POV you’re a cute little machine taking an existential stroll around an old commercial district when you hear this certified banger crackling through some ancient speakers
THE VOCALS IN 4:16 IS SO BANGER SMART WTF THE WAY IT SOUNDS LIKE WRETCHED AUTOMATON AND WRETCHED WEAPONRY ARE IN A CONVERSATION WITH EACH OTHER, THEN WHEN THEY GRADUALLY RESUME LAYERING AND HARMONIZING AT AROUND 4:32 IS JUST 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Excellent mashup! The perfect blend of old and new! Also, for those of you who didn't know: in "The Fire Of Prometheus" novella, it is revealed that P-33 (or Beepy, as Kalil affectionately called him) is the one that caused the Machines to gain consciousness! An obscure fun fact I felt I had to mention since the thumbnail shows P-33 and a stubby and most people don't know they're actually connected!
The best part was that this story started in a set of novella's in the Drakengard 10th anniversery collection for Drakengard 3. So a critical emotional connection between Nier and Nier Automata, the thing that helps make the plot what it is with machines being sentient, was originally found in a set of stories in a collector's edition for a completely different universe.
I don't know how you can say this so confidently, I have a hard time picking even a top 3 in either game, let alone my most favorite (but the organ part in shadowlord's castle is quite high, and I love the synth in end of the unknown)
I've seen many people trying to mix NieR OST and sadly failing as these tracks are so good by them self, that it's quite hard to not take away their individual charm but you good sir are creating greatness. Ever since Fleeting Shadows I am genuinely hoping for another mashup as you understand the song and make them feel more like a duette instead of just putting two tracks into one
Emi Evans' performance on Nier's tracks always makes me emotional, I love these games and I love these soundtracks and I appreciate the work of everyone involved in it, just amazing video games and art pieces. Now I also have you to thank for the amazing mashup. Thank you Jonathan!
I've listened to Fleeting Shadows around a couple hundred times by now, already. Thanks for gracing us with another phenomenal NieR mashup out of the blue. Please keep making these, they're truly special. ♥
I think the issue is that the term mashup is technically correct, but it has become more recognized of it being multiple (as in, more than two) songs chained together, and the term remix is also correct but nowadays understood as something more transformative... If I had to give it a name, I'd say this is more of a "duet/blend", the first one having some interesting implications since the vocals play a major role here. But this is something I just came up with on the spot, and I wouldn't pretend to make your job better than yourself. Naming things is one of my Aquiles' Heel after all Edit: I just had a fleeting idea. Would it be correct to call it an "orchestration" as well? Food for thought...
I’m surprised only one other channel has done this mashup between Wretched Automatons and Wretched Weaponry. Of course none compare to this masterpiece you’ve managed to cook up once again. Amazing work as always🙏🙏🙏
This mashup perfectly showcases how this Automata song is a "sequel" to a corresponding Replicant song Hopefully more mashups can be made to visualize just how similar the songs between the two games are
Very nice and interesting mashup! It sometimes feels like there are parts that oppose each other or rival to be the main part, which for me causes some tension. But not necessarily in a negative way. I can't really describe it haha. But I think it does make my favorite part feel all the more satisfying and surprising, as at around 4:43 they suddenly work together and harmonize as one ^^ Also I'm excited to hear a new video essay is coming up, hopefully about one of these/another NieR track (But I'm not gonna be disappointed if not)
Im going to have to ask for that platinum Fallen Elmaik with a huge pepe and incrusted diamonds back, the one I awarded you for outstanding achievement in the field of musical excellence last year. That award seems insufficient due to the sheer magnificence of this masterpiece. I shall have more jewels and precious metals added, forgive me.
I KNEW IT!!! I knew both Wretched Automatons and Wretched Weaponry were always meant to go together, and in a way, you proved it! Thank you for this headbanger of a song!
I love this so much, I played automata before the replicant remake, and going through the junk heap felt like seeing the start of what would become automata, and wretched automatons felt like a song that would fit perfectly in automata, it probably served as inspiration for the soundtrack as a whole, love to hear these two songs as a single piece
Thanks Jonathan! After hearing Fleeting Shadows for at least 100 times, I am so excited for this one! Keep them coming! Also very hyped for the Emil Video coming up!
He probably goes in-game and sets all sound settings to 0 except for music, or at least that’s what I would do. But to extract certain parts? There’s probably just some software, hell even AI could possibly like what Paul McCartney did for the last Beatles song.
![Penacony's main theme is pure magic [Honkai: Star Rail]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/CEfMzagGqj8/mqdefault.jpg)
![ZZZ Battle Music: "Quackjacker" Suite [Zenless Zone Zero]](/img/n.gif)
WHO LET HIM COOK
Somehow this is funny to me every time you say it, thank you
We did
Well said @@NarutoUzumaski
He's not cooking anything. He's making mixes of music.
@@TheALPHA1550 he cooked too hard
i really like the visual breakdown of the mix
A breakdown of a mashup of TWO songs!
Yes, more of this please 🙏🏼
POV you’re a cute little machine taking an existential stroll around an old commercial district when you hear this certified banger crackling through some ancient speakers
Then outta nowhere comes a robot with creator issues and her simp to kick your gears in
@@pancakedan7883 Such is life in the ancient factory
wich ancient speakers? you talking about Replicant Speakers from over 11.000 years ago?
machine lifeforms been real quiet ever since this dropped
In their defense, I hear they've become as gods
@@JonathanBarouch This is the best comment I have ever seen lol
5:22 wretched automatons singing aaaaaaaa and wretched weaponry singing iiiiiiiiiiiiii is perfect
THE VOCALS IN 4:16 IS SO BANGER SMART WTF THE WAY IT SOUNDS LIKE WRETCHED AUTOMATON AND WRETCHED WEAPONRY ARE IN A CONVERSATION WITH EACH OTHER, THEN WHEN THEY GRADUALLY RESUME LAYERING AND HARMONIZING AT AROUND 4:32 IS JUST 🔥🔥🔥🔥
*wretched weaponry
ah! thank you !
Awesome. I always loved how wretched machinery was a sequel to wretched automaton and now you combined both. Amazing remix
Missed opportunity to call this mashup wretched wretched
Excellent mashup! The perfect blend of old and new!
Also, for those of you who didn't know: in "The Fire Of Prometheus" novella, it is revealed that P-33 (or Beepy, as Kalil affectionately called him) is the one that caused the Machines to gain consciousness! An obscure fun fact I felt I had to mention since the thumbnail shows P-33 and a stubby and most people don't know they're actually connected!
The best part was that this story started in a set of novella's in the Drakengard 10th anniversery collection for Drakengard 3.
So a critical emotional connection between Nier and Nier Automata, the thing that helps make the plot what it is with machines being sentient, was originally found in a set of stories in a collector's edition for a completely different universe.
I didn't know this! Thank you
@@TokenOracle not a different universe though...
No way, i didn´t know that
@@Fami_Salami Isn't it a different universe in the same multiverse?
Both of these songs are my favorites in their respective games. This is fantastic, thank you.
I don't know how you can say this so confidently, I have a hard time picking even a top 3 in either game, let alone my most favorite
(but the organ part in shadowlord's castle is quite high, and I love the synth in end of the unknown)
I just finished Automata last week, and Replicant a few months ago. My god this is the greatest mashterpiece I've heard of Nier music!
THIS IS SOOO GOOOODD WHAA5T? AND THE VISUALIZATION IS SO BRILLIANT I'VE NEVER SEEN ANYTHING LIKE THIS BEFORE
I've seen many people trying to mix NieR OST and sadly failing as these tracks are so good by them self, that it's quite hard to not take away their individual charm but you good sir are creating greatness. Ever since Fleeting Shadows I am genuinely hoping for another mashup as you understand the song and make them feel more like a duette instead of just putting two tracks into one
love it how the two songs reach that glow-up moment xD
Emi Evans' performance on Nier's tracks always makes me emotional, I love these games and I love these soundtracks and I appreciate the work of everyone involved in it, just amazing video games and art pieces.
Now I also have you to thank for the amazing mashup. Thank you Jonathan!
This is so good. You need to make a whole album of Nier mashups and remixes.
I kid you not, I really wanted to put these together as well, but I'm so glad that you did. Amazing work as always Jonathan, you are a gem.
Awesome wretched melody
Never clicked on a video so quickly. NieR upload by Jonathan? Happy Wednesday indeed (cries)
Brilliant, my jaw is on the floor. Amazing work!
I've listened to Fleeting Shadows around a couple hundred times by now, already. Thanks for gracing us with another phenomenal NieR mashup out of the blue. Please keep making these, they're truly special. ♥
Become as gods....become as gods....
This is such a soothing remix... and yet I cannot say it's not striking me with a feeling of bittersweet melancholy... (Which is a good thing)
You still doing a video on wretched weaponry id honestly love that cause this song is kind of pivotal
When I read "mashup/remix" I wasn't sure what to expect. But it surely wasn't this beautiful masterpiece
I'm not thrilled with the title myself, so let me know if you can think of a better thing to call whatever this is
I think the issue is that the term mashup is technically correct, but it has become more recognized of it being multiple (as in, more than two) songs chained together, and the term remix is also correct but nowadays understood as something more transformative...
If I had to give it a name, I'd say this is more of a "duet/blend", the first one having some interesting implications since the vocals play a major role here. But this is something I just came up with on the spot, and I wouldn't pretend to make your job better than yourself. Naming things is one of my Aquiles' Heel after all
Edit: I just had a fleeting idea. Would it be correct to call it an "orchestration" as well? Food for thought...
@@AmaiarAiramand thank you for such a detailed and careful explanation!
Man, you're awesome! Thank you for this treat!
bro cooked so hard with this one
I’m surprised only one other channel has done this mashup between Wretched Automatons and Wretched Weaponry. Of course none compare to this masterpiece you’ve managed to cook up once again. Amazing work as always🙏🙏🙏
babe wake up jonathan barouch made a new mashup and laid it down smooth as hell as per usual
This is fantastic! Keep up the great work, Jonathan! Love the visual aide for the mix too. Very well done! God bless you!!!
WE MAKING IT OUT OF THE FACTORY WITH THIS ONE🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥
You SERIOUSLY have a talent for these mashups dude holy crap!!!😮
YOOO WHY DID I MISS THIS ?? UA-cam ?!!?!?!?!??!?! Once again thank you !
I need more of this nier mashups please ❤❤❤
This mashup perfectly showcases how this Automata song is a "sequel" to a corresponding Replicant song
Hopefully more mashups can be made to visualize just how similar the songs between the two games are
Incredible, I’m glad I got the notification for this early!
you are in my head, composing what I cannot. Thank you for your content
slick as hell. i wish i had saved that other wretched machinery mix, too.
AAAA the mix sounds amazing!!
HOW DID I MISS THIS BANGER OMG
The mashup we always needed. Can't wait for more mashups in the future
These are so good! Awesome job! Need more nier and nier automata music mash-up!
This is up there with "Wretched Medley" as one of the best mashups
Very nice and interesting mashup!
It sometimes feels like there are parts that oppose each other or rival to be the main part, which for me causes some tension. But not necessarily in a negative way. I can't really describe it haha.
But I think it does make my favorite part feel all the more satisfying and surprising, as at around 4:43 they suddenly work together and harmonize as one ^^
Also I'm excited to hear a new video essay is coming up, hopefully about one of these/another NieR track (But I'm not gonna be disappointed if not)
This is SO good
This is a masterpiece, soo glad i got to listen to this
I really like this. It's so good
This works insanely well
I always love when a mashup has a careful artistic direction put in it
Im going to have to ask for that platinum Fallen Elmaik with a huge pepe and incrusted diamonds back, the one I awarded you for outstanding achievement in the field of musical excellence last year.
That award seems insufficient due to the sheer magnificence of this masterpiece. I shall have more jewels and precious metals added, forgive me.
WE ARE SO BACK
This is WONDERFUL, oh my God.
I KNEW IT!!!
I knew both Wretched Automatons and Wretched Weaponry were always meant to go together, and in a way, you proved it! Thank you for this headbanger of a song!
Dude! WTH?! This is so good...😭
I love this so much, I played automata before the replicant remake, and going through the junk heap felt like seeing the start of what would become automata, and wretched automatons felt like a song that would fit perfectly in automata, it probably served as inspiration for the soundtrack as a whole, love to hear these two songs as a single piece
INCREDIBLE
Thanks Jonathan! After hearing Fleeting Shadows for at least 100 times, I am so excited for this one!
Keep them coming!
Also very hyped for the Emil Video coming up!
Remember folks. Beepy didn’t do anything wrong. 😞
Beepy and the little shadow is so horribly tragic
@@RepTheoAndFriendsall in nier is pure sadness
Wow, this is SUPER seemless. Amazing job as usual!!
Beautiful. Was not expecting such a gem.
Instant banger🤘
wowwwwwwww
woooow!! me encantó!! eres un genio!! 🥰
This is awesome
I wanted this so baaaad
Listened to those two songs back to back quite a few times
they match together so perfectly
OOOOOOOOOOOGGGHHHH YESSS YESS AGAIN
Another Great Remix Jonathan looking forward to the next essay coming up
Me listening to this while my phone’s getting notifications
Me: Shut up phone! I’m trying to listen to a banger remix of the machines!
MOM! JONATHAN JUST DROPPED A NEW NIER REMIX!
Good show man, this is amazing.
Brilliant.... simply Brilliant...
the next 1 would be "Grandma" mashup / remix ??
What a great remix! I like both of the tracks!
Another beautiful mashup, love your videos!
The funny thing is, the mashine music feels organic
Is this a bribe? Is this just a bit I am committed to? Who knoooooows
GOD DAMMIT YOUNG MAN WHY DID I SAY ANYTHING
(thank you but oh my god)
@@JonathanBarouch WE’RE THE SAME AGE
(Tee-hee)
THIS IS SO GOOD
Yeeesss! Your Mashups are the best!
Another banger from my man!!
I've been waiting for this
You are a genius for this!!! 🫨🤯
Oh wow I am so glad this popped up on my recommended
i've never been this happy to be part of the early gang. oh my god.
you said you used parts of the tracks that aren’t featured in the game! that’s dedication my friend!!
I worded that poorly, my bad! What I meant is those parts are much less audible in the OST but they are definitely present
Such a haunting song.
THE OG IS BACK YESSSSS
So sick
Does anyone know where to get the source files? Wanting to try my hand at something similar
He probably goes in-game and sets all sound settings to 0 except for music, or at least that’s what I would do. But to extract certain parts? There’s probably just some software, hell even AI could possibly like what Paul McCartney did for the last Beatles song.
Man it sure be nice to see a new nier mashup soon....👀👀👀
this really gives the vibe that the machine lifeforms and beepy are related
Oh but they are... 😈
Can't wait for Grandma²
Where'd you goooooo make more music theory videooooos.
At this rate, I'm gonna expect more in the future
You gotta do a video about ending E and "Carrying the weight of the world"
i want to eat this, delish
I cried a bit, it was great 🥲💖✨️
Could you do a music analysis of made in abyss? They have really beautiful pieces.
Everyone shut up, Jonathan Barouch posted another banger!
Would love to fight a boss jaming to this mix, that was insane!
Please tell me this means we're getting another Nier video soon
I can only rewatch your older ones so many times 😭😭
I JUST READ THE DESCRIPTIPN LETS FUCKING GOOOOOOO