As somebody that only has one pair of gyw boots, and doesn't plan on building up a collection, this is the best boot review I've found. When searching for good boots that will last a lifetime I went through several youtube channels, blogs, and subreddits, and every time I was left with an extremely ambiguous take on any one pair of boots. I watched Rose Anvil cut at least 50 boots in half and never give an honest objective review of a pair of boots. On the other hand I found a smaller youtuber that would just read the product page and a blog post then call it a review. Here you've gone over the facts about the boots, and given an objective review of the overall quality of the boots, educating viewers on boot structure in the process so that we know what to look for in a quality pair of boots. Fantastic video.
Which boot did you decide to purchase? And what is your recommendation for a heritage boot, as well as a moc toe boot? I'm looking for a moc toe with a low profile that works with slimmer fitting pants that can be used for light work?
Glad to have found your channel, thanks to aerosurferlv . Had this boot in the cart for the past few days, and your video really helps with details and facts. Top-notch content!
great review. i have a pair of grant stone brass boots in saddle tan with wedge soles. they're the perfect boot for someone who only wants to own one pair of all-purpose boots.
Thanks for the Goodyear welt explanation, first time I hear the split lip description. Grant stone should be my next everyday boots. Didn't had good durability out of Thursday boots, and they don't seems to care a lot for their larger feet customers.
Thanks for the review! You helped me decide what boot to buy. I chose this one. I’ve had them for a few days and, so far, they seem to be exactly what I was looking for. Thanks again!
Phenomenal review. I live your comprehensive opinions and ideas regarding their versatility in different potential environments, and how they can be styled. Since you consider this to be chunky, what is your best choice for a casual moc toe boot that can be worn with slimmer fitting clothing in urban environments, in addition to light-duty carpentry and diy?
@Bootlosophy you're probably right. Last question: which of the moc toe boot offered work best with slimmer fitting jeans? You mentioned RW moc to boots for being popular with that style, but do you consider them more appropriate than these brass boots for this application? Ty, bro
just got jungle kangaroo brass boot, only thing I don't like is how skinny the tongue is. I only have two different Thursday captains, and couple cheaper work boots, the grant stone is miles ahead of the others. This rabbit hole is going to cost some money..... Living in Seattle going to have to make the drive over to Spokane and check out Whites and Nicks ......
Hi, great informative video. I have ordered these this week after watching yours and other videos on this Grant Stone boot. I went for the natural waxy commander and took a chance on the sizing by going a full size down as most reviews seem to indicate lots of volume, I hope to receive them this weekend and hope they fit. All the best from the UK. PS the tannery ( C. F. Stead ) is around 40 miles away from Manchester where I live.
I’ve been watching you a while now and I have never seen you do a video on a pair of Ottawa’s by GS. I’ve seen the Edwards, Diesels, and Edwards. That leaves the Ottawa, Field boot, and the Cap toed boot. Are those not to your liking?
Hi Tek, great review. I have not been able to wear Red Wing 875 or Thorogood Mod Toes due to the relatively narrow and straight lasts of these boots. I remember you had an issue with the Thorogoods and had to move up in width. How was the comfort on the Brass Boot last? Do you feel going up to an E is advisable in this last? Thank you and keep up the good reviews!!
Boot newbie here.. I like boots.. mainly bcos dispite being thick, they do breathe rather well.. for this heavily waxed boot, does it breathe as well as other unwaxed leather? Thanx
Took me two years of contemplating buying chinese boots. Unfortunately im ashamed to say these boots are worth every penny. I bought two pairs of boots, a jk custom boot from the pacific north west and these. These fit me like a custom shoe, the jk had to be brokem in and it was pain ful. Both are great, the jks makes my feet feel more comfortable with them on then off after the pain went away, these are a little looser but comfortable, and you can also put a pair of orthotics in them to make them perfect.
Just bought a pair of these. They look and fit great. I’m noticing a little soreness on the bottom of my heels after a few wears. Did anyone else notice that? Did it go away? Thanks
@@Bootlosophy thanks. They look great so hopefully they’ll get more comfortable. They actually feel better today. Thanks for all the reviews! I may have more questions for you.
Trying to size mine, also went 1/2 down Brannock and my heel feels slightly loose. When you lift your toes up, where about on the boot do they sit? (I guess relative to the moc toe stitching)
Do you know if these run the same size as the Thursday diplomat? I have the diplomat in a 9d and it fits well and I’m guessing I should get these in a 9d as well? Thanks!
Thanks again Teik, Do you feel these fit the same as your diesels? I just purchased some diesels in 9.5E and they are fine but think I could have gone with a D and was wondering how you felt on the fit comparison of the two? My diesels are cxl and was thinking of this boot as next purchase and also wondered if you felt the CF Stead stretches as much as cxl?
@@Bootlosophy Thanks, I found the 875 a bit narrow there but a bit roomy in the heel and and toe. Might be a good fit for me. Did you get much more width after break in on the rw or still less than the brass?
@@Bootlosophy What about the Grant Stone Ottawa boot. Slightly different. Between the Parkhurst and the Grant Stone, which would you choose. Many thanks.
i bought the Brass boot in color 8. at first out of the box i loved them. seemed like a great deal at a high quality. but after owning them for several months I'm disappointed. There just isn't any place for them and they have become my least favorite boot and almost a pair I only wear so they are not wasted. They feel clunky without feeling robust. They are definitely not a work boot. Very easy break in period, but never really became comfortable. They really are not a business casual boot either. They seem to scuff ridiculously easy and don't really shine back up very easily. so after their original new condition they just don't look as dressy as I had expected. The color 8 seems to dim quickly and always seemed to look dirty. They are also really heavy on the feet, which would be fine if they were a robust work boot, but they are not. They have large lugs, but are too heavy to be a hiking boot. they have found a weird niche where they look like they would be well rounded and good for many uses but in reality are not good for any use. regret the purchase
As somebody that only has one pair of gyw boots, and doesn't plan on building up a collection, this is the best boot review I've found. When searching for good boots that will last a lifetime I went through several youtube channels, blogs, and subreddits, and every time I was left with an extremely ambiguous take on any one pair of boots. I watched Rose Anvil cut at least 50 boots in half and never give an honest objective review of a pair of boots. On the other hand I found a smaller youtuber that would just read the product page and a blog post then call it a review. Here you've gone over the facts about the boots, and given an objective review of the overall quality of the boots, educating viewers on boot structure in the process so that we know what to look for in a quality pair of boots.
Fantastic video.
Which boot did you decide to purchase? And what is your recommendation for a heritage boot, as well as a moc toe boot?
I'm looking for a moc toe with a low profile that works with slimmer fitting pants that can be used for light work?
Excellent, Grant Stone should pay you for this presentation.
Glad to have found your channel, thanks to aerosurferlv . Had this boot in the cart for the past few days, and your video really helps with details and facts. Top-notch content!
I love how you present information, you could be a teacher!!
That boot is absolutely gorgeous.
great review. i have a pair of grant stone brass boots in saddle tan with wedge soles. they're the perfect boot for someone who only wants to own one pair of all-purpose boots.
Thanks for the Goodyear welt explanation, first time I hear the split lip description. Grant stone should be my next everyday boots. Didn't had good durability out of Thursday boots, and they don't seems to care a lot for their larger feet customers.
Thanks for the review! You helped me decide what boot to buy. I chose this one. I’ve had them for a few days and, so far, they seem to be exactly what I was looking for. Thanks again!
You, good sir, deserve more subscribers! Your channel is excellent and very informative. 👍
Love this guy. Can watch and listen to him all day.
Why thank you sir!
I’ve ordered the Derby version of this boot, Leo last, same leather, same sole. All the benefits without the weight.👞👍😎
Absolutely in love with these things!!! Thanks for the inspiration Teik!!!!
Thank you!
excellent overview as usual , really enjoy your fair, informative and balanced reviews of different boots//troutbumandsam
Thank you very much!
Very nice boots indeed
Great review Teik! I've been considering my first pair of Moc toe boots for months. After seeing your review, my only decision is leather and color.
Your measured and thorough presentation made this very enjoyable to watch!
Excellent high quality review of the boot. Really enjoy your calm, smooth tone of your voice and knowledge! keep up the good job!
Superb review - thorough, informative, and comprehensive. You have a very pleasant presentation disposition as well. Wonderful job 👍🏻
Another great concise review teik! Cheers
they are really lovely boots, im sold. time to save up
Great looking casual or light-work boots! 👍
Superb presentation. Thanks for your excellent insights.
Just subscribed!
I love your content!
Love your videos! I look forward to seeing more of your reviews!
Phenomenal review. I live your comprehensive opinions and ideas regarding their versatility in different potential environments, and how they can be styled.
Since you consider this to be chunky, what is your best choice for a casual moc toe boot that can be worn with slimmer fitting clothing in urban environments, in addition to light-duty carpentry and diy?
I’m not sure there is one but if you think the Alden Indy would work (after all Harrison Ford was a carpenter) maybe that would do?
@Bootlosophy you're probably right. Last question: which of the moc toe boot offered work best with slimmer fitting jeans? You mentioned RW moc to boots for being popular with that style, but do you consider them more appropriate than these brass boots for this application? Ty, bro
@@NogGonnaMakeIt yeah, IMO they are better
just got jungle kangaroo brass boot, only thing I don't like is how skinny the tongue is. I only have two different Thursday captains, and couple cheaper work boots, the grant stone is miles ahead of the others. This rabbit hole is going to cost some money..... Living in Seattle going to have to make the drive over to Spokane and check out Whites and Nicks ......
The tongue in these is thin too!
Hi, great informative video. I have ordered these this week after watching yours and other videos on this Grant Stone boot. I went for the natural waxy commander and took a chance on the sizing by going a full size down as most reviews seem to indicate lots of volume, I hope to receive them this weekend and hope they fit. All the best from the UK. PS the tannery ( C. F. Stead ) is around 40 miles away from Manchester where I live.
How did the sizing work out for you? Do you like the boots?
@@InGrindWeCrust2010 Hi, yes a full size down was perfect. They took around two - three weeks to break in but are now comfy.
@@johnwaterhouse3752 Awesome! And you find they're still long enough for your foot?
@@InGrindWeCrust2010 Yes perfect thanks.
Thanks for the great video. I ended up buying a pair of brass boots in Dune/Natural CXL. Curious to know which insole/liner you use with your pair?
Just a simple leather insole from my cobbler
I’ve been watching you a while now and I have never seen you do a video on a pair of Ottawa’s by GS. I’ve seen the Edwards, Diesels, and Edwards. That leaves the Ottawa, Field boot, and the Cap toed boot. Are those not to your liking?
No, I just haven’t bought one yet. It’s a budget issue. Fancy sponsoring a review?
Yes indeed!!!
Hi Tek, great review. I have not been able to wear Red Wing 875 or Thorogood Mod Toes due to the relatively narrow and straight lasts of these boots. I remember you had an issue with the Thorogoods and had to move up in width. How was the comfort on the Brass Boot last? Do you feel going up to an E is advisable in this last? Thank you and keep up the good reviews!!
Perfect in your usual boot size for me with D width
grad video. How is the comfort compared to the Indys? Thinking about these boots, but not sure about the last, I am super happy with the truebalance
Nothing compares to the comfort of Indy’s!
Great content. Thanks 👍🏽
Wish I could afford these boots! Do they ever go on sale?
They’re 20% off now
Boot newbie here.. I like boots.. mainly bcos dispite being thick, they do breathe rather well.. for this heavily waxed boot, does it breathe as well as other unwaxed leather? Thanx
Do you have any recent pictures of the boots? I am trying to see how this Earth color looks as it gets worn
Took me two years of contemplating buying chinese boots. Unfortunately im ashamed to say these boots are worth every penny. I bought two pairs of boots, a jk custom boot from the pacific north west and these. These fit me like a custom shoe, the jk had to be brokem in and it was pain ful. Both are great, the jks makes my feet feel more comfortable with them on then off after the pain went away, these are a little looser but comfortable, and you can also put a pair of orthotics in them to make them perfect.
Hi Tek its me again! I know u own a pair of Diesel boots as well - would you go half a size smaller on these due to the bigger toe box??
I don’t think so
Just bought a pair of these. They look and fit great. I’m noticing a little soreness on the bottom of my heels after a few wears. Did anyone else notice that? Did it go away? Thanks
In my experience it will go away
@@Bootlosophy thanks. They look great so hopefully they’ll get more comfortable. They actually feel better today. Thanks for all the reviews! I may have more questions for you.
Trying to size mine, also went 1/2 down Brannock and my heel feels slightly loose. When you lift your toes up, where about on the boot do they sit? (I guess relative to the moc toe stitching)
Plenty of room in my toe, but not more so than say Red Wing mocs. My heels are fine
Just bought a pair of these in reverse Kudu. By chance, do you know how reverse Kudu does in the rain? I'd hate to mess them up.
They’ll be fine 👍
Do you know if these run the same size as the Thursday diplomat? I have the diplomat in a 9d and it fits well and I’m guessing I should get these in a 9d as well? Thanks!
I think you should be ok in the same size but you’ll find it a little roomier, which I like.
@@Bootlosophy Perfect! where did you get the leather piece that goes over the tongue? Gives them an extra rugged look
@@XxXxXGR3GXxXxX www.dalesleatherworks.com
@@Bootlosophy are those the standard size?
Thanks again Teik, Do you feel these fit the same as your diesels? I just purchased some diesels in 9.5E and they are fine but think I could have gone with a D and was wondering how you felt on the fit comparison of the two? My diesels are cxl and was thinking of this boot as next purchase and also wondered if you felt the CF Stead stretches as much as cxl?
I wear the same size in both but these are definitely roomier.
Are they less narrow across the ball of the foot than the red wing moc? Similar volume? Better heel hold? Do you take the same size in both?
I take the same in both but I find the RW 875 narrower at the waist to ball, but a little more volume (height) in the vamp/toe box
@@Bootlosophy Thanks, I found the 875 a bit narrow there but a bit roomy in the heel and and toe. Might be a good fit for me. Did you get much more width after break in on the rw or still less than the brass?
@@MadelnMachines Does RW ever break in? 😂😂😂
I've been looking for an alternative to the Alden Indy. This boot is not quit there. Any suggestions?
Parkhurst’s Niagara
@@Bootlosophy What about the Grant Stone Ottawa boot. Slightly different. Between the Parkhurst and the Grant Stone, which would you choose. Many thanks.
@@romeodambrosio9689 I thought you wanted an alternative to the Indy? The Ottawa is an NST
i bought the Brass boot in color 8. at first out of the box i loved them. seemed like a great deal at a high quality. but after owning them for several months I'm disappointed. There just isn't any place for them and they have become my least favorite boot and almost a pair I only wear so they are not wasted. They feel clunky without feeling robust. They are definitely not a work boot. Very easy break in period, but never really became comfortable. They really are not a business casual boot either. They seem to scuff ridiculously easy and don't really shine back up very easily. so after their original new condition they just don't look as dressy as I had expected. The color 8 seems to dim quickly and always seemed to look dirty. They are also really heavy on the feet, which would be fine if they were a robust work boot, but they are not. They have large lugs, but are too heavy to be a hiking boot. they have found a weird niche where they look like they would be well rounded and good for many uses but in reality are not good for any use. regret the purchase