Bf1 hands looks like the hands of a trained soldier with an excellent physiqe fit for war. Bf5 hands look like scrawny blokes who were just conscripted right away
BFV is more realistic, but not too different from BF1. The key difference is that in BFV, the character has no sleeves. It makes the wrists look more boney but that's how a wrist would look.
Evan Guthrie That's just not true at all. Whoever modeled and rigged the hands absolutely botched them. The wrist is about an two or three inches below where it should be, and the fingers are all elongated.
SilverVI True though i still think BfV’s hands look better They’re also dirtier which more accurately represents how a soldier’s hands would actually look in combat
Man, battlefield 1 was a fucking masterpiece. I’ve always played both cod and battlefield but bf1 blew everything else away. It was the first time in a long time that I actually had fun playing a fps game.
Good for you. But that game was a disaster, another step down from the BF's days of glory and amazing gameplay and a fucking insult. I would go with DOOM that year. Or Infinite Warfare.
Sound : BF1 is better. More realisitc. Motions : BF5 is slightly better. More realistic aimimg motion,fixing errors from bf1(ex-manually pulling bolt when doing tactical reload),and saving magazine or ammo when it's not empty or used. Graphic : Both are fantastic. But although BF5 used RTX,I think BF1 is more impressive because BF5's graphic is so colorful that it doesn't match with its theme(war,tragedy,etc...) but dull color used in BF1 so that it has highlited the sadness and horror of WWI. BF1 was the last gift of the original DICE devs.
@@ilovequake833 I'm afraid it will never be like it used to be again. Dice LA still hold some kind of a level, but dice sweden are too far gone. There's no more vision other than teddy bears, tom cruise and robotic claws in world war 2 lol.
If you're judging a games quality strictly off of visuals you're an absolute moron. Battlefield V has way better mechanics than BF1, this community is full of crybabies who can't actually get some skill and learn these mechanics so immediately it's a bad game.
@@ofearghailthefearless6481 they might change look at cnc remastered the game they killed and they revived it why?? because of the community the problem is sometimes they listen sometimes they dont
I hate how useless are the secondaries in BFV, everybody uses the M1911, the MK VI and the American revolver (i don’t remember the name), the other secondaries in BFV are just weak in my opinion compared to BF1 where you had a lot of good options like the P08, Mars, C93, Gasser, Bulldog, etc. and i'm wondering why the hell BFV has less bass than BF1 PS: Yup i tried the new guns, and i gotta say that the PPK is probably the best secondary in the game now (is just like a M1911 but with a higher rate of fire), the Welrod is cool too
I like the graphics of BF1, gun model, but in my opinion BFV has much more realistic sound. cuz BF1 sound has way too much echo (I prefer BF4) the animation is slower but more fluid in my opinion also some weapon flaws has been fixed
9:45 By far (in my opinion) the coldest & most aggressive shooting sound goes to the Selbstlader M1916 in BF1 I always used to use this weapon because it was super strong & it’s shooting sound was so amazing. Sad to see how BFV ruined the gun sounds, especially for that gun :(
I was about to comment that its annoying that flamethrowers would burn up trees and foliage in Call of Duty: World At War (2008), but they don't in a game made a decade later.
When will the animators realize that enfield clips can’t be flicked forward as every damn game shows, they only go out if you flick them backwards. They also eject if you hit them with the bolt hard enough, that’s by design.
You know aside from the essential weapons like the m1911, luger, webley, and so on, they could have included a lot more era appropriate weapons for bfv
@@ryanbelfield7887 yeah, after the game sort of fell flat on its face, they, allegedly, cancelled all upcoming content past June, I think. But I know that they were planning to add some, considering the two weapons in the BFV pre order bonus, the mosin nagant rifle grenade, the LAD machine gun, and leaked content
It always annoys me how in battlefield 5 the m1911's slide somehow only locks to the rear part way on an empty mag for some reason. They didn't have the problem in battlefield 1, but in bf5 the slide barely goes back halfway.
One thing that bothers me about bfv excluding the hands and the even bigger sights is the fact that the drilling uses red shells, which are made of plastic. Bf1 correctly uses brass shells
Actually I think they’re supposed to be paper shells, which I think were the predecessor to plastic. Brass shells came before that, because they wouldn’t get soggy they were favored but trench gun users. Then the paper shell came and it’s what we see in bfV. That’s my guess
As a World War One enthusiast I'm disappointed that Dice felt they has to make a whole new game so soon after launching BF1. I wish they had just decided to keep developing more content for BF1. There were a lot of battles they didn't cover, and there were still a lot of historical weapons they could have drawn on for inspiration.
CloroxBleachTM Ah yes a game that had more spam then previous games, shitty balancing, lack of content at launch, dummy retarded vehicle vs infantry balance, and most gadgets were useless, AND behemoths ruin pace and tactics of the game, they just lead to dying randomly without it being your fault, and unlike sniper, they don’t take skill. Not saying previous games didn’t have these issues, but BF1 made these problems worse.
Small mistake: I don’t think that the Gewehr 98 and the Kar98K are the same rifle. While both were manufactured by Mauser, I don’t think they are the same rifle. *PLEASE FEEL FREE TO CORRECT ME IF I AM WRONG*
After German Empire fall.. the weimar republic is not allowed to produce new firearms so they just shorten the Gewehr 98 so they have Karabiner 98 Kurz
They utilize the exact same round and the exact same action. Karabiner 98k is literally just a carbine version of Gewehr 98, with the only differences being different sights, shortened barrel and curved bolt handle on Kar98k. Still, comparing them like that is kind of inappropriate, since it's like comparing M16A4 and MK18
Details: bfv Gun-sound: bf1 Gun designs: bf1 Environment: mixed Grimmy details: bf1 Vehicles: bfv Reloading: bfv Characters: Def bf1 Lighting: bfv but bf1 is awesome so mixed. Success: Def bf1 Winner: bf1 Dice, please make bf6 like bf1 Note: I'm a fan of the series and I've been defending bfv for almost a year but later realized how stupid I was :P
@@Raystation2 Uhhh okay? Lol can you be more specific? My choice would be the following. USA: *Army and Marines* Russia India Pakistan Israel Fictional Terrorist group: One that united all major Islamic terrorist groups around the world and has grown into the millions when it comes to numbers. This all apart of my concept actually. Have a read at maps that would play out with these factions if you wish. :) You're going to have to use your imagination sadly as I don't have any cool pictures to showcase the map proposals. Although I might make them someday. docs.google.com/document/d/1HkKVRVxdnHxmSGJN2g6KcwwqkNtnw4VrkGKTSFQQOm0/edit?usp=sharing
Here comes the comments of BF1 > BFV. To me BFV has a meaty sound with that satisfying clanks of metal, and BF1 has that powerful sound that almost makes it sound like it'll fall apart.
@@XxNoMercyNL Right not enough ambiance I guess. Though in BFV, a lot of the chaos is created by the players, rather than map set pieces (for instance, artillery).
For sounds, it seems they reduced the bass on a lot of the gunshots, and the echoes seem very different. As for models, BFV’s weapons look like they’ve actually been used and are not like the factory-issued weapons in BF1. As for animations, BF1’s are definitely a lot smoother but BFV also fixes plenty of the animation errors from BF1. The Repetierpistole M1912 for example has the player eject the unused rounds into his hand rather than in the air in BFV. The 12g Automatic in BFV has the player actually depress the bolt release button while loading fresh shells which was required of the shotgun at the time, and the Gewehr M95 cycles fully this time rather than part of the bolt still noticeably obscuring the loading port.
DF AMO I agree but a lot of people think BF1 looks better because of the “cleaner” appearance. DICE pumped too much grainy fidelity into BFV that it kind of brings down the visual improvement. I hope we get even more fidelity in BF6 without the grain in BFV.
im wondering why dice didnt reused hands from bf1, (but some changes to skin tone, sleeves) since the hands from bfv just look like they haven’t eating for days
As someone who fired many guns both with hearing protection and without one (forgetting to wear it. Not intentional) BF 1 sounds, especially the tails of the shots, sound scaringly close to real life gunshot sounds when you fire a gun without hearing protection. To describe how it sounds in real life, its the loud core POP initially then your ears shut itself off to good extent then buzzing starts right away then as it goes away your hearing comes back to normal and you hear the loud reflection of gunshot. Basically its POP...buzzzzz...loud reflection. Wearing hearing protection gets rid of most of the details and the loud/exciting parts of the gunshot so most people who fired guns in real life say the gunshot sounds boring. Of course its not very exciting but the cool details are there.
Fun fact: some weapons were actually corrected in BFV, which is very important. The Steyr Hahn (M1912) in BFV now preserves bullets during non-empty reloads, compared to BF1 where it just flies away. The Browning Auto-5 (12g) in BFV is actually the correct way to reload the shotgun, especially for pre-1950 production models. BF1 ignores this. The M1911A1 actually preserves the magazine in BFV during tac reloads. The Selbstlader M1916 was also corrected: BFV actually includes the correct extra step during empty reloads. Forgotten Weapons covers this important step in full detail. The M1907 SL in BFV now has the correct rate of fire for the full auto mode. Yes, the real full auto conversions were actually as fast as BFV has shown. The Lewis Gun Suppressive 97-rounder is modeled correctly in BFV.
@@stevemc6010 with all due respect the whole supposed rattling dust cover situation is about as legit as the ping of a Garand getting you killed in combat. These rifles which bared the seal of their Emperor from a country where they brought swords to a gun fight, ran at machine guns on guts, honour and tradition alone, were instructed to scratch away the seal should rifles fall into enemy hands and were more than willing to crash their plane into a ship I can't see discarding their dust covers without being getting into some serious trouble.
@@naruto97kyubi oh boy the guy with the anime pfp and japanese name is setting me straight. Haha jk. But I recall in a Forgotten weapons video mentions that the dust covers usually got discarded which is why they are uncommon to find on matching rifles today. Also Rising Storm 1 and World at War show the IJA using dust-coverless Arisakas.
@@stevemc6010 hahahaha would you be more at ease if the pic was a flamingo in a suit and the name was John Smith haha. Yea on the boat home, US soldiers would have to take em apart with the rifle and bolt&cover being kept separate with them being reassembled when they got back State side but didn't care for matching serial no. and put which ever bolt in with the covers being lost or discarded. Which is why as the fellow below mentions that Arisaka's are generally mismatched. True those games didn't either but I wasn't defending them either haha. At the same time oh CoD WaW what a game haha. Also did they not just re use the asset from BF1 which had the cover on so I'm mighty confused as to why it disappeared but it is BFV so yea not surprised either hahaha
For instance when shooting shotguns and bolt actions, they sound exactly like bf4 audio engineering. I think the devs tried to bring back a little bf4 vibes into this game, but that was hard to do with the ww2 setting.
No way, BF3 vs BF4 sounds are night and day, and might I say BF4 sounds hella weak. Here BF1 and BFV both sound excellent, in short I'd say you are right of the more oomph/bassy style of BF1, but the base texture is definitely there in BFV, its just more shimmer/brighter (so really a preference thing). But the fact that both carry the same texture and awesomeness, I'd say both are excellent either way.
Out of 72 weapons, there are far more unique ones than copied ones from Battlefield 1. I could seriously write an entire list of all the guns in the game discounting the BF1 ports
Soldiers from ww2. They were holding it like that, because it was more comfortable and as a bonus you could rest your elbow on your knee while aiming in crouched position. So BfV wins for historical accuracy on the mp28 over Bf1 on the mp 18 (which was actually also hold this way).
At 11:00 the Gewehr 98 and the Kar98K are two different rifles, you are mistaken for the Kar98A or Kar98B and don't get me started of the WEX and M2 Flamethrower. Overall nice video.
He didn't count MP18 and MP28 did he? It's basically the same weapon, albeit the latter have some minor improvements including a fire selector and uses straight mags.
![Lp. Сердце Вселенной #60 РОЖДЕНИЕ ЛОЛОЛОШКИ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YoR0pAV9FVQ/mqdefault.jpg)
Battlefield 5 hands - stiff
Battlefield 1 hands - *T H I C C*
Nah, more like:
BFV: Skeleton hands.
BF1: T H I I I C C C C C but still looks better than BFV.
Bf1 hands looks like the hands of a trained soldier with an excellent physiqe fit for war. Bf5 hands look like scrawny blokes who were just conscripted right away
BFV is more realistic, but not too different from BF1. The key difference is that in BFV, the character has no sleeves. It makes the wrists look more boney but that's how a wrist would look.
Evan Guthrie That's just not true at all. Whoever modeled and rigged the hands absolutely botched them. The wrist is about an two or three inches below where it should be, and the fingers are all elongated.
@@SolisFactor That's your opinion. I think they look great. Good job animation team!
4:58 How delicate gentlemen reload their shotguns.
Elegant.
How sophisticated! A real gentleman I see.
Exquisite! Surely a most stupendous gentleman!
*Gutter Trash*
Lol
Bf1 holds up really well
id say its the best battlefield
@Guilherme TLOU2 it done everything great tbh,I hope the next BF wont be a massacre of bullshittery
I agree ^^
For an older game it feels more new than bfv ok bfv has the customization shit bug thats the only thinh new games have
The difference between then is the lighting
Bf1 sounds like tearing air but V just too small sounds
I'm confused, I don't hear this at all.
Evan Guthrie It doesn’t sound meaty
@@lukewarmwater6713 Both sound good to me
Cuz EA is so greedy they rushed the developers so they can earN Money
what is a "small" sound?
I choose BF1 sounds
same
++
Me too
Same
@@shadowsan8750 me too
Anyone notice how the soldiers’ hands look so fat in Bf1. Guess they took “doughboys” to a whole other level.
LOL
And BFV’s hands took “diet” to a whole other level.
SilverVI True though i still think BfV’s hands look better
They’re also dirtier which more accurately represents how a soldier’s hands would actually look in combat
no because the soldier have to wash their hands because it will be bad for them
Plastic Fart Yeah obviously, but do you think any soldier had the luxury of washing their hands during a battle?
Man, battlefield 1 was a fucking masterpiece. I’ve always played both cod and battlefield but bf1 blew everything else away. It was the first time in a long time that I actually had fun playing a fps game.
Good for you. But that game was a disaster, another step down from the BF's days of glory and amazing gameplay and a fucking insult. I would go with DOOM that year. Or Infinite Warfare.
Sound : BF1 is better. More realisitc.
Motions : BF5 is slightly better. More realistic aimimg motion,fixing errors from bf1(ex-manually pulling bolt when doing tactical reload),and saving magazine or ammo when it's not empty or used.
Graphic : Both are fantastic. But although BF5 used RTX,I think BF1 is more impressive because BF5's graphic is so colorful that it doesn't match with its theme(war,tragedy,etc...) but dull color used in BF1 so that it has highlited the sadness and horror of WWI.
BF1 was the last gift of the original DICE devs.
Jacob Stevenson what guns manually pull the bolt back when doing tactical reloads
ex- autoloading 8.35
Maybe there's another Battlefield,maybe.
@@ilovequake833 I'm afraid it will never be like it used to be again. Dice LA still hold some kind of a level, but dice sweden are too far gone. There's no more vision other than teddy bears, tom cruise and robotic claws in world war 2 lol.
If you're judging a games quality strictly off of visuals you're an absolute moron. Battlefield V has way better mechanics than BF1, this community is full of crybabies who can't actually get some skill and learn these mechanics so immediately it's a bad game.
Dang I don't know why
But I really want another BF1 update
Izza Kaiser except they don’t want to cause they only care about money and not their games or their customers
@@ofearghailthefearless6481 they might change look at cnc remastered the game they killed and they revived it why?? because of the community the problem is sometimes they listen sometimes they dont
Yah
remember when everybody hated BF1, now everyone loves it all of a sudden. Gamers are the fucking worst.
@@nolanzona1296 those self proclaim they a fan of bf franchise are,
I hate how useless are the secondaries in BFV, everybody uses the M1911, the MK VI and the American revolver (i don’t remember the name), the other secondaries in BFV are just weak in my opinion compared to BF1 where you had a lot of good options like the P08, Mars, C93, Gasser, Bulldog, etc. and i'm wondering why the hell BFV has less bass than BF1
PS: Yup i tried the new guns, and i gotta say that the PPK is probably the best secondary in the game now (is just like a M1911 but with a higher rate of fire), the Welrod is cool too
I remember the british revolver's name,its name is "Webley MK VI"
A green plane he knows the the British revolver, the American revolver is the Smith & Wesson Model 37.
@@jakey2430 27*
Kore Ops thanks, I’m not much of a gun nut
Diego Alf. • You have not played the new update right?
It's amazing that a 4 year old game looks astonishing to this day. Love playing it.
Battlefield 3 is 10 years old and still astonishing
@@Nothingeverhappens115 On PC yes. On console, no
@@jfc6132 I play on console tho and it still is
@@Nothingeverhappens115 Then you must be delusional
@@jfc6132 ok pc elitist
BF V has extremely good graphics but it lacks the overall rugged theme of BF 1
Qasim Ali yeah
@Jarrit Louttit other way around
0:43 Damn... That Luger surely got bigger over the years!
Nah. The luger went on a diet
*List of exact minutes*
Pistols
0:02 - M1911 (BattleField 1)
0:17 - M1911 (BattleField 5)
-
0:30 - P08 Pistol (BattleField 1)
0:45 - P08 (BattleField 5)
-
0:58 - P08 Artillerie (BattleField 1)
1:25 - P08 Carbine (BattleField 5)
-
1:49 - RepetierPistole M1912 (BattleField 1)
2:09 - RepetierPistole M1912 (BattleField 5)
-
2:26 - Revolver MK VI (BattleField 1)
2:45 - MK VI Revolver (BattleField 5)
-
3:01 - M1917 Trench Carbine (BattleField 1)
3:29 - Trench Carbine (BattleField 5)
Shotguns
3:57 - M97 Trench Gun (BattleField 1)
4:18 - M1897 (BattleField 5)
-
4:36 - 12G Automatic (BattleField 1)
4:55 - 12G Automatic (BattleField 5)
-
5:13 - Model 1900 (BattleField 1)
5:34 - M30 Drilling (BattleField 5)
SMGs
6:06 - Annihilator (BattleField 1)
6:23 - M1928A1 (BattleField 5)
Rifles
6:41 - RibeyRolles 1918 (BattleField 1)
6:59 - RibeyRolles 1918 (BattleField 5)
-
7:16 - M1907 SL (BattleField 1)
7:37 - M1907 SF (BattleField 5)
-
7:54 - Autoloading 8 .35 (BattleField 1)
8:11 - Model 8 (BattleField 5)
-
8:30 - Selbstlader 1906 (BattleField 1)
8:50 - Selbstlader 1960 (BattleField 5)
-
9:09 - RSC 1917 (BattleField 1)
9:27 - RSC (BattleField 5)
-
9:45 - Selbstlader M1916 (BattleField 1)
1:16 - Selbstlader 1916 (BattleField 5)
-
10:44 - Gewehr 98 (BattleField 1)
11:07 - Kar98K (BattleField 5)
-
11:39 - SMLE MKIII (BattleField 1)
11:59 - Lee Enfield NO.4 MKI (BattleField 5)
-
12:22 - Gewehr M.95 (BattleField 1)
12:43 - Gewehr M95/30 (BattleField 5)
-
13:08 - Type 38 Arisaka (BattleField 1)
13:34 - Type 99 Arisaka (BattleField 5)
-
13:56 - Carcano M19 (BattleField 1)
14:21 - M28 Con Trombocino (BattleField 5)
-
14:39 - Ross MKIII (BattleField 1)
15:01 - Ros MK III (BattleField 5)
Machine Guns
15:26 - Lewis Gun (BattleField 1)
15:52 - Lewis Gun (BattleField 5)
-
16:17 - Madsen MG (BattleField 1)
16:37 - Madsen MG (BattleField 5)
-
16:57 - Bar M1918 (BattleField 1)
17:16 - Bar M1918A2 (BattleField 5)
-
17:36 - ChauChat (BattleField 1)
17:57 - ChauChat (BattleField 5)
Other
18:24 - Wex (BattleField 1)
18:47 - M2 Flamethrower (BattleField 5)
Like the video and watch it complete so it is recommended to more people and so Tigerfield is happy!
@@TheLetterJ13 Oh damn, Thank You so much for that, i was tipping and i skiped that error
Thank youuui
Thanks, we appreciate it, but this comment should be pinned or should be at the most top comment
Bruh the bf5 hands looks hungry 😂😂
Well like ww2 soldiers
BF1 looks so much more realistic to me. They got the art style perfect.
It looks the same on some parts
I like the graphics of BF1, gun model,
but in my opinion BFV has much more realistic sound. cuz BF1 sound has way too much echo (I prefer BF4)
the animation is slower but more fluid in my opinion
also some weapon flaws has been fixed
And thin hand model in battlefield 5
Who cares dude? You guys find any fucking reason to talk shit on BFV, we get it, you're bad at the game!
@@marcusblack5810 lol
@Rayxz yeah. Do it for justice 😂😂😂😂
@@marcusblack5810 I'm pretty good at battlefield and I don't like the game or the hand model stfu 😂😂😂
@@marcusblack5810 Not our fault BFV sucks :/
Cloud : "ouch"
9:45 By far (in my opinion) the coldest & most aggressive shooting sound goes to the Selbstlader M1916 in BF1
I always used to use this weapon because it was super strong & it’s shooting sound was so amazing.
Sad to see how BFV ruined the gun sounds, especially for that gun :(
Both games are great, in our opinion
You mean in opinion of all the Soviet Union?
Nah, BFV is shitty because it doesn't have Our Motherland in DLC like BF1
No
1 > V
@@udarue Yes my Comrade
Battlefield 1 is cool but it has ONE on it which represents singularity.
I really wish the fire effects actually burned vegetation like in fc3.
It actually burns grass in bfv... I think?
@@infinitsai but not to an extent where the fire is eating away everything.
I don't know why I was thinking that was exclusive to bf4
FC 2 did that best
I was about to comment that its annoying that flamethrowers would burn up trees and foliage in Call of Duty: World At War (2008), but they don't in a game made a decade later.
When will the animators realize that enfield clips can’t be flicked forward as every damn game shows, they only go out if you flick them backwards. They also eject if you hit them with the bolt hard enough, that’s by design.
Thanks for the insight. Would’ve never known.
Just like how you can't see the famous luger animation
You know aside from the essential weapons like the m1911, luger, webley, and so on, they could have included a lot more era appropriate weapons for bfv
Shame that they didn’t add any Russian dlc
@@ryanbelfield7887 yeah, after the game sort of fell flat on its face, they, allegedly, cancelled all upcoming content past June, I think. But I know that they were planning to add some, considering the two weapons in the BFV pre order bonus, the mosin nagant rifle grenade, the LAD machine gun, and leaked content
@@raihanrivandi5025 that’s a shame they didn’t add it.
1:28 this one is best animation in entire bf v.
10:25 This one is my fav. But the P08 Carbine and the Selbstlader 1906 are definetly up there. Their reloads are really satisfying.
@@szfulop1816 10:25 this one is good but releasing mag and insterting another one is animated so bad.
@@kekodude6584 I don't know. It feels alright to me, but the cocking animation is amazing.
@@szfulop1816 yeah,cocking animation is done really good.
BF1 sounds have a more punch than BFV
It always annoys me how in battlefield 5 the m1911's slide somehow only locks to the rear part way on an empty mag for some reason. They didn't have the problem in battlefield 1, but in bf5 the slide barely goes back halfway.
BF1 has better overall sounds but BF5 got the echoing and the crack down imo. Reloads and animations are about a tie
One thing that bothers me about bfv excluding the hands and the even bigger sights is the fact that the drilling uses red shells, which are made of plastic. Bf1 correctly uses brass shells
Dude you have been commenting content to content
Actually I think they’re supposed to be paper shells, which I think were the predecessor to plastic. Brass shells came before that, because they wouldn’t get soggy they were favored but trench gun users. Then the paper shell came and it’s what we see in bfV. That’s my guess
Battlefield 1 hands are the hands of a grown-up
Battlefield V hand are the hands of a teenager
BF1 : Sound Guns
BF5 : Graphics
BF1: sounds and graphics*
They kinda looks the same
+1
Bfv graphics are so ass
BFV graphics is good on some maps like Hamada
Battlefield 5 - Happy Colors
Battlefield 1 - Real World At War Coloros
Battlefield 5 just looks too unpolished, unfinished.
Also: *WOMAN WITH ROBOT ARM*
The fuck is your pfp.
real life graphic lock suck bro
@Rafael Enriquez contrary to popular belief, clouds and smoke make everything grey. Oh and btw the battle of berlin was in an overcast day
BF1 is fun as hell and the WW1 settings is a nice change from modern and WW2
As a World War One enthusiast I'm disappointed that Dice felt they has to make a whole new game so soon after launching BF1. I wish they had just decided to keep developing more content for BF1. There were a lot of battles they didn't cover, and there were still a lot of historical weapons they could have drawn on for inspiration.
KageMinowara BF1 was disappointing as hell and BFV even more so, should have just stuck with BF4
@@bimss7969 are you stupid or high? BF1 was great
CloroxBleachTM Ah yes a game that had more spam then previous games, shitty balancing, lack of content at launch, dummy retarded vehicle vs infantry balance, and most gadgets were useless, AND behemoths ruin pace and tactics of the game, they just lead to dying randomly without it being your fault, and unlike sniper, they don’t take skill. Not saying previous games didn’t have these issues, but BF1 made these problems worse.
Squee ok nostalgic person, go back to the 2000’s because probably your that kind of person who only complains about new stuff.
BF1: sound
BFV: accuracy of reloading animations
Small mistake: I don’t think that the Gewehr 98 and the Kar98K are the same rifle. While both were manufactured by Mauser, I don’t think they are the same rifle.
*PLEASE FEEL FREE TO CORRECT ME IF I AM WRONG*
After German Empire fall.. the weimar republic is not allowed to produce new firearms so they just shorten the Gewehr 98 so they have Karabiner 98 Kurz
They utilize the exact same round and the exact same action. Karabiner 98k is literally just a carbine version of Gewehr 98, with the only differences being different sights, shortened barrel and curved bolt handle on Kar98k. Still, comparing them like that is kind of inappropriate, since it's like comparing M16A4 and MK18
A minor nitpick but I really wanna know if M30 Drilling has a third animation where he reloads all 3 rounds.
No it’s not like that which makes me sad
No the rifle bullet is a secondary fire mode
Just what I was gonna say
Details: bfv
Gun-sound: bf1
Gun designs: bf1
Environment: mixed
Grimmy details: bf1
Vehicles: bfv
Reloading: bfv
Characters: Def bf1
Lighting: bfv but bf1 is awesome so mixed.
Success: Def bf1
Winner: bf1
Dice, please make bf6 like bf1
Note: I'm a fan of the series and I've been defending bfv for almost a year but later realized how stupid I was :P
Out of curiosity. If the next game is a modern setting and it is said to introduce 6 factions on launch like in BF1. What is going to be your pick?
@@VeteranR I'll pick anyone that has Spas-12 and M16
@@Raystation2 Uhhh okay? Lol can you be more specific? My choice would be the following.
USA: *Army and Marines*
Russia
India
Pakistan
Israel
Fictional Terrorist group: One that united all major Islamic terrorist groups around the world and has grown into the millions when it comes to numbers.
This all apart of my concept actually. Have a read at maps that would play out with these factions if you wish. :)
You're going to have to use your imagination sadly as I don't have any cool pictures to showcase the map proposals. Although I might make them someday.
docs.google.com/document/d/1HkKVRVxdnHxmSGJN2g6KcwwqkNtnw4VrkGKTSFQQOm0/edit?usp=sharing
Bf5 is still fun game , I play it everyday
@@VeteranR anyone, with, Spas, 12
Or ACWR
Here comes the comments of BF1 > BFV.
To me BFV has a meaty sound with that satisfying clanks of metal, and BF1 has that powerful sound that almost makes it sound like it'll fall apart.
I can really agree with you, BFV has some nice sounds, BF1 does as well.
Would you look a that... a comment that isn't just bashing BFV and is actually saying something nice about BFV sounds... u have my respect.
The sounds of bf1 make it sound more like war in the map. Bfv war sounds like nerf. Like the environment gunsounds and tanks shooting
@@XxNoMercyNL Right not enough ambiance I guess. Though in BFV, a lot of the chaos is created by the players, rather than map set pieces (for instance, artillery).
For sounds, it seems they reduced the bass on a lot of the gunshots, and the echoes seem very different. As for models, BFV’s weapons look like they’ve actually been used and are not like the factory-issued weapons in BF1. As for animations, BF1’s are definitely a lot smoother but BFV also fixes plenty of the animation errors from BF1. The Repetierpistole M1912 for example has the player eject the unused rounds into his hand rather than in the air in BFV. The 12g Automatic in BFV has the player actually depress the bolt release button while loading fresh shells which was required of the shotgun at the time, and the Gewehr M95 cycles fully this time rather than part of the bolt still noticeably obscuring the loading port.
Annihilator prototype Thompson?
@CIA BETA Wing Thanks
Not sure if its prototype. Seems to just have been a slang term for it
The animations/detail improvements for BFV are great imo. The sounds are a tossup
DF AMO I agree but a lot of people think BF1 looks better because of the “cleaner” appearance. DICE pumped too much grainy fidelity into BFV that it kind of brings down the visual improvement. I hope we get even more fidelity in BF6 without the grain in BFV.
Your upload was good, keep the content coming fam 😎
im wondering why dice didnt reused hands from bf1,
(but some changes to skin tone, sleeves) since the hands from bfv just look like they haven’t eating for days
BF1 All The Way !
As someone who fired many guns both with hearing protection and without one (forgetting to wear it. Not intentional) BF 1 sounds, especially the tails of the shots, sound scaringly close to real life gunshot sounds when you fire a gun without hearing protection. To describe how it sounds in real life, its the loud core POP initially then your ears shut itself off to good extent then buzzing starts right away then as it goes away your hearing comes back to normal and you hear the loud reflection of gunshot. Basically its POP...buzzzzz...loud reflection. Wearing hearing protection gets rid of most of the details and the loud/exciting parts of the gunshot so most people who fired guns in real life say the gunshot sounds boring. Of course its not very exciting but the cool details are there.
bf1's gameplay is good but bf5 has better graphics and detail and guns.
Fun Fact: Battlefield V Trailer Got 300k Likes And 500k Dislikes But Still Popular
Yeah all the incel “muh historical accuracy” dumb dumbs didn’t like that there was a girl in the trailer.
@@qwerty30013 You're truly a kukold. White knighting historical inacuraccy. Give it up, she aint gonnae give ye a gammy. She didn't exist.
Me encantan estos videos!!
If I’m being honest bf1 looks better as well
Fun fact: some weapons were actually corrected in BFV, which is very important.
The Steyr Hahn (M1912) in BFV now preserves bullets during non-empty reloads, compared to BF1 where it just flies away.
The Browning Auto-5 (12g) in BFV is actually the correct way to reload the shotgun, especially for pre-1950 production models. BF1 ignores this.
The M1911A1 actually preserves the magazine in BFV during tac reloads.
The Selbstlader M1916 was also corrected: BFV actually includes the correct extra step during empty reloads. Forgotten Weapons covers this important step in full detail.
The M1907 SL in BFV now has the correct rate of fire for the full auto mode. Yes, the real full auto conversions were actually as fast as BFV has shown.
The Lewis Gun Suppressive 97-rounder is modeled correctly in BFV.
Isn't that a Type 96 rifle? It has bent bolt handle. No dust cover either haha
The Japanese did usually take the dust covers off to keep the rifles from rattling, for their signature surprise attacks.
@@stevemc6010 with all due respect the whole supposed rattling dust cover situation is about as legit as the ping of a Garand getting you killed in combat. These rifles which bared the seal of their Emperor from a country where they brought swords to a gun fight, ran at machine guns on guts, honour and tradition alone, were instructed to scratch away the seal should rifles fall into enemy hands and were more than willing to crash their plane into a ship I can't see discarding their dust covers without being getting into some serious trouble.
@@naruto97kyubi oh boy the guy with the anime pfp and japanese name is setting me straight.
Haha jk. But I recall in a Forgotten weapons video mentions that the dust covers usually got discarded which is why they are uncommon to find on matching rifles today. Also Rising Storm 1 and World at War show the IJA using dust-coverless Arisakas.
@@stevemc6010 isnt that bcause of arisakas in the US being stripped and sent as separated pieces?
@@stevemc6010 hahahaha would you be more at ease if the pic was a flamingo in a suit and the name was John Smith haha. Yea on the boat home, US soldiers would have to take em apart with the rifle and bolt&cover being kept separate with them being reassembled when they got back State side but didn't care for matching serial no. and put which ever bolt in with the covers being lost or discarded. Which is why as the fellow below mentions that Arisaka's are generally mismatched. True those games didn't either but I wasn't defending them either haha. At the same time oh CoD WaW what a game haha. Also did they not just re use the asset from BF1 which had the cover on so I'm mighty confused as to why it disappeared but it is BFV so yea not surprised either hahaha
Battlefield 1 = Battlefield Bad Company 2(sounds more hollywood, more oomph)
Battlefield V = Battlefield 4(sounds more authentic, less satisfying)
No
BF1 = BF2
BFV = BF2142
Both BF2142 and BFV felt like they are a mod of previous successful BF
For instance when shooting shotguns and bolt actions, they sound exactly like bf4 audio engineering. I think the devs tried to bring back a little bf4 vibes into this game, but that was hard to do with the ww2 setting.
@@pissyourselfandshitncoom2172 I like it actually, because a pinch of realism can be an art.
@@ReviveHF yeah wish they would go full hardcore realism with the franchise and leave behind the casual arcade. Make it like squad and post scriptum
No way, BF3 vs BF4 sounds are night and day, and might I say BF4 sounds hella weak.
Here BF1 and BFV both sound excellent, in short I'd say you are right of the more oomph/bassy style of BF1, but the base texture is definitely there in BFV, its just more shimmer/brighter (so really a preference thing). But the fact that both carry the same texture and awesomeness, I'd say both are excellent either way.
No point in comparing, both games are good, I play both for fun
I really wish that they kept the semi auto guns in the medic class I really liked them there
The reloads in BF1 are so much cooler than the ones in BFV. They feel so much better too. It's almost kinda sad actually.
The best BF1 weapon is Seven Nation Army trailer, tho...
BFV has more realistic sounds but BF1 has louder and more violent sounds
Bf1 my favourite first person shooter ever
my grandpa just threw a grenade in my room
edit: right my grandpa died
Wait what
@@autokid311 yeah when i was 3
4:36: ah yes, another brecci
IDK if you should remake this, but they just released the Sjogren Shotgun now available to everyone in BFV as their last update.
4:52 Browning Auto 5??
Battlefeild 5 has one thing going for it. The luger casings eject upwards, bravo.
The ribbyrollies 1918 sounds the most realistic in bfv but most of the guns here sound too flat
Bf5 has more weapons than bf1 and one thing I hated about bf1 was u had different variants of the same gun instead of customization like bf5
Ye i didn’t like that
The audio glitch is still a thing for the p08 m97 combo. Damnit dice you know better
Content Story Sounds Bf1
Graphics Gameplay Bf5
In my opinion
The only mission I really liked in BF5 is The Last Tiger.
Gameplay is much better in bf1 feels like war and the aiming and movement is less stiff
TBH, there's a lot of more Attention to weapon details in BFV
0:02 m1911 forever
hardest spot the difference game I've seen in a while.
Both BF are great, just any gun are same reload animations
If you look closely, more than 60% of BF V weapons are same with BF1.
Out of 72 weapons, there are far more unique ones than copied ones from Battlefield 1. I could seriously write an entire list of all the guns in the game discounting the BF1 ports
@@Dreyfuss_The_Guy BF V last patch ....
2 our 6 primary weapons from bf1... lol
but no soviet union in ww2 game bro lol
@@쭌영이 its only 20 year apart from ww1 - ww2
@@yourbestfriendtuananh3024 umm....
Okay
Menfield 1 vs Womenfield V :)
Battlefield1 vs opweaponsunbalancedjapanwomaninthegermanarmyandviceversairrealisticfielf5
It should be Overrated 1 vs Gunplay-Good V. Not a fanboy though, just the truth.
@@rosaria8384 only if you use the type 2a
@@lucio0512 nah I haven't even seen the type 2A in a long time to be honest, pretty much every gun feels good in bfv
Womenfield Vagina
15:05 ah yes, the ROS mk III
Ross. Idk why he put Ros?
@@MunchinMaQuchyprobably misspelled
I choose both because all Battlefields are good
Other than 2042 I agree
@@Nothingeverhappens115 2042 is not bad 👍🏻
@@enrasta_0606 comment was written when it was
Agree with me if Battlefield 1 is the best!
4
Idk but the recoil climb is crazy in bf5
Battelfield is the best Game ever
which one
Hahahahhahahahah
Emmm... Nope?..
It's a very nice game indeed, but I have seen better.
Ghost Special Ops wants to know your location
I really hate the hand placements in BFV, who holds the MP-28 like that?
Soldiers from ww2.
They were holding it like that, because it was more comfortable and as a bonus you could rest your elbow on your knee while aiming in crouched position.
So BfV wins for historical accuracy on the mp28 over Bf1 on the mp 18 (which was actually also hold this way).
Photographs from before show the MP28 held like that. Just like the Sten, it's always personal preference.
Anton x oh ok thanks!
Has the MP443 Grach been in any other games than CoD: Ghosts and Advanced Warfare?
@The Anti-Parents Organization yep
@The Anti-Parents Organization what About the Volkssturmgewehr?
@The Anti-Parents Organization he hasn't done a comparison video on it
M1911: 12"-13" Lenovo ThinkPad Xs
P08: 14" Lenovo ThinkPad Ts
P08 Artillerie: 15"-16" Lenovo ThinkPad Ts
Battlefield 1 weapons are og
Battlefield 5 weapons were made in china
I prefer the BFV weapon models but BF1 has better character models
But has Bf1 Günther? I don't think so...
Just kidding. I prefer the look of Bf1 soldier, because they actually have uniforms
That's so petty dude, you can't even see your character model. Who gives a shit?
Damn bfv looks good, but bf1 is more fun
Sand
@@Daldalchoi917 Stop, he doesn't like it
@@Daldalchoi917 why you bully me
@@onejediboi sorry my fault
coolgirl.buzz/WCYtngdWiyg
On the real luger PO8 you wouldn't be able to see the toggle-lock because its moving so fast.
At 11:00 the Gewehr 98 and the Kar98K are two different rifles, you are mistaken for the Kar98A or Kar98B and don't get me started of the WEX and M2 Flamethrower.
Overall nice video.
The Kar98k is technically the shortened version of the Gewehr 98. So it's correct.
Among many other things, Dice completely ruined pistols with both the sound and how effective they are.
Bf1 looks amazing whereas bf5 has that grainy look and that’s no bueno for me imo
Why didn't you compare mp28 with mp28 and automatico with MAB and the BREN R
He didn't count MP18 and MP28 did he? It's basically the same weapon, albeit the latter have some minor improvements including a fire selector and uses straight mags.
I will never understand the logic behind why you hold psitols with one hand in BF5...
Like în real life, faster movement, comfort
@@zokerino447 I doubt you're thinking about comfort whilst being shot at bro
I mean, when you crouch, your player holds the pistol with two hands
@@tastycheesebooger but in Battlefield 1, holding your pistol in two hands can only be seen in third person view. Soz
I choose bf1 because there's more factions
That’s not what the video is about
Factions with no specific vehicles on each side
everyone comparing sound designs but deep down we all know that they reused the sounds and added a bit more bass
Bfv should coome before bf1 because bf1 feels like a newer game because it looks and sounds better then a 2019 game
Exactly BF1 literally looks and sounds so much more crisp than the copy and paste bfv
In your opinion
what a spaz31 it’s factual. Look up a graphics comparison bf1 is more crisp and has more detail.
@sockyxy hhh bf5 fanboy
I’m going to say it I love both
6:49 sounds familiar.
at first, i really thought Carcano M91 (BF1) is the ancestor of KAR98 (BF5). Was it considerable?
I mean it isnt, Carcano manlichher is an italian design while the kar98k is a carbine version of the mauser gewher 98
Still can get the fact that battlefield 1 was created and fully released in 2016, yet it has greater graphic than most game.
You need to alternate the order you play the sounds. Also I think the machine guns sound better in bfv. Everything else is a tossup for me
that respotile reload is a little more smarter than B1
Damn i love gloves
The shadow on the arms in battlefield 5 disturb me every time
Hugo Thirion their weird wrists and long fingers throw me off
@@dawsongranger4940 My hands and wrists are like that. Every character must be over six feet tall with 3 feet long arms in BFV lol.