Craftsman vs Ryobi (Impact Drivers_
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2020
- I thank you for checking out this video, Im just your average guy having Fun with tools. I test tools out to see what these tools can do, and what they can't do. Please Subscribe to the channel and get that tool fix here. Have a great day!
- Навчання та стиль
Had the sears craftsman 20v impact during the start of my apprenticeship, got me through for a few months taking off panels, hanging pipe, could not get through any type of curb or structural steel, upgraded to a more compact 12v dewalt, since I was moving more towards residential service (hvac). Does exactly what I need it to
This is definitely a good review to help apprentices and homeowners buy a starting drill that will make them money
I agree and I thank you Cody
Hell now dewalt and craftsman are essentially the same. The craftsman is legitly a dummied down dewalt. Even the internals are identical ever since dewalt bought craftsman
I honestly thought this was going to be a huge Ryobi plug with all of the merch at the start of the video. Great job sir.
Craftsman won that.. ran cooler at the end, drove the biggest lag in further, did most tasks faster. Who can argue with those facts? Yes Ryobi did good but it was out done by Craftsman
correct, Craftsman won this video
That's not Ryobi flagship impact tho! If u put it up against Ryobi newest impact driver, which was released about a year and half ago, craftsman wouldn't even stand a chance lol.
@@bobbiecottrill332 Very doubtful these new craftsman’s is a dewalt in red I’ve seen guys on the jobsite with craftsman and they go just as hard as all the pro grade impacts the ryobi in this video actually has better specs and it lost ryobi is still decent
Craftsman woke up and chose violence with this tool. Pretty good comparison video and in my opinion I wouldn’t be to mad about having either one
You did a good job. Tools with souls did a similar test with the same results.
Just bought that Craftsman 820 yesterday and looking forward to using it rebuilding decking outside. I’m on the V20 line and that’s why I got it. Looks like a good product.
very good, I thank you for viewing Eco
How is that v20 line holding up? I’m curious to make the plunge now and have narrowed it down to ryobi and craftsman. I don’t need top of the line but I do need long term battery availability.
@@jo9732 still too soon to tell.
@@ecoRfan hey bro how's it holding up? Its been a year and I'm interested lol
@@ryu-ken it’s a great product, made tasks so much better.
Just an FYI, the hammer and anvil’s moment of engagement has nothing to do with the power of the motor. It’s actually dependent on the preload spring behind the hammer. They actuate when the spring tension is overcome, regardless of motor power. They all use different preload springs because an impact is a timed tool. The mechanism timing has to be within a certain threshold in order to actually use the mechanical advantage provided by the hammer and anvil.
the fact is, the anvil wasn't needed at the very beginning. Craftsman won this one
@@ManCaverTools Craftsman are always better than Ryobi, but for 119 (now) you can get a CRAFTSMAN V20 RP 20-volt Max Variable Speed Brushless 1/2-in Drive Cordless Impact Wrench that is the exact same tool as the 230 dollar Dewalt Model #DCF891B (both come with no battery) But you get a 230 tool for 119, its a no brainer. These companies do this all the time. I bought a Calvin Kline watch that had a Swiss Movement inside for 100 bucks and the movement costs you 200 bucks. Crazy.
You're tests are the best
I wouldn't be disappointed with your test if I were you. You're basically removing the equivalent of lug nuts with a quarter inch drive! I'd say they both did well.
They both did a good job for being in the class they are in
They were soooo close it really doesn't even matter. Both are excellent choices. Go with whatever battery system you have or whatever one you can get a deal on.
to some it might. that might determine what battery platform someone might buy into
Like your videos keep them coming
I thank you Benny
The craftsman went 6seconds faster with the 6in lag than the 4in lag so it's obvious that it depends where you drill into the log can make a huge difference
Mine did exactly the same thing as yours did in the opening scene, the very first time I used it.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Damn that Craftsman is pretty impressive
they both did a good job but the craftsman did a slit better
Can’t wait!
it will be a good one
Craftsman did a great job. About equal over all. It would end up being a price decision for me if it were deciding which one out of the two.
I agree and thank you Matering
Would love to see the Kobalt against either of these.
Kobalt would win, it's dang powerful but mainly due to the 24 volts.
You think so? I tried the Kobalt impact wrench. It was no match compared to the Makita one
@@gooseseey4687 i guess I don't know after watching this video, as all the specs. and the size would lead me to say the ryobi would be dominant over the Craftsman. Even the sound the Ryobi seems more powerful. Yet the Craftsman seemed to outperform the Ryobi just barely. I realize the wood test isn't very good medium to test with though as its always going to be inconsistant.
I will be getting Kobalt XTR impact soon
@@ManCaverTools I think the regular Kobalt is rated at 1700 ins/lbs which puts it in the ball park with the Ryobi or craftsman.
Craftsman same with Stanley fatmax 820,just different colour
Wouldn't the new Ryobi brushless that you swapped collets (if that is the right term) on be a better match size-wise?
no sir, because the new one is compact and wouldn't make for a good video
I’d be curious to hear. What is your favorite tool line to use as a homeowner. If you could only pick 1 line. Which would it be? If you could pick any 2 lines to use together. Which ones would you use?
Id pick Ryobi because they have a huge Variety of tools on one battery line and a good price. But 12v tools are my favorite tools. Milwuakee m12 tools are expensive
When we bought a home I needed some power tools for around the house.I needed a Brad nailer for the baseboard and crown we installed, I was going to just get Ryobi since it was cheap and proven but I'm just not a huge fan of it. I started browsing around and came across craftsman at Lowes. They had a brad nailer for $99 but just bare tool. The batteries were not on sale at the time, I think it was $80 for 1 battery and charger, but they had the brushed impact and drill + 2 batteries and a charger + bag for $99 so I got the drill, impact, and Brad nailer. I actually really liked em after using them around the house. I liked them alot. I had a ridgid brushed impact and drill I used at work and I liked em but didn't love them. I actually liked the Craftsman more than the Ridgid. I liked my craftsman stuff at home so much that I retired my ridgid stuff and bought the Craftsman Brushless impact and drill for work. I gotta say I love my craftsman brushless stuff. It works for me and what I do and I haven't really had any issues with them other than the brad nailer started failing to fire alot. I hit up customer service and they sent me a brand new one, I didn't even ask for it, I just asked how I could fix it. So it's definitly important to register your tools and get the warranty going. But if you are a DIY'er or doing like residential multihousing maintenance or the like and don't want to blow out the budget on the yellow or red, I recommend the Craftsman line. Oh, I also found out that craftsmans new line is just Dewalt stuff but Chinese made and cheaper.
Have you ever thought about for these videos to convert the in lbs to ft lbs for impacts like if the impact rating is 1700 in lbs to ft lbs would be around 142 ft lbs of torque? If divided by 12. Just a question. I dont mean for this to come off as a request but a possible suggestion.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Supposedly it's been said craftsman is basically a red dewalt, wanna, test that out for us?
Well they're the same company.. just like Chevy and GMC.. owned by the same company. GM doesn't own the tools that's just a comparison
@@rileytaylor1206 stanley black and decker owns like all the tool makers (not literally but most) and just like gm, chevy and cadillac they have different quality, still have their own signature things though.
Pretty much lol
What I've seen is it's mostly just rebranded (and maybe somewhat upgraded) Porter Cable stuff. This impact definitely looks like it has some DeWalt in it though.
@@ManCaverTools David, another hijacked video.
ua-cam.com/video/6p3TaNdnduw/v-deo.html
Old Craftsman fan whose first cordless tool were the old 19.2 v made by Ryobi. I have Ryobi now. Was excited about the new Craftsman being resurrected by Stanley Black and Decker. American owned. Sadly I find the new Craftsman red tools to be generic in looks with a cheapness to the. Like I have room to talk owning Ryobi. The Ryobi seems superior to me. I really wanted craftsman to be of a higher grade on par with Dewalt. If I had nothing I’d probably go with Dewalt. The Flex tools look great. That is something to look at if they happen to fly. Looking to upgrade Ryobi HD kept me on board. They finally have nice ergonomics that the others now have , leaving Kobalt with the chunky look.
Would use them for skrews and small bolts for bigger bolts and longer ones use an impact wrench with a good amount of torque like 300ft pounds which should the max or if someone is a mechanic get a stronger one for whatever job is needed for. Impact drivers can do the work in the video but these are diy tools even though these tools can be impressive to use for your needs but should not be for thick long bolts.
that is what I would as use them for as well. You will just end up breaking adaptors left and right for big bolts
I think the variable trigger craftsman impact is better than the 3 setting one.
Love that Craftsman impact!
it is a pretty nice impact and thank you Doug
Thanks for the stream Man caver! It was awesome see you on the next one!
I thank you Treehouse
Craftsman is the TOP tool!I really like
Very good :)
More Craftsman will be coming
Could you reply a link for those husky screw organizers please? Thanks:)
that is Milwuakee packout organizer
Kobalt vs craftsman would be a good video !
I will be getting the XTR impact soon
Would like to see you compare festoon impact with Milwaukee or dewalt
once im able to get festool I will
I have a small business glass/window and we use some Dewalt and mainly moved mainly to Ryobi tools. I like Milwaukee and Makita but to me and for what I do, I can just get more tools and batteries for the same price. And it gets the job done the same. And secondly when I have to replace tools if easier on the wallet. However recently I have my truck broken into and all my power tools were stolen (fu@king sucks). Now I have to replace my tools and looking at other options. I like that Craftsman are equaling not better than Ryobi, Ridgid and kobalt. For me I really like to support products and companies that are Made in America and I plan to replace my tools with Craftsman. I also like being in job and not worrying about loosing/mixing up my tools with all the other Dewalts/Milwaukee tools. Lastly I had this Ryobi impact and it was great super powerful and durable a little heavy, but it was stolen unfortunately.
Really good video showing the 2 tools. But most people wont use a small impact for 6 inch lags. Use a 3/8 or 1/2 impact
but its fun to see what they can do :)
Which impact adapter did it last the longest for you?
I have so many impact I use them all randomly so I didnt have a issue with one yet
@@ManCaverTools Adapter?
Do the P238 against the new ryobi compact HP impact, with a 4ah HP for both. Then try both with the 4ah black.
More videos will be coming up and I thank you for viewing Cereal
Actually very surprising that these tool can pull of some heavy duty tasks.
Do the atomic vs 12v xtreme, next! That’s at least 3 videos!
more videos will be coming up
But of all the brands Ryobi has the best color of all of them. That green is sweet.
What tool brand is all of your favourite out of every brand out there
I love all tool brands because not a single brand has the best tool in every category
Where did you get the belt clips for the craftsman
Usually comes with the kit that includes 2 batteries
it came with the tool
They come with it and are for use with the VersaTrack wall storage system.
Was the craftsman brushless? I saw where the ryobi is brushless
Yes it was. I show that it is Brushless in the video
Love ryobi but hated that p238 it was huge bulky a d break screw heads, love the new hp
Ones got rid of that p238
Very good and I thank you for viewing Jesus
Like Ryobi 👍
it really isnt bad inpact, but it is loud
I've never seen that Ryobi . My old Ryobi silent strike was tearing off screw heads constantly if I wasn't paying attantion.
Imho the Craftsman actually won, I use neither brand so I couldn't have cared less which one won lol
.. But to me the Craftsman took it.
the craftsman did win the battle. and thank you Casey
Interesting
it will be
Please show price of the tools, it's good comparison to show price to performance value
Ryobi is a good brand and have much features to beat the cheqp brands
I personally think Ryobi is a good Brand
You should put that hilti impact wrench vs the ryobi impact wrench.
I can but that would be brushed vs brushless.
Have a ryobi drill for 20 yrs now still going strong. Use it all the time. Had a hilti drill that I babied only used once in awhile. It quit working I would say after maybe15 to 20 uses. Ryobi might not win in these extreme tests but they are built well and last a long time for normal use
You know, when sink those huge(That's What She Said.!)sized Lag Bolts(the stuff I'd instinctively grab at least a 3/8" if not a 1/2" drive impact if I were to be showing a helper how to do the job that needed to be done, and way I expected it to be done(meaning as inexpensively as possible 😎.) I'd never ever plant such a bad seed as the torture test that I so enjoy watching you do.
I'm sorry... I know it's frustrating when you're making videos to go through 5 or 10 adapters for a single video, not to mention, drill-bits, saw-blades, and God whatever else you destroy in the process of making your videos.
Hey Brother!!! It just hit me! How About a somber announcement of 3 seconds of silence for the adapter bits, drill-bits, saw-blades and stuff that bit the dust during your testing..🤠🤓 make it funny, funeral music, then needle scratch, jerk off shirt&tie, and place the ball cap and safety glasses and now back to the video you came to see. It'll be hilarious, and we'll all love it. Heck, your compadres will probably love it.
I know TTC breaks bits almost constantly.
craftsman always surprising
....with a new battery platform every 6 years.
we will see on how well it does with the 6ah battery soon
I KNEW IT!!!
I thank you for viewing tool hunter
Hilti is a monster ... see you in the next video Dave 👊
I thank you Julio
I do agree that the test are truly too extreme. I would never ask of my 1/4" impact what many channels test them at.
I was always talk to use the proper tool for the proper job.
If I were to see a coworker misusing a tool, I'm deducting IQ points. That's just it.
But your brutality and others is anticipated with glee.!
that is why I changed my tests since the older videos
It’s a dewalt rebrand so technically dewalt won.
Some say get the Husky bit drivers
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Nice review boss 👍 but the brand idon't trust. Thnx.
I thank you for viewing Reginald
What I think is happening is that your heating that bit up so much you're taking the heat treat a way and that is why it's snapping off
They just not made putting 10inch lags with 1/4 drive to much constant torque then they snap think the metal is to hard also with heat treatment
that's why I do these tests. if I only did 3" screws it wouldn't make a good stress test
I thank using that 5/8 lag is a bit to extreme for the adaptors, so I will be not using it on impact drivers anymore
Why do people use the Milwaukee socket adapter for high torque tests. They are crap. The stem aka torsion zone some call it is thin as hell compared to others grab the husky 3 pack or DeWalt. You will get better milage they have thicker stems. The quarter part that goes into the collet is par for the course but thick shafted unlike the Milwaukee Makita and Ryobi socket adapters.
Why don't you put washers on so you don't sink them?
I should, ill pick them up today
Or just buy flanged bolts instead 👌👍👏👏👏👏
I can say your testing process is truly grueling. I must admit, I would've switched to a larger impact driver.
This also is an old video. My testing methods upgraded since then
@@ManCaverTools Yes Sir, I noticed that. But, I really like the way you test things. You don't abuse the tool, you operate to limit of the tools intended purposes, while illustrating their proper operational limits. If you're on a latter, and didn't bring a heavier tool with you, you've illustrated how to get job started at least. Then can come down, or holler for help.
Also ., I'm sure one was a brushless, the other was not. The builds were so very different.
Why did you never use any of german tools like ( fein , bosch , metabo.. ) in a test on your videos ???
I will be getting those tools in the future.
The ryobi didnt release the bit, you did when you broke though ithe collet hit the wood
we will see if it happens again night future
Craftsman has an incredible impact. Ryobi always lies about there tool capability, always have. They are still good but craftsman set a high bar for impact.
very good and I thank you for viewing Marcus
What do you expect they're owned by TTI same company that ownes Milwaukee and you know how much they lie
You got the bit too hot, and the reason the craftsman put in and took out the big lag was it was right next to a hole
Yes sir and I thank you Timmy
Hi Man Caver Tools
How the fuck is a 18v fair test with a 24v or 20v
Bro do u think craftsman gets more power with a bigger BATTERY?🤔
I think any tool will get more power from a bigger battery
@@ManCaverTools cool but I know the Kobalt 24v don't just get more run time but no power increase . Thanks man 💯👍
Its all your fault. If u use the same accessory for both with out resting the heat. This will always happen. U should put each tool tbere own accessory. So the accessory could take a break just like the tools get there break😁😁😁
Test the craftsman with the atomic
more videos will be coming
Craftsman hammer drill next????
that will be the next craftsman I get
@@ManCaverTools yesssss
You mention the craftsman is a USA made tool but you did not mention anything about the Ryobi tool
I just wish ryobi would learn what "compact" means, tired of the clown shoe sized case and batteries.
I agree, they need to change the battery
It drives me insane that people
Use impact drivers for bolts and such for the love of god impact drivers are only made for screws and such bolts are for impacts that’s why impact drivers get torn up cause people use them for tightening stuff
it makes a good stress test for videos to see how reliable a tool is really quick. by doing these tests we can see if they are able to handle it. and a lot of them can
They are not meant for big lags like that can break your impact
Obviously the craftsman won. Red headed step child of the dewalt is still better than ryobi
Very good and I thank you for viewing Cha
except the milwaukee amd dewalt
more videos will be coming out and I thank you fro viewing Richard
Again, the Ryobi underperforms and is outdone by yet another tool. I like your videos, they are entertaining, but those Ryobi tools are substandard.
I do think it is time they upgrade them
Well of course the Craftsman won. It's just a Red DeWalt 887
There is no testing ryobi is 18v and always will be dont put a 20v and 24v and expect to be the top notch take and 18v to 18v so its fair
You do realize that most 20v advertised tools are actually 18v themselves? Ryobi advertises actual voltage versus everyone else advertising MAX voltage. It's all smoke and mirrors. Now the 24V you have a point, but even then, there are some 18/20v models that beat them.
Wassup
What is up Rayshon
#24
I thank you Evan
Isn’t this just offbrand dewalt vs Milwaukee lol
That's not a Ryobi HP battery, it's just a plus battery
Craftsman won. At the end Ryobi couldnt pull it out. If it cant finish the job, what good is it.
Looks like your log is just about used up
Yes it is and whipped out another one
Craftsman is a far superior product to Ryobi clearly.
Ryobi lost 😕😕😕.
but not by much though
Lol craftsman impact driver won that all day!!!!!
Craftsman won!!!
yes it did
Those adapters are garbage. I’d get husky.
I Thank you so much for viewing :)
Craftsman and ryobi are 💩