All US presidents always said there is “no change in one China policy’”… but each time the US insidiously trying out new and further steps on encouraging, enticing Taiwan to be on the independence side. Very mean and shameless.
AND WHAT WILL SINGAPORE DO ONCE CHINA DECOUPLES WITH U.S. AND THE GREATER MAJORITY OF THE WORLD SIDES WITH CHINA??? SIR,THE WORLD IS AWARE OF ALL THE GREEDY MINDEDNESS OF THE U.S. CAPITALISTIC HEGEMONIC DREAMS...HOW WILL SINGAPORE WORK UP THE HUMILITY TO APOLOGIZE???
Oh STOP YOUR NONSENSE!!! THE WORLD HAS HAD KINGS AND EMPERORS WHO HAD THE GOVTS OF THEIR COUNTRIES SOLELY ON THEIR SHOULDERS!!!...AND RULED BETTER THAN PRESENT DAY GOVTS...
Beware of their outward appearance, trying to stick to one China policy . Of their steely smiles, deceit is so natural, they divide the people with propaganda and lies like second nature.
Over 30 years ago a Japanese manager adviced me: " beware anglosphere (5 "eye") countries because they master three complementary strengths: 1) They very effectively turn world opinion on their side as being natural expression of "goodness". 2) If that is not effective they don't hesitate going to war for which they are always well prepared in advance. 3) In war, avoid fighting in their own territory to minimize civilian casualties and damage to country infrastructure.
Bingo! You have hit the nail on the head. This is why you keep hearing "experts" like John Joseph Mearsheimer an American political scientist who keeps alluding to the fact the US has "stop and save" the world by defeating three "despotic cataclysmic precipice" single-handedly. More important the US has not only ended up victorious but came out stronger. Whereas countries like China does not have that experienced. However, what John Mearsheimer forgets to tell is that all these "American victories" took place on other people territories. America and Americans did not have to face the horrors of wars - the destruction, deaths, disruptions etc. One they face war on American soil, maybe John Mearsheimer won't be so "brave" about America being invincible!
If you have serious investment perspective through technical lens, would you really consider investing in a country that is constantly at wars and the best innovations from that country is none other than war related industries? That’s the best they can bring to the table for the mankind?
@@dericksmith740 你還懂得什麼叫公德私德！你們這些白种人只有兩百年歷史,懂什麼？只有幾年沒侵犯別的國家！Try to scan your conscience & help yourself & your own kind! We do appreciate your “concern”! 😩
Great talk! I love Kishore Mahbubani when he speaks to arrogant Westerners, especially Western intellectuals he speaks on behalf of the opinions of the non-Western world, especially the opinions of Asians, and he normally wins his arguments with the arrogant Westerners.
It's the 5 eyes led by the US that is most arrogant. They always say they care about the freedom of speech of those people in the countries they are against. But in truth, they just want to hurt those countries because they are competing for some resource that they cannot easily take without paying full price. If they really cared about individual people, then they would start with looking after their citizens using their own resources without trying to grab at the resources of others. It's like ftx being able to be generous with other people's money. And at the same time pocketing some of it for themselves. When it costs them personally, they can no longer be so generous.
@@physika yes, there are some westerners with very fair opinions. At the moment they are a minority simply due to the unfair china reports created by the US and the legacy media.
Singapore can stand by many powerful countries one of the reasons is producing strong mindset like Kishore .Singapore never waste its resouces doing religious events like Malaysia creating religion bigots and morons
@@dericksmith740 KISHORE has been unlawfully SUPPORTING CHINA'S UYGHUR GENOCIDES IN WAR CRIMINAL CHINA'S ARMY UNLAWFULLY OCCUPIED Uyghuristan ( aka EASTER TURKESTAN)
Kishore is always amaze me, the last question what he said is what I thought too. The west criticize Xi of appointing loyalist, but if you look at the background of those people is amazing. Xi is preparing his A TEAM to execute the master plan.
The great thing is that the leaderships is working for the better of their populations. The loving-kindness intention of these leaders to their allegiances are exhibited. They really work hard, put in so much time n efforts to their responsibilities of for the peoples' good👍👏😍🙏🙏🙏
This is my first time to view SALT video, good stuff. Kishore Mahbubani brought me here, who is one of the wisest and smartest diplomats & intellectuals in our time👍👍👍.
He was absolutely right about anglo Saxons versus as others. You can see that in wars created with them and their constant refusal to understand that the world is moving away from them.
It’s shame that Dr Mahbubani is not known to most Canadians as they are so much having their heads wrapped with Anglo Saxons media. Dr Mahbubani is an excellent speaker and a wise man.
Professor Mahbubani has been always eloquent, convincing, Intelligent and insightful. The West elites definitely should take notes when Professor Mahbubani speaks.
Singapore can stand by many powerful countries one of the reasons is producing strong mindset like Kishore .Singapore never waste its resouces doing religious events like Malaysia creating religion bigots and morons
@Nick NG he talk rubbish?? How about you?? Did you get invited to talk on the stage??? O... BIG MOUTH like you will never get invited ... what a sour grapes.
The most prize statement I heard was 15:28 “ Europe think Europe problem are the world problem, the world problems are not Europe problems “ Short and clear statement to conclude the attitude born by the western ever since the first Industrial Revolution begin. 👏👏👏 However, I feel the statement is incomplete and could have been better because clearly we are missing one very important country. The one across the Atlantic.
Great insight from Kishore! In my view, Asia Pacific will be the most important region from economic standpoint in this century, next would be North America, Europe will keep falling with no end in sight.
I have seen many Chinese commenters say this about Europe that it will decline. I know you are saying this because of the huge influx of migrants. You guys are something else. Europe would actually fall without the migrants. They are about to have a large aging population that needs care and people to fill up that void so that their pension system does not collapse. Then they are about to see some people leave when the global south starts developing another possibility for collapse. Then they have issues with their election system and rise of the extreme right which everyone knows the extreme right is nationalist and sometimes socialist. Socialist, nationalist, conservative regimes tend to stumble the economic growth of a nation, because their way of thinking limits creativity and thus people that want to create new concepts. So I do not even know what you are saying. Both Europe and the US will not collapse. If one collapse the other collapses. You are funny.
It’s not America backing off from Taiwan but the Taiwanese people voted not to be mislead and used by America to wage proxy war against China similar to Ukraine against Russia. ASEAN will move closer towards China similar to Middle East.
Just copy Indonesian President and defence minister said to the west, "Stop dictacting, Stop intervering our domestic issue, Stop said my standart is better then yours, start to nake cooperation and work together for peace and better world, remember that the west enemy is not necessary our enemy too.". Bravo Indonesia ♥️😆👍🇮🇩
Kishore is very smart and neutral ..because his neutrality he can see the weakness and the stregth , therefore he gets the solution and recommendation on how to solve the problem ..😁😊👍👍👍
Anybody else notice how the host (crabtree) assumed automatically it was a Russian missile that went into Poland, when it was in fact a Ukrainian missile. The West is so biased, it's comical.
Nah. Sanctions on Russia wasn't well-received by Singaporeans. Many pointed to Israel-Palestine and the fact that we were very likely pressured by the US to side with them in this instance, in return for neutrality on China.
If I'm the president or pm or company boss, surely I'll appoint my men who are firstly loyal and capable. Of course its stupid to appoint someone that goes against you even though he's very very smart. NOPE. Looks like those Anglo-Saxons medias are plain stupid, yes but NO. 💰🤑🤭🙈🇺🇲
The Anglo-Saxon media only reserve their "sincerely out-of-character" good advice to select appointees that are against the leadership for China. This is because they "really" luv China very much more than their own families and friends. Don't you already know this?? 🤣🤣
Why isn’t anyone talking about the elephant in the room - the current Ukraine conflict goes back to the fall of the Soviet Union, where the American-led NATO assured the Soviets/ Russians that NATO would not expand an inch eastwards towards Russia’s border. That promise was never kept (as the Americans have proven the can’t be trusted). Any country would feel threatened if a military alliance (NATO) that sees them as an enemy expands right up to their border. I used to think Russia’s actions were inexcusable, but I definitely see Russia’s point of view and why they had to invade Ukraine in 2014 and 2022. As a fellow Singaporean, I’m surprised Mr Kishore Mabuhbani doesn’t raise this crucial historical point in his various speeches and talks around the world. It does give context to this Russia-Ukraine war. Renowned American economist, Prof. Jeffery Sachs, brings up this historical aspect of the current war. I really respect Professor Sachs. He calls a spade a spade. The Americans have provoked Russia- pushing it to a corner and using Ukraine to engage in a proxy war with Russia.
@@gflaubert3423 Just in case you are not aware of Singapore’s history with Malaysia; let me remind you that Singapore was expelled from the Malaysian Federation. They rejected Singapore. 😂😂
@@gflaubert3423 Ukraine wasn't kicked out of Russia. One has to look at the back story of the Ukraine-Russia conflict. It has to do with NATO expansion eastwards towards the Russian border. Once I researched the reason for Russia's invasion. I realised what CRIMINALS the Americans really are. They are global warmongers. So yes,, I do support Russia.
Why be jealous or defame Asian countries who are better at developments than the western countries ? It's a democratic freedom of trade and global mutual friendliness.
Dr. Kishore Mahbubani is objective, balanced and bast of all, always pointing to right direction. Anyone follows his prediction to buy HK or mainland China stock after listening his comments, it has increased over 30% in value in less than two months. The best strategic thinker.
Rightly put by Indian EAM Jaishankar that Europe expects everyone to believe Europe's problem is world, but not the other way around. In fact, it is opposite.
Don't be fooled by the anti-China rhetorics, Taiwan's ruling DDP party has never been serious about Taiwan's Independence movement during its 6 year reign. Most of us living in Taiwan have wised up to DDP's vote-grabbing tactic by claiming Taiwan's sovereignty while poking at Mainland China instead of cooperating with them for the greater good of our economy & stability. The recent local election in Taiwan saw DDP soundly thrashed by KMT candidates and president Tsai stepping down from DDP chairmanship.
DPP has infiltrated the educational instituation and made the young generation all to be anti-china and pro DPP. They're forward looking in controlling the media. They're looking to a permanant one party rule like Ghana, Japan and Singapore. As far as I observed, they're close to success if not because of US rising tension with China. You're too complacent within your comfort zone.
Mean while a underwater gas pipe has blown up, largest man made gas leak eco crisis ever, and people in Europe are suffering from increase cost of living. Nobody will die but people will freeze and starve. Anglos will not hesitate to make others suffer for their own gains never forget.
Kishore should skip answering about sgingaporean view on singapore sanction. Majority dont care, and those who care are against it. Government reason of the rightness is rubbish, what did SGP do when US invaded Iraq against the UN charter. SGP didnt sanction US, but supported US by sending in medical team to support.
Chinese people in Taiwan should not be used like Ukraine. Better to quickly limit damage by uniting with mainland - not only to restore/correct historical order. Hong Kongers have not lost anything; those who left for UK are not better off than those they left (do they vote in UK?)
Scholar Kishore Mahbubani is insightful and positive to the Point . Still when a country rise and a country decline in that way common sense is rising will go on rise and decline will decline mean double digits gaps .
In the current state, I'm not sure the US, as a nation, is capable of long term strategies. There is frequent change of government officials every 2 -6 years, often replaced by people of dissimilar ideologies and goals. On top of that, officials that are put in charge have decreased in quality significantly over the past 5 to 10 years, so much so that many of these people would never have been elected to hold government positions in practically any other country. Frankly, and I'm serious when I say this, long term geopolitical strategies are too complex for many of these people to comprehend.
🤣 There was a heated moment with Xi and an amateur head of state in G20. Xi finally scolded this amateur to behave like a real diplomat. He knew, and he walked off as a bad boy. 😂
@@christopherbong6639 a moronic answer, we are constantly threatened by our neighbors if you do not know the geopolitics of singapore, then keep your idiocy to yourself
First of all, You can't use the word "invade" with the issue between Mainland China and Taiwan. As invade is only use between Countries. Taiwan is always part of China.
The reason that the conversation has changed is that the Chinese gave up on Wolf Warrior diplomacy as being unproductive (or even counter productive) and the economic straits that China has entered. In other words, China was willing to talk to the US civilly (without gratuitous Chinese insults) again. I've just bought Kishore's latest book on my Kindle. Should be an interesting read.
I like watching various viewpoints to try to make comprehensive understanding of the world and ourselves. I’d like to recommend my videos of teaching Chinese language vividly and in a funny way. I hope you can recommend my videos to those who want to learn Chinese. I hope more people can learn Chinese to get comprehensive firsthand information about China and seek more job opportunities.
You can pray all you want but it will not change the fact that there has never been a more pathetic array of greedy hypocrites who are full of hubris and lies both to the rest of the world and there own people, but the 15%of the world's population who the west think they control have woken up with Kishore Mahbubani Jeffrey Sachs Prof Jaishanker Mia Mottley and many more getting the truth out, I wonder if the interviewer put the story right when the truth came out that it was a Ukrainian rocket that hit Poland or did he think no one would realise?? 🤔🤔🏴 A Welsh man who listens to all sides of the world's information not just the lies of the Western MSM
25:06 so true...a reality hard to be accepted by the USA, UK, AUS..we don't want to choose..I believe all of us in the region, if one side keep pressuring us to choose, we will *definitely* avoid those who force us to choose a side..we are hard-headed people. Never ever underestimate the power of getting annoyed...hahahaha Even we may not like all things done by the other side, the worst of all kind of people we all hate is *annoying people* and currently USA is super duper annoying..
@BEAST MODE So what do you suggest? Kowtow to US? Well if US think they will win Nuclear war, then let's die together. Because it's been said if nuclear war happened, there will be no champion, include USA
Chips Act is extremely detrimental for China's growth in the short term. But with the kind of economic and human resources strength China possesses now, it will get out of this stronger. Now, it's all about how much China can pull off in the next 10 years without being involved in a kinetic war.
Presenter disappointingly just another Westerner. Making quick snappy judgement against Russia, without even considering a possible difference of opinion
Just invest in those countries with govt with best governance and that govt will not change in the foreseeable future because a frequent change will affect the political stability of the country.
Please try not to mispronounce the name Xi as a Gee, Jee, or Shee. The proper pronunciation under Chinese pinyin is a lighter form of Si, When in doubt, Si is approximately quite close. To be more precise, Chinese pinyin, Xi Jinping's family name is pronounced like an English 's' except lighter. Pronounced like the word "see" with a small modification of pushing the sound through your front teeth and opening your lips horizontally. I am quite happy Prof Kishore has got most of his pinpoints of China correctly. His SHE is less wrong, but still wrong, and he should simply get a Professor from Nan Yang University to coach him on a simple "s" through front teeth,. It is the host of this clip who insists on being wrong with GEEE.
What I find irritating is when people pronounce the j in Beijing like the s in television. I don't understand why some people do that, especially western journalists. Beijing is not a French word.
@@pbworld7858 How did the colonial scholars get it wrong into Peking in the first place has had me hissing with giggle. Well perhaps, the British asked a Canonese speaker and he said in Cantonese, Pak Keng. In the same failed scholarship, when Deng Xiao-ping returned to the top, Time magazine, based in Hong Kong, took it upon themselves to be The authority to teach westerner how to pronounce the "Deng" as "D-Uhg" so it has remained Dung in the tongues of westerners no matter how supposedly expter that westerner is held high in the west. Kevin Rudd, former Aussi Prme Minister, who is literate in Chinese, is unfortunately also still doing Dung.
During the times of Hu Jintao, it was hard to make a mistake given the riddle: "Who is the President of China?" Answer "Hu is the President of China." Ask again "You did not answer my question?" Reminds us of the Ulysses story of the One-eyed giant after he was blinded by Ulysses. Asked: "Who blinded you?" Giant:"Nobody blinded me!"
The colonial Brits sure did emasculate the Chinese language willy-nilly. Hugely influenced by their Preachers the Comanders got their Wade-Gilles system translation of Chinese names. Hence, the language of Beijing area was codified as Mandarin, from Man-Da-Ren, meaning Manchurian Big Man ['s officials speak]. The Brits in a move to split HK residents from the mainland, insisted on teaching till 1997, Chinese teachings in HK using Cantonese rather than the Mandarin that was set as National Language since 1911 and has been for China as well as the KMT Taiwan. Western preachers had a good discipline of going to a village in China and for about 7 years concentrated on learning to speak fluently before starting to preach. Therefore, the Brits called the city Xiamen "Amoy" because that is close to the Hokkien pronunciation of the exact same words of the city. And Hong Kong was spelled by the British from the local Cantonese Hiong Kong, quite close except using the Brit light K, rather than the hard K pinyin as G, for Gang. Guangzhou was twisted to Canton, from the Cantonese sound Kwong Toong [Wade-Gilles] Side effect of this Brit parochialism is that in the Chinatowns of the world up till recently, the dialect used in retail business tends to be Cantonese. We who are wholesalers, other dialects, have a saying. "Why are Cantonese people born?" Answer:"Somebody has to pay retail."
If you are working in Asia please correctly pronounce Xi. No excuse and Kishore has at least got it right now except the tone (Chinese is a tonal language and only ethnic speakers and keen learner of the language know what I am talking about).
To be fair, Chinese struggle with English pronunciation too. Westerners can do better ... but don't take it too personally. After 25 years in China, few Chinese have pronounced my name perfectly. It's not a problem.
No point talks after talks where those who are involved in any wars won't listen to good advice as each will claim to be mightier than the other. That's the ego where no one wants to bring it down.
Hello guys the great conversation fantastic both of you merry Christmas Ang happy new stay safe GOD protect Jesus Christ Lord God name amen 🙏♥️ peace ✌️😘😍🇵🇭💋
He is such a puppet of a Chinese favourable system in Singapore. But, the same is true for analysts on the US side, always hiding truths, tweaking facts, setting a narrative.
Taiwan or any countrys in the world that had a deeply friendly with US, isn't matters with US government, because America's business is business, so when they are see the benefits a lot more than they are kept it, and they will transfer the things that customers want,US won't do losing money business
All US presidents always said there is “no change in one China policy’”… but each time the US insidiously trying out new and further steps on encouraging, enticing Taiwan to be on the independence side. Very mean and shameless.
AND WHAT WILL SINGAPORE DO ONCE CHINA DECOUPLES WITH U.S. AND THE GREATER MAJORITY OF THE WORLD SIDES WITH CHINA??? SIR,THE WORLD IS AWARE OF ALL THE GREEDY MINDEDNESS OF THE U.S. CAPITALISTIC HEGEMONIC DREAMS...HOW WILL SINGAPORE WORK UP THE HUMILITY TO APOLOGIZE???
Oh STOP YOUR NONSENSE!!! THE WORLD HAS HAD KINGS AND EMPERORS WHO HAD THE GOVTS OF THEIR COUNTRIES SOLELY ON THEIR SHOULDERS!!!...AND RULED BETTER THAN PRESENT DAY GOVTS...
@@dragonreborn4704 Singapore will be thrown under the bus by Uncle Sam and it'll be up to China to save it or not.
非常谢谢你能客观的评价！希望这个世界多点你这样的智者！我们中国人天性不喜欢侵略！但我们中国人从来没有惧怕过侵略！谢谢你！
Beware of their outward appearance, trying to stick to one China policy . Of their steely smiles, deceit is so natural, they divide the people with propaganda and lies like second nature.
Over 30 years ago a Japanese manager adviced me: " beware anglosphere (5 "eye") countries because they master three complementary strengths:
1) They very effectively turn world opinion on their side as being natural expression of "goodness".
2) If that is not effective they don't hesitate going to war for which they are always well prepared in advance.
3) In war, avoid fighting in their own territory to minimize civilian casualties and damage to country infrastructure.
the entire world knows their lies and tricks. This is why Multi-polarity will be of great benefit to the most of the world.
@@Western_Decline right !
It is not just the 5 eyes, or Anglo-Saxon, but the West which also include the Westernised Japan.
@@wingkeeho5864 The Garbage 7 nations
Bingo! You have hit the nail on the head. This is why you keep hearing "experts" like John Joseph Mearsheimer an American political scientist who keeps alluding to the fact the US has "stop and save" the world by defeating three "despotic cataclysmic precipice" single-handedly. More important the US has not only ended up victorious but came out stronger. Whereas countries like China does not have that experienced. However, what John Mearsheimer forgets to tell is that all these "American victories" took place on other people territories. America and Americans did not have to face the horrors of wars - the destruction, deaths, disruptions etc. One they face war on American soil, maybe John Mearsheimer won't be so "brave" about America being invincible!
I was once an Anglophile, but I became an Anglophobe when I became disillusioned with the utter hypocrisy of the Anglo Saxon world.
May i know your ethnicity? And thank you for finally opening your eyes.
BBC CNN VOA 难以置信这些国家媒体天天忙着造谣抹黑其它国家
@@alquemist7532
Peru Hispana - Phillipine Chin.
Same here!
If you have serious investment perspective through technical lens, would you really consider investing in a country that is constantly at wars and the best innovations from that country is none other than war related industries? That’s the best they can bring to the table for the mankind?
Jokowi is one savvy world class and leader. He emphasized on peace and not war. I salute Pres. Jokowi😍😍😍
Western nations need to keep to themselves! Stop interfering! And the world would be safe!
@@dericksmith740 Our thinking is 公德很重要! We can sacrificing our “freedom” for the greater good. Look at the comparative graph of covid deaths.
@@dericksmith740
现在爽吧？😁
@@dericksmith740 神經病
@@dericksmith740 你還懂得什麼叫公德私德！你們這些白种人只有兩百年歷史,懂什麼？只有幾年沒侵犯別的國家！Try to scan your conscience & help yourself & your own kind! We do appreciate your “concern”! 😩
Great talk! I love Kishore Mahbubani when he speaks to arrogant Westerners, especially Western intellectuals he speaks on behalf of the opinions of the non-Western world, especially the opinions of Asians, and he normally wins his arguments with the arrogant Westerners.
As a Chinese, this Western moderator is not too bad 😅
It's the 5 eyes led by the US that is most arrogant. They always say they care about the freedom of speech of those people in the countries they are against. But in truth, they just want to hurt those countries because they are competing for some resource that they cannot easily take without paying full price. If they really cared about individual people, then they would start with looking after their citizens using their own resources without trying to grab at the resources of others. It's like ftx being able to be generous with other people's money. And at the same time pocketing some of it for themselves. When it costs them personally, they can no longer be so generous.
@@physika yes, there are some westerners with very fair opinions. At the moment they are a minority simply due to the unfair china reports created by the US and the legacy media.
Portugese sounds have some that are between Spanish and French. So it is hard to trace back to derive.
Singapore can stand by many powerful countries one of the reasons is producing strong mindset like Kishore .Singapore never waste its resouces doing religious events like Malaysia creating religion bigots and morons
A HUGE fan of Kishore Mahbubani because unlike other "experts", he is honest!
Taiwan is the
Belong to China nobody can change that
@@dericksmith740 KISHORE has been unlawfully SUPPORTING CHINA'S UYGHUR GENOCIDES IN WAR CRIMINAL CHINA'S ARMY UNLAWFULLY OCCUPIED Uyghuristan ( aka EASTER TURKESTAN)
You really think so? With all due respect, he just makes the right noises, especially with regard to the West.
@@NutopianBlr He is actually considered to be pro-China and anti-West.
@@dericksmith740 and whole world didn't believe Chinese 👍👍👍what a fart
Kishore is always amaze me, the last question what he said is what I thought too. The west criticize Xi of appointing loyalist, but if you look at the background of those people is amazing. Xi is preparing his A TEAM to execute the master plan.
Yeah keep believing that lie.
@@beastmode8203 yeah, keep living your life in illusions lol 😆
@@beastmode8203 the truth only the truth mate !!!
@@rogernguyen1273 I guess you forgot what we did with the USSR.
The great thing is that the leaderships is working for the better of their populations. The loving-kindness intention of these leaders to their allegiances are exhibited. They really work hard, put in so much time n efforts to their responsibilities of for the peoples' good👍👏😍🙏🙏🙏
This is my first time to view SALT video, good stuff.
Kishore Mahbubani brought me here, who is one of the wisest and smartest diplomats & intellectuals in our time👍👍👍.
He was absolutely right about anglo Saxons versus as others. You can see that in wars created with them and their constant refusal to understand that the world is moving away from them.
It’s shame that Dr Mahbubani is not known to most Canadians as they are so much having their heads wrapped with Anglo Saxons media. Dr Mahbubani is an excellent speaker and a wise man.
He is a Professor who wears many hats.
Professor Mahbubani has been always eloquent, convincing, Intelligent and insightful. The West elites definitely should take notes when Professor Mahbubani speaks.
Singapore can stand by many powerful countries one of the reasons is producing strong mindset like Kishore .Singapore never waste its resouces doing religious events like Malaysia creating religion bigots and morons
Decoupling between US and China might likely mean decoupling between US and the world, well said!
Kishore is a geat man, neutral wise and candid.
That kishore talking rubbish only. Hahaha.... 🤭🤭🤭
That kishore last time kept praising prc china on the raise... now change like toad. He just talking rubbish only !
@Nick NG he talk rubbish?? How about you?? Did you get invited to talk on the stage??? O... BIG MOUTH like you will never get invited ... what a sour grapes.
The most prize statement I heard was 15:28 “ Europe think Europe problem are the world problem, the world problems are not Europe problems “
Short and clear statement to conclude the attitude born by the western ever since the first Industrial Revolution begin. 👏👏👏
However, I feel the statement is incomplete and could have been better because clearly we are missing one very important country. The one across the Atlantic.
Excellent insights shared by one of the best in business Kishore Mahbubani 😍
In his 20s, Macron used to translate Kishore’s work into French ❤ 12:16
Amazing show. Smart host and guest. It’s always worthy to watch multi-times.
Great insight from Kishore! In my view, Asia Pacific will be the most important region from economic standpoint in this century, next would be North America, Europe will keep falling with no end in sight.
I have seen many Chinese commenters say this about Europe that it will decline. I know you are saying this because of the huge influx of migrants. You guys are something else. Europe would actually fall without the migrants. They are about to have a large aging population that needs care and people to fill up that void so that their pension system does not collapse. Then they are about to see some people leave when the global south starts developing another possibility for collapse. Then they have issues with their election system and rise of the extreme right which everyone knows the extreme right is nationalist and sometimes socialist. Socialist, nationalist, conservative regimes tend to stumble the economic growth of a nation, because their way of thinking limits creativity and thus people that want to create new concepts. So I do not even know what you are saying. Both Europe and the US will not collapse. If one collapse the other collapses. You are funny.
This professor is one the most intelligent human-being in the world.
It’s not America backing off from Taiwan but the Taiwanese people voted not to be mislead and used by America to wage proxy war against China similar to Ukraine against Russia. ASEAN will move closer towards China similar to Middle East.
Nope
What a fantastic talk, I can listen to Kishore for hours. Thank you!
Just copy Indonesian President and defence minister said to the west, "Stop dictacting, Stop intervering our domestic issue, Stop said my standart is better then yours, start to nake cooperation and work together for peace and better world, remember that the west enemy is not necessary our enemy too.". Bravo Indonesia ♥️😆👍🇮🇩
Kishore is very smart and neutral ..because his neutrality he can see the weakness and the stregth , therefore he gets the solution and recommendation on how to solve the problem ..😁😊👍👍👍
@sunnyday9331 do enlighten us. Do you some info on that?
Anybody else notice how the host (crabtree) assumed automatically it was a Russian missile that went into Poland, when it was in fact a Ukrainian missile. The West is so biased, it's comical.
Kishore is a real objective and rational scholar.
Well said!
Collective west is living in their colonial days!! Orang puteh!
This conversation is very insightful, many thanks.
👍👍👍👍👍Wise, fair and very insightful points
一位具有最高智慧的新加坡学者！
Nah. Sanctions on Russia wasn't well-received by Singaporeans. Many pointed to Israel-Palestine and the fact that we were very likely pressured by the US to side with them in this instance, in return for neutrality on China.
Singapore's CNA has became BBC lately, helping to smear China.
If I'm the president or pm or company boss, surely I'll appoint my men who are firstly loyal and capable. Of course its stupid to appoint someone that goes against you even though he's very very smart. NOPE. Looks like those Anglo-Saxons medias are plain stupid, yes but NO. 💰🤑🤭🙈🇺🇲
What you are talking about old man?
昂撒媒体在引导一种错误的意识，这种伎俩拙劣，用心是中国人都能显而易见的！只不过是为了本国政客的选票制造议题。或者搅乱我们。我们中国人都很相信这个领导集体。国家是时候强硬了
@@level1selamat155 Do Western leaders put their political enemies inside their cabinets? 🙄
The Anglo-Saxon media only reserve their "sincerely out-of-character" good advice to select appointees that are against the leadership for China. This is because they "really" luv China very much more than their own families and friends.
Don't you already know this?? 🤣🤣
Russia: Let's be friends
US: No
EU: No
China: Yes
Global South: Yes
China: Let's be friends
US: No
EU: Maybe
Russia: Yes
Global South: Yes
Im so glad that my family has survived COVID-19 now in BJ...Well said, professor
True to earth opinions expressed by Kishore.
Kishore always in every single interview analysis true and fact to the point.
Prof Kishore, every time you expound on a concept, I hv to rewind and listen to it again, to understand it.
Why isn’t anyone talking about the elephant in the room - the current Ukraine conflict goes back to the fall of the Soviet Union, where the American-led NATO assured the Soviets/ Russians that NATO would not expand an inch eastwards towards Russia’s border. That promise was never kept (as the Americans have proven the can’t be trusted). Any country would feel threatened if a military alliance (NATO) that sees them as an enemy expands right up to their border. I used to think Russia’s actions were inexcusable, but I definitely see Russia’s point of view and why they had to invade Ukraine in 2014 and 2022. As a fellow Singaporean, I’m surprised Mr Kishore Mabuhbani doesn’t raise this crucial historical point in his various speeches and talks around the world. It does give context to this Russia-Ukraine war. Renowned American economist, Prof. Jeffery Sachs, brings up this historical aspect of the current war. I really respect Professor Sachs. He calls a spade a spade. The Americans have provoked Russia- pushing it to a corner and using Ukraine to engage in a proxy war with Russia.
@@gflaubert3423 Just in case you are not aware of Singapore’s history with Malaysia; let me remind you that Singapore was expelled from the Malaysian Federation. They rejected Singapore. 😂😂
@@gflaubert3423 Ukraine wasn't kicked out of Russia. One has to look at the back story of the Ukraine-Russia conflict. It has to do with NATO expansion eastwards towards the Russian border. Once I researched the reason for Russia's invasion. I realised what CRIMINALS the Americans really are. They are global warmongers. So yes,, I do support Russia.
Why be jealous or defame Asian countries who are better at developments than the western countries ?
It's a democratic freedom of trade and global mutual friendliness.
The minds of the US/west say "no one should be better than us, back off or you will get sanctions and bombs."
Fuck China
I love China! I'm so happy for the rise of China! What a fantastic development for the world!
"... most likely a Russian missile." Oh dear! 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Dr. Kishore Mahbubani is objective, balanced and bast of all, always pointing to right direction. Anyone follows his prediction to buy HK or mainland China stock after listening his comments, it has increased over 30% in value in less than two months. The best strategic thinker.
Rightly put by Indian EAM Jaishankar that Europe expects everyone to believe Europe's problem is world, but not the other way around. In fact, it is opposite.
except Europe is a distraction, US is the real problem!
Amazing talk! Quite insightful!
I'd love to see number one city in Asia
It is. Shanghai.
Don't be fooled by the anti-China rhetorics, Taiwan's ruling DDP party has never been serious about Taiwan's Independence movement during its 6 year reign. Most of us living in Taiwan have wised up to DDP's vote-grabbing tactic by claiming Taiwan's sovereignty while poking at Mainland China instead of cooperating with them for the greater good of our economy & stability. The recent local election in Taiwan saw DDP soundly thrashed by KMT candidates and president Tsai stepping down from DDP chairmanship.
改课纲，花钱游说美国引狼入室，养着庞大的网军每天抹黑中国，反送中，香港暴乱，拼命买武器没反中？
Glad to see Taiwanese public wised up and refused to be used as proxy for external power competition or ended up as cannon fodder.
@@bobguard there's still going to be war.
DPP has infiltrated the educational instituation and made the young generation all to be anti-china and pro DPP. They're forward looking in controlling the media. They're looking to a permanant one party rule like Ghana, Japan and Singapore. As far as I observed, they're close to success if not because of US rising tension with China. You're too complacent within your comfort zone.
@@beastmode8203only if the USA continues on the path they are on. The USA is the only one interested in a war.
Big Keesh is great! This host is just another colonial stooge however
U a stooge for CCP? Haha 😄 🤣 😂 😆 😄
the host is on the western MIC's payroll. just look him up, crabtree works for IISS which is funded by bae, lockheed etc
@@donaldjoseph3903 u a CIA puppet?
@@donaldjoseph3903 CIA, MI6 double agent!
@@jeremyt7448 kyrin, great research. indeed👌
Always enjoy the wise words of Kishore
It was proved that Ukraine shot that missile on Poland
Mean while a underwater gas pipe has blown up, largest man made gas leak eco crisis ever, and people in Europe are suffering from increase cost of living. Nobody will die but people will freeze and starve. Anglos will not hesitate to make others suffer for their own gains never forget.
A well travelled man is a very intelligent man 👨
Kishore is most influential speaker on Asia on earth so far.
Kishore should skip answering about sgingaporean view on singapore sanction. Majority dont care, and those who care are against it. Government reason of the rightness is rubbish, what did SGP do when US invaded Iraq against the UN charter. SGP didnt sanction US, but supported US by sending in medical team to support.
Fully agree with you.
Chinese people in Taiwan should not be used like Ukraine. Better to quickly limit damage by uniting with mainland - not only to restore/correct historical order. Hong Kongers have not lost anything; those who left for UK are not better off than those they left (do they vote in UK?)
Those that left for the UK are worse off than those that stayed back.
No
Scholar Kishore Mahbubani is insightful and positive to the Point .
Still when a country rise and a country decline in that way common sense is rising will go on rise and decline will decline mean double digits gaps .
"Most likely to be Russian strike in Poland", that aged pretty bad. Lmao.
kishore真的太懂中国了，今天是2022年12月21日，中国从清零到完全开放只用了一个月时间，2023年1月3日，中国出入境也会取消隔离。2023年中国经济的表现应该会让很多人惊讶的，走着瞧吧
In the current state, I'm not sure the US, as a nation, is capable of long term strategies. There is frequent change of government officials every 2 -6 years, often replaced by people of dissimilar ideologies and goals. On top of that, officials that are put in charge have decreased in quality significantly over the past 5 to 10 years, so much so that many of these people would never have been elected to hold government positions in practically any other country. Frankly, and I'm serious when I say this, long term geopolitical strategies are too complex for many of these people to comprehend.
We will not coexist a second to China. You will get the war of all wars mutually assured destruction or not.☢️
Wonderful talks !
I like Kishore, too.
🤣 There was a heated moment with Xi and an amateur head of state in G20. Xi finally scolded this amateur to behave like a real diplomat. He knew, and he walked off as a bad boy. 😂
Ice cold😏
Great pleasure watching that scene.
Singapore’s sanction on Russia is shameful especially when part of NAM.
No. They have to as an ally of US! They weapons especially fighter jets are all in Guam!
We have our reasons. We don’t want what is happening to Ukraine to take place on our soil. Simple as that.
@@Diderot68 pray do tell how can what happened in Ukraine happen here?
@@christopherbong6639 a moronic answer, we are constantly threatened by our neighbors
if you do not know the geopolitics of singapore, then keep your idiocy to yourself
@@christopherbong6639 china Taiwan screw up , will affect SEA too
Why did they have the pro west white guy?
First of all, You can't use the word "invade" with the issue between Mainland China and Taiwan. As invade is only use between Countries. Taiwan is always part of China.
Very impressive interview.
The reason that the conversation has changed is that the Chinese gave up on Wolf Warrior diplomacy as being unproductive (or even counter productive) and the economic straits that China has entered. In other words, China was willing to talk to the US civilly (without gratuitous Chinese insults) again.
I've just bought Kishore's latest book on my Kindle. Should be an interesting read.
I like watching various viewpoints to try to make comprehensive understanding of the world and ourselves.
I’d like to recommend my videos of teaching Chinese language vividly and in a funny way. I hope you can recommend my videos to those who want to learn Chinese.
I hope more people can learn Chinese to get comprehensive firsthand information about China and seek more job opportunities.
We pray for responsible leadership in Ukraine UK US Europe NATO. Please look after your people. Please. Merry Christmas ⛄⛄⛄⛄⛄ to one and all 💓💓💓
You can pray all you want but it will not change the fact that there has never been a more pathetic array of greedy hypocrites who are full of hubris and lies both to the rest of the world and there own people, but the 15%of the world's population who the west think they control have woken up with Kishore Mahbubani Jeffrey Sachs Prof Jaishanker Mia Mottley and many more getting the truth out, I wonder if the interviewer put the story right when the truth came out that it was a Ukrainian rocket that hit Poland or did he think no one would realise?? 🤔🤔🏴 A Welsh man who listens to all sides of the world's information not just the lies of the Western MSM
25:06 so true...a reality hard to be accepted by the USA, UK, AUS..we don't want to choose..I believe all of us in the region, if one side keep pressuring us to choose, we will *definitely* avoid those who force us to choose a side..we are hard-headed people. Never ever underestimate the power of getting annoyed...hahahaha
Even we may not like all things done by the other side, the worst of all kind of people we all hate is *annoying people* and currently USA is super duper annoying..
You actually believe you won't get a nuclear war? Oh my God keep challenging the US and watch what happens to humanity ☢️
@BEAST MODE So what do you suggest? Kowtow to US? Well if US think they will win Nuclear war, then let's die together. Because it's been said if nuclear war happened, there will be no champion, include USA
Chips Act is extremely detrimental for China's growth in the short term. But with the kind of economic and human resources strength China possesses now, it will get out of this stronger. Now, it's all about how much China can pull off in the next 10 years without being involved in a kinetic war.
If all else fails you will get the war of all wars ☢️
Kishore is looking after the interest of Singapore.
Indonesia!👏👏👏👏👏
Hypocracy of US.
Insightful
A pity that someone is sarcastic to KISHORE. A change seems necessary
Kishore is too diplomatic to call America out as the chief troublemaker of the world and needs to stop
Empower the United Nations and the International Criminal Court.
Then all USA presidents will be prosecuted.
They are set up to empower Western nations.
We are now at the “earlier next year “
Presenter disappointingly just another Westerner. Making quick snappy judgement against Russia, without even considering a possible difference of opinion
Because that opinion is of our enemy.
Just invest in those countries with govt with best governance and that govt will not change in the foreseeable future because a frequent change will affect the political stability of the country.
14:00 ok this anecdote improved my opinion of macron a bit.
Western politicians and media should change the perception that they represent the whole world
On Indonesia's arranging the G20, it shows the diplomacy side of Asia while the west is confrontational. After 2 world wars, the west learned nothing!
A $1000 ticket seminar is free here on YT. Thank you
ALMIGHTY GOD IS ONE AND BLESSES EVERYONE WITHOUT ANY DISCRIMINATION IRRESPECTIVE OF CASTE, COLOUR,CREED, RACE,SEX, LANGUAGE, REGION OR RELIGION.
“At Alaska, they shouted at each other, exchanged insult..”. Who are they? From both sides? Or one sided?
There no such thing call "like minded", it just a catchy word by the west.
Shallow
Please try not to mispronounce the name Xi as a Gee, Jee, or Shee. The proper pronunciation under Chinese pinyin is a lighter form of Si, When in doubt, Si is approximately quite close. To be more precise, Chinese pinyin, Xi Jinping's family name is pronounced like an English 's' except lighter. Pronounced like the word "see" with a small modification of pushing the sound through your front teeth and opening your lips horizontally.
I am quite happy Prof Kishore has got most of his pinpoints of China correctly. His SHE is less wrong, but still wrong, and he should simply get a Professor from Nan Yang University to coach him on a simple "s" through front teeth,. It is the host of this clip who insists on being wrong with GEEE.
What I find irritating is when people pronounce the j in Beijing like the s in television. I don't understand why some people do that, especially western journalists. Beijing is not a French word.
Totally agree. I hv pointed this out to a western channel but they continually ignore. Guess it shows on them why even when told it's wrong.
@@pbworld7858 How did the colonial scholars get it wrong into Peking in the first place has had me hissing with giggle. Well perhaps, the British asked a Canonese speaker and he said in Cantonese, Pak Keng. In the same failed scholarship, when Deng Xiao-ping returned to the top, Time magazine, based in Hong Kong, took it upon themselves to be The authority to teach westerner how to pronounce the "Deng" as "D-Uhg" so it has remained Dung in the tongues of westerners no matter how supposedly expter that westerner is held high in the west. Kevin Rudd, former Aussi Prme Minister, who is literate in Chinese, is unfortunately also still doing Dung.
During the times of Hu Jintao, it was hard to make a mistake given the riddle: "Who is the President of China?" Answer "Hu is the President of China." Ask again "You did not answer my question?"
Reminds us of the Ulysses story of the One-eyed giant after he was blinded by Ulysses. Asked: "Who blinded you?" Giant:"Nobody blinded me!"
The colonial Brits sure did emasculate the Chinese language willy-nilly. Hugely influenced by their Preachers the Comanders got their Wade-Gilles system translation of Chinese names. Hence, the language of Beijing area was codified as Mandarin, from Man-Da-Ren, meaning Manchurian Big Man ['s officials speak]. The Brits in a move to split HK residents from the mainland, insisted on teaching till 1997, Chinese teachings in HK using Cantonese rather than the Mandarin that was set as National Language since 1911 and has been for China as well as the KMT Taiwan.
Western preachers had a good discipline of going to a village in China and for about 7 years concentrated on learning to speak fluently before starting to preach. Therefore, the Brits called the city Xiamen "Amoy" because that is close to the Hokkien pronunciation of the exact same words of the city. And Hong Kong was spelled by the British from the local Cantonese Hiong Kong, quite close except using the Brit light K, rather than the hard K pinyin as G, for Gang. Guangzhou was twisted to Canton, from the Cantonese sound Kwong Toong [Wade-Gilles]
Side effect of this Brit parochialism is that in the Chinatowns of the world up till recently, the dialect used in retail business tends to be Cantonese. We who are wholesalers, other dialects, have a saying. "Why are Cantonese people born?" Answer:"Somebody has to pay retail."
Good
Jealousy driving US insanity?
Are you ready for Armageddon ☢️🇺🇸
If you are working in Asia please correctly pronounce Xi. No excuse and Kishore has at least got it right now except the tone (Chinese is a tonal language and only ethnic speakers and keen learner of the language know what I am talking about).
To be fair, Chinese struggle with English pronunciation too.
Westerners can do better ... but don't take it too personally.
After 25 years in China, few Chinese have pronounced my name perfectly. It's not a problem.
So the best thing to do is to stay out!
No point talks after talks where those who are involved in any wars won't listen to good advice as each will claim to be mightier than the other.
That's the ego where no one wants to bring it down.
The speaker is so realistic and professional with deep understanding of the history of the West and East .
Hello guys the great conversation fantastic both of you merry Christmas Ang happy new stay safe GOD protect Jesus Christ Lord God name amen 🙏♥️ peace ✌️😘😍🇵🇭💋
He is such a puppet of a Chinese favourable system in Singapore. But, the same is true for analysts on the US side, always hiding truths, tweaking facts, setting a narrative.
There shall be no two (or more) tigers on one mountain. That's the law of the jungle.
Only America obeys the law of the jungle. China and Russia are not against two or more tigers.
Ok nearer🤙
So now it's confusion?
Taiwan or any countrys in the world that had a deeply friendly with US, isn't matters with US government, because America's business is business, so when they are see the benefits a lot more than they are kept it, and they will transfer the things that customers want,US won't do losing money business
no sound
OK now