It says right in the description that he did it in the stye of Gichin Funakoshi. Meaning this is an older version of the Kata, presumably one where the differences with the older Okinawan styles were fewer. Hence the higher positions and "mistakes". Karate begins and ends with respect. Seems you forgot that too.
A mi me parece que este Kata esta bien efectuado el Sensei que interpreta , acciona este Katá lo hace con total voluntad , y tratando en todo momento de hacer denotar con detalles cada golpe , no es que casi se cae , ni que no tenga los movimientos necesarios , poco importa eso, lo que interesa es como transmite aqui el grito Kiai lo dice mucho , ...para mi lo ha efectuado bien !
This video series demonstrating various KATA are very well done. Performed in slow motion, it enables the learner to see the techniques being executed clearly. He can even stand up and practise along with the sensei. It also shows the performer at the best angles where you can see his movements. If it had been a frontal shot all the way, viewers would not be able to see how the techinque is being performed if his back is facing the camera right. I think --- and this is only what I think --- some people prefer a human-like KIAI. They might find the one here and in the other videos to be too scary. Sure scares the hell out of children, as it sounds like one coming from a monster in a horror movie. Lol! Having said that, I kinda like it...serious. I like it. Lol! Show less
Shotokan is long in stance. That back stance is terrible! No hip adjustment on the blocks in the first segment.Hand position at the yoko geri is wrong,yama tsuki is way off. This is mcdojo karate not jka. Bassai dai means stroming the fortress,it is a strong kata and one you would have to take for shodan. For this effort i wouldnt award a 2nd kyu. My only positive is the format in which the video is presented. Good clear angles,proper slow motion and clear recording.
You are speaking about standard shotokan (the current one), it seems he is doing the original Funakoshi style was not with so low stances as right now, bevertheless I think this can be improved but we have to understand that this is a little different kind of shotokan.
Hell, I'm a 3kyu and my Bassai Dai is better than that (I have a great sensei who is very strict). I've been 3kyu for almost 2 years and I'm still not happy with my Bassai Dai.
That's what I felt also. I was thinking Shodan. Perhaps it's the slow motion that makes it appear that way. Though several of the moves do not look correct to me as to the direction of the forces and movements.
If you were taught this kata your instructor/ Sensei did you an injustice as this kata was intended for Dan level skill set and Brown belt senior level students. Modern day Martial arts centers, programs, Dojo’s and any other training platforms that are advancing training for in most cases to students that ill equipped with the mental skill set and certainly the physical tools to sustain the full application using Bunkai with the Kata’s. A house built on a weak foundation does not endure the elements, a house built on a strong foundation can last forever. Which foundation was your kata built on as a Kyu level Karate-Ka?
The intention of demonstrating the kata in slow motion is very good. However, the person performing the kata does not have stability at the bases and hip mobility. It presents continuous muscle contraction, without relaxation. THE very bad Kata execution. An example of how not to do it.
This is very poor. Although in slow-motion, each individual movement should reflect its function. The elements of power and evasion in this kata have been completely missed.
@@imho2278 I know nothing of Tai Chi except from observation, but, as in karate, their stance is strong, weight is dropped. This man is the opposite. This is not good karate under anyone's style, and he says he is 5th Dan!
Girls have brilliant hip flicks and can do wonderful low stances. Have respect for your genetic abilities and do not disrespect an entire gender. Now, go and train.
Excuse me? Before you judge, do you even practice karate? Are you even a black belt or just bossing around? And for your kind information, Read the description. He's doing it in another style so please next time either you comment sense or you comment nothing at all. Oss!
Totally correct. Everything is wrong. Stances are high and short. Sometimes there is hanmi where the hips should be square and sometimes square where it should be hanmi. Shuto uke is in terrible position. Turns his head to look after executing the technique. And he says he's fifth dan.
This Bassai Dai is awful! No Offense, His backstances aren't good, his kibadauch is terrible when he is doing the punches why did he do it this way? my Sensei and Shihan Taught me to have wide and stronge stances, none of that
Es la primera vez que veo un sensei 5 dan, joven, fallar tanto en una sola Kata! La anuncia fuera de orden (posiciones y saludo) en 1:26 pensaba que se caía... base corta, pies desaliñados cadera dura, movimientos cortos de brazo, y desplazamiento a zapatazos...un desastre.
You can not compare educational videos with competition videos. We all see mistakes in others but never in ourselves. Basically, it depends on who you are taught by, and what style. I would like to see a video with you performing Bassai dai, will you upload one?
@ bastrac 77 "This Bassai Dai is horrible. Who is this joker?" Can you tell me why you think this Bassai Dai is horrible? I assume you meant to say the Sensei did it horribly. Care to point out which moves were done wrong?
It says right in the description that he did it in the stye of Gichin Funakoshi. Meaning this is an older version of the Kata, presumably one where the differences with the older Okinawan styles were fewer. Hence the higher positions and "mistakes".
Karate begins and ends with respect. Seems you forgot that too.
Exactly my dude.
Agreed, Lestat
When you see "JKA" in the name, you expect it.
@Real Aiglon will you look at that? The "expert" has no videos of himself showing us whate good karate is! Well well well
Mais o kibadachi dele em 2:45 ta visivelmente fora do padrão tanto do shotkan quanto do shidorikan ou okinawa
One of my favorite Kata's when I practice Shotokan 45 years ago.
What is your age now
🔥🔥
This is simplified from the bushido version but very useful for understanding the basic application. Thank you.
It's not an application but ok
Thank you im doing karate and this helped a lot
Hello i am jska style player
Everyone complaining he's doing it wrong. I though so too, but then I read the description. He's doing it in a different than usual style.
Even in the kekomi where he brings his fists up to his chest? That's a waste of energy. The fists should come up to the belt.
It's nice video thanks you
Yes this video is very useful
Bro., THANK UUUUUUUUU
ITS SOOOOGELPFULL
Teaching my virtual students Bassai dai right now. Might use this great video to show them. Your channel inspired me to start my own. Thanks!
Thank you for a great Kata and learning reference.
I can't believe how many people think that this is good karate. It just shows you how many McDojos there must be out there.
Oh please tell us more about your traditional and original karate style. Oh creator of all fights master of all moves and katas
Thank you sir
Thank you
Im guessing you can only use this for remembering the moves. This isn't a really good example for anything else
I’m literally using it for memory lane purposes lol
How dare u
Thank you for uploading this! It is really good for my practice.
ONE WORD FABOOUS
Yes it is very useful thank you Oss
Thanks you
Arigatou🙏
Thak you
1:11 killed me.
Sensei makasih 😊😊😊❤❤
At 1:11 at the kiai, his hands aren't in the correct place.
Yes there is punch
A mi me parece que este Kata esta bien efectuado el Sensei que interpreta , acciona este Katá lo hace con total voluntad , y tratando en todo momento de hacer denotar con detalles cada golpe , no es que casi se cae , ni que no tenga los movimientos necesarios , poco importa eso, lo que interesa es como transmite aqui el grito Kiai lo dice mucho , ...para mi lo ha efectuado bien !
Tal vez lo haga lentamente con la finalidad de que se denoten detalladamente bien los movimientos del Kata
plz show gion kata i have learnd bassi
Tnx i do karata
This video series demonstrating various KATA are very well done. Performed in slow motion, it enables the learner to see the techniques being executed clearly.
He can even stand up and practise along with the sensei.
It also shows the performer at the best angles where you can see his movements. If it had been a frontal shot all the way, viewers would not be able to see how the techinque is being performed if his back is facing the camera right.
I think --- and this is only what I think --- some people prefer a human-like KIAI. They might find the one here and in the other videos to be too scary. Sure scares the hell out of children, as it sounds like one coming from a monster in a horror movie. Lol!
Having said that, I kinda like it...serious. I like it. Lol!
Show less
Shotokan is long in stance. That back stance is terrible! No hip adjustment on the blocks in the first segment.Hand position at the yoko geri is wrong,yama tsuki is way off. This is mcdojo karate not jka. Bassai dai means stroming the fortress,it is a strong kata and one you would have to take for shodan. For this effort i wouldnt award a 2nd kyu. My only positive is the format in which the video is presented. Good clear angles,proper slow motion and clear recording.
I totally agree with you!
Yeah I was like what the hell is this.
You are speaking about standard shotokan (the current one), it seems he is doing the original Funakoshi style was not with so low stances as right now, bevertheless I think this can be improved but we have to understand that this is a little different kind of shotokan.
1:11
hahahahahha
Yo tengo que dar mi examen para el 2 marrón y no lo sabía gracias
Osu thank you
Se supone que es Shotokan, no?
Las posiciones deberían ser mas largas. Sin contar que algunas técnicas están descordinadas.
I am learing karate in 6 years now I am brown 2nd bassa dai is my kata
I'm geeeezed bruh , this is so fraking bad....
lol you speak like you are even in karate bruh you dont even know
This guy must have just passed his shodan
Hell, I'm a 3kyu and my Bassai Dai is better than that (I have a great sensei who is very strict). I've been 3kyu for almost 2 years and I'm still not happy with my Bassai Dai.
Yep.
Basai dai first part: 🙂
Basai dai second part: ☠️
is this guy even a real black belt
It’s just for learning the moves Cant anyone realize that.
Good
🔥🔥🔥
Nice video Please upload video on seienchin kata
Is it black belt kata ?
There is some glitch in the video. Some part of kata does not shown in beginning
Nice
Very good
OSS!
Thanks sir
In sec 2:03 u have done a mistake sir u should stand slowly right
But u have it very fast
Great video as a reference but am a bit surprised at his technique for a 5th Dan
That's what I felt also. I was thinking Shodan. Perhaps it's the slow motion that makes it appear that way. Though several of the moves do not look correct to me as to the direction of the forces and movements.
@Real Aiglon lol :-)
I feel like I used to do this kata as a blue belt in shotokan 🧐 is it a black belt kata or na?
If you were taught this kata your instructor/ Sensei did you an injustice as this kata was intended for Dan level skill set and Brown belt senior level students. Modern day Martial arts centers, programs, Dojo’s and any other training platforms that are advancing training for in most cases to students that ill equipped with the mental skill set and certainly the physical tools to sustain the full application using Bunkai with the Kata’s. A house built on a weak foundation does not endure the elements, a house built on a strong foundation can last forever. Which foundation was your kata built on as a Kyu level Karate-Ka?
Bruh it is a brown 3 katta
Errou o kata senpai
haha sound so funny
Ottimo esempio di cosa non bisogna fare in un kata
Can you fix your stance before make the video
47 aur 48 sec pe jo stance Liya hai...vo knee jaada bend hoga ya kum??
the techniques are good but the stances aee small
Flipante...
OVE BEEN DOING IT FOR 3 YEARS
You are just beginning, grasshopper.
How the actual fuck did he get 5th degree in karate?
Kankudai
:v Ey pero vea que ese es el problema de estudiar por internet. Yo entrene esa wea pa que alfinal digan que esta mala >:c
and another thing of the original kata bassai dai was four minutes, and he made it slow in two minutes. By what logic?
It's not just slow it is turtle
What the you mine this wrong Fazzo
1:13,🤣🤣🤣
👍👍👍
The intention of demonstrating the kata in slow motion is very good. However, the person performing the kata does not have stability at the bases and hip mobility. It presents continuous muscle contraction, without relaxation. THE
very bad Kata execution. An example of how not to do it.
Yes, you can see he is not quite finishing the moves strongly.
Godan?
Filmnya jelek
@@devirina1376 Heh Klo Gk Ngerti Jan Nonton!🗿
This is very poor. Although in slow-motion, each individual movement should reflect its function. The elements of power and evasion in this kata have been completely missed.
It might be a kind of tai chi if done even slower...
@@imho2278 I know nothing of Tai Chi except from observation, but, as in karate, their stance is strong, weight is dropped. This man is the opposite. This is not good karate under anyone's style, and he says he is 5th Dan!
too many changes of camera angle.
He did it like a girl. I mean he do it without power
What do you mean do you discouraging girls
@@m.s7519 no beacause i am a girl
Girls have brilliant hip flicks and can do wonderful low stances. Have respect for your genetic abilities and do not disrespect an entire gender. Now, go and train.
Apparently he’s even 5th dan.... bruh who’s evaluating you because you’re stances are horrible
Excuse me? Before you judge, do you even practice karate? Are you even a black belt or just bossing around? And for your kind information, Read the description. He's doing it in another style so please next time either you comment sense or you comment nothing at all. Oss!
Hasan Solim if he’s 5th dan he should know to sharp technique regardless of older style, all karate styles have sharp powerful techniques
Henrick Boot Kanazawa among numerous others are very legitimate shotokan practitioners, it’s less about belt and more and intensity of training
mauvaises postures
Esta mal porque primero dijo la kata después el saludo pero es primero el saludo luego la kata yo estoy en un curso de karate por eso les digo
Medio pelo
Most of it is horrible. The stance is small, the punches and blocks are weak, and just most of it is horrible!
Sloppy stances, techniques are sluggish, there is no power in anything he does , good to learn the general moves but bad for much else
Totally correct. Everything is wrong. Stances are high and short. Sometimes there is hanmi where the hips should be square and sometimes square where it should be hanmi. Shuto uke is in terrible position. Turns his head to look after executing the technique. And he says he's fifth dan.
Shuto oke mala posición
Yes.
NO GOOD!5DAN
This Bassai Dai is awful! No Offense, His backstances aren't good, his kibadauch is terrible when he is doing the punches why did he do it this way? my Sensei and Shihan Taught me to have wide and stronge stances, none of that
Fake news
Es la primera vez que veo un sensei 5 dan, joven, fallar tanto en una sola Kata! La anuncia fuera de orden (posiciones y saludo)
en 1:26 pensaba que se caía... base corta, pies desaliñados cadera dura, movimientos cortos de brazo, y desplazamiento a zapatazos...un desastre.
No es por criticar ni nada pero tiene una pesime posicion y tecnica ;(
Yo iba a decir lo mismo...
This Bassai Dai is horrible. Who is this joker?
You can not compare educational videos with competition videos.
We all see mistakes in others but never in ourselves.
Basically, it depends on who you are taught by, and what style.
I would like to see a video with you performing Bassai dai, will you upload one?
Where in the base??? Orribile
blablabla, to teach something you have to do it well.
@ bastrac 77
"This Bassai Dai is horrible. Who is this joker?"
Can you tell me why you think this Bassai Dai is horrible? I assume you meant to say the Sensei did it horribly. Care to point out which moves were done wrong?
to complain about something you must do better
Zenkutsu dachi looks to high😳
AHHHHH
У меня только 8 кью😦😦😦😥
Que horrible :v
Ok
Ужас!!!!
Ok :) And you must see this moment: 1:13
1:13 😂😂😂😂
Lmao he’s black belt yet his bassai dai is all wrong
Bassai *Dai*
Ryan TRB yup thx, it’s because of autocorrect
OMG Im sorry but that was terrible.
It’s for the movements, obviously a black belt isn’t that bad.
Oussss
Kiai
Fuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu
Madar chote
This is ok but not ok for imma karate
WTF ???!!!!!
Wrong kata not
Boookkk