More education and not conspiracy theorists that get their “ intelligence” from UA-cam 👌. It’s been great to witness Joe gradually get more and more intelligent as he has people from so many backgrounds come on his show. Number one podcast in the world for a reason.
That's not what he would say to you. You know things he'll never know, and he not only knows that, he genuinely respects it. He's a very nice guy, but it's also part of his theory of human consciousness - which is baffling!
@@Ingens_Scherz he said photons travel at the speed of light, so they don’t experience time .. , they start and end with no time in between.. even billions of years .. the singularly till now was a less then a split second to a photon .. that idea alone is more then i would of ever known until he said it ..
But he did interviewed THE Elon Musk, and even smoked weed with him on podcast. People in a 100 years will be like "Imagine if you were Joe Rogan and smoked weed with The Emperor Elon Musk on a podcast can you imagine how would that be.."
Man is 86 years old here and speaks so elegantly and passionately. His energy level slowly increasing throughout shows how passionate he is about his work.
How on earth did Joe manage to have a conversation with a Nobel prize winning theoretical physicist and one of the smartest people ever born. Insanity. Props to Joe for trying!!
While I understand what you are saying, a simpleton like myself gets nothing out of this because I don`t follow what he is saying.... I would get more out of a show like Cosmos.
@@S_C_ the inventor of dynamite who gave it to the inventor of the USSR nuclear bomb. But it is a good thing especially in the sciences, forget about Nobel peace prize.
I love listening to scientists like sir Roger and Brian Cox, they are so humble and unpatronising. I think it is because they realise that they know only a very small proportion of all that we can know, and that in time, their theories will be surpassed by future scientists. To know that your knowledge is incomplete is a sign of intelligence.
World of AMEISO Agreed 1000%. Thats why I love this Podcast so much,I Love listening to Scientific, and Philosophy’s from a lot of these Bright People...
The average human does have an IQ of a chimp relative to these guys: (average) chimp 40, (average) human 100, Penrose 160. On top of it the precision involved in detecting gravitational waves is so exact that these theories must be on the right track. Another thing: IQ isn't everything but it does speak a lot for deductive abilities. Maybe all this means is we are not so different from chimps though...
Well our brains are just tiny specs of dust and yet we try to comprehend existence which is something far too big for us. It's like an ant trying to understand everything humans know
He's so modest he mentions Escher without even mentioning that they were influences on each other. His science was inspired by Escher's art, and Escher's art was in turn inspired by Penrose's science. Like Escher sent him art made specially for him. LOL at Penrose on JRE, it's like seeing the queen at a McDonald's.
Joe might appear McDonalds but he is such a good interviewer. He never cuts people off, or tries to push a narrative. He just lets them talk and follows up with questions that show he is listening and curious. Nothing on tv like that. A more accurate comparison would be if McDonalds sold top notch food.
Yeah I'm not trying to diss JRE by comparing it to McDonald's, I'm just saying it's surreal like seeing the queen at a McDonald's. If JRE is like a McDonald's, mainstream media is like a fancy restaurant with a snooty arrogant waiter, and the food they serve is like all tiny little morsels on a giant empty plate
Big props to Joe Rogan for this interview! I knew Joe could have great conversations with comedians like Bill Burr and entrepreneurs like Elon Musk, but here he is asking intelligible questions to a physicist and producing a fantastically enjoyable conversation on a different level. Increased my respect for him.
while I don't disagree with any of that, part of this one is that Penrose is among the greatest people on Earth to hear speak. He's intelligent and educated, but also a total individual who is fine differering with the status quo, and he's funny to boot.
@@ANTIStraussian joe has platformed alien conspiracy guys and way worse people but to his credit he has eventually debunked a lot of the crap he used to let through. i think hes too much of a bro to apply a nuanced filter to social or political issues but with the anti-scientific stuff hes done some work to push a healthy belief in science over conspiracies as a reaction to his own enabling of some goofy people.
Fun fact: Sir Roger’s uncle was a surrealist artist and camouflage expert who hung out with Pablo Picasso and his siblings are a physicist, a geneticist, and a chess grandmaster. Quite the family!
David Lenett no mate. They can’t explain the singularity so they produce complex math to make you feel this way. Fuck this theory of a so called black hole. It just doesn’t make sense.
@@smAshomAsh I'm curious, are you insinuating that black holes don't exist? Can you prove they don't? Are you also saying that the current universe we reside in was not created somehow?
@@MrSumbody69 Outer space is science fiction. It's not even rational to believe there is a vacuum adjoining gas without a barrier. Vacuum chambers are chambers for a reason. There is no model for gas adjoining a vacuum. It's pure belief. Pride and fear keep people from questioning their beliefs.
@Brian G blah blah blah black man lah blah racists bla blah white people. Fuck off with your bullshit. You just can't see shit without your race glasses can you? If Einstein was chilling on talk shows 90% of time instead of actually calculating shit in his lab he would be a science populizer showman as well.
Tyson has a gift for explaining the basics needed for people to even get interested in these ideas, and that's his contribution. But ya, listening to them side by side does give that impression.
Lol,..Usually Joe will tell the speaker to move the mic closer, or to speak into the mic but not this guy...He's a Knight and Jamie moved it for the lord..
heeere,after i saw it i was like woah!i had remembered a podcast interview about an alternative theory of the mind and that just earned him way more credibility (of course he already has lots of credibility but I meant in my mind)
Respect to Joe's staff, they didn't interrupt Sir Roger and went and moved the microphone near him if there was another guest Joe would be telling to move the mic next to their faces
"Yeah. There's this fringe podcast by this Fear Factor guy." "The UFC guy?" "Yeah." "What does he talk about? Kicks to the head and farts?" "Yeah... and black holes with sir Roger Penrose."
Wow. This guy is an intellectual giant, definitely one of the greatest minds of all time. His works in math, physics, philosophy and other areas are absolutely ground shaking. For anyone that wants a good glimpse into hid mind read "The Emperor's New Mind". It is very deep and very slow reading as the concepts are new and you need to take time to digest the material. I would read a chapter, think for a few days and then read another chapter.
@@monsterhuntervideos4446 I'll take theoretical nonsense that is actually being studied to provide factual evidence that can suggest the existence of objects in space, over the so-called, self-proclaimed religious "facts" that have been altered throughout the ages by other religions that adopted the bible. Shut the fuck up...
Its amazing how people who are actually doing science are so humble and down to earth in their claims while those who use science to advance their agenda sound ridiculously arrogant.
Flat earth nonsense was created by the cia to make anyone who questions the $1 trillion a year theft from the american taxpayers ...look like idiots. 911 so obvious.
Black holes have always brought me comfort. Knowing that we’re all going to be compressed into the same black hole as everyone we know and have ever known is kinda comforting
Videos and people like this become more and more important the more we populate the planet. Quality goes out the window with quantity, and social media is contributing to making society as a whole dumb as rocks.
I love how no one in this comment section is actually commenting about the EXPLOSIVE take this guy just had. He literally just explained to you that multiple big bangs, the birth of universes, has happen and will happen again. He was right when he said its romantic. The thought of life living and dying and living again is a beautiful conclusion to come to.
Please..Neil degrades Tyson is such a blowhard.. a total gasbag..I'd rather jam pencils in my ears than listen to that guy try and explain something with analogies and speculation.. this guy is much easier to believe
tbh this old guy rabbit trails so much and doesnt answer direct questions. First he says singularity is infinite density but then doesnt explain how such a thing could evaportate...he also doesnt answer what dark matter is just says its not dark energy and only talks about how it effects the expanse. joe doesnt realize when his questions arent being answered
@@romancotton8536 the idea of dark matter is simply that we don’t really know what it is because it’s dark lol. All we can really say is that it’s a form of matterthat was a by product of the Big Bang. It’s like a form of radiation that we can’t see, or some sort of frequency that we can’t tune into. He’s likely a visual thinker, not everyone only thinks using words lol. He can imagine it’s existence because of the way that he can visualize it effecting the matter around us, but he can’t visualize dark matter itself because u can’t see it. It must be something like the waves that u can see when u throw a rock into a pond but much bigger.
Coming back to this after watching other Penrose podcasts, you can really see how much more engaging he is on Joe's podcast. Joe seems to ask the right questions that gets Roger to explain in a calm and focused way.
So basically Einstein predicted the existence of dark energy by thinking of the Universe as being static... You know you are a genius when you can't make a mistake even if you did! xΔ
So good, this man is sharing bits of knowledge he's learned over a lifetime of dedication to academia . And to think Jamie learned all of this in his first year.
Joe Rogans podcast is like the ULTIMATE variety talk show. Comedians, scientists, actors, musicians, artists, businessmen, the list goes on he covers it all
Right , I meant it as a compliment. I love that he posits outrageous theories of ambitious scope, but can “back it up” with his intellect. I know some are controversial, but sometimes you need that to get the hivemind out of its funk.
Jason R S he’s probably never seen one but he has a theory of what that looks like. He calls it...........G-String theory. 😅 Ok I’ll see my way out now.....
Joe Rogan is extremely bright, but when you are in the presence of someone like Sir Roger Penrose you reliaze just how super intelligent some people are. If you aren't aware and in awe of such intelligence you just aren't aware period.
@@andrelaus9904 It exists equally as much as a horseshit big bang theory. We don't know anything about our creation, but a science camp and religion camp convince us that they've got it all figured out.
Just imaging sitting in your armchair and worrying about what the Universe will be like when all the black holes have popped out of existence. I find it amazing that a fellow human has a mind like that, and yet others amongst us can't fart and chew gum at the same time.
Great questions, great minds! "Yes, tell me" is possibly the most brilliant thing to ever be said in an interview with someone else. The fact it happens to be Penrose who is being nudged to tell us... Wowzers! Thank you Joe & Roger
I like how Joe is able to show a correct understanding of his guests standing. Here he shows the highest respect to the guest deserving of the highest respect of all guests to make it to his podcast.
Joe Rogan casually having a conversation with one of the greatest minds of our generation. The quality of guests on JRE is amazing. JRE is the #1 podcast in the world for a reason!
No doubt... Then you get people like Logan paul trying to claim #1 podcast in the world lmao!.... maybe #1 for trending whoever- the- fuck made whatever- the- fuck pop cultural impact, only to have Logan and Mike asking this guy who he's fucked lately, then talking about themselves and how cool they are the last 30 min
I don't ever want to stop hearing him talking. To call this interesting just is a devastatingly understating. I'm more than curious about what he is saying, I can't stop listening.
We need to record every word this man says. It most be extremely difficult for someone to even try to explain 1 idea when he has the knowledge of every topic leading to any 1 idea. He tries to dumb it down, but you will here him pause bc he knows what he is about explain is lightyears away from any simple explanation. Ive watched almost every documentary with him and every book. This guy blows are simpleton brains away. Every topic is years of rabbit hole reaearch to understand and get to the basic understanding . He spent his entire life devoted. Absolutely blows me away
This idea makes a lot of sense, though he didn't explain it quite as easily as I've seen others do... Essentially, an ever expanding universe, as it cools off and dies, starts to look the same mathematically, as an infinitely small, and compressed universe. They both converge on the singularity, where things eventually break down, and infinitely large/small/hot/cold, lose all meaning, and become 1. They are the sane thing, and start a new expansion, or are the end of a previous one. Twister theory is the name of this idea if I remember right.
Hi Joe: I have to say: I started watching your program out of interest in martial arts, UFC etc. Like everyone else. But at this point I have to say you’re one of the best interviewers out there Between this, the interview with Elon Musk, and others One of the few programs where important thinkers and doers can get into subjects in depth We get a sense of these people as human beings, not just the usual soundbites Keep it up, and thank you!
Penrose mentioned something about photons that I have always thought about. I am not learned enough to take it further, but if I look at a tree outside, I see the tree because of photons hitting my eye. From my perspective, the photon was created and aimlessly bounced around and deflected in the massive sun for as much as 40,000 years before leaving the Sun, hitting the tree then hitting my eye. It hit my eye 40,000 years later. From the photons point of view it hit my eye instantaneously as it was created. We talk about the future, but the photon is already there according to its self. it bakes my noodle, that one.
@@wardygrub I did! Thanks. I know he says detector 1 says if its a wave or particle before the decision is actually made at the other sensors because it takes longer, but as I said, the photons dont take longer to do anything. The entagled particles think they all arrive instantaneously.
@@wardygrub Bad wording.....I mean we observe them as going to the other sensors after the first one. The entangled pair have no mass so travel at the speed of light and experience no time.
More mathematicians, more philosophers, and more physicists.
Daniel Hettenbach Less Schaub
More education and not conspiracy theorists that get their “ intelligence” from UA-cam 👌. It’s been great to witness Joe gradually get more and more intelligent as he has people from so many backgrounds come on his show. Number one podcast in the world for a reason.
Agree
As if we need more existential dread.
@@aurorahiraeth5896 100%
This guy has forgotten more than I will ever know.
That's my favorite Ramsay quote of all time.
@@TwRex0410 the cook?
@@tonynova "I've forgotten more than you know. Serve the food and shut the f**k up."
That's not what he would say to you. You know things he'll never know, and he not only knows that, he genuinely respects it. He's a very nice guy, but it's also part of his theory of human consciousness - which is baffling!
@@Ingens_Scherz he said photons travel at the speed of light,
so they don’t experience time ..
, they start and end with no time in between.. even billions of years .. the singularly till now was a less then a split second to a photon
..
that idea alone is more then i would of ever known until he said it ..
When a knighted Englishman shows up in a wool blazer, you listen.
Best comment on the internet ever
Kinda nuts to think that if Einstein were to live in our time I’m sure Joe would interview him.
J S underrated comment
But he did interviewed THE Elon Musk, and even smoked weed with him on podcast. People in a 100 years will be like "Imagine if you were Joe Rogan and smoked weed with The Emperor Elon Musk on a podcast can you imagine how would that be.."
@@milosjazic7453 damn
He would need a german translator
Yea and ask him if he did DMT
People trying to outsmart Sir Roger Penrose in the comment section. Gotta love the internet.
Pshh... I know about black holes. I've seen all the Star Trek movies.
The internet is full of arrogance what did you expect?
@@outbreak49 don't mistake arrogance for attention seeking trolling, but i take yr point.
@DaKermitFrog You're a very intelligent person it seems.
Kermit Frog ... he has more experience with black holes than a youngster like you could ever imagine.
Joe's ability to take interest in literally anything and everything is what makes him so good at what he does.
Top
@@manictiger You sound dumb.
@@mattyy101 dunning-kruger effect for ya
I zoned out after 13 minutes. Too complicated, I didn´t get it, what he was explaining.....
@@chanceneck8072 I feel sorry for you
Man is 86 years old here and speaks so elegantly and passionately. His energy level slowly increasing throughout shows how passionate he is about his work.
He’s 92!
How on earth did Joe manage to have a conversation with a Nobel prize winning theoretical physicist and one of the smartest people ever born. Insanity. Props to Joe for trying!!
Trying?! He did the damn thing
He's been doing it for years. The difference between the podcast at the beginning and 8-9 years later is night and day.
I'm waiting for Ed Witten to appear. Why not have the greatest physicist alive on the pod?
Average 11 years old comment.
Rogan is a knuckle-dragging meathead
The whole time Jamie is just thinking, I already knew all of this.
Jo Po hahahahahah
Jo Po hahaha
Of course he got an A
lmaoooooooooo
HOLY FUCK.
COMMENT OF THE MONTH.
And people still watch cable news? With podcasts like this, most TV interviews now seem foolish
Only 65 to 90 year olds watch that mess. They have the money.
While I understand what you are saying, a simpleton like myself gets nothing out of this because I don`t follow what he is saying.... I would get more out of a show like Cosmos.
@@TheNaturalhumandiet this guy and that person are completely different.no comparison
@@michaeljorfi3552 You're right. I was mad and shouldn't even have written anything, it wasn't constructive.
Turk Carl Sagan had billions and billions of microtubules functioning as state machines with quantum transition probabilities.
So incredible to see Professor Penrose win the Nobel Prize.
One of the greatest minds.
@Jesse 😂
@@Jesse-xy8kw You have no idea of what you're talking about do you? Go read a book or something to educate yourself.
Who is the Nobel Prize named after?
@@S_C_ the inventor of dynamite who gave it to the inventor of the USSR nuclear bomb. But it is a good thing especially in the sciences, forget about Nobel peace prize.
@@Jesse-xy8kwclown. Pick up a book.
I love listening to scientists like sir Roger and Brian Cox, they are so humble and unpatronising. I think it is because they realise that they know only a very small proportion of all that we can know, and that in time, their theories will be surpassed by future scientists. To know that your knowledge is incomplete is a sign of intelligence.
World of AMEISO Agreed 1000%. Thats why I love this Podcast so much,I Love listening to Scientific, and Philosophy’s from a lot of these Bright People...
The average human does have an IQ of a chimp relative to these guys: (average) chimp 40, (average) human 100, Penrose 160. On top of it the precision involved in detecting gravitational waves is so exact that these theories must be on the right track.
Another thing: IQ isn't everything but it does speak a lot for deductive abilities. Maybe all this means is we are not so different from chimps though...
pyropulse As does your contribution.
Dunning Kreuger effect 👍
Well our brains are just tiny specs of dust and yet we try to comprehend existence which is something far too big for us. It's like an ant trying to understand everything humans know
He's so modest he mentions Escher without even mentioning that they were influences on each other. His science was inspired by Escher's art, and Escher's art was in turn inspired by Penrose's science. Like Escher sent him art made specially for him. LOL at Penrose on JRE, it's like seeing the queen at a McDonald's.
Well said
Joe might appear McDonalds but he is such a good interviewer. He never cuts people off, or tries to push a narrative. He just lets them talk and follows up with questions that show he is listening and curious. Nothing on tv like that. A more accurate comparison would be if McDonalds sold top notch food.
Yeah I'm not trying to diss JRE by comparing it to McDonald's, I'm just saying it's surreal like seeing the queen at a McDonald's. If JRE is like a McDonald's, mainstream media is like a fancy restaurant with a snooty arrogant waiter, and the food they serve is like all tiny little morsels on a giant empty plate
lol well said
This dude must be a super freakin important. Is it a British thing or is he world wide famous?
Big props to Joe Rogan for this interview! I knew Joe could have great conversations with comedians like Bill Burr and entrepreneurs like Elon Musk, but here he is asking intelligible questions to a physicist and producing a fantastically enjoyable conversation on a different level. Increased my respect for him.
For every cool interview like this Joe talks to people who lie to his face about either talking to aliens or working on alien space craft
while I don't disagree with any of that, part of this one is that Penrose is among the greatest people on Earth to hear speak. He's intelligent and educated, but also a total individual who is fine differering with the status quo, and he's funny to boot.
@@ANTIStraussian joe has platformed alien conspiracy guys and way worse people but to his credit he has eventually debunked a lot of the crap he used to let through. i think hes too much of a bro to apply a nuanced filter to social or political issues but with the anti-scientific stuff hes done some work to push a healthy belief in science over conspiracies as a reaction to his own enabling of some goofy people.
@@thestonethatgodcant give him a blunt and he will tell you about tic toc videos
@@ANTIStraussian bro you've seen 4 podcasts then lmfao
Fun fact: Sir Roger’s uncle was a surrealist artist and camouflage expert who hung out with Pablo Picasso and his siblings are a physicist, a geneticist, and a chess grandmaster. Quite the family!
"It's pretty hard to bore a photon." - Love it!
At the conclusion of the video, it was scientifically confirmed that I'm as dumb as a box of rocks. 😧
I'm sure you have your strong points😆
David Lenett no mate. They can’t explain the singularity so they produce complex math to make you feel this way. Fuck this theory of a so called black hole. It just doesn’t make sense.
paul mc guigan What do you have against science?
Anthony Anderson I love science but when they throw out the rules and make up stuff to explain their ideology I disagree.
Mathematically it shows the rocks in the box combined is smarter.
Joe "an elks semen can feed my family for a year" Rogan
Greater insight than the idea that black holes or the big bang are things that ever existed.
Lmfao
@@smAshomAsh I'm curious, are you insinuating that black holes don't exist? Can you prove they don't? Are you also saying that the current universe we reside in was not created somehow?
@@MrSumbody69 I know that Oprah has a couple of them. Big black holes that is.
@@MrSumbody69
Outer space is science fiction. It's not even rational to believe there is a vacuum adjoining gas without a barrier. Vacuum chambers are chambers for a reason. There is no model for gas adjoining a vacuum. It's pure belief. Pride and fear keep people from questioning their beliefs.
This guy makes Neil degrass Tyson look like a highsider
Your referring to “Token” Tyson? The weakest and least original mind in science-yeah.
Tyson is more of a showman rather than scientist. A science popularizer if you will.
@Brian G blah blah blah black man lah blah racists bla blah white people. Fuck off with your bullshit. You just can't see shit without your race glasses can you? If Einstein was chilling on talk shows 90% of time instead of actually calculating shit in his lab he would be a science populizer showman as well.
@Brian G There are many people with PhD's in many different forms of science. Many of whom are far more competent than NdT.
Tyson has a gift for explaining the basics needed for people to even get interested in these ideas, and that's his contribution. But ya, listening to them side by side does give that impression.
“Well, do you want to know my theory”. Love this guy!!
"Well, do you want to know my theory?"*
Lol,..Usually Joe will tell the speaker to move the mic closer, or to speak into the mic but not this guy...He's a Knight and Jamie moved it for the lord..
Holy shit that comment made me laugh!
U
I was just looking this comment while knight moved the mic
Well Jamie got an A in physics so
Lol no way Joe was going to correct him in any way, he was probably just so happy to have him on
Who's here after he won a NOBEL for Physics?!
A fucking NOBEL, like wtffff
Yes here.
heeere,after i saw it i was like woah!i had remembered a podcast interview about an alternative theory of the mind and that just earned him way more credibility (of course he already has lots of credibility but I meant in my mind)
I'm here after Jamie got an A in physics.
@Rom Dyson Yupp, didn't you know you silly
Lol Jamie moving the mic, what a class act and such an interesting guest a modern day Gandalf
Respect to Joe's staff, they didn't interrupt Sir Roger and went and moved the microphone near him if there was another guest Joe would be telling to move the mic next to their faces
"Yeah. There's this fringe podcast by this Fear Factor guy."
"The UFC guy?"
"Yeah."
"What does he talk about? Kicks to the head and farts?"
"Yeah... and black holes with sir Roger Penrose."
Not fringe
“Fringe podcast” it’s literally the biggest podcast on earth lol
Wow. This guy is an intellectual giant, definitely one of the greatest minds of all time. His works in math, physics, philosophy and other areas are absolutely ground shaking. For anyone that wants a good glimpse into hid mind read "The Emperor's New Mind". It is very deep and very slow reading as the concepts are new and you need to take time to digest the material. I would read a chapter, think for a few days and then read another chapter.
exponent mantissa
It’s all theoretical nonsense.
exponent mantissa
It's all biblical bullshit.
Theoretical bullshit, anyone? I miss those days.
@@monsterhuntervideos4446 I'll take theoretical nonsense that is actually being studied to provide factual evidence that can suggest the existence of objects in space, over the so-called, self-proclaimed religious "facts" that have been altered throughout the ages by other religions that adopted the bible. Shut the fuck up...
you do not know how to read
Its amazing how people who are actually doing science are so humble and down to earth in their claims while those who use science to advance their agenda sound ridiculously arrogant.
You make a great observation
It is a great observation, because that's how it is, everytime scientists say something the media distorts it for their own agenda
Unfortunately that’s often been the case throughout history. The “I am the science” guy is a joke.
I’ve got into a black hole once, cost me 50 bucks.
Then you pulled out... looked down at your member in horror... and that’s how you came by your username
Legend
LOSTBHOY 😂😂 you're an OK guy you know that? 😂💯
Unbelievable that your mother charged you 50 bucks for that.
@@VAVORiAL don't be hating on the poopstain 😂
S.ns. We must be brothers then pussy
Imagine eddie bravo here with his flat earth theories telling everyone look it up. 🤭
Super Saiyan lol I can imagine him over talking this old guy
It’s a disservice to the truth to not have both of them on at the same time for a discussion.
Flat earth nonsense was created by the cia to make anyone who questions the $1 trillion a year theft from the american taxpayers ...look like idiots. 911 so obvious.
@oolala fuega Are you turning that comment into a song or something? The lyrics don't rhyme though, sorry to tell you
Stanley is Eddie fake account
What an amazing guest. I love the British guests, so bright, polite and eloquent. I could listen to them all day.
Black holes have always brought me comfort. Knowing that we’re all going to be compressed into the same black hole as everyone we know and have ever known is kinda comforting
Lol check your neurotransmitter levels
Group hug!
Sir Roger won the 2020 Nobel prize.👏👏
It's so soothing to watch someone this intelligent speak. Maybe even more nowadays 😄
Arthur v.S just listening to Allan watts and the instrumental beats after is just like the best thing for my mind
Videos and people like this become more and more important the more we populate the planet.
Quality goes out the window with quantity, and social media is contributing to making society as a whole dumb as rocks.
I love how no one in this comment section is actually commenting about the EXPLOSIVE take this guy just had. He literally just explained to you that multiple big bangs, the birth of universes, has happen and will happen again.
He was right when he said its romantic. The thought of life living and dying and living again is a beautiful conclusion to come to.
Much better than the universe dying and staying dead forever. Hope he's right
@@seanericson907 Same here brother
If you get this guy to say “that’s an intriguing question” you know you’re a damn good interviewer
100% and I bet rogan was pumped when that happened.
He's very pleasant to listen to. *Reminds me of Neil Tyson, but WITHOUT the planet sized EGO.*
Please..Neil degrades Tyson is such a blowhard.. a total gasbag..I'd rather jam pencils in my ears than listen to that guy try and explain something with analogies and speculation.. this guy is much easier to believe
Zero comparison between them... this is 💯 pleasure to listen ♥️
Sir Roger Penrose has a gift for presenting very complex ideas simply enough for an interested non-physicist to follow.
Exactly. But at first I just thought that I'm smart af.
Especially as he's a mathematician, not a physicist.
tbh this old guy rabbit trails so much and doesnt answer direct questions. First he says singularity is infinite density but then doesnt explain how such a thing could evaportate...he also doesnt answer what dark matter is just says its not dark energy and only talks about how it effects the expanse. joe doesnt realize when his questions arent being answered
@@romancotton8536 He did explain how they evaporate though. And he didn't explain what dark matter is because nobody knows what it is.
@@romancotton8536 the idea of dark matter is simply that we don’t really know what it is because it’s dark lol. All we can really say is that it’s a form of matterthat was a by product of the Big Bang. It’s like a form of radiation that we can’t see, or some sort of frequency that we can’t tune into. He’s likely a visual thinker, not everyone only thinks using words lol. He can imagine it’s existence because of the way that he can visualize it effecting the matter around us, but he can’t visualize dark matter itself because u can’t see it. It must be something like the waves that u can see when u throw a rock into a pond but much bigger.
Sir Roger is 91...someone get on the task of copying and downloading his mind before he's gone. Such a humble and intelligent being.
I love how Sir Penrose says photons “probably” dont have conscious experiences, keeping the possibility open, no matter how unlikely and absurd.
Well, that’s the idea of panpsychism, which has become surprisingly popular and fashionable among philosophers today!
Coming back to this after watching other Penrose podcasts, you can really see how much more engaging he is on Joe's podcast. Joe seems to ask the right questions that gets Roger to explain in a calm and focused way.
So basically Einstein predicted the existence of dark energy by thinking of the Universe as being static...
You know you are a genius when you can't make a mistake even if you did! xΔ
NUKE Nobody: All Physicist after Einstein: Find me all of the “mistakes” Einstein did. The answers are there.
So good, this man is sharing bits of knowledge he's learned over a lifetime of dedication to academia . And to think Jamie learned all of this in his first year.
Joe Rogans podcast is like the ULTIMATE variety talk show. Comedians, scientists, actors, musicians, artists, businessmen, the list goes on he covers it all
I'm so thankful Joe didn't even think to interrupt this brilliant man...thank you Joe Rogan
"Infinity is blue, from the outside."
Death, from Terry Pratchett's book Soul Music
okeyyy... for the first time in a JRE video, I feel pretty stupid...
You're mistake was thinking yo're smart for listening to JRE
Ahab T never claimed to be smart for watching JRE... where have you read that? 🙂
@Reg Gia fuck you
@Reg Gia I really don't understand how you got that conclusion
Then you're ignorant because I know for sure that there are dozens of other interviewed guests that would make you or I feel stupid
19:16 Sir Roger Penrose does a Christopher Walken impression
AlpaChino2shae LMAO
Bruh.....I don’t know where you guys come up with such hilarious stupidity only on the internet! I can’t stop laughing!!! 🤭😆😂🤣😭😭😭💀
Comb-over haircut - Check
Tweed jacket over knitted sweater - Check
Coke bottle glasses - Check
This guy's legit
We can't tell but I'm sure he smells of homemade soup also
Definitely one of the more trustworthy of Joe Rogan’s guests: many other of his guests are not particularly trustworthy…
The great Roger Penrose ... a genius and the MG of physics. Always tackling problems above his weight class!
I can't figure out whether that's an insult or compliment😂😂
Right , I meant it as a compliment. I love that he posits outrageous theories of ambitious scope, but can “back it up” with his intellect. I know some are controversial, but sometimes you need that to get the hivemind out of its funk.
@@arcaliasgiants9813 I still don't know whether you're being sarcastic or giving the man respect.
Al H. Dont worry you’ll be ok
@@arcaliasgiants9813 oh I'm ok, are you though?
Joe: "You ever done DMT?"
Sir Roger: "I am DMT old bean"
Best comment yet!
Roger Penrose's List of Contributions
1. Moore-Penrose inverse
2. Twistor theory
3. Spin network
4. Abstract index notation
5. Black hole bomb
6. Geometry of spacetime
7. Cosmic censorship
8. Illumination problem
9. Weyl curvature hypothesis
10. Penrose inequalities
11. Penrose interpretation of quantum mechanics
12. Diósi-Penrose model
13. Newman-Penrose formalism
14. GHP formalism
15. Penrose diagram
16. Penrose inequality
17. Penrose process
18. Penrose tiling
19. Penrose triangle
20. Penrose stairs
21. Penrose-Hawking singularity theorems
22. Penrose graphical notation
23. Penrose transform
24. Penrose-Terrell effect
pp-wave spacetime
25. Schrödinger-Newton equations
26. Orch-OR/Penrose-Lucas argument
27. FELIX experiment
28. Trapped surface
29. Andromeda paradox
30. Conformal cyclic cosmology
List of awards
1. Adams Prize (1966)
2. Heineman Prize (1971)
3. Fellow of the Royal Society (1972)
4. Eddington Medal (1975)
5. Royal Medal (1985)
6. Wolf Prize (1988)
7. Dirac Medal (IOP) (1989)
8. Albert Einstein Medal (1990)
9. Naylor Prize and Lectureship (1991)
10. Knight Bachelor (1994)
11. James Scott Prize Lectureship (1997-2000)
12. Karl Schwarzschild Medal (2000)
13. De Morgan Medal (2004)
14. Dalton Medal (2005)
15. Copley Medal (2008)
16. Fonseca Prize (2011)
17. Nobel Prize in Physics (2020)
Joe: "Infinite mass"
Oh, no.
Haha yeah
“Well, the mass is quite well-defined actually”, haha! I love that correction from Penrose!
Is Joe going to ask him if he's done DMT?
Nah the guy is genuinely intelligent, he doesn't need drugs to pretend he is.
@vunderground1 Pretty sure he's dead and I'm not into Ouji boards.
@@DJCallidus w out drugs joe roegan is a fucking idiot like anyone else
Or had elk meat for that matter.
Jason R S he’s probably never seen one but he has a theory of what that looks like. He calls it...........G-String theory. 😅 Ok I’ll see my way out now.....
We need Jamie as a guest on JRE
Joe Rogan is extremely bright, but when you are in the presence of someone like Sir Roger Penrose you reliaze just how super intelligent some people are. If you aren't aware and in awe of such intelligence you just aren't aware period.
Kinda like how he seems very knowledgeable about cars, but then Chris Harris comes on his podcast.
Sir Roger is in a class of his own... thanks for blessing us with your knowledge
You would think Jamie got an A in physics comments woukd get old. It doesnt :D
For real. That and the whole Joe "stupid thing said here" Rogan stuff has gotten old too!
I don’t really get it did he say at some point he got an A or something or am I retarded?
he did say it yes @@muddymerkutio
Like a massive intergalactic toilet! We are circling the bowl!!!
God flushed us?
🤔🤔🤔
B. Eder except that God doesn't exist
@@andrelaus9904
God is the universe.
Nope...Doesn't exist
@@MrB1923
@@andrelaus9904 It exists equally as much as a horseshit big bang theory. We don't know anything about our creation, but a science camp and religion camp convince us that they've got it all figured out.
@Da ve - I appreciate this rational comment
Just imaging sitting in your armchair and worrying about what the Universe will be like when all the black holes have popped out of existence. I find it amazing that a fellow human has a mind like that, and yet others amongst us can't fart and chew gum at the same time.
From cosmological thoughts to fart while u chew???? Wtf
@@earlmyname4257 I have a feet fetish 😂 yummy 😋 I love smelly feet 🦶
Great questions, great minds! "Yes, tell me" is possibly the most brilliant thing to ever be said in an interview with someone else. The fact it happens to be Penrose who is being nudged to tell us... Wowzers! Thank you Joe & Roger
I love how he disregards very complex subjects and stays on the simplicity path for his audience
If you have “sir” in your name, your IQ is automatically raised by 50
Raised by fifty, and add's a +1 to Britishness.
Not necessarily . There are some sirs who a thick as shit
It fucking isn't, you can believe that.
But certainly not in this case.
I keep expecting this cat to say, "Now, do try to be careful, 007."
Penrose absolutely should be awarded the Nobel prize for his singularity and black hole work.
That moment when somebody explains something and you understand it even less than before 😵😂😂
Because it's bs
*you* are BS
@@dluvv19761 no ur just dumb stop calling things u dont understand bs
I like how Joe is able to show a correct understanding of his guests standing. Here he shows the highest respect to the guest deserving of the highest respect of all guests to make it to his podcast.
Joe Rogan casually having a conversation with one of the greatest minds of our generation. The quality of guests on JRE is amazing. JRE is the #1 podcast in the world for a reason!
No doubt... Then you get people like Logan paul trying to claim #1 podcast in the world lmao!.... maybe #1 for trending whoever- the- fuck made whatever- the- fuck pop cultural impact, only to have Logan and Mike asking this guy who he's fucked lately, then talking about themselves and how cool they are the last 30 min
It used to be
What a privilege to talk to a living legend in academia.
Let's have Eddie Bravo interview this guy, after Eddie drank a case of red bull.
Victor V. And took an adderal
Listening to this made me feel like i was getting both smarter and dumber at the same
15:14 Jamie slips the correct notes to his protégé
Aaron Casler 🤭🤭😂😂🤣🤣🤣😭😭😭💀
Dood 😹😹👍🏻💀💦
This man is 87. Wow. Can we just let that sink in?
He’s 87 and extremely nimble is his freestyle presentation.
Yeah I’ve never heard a person that old be that smart. Or to even know about this topic. All the old ppl I know don’t know shit about shit lol
Fun fact...he farted like 6 times during the interview! His mind is sharp...but he can cut cheese as well!
And still able to talk about this stuff like he's teaching it in class. that's a sharp mind.
he does look and sound senile
Joe loves the idea of another universe in a black hole. He asks every physicist and scientist on the podcast about it.
Yolo Swaggins Every.👏🏽 Single.👏🏽 One.👏🏽
no one on this earth saw a black hole , it is impossible !
@@ramzichouk4080 Nope, they exist! Nice try buddy!
@@MM-hi prove it !
@@ramzichouk4080even last year we got the first picture of one, and calculation into existence of things like black holes can be made
Penrose and Escher were friends. That's astonishing enough in itself. Well done JR. Where else can you get this sort of stuff free?
How soothing the old man voice is 😂
Whatever floats your boat, we’re not judging ❤️❤️❤️
This man is a brilliant genius, I could listen to him all day...wow
I could listen to this guy talk about space and physics for 1000 years and still be intrigued.
💯
3:29 " Rotating? " lmao this is amazing.
The therory is that a spinning black hole would have a "Ring singularity" that you could safely pass through
In summary, it's a pleasure and an honour to listen to this man speak.
This is exactly what a British philosopher should look like!
Straight from central casting!
Hes a physicist...
@@DJLiddle He's both.
@@MrSkyrimfan No. No. he's not.
The Alexander Fridman mentioned at 16:51 is Lex Fridman’s dad. Pretty interesting.
I also think Lex Fridman even had a podcast with Joe Rogan
no he is not en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexander_Friedmann
Sir Roger - "Let's not go into details here."
Me - "Uhh, okay.."
If you listen REAL closely you can almost hear both Joe's and Jamie's brain sizzle and explode..
The top of Joe's head is blinding me!
A up alburt
albert Einstein im gonna expose you im the real albert einstein
😂
Why are you so obsessed with light Albert??
Do you have an A in physics? Because Jamie does!
Does penrose know that Artem is the goat?
Met him in Oxford this year, a man who never fails to praise others and is steadfast in his work even in his nineties
This dude got Nobel Prize in Physics in 2020.
I don't ever want to stop hearing him talking. To call this interesting just is a devastatingly understating. I'm more than curious about what he is saying, I can't stop listening.
loved this interview .... more like this please joe :D
We need to record every word this man says. It most be extremely difficult for someone to even try to explain 1 idea when he has the knowledge of every topic leading to any 1 idea. He tries to dumb it down, but you will here him pause bc he knows what he is about explain is lightyears away from any simple explanation. Ive watched almost every documentary with him and every book. This guy blows are simpleton brains away. Every topic is years of rabbit hole reaearch to understand and get to the basic understanding . He spent his entire life devoted. Absolutely blows me away
Thank God for Joe Rogan. This is pure magic, he just sits there and takes it all in, so rare these days.
So proud of this fellow Brit, he’s national treasure and a gift to all societies. Joe done a great job here and have him the respect he deserved.
This idea makes a lot of sense, though he didn't explain it quite as easily as I've seen others do... Essentially, an ever expanding universe, as it cools off and dies, starts to look the same mathematically, as an infinitely small, and compressed universe. They both converge on the singularity, where things eventually break down, and infinitely large/small/hot/cold, lose all meaning, and become 1. They are the sane thing, and start a new expansion, or are the end of a previous one. Twister theory is the name of this idea if I remember right.
Hi Joe:
I have to say: I started watching your program out of interest in martial arts, UFC etc. Like everyone else.
But at this point I have to say you’re one of the best interviewers out there
Between this, the interview with Elon Musk, and others
One of the few programs where important thinkers and doers can get into subjects in depth
We get a sense of these people as human beings, not just the usual soundbites
Keep it up, and thank you!
You think Joe reads old comment sections in video that is not even his channel?
a former Ufc commentator interviewing a physics nobel laureate... quite decently too.. gawd i love the internet
*He might be THE ONLY GUEST that Joe didn't tell to move the mic closer to your mouth directly... They moved it for him* @ 15:14. 🤣😅😂
Penrose mentioned something about photons that I have always thought about. I am not learned enough to take it further, but if I look at a tree outside, I see the tree because of photons hitting my eye. From my perspective, the photon was created and aimlessly bounced around and deflected in the massive sun for as much as 40,000 years before leaving the Sun, hitting the tree then hitting my eye. It hit my eye 40,000 years later. From the photons point of view it hit my eye instantaneously as it was created. We talk about the future, but the photon is already there according to its self.
it bakes my noodle, that one.
m.ua-cam.com/video/0ui9ovrQuKE/v-deo.html
Hi. I just sent you this. Hope you find it interesting. X
@@wardygrub I did! Thanks. I know he says detector 1 says if its a wave or particle before the decision is actually made at the other sensors because it takes longer, but as I said, the photons dont take longer to do anything. The entagled particles think they all arrive instantaneously.
@@turnerthemanc what do you mean by “ think”? Isn’t that the spooky bit?
@@wardygrub Bad wording.....I mean we observe them as going to the other sensors after the first one. The entangled pair have no mass so travel at the speed of light and experience no time.
Joe Rogan is interviewing some of the most brilliant people who ever lived. You have to admire this guy’s wide ranging curiosity.
Imagine if Nikola Tesla is alive and together with Musk on podcast, that would be the best podcast ever.
Just won the nobel prize in phisics 4 months ago . Damn, now that's impressive for a 89 year old fella.