands by rich Americans, swept up whole swathes of residential properties and once they controlled a sufficient part of the housing supply, they jacked up rents, contributing to working people no longer being able to afford the rent, and the ranks of the homeless in America exploded partly as a result.
The Muscatine perspective is beautiful. This type of positivity should have equal noise to every negativity surrounding us.
Indian politician also go to foreign study countries but instead of learning anything they use their whole study tour in enjoying with foreign girls and clubs.
you give me the impression that all the indian politicians are men
Did your dad go on one of those trips? if not how do you know, Don't put everyone into one bucket
@@vkchaitanya2003 According to american hearsay once an Indian always an Indian.
@@JonyC6969 Absolutely and Proud to be Indian
@sandeep.. that is a sweeping statement. every country is different and its people are different. India has to work a way to sort out their problems. only harmony within a person/country can miracles work.
Unbiased reporting on China is rare to find these days. Thanks CNA
Actually, this video does a great disservice to establishing the truth. It helps make a case for laying the blame for the pain some Americans are experiencing on China. In truth, America benefited tremendously from trade with China. As proof, one just needs to point to the tremendous number of new American billionaires created during the two decades between 2000 to 2020. It is the American government which failed Americans who lost out during the course of bilateral trade.
How? By keeping taxes on the rich low, and protecting industries that burdened the poor. and the middle class. By protecting the healthcare industry and allowing them to charge exorbitant fees and drug costs, they aided US healthcare capitalists on the sick. Almost two thirds of those in the middle class who slipped into poverty cited a health crisis as the factor responsible.
Blackrock, armed with funds placed in their hands by rich Americans, swept up whole swathes of residential properties and once they controlled a sufficient part of the housing supply, they jacked up rents, contributing to working people no longer being able to afford the rent, and the ranks of the homeless in America exploded partly as a result.
Rare to see such a informative and neural report of both sides of the story. Great Job! Very touched and inspiring for Xi Jingping's words - "If we could have exchanges in all areas, sports, business, arts, if our people get to know each other, then our countries can get along. To me, you (the homestay family in Iowa) are America."
“If our people get to know each other, then our countries can get along.”
But the US government wants to always take an antagonist stance. It does not what to get along but wants to dominate.
There’s too many instances of it. Way too many.
We all truly need each other. It’s that simple.
Its Thats simple then its actually Done,
US economy is just draining man, Look at the facts.
If US continue with this Pace, their is no US Economy the Next 20Years.
Our government is interested in lifetime seats so they can take lifetime bribes. We are proletarians who put ourselves in debt so the GDP covers the federal debt interest on the real debt we will never pay
Theyre the same right?
Only stupid people believe that.
@@jmlin501 the real stupid people are people like you. Rather have peace with the two countries
American promoto free trade, human rights, etc etc. But when they lose they will complain. Recently like gme stock proves the same thing, when the fund lose on the 'free trade' they start to halt and block the access of retailer.
Look, the problem is that US did not even lose anything...their GDP was booming together with China. But US kept on making mistakes...Financial Crisis, recessions, and unnecessary military spending on continued war efforts....and this resulted in China overtaking them in growth. However, even with these mistakes, US economy as whole (measured in GDP) had a steady growth and almost doubled over the past generation from 2001 to date.
I mean sure the poverty level is rising because of rapid technological changes and surge in big tech giants...but when they "China is cheating and damaging US economy"... the statement is false starting from "damaging economy". Their economy is booming...just not for every American. Big corp and whatever the American government is spending on is booming.
This is about the PetroDollars! The Americans cannot printing money to pay their debts and expenses anymore!
@@evilapple3427 they lose, losing money
Also people keep blaming technology innovation for rising levels of poverty. This is funny, they need to think what's next for them. The next potential job of future people, don't just blame the big tech companies for that.
Good thing it wasn't Chinese investors who scooped up that shorting fiasco. You know how the west likes to paint the reds for everything that goes wrong. Then again, who knew the red they should have been more concerned about was reddit.
US hedge funds and Trump administation are a bit similar, when they lose because THEY SUCK, they will try their best to makes your life sucks too.
When US and CN work together, the whole world is better off.
And China could steal everything from America? Of course, Trade war will hurt not only China but also the US. However, Trade war is neccessary to prevent China's stealing everything from America and help the US gain the political purpose. For example: China waged the invasion war against Vietnam in 1979 - Do you think that the people who suffered the war could take any benefits? But China could. So, It is normal for the US to wage the trade war against China just as China did to Vietnam in 1979.
@@ThienHoang-tr3dh You meant the US failed to keep its secret?
@@ThienHoang-tr3dh 二战后美国对世界其他国家发动了40多场战争你知道吗？包括越战，偷走？请注意你的言辞，自由贸易是美国提出的观点，中国人给出更高的利益，这些商人很喜欢去中国投资，这叫偷？另外:贸易战争受伤害最大的是美国人民，中国只是收益少了一些。目前的中国只在半导体产业/基础软件落后美国，其他任何产业中国都不比美国差。这也是事实。农业，制造业，航空产业，太空产业，军事领域等等。你可以自己去对比。我不想浪费口水，最后:二战后唯一战胜美国的国家/唯一一场使美国伤亡最大的战争就是朝鲜战争，美国在二战后最大的失败不是阿富汗。美国也不是神话
why don't people just collaborate rather than clashing each other... war only destruct each other, win became ash loses became dust...
Because China does not play fair
Because cpc is now adopting an expansionist policy having troubles with all its neighbours a new challenge for west.
Because trump is a racist
@@Alex-pj8nz So racist that his grand daughter learns Mandarin as a second language? LOL
Moses Chew How stupid can you get, he is so racist he has right wing militias attempting a coup into congress weeks ago. A dimwit like you never bothers to do research and wants to be spoon fed.
Problem with claiming that China uses subsidies is almost all major tech in the US was funded by the government program or by the military and then passed onto the private sector to take advantage of.
Not to forget the bailouts. But then US preaches free market, non intervention, market forces ...
Same as companies like Samsung - big subsidies and corruption scandals.
NIH....US government funded biomedical research to a tune of $35bn a year... which the US private sector can take and commercialize for free without the US government claiming IP or patent.
@@nickl5658 ... the US gov mindset is easily laid out. With just it’s aircraft carrier fleet, the US can literally wage 5 limited wars simultaneously. Limited and no boots on the ground.
There’s such a need eh? That says it all.
US is king of double standard
I drive through Iowa every summer. There are "buy american" and "trump" signs everywhere. They also continue to elect officials that are anti- foreign anything. I would say most of them are getting what they vote for. "You can't have cake and eat it too" will always be true.
One world one people...! .
Served them right, u can't break the bowls that feed u
Those people are chosing the wrong path
It is amazing how they are complaining about the results of their own democracy.
@@michaelotieno6524 niaje. Unfortunately nchi yetu copies the American system.
Interview US companies that moved to China and ask why, you will be shocked why they chose china over US, US companies doesn't plan to return to US due to their country not favouring them but Chinese consumers appreciate them than their homeland....
I believe the problem is how US maintain theirs jobs...
Blaming china would just keep hurting the economy that's going into bankruptcy...
I can't remember China tying ropes to US companies to relocate, they freely chose China because its a land of opportunities under good leadership....
Congrats to Xi Jinping ❤️❤️❤️
You know that Xi Jinping is a dictator right? The CCP party suppresses independent opinion, partly by censoring the internet.
@@omenbrassmonkey you know i never asked for your suggestions?🙄
@@emmacares426 "Nothing in the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity"
Martin Luther King Jr.
@@omenbrassmonkey feel free to take a journey to where Martins Luther King jr is located 😁
@@omenbrassmonkey so ur chatting from the land of dead, thats nice, lemme guess 10G network speed 🤣🤣🤣
These documentaries are fairly balanced. Well done CNA.
I agree, it’s been a very long time since I’ve seen a balanced documentary from the western. The constant one sided stories from the west has completely lost me. What the lady as the very end said is true. During this period, I think I now know how the middle eastern people felt after 9/11 and they didn’t have a strong countries to give them a voice to speak on their behalf.
@Lisa Roothless what threat? The only threat i can think of is to white supremacist since people with black hair can now call now say they are equals. I can guarantee if a war does breakout it won't be the Asians shooting first.
@@vilester look at the reports on concentration camps and it’s victims! You are turning a blind eye on 21st century fascist regime! A country where anyone can disappear for what they said! If that doesn’t concern you, I’m not sure what will
@@adepil OMG, someone really believes the concentration camp story. Those places are schools for people who lived in poverty and were brain washed by terrorism, the schools aim to teach them working skills and find jobs for them so that they can live on their own. I think this is much better for them than ending up as suicide bombers.
@Cornpop Asian perspective means the truth. Where western perspective means narcissistic view and full of lies and gas lighting.
Thank you CNA, for your balanced views on the rather troubling relationships between USA and China.
Great documentary.
it's so warm to see President Xi visiting the old friends.
It is heartwarming to watch videos like this. There need to be more effort made for countries to get to know each other.
I'm Chinese, actually China has no interested in being a superpower and GDP leader! What we need are safety and happy lives and we did have such lives!
You don't, but your government do, stop being brainwashed by your government . Look at South Sea they claim 90% sea and islands belong to them and bully small countries around them.
@@huyvo1586 Sure , blame Chinese of everything since it is "politically correct".and the USA is god that we should worship, right?
@@huyvo1586 Sure, US can have Hawaii and Guam far from its continent but China has no right to claim the islands in South CHINA Sea. Great logic from a super power.
@@huyvo1586 lol america invades countries
@@huyvo1586 lmao said by a person came from a country having 800+ military base around the globe. a country have currency hegemony then blame other people because of it own failure to manage its own economy. Come on its 21st century. stop being so arrogant and learn to respect other people country and culture.
I love how the solar panel guy is using a Chinese drone (DJI Phantom) to film his workers.
Yeah it's one of the few things that China has indigenously developed and not stolen outright.
@@RKKY-mf7fe I agree. China and India were the hubs of scientific knowledge and prosperity for centuries before the invaders came.
It is Asian knowledge that provided the foundation for Europeans later on.
The issue however is that knowledge transfer isn't wrong, but IP theft is.
@@RKKY-mf7fe lol, as if your beloved guns weren't developed from Chinese technology. Bruh.
@@itsover9008 lol, no there's no such thing as "stealing" technology. By your logic the entire human history was a process of theft. next you are going to tell me youtube is "stealing" technology from tiktok?
@@ppphhh7487 If there's no such thing, then why does anyone file patents? I hope you are only a troll and not serious about your statement.
As a common citizen in SEA country, since the vast growing of china economy, its actually also bring its neighbors countries prosperity in the same time. Its a good economy ecologically brought to every level who know to takes opportunity.
You mean prosperity at the cost of the ecosystems.Pollution and destruction of land,air and water is the price you pay for prosperity.Economic means using your resources wisely and in a sustainable way not throwing away the values our ancestors lived by for thousands of years.
@borray s exactly!
@@GL-ys8je Of course the environment is in a good shape in the west because you guys ship millions of tons of rubbish and plastic wastes to Asian countries.
@@GL-ys8je "PoLuTIoN AnD dEsTrUcTIon..." what will happen to the west if the developing countries stop doing the dirty works for them?
@borray s Holy shites France did this to Malaysia too!
My friend, a US citizen for decades, Chinese American, had a small kitchen cabinet company and about 15 employees, since 2018 the tariffs skyrocketed to 400% on imports, ever since his salary was down half and after 2 years of struggle and 2020 pandemic finally he decided to close down and lay off all those American employees and he is now out of job as well
This is the most thorough analysis of the Sino-US trade war I have watched recently,
every clip hits the point and objectively.
Good job CNA👍🏻
US acts like a child in a tantrum when it losses
Your comment and and profile image struck me as ironic for two reasons. 1. Adolf hitler killed himself when he lost, talk about dramatics. 2. This whole video all I could think about when someone talked about making friends with China in this video was the Uighur minority currently kept in concentration camps in china-wonder who they took tips from. 🤷🏻♀️
@@jazz3799 The problem is that the interpretation of "Concentration Camps" is part of a propaganda war, to destabilize China, and keep it's economy from growing by International Trade. It has been debunked so many times, yet the news never gets to Americans / Westerners like you. Thus the Western Governments win and you lose. Unless you are like me a foreigner caught in between, and invest the time to examine what is out there, then it is lost on you and your friends, that I post stuff from China or Asian countries. It is brushed off as Chinese Gov't paid bots, news agencies, and I'm a brainwashed idiot. Which from my point of view is what has happened to you. A bitter circle. Happy New Year. Stay safe.
@@davidcadman4468 if you could share any sources where it is debunked with me that would be nice, as I’m always willing to educate myself. I don’t actually tend to watch American mainstream media, so all the videos I’ve seen of Uighur concentration camps have all come from in China, filmed by either Chinese people or non- American foreigners who live there or visit under travel visas- not journalist visas. Can’t say that I’ve seen any American news cover the topic aside from the occasional vague references to human rights violations.
@@davidcadman4468 Asian here and... i dont argee with you, i DO think the concertration camps exist and China has been suppressing minorities living in China, but if you have evidence to present, im more than willing to learn more about China.
Adolf Hitler It's perhaps true for US, but it's certainly true for your profile image. Your comment matches perfectly with your user name !
It is really really so unfair. Every year tremendous amount of Chinese visit US and Europe to know more about them, but why American's or Europeans don't do the same. If we know each other better we can get along together. So sad😔
And less chance being manipulated by its own gov't into wars with foreign countries.
And now you know why a great number of US oligarchs and politicians want to ban and have already banned Confucius Institute (an institute like Goethe Institute of the Federal Republic of Germany and lots of culture and language centers of a great majority of independent sovereign states, to promote culture exchange and language learning)? Because once you learn the Chinese language you are more capable to communicate with people who speak the language, to understand Chinese culture, and thus to get to be able to make your own critical thinking and judgment on many things independently of the politicians propaganda.
@@lexneuron Yeees, It has nothing to do with the Confucius Institute being part of the CCP propaganda machine
with the side-mission of keeping an eye on Chinese students and making sure they know the Government is watching them.
Despite the name, Confucius is probably the last thing you learn there.
@@HauntedXXXPancake Any proof? As long as I know the US govt didn't give any.
@@HauntedXXXPancake. You're behaving just like Kim Jong Un of N. Korea. He bans his nationals from learning about the West, whether good or bad because he's afraid of them knowing more of the Western people and culture. Shouldn't you have more faith in others' ability of discern and decide for themselves what they learn from Confucius Institute, whether good or bad? They are more intelligent than you give them credit for. You're such a phony tyrant, so much in the mould of KJU than you realise. Or more likely, you are just being true yourself - a disingenuous troll who has an irrational fear of China due to your being brain-washed by your favorite media, or a feeble mind that thinks other minds are like yours. So sad that you can't trust your own independent judgement of what is fact and what is propaganda, even if it were from your "comforting" but bias media.
Over 80% Chinese government officers have a science or engineer's degree. Chinese hire engineers to run their country, they know how things work. The U.S. hires only lawyers, because they know how to make illegal things legal.
On Jan 6 2021 Chinese government had sentenced the former chairman(Lai xiaomin) of a huge state-owned financial company to death for his corruption, receiving bribes and committing bigamy. Meanwhile in the U.S. Trump was busy pardoning his friends, Steve Bannon and other 74 people according to the Washington Post. What an irony!
The educated world needs more of these videos with balanced and evidence-based views. Please produce more soon.
*No 1: Don't Only Hope On Government For Income,*
*No 2: As An Individual Look For Different Self Income Not Only Waiting on Monthly Wages,*
*No 3: Always Save The Little You Can And Think Of What To Do With It When It Become Good For Capital.*
*It's 100% Good To Have Different Ways To Gain Income*
*Because Government have failed us so therefore let's try and survive*
Yes ! For real It is very important to have different streams of income and a diversified portfolio as for me I have already invested in crypto which is very profitable and easy to gain
Exactly I'm also happy to start investing too than to have my money sleeping in bank
Stocks are good but we have to make the right plans
Yes Stocks are good but they are alot of businesses more convenient than stocks
That’s the fact well I only invested in stocks and will love to know a better investment too
About time the World is standing up to America!!!
A lot of Chinese go to other countries to to study and learn other cultures. The US should do the same, without changing other countries' culture to suit them.
The kind of well-balanced documentary about China that western media would never make.
DW documentaries about China are pretty good. Western is not only the US...
@@SuperPrototipas Germans are pretty biased against the Chinese as well, so are the French.
China is moving ahead regardless of the bitching, lying and sabotaging by the US. China's vision of the future resonates with most the countries including the US allies, despite the differences in political systems.
> China's vision of the future
Mass censorship, violent crackdowns of protesters, and genocide isn't exactly a vision anyone's looking forward to. So, as Pew polls indicate, most people do not support the CCP or Xi.
@@Z0DI4C Thank you for pointing out the things that the United States of America is known for these days.
Your lying president was ousted. Hopefully lying is out of fad a bit even in the US. Catch up to the trend please.
@@Z0DI4C Are you sure you are not talking about the US?
@@Z0DI4C different country but i still think usa is lagging behind 🤷
@@Z0DI4C lol seems like media won at planting hatred towards china. I won't say much but you're accusing china of forced labour, while at US, companies are paying low wadges and so low quality of work that is open to world, no one seems to care about that eh ?
U.S is kinda biased when it comes to fair economy, the fact that they also implemented such tariffs against Japanese businesses so that Japan can't overtake U.S in economy. I mean I'm japanese and I studied economy, it was such a shocking moment for me when I realized that the most important and the most trusted ally of ours is actually one of the main reasons on why the Japanese economy started declining on the step of the 21st century. America should stop their pride and should think about what is the right thing to do more than doing stupid stuffs just to keep it's title as the "Greatest Country of all" thing. Now America is regretting its stupid decision in the past as China rose to be the best on both economy and military when it's supposed to be the U.S, Japan, and Germany whose handling the world. As what I saw and learned on the past few years, I no longer blame China on why they became so powerful. Every country has its own goals and I think that China is having a stable time dealing with it whilst U.S, Germany, and my country Japan is slowly declining. I feel bad for it, we shouldn't even be on such a tough spot when the U.S itself has made relentless decisions on the past. The more I hate China because of its atrocities in the West Philippine Sea and on Taiwan, the more they get to have the advantage on controlling Asia's economy. From the desserts of the middle east to the Shrines of Japan, China will overtake everything. I just hope that they won't use assault on dealing this situations.
*STARS ALLIGN* 🇯🇵🇺🇸🇩🇪🇨🇳
Good thing that more and more Japanese is becoming aware of this. They would try to make us believe that Plaza Accord isnt the reason of that, but the fact is Japan is in recession eversince the agreement and as result Japan missed the high-tech revolution in the mid 90's.
USA has only one interest:
IT IS IMPERATIVE
that no EurasiaN challenger emerges capable of dominating EurasiA and thus of also challenging America
-
Nicholas J Spykman
Zbignew Brzezinski etc.
Where n what is west philippine sea?
than you realized what you learned in your class is not what is hapening in real llife
你的国家把美国当成盟友，但事实是二战结束后日本的重新建立就已经确定了日本在美国人心中的实际地位，就是一个附属国家。这是一件中国3岁小孩就知道的事，而不是你研究后的所谓盟友关系/骄傲的美国。日本总是认为自己是欧洲国家或者西方国家，这已经是最大的错误，实际是日本就在亚洲，而在亚洲区域日本没有一个足够友好的国家关系。当日本被美国掏空的时候，就应该第一时间缓解邻居之间的历史问题，得以立即解决经济问题，但是日本一意孤行或者一心一意跟着美国的步伐行动，导致现在的日本持续失去发展速度。始终不能掌握科技贸易规则最重要的规则。你的研究……可笑。
It's so obvious who's rising and who's falling, choose your support carefully. Good luck to Australia and India.
Well, best not to choose a side
A big cause of WWI was allies and build up of weapons and event in one country meant many countries were sucked into a war due to the allies.
@@michaeltse321 The chemical war alreadt start since 2019..
As a Chinese American I’m very sad about the bad relations between my adopted and ancestral countries. We have so much to learn from each other. Imagine what we can do if we focus on cooperation and friendship.
cant you always return? I know people live in China from the US.
@@hill6045 I could but my immediate family and closest friends are here lol. It’s more nostalgia than actually wanting to go back. Last time I was in Hong Kong and Shenzhen was ten years ago and those cities blew my mind despite my growing up in Hong Kong. I love LA and it’s so different there lol.
I met a Chinese Vietnamese in LA few years ago. He was confused about who he was. He said: “In the US they call me Vnese American. In Vnam I was called Chinese Vnamese, back to China to visit, they call me American Chinese. Then who I am?
中美关系恶化是历史的必然，因为中国继续发展必然碾压美国，瓦解美国诸项霸权，这是世界范围内的革命，革命不是请客吃饭。美国会很惨，不可避免。
Unfortunately, the Americans which had roots from their ancestral Anglo-Saxon which are violent in nature can never talk about peace. They simply need wars and violence for their everyday living.
It's always nice to meet up with new friends! That's to show us we never know where life will take us seeing him back in 1985 didn't even expect him to be the leader of the 2nd largest superpower🇺🇲🇨🇳
My eyes are full of tears when hearing the Iowa lady introducing Xi Jinping’s visit. Oh the old good days when people could be friends.
CNA makes such good documentaries
pretty biased but ur thats ur opinion i guess
@@magicmagus1459 To a far left or far right, being a centrist is biased
@@rowdynerd6793 yeah except mass surveillance, total censorship, no independent journalism, illegal overfishing, border disputes, currency manipulation, IP theft, putting people in concentration camps are human rights issues. thats just common sense neither far left or right.
@@magicmagus1459 What does that have to do with anything? Singapore is not China last I remembered and CNA is actually taking a neutral stand. So there is no bias, just telling two sides of the story.
Hahahaha. CNA made good documentaries? My toes are laughing. You wld be lucky if it doesnt feed you disinfo. besides its regular misinfo & half truths. You arent aware it is part of the gvt mouthpiece whc is ranked 159th by Reporters without Borders in the same cat with North Korea ? Or, acting blind and deaf?
Watching it in hindsight today. Many events has changed from good to bad or vice versa. CN & US are having many similarities & differences. The best way is mutual respect, understanding, trust to co-operation between CN & US. Peace is good for all of us. Both US & CN need smart diplomatic solution. Let's watch it again in N years time.
Sarah Lande and family, who hosted President Xi Jinping, are the kind of Americans who impressed many leaders in the government of China. Even the former Ambassador to the US from China, Cui Tiankai said he was impressed by the US when he was studying there and later started to work there. And it is not just them; many ordinary Chinese citizens are also impressed and want to learn from US and other western first world countries. The impact has been great because China eventually managed to carry out many reforms and made China what it is today. With the US-China exchanges in different fields and industries, the world could have benefited from this as well.
However, things started to take a drastic turn during the Obama administration with its "Pivot to Asia" policy. That was when tension in the South China Sea began to heat up and "freedom of navigation" become more frequent. Then the US-China relationship has been going downhill ever since. The US has been demonising China non-stop ever since with false accusations about Xinjiang, Tibet and raising up tension in Taiwan and Hong Kong. Even Japan is using this opportunity to boost its military strength and trying to alter the Pacifist Consitution by using the "China threat" as an excuse. The good and deep impression of US and the western world among the leaders and citizens in China, in general, have now become corroded by all these actions of the West in general, especially the US. Is that how the world like this to be? Is that how the Americans and people in the West like this to be?
During the past 30 years, it can easily be seen that the US has gradually turning from being a friendly and generous country into a selfish, militaristic and hegemonic one toward other countries. It is so sad!
trade war is good and easy to win
by orange president of USA 😂
Orange president ,Get yourself updated
ayo what world do u live in trump isnt the president
@@abdiweliyusuf3929 ayo what world you live in he the one start it
@@Findyification what
Agree👍
Whoo, this channel need more subs. I'm glad I found this precious channel.
I am so amazed that the politicians and economic advisers do not know what is the right way to do business together with other countries for mutual benefit and prosperity. You have to cooperate with a rich country like China not against it. Peaceful cooperation is the answer to prosperity.
The good relationship between US and China depends vitally on the clear mind of politicians on both sides. Economy is the survival ground of both nations. Nothing else. so play it well according to the treaty both sides agreed upon.
Excellent series. Thanks CNA.
The problem is, USA is struggling to hold its power. While china is growing power with no intention to stop.
Thank you CNA for making this documentory. Learned so much and eye opening. What strike me, president XI went back to an old friend where he stayed in his very first visit in USA. Respect earns more respect. I am not surprised that China is doing great now a days.
In 2019 we went to Beijing and wonder by qr payment , we hold some cash and notice it’s only us.
It just surprise me and wondering why CNA with all of sudden can produce such an unbiased and balance documentaries compare to last year with all those propaganda narrative documentaries. It's already 2021 today and most internet user are not stupid anymore, reporting fake narratives will not work like before. Really hope CNA can continue doing their report in such way because we need more unbiased and balance news from social media.
Because the new usa president is biden and not trump.
Or was it just stuff you didn't want to hear? That you disagreed with? Most people call stuff propaganda when it's something that burst their narrative wide open.
@@justin01144 I think I can agree with you. That's why most westerners call China news outlet for instance like CGTN or even some Westerner vlogger that live in China as "Propaganda" because they just couldn't accept the fact that China rising in such tremendous speed. So it was no surprise to me Ofcom revoked CGTN license because it's something that burst their narrative wide open.
What is happening to China right now is what happened to Japan in the 80's, a new superpower emerging made the old superpower feel unaesy. As we know today that Japan finally subdued to US' demand, and they are recession for THIRTY YEARS running! Good thing that Japan monopolized 90% of southeast asian automotive market, otherwise wed be seeing the collapse of its society
objectivce, fair and visionary . Thanks you CNA insider!
Smh, every time this kind of thing happens in politics, everyone in the middle class and normal people are the ones to suffer...
oh boy how much do I wish China-US relationship can go back to the old days
Stupid!
I hope it will happen, but I don't think it will.
you mean the bad old days...
I'm deeply moved, when Mr. Green mentioned the sacrifice China made to join the WTO, which is to laid of so many workers. I'm so glad to see that there's still some people who do care about the the history, instead of seeing everything politically
Unfortunately, poisoned by the lies and distortions of people like Adrian Zenz and ETIM,many westerners have a terrible misconception of the Uyghur situation in China. The truth is first, they are Chinese citizens and as such they learn Chinese in order to join the mainstream society, just as people in the US or other English speaking nations learn English to get on. But unlike the US or UK or Australia, Uyghurs are actually taught their own language as well in schools. What is often lost on many westerners is that Uyghur Muslims have a diametrically opposite lifestyle to many Muslims outside China. It would be wrong to say they are more liberal because they are as devoted to their religion as other Muslims. But their outlook is not the darkly puritanical and tightly legalistic type seen in many Muslim countries. Their women dress in colourful dresses and are not restricted movement or activity so they go out on their own and many had good education and careers. They often sing and dance with men, something regarded as taboo in many Islamic countries. Their men do not feel compelled to have beards or wear Arab robes or shun kufirs. There is generally none of the aversion to touching someone lest they are "unclean" menstruating woman or an unbeliever who is "haram". So their have much more open society than most Muslim communities. But this lifestyle was threatened by murderous jihadists from foreign countries and Uyghurs who had been influenced by them. Terrorists acts were committed by these people to destabilise Uyghur society. Had it been successful, do you think the unique Uyghur way of life would not be changed into something resembling that of Saudi Arabia or Brunei? Women would be forced to wear burqas and only allowed out if they had a make guardian accompanying them, etc. Arabic would displace Uyghur as the language of education. China is actually protecting the Uyghurs' traditional way of life, while allowing them to evolve into modernity. But Xinjiang IS part of China, and all this has to take place in the context of China's national plan of development and laws. It would be foolish to think it can be otherwise.
👏👏👏👍👍👍👍 BLAMED.
Ｎｏｔ ａ Ｃｈｉｎａ＇ｓ ｎａｔｉｏｎａｌ ｐｌａｎ． Ａｎｙ ｔｈｉｎｇ ｄｏｎｅ ｂｙ ｔｈａｔ
ｃｏｍｍｉｓ ｃａｎ＇ｔ ｂｅ ｕｎ－ｐｏｌｉｔｉｃａｌ，ａｎｄ ｎｏｔ－ｓｅｌｆｉｓｈ， ｆｏｒ
＂ｔｈｅ ｐａｒｔｙ＂．
Both economies are doing well, the difference is how the cake is shared.
I think the difference is the willingness to bake a new cake. US are being more and more protectionist trying to hold as much of the same cake as possible without looking at making more cakes. The reason they were successful in the early years because they were innovators, then corporate greed make the protectionists. Look at Google, Facebook, Amazon etc consolidating business and strong arming start ups, US should have protected the small companies and insure that the businesses remained independent, now it’s too late where innovation is stifled.
@@CharonTFM USA, the ultimate big brother
The thing is this is NOT about sharing the cake. This is about existential threat ! Diverting attention away from Life and Death is a deception of the highest.
@@madhatterwonderland4834 Hauwei is owned by employees, Apple?
So what I get is when the trade war started and tariff were used China did not really lose a lot of business as they turned to their domestic market and find ways to negate the SWIFT system but what did the US do to soften the blow of the tariff? What measures did they take?
Blame Trump
Trade war with Canada, Mexico, Japan, South Korea, India, Turkey and yess... EU.
@@nickl5658 he was literally pointing fingers everywhere smh
China has 300 million people in it's middle class, that is equivalent to the whole US population. They are simply using their own people to replace the American market they may lose due to tariffs.
Once China is ready it shall block American companies from it's own market, what China currently recognises is that it is not ready for any sort of war with America yet but the time for war come.
Make america great again is also imported from china.
@borray s LOL, 看出来，因为我们都叫他“川建国”同志！！！
Regarding the solar panel subsidies, those subsidies only go to the projects built within China where the project investor is the one to apply for the subsidy (even though the subsidies are usually pretty much delayed). Those subsidies are not contained in the panels exported to the other countries. The reason the manufacturers can achieve lower costs than the US is the panels made in China covers the whole production chain from the silicon rod, wafer and then module and panels.
When dealing with Americans facts rarely matter.
Chinese have proven be better business peoples players in this internacional game and then as USA only knows make internacional business using interventions using military wars , at this point they don't know how to gamble . Desperation is a really frustrating feelings when you can't harass others ; that is the way USA is feeling.
A must-watch for all US-China commentators. Objective, great interviews... Well done, CNA.
The trade issue over solar panels (20:25 to 24:50) is most interesting.
Finally, an unbiased, non-partisan and comprehensive documentary on US-China relationship....and it's made in Singapore
I’ve watched pro China and anti China documentaries, it’s good to see someone providing a more objective and non bias view on the China-us issues
It's a different perspective, but it's still biased.
Curious how usa acuse china of unfair trade when they also acuse japan of the same in 1980
They could at least create new reason xd
The fact is lying takes a lot of thinking and rethinking. Basing on the CIA guideline book is the better way for a boring and mediocre job.
The ccp cheats the US .. Trump destroyed the ccp’s ambitions of ruling the US.. huuu.... haaaa....., Wake up Americans. Listens to your heats and Trump..
@@wesondesit9418 what? Trump?
The man who is idiotic enough to not actually wear a mask during a (unfortunately) real and deadly pandemic?
I dont trust idiots.
From first two episodes, you will find two different philosophies, one does not try to find out why the economy is falling and try to blame someone else and put politics in first, and the other one is always talking cooperating and try find the way out of bad situation and less emphasis on politics!
I appreciate this video. Very informative. Thank you.
Well as a non American and non Chinese citizen, I'm glad to have alternative systems from finance to day to day items. This clash of Titans provides a wider choice for the non Titan countries.
What a lovely documentary, thank you! It's our people-to-people exchanges that are our strength. They provide hope for the future. There are soooo many lovely Chinese people. It's a pity that some Americans associate them too closely with the actions of their government.
I really like this objective view of the trade war between China and the US from a third party perspective. Both sides are developing. We cannot ask China to trade sweaters for American planes and cars forever， that would be unfair to China. The United States gets its goods and services based on the work of Chinese laborers and the damage they do to the environment.
This is so sad they both need each other and they both depends on each other for economic prosperity.
Very well made documentary!!!
this is the only unbiased video on youtube i watched these days！
The U.S wanted China in the WTO because it saw the opportunity for cheap Chinese labor. Due to a lack of foresight the US didn't plan on a reduced manufacturing base in the US. Don't blame China for your own shortcomings.
How things should’ve go...vs how things are going nowadays.
I hope things getting better 2021...
Chinese cherish friendship, but Chinese also will not forget those who hurt it.
The problems of America's society are the private companies, while they create competitions, they also re-enforced people's greediness toward money. In a market economy, money is the most important thing, not any country nor any government. The control has to be there and be there a lot. the US government just doesn't have that much influence on the economy.
I think this also reflect two countries cultural root, because US likes heroism, wants to dominate and to be on top of the world, from history it had been invaded and conquered land,while China has the Confucius root which is about harmony, hope two countries will exchange and work together that will be the best
I really like Glad Cheng. God bless him.
Having more friends is always better than more enemies
Oh! By the way, Iowa, if you are reading this I admit I don't know much about you but thank you for giving us Slipknot. I mean it.
4:47 ..... sums it up in 1 sentence! .... if only every can get along...... SO WHY CAN'T we all get along? ... wealth distribution in the US is completely out of control which can create all kind of social problems
Honestly China was influenced so much by US before Trump administration. You would never have idea how much influence it is.
A lot of students used their whole family deposit for studying in America. I really can't understand American's logic and strategy
Hi I like this lady she is a real true wise lady ❤
When someone learned how to a better job than the job you used to be good at.
LIKE CHEATING OTHER COUNTRIES!
@@darthvader5300 the solar panels, really?
@@mingzmings88 that's right, like the fruit apple
Tell it to the orange men.
countries like China and Africa are beginning to see America is losing its sway on the global economic playing field
America's time as a big boss on the global playing field is almost at it's end her cracks have become even more Visual
starbucks: "nope imma stay here in china" lol
"If our people can get to know each other, then our countries can get along"........ Also please respect each other and able to understand the fact that you have your culture.... The American Way.... And we have our culture..... The Chinese Way.... Both are unique
nowadays、US government may clearly recognize that it will lose during competition with China.so US will encourage its “allies”go to the frontline as chess pieces.now Australia and Japan.future england Germany and France.who may win this competition is not clear now，but surely the “allies” of US will definitely lose
This stuff is great.
Trade wars can hardly produce winners, but rule-based trade can. Perhaps lack of middle class jobs in the US is the problem. It will be difficult to solve this problem with an invisible hand.
CNA did a great job on presenting the issues and problems we have today between the US and China. The problem is what the lady at the end of the video said about developing our own strengths to compete.
It is clear that the US government doesn't see China in those terms. As the hegemon of the world, it sees itself as the ruler of the world and makes rules that benefits itself and makes other subservient. Clearly, the US sees China as an economic threat and in particular, a technological threat. It has weaponized IP and imposes tariffs to degrade China's economic and commerce position. It's last hurrah is in technology, but herein lies a problem for the US, it is expending too much energy throwing sand into China's rise that it is damaging itself more than it is with China.
In particular, the war in semiconductors is having blowback and the US is losing. In 2022, American semiconductor companies lost $1.5 trillion in valuation caused by their loss of the China market, with sales and profits falling off a cliff. China is driving on steroids to be self sufficient in semiconductors as the US suppresses exports of not only semiconductors, but software and production machinery. All this has done is to accelerate China's drive to be self sufficient. Between 2020 and 2022, 30 new foundries were built in China. The fab portion of the semiconductor process has been China's weak point. In the first 7 months of 2022, China imported 43 billion chips, but exported 160 billion chips. China is producing over a billion chips a day to feed its domestic and export needs. The goal is 900 billion chips a year by 2025.
Further, a study by ASPI says that China leads in 37 of 44 emerging technologies, if so, the US is losing its technology monopoly. The major reason for this, is the fact that China outproduces the manpower needed for technology. China graduates 8 times more STEM students than the US and there is now a brain drain as most Chinese students studying in US universities head home instead of staying in the US. On top of that, there is a steady flow of senior Chinese scientists, engineers, and tenured professors headed back to China because of the toxic environment in the US against Asians. Some 1400 headed back to China in 2021 and an estimated 2000 are forecasted for 2022. A survey amongst these professionals showed that 60% planned to leave the US because they fear not only for their families, but for their future.
www.aspi.org.au/report/critical-technology-tracker
www.forbes.com/sites/niallmccarthy/2017/02/02/the-countries-with-the-most-stem-graduates-infographic/?sh=75c5c147268a
cset.georgetown.edu/wp-content/uploads/China-is-Fast-Outpacing-U.S.-STEM-PhD-Growth.pdf
www.wsj.com/articles/u-s-china-tensions-fuel-outflow-of-chinese-scientists-from-u-s-universities-11663866938
US trade war to China is a joke. It's like challenging an arm wrestler champion for an arm wrestling contest