YOU WON'T BELIEVE ALL THE NEW SKIN CARE AT TARGET 😆 SHOP WITH ME 🛍DERMATOLOGIST

[@jillvirchis1075]

I think it’s so funny how she just entertains herself! I’m glad I’m not alone!

[@DrDrayzday]

🤣

[@sandracrockett6882]

But she is also entertaining a million of us!

[@marianna7702]

She is a hoot.

[@Kcourt1996]

Sounds like what goes on in my head whenever I’m in Target lol

[@jillholod34]

Honestly, I'm getting "new product" fatigue with skincare just like I got "new release" fatigue with makeup.

[@DrDrayzday]

Exactly! Too many

[@cetriyasArtnComicsChannel]

I'd have less of a problem if they actually put out something new, or highly improved but all they put out is variations on moisturizers.

[@Adhara740]

I stick with the proven basics… retinoids and spf

[@Olivia-bq9rk]

@@Adhara740 yeah same. And lots of humectants

[@c3.immastonerr.48]

I never keep up with stuff like that so any time I check in because I want a change or new information I always think “damn that’s a lot of new stuff”

[@katkat3859]

"Skin care is becoming so saturated" -- Yes! I'm so thankful for your channel to help reduce the stress and overwhelm that can accompany the process of figuring out a good and sustainable skincare routine. With so many products out there, it's hard not to feel like there could be something better, even when a routine is proving positive results.

[@aTwistedSista]

I definitely do not need or want new skincare but I’ll go along for the ride. Watching vids like this helps me to not buy once I see it in person. 👍🏽

[@andreavin3674]

I am seeing more and more beauty and skin vloggers whose intent is to stop getting people to buy everything and instead focuses on decluttering, avoiding redundancy, price per ounce, and overall minimalism. Re using makeup we own already, trying new looks, etc. All great things! People need to stop spending half their income on skin care. It’s a real addiction.

[@sulakaricats]

No new products for me either….after destroying my skin barrier I’m diligently sticking to my very simple gentle inexpensive routine from my dermatologist…..but I love watching these videos and really enjoy Dr Drays approach ❤️
My derm preaches sunscreen and stop experimenting on your skin

[@db-gb5xi]

Penn Smith Skincare did a video around this time last year about repurposing your skincare and containers, etc.

[@andreavin3674]

@@sulakaricats I’ve done that before. It will heal up and your skin will be so amazing. It just takes patience.

[@sangeetachoudhary8653]

By end of video idk what to buy :(

[@KellyLudwin]

I love these videos because I feel like I'm shopping without leaving the house or temptation to buy stuff I don't need. Plus the commentary is priceless.

[@Etcabezas]

Amen!!

[@Aileenwasright]

Byoma is supposed to stock refillables for their products soon which is why their bottles are sturdy and reusable. I honestly hate having to order my skincare products online and prefer to buy in store whenever possible so if they do end up offering refills I will definitely check them out.

[@HeatherFonseca]

Cooler and cooler. I’m definitely checking them out next time I go to target

[@queenbunnyfoofoo6112]

I wonder how many times you can refill the original bottle before it grows bacteria? I don't recall seeing expiration dates on the bottles. Not trying to be a Debbie Downer...just curious.

[@HeatherFonseca]

@@queenbunnyfoofoo6112 from the video it just looks like a fancy lipstick box. It probably doesn’t get dirty enough to need to be replaced, since you would be replacing the entire tube.

[@queenbunnyfoofoo6112]

@@HeatherFonseca I see....so the cleanser/moisturizer is in a smaller container that you slip into the original one. Makes sense. I was thinking you poured it into the original one....

[@HeatherFonseca]

@@queenbunnyfoofoo6112 oh my gosh I thought I was responding to a different product I saw reviewed today. (The Fente refillable lipstick) Sorry! I have no idea how many times this one can be replaced

[@vetsai8199]

I’ve noticed, for at least a couple of years now, that Target has REALLY upped their game in the skin care and personal grooming departments! While it’s certain to be good for business, I find it hard to make a decision on what new product to try🤔

[@Sara-tq6tl]

The struggle is real. I feel your pain.

[@db-gb5xi]

Hi VE Tsai. I hope you are well and having a good day.

[@whitneybrown4067]

Greetings VE Tsai hope u r well n Happy Friday😀👍💜….

[@emilyjensenius4289]

Yup I could spend all day in there LOL!

[@ursulamullikin4723]

Exactly

[@leilaemery1909]

I ADORE the packaging of those Byoma products! Would love for you to review them at some point!

[@HeatherFonseca]

Yes please!

[@mmg2111]

Yes please could you review byoma products @drdray

[@melinagroleau]

Also Bubble brand, please! @drdray.

[@spiritualweatherman]

I’m OBSESSED with that BYOMA cleanser. I feel like that’s the only new line at Target that’s actually worth hype.

[@tisthedamnphd1244]

That’s good to know!

[@pikapew3428]

Yes. They are definitely a good set to try especially if ur new to skincare. A safe set. So far I really like the mist and pink moisturizer

[@shannic]

Time to ROAST the skin care isle at Target with Dr Dray…. my favorite UA-cam pass time.

[@SK-ut6tw]

I am from lapland. In our family for skincare we use alot of sunscreen because we are so fair. Shea butter, baby oil and Vaseline. It's works great for everyone in my family.

[@eliduran4182]

Yesterday I wanted to buy new skincare products and I was reading the labels of each one of them like if I had a clue of the ingredients 🤣🤣🤣. I just wanted Dr Dray next to me explaining if they were worthy 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@hrhsophiathefirst4060]

Oh man the top is giving me 'O Brother Where Art Though?" vibes!

[@petitmorte2186]

the ordinary will be at target when they open an ulta in specific stores. they have the products they are just in the backroom til ulta opens.

[@wfmbu]

I personally like the new skin care lines coming out as kid I didn’t have very many option. For a long time all you could get was salicylic acid or benzyl peroxide and a lot of those products had scents to them which I never knew could also irritate my skin. I appreciate Dr.Dray because she is helping me with my skin. I’m an adult now but it would have been nice to have someone like this when I was a kid because my family couldn’t afford to see a dermatologist for a long time.

[@deandrewalker6978]

People really sleep on Polyhydroxy Acid. BHA is too rough on my skin and AHAs doesn't really do much for me. Maybe I'm imagining it but I started experimenting with PHA and my skin has been glowing. The CosRX Good Night Soft Peeling Gel is the truth 🙌

[@pretaporterp]

when i go to target there's so many new brands. and im still sticking to my mainstays: neutrogena, cerave, la roche posay.

[@abell6h]

"We have a crier" lol

[@JessieDubois8]

Also, Byoma is a uk brand, and it’s nice that they’re finally making it stateside! I love the brand.

[@mirellaberrocal]

The versed cleansing balm does remove makeup but it has a strong eucalyptus scent. I prefer using the elf cleansing balm, it has no scent and it gets the job done without additional unnecessary ingredients while being more affordable

[@meganivanyos3232]

You know what really grinds my gears? the term “vegan-friendly”
It’s either vegan or not wtf.

[@flipgen5113]

"Putting salad in their pimple patches" 😅🤣😂 Dr Dray, you got me cracking up...

[@KourtneyBrooke]

I love you extra for talking about feverfew allergies!!! I’m allergic to it and hate when I see it in so many products that say for sensitive skin!

[@ambernord6274]

Some Targets in Minnesota have gotten an Ulta area in store where they carry select Oridinary products.

[@carolperdue7534]

My Target never has any of that stuff. I get so jazzed watching Dr. Dray but when I go in the stores near me its like pfft! Nada! Oh well, that probably means I don't need it anyway, lol.

[@gloomndoom6284]

Just went in today and bought the Byoma face moisturizer in the pink bottle, and love it. Nice and dewy without making my oily skin worse. I also grabbed the Eucerin Age Defense Face Sunscreen Lotion - SPF 50 (first chemical SPF to not burn the hell out of my eye area!) and it plays nice under that! Score! Thanks!

[@patsalas5170]

Lol...tzatziki...at 17.99....🤣🤣 you sure have a fun sense of humor 😉...happy Friday 😊

[@jakeroege]

I found eucerin has a new line of sunscreens! I picked up the body one and it is GREAT. A little too matte for winter for me, but is going to be awesome on my face in summer! Spf50! Dries down well!

[@BriseisMusic]

Thank you for sharing! I'm going to check out out now.

[@HeatherFonseca]

I’m going to look for that! I love my Eucerin spf 30 body cream. It’s a “hold grail” fir me, so I definitely would like to try more from them

[@TrankDuo7]

I've tried the Oil Control one and it's really shiny and feels like I'm spreading glue on my face. I have combo skin. Would not recommend.

[@DocHikes]

So good!

[@amnoirgg8563]

I was cracking up at the salad sweet chef comment 😂

[@allofustyrees8685]

It would be great if you could do a video on how to care for skin during and after radiation therapy!! 💛

[@danielsalgado183]

It’s like you can read my mind! I was just looking at the BYOMA serum and wanted to hear from you first and I see this video right after. Thank you!

[@nailac.esposito1891]

Literally what I’m doing now. At target picked these up and thought “what does Dr. Dray say?”

[@MichelleA81]

Love shopping at Target 🎯❤

[@DrDrayzday]

Always a fun time

[@thehylander266]

22:35 The Neutrogena ultra sheer has Helioplex technology which stabilizes the UV filters so that about 85% of the UVA protection is still there, lasting for about 4-5 hours per application the company claims. The other 60 SPF invisible daily defense one I don’t think has the Helioplex so it probably isn’t as stabilized and does not last as long in the sun is not far as UV protection is concerned. I use the SPF 70 age defense one for UVA protection and use Skin Aqua for around my eyes as it doesn’t sting and is four star boots rated which means it blocks at least 90% of UVA (16+ blocks out about 90% of UVA).

[@adinal1958]

I use a sunscreen mist only to refresh my sunscreen over makeup, like if I'm about to head out on my evening commute from work (back when I wasn't at home all the time). Ulta makes a decent one that they call a "setting spray" and it's similar to ones made by Coola and Supergoop, but it's a fraction of the cost.

[@Shan72393]

I saw the Byoma line the other day and was intrigued! I was hoping you’d walk by the section that has Bybi products! I’ve been using their vegan oat milk cleanser and am OBSESSED!

[@TardisLover15]

I actually love the native deodorant lol! It’s the only one that has actually been really good to my skin.

[@LK57913]

Ditto! All the other naturals that work irritate my skin.

[@soblessed3157]

I agree niacinamide stings my skin and I hate that every moisturizer now has it. They need to tone it down and make some moisturizers free of it to cater to those people who are sensitive. Also niacinamide serums are not expensive so people could get it and incorporate it into their routine if they need it for a much cheaper price.

[@db-gb5xi]

She's got a video featuring some niacinamide free moisturizers. There are so many products with it including serums so even a separate serum isn't really necessary.

[@OopyLoop]

I love that you actually went through the products and ingredients not just saying yes or no

[@Shadeydey]

Innocuous! I love your vocabulary! 😊

[@DrDrayzday]

Thanks for watching

[@helpfulnatural]

LOL! Love the beginning assessment of Native products! 😂 A while back I tried the BareRepublic sunscreens and didn't like the fake coconut fragrance. I couldn't finish the tube because of the smell. 😝

[@barbarabrownsword3880]

Thanks for identifying products with niacinimide! My skin hates it-and it is in so many things now. I feel like I have to check labels on everything, and I never had to before!

[@barjee8965]

same :'( finding a sunscreen that looks good on me is so hard, still looking -_- all the ones that look like the perfect ingredient lsit have niacinamide >.

[@carolinefpurcell]

I noticed the Byoma line last time I was in target and I want to try the clarifying serum for sure. I also like the price tag on it, all about the affordability! Maybe I'll try the mist too, I like a mist, makes me feel expensive lol

[@chrischris7003]

That's the one I ended up buying! I also needed a serum that wasn't in a glass bottle for when I travel

[@petitmorte2186]

what annoys me with native is they released a plastic free deodorant but charge 3$ more for it compared to the plastic package why??

[@derekward3512]

Because the materials are more expensive than plastic

[@DELLRS2012]

Shipping costs also go up

[@rubysresource]

That Atoderm Intensive Gel-cream is so lovely in summer. Perfect for people who don't like heavy moisturisers.

[@acewingate6993]

Neutrogena sunscreens burn my eyes soooo badly that I’ve had to pull over to the side of the road and flush my eyes with a bottle of water

[@emilyjensenius4289]

Chemical sunscreens always do that to me, they migrate to my eyes from my lids and sting. Waterproof mineral ones do better for me in that area.

[@acewingate6993]

@@emilyjensenius4289 I’m black, so mineral sunscreen will make me look soooo goofy. But Japanese sunscreens are so gentle on my eyes, I’m convinced even if I put it directly into my eye it wouldn’t sting haha

[@estellawong365]

True, mineral sunscreen does not flush out the eyes...

[@lucydeboxer2565]

I have sensitive skin and can immediately tell when there is niacinamide in a product I'm using. Thanks for the "heads up," that it's everywhere right now! Thank you for another great video and saving us all gobs of $$$.

[@Pamkkw]

It is insane the number of products out there! Gets overwhelming! Thanks for breaking it down for us!

[@jennifermacmullan8249]

Thank you so much for this video!! Makes navigating thru all of the various products fun vs overwhelming!!

[@kimberlyalmond7181]

Thank you for pointing out the products with niacinamide. I have become sensitive to it since starting tretinoin. So many of the LRP products have it unfortunately.

[@claudiamaldonado5885]

Always an adventure and always filled with very important information.
I really appreciate the time invested so we can make an educated purchase. ♡

[@sethlowman961]

Folks who are niacinamide-adverse: if you only tried The Ordinary's Niacinamide 10% + Zinc 1% serum, it may be worth trying products with a lower percentage of niacinamide. My bad reaction to the TO serum made me think that I should avoid the ingredient at all costs. Thankfully, I found when applying EltaMD's UV Clear sunscreen (which has 4% niacinamide), I was able to tolerate the ingredient and actually see an improvement in redness.

[@ayezakalim1185]

Yup totally. I've tried many other niacinamide products and they work so well with my skin but the ordinary one always gives me rashes.

[@marrykozakura9352]

Same, the TO one makes my skin even more red whereas product with a lower percentage works wonderful. I swear by the Purito Niacin Essence

[@db-gb5xi]

The thing is that niacinamide is in so many products that using a serum probably isn't necessary for most folks. As Dr Dray and other derms have said, 5% is the recommended/tested effective max of niacinamide.

[@cailinanne]

I would love an update about your mom, I hope she’s doing well. 💕💕

[@pearl0705]

You continously get more beautiful..how??? Is there a Benjamin button skincare/wellness line we don't know about??? 🤩💜💜

[@josie2219]

I love these videos, helps me not to buy crap products. Thank you!

[@Ninun721]

I love these videos!! You are the most unbiased skin channel on YT. Thank you for educating us on how to make wise choices and read labels. Have an amazing weekend 🌹

[@Danny-sx6cj]

The CeraVe PM facial moisturizer you recommended wasn't at my Walmart but found it at my Target! I was so happy. Thank you for all you do Dr. Dray!

[@SomethingClever_]

I really appreciate your target beauty videos. I work in their beauty section and your videos really help me keep up to date on information regarding ingredients, which is SUPER helpful when guests have questions about sensitivities or specific goals for their skin. I still always recommend that they check you out on YT and/or Instagram. 😄

[@UncleCharlie111x2]

The fluency of verbal technical jargon without ever fumbling on words is a remarkable achievement itself outshines the products! Have a fun weekend! Excellent video Dray! ☕️🧴💃🏻⭐️

[@DrDrayzday]

Happy Friday

[@UncleCharlie111x2]

@@DrDrayzday thanks same too you!! ⭐️

[@vetsai8199]

Good morning and Happy Friday, Uncle Charlie👍🏼. I hope you have a wonderful weekend🎧☕️❄️

[@UncleCharlie111x2]

@@vetsai8199 Happy Friday! Thanks so much have a nice weekend too!! :)

[@marylawman8603]

Hi Uncle Charlie! Happy Friday! I hope you had a blessed day. Rained all day here. Started out in the low 60's this morning and is now 35 degrees. 😂 ⛄☕

[@supersonic8071]

anyone got the same issue that every time after her videos you would start looking those products up online and start purchasing ………

[@oldandstillhere]

Scamper is an under appreciated word. Love watching you scamper to Target.

[@DrDrayzday]

Lol! thanks! Happy Friday!!

[@susanherman3456]

Let’s scamper on in to Target😀 Thanks Dr. Dray!

[@elizabethruggiero9950]

The neutrogena serum sunscreen 60 is awesome! I love it.

[@kawaiitropix4837]

I don’t need anything new. I do enjoy your quick in/out it helps confirm I don’t NEED anything new 😎

[@esmereldapinchon1422]

Your skin looks great. Whatever you’re doing it’s never looked so good.

[@troymceachren704]

The Bioderm Atoderm oil body wash is great! The fragrance is very mild and is barely there.

[@marylawman8603]

Its always fun to see what's new at Target and what you think of the products. As always, really respect and appreciate your opinions. Thanks, Dr Dray! Happy Friday! I hope you, your sweet momma and little Tybee have a fantastic weekend. ❤

[@gala5865]

Dr Dray, thank you so much for another great video, I found myself now stopping by skin care section at stores and looking at ingredients. I am still learning them, but its fun:).

[@salponce3368]

Wow, this IS your skincare year if you love niacinamide

[@meaghanmcarthy7850]

We have a cryer in the background 😂😂😂

[@karlaharvey2623]

Hi Dr.Dray. Yes I really enjoyed Niacinamide, but 😳 OMGOODNESS DOES IT STING and not just a few seconds; it stings for several minutes. To the point I’ve had to wash my face and apply Aveno oat serum to calm my skin down.
Thank you for your in~depth skincare shopping. Very good to know.

[@HeatherFonseca]

The aveeno oat stuff is fabulous.

[@karlaharvey2623]

@@HeatherFonseca yes it is!!! I do not like the delivery system, mine does not work; so have to slowly pour out a dab. But it’s saved my face from irritation from niacinamide.

[@HeatherFonseca]

@@karlaharvey2623 the little jar of lotion in the same line is fantastic too. 😊

[@karlaharvey2623]

@@HeatherFonseca Thank You Heather, I will have to put that on my list of things to purchase and try it.

[@2160missy]

Thank you for your continuous guidance and evidence!!!! It is so easy to fall in love with marketing instead of what is actually in the product.
Lol….and I am a critical care provider. I pronounce it VER-SAID, too😂

[@DrDrayzday]

Thanks for watching

[@smushface3999]

Aluminum deos never did anything but make me sweat buckets and smell bad (even rx strength), plus they often irritated my very tolerant underarm skin and would ruin every single shirt I owned. My sister also had to stop using them because they would cause her underarm lymph nodes to swell and get hard. Been using natural deos for almost 15 years with acid ones being the best. After the first month on natural deos, I started sweating and smelling less. By the time I’d been on them for like a year, I wouldn’t smell until about the 24 hour mark and stopped needing to apply every day.
Aluminum deos were hell for me and plenty of people I know who made the switch. Finding natural deos that worked turned my underarms into something I never need to worry about. I’ve never used native bc they use baking soda, but not sure why you have so much hate for something that has been super impactful for so many people that you don’t appear to have researched or tried.

[@juliam5628]

Yay another relaxing asmr shopping video😍🥰💜

[@rallimb486]

this channel helps curb my shopping habits 😅

[@mayraz5625]

My little sister reminds me of you lol she loves looking at the chemicals in products and explaining them to me (who’s clueless)

[@ahsu0208]

niacinamide is irritating for me if I have multiple products containing it…. but it’s inescapable nowadays

[@DrDrayzday]

It is in everything

[@primordialmeow7249]

The Byoma packaging is so chic. Me wannee!

[@DrDrayzday]

It is colorful

[@marianna7702]

As always, your on target. 👌

[@mollyjane01]

The way you were pronouncing “Versed” had me in tears….I was like, “welp, she sure thinks like a doctor…!” Lol. It’s good to laugh at yourself from time to time! 🤣🤣♥️♥️

[@kaseyseidman6710]

The tye dye vanilla cupcake had me giggling 🤣🤣🤣

[@pujanapokharel7313]

My daily skin care routine,
🌅
1. Cetaphil cleanser
2. Alpha abutin 2./. + HA ( the ordinary)
3. Niacinamide 10./. + Zinc 1./. (The odinary)
4. Azelaic acid suspension 10./. (The ordinary)
5. Cera ve Moisturizer
6. Sunscreen
Night 🌃
1. Cetaphil cleanser
2. Alpha abutin 2./. + HA ( the ordinary)
3. Niacinamide 10./. + Zinc 1./. (The odinary)
4. Azelaic acid suspension 10./. (The ordinary)
5. Cera ve Moisturizer
6. Tretinoin (twice a week)
7. Cera ve moisturizer
Is this layering process healthier to my acne prone skin? Expecting reply

[@angelacrowder6127]

Happy Friday Dr Dray!

[@DrDrayzday]

Happy Friday

[@jillschaefer1360]

Did anyone elae feel like you were legit on that Targ trip w/Dr. Dray, esp when checking out the prices? Asking for a friend.

[@threatlevelmidnight3588]

Hi Dr Dray. Hope you are having a great week. Your skin looks soooo glowy today in a great way!

[@DrDrayzday]

Thanks 😊 happy Friday

[@akhiker01]

Whatever… you gotta fill up space on the box 😂😂😂

[@luzestela_]

The versed retinol body cream I find that it has a similar texture, when rubbing it in, as the necessaire body lotion, but thicker. It gets absorbed pretty quick for me

[@jessicajones8080]

That oil to gel cleanser from bioderma is to dye for The fragrance is SO light I doubt it would irritate your skin if you are sensitive to that kind of stuff. It’s so Gentle you can use it on kids. Very good

[@deandrewalker6978]

Also, the Atoderm Cleansing Oil is great on my face.

[@martastjepic7043]

Same!! It dissolves makeup like nothing else, great as a first cleanse, good price, can be used on the body and you don't need to moisturise after (for lazy days haha). It does have a light fragrance, but I don't mind it since it is a wash of product.

[@almag0410]

I am ready for morning face mist recommendations! I dislike washing my face in the morning.

[@jkookie1964]

Byoma hyaluronic acid and the rich crème is amazing together since I have very dry skin

[@neurocat8837]

I think an SPF mist can be useful for reapplication for those who wear makeup

[@susane370]

All the new because they are transitioning to being a Target/Ulta section? My Target has been doing a lot of sporadic clearances in skin and makeup section as they prepare for the change-over. I got a 30.00 item for 6.50 the other day! Keep an eye out!

[@GG-xz7nv]

Versed “Gentle Milky Cleanser” with oat, in a pump bottle has been my new favorite cleanser! Especially during these harsh winter months for my extremely dry, sensitive skin. It’s a must try from that line. I wasn’t impressed with the rest of the line though. I had problems using the Aveeno Calm line because of the feverfew, so this milky oat one has been the perfect substitute for it.

[@JRed-go8wr]

I absolutely love the Versed cleansing balm! I’ve tried MANY! It is scented but doesn’t bother me. Not sure how it would do on oily skin though, probably too heavy. I’m 51 with desert dry skin. As a first cleanse, it’s great at breaking down make up without feeling stripped. I’m always interested in trying new ones but end up back to Versed every time.

[@AshleyBehrendt]

Dr dray uses “ooo! 👀” and “ew 🤮” synonymously

[@Hiiiiiiiiieeee]

This is so funny and I have to just admit it because I can’t stop thinking about it. I used to hate your videos. And the more I watch your videos now the more I realize the only reason I hated your videos in the past years was because I was obsessed with my over consuming. I’m still pretty deep into skin care but your videos are really teaching me to par down on what I use and keep things more simple. I’ll still probably use some of my more bougie items but it’s definitely good to get a truly educated opinion on the market at the moment. Thank you!

[@danielegagnon7920]

Happy Friday! We had the Target banner a few years ago in Quebec City but they closed. The Targets in the USA offer a lot more products when I watch your videos. You can't order from Target anymore!

[@DrDrayzday]

Happy Friday

[@Dkb522]

I love Native. Just the deodorant. I like the different scents and I’ve never suffered from a rash. I just like it, no clean preferences or anything.

[@HeatherFonseca]

I like it too. I’m older so I don’t really have a stinky pit problem so they work fine for me.

[@ram.4152]

I live in the Caribbean we do not have all those options of sunscreen in our stores most of us have no concept of sunscreen😂😂😂😂😂😂😂....thank God the algorithm lead me to Dr at 20

[@marywittman8248]

That Rosen brand has an INCREDIBLE spot treatment! (Called Break-out). Can’t recommend enough!

[@Razorwing]

Yeah let's go shopping (okay I don't need any new skin care but yeah still joining)🤣

[@DrDrayzday]

Thanks for watching