$128 vs $1460 Fly rod and reel comparison (Epic vs MaxCatch)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 16 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 27

  • @509bunnyhaven
    @509bunnyhaven 11 місяців тому +4

    I have found that these maxcatch glass rods are better at lower wt. my steelhead rod is a 6wt s-glass has a similar feel to a 7wt graphite rod which is kind of unforgiving. I now own a maxcatch unic 5wt and all i can say is wow, this is a medium speed, full bend, well balanced rod....like a traditional glass rod of the past. if your not in love with the cheaper glass rods they offer, try the unic, it casts similarly to redington butterstick, echo bad ass glass or orvis superfine glass.

    • @3runjosh
      @3runjosh 6 місяців тому +1

      ha! i was doing so much research around the unic and there is barely anything out there. I wanted the 4 wt but in the end I ordered the 3 wt glass overlined with 4wt line because I just didn't trust the unic bend to be full or not. I asked customer service so many times but the communication barrier between languages got me no where. On the product page it says the unic is fast action and you say medium. Maybe I will get a unic later on thanks for the info.

    • @notkeet
      @notkeet 2 місяці тому +1

      @@3runjoshi’m thinking of buying the 5wt unic too

    • @3runjosh
      @3runjosh 3 дні тому

      @@notkeet now I am thinking about 5wt unic!

  • @SRussy4325
    @SRussy4325 Місяць тому

    Thanks for the review.
    There is a lot of gear snobbery in fly fishing and ridiculous prices charged for gear and equipment. Reels are a prime example, a bit like watches, you can pay a hundred bucks for one that does exactly the same as one that costs many times more and the only difference is the bling factor.

  • @cattaraugustonawanda4426
    @cattaraugustonawanda4426 3 роки тому +6

    When I started flyfishing in the early 1990s I bought the cheapest rod I could find since I didn't know if FF would be my thing. That caught a number of fish in spite of being a beast to cast. I graduated to low end rods by major manufacturers that were better casting rods but still not expensive. The only thing I don't like about the Maxcatch is the color since white rod may spook fish in some situations. Otherwise Maxcatch would serve someone on a budget very well. I think a lot of people get caught up in the fancy rod thing when money might be better spent on other necessities

    • @SurgeonFishing
      @SurgeonFishing  3 роки тому +2

      Yeah completely agree with that. I’ve got no problems using it to catch fish. For starters I would recommend it for it, one of the cheapest setup in the market

  • @TizianoMartelli
    @TizianoMartelli 4 місяці тому +1

    Hi, I saw the very nice video, I wanted to know if you know the Italian tlt casting technique invented by Roberto Pragliola and what do you think if it is applicable to the equipment tested, greetings

    • @SurgeonFishing
      @SurgeonFishing  4 місяці тому

      @@TizianoMartelli I’m not familiar with the technique you mentioned, do you have a video of it?

    • @TizianoMartelli
      @TizianoMartelli 4 місяці тому

      tlt is a casting technique that uses light equipment dt 3 lines or 2 rods of 7 feet maximum 8 feet. Characteristic of this casting technique extremely clean and tense lines tight loops that allow you to enter the most difficult places, furthermore there are particular casts that allow you very long drifts of the fly.
      This technique also allows the fly to arrive first in the water with the angled cast that if done well is of absolute precision and silence, this technique was invented by the late Roberto Pragliola recognized worldwide for the videos you should find on the swisse tlt school or sim italia sim technique where you can also find a manual of explanations of this technique.

    • @TizianoMartelli
      @TizianoMartelli 4 місяці тому

      ua-cam.com/video/iIYCMJhcHbE/v-deo.html

    • @TizianoMartelli
      @TizianoMartelli 4 місяці тому

      ua-cam.com/video/aZQ-WnwS4RY/v-deo.html This in the video makes you understand what this technique allows you to where you can place the fly with a tight and controlled loop -

  • @Nate4kay
    @Nate4kay Рік тому +1

    Buying this exact set up because I love fishing but don’t really know if I’ll get into FF. I don’t even know how! 😂 but way I see it is if I like it and it becomes my new way of fishing.
    Just like regular fishing I’ll end up buying more expensive gear

  • @todd-617
    @todd-617 2 місяці тому +1

    I don't think the fish I've caught know where my rods were built. I'm not a fly rod snob.

  • @BlackWarriorLures
    @BlackWarriorLures 2 роки тому

    Solid information.

  • @smitbar11
    @smitbar11 2 роки тому +1

    Interesting video. I have a £200 fibreglass rod which is quite nice, its a decent quality Chinese made rod, fishes with a medium speed / action, not far behind my USA made £500 Orvis carbon rod if truth be told.
    How did you find the two reels? Was the 'Maxcatch' reel decent?

    • @SurgeonFishing
      @SurgeonFishing  2 роки тому +1

      I think MaxCatch is a great rod for starting out. But will never be my favourite rod, the material used is too heavy.
      The reel is fine, nice and light. And it’s cheap

  • @charlespalmer5807
    @charlespalmer5807 Рік тому

    Love my epic rod

  • @ronuhlenhopp5819
    @ronuhlenhopp5819 Рік тому

    There are easy ways to add weight to your Maxcatch reel to balance it perfectly with your Maxcatch rod.

  • @beachcaster56
    @beachcaster56 2 роки тому +3

    I own many top brand fishing rods...........but I get great pleasure in out-fishing the guys with all the gear and no idea with a £30 complete kit from a cheap supermarket. Thats a reel a line and a rod for £30.......Expensive golf clubs don't make you a better golfer..and expensive rods/reels/lines wont catch you more fish.

    • @nicholas2941
      @nicholas2941 2 роки тому

      I still use a rod and reel from the 90’s

  • @Iheartmyson
    @Iheartmyson Рік тому

    I also was curious, so i have the Maxcatch glass in a #3 . It casts so nice. So ordered the #6. They used to sell them for a #5 wieght . That was the weight I wanted. Also the #5 from M.C is a bit shorter than their #6. Anyway, I have see m cast with eas close as well as the complete flyline out! The 3 weight is also faster than the Epic but comes closer for comparison

  • @manko717
    @manko717 3 місяці тому

    Thought you were doing a fictional test / showing the reels - not fishing

  • @flokijhdfjkvnhsdfjkl
    @flokijhdfjkvnhsdfjkl 26 днів тому

    come on Fiberglass VS carbon way different feel

  • @christinealesi6759
    @christinealesi6759 2 роки тому

    Buy the Maxcatch and you had better learn to kowtow. Also you won't have a job so $40 bucks won't be so cheap then.

    • @taycemcintier6337
      @taycemcintier6337 Рік тому +5

      What are you even talking about senpai??

    • @todd-617
      @todd-617 2 місяці тому +1

      @@taycemcintier6337 Just someone who thinks that because a company says it's an American rod company that all their rods are built in America.