So refreshing to hear the great Dr Gilbert Doctorow on his geopolitical opinions together with Nima the maestro’s in charge of the university of knowledge and wisdom. Thank you gentlemen for your efforts. The chalice of victory is already in Russia’s hands over Nato and Nazism.
If you mean Nazism to mean NA-tional ZI-onism, then yes. Otherwise you are running cover for the usual suspect. Nevertheless, I got to hand it to you, you have most of the goyim fooled.
Last week, a new decree was issued by Russian President Putin, it is called "Decree on the provision of humanitarian support to persons who share traditional Russian spiritual and moral values." And it says that foreigners who share traditional Russian values will be able to apply for a residence permit in Russia: excluding quotas; without knowledge of the Russian language; without knowledge of Russian history; without knowledge of the basics of the legislation of the Russian Federation These can be both people with foreign citizenship and stateless people who came to us from countries that impose "destructive neoliberal ideological attitudes that contradict our values." The list of such countries should be approved by the Government within a month on the proposal of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation. So I think English will be heard on the streets of Moscow much more often. Most importantly, this permit allows you to work in Russia legally.
Yes but does not apply for people just want to come to Russia and live on social assistance and people that want to apply their own rights, their own rules.
@@ranojutro426 You speak as people are intentionally want to do that. I vouch for all people to earn their living through work but actions of west and greedy corporates plays a major role in such a crisis.... Some set of countries are targeted and bombed for the west political gains while other sets are looted to the core which makes these people are no where to go and starved off their chance to do anything. Look at India, even though it's bombed or looted like Middle east, Africa... it has one of the fastest migration rate when you consider the developing economies... people are surrendering their citizenship and passport after they gain other country resident status.... People are fleeing in mass numbers that inclusive of illegalls as well. People from India, Pakistan come on legal route and overstay which needs to be addressed as well
That is great! I have been trying to learn Russian on my own for several years, but my family had very serious problems meanwhile. What I know about Russian history is fascinating. I have many books on the history that I haven't had a chance to read. My last family member passed away from natural causes a few months ago and I no longer have to help with the medical problems, so I am free to do whatever I like. I truly detest what my country is becoming and I have been chained to a huge iron ball of Socialism here which has had me on a leash of 30 days to get my medications. I lived for a while in Mexico and Guatemala. I or my Dad had to return to the US every 30 days for my medications or else have terrible problems. I know so much more about the unending decades of evil done here before my father was even born and he was 79. If I cannot go there, I speak very fluent Spanish so that I have many options. My lease finishes in just a little over a month which means I have no legal or moral reasons to hold out with this any longer. I just want to work, have a nice enough place to live and just be content with life.
as someone said on alex jones, 'westerners and russians share 99% traditional values' so it's only natual when you are being arrested for 'not embracing transgenderism' (whatever that means), or arrested for meming your national flag, or whatever crazy new action, then it seems russia has more in common with traditions and values in the west, than the globalists who have no regard for local sovereignty and who clearly hate regular, working class people
if I were forced to choose only one analyst to follow that’d be Dr. Gilbert Doctorow. Logical, objective, clear communication without glorification of any side. Excellent interview, congratulations Nima for the selection of guests.
But there is no logic and not objective. All this statement is wishful thinking of dr. Doctorow. Nothing else. He just told that after reading some of text in FT there is a plot. It's childish. Waste of time.
Such a deep knowledge of just every angle of politics, Dr. Doctorow! Your analysis of the German political changes is to the point, Ms. Wagenknecht is the only one to count upon.
Education takes lots of time, money and effort. Everyone is getting educated now in Russia, Woke West, Global South and Ukraine. If Russia did USA thing by destroying and occupying Ukraine in couple of months in 2022 Russia would have big problems now, but by thanking time and saving infrastructure and people of Ukraine the people are having time to be educated in what’s really going on. Long live Putin, Putin knows that after war comes time where people have to live with one another and everyone’s record of past behaviour will be exposed. People around the world think differently today then they did in summer of 2022, that’s education.
Nima wears the same style shirt every day. At least it’s a different color. You ask good questions sir, and allow your guests to talk. You’re one of the best in indi media. Please keep it up.
Correction: Mongolia did participate in the war against Japan in Халхын гол 1939. Approx 300 Mongolian soldiers died, almost 800 soldiers were wounded. During this war The Soviet army under General Georgy Zhukov ( who became Marshal later) learned a lot from many ancient Mongolian war strategies, which were subsequently used successfully in the WW2.
The doctor is such a brilliant man who like most of us want peace desperately. He's smart enough to understand what the consequences are, and they're not good at all.
To me the good Dr is a welcome voice in this space. But I say be aware that he specifically said that he and PCR are 'completely' aligned in their thinking. Of course that cannot be 100% but to me PCR represents some of the harder stances that the Dr aligns with, but has chosen not to give his voice to...yet
There is one episode Dr Gilbert forgot to mention about Mongolia: 1939 & Battle of Khalkhin Gol where both Soviets & Mongolia fought the Japanese. Pivotal moment as this was at the same time as Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact & an event totally alien to the West. Red Army was fighting Japan at that time & Stalin needed peace in the West!
I really appreciate Dr. Doctorow‘s knowledge and perspective. I just wish he had a slightly better microphone (didn’t seem to be an issue last time). Btw, 15 million is €150K (not 15) 🙏🙂✌️
@@MegaBoolaBoolaSo, I wasn’t the only one noticing the miscalculation of currency exchange, while also struggling with the quality of Dr’s microphone, which badly affected my listening comprehension.
Thanks for explaining how exactly the first F-16 was destroyed. It's amazing how the fog of the official "information" in the West "covered" this story. Waiting for the next F-16 show!
For them, any variant of shooting down that plane is bad. They simply don't even know which variant is worse, when neither one is good. Therefore, fog is the best option in a given situation. We have no idea what the fuck is fog, we can't see anything.
Wouldn't 15 million Rubles be over 150,000 Euros? Your point about Russian enlistment surging after the Kursk invasion/incursion is very astute. Thanks for a great and reasoned discussion of the topics.
Informative information for knowledge seekers listening is an important asset. GET INFORMED THROUGH THE PROCESS OF LEARNING VERY IMPORTANT FOR OWNING OWN GOOD KNOWLEDGE CONCLUTIONS LEARNED. CONTINUE LISTENING. GOOD LUCK.
HISTORY OF UK AND CRIMEA READ ABOUT THE CRIMEAN WAR THERE FLORENCE NIGHTINGALE WAS SCTIVE,OR THE POEM BY LORD TENNYSON ON CRIMEAN WAR. GET MORE INFORMED THIS WAY TOO. GOOD LUCK.
NATO is not a defensive alliance. They illegally bombed Yugoslavia (direct violation of the UN Charter). We must never forget what they did to Afghanistan, Libya, Iraq, Syria etc NATO needs to understand that playing Russian roulette with a nuclear superpower is never a good idea
Vladimir Zelensky said that the country's armed forces (AFU) plan to hold the occupied territories in the Kursk region. This was stated by the Ukrainian leader in an interview with NBC News. "Ukraine will "hold" the territory, as this is an integral part of the "victory plan" to end the war," the publication reports Zelensky's words.🤣😂
Systems are at War! | Never blame individual leaders and their followers; that's no solution at all. | Jus let the smart people think of good ideas to end it.
Doctorow explains why Russia did not "take all Donbas" in 2014. They weren't strong enough a local fight and not sure of loca loyalties, but after the Nazi massacres and atrocities of 8 yrs Russia was strong enough and confident of local support. Sad but necessary delay.
Dr. Doctorow's manner of speaking requires the best quality audio equipment. Difficult to hear and understand. I turn on the transcript and follow along.
Dude, i am always suffering when waiting for u to deliver the question. Please write up ur questions before the show and write them Shorter and deliver more promptly
Zelensky didn't try to prevent the conflict through diplomacy because he lacks honor and integrity. In 2014 there was a coup. Soon after, there was a massacre in Odessa (dozens of people were burned alive). Ethnic Russians living in Ukraine were treated as subhuman. Their language and culture was being oppressed. A civil war broke out due to the rise in ethnic tensions. For 8 years the Ukrainian military was indiscriminately shelling civilians living in Donbas. If Zelensky honored the Minsk agreement and pledged neutrality, none of this would have happened. The 8 year civil war would have ended and Donbas would have remained part of Ukraine. War is the ultimate failure of diplomacy. Zelensky, Poroshenko, Merkel and Hollande admitted that Ukraine had no intention to honor the Minsk agreements. Who didn't want peace? Who advised against the 2022 peace talks in April? Hint: someone visited Zelensky in Kiev at that time Russia's national security was compromised once NATO began to expand eastwards. Russia clearly stated that Ukraine joining NATO was a red line (November 2021) and unfortunately this concern was never taken seriously. The Russians openly stated: if nothing changes, we will be forced to act in order to defend our national security. Enhancing the national security of one country at the expense of another is unacceptable. The Russians have legitimate security concerns. 20th September, 2021: Ukraine launched military drills with US and NATO. NATO is not a defensive alliance. NATO illegally bombed Yugoslavia (a direct violation of the U.N. Charter). We should never forget what they did to Libya, Afghanistan, Iraq etc. Who blew up the pipeline causing an environmental disaster? Zelensky banned all opposition and arrested a leading priest. Zelensky tried to invoke article 5 under false pretenses. Remember the incident in Poland. Ethnic Russians living in Ukraine were treated as subhuman. Their language and culture was being oppressed. Poroshenko said, “Our children will go to schools and kindergartens-theirs will hide in the basements”. Russians will never forget the 2014 Odessa massacre. The whole world needs to know about it. Why was Denis Kireev eliminated? He was a member of Ukraine's negotiating team during the peace negotiations. He wanted to help his country. Ukraine has a hit list. They target artists, journalists and ordinary citizens. Hundreds of children are on this list. 13 year old Faina Savenkova was placed on this list. Pink Floyd's Roger Waters is on this list. Jimmy Dore (American stand-up comedian, podcaster) and Aaron Maté (Canadian writer and journalist) are on this list. There is evidence that Ukrainian troops have been indiscriminately shelling civilians in Donbas (they used petal mines and targeted areas where there was no military presence). The azov troops trapped in the azovstal steelworks in Mariupol used human shields. They refused to allow civilians to leave despite of humanitarian corridors being present. Russia held a proposed cease fire in order for the civilians to leave, but azov would not allow the civilians to leave. Ukraine has committed many acts of terrorism (car bombs and other forms of assassination). Darya Dugina (journalist) R.I.P. The first terrorist attack on the Kerch bridge killed the truck driver and the individuals in the adjacent car (innocent civilian victims). The second terrorist attack on the Kerch bridge killed two parents and severely injured their young daughter. I have done a lot of research and it took me a long time to write this comment. I have stated a lot of facts and I have given my honest opinion. I have provided a brief summary of events that took place. In order to explain this whole situation in great detail, a book would need to be written. Hopefully someone will write an UNBIASED book, stating facts and allowing the readers to form their own judgments. Everything I said can be fact checked and verified.
@@soniavadnjal7553 A new game changer every interview with another Russian propagandist/collaborator. Take your pick this freak Gilbert, that traitor Ritter, that another traitor collaborator McGovern. Its a circle-jerk. Same hosts hosting same guests in a round r0bin circle jerk. THose guests have no credibility in the wider world. No one listens to them. They have nothing to contribute except pro-Putin, anti-American, anti-West, anti-Israel propaganda.
If there was a game-changer in this discussion it wasn't stated explicitly. Doctor Gilbert Doctorow gives an interesting overview of events in Ukraine between 2014 and 2022. Interestingly Dr Doctorow thinks that Zelensky will be on the way out very soon.
If and when this is all over, the nations of the world should consider adopting a new universal foreign policy of love before war, or to put it more bluntly, pre-martial sex.
@soniavadnjal7553 Look it up. He was co signing some Russian who didn't have a clue. I don't know who it's hard to believe. Not all are unbiased. He jumped on the same bandwagon as Pepe.
@@geerowr.6666if it were all so rosey for the Russians in Kursk Ukrainians would be long pushed back by now, Martyanov has a lot of insight but he's too emotionally driven and tends to idealize the state of things for Russians, fact is that they were caught off guard there and that always causes some amount of pain
JASSM missles are said to be going to Ukraine, will not make much of a difference since they are launched from jets. I can see these been shot down by the Russians before they have reached their target.
Caro Dima, vejo muitas vezes o seu programa que é super. Também me faz espécie e gostava de saber das razões porque os ingleses são tão azedos com os russos.
The British Empire hoped to conquer Russia, the "Heartland" of Asia and the key to world domination. See Halford Mackinder. Then, on 09 Nov 1917, the Bolsheviks pulled Russia out of WW I, leaving the British to fight alone. Unforgiveable!
Well, I picked the challenge to put my finances in order. Then I invested in cryptocurrency and stocks, through the assistance of my discretionary fund manager
The first step to successful investment is figuring your goals and risk tolerance either on your own or with the help of a financial professional but it's very advisable you make use of professional
@@r.w.emersonii3501 maybe but i didnt hear nothing about this on RU media, you know they have big reward if they do this, but who knows. I know only one fact in war is hard to shoot down own airplane IFF do not let you, you can push button but rocket will not shoot out and this is old technology from 60-70 today is even better and codes are predefinited for all month ahead so or Ukros antiair defense is pure trained, i doubt this mistake will be done in war situation. Maybe ukros put wrong code in IFF system.
Min 16:30 ff 15 Mio Rubles are about 150.000 €! the change ratio nis not 1:1000 just 1:100! But the offer is just 1.5 Mio Rubles so the 15.000 € is the real reward. If it was mistakenly shut down by "friendly fire" - I don't expect Moscow will grant the money to the UA-soldier - and we will have another prove, that Russia does not keep it's word! :-)))
whenever there is uncertainty in gas and oil prices because of "stress" such as conflicts, London stock exchange makes money and so does lloyds of London, insurance.
It's a complex geopolitical chess board these days. A veritable clash of titans. Victoria prodded the sleeping bear, who awoke and is slashing back on many fronts. Ukraine will be known as Victorias war, and it will be seen as the pivot to a multipolar world, or as the last gasps of a dying empire. A world directed by the greed of oligarchs will change to one directed by the producers of the world, such as Russia, India, or China and so many more. The producing countries can and likely will cut off the West when full on war with Russia is started. Without parts of all manor, society will crash like a bus without a driver. It won't be pretty. I hope the people at the top can just stop all these shenanigans and start cooperating again. Why do they all need to control the world. We can all manage our daily affairs without their wars. Right?
"I hope the people at the top can just stop all these shenanigans." Which people are you referring to? The way they behave, many of them could not be called human.
Great post. I often think of how history will write today 100 years from now (If we still exist). What you wrote is pretty spot on, love the term "Victorias war". This will only get written if the West falls down, because if not, it will be buried just like the past 200 years of darker history that they've quietly shoved under the rug. However, I think the people at the top are no different than Kim Jong Un. Sitting at the very top, with inflated egos, and with total indignation towards regular people, I could totally see them suiciding the whole thing, meaning as in, the world itself, because of how shallow their character is and how spineless their backs are. Having reached such high positions, one will many times begin to tell themselves they worked hard to be where they are, and their positions are justified. Hence why we rarely hear an apology from anyone anymore. I hope I'm wrong.
China has cut off the sale of rare-earth minerals to the West. This seems to be having a sobering effect on the U.S.. The minerals are needed for chip production.
At 22:10: If Germany (now when also France is so weak) succumbs to democracy (not the Western version of 'democracy' which means that Amercia dictates the rest of the world around) and starts to listen to the people and their votes (when Mr. Scholz has been called out)...I think that Europe will collapse, i.e., the 'leaders' or the followers or the servile followers of Washington who now are the head of the major governments in Europe, they will go. And I think the EU institutions headed by von der Leyen will be drained of their power by forces like the one Orbán has been organizing in the European Parliament. So I think this is the way there will be a change (replacing the so-called leaders), and not in a distant future. (Putin visited Mongolia on the second of September which is the anniversary day of the end of WWII, that is to say the unconditional surrender of Japan, in which Mongolia was very helpful to the Russian Red Army in their fight against the Japanese.) ~ Gilbert Doctorow
Україна - це дівчина, яка погуляла на Заході і після багатьох образ, принижень та обіцянок на ній одружитися, виснажена - лише із залишками колишньої краси, голодна, по вуха у боргах і вагітна вoнa повертається додому, до рідної Матінки... Добре якщо повернеться сама, дитину на ноги поставить, а от якщо ще й цей весь непотріб за собою притягне, то біда ще й Mатінці.
The average citizen in the USA is feeling the reality of supporting Ukraine with dollars they need for food, shelter, healthcare and transportation without anything extra for their children's education and a much needed vacation. This cash cow is almost milked dry and Ukraine needs to look for another sugar daddy. Deutschland ?Any geld left for Zelensky? His wife has payments to make on NY City property.
the time will come when Russia will send a message that will be clearly understood by the western world, just have to feel sorry for the recipient who will get this message.
Belated comments on issues linked, Mongolia and Turkey. My understanding is that China is not keen now on having gas pipeline going through Mongolia following what is seen as much cosy-ing up to the west by Mongolia. Turkey is almost a synonym for deceit so the so-called BRICS application is meaningless. After recent Turkish elections, it took clear pro US/west stance ie coming off the fence. This actually failed to gain any benefits as both US and Russia have stopped being played off against each other. Putin has delayed claimed visit to Turkey for nearly a year now and in many respects has kept a distance (perhaps following Azov betrayal). Turkey does help Russia but only when it benefits Turkey. In sum, this notion of being 'independent' is not possible - US will not allow it and Russia can choose alternative partners. Turkey is actually in mess at moment although temporarily benefitting from Ukraine war. After Modi paying homage to Zelensky, I am sure Russia will be more circumspect.
It is amazing if not incredible how these Russians are so accurate with these missiles. The Russians can land that missile on a half dollar in a parking lot anywhere in the country of Ukraine and who knows where else ? I mean they can even hit moving freaking targets with these missiles how in the hell are they doing that . I mean these are remote control drones some of these things but these missiles how do they do that ? I've watched the other websites and they show that the Russians can see all of Ukraine now I'm sure we have the same NATO has probably the same thing I just wish this war was over and stopped all this suffering and for what??? It's time for Ukraine and the United States and the NATO countries to stop count our losses and move on. This was a bad decision that should never been made especially when there was negotiations earlier that were successful that were interrupted. And there was a lot of backstabbing and dirty tricks of being played all the way up till zelensky became the president this is Joe Biden's blunder he could have stopped this . Kamala Harris. She could have helped in this. I'm afraid if she is elected she's going to run around thinking she has something to prove and I worry she's going to bite off more than she can chew is there any dangerous world and there's always a way to negotiations to settle things without having to kill each other !!! I really fear if Kamala Harris is elected I pray to God not !!!!
Fulbright scholar, educated in the west, enjoyed the perks during the time when USSR had fallen and the vultures of the west and the Russian oligarchs were bleeding Russia.... no wonder, I sense some kind of anti Russian framework there. Your surname may sound Russian but you are not .
Should be different. We are supposed to learn from our past, from our mistakes and not do it again. We are supposed to defend our self but not revenge. Revenge is big sin it is equal to pre meditate murder. We are supposed to forgive each other, love each other, and work together
So refreshing to hear the great Dr Gilbert Doctorow on his geopolitical opinions together with Nima the maestro’s in charge of the university of knowledge and wisdom. Thank you gentlemen for your efforts. The chalice of victory is already in Russia’s hands over Nato and Nazism.
If you mean Nazism to mean NA-tional ZI-onism, then yes. Otherwise you are running cover for the usual suspect. Nevertheless, I got to hand it to you, you have most of the goyim fooled.
At this point, NATO is willing to work with Nazis to fight Russia. Biden took the Azov off the terror list
Last week, a new decree was issued by Russian President Putin, it is called "Decree on the provision of humanitarian support to persons who share traditional Russian spiritual and moral values."
And it says that foreigners who share traditional Russian values will be able to apply for a residence permit in Russia:
excluding quotas;
without knowledge of the Russian language;
without knowledge of Russian history;
without knowledge of the basics of the legislation of the Russian Federation
These can be both people with foreign citizenship and stateless people who came to us from countries that impose "destructive neoliberal ideological attitudes that contradict our values."
The list of such countries should be approved by the Government within a month on the proposal of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs of the Russian Federation. So I think English will be heard on the streets of Moscow much more often. Most importantly, this permit allows you to work in Russia legally.
Yes but does not apply for people just want to come to Russia and live on social assistance and people that want to apply their own rights, their own rules.
@@ranojutro426 You speak as people are intentionally want to do that. I vouch for all people to earn their living through work but actions of west and greedy corporates plays a major role in such a crisis.... Some set of countries are targeted and bombed for the west political gains while other sets are looted to the core which makes these people are no where to go and starved off their chance to do anything.
Look at India, even though it's bombed or looted like Middle east, Africa... it has one of the fastest migration rate when you consider the developing economies... people are surrendering their citizenship and passport after they gain other country resident status.... People are fleeing in mass numbers that inclusive of illegalls as well. People from India, Pakistan come on legal route and overstay which needs to be addressed as well
It’s Best to Recruit ppl that Share: Values, Morals & Spiritual Faiths. Not like the West wanting to Totally Change their Faith & Culture!
That is great! I have been trying to learn Russian on my own for several years, but my family had very serious problems meanwhile. What I know about Russian history is fascinating. I have many books on the history that I haven't had a chance to read. My last family member passed away from natural causes a few months ago and I no longer have to help with the medical problems, so I am free to do whatever I like. I truly detest what my country is becoming and I have been chained to a huge iron ball of Socialism here which has had me on a leash of 30 days to get my medications. I lived for a while in Mexico and Guatemala. I or my Dad had to return to the US every 30 days for my medications or else have terrible problems. I know so much more about the unending decades of evil done here before my father was even born and he was 79.
If I cannot go there, I speak very fluent Spanish so that I have many options. My lease finishes in just a little over a month which means I have no legal or moral reasons to hold out with this any longer. I just want to work, have a nice enough place to live and just be content with life.
as someone said on alex jones, 'westerners and russians share 99% traditional values' so it's only natual when you are being arrested for 'not embracing transgenderism' (whatever that means), or arrested for meming your national flag, or whatever crazy new action, then it seems russia has more in common with traditions and values in the west, than the globalists who have no regard for local sovereignty and who clearly hate regular, working class people
I can set my watch to Gilbert's voice. Lucid, succinct, and always on point. Thanks. 😊
Yeh, if you can hear what he is saying with his cheap boomy microphone.
The audio quality is so bad I can't understand what he is saying...!!!
if I were forced to choose only one analyst to follow that’d be Dr. Gilbert Doctorow. Logical, objective, clear communication without glorification of any side. Excellent interview, congratulations Nima for the selection of guests.
Send Nima some cash so he can get a proper decent microphone for Doctorow. He desperately needs one.
But there is no logic and not objective. All this statement is wishful thinking of dr. Doctorow. Nothing else. He just told that after reading some of text in FT there is a plot. It's childish. Waste of time.
Such a deep knowledge of just every angle of politics, Dr. Doctorow! Your analysis of the German political changes is to the point, Ms. Wagenknecht is the only one to count upon.
As always, Dr, Doctorow is brilliant!
What an intelligent guest!
Education takes lots of time, money and effort. Everyone is getting educated now in Russia, Woke West, Global South and Ukraine. If Russia did USA thing by destroying and occupying Ukraine in couple of months in 2022 Russia would have big problems now, but by thanking time and saving infrastructure and people of Ukraine the people are having time to be educated in what’s really going on. Long live Putin, Putin knows that after war comes time where people have to live with one another and everyone’s record of past behaviour will be exposed. People around the world think differently today then they did in summer of 2022, that’s education.
That's right.
Nima wears the same style shirt every day. At least it’s a different color. You ask good questions sir, and allow your guests to talk. You’re one of the best in indi media. Please keep it up.
Not sure what the shirt style has to do with the presentation??? It is not meant to be a fashion show but a serious discussion.
Correction: Mongolia did participate in the war against Japan in Халхын гол 1939. Approx 300 Mongolian soldiers died, almost 800 soldiers were wounded. During this war The Soviet army under General Georgy Zhukov ( who became Marshal later) learned a lot from many ancient Mongolian war strategies, which were subsequently used successfully in the WW2.
The doctor is such a brilliant man who like most of us want peace desperately. He's smart enough to understand what the consequences are, and they're not good at all.
To me the good Dr is a welcome voice in this space. But I say be aware that he specifically said that he and PCR are 'completely' aligned in their thinking. Of course that cannot be 100% but to me PCR represents some of the harder stances that the Dr aligns with, but has chosen not to give his voice to...yet
@@pla9012 what is PCR?
@@fnaust Paul Craig Roberts
Thank you, gentlemen! 🙏🏻💪🙏🏻
Nima thank you.
You have the best questions! 👍
Brilliant interview. Thank you very much.
There's absolutely no reality about Zelenski's views. It's all US policy. Period!
When talking to Dr Gilbert Doctorow, it is always interesting to hear opposing views.
That's called using a "privileged binary". Please note it takes TWO to be "opposed", not one.
There is one episode Dr Gilbert forgot to mention about Mongolia: 1939 & Battle of Khalkhin Gol where both Soviets & Mongolia fought the Japanese. Pivotal moment as this was at the same time as Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact & an event totally alien to the West. Red Army was fighting Japan at that time & Stalin needed peace in the West!
I really appreciate Dr. Doctorow‘s knowledge and perspective. I just wish he had a slightly better microphone (didn’t seem to be an issue last time). Btw, 15 million is €150K (not 15) 🙏🙂✌️
I agree!! And put the microphone closer to his mouth. And close the door to his office to reduce background noise.
@@MegaBoolaBoolaSo, I wasn’t the only one noticing the miscalculation of currency exchange, while also struggling with the quality of Dr’s microphone, which badly affected my listening comprehension.
@@michaelkounine5347 Absolutely! I also noticed both of those oversights. Doctor Doctor is still pretty astute, though.
Thank you both, interesting interview.
Thanks for explaining how exactly the first F-16 was destroyed. It's amazing how the fog of the official "information" in the West "covered" this story. Waiting for the next F-16 show!
For them, any variant of shooting down that plane is bad. They simply don't even know which variant is worse, when neither one is good. Therefore, fog is the best option in a given situation. We have no idea what the fuck is fog, we can't see anything.
Wouldn't 15 million Rubles be over 150,000 Euros?
Your point about Russian enlistment surging after the Kursk invasion/incursion is very astute. Thanks for a great and reasoned discussion of the topics.
It is app. 150.000 $
One of the great truths of war, was spoken by Andrei Bolconsky in Tolstoy,s War and Peace, " the army that deals with the unexpected best will win".
Nima , Dr. Gilbert , great show ! Thanks ! 🖖
Díky!
Thank you both, excellent interview.
Pig Nuland vs Bear Putin are terrible odds.
Dont be mean!
Its "Ms" piggy Nuland.
@@Keine_Macht_fuer_Niemand😂🤣😂🤣
Nice work 👏
15:40 Kursk was a nation making event for Russia
16:30 just to clarify: 15 million rubles is roughly 150,000 euros, not 15,000 euros.
A pleasure to listen to Dr. Doctorow... Except for the poor quality of his microphone... Quite a contrast with Nima's...
The loss of Türkiye to NATO would be severe, indeed.
Informative information for knowledge seekers listening is an important asset.
GET INFORMED THROUGH THE PROCESS OF LEARNING VERY IMPORTANT FOR OWNING OWN GOOD KNOWLEDGE CONCLUTIONS LEARNED. CONTINUE LISTENING. GOOD LUCK.
HISTORY OF UK AND CRIMEA READ ABOUT THE CRIMEAN WAR THERE FLORENCE NIGHTINGALE WAS SCTIVE,OR THE POEM BY LORD TENNYSON ON CRIMEAN WAR.
GET MORE INFORMED THIS WAY TOO. GOOD LUCK.
Nima asks excellent questions.
Thanks guys for this great content God bless you both
Thank you
NATO is not a defensive alliance. They illegally bombed Yugoslavia (direct violation of the UN Charter). We must never forget what they did to Afghanistan, Libya, Iraq, Syria etc
NATO needs to understand that playing Russian roulette with a nuclear superpower is never a good idea
Excellent video guys.
Very enjoyable
Vladimir Zelensky said that the country's armed forces (AFU) plan to hold the occupied territories in the Kursk region. This was stated by the Ukrainian leader in an interview with NBC News.
"Ukraine will "hold" the territory, as this is an integral part of the "victory plan" to end the war," the publication reports Zelensky's words.🤣😂
😂😂
To be traded back in return for occupied Ukranian territory.
@@dkoz8321 🤣😂
Ukraine leader and nbc news and you believe that?
Keep in mind that there is an upsurge in contracts in Russia even though they are indefinite! Once you sign its until the end of SMO.
Get some!
SMO will end in 2025
Kier Starmer will keep sending money, at the expense of UK pensioners....
Systems are at War! | Never blame individual leaders and their followers; that's no solution at all. | Jus let the smart people think of good ideas to end it.
Doctorow explains why Russia did not "take all Donbas" in 2014. They weren't strong enough a local fight and not sure of loca loyalties, but after the Nazi massacres and atrocities of 8 yrs Russia was strong enough and confident of local support. Sad but necessary delay.
Dr. Doctorow's manner of speaking requires the best quality audio equipment.
Difficult to hear and understand.
I turn on the transcript and follow along.
Please request Mr Gilbert to use a better a Audio Mic so that his voice can be much clear. Thanks
Dude, i am always suffering when waiting for u to deliver the question. Please write up ur questions before the show and write them Shorter and deliver more promptly
same here, totally autistic
Zelensky didn't try to prevent the conflict through diplomacy because he lacks honor and integrity.
In 2014 there was a coup. Soon after, there was a massacre in Odessa (dozens of people were burned alive). Ethnic Russians living in Ukraine were treated as subhuman. Their language and culture was being oppressed. A civil war broke out due to the rise in ethnic tensions. For 8 years the Ukrainian military was indiscriminately shelling civilians living in Donbas.
If Zelensky honored the Minsk agreement and pledged neutrality, none of this would have happened. The 8 year civil war would have ended and Donbas would have remained part of Ukraine. War is the ultimate failure of diplomacy.
Zelensky, Poroshenko, Merkel and Hollande admitted that Ukraine had no intention to honor the Minsk agreements.
Who didn't want peace? Who advised against the 2022 peace talks in April? Hint: someone visited Zelensky in Kiev at that time
Russia's national security was compromised once NATO began to expand eastwards. Russia clearly stated that Ukraine joining NATO was a red line (November 2021) and unfortunately this concern was never taken seriously. The Russians openly stated: if nothing changes, we will be forced to act in order to defend our national security. Enhancing the national security of one country at the expense of another is unacceptable. The Russians have legitimate security concerns.
20th September, 2021: Ukraine launched military drills with US and NATO.
NATO is not a defensive alliance. NATO illegally bombed Yugoslavia (a direct violation of the U.N. Charter).
We should never forget what they did to Libya, Afghanistan, Iraq etc.
Who blew up the pipeline causing an environmental disaster?
Zelensky banned all opposition and arrested a leading priest.
Zelensky tried to invoke article 5 under false pretenses. Remember the incident in Poland.
Ethnic Russians living in Ukraine were treated as subhuman. Their language and culture was being oppressed.
Poroshenko said, “Our children will go to schools and kindergartens-theirs will hide in the basements”.
Russians will never forget the 2014 Odessa massacre. The whole world needs to know about it.
Why was Denis Kireev eliminated? He was a member of Ukraine's negotiating team during the peace negotiations. He wanted to help his country.
Ukraine has a hit list. They target artists, journalists and ordinary citizens. Hundreds of children are on this list. 13 year old Faina Savenkova was placed on this list.
Pink Floyd's Roger Waters is on this list. Jimmy Dore (American stand-up comedian, podcaster) and Aaron Maté (Canadian writer and journalist) are on this list.
There is evidence that Ukrainian troops have been indiscriminately shelling civilians in Donbas (they used petal mines and targeted areas where there was no military presence).
The azov troops trapped in the azovstal steelworks in Mariupol used human shields. They refused to allow civilians to leave despite of humanitarian corridors being present.
Russia held a proposed cease fire in order for the civilians to leave, but azov would not allow the civilians to leave.
Ukraine has committed many acts of terrorism (car bombs and other forms of assassination). Darya Dugina (journalist) R.I.P.
The first terrorist attack on the Kerch bridge killed the truck driver and the individuals in the adjacent car (innocent civilian victims).
The second terrorist attack on the Kerch bridge killed two parents and severely injured their young daughter.
I have done a lot of research and it took me a long time to write this comment. I have stated a lot of facts and I have given my honest opinion.
I have provided a brief summary of events that took place. In order to explain this whole situation in great detail, a book would need to be written.
Hopefully someone will write an UNBIASED book, stating facts and allowing the readers to form their own judgments. Everything I said can be fact checked and verified.
US is in charge of all aspects of this scenario.
It is self evident by the results
Just like everywhere else they get involved.
But Britain (The City of London enclave and the CFR) is in charge of the U.S..
What about cooperation between AFD and Wagenknecht?
OMG! NOT ANOTHER GAMECHANGER! I can't take anymore game changers! The game keeps changing every week.
Please explain
Um .. it's called improvising? Adapting to new situations? What do you think?
Keep this in mind, UA-camr is a business. They have to say whatever to attract viewership for their channel.
Man it is real it is not war game that you are playing on your computer. It is real human beings
@@soniavadnjal7553 A new game changer every interview with another Russian propagandist/collaborator. Take your pick this freak Gilbert, that traitor Ritter, that another traitor collaborator McGovern. Its a circle-jerk. Same hosts hosting same guests in a round r0bin circle jerk. THose guests have no credibility in the wider world. No one listens to them. They have nothing to contribute except pro-Putin, anti-American, anti-West, anti-Israel propaganda.
A wide spectrum of views is healthy. Most along such a wide spectrum of views have something to offer.
If there was a game-changer in this discussion it wasn't stated explicitly. Doctor Gilbert Doctorow gives an interesting overview of events in Ukraine between 2014 and 2022. Interestingly Dr Doctorow thinks that Zelensky will be on the way out very soon.
If and when this is all over, the nations of the world should consider adopting a new universal foreign policy of love before war, or to put it more bluntly, pre-martial sex.
We need to imagine, and visualize swirled peas. :)
🕊️🌏
...so, you are ready to launch your pork missile...
This guy is wrong, Russians already said that Ukraine cannot exist.
This guy was wrong last week about Russia almost losing. Wait til Andrei hears this. So there you go!
@@geerowr.6666When did he say that? Hard to believe.
@@geerowr.6666How to put it politely...? ;-)
@soniavadnjal7553 Look it up. He was co signing some Russian who didn't have a clue. I don't know who it's hard to believe. Not all are unbiased. He jumped on the same bandwagon as Pepe.
@@geerowr.6666if it were all so rosey for the Russians in Kursk Ukrainians would be long pushed back by now, Martyanov has a lot of insight but he's too emotionally driven and tends to idealize the state of things for Russians, fact is that they were caught off guard there and that always causes some amount of pain
15 million rubles is not $ 15.000. It is $ 150.000 .
15 million rubles are $150,000 US, not $15k
In fact, it's just north of $172K today.
This kind of reward can not be made public during active hostilities
What removal of Zelensky! He is not a president anymore!
Removal as DICTATOR.
We can't be certain of anything....well there is one certainty, I will never buy any product advertised on YT.
Note the sound of Mr Doctorow is not good. His microforn or the acoustics of his room? I can hear about 75% of what he says.
Gilbert needs a proper microphone!!! That room reverb is terrible.
Nima, your image is out of focus. What is worse, the sound of your guest’s voice is difficult to understand. Quite important, in my view.
agree
Sikorski is notorious for not having a filter; he shoots from the lip
oh, no, he's running out of Kool Aid
He's the mouthpiece for Anne Applebaum.
JASSM missles are said to be going to Ukraine, will not make much of a difference since they are launched from jets. I can see these been shot down by the Russians before they have reached their target.
Caro Dima, vejo muitas vezes o seu programa que é super. Também me faz espécie e gostava de saber das razões porque os ingleses são tão azedos com os russos.
The British Empire hoped to conquer Russia, the "Heartland" of Asia and the key to world domination. See Halford Mackinder. Then, on 09 Nov 1917, the Bolsheviks pulled Russia out of WW I, leaving the British to fight alone. Unforgiveable!
NATO is LOSING.
Let's face it, NATO has outlived it's usefulness and is now a pariah
work on your sound quality
15mil Russian rubles is 155k Euros, not 15k
How do most of you guys still making profit? Even with the downturn of economy and ever increasing life standards
Well, I picked the challenge to put my finances in order. Then I invested in cryptocurrency and stocks, through the assistance of my discretionary fund manager
Mrs Nancy Williams Laplace
The first step to successful investment is figuring your goals and risk tolerance either on your own or with the help of a financial professional but it's very advisable you make use of professional
This is correct, Nancy's strategy has normalized winning trades for me also and it’s a huge milestone for me looking back to how it all started..
Nancy is considered a key Crypto Strategist with one of the best copy Trading Portfolios and also very active in the cryptocurrency space.
The F16 crashed due to pilot error. He forgot to activate his IFF indicator. The NATO-operated Patriot system thought it was a Russian plane. Boom.
Nationalism is a powerful solution for South Africans or Africans
Spend 1/2 a Trillion on war
then Spend a Trillion on restoration. Rinse, Repeat.
Nima is obsessed with Torquay.
IFF so friendly fire will not shoot you down, but I doubt so hard mistake was done. Or somebody miss putting on air defense right code!
The alternative theory, promoted by Turkey, is that ithe F-16 was brought down by an air-to-air missile launched by a new Su-57 from 400 km away!
@@r.w.emersonii3501 maybe but i didnt hear nothing about this on RU media, you know they have big reward if they do this, but who knows. I know only one fact in war is hard to shoot down own airplane IFF do not let you, you can push button but rocket will not shoot out and this is old technology from 60-70 today is even better and codes are predefinited for all month ahead so or Ukros antiair defense is pure trained, i doubt this mistake will be done in war situation. Maybe ukros put wrong code in IFF system.
@@BorisPerc Sabotage? Many Ukrainians have come to hate being used as fodder by the "West".
Min 16:30 ff 15 Mio Rubles are about 150.000 €! the change ratio nis not 1:1000 just 1:100! But the offer is just 1.5 Mio Rubles so the 15.000 € is the real reward.
If it was mistakenly shut down by "friendly fire" - I don't expect Moscow will grant the money to the UA-soldier - and we will have another prove, that Russia does not keep it's word! :-)))
whenever there is uncertainty in gas and oil prices because of "stress" such as conflicts, London stock exchange makes money and so does lloyds of London, insurance.
It's a complex geopolitical chess board these days.
A veritable clash of titans.
Victoria prodded the sleeping bear, who awoke and is slashing back on many fronts. Ukraine will be known as Victorias war, and it will be seen as the pivot to a multipolar world, or as the last gasps of a dying empire.
A world directed by the greed of oligarchs will change to one directed by the producers of the world, such as Russia, India, or China and so many more.
The producing countries can and likely will cut off the West when full on war with Russia is started. Without parts of all manor, society will crash like a bus without a driver. It won't be pretty.
I hope the people at the top can just stop all these shenanigans and start cooperating again. Why do they all need to control the world. We can all manage our daily affairs without their wars. Right?
"I hope the people at the top can just stop all these shenanigans." Which people are you referring to? The way they behave, many of them could not be called human.
Great post. I often think of how history will write today 100 years from now (If we still exist). What you wrote is pretty spot on, love the term "Victorias war". This will only get written if the West falls down, because if not, it will be buried just like the past 200 years of darker history that they've quietly shoved under the rug.
However, I think the people at the top are no different than Kim Jong Un. Sitting at the very top, with inflated egos, and with total indignation towards regular people, I could totally see them suiciding the whole thing, meaning as in, the world itself, because of how shallow their character is and how spineless their backs are. Having reached such high positions, one will many times begin to tell themselves they worked hard to be where they are, and their positions are justified. Hence why we rarely hear an apology from anyone anymore.
I hope I'm wrong.
China has cut off the sale of rare-earth minerals to the West. This seems to be having a sobering effect on the U.S.. The minerals are needed for chip production.
This guy is way in front of the others.
Gilbert needs a better microphone.
At 22:10: If Germany (now when also France is so weak) succumbs to democracy (not the Western version of 'democracy' which means that Amercia dictates the rest of the world around) and starts to listen to the people and their votes (when Mr. Scholz has been called out)...I think that Europe will collapse, i.e., the 'leaders' or the followers or the servile followers of Washington who now are the head of the major governments in Europe, they will go. And I think the EU institutions headed by von der Leyen will be drained of their power by forces like the one Orbán has been organizing in the European Parliament. So I think this is the way there will be a change (replacing the so-called leaders), and not in a distant future. (Putin visited Mongolia on the second of September which is the anniversary day of the end of WWII, that is to say the unconditional surrender of Japan, in which Mongolia was very helpful to the Russian Red Army in their fight against the Japanese.) ~ Gilbert Doctorow
Україна - це дівчина, яка погуляла на Заході і після багатьох образ, принижень та обіцянок на ній одружитися, виснажена - лише із залишками колишньої краси, голодна, по вуха у боргах і вагітна вoнa повертається додому, до рідної Матінки...
Добре якщо повернеться сама, дитину на ноги поставить, а от якщо ще й цей весь непотріб за собою притягне, то біда ще й Mатінці.
During the Iraq war a Patriot launcher targeted a US F16. The pilot turned and attacked it. Where was IFF?
those territories voted in 2015 to reunite with Russia
🇬🇧 has now got the Challenger 3 tank. Coming soon.
Too little too late...the poms are hopeless with their pissy little army and airforce.
@@palnagok1720 Oh yeah. I want to get the hell out of 🇬🇧 This country is finished.
The average citizen in the USA is feeling the reality of supporting Ukraine with dollars they need for food, shelter, healthcare and transportation without anything extra for their children's education and a much needed vacation. This cash cow is almost milked dry and Ukraine needs to look for another sugar daddy. Deutschland ?Any geld left for Zelensky? His wife has payments to make on NY City property.
If Trump gets into office it will all stop.
How?
Trump also said that the trade war with China would be easy to win. He also said that he would build a wall and that Mexico would pay for it.
Nato stops supplying weapons and it's all over!
the time will come when Russia will send a message that will be clearly understood by the western world, just have to feel sorry for the recipient who will get this message.
start by stating the vdate
What Ukrainians were screaming for this war w Russia?
Belated comments on issues linked, Mongolia and Turkey. My understanding is that China is not keen now on having gas pipeline going through Mongolia following what is seen as much cosy-ing up to the west by Mongolia. Turkey is almost a synonym for deceit so the so-called BRICS application is meaningless. After recent Turkish elections, it took clear pro US/west stance ie coming off the fence. This actually failed to gain any benefits as both US and Russia have stopped being played off against each other. Putin has delayed claimed visit to Turkey for nearly a year now and in many respects has kept a distance (perhaps following Azov betrayal). Turkey does help Russia but only when it benefits Turkey. In sum, this notion of being 'independent' is not possible - US will not allow it and Russia can choose alternative partners. Turkey is actually in mess at moment although temporarily benefitting from Ukraine war. After Modi paying homage to Zelensky, I am sure Russia will be more circumspect.
I'm the first to comment 😏😏😏
woot
The people there voted for peace 😢
It is amazing if not incredible how these Russians are so accurate with these missiles. The Russians can land that missile on a half dollar in a parking lot anywhere in the country of Ukraine and who knows where else ? I mean they can even hit moving freaking targets with these missiles how in the hell are they doing that . I mean these are remote control drones some of these things but these missiles how do they do that ? I've watched the other websites and they show that the Russians can see all of Ukraine now I'm sure we have the same NATO has probably the same thing I just wish this war was over and stopped all this suffering and for what??? It's time for Ukraine and the United States and the NATO countries to stop count our losses and move on. This was a bad decision that should never been made especially when there was negotiations earlier that were successful that were interrupted. And there was a lot of backstabbing and dirty tricks of being played all the way up till zelensky became the president this is Joe Biden's blunder he could have stopped this . Kamala Harris. She could have helped in this. I'm afraid if she is elected she's going to run around thinking she has something to prove and I worry she's going to bite off more than she can chew is there any dangerous world and there's always a way to negotiations to settle things without having to kill each other !!! I really fear if Kamala Harris is elected I pray to God not !!!!
Woo hoo, GD
Fulbright scholar, educated in the west, enjoyed the perks during the time when USSR had fallen and the vultures of the west and the Russian oligarchs were bleeding Russia.... no wonder, I sense some kind of anti Russian framework there. Your surname may sound Russian but you are not .
☕️
Then why no stringent sanctions after Crimea ?
Pabjeda zanami
Mongols who destroyed Kiev, Vladimir and Moscow and occupied Ukraine ( proto Russians ) from 1220 --- 1400 .... how things are different now.....
Should be different. We are supposed to learn from our past, from our mistakes and not do it again.
We are supposed to defend our self but not revenge. Revenge is big sin it is equal to pre meditate murder.
We are supposed to forgive each other, love each other, and work together
Sikorski acting on advice from his wife Anne Applebaum.