So... Which Mob Should You Vote For?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 лип 2024
- Minecon 2023's mob vote includes the Crab, the Armadillo and the Penguin. But which mob has the best case for getting into the game?
▶Patreon: / simply_sarc
▶Twitter: / simplysarc
▶I use royalty-free music from Epidemic Sound. Sign-up to get 30 days free and a 10% discount on your first 12 months: www.epidemicsound.com/referra...
(This is an affiliate link. I may earn a small commission on sign-ups) - Ігри
Why is it only the wolves that get fancy armor? Sometimes, all a guy wants is to have a flying battle cockatiel that will vanquish his foes at his command.
I love this comment. So fantastical
Exactly. This is why7 I will vote Crab. Best use overall and the possibilities are kinda endless depending on how devs choose to implement even if it's simply a few block extra reach it's so much more groundbreaking than stupid Dₒg ₐᵣₘₒᵣ
@@GhostlyFilm Well it could be just a one block reach and only for placing which would be kinda useless as you can just, walk a block forward.
So true bill cipher
@@SuperDestroyerFox Ths same way, wolf armor could be leather level. With needing a scale of armadillo, I hardly see how you could fuse it with diamonds or whatever. Plus, at least for me, they should just make wolves regenerate heals naturally, maybe not fast but enough so that it doesn't die every 5 minutes. On the other hand, extended grip is truly useful, cause in many cases you are not able to just move a block on the side, which I know sounds stupid, but how many time have you tried to cut a birch tree and had to build up to get this last wood? If we want to talk about penguins, their addition would be nice, only if we get a brand new type of boat, like a big one, in which case I'm all for it, but rn, it's quite useless.
He came back just to comment on the new mobs. My man.
It’s really odd that they’d put the crab, an animal typically associated with beaches and oceans, exclusively in the mangrove swamp. In real life crabs can of course be found in coastal mangrove swamps, but why not put them in beaches and oceans too? They’d be great ambience. Honestly Minecraft’s beaches could use some sprucing up anyways. Give them some rocky crags and tidepools and palm trees
I have a suggestion, they can add the variant with the claw thing spawn exclusively in the mangrove swamps while having normal variants spawn on beaches and oceans and just make them edible or something.
I think its weird as well that they put penguins only on stone shores and not in like ice spikes or frozen oceans.
Yeah. I mean certain species of penguins can be found on stone shores but I usually associate that with Puffins. @@reid5389
I think it's supposed to be a mud crab, they are found in swamps
I think they meant something like a Blue land crab or smth but just said CRAB
It is crazy that the mob vote is not a community idea based vote. It would solve like all of these problems. Let the mojang team pick out some of the best ideas and then the community votes on the one they like most. No "only one of these mobs can come to the game" just fun, and if your vote doesnt win, you can probably bump the idea again next year.
This person has the right idea!
Nah mojang have to be very selective about what they put in the game, this would just make more problems
To be fair, they do claim that eventually all the options from the (recent) votes will be added. Not that they’ve even begun to do so, but still
Genius idea
@@kikivoorburg That is only for the biome votes, not the mob votes.
We need to know more about penguins.
Do they speed boats up when they are a passenger or just when they are nearby?
If they are a passenger, will they hop out and paddle behind the boat like an outboard motor?
Will this effect stack with ice?
Penguins could be revolutionary for travel if they work this way.
Crab is the only mob that has no huge mysteries associated with its feature.
Nobody knows what the dog armor would actually do- Would it only raise defense? Would it change the dog ai in any way? Is it customizable or will it only be an ugly brown shell?
Nobody knows how the penguin speed increase would function- Does it work when the penguin is in the passenger seat or only when it's swimming near the boat?
With the crab the only two unknown factors are how long the reach will be (even a one block of range will be a 33% increase from normal survival reach) and if it'll need to be equipped in the offhand slot to work (most likely the case).
@@FineUser yeah.
I really hope the two losing mobs get carried over to next year's vote
Who doesn't place blocks in Minecraft? Everyone will be able to enjoy the reach increase ^^
Great video Sarc, you should do more like this one! Not every video needs to be a giant amount of work!
Ong
apoco si tilin
crabego
Cheers buddy :)
@@SimplySarc
But the problem is, just how far will the extended reach be?
Mojang didn't explain that and thats one of my reasons why I'm not voting the crab.
If its just a 1 block extended reach, then its not worth it.
I feel like they made the penguin useless on purpose, just to have a big fight between the other two
I mean that's kinda how a lot of the mob votes turn out in general
The infamous one was basically just Chillager vs Glow Squid, you could argue that was more a case where instead of one thing being useless it was two, but in fairness to the Glow Squid I think a lot of folks who voted for it were optimistic something cool could've been done with it, and Mojang just did the usual Mojang thing and proceeded to drop the ball and disgustingly underutilize the Glow Ink Sacs, whereas the Moobloom had a 0% chance of doing anything noteworthy
Then there was the one where the Allay won, where it was a toss up between it and Copper Golems and the eye bush was just kinda there, but at least the Allay's concept is hard to screw up so it turn out to be fine for a win
And of course there's the one the Sniffer won and kinda did end up being a case of "2 useless, 1 cool" again, and somehow Mojang once again dropped the ball when it came to actually implementing Sniffers
It really feels like Mojang just deliberately does some of these mob vote winners so half-baked so the modders in the community have an excuse to try building upon them, but that's definitely more on the side of "personal conspiracy that only just makes myself mad at something that's probably not actually be true"
@@WhimsicottFanatic
Extremely L opinion.
"and Mojang just did the usual Mojang thing and proceeded to drop the ball and disgustingly underutilize the Glow Ink Sacs"
Average Mojang hater pessimist 'mojang always messes everything up' when glow ink sacs are extremely useful for building. I love seeing the item frames and sign text pop
"the one the Sniffer won and kinda did end up being a case of "2 useless, 1 cool" again,"
The Rascal would have been very fun to play with and the tuff golem would have livened up bases a lot while providing a more minecrafty item pedestal.
No they didnt. They just lack the ambition and imagination to come up with truly useful mobs or coherent design choices. Everything is just half-assed so might aswell bet on the crab.
@@111Maleficwho hurt u
Shouldn't even be a competition.
What really confuses is me is that they didn't put the crab on the beaches, or at least some variant of them, and use it as an excuse to make sand layers (like snow layers!). The crab is exclusive to such a rare biome, and our beaches are so desolate and 2009-looking!
I think I'm team crab. But I would also love armadillo (why lock a decade-overdue feature to make my buddy stronger/more safe behind a vote, though..). Penguin, however, would just be another panda or dolphin.. a fairly cute ambience mob with a mechanic I'll never really mean to use but will be exploited by some minecraft wizards by locking the mob in some boxes along their super-iceway.
The claw is supposed to be rare
@@Kattenb then make it drop less... that doesn't mean that the crab has to be rare
@@kodachromic you dont get the claw from killing the crab,
The penguin is cute and all but I feel like the crab’s longer reach seems much more useful unlike the gimmick faster boats would be if implemented.
Create Mod
@@Mark6O9ok? this is vanilla we're talking about, You could have a mod that gives 200 block reach, or makes wolves immortal, or makes boats travel hundreds of blocks per second. Modding isn't something you should bring up...
Dog armor is hands down better: we’ve been asking for that for years and almost everyone has a dog
Nah Armadillo for the win
@@sharkt9877 Wolves are useless, they deal low damage, die fast and have really dumb AI, at least cats are useful when sat for dealing with creepers, dogs just exist do be tamed and forgotten, armor wont make them immortal, they'll just die a little slower
Wouldn't the penguin boat speed buff, make boat on ice even faster, for more faster travel within nether hubs?
OOOOH you got a point there
I would assume it will work like thr dolphins and they will have to swim next to thr boat. And you cant have water in the nether so....
Not as useful as crabs still.
It'll probably work like dolphins, so no
They presumably would need water, so they wouldn't work in the Nether. And a status effect like Dolphin's Grace makes no sense in the context of a boat
With how focused all three are on aesthetics, I wish they'd just do all three of them. My other grievance with the Claw, is that it takes up yet another inventory spot, and when inventory management is already an issue, it's hard to justify for anything other than bringing the zone to life. The sad part is all three of this zones could use more life and could really benefit from the mobs being added.
i hope the armadillo armour isnt just like giving the dog more defence, but also allows the dog to curl up like an armadillo when in danger on low health to become invincible or near-invincible. plus it would be adorable.
regarding dog breeds: i rarely armor my horse because it covers up the pattern, and would likely do the same with my dog if armor and breeds were both introduced.
lmao you are talking about mojang, its gonna be just defense
Don't get your hopes up, the Mojang employees working 30 minutes per day won't be able to make that
I would really stay away from speculation. If Mojang doesn't say it, it's probably not coming.
After every past mob vote, I wouldn’t speculate, especially with what happened with the Glow squid ( OmG aCtUaLlY gLoWs ) and the sniffer ( NeW fRuIT )
We can speculate, but we must not let it affect our vote.
We all thought "What if" with the sniffer, but it turns out the goblin guy would've been better in the end, all because we made massive assumptions on what it would do.
Based on what we know, the wolf armour will protect the wolf, that's it.
The crab however, is guaranteed to extend reach, and you can guarantee it'll be at least 1 block, which is huge.
If there's horse armour then there can also be dog armour. Also you can heal them with meat, like how you can heal horses with apples and stuff.
I have never used horse armour, so why would i use wolf armour?
typically your horse isn't the target for combat, but your wolf is if you utilize it. I think armor would be a good way to revamp the feature as right now wolves are too squishy to be as useful, which is why they're often left at home.
@@dragofire202
@@dragofire202 It looks cool. Um, I guess just that extra bit of defense. The one main thing the I think Sarc missed was that Wolves are like the only tameable mob in Minecraft that you might use for hunting and fighting. It makes a lot of sense that you'd want to give them armor if you're using them for that reason.
I still think that this use case is kinda niche and that crab claws would probably be better in general. but wolf armor could be pretty cool.
Up Next: Doggy Saddles, to ride your great wolf into battle. XD
Up Next Up Next: Doggy Chests, to let your dog carry items.
@@dragofire202 wolves are for fighting, therefore them taking damage is uncommon. this will also decrease the chance of a creeper accidentally blowing your dog up, which has less health than horses.
Crab may be the rational decision but my love for penguins cannot be underestimated 🐧
I hope you lose
Valid point
Look at my username
Ah a fellow penguin lover
theyre just dolphins though
I love how the title is "Which mob should you vote for?" and then the video chapters are "Intro" "Crab" "Conclusion".
I think I’ll be voting for the crab, but i seriously wish all these mobs would be added! there is hope considering the swamp ended up getting updated eventually despite losing to the taiga in the biome vote.
But with the biome vote they SPECIFICALLY SAID all of them would be added, the vote determined order. But they haven't said that for any mob votes. Also they still haven't added the badlands update
People always say "i wish the three mobs were added" do you not understand the concept of making a decision or...?
Armadillo is better since we will see it more often, as the mangrove forest is rare
How many times did you see a frog, it's so rare because it only spawns in mangrove
@@111Malefic i think it's because people expect more than one single mob each _year_ from mojang
Simply Sarc Returns
Simply Sarc 429: Simply Sarc Returns
Yesir
Then dips for another year
"Somehow, he returned"
@@SimplySarcyou are dumb to say „why does a wild animal they need armor when a fucking magical being like an Ally can regenerate“ or are you ret4rded?
You should start uploading more often, I love your videos. Keep up the good work ❤
I SCREAMED WHEN I GOT THE NOTIF HES BAAAACK
honestly in the case of the wolf, its a case of classic features being grandfathered in. you can still regen their health by feeding them, but they take damage so often it's not enough to save them in active combat. the armor has been something ive seen suggested for forever now, and if this is how we get easier to use wolves im all for it.
Wolf Armor has been a suggestion since 2013. Its dumb that its locked behind a mob vote.
I mean ive never lost a dog to mobs, a majority of my dogs die from fall damage or lava. Their ai sucks and in my case they arent even worth taking into combat.
I love that Sarc just came back after a year with no explanation
The crab has functionality that will be used regardless of time spent on a world and is helpful in almost every situation
The armadillo is only helpful if you use wolves in combat, especially multiple
The penguin is only helpful if you're on a boat, and the effect most likely doesn't last, much like Dolphin's Grace
The crab is by far the best option, due to it being the only one that is designed for the longevity of this game
Not jus in combat, the reason people leave wolves at home is because its to dangerous for them to travel with them but with armor that changes.
The crab will not be used in 99% of worlds it. Spawns in the mangrove swamp and can give you 1-2 blocks reach its gonna be a mob that's cool to come across but gets no use.
one cool thing the penguin might to is add speed boosts to ice boat races? I think that could be fun but idk if it would work like that
@@AaZone. Apparently only 1% of minecraft players build.
Not really for combat more for keeping the wolves alive
All roads eventually lead down to...
Crab
Definitely has my vote :) it's the most useful and versatile
If nothing else, I'm glad that each mob actually appears to have some interesting use case that isn't just "isn't that the same as [already implemented debug tool/mechanic]?"
penguin = dolphin
Yeah but let’s be real the penguin and armadillo don’t have any actual uses aside from looking nice.
only one of them is useful from a datapack maker's perspective... it's the one that brings an extended reach attribute
@@nuklearboysymbiotefinally, some datapack makers
You mean like how the crab claw is literally just scaffolding but with extra steps?
I think it would be cool for there to be an item that makes a wolf protect a certain area. Like a bone that when placed, the wolf will stay near it and kill any surrounding mobs.
That's actually genius! Having guard wolves for your base would be super cool.
That’s what foxes are😭
@@valentai_777 Foxes are constrained to a lead and are very limited. Plus, even if foxes could do that, having an extra use for wolves would still be good.
The crab claw looks functions very similar to the extendo grip from create. At least on paper, however i do feel like its the best option as having an extended reach is always useful.
I really dont think the armadillo armor is worth it as i never actively played with dogs, they are just way to jank, also they die way to easy, which the armor could solve, but im unsure how much protection it really gives, its also just one level of armor unlike horse armor which comes in 4 different variations and protection ammounts.
The Penguin might be the second best option, especially when going on an ocean raiding spree, like ruins for sherds, monuments for sponges etc. -However it would be much much better if the would give us fins or flippers to move faster underwater, and not just boat fins, but from past mob votes we really cant expect any more than what is shown or said in the videos.- penguins are just dolphins for your boat, so no way we are getting fins.
This is pretty much how I've been looking at it wolf armor is just going to be a novelty item I mean how many people actually use wolves for combat
@@theapocalypticfish i think youre thinking almost too practically, taking a wolf anywhere is dangerous and we all know how attached people get to their pets. extended reach isnt that big a deal for the most applicable thing for the large majority of players, but wolf armour allows more enjoyment to be had with some of the older features. (+ the armadillo helps the savanna biome which is REALLY lacking)
@@Warm_n_Crowzy oh I agree the Savannah is definitely lacking in some apartments and I do hope the next biome that gets updated similarly to How The Mangrove swamp was a failed biome vote I hope we get that one Savannah update eventually.
Extended block placement reach*
Theres no overall longer reach confirmed, only further block placing, dont assume anything in mob votes
I do agree on the Crab. Most of us just leave our dogs in our homes for adventures, and dolpins exist
but often times we leave them at home because they're too squishy to take on adventures. Armor would help solve that problem and get Mojang's eyes back on wolves as a mechanic, which will hopefully prompt more features for them.
Yes, Crab seems to be the most useful option. It definitely has my vote :)
not if u accidentally hit your own wolves with your sharpness 5 sweeping edge 3 knockback 2 fire aspect. they'd never make dog armour survive that, and unless they improve the AI a lot (and i mean a lot) or implement friendly fire prevention without needing commands, or some other way to prevent player stupidity (impossible), wolf armour changes nothing. whereas they've never let the player's reach change while in-game before, and this could be very useful for command block players especially, and a completely new survival mechanic as well! armour for mobs is nothing new and neither is fast water travel. @@darkwraithraziel6362
@@darkwraithraziel6362 Even if they're not squishy I won't take my dogs on an adventure, they're just not worth the effort. There's no mob dangerous enough to warrant the help of a dog, no matter how tanky it is.
And its not like they'd say that we will be able to enchant the armour or how powerful will be
I really hope that the armadillo wins and I know its not that "cool" or "usefull" but I have waited for dog armor over 7 years so yeah...
the crab is the best option and it's not even close. Being able to build even one block further away is exponentially more useful than anything else they've added in a long time. Plus it's cute
Hard pass. Enjoy your OPINION though! 😝
Fact
Agreed. +Crab Rave
totally agree
Yes team crab
I also think the crab is the most useful. Dog armor will probably be like horse armor (no one uses it). The penguin is cool too, but only if it gives the boat a speed boost while its sitting in it. If its just like the dolphin and gives the boost when its swimming near you, its kinda pointless.
(Sorry for my bad english)
Does it move boats faster when its swimming near you or do you need to tame it and put it on the boat.
@@melvacaoyona-ollosa278 We currently don't know, but honestly all the options I can think about just suck and will be a pain to use lol.
I always use horse armor?? Do people not use horses?
@@KattenbIf there’s a skeleton horse around, might put a saddle on and trap it somewhere only to forget it exists, but as for regular horses, they’re just another source of leather
Do yall not use horses?
I think wolf armor would be really strong since then you could actually use it in combat instead of it being a gimick
Until it hurls itself off a cliff or runs into a creepers blast. Who even uses wolves for combat, everyone just leaves them at home
@@razzledazzle1662 excaclty that's why wolf armor should be a thing so they don't die the moment a creeper see them
@FallguysWolfZ then they would still die from a single creeper blast
@ftimexp armor doesn't protect against fall damage and dogs push each other around when following you, like off cliffs. Of what use is a single dog in combat, more of a hindrance than help. Waste of time
Even if it quadrupled their HP I wouldn't use wolves in combat, there's just no need and it's tedious to care for them.
Wow back after over a year, wasnt expecting this sarc. nice video.
The crab claw already exists in a mod called the create mod (Extendo-grip) and you hold it in the off hand. It's not clunky at all
That's why we need the crab! 🦀
I agree and when I did the math in the worst case scenario the crab added one block of reach.
vertical down would be 33% faster
horizontally would be 25% faster
of course worst case scenario and that is also not considering needing to reset and re position your self for the next layer.
when I tested it in game for a 29 block long 4 block high wall
3 reach top down was 35 seconds
4 reach from the side was 25 seconds
this ends up around 40% faster which does seem to add up because of reseting wasting about a second. still should have tested it with a mod.
I think they would double reach which obviously is at minimum twice as fast.
if you don't count down time.
I admire your math bro
@@jopiluis3382 yeah I already had the math prepared after someone said it wouldnt save that much time, well depending on the situation 25% is HUGE, and I think it will be better than a single block of added reach so a lot of people are under estimating the potential of the extended reach. though I do think they should just add Dog armor anyway that is not something that should be in a mob vote, same for extended reach that is important enough and obvious enough no sane person would make you vote for that. I do believe they are very likely to add dog armor however I am not sure if they will ever offer extended reach again they rarely do stuff like this for building. I wouldnt be surprised if they are adding a full armor set for dogs this update, why just add one, at least that is my hope.
THE LEGEND. HE'S BACK! I missed you videos Sarc! Really enjoy them. Also the ones you made earlier in your yt career. Really fun and inspiring to watch. Hope you make more soon. When u have time ofc. :)
4:10 "a lot of people would rather see things like dog breeds or variations in the skin"
this aged well
Lets assume for a moment that any mob we vote for will flop in implementation, because that seems to happen more often than not. I think the penguin is the better ambient choice, though I hope they make them spawn on icebergs too.
A good dev team would just add all of them.
I hope the crab claws reach is NBT, if I can see a pop more uses for dynamic then a static reach
YES i am thinking the exact same. maybe an attribute
Probably won't be useful in pvp but still
Your back, loved your content so much and happy your back for at least a short period 😁
Armadillos here in Texas are notorious for destroying gardens and flowerbeds (I personally struggle with them) I also shoot them whenever I see them. 30% of armadillos carry leprosy which killed millions of people. Wolves sit in our houses for the duration of our worlds, teleport to us then we knock ‘em into lava or into a ravine or they drown. Extra reach that the crab provides will benefit the community the most. We all build. If you vote for the armadillo, you will REGRET it, as armor will not make wolves any less useless.
True
When the world needed him most, he came back.
I really hope the crab wins, because armor for dogs and faster boats is usefull, but longer block reach can be good in literally any scenario, even in multiplayer mc
I understand your point but 1 or 2 blocks is not really worth voting for the whole mob
@@slimeprincegamer8482 kinda is ngl
"Everyone's going to hate each other for 5 minutes" - Sarc, said while still holding 3 year old grudge about glow squid!
Can we talk about Mojang's interpretation of baby penguins? Baby Penguins look very different from adult penguins, they fluffier and chubbier and most importantly they _can't swim._ Yet here Mojang is saying "hey look at this cute baby penguin" swimming around with poofy eyebrows just like the adults.
It's almost as if every single baby mob in the game looks identical to the parent except smaller and isn't trying to be a realistic representation.
@@leetri that may change once the experts chime in, just like potery shards are now named sherds.
@@leetri The reason I bring it up is because Mojang is obsessed with animal "realism" in Minecraft for some reason. Or at least a twisted view of it...
Ice highways with penguins could be game changing
I would like to kindly ask everyone to vote my friends into the game.
Not suspicious at all
Yes
sus
Crab is the best! Most useful of all 3 too! Plus we need crustacean representation in the game!
Yes sir 🦀🦀🦀🦀
The idea of having a dog having just a tiny bit of protection and just have something to put your dogs on is a really cool idea, it doesn’t necessarily have to be super useful to be fun, you sometimes just want your dog to look good
They better let us dye it though
Here’s my line of thinking:
1. Crab: Gameplay wise, it lets me place items further away, but I’ll loose an inventory slot and don’t usually struggle with this. I can already use command codes to place items further away if I want to.
2. Armadillo: I’d need to farm them, but my dogs would be stronger and not take up inventory space. Probably makes gameplay/combat easier. They’re easy to breed though..
3. Penguin: Idk, I’d sail past them, see them sitting around, and not think about them again? They’ve already added a few methods to collect items, but I haven’t hound them particularly accessible.
Ill vote for the Crab
tho i do think the crab claw is interesting i do wonder how will durability work on it ?
would it be by block placed with it ?
would it have no durability ? Essentially infinite uses, but what will we do with the overamount of crab claws we have left then ?
If we farm this what else can a crab claw do ? can it be placed ?
IF i say IF, its purpose extend to "Interactable block distance" instead of just "Block placement distance" it would have a new use in a lot of domains and playerbase:
- PvP/PvE, if you trade it against a shield(defense) or a totem(support) in the offhand slot while having a sword/axe in the other, it could let you hit opponent a bit too much out of reach, Maybe it could even affect something people dont think about but the throwing arc of pearls could be affected if its a much more powerful hand.
- Builders/Miners, thats what been shown but not the destructive part ! Having a bigger hand reach could let us place beds much farther in Netherite mining, or even have more efficient mining tunnels (remember that being farther away from a block grants you a bigger mining speed than close up)
- Redstone, for those pesky stuff you forgot to add and are just a bit out of reach to replace/place
IF the crab claw has other uses in idea, i could see it be a trophy item you can put on the ground, wall and ceiling. It would make it so that its a new block shape people can have fun with but also ... trigger it like a bear trap.
This would make "Minecraft" way of making bear traps that traps opponents down on a block, other idea i had is that it could also be used in redstone as traps, yes but also a grabbing hand in contraptions, grab items and mobs like a claw catcher and release it when powered.
I don’t think I’ll really care a lot who wins this one but I feel like everyone who votes armadillo for the sake of wolf armour will never take advantage of it because they’re also the type of people to never let their wolves leave their houses.
Ikr. Heck, for me, even if i want my dog near me when traveling, I'd always lose it. Like, it just wouldn't teleport back to me. Just go get a texture pack for your dog.
FR
Armadillo is the cutest tho😌
WONDER WHY THEY DON'T TAKE OUT WOLVES OUT OF THEIR HOMES... HMMMMMMMM LET ME THINK
This take you just made is so brain dead and legit explains itself
One problem I have with the crab is that its value as a mob hinges entirely on how good the crab claw ends up being, and since it spawns in such a rare biome, it doesn’t really have much else to offer. At the end of the day, when you vote for the crab, you're voting for an item, and if the item isn’t as good as we hoped, then we’ve all made the wrong decision yet again. As we’ve been shown in the past, we can’t always trust Mojang to make our dreams come true (no disrespect to the amazing employees at Mojang). Personally, I’ll be voting for the armadillo, as army buildings with dogs sounds like a very interesting idea to me, and let’s face it, Mojang will never add dog breeds unless they make a dog update, but I can only speak for myself. If you really would do anything to place blocks a little further, then I'd go for the crab too, but I’ll stick with the armadillo for now.
The reason I'm voting for the crab is that once you get an elytra boats are obsolete. Not everyone has a wolf, and some who do don't take them on adventures, they just keep them safe at home. But everyone places blocks, all of the time. Weather you're building a starter house, mega base, caving, exploring the nether, fighting the ender dragon or fighting other players we all place blocks. Crabs extend your block placing reach so they are the most useful. That's why I'm voting for the crab
you know it's a good day
when simplysarc uploads
Haven't had a good day since last year then
you mean a good century😂
@@Spacey_64 LMAO FR
"Global Depression mysteriously evaporated tonight, scientists are still unsure why. More at 10"
Hasn't been a single day confirmed to be good for over 365 days
The crab seems marginally useful for building. The other ones are pretty useless and will just be another ambient mob that sells plushies like 90% of new mobs. It would probably take them a month max to add all 3 but of course they would never do that.
I personally think they should add two different types of crabs, similar to what they did with the frogs, where the Mud Crabs spawn in Mangrove swamps, but then your average ocean crab spawns on Beaches
Great to see you again, Sarc!!!
He's back!!
Armadillo is a neat idea solved by mods years ago, but if it could lead us closer to a wolf update that would be amazing. Foxes can already hold weapons, what if wolves could "fetch" and use wooden items. All Fromsoftware fans want their own sword wielding dog.
*great grey wolf sif's theme playing*
mob votes never lead to updates
They should add fangs we can put onto our dogs instead of regular weapons, so we can add some more unique enchantments like the did with the trident, like cripple for slowing down mobs or poison fangs, of course it should have some regular enchantments like sharpness and mending.
A cool mechanic for dogs would be that if you give them a bone it sharpens their teeth and they do more damage
Just as always, we dont have enough information.
Crab: -how do we get the claw?
-how many blocks does it extend?
-does it have durability
-how do we activate its effect?
Armadillo: -how good is the armour?
-can we trim the armor?
-do we also fix the dogs' trash AI when we add this? (Or give them an additional use?)
Penguin: -can we just shove one in the back of our boat to basically have a permanent speed boat???
Just like every other year there are way too many variables to decides which one is the best choice, they really need to start doing AMA's about these mob votesso we can actually know WHAT we are voting for!
Welcome back! I miss your videos, they're amazing!
I think I’m going crab, but I wouldn’t mind the armadillo. I hope you can breed them, I want to create an army of crabs
I’m voting for the crab for sure. I hope that the crab claw is a potion ingredient though, I think it might be annoying to manage an additional thing you have to hold or whatever.
Adding a new potion would be sick!
Unlike sailing on a boat or needing to protect your wolves, placing blocks is a basic and fundamental mechanic of Minecraft, it’s something everyone does all the time, so anything that improves this is really useful.
But, that's basically it. Crab claws are only useful for survival, but wolf armour is useful for both creative and survival players.
Crab's ability is basically wasting offhand slot to reach probably like 1 block further, won't be better bacause of balance reasons.
Wolves had no update since almost a decade, this is our only chance to give doggos some love ❤
3:58 they do, it's called feeding them
Won't help against lava, holes or creepers
@@justaemptymall neither would the armor, really
Im torn between the crab and the armadillo, im kinda leaning towards the crab since its just plain cuter
Good choice :) And you also don't have to feel bad as it offers more usage than the armadillo.
Enjoy your OPINION. May the best mob win. 🤪
Something I've been wondering since the idea of wolf armor can be a thing, I wonder if said armor will have its own unique enchants to it. Maybe an enchant giving the dog regen when it assist in killing a mob, or maybe another enchant so that when taking fatal damage it'll instead teleport to your last spawn point and will sit there so it won't teleport to you. The dog will still be at 1 HP but hey, its far from harm at least should be.
h o r s e
a r m o r
Great to see a vid again
the crab will be as useful as the the rabbit feet making you jump higher that is already in the game. the other way that it could work is taking up an inventory slot and i don't know about you but for the past many years people have not been wishing for less inventory space when building or doing anything for that matter
Rabbit feet don't increase jump height at all though? Their use is to MAKE jump boost potions, they don't do anything by themselves
sherlock@@thevortexcrafter7060
I feel like being able to craft armor for your dog makes the most sense, horse armor already exists and you can craft the leather variant, so why not a leather wolf armor? Perhaps you could find the gold, iron, and diamond versions from dungeons the same as horse armor. Or it's sold by exclusively Taiga villagers or something.
I know wolf armour shouldn't be even be in a mob vote and mojang should just add it
they're made using the armadillo scutes, so i doubt they'll be able to be found in structures
Hopefully we will see his return to discuss about the trial chambers, or the auto crafter, or copper bulbs, maybe even the breeze or mystery key
Bro I literally found ur channel yesterday and i saw u haven’t uploaded in a year so this is quite a suprise
If we actually get armadillos, which seems like the best option (to me), I can finally get an army of wolves by my side that have extra defense.
That’ll make my survival world so much more fun!
The wolf armour won't age well. People will find it useless in a few years. Most people don't use wolves in combat like you
Crab 🦀❤
Most useful out of all three on the long run and for survival + CREATIVE
I think wolf armor has tons of validity to it. Even if they were given the ability to heal naturally, it would help them survive against groups of mobs, or especially creeper explosions
wolfs usually attack just the mob you attacked, and the mob will probably be trying to attack you so its not really common seeing a hostile mob attacking a wolf unless they stopped paying attention to you, the wolf will be more in danger because of creepers or your own sword swings, with the high damage a creeper explosion does its hard to survive, but at least gives more chance, but also we cant expect stuff like enchantments or armor variants, since we dont have that with turtle armor wich is also crafted with scute
Wolves run away from creepers anyway and mobs rarely attack them
@@unluckybean2800 Many mobs will change targets if something else attacks them. It would be nice to just let it do its thing without having to assist it with every kill. You could just command it to attack a zombie while you handle another mob, and know that the wolf will likely survive
All of these mobs should be added without the vote.
In my opinion they are too unsignificant to be put in a mob vote, and the worst thing is, that the two mobs that will lose the vote probably won't be ever added to the game.
i miss your videos Sarc. Hope you'll be posting more about anything :D
if wolf armour is strong enough for wolves to survive more than a couple of nights (and make it so you cant hit them, like allays), than sure
but i think extended reach is really more useful, perhaps even as an item you have to hold, because you could use it to mine blocks on the ceiling of caves more easily
Its for BLOCK PLACEMENT
@Kattenb i know, but how would they even limit that? because the block outline appears on the block youre facing regardless of whether you're holding a tool or a block
Omg welcome back, i missed your videos. I personally would want the armadillo because that way wolves would be more useful in the later game and you actually take them on adventures and not have to worry as much about them dying to a mob, it also opens the possibilities for enchanted dog armor. I personally think having extra reach is a bit unnecessary cuz you got legs to move towards the block plus scaffolding which becomes useless if the claw is added, there's also the factor that we don't know how much of an extra reach we get.
Not a builder?
@@ChildishSoap id say the large majority of players in Minecraft aren't that proficient at building to the point where this would be actually useful. dog armour would make wolves more viable (for companionship, definitely not attack everyone just uses their own weapons bc like that's leagues better then some ai) making the world feel more complete and retrofitting a lowkey outdated mechanic to be useful. Basically, people like their dogs alive, no matter the skill level.
@@Warm_n_Crowzy eh just my opinion
I just kill my dogs if they're taking up space
I doubt the dog armor would protect them from when the launch themselves into lava or off a cliff as they always seem to love doing
@@Warm_n_Crowzy Most builders within minecraft simply use world edit in creative instead of playing vanilla survival anyway. I would know.
I tend to look at Minecraft through the view of a late-game player, in which case the only mob that isn't next to useless is the crab.
Even when trying to emphasize with people in early game, I simply cannot see how a slight boat speed buff or armor to protect a mob that doesn't need protecting is anywhere near as useful as the crab.
I hope that they are gonna bring back the 2nd most popular mob from each of the last 4 mob-votes next year!
Crab. God please crab.
I play modded, extended reach is a game changer please crab.
We don't need nether highways to be any faster, boo penguin.
Savannah is already getting updated in the future and dog armor really just doesn't matter.
Same! I also gonna vote crab :) most useful and versatile mob out of the three.
When the world needed him the most
The return of the king, the classic SimplySarc.
I feel like players would just not use the crab claw as much. You’d have to constantly equip it (if that’s how it will be used) and the reach/mobility of the player was already designed to be convenient. I could only see it being used to build long columns as building precisely from far away will require people to click on a small part of their screen. Plus, people usually just walk up to things when placing blocks not because they’re too far away, but because that’s what people are comfortable with. IMO, the mobs with the passive benefits are heavily underrated. People don’t usually mind dolphins until they encounter them and it helps them loot some ruins easily find some treasure. Penguins could give a similar experience. The potential for wolf armor seems heavily underestimated because people usually see them as cute pet dogs to keep inside a house instead of a hunting ally. Imagine you are out mining in a cave with a single pet cat and an armored wolf. Creepers and skeletons are scared away while zombies and spiders are distracted if they hit you and the wolf hits them.
I would love if penguins dropped an ITEM that made your boat move faster, like the other candidates. imo that would make it the best choice out of the 3.
I agree, but there’s no way Mojang would encourage people to kill penguins.
Hit reach and block reach are different in Minecraft, so an important factor with the crab will be how it affects combat as well
Probably won't do anything in that regard.
Its ONLY block placement
It doesn't affect pvp reach, 100%
placing walls to run away/hide from bow shots, crystals, tnt, tnt minecarts, lava/water buckets, cobwebs, list goes on...
@@xebrax124 yeah, because this happens all the time in my survival world...
3:45 Sarc means Axolotl
And like, thats part of what sets Axolotl aside from wolves, theyre not truly tameable, but regen and can dive
Similarly foxes arent remotely tameable, but can be given weapons and "armor"
Horses are basically just mounts, and armor fits the medieval aesthetic, as well as their hitbox being bigger and under yours gives a great reason to have armor
Cats are great for scaring creepers and phantoms away,
But dogs are basically combat only pets (in function) but are used almost exclusively as stationary decoration because of their relative fragility, giving them armor might see an increase in there presence when exploring or clearing mobs outside your base. The only time i see them ever is in hordes
Or at the very least help keep them alive in skeleton farms
I'ma make an aquarium, decorate it with seaweed and coral, put some crabs in there and make a Note Block system to play Under the Sea.
Nice idea ^^ crab all the way!
Well there is a mod for breeds/skins, but keeping that poor dog alive while it follows you everywhere is a nightmare. I agree, changing the dog and giving a better AI (Stay home vs just sit or follow), and a auto healing mechanic would be nice, but we have learned take what you can. Since I have scaffolding and dirt, I dont really need extra reach, and Blue ice works well with my boats, so I think the Armadillo is the best choice. Adding in the way the past mobs voted in have done nothing like we expected, Again, dog armor seems a really safe and useful option. Seriously if they were going to give us what we WANT it wouldnt be a mob, it would be slabs and stairs for concrete, Better lighting options, or (gasp for even the thought) an inventory upgrade. I mean who needs reach, we need a few more slots and better weapon/tool swap options. So after all my rambling I hope everyone joins me and votes for the little armadillo.
Yeah, everyone who keeps saying "people don't use wolves so why do we need wolf armor?" Are missing the point
For the armadillo they need a grey one for the Jungle and a brown one for Savannah
The crab’s feature could be used everywhere in minecraft, whereas the other 2 are very specific. I do think that we need wolf armor, or more pet armor in general, but when they said “armadillo scutes” I got extremely worried. If collecting armadillo scutes is as tedious and long of a process as getting turtle scutes, then there’s no way I’m voting for it. Or maybe it might just drop a scute as soon as you kill it, but we are talking about Mojang after all. I don’t really care much for penguins. They feel like a sequel to the dolphin, but instead of speedy swimming it’s speedy boating!! 😱😱 (Not to mention that we already have ice to make boats go faster)
With every mob vote I’ve always had the thought of why not just add all of them at the same time? It makes everyone happy and it sweeps away most of the toxicity from Minecraft’s name. I think Mojang has noticed how the vote divides the community, so now they’re adding mobs that are mediocre. They don’t affect gameplay all too much if they’re added so they won’t annoy players who didn’t want them, but at the same time made it so players won’t feel super upset that they’re missing out on a really cool feature with the mob that lost.
Agree.
Crab sweep! 🦀 Like King Bdogz said
The armadillo. It’s the most useful one out of all them since it gives wolves armor.
Welcome back! Realistically, I don't see myself using any of the functions of any of these mobs, so it comes down to:
1. Which one do I generally want more? (not functionally)
2. Which function has the most *niche* uses?
3. Which mob will we interact with most regularly?
4. Which one is most clear?
(1) I want the penguins most, cuz they're cutest. (2) Boats have the most niche uses, particularly in minigames, while the other two functions are limited more to specific types of people. In create mod, I never used the extended reach beyond my testing with it. (3) Armadillos are possibly most visible in warm biomes, penguins are likely quite visible on shores, and crabs are practically invisible and I'll almost never see them. (4) Penguins are the clearest, just because they're simplest. Crab has the most up in the air design wise, and could feel very clunky, while armadillos are super super specific in use and we don't know what the armor will look like.
Pengiuns get my vote!
i think it'd be interesting if the crab claw extends your range by 0.5 to 1 block for every one you have on the hotbar, so it's a tradeoff between hotbar slots and reach
Most people including crab voters are saying the crab's extended reach will be by one block, as a minecrafter who almost exclusively builds, I just don't see it being worth my vote and I most likely won't even bother to use it in creative mode either.
Just want to point out that wolves have had 6 gameplay changes over the 12 years they have been in the game. 4 of those 6 changes were adding another mob as its aggro target. Adding wolf armor wont fix the major issue in that wolves need a complete rework to be brought up to current quality standard.
Why is the previous video about AI private now?
A few reasons, but ultimately I just don't think people were really feeling it.
That's sad to read, my inconsequential condolences.
@@SimplySarc For the record, I enjoyed it!
I think that regardless if people are feeling it I do think it’s a topic that should be addressed prior to it being a major topic.
Screw the division. Screw the disappointments. Screw the useless new mobs each vote added. Screw the mob vote. Screw all of it.
#stopthemobvote
to think about it, its really good that extended reach could come as a beacon update instead of a kinda clanky item (although i did like the idea of makingpeople swap to something other than a totem or whatever in their hardcore haha)
crabs are pretty cool animals and will probably make it in some way or another anyways, maybe even a species native to beaches haha
Great to see you back again after a year!