They missed a terrific opportunity for a great running gag. Maud accidentally helping all of Equestria's villains with their evil plots like she did Starlight.
Chrysallis: Say, do you happen to know of a rock that can repress all magic except Changeling magic? Something I could make a throne out of? Maud: Yep. Right over there.
I never focused on Maude saying it isn't hard to meet somepony she likes, but it's hard to meet somepony that gets her. It's a brief glimpse into how _lonely_ she actually feels. She likes other ponies; other ponies are very put off by her.
In other words, this episode single hoofedly implied Maud is autistic It was because of this episode that I noticed how many autistic traits Maud has, and I wouldn’t be surprised if she was written with that intention, that line almost confirms it!
Did no one else notice that Starlight's Cutie Mark is a literal kite. I can see why she likes kites, she can be able to control and manipulate people by using magic. That's pretty clever.
Literally didn't even notice her cutie mark was a kite, mind blown. It can also show that she likes leading people, even though this initially was a bad thing with how she used it. Tracks with her becoming principle.
@@babyblue_22 The Red Cross emblem is protected by the Geneva Conventions and can only be used in the context of humanitarian aid. So displaying it in a cartoon is technically a war crime.
1:39 well since the gem cave is literally covered in gems it only makes sense that yes those are very common gems if there’s so many of them in that cave
I love how he did not sin the fact that Maud literally helped Starlight enslave her village.From what I remember, Starlight actually asks Maud where she could find that staff in order to enslave ponies.She wasn't really coy about it.
"Rock Solid Friendship" is one of my favorite Maud episodes! It was interesting to see Maud get a degree in Rockology just as it was hilarious seeing Pinkie Pie go through all those shenanigans to convince Maud to move to Ponyville. And like many others when i first saw this episode i couldn't believe it when I saw the flashback revealing that Maud and Starlight met once before back when Starlight was evil. But with Starlight being reformed it was definitely the perfect opportunity for her and Maud to start over. One of my favorite parts of this episode is when Maud and Starlight discover the grotto near the gem cave it was a gorgeous underground landscape and it was good that Maud made it her permanent residents and for a number of reasons not only is the location adjacent to Ponyville but Maud also wouldn't have to worry about paying rent, bills, and taxes. lol Anyway I give this episode 9/10!!!
This episode is an absolute gem! It rocks!! I hope your month won't be too rocky!! I hope making these videos isn't too much of a bouldern! Have a stone day!!
Starlight has a secret black kite with red streamers attached and also it's a super kite that flies higher and faster than the other kites combined and can do all the cool kite tricks.
@@PinPin-ex1ct I most likely made this joke in reference to the sin at 3:25, and was poking fun at blandly-made overpowered fan OCs who are coloured black & red because that makes them 'cool' and 'edgy'.
Two things here: Even after understanding protagonist absences for other characters to develop, I do agree that for an episode with "Friendship" in the name, it was weird that this was an episode Twilight, the Princess of Friendship, didn't appear in, and 3:22 Actually, Starlight only enslaved five of the Mane 6, and that short of her hypnotizing Twilight doesn't count, especially how someone replied to me about it when I brought it up months ago.
My big issue with this episode is that it's another demonstration of Starlight being forced to be relevant by upstaging those around her. No one in all of Ponyville could connect with Maud except Starlight of all ponies? It would make more sense if Starlight was one of a few ponies who could, but just her? And even watching their friendship blossom, it felt very "let's force these characters to feel this way"-ish. I felt no chemistry between the two, regardless of Maud's "out-of-character" smile. I believe Starlight's relationship with Trixie and Sunburst. Those connections seem very natural, but not what she has with Maud. It seems manufactured. I felt like Big Mac would've been a much better fit for Maud as a friend.
I just love the fact that this is the only April fools pony video that isn't a joke so you definitely subverted my expectations, good job Littleshy! As always continue the great work and the great jokes!
2:35 Forget cross-eyed gray pegasus, what happen to all those other characters in the season 4-7 intro photo? Why didn't they ever stop an evil mastermind or have an episode centered around them?
I don't see how the water level in the cave should be a problem actually. What looks like an underground pool or pond is probably the mouth of an underground river, given how many waterfalls feed into it and the fact that you can see the body of water stretch off into the background out of sight. Heck, considering we find out later that Maud's cave is part of a cave system that extends into the Everfree Forest since it connects to the Mirror Pool cave, maybe that body of water is the underground river that flows to Winsome Falls as seen in the episode about Rockhoof, Mistmane, and Flash Mangus' legends?
Hey it's the episode I did a reanimation of back in 2020. Also that joke with the G5 stuff was hilarious, that and the end gag...oh who'm I kidding? This wgole thing was fun. Great upload.
Man, it's been a while. When this episode came out, I had already dropped the habit of watching each new episode twice, so I missed a lot. 1:55 Such as that thump from off-screen. LOL Eh, he's shown he can take a ton of damage.
Funnily enough, the sins against Pinkie regarding the time it would've taken to set up the explosives and her somehow exiting out Starlight's through a closet door can easily be logically explained in one sentence: it's Pinkie Pie, don't question it
In the panel where Derpy is getting smacked in the face by a pizza box, she has an inner leg cutie mark. Now, I at first thought Cinemare sins missed this, but upon further evaluation I can conclude that he ignored the error as it was Derpy and anything to do with Derpy is not an error but a feature
tbf tho rarity probably doesnt use her gem finding magic in the caves coz it seems to just find gems in general, not a specific *type* of gem, which would be useless to do in a cave completely filled with other gems. If she had the ability to only find certain gems she liked instead of just tracking gems in general, she wouldn't complain about other stuff, like how saphires were super hard for her to find. or maybe she would. she is rarity.
Huh... this is the first time I realized we ever got to see Maud's cutie mark in the actual show. I know there's plenty of artwork with it, but I'd figured it was just something the fans made up.
2:59 The slip and fall Saul Goodman bit is so unreasonably funny and gets a laugh out of me every single time! Why are more people not talking about this
They missed a terrific opportunity for a great running gag.
Maud accidentally helping all of Equestria's villains with their evil plots like she did Starlight.
Chrysallis: Say, do you happen to know of a rock that can repress all magic except Changeling magic? Something I could make a throne out of?
Maud: Yep. Right over there.
Maud: Sometimes, I wish it could just be night all the time. it's nice and peaceful then
Luna: Oh how kind...hmmm, maybe you're onto something
@@SeltzerFountain why are you so incredibly right
Discord (from his stone prison): Do you know how I can get out of this stone?
Maud: Yeah, I’ll just hit it with another rock.
😂😂😂
i like how cinemare sins is now at a point where every video has at least one gag that took WAY more effort to make than was ever needed
I never focused on Maude saying it isn't hard to meet somepony she likes, but it's hard to meet somepony that gets her. It's a brief glimpse into how _lonely_ she actually feels. She likes other ponies; other ponies are very put off by her.
In other words, this episode single hoofedly implied Maud is autistic
It was because of this episode that I noticed how many autistic traits Maud has, and I wouldn’t be surprised if she was written with that intention, that line almost confirms it!
The extra writing on Maud's cards might have been for speaking directions or reminders, like to pause for Pinky's outbursts
smart idea, actually
Did no one else notice that Starlight's Cutie Mark is a literal kite. I can see why she likes kites, she can be able to control and manipulate people by using magic. That's pretty clever.
Wow, that's so cool - I've never heard of that connection before! What a good catch!
Mind blown.
HOLY-
Literally didn't even notice her cutie mark was a kite, mind blown.
It can also show that she likes leading people, even though this initially was a bad thing with how she used it. Tracks with her becoming principle.
huh, I never realised that!
I respect the fact CinemareSins recognizes Tom as a symbol of all rocks!
LittleshyFIM is a very modest UA-camr for spelling the word modest as "maudest" but not drawing any attention to such a boss pun.
This comment deserves to be pinned.
@@82dorrin agreed
Would’ve been really funny if you spelt “modest” as “ muadest”
0:31 You actually censored Nurse Redheart's cutie mark. I respect your commitment to not being a war criminal.
Please, context? I don't get the joke and I desperately want to 😢
@@babyblue_22 The Red Cross emblem is protected by the Geneva Conventions and can only be used in the context of humanitarian aid. So displaying it in a cartoon is technically a war crime.
@@yondaime500 Ah....qué qué? Lol wait, seriously?? 🤯
@@yondaime500 Does it still count if it depicts a character providing humanitarian aid?
@@babyblue_22basically it’s a copyright thing
1:39 well since the gem cave is literally covered in gems it only makes sense that yes those are very common gems if there’s so many of them in that cave
I love how he did not sin the fact that Maud literally helped Starlight enslave her village.From what I remember, Starlight actually asks Maud where she could find that staff in order to enslave ponies.She wasn't really coy about it.
I don't think it was the staff she asked about, but the material used to make the cutie mark vault to hold everyone's cutie marks.
I really like Maud and Starlight becoming friends in this episode.
I’m surprised you didn’t sin the fact that Maud was the reason for a town being in slaved and was the instigator of the universe being destroyed
Maybe Starlight's afraid of being treated like a kid because the last time she did that, she got infantalized by her dad so much that she moved out.
"Rock Solid Friendship" is one of my favorite Maud episodes! It was interesting to see Maud get a degree in Rockology just as it was hilarious seeing Pinkie Pie go through all those shenanigans to convince Maud to move to Ponyville.
And like many others when i first saw this episode i couldn't believe it when I saw the flashback revealing that Maud and Starlight met once before back when Starlight was evil. But with Starlight being reformed it was definitely the perfect opportunity for her and Maud to start over.
One of my favorite parts of this episode is when Maud and Starlight discover the grotto near the gem cave it was a gorgeous underground landscape and it was good that Maud made it her permanent residents and for a number of reasons not only is the location adjacent to Ponyville but Maud also wouldn't have to worry about paying rent, bills, and taxes. lol
Anyway I give this episode 9/10!!!
Same actually.
@@GMan17256 Same what?
@@TheCommenterDragon I was just saying that's also one of my favorite Maud episodes too. I should've specified that, my bad.
LittleshyFiM: “we can’t take rock puns for granite”
Me: Gosh dang it Littleshy, I lose!
This episode is an absolute gem! It rocks!! I hope your month won't be too rocky!! I hope making these videos isn't too much of a bouldern! Have a stone day!!
You would earn a Maud Lauh for that
Starlight has a secret black kite with red streamers attached and also it's a super kite that flies higher and faster than the other kites combined and can do all the cool kite tricks.
I feel like I’m missing a reference
@@PinPin-ex1ct
I most likely made this joke in reference to the sin at 3:25, and was poking fun at blandly-made overpowered fan OCs who are coloured black & red because that makes them 'cool' and 'edgy'.
Two things here:
Even after understanding protagonist absences for other characters to develop, I do agree that for an episode with "Friendship" in the name, it was weird that this was an episode Twilight, the Princess of Friendship, didn't appear in, and
3:22 Actually, Starlight only enslaved five of the Mane 6, and that short of her hypnotizing Twilight doesn't count, especially how someone replied to me about it when I brought it up months ago.
She didn't do it on purpose and I never saw her hypnotize twilight
This episode about rocks was pretty down to earth.
2:40 Twilight already tried and failed with Maud before. Makes sense to try out a new element that wasn’t there before, Starlight.
My big issue with this episode is that it's another demonstration of Starlight being forced to be relevant by upstaging those around her. No one in all of Ponyville could connect with Maud except Starlight of all ponies? It would make more sense if Starlight was one of a few ponies who could, but just her? And even watching their friendship blossom, it felt very "let's force these characters to feel this way"-ish. I felt no chemistry between the two, regardless of Maud's "out-of-character" smile. I believe Starlight's relationship with Trixie and Sunburst. Those connections seem very natural, but not what she has with Maud. It seems manufactured. I felt like Big Mac would've been a much better fit for Maud as a friend.
5:23 is probably your best endgag ever…… No bias here!
Let’s get #kitesarekool trending to continue the starlight glimmer cult
I’m waiting for one of the very last episode. These are truly masterpieces
I just love the fact that this is the only April fools pony video that isn't a joke so you definitely subverted my expectations, good job Littleshy!
As always continue the great work and the great jokes!
The greatest April Fools prank about this, is it's an actual Cinemare Sins!
I never expected that!!!
So it was Pinkie who blew up the library. But I thought you said she was always right!
Does this mean you work for Hasbro?
0:24 RIP Stefen Carl. He was number one.
Another epic Cinemare Sins, Starlight's like for kites is an awesome aspect of her character tbh 💯
i'm always afraid of watching these on april 1st, but incredible video as usual
"Hi, I'm Saul Goodhorse. Did you know you have rights? Celestia says you do, and so do I."
2:35 Forget cross-eyed gray pegasus, what happen to all those other characters in the season 4-7 intro photo? Why didn't they ever stop an evil mastermind or have an episode centered around them?
I don't see how the water level in the cave should be a problem actually. What looks like an underground pool or pond is probably the mouth of an underground river, given how many waterfalls feed into it and the fact that you can see the body of water stretch off into the background out of sight. Heck, considering we find out later that Maud's cave is part of a cave system that extends into the Everfree Forest since it connects to the Mirror Pool cave, maybe that body of water is the underground river that flows to Winsome Falls as seen in the episode about Rockhoof, Mistmane, and Flash Mangus' legends?
Replacing Celestia with magic crystals was noteworthy until that repeatedly reappearing note ultimately replaced Celestia for good.
Hey it's the episode I did a reanimation of back in 2020. Also that joke with the G5 stuff was hilarious, that and the end gag...oh who'm I kidding? This wgole thing was fun. Great upload.
At this point animation errors will rule all of TV
This episode 🪨s
You put a lot of effort into this video, it more than paid off
1:17
Did a double take there. I was reading along, blinked, and the word changed while my eyelids were down.
Man, it's been a while. When this episode came out, I had already dropped the habit of watching each new episode twice, so I missed a lot.
1:55 Such as that thump from off-screen. LOL Eh, he's shown he can take a ton of damage.
I was expecting the Spongebob explosion at the end.
1:48 I was wondering why rarity couldnt see gems hidden in walls anymore in this episode and in other later seasons anymore.
0:37 Oh come on now, that was clearly a portmanteau.
3:38 yep. Summed that up pretty good.
Ratio joke XD good episode well done
5:32 manaicial laughter ensues.
Funnily enough, the sins against Pinkie regarding the time it would've taken to set up the explosives and her somehow exiting out Starlight's through a closet door can easily be logically explained in one sentence: it's Pinkie Pie, don't question it
4:18 nice
3:40 derpy was so happy even after getting hit 😭
Awesome video bro.
I love those videos so much they're always hilarious. Seriously. How can I not sound like a bot? I love pinkie.
Another sin for you! Pinkie pies hair changes color when she was slimed but then is fixed a few seconds later.
“Because a foam hoof would imply every pony is number one”
*we are number one plays*
surprised the ending jokes didn't include Starlight doing asdfmovie's "I like trains" gag!
And we're finally back.
"Ratio" made me choke on my food
I love how Maud specified that Starlight hadn't enslaved anypony _lately._
Omg the cutie mark reveal as a "rock" censor. I love that. I'm still in pain how long ago mlp fim ended
The way Maud roasted Rarity 😂
4:32 are we gonna ignore the fact that the hoof prints are horseshoe shaped even though she wasn't wearing any horseshoes
I WAS LOOKING FOR THIS A FEW DAYS AGO LMAOO that’s really funny
Good pones
I thought I was going crazy at 1:19.
Banger video for a banger episode! Nice work Littleshy!
In the panel where Derpy is getting smacked in the face by a pizza box, she has an inner leg cutie mark. Now, I at first thought Cinemare sins missed this, but upon further evaluation I can conclude that he ignored the error as it was Derpy and anything to do with Derpy is not an error but a feature
0:26 I can imagine the weight of that rock shape graduation hat
AFTER YEARS OF SEARCHING I’VE FOUND HIM AGAIN
good. a real legit video on april first.
This is the first video I've watched made today without a Rickroll. Instead, it had a Rockroll.
tbf tho rarity probably doesnt use her gem finding magic in the caves coz it seems to just find gems in general, not a specific *type* of gem, which would be useless to do in a cave completely filled with other gems. If she had the ability to only find certain gems she liked instead of just tracking gems in general, she wouldn't complain about other stuff, like how saphires were super hard for her to find. or maybe she would. she is rarity.
4:24 “pinkie, I don’t have a closet”
Of course you had to censor nurse redheart's red crosses.
2:31 If anyone else in the comments makes a reference to a certain Pizza Pinkie Fanboy Pony that rhymes with Casper Die, I will end you.
Couldnt have started my April any better way tbh
Me to Starlight. I love My little... I mean Kites.
Me: Littleshy made a new video? screw homework
Yeeees a new video🎉🎉
I half expected this to be a April fool's joke vid
The Golden Oak Library just can't catch a break.
5:24 missed da rock joke opportunity. *ding*
Great censorship on Redheart's cutie mark.
0:31 what’s wrong with using a Red Cross ? Why did they sensor it?
Did u know Pie family is immortal
But also.. DERPY:D (my fav non main 6th
2:36 It’s true! Derpy is all of us … 😌
But starlight doesn’t have a closest?
One sin removed for doing this episode, where Pinkie Pie is near her most foolish, on All Fools' Day!
I lost it at the ending lmfao
Derpy! She gets abused in this episode but at least she gets pizza for free.
Huh... this is the first time I realized we ever got to see Maud's cutie mark in the actual show. I know there's plenty of artwork with it, but I'd figured it was just something the fans made up.
0:29
A rock sonic screwdriver or a blue phone rock.
No? Just me?
The episode that gave me one of my favorite ships (even if it’s sadly not canon)
0:21 this thing again
5:12 😂
2:59 The slip and fall Saul Goodman bit is so unreasonably funny and gets a laugh out of me every single time! Why are more people not talking about this
1:06 😂
Amazing
I'm surprised on you not sin the check mark shaped rock
This one missed the forty-sin mark.
😭 every single video- i expect the angry birds theme song