Violin vs Fiddle, what's the difference?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 4 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 75

  • @ThomasMHead
    @ThomasMHead 11 місяців тому +187

    Cousins with different regional accents.

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +11

      I'm here to answer the hard questions, Thomas. 😂

    • @ThomasMHead
      @ThomasMHead 11 місяців тому +1

      How did my comment get 100 Likes in 2-ish weeks!? 🤯

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +4

      My joke was apparently popular for a little bit 😂

    • @ThomasMHead
      @ThomasMHead 11 місяців тому +1

      @@SheaViolinthat's what I hope! That you've cracked through to the next layer of The Algorithm's favor!

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +2

      I guess I should be funny more often 😂

  • @Scorchedlnfern0
    @Scorchedlnfern0 11 місяців тому +130

    In case anyone is actually wondering, fiddle is a style of playing an instrument, not a separate instrument.

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +30

      I was hoping people would be able to drawl that conclusion 😜

    • @sofalicious
      @sofalicious 11 місяців тому +1

      @@SheaViolinhah!!

    • @timgrant1219
      @timgrant1219 3 місяці тому +2

      Actually, no.
      VIOLIN/FIDDLE
      Since I've been with Lindsey Stirling for nine years, I have read many posts either saying that Lindsey plays the fiddle or that the violin and the fiddle are the same instruments. So, I investigated it myself. This is what I learned…
      The violin came from Italy and the fiddle came from Scotland. Now, both meanings of both words do come from the same origin. So, maybe they were the same at the beginning but both went their different ways. That's why the distinction - two different instruments. And the fiddle has a flatter bridge. And has a lot more different kinds.
      The violin is tuned to G D A E. The fiddle is tuned to A E A E, D D A D, G D G D, G D G B, A E A C#, or E D A E. This means that they are tuned differently. And not the same. Although, they could be.
      Now, for the biggest difference. The two are different. You can go to almost any store and ask for a violin OR a fiddle. Amazon sells both, violins AND fiddles. And all the receipts will say violin OR fiddle...NOT violin/fiddle. Lindsey has 25+ violins now. No fiddles, no violas. And when she bought her Yamaha Violin, it said Violin -- not violin/fiddle. Lindsey doesn't like fiddles. She says that they just feel weird and they are not tuned well or properly. And I can't see why one would want 2 strings of A and 2 strings of E. But some people are weird.
      Now, this all being said, one could flatten a violin's bridge and restring the strings to match the fiddle's range. They may need extra strings, and/or maybe a B string. But you can turn your violin into a fiddle or vice versa. But you can only have one. Is the bridge flat? What is it tuned to? If you pick one up and the bridge is rounded, it is a violin...not both.
      Just because you can fiddle on a violin, doesn’t make them the same. Just as you can throw your sandwich like a Frisbee, it doesn’t turn it into a Frisbee.
      So, in conclusion, the two are different BUT they can be interchanged. One can make a fiddle from a violin AND one can make a violin from a fiddle.
      As long as there is a distinction, I shall maintain that distinction.

  • @fiddlerjack
    @fiddlerjack 2 місяці тому +1

    What's always made sense to me is that fiddle is a blanket term for Bowed instruments played under the chin AKA violins and violas

  • @williamgregory1848
    @williamgregory1848 3 місяці тому +5

    They’re both the same instrument, but the key difference between a fiddle and a violin is simply in the style of music they are used to play. Violin players are typically used to perform classical music, such as in orchestras and string quartets. Fiddle players, on the other hand, typically perform country music, and other folk music.

    • @timgrant1219
      @timgrant1219 Місяць тому

      Actually, no.
      VIOLIN/FIDDLE
      Since I've been with Lindsey Stirling, I have read a lot of posts either saying that Lindsey plays the fiddle or that the violin and the fiddle are the same instruments. So, I investigated it myself. This is what I learned…
      The violin came from Italy and the fiddle came from Scotland. Now, both meanings of both words do come from the same origin. So, maybe they were the same at the beginning but both went their different ways. That's why the distinction - two different instruments. And the fiddle has a flatter bridge. And has a lot more different kinds.
      The violin is tuned to G D A E. The fiddle is tuned to A E A E, D D A D, G D G D, G D G B, A E A C#, or E D A E. This means that they are tuned differently. And not the same. Although, they could be.
      Now, for the biggest difference. The two are different. You can go to almost any store and ask for a violin OR a fiddle. Amazon sells both, violins AND fiddles. And all the receipts will say violin OR fiddle...NOT violin/fiddle. Lindsey has 25+ violins now. No fiddles, no violas. And when she bought her Yamaha Violin, it said Violin -- not violin/fiddle. Lindsey doesn't like fiddles. She says that they just feel weird and they are not tuned well or properly. And I can't see why one would want 2 strings of A and 2 strings of E. But some people are weird.
      Now, this all being said, one could flatten a violin's bridge and restring the strings to match the fiddle's range. They may need extra strings, and/or maybe a B string. But you can turn your violin into a fiddle or vice versa. But you can only have one. Is the bridge flat? What is it tuned to? If you pick one up and the bridge is rounded, it is a violin...not both.
      Just because you can fiddle on a violin, doesn’t make them the same. Just as you can throw your sandwich like a Frisbee, that won’t turn it into a Frisbee.
      So, in conclusion, the two are different BUT they can be interchanged. One can make a fiddle from a violin AND one can make a violin from a fiddle.
      As long as there is a distinction, I shall maintain that distinction.

  • @Amir_Akhmetzyanov
    @Amir_Akhmetzyanov 11 місяців тому +5

    Wow thanks! I was wondering what is the difference, you helped me a lot 😂😊

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +2

      You're welcome! I'm glad I can answer the hard questions ;)

  • @ImportantAntWorking
    @ImportantAntWorking 11 місяців тому +47

    Answering the tough questions here

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +3

      Really putting my journalism experience to work.

  • @julesviolin
    @julesviolin 11 місяців тому +5

    We have hours of leg pulling with this subject !!!!!

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +1

      You've got to play the joke slowly to pull the leg-ato!

  • @josieb9402
    @josieb9402 12 годин тому

    cute..😊 I've been listening to you a while because of Mcp. I finally subbed. you're amazing!

  • @jamesbarros950
    @jamesbarros950 11 місяців тому +37

    In my experience the difference is about $10k, and that’s just the dry cleaning bill for what they wear

  • @erikoftheinternet
    @erikoftheinternet 11 місяців тому +19

    oh Shea, we need more of this content

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +1

      😆 my children tell me to stop playing with my words more than I tell them to stop playing with their food, so I could probably do more

  • @aaronl3460
    @aaronl3460 11 місяців тому +7

    😂 You got me! 👏 👏 👏

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому

      😂 Thanks for refraining from checking the comments ahead of time for the full effect!

  • @MacGWA
    @MacGWA 18 днів тому

    In the words of the immortal Frankie McWhorter: “nobody cares if you spill beer on a fiddle!”

  • @salemzarves
    @salemzarves 2 місяці тому

    The sound makes a difference, the voilin sounds more smooth and the fiddle has more of a gravely and harmonic sound

  • @Goated_Earl_Sweatshirt
    @Goated_Earl_Sweatshirt 11 місяців тому +1

    if anyone is actually wondering, it depends on tge genre

  • @TravelwithJubayer-
    @TravelwithJubayer- 6 місяців тому

    It's really great💜

  • @King_krobit
    @King_krobit Місяць тому

    Same instrument different style of playing. It’s like the difference between flat picking and thumb strumming on guitar.

  • @darthcalculusmusic
    @darthcalculusmusic 6 місяців тому

    Absolutely perfect

  • @RawMeat1226
    @RawMeat1226 2 місяці тому

    I love this

  • @timgrant1219
    @timgrant1219 3 місяці тому

    Hello. Well said. It was funny and a bit inaccurate but well said.
    VIOLIN/FIDDLE
    Since I've been with Lindsey Stirling for nine years, I have read many posts either saying that Lindsey plays the fiddle or that the violin and the fiddle are the same instruments. So, I investigated it myself. This is what I learned…
    The violin came from Italy and the fiddle came from Scotland. Now, both meanings of both words do come from the same origin. So, maybe they were the same at the beginning but both went their different ways. That's why the distinction - two different instruments. And the fiddle has a flatter bridge. And has a lot more different kinds.
    The violin is tuned to G D A E. The fiddle is tuned to A E A E, D D A D, G D G D, G D G B, A E A C#,
    or E D A E. This means that they are tuned differently. And not the same. Although, they could be.
    Now, for the biggest difference. The two are different. You can go to almost any store and ask for a violin OR a fiddle. Amazon sells both, violins AND fiddles. And all the receipts will say violin OR fiddle...NOT violin/fiddle. Lindsey has 25+ violins now. No fiddles, no violas. And when she bought her Yamaha Violin, it said Violin -- not violin/fiddle. Lindsey doesn't like fiddles. She says that they just feel weird and they are not tuned well or properly. And I can't see why one would want 2 strings of A and 2 strings of E. But some people are weird.
    Now, this all being said, one could flatten a violin's bridge and restring the strings to match the fiddle's range. They may need extra strings, and/or maybe a B string. But you can turn your violin into a fiddle or vice versa. But you can only have one. Is the bridge flat? What is it tuned to? If you pick one up and the bridge is rounded, it is a violin...not both.
    Just because you can fiddle on a violin, doesn’t make them the same. Just as you can throw your sandwich like a Frisbee, it doesn’t turn it into a Frisbee.
    So, in conclusion, the two are different BUT they can be interchanged. One can make a fiddle from a violin AND one can make a violin from a fiddle.
    As long as there is a distinction, I shall maintain that distinction.

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  3 місяці тому +1

      I appreciate your passion for the violin and fiddle! It sounds like you've really done your homework on this!

    • @timgrant1219
      @timgrant1219 3 місяці тому

      @@SheaViolin
      Thank You. 😃
      Again, very well said, true, and very nice.
      Thank You again. 🙂

  • @Duran264
    @Duran264 11 місяців тому +2

    Doesn’t violins specifically used for fiddling have a flatter bridge?

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +3

      Not necessarily, you can set it up differently with a flatter curve on the bridge, but I think it makes it harder to play. Most fiddle players play a standard setup.

  • @alexmfholmes
    @alexmfholmes 2 місяці тому

    Nice

  • @Lovasvook
    @Lovasvook 11 місяців тому

    Me I love violin 😂❤ my best ❤

  • @maxraabe5745
    @maxraabe5745 27 днів тому

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤🎉

  • @jumpforj0y107
    @jumpforj0y107 7 місяців тому

    the ungodly snork that erupted from me just now

  • @annapiotrowska1912
    @annapiotrowska1912 8 місяців тому

    🤩🥰🤗☺️🌹

  • @KinG_KinG-33
    @KinG_KinG-33 8 місяців тому

    I'm sure you get another question asked a lot

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  8 місяців тому +1

      You're right, I do! But I'm sorry I don't have any lesson spots available right now because I'm focused on the performance side. Sorry to disappoint!

  • @potatofries8392
    @potatofries8392 11 місяців тому

    my opinion but a fiddle is just country

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому

      Or even more broadly, "folk"

  • @fernando47180
    @fernando47180 11 місяців тому +1

    I came here eager to learn something new. Must say that I leave slightly amused, but certainly disappointed. Then again, I can just Google it later.

  • @SeveralAnts
    @SeveralAnts 11 місяців тому

    Ay que lindo

  • @HANABI_Music
    @HANABI_Music 11 місяців тому

    😂😂😂

  • @diyVT
    @diyVT 7 місяців тому

    Violin music is culture, fiddle playing is agriculture.

  • @jeremyLesleyreview
    @jeremyLesleyreview 11 місяців тому

    Not to offend y'all but this is one of the worst fake southern accents ever

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +2

      Thanks! Hopefully the joke still worked. 😂

    • @jeremyLesleyreview
      @jeremyLesleyreview 11 місяців тому

      @@SheaViolin it was still kinda funny I'm actually a cello player

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому +1

      @@jeremyLesleyreview nice! I just started teaching myself cello this year. It's a way more physical instrument than violin. I started going to the gym to build up some more arm endurance so I could play with more control!

    • @jeremyLesleyreview
      @jeremyLesleyreview 11 місяців тому

      @@SheaViolin I am still in school and actually this year for our concert we are playing "Die Meistersinger von Nürnberg" and Dvorak symphony NO. 9 movement 2 and 4 plus the theme from howls moving castle

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  11 місяців тому

      Oh I love howl's moving castle! I'm planning to do that one with a harp player some day.

  • @Trustworthy_McLegitimate
    @Trustworthy_McLegitimate 9 місяців тому

    ooooh.... now i wanna hear Wild Arms theme played by them fiddle

    • @SheaViolin
      @SheaViolin  9 місяців тому +1

      Hehe it's on my list of ideas for some day!