No Sir Frank Worrell Windies opening batsman and fast medium pacer? How about Bernard Julien, Keith Boyce and Joseph (Joe) Solomon? I will throw in David Halford while I am at it.
Did you guys hear about BERNARD JULIEN. Well he opened bowling W.I. along with Keith Boyce. Also bowled back of the hand stuff. He made one test century that I can recall. Held some brilliant catches and was dubed the next sobers. In my view he should be in the top six.
Vanburn Holder , Sir Iaac Vivian Alexander Richards ( although the great one kept his bowling mainly for One Dayers ), even Rohan Kanhai was probably a better All Rounder than Bloody Roger Harper . Bernard Julien and Keith Boyce were both Victims of World Series Cricket . I seem to recall Malcolm Marshall scoring a Test Century against India back in the Early 80's .
A nice topic 😊 Sobers, Hooper, Gayle, Harper, Marshall, Franklyn Stephenson, Collis King, Jimmy Adams, Holding & R Chase are among the best I've seen or heard about. Thoughts? 😊
Franklyn Stephenson, if only he didn't go to SA. What a English county career he had he would have been an all-time test great and most likely no.2 in this list.
There are many great players who were victims of unfortunate circumstances, which deprived the cricketing world. We are working on a video on Unsunh heroes of West Indies cricket. Perhaps everyone can provide feedback on that list. Thank you for watching and being part of our community 😊 🙏
What about Bernard Julien who though did not have a sustained career but was a much more complete and talented cricketer than Daren Sammy. He was one of Clive Lloyd’s gifted players of the 70’s
A lot of viewers brought up Bernard Julian. He was definitely one of the more talented players in the 70s. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and being part of our community 😊 🙏.
@@thereversescoopUSA 👍 Though, we have to Hail up & acknowledge two forerunners to Roger too....The Big Cat Clive Lloyd...& the electric Sir Vivian Richards ☺
Observations Harper is a specialist off spin bowler, Holder is a specialist fast bowler, Walcott was a specialist # 3 batsman, none of these players were selected as allrounders like Clive Lloyd, Bernard Julian & Collis King.
Thank you for your feedback. Yes, that appears to the community consensus. Some of these names will be mentioned in our Top 10 West Indies Unsung Heroes rankings. Stay tuned for that 😉 😎
All-rounder in whichever form of cricket and the impact and importance of their performance.there can never be a top ten best All-rounder list without collis king
My top 10 would have Keith Boyce and Bernard Julien. Here we go:- Sobers > Walcott > Hooper > Gomez > Collie Smith > Keith Boyce > Bravo > Constantine > Bernard Julien > Harper Honorable mention: Eldine Baptiste/Sammy/Collis King
You are absolutely correct. Though these players couldn't make our top 10, they were definitely handy with the ball, and all of them had a golden arm. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
With no Bernard Julien means that you have unknowingly not done good enough research. Sir Garry Sobers, Carl Hooper, Jason Holder, Sir Larry Constantine, Bernard Julien, Collis King, D Bravo, D Sammy, Keith Boyce. These are the top ten all-rounder in West Indies cricket. Let no one fool you.
This is one category that the West Indies has struggled with. I too have struggled to come up with many alternatives. If I had to choose I would add Malcolm Marshall he was nice with the bat and I believe he was a couple of test fifties. Franklyn Stevenson comes to mind but he never made it in the West Indies test team. Bernard Julien and Gayle were decent as well. I didn't like the Harper selection but if you added his fielding to the mix. I can't hate on it as he top draw when it comes to fielding. David Holford wasn't bad either.
Thank you for your feedback and your insightful comment. Malcolm Marshall was definitely a good lower order batsman. Who would you replace for Harper on this top 10?
@@thereversescoopUSA Both average 18 in test match batting. It's like oranges and apples. To be fair this is the first time I have heard of Harper being an all rounder. Marshall on the other hand was touted as one and some believe he under performed as a batsman. In addition Marshall has a high score of 92 in test.
@PunanyChemist Absolutely, not to discount Marshall batting abilities, Harper, was more unlucky in our opinion. He played at a time when West Indies mostly used the 4 pronged pace attack. But his batting abilities weren't fully utilized, and lack of gametime made it tough for him. Thank you for replying again. it is much appreciated
@@thereversescoopUSA Unlucky that's a new one. Who were unlucky were those guys that went to South Africa that were branded rebels and had lifetime bans. Harper had plenty of opportunities and not once did he stand out with the bat, that I can recall. In my humble opinion Marshall was a better batman than Harper. Dude even hit a 4 batting with one hand lol.
How could you not mention James Adams who was such a good spin bowler excellent batsman and versatile wicket keeper and also the great wicket keeper batsman Jeffrey Dudgeon
You will see these names feature in one of our other West Indies Rankings videos. Make sure to check out our latest episode drop on the quickest West Indies Bowlers of All Time.
Thank you for watching, both names you mentioned were part of the pool we got down to 25. picking 10 out of them was not an easy task. What does your all time West Indies allrounder rankings look like?
Taking nothing away from Darren Sammy's achievement he was a good captain and brought the team together but he was at best an average cricketer how he made this list ahead of others more deserving is beyond my understanding.
Gayle & Marshall weren't complete All-rounders. They could handle themselves with and ball, but the players who actually had an allrounder role within the team is who we were looking for.
I consider allrounders who can bat, bowl and feild and can get a century and get 5 wicket haul ...i consider holder and sobers are the best allrounders for me ..........holder , sobers.. gayle , hooper , sammy , bravo , Richards , julien , chase , collis king ..............................all are the best allrounders check their stats ......
All-rounder is batting and bowling...selecting Walcott means you have to select Dujon. Keith Boyce, Collis King, Bernard Julian were true all-rounders. All better than Harper and Sammy.
Good afternoon l am a Guyanese but a West lndian cricket fan to the bone. How could you not have Collis King on this list but have Roger Harper on it. As an all rounder Boyce and Julien were also better than Harper. Good try but do a little more research next time.
Keith boyce and brendan julian were genuine all rounders the inclusions should have been, when you consider carl hooper gets a nod with an average of 50 as a bowler , clyde walcott great bat, as a bowler 11 test wickets how does that qualify, that's poor selection process, david holford was also a good all rounder Do better is the call here
Harbajan Singh has atest not County double century. I have never ever heard anyone calling him an allrounder. Come on accept fair criticism. Harper was never an allrounder.
@@keithcampbell6806 Harbajan was a proper tailender who made a 100 on a dust patch that yielded Over 1,000 runs in 3 innings. Many bowlers have for lucky and got themselve a 100, to make 236 you have to be able to bat. Do you know how many top batsmans never track that score in their careers?
We looked at players who actually played the role of an Allrounder in the team. Gayle, though, was a useful off spinner much like Sir Viv, but he was mainly in the team as a batsman and not an allrounder. So this list we picked is based on the Allrounder role.
We looked at players who actually played the role of an Allrounder in the team. Gayle, though, was a useful off spinner much like Sir Viv, but he was mainly in the team as a batsman and not an allrounder. So this list we picked based on the Allrounder role.
Gayle, we have already highlighted in our Top 10 Batsman of All time, which I believe is where he has shines mostly. For the all-rounders rankings, we wanted to look at the all rounders that played the role of an allrounder the best over a period of time. Thanks for watching and being a part of our community 😊 🙏
@thereversescoopUSA Your logic is incorrect. A wicket field the ball just as any fielder on the ground. An all-rounder is a cricketer who is competent balling and batting the ball. A wicket keeper is supposed to be a specialist in that position.
What about Chris Gayle? Remember at once time, Chris Gayle was the number one ALLROUNDER .in the world. How can he be omitted.Was this done based on personality, or on performance.? DO YOUR RESEARCH, and stop using OPINION.
Guys Jeff Dujon was easily better than Sammy and Holder, etc again you are showing you have seen most of these guys play. He was easily Windies best keeper and at his peak a graceful stroke Maker a joy to watch. Go and watch highlights of Duj I n in action keeping to the fastest attacks of all-time.
Absolutely, Dujon was a great player, and if we didn't go with Walcott, then Duj was the choice to keep. Thank you for your feedback and for being part of our community 😊
@thereversescoopUSA GUYS You said TOP 10 all-rounders, there was. mention of a team. A team of mediocre all- rounders that's novel. Dujon was better than Sammy. .more runs. .more dismissals He was better than Holder .More runs .More dismissals Dujon's test run scored was higher Dujon's career runs was higher Dujon's Test average was higher Dujon's career average was higher Dujon won more international games than nearly the whole list put together ( minus Hooper) You have no statistical fact that can place two mediocre players above a GREAT. Your selections are based on bias or you haven't got the knowledge, the top 10 is the top 10 and Dujon is top 5.
He'll lead our West Indies Wicket Keeper of All Time list for sure. Stay tuned for that episode drop. Thank you for your feedback and insightful knowledge.
Chris Gayle was definitely on the radar. However, we wanted to highlight Allrounders that had an equal impact with Bat and Ball. Gayle was a batsman who could bowl some offies, so was Sir Viv, but we can't name them in the top 10 Allrounders since that was not their primary role.
Harper is the weakest aii rounders the wi has produced........a great fielding ....how many fifties he has....how many 5 fors he has .....I'm from Guyana but harper is weak.....do not put a twist to the all rounder title Walcott has no place there........sir Viv is a great all rounder. Among the best..Also Collis king
![BDG Thursday Mix FunPlay [Court1 - Set3] 14112024 @DJI](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/KZZ4n_ULK3w/mqdefault.jpg)
Like & Subscribe for more content like this :)
Also let us know in the comments your thoughts on these rankings.
No Sir Frank Worrell Windies opening batsman and fast medium pacer? How about Bernard Julien, Keith Boyce and Joseph (Joe) Solomon?
I will throw in David Halford while I am at it.
@@WesleyMcpherson-lu1rf those are some great suggestions.
My first three selections, before reading the list, are Sobers, Julien and Boyce. I even considered David Holford.
Some great names there 👌 👍. Thank you for sharing your thoughts 🙏
Did you guys hear about BERNARD JULIEN. Well he opened bowling W.I. along with Keith Boyce. Also bowled back of the hand stuff. He made one test century that I can recall. Held some brilliant catches and was dubed the next sobers. In my view he should be in the top six.
Of course, that's a great suggestion and some awesome insights 👌
Right on Franklin!
@@WesleyMcpherson-lu1rf
I agree with you Bernard Julien should be in that lineup, he was a brilliant all rounder
Thank you for your feedback. Let us know your thoughts on our other West Indies rankings.
All you joking ah what ? All u never heard of Bernard Julian and Keith Boyce ? Julian , Boyce and Sir Garry for me guys
Vanburn Holder , Sir Iaac Vivian Alexander Richards ( although the great one kept his bowling mainly for One Dayers ), even Rohan Kanhai was probably a better All Rounder than Bloody Roger Harper . Bernard Julien and Keith Boyce were both Victims of World Series Cricket . I seem to recall Malcolm Marshall scoring a Test Century against India back in the Early 80's .
Malcolm Marshall higest score was 92 never scored a test century.
A nice topic 😊 Sobers, Hooper, Gayle, Harper, Marshall, Franklyn Stephenson, Collis King, Jimmy Adams, Holding & R Chase are among the best I've seen or heard about. Thoughts? 😊
Pretty great list. Love all your suggestions 👍
great list
Franklyn Stephenson, if only he didn't go to SA. What a English county career he had he would have been an all-time test great and most likely no.2 in this list.
There are many great players who were victims of unfortunate circumstances, which deprived the cricketing world. We are working on a video on Unsunh heroes of West Indies cricket. Perhaps everyone can provide feedback on that list. Thank you for watching and being part of our community 😊 🙏
What about Bernard Julien who though did not have a sustained career but was a much more complete and talented cricketer than Daren Sammy. He was one of Clive Lloyd’s gifted players of the 70’s
A lot of viewers brought up Bernard Julian. He was definitely one of the more talented players in the 70s. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and being part of our community 😊 🙏.
Where is Keith Boyce
Reachingout from Jamaica holder in front of Julian and Boyce crazy thinking
Awesome! Thank you for watching and sharing.
I made my selection before watching your video 😊 Listening to it now. Fascinsting. Listening to your Harper pick, pretty spot on. A great fielder..
Harper set a new standard for fielding in West Indies cricket. Thank you for your comment 🙏 😊
@@thereversescoopUSA 👍 Though, we have to Hail up & acknowledge two forerunners to Roger too....The Big Cat Clive Lloyd...& the electric Sir Vivian Richards ☺
Absolutely, those are some great mentions.
@@richposports7030
Observations Harper is a specialist off spin bowler, Holder is a specialist fast bowler, Walcott was a specialist # 3 batsman, none of these players were selected as allrounders like Clive Lloyd, Bernard Julian & Collis King.
Thank you for your feedback. Some great points and observations!
Bernard Julien is a surprised omission. Maurice Foster as well.
Thank you for your feedback. Yes, that appears to the community consensus. Some of these names will be mentioned in our Top 10 West Indies Unsung Heroes rankings. Stay tuned for that 😉 😎
All-rounder in whichever form of cricket and the impact and importance of their performance.there can never be a top ten best All-rounder list without collis king
Thank you for your feedback. Let us know your thoughts on our other West Indies rankings.
Commendable list; however, I would opt for Keith Boyce instead of Roger Harper and swap Bernard Julien for Dwayne Bravo.
Those are some great suggestions. Thanks for watching and being part of our community 😊
Bernard Julien's omission is glearing.
That appears to the community consensus. Thanks for watching and being part of our community 😊
Watching from New Orleans, USA
Awesome 👌 👏 thanks for watching
What about eldine baptiste from Antigua
He was definitely discussed about, but ultimately, was a tough squeeze for top 10.
My top 10 would have Keith Boyce and Bernard Julien.
Here we go:-
Sobers > Walcott > Hooper > Gomez > Collie Smith > Keith Boyce > Bravo > Constantine > Bernard Julien > Harper
Honorable mention: Eldine Baptiste/Sammy/Collis King
What a great list. Thank you for sharing.
Good list but Walcott and Harper .NAH MAN.
Chris Gayle, Viv Richards and Frank Worrell worthy of mention
You are absolutely correct. Though these players couldn't make our top 10, they were definitely handy with the ball, and all of them had a golden arm. Thank you for sharing your thoughts.
We ar speaking of all rounders none of the ones u spoke were all rounders
We're sorry you feel that way. Thank you for your feedback.
Where's Chris Gayle?? 100+ tests, former captain, 73 test wickets and 7000+ runs!
From Barcelona
Not enough wickets to be warranted a full allrounder. But he was definitely a handy off spinner.
@@thereversescoopUSA bit harsh! He was listed as an allrounder even in his last days as a t20 slugger
@@davidalvarez5981 thats fair. maybe we can list him in the top 10 allrounders in T20 cricket from West Indies Cricket.
With no Bernard Julien means that you have unknowingly not done good enough research.
Sir Garry Sobers, Carl Hooper, Jason Holder, Sir Larry Constantine, Bernard Julien, Collis King, D Bravo, D Sammy, Keith Boyce.
These are the top ten all-rounder in West Indies cricket.
Let no one fool you.
Some great names. Thank you for watching and sharing. Check out our latest episode drop on the quickest west indies bowlers of all time.
Good morning this person did their homework. I would add Collie Smith and Gerry Gomez and this would be my list.
This is one category that the West Indies has struggled with. I too have struggled to come up with many alternatives. If I had to choose I would add Malcolm Marshall he was nice with the bat and I believe he was a couple of test fifties. Franklyn Stevenson comes to mind but he never made it in the West Indies test team. Bernard Julien and Gayle were decent as well. I didn't like the Harper selection but if you added his fielding to the mix. I can't hate on it as he top draw when it comes to fielding. David Holford wasn't bad either.
Thank you for your feedback and your insightful comment. Malcolm Marshall was definitely a good lower order batsman. Who would you replace for Harper on this top 10?
@@thereversescoopUSA Both average 18 in test match batting. It's like oranges and apples. To be fair this is the first time I have heard of Harper being an all rounder. Marshall on the other hand was touted as one and some believe he under performed as a batsman. In addition Marshall has a high score of 92 in test.
@PunanyChemist Absolutely, not to discount Marshall batting abilities, Harper, was more unlucky in our opinion. He played at a time when West Indies mostly used the 4 pronged pace attack. But his batting abilities weren't fully utilized, and lack of gametime made it tough for him. Thank you for replying again. it is much appreciated
@@thereversescoopUSA Unlucky that's a new one. Who were unlucky were those guys that went to South Africa that were branded rebels and had lifetime bans. Harper had plenty of opportunities and not once did he stand out with the bat, that I can recall. In my humble opinion Marshall was a better batman than Harper. Dude even hit a 4 batting with one hand lol.
Lol 😆 🤣 we feel you. Let us know your thoughts on our other ranking videos
How could you not mention James Adams who was such a good spin bowler excellent batsman and versatile wicket keeper and also the great wicket keeper batsman Jeffrey Dudgeon
He is definitely an honorable mention, and dujon tops our West Indies all time wicket keeper list.
Bernard Julien, Collis King, k Pollard.
You will see these names feature in one of our other West Indies Rankings videos. Make sure to check out our latest episode drop on the quickest West Indies Bowlers of All Time.
Hard to believe that Keith Boyce and Collis King are both omitted.
Thank you for watching, both names you mentioned were part of the pool we got down to 25. picking 10 out of them was not an easy task. What does your all time West Indies allrounder rankings look like?
Boyce and king two players that would beat the best bowling attack on any team
Nonsense a wicket keeper is not n alrounder
Thank you for your feedback. Be sure to check out our other rankings on West Indies cricket 🏏 😀
You guys left out Keith Authurton, Jimmy Adams, Clive Lloyd and Jeffrey Dujon.
Unfortunately there were only 10 spots..lol but some great mentions there.
Reaching out from Johannesburg, South Africa.
Wow, awesome, Lester! 👌 Welcome to The Reverse Scoop!
Those apart of the elite list should play a minimum of 25 tests. There is class and leagues base on amount of matches.
That's a great suggestion. We will look to separate eras since back in the day, some of the greatest players couldn't play 25 test matches.
Taking nothing away from Darren Sammy's achievement he was a good captain and brought the team together but he was at best an average cricketer how he made this list ahead of others more deserving is beyond my understanding.
Thanks for sharing your thoughts, though Sammy skills were limited he did make some impactful contributions.
Holder was number one in theworld .scored a double century against England
No Chris Gayle or Malcom Marshall?
Gayle & Marshall weren't complete All-rounders. They could handle themselves with and ball, but the players who actually had an allrounder role within the team is who we were looking for.
@thereversescoopUSA Marshall was an opening batman from dayone... did it all..
I consider allrounders who can bat, bowl and feild and can get a century and get 5 wicket haul ...i consider holder and sobers are the best allrounders for me ..........holder , sobers.. gayle , hooper , sammy , bravo , Richards , julien , chase , collis king ..............................all are the best allrounders check their stats ......
What a great list. Thank you for your suggestions, and let us know your thoughts on our other West Indies rankings
What about Hooper as one of d best spinnners
Hooper was an outstanding golden arm.
How did Sammy get in there?😅
Just for his leadership I assume..lol
Good List. Patric Birmingham UK
Thank you for watching and being part of our community.
Eldine Baptiste
🤔🤔 the Antiguan Allrounder? Fun fact about Eldine Baptiste, West Indies won in all 10 Test Matches that he played in. Thoughts on that?
All-rounder is batting and bowling...selecting Walcott means you have to select Dujon. Keith Boyce, Collis King, Bernard Julian were true all-rounders. All better than Harper and Sammy.
Those are some great suggestions. Thank you for your feedback. Do let us know your thoughts on our other West Indies Rankings videos.
Garfield Sobers
Great guess 😅. Thanks for watching
Good afternoon l am a Guyanese but a West lndian cricket fan to the bone. How could you not have Collis King on this list but have Roger Harper on it. As an all rounder Boyce and Julien were also better than Harper. Good try but do a little more research next time.
Thanks for your feedback 😀
Sammy was not in Boyce and Julien league
Thank you for your feedback. What does your top 10 allrounder list look like?
Please do not include exclusively as west indian all rounder; he is the worlds greatest only allrounder for all the time always he will remain so.
No doubt about that
Bernard Julien also open 4 WI against Australia Faced Thompson n Lillie made 51
Wow thanks for sharing that info.
Don't bernard jullien hit a century at lords
www.espncricinfo.com/cricketers/bernard-julien-52208
His stats here.
Keith Boyce And Gale for Harper and Walcott was great batman and good wicketkeeper not all-rounder
Thank you for your suggestions, some great picks. 👍
Keith boyce and brendan julian were genuine all rounders the inclusions should have been, when you consider carl hooper gets a nod with an average of 50 as a bowler , clyde walcott great bat, as a bowler 11 test wickets how does that qualify, that's poor selection process, david holford was also a good all rounder
Do better is the call here
Noted. Stay tuned for our ultimate rankings on West Indies All-rounders of all time.
How can Worrell not be in the top 10 all-rounders?
Collie Smith should be higher.
Who are you replacing him with?
Roger Harper could bat you don't make a double hundreds in England unless you can bat.
😅😅
Harbajan Singh has atest not County double century. I have never ever heard anyone calling him an allrounder. Come on accept fair criticism. Harper was never an allrounder.
@@keithcampbell6806 Harbajan was a proper tailender who made a 100 on a dust patch that yielded Over 1,000 runs in 3 innings. Many bowlers have for lucky and got themselve a 100, to make 236 you have to be able to bat. Do you know how many top batsmans never track that score in their careers?
Watching from jamicia
Awesome. Thanks for watching.
What happened to Chris Gayle
We looked at players who actually played the role of an Allrounder in the team. Gayle, though, was a useful off spinner much like Sir Viv, but he was mainly in the team as a batsman and not an allrounder. So this list we picked is based on the Allrounder role.
Roger Harper made is test debut early as 1983 at the age of 20yrs and last play 1996
Thanks for sharing that insightful information.
What about Gayle?
We looked at players who actually played the role of an Allrounder in the team. Gayle, though, was a useful off spinner much like Sir Viv, but he was mainly in the team as a batsman and not an allrounder. So this list we picked based on the Allrounder role.
Bernard jullien hit a hundred at lords plus eldine Baptiste
Some legendary names there.
Keith Boyce
👍👍
Lawrence Yaga Rowe is the best batsman ever
Some great names there. 👌
This bias still. Example how Roger harper over Gayle explain that intact how harper in top 10 and how hoper so high .
Gayle, we have already highlighted in our Top 10 Batsman of All time, which I believe is where he has shines mostly. For the all-rounders rankings, we wanted to look at the all rounders that played the role of an allrounder the best over a period of time. Thanks for watching and being a part of our community 😊 🙏
I am surprised that Malcolm Marshall didn't make the list
He is close but tough to get him in the top 10.
Hi, wicket keeper is Fielder, not an all-rounder.
Wicket Keeper Batsman are considered all rounders technically.
@thereversescoopUSA Your logic is incorrect. A wicket field the ball just as any fielder on the ground. An all-rounder is a cricketer who is competent balling and batting the ball. A wicket keeper is supposed to be a specialist in that position.
Specialist wicket keeper who can bat? What would you call them?
@thereversescoopUSA just what you said. " a wicket keeper that can bat".
👍
If Collis King is not this list it’s wrong !!
Thank you for your feedback. Perhaps we missed out on Collis King, which seems to be the community consensus. What does your top 10 ranking look like?
OutReaching
👍👍🙏🙏 Thank you for being a part of our community 😊
🇦🇬🇦🇬🇦🇬🇦🇬🇦🇬
😊😊
Walcott was a wicket wicket keeper bstsman
Sir Garry
Absolutely correct 👍 👏 👌
What country he is from Gary sobers ?
Barbados
What about Chris Gayle? Remember at once time, Chris Gayle was the number one ALLROUNDER .in the world. How can he be omitted.Was this done based on personality, or on performance.? DO YOUR RESEARCH, and stop using OPINION.
This was based on the role the players had within the team. Gayle played as a batsman who could roll the arm over, which was handy at times.
Garfield sobers
That's correct! Thank you for watching.
Bernard julien
Thanks for mentioning him.
Garfiel sobers
The Goat 🐐
Guys Jeff Dujon was easily better than Sammy and Holder, etc again you are showing you have seen most of these guys play.
He was easily Windies best keeper and at his peak a graceful stroke Maker a joy to watch.
Go and watch highlights of Duj I n in action keeping to the fastest attacks of all-time.
Absolutely, Dujon was a great player, and if we didn't go with Walcott, then Duj was the choice to keep. Thank you for your feedback and for being part of our community 😊
@thereversescoopUSA
GUYS
You said TOP 10 all-rounders, there was. mention of a team.
A team of mediocre all- rounders that's novel.
Dujon was better than Sammy.
.more runs.
.more dismissals
He was better than Holder
.More runs
.More dismissals
Dujon's test run scored was higher
Dujon's career runs was higher
Dujon's Test average was higher
Dujon's career average was higher
Dujon won more international games than nearly the whole list put together ( minus Hooper)
You have no statistical fact that can place two mediocre players above a GREAT.
Your selections are based on bias or you haven't got the knowledge, the top 10 is the top 10 and Dujon is top 5.
He'll lead our West Indies Wicket Keeper of All Time list for sure. Stay tuned for that episode drop. Thank you for your feedback and insightful knowledge.
WHAT A SILLY NUMBRING.
Thank you for your feedback. What does your list look like?
If Carl Hooper can be considered an all rounder, Viv Richards should be one too!
Fair point. Thank you for watching
Not Roger Harper at all .he was a failure at test level
Sobers
You are correct, sir! Great job 👏 👍
Sir gaey sober
The one and only
Your list is off
How so?
NO CHRIS GAYLE 😮
Chris Gayle was definitely on the radar. However, we wanted to highlight Allrounders that had an equal impact with Bat and Ball. Gayle was a batsman who could bowl some offies, so was Sir Viv, but we can't name them in the top 10 Allrounders since that was not their primary role.
@@thereversescoopUSA Gayle had more than an 100 wickets one of a few persons to so do
Absolutely but later part of his career he hardly bowled.
You guys are waking up from a bad dream David Halford,Richard Austin, Robert Haynes, Maurice Foster , Collis King, Wake up
Lol thank you for your feedback. Let us know your thoughts on our other West Indies Ranking videos.
Harper is the weakest aii rounders the wi has produced........a great fielding ....how many fifties he has....how many 5 fors he has .....I'm from Guyana but harper is weak.....do not put a twist to the all rounder title Walcott has no place there........sir Viv is a great all rounder. Among the best..Also Collis king
noted, thank you for your feedback.
Julian and Boyce weren't all rounders
They were considered allrounders and were part of our final 15 but didnt make the cut in top 10.
False list
Thank you for your feedback. What does your list look like?
Sir Garry
Absolutely correct 👍