The two research papers that we are referencing in the video - 1. An Ancient Genome from the Indus Valley Civilization - pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31626767/ 2. The Formation of Human Populations in South and Central Asia - www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6822619/
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳haHum khi se bhi aai ho hme sirf dikhta hai chankye ka bharat or hme wo bharat banana hai kisi bhi keemat pe hamare dill mai bharat rehta hai hum bharat k liye jeete hai or bharat k liye hi mar bhi jaaenge sochenge nhi soch sirf 1 hai no 1 pe bharat hona chahiye baat khatam
Thank you for the references. I just don't get why many Indians can't accept the simple fact that people throughout history have migrated to different places. Migration isn't a recent phenomenon, it's an inherent trait of being human. That's how we adapted & survived for so long!!
@Being Ricky seriously bro the reasearch papers are based on or influenced by West and they want to prove that we are descendents of west it's as simple as that .
What are you going to prove by this research paper or articles they are us influenced by US you are promoting the things that US wanted to be promoted . The Aryans invasion theory is completely fake . Guys please refer abhijeet chavda's videos not this
It doesn't matter from where our ancestors were belongs to today we're just Indians that's the most important thing, I'm from Assam and my ancestors were from Mongolia, that's why we kinda look like Thai or Chinese, Korean whatever you say but we're just Indians by our heart and our language
don’t matter what ur ancestor are I find the diversity of Indian interesting because it shows that’s it’s the cross road of civilization. I my self have ancestry from southern Europe, North Africa, Middle East, Melanesia, sub-Saharan Africa, east Asia and Central America. I’m Mexican mestizo
northeastern people did not originate from Mongolia, their ethnic origin lie in Tibeto-Burman region, there is no ethnic group in India which traces their ancestry back to Mongolia.
it does not matter for me also, but i need to reply to those who spread either wrong information for some political agenda or any other kind of gain. An influencer should not spread his opinion with any kind of biasness . I am only replying because these theories that our ancestors came from some other place and made us civilised (which is wrong) brings some kind of inferiority complex to Indians . These theories where planted in Indian people's minds by the British during there rule . And now these theories are promoted by west to show themselves superior . These superior feeling of the west started the world war 2 by Hitler (he believed German to be superior race) and now these theories promote racism in west . Indians and other south asian peoples suffers a lot due to this . A very few research has been made by our Archaeological survey of India about our history and culture and that is why we do not have proper evidence about our rich culture of old times. Also these theories are made to divide India into many parts . And this is mainly done by the west,who do not want a powerful India again which will replace the west again as a global super power. These statements that south Indian genes are different from North Indian are completely wrong . First of all south and north are just directions . and secondly there are Scientifically proven evidences that the genes are same and there is the colour difference just because of the distance from the equator . when we live very near to the equator we get a lot of uv rays from sun which can lead to cancer and other diseases thats why our body produces more amount of melanin which makes dark protective layer on our skin to protect from extra uv rays. At least we should know the actual history and should not be influenced by some wrong or biased theories. By the way I also leave in Tinsukia, Assam, India
@@gurjindersingh3843 it's idiotic. Cz u consider the base theory as ki bahar se to pakka aaye hai hum.. So stupid have I not known about your princess citranganda from manipur who married to arjun. ....... The mindset of you all people's that we had come to india from outside is very wrong,,, yesterday one guys studied very hard. He was a thakur aur raghuwanshi. Telling us that he is from thokarian civilization from europe. 😂 ohk so now prabhu shree ram and his ancestory is also from europe. So stupid We are from here only. Thesee theories are created and supported since their are many foreign religion in India and a particular religion says we are not from outside. We are from outside then you are also to sustain their political benifitts
bhyi ye insan kitna desperately facts ko chhupa rha hai, go and watch Abhijit chawda on Aryan invasion theory and discovery+ series on Sinauli archeological discovery.
I am from south india andhra...yes aryan theory is false....but we are dravidians....not based on colour of skin but based on language... we proud that we are dravidians... saying we are dravidians doesnt mean we support aryan theory...
Why we can't be under one umbrella ...why divide....we also have our states language and culture but we never identified anything other than bharatvarsha
I'm Chinese and my bf is Indian. I found India is a very fascinating country and has very intersting history. This is a perfect video, thank you so much!
all chinese scholars always found India fascinating. they used to come to India for learning lot of cultural things and took it back to china like ayurveda, buddhism, tantra, and many more. You can research on it, they used to study in Nalanda Takshila etc
@@SpecialGlobalTalks yeah what a coincidence that everyone residing in a country whose borders were made less than 100 yrs ago have the same dna makup
According to Europeans and britishers- buddha was a european named broady...But when he came to china he was called Boaqin and whe in last days..He came to india...Indians as were illitrate...Were unable to pronounce his same so they start calling him Buddha(a name an old age given to be mocked). Later this name became famous and broady was known as buddha. Also he brought 'ficious religiosa' from England to India which was later known as peepal tree.
Hindu 🕉️ dharm is a single religion code or representation for all majority indian subcontinent faith and culture 🙂 and that all faith and culture made in indian subcontinent 🙂
WHAT SHIT YOU ARE SPITTING .. I KNOW THAT IN BACKWARD AREAS THESE THINGS EXIST BUT IN CITIES AND TOWNS THIS THING DOESNOT EXIST ... I DONT BELEIVE IN CAST SYSTEM I HAVE ALL TYPE OF FRIENDS ...
@@_Tushar_Sharma... In which city you leave, I was in Jaipur and owner before giving me room for rent they are asking my caste and I told them I am from Shedule Caste and they did not rent me their room. Casteism is most relevant today and especially in BJP state Casteism is on another level. I am staying by my words Yes, Upper Caste see themselves and always want themselves to Superior to Lower Caste because they think themselves as Agents of God.
@@_Tushar_Sharma... Don't want to take conversation forward but just wanted to say that Casteism is practised in every part of India today, even in Jaipur I heard from my Brahmin Friend his family teaching him to don't eat with Dalit and He said this himself. So saying that Casteism is only exists in villages is wrong.
I am a South Indian from Coastal Karnataka , we speak Tulu - a language which is either the mother of Dravidian languages or the child of Dravidian languages because we have words which are in Tamil , Telugu , Kannada , Malayalam and Korean !! Surprising fact is : I have genes from iranian side from my dad and China from my mom’s side …
Mohak, I definitely urge you two things. Please consider: 1) A video on Harappan Language/Indus Valley Civilization. 2) Book recommendations in the end of videos like this which can satisfy our need to learn more about the topic of discussion.
Harrapan was Dravidian civilization. It was wiped out because of the floods. Aryan theory is real.. but I don't think it was an invasion. If you look up the North Indian DNAs of people like Jatt they have central Asian South Asian and Irish Caucasus DNA
@@peteck007 It was not completely a Dravidian civilization, people from Indus Valley Civilization after its collapsed mixed with people of Ancient South India and spread their language.
What I smell in your comment is a latent dissatisfaction with the facts presented in the video. Your imploration for a separate research conducted by 'Indian' scientists suggests that you downplay all the archaeological and biological evidences put forth by the researchers of the west. Now I understand that we Indians tend to respect our research better, but we also tend to forget more often than not that what others do is more likely to be bias free, especially in matters as sensitive to our sense of identity and belonging like these. An average researcher from the west is least likely to interpret the data with an implicit bias because whatever the conclusion of his findings be, it has no bearing on his sense of identity. You could see in the video itself that two Indian researchers working together and publishing at the same time couldn't agree about the languages of the Indus valley civilization. What could be a possible reason? Well, simply realising that the matter is sensitive and that for very many Indians, even the researchers themselves, it will be disheartening to come to terms with some conclusions of the findings. Now, obviously the current government will some day 'fund' an investigation and maybe you'll have results being published, but tell me honestly, will you be able to judge that the researches 'funded' by government like the extreme right BJP can ever be free of bias?
I live in North Punjab, Pakistan. It seems like we have been living in this area for thousands of years and we have become converted Hindus to Muslims because the stories our ancestors used to tell us were all Hindu related stories. I want to know which Hindu caste we belong to. We don't even belong to upper caste and our forefathers have been doing weaving job means julahas
@@parthgautam4605 Yes there is a vast difference when we talk about Aryan Invasion Theory and Aryan Migration Theory we often interchangeably use Invasion and Migration thinking that both are the same but The truth is they're not as we say "The devil is in the details" It completely changes the context and conclusion Let's understand How * First if we talk about Aryan Invasion Theory it states that a group of people called Aryans invaded northern India and destroyed the Indus Valley Civilization. Context and conclusion: Now as we know that when we're talking about Aryan Invasion Theory it means that Aryan were foreigners who were probably either killed, subjugated or displaced the native or indigenous people (dravidians) to south who were living in India (specifically in Indus Valley Civilisation) for 1000 of years. After the Invasion Aryan forcefully imposed the Vedic Society in North India. All these arguments can only be concluded if there was an Invasion because an Invasion is an act of controlling something or someone by force. Nowadays many people use this Invasion I repeat Invasion Theory to support North Vs South Divide as they argue that dravidians are the first Indian. This Theory had been used by the British to create a division between North Vs South and justify their colonial ambitions. * Now let's understand the Aryan Migration Theory Aryan Migration Theory states that The Aryan was part of Indus Valley which eventually turned to migrate into the Ganges Plain from 1800 BCE to 1500 BCE. Context and conclusion: Now in Aryan Migration Theory Historians argue that Aryans were not foreigners either they were part of the Indus Valley Civilisation which eventually declined (due to act of god) so they migrated to a large, fertile plain encompassing most of northern and eastern India and established the Vedic Society or Aryan were group of foreigners from the north are believed to have migrated to India ( settled in the Indus Valley Civilisation ) and got assimilate in Indus Culture after which Indus Valley Civilisation declined (due to act of god) so they migrated to Gangetic Plans and established Vedic Society. All the arguments conclude that either Aryan were native people of India they should not be considered as foreigners or Aryan should be recognised as indigenous despite the fact that they migrated into India because they assimilated in Indus culture peaceful not forcefully this is only possible in migration because migration is the movement of a person or people from one place to another ; Here an alternative Theory had been proposed by some people that Aryan Migration from India to Other countries of the World and spread Vedic Culture Which eventually transformed into other religions. This Totally Ends The North Vs South Divide and Debate because we both are the Same People One Culture One Civilization and One Heritage. Note : These things get more complex and arbitrary All the things I have written in this comment are available on the Internet. There are many more complexities but I have tried to clear the maximum concept in One Comment.
@@parthgautam4605Aryan Invasion is when the Aryans plunder like warlords, destroying the settlements of the native population, imposing their language and culture upon the natives, as well as raping them. Yes according to the theory, Aryans were mostly men. Aryan Migration on the other hand is migrating into India bringing their language and culture and somehow imposed it on the local population without violence, and interbred. But what they have in common? Hinduism, Sanskrit and the fair so-called Caucasian genes are foreign to India.
I'm PhD student working in the area of population genetics. I would like to appreciate the entire team as this video is simple, summarised, accurate and neutral video available on internet on this topic.
Indeed there's no doubt that there's mixture , since we see Meghwal is has more ANI ratio than UCs of Southern India but at the end , it's the caste which frames this society , UCs ( military caste) of South India might have less ANI ratio than Meghwal ( reason - the former is a military caste) but the former has more than it's counterparts of Southern India , the Namboodris have more than them , hence it's decides which caste can rule , ultimately it's the ANI (the Aryan culture) in the blood which decided who can rule. Aryan Invasion can't be brushed under the carpet like anything.
@2K19/ME/216 SARTHAK JAIN if aryans have come from europe and invaded the indus valley civilization than why there is not any statues toys are found which are influenced by european culture. All those evidences are influence from hinduism and it's culture.
As long as we believe that we are Indian from heart nothing else matters. In contemporary world, we should work together in making this world happy and safe ! ❤️🇮🇳
Absolutely Proud to be a Bhartiye. Our history starts back from Bharat King(after whom our country is named) . These Aryan invasion theories bs r not going to be proven correct... Lets wait nd watch.
Sometimes people even assume caste based on colour. I am a low caste Hindu with light skin. Many just assume I must be high caste. Some even have used our caste name as slang infront of me thinking I am a high caste like them. It definitely feels bad and I just think should I tell them or not. 😅
@@mangopudding5948 Casteism is not eradicated completely but is reduced very much compared to before Mostly People who do casteism today are Politically motivated person or want reservation
In Dhruv Rathee's video he mentioned that the Indus Valley language is written from right to left but I don't think South Indian languages are written in that way. Actually the history that we were taught was taught in a black and white manner. We were told only one side of the story that fitted the left narrative. We were never told that it's a grey area. This is a criminal offense done by the historians. P.S. Dr. B. R. Ambedkar also didn't accept the Aryan Invasion Theory.
The Aryan Invasion Theory is false, but there was definitely a migration of Indo-Iranians as well as Dravidians into the sub-continent, it's just not as violent as we think. There was likely a lot of peaceful relations between the two people groups, since there is some significant Dravidian influence like retroflex consonants in Rigvedic Sanskrit that is not found in any other IE languages.
Yes man , even William Jones said ( Sanskrit is the mother of all Western languages , then how it is possible that , mother copied her origin from her children , i.e, German / french etc 😂😂😂 ) It is totally wrong to say that Aryan migration happened , Actually Aryan Expansion happened 🙏
Spoken language /=/ written language. Indus valley languages may have used a different script to write their sentences and words but their vocabulary has a startling similarity to Dravidian languages.
The Indus valley script was completely different, and it was more like heiroglyphics than today's language scripts. Today's Southern Indian and Northern Indian languages are written in Brahmi scripts, Brahmi scripts were invented about 2,500 years ago. The Indus valley script is lost to time. Just because it is written from right to left, you cannot say that it isn't related to Southern Indian languages. Even, Arabic is written from right to left, so, will you say that Indus valley language is related to Arabic?
It all depends on what political ideology do you follow and which research work you follow to build your perception or to strengthen your prejudiced perception.
Still in long run the burden of truth and evidence form these studies will either give confidence or loose confidence to claim you're statements in public.
So true. I just want to know the truth, but this topic is so heavily politicized that it get's very tiresome to keep separating science from political agenda.
For example after watching this video no one would claim that I'm a pure Aryan, Dravidian or anything etc... Even if he claims the burden of gene pool study relys on him.
WA university is inside joke because WA means WhatsApp, lots of hindu nationalist majority of them speak hindi so they are the same ethnic stock, they spread from rajasthan to bihar, they are also called as hindians which is derogatory term because they are agrressive and annoying, so the inside joke flourished all over india that these Hindians believed that they are the original humans of india even they believe that all ancestors of humans are them
Hi Mohak... really appreciate all the research that went into this video... but as a person from the North East i expected atleast one sentence which mentions the so called 'Asian' look of majority of North Easterners. India is not only about Northern and South Indians. There have been migrations from Myanmar, Southern China, Thailand etc. Infact Ahoms of Assam spoke Tai language which is similar to Thai language.
Yah...may be because he only focused on major migrations so didn’t talk about tibetan and burmese genetic influence. I am a Bangladeshi bengali and we also have about 7% of our ancestry from tibetan-burmese people
@@srijantata no, the people that migrated 4000 years ago from Myanmar are not related to present day burmese or north-east indians. They are the ancestors of munda, santhalis etc.
Read shrikant talageris book (genetics and Aryan debate - early Indians, Tony Joseph's latest assault) where he debunks Tony Joseph's Aryan MIGRATION theory which was invented when left1sTs started realising that Aryan INVASION theory is failing These theories were invented to divide h1nduzz
@@Mr.Endlesss aryans could be in small numbers but they didn`t found SANSKRIT language. it can also be that , some sanskrit word must be passed from places to places by travellers because there was also connection and trade between INDIA and ROMAN civilisation.
@@thenoobdashow7428 Brahmins bhi bahut small number (maybe 5%) me hai par jitna unka pakad hai Government & Government machinery & Hindu religion me hai door door tak koi nahi hai Aryan small number me the isliye Sanskrit kabhi ordinary Indians ki language nahi ban pai bo sirf Elite class aur court language thi locals prakrit, Pali Awadhi, maithli Punjabi Munda etc. Languages bolte the
@@thenoobdashow7428 Kushan Huns Cytheans & Turk-Mughal Afghan bhi bahut kam the phir bhi kai centuries tak inhone ruled kiya Jabki Aryan ke paas Dharm ka bhi factor tha jisse bo dusro par supremacy established karte the
All theories, nothing scientific, no evidence.. these theories increasing difference between indian people which were started by Britishers. What we will achieve by knowing these..
"According to the Tholkappiyam, the earliest work of Tamil literature, eighteen clans of the Velirs came from the city of Tuvarapati under the leadership of the sage Agastya". And that the ancestors of the Velir may have been related to the inhabitants of the post Harappan Chacolithic Black and Red ware sites (after the fall of Indus valley civilization). People were already living in South when they migrated to South. There's a Possibility of Early Indians settlement in South India. We can see the Direct similarities and slightly modified version of some symbols that were found in Keezhadi civilization and Indus valley civilization.
It would be good if you mention which book in the anthology says this. Which song in Tolkapiyam mentions Velir you will give the song and the song me but it will be fine?? It would be good if you also mention in which chapter it is mentioned?? You will also mention where there is a reference to Agastiya in the Tolkapiyam but that would be fine?? Which Sangam literary hymn contains a reference to Agastia? What is that song number? Which Sangam literature has a reference? Would it be ok to share??
@Haris V C Which song has a reference to him in Sangm literature and tholkappiyam?? Is Agastiya a mythological legend or is there any mention of him in any sangam song??
I am from Odisha, here you can see a crazy mix of north indian and south indian cultures.😁 sometimes we make fun of north and sometimes of south, but love both. Intermixing had happened here a lot, it had become a lot homogenous here
@@sbiibps8266 lol, I am Marathi, and Marathi and Hindi shares 40% same words , if you come to Maharashtra you will see people having names like Pooja, Ashwini, Ramesh, Suresh, chintu, pintu etc... Marathi and Sanskrut shares 60-70% word similarity
7:42 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️ You found some similar words b/w sanskrit and European language that's means sankrit people came from Europe !!! Koreans and Japanese have many similar words with South Indians that means South Indians came from Korea 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️!!! Sankrit is more similar to south Indians languages than European languages, And south Indians languages is more similar to sankrit than Koreans or Japanese!!! Today due to urdufication of North India we are uncomfortable by languages !!! But you can check Assamese/Nepali/ pahadi/kashmiri/Bangla ect... languages are more similar to southindians languages than Hindi(Urdu🤐) !!!
The rakhi garh skeleton is a female Skeleton, it is not possible to find R1A1 Gene in them, R1A1 Gene is Y-Chromosomal Male Gene and only be transferred from Male to Males .
@@prashantkushwaha6055 Haplogroup F is a gene that originated almost 60,000 years ago in India. But, R1A1 originated less than 10,000 years ago, but, in Central Asia.
@@Dont_hate_Muslims His research is incomplete because this same research can be relevant 4-5 years back now the recent excavation in UP proved everything the facts he presented is outdated the information updated now.
Offcourse aryan invension/migration theory real leave the Dna studies lets discuss social and religios structure of indus valley 1. No temple , yagya kund found in in indus valley as opposite with steppe or aryan people use to follow in polytheistic religion use to do yagya or yagna and make temples 2. No social hierarchy found in indus valley unlike yamanya or aryan or steppe people always manage social hierarchy. 3.and also no steppe dna found in rakhigiri hissar civilization's Skelton. Before the aryans arrived most of the people of india use to workship shiva.......indira brahama and vishnu has nothing to do with bharat bhumi they are ancient irani Gods, Rigveda almost similer to old persian religious book aventa.....old persian is also very much similer to sanskrit
apne propoganda ko suit karti sab baat deekha di main nhi deekhai sunauli ma mili tombs ma same practice hoti thi jo Egyptian karte the iska mtlb vo egypt se aye the. 😂😂 Harappa mai Pashupatinath ki seal shivling hawan vedi tantrik bali pratha ki wall painting bhi mili ab bol dena persians bhole nath ki puja karte the 😂😂 5000 years phela se saraswati river extent hone lagi thi mention mahabharat. Magar Rigveda ma usko ufan vali tez bahav ki nadi bataya hai. Ukrainian itne intelligent the phela aryans banke bharat aye phir time travel karke satelite se sarswati river deekhi phir time travel karke 3000 bce ma gaye river ke dry hone ki baat likhi phir 7000 sal phela gaye raam setu banaya mulnivasi ravan ko mara phir aur 3000 sal phela gaye dwarka basai aur dubai bhi. phir apne time ma vapas ake vedas likhe purans likhe upanishad likhe Bharatvarsh ki puri geography study ki even minor minor villages tribes bhi study ki pata nhi konse alien tech se😅 aur sab likha. Aur vo ukraine wale aj khud christian bane baithe hai aur itne tejasvi hone ke bavjood bhi apna desh nhi bacha pa rhe😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Harappan aur so called africans ke saath dingi dingi ki. Itna sab kuch kar liya 😂😂😂😂😂 Tabhi to modi ji bolte hai itne tajasvi log hai 😅😅😅😅😅 Aryan migration invasion picnic irani migration these all are myth after reading some articles this guy think he is a DNA or archeological expert There is one and only truth and that is Out of india migration. That's why we see the similarities between Hinduism and other old polytheistic religions
I took my 23andme DNA ancestry test a couple of years ago. The results are fascinating, I am 45% of south Indian origin and 43% North Indian origin and 9% Bengali and Northeast Indian. I checked my Maternal haplogroup which traces back to Mitochondrial Eve then Group L migrates from Africa to Middle east 200,000 years ago which branches off into N and R and the offshoots of Group R are Group U which migrated to different parts of Europe, Central Asia and India. The haplogroup U2b traces back to the original inhabitants of the Indus River valley which explains the 43% North Indian ancestry.
I am a Bengali Brahmin, and my DNA test showed close to 75% North Indian/Pakistani ancestry, which at the time seemed strange but now I know why. Also, just how North Indians and South Indians fight over ancestry, I have noticed East and West Bengalis do the same too.😂
Feeling sad for tamilians. .who think hinduism is a foreign religion for them..... their whole life was a lie😂 actually dravidian peoples r the earliest hindu from ivc
Tamilians are among the most Religious(and sometimes Superstitious) Hindus. I don't know how people in the North think that they are "Anti-Hindu" or whatever.
Actually we indians are mixter of 4 races found in indus valley civilisation Meditarian (dravidian south ) Proto Autroloids(north ) Nordic or Alpanoids (north west ) Mongoloids ( north east ) And aryan were one who came to bharat from central asia
Actually, I read somewhere that Aryan Invasion Theory was basically created because the British did not want to attribute that Indians who they considered an inferior, ugly race could have created or written Vedas and other evolved texts. Macaulay was very influenced by Indian texts but wanted us to think of ourselves as inferior. Originally as per British it was not North Indians, Aryans were a white European race, since obviously only White people are capable. At some point it shifted to North vs. South - not sure because of politicians or our own internal racism. Today, the south states and leftists hold on to this Aryan Invasion theory because they want to sow separatist ideas in south. The only exception being brahmins according to them. So it has gone to the extent of attributing different castes of being different race. The Hindu is part of left wing media outlet so their headline is not surprising. Also, why aren't we willing to acknowledge the role of Islamic invasions in why North Indians look the way they do. Infact, even if you look at tamils in India, they look much more mixed compared to tamils in sri Lanka or Malaysia who are more homogeneous. It only takes 1-2 generations of mixing a population for appearance to change.
DRAVIDIAN and SANSKRIT mai bhi bahut se words miljiltha hai... Aryan invasion is bullshit and india is land of first man with proofs emerge from 10000 of years before... NEVER TRUST ANY FOREIGNER BOOK ABOUT INDIAN HISTORY..
I get considered to be an Arab or a Pakistani because I speak Nawayathi (Konkani dialect ). It’s an amalgam of Farsi, Urdu, Marathi, Arabic and Konkani. It’s spoken in coastal regions of Karnataka. Again majority of our people are fair but we also have people of darker skin tones. I am in the middle. India is diverse more than any other country 🇮🇳 ❤
Actually ( Aryan Invasion ) never happened ..... ( Aryan Expansion ) Happened .. Sanskrit is the mother of all Western languages -- ( William Jones ) ( Then how it is possible that mother copied her babies , if someone believe in Aryan Migration theory ) 😂😂
There are dozens of other researchers who believe in AIT but they have propoganda but William Jones is telling the truth? One westerner supports you now he is telling the truth. How convenient
Falsehood, sanskrit is itself one of languages developed out of proto Indo aryan languages. The Proto Indo Aryan is branch of Indo European languages.😂
I totally disagree with this content ! Because every theory is just assumption and in science we believe only in concrete answer which is acceptable all around the world not by pressuring one to accept it ! Also here the case on Indians and their identity so as per my study and knowledge gathering by authentic books ...our Vedas were not written by a men also science is proved that these holy scriptures "Has No Writer and if It Has Then He was divine-LORD BRAHMA" . Coming to your video It seems that you only provide contents which is simply available on internet (written & provided by sickbrains) so kindly do reasearch and please read Vedas first then talk about Aryaas and Indians ! The African theory has also been told wrong and there is still a lot of improvement to be done in the research paper which has been told. I request you to don't mislead Indians ! Hail Sanatan Dharma 🧡
We South Indians are a different race from most North Indians!.. It is very clear in our physical appearance itself!!.. It is as simple as that.. Aryans came from Steppe Grasslands in Europe about 3,500yrs ago & brought Vedhas from there.. The word Aryans is there in many cultures of Europe!.. Iranian Zoro Astricism & Vedhas based Hinduism have a lot of similarities..😮 The tamils have absolutely no connection with your Iranian migrated people at all!!.. Stop saying false stories!..
@@Pihu523because most Dravidian names have become outdated because of Sanskrit cultural influence from the upper castes who naturally dominated, nothing wrong though.
Read shrikant talageris book (genetics and Aryan debate - early Indians, Tony Joseph's latest assault) where he debunks Tony Joseph's Aryan MIGRATION theory which was invented when left1sTs started realising that Aryan INVASION theory is failing These theories were invented to divide h1nduzs
@@aayushkumar6955 Discrimination regarding caste was not introduced by BR Ambedkar, A kulin bramhin marrying 109 girls was not introduced by Ambedkar, Reservation in temple for priest being only born in a bramhin family was also not introduced by Ambedkar but certainly he played a role in stopping these discriminatory practices through hindu marriage act, hindu code bill and reservation of sc and st(which was made by Gandhi actually Ambedkar asked for separate electorate just like muslims, read poona pact) to end these discriminations (i named only few) and make India united. Social justice is important for a nation to survive, so my friend end caste discrimination from the society reservation will also end.
14411 is a male skeleton. His Y dna haplogroup was H which again is native indian hunter gatherer marker. Male closest to his affinity are found in South indian tribal community. The thing is when they were excavating in Rakhigari they could recover both female and and male skeleton for genetic testing. The female one was done by indian archaeologists but male one was in most likely korea (I could be wrong here though). In mainstream media only the rakhigari female ancestry is highlighted but not male one. The very reason is, almost all genetic research done on this topic agrees upon the fact that the aryan migration that happened in india were predominantly male. They brought little to no females with them. So, the sudden change in Y dna haplogroup (native male vs aryan male) actually reinforces the controversy back to square one. It is evident that in every video,article on this topic, the ancestry of rakhigari female is highlighted but rakhigari male's one is never ever discussed or mentioned.
@@lifa7660 interesting! Haplogroup H shows maximum diversity in our subcontinent showing that it originated in India but same is the case for R1a1 and R1b both of them show maximum diversity in Indian subcontinent and genetics it's the diversity that indicates the origin not the concentration. That just made me sceptical about AMT again then I saw the research paper referred by Mr Joseph i.e. of Mr Reich's work with 92 scientist. The conclusions were interesting but again the papers were non peer reviewed and none of the journals accepted as it had lot of circular arguments and methodologically incorrect! The research papers showing that rakhigarhi male specimen had Haplogroup H is true and the work done by the scientists is something that should be appreciated. But when it comes to the research on topic of 'Origin of Haplogroup R1a1 and R1b' there are no valid research (peer reviewed) that shows it originated in central Asian region. This was out of pure genetics perspective. The linguistic and cultural arguments that AMT provides can be countered in multiple ways but genetics is the key for understanding the truth i believe.
Read shrikant talageris book (genetics and Aryan debate - early Indians, Tony Joseph's latest assault) where he debunks Tony Joseph's Aryan MIGRATION theory which was invented when left1sTs started realising that Aryan INVASION theory is failing These theories were invented to divide h1induzz
How id krishna he is also came from first Indian who is Rama he is also came from first Indian where is sooryavansham many bump shows they also came from first Indian what do you saying India is the old and only oldest and oldest country Hinduism very very oldest religion came from Rama from Satya Yuga to kaliyuga
I speak Kannada and I can tell you that Kannada has more Sanskrit than Modern Hindi and is the 3rd oldest language in India after Sanskrit and Tamil.. That's the reason why we need to preserve our ancient languages.
North India lost it's sanskrit words due to islamic/Turkish invasions that's why south indian people find hindi as an alien language for example for vegetables we use a Persian word "sabji"
@@deku006 Iam Malayali girl who knows hindi somewhat I don't much about other South Indian languages malayalam is a language which have 50 percent sanskrit even more than hindi. I think kannada also have good percentage of sanskrit. Tamil has the least
Please share proper references behind tour claim… as far as we are aware whether harrapan language was ‘Dravidian’ or not .. ithis claim has not been peer reviewd properly or established yet
@@aseemkumar4429 well this video is all about theories only.. theories have some genetic evidences in their backing, hence their ground is strong..you must be aware about the recent genetic studies which upheld the Aryan Migration theory ... however, they face a strong opposition from the Hindu nationalists that rather propagate the Native Aryanism theory ... Which is what is stopping the Aryan Migration theory from being established, even after having genetic and linguistic evidences...
This guy didnt show the DNA result of 14411, instead made whole video on the result of it, a simple Google search on dna result of 14411 reveals that Aryan Invasion theory is Fake, but this guy is trying to say otherwise , there is 15 lakh rs offers form renowned indian historian from Rajasthan for whoever proves any authenticity of AIT, as you Mr. Mohak saying it happened, why not claim that prize.... !!
Fun fact : pre independence almost all political leaders believed in Aryan invasion theory and considered themselves Aryan eg Gandhi, Tilak, Nehru,savarkar, golvelkar etc only Ambedkar opposed it. Now right wing opposes it and left believe in it.
Nearly everyone around the globe believed in Aryan invasion theory back then because that was the *leading theory* at that time. Also, Aryan invasion theory has already been debunked ages ago (late 20th century) in favor of Indo-Aryan migration theory. Indo-Aryan migration theory has nothing to do with racism, western imperialisms or politics if you go and read the actual papers. People who want to trivialize this whole area of study for their own reasons are the only ones who still refer to Aryan invasion theory be it left or right... like you Stop bending the truth.
@@dishuuu112 That's pretty dumb. All Bronze age civilizations from Hitties, Ugher to Egypt have written letters and records of Sea People invasion which caused the Bronze Age collapse. Apparently due to Climate change around that time a massive drought occur which caused Mass migration and invasion of people of grasslands towards these River Valley civilization. We have famous Last cry of help from Ugher, Ramses proclamation of Victory over these Sea people. Now the thing is we cannot read IVC scripts but considering what happened to to other Bronze age empires, it's fair to say same destruction and invasion came to IVC.
@@aniket385 Many of the genetic results and carbon dating of the skeletons opposed this "invasion" theory as none of them showed West Eurasian or Bronze age component.
I was very curious about this topic and tried messaging different youtubers on it and commenting on their videos.... finally thank you for making it and please make a video on indus valley language and culture, looking forward to it 🙂
@@GireeshSharma0510 He's a shameless sanghi who spews bullshit shamelessly like a cow 🐄 on the streets bullshits publicly. His dad didn't beat him up enough.
Telugu ,marathi , and many other south languages are some similarities with sanskrit. Some words like kutumbha which is family in english are same in tamil and sanskrit.
Modern Telugu has a lot of sanskrit words but it was after Nannayya used many sanskrit in Telugu translation of Mahabharatam and later several poets followed the same. So there is huge Sanskrit influence on Telugu.
Arya invasion theory is a myth, recent excavation of Sinauli completely exposed this theory, the Aryans genes were found in Sinauli which pre date's arayan invasion, also war equipments and chariots were found which indicates us that the warrior culture was present in those times
We're okay with everyone. Whether indian, Aryan, Persian, Dravidian. Only tamilians care about that. I do not understand why are they so angry about everything everytime?
@@deku006 every time I see them in news they are angry 😂 at North Indians and call them you Aryans go back. Or it's you can't force hindi on us. Well Mr. Jaishankar is my favourite person in BJP so will not complain much about tamilians.
Nowadays, talking about aryan- Dravidian origin is useless as these theories were the brain child of Britishers & some secular political parties. After all it's unity in diversity which matters which we have achieved. At the time of independence there were nearly 545 princely states which merged with new india willingly except nizams of hyderabad. So, during this time, theory of aryan invasion has become outdated & obsolete. Now, I am 65 yrs old & during my primary school days this aryan theory was in school books & now it should be removed if it's still there. 😊
It's actually a collective tribal, local beliefs and polytheism grouped, and people made it collectively called it Hinduism or Santana dharma etc.. and mostly the textual books of Hinduism are from nort east indians adapted by other parts of India .. even middle East had same polytheist belief before chirstianity, Islam , jews .. and that is why Muhammad ﷺ is considered last of all prophets, there will be no messengers of God after to convey the message of worship only one God.
We need a language for communication otherwise we have to speak that English language everywhere. I don't think they are imposing ,you can still speak your mother tongue and it will be still your State language.dont worry. 🙏
Yeah bro I'm from north and it hurts that you people are facing situations like this I understand there is need of a common language but it can take time we don't need that plan immediately
I am also a Kannadathi, what I really think is Hindi is the most used language across India and we have 22 official languages, here people choose Hindi to connect with everyone when we have linguistic difference so its difficult to communicate but most of us prefer english to use but forcefully imposing on us & making it compulsory is a bad thing I obligate that, see when you try to live in any place in this world people always try to adapt which is in majority, we are the one who get benefit by learning and communication become flexible with others and also its better to communicate/understanding in Hindi than in English with outsiders ,I used to hate learning Hindi in my school days never liked it ,but now most of the content available in any platform is almost in Hindi (regional channels) this video is also in Hindi that's how it works
I disagree with the bit where you said Indians stopped marrying outside their caste 1900 years ago during Gupta period because Vedic religion became popular. First of all the vedic religion has been popular for atleast 4000 years, also Gupta rule didn't even exist 1900 years ago. The most recent study says that endogamy started in India around 1570 years ago during the Gupta period and has more to do with the fact that, India was most prosperous during this period and family occupations had started to develop, so carpenter would only marry a carpenter to make sure that the skill of carpentry continues over the generations.
@@alezrandom4146 The Mittani Kingdom existed 3500 years ago in modern day Syria, they used late vedic sanskrit and not the early or middle vedic sanskrit, which means the vedas were written atleast 7000 years ago(keeping the fact in mind that Saraswati river dried up 4000 years ago, and the Rig Veda mentions Saraswati river as a giant roaring river and not a tiny drying river.) If the late vedic sanskrit reached syria 3500 years ago, it is safe to assume the vedas were popular in India by that time. And why the hell should i provide sources? How hard is it for you to use google?
No, there were people before. The next group mixed in with the native population! There is no such thing as pure DNA in any place in the world. Everyone has mixed in a much! Please stop reading messages from Watsapp university or Right-wing nationalists!
Read shrikant talageris book (genetics and Aryan debate - early Indians, Tony Joseph's latest assault) where he debunks Tony Joseph's Aryan MIGRATION theory which was invented when left1sTs started realising that Aryan INVASION theory is failing
@@saransh9373 geography is a thing. We tend to adapt to the behaviour. Its also a well established fact that people who have lived in sunny and hot areas tend to be darker so that they can protect themselves from the harmful radiations from sun.
You are qouting all sources except sanskrit because you want only viewership ,have u ever read rig veda where they says aryan as invader no , Whenever someone write there history or custom it always highlight there roots (the same way when u go outside u praise your culture ) so before making any such video please make sure you have the same mean in both side.otherwise don't..😔🤐
I think this is not 100% correct all the North East West and South Indians are bases on same genetic roots that is Haplogroup F for males and Haplogroup M and N for females which originates in India around 60k years ago and these genes went outside India all the way to Europe and Australia and there was no such Aryans Invasion or Migration happens because when such large scale Migration happens it changes entire genetic lineage and culture of this place and Indian culture remain same at its core from 10000 years ago with regional variation because India was diverse right from its beginning but if you consider Europe its genetic and culture completely changed 4000 years ago because at this time the Yamnaya invasion happens in Europe which was an Indian tribe who rampaged around Europe doing horrible massacres and it changed their genetic lineage culture architecture pottery etc so it is true that it is actually Indian who went outside and spread their culture and language though small scale Migration always happens in India over the years but this was never so huge and significant and how can someone say the name of elephant in indus valley civilization is similar to South Indian language when the script is not yet deciphered these are only some foolish political move to play Dravidian and Aryan politics
Well I am from Uttarakhand but I have seen more of Greek features in me compared to Mongolian/Chinese Also by passing time dilution is happening and in the end it doesn't matter much Coz everyone came from Africa.
Same bro but I’m from Rung community and I think we’re more like oriental. In my opinion, Jaunsaris are closest(in terms of facial features)to the North Western people here.
Read shrikant talageris book (genetics and Aryan debate - early Indians, Tony Joseph's latest assault) where he debunks Tony Joseph's Aryan MIGRATION theory which was invented when left1sTs started realising that Aryan INVASION theory is failing
The colour of the skin depends on the environment and place. We all are pure Indian , and we aren't immigrants nor our ancestors,. The appearance of your researcher is our ancestors'bad character .
@@16yearsold902 science aur DNA ke mutabik humare ancestors bhi toh Africa ja sakte hain bharat se ? Ye iss se thode pata chal raha ki wahi yaha aaya tha?😶
I think you need a little more research. While trying to find a middle ground, you kept pointing at the right wing and ended up saying what the left wing says but with some compromise. There are plenty of good arguments in the comment section to take on.
If we inverse his arguements 🤔can it be possible history. Didn't indians go out of india in last he said some people came from combodia, can't it be possible that indian went to combodia🤔🤔🤔
Even Korean language consists of Various Dravidian words but no dravidian migration is shown, it could be the same in the case of Indo-Europian Culture, there is no necessary information for people migration.
Koreans think that their language is not influenced by any other language and they take pride in it....if you will tell them this then they will get angry. Even The korean alphabet HANGEUL is similar to DEVANAGARI....but they will refuse it
Just a correction - the word for three in Sanskrit is त्रयस् (त्रयः - masculine, nominative, plural) and not त्रायस्. Nice efforts! But the theories are too complex, and it will be early if we jump to a conclusion as researchers are still digging into it!
I have been taught that 1 is ekam 2 is dve and 3 is trini 4 chatvari 5 pach 6sath 7sapth 8asth 9nav 10dash from my 5 to 10 grade. Sanskrit is very complex and interesiting language like you have to use the correct vibhakti also depending on situation which is similar to karta karm karaak in hindi also it can be either ekvachanam dvivachanam and bhaovachanam which changes the way a sentence is writing unlike only singular and pural in hindi.
@@ddevilfromhell97 nope sanskrit did not influence other IE languages (and neither was sanskrit influenced by other IE). In fact all indo european languages diverged from a single source. And there is nothing called "advanced for its time" wrt languages
I am a Tamilian with fair skin and a lot of people assume that I am a North Indian. When I tell them that I am a Tamilian they get shocked lol. (Not all South Indians are dark like how not all North Indians are fair guys)
@@blade3625 yeah but mutation exists too. Some people can be born with lighter skin tone and over a period of thousands of years can have lighter skin tone.
@@blade3625 bro the chances of a mutation is rare but it happens. And when the people with the mutation procreate, they gene is carried over many generations. And it has been happening for thousands of years. That's why some South Indians have fair skin. Immigration from north is another reason why South Indians have fair skin too.
@@blade3625Dravidian have h and l1 haplogroup ( They also has r1a ) but h1 is considered main haplogroup of tamilian H ancestors lived in Mesolithic Europe ( oldest detected linage marking of h ancestors) Vast majority of Dravidian are Western Eurasian population
Definitely we have different Languages, Color, Religion, Cultures, Practices, Rituals and Region! But one Emotion which keep us United is, "BHARAT MATA KI JAI"🇮🇳♥️
What abt discrimation nd suppression in the name of caste religion nd region??? Can a mother (Bharat matha) show discrimination among her children??? If this Bharat matha made her own son a slave of her other sons (Brahman, Kshatriya nd Vaishya) i dont want this matha. If u r a victim then ur emotion will definitely change my friend.
@@JaiHind-ti7eb Caste system was increased by British. I am not saying it didn't existed but when Alexander came to india and budhist monks from China visited India. They never wrote about it in the records. Caste is also a Spanish word. Obviously their were class division. People were rich and poor. But it was increased in British Empire and Mughal Empire...
Great information Mohak! Wonderful that you will share your Genetic details on ANI & ASI genes within you. Still, these are just theories & this shouldn't become a fodder for any Political hunger to create divisions in India
See abhijit chavda videos on it, there things are utter non sense, R1a gene proves it and soon it's origin reports, (which are likely to say that it originated in india) will conclude this debate.
i dont know about anybody else but my motivation to go abroad was to see and stalk blondie girls. though it may sound creep but i have love for blondie and slavic people. blondie / white girl is more beautiful than brown girl. love from canada.
You by creating confusion wants to say reality is middle, by doing cherry picking of data, i strongly condemn any such action, Bharat is thousands of year old civilization 10000years old city are found in submerged ocean, aryan theory or Dravidian all are engineered only and only to divide Bharat under divide and rule policy so believing in any such thing mean making Britishers sucessful,, Dravidian, what is it based on language: We all know Sanskrit is mother of all languages, 60-70 % words in Telugu is from Sanskrit, 40-50% in tamil words are Sanskrit. And surely all present language are seperate from each other, Bharat is a vast country all over bharat there are some new thing and missing some previous one, Thats how distance of UP to TN become so much that local language hardly remain understandable, 3rd northern part of Bharat constantly facing outsiders attacks, If we compare 80% of all infamous attacks are in northern part so all major culture continuity badly affected,
India has always been the melting pot of all cultures from across the world. India has always been a refuge for persecuted people from all across the world. No matter what happened in the past, today this country is a great example of unity in diversity. Be proud to be an Indian. Jai hind.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
@@SatpalVerma000 Bharat india has it's official name and no india got independence in 1947 it existed before that it's boder territory are pre defined before 1947 which got changed in 1947 one country came out of it called Pakistan
@@divineflu34567 Italy was created in 1860. Of course its land existed before that. Roman empire was not Italy. British Indian empire, mughal empire ashoka empire was not India. India was created in 1947.
Numbers in Dravidian languages Okati, Onnu, Ondru, Ondhu Rendu, Randu Irandhu, Iradu Moodu, Moonu, Mundru, Mooru Nalugu, Naalu, Naalu, Nalgu Aidhu, Anji, Andhu, Aidhu Aru, Aru, Aru, Aru Edu, Ezhu, Ezhu, Elu Emmidhi, Ettu, Ettu, Entu Thommidhi, Onbadhu, Onbatu Pathi, Pathu, pathu, Hathu No Aryan language Ek, Ekah Dho, Duvah Theen, Tryah Char, Catvarah Panch, Pancha Se, Sat Saath, Saptha Aat, Asta Nav, Nava Dhas, Dhasa This shows that both are not same. But some illiterate northies claim there is no Aryan and Dravidian languages. What we can say
@@pro-telugu1593 I support your opinion but what is the meaning of this. This made a. Seprate belief in mindset of people across the country. Elite class and politician set a propaganda to ripening their. Won benefit at the cost of national integration. And that a person like you,so-called litterate easily trapped in this. Same on you
Thank you so much for this video! It's hard to believe that people who believe in the Aryan invasion theory exist. One of the theory's biggest supporters is DMK which has a long record of anti-Hindu and anti-Brahmin hatred. Also, I would love a video on Harappan civilisation, their trade routes, the language, culture, its connections with sanātan dharma and how the civilisation came to an end.
Tamil people be calling tamil brahmins non tamils even tho they speak in tamil. Also appointing leaders who non tamil origin. Stalin Karunanidhi or something Jayalilitha Even periyar was born in karnataka border🤣
I am curious to know where do Hindu stories like Ramayana, Mahabharata come into the picture. We know that many places and events described in the scripture have geographical evidences across the world.
Aryan propaganda that dehumanizes and is racist towards South Indians. Krishna or Rama or whoever the fuck that is sends an Aryan monkey 🙉 Hanuman from North to defeat the brutal barbarian South Indian Ravannan that lives in Sri Lanka. Hanuman with the mighty power of plot armour jumps across the sea (i see where bollywood gets its action scenes inspiration from) and defeats South Indian. This blatant propaganda is celebrated as Ram Leela. LOL 😂😂. I don't why South Indians haven't already started celebrating Ravan Leela.
@@eraofrage no, its between Jamuna and sutlej. Post vedic texts mention Saraswati river in declining phase along with location it flows. There is no literal evidence that helmand river is saraswti river that RV mentions
@@raghav5903 there is no mention where saraswati is..or it is in declining phase either...just saraswati river is mentioned and its water...most historians say helmand river is saraswati...even we havn't found any evidence of big dried river in punjab...
"Dravid" means A Land which is Bordered by Water or Sea "Drav" means Water, and "Id" means Landscape and That is Bharat,, if Kerala is part of Dravid then Kashmir is also part of Dravid, and Gujrat, Maharashtra, West Bengal, Odisha, and North East India also Part of Dravid And there is no Aryan Invasion Theory, this is false conducted by the British and Leftists,, ARYANS are not race, Arya this is Sanskrit word, Arya is a Philosophy, The man who Protects the Dharma is an Arya, who fight for Righteousness he is Arya, and Bharat was called Aryavart, because the people of Bharatvarsh fight against Adharma, they fight for Righteousness, .. if Afganistan, Pakistan (that time of land), Kashmir, UP was known as Aryavart then Kerala, Tamilnadu, Andhrapradesh also known as Aryavart,, the people of Bharat all used to fight for Dharma
@@thesentry1434 No no, if you trace the history back to pre-Christian times, you'll see that the Dravidians and the Aryans were completely different ethnic groups. Your reasoning for saying "There is no such thing as Aryans. It's all been invented by the West!" sounds fake and I can't believe it🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣. First of all, if your theory that the Aryans don't exist were true, it would be known to the public, so why isn't it considered popular in India? That's because the basis for it is questionable and it's just your personal opinion. 😂
@@SpecialGlobalTalks No, in the DNA test of Indians, it was found that the DNA is largely divided into two groups, 70% of the total is the same as the DNA of the north, and 30% of the total is the same as the DNA of the south. This is why the north Indra is said to be Aryan and the south Indra is said to be Dravidian. How can we say that the DNA of all Indians is the same when it is clear that the south and north have completely different DNA?🤣🤣
Both Aryan and Dravidian are languages that originated in the plateau, but they are from different eras, more than 1000 years apart, so at least there are ethnic groups called Aryan and Dravidian. You, who are blabbing that all Indians have the same DNA, should study a bit more. It is absolutely impossible for all people in a biologically connected country to have the same DNA. And the evidence that the Aryan invasion theory is a lie is too weak.🫵
Earliest traces of Hinduism vs 14411 carbon dating have a huge gap interms of the years where one predates the other by a huge margin. While Mohak is correct while quoting the paper, the paper has made a lot of assumptions which are contradictory with other evidences, examined that predates this theory.
The two research papers that we are referencing in the video -
1. An Ancient Genome from the Indus Valley Civilization - pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31626767/
2. The Formation of Human Populations in South and Central Asia - www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6822619/
yes , make a video about Harappan and Dravidian languages
🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳haHum khi se bhi aai ho hme sirf dikhta hai chankye ka bharat or hme wo bharat banana hai kisi bhi keemat pe hamare dill mai bharat rehta hai hum bharat k liye jeete hai or bharat k liye hi mar bhi jaaenge sochenge nhi soch sirf 1 hai no 1 pe bharat hona chahiye baat khatam
Thank you for the references. I just don't get why many Indians can't accept the simple fact that people throughout history have migrated to different places. Migration isn't a recent phenomenon, it's an inherent trait of being human. That's how we adapted & survived for so long!!
@Being Ricky seriously bro the reasearch papers are based on or influenced by West and they want to prove that we are descendents of west it's as simple as that .
What are you going to prove by this research paper or articles they are us influenced by US you are promoting the things that US wanted to be promoted . The Aryans invasion theory is completely fake . Guys please refer abhijeet chavda's videos not this
It doesn't matter from where our ancestors were belongs to today we're just Indians that's the most important thing, I'm from Assam and my ancestors were from Mongolia, that's why we kinda look like Thai or Chinese, Korean whatever you say but we're just Indians by our heart and our language
I wish we got to see more North Indian characters (not stereotypes) in Bollywood movies.
don’t matter what ur ancestor are I find the diversity of Indian interesting because it shows that’s it’s the cross road of civilization. I my self have ancestry from southern Europe, North Africa, Middle East, Melanesia, sub-Saharan Africa, east Asia and Central America. I’m Mexican mestizo
northeastern people did not originate from Mongolia, their ethnic origin lie in Tibeto-Burman region, there is no ethnic group in India which traces their ancestry back to Mongolia.
it does not matter for me also, but i need to reply to those who spread either wrong information for some political agenda or any other kind of gain. An influencer should not spread his opinion with any kind of biasness . I am only replying because these theories that our ancestors came from some other place and made us civilised (which is wrong) brings some kind of inferiority complex to Indians . These theories where planted in Indian people's minds by the British during there rule . And now these theories are promoted by west to show themselves superior . These superior feeling of the west started the world war 2 by Hitler (he believed German to be superior race) and now these theories promote racism in west . Indians and other south asian peoples suffers a lot due to this . A very few research has been made by our Archaeological survey of India about our history and culture and that is why we do not have proper evidence about our rich culture of old times.
Also these theories are made to divide India into many parts . And this is mainly done by the west,who do not want a powerful India again which will replace the west again as a global super power.
These statements that south Indian genes are different from North Indian are completely wrong . First of all south and north are just directions . and secondly there are Scientifically proven evidences that the genes are same and there is the colour difference just because of the distance from the equator . when we live very near to the equator we get a lot of uv rays from sun which can lead to cancer and other diseases thats why our body produces more amount of melanin which makes dark protective layer on our skin to protect from extra uv rays.
At least we should know the actual history and should not be influenced by some wrong or biased theories.
By the way I also leave in Tinsukia, Assam, India
@@gurjindersingh3843 it's idiotic. Cz u consider the base theory as ki bahar se to pakka aaye hai hum.. So stupid have I not known about your princess citranganda from manipur who married to arjun. ....... The mindset of you all people's that we had come to india from outside is very wrong,,, yesterday one guys studied very hard. He was a thakur aur raghuwanshi. Telling us that he is from thokarian civilization from europe. 😂 ohk so now prabhu shree ram and his ancestory is also from europe. So stupid
We are from here only. Thesee theories are created and supported since their are many foreign religion in India and a particular religion says we are not from outside. We are from outside then you are also to sustain their political benifitts
bhyi ye insan kitna desperately facts ko chhupa rha hai, go and watch Abhijit chawda on Aryan invasion theory and discovery+ series on Sinauli archeological discovery.
It's completely biased
I am from south india andhra...yes aryan theory is false....but we are dravidians....not based on colour of skin but based on language... we proud that we are dravidians... saying we are dravidians doesnt mean we support aryan theory...
Good🙏🏻
Thank you🙏
video literally said aryans did migrate from europe. how can you be so blind? it is true.
@@ਗੁਰਸਿਮਰਸਿੰਘ he is taking about Aryan invasion theory
Why we can't be under one umbrella ...why divide....we also have our states language and culture but we never identified anything other than bharatvarsha
I'm Chinese and my bf is Indian. I found India is a very fascinating country and has very intersting history. This is a perfect video, thank you so much!
This is nothing compared to the total history os india...altho we had a great relationship with china in the ancient times...
all chinese scholars always found India fascinating. they used to come to India for learning lot of cultural things and took it back to china like ayurveda, buddhism, tantra, and many more. You can research on it, they used to study in Nalanda Takshila etc
@@LightLoveLaughwas mainly for bhuddism
All indians have same DNA 🧬 by science and it is proved 🙂
@@SpecialGlobalTalks yeah what a coincidence that everyone residing in a country whose borders were made less than 100 yrs ago have the same dna makup
They are Indians
Went to Europe
Came back
"Aryan Picnic Theory"
😂🤣
Be a matured
@@jaishivji3246 Please check modern genetics history 😏,
Ice Age
Yeah, horses were never native to Steppes, Caucasus. It's so cold there - Ice Age.
😂
"We are Indians, firstly and lastly"
- Dr. B.R. Ambedkar
❣️🤍💙
No word india exist at that time, how come you tell that south india north India ,bharath varsh and akanda bharath is the only truth.
The best thing about India is that we are known to be the most diverse country. 🌸
@@krishnavamshi5562 there was no bharat neither akhand bharat only jambudvip.
and you are dalit firstly and i am rajput jai rajputana
😂😂😂
Europeans be like : budha come to India from china
According to Europeans and britishers- buddha was a european named broady...But when he came to china he was called Boaqin and whe in last days..He came to india...Indians as were illitrate...Were unable to pronounce his same so they start calling him Buddha(a name an old age given to be mocked). Later this name became famous and broady was known as buddha. Also he brought 'ficious religiosa' from England to India which was later known as peepal tree.
@@TheLeo13 that was so funny to read
All indians have same DNA🧬 by science and it is proved 🙂
Hindu 🕉️ dharm is a single religion code or representation for all majority indian subcontinent faith and culture 🙂 and that all faith and culture made in indian subcontinent 🙂
@@TheLeo13 man why do you want to play victim so hard
No problem from where you come from but I have problem with Upper Caste because they consider themselves Superior in comparison to the lower caste.
WHAT SHIT YOU ARE SPITTING .. I KNOW THAT IN BACKWARD AREAS THESE THINGS EXIST BUT IN CITIES AND TOWNS THIS THING DOESNOT EXIST ... I DONT BELEIVE IN CAST SYSTEM I HAVE ALL TYPE OF FRIENDS ...
@@_Tushar_Sharma... it's really hard for the criminals to confess.
@@_Tushar_Sharma... In which city you leave, I was in Jaipur and owner before giving me room for rent they are asking my caste and I told them I am from Shedule Caste and they did not rent me their room. Casteism is most relevant today and especially in BJP state Casteism is on another level. I am staying by my words Yes, Upper Caste see themselves and always want themselves to Superior to Lower Caste because they think themselves as Agents of God.
@@anubhavkumar9403 I AM FROM HIMACHAL PRADESH ... THE THINGS HERE YOU SAID DOESNT EXIST IN MY AREA ...
@@_Tushar_Sharma... Don't want to take conversation forward but just wanted to say that Casteism is practised in every part of India today, even in Jaipur I heard from my Brahmin Friend his family teaching him to don't eat with Dalit and He said this himself. So saying that Casteism is only exists in villages is wrong.
I am a South Indian from Coastal Karnataka , we speak Tulu - a language which is either the mother of Dravidian languages or the child of Dravidian languages because we have words which are in Tamil , Telugu , Kannada , Malayalam and Korean !!
Surprising fact is : I have genes from iranian side from my dad and China from my mom’s side …
Same bro histroy is fcked up 😢
I am telangana and if ait is true dome religious thinks will be false
Tamil is the mother language
ok Tamil, Telugu , kannada, Malayalam but korean ..Wtf
ur mom and dad are actually indians right ... but their genes are Iranian and Chinese
Ky Frk padhta h !
Sb mar jayenge ek din !🙂
Aur kuch na le jayenge sath ! 🙂
Bhai itna depressed kyu hai tu 💀
Mohak, I definitely urge you two things. Please consider:
1) A video on Harappan Language/Indus Valley Civilization.
2) Book recommendations in the end of videos like this which can satisfy our need to learn more about the topic of discussion.
Proud to be Indian ❤️🇮🇳❤️
Ancient history by upinder singh.
You can also read Ranveer chakraborty
Harrapan was Dravidian civilization. It was wiped out because of the floods. Aryan theory is real.. but I don't think it was an invasion. If you look up the North Indian DNAs of people like Jatt they have central Asian South Asian and Irish Caucasus DNA
Harappan language hasn't been deciphered yet..
@@peteck007 It was not completely a Dravidian civilization, people from Indus Valley Civilization after its collapsed mixed with people of Ancient South India and spread their language.
Le nile kabooter - brhman ko bahar nikalo😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂
definitely need a video on Harappan language mystery :) it's always great to listen you mohak !
Druv has explained nicely I believe
@@mayankkapri7305 it's better to listen modi than listing to Dhruv Modi's lies look appealing atleast
@@mayankkapri7305 i don't need 1 Side of story.
@@jaymehta9638 alright
Certainly need a video on Harappan languages
I wish more of this research was done by Indian scientists themselves.... if only some private/gov sector could fund actually good research
Sab isko le k biased h, isiliye ispe kuch na ho toh acha h.
What I smell in your comment is a latent dissatisfaction with the facts presented in the video. Your imploration for a separate research conducted by 'Indian' scientists suggests that you downplay all the archaeological and biological evidences put forth by the researchers of the west. Now I understand that we Indians tend to respect our research better, but we also tend to forget more often than not that what others do is more likely to be bias free, especially in matters as sensitive to our sense of identity and belonging like these. An average researcher from the west is least likely to interpret the data with an implicit bias because whatever the conclusion of his findings be, it has no bearing on his sense of identity. You could see in the video itself that two Indian researchers working together and publishing at the same time couldn't agree about the languages of the Indus valley civilization. What could be a possible reason? Well, simply realising that the matter is sensitive and that for very many Indians, even the researchers themselves, it will be disheartening to come to terms with some conclusions of the findings. Now, obviously the current government will some day 'fund' an investigation and maybe you'll have results being published, but tell me honestly, will you be able to judge that the researches 'funded' by government like the extreme right BJP can ever be free of bias?
@@donttaponthis me and who
pdh le naam papers me, kafi sare indian bhi the, and yh sb chize noble prizes tk jati h, isme biasednes ni hota, except in presentation
DNA testing by Dr. Lalji Singh, and Harvard University has already debunked the Aryan Invasion Myth
I live in North Punjab, Pakistan. It seems like we have been living in this area for thousands of years and we have become converted Hindus to Muslims because the stories our ancestors used to tell us were all Hindu related stories. I want to know which Hindu caste we belong to. We don't even belong to upper caste and our forefathers have been doing weaving job means julahas
Chamaar
Many Rajput , Chouhan were also converted to islam , and they are upper caste hindu...
@@Avengers-mc7join kashmir almost all muslims are Brahmans pastly what you can say now
Darji means sc
What’s your real last name? Before you took on a Muslim name
People don't understand that there's a difference between Aryan invasion theory and Aryan migration theory.
Whats the difference? Pls elaborate
@@parthgautam4605 Yes there is a vast difference when we talk about Aryan Invasion Theory and Aryan Migration Theory
we often interchangeably use Invasion and Migration thinking that both are the same but
The truth is they're not as we say "The devil is in the details" It completely changes the context and conclusion
Let's understand How
* First if we talk about Aryan Invasion Theory it states that a group of people called Aryans invaded northern India and destroyed the Indus Valley Civilization.
Context and conclusion: Now as we know that when we're talking about Aryan Invasion Theory it means that Aryan were foreigners who were probably either killed, subjugated or displaced the native or indigenous people (dravidians) to south who were living in India (specifically in Indus Valley Civilisation) for 1000 of years. After the Invasion Aryan forcefully imposed the Vedic Society in North India.
All these arguments can only be concluded if there was an Invasion because an Invasion is an act of controlling something or someone by force.
Nowadays many people use this Invasion I repeat Invasion Theory to support North Vs South Divide as they argue that dravidians are the first Indian.
This Theory had been used by the British to create a division between North Vs South and justify their colonial ambitions.
* Now let's understand the Aryan Migration Theory
Aryan Migration Theory states that The Aryan was part of Indus Valley which eventually turned to migrate into the Ganges Plain from 1800 BCE to 1500 BCE.
Context and conclusion: Now in Aryan Migration Theory Historians argue that Aryans were not foreigners either they were part of the Indus Valley Civilisation which eventually declined (due to act of god) so they migrated to a large, fertile plain encompassing most of northern and eastern India and established the Vedic Society or Aryan were group of foreigners from the north are believed to have migrated to India ( settled in the Indus Valley Civilisation ) and got assimilate in Indus Culture after which Indus Valley Civilisation declined (due to act of god) so they migrated to Gangetic Plans and established Vedic Society.
All the arguments conclude that either Aryan were native people of India they should not be considered as foreigners or Aryan should be recognised as indigenous despite the fact that they migrated into India because they assimilated in Indus culture peaceful not forcefully this is only possible in migration because migration is the movement of a person or people from one place to another ;
Here an alternative Theory had been proposed by some people that Aryan Migration from India to Other countries of the World and spread Vedic Culture Which eventually transformed into other religions.
This Totally Ends The North Vs South Divide and Debate because we both are the Same People One Culture One Civilization and One Heritage.
Note : These things get more complex and arbitrary All the things I have written in this comment are available on the Internet. There are many more complexities but I have tried to clear the maximum concept in One Comment.
@@parthgautam4605Aryan Invasion is when the Aryans plunder like warlords, destroying the settlements of the native population, imposing their language and culture upon the natives, as well as raping them. Yes according to the theory, Aryans were mostly men.
Aryan Migration on the other hand is migrating into India bringing their language and culture and somehow imposed it on the local population without violence, and interbred.
But what they have in common? Hinduism, Sanskrit and the fair so-called Caucasian genes are foreign to India.
No matter which indian are you always proud to be indian 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
Jai hind
Proud to be Indian from America (indigenous people) 😇🙏
@@OkarinHououinKyouma itna hi proud hai toh india aaja bhai
@@radiem321 dollar is stronger than rupee
@@_prash we're hospitable people bro
I'm PhD student working in the area of population genetics. I would like to appreciate the entire team as this video is simple, summarised, accurate and neutral video available on internet on this topic.
Indeed there's no doubt that there's mixture , since we see Meghwal is has more ANI ratio than UCs of Southern India but at the end , it's the caste which frames this society , UCs ( military caste) of South India might have less ANI ratio than Meghwal ( reason - the former is a military caste) but the former has more than it's counterparts of Southern India , the Namboodris have more than them , hence it's decides which caste can rule , ultimately it's the ANI (the Aryan culture) in the blood which decided who can rule. Aryan Invasion can't be brushed under the carpet like anything.
@@Nik-ns1ho It can be brushed, and it has been, sorry
@2K19/ME/216 SARTHAK JAIN if aryans have come from europe and invaded the indus valley civilization than why there is not any statues toys are found which are influenced by european culture. All those evidences are influence from hinduism and it's culture.
@2K19/ME/216 SARTHAK JAIN ashvamedha is not about horse sacrifice bro please correct yourself.🤣
That's so nice.
As long as we believe that we are Indian from heart nothing else matters.
In contemporary world, we should work together in making this world happy and safe ! ❤️🇮🇳
Mature comment 👆
Bhartiye/arya ,indian is foreign term
@@mtk3755 jAabe bachodi mat kr
Absolutely Proud to be a Bhartiye.
Our history starts back from Bharat King(after whom our country is named) . These Aryan invasion theories bs r not going to be proven correct... Lets wait nd watch.
@@hitmmann Aryan Invasion has been debunked already and abandoned by scholars, Aryan Migration theory is accepted right now.
who were making Handaxes in India 1.8 mya, you?
dont make videos related to archaeology if you dont know Indian Pre-history.
Sometimes people even assume caste based on colour. I am a low caste Hindu with light skin. Many just assume I must be high caste. Some even have used our caste name as slang infront of me thinking I am a high caste like them. It definitely feels bad and I just think should I tell them or not. 😅
color and DNA are different
people still bother about caste? I thought they stopped
@@mangopudding5948not everyone but some
@Akarsh2008 yeah reservation is biggest problem for general category like us.
@@mangopudding5948 Casteism is not eradicated completely but is reduced very much compared to before Mostly People who do casteism today are Politically motivated person or want reservation
In Dhruv Rathee's video he mentioned that the Indus Valley language is written from right to left but I don't think South Indian languages are written in that way. Actually the history that we were taught was taught in a black and white manner. We were told only one side of the story that fitted the left narrative. We were never told that it's a grey area. This is a criminal offense done by the historians.
P.S. Dr. B. R. Ambedkar also didn't accept the Aryan Invasion Theory.
Chakroborty?!
No wonder you commented this 🌚
The Aryan Invasion Theory is false, but there was definitely a migration of Indo-Iranians as well as Dravidians into the sub-continent, it's just not as violent as we think. There was likely a lot of peaceful relations between the two people groups, since there is some significant Dravidian influence like retroflex consonants in Rigvedic Sanskrit that is not found in any other IE languages.
Yes man , even William Jones said ( Sanskrit is the mother of all Western languages , then how it is possible that , mother copied her origin from her children , i.e, German / french etc 😂😂😂 ) It is totally wrong to say that Aryan migration happened , Actually Aryan Expansion happened 🙏
Spoken language /=/ written language.
Indus valley languages may have used a different script to write their sentences and words but their vocabulary has a startling similarity to Dravidian languages.
The Indus valley script was completely different, and it was more like heiroglyphics than today's language scripts. Today's Southern Indian and Northern Indian languages are written in Brahmi scripts, Brahmi scripts were invented about 2,500 years ago. The Indus valley script is lost to time. Just because it is written from right to left, you cannot say that it isn't related to Southern Indian languages. Even, Arabic is written from right to left, so, will you say that Indus valley language is related to Arabic?
It all depends on what political ideology do you follow and which research work you follow to build your perception or to strengthen your prejudiced perception.
Average Sandip Patra fan
Still in long run the burden of truth and evidence form these studies will either give confidence or loose confidence to claim you're statements in public.
So true. I just want to know the truth, but this topic is so heavily politicized that it get's very tiresome to keep separating science from political agenda.
For example after watching this video no one would claim that I'm a pure Aryan, Dravidian or anything etc... Even if he claims the burden of gene pool study relys on him.
@@riichobamin7612 Same with me
Very happy to see India's youth still following research-based evidence to seek answers - rather than joining the ranks of WA university! Keep it up 👍
What is WA University? I am not from India, is it an Indian University or Institute?
WA university is inside joke because WA means WhatsApp, lots of hindu nationalist majority of them speak hindi so they are the same ethnic stock, they spread from rajasthan to bihar, they are also called as hindians which is derogatory term because they are agrressive and annoying, so the inside joke flourished all over india that these Hindians believed that they are the original humans of india even they believe that all ancestors of humans are them
Where u came from?
@@joqqy8497 In India some people spread fake news from WhatsApp so we call it wa university
@@joqqy8497 whatsapp university lol
Hi Mohak... really appreciate all the research that went into this video... but as a person from the North East i expected atleast one sentence which mentions the so called 'Asian' look of majority of North Easterners. India is not only about Northern and South Indians. There have been migrations from Myanmar, Southern China, Thailand etc. Infact Ahoms of Assam spoke Tai language which is similar to Thai language.
It means you have not paid attention to the video
@@srijantata Lol no he didn't mentioned anything about Northeast
Yah...may be because he only focused on major migrations so didn’t talk about tibetan and burmese genetic influence.
I am a Bangladeshi bengali and we also have about 7% of our ancestry from tibetan-burmese people
@@srijantata no, the people that migrated 4000 years ago from Myanmar are not related to present day burmese or north-east indians.
They are the ancestors of munda, santhalis etc.
Read shrikant talageris book (genetics and Aryan debate - early Indians, Tony Joseph's latest assault) where he debunks Tony Joseph's Aryan MIGRATION theory which was invented when left1sTs started realising that Aryan INVASION theory is failing
These theories were invented to divide h1nduzz
I am an Indian.
That's the only thing matters.
Long live the Motherland ✊✊
Long live mother india ✊✊
Vande matram 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇮🇳
Chad Username
Proud to be an assamese.
@@ghs89 haan Bhai Assam khaha h ? 🧐
Go watch Schindler's list before using the profile pic. And if you want to use Swastika use the Indian one not the Hakenkreuz
@@ghs89 it's a same thing indian and Assamese
British before: Aryans invaded india.
Now: Aryans took refuge in india.
Future: Aryans came for a picnic in India.
Abhi Kisne kaha Aryan Refugee bankar aaye?
Future : Aryans are true indian rest of them are invaders
@@Mr.Endlesss aryans could be in small numbers but they didn`t found SANSKRIT language.
it can also be that , some sanskrit word must be passed from places to places by travellers because there was also connection and trade between INDIA and ROMAN civilisation.
@@thenoobdashow7428 Brahmins bhi bahut small number (maybe 5%) me hai par jitna unka pakad hai Government & Government machinery & Hindu religion me hai door door tak koi nahi hai
Aryan small number me the isliye Sanskrit kabhi ordinary Indians ki language nahi ban pai bo sirf Elite class aur court language thi locals prakrit, Pali Awadhi, maithli Punjabi Munda etc. Languages bolte the
@@thenoobdashow7428 Kushan Huns Cytheans & Turk-Mughal Afghan bhi bahut kam the phir bhi kai centuries tak inhone ruled kiya
Jabki Aryan ke paas Dharm ka bhi factor tha jisse bo dusro par supremacy established karte the
Don't know why but that Pizza Analogy got me teared up , Genetics , religion, politics nothing matters , I'm proud to be INDIAN
yeah same, it feels like India is just one whole world mixed together, the actual Vasudeva Kutumbakam
All indians have same DNA🧬 by science 🙂
This guy excudes such a positive energy that he tends to lift everyone's spirit,,,
shadi krle
@@hellobois bruh ☠️
Generic comment check ✔️✅
@@hellobois 😂
@@hellobois chill bro chill
BJP Supporters: Theory is totally false
DMK Supporters: Theory is totally true
India: civil war occuring in 3….2….1:
Sab ye dekhne me busy hai ki hum kaun hai, kaha se aaye. Hume kaha jaana hai ispe focus krenge to kitna achha hota...
North or South, East or West . Always a proud Indian
Proud to be a Mulnivasi.
Abhijit CHAD VA?
What is there to be proud ?
@@ghs89 who mulniwasi ?
@@ghs89 jai mim bhi toh likh aage 🤣🤣 likhimpuri mai aa gya swad
All theories, nothing scientific, no evidence.. these theories increasing difference between indian people which were started by Britishers. What we will achieve by knowing these..
🧢🧢🧢🧢🧢🧢
"According to the Tholkappiyam, the earliest work of Tamil literature, eighteen clans of the Velirs came from the city of Tuvarapati under the leadership of the sage Agastya". And that the ancestors of the Velir may have been related to the inhabitants of the post Harappan Chacolithic Black and Red ware sites (after the fall of Indus valley civilization).
People were already living in South when they migrated to South.
There's a Possibility of Early Indians settlement in South India. We can see the Direct similarities and slightly modified version of some symbols that were found in Keezhadi civilization and Indus valley civilization.
He is not agasthya,he is Agathiyar
It would be good if you mention which book in the anthology says this. Which song in Tolkapiyam mentions Velir you will give the song and the song me but it will be fine?? It would be good if you also mention in which chapter it is mentioned?? You will also mention where there is a reference to Agastiya in the Tolkapiyam but that would be fine?? Which Sangam literary hymn contains a reference to Agastia? What is that song number? Which Sangam literature has a reference? Would it be ok to share??
@Haris V C Which song has a reference to him in Sangm literature and tholkappiyam?? Is Agastiya a mythological legend or is there any mention of him in any sangam song??
@@சொல்லாட்சி idk xactly in which book
Its okay
Now i want to ask why bhagts always say that mughals were not indians🤔
While bhagts parents were also not indians 🤣😂
I am from Odisha, here you can see a crazy mix of north indian and south indian cultures.😁 sometimes we make fun of north and sometimes of south, but love both. Intermixing had happened here a lot, it had become a lot homogenous here
*Listen to Dr. Neeraj Rai and Shrikant Talageri*
Same with Maharashtra 😁
Also in Maharashtra
@@Hindu428 Aarushi is a north indian name
@@sbiibps8266 lol, I am Marathi, and Marathi and Hindi shares 40% same words , if you come to Maharashtra you will see people having names like Pooja, Ashwini, Ramesh, Suresh, chintu, pintu etc...
Marathi and Sanskrut shares 60-70% word similarity
7:42 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️ You found some similar words b/w sanskrit and European language that's means sankrit people came from Europe !!!
Koreans and Japanese have many similar words with South Indians that means South Indians came from Korea 🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️!!!
Sankrit is more similar to south Indians languages than European languages,
And south Indians languages is more similar to sankrit than Koreans or Japanese!!!
Today due to urdufication of North India we are uncomfortable by languages !!! But you can check
Assamese/Nepali/ pahadi/kashmiri/Bangla ect... languages are more similar to southindians languages than Hindi(Urdu🤐) !!!
Bhai tu bhi abhijeet sir ka fan h 😁😁
@@deku006 yes !!!
Yes Even Marathi, i have read it somewhere that Marathi is closest to Sanskrit language, i mean 60%-70% they are similar
@@Hindu428Because sant dnyaneswar created marathi language 😊
Yeah but marathi also have many foreign words due to invasions@@Hindu428
I'd like to get my genes tested aswell. I think It'd be cool to know my genetic history.
Any suggestions regarding the testing agencies?
All indians have same DNA🧬 by science 🙂
The rakhi garh skeleton is a female Skeleton, it is not possible to find R1A1 Gene in them, R1A1 Gene is Y-Chromosomal Male Gene and only be transferred from Male to Males .
@@souventudubanned steppe mlba
@@souventudubanned R1A1
R1A1 is originated from Haplogroup F whichever is originated in India
You forgot the Scythian and Kushans invasion. Jaats have Scythian genes and Gujjars have kushan genes. They were Ayranised.
@@prashantkushwaha6055 Haplogroup F is a gene that originated almost 60,000 years ago in India. But, R1A1 originated less than 10,000 years ago, but, in Central Asia.
Bhai your research is so incomplete.
😂tiwari
Sharma
...crying in comments.
@@Dont_hate_Muslims His research is incomplete because this same research can be relevant 4-5 years back now the recent excavation in UP proved everything the facts he presented is outdated the information updated now.
@@Dont_hate_Muslims Better than FUKTA Bhimtas who live on taxpayers still keep abusing them on shits...
Big shoutout to 14411, we are grateful for your contribution to understand ourselves better.😜
True, but 🤣
Offcourse aryan invension/migration theory real leave the Dna studies lets discuss social and religios structure of indus valley
1. No temple , yagya kund found in in indus valley as opposite with steppe or aryan people use to follow in polytheistic religion use to do yagya or yagna and make temples
2. No social hierarchy found in indus valley unlike yamanya or aryan or steppe people always manage social hierarchy.
3.and also no steppe dna found in rakhigiri hissar civilization's Skelton.
Before the aryans arrived most of the people of india use to workship shiva.......indira brahama and vishnu has nothing to do with bharat bhumi they are ancient irani Gods, Rigveda almost similer to old persian religious book aventa.....old persian is also very much similer to sanskrit
@@uncensoredhealth1453 Middle East was a part of akhand bharat
@@yash432 whole universe is Akhand Bharat
@@rishavkumar1250 yes brahmand is in Hinduism 😂
apne propoganda ko suit karti sab baat deekha di main nhi deekhai sunauli ma mili tombs ma same practice hoti thi jo Egyptian karte the iska mtlb vo egypt se aye the. 😂😂
Harappa mai Pashupatinath ki seal shivling hawan vedi tantrik bali pratha ki wall painting bhi mili ab bol dena persians bhole nath ki puja karte the 😂😂
5000 years phela se saraswati river extent hone lagi thi mention mahabharat. Magar Rigveda ma usko ufan vali tez bahav ki nadi bataya hai. Ukrainian itne intelligent the phela aryans banke bharat aye phir time travel karke satelite se sarswati river deekhi phir time travel karke 3000 bce ma gaye river ke dry hone ki baat likhi phir 7000 sal phela gaye raam setu banaya mulnivasi ravan ko mara phir aur 3000 sal phela gaye dwarka basai aur dubai bhi. phir apne time ma vapas ake vedas likhe purans likhe upanishad likhe Bharatvarsh ki puri geography study ki even minor minor villages tribes bhi study ki pata nhi konse alien tech se😅 aur sab likha. Aur vo ukraine wale aj khud christian bane baithe hai aur itne tejasvi hone ke bavjood bhi apna desh nhi bacha pa rhe😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Harappan aur so called africans ke saath dingi dingi ki. Itna sab kuch kar liya 😂😂😂😂😂
Tabhi to modi ji bolte hai itne tajasvi log hai 😅😅😅😅😅
Aryan migration invasion picnic irani migration these all are myth after reading some articles this guy think he is a DNA or archeological expert
There is one and only truth and that is Out of india migration. That's why we see the similarities between Hinduism and other old polytheistic religions
Please add English subtitles.
Request from South India :)
why not Tamil/Telugu subtitles?
@@yashhmeshram then the video will be filled with words not content 😂
@@yashhmeshram can all South Indians understand Telugu/Tamil. 🤦🤦
They'll eventually. In a week's time.
Important issue raised. Mohak must take note of this request
I took my 23andme DNA ancestry test a couple of years ago. The results are fascinating, I am 45% of south Indian origin and 43% North Indian origin and 9% Bengali and Northeast Indian. I checked my Maternal haplogroup which traces back to Mitochondrial Eve then Group L migrates from Africa to Middle east 200,000 years ago which branches off into N and R and the offshoots of Group R are Group U which migrated to different parts of Europe, Central Asia and India. The haplogroup U2b traces back to the original inhabitants of the Indus River valley which explains the 43% North Indian ancestry.
where can we get this test ? and what is the cost associated with it ?
What is your mother tongue anyway ?
I am a Bengali Brahmin, and my DNA test showed close to 75% North Indian/Pakistani ancestry, which at the time seemed strange but now I know why.
Also, just how North Indians and South Indians fight over ancestry, I have noticed East and West Bengalis do the same too.😂
@@PaulAllen6304 where did you get this test bro ?? And what is the cost for DNA testing ??
@@PaulAllen6304 strange
Feeling sad for tamilians. .who think hinduism is a foreign religion for them..... their whole life was a lie😂 actually dravidian peoples r the earliest hindu from ivc
Yeah!
Tamilians are among the most Religious(and sometimes Superstitious) Hindus. I don't know how people in the North think that they are "Anti-Hindu" or whatever.
well you vote for party that wants to eradic*te hinduism.that time and again defames and insults hindus....so it is natural for us to think that.
Actually we indians are mixter of 4 races found in indus valley civilisation Meditarian (dravidian south )
Proto Autroloids(north )
Nordic or Alpanoids (north west )
Mongoloids ( north east )
And aryan were one who came to bharat from central asia
Actually, I read somewhere that Aryan Invasion Theory was basically created because the British did not want to attribute that Indians who they considered an inferior, ugly race could have created or written Vedas and other evolved texts. Macaulay was very influenced by Indian texts but wanted us to think of ourselves as inferior. Originally as per British it was not North Indians, Aryans were a white European race, since obviously only White people are capable. At some point it shifted to North vs. South - not sure because of politicians or our own internal racism. Today, the south states and leftists hold on to this Aryan Invasion theory because they want to sow separatist ideas in south. The only exception being brahmins according to them. So it has gone to the extent of attributing different castes of being different race. The Hindu is part of left wing media outlet so their headline is not surprising. Also, why aren't we willing to acknowledge the role of Islamic invasions in why North Indians look the way they do. Infact, even if you look at tamils in India, they look much more mixed compared to tamils in sri Lanka or Malaysia who are more homogeneous. It only takes 1-2 generations of mixing a population for appearance to change.
It ia true only
He takes aryan invasion theory directly a concept..
But it is claim
true and this youtuber is also wrong we r indfian we evolved in Sarasvati not in Iran sir
true this video is fake, aryan invasion theory is a myth. i beleive in out of india migration.
Evolved texts? What are they, Pokemon? lol.
You read some false propaganda article
next topic : why do south indians always have this superiority complex?
How about why north Indians come out as very ignorant and egoistic???
Seriously, What???
Next topic: why do North Indians think protest against hindi imposition is against hindi language.
@@nknkannadiga9742 me as a north indian
think hindi imposition is wrong my first language is kashmiri then hindi
@GOUTHAM KRISHNA lol racism is everywhere even in south
One of the fact-based channels..love from Pakistan 🇵🇰
Actuallllly
Like dhruv rathee
@@ujjavalverma6092 us gelsappe ka name kyo bol rahe ho bhai 😂
@@ujjavalverma6092 yah channel pakistan se kuch jyada hi love paata hain
@@ujjavalverma6092 he's a bad news for andhbhakts
DRAVIDIAN and SANSKRIT mai bhi bahut se words miljiltha hai...
Aryan invasion is bullshit and india is land of first man with proofs emerge from 10000 of years before...
NEVER TRUST ANY FOREIGNER BOOK ABOUT INDIAN HISTORY..
I get considered to be an Arab or a Pakistani because I speak Nawayathi (Konkani dialect ). It’s an amalgam of Farsi, Urdu, Marathi, Arabic and Konkani. It’s spoken in coastal regions of Karnataka. Again majority of our people are fair but we also have people of darker skin tones. I am in the middle. India is diverse more than any other country 🇮🇳 ❤
Very interesting. Never knew this.
Not only the coastal region of Karnataka but also Maharashtra coastal region
Its okay
Now i want to ask why bhagts always say that mughals were not indians🤔
While bhagts parents were also not indians 🤣😂
Konkani ko western maharastra (kokan) me boli jati he. Thodi bahot karnatak me. Kokani sublanguag he marathi ki. Marathi aryan language he.
Pakistanis also comes under Aryans
Actually ( Aryan Invasion ) never happened .....
( Aryan Expansion ) Happened ..
Sanskrit is the mother of all Western languages -- ( William Jones )
( Then how it is possible that mother copied her babies , if someone believe in Aryan Migration theory ) 😂😂
There are dozens of other researchers who believe in AIT but they have propoganda but William Jones is telling the truth? One westerner supports you now he is telling the truth. How convenient
No we tamils are original people
Falsehood, sanskrit is itself one of languages developed out of proto Indo aryan languages. The Proto Indo Aryan is branch of Indo European languages.😂
@@freetamilnaduandsouthfromi2984 okk bro , liberation force ??? 🙂🙂🙂🙂 New country coming soon 🙏🙏🙏
Lol true. Sanskrit has influence over European, Middle Eastern and even South East Asian languages.
I totally disagree with this content ! Because every theory is just assumption and in science we believe only in concrete answer which is acceptable all around the world not by pressuring one to accept it ! Also here the case on Indians and their identity so as per my study and knowledge gathering by authentic books ...our Vedas were not written by a men also science is proved that these holy scriptures "Has No Writer and if It Has Then He was divine-LORD BRAHMA" .
Coming to your video It seems that you only provide contents which is simply available on internet (written & provided by sickbrains) so kindly do reasearch and please read Vedas first then talk about Aryaas and Indians !
The African theory has also been told wrong and there is still a lot of improvement to be done in the research paper which has been told.
I request you to don't mislead Indians !
Hail Sanatan Dharma 🧡
We South Indians are a different race from most North Indians!.. It is very clear in our physical appearance itself!!.. It is as simple as that..
Aryans came from Steppe Grasslands in Europe about 3,500yrs ago & brought Vedhas from there.. The word Aryans is there in many cultures of Europe!..
Iranian Zoro Astricism & Vedhas based Hinduism have a lot of similarities..😮
The tamils have absolutely no connection with your Iranian migrated people at all!!.. Stop saying false stories!..
Bro why you have Sanskrit name?
@@Pihu523because most Dravidian names have become outdated because of Sanskrit cultural influence from the upper castes who naturally dominated, nothing wrong though.
And so what if the Aryans came from outside? Dravidians also came from outside. Everyone came from Africa.
11:50 Goosebumps Moment🇮🇳
Our identity is not Aryan or Dravidian, Like B.R Ambedkar said "We are Indians firstly and lastly" Jai hind🇮🇳
They he introduced reservation which is quite contrary to his statement 🤦🏻♂️
@@aayushkumar6955 social justice is necessary
You can't have a india where majority of its population still face discrimination
Read shrikant talageris book (genetics and Aryan debate - early Indians, Tony Joseph's latest assault) where he debunks Tony Joseph's Aryan MIGRATION theory which was invented when left1sTs started realising that Aryan INVASION theory is failing
These theories were invented to divide h1nduzs
@@aayushkumar6955 Discrimination regarding caste was not introduced by BR Ambedkar, A kulin bramhin marrying 109 girls was not introduced by Ambedkar, Reservation in temple for priest being only born in a bramhin family was also not introduced by Ambedkar but certainly he played a role in stopping these discriminatory practices through hindu marriage act, hindu code bill and reservation of sc and st(which was made by Gandhi actually Ambedkar asked for separate electorate just like muslims, read poona pact) to end these discriminations (i named only few) and make India united. Social justice is important for a nation to survive, so my friend end caste discrimination from the society reservation will also end.
@@vipint3694 absolutely 👌
'14411' was a 14 year old female
The so called Aryan Gene is Haplogroup R1a1 which is Y-linked . How can it prove or disapprove AMT?
By studying mitochondria
@@kdjoshi726 but mitochondrial DNA isn't gender specific. R1aq1 is
14411 is a male skeleton. His Y dna haplogroup was H which again is native indian hunter gatherer marker. Male closest to his affinity are found in South indian tribal community. The thing is when they were excavating in Rakhigari they could recover both female and and male skeleton for genetic testing. The female one was done by indian archaeologists but male one was in most likely korea (I could be wrong here though). In mainstream media only the rakhigari female ancestry is highlighted but not male one. The very reason is, almost all genetic research done on this topic agrees upon the fact that the aryan migration that happened in india were predominantly male. They brought little to no females with them. So, the sudden change in Y dna haplogroup (native male vs aryan male) actually reinforces the controversy back to square one.
It is evident that in every video,article on this topic, the ancestry of rakhigari female is highlighted but rakhigari male's one is never ever discussed or mentioned.
@@lifa7660 interesting! Haplogroup H shows maximum diversity in our subcontinent showing that it originated in India but same is the case for R1a1 and R1b both of them show maximum diversity in Indian subcontinent and genetics it's the diversity that indicates the origin not the concentration. That just made me sceptical about AMT again then I saw the research paper referred by Mr Joseph i.e. of Mr Reich's work with 92 scientist. The conclusions were interesting but again the papers were non peer reviewed and none of the journals accepted as it had lot of circular arguments and methodologically incorrect! The research papers showing that rakhigarhi male specimen had Haplogroup H is true and the work done by the scientists is something that should be appreciated. But when it comes to the research on topic of 'Origin of Haplogroup R1a1 and R1b' there are no valid research (peer reviewed) that shows it originated in central Asian region.
This was out of pure genetics perspective. The linguistic and cultural arguments that AMT provides can be countered in multiple ways but genetics is the key for understanding the truth i believe.
Read shrikant talageris book (genetics and Aryan debate - early Indians, Tony Joseph's latest assault) where he debunks Tony Joseph's Aryan MIGRATION theory which was invented when left1sTs started realising that Aryan INVASION theory is failing
These theories were invented to divide h1induzz
How id krishna he is also came from first Indian who is Rama he is also came from first Indian where is sooryavansham many bump shows they also came from first Indian what do you saying India is the old and only oldest and oldest country Hinduism very very oldest religion came from Rama from Satya Yuga to kaliyuga
I speak Kannada and I can tell you that Kannada has more Sanskrit than Modern Hindi and is the 3rd oldest language in India after Sanskrit and Tamil.. That's the reason why we need to preserve our ancient languages.
Telugu is the 3rd oldest
Same with Malayalam. Malayalam is made by mixing tamil and Sanskrit called Manipravalam
@@ghs89 nah it's the oldest by evidence even older than Tamil evidence
North India lost it's sanskrit words due to islamic/Turkish invasions that's why south indian people find hindi as an alien language for example for vegetables we use a Persian word "sabji"
@@deku006 Iam Malayali girl who knows hindi somewhat I don't much about other South Indian languages malayalam is a language which have 50 percent sanskrit even more than hindi. I think kannada also have good percentage of sanskrit. Tamil has the least
Please share proper references behind tour claim… as far as we are aware whether harrapan language was ‘Dravidian’ or not .. ithis claim has not been peer reviewd properly or established yet
Well he's not claiming anything by himself..he is just telling the theories being propagated by the researches..
@@ashwinikumarsingh4474 no he concluded this topic with those research which r not yet aproved by any agency
@@aseemkumar4429 that's why I said "theories" ..
@@ashwinikumarsingh4474 theories should not be used to conclude any topic that is what I am saying
@@aseemkumar4429 well this video is all about theories only.. theories have some genetic evidences in their backing, hence their ground is strong..you must be aware about the recent genetic studies which upheld the Aryan Migration theory ... however, they face a strong opposition from the Hindu nationalists that rather propagate the Native Aryanism theory ... Which is what is stopping the Aryan Migration theory from being established, even after having genetic and linguistic evidences...
Western Historians and Academics: Aryans came from Central Asia
Hindu Right: Uno reverse
Based
So who is right ?
@@sumo6199 Both are wrong.
@@_prash Average Pseudo historian follower.
@@_prash no both r wrong becoz we r no different only north indians have some aryan dna
This guy didnt show the DNA result of 14411, instead made whole video on the result of it, a simple Google search on dna result of 14411 reveals that Aryan Invasion theory is Fake, but this guy is trying to say otherwise , there is 15 lakh rs offers form renowned indian historian from Rajasthan for whoever proves any authenticity of AIT, as you Mr. Mohak saying it happened, why not claim that prize.... !!
All indians have same DNA🧬 by science 🙂
Perfect bro 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
Fun fact : pre independence almost all political leaders believed in Aryan invasion theory and considered themselves Aryan eg Gandhi, Tilak, Nehru,savarkar, golvelkar etc only Ambedkar opposed it.
Now right wing opposes it and left believe in it.
Nearly everyone around the globe believed in Aryan invasion theory back then because that was the *leading theory* at that time. Also, Aryan invasion theory has already been debunked ages ago (late 20th century) in favor of Indo-Aryan migration theory.
Indo-Aryan migration theory has nothing to do with racism, western imperialisms or politics if you go and read the actual papers. People who want to trivialize this whole area of study for their own reasons are the only ones who still refer to Aryan invasion theory be it left or right... like you
Stop bending the truth.
@@dishuuu112 That's pretty dumb. All Bronze age civilizations from Hitties, Ugher to Egypt have written letters and records of Sea People invasion which caused the Bronze Age collapse. Apparently due to Climate change around that time a massive drought occur which caused Mass migration and invasion of people of grasslands towards these River Valley civilization. We have famous Last cry of help from Ugher, Ramses proclamation of Victory over these Sea people. Now the thing is we cannot read IVC scripts but considering what happened to to other Bronze age empires, it's fair to say same destruction and invasion came to IVC.
Nah.. We are aryans..
Aryan Invasion/Migration is unavoidable. It’s based off genetics.
@@aniket385 Many of the genetic results and carbon dating of the skeletons opposed this "invasion" theory as none of them showed West Eurasian or Bronze age component.
I was very curious about this topic and tried messaging different youtubers on it and commenting on their videos.... finally thank you for making it and please make a video on indus valley language and culture, looking forward to it 🙂
try watching abhijeet chawada videos he explained with more accurate scientific proofs.
Yes
@@GireeshSharma0510 He's a shameless sanghi who spews bullshit shamelessly like a cow 🐄 on the streets bullshits publicly.
His dad didn't beat him up enough.
@@GireeshSharma0510 chawda is a right wing andhbhakt
@@GireeshSharma0510 completely agree watch abhijit chavda instead these mainstream youtubers they have no research on this topic.
Telugu ,marathi , and many other south languages are some similarities with sanskrit. Some words like kutumbha which is family in english are same in tamil and sanskrit.
Marathi is Indo Aryan language
But have lot of Dravidian influence
Old Kannada has dravidian influence
New Kannada has sanskrit influence
Modern Telugu has a lot of sanskrit words but it was after Nannayya used many sanskrit in Telugu translation of Mahabharatam and later several poets followed the same. So there is huge Sanskrit influence on Telugu.
Just got assimilated over years...
Uninformed comment.. Marathi is Indo European language.
Arya invasion theory is a myth, recent excavation of Sinauli completely exposed this theory, the Aryans genes were found in Sinauli which pre date's arayan invasion, also war equipments and chariots were found which indicates us that the warrior culture was present in those times
Invasion theory is not myth
Hinduism kaa origin India Mae hee hua hai.
Sirf Kuch cheeje similar hai invasion aur Aryan kaa.
Sinauli is not of Indus valley times
@@furqanshariff it is of indus valley time
@@SureshSingh-fc3uh It belongs to late broze age when the civilisation was collapsing.
There is nothing in excavation of sinauli, shows Aryan migration theory wrong.
We're okay with everyone. Whether indian, Aryan, Persian, Dravidian. Only tamilians care about that. I do not understand why are they so angry about everything everytime?
LoL it's just Stalin and that Periyar guy (he used to)
@@deku006 every time I see them in news they are angry 😂 at North Indians and call them you Aryans go back. Or it's you can't force hindi on us. Well Mr. Jaishankar is my favourite person in BJP so will not complain much about tamilians.
As an maharastrian we don't care, we want to know who is behind the shifting of semiconductor chip plant from Maharashtra to Gujarat
Dammmmm🤣🤣
Kdk bhau
As a gujarati, i would say we all know who is behind this
Don't worry man, you at least have sanjay raut
Loudi ji
We don't need semiconductor plant because we already have world's best leader sharad pawar.
Nowadays, talking about aryan- Dravidian origin is useless as these theories were the brain child of Britishers & some secular political parties. After all it's unity in diversity which matters which we have achieved. At the time of independence there were nearly 545 princely states which merged with new india willingly except nizams of hyderabad. So, during this time, theory of aryan invasion has become outdated & obsolete. Now, I am 65 yrs old & during my primary school days this aryan theory was in school books & now it should be removed if it's still there. 😊
Hinduism is not a homogeneous religion like other Abrahamic religion but a has influence of both Aryan, Dravidians and many tribal beliefs.
It's actually a collective tribal, local beliefs and polytheism grouped, and people made it collectively called it Hinduism or Santana dharma etc.. and mostly the textual books of Hinduism are from nort east indians adapted by other parts of India .. even middle East had same polytheist belief before chirstianity, Islam , jews .. and that is why Muhammad ﷺ is considered last of all prophets, there will be no messengers of God after to convey the message of worship only one God.
@@pathofseekingknowledge9813 He may have been lying.
@@instantdominator2121 he was
Hinduism became a so-called official religion only during British rule.
Abrahamic religions are also not homogeneous either historically speaking. There has been several influences and syntheses over the centuries
Full fake video.
I'm from Karnataka 💛❤️ proud to be history language culture 💪💪...
But now central government hindi imposition 🤬
We need a language for communication otherwise we have to speak that English language everywhere. I don't think they are imposing ,you can still speak your mother tongue and it will be still your State language.dont worry. 🙏
No one has imposed Hindi. Hindi is not a compulsory subject in non Hindi speaking states
We need Dravida Nadu
Yeah bro I'm from north and it hurts that you people are facing situations like this
I understand there is need of a common language but it can take time we don't need that plan immediately
I am also a Kannadathi, what I really think is Hindi is the most used language across India and we have 22 official languages, here people choose Hindi to connect with everyone when we have linguistic difference so its difficult to communicate but most of us prefer english to use but forcefully imposing on us & making it compulsory is a bad thing I obligate that, see when you try to live in any place in this world people always try to adapt which is in majority, we are the one who get benefit by learning and communication become flexible with others and also its better to communicate/understanding in Hindi than in English with outsiders ,I used to hate learning Hindi in my school days never liked it ,but now most of the content available in any platform is almost in Hindi (regional channels) this video is also in Hindi that's how it works
ARYANS NEVER INVADED INDIA WE ARE NATIVE OF THIS LAND
Aryans migrated to India
@@SUD7117 NEVER
@@SUD7117 THEY REMAIN TILL THE AFGHANISTAN NOT IN INDIA
@@SUD7117 ITS A MYTH TO DIVIDE PEOPLE
I disagree with the bit where you said Indians stopped marrying outside their caste 1900 years ago during Gupta period because Vedic religion became popular. First of all the vedic religion has been popular for atleast 4000 years, also Gupta rule didn't even exist 1900 years ago. The most recent study says that endogamy started in India around 1570 years ago during the Gupta period and has more to do with the fact that, India was most prosperous during this period and family occupations had started to develop, so carpenter would only marry a carpenter to make sure that the skill of carpentry continues over the generations.
Vedic religion was not popular before 4000 years ago and give source to all of them
How is bullshit propaganda like this upvoted?
@@alezrandom4146 Vedic religion was quite popular among north india, especially the gangetic plains.
@@alezrandom4146 The Mittani Kingdom existed 3500 years ago in modern day Syria, they used late vedic sanskrit and not the early or middle vedic sanskrit, which means the vedas were written atleast 7000 years ago(keeping the fact in mind that Saraswati river dried up 4000 years ago, and the Rig Veda mentions Saraswati river as a giant roaring river and not a tiny drying river.) If the late vedic sanskrit reached syria 3500 years ago, it is safe to assume the vedas were popular in India by that time.
And why the hell should i provide sources? How hard is it for you to use google?
Ya he mistaken Puranic religion for vedic
Tamils are the purest native dark Dravidians without mixing with any other groups unlike other states(excluding tamil brahmins tho)
@GOUTHAM KRISHNA think it has to do with hot climate in tamil nadu and possibly some east African genes too..
Not at all, they did mixed with other people. There are many light skinned people in Tamilnadu.
No, there were people before. The next group mixed in with the native population!
There is no such thing as pure DNA in any place in the world. Everyone has mixed in a much!
Please stop reading messages from Watsapp university or Right-wing nationalists!
We are lucky to citizens of India 🇮🇳 ❤️
Vibrant culture, awesome unity. Kedar se Rameshwarm tak, Dwarikadhish se Jagannath tak ❤️
No word india exist at that time, how come you tell that south india north India ,bharath varsh and akanda bharath is the only truth.
Read shrikant talageris book (genetics and Aryan debate - early Indians, Tony Joseph's latest assault) where he debunks Tony Joseph's Aryan MIGRATION theory which was invented when left1sTs started realising that Aryan INVASION theory is failing
Jagannath nhi Arunanchal tak
@@user-563-e8 na Akhand bharat tha , gazawa-e-hind sab politicians ka natak hai
@@no_smoking__6608 kya
Don't just repeat knowledge you read up on the internet like some kind of parrot. There is no real insight in this video.
किसी का हमने छीना नहीं, प्रकृति का रहा पालना यहीं
हमारी जन्मभूमि थी यहीं, कहीं से हम आए थे नहीं...🙏
जयतु भारतम🇮🇳
We all came from africa 😅😅😅😅 aiven hi senti hone ki jarurat nhi h
@@archiem654 proof?
@@saransh9373 plenty of research papers that prove that. Its very well established fact ... agreed upon by scientists
@@archiem654 but indians and slavic are different lol.
@@saransh9373 geography is a thing. We tend to adapt to the behaviour. Its also a well established fact that people who have lived in sunny and hot areas tend to be darker so that they can protect themselves from the harmful radiations from sun.
Initially
AIT : Aryan Invasion Theory
Then
AIT : Aryan Immigration Theory
In future :
AIT : Aryan Imagination Theory
😅🤣😂
Not it's called aryan tourism theory. 😂😂😂
@@vishalsinghbaghel I heard a similar one, Aryan Picnic Theory
There are no strong to justify Aryan Invasion, they could had fought wars with Indus people described in the Rigveda but mixed with them later.
lol, yeah..They are so offended and they will like saying the Mughals, Alexnder went on a tour theory to India!
You are qouting all sources except sanskrit because you want only viewership ,have u ever read rig veda where they says aryan as invader no ,
Whenever someone write there history or custom it always highlight there roots (the same way when u go outside u praise your culture ) so before making any such video please make sure you have the same mean in both side.otherwise don't..😔🤐
I think this is not 100% correct all the North East West and South Indians are bases on same genetic roots that is Haplogroup F for males and Haplogroup M and N for females which originates in India around 60k years ago and these genes went outside India all the way to Europe and Australia and there was no such Aryans Invasion or Migration happens because when such large scale Migration happens it changes entire genetic lineage and culture of this place and Indian culture remain same at its core from 10000 years ago with regional variation because India was diverse right from its beginning but if you consider Europe its genetic and culture completely changed 4000 years ago because at this time the Yamnaya invasion happens in Europe which was an Indian tribe who rampaged around Europe doing horrible massacres and it changed their genetic lineage culture architecture pottery etc so it is true that it is actually Indian who went outside and spread their culture and language though small scale Migration always happens in India over the years but this was never so huge and significant and how can someone say the name of elephant in indus valley civilization is similar to South Indian language when the script is not yet deciphered these are only some foolish political move to play Dravidian and Aryan politics
How are you still considering "Out of Africa theory" when stone age tools found in Attirampakkam near Chennai dates back to 3,85,000 years Ago!!!
the video is wrong obviously, but do you know the oldest stone tools are found in africa not outside of it.
@@handIe. prove it
@Screen Shot Posting wtf are you saying? 🤦♂️
Because gna haplotype showed that the genome type was first found in africa
Bs
Well I am from Uttarakhand but I have seen more of Greek features in me compared to Mongolian/Chinese Also by passing time dilution is happening and in the end it doesn't matter much Coz everyone came from Africa.
Same bro but I’m from Rung community and I think we’re more like oriental. In my opinion, Jaunsaris are closest(in terms of facial features)to the North Western people here.
Read shrikant talageris book (genetics and Aryan debate - early Indians, Tony Joseph's latest assault) where he debunks Tony Joseph's Aryan MIGRATION theory which was invented when left1sTs started realising that Aryan INVASION theory is failing
Greeks were here for 400 years esp. in the mountain regions protected from continuos forthcoming invasions
The colour of the skin depends on the environment and place.
We all are pure Indian , and we aren't immigrants nor our ancestors,.
The appearance of your researcher is our ancestors'bad character .
Our ancestors belongs to Africa
@@16yearsold902 not mine , my ancestors were always Bhartiya
@@RoshanKumar-qy8pk science aur dna ke mutabik Africa hai
@@16yearsold902 science aur DNA ke mutabik humare ancestors bhi toh Africa ja sakte hain bharat se ?
Ye iss se thode pata chal raha ki wahi yaha aaya tha?😶
@@RoshanKumar-qy8pk You should go to school and read some real books instead of mahabharata and Manusmriti
I think you need a little more research. While trying to find a middle ground, you kept pointing at the right wing and ended up saying what the left wing says but with some compromise. There are plenty of good arguments in the comment section to take on.
If we inverse his arguements 🤔can it be possible history. Didn't indians go out of india in last he said some people came from combodia, can't it be possible that indian went to combodia🤔🤔🤔
@@abhirajan_k of course dravidians and Chinese moved to South East Asia and produced mixed offspring and some of them came back
Even Korean language consists of Various Dravidian words but no dravidian migration is shown, it could be the same in the case of Indo-Europian Culture, there is no necessary information for people migration.
Koreans think that their language is not influenced by any other language and they take pride in it....if you will tell them this then they will get angry.
Even The korean alphabet HANGEUL is similar to DEVANAGARI....but they will refuse it
@@handle0007 but think there language is more influenced by other languages compare to any languages😂😂
Just a correction - the word for three in Sanskrit is त्रयस् (त्रयः - masculine, nominative, plural) and not त्रायस्. Nice efforts! But the theories are too complex, and it will be early if we jump to a conclusion as researchers are still digging into it!
I have been taught that 1 is ekam 2 is dve and 3 is trini 4 chatvari 5 pach 6sath 7sapth 8asth 9nav 10dash from my 5 to 10 grade. Sanskrit is very complex and interesiting language like you have to use the correct vibhakti also depending on situation which is similar to karta karm karaak in hindi also it can be either ekvachanam dvivachanam and bhaovachanam which changes the way a sentence is writing unlike only singular and pural in hindi.
@@ddevilfromhell97 just compare that to Russian....1 Odin 2 dva 3 tree 4 chitirye 5 pyat 6 shesht 7 cem 8 vocem 9 devit 10 decit.
Ya sankrit influenced a lot of indo-european langauge which I think is because it being pretty advance for its time.
@Ddevil from hell त्रीणि is neutral, nominative, plural of nominal stem (प्रातिपदिक) त्रि.
@@ddevilfromhell97 nope sanskrit did not influence other IE languages (and neither was sanskrit influenced by other IE). In fact all indo european languages diverged from a single source.
And there is nothing called "advanced for its time" wrt languages
I am a Tamilian with fair skin and a lot of people assume that I am a North Indian. When I tell them that I am a Tamilian they get shocked lol. (Not all South Indians are dark like how not all North Indians are fair guys)
The real colour of Dravidian is Dark.
@@blade3625 yeah but mutation exists too. Some people can be born with lighter skin tone and over a period of thousands of years can have lighter skin tone.
@@trenboloneacetate1 i didn't understand, so you're saying the mutation did not happened for 3k years and it happened in 400 years?
@@blade3625 bro the chances of a mutation is rare but it happens. And when the people with the mutation procreate, they gene is carried over many generations. And it has been happening for thousands of years. That's why some South Indians have fair skin. Immigration from north is another reason why South Indians have fair skin too.
@@blade3625Dravidian have h and l1 haplogroup
( They also has r1a ) but h1 is considered main haplogroup of tamilian
H ancestors lived in Mesolithic Europe ( oldest detected linage marking of h ancestors)
Vast majority of Dravidian are Western Eurasian population
14411 be like Aaj moksh mil gaya 😂
Definitely we have different Languages, Color, Religion, Cultures, Practices, Rituals and Region!
But one Emotion which keep us United is,
"BHARAT MATA KI JAI"🇮🇳♥️
What abt discrimation nd suppression in the name of caste religion nd region???
Can a mother (Bharat matha) show discrimination among her children??? If this Bharat matha made her own son a slave of her other sons (Brahman, Kshatriya nd Vaishya) i dont want this matha.
If u r a victim then ur emotion will definitely change my friend.
Jai shree ram 🚩🚩🚩🚩
@@JaiHind-ti7eb Your love for country will decrease.. right??
@@JaiHind-ti7eb still its does not happen now?not on the same scale
@@JaiHind-ti7eb Caste system was increased by British. I am not saying it didn't existed but when Alexander came to india and budhist monks from China visited India. They never wrote about it in the records. Caste is also a Spanish word. Obviously their were class division. People were rich and poor. But it was increased in British Empire and Mughal Empire...
My name aryan 😅
Great information Mohak! Wonderful that you will share your Genetic details on ANI & ASI genes within you. Still, these are just theories & this shouldn't become a fodder for any Political hunger to create divisions in India
See abhijit chavda videos on it, there things are utter non sense, R1a gene proves it and soon it's origin reports, (which are likely to say that it originated in india) will conclude this debate.
i dont know about anybody else but my motivation to go abroad was to see and stalk blondie girls.
though it may sound creep but i have love for blondie and slavic people.
blondie / white girl is more beautiful than brown girl.
love from canada.
DNA testing by Dr. Lalji Singh, and Harvard University has already debunked the Aryan Invasion Myth
You by creating confusion wants to say reality is middle, by doing cherry picking of data, i strongly condemn any such action,
Bharat is thousands of year old civilization 10000years old city are found in submerged ocean, aryan theory or Dravidian all are engineered only and only to divide Bharat under divide and rule policy so believing in any such thing mean making Britishers sucessful,,
Dravidian, what is it based on language:
We all know Sanskrit is mother of all languages,
60-70 % words in Telugu is from Sanskrit,
40-50% in tamil words are Sanskrit.
And surely all present language are seperate from each other,
Bharat is a vast country all over bharat there are some new thing and missing some previous one,
Thats how distance of UP to TN become so much that local language hardly remain understandable,
3rd northern part of Bharat constantly facing outsiders attacks,
If we compare 80% of all infamous attacks are in northern part so all major culture continuity badly affected,
@@read1343 hilarious motivations, btw did you get a blonde girl? or you did you realize the truth?
India has always been the melting pot of all cultures from across the world.
India has always been a refuge for persecuted people from all across the world.
No matter what happened in the past, today this country is a great example of unity in diversity.
Be proud to be an Indian.
Jai hind.🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳
India was created in 1947. May be you meant Indian subcontinent or Hindustani subcontinent
@@SatpalVerma000 Fact👍
@@SatpalVerma000 Bharat india has it's official name and no india got independence in 1947 it existed before that it's boder territory are pre defined before 1947 which got changed in 1947 one country came out of it called Pakistan
@@divineflu34567 Italy was created in 1860. Of course its land existed before that. Roman empire was not Italy. British Indian empire, mughal empire ashoka empire was not India. India was created in 1947.
@@SatpalVerma000 What was the name of the British company again? "East *something* Company" if I remember correctly?
I am only INDIAN neither Aryan nor Dravidian and I am very. Proud of being INDIAN 💝❤️
You are neither Aryan nor Dravidian, you are a Gujjuuuuu 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@sbiibps8266 be jaat kon puch rha hai 😂
@@sbiibps8266 Patel sir name sirf gujrat me hi nhi chalata hai.
I m belong to up.
Numbers in Dravidian languages
Okati, Onnu, Ondru, Ondhu
Rendu, Randu Irandhu, Iradu
Moodu, Moonu, Mundru, Mooru
Nalugu, Naalu, Naalu, Nalgu
Aidhu, Anji, Andhu, Aidhu
Aru, Aru, Aru, Aru
Edu, Ezhu, Ezhu, Elu
Emmidhi, Ettu, Ettu, Entu
Thommidhi, Onbadhu, Onbatu
Pathi, Pathu, pathu, Hathu
No Aryan language
Ek, Ekah
Dho, Duvah
Theen, Tryah
Char, Catvarah
Panch, Pancha
Se, Sat
Saath, Saptha
Aat, Asta
Nav, Nava
Dhas, Dhasa
This shows that both are not same.
But some illiterate northies claim there is no Aryan and Dravidian languages. What we can say
@@pro-telugu1593 I support your opinion but what is the meaning of this. This made a. Seprate belief in mindset of people across the country. Elite class and politician set a propaganda to ripening their. Won benefit at the cost of national integration. And that a person like you,so-called litterate easily trapped in this. Same on you
Sigh...😩
BJP science.
Thank you so much for this video! It's hard to believe that people who believe in the Aryan invasion theory exist. One of the theory's biggest supporters is DMK which has a long record of anti-Hindu and anti-Brahmin hatred. Also, I would love a video on Harappan civilisation, their trade routes, the language, culture, its connections with sanātan dharma and how the civilisation came to an end.
Tamil people be calling tamil brahmins non tamils even tho they speak in tamil. Also appointing leaders who non tamil origin.
Stalin
Karunanidhi or something
Jayalilitha
Even periyar was born in karnataka border🤣
@@nknkannadiga9742 As a Tam bram, the pain is real🥲
@@vardhanv.8579 @Nkn Kannadiga Guys , don't feeling like that if you are Tamil Brahman still you guys are Tamilian only 🤍🤍🤍
Bahamian themself believe in that they feel proud that they were foreigners and they are better. Even veda support this
@@nknkannadiga9742 Periyar is half Telugu half Tamil.
What about Indo-Mongoloids?🙄
Especially Indians that speaks languages belonging to Sino-Tibetan language family.
they were from chinese origin.
@@helcurt2509 not everyone is Chinese origin 🤡
@@iNeed2.p LoL 😂
I am curious to know where do Hindu stories like Ramayana, Mahabharata come into the picture. We know that many places and events described in the scripture have geographical evidences across the world.
Aryan propaganda that dehumanizes and is racist towards South Indians.
Krishna or Rama or whoever the fuck that is sends an Aryan monkey 🙉 Hanuman from North to defeat the brutal barbarian South Indian Ravannan that lives in Sri Lanka.
Hanuman with the mighty power of plot armour jumps across the sea (i see where bollywood gets its action scenes inspiration from) and defeats South Indian. This blatant propaganda is celebrated as Ram Leela. LOL 😂😂.
I don't why South Indians haven't already started celebrating Ravan Leela.
Mahajanapada period, kuru and other kingdoms were on rise near indraprastha
@@_prash saraswati is still alive helmand river
@@eraofrage no, its between Jamuna and sutlej. Post vedic texts mention Saraswati river in declining phase along with location it flows. There is no literal evidence that helmand river is saraswti river that RV mentions
@@raghav5903 there is no mention where saraswati is..or it is in declining phase either...just saraswati river is mentioned and its water...most historians say helmand river is saraswati...even we havn't found any evidence of big dried river in punjab...
"Dravid" means A Land which is Bordered by Water or Sea "Drav" means Water, and "Id" means Landscape and That is Bharat,, if Kerala is part of Dravid then Kashmir is also part of Dravid, and Gujrat, Maharashtra, West Bengal, Odisha, and North East India also Part of Dravid
And there is no Aryan Invasion Theory, this is false conducted by the British and Leftists,, ARYANS are not race, Arya this is Sanskrit word, Arya is a Philosophy, The man who Protects the Dharma is an Arya, who fight for Righteousness he is Arya, and Bharat was called Aryavart, because the people of Bharatvarsh fight against Adharma, they fight for Righteousness, .. if Afganistan, Pakistan (that time of land), Kashmir, UP was known as Aryavart then Kerala, Tamilnadu, Andhrapradesh also known as Aryavart,, the people of Bharat all used to fight for Dharma
All indians have same DNA🧬 by science
@@SpecialGlobalTalks yes
@@thesentry1434 No no, if you trace the history back to pre-Christian times, you'll see that the Dravidians and the Aryans were completely different ethnic groups. Your reasoning for saying "There is no such thing as Aryans. It's all been invented by the West!" sounds fake and I can't believe it🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣. First of all, if your theory that the Aryans don't exist were true, it would be known to the public, so why isn't it considered popular in India? That's because the basis for it is questionable and it's just your personal opinion. 😂
@@SpecialGlobalTalks No, in the DNA test of Indians, it was found that the DNA is largely divided into two groups, 70% of the total is the same as the DNA of the north, and 30% of the total is the same as the DNA of the south. This is why the north Indra is said to be Aryan and the south Indra is said to be Dravidian. How can we say that the DNA of all Indians is the same when it is clear that the south and north have completely different DNA?🤣🤣
Both Aryan and Dravidian are languages that originated in the plateau, but they are from different eras, more than 1000 years apart, so at least there are ethnic groups called Aryan and Dravidian. You, who are blabbing that all Indians have the same DNA, should study a bit more. It is absolutely impossible for all people in a biologically connected country to have the same DNA. And the evidence that the Aryan invasion theory is a lie is too weak.🫵
Earliest traces of Hinduism vs 14411 carbon dating have a huge gap interms of the years where one predates the other by a huge margin. While Mohak is correct while quoting the paper, the paper has made a lot of assumptions which are contradictory with other evidences, examined that predates this theory.
Nhi
You are correct check my comment above.
@@jioboy2676 you can try finding a single evidence of sanskrit before samrat asoka. And his pillars and rock edicts.
Aryan invasion is a myth.
Mohak doesn't make sense
@@pranavw1763 I am also saying that...Hinduism is a new religion....Not 5000 yr old as claimed
I am proud to be sanatani n Indian doesn't matter from where I came 🙏