This is one of Zepplin's songs I like to kick back, feet up, room candlelit and a glass of wine nearby. It transports me somewhere else. Of course that's true for most of Zepplin and Pink Floyd. Once again, I like your analysis, I think you're right on with the analogy of the River Styx.
"What the hell am I hearing?" You're hearing what happens when four of the most talented musicians the world has ever seen all get together and make each other even better musicians: ethereal magic.
The story, as Robert Plant tells it, is the very first time they jammed together - this is the magic that happened. They all stopped, stared at each other, and realized how precious and unusual this was. The band was still going by "The New Yardbirds" at that time. One gig later, and the whole Yardbirds thing was out the window. This was a new animal. Led Zeppelin is, by far, (in my opinion), the greatest rock band ever. And this is the music that informed my childhood. Those of us who grew up during the 60's, 70's and 80's were truly blessed. And we took it for granted.
I've watched and been amused by music reaction videos on dozens of channels but you are offering some of the most insightful and intelligent commentary. Kudos!
You've got to watch the live version from Madison Square Garden, it will blow your mind. Plant was big into Viking mythology, I've always thought of this song as a quest.
@@SyedRewinds Definitely watch it, but please keep reacting to the studio versions- live shows are incredible, but the studio track is what the band wanted you to hear- plus, with Zeppelin, you lose so much of Jimmy’s layered guitar tracks. As I said, listen to the live shows, but react to the canon track. Cheers
Viking stuff in general.... "The Immigrant Song", one of their shorter ones. The last verse shows that even back then Plant knew his material. It tells how after the slaughter, vikings often turned enemies into friends and equals. And it's a great song as well.
One of the key characteristics of Zeppelin is what Page called “Light and Shade”…..it was about textures, contrasting a soft, often acoustic beginning and then the hammer comes down and you get massive electric guitar riffs. Page is considered one of the greatest of guitar riff masters.
Beatles, Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin. They are the three greatest rock bands of all time. They have the greatest range and deepest catalogues. Entire albums stand up as works of genius with few, if any, "bad songs." But for me, the one band that could summon the most exquisite, quintessential, most pure and unadulterated ROCK experience, with all the sex, drugs, adrenaline and heartbreak that word entails... was always Led Zeppelin. No band captured it better.
I definitely agree with those asking for the MSG live version. That got me into LZ. Also has my favorite guitar solo. Page goes off. Again, love the review.
There are just so many gems from this band. Your reactions remind me of mine in 1980 when I was 12. My mind was blown and still is. Off of Led Zeppelin III, Since I've Been Loving You. You may be speechless.
@@tymega7680 I wouldn't even say they were my favourite band... I'm not sure I've got one. But I've never heard a bad track from them. And they are so far beyond being a band that carried no passengers. Each one of them is (rightly) recognised as a Grand Master of their instrument. Each one of them is on the "All time " list.
Interesting take on the journey to hell of a warrior. I always got the impression of a small group of fierce, brave warriors making a desperate journey through a blizzard to their king to inform him of an invasion. The "dogs of doom" I assumed to be a pack of wolves hounding them, waiting for one to falter so they can take him down. They neither give quarter nor ask for quarter - they will complete their mission or die trying.
Some excellent analogies there Syed. The dogs of doom actually howled just after the line. It reminded me of Pink Floyd's Animals album, where Gilmore delivers a brilliant 'dog' via guitar on the "Dogs" track and Wright gives us sheep via keys and synth on "Sheep".
Yeah, John Paul Jones is killing it in this studio version because he's playing 4 different instruments on different tracks. He's playing keyboards, piano, bass guitar and synthesized bass. Awesome! And if you like the studio version, just wait until you hear the live version. And when Plant says that line live "The Dogs of Doom are Howling More". Page uses an instrument called a Theremin for the sound of the howling dogs. And that sound? Wow!
I was 13 when this came out on 1973 and you just couldn't get enough of it then and it just gets better with age. First time hearing your reaction and great interpretation and understanding of what the band is doing. Well done, you get it! Cheers!
Truly a soundscape. I'm actually envious that you're hearing this for the first time, lol. Absolutely love this tune and your reaction to it and appreciation of it and the synergy these lads had when they played together.
Thanks for listening! haha at least you can relive the first listens through me, im glad you enjoyed mate. Their chemistry seeps through on every track
@@SyedRewinds Vicarious living through the younger generations, lol! Any more recommendations from yourself? I'm always open to new music/genres and very much enjoyed B.O.B.
I'm not really good with 1st time listens, all my favorite songs took a couple listens to really click. This one took me 5 listens to get hooked and realize how cool and badass that riff is riding around with sun glasses feeling like a rocker
I have every led Zeppelin albums and have listened to them to many times to count. But dude your excitement and appreciation has excited me I feel like I did the day I got these albums. Damn I'm glad I come across your channel.
Great, literate reaction. I used to work at a radio station when this LP was released, and I had the acetate copy of this...I wish I still had it! Anyway, it was tough to get information about this LP back then as there was no internet or Google. Zeppelin was a somewhat mysterious band, and I felt the same way about the conjured images this song expressed. So nice work! This was like a time machine, and I thank you for that.
I think you have the right general mood, but I've taken it a different way. The mood for me is dread, fear, but iron resolve... Like a group of warriors tasked with an impossible mission, maybe what we'd now call a "Black op", and people back at home waiting either for news of them, or some enemy kicking down the doors in the middle of the night, killing everyone inside. When this was written, they had quite an obsession with Tolkien's "Lord of the Rings". I've always thought it was related to that in some way. You're spot on about J-P-J. Massively underrated and hugely talented multi-instrumentalist. You're also right about the meaning of "No Quarter"... No mercy given or expected... All in... Balls to the wall. Not related to this, but check out JPJ's version of "When the levee breaks" with the "Playing for change" people on youtube. Dude still has the fire in his belly. I hope you realise, this is only your top track until ... well... I don't know which ones are going to light you up, but there are many. Bluesy / guitar at "boss" level ? That would be "Since I've been loving you". Stadium rock on a massive scale ? Hmm... Many, but "Kashmir" I think. Melancholic/philosophical and ... well... my all timer... "The Rain Song" (suggest you go with Plant and Page Unledded Live performance for this and Kashmir, because your chin will just hit the floor... Stunning). Ok, I'm gonna shut up now before I suggest everything they ever recorded. Enjoying sharing your journey with you. It reminds me of my own. :-)
@@SyedRewinds The title makes sense with that. And "They carry news that must get through", sounds like someone slipping through hostile territory with vital info, at any cost.
Another fabulous reaction. I really appreciate that you're actually listening to not just the song, but the artistry of each band member. Thanks for that. Rock on! :)
Finally, JPJ recognized for the multi instrumentalist/arranger genius that he was! When Page wanted to form Zeppelin, he first went to JPJ because he was an established artist much like himself-soooo underrated!!
John Paul Jones quicky became my favorite member of Led Zep because I release how much he brought to the band so much going on on the background. He started another band with David Grohl the drummer of Nirvana and singer of the Foo Fighters and Josh Homme singer for Queens Of The Stone Age called Them Crooked Vultures, defiantly worth a listen.
The subtlety of this song always got me. I imagined a group of warriors leaving their village to deliver a scroll or pass info on to some other village far away
Same here .. the message that must get through... Fight to the last man is the message given as they ask no quarter... Which makes it sad that their is no escaping destiny.
And this is why I enjoy watching reaction videos! It takes me back to when I first put the headphones on and dropped the needle on this LP. I will agree that the live version from The Song Remains the Same is awesome BUT.. there are a variety of mixes. I personally favor the ORIGINAL live album version (not the CD or video), as I think the solo section is just amazing - one of my top 3 solos by Mr. Page.
This is the best description of this song I've ever heard! I've only just come across your channel and I'm subscribing. Led Zeppelin is one of my most favorite bands since I was 13 and I'm 55 now, and still rockin. Everything you're saying here is exactly why when Bohnam passed, they could no longer go on without him. Fantastic reaction!!!!!!!!! Btw, You have got to watch the movie The Song Remains the Same. This song is portrayed in the movie and it is epic!
Get "The Song remains the Same" video. Then put yourself in a Dark room with your best Sound System. It will be the closet you will ever get to a Led Zep Concert/Fantasy. I saw it in a 2,000 seat Cinema sitting up close and it was 70mm with Surround sound which had just come out.
I am already subscribed, but this reaction would have made me subscribe again! I really like how you manage to appreciate and analyze all of the stuff that's going on, while still letting the song draw out emotions and take you on a journey just based on feeling. That's not easy to do for a first time listen. Also Black Sabbath and Led Zeppelin are two of my favourite bands, so as long as you keep uploading these two, I am happy lol (btw, talking about ability to create atmoshpere and imagery... listen to the song titled Black Sabbath)
What a fucking good performance for an equally fucking great song. Thanks for sharing, from today I'm with you - all thumbs up. Best regards from hamburg (germany)
I have to say that your reactions are far more than someone listening to great music. The depth to which you analyze lyrics, tempo, and atmosphere of a piece of music is truly amazing. I think we all were awestruck when we first heard this track many years ago, and we dove deeper into it with every hearing of it. You have picked up on this aspect on your first listen. Other reactions only glaze the surface. They don't realize the depth of musical genius that went into creating it. Thank you for putting out a mature and informative product. So refreshing.
This song would become Jonesy's showpiece when performed live. He would improv through a keys solo and add things like bits of classical, jazz, blues...whatever he felt. They've all been talented since the beginning; Jonesy was choir master at his local church when he was 14. His performance of this from MSG was great, however, correct video links for it on UA-cam are rare to find and, of course you wouldn't know if it was correct or not until you'd listened/watched and then its too late. As I said, this was Jonesy's showpiece and in the concert movie The Song Remains The Same, the action was supposed to focus on him, but instead, every UA-cam link you find shows a hodge podge of various parts of the movie that have nothing to do with the song and really ruins it. This definitely has a bit of prog-rock feel as they always tried to explore the obscure path of music. Song meanings can be a bit "In the eye of the beholder", so to speak - the meaning you get out of their songs are unique to the individual, the way art should be. Personally, I believe this has a link to Lord Of The Rings (Robert was a huge fan). The "winds of Thor" could also be Mount Thor in Canada and he could be describing the Fellowship of the Ring on their journey across the Misty Mountains where a blizzard and avalanche almost killed them all ("the snow drives back the foot that's slow"). Of course, they're all "wearing steel that's bright and true, and carry news that must get through" meaning the ring must be destroyed in Mordor and, if successful, will "build a dream for me and you" meaning there will be peace without Sauron's evil. Different viewpoint yet not more or less valid than yours or anyone else's. Please - I *strongly* recommend you go in album/track order so you get the full evolution of their music.
Another great reaction , man, love your enthusiasm and intelligent insights. Personally I prefer Jimmy Page's mix of this track that appears on the 1990 'Led Zeppelin Remasters' triple album much better than the one on 'Houses of the holy', it just has an extra depth and warmth to it.
23 min + Song Echoes by Pink Floyd is quite the epic atmospheric song 😁🤟🎸 On their Studio album "Meddle" & live in Pompeii... both amazing versions to check out 👍
COOL! Very glad I came across this Vid, I so very much relate to it, as I was also blown away by this song many years back as a teenager. Your initial reactions are fantastic, and a fantastic song will take different listeners to different places... I can definitely appreciate 'After-World Imagery' coming to your mind, and it's articulated so well, that's Awesome! I believe though that Robert Plant, in writing these haunting lyrics, was most definitely drawing off his fascination of the (mostly) 9th to 11th century Vikings/Norseman venturing out to brutishly and mercilessly (Yep, I agree with you that is exactly what 'No Quarter' refers to..) ahh... raid-pillage/plunder mostly small villages in/about England and wide areas of Europe. In those beautiful lyric-lines you pondered - "They're wearing steel that's bright and true" - I believe simply refers to that deadly sword the warriors had hanging at their side, and - "The dogs of doom are howling more" references the 'murder in the air' , if-you-will, as they approached yet another here-to-fore (mostly) peaceful village to wreak murder/mayhem upon... Moreover, Plant had already absolutely drawn inspiration from and referenced this exact same theme - 2 albums previous - on "Led Zeppelin III", in "The Immigrant Song". For lyrical example (Paraphrased) ... "From the land of the Ice and Snow... We sweep with Threshing Oar... Our goal the Western Shore..." But again, it's how the song conjures such stark imagery (even on first listen!) which illuminates the biggest force of what makes it great! At least I believe... But Awesome Vid. man. Peace.
First time here... you're on it! This song creates an almost hypnotic, swirling storm that you are walking through. Listen to the sustain of the cymbals, and how Bonham would delay some cymbal strikes... the timing in the song swirls and swirls, losing you, carrying you along.. one of the greatest songs ever. Nobody can do this stuff but Zeppelin.
You came up with very interesting lyrical analysis. Robert Plant in particular was a massive book reader (as would any writer need to be). Yes, this song shows the bands mastery in so many areas. Listen again w/ eyes closed with no pauses.
:) Great perspective...I've been listening to this album since the 70's and have always loved No Quarter but; I just always loved the Bonzo beat and Jimmy page guitar I never thought about the lyrics.....They play this live on The Song Remains the Same movie...It's amazing to see at Madison Square Garden, back in the day...:)...Glad you liked it...
It starts as something that Pink Floyd might have conjured, but then turns to a jazz vibe and now we're off on an ancient journey. An excellent and learned interpretation. I loved it!!!
The very best rendition of this is live at Madison Square Garden. That is a magnificent, atmospheric experience. You just listen to it with eyes closed. It’s jazzy, funky and progressive. The riff is the ultimate. Jimmy hits a tone in his solo that is exquisite.
Yeah, just next level shit. Writing, playing and singing, sound production - just insane that all of this came together like it did. How fortunate we are!! Great video as always, keep up the great work!
I've been around since 1959 and have heard a wide variety of great music. One day I decided to compile a list of my favorite songs, and had no trouble deciding on "No Quarter" as one of them. The song kills me every time I hear it. Great reaction!
Imagine being 10 years old and hearing this your first time ! That Is my life It was new then and changed my life! I am a Zeppelin fan forever now can't help that !!
I don't know if you're right but it's one of the best explanations of this song that I've heard. On to the live version for another mind blowing experience.
Syed, you’ve chosen two great tracks from the greatest rock band to walk the earth. Every musician is considered one of the best if not the best. Their studio catalogue is magnificent but to watch them live is a completely different world because they do not play their songs the same as the studio or from one gig to the next. Live from MSG, this tune is a MASTERPIECE!! Jimmy Page was a highly sought studio musician who finally joined a band, The Yardbirds as their Bassist. They toured the US and Guitarist Jeff Beck burned out o Jimmy took over guitars. After the tour, the band broke up and Jimmy was left with a commitment to tour Scandinavia so he summoned fellow studio musician, John Paul Jones who plays Bass, Keyboards and various strings. The singer he wanted wasn’t available but he recommended 19 year old Robert Plant who in turn recommended his long time friend, John Bonham for drums. They toured as “The New Yardbirds”. John Entwhistle and Keith Moon of the band The Who whom Page recorded with in studio, heard of the band name and famously said, “Jimmy Page’s career is going over like a lead balloon”. After Page heard that comment, h named the band Led Zeppelin. I’d suggest you start with Led Zeppelin, Led Zeppelin II, Led Zeppelin IV just to see how the band progresses from great to greatest. Btw No Quarter live is awesome!!
Great reaction!! I still recommend going in order. They are not like most bands where they have 2 good songs per album and the rest OK fillers. LZ is unique where every song is good to great. You may miss your favorite by skipping around. Lol!!. If not, I suggest Achilles Last Stand, Kashmir, In My Time of Dying, In the Light. Just to name a few.
@@SyedRewinds I'll second this suggestion again, and for a few reasons. First, you'll not get lost in the maze of recommended songs that you'll receive. Besides, eventually every song will end up being recommended. ;) Second, you'll better learn the progression of their artistry as they moved through their 12 years together, and just how masterful Page was as a producer, especially for the time. Also, he wanted listeners to experience their music by first absorbing each album as a whole (he really didn't like single releases, which is why there were so few). By jumping around on a first listen, that's not possible. Lastly, when they burst onto the scene, we were in staggering awe. By going in order, it would be a kick for you to hear how it came to us. As a die hard LZ fan from the beginning, I guess I'd like you to experience LZ the way we did, but, of course, that's up to you. I'll follow no matter how you decide to go about it. :) BTW, it's incredible to realize that there was no auto tune back then. Most of us never got to see LZ live but we knew that what we heard on their albums was truly the way they sounded, which was stunning.
@@algoner4421 Did you ever read "Nobody ever asked me about the girls?" Lisa Robinson. She was a rock critic. She said a few people didn't like Plant and he was devastated. For years. Library has it. Great book on music.
The keyboard at the beginning that evoked a church organ. I believe it is a Wurlitzer which creates a swirling sound run through a wah-wah. This really sets the framework and mood by which the whole painting is made.
Well you nailed it !!! Well done!! JPJ adding light and shade , Page bringing impending doom and dread …and Plant taking you on a journey into the afterlife !!
You will lose your mind over the live version from THE SONG REMAINS THE SAME...Unreal. Love your channel. Keep up the great work. Enjoy the ride my man
Hi, yes a trip through hell via the turntable. As this band progressed they had a lot of songs that anyone who heard them ends up with a different opinion of the meaning...of course if you want the ultimate Zep example of this > Stairway to Heaven. It's hard to think you haven't heard this one though. They really don't have any bad songs, best band ever. I liked your reaction. I played this song over and over back when it came out. Phoenix Arizona
Your reaction is interesting. The riff for the song was inspired by a Hendrix riff from the Band of Gypsies album, although Zeppelin took it into a totally different place. The lyrics are based on a chapter from Tolkien's Lord of the Rings, called "The Paths of the Dead". If you've seen the movies it is in Return of the King extended version when Aragorn leaves behind the Riders of Rohan and has to pass into the world of the dead to rally the spirits to his cause. Plant was a big Tolkien fan. I saw them play it live in London in 1975 and they played a 20 minute version of this that was totally transcendent. Some of the live versions in 1975 Page played more of the Hendrix riff. Of course it was Jones' tour-de-force. Great to see this ancient music reaching a new generation.
Hioy shite dude……you are on top of the mythical references…..you’re a VERY intelligent reviewer. New sub. With pleasure. I hope you tackle more classic rock….. Pink Floyd, Zeppelin, Yes, Rush, Tool, Nightwish…..
Change it to "Hip Hop head fucking gets music man!" Damn dude, very insightful and deep reaction. You really really get it. Best reviews honestly. You get it.
Well discussed, informed commentary, and you have some deep insights. One of their best. Nice guitar solo over keys. "No quarter" is a medieval? term for no mercy in battle, it's a fight to the end, no prisoners taken. "They choose the path where no-one goes... They carry news that must get through, to build a dream for me and you...." I'm taking this as a generic story of the journeys of all legendary warrior heroes that have delivered us our present and future and paid the price... Worth bearing in mind the Vikings travelled to lands no-one else had. The Battle of Evermore goes with this. LOTR vibe. Yessongs from the band Yes is pretty good and has a LOTR vibe at times, high range singer too.
You are so getting it! John Paul Jones was a session player during the time Jimmy page was and he's a beast that's why Jimmy chose him- he's the unsung hero - just amazing 👏
This is one of Zepplin's songs I like to kick back, feet up, room candlelit and a glass of wine nearby. It transports me somewhere else. Of course that's true for most of Zepplin and Pink Floyd. Once again, I like your analysis, I think you're right on with the analogy of the River Styx.
I'll be listening to this all night maybe some candles are needed lol
@@SyedRewinds Candlelight for the atmosphere. This song is hauntingly beautiful.
Ah man, Floyd and Zep, possibly the two greatest bands of all time?
Lol, we used to turn on the black lights, light the incense and have a joint nearby.
@@helmedon lol, I left out some of the details of what it takes to set the right mood.....we were partial to Panama Red and Patchouli.
It’s refreshing to listen to someone who can not only appreciate the genus of music but also can properly or smartly interpret the lyrics.
It's such a simple riff, but in context and tone it is so incredibly menacing and foreboding. Jimmy is such a master of tonality.
Along with John Paul Jones
"What the hell am I hearing?" You're hearing what happens when four of the most talented musicians the world has ever seen all get together and make each other even better musicians: ethereal magic.
The story, as Robert Plant tells it, is the very first time they jammed together - this is the magic that happened. They all stopped, stared at each other, and realized how precious and unusual this was. The band was still going by "The New Yardbirds" at that time. One gig later, and the whole Yardbirds thing was out the window. This was a new animal. Led Zeppelin is, by far, (in my opinion), the greatest rock band ever. And this is the music that informed my childhood. Those of us who grew up during the 60's, 70's and 80's were truly blessed. And we took it for granted.
They had that magic right from the start, that's awesome!
Zep was a class above
Loo ok be that you are so feeling the mastery of JPJ. He was as is a master.
Some say they sold their souls for their music.
11/10 💯
Gives one the sweats 🥵
And the chills 🥶
“Like raindrops hitting the keys”
Bravo man 👏
Their musical diversity is unmatched. Lyrics are awesome. Incredible musicianship. You’re listening to the greatest rock band ever!!
Take any top ten list of their best songs, erase them from existence, and they still would easily land on top.
I've watched and been amused by music reaction videos on dozens of channels but you are offering some of the most insightful and intelligent commentary. Kudos!
You've got to watch the live version from Madison Square Garden, it will blow your mind. Plant was big into Viking mythology, I've always thought of this song as a quest.
Will check it out Kent! It'll be hard to top this studio version, this was amazing
@@SyedRewinds Definitely watch it, but please keep reacting to the studio versions- live shows are incredible, but the studio track is what the band wanted you to hear- plus, with Zeppelin, you lose so much of Jimmy’s layered guitar tracks. As I said, listen to the live shows, but react to the canon track.
Cheers
Viking stuff in general.... "The Immigrant Song", one of their shorter ones. The last verse shows that even back then Plant knew his material. It tells how after the slaughter, vikings often turned enemies into friends and equals.
And it's a great song as well.
@@SyedRewinds The 1973 MSG version is one of the few times I like the live version of a song better. The solo is much longer and one of the best ever.
@@SyedRewinds it's way better... crazy... like 2 separate songs...
One of the key characteristics of Zeppelin is what Page called “Light and Shade”…..it was about textures, contrasting a soft, often acoustic beginning and then the hammer comes down and you get massive electric guitar riffs. Page is considered one of the greatest of guitar riff masters.
this shifting dynamic is awesome, love when bands do this
Beatles, Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin. They are the three greatest rock bands of all time. They have the greatest range and deepest catalogues. Entire albums stand up as works of genius with few, if any, "bad songs." But for me, the one band that could summon the most exquisite, quintessential, most pure and unadulterated ROCK experience, with all the sex, drugs, adrenaline and heartbreak that word entails... was always Led Zeppelin. No band captured it better.
Yes! So very true!
My 3 favorite groups are Floyd, Zeppelin and Rush. The Beatles are my 4th, lol. I feel you man and cannot argue with your statement.
Tool is the best rock band in the world.
@@mushroom11g55 Even tho i love your hate your lgbt shit you're out of your mind. Tool is nowhere near.
Tool. You forgot tool
I definitely agree with those asking for the MSG live version. That got me into LZ. Also has my favorite guitar solo. Page goes off. Again, love the review.
Madison Square Garden performance has been mentioned a couple times now, will 100% look into doing this. Good to see you again Janice :)
No Quarter live 73 msg Jimmy's solo is telling you a story by itself!
There are just so many gems from this band. Your reactions remind me of mine in 1980 when I was 12. My mind was blown and still is. Off of Led Zeppelin III, Since I've Been Loving You. You may be speechless.
I still am.
Among the best blues rock , maybe the best ever recorded.
@@neilandfi probably some of the best music in general, these guys always make me feel the music
@@tymega7680 I wouldn't even say they were my favourite band... I'm not sure I've got one. But I've never heard a bad track from them.
And they are so far beyond being a band that carried no passengers. Each one of them is (rightly) recognised as a Grand Master of their instrument. Each one of them is on the "All time " list.
Added to the list! Thanks
Interesting take on the journey to hell of a warrior. I always got the impression of a small group of fierce, brave warriors making a desperate journey through a blizzard to their king to inform him of an invasion. The "dogs of doom" I assumed to be a pack of wolves hounding them, waiting for one to falter so they can take him down. They neither give quarter nor ask for quarter - they will complete their mission or die trying.
I always took this song to be a pair with their "Immigrant's Song" - both about Viking raiders and their ethos of conquest and a good death.
My good man, I am totally impressed with your internally feeling of the music, not to mention your take on each song, brilliant 😎
Some excellent analogies there Syed. The dogs of doom actually howled just after the line. It reminded me of Pink Floyd's Animals album, where Gilmore delivers a brilliant 'dog' via guitar on the "Dogs" track and Wright gives us sheep via keys and synth on "Sheep".
The live version from the movie is even better... it's like 2 songs in one.. mind blowing
Yeah, John Paul Jones is killing it in this studio version because he's playing 4 different instruments on different tracks. He's playing keyboards, piano, bass guitar and synthesized bass. Awesome! And if you like the studio version, just wait until you hear the live version. And when Plant says that line live "The Dogs of Doom are Howling More". Page uses an instrument called a Theremin for the sound of the howling dogs. And that sound? Wow!
JPJ talent as a musician is next level and with page masterminding everything, they created such a brilliant atmosphere
I was 13 when this came out on 1973 and you just couldn't get enough of it then and it just gets better with age. First time hearing your reaction and great interpretation and understanding of what the band is doing. Well done, you get it! Cheers!
What a delicate bit of piano during the middle passage. Jones is amazing.
Truly a soundscape. I'm actually envious that you're hearing this for the first time, lol. Absolutely love this tune and your reaction to it and appreciation of it and the synergy these lads had when they played together.
Thanks for listening! haha at least you can relive the first listens through me, im glad you enjoyed mate. Their chemistry seeps through on every track
@@SyedRewinds Vicarious living through the younger generations, lol! Any more recommendations from yourself? I'm always open to new music/genres and very much enjoyed B.O.B.
I'm not really good with 1st time listens, all my favorite songs took a couple listens to really click. This one took me 5 listens to get hooked and realize how cool and badass that riff is riding around with sun glasses feeling like a rocker
I have every led Zeppelin albums and have listened to them to many times to count. But dude your excitement and appreciation has excited me I feel like I did the day I got these albums. Damn I'm glad I come across your channel.
Great, literate reaction. I used to work at a radio station when this LP was released, and I had the acetate copy of this...I wish I still had it!
Anyway, it was tough to get information about this LP back then as there was no internet or Google. Zeppelin was a somewhat mysterious band, and I felt the same way about the conjured images this song expressed. So nice work! This was like a time machine, and I thank you for that.
I've not done this before, but I think this is my favourite song I've heard on the channel so far. A trip down the river Styx to meet Hades! Unreal
I think you have the right general mood, but I've taken it a different way.
The mood for me is dread, fear, but iron resolve... Like a group of warriors tasked with an impossible mission, maybe what we'd now call a "Black op", and people back at home waiting either for news of them, or some enemy kicking down the doors in the middle of the night, killing everyone inside.
When this was written, they had quite an obsession with Tolkien's "Lord of the Rings". I've always thought it was related to that in some way.
You're spot on about J-P-J. Massively underrated and hugely talented multi-instrumentalist.
You're also right about the meaning of "No Quarter"... No mercy given or expected... All in... Balls to the wall.
Not related to this, but check out JPJ's version of "When the levee breaks" with the "Playing for change" people on youtube. Dude still has the fire in his belly.
I hope you realise, this is only your top track until ... well... I don't know which ones are going to light you up, but there are many.
Bluesy / guitar at "boss" level ? That would be "Since I've been loving you".
Stadium rock on a massive scale ? Hmm... Many, but "Kashmir" I think.
Melancholic/philosophical and ... well... my all timer... "The Rain Song" (suggest you go with Plant and Page Unledded Live performance for this and Kashmir, because your chin will just hit the floor... Stunning).
Ok, I'm gonna shut up now before I suggest everything they ever recorded.
Enjoying sharing your journey with you. It reminds me of my own. :-)
Led Zeppelin - It's your favorite song till you hear the next one
@@neilandfi mate I love the idea of resolve, totally works for the tracks vibe and lyrics. Never would have thought of that!
@@RC-lc8xl haha true!
@@SyedRewinds The title makes sense with that. And "They carry news that must get through", sounds like someone slipping through hostile territory with vital info, at any cost.
Now that's a reaction from a guy whose appreciation brings joy to Led Zeppelin fans.
Haha glad you liked it mate
Another fabulous reaction. I really appreciate that you're actually listening to not just the song, but the artistry of each band member. Thanks for that. Rock on! :)
Thanks for the kind words mate!
Finally, JPJ recognized for the multi instrumentalist/arranger genius that he was! When Page wanted to form Zeppelin, he first went to JPJ because he was an established artist much like himself-soooo underrated!!
John Paul Jones quicky became my favorite member of Led Zep because I release how much he brought to the band so much going on on the background. He started another band with David Grohl the drummer of Nirvana and singer of the Foo Fighters and Josh Homme singer for Queens Of The Stone Age called Them Crooked Vultures, defiantly worth a listen.
The subtlety of this song always got me. I imagined a group of warriors leaving their village to deliver a scroll or pass info on to some other village far away
Same here .. the message that must get through... Fight to the last man is the message given as they ask no quarter... Which makes it sad that their is no escaping destiny.
And this is why I enjoy watching reaction videos! It takes me back to when I first put the headphones on and dropped the needle on this LP. I will agree that the live version from The Song Remains the Same is awesome BUT.. there are a variety of mixes. I personally favor the ORIGINAL live album version (not the CD or video), as I think the solo section is just amazing - one of my top 3 solos by Mr. Page.
Im glad my videos can take you back to the first listen, that's so awesome to me!
this is now in my top 5 reactions ever. awesome my friend... just awesome
This is the best description of this song I've ever heard! I've only just come across your channel and I'm subscribing. Led Zeppelin is one of my most favorite bands since I was 13 and I'm 55 now, and still rockin. Everything you're saying here is exactly why when Bohnam passed, they could no longer go on without him. Fantastic reaction!!!!!!!!! Btw, You have got to watch the movie The Song Remains the Same. This song is portrayed in the movie and it is epic!
I used to lay on my bed with headphones and get lost to Led Zeppelin. Love that you're loving them.
Same... :)
❤❤❤This is one of my favorite songs from Led Zeppelin....it is at the top of my list. This song is a Masterpiece!!! ❤❤❤❤❤
Love love love this reaction!!!! So mystical … Zep will live on forever
Get "The Song remains the Same" video. Then put yourself in a Dark room with your best Sound System. It will be the closet you will ever get to a Led Zep Concert/Fantasy. I saw it in a 2,000 seat Cinema sitting up close and it was 70mm with Surround sound which had just come out.
I am already subscribed, but this reaction would have made me subscribe again! I really like how you manage to appreciate and analyze all of the stuff that's going on, while still letting the song draw out emotions and take you on a journey just based on feeling. That's not easy to do for a first time listen.
Also Black Sabbath and Led Zeppelin are two of my favourite bands, so as long as you keep uploading these two, I am happy lol (btw, talking about ability to create atmoshpere and imagery... listen to the song titled Black Sabbath)
What a fucking good performance for an equally fucking great song. Thanks for sharing, from today I'm with you - all thumbs up. Best regards from hamburg (germany)
I know led zeppelin for years never heard this song 🎵 good stuff bro
Enormously receptive of you. Once again made me rediscover a favourite song.
I have to say that your reactions are far more than someone listening to great music. The depth to which you analyze lyrics, tempo, and atmosphere of a piece of music is truly amazing. I think we all were awestruck when we first heard this track many years ago, and we dove deeper into it with every hearing of it. You have picked up on this aspect on your first listen. Other reactions only glaze the surface. They don't realize the depth of musical genius that went into creating it.
Thank you for putting out a mature and informative product. So refreshing.
Sooo proud to have lived through those times, of musical genius in the UK, greatest country on Earth bar none!.
This song would become Jonesy's showpiece when performed live. He would improv through a keys solo and add things like bits of classical, jazz, blues...whatever he felt. They've all been talented since the beginning; Jonesy was choir master at his local church when he was 14. His performance of this from MSG was great, however, correct video links for it on UA-cam are rare to find and, of course you wouldn't know if it was correct or not until you'd listened/watched and then its too late. As I said, this was Jonesy's showpiece and in the concert movie The Song Remains The Same, the action was supposed to focus on him, but instead, every UA-cam link you find shows a hodge podge of various parts of the movie that have nothing to do with the song and really ruins it. This definitely has a bit of prog-rock feel as they always tried to explore the obscure path of music. Song meanings can be a bit "In the eye of the beholder", so to speak - the meaning you get out of their songs are unique to the individual, the way art should be. Personally, I believe this has a link to Lord Of The Rings (Robert was a huge fan). The "winds of Thor" could also be Mount Thor in Canada and he could be describing the Fellowship of the Ring on their journey across the Misty Mountains where a blizzard and avalanche almost killed them all ("the snow drives back the foot that's slow"). Of course, they're all "wearing steel that's bright and true, and carry news that must get through" meaning the ring must be destroyed in Mordor and, if successful, will "build a dream for me and you" meaning there will be peace without Sauron's evil. Different viewpoint yet not more or less valid than yours or anyone else's. Please - I *strongly* recommend you go in album/track order so you get the full evolution of their music.
Awesome info and interpretations in this comment Henrietta!
@@SyedRewinds I'm a huge Zep fan and always happy to share info.
@@SyedRewinds I second Henrietta, go in order to experience their progression!
That terrible winter of 87 UK the version off the live Album Song Remains The Same. Total bummer of a Winter.
When I was in college, I used to walk around campus at 2 in the morning listening to this with my Sony walkman. A different age.
Another great reaction , man, love your enthusiasm and intelligent insights. Personally I prefer Jimmy Page's mix of this track that appears on the 1990 'Led Zeppelin Remasters' triple album much better than the one on 'Houses of the holy', it just has an extra depth and warmth to it.
Thanks for the heads up, I'll check that out personally off camera. Im gonna be playing this one all day anyway
Can’t wait for “Physical Graffiti”
Wonder if you could do it front to back.
IMO and many other long time Zep fan’s favorite album.
New sub here...loved your Zeppelin analysis...Dazed and confused...studio version...enjoy
haha thanks will defo check that out
This live full version in 1973 at MSG is magnificent!! Need more volume on the song.
23 min + Song Echoes by Pink Floyd is quite the epic atmospheric song 😁🤟🎸
On their Studio album "Meddle" & live in Pompeii... both amazing versions to check out 👍
COOL! Very glad I came across this Vid, I so very much relate to it, as I was also blown away by this song many years back as a teenager. Your initial reactions are fantastic, and a fantastic song will take different listeners to different places... I can definitely appreciate 'After-World Imagery' coming to your mind, and it's articulated so well, that's Awesome! I believe though that Robert Plant, in writing these haunting lyrics, was most definitely drawing off his fascination of the (mostly) 9th to 11th century Vikings/Norseman venturing out to brutishly and mercilessly (Yep, I agree with you that is exactly what 'No Quarter' refers to..) ahh... raid-pillage/plunder mostly small villages in/about England and wide areas of Europe. In those beautiful lyric-lines you pondered - "They're wearing steel that's bright and true" - I believe simply refers to that deadly sword the warriors had hanging at their side, and - "The dogs of doom are howling more" references the 'murder in the air' , if-you-will, as they approached yet another here-to-fore (mostly) peaceful village to wreak murder/mayhem upon... Moreover, Plant had already absolutely drawn inspiration from and referenced this exact same theme - 2 albums previous - on "Led Zeppelin III", in "The Immigrant Song". For lyrical example (Paraphrased) ... "From the land of the Ice and Snow... We sweep with Threshing Oar... Our goal the Western Shore..." But again, it's how the song conjures such stark imagery (even on first listen!) which illuminates the biggest force of what makes it great! At least I believe... But Awesome Vid. man. Peace.
The album versions of Zeppelin songs are great, but the live versions are always on a whole other level!
will be checking them out soon enough Jim
I love this guy’s analysis. It’s more than most reaction videos. Him and Elizabeth Zharoff give some of the most thoughtful analysis on UA-cam.
First time here... you're on it! This song creates an almost hypnotic, swirling storm that you are walking through. Listen to the sustain of the cymbals, and how Bonham would delay some cymbal strikes... the timing in the song swirls and swirls, losing you, carrying you along.. one of the greatest songs ever. Nobody can do this stuff but Zeppelin.
You forgot to light up a fatty and turn on the blacklight before playing this. That's time traveling to the 70's. Great reaction!!!
You came up with very interesting lyrical analysis. Robert Plant in particular was a massive book reader (as would any writer need to be). Yes, this song shows the bands mastery in so many areas. Listen again w/ eyes closed with no pauses.
Now this is a reaction. I would love to go back in time to hear this song for the first arm again. Zeppelin is the absolute Pinnacle of music
:) Great perspective...I've been listening to this album since the 70's and have always loved No Quarter but; I just always loved the Bonzo beat and Jimmy page guitar I never thought about the lyrics.....They play this live on The Song Remains the Same movie...It's amazing to see at Madison Square Garden, back in the day...:)...Glad you liked it...
Smart analogy of the song ,, after 45 years of hearing it I get it now.
Plants improvisation during fade outs are legendary
It starts as something that Pink Floyd might have conjured, but then turns to a jazz vibe and now we're off on an ancient journey. An excellent and learned interpretation. I loved it!!!
The very best rendition of this is live at Madison Square Garden. That is a magnificent, atmospheric experience. You just listen to it with eyes closed.
It’s jazzy, funky and progressive. The riff is the ultimate. Jimmy hits a tone in his solo that is exquisite.
I love reviewing the reviewer. PRICELESS.
Channel is growing fast, just waiting for it to snowball!
Yeah, just next level shit. Writing, playing and singing, sound production - just insane that all of this came together like it did. How fortunate we are!! Great video as always, keep up the great work!
I've been around since 1959 and have heard a wide variety of great music. One day I decided to compile a list of my favorite songs, and had no trouble deciding on "No Quarter" as one of them. The song kills me every time I hear it. Great reaction!
This is the most enlightened interpretation I've ever, ever heard about this song. Thank you, that was brilliant!
Imagine being 10 years old and hearing this your first time ! That Is my life It was new then and changed my life! I am a Zeppelin fan forever now can't help that !!
My head would explode
I don't know if you're right but it's one of the best explanations of this song that I've heard. On to the live version for another mind blowing experience.
Your impressions are spot on. This is exactly why it had such an impression on my generation. We understood everything you are describing.
GOAT = Led Zeppelin .
True!
This is one of my top Zep favourites. It transports me to a dream world. Greatest band no doubt at all.
You had me at The Stank Face into the 'Whoa!' - when the riff hits (great musical appreciation reaction, brilliant)
New sub here. Loved how your reaction matched mine from 49 years ago!! Can't wait to watch more!!
To be all those things-plaintive and moaning, heavy and dark…it’s also a crazy groove.
Syed, you’ve chosen two great tracks from the greatest rock band to walk the earth. Every musician is considered one of the best if not the best. Their studio catalogue is magnificent but to watch them live is a completely different world because they do not play their songs the same as the studio or from one gig to the next. Live from MSG, this tune is a MASTERPIECE!! Jimmy Page was a highly sought studio musician who finally joined a band, The Yardbirds as their Bassist. They toured the US and Guitarist Jeff Beck burned out o Jimmy took over guitars. After the tour, the band broke up and Jimmy was left with a commitment to tour Scandinavia so he summoned fellow studio musician, John Paul Jones who plays Bass, Keyboards and various strings. The singer he wanted wasn’t available but he recommended 19 year old Robert Plant who in turn recommended his long time friend, John Bonham for drums. They toured as “The New Yardbirds”. John Entwhistle and Keith Moon of the band The Who whom Page recorded with in studio, heard of the band name and famously said, “Jimmy Page’s career is going over like a lead balloon”. After Page heard that comment, h named the band Led Zeppelin. I’d suggest you start with Led Zeppelin, Led Zeppelin II, Led Zeppelin IV just to see how the band progresses from great to greatest. Btw No Quarter live is awesome!!
Great reaction!! I still recommend going in order. They are not like most bands where they have 2 good songs per album and the rest OK fillers. LZ is unique where every song is good to great. You may miss your favorite by skipping around. Lol!!. If not, I suggest Achilles Last Stand, Kashmir, In My Time of Dying, In the Light. Just to name a few.
many ppl have recommended this to me now, maybe worth doing it all in order
@@SyedRewinds I'll second this suggestion again, and for a few reasons. First, you'll not get lost in the maze of recommended songs that you'll receive. Besides, eventually every song will end up being recommended. ;) Second, you'll better learn the progression of their artistry as they moved through their 12 years together, and just how masterful Page was as a producer, especially for the time. Also, he wanted listeners to experience their music by first absorbing each album as a whole (he really didn't like single releases, which is why there were so few). By jumping around on a first listen, that's not possible. Lastly, when they burst onto the scene, we were in staggering awe. By going in order, it would be a kick for you to hear how it came to us. As a die hard LZ fan from the beginning, I guess I'd like you to experience LZ the way we did, but, of course, that's up to you. I'll follow no matter how you decide to go about it. :) BTW, it's incredible to realize that there was no auto tune back then. Most of us never got to see LZ live but we knew that what we heard on their albums was truly the way they sounded, which was stunning.
Agreed. It will be cool to "grow" with them. Keep in mind when they released their first album drummer n singer were 19. Stupid levels of talent.
Friggin "Achille's," lol.. I've had drummers playing 50 years go, "You really pick some hard songs."
@@algoner4421 Did you ever read "Nobody ever asked me about the girls?" Lisa Robinson. She was a rock critic.
She said a few people didn't like Plant and he was devastated. For years.
Library has it. Great book on music.
Led Zeppelin "What Is And What Should Never Be"....Nuff Said.
Every Zeppelin song is worthwhile for a listen
@@timothyjesse5787 Agreed.
..they carry news that must get through.. !! (that's what the mission is all about) Thanks for this reaction!! 💪😁
great analysis --- I would love to hear more
The keyboard at the beginning that evoked a church organ. I believe it is a Wurlitzer which creates a swirling sound run through a wah-wah. This really sets the framework and mood by which the whole painting is made.
Well you nailed it !!! Well done!! JPJ adding light and shade , Page bringing impending doom and dread …and Plant taking you on a journey into the afterlife !!
You will lose your mind over the live version from THE SONG REMAINS THE SAME...Unreal. Love your channel. Keep up the great work. Enjoy the ride my man
Led Zeppelin buddy ...they just set the bar to high...period!!!
Zeppelin was always "top dog" of all the great bands of our time.
Hi, yes a trip through hell via the turntable. As this band progressed they had a lot of songs that anyone who heard them ends up with a different opinion of the meaning...of course if you want the ultimate Zep example of this > Stairway to Heaven. It's hard to think you haven't heard this one though. They really don't have any bad songs, best band ever. I liked your reaction. I played this song over and over back when it came out.
Phoenix Arizona
Your reaction is interesting. The riff for the song was inspired by a Hendrix riff from the Band of Gypsies album, although Zeppelin took it into a totally different place. The lyrics are based on a chapter from Tolkien's Lord of the Rings, called "The Paths of the Dead". If you've seen the movies it is in Return of the King extended version when Aragorn leaves behind the Riders of Rohan and has to pass into the world of the dead to rally the spirits to his cause. Plant was a big Tolkien fan. I saw them play it live in London in 1975 and they played a 20 minute version of this that was totally transcendent. Some of the live versions in 1975 Page played more of the Hendrix riff. Of course it was Jones' tour-de-force. Great to see this ancient music reaching a new generation.
You really have some great reactions. The raindrop idea is perfect.
Hioy shite dude……you are on top of the mythical references…..you’re a VERY intelligent reviewer. New sub. With pleasure. I hope you tackle more classic rock…..
Pink Floyd, Zeppelin, Yes, Rush, Tool, Nightwish…..
Change it to "Hip Hop head fucking gets music man!" Damn dude, very insightful and deep reaction. You really really get it. Best reviews honestly. You get it.
Well discussed, informed commentary, and you have some deep insights. One of their best. Nice guitar solo over keys. "No quarter" is a medieval? term for no mercy in battle, it's a fight to the end, no prisoners taken. "They choose the path where no-one goes... They carry news that must get through, to build a dream for me and you...." I'm taking this as a generic story of the journeys of all legendary warrior heroes that have delivered us our present and future and paid the price... Worth bearing in mind the Vikings travelled to lands no-one else had. The Battle of Evermore goes with this. LOTR vibe. Yessongs from the band Yes is pretty good and has a LOTR vibe at times, high range singer too.
You are so getting it! John Paul Jones was a session player during the time Jimmy page was and he's a beast that's why Jimmy chose him- he's the unsung hero - just amazing 👏
The guitar in this song is absolutely AWESOME, amazing track. Zeppelin are one of the best bands ever 👍😎
You totally have to watch the MSG live version. Good intro to their live. It will blow your mind!
Wow! What fantastic commentary! You really pick up the feel of the sounds.
Keep on keepin’ on with this channel. Best of luck with all your future ventures. I know you’ll do great.
Really appreciate the level of commitment and focus your putting into this....
Robert 's on Ludes .. "Dudes on Ludes should Not drive " haaaauu
You got it , you good