THE REASON WHY TWILIGHT SPARKLE FAILED AS A PRINCESS...

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 28 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 91

  • @skytwinkle7
    @skytwinkle7 2 місяці тому +122

    Celestia seriously should've made all mane 6 alicorns, I mean Twilight is the princess of friendship and where her power come from? Right, her friends. Once they pass away, Twilight might be really sad or even worse, in depression, how can she rule the realm without them😟

    • @BrandonHenderson-n8f
      @BrandonHenderson-n8f 2 місяці тому +17

      I agree. The rest of the Mane 6 should have been turned into alicorns, thus resulting in the sextet being called the Princesses of Harmony

    • @GlumandGloomy
      @GlumandGloomy 2 місяці тому +6

      True but at a part some ponies of the mane 6 said that’s not everyone’s dream bout getting turned into alicorns

    • @IsabellaYourPookie
      @IsabellaYourPookie 2 місяці тому +5

      But then being a Alicorns wouldn’t be special

    • @R0S3MARY831
      @R0S3MARY831 2 місяці тому +2

      I don't think she could. You become an Alicorn by making NEW magic. So all of them would have to make new different magic.

    • @timblaisdell5108
      @timblaisdell5108 2 місяці тому +1

      I wonder what would have happened if applejack, flusttershy, pinkie, rarity and rainbow dash became alicorns.

  • @AsmorFederation
    @AsmorFederation 2 місяці тому +38

    Justice for Twilight. Clearly some overwhelming odds, must have happened to her (with most likely her friends already passed away from old age) based on past behavior...I believe she is in some type of exile, depressed and alone.

    • @kingstar5494
      @kingstar5494 2 місяці тому +4

      My theory is that Twilight died trying to save Equestria. Possibly the other princesses had the same fate.
      It’s sad theory, but it does explain why we don’t see Twilight or the other princesses in G5.

    • @AsmorFederation
      @AsmorFederation 2 місяці тому

      @@kingstar5494 Sad but plausible. The other question is, what happened to Cadence and the Crystal Empire?

    • @kingstar5494
      @kingstar5494 2 місяці тому +2

      @@AsmorFederation Maybe the Empire fell apart just like Equestria and become a frozen wasteland. Or Flurry Heart became leader and manage to save the empire, but unable to save Equestria.
      (I prefer the ladder.)

    • @AsmorFederation
      @AsmorFederation 2 місяці тому +1

      @@kingstar5494 fair point. Magic aside, it parallels the history of Monarchies collapsing in recent history. A loss of Leadership on such a grand scale, in a way causing Equestria to go separate ways. The most sad thing is, if hasbro just stuck with Gen 4 ending, then everything would be a happier society. (But that don't sell toys) Gen 5 timeline is what... 3...400 years in the future?

    • @kingstar5494
      @kingstar5494 2 місяці тому +2

      @@AsmorFederation the amount of time that passed between G4 and G5 varies.
      If I remembered this correctly, I think most people agrees that 200 maybe even 300 years has passed since the fall of the nation.
      Even though it’s not as long as 1000 years, that is a long time for a nation to be an anarchy. It’s almost like fallout, minus the nuclear radiation.

  • @PalominoPaint
    @PalominoPaint 2 місяці тому +32

    Candace? What why? I kinda interested but um why would twilight fight her sister in law? CANT WAIT

    • @ShawnPickettPauley
      @ShawnPickettPauley 2 місяці тому +1

      (😲Gasping)! 😲 Twilight♀️!?
      😠 Shame on you! That's a naughty thing to treat everybody!

    • @Bobatea4eva
      @Bobatea4eva 2 місяці тому +3

      @@ShawnPickettPauley lol ok 23 year old man

    • @ridkarridkar526
      @ridkarridkar526 2 місяці тому

      ​@@ShawnPickettPauley LOL 👁👄👁

  • @ronaldpagar6513
    @ronaldpagar6513 2 місяці тому +42

    Or better yet, Why luster dawn and her friends or starlight glimmer to help twilight sparkle to fight against opaline aracana?

  • @kylegraham6923
    @kylegraham6923 2 місяці тому +23

    If I remember from the IDW Comics, it was Opaline who started it all, by spreading information and turning ponies against each other. The only way Twilight did to stop the fighting was to create the crystals only to make things worse.
    Plus during her fight against Opaline, Twilight uses the crystals to sacrifice herself and trap Opaline inside her own castle never to come out till years later, and Twilight transferred all her Alicorn magic inside the crystals and then fading away.
    A little dark but it’s my theory, plus I think Sunny’s Mom was an Alicorn from Skyros but banished to the stars by Opaline.

    • @ronaldpagar6513
      @ronaldpagar6513 2 місяці тому

      How about luster dawn and her friends to stop opaline aracana? Or starlight glimmer, the young six or the pillar six?

    • @asadqasmi4537
      @asadqasmi4537 2 місяці тому

      I agree

  • @Jenkinsmum
    @Jenkinsmum 2 місяці тому +6

    Twilight's biggest mistake was the creation of the Unity Crystals which basically stripped free-flowing magic from the land and robbed every creature of it essentially. Another stupid idea she had was changing Canterlot so that only believers of friendship could enter and nopony else, which is incredibly unfair for those who could do with lessons such somepony like Trixie before she befriended Starlight, particularly Lighting Dust. Compared to Celestia and Luna, Twilight's decisions were terrible, absolutely terrible. But there's another unanswered question that arises: What of Tirek, Cozy Glow and Queen Chrysalis? Surely after a 1000 years the petrification would have worn off, particularly after the chaos which Posey Bloom caused.

  • @btsrosaline3559
    @btsrosaline3559 2 місяці тому +14

    I personally think twilight might be alive just in the à la corn civilization where sunny will most likely later on go and tell her everything and then become a full princess

  • @aleheatherqueenxoxo
    @aleheatherqueenxoxo 2 місяці тому +6

    No, the last thing is incorrect. If you go to the last episode, flurry heart does appear, in a stained glass window.

  • @ulv6760
    @ulv6760 2 місяці тому +9

    Anyone who had seen MYM Ch. 1 had difficulty understanding how dangerous uncontrolled pony magic is when there was discontent and unrest among the ponies, especially between the three different races - unicorns, pegasi and earth ponies. Maretime Bay was nearly swallowed by a portal that led into a mysterious vacuum - from which earth pony magic came after Sunny had gone there. This was repeated in the IDW Discord arc where magical storms were depicted, which even the Lord of Chaos could not deal with. In a TYT episode it was seen how the Unity Crystals prevented the ponies from attacking each other when emotions got too hot during races. When the earth pony magic got out of control in MYM ch. 2, it turned out that emotional reactions could trigger uncontrolled ripple effects. This proved that the ponies' magic could be destabilized and become a threat to the surroundings.
    Twilight couldn't solve the problem without tapping into the very essence of the ponies' magic. So if it can't be resolved - it needs to be controlled, and that's why the Unity Crystals came about. Twilight didn't take the magic from the ponies - she blocked their use of active magic without affecting their internal magic, and only the ponies around the world were affected. She used secret knowledge from the alicornhood and had help from Spike and her friends. The idea was never to take the magic; it had to be checked. But a serious weakness was later discovered. If the crystals are separated from each other, the magic will not disappear. But they must be put together occasionally to let the magic "flow" - because if too much time has passed, the magic will disappear. Spike was clearly aware of this weakness as revealed by his reaction in MYM.
    Opaline then stole the dragons' magical fire and became so powerful that she could go to the frontal attack, it was likely when only the long-lived were back - Twilight, other alicorns, the dragons and Discord. There was a final showdown that forced Twilight, who was about to lose, to use the Unity Crystals to steal the magic from the fire alicorn. But Opaline escaped, Twilight had had to pay a heavy price judging by the look on Spike's face. At least we know that Twilight was in life after Opaline disappeared outside of Equestria.
    But something happened; the middle of Equestria had to be evacuated - Ponyville was emptied of its inhabitants who fled to other places like Maretime Bay, and no one knows what happened. It seemed to have happened in the time between Opaline's defeat and Twilight's disappearance.
    From MYM ch. 3 it is known through a book, that the ponies still had magic after Twilight disappeared, the responsibility for the Unity Crystals that "fell from the sky", fell on three guardians. How long Equestria was without Twilight as reigning princess remains unanswered. But then the guardians began to forget and split up. It was this that led to the disappearance of magic for the ponies, who did not understand how it happened and then placed the blame on each other, the unicorns thought it was the pegasi who were behind this. The contents of the book and Elderflower's account, possibly from this time, suggest magical manipulation by an unknown party.
    Also, the Unity Crystals is an enigma, it has an intelligence that occasionally had an active role, especially in TYT episodes, among other things by helping or manipulating Sunny and her friends, as well as reacting to their acts of friendship. We also know that the Unity Crystals react rather unusually with the Wishing Star which for one reason or another is the subject of celebration by all ponies every time it "stopped" once a year. In both MYM and TYT.
    The script behind MYM, which was prepared before the ANG movie came out, is still not known in its final form, but it has been subject to rewriting and it was not a good job. It's possible that the controversy of Twilight outliving her friends may have contributed greatly to that; Gillian Berrow, who later left the G5 team, was in close contact with Meghan McCarthy, who firmly believed that Twilight should not outlive her friends.
    But there are many indications that Twilight would rule in Equestria for a long time. Her disappearance is in itself proof that she had lived long after her friends. She managed to save Equestria probably several times, and actually she succeeded very well - the old feudal antagonisms between the unicorns, the pegasi and earth ponies had disappeared. When the ANG movie came to an end, it had become clear that the ponies had prejudices and untruths as the basis for their dislike of each other. The old conflict topics from G4 were no more.
    We just don't know what turned the G4 into the G5.

  • @ClearHeartAppleMLP
    @ClearHeartAppleMLP 2 місяці тому +4

    Its very clear what happened if you look at all the bits that were revealed in MYM and the Discord arc in the g5 comics.
    Sometime after the season 9 finale of FIM Opaline is banished from the Alicorn homeland of Skyros and atrives in Equestria. Once there she starts spreading Disharmony to destablise the land and make it easier for her to replenish the magic stripped from her on her banishment.
    The older Mane 6 eventually intevene and defeat her, which forces her to retreat and plan.
    She made her way to the Dragonlands and drained many of the dragons of their fire and life force to transform herself into a Fire Alicorn. Easily capable of defeating the guardians of friendship and claiming all .agoce for herself.
    The few surviving dragons manage to make it to Canterlot and relay the devistating news to Twilight.
    Now knowing that Opaline intends to claim all.magic for herself she sees no other option but to seal all magic away to save the world. She sends Spike away to the Isle of Scaley to safeguard the surviving dragons, where upon arriving they would all enter an enchanted sleep that would hopefilly protect them from Opaline. Opaline finding the new dragon lands would doscover she couldnt drain them.and imediately traveled direct to Twilight.
    The final confrontation seen Twilight possibly sacrifice all to seal all the magic into the unity crystals , lock Oplaine into what would brcome her castle, and place a protective sheild over the areas😢 where the ponies had evacuated to

  • @BrandonHenderson-n8f
    @BrandonHenderson-n8f 2 місяці тому +3

    There are a TON of unanswered questions in mlp g4, and how it switched to g5 is the biggest mystery next to where Cadence and Discord came from.

    • @SillyDartPony
      @SillyDartPony 2 місяці тому

      No need to know discord, he's just chaos itself as a person

  • @erixnnxx7782
    @erixnnxx7782 2 місяці тому +3

    Poor twilight, i feel so bad for her tbh.

    • @ronaldpagar6513
      @ronaldpagar6513 2 місяці тому +2

      Idk if she deserves it or not but she deserves it and I don't know if she still alive in Skyros or somewhere hiding in the cave despite of her guilt and suffering to see destroyed

    • @erixnnxx7782
      @erixnnxx7782 2 місяці тому +2

      @@ronaldpagar6513 she didn’t deserve to be made into a princess without getting asked, she didn’t deserve to out live everyone she loves. she didn’t ask to save the world multiple times and have the responsibility laid on her

    • @ronaldpagar6513
      @ronaldpagar6513 2 місяці тому +1

      @@erixnnxx7782 it's her the one responsibility to make her an alicorn and she would never messed up in the first place

  • @Pyro7693
    @Pyro7693 2 місяці тому +12

    Shouldn't it be Opaline she's fighting? 🤨

  • @omegadarkness3826
    @omegadarkness3826 2 місяці тому +9

    We can clearly say that G5 had absolutly no respect for G4's lore. And just because a pony got hurt, Twilight sealed all the magic? Ugh, G4's biggest feat WAS to talk about problems and to forgive your enemies. And in G5, it wasn't even a threat. Just an accident, but Twilight went completely overkill. Yes, this is how we got to know her in S1, but she grew And matured. And Twilight's reaction in G5's past sounds nothing like the Twilight from the end of G4 would do.
    G5 had so much potential, yet Hasbro destroyed all of it...

  • @moisieiev7124
    @moisieiev7124 2 місяці тому +1

    I think that Mane Six could trap themselves in Limbo as the price for trapping the magic in Crystals. Just like Pillars who trapped themselves in Limbo in order to trap the Pony of Shadows

  • @princeedmirovillar8044
    @princeedmirovillar8044 2 місяці тому +6

    Are you saying that Twilight Sparkle had somehow contributed to the occurrence of the Great Division?

  • @SaiBoBo-k1l
    @SaiBoBo-k1l 2 місяці тому +2

    Opaline : existed. Equestria : fall into disharmony despite being it was found by the foundation of friendship and love.

  • @SnowieWinter3
    @SnowieWinter3 2 місяці тому +12

    What

  • @ponytailpxs
    @ponytailpxs 2 місяці тому +1

    Wrote a mini essay on Opaline in a previous vid happy to reshare 😂 Opaline, she's formidable.
    Pony tribes have been easily separated before so why not again? Opaline was powerful enough to scare Twilight into using all her alicorn magic, this shedding her alicorn form, into creating the crystals. Maybe the comics explore this more no clue haven't read would like to though.
    But yea it's the fear of Opaline.
    And over time Opaline became far more relaxed as she believed there to be no true threats

  • @PATELSTREEM
    @PATELSTREEM 2 місяці тому +2

    (History of mlp between g4 and g5 (according to me )
    As history passed a villain from alicorn land (I don't remember the name): was banished into equestria in need of showing suppiriority of her being a alicorn she began a rampage of rule she was extra extra strong then when she was banished out twilights friends died leaving twillight alone forever so then like the pillars did she put all her power into the unity crystals to protect equestria then she split the tribes hoping some special pony can reunite them and return magic then opalein lost alot of her power and the lost or magic took her power to but when it returned she didn't get the powers and depended on her leftover fire magic
    1. Extra point I think after alicorn die they go back to alicorn land and that's how she contacted equestria by the hologram

  • @RUBPROMAL
    @RUBPROMAL 2 місяці тому +3

    3:20 Exactly!

  • @SleepyBus-en7zu
    @SleepyBus-en7zu 2 місяці тому +2

    She could be still among other pony's.

  • @nataliawhite6096
    @nataliawhite6096 2 місяці тому +5

    How does the moon and sun rise in g5?

    • @ToonTimeEUA
      @ToonTimeEUA  2 місяці тому +6

      Remember that advice Celestia gave to Twilight control the Sun and the Moon while she and her sister went on vacations? I think she made it permanently. Working without any pony

    • @aidansworld7616
      @aidansworld7616 2 місяці тому +1

      ⁠@@ToonTimeEUAI don’t know if twilight’s still alive

    • @ronaldpagar6513
      @ronaldpagar6513 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@aidansworld7616maybe she is in Skyros or in the cave

    • @saintzeroinfinity
      @saintzeroinfinity 2 місяці тому +1

      Maybe A.I took over the job of raising the sun & moon.

  • @m.bhopal
    @m.bhopal 2 місяці тому +1

    if im right then
    twilight created a land where all the alicorns can exsist meaning that luna,clestia,cadence and flurry heart+all other exsisted alicorn ponies came to settle down moreover this explains where because we never see any traces or ponies are too busy to find out

  • @MrVideo-dj7dl
    @MrVideo-dj7dl Місяць тому +1

    No, the reason Twilight failed as a princess in G5 is bad writing.

  • @brayancaballerorojas8347
    @brayancaballerorojas8347 2 місяці тому +1

    no creo que twiligth haya sido una mala gobernante.creo que el reinado de twiligth duro mas de lo que pensamos, ya que antes que opaline llegara a equestria pasaron siglos.

  • @RUBPROMAL
    @RUBPROMAL 2 місяці тому +7

    Personally I think this whole G5 world is like a fever dream or a made up world by a bunch of fillies who play the "main characters"

  • @YinkaAbdullahDosunmu
    @YinkaAbdullahDosunmu 2 місяці тому +3

    Wait Candance?

  • @mlpmidnightsky
    @mlpmidnightsky 2 місяці тому +1

    I think the crystals were a last resort like the dragon stone and Twilight had no choice to go into hiding

  • @garthdavis4320
    @garthdavis4320 2 місяці тому

    The way I see it, Twilight failed to defeat Opaline, with or without her friends.

  • @filip1747
    @filip1747 2 місяці тому

    i think that Twilight used her magic to create the unity cristals so ponies won't attack each other and so that opaline wouldn't steal the magic

  • @lexiedgrooms5361
    @lexiedgrooms5361 2 місяці тому +1

    Merlin in every cartoon, I swear

  • @Kenziique
    @Kenziique 2 місяці тому +2

    My question is, what happened to luster dawn? Lol

  • @katherinestives940
    @katherinestives940 2 місяці тому

    I haven't followed any of the current stuff, so I was wondering about something while I watched the video. What happened to the windigoes? If there was strife among the pony races shouldn't the windigoes have returned?

  • @AiahElkishky
    @AiahElkishky 2 місяці тому +1

    Well I think that twilight sparkle is a good
    Ruler and if you are right I strongly
    Disagree

  • @Mates106sk
    @Mates106sk 2 місяці тому

    Or maybe everything went fine for long time bur at some point Twilight decided to retire as Luna and Celestia did and maybe she passed her duty on some student she might had but that student failed to keep it up

  • @timothymathews8859
    @timothymathews8859 2 місяці тому +1

    There was times she lost

  • @DembiBrox
    @DembiBrox 2 місяці тому

    Well, let’s take a look at Twilight character we all know she’s a very smart and caring person but she’s not very good at making the right choices unless she’s guided down the right path Celestia struggled for 1000 years on her own without a Luna. I think it was a mistake to think that twilight could do the same there were many things that Twilight cannot do on her own without her friends to guide her and support her, which is why I think all six of them should’ve become alicorns it should’ve been a council not just one ruler.

  • @YinkaAbdullahDosunmu
    @YinkaAbdullahDosunmu 2 місяці тому +3

    I can’t wait

  • @dokaratefightshotokhan997
    @dokaratefightshotokhan997 2 місяці тому +1

    tell me why they dosnot included mane 6 if they can be immortal like starsval was

  • @AvaLeonard-k4j
    @AvaLeonard-k4j Місяць тому

    Maybe twilight made the crystals and went to skyros

  • @Spiderbrony
    @Spiderbrony 2 місяці тому

    I want it to be true that the other alicorns went in exile in some random realm

  • @Embermoon91
    @Embermoon91 2 місяці тому

    Who else besides me thinks Twilight went to Skyros?

  • @teeganearl4425
    @teeganearl4425 2 місяці тому

    Honestly I don’t even consider gen 5 to be cannon

    • @HandheldGamer1991
      @HandheldGamer1991 2 місяці тому +1

      Good choice. It makes no sense andnspits on g4 while taking a huge dump at the same time. Trying to make sense of it only makes it look worse.

  • @GrimWolf001
    @GrimWolf001 2 місяці тому

    There are answers in Cannon, however some of them are hidden:
    ua-cam.com/video/38In3OgVfvw/v-deo.html
    Twilight didn't messed up, she didn't took away the magic, but if I simply tell you how it disappeared you wouldn't believe me:
    ua-cam.com/video/YE-kpqiX1LM/v-deo.html
    Thank you very much for the video, it was really enjoyable.

  • @ZFluffyheartsnotaprinces-js9dc
    @ZFluffyheartsnotaprinces-js9dc 2 місяці тому

    Cadence And flurry heart And all the alicorns went to A Alicorn kingdom Where all alicorns Camera Can live Alone they don't have to be royals But most of them are Just a fairy You never know It could be real official there is 1 I'm pretty sure there is 1 though Cause I heard about it in the new season on a video I don't know if it's true But research it Yourself

  • @NaadhinMohamed
    @NaadhinMohamed 2 місяці тому +4

    My little pony is great but why did they fail 😢❤️🌈

    • @m.bhopal
      @m.bhopal 2 місяці тому +1

      of the friendship is magic?
      well due to story was alot perfect and yet it reached to season 9 where they decide to end not because of faliure but because of the story that reached the end of it since they decide to end it

    • @manuproulx2764
      @manuproulx2764 2 місяці тому

      Did you read the g5 comics? The story is horrendous!

  • @HandheldGamer1991
    @HandheldGamer1991 2 місяці тому

    You are trying to make sense of g5 the series that didnt give a flying F about g4 and only used it to keep older fans around.
    Twilight failing is the biggest joke and will never make sense given what we see in g4 especially against someone like pffff opaline.

  • @readingwithkaitlyn2714
    @readingwithkaitlyn2714 2 місяці тому

    Twilight got reincarnated?

  • @bonbonbunny2978
    @bonbonbunny2978 2 місяці тому +3

    So long story short, it's just bad writing? It seem that there are way too many loop holes.

  • @valeriahernandez2828
    @valeriahernandez2828 2 місяці тому +1

    Voy a opinar algo espero que no funen.
    Creo que a twilight se le subió el poder, porque no ha podido superar la perdida de sus amigas y también su compañero de poder discord, y cuando vino opalina aprovecho el bug del desastre y robo la magia. Y para no dejar los ponis indefenso replicó los cristales con ti magia. Y se los dió a los ponis, y las demás alicornios como él desastre ya estaba hecho no podían hacer nada y se fueron no sé, pero se fueron. Y twilight dejo Canterlot indefenso y fue crear su propio imperio fuera de Equestria. Utilizando como subditos los ponis del imperio de cristal y le quitó el hechizo que tenían conectados con el corazón de cristal para que no dependan de ese artefacto.
    Por favor no me funen solo opino 😅😅😅😔😔😔🙈🙈🙈
    👁️👄👁️👍🏻

  • @Liam-si9tr
    @Liam-si9tr 2 місяці тому +1

    Twilight is a good ruler, she’s probably just confused. So those who agree with me pls like the comment

  • @saintzeroinfinity
    @saintzeroinfinity 2 місяці тому

    Maybe at the end of the series the new mane6 go back in time and change the future. Thus Opaline doesn't win against Twilight or have Misty become her friend in the past so Opaline could have a better future.

  • @aidanbarnes4290
    @aidanbarnes4290 Місяць тому

    she failed cause she wouldn't shut up about friendship and was more worried about that than the fire alicorn that messed up equestria. It was her and the mane 6's pointless lessons and worries that made them unlikable