The Controversial $10 D2 Knife They Shouldn’t Have Made

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 13 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1 тис.

  • @OUTDOORS55
    @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +30

    The Real Knives in this video⬇😉Sorry I had to include the last best one🤷‍♂
    amzn.to/417uRkh
    amzn.to/498AMaQ
    amzn.to/41bTXyN
    Affiliate links
    As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases.

    • @QH96
      @QH96 Місяць тому +1

      Can you make a video on the difference between black ceramic and white ceramic blades, apparently black ceramic goes through a extra processing step that makes it extra strong.
      A black (HIP) blade is made out of black zirconium oxide and offers extra durability. This type of blade goes through an extra firing process called a "hot-isostatic press," creating a tighter weave between the ceramic molecules, thus creating a tougher blade.

    • @jeffallen3382
      @jeffallen3382 Місяць тому +1

      I just realized I have what Walmart calls their "Ozark Trail Tan Flip Opening knife". I paid $10 for this years ago after seeing a video from the channel 8541 Tactical here on UA-cam. It looks like he has pulled the video down as I don't see it anymore. But I can ship this one to you for testing if you want?
      It has been opened from the package but I don't believe I have ever sharpened it and I've only used it for opening the tape of delivery boxes. Which hasn't been many...
      Funny thing is I just started carrying it the other day but the sharp edges and bulk of it make it uncomfortable for pocket carry. Just last night I was thinking about taking a file and softening the edges to make it more comfortable but I haven't done this yet.
      You're more than welcome to try it out?

    • @jeffallen3382
      @jeffallen3382 Місяць тому

      *carrying it again. That is...

    • @Haps_q
      @Haps_q Місяць тому

      IDK if its just me but all the affiliate links are messed up...
      EDIT: Oh, the crowbar, Its a joke?

    • @eightfooter88
      @eightfooter88 Місяць тому

      @@OUTDOORS55 - just bought one because of this video! Can’t wait to see how it outperforms the Walmart knife!!

  • @seth30v
    @seth30v Місяць тому +211

    Without even touching on the topic at hand here I just have to say WOW your videos have gotten so good! The sound design, the pacing, the macro shots, the visual humor, the storytelling... been watching for years now and I really admire how you've pushed yourself to improve over time. Respect.

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +27

      Thanks my friend 🙏👊

    • @johanneswerner1140
      @johanneswerner1140 Місяць тому +4

      I'll totally second that!
      Glad you are back, glad you are producing videos of that quality. It always makes me more motivated to touch up a bunch of our kitchen knives
      I sharpen mostly chisels and plane irons, idea and goal are the same, technique is very different 😁 (so I suck at knife sharpening, but I'm slowly improving, thanks to the videos)

  • @sleepyheadz
    @sleepyheadz Місяць тому +257

    Ozark hit a marketing homerun with this knife. Heat treat the first couple batches properly, and once the positive reviews have flooding the market, they can sell you 5CRs and nobody would believe it isn't D2.

    • @blueovalfan23
      @blueovalfan23 Місяць тому +18

      idk.. anyone that has ever sharpened a d2 blade might. not many know how to sharpen them without a guided fool proof method anymore. my experience with d2 has been it's a nightmare to sharpen. i've tried normal stones and even a a belt sander, work sharp. neither seemed to phase it. if they have zero experience with good d2, they'll be fooled for sure, no doubt. then people will think all d2 is trash metal. truth is, it's pretty decent. best edge retention for the money imo.

    • @TheBergersven
      @TheBergersven Місяць тому +28

      Ozark is a brand owned by Walmart. They may even order the knives from multiple asian manufacturers.

    • @fredEVOIX
      @fredEVOIX Місяць тому +16

      not a knife guy I guess youtube recommended this as I hike but I can tell you this is true for almost everything electronic TV, computer parts monitors gaming consoles they all do that, this is why for example on tvs they have super vague descriptions for example brightness UP TO 10'000 or whatever it's to allow them to downgrade down the line once the reviews are out it's especially bad for computer monitors as sometimes they source the sceen panel from a completely other manufacturer which means you're buying a completely different product, I also worked with a PCB designer (computer motherboard, smarthphone etc..) and he had engineering classes on how to design the best possible product and then lower the quality of individual components so the product lasts just enough for the warranty, they actually teach that >< this is why modern cars are so bad because they calculated their life expectancy wrong

    • @philmachen6508
      @philmachen6508 Місяць тому +8

      I've had one since day 1 and bought several more for history's sake. The one I use has been a good knife for universal use. I guess I got a good batch. Not having one would make me an unfulfilled collector, and having a couple more still in the wrapper is even better. Funny part is I gave one to my Grandson and have a carry one, 2 brand new ones and all 4 were paid for by selling a few others above list to VERY eager buyers.

    • @tacticalcenter8658
      @tacticalcenter8658 Місяць тому +3

      What review stated the heat treatment was good?

  • @Sweetknives
    @Sweetknives Місяць тому +208

    I got another brand new one in package, I’ll send it to you just so you can make a follow up video. Free of course. Love your channel, keep up the great work!

    • @quickdrawz05
      @quickdrawz05 Місяць тому +17

      Do this!!!! Please!!!! The collab we need!

    • @osahinmartinez3371
      @osahinmartinez3371 Місяць тому +6

      He keeps deleting my comment with the link to a video of a guy cutting cardboard for 4 plus hours non stop

    • @Tig3rj
      @Tig3rj Місяць тому +14

      ​@@osahinmartinez3371 It's not him.. It's YT bot doing it as they don't allow links in comments.

    • @quickdrawz05
      @quickdrawz05 Місяць тому +4

      @ that guys gonna do an updated test this Saturday. Even then, it doesn’t rule out the findings that Outdoors55 found on his blade. Having differing results may be an indication of inconsistent quality of product

    • @burnburn645
      @burnburn645 Місяць тому

      @@osahinmartinez3371 welcome to youtube/other online social platforms. >_> you clearly didnt grow up in the LEMONPARTY era xD lol

  • @F1083
    @F1083 Місяць тому +368

    The great thing about knife steel claims is that so few people have access to an Optical Emission Spectrometer so claims can almost never be looked into.

    • @BryonLee
      @BryonLee Місяць тому +10

      @@F1083 same thing with the answers on your search engine about Mount Everest. Is being able to sniff BS; for example I would believe this man over anybody's wife.

    • @richardcranium5393
      @richardcranium5393 Місяць тому

      Test for d2 with vinegar you douche

    • @cinemoriahFPV
      @cinemoriahFPV Місяць тому +2

      It's not fake D2

    • @DarthCiliatus
      @DarthCiliatus Місяць тому +14

      @@cinemoriahFPV Probably just D2 with a shitty heat treat

    • @ashkurdin
      @ashkurdin Місяць тому +7

      D2 can be wrong in a particular case, but with the cheap steels like this you want rough “microserrated” apex basically turning it into a micro-scale saw. It won’t hold the apex with the “mirror finish”. Just a different league, different tool, different approach to do things.

  • @NeevesKnives
    @NeevesKnives Місяць тому +41

    What a great video, you put a ton of effort into these videos much appreciated

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +6

      Thank Jerad! Thanks for your contribution 🙏👍

  • @russbowman6801
    @russbowman6801 Місяць тому +32

    As a retired tool maker, I used D2 for stamping dies. Proper hardening and draw back is critical. The more drawn back after hardening the less hard and brittle it becomes, so tempering is a choice between these two choices. Identical tool steels with different tempers makes all the difference.

    • @pauljones639
      @pauljones639 Місяць тому

      Ill add, not all D2 steel is the same. Its quality can vary wildly depending on who made it
      51crv4 would be a much better knife steel for the same price

    • @privateassman8839
      @privateassman8839 Місяць тому

      ​​@@pauljones639 what makes you recommend 51crv4?

  • @BluetoothBlades
    @BluetoothBlades Місяць тому +27

    This is why i LOVE your videos...the creative imagination you bring to the big screen is LEGENDARY 😂

  • @vano__
    @vano__ Місяць тому +26

    I truly love how you are able to make these videos entertaining, the creativity is blooming, really shows you are passionate about this stuff. Great video, love it!

  • @jimboneutron8399
    @jimboneutron8399 Місяць тому +25

    You should do edge testing on ceiling tiles and the tests will be much quicker. A standard utility blade only makes about 5 cuts before its so dull that it just rips the tile. So only 10 cuts per blade. They will absolutely kill a pocket knife real quick. Probably more challenging for the blade and will make the test less time consuming

    • @garethbaus5471
      @garethbaus5471 Місяць тому

      It also makes it harder to distinguish quality.

  • @pelewads
    @pelewads Місяць тому +16

    I must have gotten lucky. I bought one of the first ones out. And have really enjoyed it. I strapped it after every use. Just like I do with all of my knives. And it's been doing just fine

    • @carlh7795
      @carlh7795 Місяць тому +2

      I bought 10 right at first. Been using most of them. They're doing well. Not 20cv Kershaw good (one of my other common carried knives), but what I expect from d2

  • @clandestinetactical
    @clandestinetactical Місяць тому +34

    Lmfao the “burnt edge” subliminal message voice 😂😂😂

  • @GalvestonCountyMike
    @GalvestonCountyMike Місяць тому +6

    Several months ago, I bought four of the $9.97 orange Ozark Trail knives. Once I treated it with Japanese camellia oil, the action became wonderfully smooth. On the days I don't carry my Buck 110 from 1999, my orange 'Walmart' knife is with me. Love your videos! Semper Fi from Texas! (Old Marine 0311)

    • @bigdm9349
      @bigdm9349 Місяць тому

      Buck 110 let's go.

    • @mc4906
      @mc4906 11 днів тому

      Is the Japanese camellia oil used on the knife action, the blade, or both?

  • @AlbertFrederickLarun
    @AlbertFrederickLarun Місяць тому +5

    I think the steel on the Ozark Trail knife is D1.95. The marketing and legal teams of Ozark Trail got together and rounded it up to D2, slapped the price on it, and let it rip in the Empire of Cheap (USA). This is a good lesson in value versus price of goods. Nice work!

  • @tricky48
    @tricky48 Місяць тому +3

    I call you out to folks whenever I am in a sub or a thread where someone mentions wanting to learn knife sharpening, but I deliberately leave the rest of your content as a nice reward for them to discover, and don't allude to it at all... your quality just keeps upping, brother, keep it up!

  • @Camelotsmoon
    @Camelotsmoon Місяць тому +11

    Mine was pretty good, I bought it in the first batch when it first hit. Mine only dulled to a working edge because I tried to cut a fiberglass pole with it lol.. it's still worked great for hacking down small branches and cutting a few things here or there... Possible the next batch had some issues, not sure.

  • @Mo.89.
    @Mo.89. Місяць тому +11

    Great video. They’re not making this knife for us though.. my Dad carried a dull Chinese made ripoff of a Buck 110 for years at work and loved it. It still split tape and tore cardboard which was “cutting” to him. To someone like Dad, this would’ve been a great deal and I think that’s who they ultimately made this for. People who’ve never had a good, sharp knife. The curious thing is branding it as D2 and not “aviation grade stainless” or something ridiculous. Naming D2 as the material really seems like an attempt to attract knife guys and it certainly worked.
    But again, great video and very interesting. I’d love someone to be able to test the steel to see what it’s made of, it can’t be D2 surely.

  • @jdrew500
    @jdrew500 Місяць тому +17

    I've bought several knives off Amazon, none of them very expensive. I am an old fart cake eater that never spent a minute in the woods for work. I like knives. I buy knives because of a specific feature on that particular knife. I've learned how to sharpen them to a hair shaving tolerance but nothing more. My last knife purchase was the DAOFENG EDC Black Lightweight Folding Pocket Knife. As I said cake eater. I bought this knife as an EDC. It came razor sharp and stayed that way for most of the cake eating things I needed AND it weighed 1.4 oz!!! An old man with 4-6 oz of steel in his pants is going to be picking his pants up off the floor multiple times a day. So specific knives for specific purposes. Works for me.

    • @GoodmaneYT
      @GoodmaneYT Місяць тому

      Stop eating old fart cakes. Get yourself some fresh fart cakes.

  • @glockgaston2922
    @glockgaston2922 19 днів тому

    Alex really good video thanks for all the time and energy you put into making them it’s really appreciated

  • @DaroffApFire
    @DaroffApFire Місяць тому +47

    I'd like to see you disassemble this knife and re-heat treat and re-temper it according to D2 steel specs and then try again to see if that changes anything.

    • @very5ick112
      @very5ick112 Місяць тому +4

      cannot do that because it is sharpened

    • @ighmur
      @ighmur Місяць тому +4

      @@very5ick112 no it is because the handle is orange

    • @very5ick112
      @very5ick112 Місяць тому

      @@ighmur handle does not matter

    • @ighmur
      @ighmur Місяць тому +1

      @@very5ick112 even though it's made of matter.

  • @echos-myron
    @echos-myron Місяць тому

    Your shop tools and gear are wild; watching your videos for several years now and seeing the progression and dedication is inspiring stuff. Your content was always great; the quality has only gotten better.

  • @OMGBEES
    @OMGBEES Місяць тому +6

    Incredible video, i subscribed before it was even over. Also one of the best ads i have ever seen, I hope Vosteed sends you a really nice Christmas present.

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +2

      Thanks for the sub, Appreciate it!

  • @leonardomatheus1888
    @leonardomatheus1888 Місяць тому +26

    If you want a good, cheap d2 steel knife, you should buy the ganzo ones.
    They are real d2 with good heat treatment and costs around 25$

    • @tacticalcenter8658
      @tacticalcenter8658 Місяць тому

      They are not a good heat treatment. Benchmade at 58rc outcuts ganxo d2 at 62rc.

    • @Magneticitist
      @Magneticitist Місяць тому +3

      I think most people would be surprised if all they did was blind tests with blades. They may only notice a real difference when trying to put an edge on the blade again.

    • @flowerpt
      @flowerpt Місяць тому +9

      ​@@tacticalcenter8658
      The $250 Benchmade is better than the $25 knife?

    • @SpiritualWarfare337
      @SpiritualWarfare337 Місяць тому +1

      Or an opinel

    • @chris-zt7eo
      @chris-zt7eo Місяць тому

      I like the OKC Rat 2 in D2 better

  • @krispytoo12
    @krispytoo12 Місяць тому +3

    Nice camera work and editing. This was a pleasure to watch.

  • @bankuei
    @bankuei Місяць тому +17

    Usually when friends ask me for a recommendation of a budget blade, I point them to Spyderco's Byrd knives. $25-30, super slicey, and they hold up. Yeah, it's a backlock and you don't get the fun fidget factor, but... if you're talking a budget knife that works, you don't need the extras.

    • @odie2763
      @odie2763 Місяць тому +3

      A knife is a knife. it's just supposed to cut things.

    • @chrimony
      @chrimony Місяць тому +2

      I dunno, I really want a budget knife that works and is cool to flick open and close with one hand.

    • @chemistryofquestionablequa6252
      @chemistryofquestionablequa6252 Місяць тому

      I have a Byrd and one of the Ozark Trail D2 knives. Maybe I just got lucky but the Ozark Trail one is great. I carry it when I want something a little lighter and more discreet than the Byrd.

    • @jamesruth100
      @jamesruth100 Місяць тому +6

      @@chrimony That's gonna depend on how budget you want your budget knife to be. CJRB's Pyrite Light is 29 bucks and is arguably the best EDC knife at that price point that also has a high fidget factor. Button lock + thumb studs, AR-RPM9 steel (stainless, pretty decent qualities), 3.34 inch long wharncliffe blade, and it weighs 2.75 ounces; it's going to be hard to beat, even if you stack it up against some more expensive knives.
      If you're fine sacrificing a little fidget factor, Civivi's Mini Praxis is also pretty good and is basically the same price. Liner lock + flipper tab (no thumb studs), D2 steel (not stainless, but will probably hold its edge longer than AR-RPM9), 2.98 inch long drop point blade, and it weighs 2.77 ounces; it flicks open nicely and liner locks can be disengaged with one hand, but liner locks aren't as finger safe and limit how smoothly it closes (since you have to move your thumb out of the way).
      Obviously, your options increase the more money you put into them, but that's also blurring the lines of what "budget knife" means. Personally, I'd call any knife below 50 bucks budget, but I know other people who would put a hard cutoff at like 20-25; it's all relative to what you expect to get out of it.

    • @chrimony
      @chrimony Місяць тому +1

      @@jamesruth100 Thanks for your informative comment. Maybe I'll scratch that itch for Xmas.

  • @knivesiguess
    @knivesiguess Місяць тому +84

    So this is WEIRD. I did my edge retention testing on 3 of them. The first one on the factory edge took 7 hours of cutting cardboard to reach total devastation. It wasn't tearing and rolling the cardboard until the end of that run. Putting a new 18° per side if I remember right pushed it out to 8 hours. The second factory edge took 6 hours. On a 15° per side edge it took a bit over 4 hours. The reviews and results of these things have been all over the place. The live streams where I did the testing are all up, there are receipts. We DID count about 30 minutes worth of cuts at about 900 cuts averaged to 6 inches. I DO go to absolute devastation where it hits 550+ on the edge tester.

    • @leyline77
      @leyline77 Місяць тому +9

      I was there I watched him do it! (on stream) You were on stream begging for the insanity to end!

    • @TacticalLlamaEDC
      @TacticalLlamaEDC Місяць тому +30

      Took a brief look at the stream and realized its cutting along the grain of single wall cardboard which is the equivalent of cutting 2mm thick paper. Not impressed and not a point of data in my opinion. One cannot compare results unless equal tests are performed. Try cutting against the grain of single or double wall cardboard with the ozark trail and then report back please.

    • @knivesiguess
      @knivesiguess Місяць тому +10

      I'll take a look at that, actually

    • @knivesiguess
      @knivesiguess Місяць тому +14

      One unanswered question though is how it went double the normal time of all of my other D2 knives making the same cuts. Just weird.

    • @TacticalLlamaEDC
      @TacticalLlamaEDC Місяць тому +16

      @@knivesiguesslet me rephrase my initial statement and I apologize for how it sounded.
      I checked out your stream and really liked the style and setup! I was enjoying the cutting, the table, the lights, and the content. Once I broke the enjoyable hypnosis I focused on the test itself. I would be interested to see a cut test where you go “against the grain” of the cardboard rather than alone. Not saying what you did is invalid. Just looking to compare similar data points.

  • @GrimmDesires
    @GrimmDesires Місяць тому +2

    I got an old Sheffield $5 knife from walmart YEARS ago. I still have that thing and it's still in great shape. I use it all the time. I've used this thing as a hammer before cause it was $5 and it has an all metal body and such. Still works great, has never come lose or anything. 5 bucks can't beat it. Though I do love my more expensive knives too.

  • @MikePuorro
    @MikePuorro Місяць тому +7

    Not a folding knife guy, but I have an ozark trail fixed blade that i carried temporarily after losing a good knife, and as far as being there when I needed it for daily use, it does everything a good knife can do but hold an edge.
    Any knife is a good enough knife if you sharpen it every day.

    • @MsDestroyer900
      @MsDestroyer900 Місяць тому

      I don't agree with your last statement. Even with my generic 1 dollar kitchen knife retains its shaving edge for at least 3 weeks. A knife that has to be sharpened everyday sounds like it's a terrible knife

    • @MikePuorro
      @MikePuorro Місяць тому

      @@MsDestroyer900 It is terrible, all I'm saying is that if you sharpen it after every use, it can still do the usual job of a good carry knife.
      (I found my CRKT!!!)

    • @OldBadger1
      @OldBadger1 Місяць тому +1

      That is how I was trained. Spend 5 minutes sharpening before work. Every Day.

  • @larshoneytoast722
    @larshoneytoast722 Місяць тому +2

    Dude your videos just keep getting better and better lol this was fantastic

  • @andrewszot3094
    @andrewszot3094 Місяць тому +7

    Glad you made this. Walmart has been sold out and I was feeling left out.

    • @notademonrat
      @notademonrat Місяць тому

      you were left out this dudes an idiot everyone else that reviewed it was in love with it.

    • @matthewshannon6946
      @matthewshannon6946 Місяць тому +1

      I ordered 2 off the website today...first time I've seen them available and I've been looking...

  • @MsDestroyer900
    @MsDestroyer900 Місяць тому

    Your videos keep improving. Some of your previous videos had some weird pacing issues here and there but thats almost completely gone at this point. I really love fhis channel good job!

  • @Hydrazine1000
    @Hydrazine1000 Місяць тому +7

    If you want to follow up on this: See if there is a company nearby that can do spark discharge spectroscopy. D2 is supposed to have 11 to 13 wt% (percentage by weight) chromium, 1.4-1.6 wt% carbon, 0.7-1.2 wt% molybdenum and 0,5-1,1 wt% vanadium. (And a little bit of manganese and silicon as well)
    Any decent lab with spark OES will be able to quickly tell if the blade is D2 or not.

    • @tacticalcenter8658
      @tacticalcenter8658 Місяць тому +1

      It's real d2. Import d2 is poorly heat treated across the board.

    • @Hydrazine1000
      @Hydrazine1000 Місяць тому +6

      @tacticalcenter8658 How can you tell? How do you know for certain?
      I know I can't tell, not by just looking at a video of it.
      But I am a metallurgist and I do know that, say, skimping on the vanadium in that alloy would definitely diminish edge retention.
      All we know is that it hits 60 HRC. If the manufacturer used type 440C instead of D2, it could hit 60 HRC too. But 440C has no vanadium...

    • @user-im6fy4qp6m
      @user-im6fy4qp6m Місяць тому

      @@Hydrazine1000 because its made in china

    • @Hydrazine1000
      @Hydrazine1000 Місяць тому

      @@user-im6fy4qp6m And that is a convincing argument? Tesla and Apple have manufacturing in China. So do Volkswagen, Samsung, Siemens, General Motors, Intel, Dell, Caterpillar, Sony, Toyota, BMW, LG, Bridgestone, HP...
      "Made in China" in and of itself isn't a valid reason to say it's of poor quality.

  • @AereForst
    @AereForst Місяць тому

    I got 4 of these to open delivery boxes. Very happy with the purchase. To chop up cardboard I use a cordless portable reciprocating saw with a Bosch 2330057 Sabre Saw Blade. Works like magic.

  • @fpassow1
    @fpassow1 Місяць тому +27

    It's fair to complain about a $10 knife that performs badly when the same brand offers a dozen models of $6 knives that perform badly. 🙂 (To be honest, I like the cheap Ozark Trail knives. I bought a ton of them back when they were $4.99. They're fun to buy and great to keep in places where you might need a knife for occasional light use.)

    • @wulf67
      @wulf67 Місяць тому +7

      I have the perfect place to keep a knife that I might need for occasional use: It’s called my right front pocket, and there’s only room for one knife in there. People who know how to use and maintain tools seem to always prefer to have the best quality tools they can buy. I would much rather have one good knife than 15 junk knives.

    • @pauledge1621
      @pauledge1621 Місяць тому

      I pick up multi packs when they get marked down around Christmas. If I lose a

    • @eda715
      @eda715 Місяць тому +1

      I travel for work and lose knives all the time. So I only buy cheap below $10 knives. Either I set them down somewhere or TSA gets them or someone borrowed it. They always end up missing. For me they get pretty light use and I don’t mind touching up the edge at the end of the day.

    • @spldrong
      @spldrong Місяць тому

      I bought about 6 of these for $1 each about 10 years ago, I still have an use a few of them

    • @missyoujoel3275
      @missyoujoel3275 Місяць тому +2

      He was trying so hard not cut the paper right lol didn't even show cutting shit either and the paper doesn't mean shit is what the professionals say about high end knive when they shit out at the same tests

  • @daviddrake806
    @daviddrake806 11 днів тому

    Omg you r a sit down comedian! The use of lighting is telling that you definitely have a squeeze for filmmaking beyond most of the documentaries I see on Sunday and even Curiosity

  • @samuraidriver4x4
    @samuraidriver4x4 Місяць тому +14

    I know its not a folder however a €15 Mora Companion out of the box holds up alot better then that thing.
    For €17 there is also a stainless version.

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +9

      I agree a mora os a better buy. However it is a fixed blade, but still a better buy imo🙂

    • @josephkebbekus5780
      @josephkebbekus5780 Місяць тому +3

      @@OUTDOORS55 I've seen plenty of people who bought this as a truck knife and not as an EDC, so a fixed blade would work just as well. I know $10 is cheap enough that it is almost disposable for a lot of knife collectors, but if it's junk it doesn't mean it's a good deal. IMO, if you want to get a beater knife that is so cheap you don't need to worry about what you do with it, a cheap fixed blade or even a utility knife seems like it would be a better choice for the vast majority of use cases.

    • @TheRealGOTdurrrred
      @TheRealGOTdurrrred Місяць тому

      Fixed blades are for men. Folders are for women.

    • @robertmarks2379
      @robertmarks2379 Місяць тому

      @OUTDOORS55 why is there so much hate on mora knives? I've never bought one and had to worry about it or it's edge and I'm hard on knives battening firewood. But I hear a lot of people hate on them

    • @CetomimusGillii
      @CetomimusGillii Місяць тому

      ​@@robertmarks2379My experience suggests that most people hating on well-known value knives do so because they feel a subconscious need to justify the hundreds or thousands they've spent on high-end knives that. Seriously, a lot of these people just can't admit to themselves that they're buying fancy boutique knives because they're cool, and not because they actually need whatever extra performance you can get with them over something like a Mora, Opinel, Victorinox, Buck Bantam, etc.
      I get it. I was in that same camp for a while. I enjoy the very few knives I've bought in the last few years all the more now that I'm not doing mental gymnastics to convince myself it's not just a fun thing to buy

  • @richterknives
    @richterknives Місяць тому +2

    Probably the best video and editing I’ve ever seen you do…and that’s saying something. Awesome job bud

  • @timwagster9458
    @timwagster9458 Місяць тому +2

    So glad you got one to test properly. Now I will not even bother with it. 👍😁
    In the making of this video, it appears that you are feeling better. I sure hope your situation is progressing ti the possitive. Always in my prayers. 🙏❤👍😁

  • @bobclarke5913
    @bobclarke5913 Місяць тому +1

    I bought a couple, don't regret them. I'm not a knife guy, never really thought about the blade steel. "Stainless?" Sounds fine. I love the crossbar lock, never knew that was a thing. So nice and light that I'm carrying a knife regularly for the first time. As a gateway drug this thing is a winner. And now we newbies get to find out what's better so thanks for the learnin' up.

  • @basildraws
    @basildraws Місяць тому +4

    Funny thing is I have a $120 CRKT that performs EXACTLY like that Ozark Trail D2.

  • @andysanford3272
    @andysanford3272 Місяць тому +1

    Love this video. I fully understand the value of quality heat treating and good knife steels. I understand that a good steel can be rendered virtually useless by bad heat treating. I have good quality knives, that I love and use. I also often carry a cheap $6 Ozark Trail knife in my pocket in addition to a decent make and model of knife (I don't have any knives over $70 in my collection), my good knives are roughly $35-$55 knives. I carry an el cheapo to use when I don't want my better knife to get...?
    You are right about this knife, but I am still gonna get one as soon as I can find one, because it looks good and I like to have a trashy knife handy. Call me crazy, but it is also blaze orange, love it!

  • @cuyverswanson5536
    @cuyverswanson5536 Місяць тому +7

    Can you take it apart and heat treat it and see if it is any better?

  • @SageAttacks
    @SageAttacks Місяць тому +1

    I'd be really interested to see you test and review the Harbor Freight Icon D2 Knife! This was really informative.

  • @victorfranca85
    @victorfranca85 Місяць тому +4

    I bought so many mystery Chinese knives while stuck in the hospital, I went over budgets. But I’ll find the diamond in the rough. Mostly fixed blade. I like having a holster sheaf

    • @ClaudeSac
      @ClaudeSac Місяць тому

      sheaf

    • @mikafoxx2717
      @mikafoxx2717 Місяць тому +1

      Good old mora knives.. they just work.

  • @philochristos
    @philochristos 8 днів тому

    I haven't had to cut a lot of cardboard with mine, but so far it's done everything I've asked of it. I was at my local Walmart a couple of days ago, and I saw six of them on the shelf. I didn't buy any because I already have four.

  • @groosbro1
    @groosbro1 Місяць тому +18

    I bought a $20 Camillus folding knife with D2 steel that I use for fishing. After four years of use, cutting fishing line, sometimes steel wire for rigs, I haven't had to sharpen it yet.

    • @Cyber_Kriss
      @Cyber_Kriss Місяць тому +7

      Yeah... but does it cut PAPER ?

    • @groosbro1
      @groosbro1 Місяць тому +2

      @Cyber_Kriss
      Goes through bait like butter...

    • @Nick-te3nv
      @Nick-te3nv Місяць тому +1

      😂

    • @Nick-te3nv
      @Nick-te3nv Місяць тому +7

      You have no idea what a sharp knife feels like then

    • @groosbro1
      @groosbro1 Місяць тому +5

      @Nick-te3nv
      You make assumptions you shouldn't...

  • @freshkidjo
    @freshkidjo Місяць тому

    Love your videos. Debunking myths and showing actual facts. I'm asking if you can reheat treat the knife to prove that it's actually a bad heat treatment

  • @PANTERALEO56
    @PANTERALEO56 Місяць тому +8

    Well look on the bright side ...
    They'll be in stock after this video 😂

  • @letsdothis9063
    @letsdothis9063 Місяць тому

    I bought one of these to replace my other cheap knife that i used for cutting boxes and straps ect... at work. This was several years ago. I still carry it and use it everyday. Mine has been great 👍.

  • @byrdprecision8824
    @byrdprecision8824 Місяць тому +7

    I have personally Rockwell tested mine and I was getting a range between 60-64HRC following ASTM E18, I was shocked. Those hardness measurements were done through out the blade, not just in one spot either.

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +7

      I didn't include this in the video since it would just complicate things but i did get a handful of random 55hrc readings. 🙂

    • @drewrinker2071
      @drewrinker2071 Місяць тому

      I don't have Rockwell tester but I have file set that goes up to 60hrc, and the 60hrc file skated across easily so I know it's definitely above 60

  • @Lumberjacknooj
    @Lumberjacknooj Місяць тому

    After a fun trip to Smokey Mountain Knife Works and buying some pricey knives- my everyday carry is a $10 Smith & Wesson m&p folder I found near the checkout counter.
    If I lose it, my feelings aren’t hurt. Yet it does all I need in an every day carry knife.

  • @pharmis
    @pharmis Місяць тому +3

    Bought a couple when they came out and they have literally been amazing, especially for the price. The knife works for what 80% of knife users need on a daily basis. this is, for sure, more of a light-use knife, but that is okay; most knives are. the knife world has gone insane with prices, so hopefully, this will wake up manufacturers that they are charging way too much!
    People are not buying this to sit on shelf like most knife nerds... they want it because it is a basic tool that is not 50-100$. great for a truck knife or a travel knife, which is the point. comparing it to a 40$ knife makes no sense, it is 4x the price

    • @mrRoverkane
      @mrRoverkane Місяць тому

      Yup. Right on. People get so wrapped up in unnecessary “testing” and fail to realize people just want a beater to every day tasks. Not a spec queen that sits on the shelf and occasionally cuts up cardboard 😂

    • @Temporalplace
      @Temporalplace Місяць тому

      If you are using a knife as a beater meaning to cut a can, romove ails, as a prybar then ofourse its best to use cheapie and thats why its best to have 2 knives ith you one as a praybar and other for actully cutting non metal things.

  • @petersonmountain
    @petersonmountain Місяць тому +2

    You could get a handheld XRF, it would be very useful to determine steel alloy contents. Used ones are ~5k.

  • @BryonLee
    @BryonLee Місяць тому +3

    I would like to give my opinion if I may. I trust this man. I like his style very much who wouldn't. He's giving us a lot of valuable information. I'm very grateful that he does so. I have acquired more skill and knowledge because of him and I pass it on. What I've learned from him has helped me help others or sharpen their knives. I should not say this but last year and part of this year I was fighting a DUI and I won. It took time and I lost my commercial license for a little while, I was homeless and I almost lost everything. One thing that kept me above water, made me welcome in people's homes, put money in my pocket during that hard time was that I was paid to sharpen knives or people would give me food and a place to stay if I sharpened all of their knives. Or they would take me out to lunch at expensive restaurants where I met more of their friends and more people. So the proof about this man is in the results and how he helps us and teaches us. Sometimes in the midst of worry it feels good to have a nice hobby and like I said above I trust this guy, and that's hard to find man.

  • @DanR6793
    @DanR6793 Місяць тому +2

    Mine seemed to do pretty good holding an edge in cardboard. But I actually had a failure of the little plastic "bearing cage" washer, which ended up splitting, and loosening up the action. I did tighten the pivot screw up just enough to take out the little bit of blade play shortly after I got the knife though.

  • @adanma17
    @adanma17 Місяць тому +16

    This is like some Sherlock Holmes level of investigation. Awesome 😊

  • @mrpibb7781
    @mrpibb7781 Місяць тому +2

    Great video as always man. Hope you're doing well. I know awhile back you said you were dealing with some health stuff. Happy Thanksgiving to you and yours. Just a reminder, your ebay Damascus video is still one of the funniest things I've seen on YT 😅

  • @KnivesFAST
    @KnivesFAST Місяць тому +8

    So I've never seen your channel before but if you were sent me this video and this is incredible. I also tried to get one of these because I didn't believe the hype. Was not able to. Glad to see it exposed. Great great video

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +4

      Thanks for stopping by👊

  • @sjSilvain
    @sjSilvain Місяць тому

    You always talk about those different steels, I would love a video of you explaining the difference between all those and the applications. I would also love a video about EDC knives to start with.

  • @robthompson8285
    @robthompson8285 Місяць тому +23

    Watching Alex always makes me feel a little less crazy about my edge obsession 😅

  • @EverydayCityCarry
    @EverydayCityCarry Місяць тому

    This is such a banger video. I rarely watch knife content but this was captivating bro.

  • @hellhound2260
    @hellhound2260 Місяць тому +8

    I've seen people get much better results so most definitely it's just a roll of dice when buying this knife, when they're producing it this cheap there's definitely no room for any QC. I mean maxlvledc got 10 of them and 3 had warped blades lol.

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +12

      I think if you have to buy 3 to get a good one its a $30 knife at that point 😉😂

  • @chronicon5616
    @chronicon5616 Місяць тому

    Thanks for the info! Great video production by the way, you definitely put a lot of effort into this.

  • @SirGalath
    @SirGalath Місяць тому +11

    "If its too good to be true, it most likely is" remains as true as ever

  • @chrisgleason1196
    @chrisgleason1196 Місяць тому

    I laughed so hard at this one. Even the background music is carefully chosen. Thank you for being entertaining and informative. Wasting money avoided!

  • @jeffallen3382
    @jeffallen3382 Місяць тому +5

    Could redoing the heat treat help?

    • @heiner71
      @heiner71 Місяць тому

      Why would anybody do that? Just buy a better, more expensive knife.

    • @jeffallen3382
      @jeffallen3382 Місяць тому +4

      @heiner71 it's a thought experiment dude... 🙄

  • @Killer_Space_2726-GCP
    @Killer_Space_2726-GCP Місяць тому

    Probably one of my favourite knife reviewers and instructors on UA-cam! Very well done video.

  • @blueswan2175
    @blueswan2175 Місяць тому +3

    I've been burned on an Ozark knife about 5years ago best lesson ever,I experienced exactly what you did..

  • @larryhart4880
    @larryhart4880 Місяць тому

    I would like to see you review harbor freights icon with D2 steel. I got one and absolutely love it. It held up really great . Plus it kept it edge superbly.

  • @BestDamnEDC
    @BestDamnEDC Місяць тому +9

    Man, how much did Benchmade pay you to make this video? Clearly the $10 Ozark Trail is the best knife ever made. How dare you be so biased!
    /s

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +9

      Im retiring next month in the Hamptons with the check.
      I don't even own a benchmade😆

    • @BestDamnEDC
      @BestDamnEDC Місяць тому +3

      @@OUTDOORS55 🤣 Thank you for being willing to go a scientific. I appreciate what you do and sheer mind-numbing efforts some of these videos must be.

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +2

      Enjoy your content as well my friend 👍

  • @maxlvledc
    @maxlvledc Місяць тому

    Side note, I have 3 left from the newest batch if you want to test them to see if its a consistency issue or not. This is not something I would spend time on personally. Let me know.

  • @krazmokramer
    @krazmokramer Місяць тому +7

    I bought one the first week they were released. The blade was sharp and decent. The pivot was a POS. And the steel liners were very flexible. The pivot showed wear after a week of limited use (yes, I took it apart and looked at the worn pivot. The blade had side to side play due to that crap pivot, the overly large pivot hole in the blade, and those flexing liners. The only good thing I can say about this knife is that I sold it for 2.5 times what I paid for it! I used that money to buy the Civivi Zizzle for $25 from WM. The Wugout was an okay knife for $10. The Zizzle is just a really good knife!

    • @Doobie603
      @Doobie603 Місяць тому +2

      Scam artist thing to do.

    • @krazmokramer
      @krazmokramer Місяць тому

      @@Doobie603 How so? And who the f*** are you to judge someone you don't even know.

    • @Trustory209
      @Trustory209 27 днів тому

      He’s lying. He has both knives still lol he just likes the civivi more that’s all

  • @dank5015
    @dank5015 10 днів тому +1

    I just played with the axis lock on mine flipping it around for a bit then placed it into a drawer. I've never cut anything with it. I'm probably their ideal buyer.

    • @philochristos
      @philochristos 8 днів тому +1

      It's crazy how well they hold an edge when you don't use them. Sometimes, I'll strop mine unnecessarily and get it ridiculously sharp, and it just STAYS that way. I'll shave some hairs every now and then and strop it some more, and the same thing happens. It's such a reliable knife!

  • @phantom3048
    @phantom3048 Місяць тому +3

    12:14 im actually looking for a ~10$ knife that can kinda handle that type of abuse. Of course I'm not expecting it to stay sharp. I'm fine with resharpening I just want something that can be easily replaced after I abused it too much and it had a catastrophic failure or I lost it or something. Would just be nice if it was at least at the quality level of the 9$ Amazon knife you showed and stayed at that price.

    • @Jake-bt3fc
      @Jake-bt3fc Місяць тому +2

      morakniv or hultafors

  • @steveyoung9951
    @steveyoung9951 Місяць тому

    I love your humor ! Great informational video, Thanks

  • @TranceMechanic7
    @TranceMechanic7 Місяць тому +3

    Well, it's interesting that you've gotten bad results with it. I've had the exact opposite experience. Right out of the packaging super sharp, held an edge longer than my 14c raccoon (by a lot), sharpens easily, and still keeps a good edge after plenty of abuse and sharpening. I liked it so much I bought a bunch more and gave them to all my friends. They have had similar experiences. So over 12 individual knives, I haven't found a stinker.

    • @tommysuswick9751
      @tommysuswick9751 Місяць тому

      @@TranceMechanic7 great knife. This guy's career is knifes and couldn't find more than 1

    • @LogisticallyMisrepresented
      @LogisticallyMisrepresented Місяць тому

      If he went to 4 Walmarts, somehow that is not sufficient, ​@@tommysuswick9751 .?!

    • @LogisticallyMisrepresented
      @LogisticallyMisrepresented Місяць тому

      What kind of geometry is the other knife sporting.?

    • @TranceMechanic7
      @TranceMechanic7 Місяць тому

      @LogisticallyMisrepresented factory edge, whatever that happens to be for them

    • @LogisticallyMisrepresented
      @LogisticallyMisrepresented Місяць тому

      it may have not been configured as a durable edge, and that makes comparing edge vs edge difficult some times. @TranceMechanic7 Seems you were a lucky Ozark edge getter.

  • @crxk20r59
    @crxk20r59 25 днів тому

    I bought twelve 1st gen's & nine 2nd gen's. I kept a few of them & gave away a couple. Been using my 1st gen daily for many months & have zero issues so far 👍 Oh, and I'm selling my extras for $20 each.

  • @bcrocks3935
    @bcrocks3935 Місяць тому +8

    A knife that doesn’t cut is worth $0.00

    • @notademonrat
      @notademonrat Місяць тому +1

      it cuts i use it almost every day this dude is a liar

  • @paulbrooks4395
    @paulbrooks4395 Місяць тому +2

    Thanks to your channel I started sharpening knives and found an amazing difference in material types. The high chromium steel takes many times longer to grind due to its toughness. I found that low toughness high hardness steel is easier to grind but seems to start out with chips and needs more reprofiling, but holds and edge better when used on low impact tasks on materials that don't have as much hidden hard bits. My takeaway is that this is false advertising and the company folder shop after dumping a bunch of blades made from mediocre, excess steel they got from another job.

  • @33736
    @33736 Місяць тому +3

    I bought 4 of them and I love them. If you use it for its intended purpose and take care of it, it will last a lifetime. I gave them to my family.

    • @wulf67
      @wulf67 Місяць тому +1

      Why would you want an Ozark Trail to last a lifetime? You might go your whole life never knowing what a good knife is!

  • @gregmccarter2176
    @gregmccarter2176 11 днів тому

    I bought a cheap clip blade knife, at a pawn shop for $7.00..bright orange..para force...it was razer and holds edge pretty good...easy to sharpen...just a few strokes and leather strop..it will shave

  • @joshuasharrock466
    @joshuasharrock466 Місяць тому +4

    To be fair, you did compare d2 to 14c.. Which in my opinion is the best budget steel. I know d2 On paper is supposed to outperform sanvik but In every real world test 14c28n Is the budget magnacut

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +2

      I know, i didnt plan that. I literally grabbed it because it's about $40, the same color, and axis lock. I guess the stars aligned 😂

    • @nosrin1988
      @nosrin1988 Місяць тому

      Really? 14c28n you say? better than D2?
      You have my interest now, I do have at least one already in that steel, maybe I should look into more.

  • @ssnerd583
    @ssnerd583 Місяць тому +2

    I have a D2 blade that I cannot put a 20* edge on and have it last....but at 24* it works great

  • @stuartb9194
    @stuartb9194 Місяць тому +4

    Misinformation! You're going against the narative. Ozark knife has "middle class upbringing" 😂

  • @cincinnatifunk
    @cincinnatifunk Місяць тому

    showing your calibration got a sub here. good work and nice video.

  • @alexolivarez732
    @alexolivarez732 Місяць тому +4

    I can't believe you sold out to a sharpening machine.

    • @SuperSteelSteve
      @SuperSteelSteve Місяць тому +4

      What?😂😂

    • @alexolivarez732
      @alexolivarez732 Місяць тому

      @SuperSteelSteve he used to be the Whetstone King. That's why I started watching him. Extremely talented. Now, he uses a machine that every Tom Dick and Harry without any experience can use. No Talent there.

    • @SuperSteelSteve
      @SuperSteelSteve Місяць тому +4

      @alexolivarez732
      So because he changed his sharpening style he's a sell out?? 🤣🤣
      Bro, you can't be serious.
      People's preferences change. Maybe he doesn't feel like spending the mental concentration to sharpen every single time. Maybe the fixed angle system is just faster for him.
      His value as a youtuber creator, and as a human doesn't hinge on how often he uses whetstones.
      Hes definitely no sell out. My first car was a stick shift, but I buy automatics now because it suits my lifestyle now.
      Same idea man.

    • @OUTDOORS55
      @OUTDOORS55  Місяць тому +10

      Haha, it was so i can put an exact 20 degree edge on everything tested 🙂

    • @PluckyPackrat
      @PluckyPackrat Місяць тому +1

      @@OUTDOORS55 An exact 20 degree angle? How could youuuuuuuu🙀

  • @nosrin1988
    @nosrin1988 Місяць тому +2

    At the end of the day, it's an amazing fidget toy for me. The action is really loose and smooth and I can flick it back and forth constantly. It's got a better action, in my humble opinion, than a bunch of the more expensive ones I got.
    This knife got me obsessed with axis locks, don't ask how many I've bought since I picked up the OT-D2. XD

  • @firun2635
    @firun2635 Місяць тому

    You know, a video of you buying all kinds of cheap knives on Amazon to find out if any of those are any good would be fun. Great video!

  • @gmpny3945
    @gmpny3945 4 дні тому

    I bought one last month and liked liked it alot. When I went back to order 2 more they were sold out. I wonder if Walmart is going to restock. BTW the white $5 stormtrooper axis knife now lists for $14.30 on the Walmart website. I could only imagine what they will charge for the orange knife.

  • @RussianColluder
    @RussianColluder Місяць тому

    My Walmart had a bunch. I bought 3. I can pick some up and send em your way if you wanted to continue research.

  • @hcmlopes
    @hcmlopes Місяць тому

    Thx for the review. I heard so much from non experts that I almost got suckered into getting one

  • @mrkultra1655
    @mrkultra1655 Місяць тому

    When I first got wind of these knives, 2-3 months ago or so, I ran down to my local Wally World to check ‘em out. They had 4, bought them all, haven’t seen any since. They can’t even get the white handle ones anymore. All my everyday needs for a knife are ok, and I normally use a razor knife to cut up weird stuff.

  • @davidhenriksen4368
    @davidhenriksen4368 6 днів тому

    It's 10 bucks! It works fantastic for me. Cutting and fidgeting. I don't jerk off to knife steel like you guys, but for ten bucks it's been working great for me.

  • @MichiganSilverBack
    @MichiganSilverBack Місяць тому

    I have a benchmade bugout, and I just bought 5 of these for $5 each. I cant tell you how many times I've been sick because I thought I lost my bugout... all my son in-laws got these for stocking stuffers this year and it is now my every day carry knife.

    • @Trustory209
      @Trustory209 Місяць тому

      Yeah the $5 white ones are thin and smooth

  • @indigobasile3883
    @indigobasile3883 Місяць тому

    Editing unstoppable! Keep up the good work!

  • @Seppiedog
    @Seppiedog Місяць тому

    The newer version was available on the website, it has a reverseable pocket clip. Thanks for sharing

  • @vanishwolfen
    @vanishwolfen Місяць тому

    Epic! Really love to see you do content like this. I learned a lot from you. Keep up the great work!

  • @JohnSmith-gs4lw
    @JohnSmith-gs4lw Місяць тому

    Point of order. The SteelNerds data you were looking at was for CPM-D2. Probably not CPM steel in your Walmart special.

  • @elihernandez330
    @elihernandez330 Місяць тому

    Great video, very detailed and thorough.

  • @3rdpig
    @3rdpig Місяць тому

    I bought two of them because I love D2 blades and I like high a visibility grip. It's been my every day beater knife for a couple of months. While I don't cut card board I do tend to use it a bit harshly. I've resharpened it once. But I think I'lj pick up a racoon anyway, for the same reasons. Thanks for the extensive test!