Це відео не доступне.
Перепрошуємо.

Monster (Magic: The Gathering Parody)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 гру 2020
  • Sometimes the interactions get complex.
    Announcing a Patreon! / mtgremy
    LYRICS:
    I played a Fleecemane Lion and priority was passed
    I sac’d my Ember Hauler put the trigger on the stack
    I paid five for monstrosity to make it proof from hex
    I Vial’d in Palace Jailer then to make myself the best
    I made a Jailer copy with my Faerie Artisans
    But what if I Tragically Slip?
    And what if I Doomedly Fall?
    Then am I the monarch?
    Just let me know
    And what if I Powerdly Sink?
    And what if I Mindedly Break it?
    Then am I the monarch?
    Just let me know
    I played my Palace Jailer first and I was in control
    I got my copy second, second to resolve
    No, the effect goes on the stack, the last is first to go
    Well if you really wanna know-
    What if I Tragically Slip?
    What if I Doomedly Fall?
    Then am I the monarch?
    Just let me know
    And what if I Powerdly Sink?
    And what if I Mindedly Break it?
    Then am I the monarch?
    Just let me know
    Mastering and background vocals by Ben Karlstrom
    Subscribe to MTGRemy! www.youtube.co...
    Filmed on iPhone during quarantine.
    Follow me at an appropriate social distance!
    Twitter: / mtgremy
    Instagram: / mtgremy
    Want to dress like Remy? WHY??? teespring.com/...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,4 тис.

  • @TolarianCommunityCollege
    @TolarianCommunityCollege 3 роки тому +7227

    We don't appreciate judges enough.

    • @michaelmcdonald2005
      @michaelmcdonald2005 3 роки тому +60

      Cheers to that.

    • @Masterchief1621
      @Masterchief1621 3 роки тому +80

      Omg is that Tolarian Community College?!
      (Make this sound like the"is that a Supra!?" Meme)

    • @lunabm
      @lunabm 3 роки тому +38

      Thanks, Professor. T.T

    • @gregoryrehling2988
      @gregoryrehling2988 3 роки тому +82

      Having the Professor's active participation in the greater Magic social media/UA-cam space is the sort of thing that gives me a glimmer of faith for the hobby. And the sentiment is spot-on.

    • @sphj3493
      @sphj3493 3 роки тому +15

      100% Prof. True that.

  • @RaynmanPlays
    @RaynmanPlays 3 роки тому +2414

    Imagine actually knowing the rules to this game.

    • @leefisher6366
      @leefisher6366 3 роки тому +31

      It would be good, but far less likely than knowing the rules of 'Mornington Crescent'.

    • @ghoulofmetal
      @ghoulofmetal 3 роки тому +36

      I know the rules well enough to recognize when to go into judge irc chat and what to ask xD

    • @RBGolbat
      @RBGolbat 3 роки тому +8

      @@ghoulofmetal look at this guy still using irc

    • @kaleidoslug7777
      @kaleidoslug7777 3 роки тому +1

      Couldnt be me

    • @jackcarsen6247
      @jackcarsen6247 3 роки тому

      imagine

  • @KingBobXVI
    @KingBobXVI 3 роки тому +905

    You know, the etiquette for joke parodies is to keep it short so it doesn't get stale by the end, and Remy does this absolutely perfectly, but we're at the point now where his raw skill and talent are surpassing the source material and I'd be _so_ down for a full version of the songs :P

  • @gunrugger
    @gunrugger 3 роки тому +498

    For those of you who are curious here is the official ruling:
    Neither player is the monarch. Due to the way the effects are stacked, the table becomes flipped before the judge activation can resolve.
    (source: I'm a level 4 judge)

    • @maggoteater2290
      @maggoteater2290 2 роки тому +41

      Well and I'm a level 6 laser lotus

    • @shiranui498
      @shiranui498 2 роки тому +13

      @@maggoteater2290 You're streets ahead!

    • @GubbiGap
      @GubbiGap 2 роки тому +25

      So do you flip the table or do the players? :p

    • @geinerelizondo2019
      @geinerelizondo2019 2 роки тому +6

      Basically, thrust me in this one!

    • @asterism343
      @asterism343 Рік тому +5

      lol. but serious question, what does Monarch even mean? (I'm a new player, I don't know these things)

  • @TheCommandersQuarters
    @TheCommandersQuarters 3 роки тому +3186

    This is going to be stuck in my head for days!

    • @godspeedhero3671
      @godspeedhero3671 3 роки тому +16

      Same! Superb lyricism here.

    • @pauljimerson8218
      @pauljimerson8218 3 роки тому +44

      Remy needs to mix in Wayfarers baubles into a song

    • @Circu_ch
      @Circu_ch 3 роки тому +5

      oh no TCQ is here :3

    • @Masterchief1621
      @Masterchief1621 3 роки тому +13

      Omg is that The Commanders Quarters?!
      (Make this sound like the"is that a Supra!?" Meme)

    • @sphj3493
      @sphj3493 3 роки тому +1

      Remy sure has a way with words!

  • @AndrewWoodford
    @AndrewWoodford 3 роки тому +1285

    Obviously Remy is the Monarch

    • @Shadowrunner123
      @Shadowrunner123 3 роки тому +51

      When you purposefully talk over the judge, they officially become monarch and the token is removed from the game.

    • @lifeiaskedfor
      @lifeiaskedfor 3 роки тому +17

      nah nah nah, remy is the monarch not remy

    • @Blomstermark
      @Blomstermark 3 роки тому +6

      @@lifeiaskedfor ha! i knew it.. glad i still can the rules.

    • @EGH9701
      @EGH9701 3 роки тому

      Right remy right

    • @coreyr.1012
      @coreyr.1012 3 роки тому

      😂

  • @wurfelkabinett-nerdkramso3046
    @wurfelkabinett-nerdkramso3046 3 роки тому +2503

    In case anyone is wondering what is actually happening, and since I'm not getting this song out of my head:
    Assuming Player A) is the active Player / its Player A’s turn, since we don’t see any flash-outlets and he plays a creature:
    1) [Fleecemane Lion] is cast and resolves => [Fleecemane Lion] is on the battlefield
    2) [Ember Hauler] is sacrificed => 2 Damage to [Fleecemane Lion] are on the stack (Stack: [Ember Hauler])
    3) Monstrosity is payed (Stack: Monstrosity > [Ember Hauler])
    4) Aether Vial is activated to put [Palace Jailer] into play. [Palace Jailer] has two triggers: 1. You become the monarch 2. Exile target creature an opponent controls until an opponent becomes the monarch. Additionally, [Faerie Artisan]s trigger. Now, the active player (Player A) puts his trigger ([Faerie Artisan]s) on the Stack first, (Stack: Player B becomes monarch > Player B [Palace Jailer] > [Faerie Artisan]s trigger > Monstrosity > [Ember Hauler]). Now, player B could either target [Faerie Artisan]s with his Jailer or [Fleecemane Lion]. Since he tries to [Tragic Slip] [Fleecemane Lion] I’ll assume he wants his Jailer to target [Faerie Artisan]s)
    5) Player B casts [Tragic Slip] targeting [Fleecemane Lion] (Stack: [Tragic Slip] > Player B becomes monarch > Player B Palace Jailor > [Faerie Artisan]s trigger > Monstrosity > [Ember Hauler]). Since Player A next casts [Doomfall], which is a sorcery and the stack needs to be empty for player A to cast a sorcery we now need to let the stack resolve. Let’s see
    Stack Resolve:
    1) [Tragic Slip] targeting fleecmane Lion: [Fleecemane Lion] gets -13/-13 (morbid cause of the sacced creature) and becomes a -10/-10 / Dies
    2) Player B becomes the monarch
    3) Player B’s [Palace Jailer] exiles [Faerie Artisan]s
    4) [Faerie Artisan]s still trigger and put a [Palace Jailer] Token into play under Player A’s control (Two new triggers on the stack: Player A becomes the monarch, and player A exiles a creature) - Stack: Player A becomes monarch > Player A [Palace Jailer] > [Faerie Artisan]s trigger > Monstrosity > [Ember Hauler]
    5) Player A becomes the monarch. This will fulfill the “until an opponent becomes the monarch” condition of Player B’s [Palace Jailer] and [Faerie Artisan]s will return to the battlefield
    6) Player A exiles a creature with his [Palace Jailer] => Player B’s [Palace Jailer]
    7) Monstrosity fizzles, since fleecemane lion is not there anymore.
    8) [[Ember Hauler]] fizzles, since it has no more valid targets ([Fleecemane Lion] is dead => [[Ember Hauler]] can’t target it anymore)
    Now player A casts [Doomfall]… since Player B has no more creatures (his palace Jailor is in exile) Player A will probably choose the "exile a nonland card from opponents hand" mode and exiles a nonland card from Player B’s hand. Next Player A casts [Powersink]… since the only other spell on the stack at this moment is [Doomfall], he targets his own spell for [Reasons] (Decksperado?). Player B chooses to cast [Mindbreak Trap] (for free btw, Player A cast 3 spells this turn: [Fleecemane Lion], [Powersink] and [Doomfall], altho only two of them are currently on the stack) and can now choose to exile any number of spells from the stack ([Doomfall] & [Powersink]) and will probably do so for [Doomfall] or both.
    To answer the question: No it is not a monster, but dead and Player A is the monarch.
    Summary:
    - [Fleecemane Lion] is dead > not a monster
    - Player A’s [Palace Jailer] Token exist
    - Player A’s [Faerie Artisan]s exist
    - Player B’s [Palace Jailer] is in exile, due to Player A’s [Palace Jailer] Token’s effect.
    - Player A countered his own [Doomfall] and player B countered Player A’s [Doomfall] and Player A’s [Power Sink].
    Now there are a few other assumptions to be made:
    => What if they missplayed [Doomfall] as an instant and put it on the stack?
    [Mindbreak Trap] would have exiled [Doomfall] and powersink (which would probably have been targeting [Tragic Slip] in this case) => Exact same results (All the other stuff happening were abilities, not spells, so [Mindbreak Trap] can't interact with them) (Also: Judge would probably rewind the game to the moment [Doomfall] was played and let the stack resolve first?)
    => What if Player B’s [Palace Jailer] targeted [Fleecemane Lion]? Nothing, since its dead when the effect resolves
    => If player B would be the active player (player B's turn) and player A has flash outlets for Creatures AND sorceries that we don't see the Player B [Palace Jailer] / Player A [Faerie Artisan]s trigger would be reversed ([Faerie Artisans] > Player B Monarch > Player B [Palace Jailer]) which would lead to: [Fleecemane Lion] is still dead. Player B is now the monarch, instead of Player A and the [Faerie Artisan]s would be in exile, instead of Player B's [Palace Jailer]. In that case it would not be a Monster and Player B would be the monarch.
    Correct me if I'm wrong somewhere :D
    I had to edit this because I forgot that saccing a creature triggers morbid, thanks @Rovesul

    • @K1llerKreal
      @K1llerKreal 3 роки тому +139

      After having to redo my answer multiple times, I have to point this out in your summary:
      Because of the sacrifice cost in Ember Haulers activated ability the Tragic Slips Morbid effect is active meaning it will give the Fleecemane Lion -13/-13 instead, thus making it not a monster and just dead.
      Otherwise, really great and exactly the kinda stuff I would do too xD

    • @TheCart54321
      @TheCart54321 3 роки тому +40

      🤯

    • @wurfelkabinett-nerdkramso3046
      @wurfelkabinett-nerdkramso3046 3 роки тому +41

      @@K1llerKreal Oh damn i totaly forgot that morbid was indeed active xD.. will edit, and quote you, thank you :D

    • @in_vulkan_we_trust4904
      @in_vulkan_we_trust4904 3 роки тому +4

      Thank you!

    • @ryanjones_rheios
      @ryanjones_rheios 3 роки тому +6

      @@K1llerKreal Has the Ember Hauler's ability activated yet? Isn't its activation trigger still on the stack and not yet resolved? So Tragic Slip wouldn't get Morbid until afterwords? We've may have entered into layers with this and I don't have any of that memorized.

  • @beakychugger1109
    @beakychugger1109 3 роки тому +180

    I love how he's actually a really good singer

    • @KingBobXVI
      @KingBobXVI 3 роки тому +30

      Honestly, it's unironically better than the original song, lol.

    • @hive_mind5869
      @hive_mind5869 3 роки тому +1

      @@KingBobXVI I agree

  • @ChakraX2
    @ChakraX2 3 роки тому +863

    Morning everyone, best Christmas present i could ask for

  • @bryanwilson8130
    @bryanwilson8130 3 роки тому +317

    Glad to see Mr. Melgard, Lv. 2 Judge make an appearance...

    • @RedellaStrada47
      @RedellaStrada47 3 роки тому +19

      I hope he is alright and he'll bring back the Judge's Mailsack serie!

    • @captainc0rgi
      @captainc0rgi 3 роки тому +23

      I hope he got his revenge on the Minnesota family court system.

    • @monopoman
      @monopoman 3 роки тому +1

      Hopefully someday he gets an official judge shirt, he has to be the only level 2 judge without the actual judge shirt.

    • @matthewnabb4482
      @matthewnabb4482 3 роки тому +7

      Has he figured out how layers work

    • @mikestyer3909
      @mikestyer3909 3 роки тому +2

      @@matthewnabb4482 he’s working on understanding “feelings”

  • @subtlewookiee
    @subtlewookiee 3 роки тому +434

    The way he says "JUDGE" is exactly how every player in a tournament says it. Little details like this are what make these videos so great.

    • @jrt9192
      @jrt9192 3 роки тому +23

      Seriously! Even the judge's mannerisms and facial expressions are so accurate, its hilarious.

  • @codycosman8271
    @codycosman8271 3 роки тому +78

    When the judge is like “you’re both wrong but it’s too late.”

  • @elbe0072
    @elbe0072 3 роки тому +281

    New Upload
    _
    -> Watches whole playlist again

  • @user-po6kl5sz8r
    @user-po6kl5sz8r 3 роки тому +384

    Remy is the gift Magic needs giving this year

  • @hanklestank
    @hanklestank 2 роки тому +160

    That
    "And WHAT IF I TRAGICALLY SLIIIPP (OHHHH!!!)"
    When the judge looks like he's going to break in and explain everything level headedly and normally, and then... sudden Remy belting!
    Haha it's just so *chefs kiss* perfect. Fucking love it.

  • @WoodenSwordFighter
    @WoodenSwordFighter 3 роки тому +23

    I like how these two are having an insane counter war and meanwhile the 2 damage from ember hauler wasn't enough to kill the 3/3 fleecemane lion in the first place

    • @Ouja
      @Ouja 2 роки тому +11

      Sometimes the tiniest thing can set off an insane chain of events. We had a 20 minute instant war with counters, bolts, and dozens of others spells and effects at our table once. It ended with a boardwipe. All over a Shanodin Dryad...which survived.

  • @GodOfReality
    @GodOfReality 3 роки тому +148

    To me, this is Remy's best video. The singing, the humour of the skit, the combination of how the song is a part of the skit in a sensible way. This is hilarious. AM I THE MONARCH?

    • @TheGreenLing
      @TheGreenLing 6 місяців тому

      Slivers/Shiver is really good as well.

  • @SnapBolt
    @SnapBolt 3 роки тому +191

    Best Part 1:32
    "What if I powerdly sink....... Old Skooooool!"

  • @1mrlee
    @1mrlee 3 роки тому +52

    oh man, i lost it when you said: "we need a ruling..." at the end.

  • @Pintyhet
    @Pintyhet 3 роки тому +176

    I’m just continuously impressed with the writing and singing chops delivered every song.

  • @ivobiz2445
    @ivobiz2445 3 роки тому +216

    I cant give this guy enough likes on his videos, pure comedy genius

    • @egregius9314
      @egregius9314 3 роки тому +7

      I can't believe I'm limited to one like :(

  • @justanothercommenter5835
    @justanothercommenter5835 3 роки тому +91

    The judge just giving up at the end is hilarious. As is what deck they’re both playing.

    • @DakonBlackblade2
      @DakonBlackblade2 3 роки тому +34

      5 colors everything with monarchs and ways to generate more or less 15 mana per turn obviously.

    • @ralr
      @ralr 3 роки тому +28

      @@DakonBlackblade2 you know, regular magic

    • @h-squid
      @h-squid 3 роки тому +17

      @@DakonBlackblade2 well yes but not enough to reactivate monstrosity ofc

  • @peytonoka5962
    @peytonoka5962 3 роки тому +3

    Okay, so... Blue sweater Remy played Fleecemane Lion. Then Red Shirt Remy sacrificed his Ember Hauler targeting the Fleecemane Lion. In response, Blue Sweater activated Monstrosity. In response to that, Red Shirt activated Vial putting Palace Jailer into play, this put both Palace Jailer's ETB triggers on the stack. (He did not declare a target for the second half of Palace jailer so we are going to ignore it.) When Palace jailer came into play Blue Sweater's Faerie Artisans triggered making a copy of the Jailer into play putting his ETB triggers on the stack.(He also did not declare a target for the Jailers second trigger.) Red Shirt then cast Tragic Slip in response, targeting the fleecemane lion. (who is still not monstrous because the ability has not resolved yet.) Blue Sweater then cast doomfall on Red Shirt's Jailer. (Blue Sweater cast a sorcery at instant speed but we will allow it.) Blue Sweater then cast Power Sink. (I am assuming he is targeting the Tragic Slip.) In response, Red Shirt cast Mindbreak Trap on the Power Sink and Doomfall. So, The Power Sink and Doomfall would get countered by the MindBreak. Tragic Slip would then resolve, killing the Lion. The copy of Jailer would trigger first making Blue sweater the Monarch. Then Red Shirt's Jailer's trigger would resolve making him the Monarch. In the end Remy is the Monarch. Have a Merry Christmas everyone.

  • @abrafo1891
    @abrafo1891 3 роки тому +41

    The face you made when you asked “ is this a monster?!” Had me irl laughing!

    • @hyoroemongaming569
      @hyoroemongaming569 Рік тому

      I dont understand why that question is asked

    • @smoki102
      @smoki102 Рік тому +3

      @@hyoroemongaming569 Because of the monstrosity ability - if it's a monster then it has hexproof and tragic slip shouldn't work anymore

  • @wetwillyis_1881
    @wetwillyis_1881 3 роки тому +90

    This was so freaking great, this was worth the wait.

  • @SteakOSaurier
    @SteakOSaurier 3 роки тому +19

    i love the part where the judge is like "Well if you really wanna know-" and gets immediately interrupted by two passionate MTG-Singers 😂💖

  • @raithhamzah9545
    @raithhamzah9545 3 роки тому +73

    Remy , your recent content on this channel has genuinely helped lift me out of a depression these last few isolated covid months. This parody is just another example of how incredibly funny you are. Thank you so much for starting this channel and helping to remind us all how capable of laughter we are. You are a gift.

    • @Chromiummtg
      @Chromiummtg 3 роки тому +3

      You can get through it man I believe in you

    • @KingBobXVI
      @KingBobXVI 3 роки тому +4

      We may all feel isolated in this horrible time, but we're all in this together. We've got this :)

    • @Chromiummtg
      @Chromiummtg 3 роки тому +1

      @@KingBobXVI and we have remy to push us through

    • @MTGRemy
      @MTGRemy  3 роки тому +30

      wishing you health and happiness brother, thank you for the kind note. more videos on the way !

  • @DrummerScaper97
    @DrummerScaper97 3 роки тому +20

    Oh my goodness when the chorus interrupted the judge I actually laughed out loud. Thanks as always for the great video!

  • @TxarlesN
    @TxarlesN 3 роки тому +72

    Remy, thank you for this mater piece. I'm so happy i found your channel. Happy holidays, dude. Saludos desde México.

    • @MTGRemy
      @MTGRemy  3 роки тому +26

      Happy Holidays, Carlos!

  • @alexanderturner8554
    @alexanderturner8554 3 роки тому +259

    Three people tragically slipped onto the dislike button.

  • @iandick1364
    @iandick1364 3 роки тому +5

    Conclusion: the player with the non-monsterous lion is the Monarch.
    1. Two damage on lion
    2. First jailer enters (Monarch) Presumably targeting the lion. This card's effects must fully resolve for Faerie Artisan to trigger.
    3. Faerie Artisan trigger on stack.
    4. Tragic Slip on stack. The lion is in exile and so an invalid target. This is probably a bad play but Faerie Artisan is a valid target.
    5. The stack must resolve before downfall can be played. Faerie Artisan gets 13 -1/-1 counters and is sent to the graveyard by state based effects.
    6. Jailer token enters making a new Monarch and presumably targeting the nontoken jailer. The order of triggers will determine the order but the lion returns & the nontoken jailer is exiled.
    8. Doomfall was played presumably forcing the old Monarch to sacrifice a creature but he doesn't appear to have a creature so it does nothing.
    Extra Conclusion: these players should have called a judge when the jailer was copied before it had resolved.

    • @1mrlee
      @1mrlee 3 роки тому +1

      yeah was wondering how a sorcery was played with a stack, but for the sake of the humour, i let it slide.

  • @JustABrokenToy
    @JustABrokenToy 3 роки тому +108

    I went and looked up the original, and I think this is much better. sure, I'm a bit biased, but, "what if I tragically slip" is much better lyrically than "what if I, what if I slip." just my opinion, but the original seems lazy in comparison to this masterpiece.

    • @patrickspens497
      @patrickspens497 Рік тому +7

      that's because this was written by one solid artist while pop songs are written by a team of people who have done the market research to figure out which lyrics, melodies and rhythms are the most likely to get stuck in the average mall-goer's head

  • @godspeedhero3671
    @godspeedhero3671 3 роки тому +47

    I present to you, the BEST MTG content channel, Y'all.
    lmao that judge was like "aw, naw, you on your own."

  • @jasonostergaard681
    @jasonostergaard681 3 роки тому +49

    For those who really want to know:
    Blue Remy seems to be the active player, because he played the Fleecemane Lion, a creature.
    Fleecemane Lion is put on the stack and resolves.
    Red Remy activates Ember Hauler's ability, targeting Fleecemane Lion (notably, this is not a triggered ability per the lyrics).
    Blue Remy responds by activating Fleecemane Lion's monstrous ability. The stack now looks like this:
    [(B) and (R) represent ownership by blue and red shirt Remys, respectively]
    Fleecemane Lion's monstrous ability (B)
    Ember Hauler's activated damage ability (R)
    Next, red Remy activates his Aether Vial's activated ability. We'll assume blue Remy immediately passes priority and allows the Vial ability to resolve. Red Remy puts a Palace Jailer onto the battlefield. Red Remy's Palace Jailer's abilities trigger, and Blue Remy's Faerie Artisans' ability triggers. The triggers are put onto the stack in active player, then non-active player order, so now the stack looks like this:
    R's Palace Jailer's monarch triggered ability (R)
    R's Palace Jailer's exile triggered ability (presumably targeting Fleecemane Lion) (R)
    Faerie Artisans' triggered ability copying Palace Jailer (B)
    Fleecemane Lion's monstrous ability (B)
    Ember Hauler's activated damage ability (R)
    Here's where things get messy, because it seems like the Remy's may not be properly resolving abilities and passing priority to one another after this point. The next thing we see is blue Remy putting the token copy of Palace Jailer into play, so that means that red Remy's Palace Jailer's abilities must have resolved. Blue Remy's token copy of Palace Jailer's abilities trigger, and the game and the stack look like this:
    The game:
    Red Remy is the monarch
    Fleecemane Lion has been exiled
    The stack:
    B's Palace Jailer token's monarch triggered ability (B)
    B's Palace Jailer token's exile triggered ability (presumably targeting R's Palace Jailer) (B)
    Fleecemane Lion's monstrous ability (B)
    (now orphaned)
    Ember Hauler's activated damage ability (R) (now missing a target)
    Next, we see red Remy casting Tragic Slip targeting Fleecemane Lion. What must have happened is that Blue Remy's Palace Jailer token's triggers must have resolved, making blue Remy the Monarch, and exiling red Remy's Palace Jailer. That would leave us here:
    The game:
    Blue Remy is the Monarch
    R's Palace Jailer's one-shot effect from it's exiling ability has ended, so Fleecemane Lion is back on the battlefield
    The stack:
    Fleecemane Lion's monstrous ability (B)
    (now orphaned)
    Ember Hauler's activated damage ability (R) (now missing a target)
    Now Red Remy can cast the Tragic Slip targeting Fleecemane Lion (with morbid activated from the Ember Hauler that was sacrificed earlier).
    The game:
    Blue Remy is the Monarch
    Fleecemane Lion is back on the battlefield
    The stack:
    Tragic Slip targeting B's Fleecemane Lion (R)
    Fleecemane Lion's monstrous ability (B)
    (now orphaned)
    Ember Hauler's activated damage ability (R) (still missing a target, as B's newly returned Fleecemane Lion is a new object)
    Next comes the first apparent rules violation: Blue Remy seems to cast Doomfall in response to Tragic Slip, even though it's a sorcery. He must think it's an instant, because he next tries to Power Sink red Remy's Tragic Slip, which means that Tragic slip must still be on the stack at this point. Red Remy responds by casting Mindbreak Trap (with the trap cost enabled by blue Remy's Fleecemane Lion, Doomfall, and Power Sink) targeting blue Remy's Power Sink, leaving the stack like this:
    R's Mindbreak Trap targeting B's Power Sink
    B's Power Sink targeting R's Tragic Slip
    B's Doomfall (inappropriately casted) targeting R
    R's Tragic Slip targeting B's Fleecemane Lion
    B's Fleecemane Lion's monstrous ability (now orphaned)
    R's Ember Hauler's activated ability targeting B's Fleecemane Lion (missing a target)
    It seems like the conflict here stems from confusion about the order in which the Palace Jailer triggers resolved. The Remy's agree that red Remy got his Palace Jailer first, and blue Remy got his second, but due to active player, then non-active player trigger ordering, Red Remy's triggers will resolve first, and blue Remy's second. The bit about the removal spells is more or less irrelevant (Doomfall timing aside) because Palace's Jailer's exile ability only cares about who's the monarch, not whether or not Palace Jailer is still in play.
    To clean up the situation, a Judge might decide to back up to the point where blue Remy inappropriately casted the Doomfall, or might decide to leave the stack as is, because a couple of hidden counterspells have been revealed. In either case, Blue Remy is the Monarch, and Fleecemane Lion is not monstrous.

    • @thespiritphoenix3798
      @thespiritphoenix3798 3 роки тому +3

      Holy shit man thanks

    • @BlaidTDS
      @BlaidTDS 3 роки тому +6

      This is the EXACT information I waded into the comments to find. Thank you!

    • @SovereignTonic
      @SovereignTonic 3 роки тому +1

      This guy judges

    • @thetruemathulhu4222
      @thetruemathulhu4222 3 роки тому +2

      @@experimentalconference6623 He might have given Doomfall flash somehow also.

    • @isaacking1524
      @isaacking1524 3 роки тому +1

      Nice answer! One correction- Palace Jailer's trigger creates a one-shot effect, and then a second one-shot effect when the opponent becomes the monarch. There are no state triggers here.
      You could also interpret all actions in the song as legal, in which case Doomfall was cast after everything resolved, and blue Remy is Power Sinking their own Doomfall. (They never indicate in the video what it's targeting.)

  • @oscarhardingisatwat
    @oscarhardingisatwat 3 роки тому +9

    Next to "Wake me up before you combo" this is one of your best, well done it was really entertaining :)

  • @vornamenachname4756
    @vornamenachname4756 3 роки тому +20

    "_we need a ruuuling_" is killing me

  • @TheDanorte
    @TheDanorte 3 роки тому +143

    You are ridiculously talented.

    • @jonbetts8473
      @jonbetts8473 3 роки тому +9

      SERIOUSLY. It's hilarious and even sung and mixed well .... jeez.

  • @Googleflax
    @Googleflax 3 роки тому +12

    Your Magic song parodies are honestly always great; definitely my favorite MtG Parody content creator

  • @jongibson4766
    @jongibson4766 3 роки тому +4

    This is unironically one of the best songs I've heard in so long, it's been stuck in my head for a week I can't stop watching it.

  • @ChrisMTG
    @ChrisMTG 3 роки тому +6

    I've listened to this half a dozen times already and I still can't get it out of my head! This is just musically fantastic. Well done.

  • @toyyer8176
    @toyyer8176 3 роки тому +10

    The best song really ever heard. Magic is back in this hard time. I am the monarch.

  • @PenguinJack
    @PenguinJack 3 роки тому +7

    Your work is so amazing. This is the first channel I have actually turned notifications on for in the 10+ years I have been on youtube.

  • @kwekvonscaf
    @kwekvonscaf 2 роки тому +2

    The "Ooooooooooold Schooooooooool" part, is truly the cherry on top.

  • @hjc1710
    @hjc1710 3 роки тому +3

    Wow, this is really impressive. The specific card references, the acting, and the vocals? You've really elevated yourself Remy.

  • @godspeedhero3671
    @godspeedhero3671 3 роки тому +71

    Imma need a Secret Lair: MTGRemy.

  • @dazaran714
    @dazaran714 3 роки тому +5

    Resolving the stack: mindbreak trap exiles power sink and doomfall (which shouldn't be castable unless there is a leyline of anticipation or similar effect), then tragic slip will resolve and give fleecemane lion -13/-13 (since ember hauler died this turn) and die due to having less than 0 toughness, then (and it gets complicated, I messed this up the first time I tried to comment this) the real palace jailer's ETBs will resolve, the exile effect will have no valid targets and be removed and hat Remy will become the monarch, then faerie artisans' trigger will resolve (artisans and palace jailer trigger from the same event, so active player's effects go on the stack first, which would be no-hat Remy's faerie artisans) and create a palace jailer token, the token's ETBs go on the stack, palace jailer will be exiled and no-hat Remy will become the monarch, then fleecemane lion's monstrous ability will resolve and do nothing, then ember hauler's ability will have no legal targets and be removed and the stack is clear.
    This assumes that it is no-hat Remy's turn, however since he played a sorcery at instant speed it could be hat Remy's turn in which case it will be different, let's have a look.
    Everything is the same until after fleecemane dies, then faerie artisans' trigger resolves and creates a palace jailer token and its ETBs go on the stack, palace jailer is exiled and no-hat Remy becomes the monarch, then the original palace jailer' ETBs resolve, the exile effect will have no valid targets and be removed and hat Remy becomes the monarch, the original palace jailer will be returned to the battlefield and its ETBs will trigger, hat Remy will exile either faerie artisans or the jailer token and will become the monarch again, then the rest of the stack is the same as above.
    TLDR; fleecemane dies no matter what and, depending on whose turn it is, either no-hat Remy gets absolutely blown out with no crown or no-hat Remy has a decent board advantage and the crown.

    • @Arcticsharpshooter
      @Arcticsharpshooter 3 роки тому +1

      After reading through your analysis, I would like to point out three things that you missed out.
      1) HR tells the judge he "Mindedly breaks IT", it being the Power Sink. We can assume that Mindbreak Trap counters only Power Sink.
      2) In the first scenario, where it is NHR's turn, you forgot the Faerie Artisans which can be targeted by Palace Jailer's trigger.
      3) In the current state of the battlefield, NHR's Palace Jailer token is already on the battlefield! It was put there on resolution of his Faerie Artisans, which, as you correctly remarked, was put onto the stack at the same time as the two triggers of HR's Palace Jailer. So, in the scenario where it is NHR's turn, HR is already a Monarch when we start taking down the top of the stack.

    • @dazaran714
      @dazaran714 3 роки тому +2

      @@Arcticsharpshooter 1) That is true, but I assumed that HR exiled doomfall because there is no reason not to and it leads to a worse board state in every permutation of stack resolution (It was probably a incorrect play anyway since it is a sorcery AND he played another instant afterwards without announcing that he was holding priority).
      2) Another assumption from me was that if someone vials in palace jailer in response to someone giving a creature hexproof that they will be targeting that creature. Otherwise they should have targeted faerie artisans with the ember hauler trigger (especially because it can't kill fleecemane lion regardless).
      3) A lot of the visual stuff in this reenactment is wrong because it is a parody music video. If it is NHR's turn and the stack resolved enough for the token to come out, then fleecemane lion would have been exiled by the time tragic slip was played.

  • @ianadair1280
    @ianadair1280 3 роки тому +1

    I cant express to you how happy i am that you had Power Sink in there😂 i have been running that jank for so long

  • @scruffythelilslugger
    @scruffythelilslugger 3 роки тому +2

    All of the parodies have been amazing. But this one was spectacular, by far my favorite one so far.

  • @dragoslove
    @dragoslove 2 роки тому +4

    The random "Old School!" gets me every time.

  • @AnomAnomMTG
    @AnomAnomMTG 3 роки тому +9

    This channel is getting attention from all the other great MTG channels, and it is well deserved.

  • @milesthatcher
    @milesthatcher 3 роки тому +1

    Please do not stop making content. You are the best Remy!

  • @treymata7231
    @treymata7231 3 роки тому +1

    Every time I see one of your videos it brings joy to my day. I love you Remy keep it up, king.

  • @colecarmichael5724
    @colecarmichael5724 3 роки тому +6

    Honestly I never laughed so hard with something related to magic. The stack at my friends house get so crazy especially when it’s a 4 player commander game and my friend casts LIVING DEATH

  • @grega7479
    @grega7479 3 роки тому +5

    Remy is quickly climbing to the top of my favorite MTG content

  • @xyphi_7590
    @xyphi_7590 3 роки тому +1

    Players: *sing about possibilities*
    Judge: *Proceeds to Explain*
    Players: *singing intensifies*

  • @fuquantiegermann3776
    @fuquantiegermann3776 3 роки тому +1

    How did I miss this??? Soooooo good! Remy, my man, you slap so hard.

  • @Not_Jhinx
    @Not_Jhinx 3 роки тому +5

    the irony here is that the judge would probably rule the stack with a setback because remy casted a sorcery at instant speed (doomfall)

  • @carlsidgwick5854
    @carlsidgwick5854 3 роки тому +5

    The best magic channel I've found in lockdown :)

  • @Paws-sn7nl
    @Paws-sn7nl 3 роки тому +2

    I watched all of these parodies over and over, this is the best one

  • @gatodeluvas6514
    @gatodeluvas6514 3 роки тому +1

    PLEASE continue to do those parodies! so good

  • @badgerwatkins
    @badgerwatkins 3 роки тому +4

    The song parodies are always the best of the best! :)

  • @MrEmm
    @MrEmm 3 роки тому +3

    Another classic! Seriously MTGRemy is pumping out some of the best magic content of 2020.

  • @wannabevampirelizard
    @wannabevampirelizard 3 роки тому +1

    This is ridiculously good, both music and comedy are top notch. I keep listening to it over and over again.

  • @dekappatated73
    @dekappatated73 3 роки тому

    straight up, best magic the gathering channel. Not even a contest. Beautiful.

  • @patrickmchugh4616
    @patrickmchugh4616 3 роки тому +13

    Love the "OLD SCHOOOOL!" ad lib at the end haha

  • @bear_6875
    @bear_6875 3 роки тому +10

    Can I get the full album here? This track is an absolute banger. Probably listened 50 times now. Time to get Remy to top 40 radio.

  • @Dreadnaught1985
    @Dreadnaught1985 3 роки тому +1

    Coming back to this about a month later. This song is still stuck in my head, it's a proper bop.

  • @joshuabailey3657
    @joshuabailey3657 3 роки тому +1

    I can't stop coming back to this video.

  • @mathieuaurousseau100
    @mathieuaurousseau100 3 роки тому +12

    I'm calling it now, the Judge's name is Jemmy

  • @thewillybot
    @thewillybot 3 роки тому +3

    Fantastic work. Glad to have found your channel.

  • @861020
    @861020 2 роки тому +2

    "Old school~~~" that part got me good

  • @Shattered_Entertainment
    @Shattered_Entertainment 3 роки тому

    i love your magic the gathering songs i cant get the sound of silence or wake me up when you combo out of my head lol and im pretty sure this joins them cant wait for a new one again

  • @leonardoempiolamarca5176
    @leonardoempiolamarca5176 3 роки тому +4

    Man! I discovered you today and today I watched all of your videos! H-U-G-E thumbs up, the song covers are awesome and, actually, 867509 (or something) is really a good song I had never heard before!!
    Keep up the good work and thanks for the laugh!! (my gf heard me laughing and asked me: why are u laughing? I answered: someone making joke-songs about magic mechanics.. I swear it's more fun that it sound)
    +Elite Vanguard in our hearts

  • @matthewsawczyn6592
    @matthewsawczyn6592 2 роки тому +4

    I'm gonna need a ten hour version of this

  • @Fmanjavachi
    @Fmanjavachi 2 роки тому +2

    This is by far the my favorite parody... Thanks Remy!

  • @HanifFiremind
    @HanifFiremind 3 роки тому +1

    Alright you need to put these on spotify. This is too good.

  • @MsMollieMac
    @MsMollieMac 3 роки тому +3

    Remy you are a gift to this community

  • @GrimmTutelage
    @GrimmTutelage 3 роки тому +3

    This man's efforts and comedy are severely under appreciated 🤣 so glad I found this channel

  • @danacoleman4007
    @danacoleman4007 3 роки тому +2

    WOW!!! thanks, Remy! Merry Christmas!

  • @burkegiordano675
    @burkegiordano675 3 роки тому +1

    You have a special talent. I hope it brings you as much joy as it brings me and others. Thank you for sharing your work.

  • @GKiernan01
    @GKiernan01 3 роки тому +5

    Good to see Judge Brad is back on his feet.

  • @r1k0rose20
    @r1k0rose20 3 роки тому +5

    Oh my god...i think i was never this early on any video! Im happy it was one of Remys!

  • @infiternalcg5289
    @infiternalcg5289 Рік тому +2

    why is this so much better than the original song???!

  • @Mekkles
    @Mekkles 3 роки тому +1

    Your singing chops are literally insane. Love your work.

  • @IFGchannel931
    @IFGchannel931 3 роки тому +3

    Your song parodies are the best!

  • @jacewilliamson4698
    @jacewilliamson4698 3 роки тому +4

    Can confirm, half of all questions I get sound exactly like this
    Source: me judge
    Source for source: trust me bro

  • @JoeManLuke
    @JoeManLuke 3 роки тому

    Man, your parodies always put the biggest fucking smile on my face. And you got some real pipes!

  • @emperornapoleon6204
    @emperornapoleon6204 3 роки тому +2

    Judge Remy’s face when they burst back into song is priceless!!

  • @niktee431
    @niktee431 3 роки тому +4

    This truly made my day. "Olllddd schooollllll", Subscribed!

  • @chrispowell2480
    @chrispowell2480 3 роки тому +6

    For those wondering:
    -Fleecemane Lion Resolves
    -Ember Hauler Trigger Goes On The Stack
    -Monstrosity Is Activated In Response
    -Palace Jailer Vials In, His trigger and Faerie Artisans Go On The Stack
    -APNAP, Player 1's Turn, Faerie Artisans Trigger Goes On The Stack First, So Palace Jailer Resolves, Exiling Fleecemane Lion And Making P2 The Monarch
    -Palace Jailer Token Enters The Battlefield, Exiling Palace Jailer And Making P1 The Monarch
    -Fleecemane Lion Returns To The Battlefield Because P1 Is The Monarch, No Longer Monstrous Because It Is Considered A Separate Instance Of The Creature
    -Tragic Slip Goes On The Stack With Morbid, As The Ember Hauler Was Sacrificed Earlier That Turn
    -Doomfall Is Both Unable To Be Cast, As It Is A Sorcery, And Is Also Unnecessary As P2's Palace Jailer Is Already Exiled
    -Power Sink Goes On The Stack To Counter Tragic Slip (Assuming P2 Can't Pay For It)
    -Mindbreak Trap Goes On The Stack, Exiling Power Sink
    -Power Sink Is Exiled
    -Tragic Slip Resolves, Killing Fleecemane Lion,
    -At The End, P2 Just Has A Vial, P1 Has A Palace Jailer Token, Has Fairy Artisans, And Is The Monarch.
    Solved.

    • @clemos1845
      @clemos1845 3 роки тому +1

      but am I the monarch?! Just let me know - ow ! ;)

  • @bubblesbubbles368
    @bubblesbubbles368 3 роки тому +1

    This is amazing, I needed a smile today and you achieved that!!!Thank you so much!!!!

  • @turnersmith8009
    @turnersmith8009 3 роки тому +2

    The days Remy releases a new video should be national holidays

  • @chancylvania
    @chancylvania 2 роки тому +3

    The judge is more confused by the singing than the actual mechanics of what’s going on

  • @clementtolinos4766
    @clementtolinos4766 3 роки тому +8

    Et hop un commentaire en français 🇨🇵!! MTGRemy est un génie

    • @benikujaku4567
      @benikujaku4567 3 роки тому +1

      Camarade‚ tu mérites d'être le monarque juste pour ça

    • @clementtolinos4766
      @clementtolinos4766 3 роки тому

      @@benikujaku4567 Je déclare donc créé le Royaume de France dans les commentaires de MTGRemy ! Vive le Royaume de France ! Vive Magic ! Vive MTGRemy !!

    • @benikujaku4567
      @benikujaku4567 3 роки тому

      @@clementtolinos4766 Ouais!

  • @wiatcheslavsidortsov5235
    @wiatcheslavsidortsov5235 3 роки тому +1

    Every time I see a new Remy upload, I watch it , then go and rewatch the mtg rap stuff again. Dude, you are the best thing that happened to Magic in 2020.

  • @h2ojr1
    @h2ojr1 5 місяців тому +1

    i keep coming back to this one, so dope

  • @suikodin2501
    @suikodin2501 3 роки тому +4

    Every game where there is a question about Monarch: Lemme play this vid real quick...

  • @kilo3989
    @kilo3989 2 роки тому +3

    That feel when you're too busy riffing with your opponent to let the judge get a word in edgewise 😂

  • @johnnyd9174
    @johnnyd9174 3 роки тому +1

    Just found Remy’s channel… amazing. The judge’s face when the beat drops is classic.

  • @roscode96
    @roscode96 3 роки тому +1

    Oh my goodness another absolute banger from MTGRemy, couldn't ask for a better start to the day! I especially love all the extra details like facial expressions from the judge (can't stop laughing at 1:19) and the expressiveness of the players (e.g. 1:31 lmao), and the quality of the performance is also just top notch and truly enjoyable on it's own merits. Keep up the great work!