The Animated History of Italy | Part 2
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 кві 2018
- The first 206 viewers to use this link will get 2 Months on Skillshare for FREE! skl.sh/suibhne2
WATCH
The Armchair Historian Collab: • How did Italy Become a...
The Animated History of Italy | Part 1: • The Animated History o...
Beginning part two, Italy has been recaptured by the Byzantines thanks to the tenacious ambitions of Emperor Justinian. But throughout the Middle Ages, the land became a battleground for more powerful empires. The 19th Century Italian revolution would see the peninsula swept up in the waves of Nationalism that was taking the continent by storm.
LINKS
PATREON: www.patreon.com/user?u=3585241
TWITTER: / suibhneofficial
MERCHANDISE: www.zazzle.com/suibhne
SECOND CHANNEL: / @suibhne2
Great working with you Suibhne! And an awesome video as usual.
Griff
The Armchair Historian your portion of the video was difficult to listen to. Lots of spikes on your “s”s
Great video next video history of turkey
wonderful duo !
It’s not great work, he forgot the important and more popular Italian socialist republic. Ignorant people who are largely bias shouldn’t make history videos.
The Armchair Historian that’s great
In my opinion, Italian history is the most difficult, and very rich, full of wars, cultures, and different kingdoms but above all for its fascinating history from the Roman Empire to the Italian kingdom and today Italy
China would like a word
@@austinhavard9850 India would like a follow up
@@youreright...1284 india is a bit boring
@@hybrid5362 India was barely unified and suffered lots of attacks, also court intrigue is a big part of the fall of many empires, think about it Whne studying the history of India you are studying the history of many many kingdoms and empires simultaneously.
@@austinhavard9850 China is trash
"Giusepi Giaribaldee? Are you joking?" "No, dude. Just like Uiliam Scec- spir".
Love Italy from Greece. I feel you Italians really close to us Greeks
love greece from italy
Mediterrean brothers.
I don't know how you could do a "History of Italy" series and not even mention Dante. The Renaissance section was also incredibly short, especially considering how important it is to Italian history and culture
Dear, he didn't spend much time on Roman Empire too, and its history it's huge, trust me 😅
It's history, not literature
Well, Dante is very important because most of the terms that Italians (such as me) use, are from its "Divina Commedia" (that is why Italians can, relatively easily, understend it) but; historically talking, Dante wasn't really important.
It's a little bit long to explain all the history of Dante, explaining Guelfi and Ghibellini and the motivations of the Exile from Firenze
@@Gaetano2005 Dante non è stato storicamente importante? Cosa ho letto? Dante, Petrarca e Boccaccio sono i 3 che hanno formato la cultura occidentale dopo l'impero romano.
3:44 "giuseppe girobaldi" ahhh, it hurts so much..
I winced at how he pronunced Garibaldi's name
Same, but he tried :D
Giuseppi Giariboldi
Giuseppi Gerribaldi
Onion Shark Baldi xD
"Giuseppi Jerrybaldi"
You did a good editing job but you made some critical errors:
- It's Garibaldi not Giribaldi. Pronounced Gawreebaldee.
- italy didn't "switch side" in ww1, the triple alliance was only a defensive pact and austria was the aggressor.
- it's not true that italy only progressed in WW1 with the help of uk and france. The first battle of Piave river was fought by the italian army alone and started the offensive against the austrians.
- Mussolini believed in italian culture superiority, not racial, and wanted to restablish a roman empire.
- last communist member expelled in 1947? not at all, the PCI (italian communist party) was a major party since 1992 when it changed name in PDS (democratic left party) after the USSR collapse.
Plus italy didn't conquer "new land", they liberated territory under the austrians
I'm from Gorizia and no, they didn't free us. Simple war of conquest. Only a small minority of burgeois was pro-Italy.
Yes, they switched sides when it looked good.
@@maybug No, we didn't, open an history book
PCI
@Spada del Nord and Istria
4:40 NOTE:
The reason why Italy had changed sides was because the Triple Alliance was a *defensive* alliance. The Austro-Hungarians were the aggressors, so Italy didn't have to be on their side. That's also why Romania had ''changed sides.'' They didn't betray the Triple Alliance or anything.
The Blue Mapper Bunch of traitors, Italy and Romania were the worst allies ever.
I've seen you before. You're just a nationalist who likes fighting. No point in arguing with you.
Yeah, same for Romanian ones.
The only reason Romania and Italy had joined the Triple Alliance were other threats. This was probably the best choice for them. It's not like they ever wanted to be close to the Germans and Austro-Hungarians.
Thank you +The Blue Mapper
Oberpfälzer
*Would have won
The way you said Giuseppe Garibaldi like "Giuseppe Giaribaldi" hurt my italian soul
Italian that are watching this video : gseppi ciaribaldi
Also italians: AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Maybe you mean...Giuseppe Garibaldi.
7:46 The italian Communist party was the strongest outside the eastern block, and it was totally legal and held a lot of seats in both branches of parliament. It was crucial for the creation of the constitution.
Francesco Foccillo infatti penso sia stato un lapsus, intendeva sicuramente il partito fascista
PowerfullPillow Spero sia così
Casteddu Mapper Per fortuna
Casteddu Mapper non vedo il motivo della tua affermazione, la mia era una precisazione storica, le nostre opinioni politiche sono personali, nonché anacronistiche.
Detto ciò comunismo merda
Generally good video but it’s worth noting Mussolini’s African ambitions weren’t driven by racial motivations like the video states, they were driven primarily by territorial and colonial rivalry with France and Britain. The race politics were more or less unique to Germany and Japan, it was even a strong point of negative relations between Italy and Germany given Hitlers view of Italians as an inferior race and the fact that many of the Fascist Party’s earliest and highest up members were Jewish. The closest argument I can think of would be Italy’s race laws instated in 1938 but these were very likely instated under heavy German pressure and Italy’s one real war in Africa outside WWII, in Ethiopia, preceded them by 3 years.
There’s a lot to criticize about Mussolini and the Fascist regime, but making up or misrepresenting facts feels like a distraction away from discussion on what there actually was in Fascist Italy that went awry.
@@nate5082 late of 1 year. Oh well.
Actually the italian army was crushed.. by itself😅
We LITERALLY stormed our naval forces with bombs bc of an error.. Mussolini was NOT a general, but a politicians, and having him doing military things resulted in a Total massacre and humiliation to Italy and Mussolini himself.
Italian history is way more complex and complicated. Specially the last 200 year. This video contains only "half-truths"
Yes a 10 minute video cannot go over every complexity of 200 years of history
I guess this video was made to encourage more people to inform themselves through books and other videos. Do not expect to learn most of the topic by watching a 10-minute video.
i love italy so much
Pasta pizza
not only this engineering culture philosophy and proper cooking
Darth Vader pizza,pasta,baba,lasagne,mozzarella,cannoli siciliani, tiramisu,pandoro ecc. The important cityes are florence,venice,milan,torin,rome,naples,bologna ecc.we are leonardo.da vinci,julius caesar,giuseppe garibaldi,luca giordano,vittorio emanuele,ferdinando i,dante alighieri,petrarca,boccaccio,alessandro manzoni,vespasiano,macchiavelli,lorenzo de medici,umberto i,enrico fermi,masaniello,Ludovico ariosto,caterina de medici,cristoforo colombo,amerigo vespucci,selena gomez,madonna,lady gaga and other.the italy is the best country of the world
PietroPio Espasiano
In France we have frogs. And bread. And cheese. lol i still love my country
when you go from leonardo to lady gaga, you know why your country has become a cultural dustbin.
The comunist members of the Parlament were not excluded😅 the comunist party was the second biggest party from 50's to 90's
true , propaganda :P
Copyright strike
Italians hate comunists.Btw I'm an Italian and I hate them on Italy will call they "I mangia bambini" (The kids eater).
@@mattiagolino4678 bullshits lmao italians are all socialist in some form and dont even know it
Y'all just repressed, because of the inefficiency of the state and corruption
E si sono Italiano, e di comunisti ne conosco a frotte
@@mattiagolino4678 ah e, mangia bambini li chiamano solo gli imbecilli o i vecchi,manco tutti
Che in italia sono più o meno la stessa cosa
Great video!
One thing I do have to comment on as a correction - the general consensus among historians is that the Balkan affairs did *not* delay operation Barbarossa, and that was a factor later attributed as a result of one of Hitler's rants about his allies. The *real* cause for the delay was the late spring 'wet season' which prevented operations from commencing earlier - even Guderian stated as much about Barbarossa.
Oh my favourite country in modern times
Darth Vader says this lord vader huh?
Edit:My idol Napoleon Loved italy too.Thats why Me Joffre loves it.
My idol is julius caesar
@@josephjacquescesairejoffre70 Napoleon freed Italians from the hegemony of the status quo and helped revolutionary ideas spread. We influenced France with Renaissance and one of its consequences helped Italy back. That's a marvellous testament to Franco-Italian relations over the centuries.
Napoleon family was italian, but why you love my country in moderna times(yes we have a good hystory) but on WW2 we was very weak..
But thank you and love from italy to france❤️🔝
2:50: "... the rich Italian states had the money to waste..."
Are you suggesting that the start of the Renaissance was a waste of money?
PLEASE FOR THE LOVE OF HISTORY DO GREECE!
GREECE!!!
I'm italian but Greece is reaally interesting in my opinion
William Lag YESSSS!!
Yes pleaseeee
William Lag yes mate
The old theory that the Renaissance was caused by a great influx of Byzantine refugees coming to the West after Constantinople's fall in 1453 is not accepted today by any reputable scholar. It is indisputable that the Renaissance was a Latin, not a Greek movement. The Renaissance was already happening in Italy and in Florence long before 1453, and had nothing to do with Byzantine scholars. Multiple factors brought the birth of the Renaissance in Italy: the economic, cultural and political situation, the work of Italian scholars and writers such as Petrarch, Coluccio Salutati, Niccolò de' Niccoli, Poggio Bracciolini, etc. all combined to bring the birth of the Renaissance in Italy. Petrarch is known as the father of the Renaissance, and he was staunchly anti-Greek. If there was such an overflowing of Greek scholars, why didn't these Byzantines ever create anything like the Italian Renaissance in their own country? To attribute the start of the Renaissance to some Byzantine refugees is simply bad history.
It's not a "theory", it is widely known that ancient Greek texts were lost during the medieval ages in Western Europe. After the fall of the Eastern Roman Empire(Byzantine Empire) many scholars carried with them the texts of philosophers, mathematicians, scientists etc. While you ask why the Byzantine Empire did not have a Renaissance, well that's because in the last 200 years, the empire had crumbled in different states, very few territories were held and they didn't have any time for cultural rebirth. Although you can say that in medieval times there were less superstitions etc. in the Byzantine Empire than in Western Europe, such as they did not kill black cats, they did not burn witches and that they largely accepted catholic christians in the empire. Of course Italy is the major factor in the Renaissance but we must not forget it's roots just by choosing not to believe some historical facts.
@@balkanmountains2103 pretty sure the other italian states weren't those who killed black cats and burned witches, just watch the Kingdom of Sicily under Frederick II of Hohenstaufen, it was extremely advanced.
It's either that the scholars brought them or what the Latin knights brought them after the fourth crusade or a combination of these two. No matter how you look at it all this ancient knowledge that sudenly came back to the west originated from the preserved ancient texts of the Byzantines. People don't call them the Eastern Roman Empire for nothing. Although Christian they actually retained ancient culture and artifacts. Constantinople was filled with statues of emperors and generals, they viewed horse races, they had knowledge of ancient mythology, the works of Homer were a part of their educational system. All that during a time perriod western Europe calls "the dark ages".
3:44 I don't know any General named Gisepi Geriboldi...
Oh, maybe you mean Giuseppe Garibaldi?
Ahahah
To be honest I think you missed many important parts of history of Italy, as it is difficult to make a video of 2700 years of history in 15 minutes... You didn't speak about the economic boom of 60's, the political crisis of 90's, the importance of communist party in Italy between the II W.W. and the 90's, the terrorism of the 70's... You didn't speak neither about the wars between Northern Italy cities and Holy Roman German Empire in late middle age. You didn't speak about the competition between "guelfi" and "ghibellini" in every cities of northern-central Italy of middle age. The short story of Italian colonialism... The war between France and Spain in Italy... The coming of Normans in Southern Italy... The rhole of Venice againts the Ottoman Empire and Austria... And many other things...
Italian states where rarely conquered, but pretty much always subjugated, as their territories where to rich and contested to mantain power on.
Naples was the capital of the Aragonese and Angevin empire for centuries. This means that the French and Spanish kings came to live in Naples. Unfortunately this changed with the Habsburgs who moved the capital to Madrid, creating the Spanish state that did not exist before. It is kings and armies that make nations, never peoples.
Well, sicily and naples is never been conquered (sorry for my English) because the Aragonese sicily was just a part of the Aragonese crown, it wasn't annexed and this is also for Naples.
Erm, Mussolini did not care about race. In fact, he thought it was trivial.
"Race? It is a feeling, not a reality. Ninety-five per cent, at least. Nothing will ever make me believe that biologically pure races can be shown to exist today.… National pride has no need of the delirium of race."
~Talks with Mussolini, 1932
Sulkro but didn't he consider the Ethiopian inferior as a people? That's what I thought. If not then I can hate him a little bit less but not by much
Even if he did believe that they were inferior, it would not have been a unique viewpoint. This sentiment was widespread across all parts of Europe, not just Axis countries.
Fascist Italy adopted a view on race more akin to the Roman Empire where emphasis was put more in loyalty and national status than race, in the same way that there were Roman Emperors from many of the places Rome conquered (namely Syria) there was the idea in Fascist Italy that once someone was under the Italian flag they were Italian
(until the race laws of 1938 were instated but there’s good reason to believe that that was under heavy German pressure considering a large portion of Fascism’s earliest and most dedicated supporters were Jewish and Mussolini had previously called Hitler a barbarian for his racial views)
Thank you +Sulkro for sharing.
Animated history of Greece please.
yess
Yaaaaaaaaas
Let's all thank Mussolini for helping the Allies defeat the Nazis :D
You re a freaking genious
its funny cause its true
nahte armystrong its not funny because its not true
Actually Mussolini sent the majority of the Italian army devoid of efficient weapons. The German soldiers were costantly making fun of the Italian soldiers for the fact that the Italians were the ones without good stuff and equipement
Nonsense comment...So they both had rifles with 5 rounds and bolt actions...And an Smg....How the german soldiers had better stuff ?... Tottaly Nonsense, real data is that the german army liked the italian granades because they explode on impact rather than time, and the italian SMG was way better than the MP40 German Or Russian PPS, If Italy had more time, they would make the most advanced SMG's in the world at that time. (if you want to know more, do your research about it).
All the best things come from Italy! 🇮🇹, the Renaissance, Pizza, Rome, Fascism.........
Wait a minute
Commander Appo fascism is great!
@@el_fuerte9990 fascism is a cancer!!!!!!
Marghe M yes the fascism are the cancer for the Italy and I confirm I am italian from the eternal city rome
@@Mal69000 how’s the weather been there lately?
@@Mal69000 i want to visit rome oneday in my life
Sorry, I know I'm being a jerk but...
"Jusepi Jerrybaldi" hahaha :D
it's "Giuseppe GARibaldi", pronounced 'gar' as in 'garment'.
My bad!
They aren't latins
Io mi stavo uccidendo dalle risate quando l'ha pronunciato in quel modo 😂😂
Honour to Italy in Ww1 🇮🇹❤️
Great video man, I really appreciate you helping me learn about my country's past
Italy - the origin of Renaissance :-0
Hoàng Kim Việt Off course but this Renaissance in Italy was thanks to the Greek intellectuals who fled their country before its anihilition by Turks .
Philippe Gromitsaris partly, yes.
Really? Then what was the Islamic one! :D
Italy and Greece ; )
Philippe Gromitsaris actually its tanks to the heritage from Lorenzo de Medici
"The rich Italian cities had a lot of money on translating these books". I stopped watching the video there, describing the Renaissance to be born on a waste of money is so disrespectful. And reading all the other feedbacks, I can get a general idea on the poor quality of the video.
wow, you're really getting worked up over a line the isn't even said like that XD
look here 2:48
BESIDES, yours and 1 other comment are the only TRUE comments of feedback
sono americani, che ci vuoi fare....barbari, ignoranti, grezzi, non hanno storia, non hanno cultura, non hanno nemmeno una terra (appartiene ai nativi americani e non agli imbastarditi che la abitano oggi)
This is why I unsubbed. Disrespecting other nations history is nothing I support.
History of Italy without covering my main man D'Annunzio?!
Painfully Incomplete.
RE Riprenderemo mai Fiume?
Sir SaladAss no
Or the Tre Corone...
That’s probably because he was disgraced for embezzling funds, which led to people to look for a new leader of the people in Mussolini
RE D'Annunzio: Il "sommo vater" 🤣
(hilarious joke impossible to translate stating D'Annunzio was the "acme of all water closet poets") 🤣
Great video
Very nice, I love the serie and I thumbs up! :)
^^
Could you cover the animated history of China?
Gipsy Danger History of which China? People's Republic on the mainland or the Republic in the island of Taiwan.
Mod maker
I would assume both
Gipsy Danger 50 episodes
That will be a long one, and it will depend on what you consider part of China (Tibet, Taiwain, etc).
TR_AtaOzd I thought it was 6 episodes
Thank you for these videos. I will be spending a lot of time in Italy (Piemonte). Two months this year. So nice to have a simple and informative class like this.
Absolutely love this series!! Would you ever consider doing a history of Wales ?
Good video dude.
Animated history of Greece???
Yes is very interesting
Great video as always!
love your channel man
I would be most pleased if you could make a Animated history of Sweden =D
Interesting history, especially about Roman empire, thanks for video! Love Italy from Ruthenia (Ukraine)!
I love these video!
Have you ever thought about including subtitles? They could be useful and the automatic ones are not always that good...
YAYYYYYY love seeing that notification. you are a gem man. quality history vids.
I'm relatively new to the channel, but I've blown through nearly every video you've done already. I'm gonna request something I don't think you do, but I would like to hear about the history of a country outside of europe and go for thailand since I'm going there next year. If not it would be cool if you could do switzerland or portugal.
Thanks for making these videos, i'm proud my country has the oldest history in Europe, alongside with Greece.
A collaboration between Suibhne and Armchair historian that really good I like both
Bravo, ottimo lavoro
Thank you for part 2 =D
You're literally everywhere!
WW1 italy switch Side becose the pact of triplealliance said that it's only for defence not offensive (so germany and Austria-Hungary make theyr first mistake). And we joined the allies for the land that austro hungary had. BUT the pact of London (pact that said that all the italian land that was occupied by Austria Hungary should brought back to The italian) Oviusly by the end of the war The Allies didn't respect the pact and that's why after the war italy never accept an aliance to The allies. Then idk where did you Pick up that thing that english and frence help to The italian front becose it's Soo fuking false.
Sei italiano? /are you Italian?
Se si. BRAVO QUESTA È LA STORIA, IL PATTO DI Londra RIDAVA ALL' ITALIA I TERRITORI OCCUPATI DALLA AUSTRIA E... (non ho voglia di spiegare in italiano perché non ho voglio di cercare di tradurre)
Great job!! Excellent video and explanation. Can you please make a video for the Greek history?
Thank you so much for your videos
“Fascismo”
UA-cam captions: fishy smell
Please do Greece, I'd love to see videos that cover Greek history after the Classical Era (Especially Byzantine Greece and the birth of modern Greece)
Great work! I’d love to see a history of England soon
YOU DID ALL OF YOUR VIDEOS IN ILLUSTRATOR?!?! WHAT A HUGE AMOUNT OF WORK!
Respect, from Italy ;)
I enjoy your video's and see alot of the generic recommedations in this comments section (China, USA, Greece, UK, their own country). I would love it if you did a country that people haven't heard of before, let alone know anything about. Like Indonesia, Ecuador or Honduras for example, or even more obscure ones like Uzbekistan, the island of Socotra or perhaps the history of an Oceanic or Caribbean nation :) Thanks for the videos.
Can You make one about Portugal mate?
Do Australia next please
Finally part 2!!! Good!
Nice overview, of course it's impossible to expect you'll go over too many details in only 10 minutes; but it would've been worth at least mentioning the italian resistance during WW2. Certain areas of Northern Italy freed themselves from the Nazi-Fascists multiple times through the years. It had a lasting effect on culture and politics and, while today it only resembles what it used to be, it still had a big impact on life. Speaking of which, in two days it will be the Liberation Day anniversary (25th April).
you kinda skipped ~350 years from 1453-1800s
You have a wonderful channel!!! Cheers from Italy ;)
Great series as usual. Viva l'Italia!
Now do History Of Greece!
Congrats on 200k
Great job
7:45 "The communist members of parliament were expelled in 1947."
Uhm no, it never happened.
Simply in 1947, under american pression, the italian premier De Gasperi, centrist leader, rearranged the composition of the govern of national unity, exluding (and dividing) part of the 40% left union party.
Who among the comments is Italian?
And how many had a heart attack when he said that way Garibaldi?
But still great video
Gaius Iulius Caesar Octavianus Augustus praticamente tutti....
Jewsepi Jerryboldi...brrrrr!!
Cool channel, subscribed!
You're one of the best people who tell about history:-)
History of Sweden
(I'm Italian): I was going to love your videos but this, my friend...I think this video is really too superficial about the WWII on the events of the allied invasion of the South: You have not talked clearly about the creation of the Italian Social Republic [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Italian_Social_Republic] (RSI, founded in Salò by the Third Reich on Mussolini's - fake - leadership) and the Resistance made by both partisans (in the North) and Italian (allies co-belligerant) Royal Army (from the South) of the "Kingdom of the South" [it.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regno_del_Sud] led by King Victor Emmanuel III and his Prime Minister Pietro Badoglio after the Armistice of Cassibile [en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Armistice_of_Cassibile]. Moreover, in my opinion, even the part about the Institutional Referendum granted by King Umberto II in 1946 is terribly superficial and worse not objective.
The history of Italy in two ten minute videos... good work!
Do animated history of Croatia!
Please!
Can u make a video with history of Hungary?
Do The animated History of CYPRUS ❤❤
Very cool. Thank you
History of Mexico please
draco 1001 No
Hungary or Greece next!
You should do an animated history of Austria and the Habsburgs.
love the artstyle
Animated History of Portugal
Can you do Iran please ?
Lemon Gerard That'd be amazing
What an awesome video.Can you do the animated history of Greece next pls
Great vidwo
History of Greece
Respect to Italy/Italians from Poland, especially in the light of the recent elections
i can't wait to see your series on the merchant republics
Good I was bored and great video as usual
You forget that the Byzantiens reunite the most of Italy (70-80%) when Ioustinianos was the leader of Byzantium.
Ανδρόνικος Τζερεφός Even 100% of Italy
Forgetting him its a capital offense
Scipione l'Africano yes but he show like Byzantium conquer only a part of the south Italy and Silecy.
He showed that in Part 1...
Italy STRONK (NOT REALLY)
Why does nobody covering this topic ever mentions the reason Italy didn't join Germany and Austria-Hungary during World War I? The so-called alliance was actually a defensive pact and the reason Italy initially stayed neutral was that Austria-Hungary was the aggressor, which went against the pact's agreements. I've noticed at least another comment on this, from The Blue Mapper. Please, if you fancy yourself an educator, stop perpetrating idiotic myths about Italy being the side-switching nation, it is highly dishonest from an intellectual stand point and flies in the face of actual History
Van you do Portugal or Nepal next
Finally i have waited
7:40 "The communist members of parliament were expelled in 1947"
What? How would it be democratic? It seems that your history knowledge has been misled by some political opinion of yours... Maybe in Australia you are not so used to the the idea that each political opinion deserves to be represented in the parliament. But let me tell you something that i hope you just haven't find evidence of: as the matter of fact the communist party was the second biggest in Italy until the '90s, soaring 'till a maximum of 35% of approval rate in '76 elections. Furthermore many of the founding fathers of the republic who wrote the constitution were indeed communists.
"each political opinion deserves to be represented in the parliament"... including fascism? Communism = totalitarianism, as well as fascism. The only reason PCI was in parliament was because they participate at the partisan war, not because of democracy. Fortunately nowadays only some rich and bored young people call themselves 'communist' in Europe.
History of Hungary ?
Feri Maczik most importantly when they lost all their territory
History of Hungary? that country has no history
Cavalerul Negru wtf ? xD
Feri Maczik Yeah, 2nd class joke. Funny right?
Cavalerul Negru We have no history? Every people heard about huns or Attila in the world, the Hunnic Empire was bigger than Macedonian Empire.