Layout Switch Replacement How-To

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 сер 2024
  • In this how-to video we replace a failed switch on my layout. Enjoy!
    Support Eric’s Trains: / ericstrains
    Eric’s Trains Merch: www.ericstrains...
    Try my other channel: / kitbashedsurvival
  • Розваги

КОМЕНТАРІ • 114

  • @RBPTrains
    @RBPTrains 3 роки тому +3

    I can only imagine how you felt when you noticed the switch was dead. Awesome video as usual and thanks for taking us through the process!

  • @agrailroad1560
    @agrailroad1560 3 роки тому +12

    I don't know if I am seeing things, but it appears that there is a rough spot in the middle of the switch. not on your joints which are perfect, but in the middle of the switch. Great video, learned a great deal. Man that cylinder steam effect has been improved a lot since the S3. Very cool.

    • @ronhood7773
      @ronhood7773 3 роки тому +1

      I noticed that also. Maybe solder in flange area.

    • @alfrednawrocki8061
      @alfrednawrocki8061 3 роки тому +2

      Your a pro Eric !! Excellent tutorial !

  • @davidmaines8093
    @davidmaines8093 3 роки тому +11

    I love the Point of view videos... gotta do more of them of whole layout like ya used to do

  • @JonatanGronoset
    @JonatanGronoset 3 роки тому +8

    Eric: "I'll solder the rail joints"
    Super-scale TIG welding!

  • @UtahUPman
    @UtahUPman 3 роки тому +4

    'Top secret instructions' isn't that the truth haha! I love my Jetboil! Especially for backcountry skiing. I also repurposed some of my old rails, I threw a few in yard with weeds growing around them & I detailed a flat maintenance car using a small stack of rails. Great 'how to' switch fix tutorial Eric! I just learned about these adapter pins & hotwater technique to remove ballast; very cool. Reviews are fine, but I find these tutorial videos much more informative--seeing how you like to do your fixs--and also my favorite part of the hobby. It's like "This Old House" for model railroading! BTW.. nice touch using the VL GS-4 to test the rails!

  • @frankiecrocker
    @frankiecrocker 3 роки тому +3

    Love the up close view, looks much more like a real railroad video from that angle!

  • @kenhoganson9481
    @kenhoganson9481 3 роки тому +4

    You should have cut the rail-joiners with a razor saw before prying off the switch, but hard to down in there to do. Thanks for this demo Eric. I think I prefer the Atlas look.

  • @danielbrown1323
    @danielbrown1323 3 роки тому +6

    Q: Why not use a dremel cut-off wheel and cut behind the joiners, then remove the switch and just pull the cut-off rail section out once the switch was gone, thus eliminating damaging the adjacent track?

    • @patrickbolmeyer9515
      @patrickbolmeyer9515 3 роки тому

      I was thinking the same thing! Also, I don't glue the ballast surrounding the switches.

    • @gdlkfanseth4197
      @gdlkfanseth4197 3 роки тому

      yup, my thoughts exactly!

  • @The_PaleHorseman
    @The_PaleHorseman 2 роки тому

    Coolest stuff ever! Just bought my first Lionel set, 37 years late but hey! I'm learning.

  • @greatsmokymtnsrailfan
    @greatsmokymtnsrailfan 3 роки тому +10

    Eric: "This is gonna get quite destructive."
    Me: Meh
    Eric: *Starts ripping the track to bits*
    Me: Oh god I was not expecting this

  • @Deadbuck73
    @Deadbuck73 3 роки тому +3

    Man your layout is gorgeous!

  • @noahwilliams8918
    @noahwilliams8918 Рік тому

    Great video, Eric! I would love to see track manufacturers produce “CWR” “thermite welding” kits (molds for soldering that go around a rail joint)! That would be such a great tool for producing consistent and easy “welds” across hundreds of joints on a layout

  • @jim293
    @jim293 3 роки тому

    Glad I stopped in today. My Atlas 0-72 right hand switch just failed and I am needing to do that exact same thing. Thanks for the tutorial.

  • @beeking1792
    @beeking1792 2 роки тому +1

    I wonder If changing track would be easier if you just spread gravel that you find in pet stores for fish aquariums, that way when changing the track you simply take the gravel, remove the track and remove more gravel. Maybe by doing that you can replace the track and put the gravel back as if nobody knew the track was just switched out. Sure the gravel may get all over the track and could cause trouble, but in the end of the day it would be more cheaper and less time consuming.

  • @djmpvae27091978
    @djmpvae27091978 3 роки тому

    Fantastic railroad operation room.

  • @blanza45
    @blanza45 3 роки тому +1

    You should try to use a dremel cut off wheel and cut the rail in 2 or three places to make it easier to remove.

  • @josephcirillo5292
    @josephcirillo5292 3 роки тому

    Always love your tutorials the BEST!!!...this is a great help....I go back often to your older tutorials many times....thanks once again Eric!!!

    • @Ericstrains
      @Ericstrains  3 роки тому

      You're welcome. Glad you like them!

  • @Chessie1985
    @Chessie1985 3 роки тому +1

    Great replacement of the switch Eric!!!

  • @roberttrains
    @roberttrains 3 роки тому

    Eric I used a Fein tool with the flat scraper to clean up the ballast and remove the switch the vibration of the tool and a little force works great

  • @BXGUY73
    @BXGUY73 Рік тому

    @ERIC'S TRAINS - where is the TRACK REPAIR Crew? Perhaps they have been SLACKING OFF and having beers in a Freight Train's Caboose. LOL!

  • @dantop1280
    @dantop1280 3 роки тому

    MOW !! Great video and great workmanship! Keep that up and you will move up the corporate ladder in that company!!!!! I love the idea of using a screw and some washers to level out the rail.... quite surprised of the size difference of the ties between the two manufactures! Thanks.....

  • @hiryu6672
    @hiryu6672 3 роки тому

    Inspiration from your videos have driven me to make my own model of an o gauge gs4, Thank you and wish me luck.

  • @cwt180432
    @cwt180432 3 роки тому

    Great video, a little bit of aggression on the removal, lol...Not sure if you hadthis problem, but, I found that I had to fix the atlas switches on my layout by soldering together the pieced center rails. The light guage wires under the switch tend to burn out with higher amp draw trains. The ross switch looks out of scale, and switch point hinges look too loose causing the wheels to drop rocking the rolling stock. A atlas replacement with modified soldered middle rails will be my replacements. Keep the instructional videos going, always a varied opinion which makes them interesting.

  • @dixienormous2704
    @dixienormous2704 3 роки тому

    Every repair requires a blood sacrifice in order for it to be done properly. I have a feeling that the new turnout should last just as long if not longer than the original Atlas with your blood donation!

  • @CLELDKFKEJ
    @CLELDKFKEJ 3 роки тому

    If only real track work was this easy!

  • @zacharymichael6897
    @zacharymichael6897 3 роки тому

    Looking great Eric, and I was going to say, if lionel does another run of 2-6-6-2's for the 1309 restoration you should get a 1309 model because the more Chessie the better :)

  • @kenhoganson9481
    @kenhoganson9481 3 роки тому +1

    Even as O72's the cross-overs look like sharp curves from the train camera view. You should maybe have done all four turnouts with numbered turnouts.

  • @timothydemarco3525
    @timothydemarco3525 3 роки тому

    Happy Valentine’s Day Eric

  • @austinmilich648
    @austinmilich648 3 роки тому

    That GS-4 is gorgeous

  • @drgwnut
    @drgwnut 3 роки тому

    Very well done video. In your opinion, why do you glue the ballast? Why not just leave it loose - it's not going anywhere is it?

  • @Leaden-plural0
    @Leaden-plural0 3 роки тому

    Your Video is Awesome Eric I Hope you do the Strasburg Railroad 2-10-0 Decapod and the Matching Passenger Cars Video Somepoint in the Future

  • @ironhorsehistorian9871
    @ironhorsehistorian9871 3 роки тому

    F in the chat for the atlas left hand turnout. Maybe you could use bits of the switch on the abandon track in the hall way room. Just an idea.

  • @HerksTrainShed
    @HerksTrainShed 3 роки тому

    i love these videos id like to see a how to video on wiring the DZ1000 switch machines for the layout im up at so we dont have to hand throw every switch

  • @Mnrr6131
    @Mnrr6131 3 роки тому +4

    21:33 Warbaby GS-4 needs more smoke

    • @TheCobraCommander
      @TheCobraCommander 3 роки тому

      And that looks like one of the new Vision Line models as well. I have a GS-5 of the same lineup.

  • @PedrotheOscalecollector
    @PedrotheOscalecollector 3 роки тому

    Awesome video Eric and I see that switch had alot of used and that new switch look really nice

  • @Trainboy11
    @Trainboy11 3 роки тому

    Nice black GS4 man

  • @PhotoMan69
    @PhotoMan69 2 роки тому

    Very informative video. Keep up the great work.

  • @Rafe0921
    @Rafe0921 3 роки тому

    You could you the rails for scenery as replacement rails or just old rusty rails

  • @IansTrains
    @IansTrains 3 роки тому

    Great video!! I think you should have left the switch the same color to make it look like the railroad came and replaced it

  • @Shipwright1918
    @Shipwright1918 3 роки тому +1

    Just out of curiosity, is is possible to ballast the track so the track merely rests upon it instead of being buried in the ballast and the glue? Would certainly make repairs of this nature a lot less destructive. On the upshot, found it very informative, thanks for sharing!

    • @Deadbuck73
      @Deadbuck73 3 роки тому

      On my layout from the 50’s... 027 on a 4x8... there was just a stripe of paint uniformly painted with sand mixed in under the tracks. It gives the appearance of ballast sort of. The rest of the table was just left to age after being in the attic for 50 years... on the bright side it smells great! 😝

    • @Shipwright1918
      @Shipwright1918 3 роки тому +1

      @@Deadbuck73
      Well, I've also considered laying down a strip of cork or other material to represent ballast, but ultimately it wasn't a "must-have" for me as I went for a retro-style layout over a scale super-detailed one.
      Although a new-build, my layout is much the same, O-27 tubular on a 3x6 door and a 4x8 plywood table linked with a bridge piece.

  • @DanielBrody
    @DanielBrody 3 роки тому

    Eric Your channel is great as I get back into the hobby. I have lots of post-war tube track and 022 switches I have cleaned up the track and some of the switches I have restored. I am building out a 12 x 6 layout, in your opinion should I stick with the O tube track or move to Atlas. All my trains now are O and O27 post-war to early 70s'. Really looking for your feedback.

  • @DestroyertheRailwarrior
    @DestroyertheRailwarrior 3 роки тому

    Instructions! Why I've never heard of such. It can't be that simple

  • @gustman9048
    @gustman9048 3 роки тому +1

    You should do the others

  • @TruenoD12
    @TruenoD12 Місяць тому

    I love your GS4484 Northernlocomotive

  • @trainsandsirensofilinmiwi2080
    @trainsandsirensofilinmiwi2080 3 роки тому +1

    awesome. keep it up with the model trains

  • @medora2499
    @medora2499 3 роки тому

    Wow, that's an amazing GS class! When are you going to review it?

  • @patrickbolmeyer9515
    @patrickbolmeyer9515 3 роки тому

    Ah-ha! You forgot to weather the unseen part of the new switch rails! No worries! I did the same to mine. LOL!

  • @sawilson56
    @sawilson56 Рік тому

    What is your "top secret" paint formula? It's the most realistic I've seen!

    • @Ericstrains
      @Ericstrains  Рік тому

      It’s just brown paint.

    • @sawilson56
      @sawilson56 Рік тому

      @@Ericstrains I searched the Tamiya paint website (I assume that's what you used) and found multiple variants of brown. Was there a specific type of brown you used?

  • @Coolbradandrew87
    @Coolbradandrew87 3 роки тому +1

    When will you review the Vision Line GS-4s?

  • @TonyLasagna
    @TonyLasagna 3 роки тому

    Awesome video! That GS tho 😍😍😍

  • @chuckhunter328
    @chuckhunter328 3 роки тому +6

    No project is completed until blood is drawn😄

  • @daivdwalker2374
    @daivdwalker2374 Рік тому

    Some people say the Ross track isn't much better than tubular track because it uses pins I'm gunna build my layout soon what you think about Ross Track and the pins far as flow of current I'm leaning towards Atlas but Ross is little cheaper what you think

  • @blairterry9435
    @blairterry9435 3 роки тому +1

    Cool it's the Lionel Vision Line GS-5!

  • @necjerseyrailfan7500
    @necjerseyrailfan7500 3 роки тому

    Great video!

  • @michaeltorrent7829
    @michaeltorrent7829 3 роки тому +1

    5:29 Yikes! I might have dremeled through the rail on the old switch so exactly that didn't happen. Just a thought.

  • @TrainBandit
    @TrainBandit Рік тому

    The fact that their made in America really sells me on ross

  • @CasperTrains
    @CasperTrains 3 роки тому

    Great video like deserved

  • @Torpedomtb
    @Torpedomtb 3 роки тому

    I think a steamer like used to clean stuff would work better than the boiled water

  • @claytons8263
    @claytons8263 3 роки тому

    Hi Eric
    I have a Athearn Genisis Promontory Edition 4014 big boy 2019 build year
    Question is. Why are there red hand wheels on the left side of the engine when it's not prototypical of the original after restoration in 2019?
    Thank you
    Clayton

  • @tadavis34
    @tadavis34 3 роки тому +1

    Question Eric, the the big bridge as well as the structures that support it. Are they custom made or did you purchase them from someone/somewhere?

  • @garyruark9506
    @garyruark9506 3 роки тому

    Good video but I think I'd use Atlas switch next time.

  • @timothystevenhoward
    @timothystevenhoward 3 роки тому

    kind of glad I have fastrack now ;)

  • @BXGUY73
    @BXGUY73 Рік тому

    @ERIC's TRAINS - Did one of your trains get DERAILED as a result of this MALFUNCTIONING Switcher Track? Or did you notice it before a disaster resulted?

  • @baxter3998
    @baxter3998 3 роки тому +1

    Question: why did you use transition track pins on only one end of the switch and not the other end which you just soldered? In other words can you just solder both ends or use track pins both ends or is it just personal preference.

    • @jimsmoter4510
      @jimsmoter4510 3 роки тому

      the rails were too close together to allow for the track pins, he would have had to cut too much of the rail thus leaving a huge gap.

  • @stephenswift5531
    @stephenswift5531 3 роки тому

    I agree

  • @davidstrainsandlego
    @davidstrainsandlego 3 роки тому +1

    RIP atlas switch 2007-2021

  • @alexlife470
    @alexlife470 3 роки тому

    Do a review on the Lionel nkp 587, PLEEEEEES

  • @Orangeshirt_Railfan
    @Orangeshirt_Railfan 3 роки тому

    I saw you on the camera on your website wondering what you were doing

  • @20thcentlimited
    @20thcentlimited 3 роки тому

    Excellent video, thank you. ps way too many commercials.

  • @Bigboy4018
    @Bigboy4018 3 роки тому

    do you use a tinted glue for securing the ballast?

  • @TheSonofruss
    @TheSonofruss 3 роки тому

    Just wondering why you don’t have under mounted switch machines?

  • @bloxy_pie
    @bloxy_pie 3 роки тому

    Will you review the Canadian pacific number 2816

  • @aidensypolt
    @aidensypolt 3 роки тому

    be very careful when painting track

  • @fredhouseal3987
    @fredhouseal3987 3 роки тому

    Eric, can you help me , why do some of my switches flutter back n forth rapidly. Ty fred

  • @arthurlites8580
    @arthurlites8580 3 роки тому

    Hi Eric . I have all atlas switches and have failure of the switch machine have you ever just replaced the atlas with the
    DZ 1000.

    • @Ericstrains
      @Ericstrains  3 роки тому

      I've never had an Atlas switch motor fail.

  • @miguelangelgarrido7233
    @miguelangelgarrido7233 3 роки тому

    hola buenas tarde muchas gracias por subir el video abrazo grande

  • @scottscherer
    @scottscherer 3 роки тому

    Awesome

  • @tylermccoy5121
    @tylermccoy5121 2 роки тому

    Did he do a review of that Southern Pacific 4457 steam locomotive? If so, someone please send me a link.

  • @zangryomani1257
    @zangryomani1257 3 роки тому

    this is why my tracks arent coverd in ballest or have any permenant things, its a pain in the butt to remove or replace.
    tho thats just me. we all have are own way of doing things

  • @yankeesandy2545
    @yankeesandy2545 3 роки тому +1

    Since when did your cat have a Patreon

  • @DJ_Timmay
    @DJ_Timmay 3 роки тому

    Should i be concerned with my switches failing? Or is this a rare thing?

    • @starlightproductions9723
      @starlightproductions9723 3 роки тому

      It’s not common, but if you use it for a long time, there’s a possibility that it would fail.

  • @raymondleggs5508
    @raymondleggs5508 3 роки тому

    And the dremel tool goees 'aaaaaaaaaaawwww nuf nuf nuuuf neeeeeeeeeaahhh neea neeeeeaaaaaaaaaHHH

  • @Garlic227
    @Garlic227 3 роки тому

    Noice

  • @joshbarnes9632
    @joshbarnes9632 3 роки тому

    why would you glue ballast down? It's not done in real life ??

    • @Ericstrains
      @Ericstrains  3 роки тому

      So that it stays put and doesn't get messed up and/or get stuck in the gears and wheels of the trains.

  • @Josephcavagnaro
    @Josephcavagnaro 3 роки тому +4

    Imagine having atlas track
    This post is brought to you by the lionel fastrack gang

  • @raymondleggs5508
    @raymondleggs5508 3 роки тому

    RIP atlas switch

  • @ericowens964
    @ericowens964 3 роки тому

    Am I the only one bothered by this guy not getting out the vacuum? "I want to make sure you have no debris in the way." Hmmmmm. Me too!

    • @Ericstrains
      @Ericstrains  3 роки тому

      I did use a vacuum, it's just not in the video.

  • @talis84
    @talis84 3 роки тому

    Top secret document you say... I don't believe it.

  • @jerzeydolphins
    @jerzeydolphins 3 роки тому +1

    odd Eric , i dont see the proper Certifications for you to begin any type of construction , lmmfao

  • @ericowens964
    @ericowens964 3 роки тому

    Extricate

  • @watson9337
    @watson9337 3 роки тому

    When he started his Dremel or did anyone else notice it’s all Like a siren