The Jedi’s Most BRUTAL War Crimes
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 вер 2024
- Could the Jedi be considered war criminals if judged by real-world laws and standards?
#starwars #jedi #sith #starwarslife #starwarsnerd
Become a channel member to get access to perks: / starwarsapprentice
Get Star Wars news delivered to your inbox ➡️ Sign Up: www.holonewsne...
The Jedi often crossed the line, engaging in acts that would undeniably be considered torture. From combining their abilities to perform a powerful Jedi Mind Trick to the physical beating of Separatist prisoners, the Jedi reveal a shadowy side that complicates their legacy. Jedi generals often commanded their clone troopers to pursue fleeing Separatist forces, primarily composed of battle droids. This practice stands in stark contrast to the teachings of Yoda when he instructed Luke Skywalker that Jedi should only use their skills for defense, never for attack. The Jedi also authorized the breaking of a century-long treaty with Mandalore that prohibited the Republic from invading its sovereign territory. By sending Ahsoka Tano and Captain Rex to lead clone troopers against Maul, the rightful ruler of Mandalore, even Obi-Wan Kenobi acknowledged this bold move violated the treaty. In your opinion, who's the bigger war criminal: the Jedi Order or Chopper?
Chopper, is that a question
This bot kills for fun 😅
I fear no man...
But that thing...
It scares me
I don't know what you're talking about.He did nothing
@@YourFutureleadernice joke bro😅
The line that gets me the most out of all the Star Wars films is “we are keeper of the peace not spillers of war” And then you have ki adi mundi pull out frickin flame throwers
To be fair they were used against zombie genosians.
*fortunate son starts playing*
@@dakotaburnside994 Zombies? they weren't Zombies!
@@CIS-PD dead genosians puppeted by mind control worms sounds like a form zombies to me.
@@dakotaburnside994those where only in the catacombs the genosians they deep fried were normal
Top war criminals in star wars universe :
-C110P "chopper"
-anakin skywalker
-ahsoka tano
-R2D2
-ki-adi mundi
What about pong krell
And that time Obi-Wan faux-surrendered.
@@Captain_Communisumit aint warcrimes mate, just old school Russian war tactics, soldier losses don’t count
Bro forgot moff tarkin. Palp and vader
@@panmopsel well I hate how you aren’t wrong
lol I will never forget Ki Adi Mundi and his flamethrowers 😂
its actually not a war crime. It feels like it should but it isn't. Only when they are used on civilians is it a war crime
@@leon_brave_racing898so it’s only a war crime when not used on civilians?🤣🤣
@@TylerMcCaughey I meant the other way haha
The geos ate the clones 🤷♂️who cares
@@leon_brave_racing898flametrowers are banned you cant use them so if you do its war crime
I believe Chopper Is a sith lord
a SITH Lord ?
He is so much cooler than a sith lord, he does all that without the force
It's possible
@@warshield924chopper is a poor mans r2d2... and not cooler than a sith either
Darth Chopper did nothing wrong
Chopper No question.
Chopper. I love that little psychopath but yeah the war crimes. To say nothing of the war crimes he was prevented from committing by Hera.
Chopper, like Chopper would do those things without a second thought (in worse ways too)
"War Criminal" is a label for people/nations that break the rules established in the Geneva Convention. Most countries break these rules routinely on earth, so I can imagine it'd be the same in a galaxy far away
Chopper isnt just a war criminal he's a menace
Chopper. My dude feeds off of warcrimes
If you were to tell me that Chopper was wanted in 16 systems, I believe you
Without any doubt, Chopper.
War crimes are the stupidest thing ever. Haven’t they ever heard that all is fair in love and war?
Flamethrowers are good if you use them on enemy soldiers.
Meanwhile, whatever the hell Skywalker and the 501st kept pulling were definitely war crimes. (false surrender, torture of POW's, training of the Onderon rebels (technically terrorists but definitely against their government))
Nah, Chopper has done some weird shit when we didn't look, and even when we looked, Chopper 100%
It's never a war crime the first time .
Jedi have a lot of war crimes but chopper is unbeatable
Chopper for sure! He loves every maniacal minute! *chopper laugh*
Chopper is the Ad0lf H1tler of star wars
We ain’t even talking about all the counts of false surrender? 💀
Chopper can easily take on the whole jedi order at the peak of its power it would not even be a fight
I hate to say it because I absolutely love Chopper, but I have to say Chopper. He is a true character
Obviously Chopper's name was just thrown in there at the end as a joke, but is really a deeply misunderstood character... 😏
bro its darth chopper easily
Aside from Anakin, no jedi enjoyed the war. Chopper chuckles whenever he commits both a war crime and
multiple war crimes at once.
Definitely Chopper😂
That’s just one war we know about. The Jedi are thousands of years old. Absolutely they’d be considered war criminals. Chopper technically is a program.
The republic also used flamethrowers in the 2nd battle of Genosis (which is a war crime) 😂
chopper wanted to do more killing then the jedi order
Chopper. By far. 😂
100% Chopper
Don’t forget (as a b1 I don’t fully have this knowledge but) I heard the the clones were super aged children
Chopper has a good spirit…
Sometimes you've got to do a wrong in order to make a right to fix a wrong. Ghandi said that.
Well, since Chopper is still around and the Jedi aren't, I say the Jedi are the war criminals! (says this as I prime my ion blaster in case Chopper comes after me, LOL)
In real life international law is only a suggestion
Diplomatic Immunity have you heard of it?
To be fair, the Mandalorians asked for the Republic's help, and I would hardly call Maul their rightful ruler. He only became ruler by killing the previous one, who himself usurped the throne through treachery.
Exactly! the government of mandalore that made the deal with the Republic had fallen, a previous governments deals do not matter unless the new one decided to re up their dealings.
@@GeneralSturnn this is true governments that make a deal only are legitimate while the government that introduce the documents still exist. once they fall the new government is under no obligation to uphold the previous government standing. deals have to be made before 'the event' to ensure the continuation of previously establish documents.
Old Republic: Yall are wussys 🗿
Anyway, ahsoka wasn't part of the jedi order, and Bo was technically the new ruler of mandalore and asked the jedi for aid. Its like real world conflicts today
Star Wars Content: *Hello There!!!!*
Chopper scares me more
A technicality is that Anakin Skywalker committed false surrender at one point and that is a war crime under section 1 of the Geneva Convention
fake sarrunder was key stratagy of jedi
Ki adi mundi, Anakin, Ashoka and certain jedi with four arms: Is not war crimes is happy accidents
Darth Chopper for real
Chopper vs Jedi order,
If we count in Anakin to jedi order, we might get a draw
He ruined my life for nothing due to his PTSD
Jedi mind trick isn't a war crime, according to real life law, because there is nothing in real life law that covers space magic.
You can shoot a fleeing enemy. As long as they're not Hors de Combat they can be targetted. There are three things that make you Hors de Combat
1. Anyone who is in the power of an adverse party (I.e. being a prisoner)
2. Anyone who is defenceless because of unconsciusness, shipwreck, wounds or sickness
3. Anyone who clearly expresses an intention to surrender
And that is as long as he or she abstains from any hostile act and does not attempt to escape. It also means that as long as you are in uniform, you do not need to be armed to be a legal target
It’s chopper that’s not even a question
Chopper no question
choper, no question
Idk who chopper is but I'm pretty sure Disney is the true war criminal 😂
The Jedi literally abduct children and give them deadly weapons. Plus the whole clone slave army thing.
Is "killing" a droid even the correct terminology.
Anyway, everything gets worse with lawyers...
The Jedi of the bigger war criminals.
Choppers on his own scale of death and destruction.
The Sith are the real heroes.
No It is R2 or chopper
Let's not forget the many time they falsified surrender
No, the Jedi wouldn’t be war criminals by any stretch. This is just more Jedi hating and bashing.
You could make the case that they made bad decisions in their strategy decisions but they aren’t war criminals. The examples you give don’t amount to war crimes. Doesn’t mean they were wise decisions but that’s not a crime. As for pursuing the separatists that isn’t a violation of the Jedi code of using their power for defense only. In the context of war the old adage that a good defense is a good offense applies. The separatists were the offensive force against the Republic and the Jedi were defending the Republic. Of course this is before they were aware of what was going on. But defending doesn’t always mean to sit back and wait to be hit. By pursuing the droids they were in fact staying in a defensive posture.
What Master Yoda means is that the Jedi don’t offensive attacks. Not that you can’t pursue attackers once they start it. Is Yoda guilty of violating this code or rule by entering Palpatine’s office chambers and seeking to off him? I don’t think so.
Im not familiar with the other examples but those wouldn’t be war crimes in my view. I’m talking about killing civilians or grotesque acts of torture. Simply making some feel uncomfortable isn’t it.
Chopper duh
yes
Also, the Jedi were happy in suddenly being made officers of a pretty much slave army.
Wait wait, Ashoka was the bad guy?!
oh yeah totally. according to real world international laws regarding what is and isn't a War Crime, the Jedi have committed quite a lot. a common war crime is using a flag of truce to trick an enemy. that's a very common one that a lot of Jedi have pulled, Anakin doing it at least three times
Both
They don't see what they have become just like all people put in power over weaker people, they turn into tyrant's 😢
Chopper
The bigger one is ofc The Emperor
The Jedi = Anakin
The Jedi are most certainly war criminals
The Jedi had a child slave army, its not even close.
Bc of palpatine if he wasn’t chancellor none of this would if ever happened not the war not the clones y’all blame the Jedi way to much then what they were practically forced to do
Obi Wan Kenobi, because he moves by believing to gossips.
Palpating could have used this n much more to paint the Jedi councils as war criminals turning even the youngest to his side if order 66 had taken out only the masters n knights off world as Anakin n the 501st stormed the temple palpatie could have had say a hundred younglings he could have trained to be inquisitors assassins royal guards acolytes to transfer his essesns at least it be better than sum how he came bk Hhaha
chopper.
Jedi
is anakin involved
Yea no all the people who said the Jedi were fucked by the time of the clone wars were 100% right. The council members were all too stupid and stuck up or too complacent. No wonder they got screwed over by sidious’ plot.
chopper
the jedi? maybe not
anakin?.....yes...definetly yes...
The jedi order is bad, George lucas said that
@@datcheesecakeboi6745 as far as fanatical cultists go, they're pretty good
Happy to let everyone be, don't want to interfere or make everyone like them, aren't a suicide cult
Their only major beef is with the psychotic, power hungry, despotic, cruel and outright evil version of themselves
They're pretty good in contrast
Both are wrong. It's I who is the war criminal and not them
Pff who cares they look cool.. OH SHIT
They lost the war, so yes
To be fair most of the torture was Anakin
me
Jedi? Or just anakin
Anakin is a jedi, and the jedi were corrupt before anakin
Chopper