Rabbi Tovia Singer responds to Messianic: 'Talmud says suffering Messiah son of Joseph will return!'
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 лют 2021
- Let’s Get Biblical Study Guide (Volume 1 & 2) outreachjudaism.org/shop/lets...
Help us combat aggressive evangelization in Israel: outreachjudaism.org/partners/
outreachjudaism.org/ www.toviasinger.tv/
/ tenaktalk
Music: www.purple-planet.com
![Lp. Последняя Реальность #107 РОДНОЙ ДОМ [Финал] • Майнкрафт](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/IK3QKzKUlHM/mqdefault.jpg)
Always amazed by Tovias in depth knowledge of the entire Bible
That is what annoys me and he has a very superficial acquaintance with the Koran which is so much closer to Judaism.
I want to ask the rabbi why he has been reading the Christian bible which is full of blasphemy. As a muslim I find it abhorent.
@@septemberwaqar6576 because in order to be able to better refute a book 📙, one must read it through. There's no other choice.
@@dumbledor22 That is true. However what happens if we were to delete every word of Paul. Would Christianity still be a false story for the Rabbi? Would Jesus still be an imposter? This is the real litmus test.
@@septemberwaqar6576 yes, because he didn't fulfil "any" of the criteria the messiah has to meet, neither did anything happen in his days that is supposed to happen when the messiah has finally come and revealed himself and rules over us.
Besides, the burden of proof is always on "them Christians" - not on us.
My dear Rabbi Singer, how much Torah of Hashem blessed is He. No wonder why He blesses you with so much wisdom and love. I wish that I could see and hear all Sages speak of all the wonders of our Creator, blessed is He! Thank you for sharing your knowledge with us.
Thank you dear rabbi for your time and amazing teachings!
Thank you Rabbi for such wisdom of Torah and clearing up my mind and directing me to Hashem and Torah. Torah always spells out Emet. Thank you again for sharing truths.
Hashem has Blessed Rabbi Singer with a mind that can hold all this information and share it with us in such a way as to make the complex understandable. B'H He is a blessing to all of us and may he continue to share truth with the world. I wish more people would listen and take to heart everything he teaches. What an amazing Rabbi! Thank you Rabbi Singer!
@Abraham Mani perhaps you can explain why the "Lord's Prayer" asks G-d to forgive and asks that He deliver us from evil but says NOTHING about your mangod. One would think this would be a good place to insert a mangod IF he were legit.
Learned a lot listening to you then i did 4 yrs ago reading books and attending service
I liked before listening. I am your student Rav Tovia .We thank Hashem for you.
@Iyas kelu pay close attention to the text sir .Please listen again to Rabbi @ 6:44 Perhaps arrange zoom meeting , so we can look at text together.
@Iyas kelu Riddle me this do you accept the book of Mormons? It's the same reason we don't accept the new Testament.
Thank you so much this is great.
Very good content.
תודה ל ! Thank you!
Thank you so much! This question comes back often. This is so well explained.
Maayan why does the rabbi not answer my question which is.......
Paul came centuries later than Jesus .Why did the Jews mislead the Romans and get Jesus crucified. My God he is probably the only prophet to have suffered such a painful death.
The Jews do not accept two of the greatest prophets sent by God. What is the point of asking them anything ?
The fact that the message of Jesus was corrupted means he was a prophet and did come with instructions. Does that mean the rabbi accepts this fact. If so then he is not a Jew but a muslim.
@@septemberwaqar6576 where did you asked it to him? This video isn't the subject. I advice you to write to him on his internet site.
Paul didn't come centuries later. He didn't know Jesus. But was born in the beginning of the 1st century and died around 67 CE
This is pretty heavy. This is one I gotta come back and watch again.
Thank you so much Rabbi!
I love this Rabi, May Hashem bless him and give him a lot of life and days so he might teach us more from the holy scriptures. Baruj Hashem
You are trying to make every body in bible is liar.I thinnk u r.the one telling so much lies.
Your discussions have brought me a sense of peace and understanding that years studying in chabad never did. Bless you Rabbi Singer
It incredible how much knowledge you know rabbi.
Mind blowing, exciting times ahead
Probably very hard to unlearn years of Christian teaching. Hope Hashem helps me to learn and do what I learn.
I hope you already accepted the 7 Noahide commandments.
@A Sojourner I couldn’t agree more...Hashem, our Father, our King is sure is merciful.
Be in touch if you have questions. I'm a Jew from birth, born in the USA and living in Israel for many years. I work with Rabbi Singer and other antimissionaries, and with Noahides.
@@BornAgain926 I was referring to BeTrueth. In any case, you're referencing an NT source. We don't accept the NT as authoritative, since it is foreign to Torah and negates it. So we do not accept what it says about Rabban Gamliel.
It is definitely a struggle to get it out of your head even after years of leaving. Songs, verses, memories, fears...the lies just don't disappear.
Rabbi Singer, THANK YOU !!!!!
Great video!
Wow, mind blown...amazing, much love.
Lol. All of the sudden, Messiantics are interested in the teachings of the Talmud. They always bash the Talmud and Oral Law, until they find something that they think they can twist to support Christian theology.
Rabbi you are blessed by the way you explain, it is not only reading the Tanakh, but also interpreting the verses by looking at the verses through Jewish eyes, something Rabbi Shulman pointed out, it gives reading the Tanakh a whole new meaning and understanding.
The more I read the Tanakh the more I discover.
Thanks very much for this explanation.
And yet Christians treat Paul's message as divine.
Thank you Rabbi
Hurray, hurray, peace. Shalom, shalom aleichem!
Mind Blowing!❤
The Almighty takes the weakest, most unexpected, unassuming, or unlikely candidate for the occasion, and raises them up to strength and greatness; e.g. Moses had murdered, yet was chosen to deliver the law; Jonah repeatedly ran from the Lord's calling, but became a prophet; David was a shepherd, yet he became a warrior and a king. The Almighty does this throughout all the scriptures. This is just one thing that shows how great He is why I love Him. It's just such a wonderful and beautiful thing.
Amen. Very true.
@A Sojourner the Old Testament is not exclusively from the Creator,explain why science denies everything the Bible says?
Give me back a yesterday And take my tomorrows Science is not exclusively factual or objective. It’s littered with gap-filling of opinions without evidence, and provable evidence found to be contrary to popular opinion tends to be ignored. What I find to be a common theme amongst those arguing science vs scripture is an insufficient understanding of either. A basic college-level understanding of the sciences should have one questioning how scientists have made their conclusions, if not from their own imagination. And often a conclusion made by one branch of science is completely rejected by another.
@@monkeyslap who’s the almighty and what scriptures and prophets are you talking about?
Proverbs 26:4, anybody? May you all be blessed by the Most High, in accordance with His will.
הללויה!! איזו שיחה נהדרת! תבורך
Bach's Brandenburg concertos are magnificent......
~15:30---"if you will absorb this Holy (Kodesh) Toreh, you mamesh become a new person----
I have known this in my heart to be true for over 20 years. Thank you!
Rabbi you really know your Bible old and you I appreciate your willingness to share... you are A WONDERFUL TEACHER... THANKS.
@@dallyjacobson2146 actually, this rabbi "does" have videos addressing all of those Christian claims and so called proofs. Nothing is brushed under the carpet, and he has nothing to hide.
Always learn so much from tovia
Rabbi please can you find a Spanish interpreter si that translates tour teachings.........alot of Christian's needs to hear this .millions of spanish Christians belivers need to hear this.
Wry smile .... it is a bicycle kick 👍🏽😉..... but this detracts Rabbi Tovia .... your explanations are insightful and valuable.
It's impressing how well he knows the shaas, I wanna know how many times he finished it
Look we should all be looking for the truth only.
●Why did Adam disobey God?
● Why is a woman supposed to be the instigator? Eversince we find male authors blaming the woman for man's.
transgression.
● What role does the serpent play in the universe ?
Well?
Facts he legit knows all Jewish holy books by heart. He is a true sage.
Excellent.with out screaming or jumping just simple and clear.i like it.
Genious Rab!!! 👏👏👏👏👏👏
Omy i was just wondering about this
Christians misquote our Talmud, midrash. Zohar and commentators. They are desperate and pathetic
He's a very well learned man.
if hes so smart why after the temple is built and the so called messiah comes why is god going to pull wrath on the earth?. if it was truly the messiah there would be peace forever on earth.
בטח! יהודי! כמוני !🥸
@@marcellofunhouse1234 Revelations 19:11-12 he doth judge and make war.
12 His eyes were as a flame of fire, and on his head were many crowns;
@@marcellofunhouse1234 Matthew 3:7 when he saw many of the Pharisees and Sadducees coming ... he said to them: “You brood of vipers! Who warned you to flee from the coming wrath?"
@@marcellofunhouse1234 Matthew 10:35 “I have come to turn 'a man against his father, a daughter against her mother, a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law. '” “I have come to set 'a man against his father, a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law. '”
tell me more!!
Paul drashed Isaiah 27:9 with Isaiah 59:20 using the common theme of “Jacob.”
This isn’t a mutilation of the text according to the rules of Hillel, ie Gezeira Shava.
Excellent
Rabbi, the Torah teaches that Messiah comes twice via the example of Moses: in that Moses himself came twice to save his people. The first time the people rejected him with the phrase "who made you prince over us?", and the second time he came riding on a donkey and delivered them out of Egypt into the Promised Land. Even our understanding of the Prophets, if we hold them to be canon (which we do) when talking about Messiah, our understanding of their writings has to be in line with the Torah's examples or we miss the truth altogether. Furthermore to say that mashiach in one place can not be used to further understand Mashiach, totally discredits the Torah's teaching that we understand Torah truth through PaRDeS of which Remez is one of the methods of interpretation the Torah itself teaches us to use in delving into its mysteries. And in fact, it is ony at the level of Remez that we even know about Mashiach from Torah, since no where in Torah is Mashiach found at the Peshat level as referring to the son of David who redeems Israel at the end of this world. So by cautioning people to not look at Remez when it comes to mashiach, you actually wind up removing Mashiach from Torah altogether.
Still, in the "prophets" it's mentioned explicitly that moshiach must be a descendant of king 👑 David.
@Ian Meijer not according to their own claims, who maintain that he's the son of god: you can't be both.
@Ian Meijer dosen't help. In Judaism tribal lineage is determined by the father.
@Ian Meijer it's important not to get confused, and to be able to make distinctions between things that are not the same, even if they seem so: in Judaism whether you're a jew at all, is determined by your mother. But once your Judaism has been established, which "tribe" you're from, is determined by your "father", as the torah clearly states
@Ian Meijer I just looked it up, and i can't understand what you want to get at with this.
I wonder how many Christians know the term "Rabbi" means teacher? Your teachings that have helped me understand much that has troubled me as a former christian (12 years in Catholic school). Of great concern to me is the influence conservative christian organizations and individuals have on American politics. Thank you and best regards.
Yep. Means torah teacher
Such a deep understanding of the original text , he is just amazing!
How can I read in English what I need to know? Every invitation to learn "original" Torah turns out to be from Jews for Jesus. Where can I find a good English translation? Also how can I know what is in the Sanhedrin if I don't know how to find one?
Jewish Publication Society or Koren both have a good translation of the Torah. You can find them on Amazon. The Sanhedrin isn't a book, it was the court of 71 delegates in Jerusalem.
Thank you Rabbi for being a true light to the nations!
Ethics of the Fathers 4:13 states "There are three crowns - the crown of Torah, the crown of priesthood, and the crown of kingship."
Rabbi Dr. Michael Schulman explains the crown of Torah applies to observant Jewish Torah scholars, and to observant Noahides who become expert in the details of the Noahide Code.
Do you get paid for advocating the Noahide Code? I am tired reading every post of yours about the Noahide code. Anything else to share with us Jews and non-jews? Shabbat shalom.
@@nandinibandhini Yes, Hashem pays me.
@@hrvatskinoahid1048 Yes I thought u were on his payroll. LOL Gets boring though. Enlighten the comment section with something out of this world based on Tanakh.
@@hrvatskinoahid1048 You even work on Shabbath! Hashem Ye Rachehm. Chas ve chalila. Death penalty under the Sanhedrin of old days.
@@nandinibandhini After 2000 years of being neglected, the Noahide Code is finally being promoted, and you find that boring? Yes, I work on the Shabbath, because I am not a Jew.
In it’s time, also know until the fullness of times or time.
@Janis Hart, I am trying to reply to your comments but I can't find them on the thread.
Hi Patricia. UA-cam 'removed' my account yesterday for a few hours, for 'violating their guidelines'! I just got my account back around 3 a.m. this morning after informing them that THEY are in violation of my HUMAN RIGHT to FREEDOM OF SPEECH, and that the purpose of a comment section is the "FREE" exchange of ideas between people with differing 'opinions'.
I reminded them that I had NOT threatened anyone with physical harm, nor had I made any seditious comments against the Gov't. After reading my complaint about my account being deleted, and reviewing my account, they restored it a couple of hours later, with an apology, saying that I had NOT, in fact, violated their guidelines - but in typical YT fashion, they never tell you WHAT you said that 'violated' their 'guidelines'! This also happened twice before, when my account was "suspended" for a couple of weeks, instead of being "deleted" - no explanation!
So, I guess my former comments are gone, unless I beg them to put them back, but the fact that they deleted my account stressed me out so much (on top of the personal stress I am already under!) that I don't have the energy for another fight with them! Do you remember what I said? They must be doing this to a lot of people, because I often go looking for people's previous replies, and they're just gone, and I can't respond to them! YT must have an overzealous employee enforcing their 'guidelines', according to their OWN 'opinion' - dunno!
@@janishart5128 Why would they shut down your account? You don't say anything bad. I noticed that sometimes my comments disappear for no reason. Strange.
@@patriciaperez9454: UA-cam NEVER gives you a reason why they disable your account - they just send you a 'form-letter' type of response telling you that you've 'offended their guidelines' - and you only get ONE chance to 'appeal' your case to them. If you reply more than once, you get another 'form letter' type of e-mail, to which you can't respond (it's one of those '@donotreply' ones!), saying that you're only allowed ONE 'appeal' in reference to your account!
SO...you never know exactly WHAT you said that 'set them off' and caused them to shut down your account!! They're NOT easy to communicate with, that's for sure!! Either somebody took offence to something I said and reported me, or, as I said, maybe UA-cam has an overzealous employee working for them, who offends easily - dunno, and never will, apparently! Also, some people just can't stand to to read the Truth, so they try to silence it whenever they can.
@A Sojourner: Hey, thanks, pw! And I'm REALLY glad to be back 'in the land of the living', as it were! I've checked out other social media platforms, like Bitchute and Gab, but I don't find them user-friendly, and I don't like their formats as much as I do UA-cam's! There's another one that someone suggested, called MeWe, but I haven't checked it out yet.
@@janishart5128 That happened to me once when they temporarily closed my account and they told me it was because of "suspicious activity." Lol. But then I recovered my account.
I think that maybe someone flagged us and then reported us. People these days will report a person to UA-cam for the dumbest things. This is why alot of people today are afraid to post comments on UA-cam. There is too much censorship.
Can I ask something is Pslam 91, Pslam 22 , Pslam 114,115,116 messianic prophecies?
In Judaism Psalms are not "Navi'm" ( prophecy).
@Leonardo DaVinci Why did you paint "last supper " with European s with bread on Passover table?
Lol
@Leonardo DaVinci then why worship a corpse?
@Leonardo DaVinci Because God is not a man.
@Leonardo DaVinci The Torah says what it says.
@Bug Out Now, Where did you get the idea that Paul was actually Pliny the Younger? Please provide some proof, dear.
It seems a little far fetched to say the gospels were written by the Romans.
It's called history
@@rawintexas That's not proof
@@patriciaperez9454 Sounds like something Q anon came up with. Lol
@@CarlosGarcia-ij4yg He got it from "Ceasar's Messiah." I saw the video on UA-cam but I thought it was a little far fetched and unconvincing.
It's another one of many conspiracy theories about Christianity.
@watluktwel The Romans spoke Latin, not Greek. The gospels were written in Greek.
The Romans also persecuted the Christians. Why would they persecute the Christians if they made up Christianity? It doesn't make sense.
I suppose my question would be if your not supposed to add to the Torah as stated in Deuteronomy, why would the Servant of HaShem accept the Talmud? I am a Noahide, (and about to change that unless I can get an explanation tho I praise HaShem no mater what)rather ignorant that I didn't know that the Noahide Law is not found in Torah, but rather is found in the Talmud? I'm reading the Talmud, and there is some disturbing things in it so far...if someone can help it would be appreciated.
Just a quick notice: The whole vers is changed. In Isaiah it says:''And a redeemer will come TO Zion'' even more the NKJV says ''The deliverer will come OUT OF Zion'' or ''come from Zion'' as in the vers presented here. Now from ''come to a place vs come out of that place'' is a huge difference. Example: Coming to Jacob is not the same as Coming out of Jacob. Baruch Hashem.
Very sad to see messianic jews betraying Moses and Abraham and believing in a man god.
Hear the words of the Lord: *'Verily, verily I say unto you, before Abraham was, I AM.'*
@@hawkeye2958: NOWHERE does this verse appear in God's ETERNAL Hebrew scriptures! It comes from the false, pagan, man-made work of fiction "New Testament", that preaches AGAINST what God said to us at Mt. Sinai, and therefore, DID NOT come from God! PLEASE do some research on how Christianity started, and you WILL discover that it absolutely DID NOT come from God, Creator of the universe!
No one seen God at anytime
Check out Zechariah 3:8. The Messianic high priest's name was to be Yehoshua (Yehovah is salvation), which it most certainly is. I think that what repels Jews the most from "Christianity" is the Trinity doctrine, which is a false doctrine. Neither Messiah Yehoshua nor the apostles were Trinitarians.
The the Scripture you quoted is about Yahoshua the Priest who was a High Priest during the Babylonia Captivity.
The time of Jacob’s Trouble begins on the 10th day of Iyar; 1,260 days hence, we will be redeemed.
Be not discouraged, for the trouble which soon must come is necessary, and chastisement has not yet ended while the final work yet remains.
Our Abba loves us with all of His being, and all we must do is TRUST Him and keep HOPE alive as we persevere.
Adonai has protected us numerous times in the past and only allows us to suffer for our own good.
so the true redeemer that we are waiting for. if he says hi im the redeemer, how would we know its the real IAM or not? does GOD make us know or is there like a list of things that he has to be.
Read the tenach through thoroughly, the prophets mention a list of things that he has to accomplish, and how the world will look like when he rules. (none of which jesus accomplished)
Other videos of this rabbi talk about it actually also.
I think God will also let us know, we will feel the truth in our hearts 💕. Like those stories of people who met God (as happened to me as well more then once) , and knew instinctively without a doubt that that's God, or other such similar stories. Kind of like when you have a headache you know you have a headache - you feel it, you don't need proof, or like you don't need proof that you're hungry.
Gentiles are commanded to save a person's life. This is a positive aspect of the Noahide prohibition of murder, based on the Oral Torah rule "from the negative, one can infer the positive." In other words, not murdering implies saving a person's life.
Maybe, but they aren't punished with the death penalty if they don't.
Never played soccer in Borough Park. Stickball only.
and punch ball, but no soccer in Brooklyn.
@@ToviaSinger1 we did some stoopball on 44th street.
There is soccer in Brooklyn but not in hemishe community's (you would have to go to prospect park)
@Bug Out Now! They were handball courts. Punchball didn't usually require a wall.
@@ToviaSinger1 Peace and blessings be upon you, son of Abraham and Isaac. ❤
Chaos=uncertainty and both certainty (finitude) and uncertainty (infinity) are fundamental parts of logic (God).
I wish you would leave the scriptures up on screen for a bit longer. Just saying
Hellos Rabbi, I want to become a Jew and I am sure about it and I have been a bnei Noach for a little over a decade and o have been lied to by the Jesus followers, although many of them are wonderful people, how I go about it if my wife won’t convert yet although she is interested? And why I always find someone telling to go orthodox because conservative is not legit?
Absolutely...the only CONVERSION is an orthodox. Youd still be unconverted if you did a conservative one. There's only one Judaism...not a transformed one..only the word of G-d, it is not a torah of convenience...it is a Torah of laws...strict .laws..no pick and choose here.
@@anonymousanonymous-qx7mv anonimus, WHY ARE YOU LYING?
Why are you lying, 2 - anonymous ?
@@mihailgae-draghici4864 Im not...simple answer!
@@anonymousanonymous-qx7mv 4 B For the purpose of this Law, " Jew" means a person who was born of a Jewish mother or become *converted to Judaism and who is not a member of another religion. " Law of Return 5710 -1950 & 5730 -1970 *The conversions made by the rabbis of the Reform Judaism ARE A C C E P T E D, THEY ARE R E C O G N I Z E D BY THE STATE OF ISRAEL. QUOD ERAT DEMONSTRANDUM!
👏👏👏🙏🙏🙏🕎🕎🕎
❤❤❤❤❤❤
The answer Rabbi gives sounds ad hoc. Where in Torah does it say the manner of God's redemption of Isreal depends on what They do?
Watch the video a couple of times, maybe you will be able to understand what's he is saying.
@@rutbrea8796 interesting that you didn't respond to what I said directly. Usually when someone doesn't have the answer themselves they pretend to by telling the other to do "their" homework. I see you friend..brahaha
Jesus is just an improved version of Dionysus. The whole die and rebirth thing came from drinking a psychedelic drink. Not actually from someone dying. Rome has perverted everything but what do you do? Baruch Hashem
That was my understanding, too.
@Adam Malik In the future, the Messianic king will arise and renew the Davidic dynasty, restoring it to its initial sovereignty. He will build the Temple and gather the dispersed of Israel.
Then, in his days, the observance of all the statutes will return to their previous state. Jews will offer sacrifices and observe the Sabbatical and Jubilee years according to all their particulars as described by the Torah, and Gentiles will observe the 7 Noahide commandments.
@@divnts yup, common knowledge my friend. I personally don't believe he ever existed. 1: That was a common name back then 2: There is no evidence Paul even every existed 3: His story is a combination of pagan Greek deities with a sprinkle of Rome ideology.
@@divnts The belief in a divine trinity is an idolatrous concept, since it is a belief that God (or according to some, a second separate divinity) has characteristic features, and the characteristics of a body.
@@divnts God is one. He is not two or more, but one, unified in a manner which surpasses any unity that is found in the world. He is not one in the manner of a general category which includes many individual entities, nor one in the way that the body is divided into different portions and dimensions. Rather, He is completely unified, and there exists no unity similar to His in this world.
The very
fact that people in the world still experience pain and suffering is due to the mystical truth that God's Divine Presence in the world, the Shechinah, is still suffering along with us in our temporary condition of spiritual exile and the continuing destruction of His dwelling place, the Holy Temple in Jerusalem.
HASHEM does nor suffer! Watch out for what you are saying!
@@adellaadams8018 I cited the book Seven Gates of Righteous Knowledge by Rabbi Moshe Weiner and Dr. Michael Schulman, page 136.
@Bug Out Now! HASHEM does not suffer! HE does not suffer in the Torah and that is a foreign thought!
@@hrvatskinoahid1048 Who are they?
@@adellaadams8018 The greatest Torah scholars in the world specializing in the area of the 7 Noahide commandments.
Hi there Rabbi Singer, how you have you been, sir?
I just want to ask a question.
The Messiah is a concept of Judaism, and then incorporated and syncretized into Christianity. But the problem is, at least how I understand the concept, is that the Messiah has to have the lineage of King David.
This alone refutes the Christian claim.
But some Christian apologists claim that the lineage is through his mother, i.e., Mary.
So the question is - how would one address the claim?
Is Mary a descendant of King David?
And even if that is the case, can her lineage be legitimate in Judaism, i.e., maternal lineage as opposed to paternal lineage, i.e., through the father?
Thank you, and please stay safe, Rabbi.
...
Absolutely not! Only paternal leniage counts. It doesn't help at all if your mother is from king 👑 David.
And keep in mind by the way, that even if it's possible that jesus is descended from King David, and even if we would know for sure that this is the case, (and even if we would have no other problems and contradictions with Christianity whatsoever), the burden of proof is still on the "Christians" to prove that jesus is the messiah - not on us.
@@dumbledor22 Thank you so much for the answer, sir.
Hey rabbi what the heck does judges 1-1-9
G-d can’t defeat iron chariots.
He can, but he always prefers to work with nature, rather then go against it and make a miracle
Christianity's downfall will happen, be'ezrat HaShem very soon.
Why can't you keep it simple?
The messiah in judaism is NOT divine ("son of god) , but a mortal human being - like all of us -, but with a special task.
get ur truth from Christ himself NOT MAN or anything MAN writes.
@@relevant.c5411 can't. He hasn't been here before. You can't ask someone something if they have never been here
Do you think that there would be a soccer game for the non-Jews that’s different as in “pregame” before the Jewish soccer game? I wish I could talk to you…
Rabbi singer again I think you’re wonderful. I’m an atheist.
Why don’t you ask Christian this question if you haven’t, how do you justify the Messiah second through the old testament seconds? I’m using my voice recorder. Something spelled wrong. It doesn’t make sense too bad I’m too lazy to fix it.
Ask the christians 😅 why in the New Testament does Paul and the others miss quote and outright change words from the Old Testament, the Torah, the Jewish still original word of God I would love to hear their answer for that
I really like this channel... but I really hate the rabbi’s tendency to casually drop rape analogies. It’s beneath his status and inappropriate for his topic of discussion.
Talk about three-card monte, let's just talk about anything except what was asked.
Rabbi Tovia, when you said that the "son of Joseph" will come but he will die in battle in the end times , and this act will make Jews to repent. Is that only written in the Talmud or is it written anywhere in the Tanakh? Thank you
I didn't understand Is.60:20
Alma it means The Most High’s glory will out shine the brightness of the sun forever. The last part of the verse means the punishment of Israel will have come to and end, and the fulfillment of Genesis 12:3 I will bless them that bless thee and curse them that curse thee.
These curses will now be brought upon the gentiles nations that did Israel wrong! Isaiah 51:17-23 KJV measure for measure!
Every nation that has ever held Israel captive has met the same Fait they were ALL destroyed!
1.)EGYPT (Yah)
2.)BABYLON (Darius)
3.)MEDES/PERSIA (Alexander)
4.)Greece (Constantine)
5.)ROME (Odoacer) 476 C. E.
6.)MYSTERY BABYLON (10 kings) & (Yah)
“Therefore all they that devour thee shall be devoured; and all thine adversaries, every one of them, shall go into captivity; and they that spoil thee shall be a spoil, and all that prey upon thee will I give for a prey.” Jeremiah 30:16 KJV I hope this brought ah little clearer picture to your out of focus lens that you see things the way The Most High see things.
Revelation 22:16
I Yeshua have sent mine angel to testify unto you these things in the churches. I am the root and the offspring of David, and the bright and morning star.
Amen:)
@Bug Out Now! Matityahu 5:17 Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil.
Ravi Zacharias was not the greatest man. Lol
lol
@@favian669 at first I thought you said your mom. Lol hahaha
@@favian669 who’s momo?
@@favian669 keep it simple. Just look at evidence. Lol. Dont assume things. Otherwise you get burnt. :)
@Alpha Dog my cat is in charge of the servers
Jesus, he was not came from Joseph line. Why Christians twisted Torah in order to fit they agenda? Rabbi Tovia always explained in every videos and he do it well.
I'm using this parable so you understand... you definitely have a sense of humor haha
I bet this Rabbi has a dartboard in his bedroom with a picture of the Apostle Paul.
He probably throws darts at Paul's picture whenever he thinks about the Christian missionaries! 😂😂😂
The number of Jewish people who have been adversely affected, maimed, and
murdered in the name of Jesus throughout the history of Christianity significantly exceeds the six million who were massacred by the Nazis during the Holocaust.
@@hrvatskinoahid1048 Unfortunately, Christian Europe commited horrible crimes against the Jews. So it's understandable that Rabbi Singer feels an aversion to the Christian religion.
@@patriciaperez9454 Fortunately, God certainly accepts sincere repentance, and forgives the repentant sinner for his transgression.
@@patriciaperez9454 not because of the murders...but because the religion is a LIE ..and needs to be exposed. Our job is to be a light onto the nations, to make G-ds name known throughout the world!
@@billyhw5492 I noticed that he only bashes Paul. I very rarely hear him complain about the other Apostles.
Remember what Jesus said, the way people have enmity with me, in the same way they will enmity you as well.
Jesus was a Jew, so he lived his life as a Jew therefore Jewish people are being oppressed for being faithful to Hashem and Jesus did say My Father is greater than I, meaning to say he knows Hashem is greater than him, and as a Jew, we view Hashem as our Father, our King.
@@user-qm4hz8ii8s how about Jesus, just a human.
@@user-qm4hz8ii8s But why ever call God Almighty father?
“But you, Beit-Lechem near Efrat, so small among the clans of Y’hudah, out of you will come forth to me the future ruler of Isra’el, whose origins are far in the past, back in ancient times. Therefore he will give up [Isra’el] only until she who is in labor gives birth. Then the rest of his kinsmen will return to the people of Isra’el. He will stand and feed his flock in the strength of Adonai, in the majesty of the name of Adonai his God; and they will stay put, as he grows great to the very ends of the earth; and this will be peace. »
Mikhah 5:1-4
“Who has gone up to heaven and come down? Who has cupped the wind in the palms of his hands? Who has wrapped up the waters in his cloak? Who established all the ends of the earth? What is his name, and what is his son’s name? Surely you know!”
Mishlei 30:4
“The earth’s kings are taking positions, leaders conspiring together, against Adonai and his anointed. They cry, “Let’s break their fetters! Let’s throw off their chains!” He who sits in heaven laughs; Adonai looks at them in derision. Then in his anger he rebukes them, terrifies them in his fury. “I myself have installed my king on Tziyon, my holy mountain.” “I will proclaim the decree: Adonai said to me, ‘You are my son; today I became your father. Ask of me, and I will make the nations your inheritance; the whole wide world will be your possession. You will break them with an iron rod, shatter them like a clay pot.’” Therefore, kings, be wise; be warned, you judges of the earth. Serve Adonai with fear; rejoice, but with trembling. Kiss the son, lest he be angry, and you perish along the way, when suddenly his anger blazes. How blessed are all who take refuge in him.”
Tehillim 2:2-12
““When that day comes, I will seek to destroy all nations attacking Yerushalayim; and I will pour out on the house of David and on those living in Yerushalayim a spirit of grace and prayer; and they will look to me, whom they pierced.” They will mourn for him as one mourns for an only son; they will be in bitterness on his behalf like the bitterness for a firstborn son. When that day comes, there will be great mourning in Yerushalayim, mourning like that for Hadad-Rimmon in the Megiddo Valley.”
Z'kharyah 12:9-11
Ok, the symbolism here. But again, horses are kept as pets & for labour of many kinds.
So she got it wrong, on where exactly in the Talmud the quotes were. It doesn't mean it wasn't mentioned, just because you said so.
Sukkah 52a
Apropos the eulogy at the end of days, the Gemara asks: For what is the nature of this eulogy? The Gemara answers: Rabbi Dosa and the Rabbis disagree concerning this matter. One said that this eulogy is for Messiah ben Yosef who was killed in the war of Gog from the land of Magog prior to the ultimate redemption with the coming of Messiah ben David. And one said that this eulogy is for the evil inclination that was killed.
So the rabbis don't agree either aye?
Why focus on what Paul changed, or sports analogies, and just address what's in the Talmud? What was that about card tricks?
That is how the Talmud works. There are disagreements about everything and there are rules whom we follow when... when the disagreements have a practical application. This disagreement is insignificant because it does not have a practical application, just a different reading of what the eulogy is about.
@@boriszakharin3189 Rules are not a "whom". How is any of that relevant to my comment?
why after the temple is built and the so called messiah comes why is god going to pull wrath on the earth?. if it was truly the messiah there would be peace forever on earth.
Torah: Exodus 13:13 and Exodus 34:20
Mishneh Torah: Hilchos Bikkurim 12:4
The Petter Chamor (Hebrew: פטר חמור) or Redemption of the firstborn donkey, is a mitzvah in Judaism in which a male firstborn (bechor) donkey is redeemed by the owner of the donkey, who gives a lamb or kid to a Kohen. ... The other animal is then given to a Kohen who usually eats it.
Gen 49:17 Dan shall judge his people as one of the tribes of Israel. Dan shall be a serpent in the way, a viper by the path, that bites the horse's heels so that his rider shall fall backward..
Israel is his firstborn and the firstborn left Jerusalem and left in the ships of Dan at the time of the Judges.
Luke 11:32
The Sign of Jonah
…31The Queen of the South will rise at the judgment with the men of this generation and condemn them; for she came from the ends of the earth to hear the wisdom of Solomon, and now One greater than Solomon is here. 32The men of Nineveh will stand at the judgment with this generation and condemn it; for they repented at the preaching of Jonah, and now One greater than Jonah is here. 33No one lights a lamp and puts it in a cellar or under a basket. Instead, he sets it on a stand, so those who enter can see the light.…
Matthew 12:41
The Sign of Jonah
…40For as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the great fish, so the Son of Man will be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth. 41The men of Nineveh will stand at the judgment with this generation and condemn it; for they repented at the preaching of Jonah, and now One greater than Jonah is here. 42The Queen of the South will rise at the judgment with this generation and condemn it; for she came from the ends of the earth to hear the wisdom of Solomon, and now One greater than Solomon is here.…
"All Israel, from Dan to Beersheba".
WIKI Tribe of Dan... "experts in war"
GOD IS GOD ! he knows the truth of the time and the hour and when death will take the life from each of us! God knows the truth of whom he revealed himself and whom are confused and with doubt yet still cry to him!...how many must keel crying? How many will have many more says of suffering? GOD knows ! Whom will make it ,who wont make it, who will seek a peaceful death and not have peace ! ...its time for this world to return all that belongs to God back to God! Read the first verse of the bible read the truth as rabbi tovia singer explains, yet know the only way to life and peace? GOD! the only heart and hand that can provide? GOD! ... the voice of God is the only voice that matters!
Paul I believe thinks he is divine.
Are you suggesting the donkey in Zechariah 9 is just an allegory? I don't know about that, Rabbi. I
think Zechariah meant this to be understood literally.
With respect to Zechariah 12, I kind of agree with Rabbi. I think the general interpretation of chazal was that Messiah Ben Yosef would be slain in the War of Gog and Magog and Israel will mourn for him. His death will also atone for Israel's sins.
The idea of vicarious atonement is very Jewish. I know there is a tradition in Judaism that the death of a tzaddik can atone for sin. We also see examples of vicarious atonement in ancient Israel when the high priest would offer a sacrifice for the sins of Israel every year on Yom Kippur.
Yes, it is an allegory. And the pessage in Daniel that says he'll come with the 🌥 clouds of heaven, i heard there is a midrash that explicitly says that this refers to an 🛬 airplane (imagine to write such a thing in their time about 2000 years ago!), but this too is a metaphor, it describes the possible ways moshiach might come, if we repent of our own will, it will be smooth sailing and great fun, like an airplane ride. And if god has to cause suffering to force us to repent, then it will be like the slow laborious ride of a donkey (exactly as the rabbi explained).
Regarding your other question: yes we do believe that the suffering of the righteous, for example moshiach son of yosef (and son of David as well) can atone for the generation. But what Christians believe about jesus is going much to far with this. We jews believe that suffering can only atone for sins "already" committed, not for what you "will" sin in the future, and Christians want Jesus's suffering to atone for the sins of all future generations. Well that's like paying the police 🚨 a fine and then saying " i paid you in advance, now let me speed", that's called bribe - not a punishment.
Also the suffering of the saints never absolves you of your sins completely, it just "delays" the punishment of the wicked to give him more time to repent, but eventually he must repent and pay for his own sins.
Also Christians believe in the doctrine of original sin, that you're going to hell even if you're completely righteous, unless you have jesus save you, which of course is also completely against Judaism.
Where does it say that Messiah is coming back in 6000 years.
Why Tanakh doesn't feel to speak about the mericles of Mashiah when he himself is a very important to God and Jews?
@A Sojourner You being a former Christian & accusing other Christians of using verses in the Old Testament to justify a false claim, are guilty of doing the same. Yes God warns us of following a young false prophet into idolatry (worshipping other Gods) (yes I know you understand the meaning), however the Lord, God’s Son, states there is only 1 God, His Father. God also says he must be stoned to death, not crucified. So how do you justify Jesus being that young false profit that God specifically warned us about?? Jesus clearly stated God is His Father, NOT that He Himself is God, plus He never ever, anywhere in OT inspired ANYONE to worship anyone other than Almighty God. Besides, if you don’t believe (anymore) that Jesus existed, how can you claim it indeed is Jesus that God warned us about in this passage?? This time Ms. A Sojourner, you are really contradicting yourself. God confounds those who have abandoned the Lord, His Son, our Savior
@A Sojourner Deuteronomy 13:2-3 2-If there will arise among you a prophet or a dreamer of a dream, & he gives you a sign or a wonder 3- & the sign or the wonder in which he spoke to you happens, and he says” let us go after other gods which you have not known & let us worship them” Don’t you see that God is very specific here in saying “A sign” or “A wonder” (meaning 1 sign or 1 wonder)?? So first of all, the Lord never predicted any sign or any wonder. But by the power of His Father Almighty God, did He indeed perform miracles (multiple miracles not just 1), never (A) prediction which came true after He predicted it. Second of all, the Lord NEVER ever said “let us go after other gods & worship them” & He certainly did NOT perform miracles to entice people away from Almighty God & over to other gods! If you don’t believe in the Lord ( or the NT ANYMORE), why use Deuteronomy (from the Torah) to reiterate God’s word as to warn us against Jesus?? Don’t you see this as an oxymoron?? Do you or don’t you believe Jesus existed?? You continually contradict yourself Ms. Sojourner & the bitterness in your tone NO doubt comes from your erroneous decision to abandon the Lord. I honestly can’t understand why you did, because anyone who truly loved the Lord would NEVER abandon Him. I’m sure your Christian (Catholic perhaps?) faith was not imbedded correctly into you or you would never have abandoned Him. I’m interested (genuinely) to know, if you care to share. Never too late for “an old lady” to be born again, again
How much corruption have done the filthy writters of the new teatament.
Luke 24 verses 44,46 say that Jesus pbuh will be crucified and raised from the dead.
Verse 44: And he said unto them, These are
the words which I spake unto you, while
I was yet with you, that all things must
be fulfilled, which were written in the
law of Moses, and in the prophets, and in the psalms, concerning me.
46. And said unto them, Thus it is written, and thus it behoved Christ to suffer,
and to rise from the dead the third day:
Better look at the Health plan
Is that what the xtians are trying to do, make sure that the Jewish people don't repent, instead join the church so that the promise could not be fulfilled? The satan is very smart, but Hashem blessed is He, will win, because HE promised and it shall be done! Yes, we are in a weak flesh and very vulnerable, but our CREATOR, SAVIOR, and REDEEMER, knows what to do. The ultimate battle! B"H
The Questioner seems to think that riding into Jerusalem on a donkey is the complete fulfillment of the messiah. The irony is that Christianity has so badly understood this passage that it has Jesus doing a circus act simultaneously riding into Jerusalem on 2 donkeys. (See, The Jew and the Christian Missionary: A Jewish Response to Missionary Christianity by Gerald Sigal). When we have fulfillment of the messianic prerequisites specified by Isaiah and Ezekiel, it will not be debated as to who the messiah is: i.e. that person who - (i) causes nations not to make war and destroy their weapons of mass destruction; (ii) rebuilds the holy temple so that (iii) the messiah can bring a sin sacrifice on behalf of himself; (iv) destroys the wicked with the breathe of his lips; (v) acts as a righteous judge; (vi) reinstitutes the sacrificial system; and (vii) ingathers the jewish people back to Israel from the four corners of the world. Unfortunately, as Rabbi Singer has amply demonstrated, Christians are believing in a failed Messiah.
Rashi explains on Genesis 36:3 "There are three people whose iniquities are forgiven: One who converts to Judaism, one who is promoted to a high position, and one who marries. For this reason she was called Mahalath, because Esau’s sins were forgiven.
If every converts to Judaism then no one has to believe in God,were all land animals and Adam created in 24 hours 6000 years ago?before inviting people to Judaism you need to be sure that their book is free if error.
@@tomorrowmaynevercome3171 Gentiles are not obligated to convert to Judaism.
@@hrvatskinoahid1048 the Bible has failed its followers because the brains That God gave us cannot accept what the Bible says about many issues,unless you can convince the scientific community that earth is few thousand years old and Adam was the first creation then the Bible will have hard time to stay afloat.
@@tomorrowmaynevercome3171 3 million people personally heard the voice of God at Mount Sinai with their own ears. This proves the Divine origin of the Torah.
Mahalath? Genesis 36,3 > Bosmat / Basemath < Heb. Basam, which is rel. to Heb. bosem = balsam , word of Semitic origin.