Why NITIN GADKARI is pushing GREEN HYDROGEN for Indian Industries : Green Hydrogen Case study
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- Manage your money like a Pro with Dezerv: bit.ly/3vx7mRP
VIDEO INTRODUCTION:
In march 2022, Nitin Gadkari sir surprised the entire nation as he arrived at the parliament in a hydrogen powered car!! And as soon as this happened, we all saw how viral this went on twitter!! and guess what this was not just gimmick but a clear indication to the people of India that Hydrogen fuel is the future!! Because its not just the govt, Mr. Mukesh Ambani is boldly investing into both blue and green hydrogen, Adani group is said to invest *$70 bn into renewable energy and aims to produce the cheapest hydrogen on earth and the Tata’s are already looking to build hydrogen buses for India!*
So the question is,
What is this Green hydrogen all about?
How is it going to play out in comparison to the lithium ion batteries?
and most importantly, as investors, what are the factors and challenges that you need to consider before investing into Green hydrogen related stocks!!
Check out Think School's Online courses:
1. Learn how to communicate ideas like us: www.thethinksc...
2. Land your dream jobs: linkedinmaster...
3. Create a Perfect Resume in less than 90 minutes: www.thethinksc...
Study materials
[www.energy.gov...](www.energy.gov...)
[www2.deloitte....](www2.deloitte....)
www.irena.org/...
www.teriin.org...
www.thehindubu...
www.abc.net.au...
Want to buy the equipment we use?
1. Our Laptop: amzn.to/3z66odv
2. Our Mic: amzn.to/3liQQyi
3. Camera Stand: amzn.to/3z8l3ov
4. Mobile holder for stand: amzn.to/3xgCF25
5. Laptop: amzn.to/3gMYXRi
To support our work you can donate here: www.instamojo....
#hydrogenfuel #nitingadkari #indiafuelcrisis
#thinkschool Credits: CNN-News 18, WION, NBC News, Money control pro, Business standard, TV18,Business Today, ABC news, CNBC, ET now ,Bloomberg originals, Financial Times, DW documentary, AL Jazeera English, BBC news, Firstpost. Fair use - This video is for educational purposes only. All materials used in this video, including images, audio, and video clips, are the property of their respective owners and are used here under the doctrine of fair use. This video is intended to provide commentary, criticism, research, and education on the subject matter. We believe this constitutes a fair use of any such copyrighted material as provided for in Section 107 of the US Copyright Law.
Gadkari is the real Gem of the Cabinet, Proud to a Nagpuriyan from his constituency
And The only longest serving transportation minister ever...
S Jaishankar, N sitharaman, R Singh, A Shah are also few worthy cabinet members. But yes Gadkari sir is amazing as well 👍👍👍👍
Hydrogen jada environment m dalne s kahi pani to bnne lg jayega jisse bahot jada barish hogi ??? Jese jada carbon dioxide s garmi bdne lgi h..
Rss chaddi gang member
Nagpur mei paida hua hai reh Raha hai tu toh isme proud hone jaisa kya hai? Koi achievement hai nagpur mei rehna?
Its good to see that Billionaires goals are alligned with governemnt goals and that is what a developing country needs
Still some people Business mans
@@sasikanthmynampati158 ???
that's why anti national oppostions hates Ambani adani
but can't talk about ratan tata thought he's same as close to bjp as Ambani adani
Billionaires goals are always alligned with their own interests bro...
But India have only two businessmen,😂😂
India planning , this guy : let's send spoilers to other countries 😂
During my college years, my final year project was running vehicle engine on combined fuel of hydrogen and petrol. It was in 2007, so no companies were interested in this idea due to cost issues. Good to see that hydrogen production costs are coming down. More applications of hydrogen will be promoted in near future.
It was my mini project too. The reception from professors wasn't that good though.
It's shocking how shortsighted people are. Even if it is too expensive right at that moment, how can they not know it can and will become more economic in the future?
Wowww
Q) why there is gas stations for hydrogen rather than a pre filled gas tank that can be inserted in car? (The gas tank which is setup in various location in a city does not work on full capacity as there is extremely less number of car that are filled in night (so the gas station has less than half productivity which increase the amount the consumer has to pay), so instead of this if we had a gas plant in every city which can fill insertable gas tank (which can be inserted in vehicles)and the insertable tank was made available to various parts of cities then it may reduce cost ]- but as we know this is not right, but why?
India lost again why might you ask ua-cam.com/users/shorts5A-s77aLEsk?feature=share watch this
BJP brings in innovation,
Great innovative effort by BJP
Nitin Gadkari is perfect for his ministry
If he becomes our PM
I would never say anything bad about bjp in my life 🔥💋💋
@@thegod-1614 bro but reality is hes not a great vote pullar or election machine like modi, Amit Shah or Yogiji which guarantees bjp a majority in lok sabha elections eventho his work speak for itself we as Indians are still not mature enough
@@notorious_biggie Can't agree more
@@notorious_biggie He can be made PM like Dr.Manmohan Singh, P.v Narshimha Rao
@@ashutoshsingh3007 These both cases were on some Emergency needs
Nitin Gadkari Ji nicknamed as "The Bob Builder Of India".
Nitin Gadkari has totally transformed the transport infrastructure landscape in the country today. A visionary man with great ideas and innovative approach, he is widely acknowledged as the top performing minister in the Modi Government. From his days as the PWD Minister in Maharashtra to his present role as the Highways, Shipping and Water Resource Minister in the Centre, Gadkari has worked very hard to give India a world class transport infrastructure. His hardwork is clearly visible in every infrastructure.
nope his real name is ... " Nitin Roakari "
Bob the builder kar ke dikhayenge.... Haan bhai haan😜😜😜
@@narakaasur liberal=lodu
@Global Ez problem will resolve when u will stop eating shit
@@narakaasur Rakshas 😂
Nitin Gadkari is one off if not the best Cabinet Minister India has. He knows what he's doing and does it well. Gadkari and Jaishankar are the gems of the Indian Cabinet.
CHAD Gadkari
ashwini vainhnav also
why does piyush goyal always get ignored... he has done such good work in railways and coal. I wish he was the fin min
Very well said ❤️
Gadkari should be made the Prime Minister
He is one of my fav Ministers of all time. His work in infrastructure building (Highways) is unparalleled; I have never seen this much efficiency in road building in my country in my 27-year existence here. A lot to learn from him, a lot.
I know in Other Video You will say This about Dr. S jaishankar Too 😂
Everyone Does. 👍😂
Toll tax very high
@@Himachali_Protagonist you are saying as if its a bad thing
Amazing. India is breaking barriers that is absolutely necessary. Loving it. India being such a vast land can change the future. Love from Bangladesh.
India lost again why might you ask ua-cam.com/users/shorts5A-s77aLEsk?feature=share watch this
Energy Security, will eventually lead to Economic Security, and will be the foundation of a resilient Economy.
You beat me to it........once India becomes self sufficient in Energy Production our Industrialists ( Tata, Adani, Ambani, Birla, Bajaj etc) will focus more on other sectors like Digital/ Computer technology, Electronics, Space etc....I hate to say but India is still struggling to fulfill its fundamental needs. Jai Hind !
@Amrit Waiba the thing a lot of people dont realise is that a country's development doesnt so much depend on its politicians or beaurocrats but on its Industries. If u look at the corruption perception Index India, China & South Korea have close rankings.
If u r not convinced yet then look the top American politicians and congressmen, they r no better than Indian Politicians. The reason US, China & South Korea are so developed because they entered the digital & electronics market in the early 80s & have since benefitted from 1st & 2nd industrial revolution.
India is late in the game but as our Industries diversify their portfolio into Digital & Electronics Tech, India will also sooner or later become an advanced economy.
Our ppl dont respect businessmen
As India grapples with an unprecedented power-crisis, Adani Power’s net profit quadrupled to a whopping ₹ 4,911.50 Crores in FY 2021-22 as against ₹ 1,297 Crores in FY 2020-21.
Q) why there is gas stations for hydrogen rather than a pre filled gas tank that can be inserted in car? (The gas tank which is setup in various location in a city does not work on full capacity as there is extremely less number of car that are filled in night (so the gas station has less than half productivity which increase the amount the consumer has to pay), so instead of this if we had a gas plant in every city which can fill insertable gas tank (which can be inserted in vehicles)and the insertable tank was made available to various parts of cities then it may reduce cost ]- but as we know this is not right, but why?
Being a chemcial engineer workig in an hydrogen unit in oil & gas refinery i can say that, this video has covered almost everything one needs to know about hydrogen industry, excellent presention and kudos to you guys for deep research and explaining this complex topic in an laymen terms , just i would like to add some points
1. In chemical plants hydrogen requirement is 24×7, now if i am producung my electricity from solar, for the night i need alternate electricity source or energy storing device which can increase CAPEX cost higher making grern hydrogen ineffective currently in particular case
2. For the immediate situation IOCL has started blending of green hydrogen with Natural gas, not only this would act as better fuel but will have lower emissions value and on economic front lower import bill to.
3. Reliance is currently investing heavily on solar cell manufacturing, battery and elecrrolyzer manufacturing , there recent acquisition of UK based company with deep research in Na- ion battery will make a big difference in the manufacturing cost of green hydrogen when done at a scale.
So i am ambitious for the future of green hydrogen , it has certain bottlenecks but with the technological advancement and scale of economy the said 1$/kg hydrogen is possible.
I watched a video about hydrogen on real engineering channel. Here he didn't show anything related to how hydrogen can be transferred by a Transport system and how it can be stored like petrol? The initial price of A hydrogen station is 400 times that of a petrol station. There are many issues like the price of a base hydrogen car is much higher than petrol and ev. So hydrogen can be used for commercial vehicles like trucks, buses and planes in future India is still miles away from this because here significant people are still using wood and gas is new for them .
@@logohub1234 I was going to comment same
1kg = 1L ,So 75 rupees for a liter,With taxes it will up to Rs 100 ,Then why hydrogen we can still uses efficient petrol for that price
The Hydrogen be Created by Breaking Water using Electrolysis...."
So my Question is...
"Why the Hell He didn't talked about Water??? There is Usable-Water Shortage all over India/World!!!
How can you miss on such a big point???"
He missed on a very Imp topic of Water.
Accept that BJP has best leaders which can make india a superpower.
You're generalizing exceptions. Gadkari and Jaishankar are undoubtedly performing good.
But don’t u think it is gimmick when petrol prices are roaring, bjp gives perception about hydrogen, for which India needs 10-15 years
@@jashanvirsingh2166 bro have u seen prices of other countries? See whole europe, India has still maintained good prices comparatively due to its diplomacy with Russia and the west. If Modiji would have stopped buying Russian oil due to pressure from west, you don’t even know that prices would have gone to rs200 by now
@@stardust286 you are generalising exceptions my bro. There are some exceptions of bad ministers maybe, rest all are top notch. Yogiji, Modiji, jaishankar, nitin gadkari, defence minister, etc…..
No
76,000 in two weeks 🥰
Me too I've been earning greatly from Mrs Sarah Joy Greenes trading services
$24k and still counting in just 2 months, Expert Sarah Joy Greene is the trade queen as far I'm concerned.
Crypto currency and NFTs will outsmart the banking system in the nearest future serving as a global fiat. Already making over 85% profit from my current investment
This woman has really changed the life of many people from different countries and l'm a testimony of her trading platform.
The Politician with a mind like an entrepreneur ❤️. Proud to be a Nagpurkar.
I must really appreciate you Mr. Think school for bringing new-age content into UA-cam. Thanks
Intellectual guy, makes contents easy to understand.
What new age content
Nitin gadkari have done amazing job here in uttrakhand on all weather road project and new kailash mansarovar road ..it will also help army in border..
Thanks alot for your awesome content which helps us to gain knowledge towards green economy..👌
@Global Ez yea coz you will start begging on road
Thanks for sharing this helpful insight! I've gain so much knowledge about Crypto trading I'm so excited I've been making $25,000 and above
Hello. I have been looking for such a profitable signal's and guides from a pro trader for some time now, how do i contact him?
@Profit_peter_fxt
You can communicate with him on TELEGRAM.s with the
username above ..
Thanks for sharing his telegram handle, i’ll surely reach out to him and start learning the right way, tired of loosing from price drops.
Nice info, i appreciate your concern this will help a lot especially to the young bitcoin investors who have no or lesser knowledge on how bitcoin market works.
This is one of the best explanation I have found here especially in terms of the scientific hurdles of green hydrogen production.
As material scientists we have synthesized several efficient Pt free catalysts and we are hoping to see their commercial utilisation in near future..😊
Do you work in the field of catalysts ?
Which company?
@@yashkataria4981 yes
@@omkarvelankar4439 I'm in academia RN.
If india is able to crack the green hydrogen then imagine billions of foreign exchange saved and oil producing countries will be looking at uncertain future..at present they are benefitors from uncertain oil world..
There is also the problem of electricity we are using coal mostly and are not able to use nuclear energy much because of less abundance in our country
India wont crack green hydrogen.
Ambani adanis would and profit go to them and not to India.
Please get this
@@scienceisreligion5618 money would be in India so what's the problem who so ever is gonna crack it btw I am a fan of privatization things are always very organized in private organization
@@kushalsingh3082 how will money be in India? I dont clearly undertand.
For eg., Infosys daughter moved away from India to Britain. Meaning money is moving away from India.
Now she is paying tax there and she will settle there.
The same go to Ambani. Ambani bought Biggest Kingdom like house in Britain last month. Are you sure their daughter or son wont move in any time soon?
@@scienceisreligion5618 Akshita murthy has more money then the queen of England why would she even take the money from India and having properties all across the world is very much like a business men. Bro I don't understand one thing why in our country people just want to criticize you grow your own business become as successful as them who will stop you. If some business men like Elon musk in us become successful same people congratulate them but dont wanna see indian business grow. Just yesterday I saw Adani came in some top list of rich people I was surprised that where were many people instead of congratulating him were laughing on him. Even if we leave this all what do you think there should be no good business men in India. Just see once what percentage of our GDP is their contribution. Please think with an open mind.
TATA' s always no.1 in any field proud that it represents India
You guys are dumbf because you guys cant appreciate adani and reliance while they also pay equally to indias growth
Haha it does not feature in any top 10 global car company
@@superjit6190 Sir wait for 10 Years the game is just started TCS is in 2nd position soon it will be the largest IT Company in the World also watch TATA MOTORS it will be 2nd largest in terms of sales in this year only
@@superjit6190 but one of the most safest cars no doubt, beats some European and all Chinese brands
@@pavilion0420 Not all Chinese brands specially in ev tata has no match for BYD.
Nitin Gadkari is a wise guy who foresighted the energy crisis and hydrogen is the common element in who universe.
Then why people voting for AAP
@@yashpalchaudhary9752 fools who like short term gains like freebies
@@user-lk3cf6yx6c Aapians think unlike that people who vote for bjp are fool, then who is wise? In my opinion all parties are same.
True nitin gadkari is a gem In Indian politics
The man made energy crisis ( America, Ukraine and Europe doing their utmost to push Russia down because American ego via Biden wants to be top dog)
@thinkschool team, you guys are absolutely rocks in every videos. I have been following such YT channels from past 2 years. But really Thinkschool is the best amongst all. The team always provides right and very precise information on every topic. I have gone through the research materials in the descriptions. You guys are doing commendable job. Thanks and always keep going likewise.
Proud of you, son. People like you of the younger generation will make not just India, but the entire world a better place to live.
Hydrogen is also good for grid level energy storage for when solar does not work during night, etc.
It's not. H2 production is just fuel production when you compare. When making H2 with excess green energy, your not shutting down coal and gas power on those periods.
Hence I've could just be doing that instead.
@Σ solar ain't inefficient. The watt per m2
Might not be dense. However. Sun is free of power input.
Producing H2 cost abundance of energy that better used directly. Battery storage is there. And especially in countries as India there is more sun than countries up north which are already more involved in solar.
I recently visited an Startup incubator where I saw a start-up which produces hydrogen from Dirty water. I was so fascinated by the idea bcoz even purifying dirty water is not sustainable but what they are doing is super sustainable. They even established a full scaled working model for Tatas.
Would really appreciate if can share some details about the startup.
Was that in India? If so, where?
@@Robertsmith001 why are you surprised if it's in india or not?
Yes. A few days back in Raisina Dialogue 2022 Nitin Gadkari told the same thing.i.e producing hyderogen from dirty water .
@@sujalverma8033 he may not be indian thats why
there is only one guy in politics who every indian trust and that is without a doubt Shri Nitin Roadkari ji .....
Roadkari🙄
@@AttackTitan008 he build road so and in marathi kari means done so road builder
@@AnuJ-vu5xn ahh that's nice
I thought you were trying to mock him
Very nice content Bro.
I agree on the efficiency point, as on today it's very costly to convert green hydrogen. The efficiency is somewhere around 20% only. But, this is the Future. And hope like solar plants cost back than a decade ago and now, Green Hydrogen may also become affordable one for all energy sector components.
Thanks for Keeping us informed
🙏
#SayYesToGreenHydrogen#SayYesToPollutionFreeIndia
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
I did some research on Hydrogen for my investment, Expect to read this story repeatedly over the next decade:
1) Politicians seduced by H2 Fuel Cell technology;
2) Price signals suppressed throughout the value chain - subsidised hydrogen via subsidised distribution to subsidised vehicles;
3) Physics and Economics spoil the party.
The best case H2 is worse than the worst case battery storage in terms of both cost and efficiency. Also battery cost is declining rapidly while H2 cost is more than hydro carbon fuels. Cost decline in H2 happens only on paper. Even lead acid battery storage is better than hydrogen storage let alone Li-on battery. H2 cost savings we see in the news are carefully selected half-truths. They say it takes 5 minutes to refill hydrogen fuel cells but they won’t say, how long it takes to produce, compress & transport H2. Those cost & time must be accounted somewhere in the value chain and they are enormous!
Unfortunately many nations are investing in H2 heavily, which is going to be waste of Taxpayer’s money. Even Reliance is going to invest heavily in Hydrogen. Not sure if there are any engineers with economic sense. Scientists are different from Engineers; Engineers are different from Manufacturers; Manufacturers are different from Raw material producers; and Businessmen are different from all of them. For any product or service to reach masses, it must make sense for all of these players. But unfortunately here politicians & businessmen are talking to scientists and announce it to public to please the voters & shareholders.
We must remember, H2 is NOT an energy SOURCE but an energy storage mechanism. H2 is the most abundant naturally occurring material in the universe BUT NOT on EARTH. It must be extracted either from Methane(CH4) or Water(H2O). Extracting H2 from Methane is definitely economical but Methane is again hydrocarbon and it warms the atmosphere 86 times more than carbon dioxide. So we would be better off with petroleum & Coal than Methane based H2.
To extract H2 from water, Electrolysis is needed which is an extremely energy intensive & inefficient process. To extract H2 from water, we need to spend 3 times more energy. If we want to store 1 KiloWatt energy in Hydrogen fuel cell, we need to spend 3 Kilowatt energy. Are we living in any kind of energy abundance situation, to waste 2 Kilowatt for every 1 Kilowatt of usable energy?. Green Hydrogen is definitely green, I mean there is no carbon by product there. But we're wasting 70% of energy produced by Solar & Wind while storing it in H2 fuel cell.
Also H2 is a colorless, odorless, and tasteless gas. It is the lightest gas and is explosive in air at concentrations greater than about 4%. In contact with chlorine, oxygen, or other oxidizers, hydrogen is flammable and explosive and burns with a nearly invisible flame. Because H2 is the lightest gas, it needs huge physical space to store though the mass is super low. To handle this, it has to be compressed or liquified in a pressure chamber. How’re we going to transport this kind of material from production facility to all over the refill station?. H2 Pipelines across the continent, seriously?. Who is going pay for such a massive and hazardous infrastructure?.
Green H2 makes sense, only when we have energy abundance and don't know what to do with such excessive energy.
If you're not convinced, No less than Elon Musk says, H2 is dumb idea. Nuclear is by far the most reliable and safe energy source followed by Solar & Wind + Battery storage.
H2 may not be an effective replacement of Petrol and diesel, but it can be a replacement for coal and natural gas in Indian industries.
I did same calculations and drive an ebike in bangalore.
But when India will have lots of solar (in 2025), then the efficiency wont matter as the electricity prices will drop to 0 (or even negative).
Any usage of that excess solar is GOOD, and hydrogen seems to be one such use case.
Plus not needing to use USD as reserves for Indian trucks / buses / ships will be a game changer in geopolitics.
@@ajaivaidyanathan5880 No. Coal & Natural Gas are energy sources, but H2 is not. We need to spend either Solar/Wind energy or Coal/Natural Gas energy to produce H2. In that process, we'll be wasting 2KW for every 1KW usable energy. Why are we promoting this 70% energy loss, while battery storage has less than 10% loss?.
@@dskrishnan Correct
Bro H2 is Bad idea for Cars but For bigger picture it can serve, like Trucks and industrial use.
@Think School beautiful explaination! Most of the chemical engineering aspects were explained in a simple and correct way!!
India is abundant in one thing. Solar power - with abundant sunshine and land area. We need to lay more Solar farms. A lot more. 400 to 500 GW of solar power by the next decade. Solar is already the cheapest form of energy, so why not ..
And solar power can produce Green Hydrogen for energy storage (instead of batteries) and for green transport.
Good. Now do tell me how trusting the solar is. China has monopoly over the raw materials. You need lands for the same. You need storage units to cater to fluctuating production.
Yes but H2 storage is big issue H2 being highly flammable the safety of vehicles reduces and it transportation cost is much high..
India's weakest link has been energy security. This open risk was not plugged for the last 70 years. This resulted in the indian populace in dire poverty. Its time to uplift the masses and improve the human development index. Nitin Gadkari is a visionary statesman who is making the right moves. The investment in research and development in this area has to speed up to get it to the level of maturity. Research and Development center for next age technologies in India has to happen through a consortium of top Indian companies working together to create global standards with patenting. This will help it in the long run. Operational efficiency of India has been good, however investment in research and development is below global benchmarks.
Ganesh fabulous animation and explanation budy...
I am following your channel when you were having nearly 9,800 subscribers..
And till date i have never missed a single video...
And the way you have evolved is just unbelievable specialy the animation you guys use during your videos.
Can you please share which software you use for making animation so that I could use it in my lectures.
Thanks alot :)
We use Adobe After effects
@@ThinkSchool thank you :-)
I like how you bring critical issues to such a simple conclusion for us.
PLEASE do one video on dropping Ground water level in India esp in regions close to Delhi.
Thanks
Will his video increase water level.
@@yashpalchaudhary9752 atleast it will encourage not the least single person to save water
*If* India succeeds in this sector, then the Middle East's major source of income will get a big hit, wonder how they'll handle it, anyway it's evident that 1 day these fossil fuels will get exhausted (maybe in next 60 years or so)
Fossil fuels will be there for 1000+ years ,humans have only extracted a tiny bit of it and there's plenty more to come
Well countries like saudi and uae are transforming themselves
All these are hawa.. Remember 2 months back,ethanol mixed petrol was marketing term for gadkari. Before that solar grid.. Keep changing goal posts
How do u think flights and ships move?
@@MOHAMMED-gi2uh check the first letter of my comment it's in bold saying "If"
Well Flights and ships OK got your point, but there are more flights and ships in the world than Cars, bikes, buses and trucks..? If the latter 4 use green hydrogen majority of the oil consumption will be gone isn't it??
If u give 20 more years to this govt in central govt India will completely transform. India will dominate the world in every sector. Present govt is visionary and honest towards country.
Jai Hind Jai Bharat
Naa you're trippin
@@weexist54 haha you will witness it by yourself.😉
@@harshabhargava681 I am already seeing the change. Just backwards.
@@weexist54 then in that case I'm sorry to say you have problem in your eye sight 🙂
@@harshabhargava681 and you have a clear problem in your brain too.
Adios
Bro kudos!
I am a green energy practitioner and an environtalists working with Centre for Science and Environment.
Awesome research, happy to see all those reports from TERI, IRENA, IEA.. 👏👏
Thumbnail 👍.
Modi has chosen some best ministers
Nitin ji
Dr Jaisankar
Aswhwini sir
Piyush Goyal is also doing well commerce suites him.
@@ayushc5704 Yup!! I don't know why libtards arent seeing this. He is doing some pretty good job but he has some extra works to do as he has MSME and it emplys largest non-agrigarian mass. It is in bad shape/
Nitin Gadkari Ji
Dr Jaishankar Sir
Ashwini Vaishnav Sir
Piyush Goyal Ji
Hardeep Singh Puri Sir
Jyotiraditya Scindia Saab
Best and Performing Ministers in Modi Ji's cabinet
Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles are good in terms of time it takes for refueling the vehicles but are not at all energy efficient with respect to EV as EV's are around 80% energy efficient where as HFCV are 40-45% efficient and if we look closely the whole process of electrolysis is acting as a middle mam as we could directly use the renewable energy for transports via EV's ........ I think the future could be a hybrid vehicle where we can use both a hydrogen fuel cell as well as a lithium ion battery which could not even reduce refueling time but also will be cost efficient. such that if a person has time to refuel he can choose to charge it with electric charger at a low cost and save up some money where as if a person is in a hurry he can refuel his vehicle with hydrogen and save up some time.
Same thing I was thinking. That compared to EVs hydrogen fueled cars are way less efficient. But also production of lithium ion bartteries are environmentally hazardous.
The comparison is not really apple-to-apple. it is clear that consumer level car is going to be completely EV with no doubt. But there is a large space where energy needs and requirements are completely different where batteries just cannt solve the problem, e.g., large commercial fleet, industrial needs etc.
but what i was thinking is that, through the process of electrolysis water is splitted in to both oxygen and hydrogen, the resultend oxygen can be also used as a commercialy like selling oxygens in to end users like hospitals and patients, so that the cost of hydrogen fuel can also be reduced. but i hope they may have already considered this before making an estimation about the cost and price of green hydrogen fuel
@@krishnaprasad2006 yea right and that companies doing that already
Hybrid isn't possible at costs it will increase the price and weight of the vehicle and off couse the maintenance so i think the future vehicles will be divided into batteries and hydrogen cells
Indian market is one of the biggest market I had ever seen.
Im not from a well to do family, have no one to learn all this from. Thanks for posting amazing contents, specially global issues, and geopolitical topics. Learning a lot. God bless you
From odisha
Green hydrogen will help us show MIDDLE FINGER to OIC/OPEC
Itna jaldi wow your great it's too hard sir I think there is a separate research team for think school who has only work of researching
Yeah, they have a research team.
More than half of energy is lost even before it reaches the car also storage is a big big problem, being slightly more dangerous still, i think we need to work more on the technology before getting our hopes up. Green as per now atlest let's see.
Hmm need more development of technology.. so it will take time and scale.
It can be used as large scale grid storage to store renewable energy generated by wind and solar. And used during peak demand hours by using fuelcell/ gas generators. For Vehicles I will still choose electric/ methanol over hydrogen.
You go and join Nitin cabinet and suggest him, don't you think he doesn't know about pros and cons of this initiative you are a common man think like that, they are ministry with highly qualified technicians other staff they will have thier plan to protect wait and watch
@@KGF74843 🤣 If Politicians really wanted just progress we wouldn't be discussing this bud, it's all for attention
People always take Modi's name and although I think despite all the hype he is still underrated but also we fail to acknowledge the other performers in his team-Sushma Swaraj, Manohar Parikkar, Nitin Gadkari, JaiShankar, and numerous other excellent performers
I don't think anyone underrates the names u mentioned... Adding Arun Jaitley too
@@beingselmon8602 Yes
So having right people on team is important as a leader
Wtf? Modi is trash. Nitin gadkari is good
2-5 hrs power cuts across India now due to modi govt's incompetence.. Artificial coal shortage to benefit adani
Hi. I just discovered your videos and love how deeply informative they are. Thank you for what you do!
That said, I wonder if you would comment on the fact that Green Hydrogen is derived from renewable energy sources which is presumably preferred - yet in 1st video of yours I watched which is 1 of the 3-part China Silk Road world domination series - you mention datapoint that China produces like 94% of critical solar panels & photon cells… what is India’s plan to displace that stranglehold? How can USA help? I definitely see the Lithium Ion & Cobalt mining crisis coming & wish more people were seeking to u sweat and the issues you communicate. Thank you 🙏🏼
We are going to manufacture solar panels in India.
Based on the explanation, we need water for the requirement of GREEN HYDROGEN. That is a direct implication that THERE WILL BE WATER SHORTAGE & CRISIS, which it will increase drastically. A lot of places in INDIA are facing Water shortages.
We are giving OUR MOST IMPORTANT WATER (which CANNOT LIVE/SURVIVE without it) , for the fueling of vehicles.??
Your videos are amazing. Also your audience; even if the video explains a controversial political content 95% of comments are polite and courteous.
People express their views politely even they oppose to each other.
Honestly not always
@@vedantmungre1702 yep. I saw some of them who got triggered.
until you see the replies
@@shivam_nagar69 it's way better than the news channels
@@orionsbelt9381 hmm
I really needed this video thank you ganesh bhai and your team for giving such an insightful knowledge about green hydrogen
I am saying this cuz I am an IIT aspirant and there is a part in our chemistry NCERT book Hydrogen as a fuel and there it is clearly stated as hydrogen is going to become the next fuel in the future and only by then I had foreseen myself as a researcher and developer in hydrogen economy.......I hope I become one and get my country on the top in this fuel race.
Thanks a lot!!!!
Wow all the best for future endeavours! India needs smart innovative young people like you
Ganesh is so good at research that he should be probably in NITI ayog,our nation needs such guys❤️❤️
well said bri
@@canadiangabru6796 no we vote only un educated gundas..
@@jeffrinjohnsoncmaacca Hope people will not elect Scamgress again.
@@Yuva_Maddy Yeah, they will definitely ruin all these developments & we'll go back to those SCAMgress days again 🙏
Good topic but significant flaws in research. Firstly, you have compared current battery technology with future hydrogen technology regarding use in vehicles. There are a lot of safety, technical and regulatory challenges for adoption of hydrogen as a vehicle fuel. Solid state batteries are far safer with sufficient energy density for use in vehicles. They will dominate when they're mass produced at lower costs.
Secondly, steel manufacturing in India is mostly done using coal not grey hydrogen.
Why I discovered this Channel so lately. I could have been more informed but still great to discover this channel.
There are so many people working tirelessly behind the scenes to solve this challenge.
If Govt along with top 10 companies of India are pushing for green hydrogen,these entities have the most skilled,experienced and smartest people working for them
and all of them gonna collectively pump billions of dollars,they will have plans to safeguard their investments at the least.
We may not achieve the target in stipulated time or the desired costs but we can come close.
Absolutely love all your case studies and the story-telling in your videos!! Kudos to all the research and hard work you put into this!
👏👏👏
I just love this guy 💓😘😘....thanks for making it so simple to understand... always enjoy think school's videos...kudos to you and your team..❤️
Calm Down.
Amazing to see someone who trades with Mrs Victoria Olga, i am currently on my 7th trade with her and my portfolio has grown tremendously
I invest with Mrs Victoria too she charges a 15% commission on profit made after every trading session which is fair compare to the effort she put in to make huge profit…
I will forever be indebted to you Mrs Victoria and this channel you’ve changed my whole life I’ll continue to preach about your name for the world to hear you’ve saved me from a huge financial debt with just little investment thanks so much Mrs Victoria Olga
Thankyou so much think school I am your subscriber way before you hit million
Basically we had a poster presentation in our college regarding sustainable development we choose this topic and followed your study materials...
AND I AM VERY HAPPY TO SHARE WITH YOU THAT WE WON 1ST PRICE IN THAT POSTER PRESENTATION IN WHOLE UNIVERSITY🎉😄
ONCE AGAIN THANKYOU SO SO MUCH THINK SCHOOL ❤😘
Green hydrogen is future. Not current evs
Nitin sir dil se chate Hu, Aap hamare next prime Minister bano.
I want Gadkari sir to be our future prime minister.... He's the best ❤️
India requires more Responsible Rich people
In Communities , as to MORALS -
To serve the poor - within their "SPAN OF CONTROL".
It is not possible by any government or any power
ANY where on EARTH. -
TO SATISFY-
THE GENERATION NEEDS
OF HUMANS Via
Present day , CORPORATE
MEANS. *
EVERYTHING IS SIMPLE
IF YOU KNOW IT..
CHEERS. *
Gadkari sir should lead the country as prime minister......how many of u think the same.....
Well another visionary leader is Navin Patnayak...... 🙏
Jai hind jai bharat 🇮🇳🙏
"As a student of business and investors what are the key points that you need to keep an eye on" this line has a seperate fanbase ❤️✨
i really love gadkari nice vision just hope it implements perfectly as the electric bike segment has already failed badly batteries blast and much more issues and EV cars are still under testing phase where they are proving ..i hope the best when govt back something their should be no error..like humid climate effects on H2 and isolation wow man we ware going to witness the Indian engineers first time at the best and full potential ..i hope it to be safe and heck yeah I'm excited
The other advantages and disadvantages notwithstanding, the reality is Hydrogen is a way to keep the fossil fuel based petro-chemical industry going by making up for any reduction in profitability from fall in demand for oil products in the future
Hello there; your explanation regarding hydrogen fuel cell in transportation is kinda misleading!
1.First of all, electrolysis of water to produce hydrogen in itself is a very tedious task.. meaning that a large amount of voltage is required to breakdown the water molecules into hydrogen and oxygen atoms.
2. Furthermore, storage of hydrogen is a big headache coz being a volatile element, it's difficult to store hydrogen as such and thus they are being compressed at high pressure and dropping temperature.
3. Moreover, if at all hydrogen driven economy comes into picture, we will still suffer because of high cost of construction of hydrogen gas stations. For example, it takes about 300000$ for setting a gas station whereas it takes about 2 million$ for setting a hydrogen gas station just because of the complexities involved in storage.
4. Last but not least, to increase efficiency of the fuel cells, we use electrodes of platinum or titanium oxide, which obviously doesn't suit in a large scale. Also, since there are different classification of fuel cells, selection of right fuel cell for transportation is complex.
5. Just for an example, the hydrogen powered Toyota mirai takes upto 9 seconds to go from 0 to 60..which is really bad.
All i wanna convey is that we are still under development and there's a lot more to come with fuel cells than getting them into roads!
Jai hind!!
Theory will NOT help. Lack of will in execution is keeping India down. Gadkari is hippo who makes bold statements which gets applause from masses.
If you will listen to speeches of nitin gadkari .. keeping your political ideology aside ...
It's truly engligntening for a infra enthusiasts..
They always mention India when there’s anything negative on earth, western countries are so much biased. CO2 must have a cost certainly & that include historical too, this can be easily calculated by the presence of CO2 in atmosphere and it’s origin over at least 100 yrs. Also , allocation of CO2 should be per capita & penalties must be as per capita sufferings.
I was going to say that this was a poorly researched video, but to give you credit, you covered all the issues of hydrogen in the conclusion. But I wish you talked about it in more detail. So I would like to add a couple of points
Honestly, I don't think green hydrogen is going to work for transportation. Mainly because the storage and transportation issues are more of a physics limitation than a technological limitation. Hydrogen is the tiniest element in our universe and making a leakproof container to store it is pretty much unfeasible for massive consumption. And if it leaks, it will all just rise through the atmosphere making it irrecoverable. Hydrogen is also extremely flammable, so safety again becomes a concern (remember zeppelins?)
With the rate at which Lithium-Ion batteries are getting better + and intense research into alternative batteries such as solid-state, aluminium, etc I think battery tech is going to improve way faster, that we won't really need to look towards hydrogen for commercial transportation. And the great thing about BEVs is that they can be used even without infrastructure given the advent of electricity everywhere, but making safe, reliable Hydrogen stations in such a short time to meet our climate goals is next to impossible
Also, you made a point about how if anyone cracks the code for perfecting electrolysis and green hydrogen production, they're going to be a net energy exporter. I don't really understand how you came to that conclusion because once the tech is out there, it will only take a handful of years before almost every country can invest in their own hydrogen production plant since the inputs required for it is just water and electricity. Transporting hydrogen across the seas over a period of months or pumping it through a pipe is not feasible at all as I mentioned in the first paragraph
For industrial uses, hydrogen could definitely be a viable option. But it needs to be local and there needs to be a proper and clean channel to bring in seawater for electrolysis use rather than digging up underground water like how most industries operate today
Spliting h2o ie water will reduce total water in the ecosystem? Will it not create imbalance? If yes, will it not dry up the water on this planet after many decades as the energy consumption is never going to end. Also there will be too much o2 in air after electrolysis ie more than 21% which is required for ecological balance. So increased O2 in air might catch fire. Just asking. Can someone explain if I am misunderstanding anything?
Hydrogen fuel is very expensive to transport requires lot of safety as it's highly explosive and requires expensive cryogenic containers which need cool down requires again more energy,
Hydrogen pumps setup are 8 to 9 times expensive requires a lot of safety, these are two main reason hydrogen power for automobile model is not much successful from last 10 years in USA, hope it will get solved in future but still very tough!
Hydrogen powered vehicle is a great innovation by man.
Not against the idea but they come with huge infrastructure to invest in ie. Hydrogen fuel pumps need very huge investment compared to electric charging stations.
Also hydrogen is produced by electrolysis of water generally which will be of 60% power efficient.
If you are using electricity to produce hydrogen, why not use it directly to recharge your car?
Bro watch video again, Efficiency of lithium ion battery decrease for trucks and heavy vehicles. Thats why hydrogen good for them
@@shubhampreetsingh8630for those we use biofuels or swapable battery
We required out of the box thinking for hydrogen extraction from environment with our existing sources. People initiative will help a lot.
Present buddy ❤️
Thank you for your efforts both of you ❤️
Loved it ❤️
Ye Dil Maange More ❤️
Nitin gadkari is a great political leader of India.
This video is very informative. I appreciate your hard work for this video.
Really your video is very knowledgeable for me .
Love from Bihar.
Electric cars Vs hydrogen cars.
Check and compare.
for electric The charging time they will eventually find a solution. The hydrogen as a carrier brings a complexity and dependancy also.
You didn't mention a single time that hydrogen is viable only in liquid form and it is extremely difficult to contain and store in liquid form. Hydrogen containers will take far more space than regular fuel containers for a reason why you cannot carry more/enough hydrogen and also make it efficient. Furthermore, hydrogen molecule is the smallest compared to any other molecules. It is impractical to cage it successfully. It's only about time that the fuel container will get emptied by itself (almost).
But bhai hydrogen cars toh available h....usme kaise store hota h??????
@@siddharthgupta1840 bhai, available hain, lekin efficiency bohot hi poor hain.
@@shounak911 ok....thank you bhai 👍👍👍👍👍🙏
@albion yes I got the reply earlier 👍
Think is the real school and if children have this kind of school they would more than happy to go to school all 7 days atleast I would have been
So much research and hard work is put in each video
Kudos to you sir
My guru gem of this land " Shree Nitin Gadkari ji "
That is the exact reason I advise both new and old investors to trade with a professional who understands the market quite well that way maximum profit is attainable She is the best I know so far Victoria Olga
I will forever be indebted to you Mrs Victoria and this channel you’ve changed my whole life I’ll continue to preach about your name for the world to hear you’ve saved me from a huge financial debt with just little investment thanks so much Mrs Victoria Olga
@@feggcraig1600 Same here, i started with $5,000 now earning $16,200 biweekly profits with her trading platform
VENTURING into the trading world without the help of a PROFESSIONAL, trader and expecting profit is like turning water into wine you would need a miracle, that's why i trade with Mrs. Victoria Olga, her skills set exceptional
Same here, i started with $5,000 now earning $16,200 biweekly profits with her trading platform
VENTURING into the trading world without the help of a PROFESSIONAL, trader and expecting profit is like turning water into wine you would need a miracle, that's why i trade with Mrs. Victoria Olga, her skills set exceptional
Hello, I'm new to Bitcoin trading and I've been making losses but recently I see a lot of people earning from it. Please can someone tell me what to do and the rightful Bitcoin Expert Trader I can manage with for some week trading?
How can someone know a professional Acct Manager that is trustworthy and legit they are hard to find this period?
In my view Gadkari is the best union minister at present. Not only does he do his job well, he takes everyone including the opposition along with him. Our Nation needs such leaders. Hope he will be our next PM.
4:06 u do know that the conversion of electrical energy into chemical energy (H) through is very inefficient
And at the end the energy loss using hydrogen cells at the end is a loss of more than 50% of energy
Hence unless the efficiency is increased its just wastage of resources
India doesn't have enough capital to establish a hydrogen supply chain
A hydrogen station costs 100-200x more than a ev charging station
Electric vehicles have minimum efficiency of 80% and max of 95%
While in case of hydrogen vehicles it's min of 30% to max of 40%
P S i do believe hydrogen has a place in our world but unless there's a few break throughs for increasing efficiency in EVT(energy vector transmission){the T can wrong i don't remember what was it}
Tell me one great invention that reach worldwide from india for the past 50 years. You are expection too much from indians lmao. The gap between rich and poor is becoming larger day by day and these idiots are too dumb to realise and instead they will chant "proud to indian" for no absolute reason. They even choose a tea seller to be their pm. I mean is there anyone who is more educated like at least graduated in political related? India has a nickname btw "millions of idiots in billion" which is true. China has almost the same population as india but is 7 times richer than india
I am also having same opinion. Instead of generation of Hydrogen by using electricity by loosing its efficiency....why cant we use electric vehicles directly?
@@Ravi-ur6iq the issue with EVs is the batteries-raw material, production, limitations by weight and size of battery etc
While the issue with HVs is efficiency of conversion of energy- hydrolysis (60-70% efficiency), transportation loss(15-20% loss)
High cost of infrastructure etc
Both have their plus and minus points
@@wokenessaplague5387 We can store the surplus renewable energy in hydrogen which is far more cost effective.
@@navaneeth1087 sigh
1 it's not cost effective u have a min loss of 50% energy i don't understand why u think it's a good think
Second do mention which storage process u r refering to specifically
Q) why there is gas stations for hydrogen rather than a pre filled gas tank that can be inserted in car? (The gas tank which is setup in various location in a city does not work on full capacity as there is extremely less number of car that are filled in night (so the gas station has less than half productivity which increase the amount the consumer has to pay), so instead of this if we had a gas plant in every city which can fill insertable gas tank (which can be inserted in vehicles)and the insertable tank was made available to various parts of cities then it may reduce cost ]- but as we know this is not right, but why?
Removing and inserting high pressure tanks is not trivial at all. There are heavy and require skill to fix properly. Fitting and removing the cylinders frequently is a hazard and will most likely cause leaks.
@@rover9488 because LPG is mostly liquid, the pressure inside the cylinder is only a few bars. Thus the storage tank can be light weight and transported easily. Whereas CNG (mostly methane) is a pure gas and has to be compressed up to 250 bars. Hydrogen is compressed at even higher pressure, otherwise the tank required will be very big. So it is a safety risk to have high pressure removable tanks.
It's amazing how a little political will can have such massive consequences.
You haven't addressed all the power losses inherent in the conversion to hydrogen, also battery technology is on an unstoppable pace, it makes more sense to convert solar and wind energy directly into electricity and just use the electricity, also it takes 9kg of water to make 1kg of hydrogen, in a world where clean water is quite limited this seems foolish. You could use desalination but that is costly and produces its own waste. I'd hate to see a hydrogen vehicle catch fire, anybody remember the hindenberg?
This project should be accelerated and should be given priority. I think Modiji can achieve it as quick as possible.
Ganesh, production quality has improved multifold. Congratulations on that!
Thank you :)
one thing i like about your videos is that you make me optimistic that there are immense business oppurtunities right now in the market and motivate me to work
This is absolutely awesome video and information. 👍👍👍🙏🙏
Keep bringing such a valuable information with futuristic solutions to current burning problems in India.
I am pretty negative minded and will only believe this is more than just a stunt when they deliver on something... Seen many projects starting and just becoming a way of funding for something else.
Hydrogen it self, Is Not yet the feasible for Commercial Ppl to Invest.
So wont last untill gov runs outaa funds
Thanks for the amazing content...I really was amazed how you explained problems with EV and combined them with advantages of HY.
Now this is called development for future 👏 🙌
Top notch quality💯. Great knowledge, thanks for your work to give us such good videos✨
Wat happened to the 100 smart cities? What happened to tesla manufacturing in India? What happened to ganga action plan? Only jumla happening in this country for last 8 years
Nithin Gadkari ji upna next Raasstrapathi banna PM Modi ji ki double support banjaathaa,
Then India will be stronger than ever.