Bollywood's Biggest Problem
Вставка
- Опубліковано 18 тра 2024
- Join Harkirats cohort : harkirat.classx.co.in/
Follow me on LinkedIn: / mohakmangal
******
📃Sources: docs.google.com/document/d/1x...
******
🔍✍️Research:
Zaira Khan: / zaira-khan-7435a9189
Antara: / that_musical_note
✂️🎛️Editing:
CharanTeja: / mograph.charantej
Mohit Bharti: / mohitbharti_
Utpal Singh Jadon: / utpalsinghjadon
🎨Thumbnail :
Aanchal Verma: / aanchal_creates
Want to work with us? Check this link!
tinyurl.com/22pxjjtv
******
🐦Twitter: / mohakmangal
📷Instagram: / mohak.mangal
👤Facebook: / sochyoutube
******
Indian Film Industry means glamour but are you aware of its not-so-glamourous side? Have you ever wondered why so many movies fail despite big stars? In this video, we discuss how the Indian Film Industry's glitz meets some real challenges as we uncover why actors' paychecks are causing a stir, making the already tricky movie business even more complicated. But are actors' high fees the REAL problem? From remakes and poorly-written scripts to disastrous VFX, this video uncovers shocking realities behind your favourite blockbusters and also those big-budgeted movies that brought about a much bigger disappointment.
Markers:
00:00 Introduction
03:57 History of Indian Film
17:21 Big stars don’t guarantee hit movies
18:05 Lack of creativity
24:46 Audience taste
Join Harkirats cohort : harkirat.classx.co.in/
First time any youtube sposership have helped me. I was going to purchase the same course, but just day before price increased from 5K to 6K, now I have got 20% discount, I have purchased course. Thank you.
@@ujjawalshrivastava1418bro are you serious?😂 The cohort starts from 2nd December. How will there be videos before that?
Please Upload 3English Subtitle
Plz make a vid on what the motivations for people like J Sai Deepak's ideologies are and share your views on them
SRK king of Bollywood and Modi king of panauti.
Who believes that bollywood is just garbage without remakes😂😂
You
Even with remakes they're garbage
Lagta hai ye comment viral hoga 😅😅
❤day Bollywood is better than your rip physics talliwood 😂
Just you
Don't blame the audience.
Although '12th Fail' had a budget of 20 CR, it earned 2.5 times that amount, collecting 56 CR. I personally supported it due to the quality of the story.
People still appreciate a quality story over junk.
@@slayer_142 No.
1. Vikrant Messy's acting kills it,
2. Direction is top notch,
3. Based on true story .
Kyu ki saare school waalo ne promote kiya tha , indian audience is still shit
@@slayer_142ab tumhara dimag ghutane main usse ham kya kare...😂
it was good flim but not extraordinary but still earned that much because of UPSC theme there are some gem movies which gets flopped@@PradeepSinghRajputOfficial
Bro after seeing hollywood films and series why would anyone watch Bollywood movies with low quality vfx
Jawan was produced by Red Chillies which is owned by SRK. The whole 60 percent profit plus 100 crore fee is just him reinvesting the money back into his production company. And given that Atlee is the director while SRK being the lead, it was guarantied that this film will make massive bank. SRK is actually a very smart guy; he knows the economics of the industry in-and-out and know which projects to place bets on. Also, a big chunk of his money actually goes into VFX division of Red Chillies which India's top VFX STUDIO.
Is ko knowledge nhi aa gya video banane
Interesting SRK produce his own movies and still took for him 31 years to enter the1000 crore club, he could be really smart business wise, but he or somebody else is paying millions trying to keep his image and standing in Bollywood, it is a 24/7 business convincing people of your value.😃
Kamu Banyak berbicara dari pada bekerja, itu bedanya dengan mu
@@bertilasanchez2909you act as if making a 1000 crore film is easy for Indian movies, despite India producing 1000 films a year there are only 6 movies in the 1000 crore club.
This is the problem quantity not quality , how a cinema. industry expect to make real blockbusters worldwide if at home cannot found enough support , charity begins at home.I gave my opinion simply. @@AnAverageCommonMan
I'm not really into SRK, but gotta admit, dude's been in the game for 30 years from dealing with the underworld back in the day to handling political stuff today. Pretty wild journey haha. Probably the only actor with a spine.
Srk teri dadi ka bf tha 80s m
Absolutely right 👍🏽
Do you even understand how PR works?
with a spine? lmfaooo
he promotes pan masala and gambling apps what spine are u talking abt?
@@aryanram02 he's not doing anything illegal. If sales of these products are legal, so is promotion. SRK is not in public service - he has no obligation to set any moral benchmarks and neither is anyone looking to him for that. So your point is not really valid.
One solution to this problem could be to make movies with new actors who are formally trained in acting, such as FTII graduates. This way, a lot of new fresh talent would get an opportunity to get introduced and the producers can spend more money on hiring experienced directors and behind the scene artists as well as visual and other special effects.
Lol, untill Srk Ajay Akshay Salman Ranbir are not retiring, atleast 20 deserving actors won't get a contract
high risk, such movie won't earn money, in foreign countries directors are bigger star than actors that's why it works there
tiger 3 was flop, akshay all movies are flop, ranbir shamsheera bombed, ajay movies flopped back to back now nothing is guaranteed @@Iamthedeadrocker69
they arent getting a contract cuz audience wont watch them. Its easy to say to bring new actors, but as an audience it will be very hard to believe in that movie.
There is a reason why Average movies earns 1000 cr...the star factor. @@Iamthedeadrocker69
Indian audiences only watches movies base on star casting
South Indian actors : generations of nepotism
Allu Arjun fee : 120 cr
Prabhas : 150 cr
Jr NTR : 80 cr
Kamal hasan : 160 cr
Why you always target bollywood because it’s a trend ??
Wahi to rajni sir jaise senior ne bhi 180+ cr liye jailer ke liye
Exactly bro u said right.they don't know about telugu industry .our heros charged more money and movies are like rotta masala movies .e movies malli Bollywood vallu remake chesthunaru karma .see what Tamil industry and malyalam industry is doing different films different concepts.
Jo bada hota hai ussi ko gaali parti hai bruhh... Chothe bacho ko zyada nhi bolte... Hope u understand..
What colour is your oscar song 🙃💀
shivakarthikeya will work for free for his new movie... Ayaalan.
I feel only malayalam industry is following the story based movies.
One of the best malayalam movie of this year is '2018'.
It's due to the audience taste
Watch "Bramayugam", I think it will be the best Malayalam movie of this year
A special and personal video coming on Friday! Do watch it ❤
Problem is with producers 😂if they stop investing in films then actors will automatically reduce their fees and everything will be on track again😅
Let me ask you a question, will you watch a Bollwood movie which doesn't have any Super Star like Salman or Sharukh,etc but a pair of new actors that you nothing of. If yes, which is the last Bollwood movie that you saw which only had new and unexpensive actors?
@@rahulsar2030yes
@@rahulsar2030 brother I guess ur an amateur in this film world. Ur stucked at 90's era where people went to watch movies just to see their favourite hero. This is 2023 where good plot and direction steal the show. U don't know how many films till date I watched😅
@@rahulsar2030 I don't know about Bollywood but in South irrespective of the actor most of the audience watch good content movies, my mother tongue is Telugu but still I watch all South movies if they have good content. I liked prabhas even before Baahubali becoz he made some good entertaining movies but I didn't watch his bad movies be it Adipurush or Radhe Shayam.
@@pramodvulloji5920 yes bro in terms of quality content south is far better than Bollywood, I have watched so many South Indian movies without even knowing the actors name 😅
A slight correction: L' accoudour the french movie was the inspiration for Andhadun, you can't say it's a remake. the french film is a short film which is 13 mins long while the Andhadhun movie is 2 hours+, the concept is the same but the story expands and adds so much more. i wouldn't call it a remake.
Exactly, I thought the same. Andhadhun is way above the crappy hits Hindi film industry churns out.
Thanks for correcting me!
exactly I was caught off guard with that comparison , I have seen both films and andhadhun is a very original film
Yes exactly
@@mohak_mangalyeah exactly
Prabhas is just overrated 🙏
wrt to writers, Korean industry seem to be doing something right. They give due credit to the writers, many dramas would have hype around who the writer is compared to actors. Since Kdrama caters to an international audience rather than relying on star power, many times writers will also be part of casting. You can also see interviews where writers like kim yun sook would share why they took a particular actor for their story.
Mostly of kdramas are for women. Romcom krama doesn't even have international market.
@@piyushsalvi4274 Bollywood has been making romcoms since it's inception. Men avoid kdramas only because the actors look feminine.
@@piyushsalvi4274 so what they still earn a lot of money from female audience. Also a lot of kdramas like all of us are dead, etc are liked by general audience that includes both men and women
@@thesevenkingswelove9554 series like all of us are dead, Alice in boderland, squid game are made for universal audience. But that feminine kdramas doesn't cater audience worldwide. I recommend you to watch kingdom
@@Qwerty-jc3so But characters in kdramas act too feminine. I have seen many korean film, not the gayish one.
Also, the another reason is lack of movies, adapted from Indian literature. If you look in Hollywood, you will find many movies which were adapted from literature. Forrest Gump was also an adaptation from a novel of the same name. I have read some of the stories of writers like Bhagwati Charan Verma, Munshi Premchanda, Mridula Garga and Vijay Tendulkar. And I will tell you most of the Indian writers of 20th century were very much ahead of their time and you will also enjoy their stories. Most of these writers had come to the film industry but they ended up being disappointed with the system. But some writers like Vijay Tendulkar had written screenplays of some of finest films like Manthan, Ardhasatya, Nishant. I also recommend you to read his plays. If you don't have time to read the indian literature, atleast hear the radio play adaptations of them, produced by Aakashvani.
U mean from books right also series uk like heartstopper which is such a classic and the show elevated the overall experience of the whole book even without diminishijng its essence
Well, I 've never heard of this show but thanks for telling about the show.
Look man, in creative arts, there are no rules. I 've read the Forrest Gump novel as well as I have watched the movie. Just the main characters are same in both novel and the movie but the plot is entirely different. I will suggest you to read it, you will find it as amusing as the movie.
I surely will
I don't think it can be a big reason. Our bengali film industry, which we call as Tollywood, is currently at the worst phase that we don't even know what films have released in last 5 years. But what we've seen, atleast >50% of our films are direct adaptations, with genres ranging from romance, horror, detective, social setup/periodic.
What I believe, why Bollywood is failing (even our industry) and the Southern industries are thriving, us because they have larger level of conviction and think out of the box. You can have millions of stories written for you, but if you lack the ability to setup it in large frame in grandeur, it's waste of money.
But that is the case with Bollywood, they can do grandeur and large scale easily. But they need to appreciate story and writers. Good writer - director is the foundation of a film, not an A list actor.
I think that Bollywood should focus on fun and realistic stories and avoid cringe scenes in movies. And also that it's better to use songs as BGM while progressing the story, and not as overextended filler dance video.
South too just bgm and cringe dilogue
Bollywood was good in comedy movies
Honestly Bollywood has always been known for the dance numbers, and that is the essence of it. Change needs to be made but embracing and keeping the essence in mind is also important
Just boycott Amir Khan he is king of cringe 😂
Very well said. One of the reasons I just dont watch Bollywood content and will not until this cringe tradition goes away.
Lets talk about Kantara, a huge hit.
Such a low budget movie. But strong story and impeccable script and brilliant acting.
Bollywood should focus on that. Be with stars or without.
Lets talk about 12th fail
Let's also talk about Kantara's prequel, Chapter One.
from 16 cr of Kantara to 125 cr of Kantara chapter one. The thing was that the actor was not a star before so he was no one but now he is at least for that movie, so fees up.
Same is the case with KGF.
and who says Bollywood never focused on script and acting? Take out the lists of the top 200 films made in India, most of them are in Hindi or Bengali language, this sudden negative campaign against Bollywood is only running down South. Not a fan of SRK but the man showed how at 58 he is far better than most of the Southern superstars being hero-worshipped amongst their audience, two films already crossed the 1000cr + marks one more biggie left. Bollywood has always been content just that people have been brainwashed into thinking that they don't make good films anymore and I am not even talking about the critical cinema here.
@@okayaresd True and even most of the box office records in the history of Indian cinema are made by Bollywood movies
@@okayaresd bollywood is garbage
Every artist should be respected.
A film just doesn't revolve around the star or actor ; Movie is a combined effort of the director , script writer, producer , technical artist and other crew members. Not only the star but all the crew should be appreciated for the success of a movie.
Well said Mohak Mangal 💯
Indian people movie ko sirf time pass samjate h ye log art ko sirf time pass nachniya bolkar mazak udate h
Main problem with Bollywood is:
Bollywood movies are mostly low in IQ and actors stardom centric rather than content centric (Irrespective of few directors)
If they continue to do so then we will witness the fall of Bollywood
Sometimes I just think what the hell they are doing...
The reach that Bollywood has in India also around the world if they had focused more on content than actors stardom also inefficient star kids by bringing/exploring new faces around India
Today instead of struggling, Bollywood could compete Hollywood
Indian Film Makers should set standard, evolve and make movies like Marvel Studios, John Wick, Avatar, Jurassic Park, Matrix, Terminator etc. instead of Bheekh manga, Gharelu Bibaad, Emotional Fool movies, Illogical Love stories etc.
Well explained bro totally agreed
@@andromeda45188even most words in songs are actually urdu not hindi😂.
@@Dattebayo3089haan aur usi par tumhari industry chal rhi hai 😂 agar Urdu na hoti toh Naa Sonu Nigam hota na kk na Arijit na hee koi srk hota Naa koi Naseeruddin shah Naa koi dilip Kumar Naa koi Irfan Khan aur Naa hee Amitabh Bachchan
watch the video again. yes neptism is an issue, but Indians want to watch such movies and not content based movies. it's the just the way it is.
@@naushabatalat1332 ye bakwas band karo , nahi bhi hota toh kya hi ho jata , it's soo egoist thing , to think like this
The problem is culture of religion in India, we make everything religion and one god like Bollywood stars, sachin, virat and dhoni in cricket....india needs to get out of religious mindset....
True
You forgot to mention the "Credit taking God" of India 😂😂😂😂
Bhai ab aisa nahi hai tabhi no hindi movies jinke actors ko hum nahi jante wo bhi accha kar rahi hai toh main nahi manta ab aisa hai haa agar movie ki marketing aur promotion achi tarah se kare toh log movie ko jaan payege toh wo dekh payega jo film nahi chali unki promotion dhang se nahi hui aur media bhi promote nahi kar rahi thi aur audience ki bhi galti hai woh interest nahi lete nahi toh aur bhi achhi gumnam filme hai
So trueeeee. People literally treat them like GOD. like seriously 😂😂😂😂😂
Exactly!
most Bollywood movies bas 3 ghante ke Tik Tok videos hai 😂😂
As a aspiring writer and a member of SWA .. I was appalled when i got to know about the compensation of writers. How do you expect a writer to give his 100% when you pay them 8 to 30 lac for the movie being made on the budget of 50 to 100 crore.. There are thousands of writers in the industry getting scammed.. there was a writer who only got paid 10000 for his movie in exchange of credits.. Indian movie industry will not get better until writer and other artists are paid well..
And yeah very strict timeliness
With how bad 2021-2022 were, its nothing short of a miracle how Bollywood bounced back this year. Huge hits one after the other and December is poised to be the biggest month!
Animal will be blockbuster also after trailer it created great hype
i think dunki might be even more bigger
@@dheeraj009.1
Huhh!
Tum bhi fake PR team k numbers pe aa gaye😮😢
Hits bhi super stars ki wajah se chali . Stars ke bina nahi chalti ye sab movies
@@yashshukla9350fake pr ? I think sirf pathan aur gadar 2 me hua tha pr baaki sab organic hits hai like tjmm , tiger 3 , kerela story , 12th fail aur bhi bohot, aur coorporate hits bhi thi like jawan
Very informative and highly recommended to those who says Bollywood movies are trash at least now they know the reason !
One more issue that I feel is really important is Many movies releases EVERY Friday and the trend will or somewhat have been established with OTT's also for Sunday. Do not pressure artists for such a useless norm of every friday release is a must. Unnecessary time limitations will not give better art so just forget about Masterpieces. There is absolutely never-ending material already present in the world of Cinema that is sufficient for any individual for a lifetime, so it is my sincere request to all the movie studios, filmmakers that take your time and give it to the writers to create something meaningful, put your money in surveys and do the needful accordingly. We have such an audience right now that is mature enough to understand complex stories.
Prabhas 150 cr😂
I want to add about the studio era. Being a person from Andhra Pradesh, I can say this: Some of the Epic classics, which are even widely acclaimed to this day were made during the studio era. Films like Mayabazaar (1957) and Pathala Bhairavi (1951) were epic fantasy movies, which were made by the Vijaya Vauhini studio, are still considered classic movies even to this day, with their beautiful dialogues, set pieces, and story+screenplay combinations.
PS: Thank you for raising the issue with Tollywood as well (even if done in passing). The problem of high upfront fees is prevalent not just in Bollywood, but also is creeping up in Tollywood.
The worst in south india for high fee for actors is in Tamil Nadu and producers cry over here and hail Malayalam industry actors for their nominal fee and Telugu actors for reducing their fees or helping producer in case of movie failure but in Tamil industry 60 percentage of the budget goes as salary to the main actor
@@GuruPrasad-tb3qk Oh, I didn’t know that the issue was this dire in Kollywood as well.
Mayabazaar and Missamma (1955) are two of my family's favorite movies.
@@GuruPrasad-tb3qk only the biggest of the stars do that. Rajni, Vijay, Ajith do that. Rest of them don't do it (because they don't have a big box office pull) But in Tollywood, even small actors are increasing their fees which is not there in Tamil.
And Malayalam is benchmark example for actors fees.
It's a tricky situation in Jawan's case: there are 2 producers gaurav and srk. So after all the equations, the movie made certain crores and from that srk takes percentage sharing as an actor which directly goes to his personal account.... remaining amount would be shared by gaurav and srk(red chillies) as per their percentage investments. Here Shahrukh got more benefits as compared to Pathaan but with that extra headache of managing everything needs to be handled.
@@andromeda45188umm wtf ? tu paida hone par sarr par gira tha kya? Jo har baat pe hindi-muslim le aata hai
No , Gaurav Verma works for SRK. he's employee Red chillies & producer by profession. Film was completely produced by Red chillies entertainment only , SRK invested his own money.
Gaurav is a part of RCE as far as his LinkedIn says. Actually what happens is that when their position is too high in the company, their name is displayed probably because they are a part of the decision-making body as well. Like he must have also sanctioned that they should invest in Jawan
Red Chillies is wholly owned by SRK & Gauri Khan! Gaurav Verma works for Red Chillies. Basically, SRK/Gauri Khan ne khud SRK ko hi 100 crore ka paycheck diya! 🤣
@@ChiSa123 yes he took a fee, not just him, many actors do that. Their fees are a part of the budget in their own production houses' films
There are a number of New Actors who did really good Story Films but didn't get appreciation because they were new... Like Sidharth Malhotra, Kartik Aaryan, and a lot more....
But now People are realizing what actual talent is and now They're very Popular 🙂
Have always loved Siddharth Malhotra
I don't think lack of material is an issue. even producers will easily find these literature pieces and plays etc. but they will never adapt it due to lack of majority interest or risk of losing money after paying the actors in crores. it may sound bad but the primary source of money is common people and common people in india are not mature enough or simply not interested in seeing those movies. Also in the west they have relatively homogenized language and culture(except the immigrants but even they adapt) so you can easily adapt because lot of people are interested already. I feel even if tomorrow someone makes a great adaptation with big stars it will fail cuz common people don't want to waste their hard earned money to see no action no item song , no hot scenes. atleast thats how i feel.
We need to let more fresh actors get a chance. These big actors are always considered first for roles because of their popularity but their fees hits the production so bad that they only face loss.
@@slayer_142 Fir dekteh raho 50 saal ke buddhe or buddhi ko, fir complain mat karna India mai acche film kyun nahi bante.
@@slayer_142 I barely watch South Movies because I couldn't able to relate with them. However Bollywood movies are becoming trash day by day. I prefer international movies.
@@slayer_142 That is why I dislike them and now bollywood is copying the same shit
That's because of the audience do you think you will watch a movie without a super star
but 12th fail was hit. Hindi audience have started to watch different types of movies. the problem is with south audience @@sonashisworld7290
1) writers should be paid well. They are the stars. 🌟🌟
2) directors need to be paid well and respected for their craft
3) ACTORS ARE JUST ONE PART OF THE MOVIE... stop saying "shahrukh" ki film. Its a film that has shahrukh. Soo many other people are involved. Give them RECOGNITION
I see many people praising the directors more than actors of Hollywood films..and thus their movies are also good
yahi toh baaat h sab salman ya sharukh ki movie khte jbki director aur writer ka haath zyada hota aur kbhi kn]bhi toh log movie dkh aat h pr na director na writer ka naam pta hota h
exactly!! Writers , Director and Editor - the three pillers of foundation of a movie. Actors can put the cherry on the cake, but if the foundation is bad, noting can save it. But a good director and editor can make a bad actor seem okay.
@@slayer_142 India does whatever upper middle class wants. They set trends. If these people decide they want to replace it with some other content, bollywood will be in trouble. Lower middle class follows upper middle class...and that eventually trickles down to all classes. So, if they don't want to be replaced by Korean, Japanese and American content, they better change their ways.
@@valley-girlsouth industry alone dominated even marvel in 2022 due to RRR, indian creativity is vast but they need recognition
Summery of Video
00:02 High fees of actors in Bollywood movies
02:09 High flat fees of Bollywood actors pose a problem for producers
06:31 Opportunity to develop new skills with Harkirat Singh's live coding sessions
08:31 Film producers in Bollywood faced financial challenges and turned to the underworld for funding.
12:49 Recognition of Bollywood as an industry led to increased investment and growth
15:16 Actors demanding profit sharing reduces the ability to cast multiple big actors in one film.
19:29 Lack of creativity and clichéd scripts are the biggest problems in Bollywood.
21:29 Bollywood directors prefer scripts they have contributed to, leading to talented writers being ignored.
25:25 Indian audience prefers massy movies
Pravas should have returned his fees for the film.
1. Bollywood need to support writers. Thats why atleast critically Malayalam Industry is Reigning.
2. Take as Time as you want. 4 years or 5 years.
3. Put efforts into Other aspects such as Background Music. ex - Anirudh
4. No MULTIGENRE FILMS. Make films Like Lokesh or Rajamouli, they concentrate on a single genre not do a film like Atlee as he is dependent of Mass Films which has its separate Audience but not everytime works.
😂😂😂😂
So, what do u think Rajamouli made? It's also a Masala movie: the multi genre movie
@@Z71990 but rajmouli makes movies with passion there is good vfx good acting good music it is not much focused on just one star. same for lokesh or SLB
rajkumar hirani?@@riderchallenge4250
3. If you're talking about BGMs then add Bahubali
Actresses are really underpaid. Can’t believe that after almost a decade in the industry Kriti charges only 3 cr
No one goes to the cinema to watch kriti or katrina , and thats a fact , dont label me a sexist.
You cant expect a very high fees when you dont really contribute anything in the profit.
@@PantheraGoat If they are not watched why are they included in films?
@@asthasingh1016 the bollywood of india mostly include female characters just to oversexualise them , and to certain extent its the fault of the actresses as well.
When actresses treat themselves like an object , they will be paid like an object only.
They need to choose better script , stand for themselves and focus mainly on the acting and not just try to sell their bodies , like many do.
@@PantheraGoat you have to be bold enough to ask for more as well. Unless you ask, male producer will not pay you more than what you think you are worth. You also have to back it up with the results as well. Kriti plays a relatively less sexualized roles than other actresses, she definitely deserves more.
@@nikhilkay1 Yes , you are right and not only Kriti but all other actresses who play less sexualized roles and act well should be paid to their worth. Moreover, the male actors who show their bodies in films should be paid less. But, the problem is that they are being paid more for doing that ,😔😔whether they are good enough for acting or not (e.g. Salman Khan)
One thing u have left about Politics in Movie Making these days Ex: Kshamir Files,Kerala Story,Gadar 2,etc. these are politically motivated movie and earlier Underworld had controlled the Cinema but Today it is the Big Politician who are controlling it to promote their Party interest.
This is an important point u need to show also ❤
Hollywood me pentagon involved hota hai pta bhi hai kuch uske baare me games or Hollywood me 😊
I'm not really a fan, but gotta admit, SRK has been in the game for 30 years from dealing with the underworld back in the day to handling political pressure. Probably the only actor with a spine.
he is spineless bro
Bolon zuban kesari,
Unreal hate towards SRK @@aryanram02
Shahrukh’s most of film are produced by red chilli production and sometimes in collaboration with yrf . So ultimately he is paying himself those fees. That also reason he works very closely to make film commercially profitable.
One correction (in 19:34), Andhadhun wasn't a remake remake of L'accordeur, just that it had taken an inspiration from it, big difference as many and most original movies take inspiration from some movies or others. L'accordeur was a 14 minute short film, while Andhadhun was a 2+ hr long movie, with personal dynamics, twists and interests driving the movie.
@@DeeprajChauhan-oh8vvnot defending anyone or anything, but andhadhun was genuinely not a remake in the genral sense, remakes have almost the entire plot same as the original, run time not very different, many scenes are remade but in different context, but this movie (as per the admission of the creators) had taken inspiration from that short film, as in the part where a fake blind pianist witnessed a murder, but it wasn’t shot-for-shot remake, instead they expanded on the story with character motivations, greed, lust and dynamics, and finally a open eding, something the 14 minute short film lacked. Look mate I believe bollywood needs ti learn from different industries (also the its old self) but this was one of those movies that was innovative and different from other bollywood movies, and you will find many ‘acclaimed movies’ that are infact inspired by other movies but take a very different turn from the original movie and only have a fraction of it similar.
@DeeprajChauhan-oh8vv have you even watched both movies and compared them? do you even know what a remake is?
just asking, not to say i'm against you or anything
@@aayushpal6621bro leave then he is from south obviously that Doesn't make sense to explain a person who come from south they are using Jay prabhs,Jai mahesh babu so you understand how they are
@@ShivPatel-ds3kp how did you come to the conclusion that the guy I was talking to was from the South?
Do you know them personally or something?
Not to say I'm defending his argument
@@aayushpal6621 A remake is a film, television series, video game, song or similar form of entertainment that is based upon and retells the story of an earlier production in the same medium-e.g., a "new version of an existing film".
I make it a point to NOT go to the theatre for mass movies that has garbage story and only has an actor’s name attached to it. Never been a fan of ‘larger than life’ movies. Even as a kid.
I definitely DON’T want to spend my hard earned money on them.
Rather, I’d happily spend my money on movies like 12th Fail etc, where there’s a beautiful story, wonderful acting and a good message too.
Hollywood is kind of realistic, and they try to fit logic in even fictional movies, whereas Bollywood is a kind of dreamy thing where there's a dance, song, colorful costumes, action, and heavy dialogues in its core form.
I Guess Now New Era is Coming Franchise Era
1 LCU
2 KGF Universe
3 Spy Universe
4 Bhramastra trilogy
5 Kanata Squial
6 Hanuman Universe
7 Pushpa Squeal
8 RRR sequel
And many more
No people always talk about actor's not franchises
lol no
Directors and producers should be given incentive for making good movies. Star getting incentives is not ideal for the industry
Yup I think there should be a option to support directors like after watching movies you can give review as well as extra money to motivate or support director
Just a question mohak. Jawan was entirely produced by Red Chillies Entertainment (Which is owned by SRK himself). So how can he take fees from his own money?
he will reduce red chillies profits by debiting this fees as cost thereby reducing the taxable profits of red chillies... Dont go abt correcting people without having any knowledge.
Probably to optimise to the minimum tax burden
Red chillies is a company it has seperate legal identity from its founders, hence he can take fees salary whatever he wants
@@swatisaini6447ha ceo bhi salary leta hai na company main waise hoga
@@pranavsohoni3270 director remuneration ki limits hoti hai but fees given for professional services pe koi limit nahi hai kitna bhi de sakte hai
Mohak, I'm a fan of knowledge based videos and you're just hitting it out of the park with your research. You're now the finest of India's knowledge based video maker. ❤❤❤❤
thank lol
All i want good movies. And also hope new faces from different family names can do main lead roles.
Dont Target only Bollywood every industry has same problem.
South industries have nepotism,woman discrimination,high fees.
This year Bollywood earned over 5500crs which is way ahead of all other industries from south.Moreover this 2023 is the most successful year in history of Bollywood.
In my opinion Bollywood content is more evolving and progressive rather than south mass masala illogical movies (except Malayalam cinema)
Tamil cinema is most balanced industry 😊😊😊
When you say South Indian movie, you are referring to South Indian movies which are dubbed into Hindi. Southern Industry offers a wide variety of stories across Tamil, Kannada, Telugu, and Malayalam. Some of the great movies outside Malayalam which never crossed borders are Asuran, Karnan, Jai Bheem, Soorarai Pottru, periyurum perumal, Sapta sagaradaache ello, Dia, Garuda Gamana Vrushabha Vahana, Kavaludari, sa hi pra shaale Kasaragodu, ondu motteya kathe, Daredevil Mustafa, aachar & co, hostel hudugaru bekagiddare, Sita Ramam, Thiruchitrambalam, Gargi
The list goes on..
@@pavankumarhk7074only thing which is eats creativity in any industry is PAN INDIAN SUCCESS ,believe me or not , pan indian south movies have worse content than their regional story
Don't know why Soch has less subscribers , his content are not repetitive , his topics are much more realistic and innovative, reasearch is solid , uploads regularly with high frequency but doesn't get subscribers 😔😔 .
I am proud I subscribed from when he had only few lakhs subscribers . 😊
Because he speaks what people NEED to hear, not what people WANT to hear
share his videos everywhere
28 lakhs is less subscribers?
Because he doesn't focuses on cheap politicians conspiracy and instead covers important topics in everyday life
We are a middle class family or a common man
We don't need stars but we need stories 😞
Pre production activities of the movies are rewlly important. U can see south directors start preparing so many months before the actual shooting starts. Hell the cgi work started for leo even b4 the shooting
3 issues in this video
1 - Andhadhundh was not remake of that French short film
2 - RRR had very bad VFX
3 - UTV motion picture is no more
No RRR's vfx is not that bad, it's still watchable comparing to adipurush.
@@vedantsuryavanshi9656 rrr was a shitshow i have no clue why anyone with critical thinking would love that movie.
it was so boring the entire time, there was no proper story line, its like he mixed 3-4 stories which can be their own movies, there is a start to each story, there is the establishment of characters but that's it, there is no proper role like ajay devgan in the movie, they brought him onto the screen, gave little backdrop and gone, again something else only starts off.
but ofc, indian audience loves seeing their stars on screen even if it makes 0 frickin sense or if it adds nothing to the film lol.
but i am being honest, rrr had fantastic cinematography and hatts of to the camera crew and director, the shots were beautiful, songs were good but rest was a shit show.
Appreciate your point of view. But once James Cameron says he is a fan of a film, we have to accept its greatness - no matter how we like it
A remake is a film, television series, video game, song or similar form of entertainment that is based upon and retells the story of an earlier production in the same medium-e.g., a "new version of an existing film".
RRR VFX was definitely below average but the fun factor made up for it. Adipurush took itself too seriously so it was just boring
The difficult Bollywood economics is easy to understand with mohak😊
SRK himself produced Jawan. How can he charge. He only does profit sharing.
02:05 ❤ SRK
Pathaan 1050cr
JAWAN 1148cr and now
*Dunki 🔥*
$ 130 million and $140 million are big numbers only domestically. 😃
Bro jawan film ko shah rukh ke khud ki production company ne produce kia ha
To phir wo apne hi production company se fees kyu lega?
Biggest problem of bollywood ❌
Biggest problem of Indian cinema✅ no offense
Except malayalam, their movies are pure story based and i hope they dont fall in this pan india movement infection, telugu movies after pan india success seems like they are also going somewhat low on content same with tamil
Very good analysis on why Bollywood and underworld had to join hands!
Bollywood is good at coping stories either from Hollywood or from tollywood or from literature (devdas written by sharatchandra bose etc)
I completely agree Indian audience is not mature enough for politics and movies
Thank god these things are changing now.. should give more and more room to content driven movies and regional movies.
Yaar muh band kar baas a Rahi he
I beleive that retro actors should retire like cricketers do so that we can have fresh talent in the industry while keeping the price in control
Actor ki fees problem kyo?
Galti director ki hai, unko khud ki kabiliyat pe bharosa hota to struggling actor ko mauka deta...
andhadhun is not a remake ,it shares one scene from the french short film, rest entire movie is original
Anadhadhun is not a remake
It is a complete film with a blind pianist
Ya
It is also a remake
@@mdmustafashafi4950of which film ?
It’s inspired by a French short film ‘The piano turner’ but the rest of the cast and step was original!
@@toshibatewari5926 every art has inspiration of others that doesn't mean that art isn't original.
Because Bahubali also took some inspiration from Ramayana or the lion King still it's one of the best periodic film in India
This is actually great. Let them charge cores and only then new, young talents will get a chance. ❤
Mohak Bhai. You got a good point on film industry basis. We common people too suffering for higher rates of movie tickets nowdays. It's sad but harsh reality😑
Maturity when relies that even south actor charges 100cr like rajni sir and talapaty vijay,ram charan 💀💀💀
Naseeruddin shah did 20,25 movies for free
Because his everage movie recover the budget of movie 👉 stardom
@@KrishanKumar-ec1chone person ?
@@Sumit_Girhe ?
They have die hard fans , mean they love them then their life so there is particular stamp for director , and ram Charan wife is Apollo hospitals chairman , & his dad is megastar Chiranjeevi he is rich guy there is not lack of money for them so basically he is not curious about how much they pay , he only taken 100cr for rrr & worth it too
I wanted to become VFX and animation artist but when i gone to studio who teach it they told me cost of teaching is ₹2 lack but job gurantee is ₹10,000 and not only that office hours of studios unpredictable sometimes u have to do work more than normal working hours😢 though now thing might be different due to its importance and due to OTT platform which needs content run thair business
Not only Bollywood
Same problem on sports
Only glory & money in cricket other sport no body watch & no money please mohak make video on that topic also
If 12th fail is released in China.
It will be top earning movie,
Where content is king..
so true chinese people like these type of social issue movies for some reason, even secret superstar earned more in china than it earned in india
China has quota system. Only a few foreign cinemas are allowed to be screened there. Not because of any fanbase.
People hating on Bollywood must realise Bollywood is not just recent day films its the work of Raj kapoor, devanand, sharmila ji etc followed by other directors and actors just this particular new lot is not good doesn't mean the industry is bad. Every business has its ups and downs.
We hate post 2000 bollywood, crushing new commers, nepo, drugs, Terrorist, sex addicts, porn films 🤢
People are questioning the current quality of content bollywood is releasing. Not the whole industry. People of all ages still fondly listen to the old 50s-60s Bollywood songs & watch movies
Very well researched and written ,loved the presentation too! Congratulations!!
I will always support movies based on content especially low budget movies e.g. 12 th fail, Gangajal, Shool, Apaharan, Madras Cafe, 3 idiots These are some of the best movies in Bollywood apart from that The southern region the movies are great especially Kantara ( Kannada)Minnal Murali, Jana Gana Mana ( Malayalam) have outperformed the Bollywood by G.O.A.T levels.
I'll also add Lapa chapi (which also has a bollywood remake), a marathi horror film. Regional movies have so much quality but unfortunately it goes unnoticed
Satyajit Ray is the one of the finest directors Bengal has ever produced.
Who tf decided to give 150cr to Prabhas 🤡
Littrely 150 cr bahuttt Jayda hota hai
😂
I watched his old interviews he says if he asks for a big amount and the director and producer are okay with it then he will take it but if it hampers the film itself he will charge less which he did for bahubali
It's the producers who are ready to give 100+cr to an actor just for them to be in it so that the movie can earn a little more than the budget
@@gassyalwaysSALAAR 😈COMEBACK HOKE RAHEGA 😈
@@RAJU_DANCOMMENT MERA PADH LO PATA CHAL JAAYEGA
Jawan producer is gauri khan and red chillis is srk production house so thats his money and also profits
Thangod I turned to south movies in 2010/ 11 an even learn5 telugu just by watching movies, those days I observed most of movies were remakes of south films and I was frok southern states who knows hindi an used to watch bollywood mostly, but back then I woke up to reality😂
"Do tera do mera, tin tera tin mera" got real 🤣🤣
Hello mohak, one topic suggestion for video
Please make video on ielts industry,
Nowadays in India study abroad trend is increasing so idp is only company in India for ielts exam because of that idp enjoying monopoly in ielts industry, which unfair for students
Government don't have any interfere or regulation on it so idp also increased exam fees and some time exam results are unfair
Also black marketing of ielts bands in Gujarat and punjab
In others countries students have choice to reappear in one module ( pen paper based exam) but in India it's not available
Many students face struggle to give exam again in all modules, mentally it also effects the amount of time and money involves
Doesn't British Council also conduct IELTS?
@@meerars4906 no, British council left India during covid time
Well written and shot and the flow of information is so good keep up the good work
As per Porter's Five forces, the power of suppliers i.e.actors here, is super high in Bollywood, which leads to poor allocation of funds to other major activities in making of a good movie leading to poor movie scripts and repetitive production of typical Bollywood movies
The way to resolve this problem is to have a profit sharing mechanism with actors as fees
Ticket prices are sky high thats why i don't watch movies on cinema, now I watch 2 movies in 1 year on cinema hall
Dunki will change the mass taste. Blockbuster storytelling. btw jawan was produced by srk so unki fees news would be false.
Very well explained! And kudos to your team!
I think fees was just for stardom. look a prabhas salaar budget was 250 cr and Netflix itself brought it for 350cr.
Which will not happen if it's a small actor.
Hollywood actors also charge high fees.But Hollywood films always spend more on script,story and film production.
You know this high fees problem is also seen in Bangladesh too.That's why films get flopped over the time.
25:31
That's true
Larger than life movies are preferred by audience
Because They want to escape from their day to day mundane life for 2 to 3 hours
Not only in Bollywood but also in Hollywood it's a major problem and a misinformation is that jawaan was produced by gauri khan and she is srk's wife so how in the world srk charged fees? PLEASE REPLY
Bollywood may not stop making films anytime soon, but its golden period was over after the 90s. The industry is now creatively bankrupt, doesn't provide meaningful entertainment anymore and well past its prime. Plus we have a plethora of other options when it comes to content in this digital age.
This is not the problem of only Bollywood but also of other industries.
Exactly
But criticising Bollywood is a trend now😅
Isn't this the film industry of your country? The other industries have law of taking only certain % of the earnings
19:34 Andhadhun is an original movie, it is inspired from the french movie but not copied, Ayushman being a blind pianist is the inspired part, but the plot twist is original in Andhadhun
19:30 Andhadhun was inspired from that short film & both are much different from each other
I really appreciate your efforts and you have fantastic sixth sense, I love the part when you show the picture of Satyajeet Roy
20:24
True 💯💯
Bollywood has become a money making machine and the quality of the movies are lost 🤦🤦
Just like cricket
I always choose my indian things before choosing foreign things but hollywood movies, foreign series, anime, manga are just best then 99% of indian movie still there 1% which are good but overall nahhhh
You should make a video on the failure of the Indian cricket team's failure to win an ICC tournament. A detailed and deep analysis on how BCCI's greed and politics is causing this failure.
It's not BCCI'S fault that the Indian team lost in the World Cup finals in front of more than 1 lakh people on home soil. They are chokers, can't handle the ultimate pressure and as such they deserved to lose. Simple as that.
Mohak bro, like always great research and analysis. But, unfortunately, the subtitles are not working for this video.
It's reflecting in Hindi [auto-generated].
Kindly make a look into it, so non-hindi speakers can also enjoy this video.
Jawaan was produced by Srk own production company red chillies .
So Srk kiyu paise lega , sara movie ka collection to usi ke pass ayega😂
Ek Srk Sab South Walon Se Bhari😂
Thalapathy Vijay stardom 😂😂😂😂
@@mrgurujifact4525 Thalapathy Vijay Stardom Hai Par Sirf 1Din Ke Liye
Most of the profit of Bollywood came from Remakes!
Inflated numbers of movies like Pathaan and Jawan just to prove a point that this Hakla s “King”