Police stop me from filming Q153......5-22-2013
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 чер 2013
- In Pulaski NY in the Tops Parking lot Filming the Q152 a Police Officer stops me from filming in a public parking lot. The train had 32 cars. The audio explains it all...And For More Info See My Vid Titled A Day on the CSX St-Lawrence Sub...7-19-2013.
- Авто та транспорт
Fact is it's not illegal to film trains while on public property. So long as you remain off the railroad's property, stay clear of traffic and even give the conductor a little wave, you likely won't hear a complaint. I work for a railroad. We know who railfans are.
The police have no reason to stop you if you aren't doing something illegal, holding up traffic or causing a disturbance. Engineers and conductors see railfans filming them all the time. A quick and simple wave is always appreciated. Anything more drastic could be interpreted as an emergency up ahead.
Enjoy your filming, have fun. The railroad is one heck of a place!
I got lucky when a cop pulled up and said “anything good coming” and I said we’re just waiting for something to come, then he said have a good day and left.
This is the problem with the USA. A cop demands id with no legal justification; the guy complies; the guy responds to the interrogation; and then the guy THANKS the officer. Wake up people.
John Thomas EXACTLY!
@John Thomas...there is a fine line, sometimes, between being a jerk, and just inquiry. Cops today, have it tough, with citizens who are jerks...and some cops, too. thanks.
Why did you I D
Do you have legal justification to be an ass? Some day you might be a crime victim but there's no officers to respond because of shortage because of people like you just being difficult.
They need to see who he is, and if they think this is suspicious activity they want to see if he has warrants ......not a hard concept
Railfanning is NO threat and NOT illegal!
that conversation would have been over when he asked me what i was doing... i don't owe him an explanation...
dahmeredsback So how should i handle this situation? What would you tell the cop? Would you give him your id?
it's very simple...if i'm not a criminal...i don't owe a cop any kind of explanation about myself... end of story....
dahmeredsback So you would tell the cop "i don't owe you any kind of explanation"?
of course...and you should always have a live stream going with any
police interaction.... if i'm not engaging in criminal activity...him
asking me what i'm doing..and who i am....is equivalent to the guy that
sold me a doughnut that morning asking me for my personal
information....none of your business....
There is evidently an intelligence test to become a Police Officer in Pulaski, NY. Tell him if you can't film trains, you'll go and film planes at the airport. And if he doesn't like that, ask him which police station he works at and tell him you'll be going to film there, due to your enthusiasm for police work.
First of all, ask am I being charged or detained?? If the answer is NO, exercise your fifth amendment rights to remain silent. Filming from public place is NOT ILLEGAL!!! If we the people keep giving up our rights, soon, we wont have any. BTW, I was a LEO for 18 years, been a rail fan 40 years and understand my rights.
Eggs-zackly!!
Mike Jones What is a "Leo"?
Law Enforcement Officer.
Hell yes ! You know the laws and I think he should have never done this maybe he was just wondering what was going on maybe trying to give a ticket or two for the extra bonus .😁
National security?
If I plan an attack I don't have to put in all that unnesecary effort of going to locations, taking pictures etc. The whole damn railroad network can be seen on Google maps!!!!
Moron Bush/Obama era fascists.
When I railfanned back in the '70's I'd get questioned by cops. It's nothing new. Wrong, but not new.
Why is it that everyone with a camera is labeled as a terrorist? This is just ridiculous. #StopRailfanHarrassment
why does this clip start with Dany D and Lauren form American Pickers.?
You did not have to show the officer[s] your ID. If that same situation ever happens again, politely inform them that you DO NOT consent to answering questions -or- providing identification unless they are charging you with a crime. If the officer[s] insist on you giving them your ID and answering their questions, just keep asking them if you are being detained or are free to go. Don't give in just because it's the easiest way out. Stand by your Constitutional Rights!
The only issue I've had with cops in regards to train watching was when I stopped to watch a then new CSX C60AC pull out of the yard and I was inadvertently 1 foot over the property line and I was trespassed by a CSX police idiot. I never got out of my car, and had no idea I was one foot onto CSX property. Except for that one time, in 65 plus years of railfanning, I've never been hassled. I used to have CR employees take me to see wrecks several times, and almost every train crew member and MOW knew my dog from his 14 years of being with me most of the time.
Hope you obtained his name & badge #. This kind of behavior should be reported. You weren't breaking the law!
Screw them if they get nervous that's the problem. I wouldn't have given him my Identification
I am actually very surprised that I've never had a police officer approach me when I'm railfanning. In fact, I've been railfanning and I had 3 Ontario Provincial Police cars with lights and sirens off, pass me at a crossing less then 10 minutes apart. I also had a scanner with me at the time and my older brother and I where both very surprised when none of them stopped to question us.
My advice to railfans out there: Always carry ID with you. I know it sounds weird, but trust me, you never know what might happen.
well that was in Canada where the police aren't power abusing dictators
Never carry ID, its crazy.
You do never have to show ID, never.
New York and California are poophole states though to be fair.
Somebody called in a complaint. Police had to check it out. Not the best situation. Neither party was at fault.
by contrast in japan, some railfan are in the middle of coupling operation, yet nobody seems to get angry
What's wrong with filming a passing train. It's not like it's a crime
Well, getting pulled by the cops was much more exciting than the boring train video
You should have filed a formal complaint against him.
he said he was on the job 26 years and never saw anybody filming trains. yea right. this guy must live inside a bubble.
CSX railroad cops have been a pain in the ass
Would kindly ask the cop to please name just ONE genuine terrorist attempt that has been made on a domestic cargo train .
That was pretty stupid. IT'S A PUBLIC PARKING LOT PEOPLE!!! There's no place in that parking lot to be trespassing! I agree with what everyone else said. To be honest, this railfanning and police stuff is confusing. Anyway, good catch.
A lot of cops are stupid. One cop made me miss a Union Pacific train.
Should have asked him for his name and badge # , then file a formal complaint ..... You owed him NOTHING !!
Yep, I sure get tired of explaining myself.
It's happened to me recently but I was never asked for any information.
This has happened to me at least 2 times.
Just curious what do you say when they approach you?
halfhumanhalfzombie Just that I wasn't tying to cause any harm what so ever to the railroad then they left me alone.
Sheesh, never once to me... I have no idea how many officers in cars and on foot have just smiled and waved... hmmm.....
why in the hell did you even cooperate with this thug.
Was this an actual CSX officer or a village, county or state officer?
Do not give them an ID...
I would not give them my ID and stuff they’re just trying to find stuff at that point. If you’re not committing a crime, just stand there and say I’m not speaking to you and tell them you’re right and if they don’t leave you alone sue them for constitutional rights violations, I don’t get why people are giving into it
why can't cops do their job like arresting thief's and criminals. In stead of messing with rail-fans. Almost forgot cops eat your doughnuts leave us alone and in peace.
thanks for sharing
You gave him your ID - shame on you.
You can legally film or photograph any thing or any body you can view from public property. Those cops are stupid as hell they violated your rights.
i would file a complaint on the officer for breaking my rights.
I am reading some of the comments about how people should never show their IDs or give out their reasons for filming trains but I actually think the opposite works better, at least where I live. One time I went railfanning and the cops were patrolling the train station. So I approached them, told them that I wanted to railfan and they actually gave me permission to film there. The one officer said that telling them ahead of time is actually better because then you do not come off as doing anything suspicious. And the other cop was a railfan in his off duty time and showed me his collection of train pictures over the years. Anytime I go there now, the cops and railroad employees are friendly to me. So sometimes you get friendly cops if you tell them ahead of time what is going on.
Considering the times this doesn't seem unreasonable. The cop was a little aggressive to start but it ended well if you ask me.
idiot
Russell Smith ya he didn't get shot. What that cop said is bs. Hard to respect cops when they lie to your face.
I film trains in the worst part of Houston every week and although alot of cops dont patrol that area because frankly it's abandoned and rundown when I do see cops they don't mind me a bit but that's because I'm not selling drugs or killing people hahaha
I only wish someone comes up to me and says something !
yeah like filming a empty train is a danger to national security the only thing their hauling was their own weight and diesel fuel
This cop is living in the dark ages before youtube. I know of at least 8 railfan channels and that's probably tip of the iceberg. To suggest railfans filming are involved in terrorism ("national security") is absurd.
Hey man you can video csx in my state
tops parking lot looks far enough away to be safe.
trains get nervous when you film them but in his 26 years as a cop he has never seen anyone film trains. What? Liar Liar LOL.
wow
First id refuse to i.d. second i would inform them of the constitution that protects my rights third id get badge and names and file a formal complaint.
Its a good thing you gave him your ID because then the situation would have gotten alot worse. In my opinion, nice job, keep up the good work
Wrong.
now ill be sick the rest of the day. educate the public and cops on our hobby.
How come planespotters don't get crap because of all this 9/11 crap but railfans can't pull out a small camera?
I bet the loco conductor called the cops on him or her
Blame Terrorism!
A lot of train crews calls in anybody they see with a camera near the tracks-its fun for them knowing a railfan (that's putting it nicely) is being hassled. by the police.
Why?
Train crews don't like being photograph period and usually don't like "stupid train buffs"..
thank you. you actually get it
There are many train crews, in particular in the past, who did not care if railfans took pictures or video. The problem is that minority of railfans who are rude, trespass or post videos second-guessing the very people they are following. More and more railroaders are aware of railfans like Millineum Force who trespass, set up simulated dangerous events or criticize when they do not know what they are talking about. So when you wonder why railroaders treat you with a cold shoulder.....look no further than people like this sick dude
False. Stop being autistic and making stuff up.
Natn'l S'curity, sure.
WTF Police!!
It's not a legal reason to contact someone. Officer's violating the man's rights
police hate railfans
Not be saying "yes sir" when asked if they take the cuffs off will they stop running their mouths.
Is this country going to split soon or what? I’m not fighting again.
why didn't you film their faces its your constitutional right to and don't give them your ID without asking why and tell them no if they insist and your on public property ask them for their personal ID and their badge number they HAVE to give you their number and it always helps to get their faces and remember stand up against the police remember you control them they don't control you.
welcome.to.freedom!!!!!!
I dow it some times
Kentucky
The police over in my state don't care
They won't bother you
Kentucky is a free state
Why did you show that cop your ID. Nervous? Somebody filming me in a engine never bothered me. One guy was standing on the track getting ready to take a head on shot of the engine and when he was just about ready to click the picture I hit the horn. He almost dropped his camera. We thought that was funny as hell. A few minutes later the fat female guard came out and started giving him a hard time. Later on we said to each other "we should of invited him onto the train"
26 years on the job and you're the first guy. He's a F'ing liar!
You're also doing a constitutionally protected activity.
FOR WHAT PURPOSE???? BECAUSE I PLAN TO BLOW UP THE NEXT TRAIN AND I NEED TO MAKE PLANS....... IS THIS THE FREEDOM WE ALLOW TO BE LOST??? "I'TS NONE OF YOUR FUCKING BUSINESS, GOOD NIGHT" DO I NEED A REASON AND WHY DOES IT CONCERN YOU?? IF I WAS UP TO NO GOOD I WOULD HIDE IN THE WOODS AND FILM FROM THERE.
He asked you questions he had no business asking. You did not have to provide ID, even. Just saying.
I'd never tell you what to do in a situation like that. Every time can be different. He had no probable cause to ask you anything at all. A call from a "concerned neighbor" is not probable cause when your activities are plain to see. Your entire conversation with him was actually totally voluntary on your part.
Just be nice.
He didn’t stop you from filming. He just asked what you were doing. What is wrong with that? I which someone had asked the 9/11 terrorists what they were doing.
That's because we are all potential domestic terrorist now, I don't know about you, but felt safer when I was on my own, than having big brother watching over me.