Resident Evil - PS1 vs Saturn - Game vs Game feat. Miketendo
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 вер 2024
- In this Halloween Crossover with Miketendo, the Spencer Mansion beckons. Mike and Eric dive in to pit Resident Evil: Director's Cut on PlayStation versus Resident Evil on Saturn.
Dude, You Haven't Played This Game?! Resident Evil REmake - • Dude, You Haven't Play...
Check out Miketendo's channel: / dongled
Oh...the struggle to decide on a Halloween episode. Nice ringtone too. Overall great opening skit!
thanks! i think i've got a good one for next year, so hopefully will save me the trouble!
The only thing that came to mind when you guys mentioned the Director's Cut, all I could think of was...
*_The BASEMENT TRUMPET._*
Its cool to note that you could play the original Resident Evil 1,2, 3 and Code Veronica, all on SEGA Hardware. You don't even need to get a Playstation or Gamecube.
As a matter of fact, its probably better to get them on SEGA consoles anyway for the following reasons.
1) The SEGA Dreamcast supports VGA output which has the best picture quality for Resident Evil games
2) Resident evil 2 and 3 for the SEGA Dreamcast come with their own unique special features
3) All of the Resident Evil games that came out after Code Veronica (Resident Evil Zero, Resident Evil Remake, and Resident Evil 4) all have had HD remakes on current and last generation systems making the progression seamless between the games in the series.
Resident evil part 1 wasnt released on the Dreamcast only on Saturn
Being a huge resident evil 1 fan I have to point out some things. First of all on the ps1 jill is the only one who gets 3 save ribbons, while chris gets 2 per pickup (and a lot less pickups). The original resident evil (non-directors cut) is the hardest of the ps1 versions. Capcom changed a few minor things for the directors cut and some enemies were nerfed, such as the hunters now die in one rocket launcher shot. They were trying to make certain enemies more vulnerable to certain weapons I believe, but it made the game slightly easier. Another thing to note is that the directors cut (non-dualshock version), has a problem. It does not work with the sony dualshock controller, which is pretty much standard. I had to use a 3rd party controller or a ps1 digital controller. Advanced/arrange mode is an interesting addition however I prefer the original. In advanced mode you will get a gun that blows zombies head off making all zombies incredibly easy. And as you stated never play the dualshock version with the game-wrecking music! Overall I choose the original resident evil ps1. I don't like enemies being nerfed even in a minor way, and the only other difference it seems is that chris is not smoking a cigarette in his intro. Someone else said that the zombies arms don't get blown off in the original, only the directors cut, I am not sure about that one. Thanks for the video I do want to play the saturn version, with more challenge (maybe) and the golden tyrant I never knew about that. I think that perhaps the saturn version is the same base game as the original ps1 release, but I do like a challenge, unfortunately not gonna buy a saturn just to play it probably. Original ps1 version with chris is already quite challenging. Play with Chris, it is much harder and scarier!
Regarding the loading times between rooms on saturn I think you may need to check your disc or laser. The PSX version is faster but there is no way in hell my my copy is as slow as it is showing in your video, honestly. That's the only issue I take with this otherwise excellent video :) Great work.
i wondered the same thing, honestly, i had some other issues with my disc, but unfortunately for the saturn, that was my experience. I need the get the thing resurfaced and give it another go to see perhaps a more authentic RE Saturn experience.
Game vs Game It's a shamr that's how it was for you but figured it's something to make a note of on your video in an annotation not to mislead people into thinking it's as bad as it looked on here. Again awesome stuff though and it's a true classic, it's great to see people playing it for the first time enjoy it as much as those of us who played it back in 96/97 :)
you are right, posted a little note.
I only had that loading from room to room issue when my original Saturn was about to die. My current Saturns aren't too far behind the PS1 version. Both which I have.
Don't throw away your Saturns! Just grease the lens rails with silicon spray or something. Works like a charm.
Resident Evil 2 - PS1 vs N64 vs Dreamcast vs GameCube, vs PC vs Tiger Electronics!
vs Game.com!
Its cool to note that you could play the original Resident Evil Trilogy and Code Veronica, all on SEGA Hardware. You don't even need to get a Playstation or Gamecube.
Rob Mitchell but still curious about resident evil 2 or 1.5 on Saturn but they never make them
GameCom hands down
@@stopthrm clearly a sega bum boy
We've been talking about this collaboration for almost a year, and it really paid off. This was so much fun and I look forward to working on something special in the future with you!
definitely, really happy with how it's come together! we'll definitely have to put together some more projects :)
Best ep ever! I've always kind of like the look of the Saturn's dithering. It always just kinda reminds me of cool looking Saturn games, but yeah, PS1 wins for sure. On the plus side, the Saturn ver has a fucking cool ass box.
haha thanks Jared, i definitely don't have anything against dithering techniques, but getting into that generation it's surprising it was still around instead of using transparency effects. and yeah i never got the doom-vibe guy (presumably Chris) on the PS1 cover with the wonky eye, zombie on black is way more bad ass!
I would like to say that the saturn does do transparencies well. but it's VERY hard to program. games like burning rangers and panzer dragoon saga show how well it could be done.
I like the crossovers that you do with other UA-camrs..other crossovers are generally pointless and the guests offer little to the video as a whole, but the guests in your crossover vids actually add good analysis. nice job!
thanks! i've tried writing others in to share the presenting load as evenly as possible, glad it pays off! thanks for watching!
Berry doesn't exactly have a different dialogue in the plant boss scene ( in the PS1 version), he says the same lines but with more enthusiasm. in the Saturn version he sounds like he just woke up and hasn't had his coffee yet. Very low and groggy sounding.
The reason the Saturn version doesn't have translucency, is due to the lack of the use of the VDP2 chip. There are plenty of Saturn games that have translucency.
I think the Saturn version did pretty well all things considered. To be fair the PS1 original was intended to take advantage of that hardware. Not sure Capcom ever thought about Saturn originally for the game.
Great vid, really well made. Really looking forward to the next one.
Cheers Dan!
This are still such awesome Games, I got all the Versions ;-)
Love them all, especially the DIRECTORs CUT Version.
Which Version you like the most from RESIDENT EVIL 1 ???
Console Wars sent me. Good stuff, and your Castlevania episode was also very good.
I just found this channel through Miketendo.
BTW when I'm done with part 2. Gonna check out some of your other episodes.
awesome! our plan worked! :) glad to have you
The Gamecube REmake had such amazing atmosphere. The recent HD ports only made it all the better.
seriously excited to check out the rest of RE1's 87 versions
That game might be the best survival horror of all time and one of the best looking games ever (for its time)
Mike's the best! This is an awesome collab between you two :)
isn't he though?? thanks for watchign and glad you enjoyed it!
Retro channels definitely need a Halloween special. I really like holiday special themed episodes on my favorite youtube channels because it gives me another thing to look forward to in the holidays and gets me in the spirit of the holiday.
Strange enough i've still never played this original resident evil. I remember always seeing the directors cut ps1 version available at the rental store and thinking it looked super cool so i have no idea why i didnt' rent it ever. I know i'll eventually get around to playing this and beating it since i feel like its a must to experience the first since its such an iconic franchise now.
Very nice video intro, Great video in general. Really enjoyed it, thanks.
got me feeling all warm and comfy
7:26 you mean *Saturn* version, right? I love the Sega Saturn as a competitor to the Playstation; I think they should have made an analog controller for it with two sticks similar to the Dualshock.
Always nice to see a new GvG video. :)
thanks! always nice to see fans eagerly awaiting the next release :)
If saturn games where well programmed. Transparency wasn't a problem. If you see panzer Dragoon zwei, sonic R. The last one wasn't even possible on ps1. But still, Resident Evil on Saturn is a great game.
Sort of, it wasn't really an issue of being "well programed", but more an issue of the way the Saturn composited the images generated by its two graphics processors together. While VDP2 can do true transparency it can't receive more data from VDP1 after the fact so it has to make do with the initially processed image from VDP1. VDP1 meanwhile cannot do transparency and generates everything as opaque, but VDP1 can tell VDP2 to make something transparent at the same time it hands over the image. The issue arises when an object from VDP1 needs to be behind another object from VDP1 that is flagged to be transparent. VDP2 essentially just receives a single flat image from VDP1 and then goes to work on it like Photoshop, and like I said it can't get more data from VDP1 at that point, so anything behind the transparent effect has to be generated by VDP2 or else it simply doesn't exist because VDP1 accidentally covered it up with an opaque "transparent" object before handing it off. The thing is VDP2 only handles the background in most cases, all the models and sprites are done by VDP1, so if they had tried to make the water in Resident Evil truly transparent Jill's/Chris's legs and the sharks would disappear below the water line because VDP1 drew the water opaque and then VDP2 turned it transparent later. The dithered mesh pattern is the only practical way around that problem.
If you play through Radiant Emerald on Sonic R there's a part where you should be able to see another part of the track through the part that you're on, but while you can see it going under, it vanishes underneath the part you're on even though the whole track is transparent. This is because VDP1 generated the track as solid and opaque, and while VDP2 turned it transparent in relation to the background layers it couldn't go and rebuild that other part of the track that was covered up originally.
Good as always, I think you got confused when you said the Playstation version will run you shorter and think you meant the Saturn version, looking forward to part 2, is it just comparing the ps1 to gc or may we get some extra versions like Deadly Silence?
It's mostly a review of REmake with some mention of PS1 for comparison, as well as the Wii/HD versions. The video is up on my channel so feel free to click it if you're interested in what we have to say about it. :)
nooooo! you are right, thank you for pointing that out, i put a little annotation to try to help clarify. i don't know how many times i listened to that line and didn't actually hear i said the wrong damn thing. thanks though for watching and enjoying all of the other words i said correctly!
i am thinking at some point i'll come back around to check out the remakes and other ports (really curious about Deadly Silence) to see how the series progression affected the tone of the original in its various forms over the years
How both of them compere to the PC version? it was the one I played as a young lad.
The Saturn and PSX games are more similar than different. I understand why people would prefer the PSX version, although many people would prefer the Saturn controller and some people prefer the graphics. In the end of the day a hardcore fan of Resident Evil should get both consoles and games because you cannot get the complete experience by limiting yourself to one version of the game. Despite their extreme similarity they have a unique look and feel. The Saturn version is not a downgrade of the PSX version, just a different take on one of the most important games and arguably the most important mid 90's game.
I may be in the minority, but I prefer the Saturn version. I like the controller better and the graphics I always thought were more appealing. I agree, you can't go wrong either way.
Your show is really awesome, I love it! Subscribed and looking forward to future videos!
Covering Resident Evil on Halloween seems to be a UA-cam right of passage. Pretty spot on with this one. Saturn ports rarely come off better. Splatterhouse next year?
haha, are you saying i pick low-hanging youtube review fruit? it really did feel like a coming of age of sorts, my second major crossover and first time delving into RE (only ever played a bit of RE4 before) so i'm fine with that :) as for Splatterhouse, i have considered it as an eventual episode, but main thing standing in my way right now is no TurboGrafx :( i do have a potential topic for next year though, on the more obscure list.
Game vs Game heh. everyone has to cover resi eventually. You've got a unique format for it though. I should have planned out a Halloween thing this year. are turbografx as expensive to get in the US as they are here? we've got a pc engine from Japan but it doesn't work too well.
yeah can be absurd here, especially if you want the CD attachment or the Duo. one day i'll have one.
They are great little consoles with some real weird quirks depending on where you get one. I'd settle for an emulation console but probably not a market for that seeing as it was never that huge a seller.
the RetroFreak thing supports it
5:32 ish
This is misinformation. The Saturn can do transparency just fine. SEGA complicated the hardware last minute and didn't really hand out a ton of documentation for the devs, so a lot of them resorted to dithering because it was quicker to code.
i know, discovered this after publishing the video (doh!). is the annotation not up on the video anymore? i had put one up to correct that.
I didn't see it because I was on mobile. My b
Hey awesome episode! I always see a Saturn version at a local game store and always wondered how it was different. I only have an original copy so I'll have to get one of those Director's Cut copies!
thanks man! that unfortunate thing with the Saturn copy is its price, complete you're looking at $80-$100+ (someone on eBay right now is asking $150... geez!), Director's Cut might run you $30 tops. can't go wrong there!
Yeah, the Saturn one seems a little pricier and since the PlayStation one seems to be the superior version there's really not much of a point unless I want to collect one for collecting's sake. I'll be on the lookout for a Director's Cut copy! Thanks for the response!
If you get a Saturn, you're better off getting hold of an ODE to play the games. Unfortunately the best Saturn titles can go for upwards of £150, and a quite appalling £500-1,000 for Panzer Dragoon Saga (I hate scalpers). I've got the original physical copy of RE for Saturn and Director's Cut for PSX. Funnily enough, they both cost me £45 each. The rest of my Saturn physical games collection (about 18 games in all) has some that cost £70+ each. My ODE though was £120 and that allows me to play hundreds of games via micro SD, it just depends on whether you want to own the actual games themselves I guess?
I must be the only person in existence who likes original/director's cut better than Remake.
Remake is a good game don't get me wrong, but removing the added complexity of having to burn the corpses of zombies that I've already killed is why I like director's cut so much. It feels more direct and less contrived.
No, you're not the only one. I personally never see the point with remakes; the originals are almost always just fine.
@@PeediSigel i prefer the original , but the remake was amazing too
I have both versions and everything you said is on point. The loading, colors, save speeds, and opening doors speeds. I must say from the public eye the Ps1 graphically looks better. In the Saturn version the faces were almost unrecognizable looking like a bunch of squares mashed up together.
What's the difference between the black and green label Director's Cut PS version? I played the green one, back in the day.
the main thing is the greatest hits version has a completely different soundtrack from the original black label, which most people don't care for - i don't ave any experience with it, myself. the other big thing is that some of the green labels (i don't think all of them, just certain version numbers) offer dual shock controller support so you can use the analog stick to move instead of the d-pad.
Thank you sir!
Code Veronica on the dreamcast was/is Still the best resident evil game 👌
fakk you I think it's the weakest. Different strokes...
I like the Gamecube version better.
Dreamcast Rules!
Awesome video, I've never played 1-3 all the way through but I really like 4. Highly recommend.
before this, RE4 was the only one i'd played even a bit (tho went through too much ammo and am stuck escaping the town), watched my roommate play a bit of RE3 but that was the extent of my RE history
While RE for Saturn might look much worse than the PS version with its blocky, choppy, fat characters and abysmal transparencies (Tomb Raider is even more cringeworthy) and plagued with excesive loading times, the 2D capabilities of the console were fantastic.
Andrew Gamer Lol goddamn exaggerate much? The Saturn version does not look "much worse" then the PS1 version.
Enjoyed this video quite a lot, great game, pure gem and its soundtrack.
You could have been a Jill Sandwich
I mean, a game being harder is kinda a good thing as long as it's not immensely harder. And the characters do look better on Saturn. I'm going with Saturn. Just my opinion
I prefer the Saturn's control's over the Ps. The D pad feels much better.
Nice video, although I'm a bit surprised that you didn't mention the content censored in the West version of the game (even though is widely known, but still)
Nice; never played the Saturn one before so this is cool to see.
yeah i was really curious about it going into this, unfortunately had some issues with my disc as you may have seen my note on the loading times sample... but still holds up really well
Yeah; gotta love that voice acting in this game too lol. If you like old school games, btw, feel free to check out our show as well.
been subbed for a while, my friend! i've enjoyed everything of yours i've watched, really enjoyed your no-death Friday the 13th run/walkthrough from a while back.
REmake so good especially since it's now on the Nintendo switch.
Resident Evil DS should be compared to these cause it's the original RE on the DS but using 3d graphics instead of pre rendered graphics.
As a big RE fan, this was a very interesting vid. Though, I personally prefer the Dual Shock Director's Cut version. Yeah yeah, the soundtrack has a couple of pretty bad tracks (the one everybody loves to mock is the one for the kitchen) but 90% of it was pretty atmospheric and made the game even more immersive.
If you're curious, I recommend listening to "Quieto" and "Quietamente", two tracks from the arranged soundtrack that I think are awesomely creepy. Just search for the arranged soundtrack album "Biohazard Symphony 91".
Acting classes with the janitor
Miketendo is the man.
Thanks dude! :)
I have yet to explore the first game. My first experience was with RE2, but I've always wanted to visit the first.
Never played Resident Evil!? I seriously cannot believe that you have never played RE. I am hoping that was a joke as it was such a big game for its time.
Look back at this video and pay attention to the end of Barry's revolver. It gas dithering when he fires tge weapon...it looks like he is killing the zombie with rainbows.
Love me some Game vs Game!
would have been fun watching you playing the game for the first time
Resident Evil 1, now that's a game.
Capcom felt the *Japanese* dub was too bad?
Dear god.
Dear GOD.
"Saturn wasn't as capable as Playstation"
No, it was as capable and could do things the PS1 could never do, it was the architecture, and SEGA not updating their graphics library/programming tools that held it back. Games like Sonic R, Burning Rangers, Panzer Dragoon, Quake and more proved that the hardware was very capable in the right hands.
Even modern programmers are squeezing more out of it than ever, like XL2 - ua-cam.com/video/yI-dmi9T5vM/v-deo.html
Fantastic.
Why didn't you show Zombie Wesker?
Is that a Wii case you are using for the Saturn Resident Evil game?
Just a white DVD case. I do the same for Sega CD, but with blue ones. Saturn and Sega CD stuff is way too pricey to spend on CIB, so I get disc only and print covers from thecoverproject.net for standard DVD cases.
Nice video, not pretentious or too flashy
Gv.G, would like you to collaboratte with guys at Console Wars, Sega and Nintendo. Also, The guys from Game Sack. But I really dont know about what exactly....
the Console Wars guys are awesome, i've met them a couple times at Too Many Games, great dudes! would love working with them on something. unfortunately don't know the Game Sack guys so i think there's not much hope for something like that :p
A more fair comparison would have been the original PS1 version instead of the Director's Cut version up against the Saturn version. I am glad you chose to stay away from ReMake for this video as I'm probably the only Resident Evil fan that absolutely hates ReMake. Visually I liked it but that's about it.
Same, however I just hate remakes in general. If it's not broken...
You should do Resident Evil 2 and 3
definitely looking into it :)
Great vidoe my fave game ever. U should check out the PC version also. When beaten. U can go back thru the game with a gun with unltd ammo. Chris gets a machine gun and Jill a Mac 10. It's really fun u can run thru the game again and own even kill the snake first time if u want
You guys should've mentioned the European as well, since it's also based on the Japanese version.
Do the remake and re2
do resident evil 2 on the n64 and PlayStation
saturn for clarity,
saturn RGB signal and color better than ps1 on RGB colors
saturn have faster changing camera with many places in the rooms in this game , it is faster and better thing , it make game more enjoyable , ps1 camera freeze the character some milliseconds then changed ,
Saturn is one of , if not my favorite system, but the Playstation is superior graphically in this comparison, imo anyway. Light sourcing much better also.
Zombie Wesker & new enemies > everything Playstation offers
Sorry yo. Eitger way, awesome vid!
and thanks :)
Uzi pistol is awesome
Everything was so great about the Director's Cut ne xecept the atmosphere which was destroyed by the different soundtrack.
Why would you compare the Saturn version to the Director's Cut instead of RE Vanilla? On top of that the Vanilla RE PSX version is far superior to the shoddy directors cut. Director's Cut is so bad, it's sad.
Either not Saturn original case to storage msnual and original back art🤔🤔🤔 ...but I really love your videos 😙❤😙
I think Sega Saturn version looks better and more realistic, I played both and now I play the Remastered HD version on PC, this game is a masterpiece
I have both, the Saturn version is really poor graphically. It's still a good game though.
The Saturn definitely COULD handle transparencies, but unfortunately programmers were too lazy to get the best out of the console. Check out games like Panzer Dragoon Zwei/Saga, Duke Nukem, Quake, Exhumed, Shining Force 3, Dead it Alive, Grandia and others for the visuals potential it had. Nights was awesome too. Because PSX was easier to program 3D, everyone assumed Saturn was the weaker console, when in fact it was the better all round machine for 2D and 3D, and probably had more powerful specs on paper. It always frustrated me that it rarely got the attention and respect it deserved from game designers and the public. Don't get me wrong, I still own both machines, and they both have quality titles, along with the N64. I honestly feel like gaming went downhill after these machines (well, maybe after the Dreamcast, PS2 and Gamecube). Something about modern machines I just can't get into, as much as I try.
You guys are part of keeping the retro scene in resurgence, and I applaud you all for that!
Great work! You got a sub from me!
so......... chessy........
Collaboration!!!
OMG!!!
haven't heard from you and GF in a while, hope you guys are doing well!
Isn 't this kind of cheating?....you are comparing an original game to an enhanced remake with added features...why not compare the original ps1 version with the original saturn version instead of comparing the original saturn version to the ps1 directors cut?... bit 1 sided
i see where you're coming from, but swinging the other way, the saturn version compared to the original PS release would be an enhanced version with added features. every release of RE1 changed or updated something, it makes my head spin. in the end i looked at it as giving both platforms their best chance.
I personally think the latest remastered release of the 2002 remake is the best way to play the game, graphically, and is the most accessible to new comers, since it has modern controls, plus it does not require to own older consoles
I've only played the GH DC...
if mullet mike approves you get a subscribe from me
I get really tired of intros. Just go to your video please
Suuuuu guuuuud
Your game vs game graphic comparisons are awesome. Please keep making more.
thanks, appreciate that! and i certainly plan to!
Gta 2 ps1 vs dreamcast
Ulon
lol
I kinda prefer the Saturn version for the visuals
30 seconds into this video and I can't make it until the end- lame.
Saturn never had a directors cut so saturn beats out the original re on ps1.
Now if saturn had a directors cut you can compare the two.
Direct Cut sux. Biohazard is The best Version.
That's some cringe acting. Get straight to the game next time please
This is so depresing... The saturn had better hardware than the play station. If you just bothered to look at the technicall specifications, you dont even need to be something like a software ingeenier (or at least an student like me) to be able to tell which one had the more powerful hardware, (The satun can only show Quad polygons but that was done on porpouse because of the very uncapable Cpu's of that time.) Also, the saturn was totally capable of displaying transparencies.
Also, the Saturn had an added Battlemode which wasnt in the any of the PSX Releases.
Yup, I bought the Saturn version day 1. Still prefer it to the ps1 version.
PS4 has the best Resident Evil game, but not PS1 or Saturn!!
Lame and bad acting lol