If you use this link to sign into World of Warships: wo.ws/3Kqt54a You will get these amazing rewards: 200 Doubloons, 7 days Premium time, 1 MILLION credits, and more! You can also use this code: DDAY80TH If you enjoyed the video, make sure to follow me on twitch.tv/TICANick! and join our discord community! discord.gg/ybqXTYeT
Fact: the term "Crime against humanity" was first used by American writer Mark Twain to describe the treatment of the Congolese people by the Belgians. Glad he mentions it on map.
This is an incredibly biased retelling. Islamic antisemitism is completely left out, obscure conversations between individual Zionists are treated as doctrine, several quotes by British officials were deliberately misinterpreted (especially Balfour), and one-sided massacres against Jews, such as Nebi Musa were largely just framed as clashes. Oversimplified would do better.
it's a propaganda to those wrongly taken the Palestinian land, it's a deadass fact that Zionist has no legitimate claimed over Palestinian land and subjugation of its people, Muslim, Arab, Christian, Jewish alike, they have been living peacefully there under Ottoman, heck even for centuries, then come this one racist group from Europe that don't even believe in God. claimed to be God chosen people.
@@dewilew2137 Information being true doesn't mean it hasn't been presented in a way lacking context and intending to be misleading. An 'origin' video of this conflict which early on states that the Palestinians were 'just there' and the Jewish were kicked out by the Romans is misleading. The Temple of Solomon was built in the Kingdom of Israel in BCE, thousands of years ago. It was burned down and rebuilt, still BCE. The Neo-Assyrian Empire then destroyed the Kingdom of Israel and now there are two mosques built on top of the holiest site in the Jewish religion. These are the modern day Palestinians. I'd think that would be important context in a video explaining the origin of this conflict.
I've been there as a Christian tourist, met the Palestinians and those people have the most legitimate grievances one can ever hear. The Gaza war taking place there now is breaking my heart and I hope both the Jewish and Arab people who were so good the me there are alright.
Does not make them right! It's a consequences of their leaders making wrong choices. By the way this video uses a sloppy historian as source. Pappe is a manipulative historian, just as the video maker. I am raised with the Bible, I know about the history of Israël. And this video even suggests christians want Jews to burn forever, right from the beginning. What a nonsens.
They have the greatest lies that other victim minded abusers love so they can pretend they're good while they commit their Deceitful atrocities. Narcissists!
@@helloitsme1350don't start wars that you can't win and stop the terrorism attacks, in the end you're only reducing your chance for the country, not increasing it.
@LeviAckerman-ec8wr i have and since ancient times israels official name is linked to judaism its official name is judaea which comes from the kingdom of judah the romans used palestine to try and tick off the jews and force them to leave or to die
@ so sometime thousands of years ago they lived there so now they are allowed to come back and take land that has been inhabited for hundreds of years by others?
@@RobPires you know what's funny let say your right and how who cares if Israel was first by a few hundreds years and you only care who is first now it would be a tie 😂 so by your thinking Israel and Palestinian should get 50/50 of that land so no matter how you look that things Israel has a right to that land😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
always the islamists who forget holding all middle eastern christians and jews as dhimmis for over a millenia(and not even recognising alawite and yazidis right to exist) yet cry when the brits and french stopped those massacres
@@natigolden-l6s Yazidis actually have the right to exist lol none one is stopping them except isis and isis kills everyone they kill Muslims Christians jews yazidis Buddhist also isis has nothing to do with Islam as isis kill and do horrible things which aren't allowed in islam
This is an incredibly biased retelling. Islamic antisemitism is completely left out, obscure conversations between individual Zionists are treated as doctrine, several quotes by British officials were deliberately misinterpreted (especially Balfour), and one-sided massacres against Jews, such as Nebi Musa were largely just framed as clashes. Oversimplified would do better.
The Palestinian are the real descendent of ancient jews, they just converted from Judaism to Christianity and to Islam. Blond settlers from Hungary and Poland aren't indigenous to the middle east
LOL. That sure makes a lot of sense. Why are Palestinian genes nearly identical to Lebanese and Jordanian genes? Why can Jewish DNA be traced thousands of years back to the Levant? Why can historians trace the Jewish diaspora from the land of Israel to those European countries you spoke of? Why were the jews in those countries to begin with? The Arabs came from the ARABIAN peninsula in the 7th century and colonized the Middle East. Why do you think there are so many Arabs? But yeah, totally makes sense.
@@inferno-sushi1738 The Palestinians have been genetically proven to descend from Jews who converted to Christianity and Islam. They just never left the land. They are not 'recent Arab migrants' and are genetically almost indistinguishable from Mezrahis. They are Levantines who speak Arabic. Before the Levantines, the Natufians lived in that region for thousands of years. The fact that Jewish identity is now based on invalidating the identity of the Palestinians is really awful and sad to me, and did not exist before the Zionist movement. I refuse to define Judaism as a race when science shows it is not a unique race. It is a religion where people can convert to , like Ivanka Trump. In genatics, there is no such thing: (Jordanian, Lebanese or Palestinians) rather there are Levantines because it was one area for decades. In fact, these classification came up after the British and French mandate over the Levant in 1916 The Sykes-Picot Agreement.
@@ialyan9536the Palestinians today, are not a people. They are from different areas and are asking for a right to the land that is not theirs. There's no country called Palestine. If there were, Palestinians would have an argument. But their claim is on a "people" but they are not a"people" they come from neighboring countries
@@GodOfMySalvationIsYeshua Modern day Palestinians are much more genetically closely related to the Jews from Israel that faced the Diaspora after the Romans sacked Jerusalem in 70 A.D. than anyone else. Ashkenazi Jews are largely European descendants of people who were known as “Khazarians.” They converted to Judaism as their kingdom was in between a Christian empire and Muslim empires. This theory was proposed and researched by the Jewish professor Schlomo Sand. Later, forensic genealogists examined the matter further and proved his theories were accurate. Of course, modern day Ashkenazi Jews call this a “debunked anti-Semitic conspiracy theory” because it is threatening to their narrative about how Israel belongs to them. The reason most Jews look so European is because they are at least 40% European, if not much more.
I think he did well except he didn't really give much detail to the fact that Jews inhabited the land forever until Rome kicked them out. Most persons act like the Palestinians has been there for all of time and the Jews have zero claim to be there. Both groups have legitimate claims.
@shanefrederick7731 The issue is that any random person from any random corner of the world can convert and become jew and then turn around and say “ give me my 5 acres and a mule” when they have 0 blood ties to that region.
@@checo8187yeah that’s not how Judaism works. In contrast to other religions that try to expand. Jews try to keep their historical roots intact. That’s why not anyone is allowed to convert. And typically the only people allowed to do that are people who are marrying a Jewish person.
@@shanefrederick7731 also according to your logic, thr natives should attack and occupy the US and the americans should allow them to. Same with Australia. Your logic could even be extended to the fact that if pagans return, the jews should give them the land because they were there first. Flawed logic.
@@Breakfast.pancakeyep. Started with European immigrants who set out to displace the native inhabitants, those European immigrants admitted that was their goal, and agreed that the natives would fight back and that they were right to fight back. Was never about religion. Was just always about settler colonialism and greed. Even if you argue the ethnic cleansing of the 1947-48 war was a visceral reaction to the Holocaust, which is understandable, there are nearly 800,000 criminal squatters living on stolen land in the West Bank. That's not "defending yourselves" if you're killing Palestinians on their own land, to protect your own violent illegal immigrants from the people they stole from.
This is an incredibly complex topic. Unfortunately, this video does not analyze this historical event from a neutral standpoint. There are a bunch of statements that are not sourced because they are opinions, unfortunately. These opinions are stated as truths. A neutral analysis does not work this way. I will show below the timestams when opinions or false information is stated as truths. 'There was no Jewish or British plan to expel Arabs from the proposed Jewish state' 20:05 'Not just people but Jews were hiring Jews. Also Arabs were hiring Arabs. That's not a big surprise. Although it is made to sound as if the British imposed segregation laws, which I could not find.' 16:38 'Well, it is the author's personal opinion to state that zionism is a colonial project.There are plenty of reasons why this can not be true.' 9:56 'While it is true that the British gave military assistance to the Palmach forces of the Haganah in 1942. It is not mentioned, however, that the British stopped doing so in 1943 and attempted to disarm the Haganah. Making it sound as if the British played the main role in building the Haganah.' 24:58 Let's also not forget things that were not included in this video, which could explain things that seemed a bit sketchy. For example, the Jewish bitterness towards the British was not simply about restricting Jewish imagination. Jewish refugees during WW2 that fleed to the british mandate were intercepted by the royal navy and placed in concentration camps in Cyrus. If it was mentioned what actually happened to Jewish refugees who tried to enter the British mandate, Lehi's sentiment would have made some logic.
So I've been seeing a bit of map inaccuracies in this video, so when Britain colonized Palestine after the Ottomans fell, it was called "The British Mandate of Palestine" which includes of Israel (minus Golan Heights), Palestine, and Jordan. And in 25:09, when it shows Vichy France over Syria and Lebanon it also shows Turkey there too, which is inaccurate. Turkey stayed out of the conflict entirely. I don't want to send hate, I just want to point out some inaccurate stuff mapping.
@@DinoBryce TICA admits to being biased. Did you find any incorrect information? Part of the purpose of these vids is to show a side of a story you aren't usually told.
@alexkuron5069 It's not conducive to a conversation when a viewpoint's premise is overt and admitted bias. Even worse, the format is a shameless plagiarism of a popular channel.
@@alexkuron5069 Not really, he used people like Khalidi, one of the most biased Muslims sources. He puts deaths from Jews on Arabs 3 - 7 Times higher than Arabs on Jews. Also, of this guy claims to be biased, then why is this marketed as an educational Channel?
@@allroundlad i agree it shouldnt.. but for a content creator to speak out about this specific issue on a platform that is so heavily influenced if not controlled by the same people he is speaking out against does take some guts. most content creators avoid this topic like the plague or even worse they will side with the occupier just because its the easy thing to do.
I love this channel as much as I love Oversimplified. The creator of this video told histories from both sides of the conflict and did not even sugarcoat any war crime or attrocities commited by both sides (such as attrocities commited by US and South Koreans during Korean War) , which helped me listening to the other side of the story and helped with my history research. Keep up the good work, brother ❤
Are you serious? He sugarcoats this SO much for the Arabs. This video is infuriatingly biased. He paints the Jews as evil and the Arabs as innocent victims. This is essentially the “history” of the region as told by Yassar Arafat, but without the outright Jew-hatred.
@@markbisson6166Who persecuted the 'jws' in Europe and who should pay for it? The answer to both is not Palestine. Everyone can see the injustice here.
I'm left wing, and I can't believe you think this video shows the conflict from both sides. Its extremely biased towards the arabs, leaving out countless terror attacks commited by them, while bolding out the Lehi's terror and minimizing the Jewish ancestry and origin in the land (essentially the de-colonization of Israel). Also not taking into account that Jews were always praying to Israel, calling it "Eretz Israel" even on old coins before 1948. You can choose a side, that's fine and it's your choice - but blindness is another thing.
@YuVaL77777 The biased calling the other side biased is always fun to see. Nobody on Earth "owns" land indefinitely. Especially not from over 2000 years earlier. This is why your religious types are so insideous. You believe everyone else in the world has to subscribe to your versions of fairytales to the tune of literally causing wars.
I found your channel yesterday. I have to say this is the best historian animation channel on whole UA-cam because the details you mention and every side story man... I love it. I love you ❤.
Never will this be possible you're asking the Palestinians to come to peace with their parent's killers? That's like asking the jews to come to peace with the nazis
You don't know how much deception and injustice there is in this.First, use the term conflict.It is wrong because there is no equality between the two parties.There is an occupying party and a party being occupied. A party that owns tanks, planes, technology and rules all Palestinian territories America and the West support him And a party that can't leave its house to go to the grocery store Without being subjected to an Israeli checkpoint where he would be humiliated and possibly arrested. Or leaving his home only to find an Israeli family occupying his home with the support of the Israeli government.
Gotta love the animations and the style! Also, excellent work on simplifying such a controversial AND complex situation, with humor, while also being respectful to the events themselves. Thanks for the video, and looking forward excitedly for part 2 :D p.s. Kudos too for the new animator! He's a highly positive addition to your work :D
what is so good about this job? the guy skipped 1929 hebron and safed pogrom(against 2 unarmed ,non zionist religious communities) and said 1921 riots were over a cloth in a muslim "religious site" -it wasnt in al aqsa but in the western wall,place that was never holy for the muslims. history is not his strong side .skipped us mizrahis (most israelis today,sixth of the hebrews in the land of israel prior to 1948,among the founders of tel aviv and west jerusalem and rehovot).
This is an incredibly complex topic. Unfortunately, this video does not analyze this historical event from a neutral standpoint. First of all, there is barely if no mention of the Jews who were on the land for millennia and resided in what is known as the Old Yishuv. Furthermore, without careful consideration throughout the video, it is stated that zionism is a colonialist project. This quote by history professor Alexander Yakobson perfectly describes where this argument collapses: "In other words, zionism was a colonialist phenomenon in all respects and fully resembled other examples of modern colonialism apart from the fact that it was a national movement, that it was not motivated by the desire of economical gain, that it arose out of Jewish suffering, and was realized by people who may be defined as refugees, that the settlers had no colonial mother country, and that the bond with the land of Israel was part of the traditional historical identity of the Jewish people. Otherwise, it is totally colonialism." Moreover, unlike what is claimed in the video. There was never a plan by the Hagana or the Jewish administration to expel Arab Palestinians from the proposed Jewish state. The reason why Arabs fled during the 1947 war is due to their initiation of a war to destroy the self-proclaimed Jewish state. Indeed, Arab villages were destroyed during the 1947 war, but none of that would have happened if no war had taken place. The fact that many Arabs after the war stayed in Israel should be an indication. Also Jews in the West Bank and the Arab world ended up getting displaced as a result of this war. Also, why is there no mention of the deportation of Jewish refugees to camps in British controlled Cyprus during WW2 due to the white paper? This is important information that could explain why many Jews viewed the British as an enemy. The reason why this conflict has not been solved for so long has to do with the Palestinian misinterpretation of Israelis. Palestinians see Israeli Jews as Europeans with no historical connection to the land and, therefore, should be driven out to the sea and never be negotiated with. Since Israel supposedly has no right to exist from the get go. This claim that zionism is colonialism only justifies the Palestinian perception of Israelis and would make coexistence and mutual understanding between nations impossible. (Even though, most Israeli Jews today are Mizrahi. Ashkenazi, Sephardic, and Mizrahi Jews have 20 to 40 percent Samarian DNA. There is a strong Jewish cultural connection to the land and much archeological evidence of ancient Jewish civilizations on the land.) The PLO drew inspiration from the FLN's fight against France to the point where they use the same tactics. Making it too costly for the colonizer to stay. But the French left, and the Jews never did because the French had somewhere else to go, but the Jews never did. The Palestinian elite understood the Jews completely wrong. They think that Israel continues to survive because of an empire. But what they fail to grasp is that the empire kept changing. It went from the Russian empire in the 19th century, to the British empire in the early 20th century, then the Soviet empire in the mid 20th century, afterwards the French empire after the Suez crisis, and lastly it became the American empire in the late 20th century. Because the Jews sought help from different powers for their own survival, just like many 3rd world nations. The British were not always on the Jewish side, especially when they voted against the UN partition plan that enabled the Jews to have their own state. Hopefully, some of this will be considered in the next part of this series.
@jasporflex1976 first of all, Israel has every right to exist and to defend itself; it s the Palestinians who dont. Secondly, tldr _ I stopped when you said zionism is not colonialism. You need to read more and inform yourself better . Zionism goes further than just colonialism; its jewish racial supremacy. It has embedded the same racism that jewish people had suffered throughout the story. You need to learn how to be more concive and deliver your message. Israel is a terrorist state that disregards Geneva Conventions, bombs UN buildings, hospitals, schools; accuses hamas of using human shields and guess what, IDF itself uses human shields. Israel wants to stop terrorism behaving like terrorist. The only way to stop this GENOCIDE is to provoke the international comunity to intervene. STOP PALESTINIAN GENOCIDE. STOP PALESTINIAN GENOCIDE.
@jasporflex1976 First of all it was all about british colonialism. And colonialism cannot be seen separately from Racial Supremacy. Secondly, zionism goes further than just colonialism; it is Jewish Racial Supremacy. They try to enforce into the Palestinians the same treatment western powers gave them all throughout history. Jewish people have close ties to colonial administration, fascism, apartheid and are used to colaborate with the exploiters. Did you know that jewish peolpe were the administrative leadership to the ghetos in Europe actively cooperating with the holocaust? They had to give their own keen to be transported to the killing camps. Further than that, the fuher himself had to expel some of the Jewish official he had on his army. The jews get mad because the Palestinians refuse to play the same roll. And the IDF promote terrorism while acuse hamas of the same. Israel bombs UN building and kill UN personel, bombs hospitals, schools whilst accusing the hamas of using human shields and guess what IDF itself uses human shields, we ve seen a paleatinians straped to the front of a wartruck (they learned from the UK) , They placed some strategic Security offices in the middle of highly populated areas. Israel wants to have the cake and eat it. Israel disrespects the Geneva Conventions it s signatory. And war crimes are imprescritibles. You need to read more and inform yourself better. STOP PALESTINIAN GENOCIDE!
2:21 i have a big problem with "let them go BACK to the arab countries" palestinians have lived in palestine for millenia and can trace their ancestry back to the people of Canaan.
They always say the land was there's despite their holy scripts saying that they were Egyptian slaves who ran away with Moses They gen-ocided the Canaanites and took their land and called it isr🤢🤢ael Isra🤢🤢el was not supposed to be a thing
First of all, the zionist movement was never advocating for the exile of palestinians in the first place, some zionists promoted that idea but it didn’t reflect the movement and this video is extremely misleading. Secondly, palestinians are factually descendants of jordanian and egyptian immigrants that were named palestinians by the romans to spite the indigenous jews after exiling them. Do more research on that.
@@melodicvirginia did you bother to read my or my fellow colleges comment? Canaanites (called akhamalites)are mentioned in the Torah and bible, that essentially says the same thing
And NOT an accurate representation of the Jewish or even the ZIONIST movement's reaction. It was NOT a "great we're happy with this"! It was more "we'll take it because we would RATHER not have to actually kill people.
I’m so happy that I’ve been finding rational, honest, unbiased sources of information on this conflict lately. I’ve been searching since 7. October, as I refused to speak on the topic until I fully understood the nuance. It is not easy finding unbiased information on this subject, even websites and books. I hate that the extremist channels spreading false history and religious narratives are the channels getting millions of views and subscribers. Channels like yours are the channels I will help to promote. ❤
@@shnubblebitts6193she meant to say “I was specifically researching and looking for a narrative that boost my own agenda and belief. I’m amazing, I’m smart and awesome! Thanks for confirming that.”
@@MoonlightSonata160 Please tell me the be parts that were not factual. I already said that I’m looking for the objective truth, and when you’re coming from a position of knowing nothing about the subject, as I was, it’s very hard to tell which sources are biased and which aren’t. If I’ve come across slanted information, please tell me what was incorrect so I can do more research and correct my acquired biases, rather than trying to insult me. Contrary to what you assume, I don’t think I’m any smarter than the average person. I do think I’m more honest, and not nearly as ego driven, so your attempt at hurting my feelings hasn’t worked. Thank you for at least recognizing that I’m a woman. I’ve noticed that people who reply to women on UA-cam will automatically assume they’re talking to a man, unless the comment explicitly states otherwise.
@@shnubblebitts6193 Unless by some miracle, this link led to one video for you, and a separate video for me, I’d have to say we watched the same video. Please tell me what you believe was inaccurate or biased.
13:12 ERROR HERE: the building with a golden dome is NOT the mosque. Everyone gets this wrong… the important mosque is a less imposing building near it, the thing with the gold on top (which is not actually gold by the way) is a just a shrine, and not the holy thing
@@mesoiq I don’t question how important the golden building may be, but as far as I understand the building with the golden dome is not the one that is the third most important site for the religion, that one is another building (without gold) a few yards away, and lots of people confuse it with the golden one. Am I wrong?
The video infers that Palestine was an Islamic place prior to the creation of the Jewish state. The Jews and Muslims lived in Palestine since the Romans
I've read 2 history Israeli books 3 palastineans history books Like 30 random history articles The full united nations history report of palastine between 1917 And i can tell you this video can be summarized into one word: facts
Most the books I read abt the holocaust and their story had them talking about Palestine and moving there using the word Palestine. So they knew people still lived there and most the authors disagreed with the Zionism
I mean 3 minutes into the video and it's already wrong in the 1900s the idea of Jewish state was only brought up essentially never it was stated they wanted to take the land from the people who were tbh not there also there are no native people from palestine the place was called by the romes when they conquered kingdom of judea the "Palestinian people" are in reality settlers that most of them came in between 1915 to 1926 there was huge migration into that land to proof that there was a french journalist who visited the land in 1852 and said he saw nothing in the land from left to right basically no people no nothing Jerusalem and the golden heights were the only populated places at that time and you can guess who were in Jerusalem it were the jews
@@yanyannolife326 not true take a look at DNA on palestinians. its all israelites. the original jews all got converted or just don't live there anymore. most moved because they werent making profit from the land
@@yanyannolife326 seriously I personally know 6 people who had who had records of there great grandparents from the 1850s I spent alot of time verifying this And each got an average of 10 kids Each of those got an average of 7 kids and those now have kids It's called population growth not by settlements and migration infact I would bet that between 1800 and 1930 more Palestines lift to other countries then the other way around And for those who say "well gaza population is increasing since 1948 " I will ask of them to search a simple thing How many people were forced Into gaza since 1948 by is not ral
What occupation Israelis own that land and it belongs to the Jews the “ native “ Palestines colonised and killed anyone who was Jewish after ottomans conquest
@@zvistachEven david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict. It's very simple European jews wanted to colonize palestina. According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
Wow my dad was born in teera,haifa 1945 he told me all kinds of stories about what happened there and i was surprised that you mentioned the tying to convoys , thanks for this video btw my ancestors lived in palestine for 560 years i hope some day i can return ❤️
This is an incredibly complex topic. Unfortunately, this video does not analyze this historical event from a neutral standpoint. There are a bunch of statements that are not sourced because they are opinions, unfortunately. These opinions are stated as truths. A neutral analysis does not work this way. I will show below the timestams when opinions or false information is stated as truths. 'There was no Jewish or British plan to expel Arabs from the proposed Jewish state' 20:05 'Not just people but Jews were hiring Jews. Also Arabs were hiring Arabs. That's not a big surprise. Although it is made to sound as if the British imposed segregation laws, which I could not find.' 16:38 'Well, it is the author's personal opinion to state that zionism is a colonial project.There are plenty of reasons why this can not be true.' 9:56 'While it is true that the British gave military assistance to the Palmach forces of the Haganah in 1942. It is not mentioned, however, that the British stopped doing so in 1943 and attempted to disarm the Haganah. Making it sound as if the British played the main role in building the Haganah.' 24:58 Let's also not forget things that were not included in this video, which could explain things that seemed a bit sketchy. For example, the Jewish bitterness towards the British was not simply about restricting Jewish imagination. Jewish refugees during WW2 that fleed to the british mandate were intercepted by the royal navy and placed in concentration camps in Cyrus. If it was mentioned what actually happened to Jewish refugees who tried to enter the British mandate, Lehi's sentiment would have made some logic.
Let's download this video before it's taken down by youtube. Then later we can reupload and spread this history forever! Everyone need to know the truth.
Bro used the wrong eagle to inpersonate austria. Before n4z1s there was no broken chain at the claws. After ww2 austrias eagle had them to show they finally are free again
the guy skipped 1929 hebron and safed pogrom(against 2 unarmed ,non zionist religious communities) and said 1921 riots were over a cloth in a muslim "religious site" -it wasnt in al aqsa but in the western wall,place that was never holy for the muslims. history is not his strong side
@muntTV not all the land purchased. Zeev Jabotinsky said in 1921: "I don't know of a single example in history where a country was colonised with the courteous consent of the population".
We Palestinians don’t have to argue with racist westerners in a UA-cam comment section to prove our national identity. Our country is our right and it is our right under international law to bear arms and resist the colonizers.
So raping and murdering innocents is resistance? Nah mate look what it caused 30 thousand Palestinians dead. Lay down your arms accept the jewish state and you'll get your own country in gaza and the west bank.
So get out you colonizers. When abu bakr first entered Jerusalem he mentioned Jews in that land, while there still no Arabs there. All in thr last 3000 years, the Jews persist to present there. So logically its their land and u lot are occupiers.
@@ahmadaltaher1524 lol, you Arabs are conguerors and colonizer of that land, return to ur ancestral land, lat the Jews back to their ancestral land as well
Wrong. You MIGHT have some rights to some of the disputed territories. Israel belongs to the Israelis. They built a country out of pretty much NOTHING. Palestinian Arabs are brainwashed by their disgusting murderous leaders that Israel actually belongs to them. Go for peace like decent humans and perhaps you'll have a state.
@@sirblank2384 they are being attacked . are you an israeli? west bank recieves raids of their mosque every year for absolutely no reason. search it up
Hey so first of all love the new animation looks great now that you have your definite style great work. Also I have been getting replies on some comments I put on your videos and other commenters that say you’re spreading misinformation this happened during your Korean War two parter I love your channel don’t get me wrong but I worry that I’m spreading misinformation.
You should ALWAYS fact-check what anyone says! Whether it is me or other people. Use my videos as a starting point to learn more about all these topics! And never share information without checking it first. With that, you can rest assured you won't be spreading misinfo
@@ThingsICareAbout okay thanks I will view it like that and try to research it more in the way you suggest I’m sorry to trouble you with this it’s just been looming on my mind recently.
Mostly what he mentioned was actually true. If you want more details you can go to wiki or read the book about Palestine like the ethnic cleansing of Palestine by ilan peppe@@haikalmaulanapasha4676
@@haikalmaulanapasha4676the only ones saying he's biased towards Palestinians are zionists and most likely Israelis. It's like Americans saying that America isn't racist. You pretty much already know which groups of Americans would say that America isn't racist.
If you have a majority group facilitate the relations of two marginalized communities, it never ends well. Especially if the major group was the reason the smaller ones were marginalized.
Fun fact: Jordan was also used to be part of British Mandatory of Palestine. 1 year before the creation of the State of Israel, Transjordan had already declared independence.
Arab and jew what comes to my mind is i think there should be more that we are agreeing. I my self as a strict Muslim think that the Jews think that somehow we hate them because they are Jews. As an Arab I am proud of my brother the children of ishaq AS the intelligent one in our family. Don't you think that we could live together under one flag the flag of our father Ibrahim AS. But i don't know how you all are Brain washed and you come over our house and stealing it even the Torah doses not allow it. I am not saying it's you as individual jew But the fact it's out of ordinary jew who follows Torah and Adonai commands it means someone really out of the boundary of this ibrahimic family is controlling things? Who do you think that is ?
Am sorry bro but you need a fact check. alot of what you presented is a twisted version of the truth or missing (out of context). For example Jewish ownership of Palestinian land by purchase never reached more than 10% all the rest was taken by force amongst others
How about the simple fact that it shouldn't have happened in the first place? But one thing is true in every context, everywhere caucasians go. Death and destruction follow. They can't escape that. At first, it starts with the spreading of their Lord, Jesus Christ, with Christian or Catholic pilgrims. Then, traders, diplomats last it's the military No matter who they are, where they come from, their M.O. is the same. Conquer and expand No matter if they're European, German Irish, Russian, French, or American. In the modern day, you know them as the U.N. Which broke off and created its own subset. But this is nothing more than a ploy to capture Earth's natural resources for the wealthy. They have a subset within their own ranks to determine. Who is more worthy and pure from within the Caucasian ranks. What makes this more sad is the fact that all these other races, that are not Caucasian think they have a place at this table. And they don't. they use the people of these other countries. To gather up their natural resources and distribute them to other Caucasian nations so that they can become rich. While leaving the country that they got said riches from people broke in desolate, and this is, after they divided up the land and it's people between other Caucasian nations. And that's just the abridged version. Still factually, right.
great video. slight problem Alaqsa mosque is not the golden rock it's actually behind it. common confution. hope if more vids on this topic comes you will fix it. 😊
All i can say is thank You things i care about , people take for granted the impact colonialism and racism had on the events that led to WWI &II , the subjugation of the palestinian people and the creation of the state of Isreal....
I like the animation and all. Great Work! But I feel like your videos are a bit biased. This one was no exception. If being biased was never the intention, I highly recommend you do more research into topics like the Israel-Palestine conflict before uploading anything including part 2. It will take a little longer, but trust me it'll be worth it. You will likely get attacked by both sides, but that's a sign you've made improvement. And also a sign humans are idiotic creatures when someone disagrees with them.
@@CelticChu okay I will do that but, since I am usually a person who tends to miss some details, I would glady appreciate it if you point it out for me if you can. Thanks for your reply though.
What do you mean by northern syria? Are you serious? Palestine is south of syria and no they didnt, the land was called palestine for a long time and the people there started calling themselves palestinians even before the british came.
If you use this link to sign into World of Warships:
wo.ws/3Kqt54a
You will get these amazing rewards: 200 Doubloons, 7 days Premium time, 1 MILLION credits, and more!
You can also use this code: DDAY80TH
If you enjoyed the video, make sure to follow me on twitch.tv/TICANick! and join our discord community!
discord.gg/ybqXTYeT
i was the 100 person who liked lets go love all ya in the comments
World of warships sponsor in a Palestine / Israel video is crazy 😭
I respect the accuracy
I just noticed, you didnt include me in tle list of channel members in the description.
@@501stcloneboi2 ohh the list on youtube must have been bugged! I'll fix it as soon as possible,I'm so sorry!
@@501stcloneboi2 Okay I fixed it! Apologies!
Bro was tired of Oversimplified's upload schedule and became Oversimplified.
Not oversimplified, just regular simplified
@@JadoYankee no he’s really oversimplified
oversimplified who? 🔥🔥🔥🔥
Ultrasimplified 🔥🔥🔥
@@IRON9LORD Palestinified
Fact: the term "Crime against humanity" was first used by American writer Mark Twain to describe the treatment of the Congolese people by the Belgians. Glad he mentions it on map.
Hm i wonder how mark twain described the land of Israel when he visited it when it was under ottoman rule
hello Piccolo from Dragon Ball
@@BEEFYP.I.M.P. funny you saying that,because back then ottoman empire was the most tolerance place
@@sillyguy-rv6xlmaybe to palestynians but to Greeks and other balkan people ohhh they were cruel
@@cub-square EXAMPLE?
I bet this video won’t have controversial comment section
The Star Wars Prequels are better than the Originals or Sequels
Same
@@aramhalamech4204 You monster, Im sending you to Detroit
No no not Detroit
can't have shit in Detroit
Not even opinions 😔
If you see two fishes fighting in a pond, just know that a British has passed by.
They brought the fish it self
As usual the world won't take responsibility for their own actions and blame the English
Like Britain didn't divide the world in half@@sean501st
@@OmarBahure technically the world representatives did, brits were asked to start the meeting
Oi, dey just wan' fish n' chips, innit!
*Watching Historical video* : 😠
*Watching Historical video with stick animations* : 🙂
😎😎😎
exactly
These aren't stick people smh
This is an incredibly biased retelling. Islamic antisemitism is completely left out, obscure conversations between individual Zionists are treated as doctrine, several quotes by British officials were deliberately misinterpreted (especially Balfour), and one-sided massacres against Jews, such as Nebi Musa were largely just framed as clashes. Oversimplified would do better.
But video have false information
So the moral of the story is that the British and other European nations were responsible for most of these conflicts
British empire is responsible for almost every conflict in the 20th to 21st century
Ya British just allowed Palestine problems to increase
True
Ya doesn’t take a genius to figure it out
Aren’t all of the world’s problems
Its insane how they come in the comments calling this propaganda.. but in the end ALL of these documents can be googled & read as public information..
They can but the commentators opinion to say they meant something else or there was an alternative agenda is propaganda.
LOL someone doesn’t know what propaganda means
it's a propaganda to those wrongly taken the Palestinian land, it's a deadass fact that Zionist has no legitimate claimed over Palestinian land and subjugation of its people, Muslim, Arab, Christian, Jewish alike, they have been living peacefully there under Ottoman, heck even for centuries, then come this one racist group from Europe that don't even believe in God. claimed to be God chosen people.
@@professord2807 anything can be used as propaganda, but that doesn’t mean that the information isn’t true.
@@dewilew2137 Information being true doesn't mean it hasn't been presented in a way lacking context and intending to be misleading. An 'origin' video of this conflict which early on states that the Palestinians were 'just there' and the Jewish were kicked out by the Romans is misleading. The Temple of Solomon was built in the Kingdom of Israel in BCE, thousands of years ago. It was burned down and rebuilt, still BCE.
The Neo-Assyrian Empire then destroyed the Kingdom of Israel and now there are two mosques built on top of the holiest site in the Jewish religion. These are the modern day Palestinians.
I'd think that would be important context in a video explaining the origin of this conflict.
I've been there as a Christian tourist, met the Palestinians and those people have the most legitimate grievances one can ever hear. The Gaza war taking place there now is breaking my heart and I hope both the Jewish and Arab people who were so good the me there are alright.
Does not make them right! It's a consequences of their leaders making wrong choices. By the way this video uses a sloppy historian as source. Pappe is a manipulative historian, just as the video maker. I am raised with the Bible, I know about the history of Israël. And this video even suggests christians want Jews to burn forever, right from the beginning. What a nonsens.
They have the greatest lies that other victim minded abusers love so they can pretend they're good while they commit their Deceitful atrocities.
Narcissists!
Hey a Palestinian christian here, do you know that we exist too? Do you know how much we suffer from the occupation? F isnotreal and free palestine 🇵🇸
@@helloitsme1350don't start wars that you can't win and stop the terrorism attacks, in the end you're only reducing your chance for the country, not increasing it.
What about the way they celebrated on october 7th?
Is that legitimate grievance?
New Animator here!, Hope you all enjoyed! I and Nick worked really hard on creating this video so make sure to leave a Like and comment
Welcome to the team!
The video looks way better bro!❤
@@ThingsICareAbout Thank you Nick
@@aicarambaaaa9694 no
It was called Palestine (there are maps that prove this) before they named it Israel wth
1920: Mandatory Palestine
1947: Recommended Palestine
1967: Optional Palestine
xdd
🤌🏽
And none were real countries
@@lolgic930 Plot twist of history
1918 Ottoman Empire lost WW1
“Oh wow I bet this video with have a civil comment sec-“
SHUT UP
*punches wall*
"One time is funny, two times is fucking annoying, no?"
-- Vaas
SMOSH video intro be like😂
@@nverdice9333 bc it's full of historical errors?!
@@DylanoRevsdid I ever tell you the definition of insanity?
1. Haifa Massacre 1937
2. Jerusalem Massacre 1937
3. Haifa Massacre 1938
4. Balad al-Sheikh Massacre 1939
5. Haifa Massacre 1939
6. Abbasiya Massacre 1947
7. Al-Khisas Massacre 1947
8. Bab al-Amud Massacre 1947
9. Jerusalem Massacre 1947
10. Sheikh Bureik Massacre 1947
11. Haifa Massacre 1948
12. Tantura Massacre 1948
13. Jaffa Massacre 1948
14. Khan Yunis Massacre 1956
15. Jerusalem Massacre 1967
16. Sabra and Shatila Massacre 1982
17. Al-Aqsa Massacre 1990
18. Ibrahimi Mosque Massacre 1994
19. Jenin Refugee Camp Massacre 2002
20. Gaza Massacre 2008-09
21. Gaza Massacre 2012
22. Gaza Massacre 2014
23. Gaza Massacre 2018-19
24. Gaza Massacre 2021
25. Gaza Genocide 2023 is still ongoing
Palestines name means jewish land
@@sirblank2384have you even watched this video
@LeviAckerman-ec8wr i have and since ancient times israels official name is linked to judaism its official name is judaea which comes from the kingdom of judah the romans used palestine to try and tick off the jews and force them to leave or to die
@ so you think that justifies everything that happened afterwards? Do you not hear how racists the laws were that got those Jews to Palestine
@ so sometime thousands of years ago they lived there so now they are allowed to come back and take land that has been inhabited for hundreds of years by others?
You're a braver person than I am by making this video
Idk what would be crazier. This video's comment section or a video about Israel-Palestine having a sponsor
@@Amelia_-qy9nz the sponsor just lightens the mood
he needs to feed himself too also mate
Claiming you used to own the land thousands of years ago is craziest.
@@RobPires you know what's funny let say your right and how who cares if Israel was first by a few hundreds years and you only care who is first now it would be a tie 😂 so by your thinking Israel and Palestinian should get 50/50 of that land so no matter how you look that things Israel has a right to that land😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@AlejandroMata-w6vtwo state solution
but west bank is kinda occupied
and hamas and hezbollah are fucking pricks
yeah there’s no good solution
It’s Always the British
always the islamists who forget holding all middle eastern christians and jews as dhimmis for over a millenia(and not even recognising alawite and yazidis right to exist) yet cry when the brits and french stopped those massacres
@@natigolden-l6s
More paid propaganda comments
@@natigolden-l6sshut yo as up you know nothing
as an Irish, yes
@@natigolden-l6s Yazidis actually have the right to exist lol none one is stopping them except isis and isis kills everyone they kill Muslims Christians jews yazidis Buddhist also isis has nothing to do with Islam as isis kill and do horrible things which aren't allowed in islam
Oversimplifieds been real quiet since this one dropped
Bro was quiet for ages💀
This is an incredibly biased retelling. Islamic antisemitism is completely left out, obscure conversations between individual Zionists are treated as doctrine, several quotes by British officials were deliberately misinterpreted (especially Balfour), and one-sided massacres against Jews, such as Nebi Musa were largely just framed as clashes. Oversimplified would do better.
Literally 💀
This is Definitely influenced by oversimplified but I'm not mad 😂😂 at least this guy uploads
No. He releases new videos or video every 6 months or so. When they come out, tho its super exciting.
The Palestinian are the real descendent of ancient jews, they just converted from Judaism to Christianity and to Islam. Blond settlers from Hungary and Poland aren't indigenous to the middle east
LOL. That sure makes a lot of sense.
Why are Palestinian genes nearly identical to Lebanese and Jordanian genes? Why can Jewish DNA be traced thousands of years back to the Levant? Why can historians trace the Jewish diaspora from the land of Israel to those European countries you spoke of? Why were the jews in those countries to begin with?
The Arabs came from the ARABIAN peninsula in the 7th century and colonized the Middle East. Why do you think there are so many Arabs?
But yeah, totally makes sense.
@@inferno-sushi1738 The Palestinians have been genetically proven to descend from Jews who converted to Christianity and Islam. They just never left the land. They are not 'recent Arab migrants' and are genetically almost indistinguishable from Mezrahis. They are Levantines who speak Arabic. Before the Levantines, the Natufians lived in that region for thousands of years. The fact that Jewish identity is now based on invalidating the identity of the Palestinians is really awful and sad to me, and did not exist before the Zionist movement. I refuse to define Judaism as a race when science shows it is not a unique race. It is a religion where people can convert to , like Ivanka Trump.
In genatics, there is no such thing: (Jordanian, Lebanese or Palestinians) rather there are Levantines because it was one area for decades. In fact, these classification came up after the British and French mandate over the Levant in 1916 The Sykes-Picot Agreement.
@@ialyan9536the Palestinians today, are not a people. They are from different areas and are asking for a right to the land that is not theirs. There's no country called Palestine. If there were, Palestinians would have an argument. But their claim is on a "people" but they are not a"people" they come from neighboring countries
Idiot@@GodOfMySalvationIsYeshua
@@GodOfMySalvationIsYeshua Modern day Palestinians are much more genetically closely related to the Jews from Israel that faced the Diaspora after the Romans sacked Jerusalem in 70 A.D. than anyone else.
Ashkenazi Jews are largely European descendants of people who were known as “Khazarians.” They converted to Judaism as their kingdom was in between a Christian empire and Muslim empires. This theory was proposed and researched by the Jewish professor Schlomo Sand. Later, forensic genealogists examined the matter further and proved his theories were accurate. Of course, modern day Ashkenazi Jews call this a “debunked anti-Semitic conspiracy theory” because it is threatening to their narrative about how Israel belongs to them. The reason most Jews look so European is because they are at least 40% European, if not much more.
3 words, Blame the British.
Jews*
@@al3l16real5 no it's really the british that are behind most issues there
@@al3l16real5Wow great a new idiot who didn’t watch the video
@@Justaguyaroslav1234 Ok commie
@@al3l16real5both
Finally someone who simplifies this conflict and gives it detail
Edit:why yall fighting in the replies
Ya it’s honestly fun watching people explain it but then a few days later the comments go like free Palestine 😅
I think he did well except he didn't really give much detail to the fact that Jews inhabited the land forever until Rome kicked them out. Most persons act like the Palestinians has been there for all of time and the Jews have zero claim to be there. Both groups have legitimate claims.
@shanefrederick7731 The issue is that any random person from any random corner of the world can convert and become jew and then turn around and say “ give me my 5 acres and a mule” when they have 0 blood ties to that region.
@@checo8187yeah that’s not how Judaism works. In contrast to other religions that try to expand. Jews try to keep their historical roots intact. That’s why not anyone is allowed to convert. And typically the only people allowed to do that are people who are marrying a Jewish person.
@@shanefrederick7731 also according to your logic, thr natives should attack and occupy the US and the americans should allow them to. Same with Australia. Your logic could even be extended to the fact that if pagans return, the jews should give them the land because they were there first. Flawed logic.
This isn’t Oversimplified, this is Undercomplicated
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Great name 😂
Lmao
Politicians & Media often try to label & portray this conflict as SUPER complicated. This in order to escape mentioning unfavourable truths.
@@Breakfast.pancakeyep. Started with European immigrants who set out to displace the native inhabitants, those European immigrants admitted that was their goal, and agreed that the natives would fight back and that they were right to fight back.
Was never about religion. Was just always about settler colonialism and greed. Even if you argue the ethnic cleansing of the 1947-48 war was a visceral reaction to the Holocaust, which is understandable, there are nearly 800,000 criminal squatters living on stolen land in the West Bank. That's not "defending yourselves" if you're killing Palestinians on their own land, to protect your own violent illegal immigrants from the people they stole from.
Covering such edgy topics takes courage. Thank you for providing historical context on this topic. Keeping them coming.
Idk how this topic is edgy but ok bro
To bad he’s wrong🤷♂️
Yea man. Making a video is almost as brave as fighting s war 😂😂😂😂😂😂
This is an incredibly complex topic. Unfortunately, this video does not analyze this historical event from a neutral standpoint.
There are a bunch of statements that are not sourced because they are opinions, unfortunately. These opinions are stated as truths. A neutral analysis does not work this way.
I will show below the timestams when opinions or false information is stated as truths.
'There was no Jewish or British plan to expel Arabs from the proposed Jewish state' 20:05
'Not just people but Jews were hiring Jews. Also Arabs were hiring Arabs. That's not a big surprise. Although it is made to sound as if the British imposed segregation laws, which I could not find.' 16:38
'Well, it is the author's personal opinion to state that zionism is a colonial project.There are plenty of reasons why this can not be true.' 9:56
'While it is true that the British gave military assistance to the Palmach forces of the Haganah in 1942. It is not mentioned, however, that the British stopped doing so in 1943 and attempted to disarm the Haganah. Making it sound as if the British played the main role in building the Haganah.' 24:58
Let's also not forget things that were not included in this video, which could explain things that seemed a bit sketchy.
For example, the Jewish bitterness towards the British was not simply about restricting Jewish imagination. Jewish refugees during WW2 that fleed to the british mandate were intercepted by the royal navy and placed in concentration camps in Cyrus.
If it was mentioned what actually happened to Jewish refugees who tried to enter the British mandate, Lehi's sentiment would have made some logic.
To show so many lies and wrong fakes takes courage
So I've been seeing a bit of map inaccuracies in this video, so when Britain colonized Palestine after the Ottomans fell, it was called "The British Mandate of Palestine" which includes of Israel (minus Golan Heights), Palestine, and Jordan. And in 25:09, when it shows Vichy France over Syria and Lebanon it also shows Turkey there too, which is inaccurate. Turkey stayed out of the conflict entirely. I don't want to send hate, I just want to point out some inaccurate stuff mapping.
Absolutely correct.
@@Tamir_KarnielyThis is actually a very biased video, just look at the sources. The only objective source he used was Benny Morris.
@@DinoBryce TICA admits to being biased. Did you find any incorrect information? Part of the purpose of these vids is to show a side of a story you aren't usually told.
@alexkuron5069 It's not conducive to a conversation when a viewpoint's premise is overt and admitted bias. Even worse, the format is a shameless plagiarism of a popular channel.
@@alexkuron5069 Not really, he used people like Khalidi, one of the most biased Muslims sources. He puts deaths from Jews on Arabs 3 - 7 Times higher than Arabs on Jews. Also, of this guy claims to be biased, then why is this marketed as an educational Channel?
16 views in 14 seconds... that's actually pretty good!
TICA has risen…..
no it's not
@@___Anakin.Skywalker Try Better
man you are brave for daring to speak out on this.
Knowledge should never require bravery, it is everyone's duty to know the facts and what started all this.
@@allroundlad i agree it shouldnt.. but for a content creator to speak out about this specific issue on a platform that is so heavily influenced if not controlled by the same people he is speaking out against does take some guts.
most content creators avoid this topic like the plague or even worse they will side with the occupier just because its the easy thing to do.
I love this channel as much as I love Oversimplified. The creator of this video told histories from both sides of the conflict and did not even sugarcoat any war crime or attrocities commited by both sides (such as attrocities commited by US and South Koreans during Korean War) , which helped me listening to the other side of the story and helped with my history research.
Keep up the good work, brother ❤
Are you serious? He sugarcoats this SO much for the Arabs. This video is infuriatingly biased. He paints the Jews as evil and the Arabs as innocent victims. This is essentially the “history” of the region as told by Yassar Arafat, but without the outright Jew-hatred.
@@markbisson6166Who persecuted the 'jws' in Europe and who should pay for it? The answer to both is not Palestine. Everyone can see the injustice here.
@markbisson6166 Correct, the Jewish AND NATIVE Palestinians hatred came from Europe.
I'm left wing, and I can't believe you think this video shows the conflict from both sides. Its extremely biased towards the arabs, leaving out countless terror attacks commited by them, while bolding out the Lehi's terror and minimizing the Jewish ancestry and origin in the land (essentially the de-colonization of Israel). Also not taking into account that Jews were always praying to Israel, calling it "Eretz Israel" even on old coins before 1948. You can choose a side, that's fine and it's your choice - but blindness is another thing.
@YuVaL77777 The biased calling the other side biased is always fun to see. Nobody on Earth "owns" land indefinitely. Especially not from over 2000 years earlier. This is why your religious types are so insideous. You believe everyone else in the world has to subscribe to your versions of fairytales to the tune of literally causing wars.
I found your channel yesterday. I have to say this is the best historian animation channel on whole UA-cam because the details you mention and every side story man... I love it. I love you ❤.
I do hope that Israel and Palestine can come to a place of peace. I don’t want suffering among the Arabs or Israelis.
Islam peace😆😆😆 good luck with that.
Never will this be possible you're asking the Palestinians to come to peace with their parent's killers? That's like asking the jews to come to peace with the nazis
You don't know how much deception and injustice there is in this.First, use the term conflict.It is wrong because there is no equality between the two parties.There is an occupying party and a party being occupied. A party that owns tanks, planes, technology and rules all Palestinian territories America and the West support him And a party that can't leave its house to go to the grocery store Without being subjected to an Israeli checkpoint where he would be humiliated and possibly arrested. Or leaving his home only to find an Israeli family occupying his home with the support of the Israeli government.
@@detectivemz2544What if someone was born in Israel?
@@LucasIvey-pl7lv so?
Zionists: we don't believe in god, but he sure as hell promised us this land lol
You can be sure that Zionists 👹 are more atheistic than you 😸
Gotta love the animations and the style! Also, excellent work on simplifying such a controversial AND complex situation, with humor, while also being respectful to the events themselves. Thanks for the video, and looking forward excitedly for part 2 :D
p.s. Kudos too for the new animator! He's a highly positive addition to your work :D
It’s a knockoff of a channel called oversimplified. This channel is 💩. Check the original channel please.
It's not that complicated, it's very very simple
“We beat up the Jews,” why did I laugh at that so badly, I’m going to hell 💀💀
damn
As a Jew, I approve of your laughing
@@R0DBS ha
“And Thomas”
@@MrRhombusdon’t forget thomas
Really nice animation improvements, keep up the good work!
I think I’ve just witnessed the rise of a brilliant content creator. Good luck going forward, ThingsICareAbout!
Wake up, a new TICA upload just dropped. That new animation is aweosome BTW.
Oversimplified has a long upload time thankfully this guy has fast production
Your channel is a godsend to oversimplified fans
You should do about the conflict in Ireland
troubles?
You have really outdone yourself with the animations in this video! Good work!
what is so good about this job? the guy skipped 1929 hebron and safed pogrom(against 2 unarmed ,non zionist religious communities) and said 1921 riots were over a cloth in a muslim "religious site" -it wasnt in al aqsa but in the western wall,place that was never holy for the muslims. history is not his strong side .skipped us mizrahis (most israelis today,sixth of the hebrews in the land of israel prior to 1948,among the founders of tel aviv and west jerusalem and rehovot).
You ve managed to be thorough and yet simplified. Maybe the best video on the subject I ve ever seen.
10/10
This is an incredibly complex topic. Unfortunately, this video does not analyze this historical event from a neutral standpoint.
First of all, there is barely if no mention of the Jews who were on the land for millennia and resided in what is known as the Old Yishuv.
Furthermore, without careful consideration throughout the video, it is stated that zionism is a colonialist project.
This quote by history professor Alexander Yakobson perfectly describes where this argument collapses: "In other words, zionism was a colonialist phenomenon in all respects and fully resembled other examples of modern colonialism apart from the fact that it was a national movement, that it was not motivated by the desire of economical gain, that it arose out of Jewish suffering, and was realized by people who may be defined as refugees, that the settlers had no colonial mother country, and that the bond with the land of Israel was part of the traditional historical identity of the Jewish people. Otherwise, it is totally colonialism."
Moreover, unlike what is claimed in the video. There was never a plan by the Hagana or the Jewish administration to expel Arab Palestinians from the proposed Jewish state. The reason why Arabs fled during the 1947 war is due to their initiation of a war to destroy the self-proclaimed Jewish state. Indeed, Arab villages were destroyed during the 1947 war, but none of that would have happened if no war had taken place. The fact that many Arabs after the war stayed in Israel should be an indication. Also Jews in the West Bank and the Arab world ended up getting displaced as a result of this war.
Also, why is there no mention of the deportation of Jewish refugees to camps in British controlled Cyprus during WW2 due to the white paper? This is important information that could explain why many Jews viewed the British as an enemy.
The reason why this conflict has not been solved for so long has to do with the Palestinian misinterpretation of Israelis.
Palestinians see Israeli Jews as Europeans with no historical connection to the land and, therefore, should be driven out to the sea and never be negotiated with. Since Israel supposedly has no right to exist from the get go. This claim that zionism is colonialism only justifies the Palestinian perception of Israelis and would make coexistence and mutual understanding between nations impossible.
(Even though, most Israeli Jews today are Mizrahi. Ashkenazi, Sephardic, and Mizrahi Jews have 20 to 40 percent Samarian DNA. There is a strong Jewish cultural connection to the land and much archeological evidence of ancient Jewish civilizations on the land.)
The PLO drew inspiration from the FLN's fight against France to the point where they use the same tactics. Making it too costly for the colonizer to stay. But the French left, and the Jews never did because the French had somewhere else to go, but the Jews never did.
The Palestinian elite understood the Jews completely wrong.
They think that Israel continues to survive because of an empire. But what they fail to grasp is that the empire kept changing. It went from the Russian empire in the 19th century, to the British empire in the early 20th century, then the Soviet empire in the mid 20th century, afterwards the French empire after the Suez crisis, and lastly it became the American empire in the late 20th century. Because the Jews sought help from different powers for their own survival, just like many 3rd world nations.
The British were not always on the Jewish side, especially when they voted against the UN partition plan that enabled the Jews to have their own state.
Hopefully, some of this will be considered in the next part of this series.
@jasporflex1976 first of all, Israel has every right to exist and to defend itself; it s the Palestinians who dont. Secondly, tldr _ I stopped when you said zionism is not colonialism. You need to read more and inform yourself better . Zionism goes further than just colonialism; its jewish racial supremacy. It has embedded the same racism that jewish people had suffered throughout the story.
You need to learn how to be more concive and deliver your message. Israel is a terrorist state that disregards Geneva Conventions, bombs UN buildings, hospitals, schools; accuses hamas of using human shields and guess what, IDF itself uses human shields. Israel wants to stop terrorism behaving like terrorist. The only way to stop this GENOCIDE is to provoke the international comunity to intervene.
STOP PALESTINIAN GENOCIDE.
STOP PALESTINIAN GENOCIDE.
@jasporflex1976 First of all it was all about british colonialism. And colonialism cannot be seen separately from Racial Supremacy. Secondly, zionism goes further than just colonialism; it is Jewish Racial Supremacy. They try to enforce into the Palestinians the same treatment western powers gave them all throughout history. Jewish people have close ties to colonial administration, fascism, apartheid and are used to colaborate with the exploiters. Did you know that jewish peolpe were the administrative leadership to the ghetos in Europe actively cooperating with the holocaust? They had to give their own keen to be transported to the killing camps. Further than that, the fuher himself had to expel some of the Jewish official he had on his army. The jews get mad because the Palestinians refuse to play the same roll.
And the IDF promote terrorism while acuse hamas of the same. Israel bombs UN building and kill UN personel, bombs hospitals, schools whilst accusing the hamas of using human shields and guess what IDF itself uses human shields, we ve seen a paleatinians straped to the front of a wartruck (they learned from the UK) , They placed some strategic Security offices in the middle of highly populated areas.
Israel wants to have the cake and eat it.
Israel disrespects the Geneva Conventions it s signatory. And war crimes are imprescritibles.
You need to read more and inform yourself better.
STOP PALESTINIAN GENOCIDE!
@@jasporflex1976you need to write it as a comment on the video and not just a comment on a comment because more people need to see this!!!
@@shirrippa4928Dw, I already did
2:21 i have a big problem with "let them go BACK to the arab countries" palestinians have lived in palestine for millenia and can trace their ancestry back to the people of Canaan.
You know what's up man
They always say the land was there's despite their holy scripts saying that they were Egyptian slaves who ran away with Moses
They gen-ocided the Canaanites and took their land and called it isr🤢🤢ael
Isra🤢🤢el was not supposed to be a thing
First of all, the zionist movement was never advocating for the exile of palestinians in the first place, some zionists promoted that idea but it didn’t reflect the movement and this video is extremely misleading. Secondly, palestinians are factually descendants of jordanian and egyptian immigrants that were named palestinians by the romans to spite the indigenous jews after exiling them. Do more research on that.
@@melodicvirginia did you bother to read my or my fellow colleges comment?
Canaanites (called akhamalites)are mentioned in the Torah and bible, that essentially says the same thing
@@melodicvirginia stop spitting hasbara
8:22 accurate representation of Palestinians reaction to the Balfour declaration
And NOT an accurate representation of the Jewish or even the ZIONIST movement's reaction. It was NOT a "great we're happy with this"! It was more "we'll take it because we would RATHER not have to actually kill people.
I love how fact-driven your videos are. And they look more and more professional every time. Keep up the good work!
Nothing about this was fact based lol. I couldn’t count on two hands the amount of historical revisionism and bias in this video
Close enough, welcome back oversimplified
No its not 😢they are not funny
Close enough welcome back Oversimplified
I miss it😢
You want a person who really understands this conflict, his UA-cam channel the easy way
I came for historical accuracy, but stayed for the quality animation
The new animation style is really good!
This is the best simplification of Zionism I have heard.
I’m so happy that I’ve been finding rational, honest, unbiased sources of information on this conflict lately. I’ve been searching since 7. October, as I refused to speak on the topic until I fully understood the nuance. It is not easy finding unbiased information on this subject, even websites and books. I hate that the extremist channels spreading false history and religious narratives are the channels getting millions of views and subscribers. Channels like yours are the channels I will help to promote. ❤
Dude this is biased af. Are we watching the same video?
@@shnubblebitts6193she meant to say “I was specifically researching and looking for a narrative that boost my own agenda and belief. I’m amazing, I’m smart and awesome! Thanks for confirming that.”
@@MoonlightSonata160 exactly lmao. I kinda feel bad for oversimplified with such an awful dude copying him.
@@MoonlightSonata160 Please tell me the be parts that were not factual. I already said that I’m looking for the objective truth, and when you’re coming from a position of knowing nothing about the subject, as I was, it’s very hard to tell which sources are biased and which aren’t. If I’ve come across slanted information, please tell me what was incorrect so I can do more research and correct my acquired biases, rather than trying to insult me. Contrary to what you assume, I don’t think I’m any smarter than the average person. I do think I’m more honest, and not nearly as ego driven, so your attempt at hurting my feelings hasn’t worked.
Thank you for at least recognizing that I’m a woman. I’ve noticed that people who reply to women on UA-cam will automatically assume they’re talking to a man, unless the comment explicitly states otherwise.
@@shnubblebitts6193 Unless by some miracle, this link led to one video for you, and a separate video for me, I’d have to say we watched the same video. Please tell me what you believe was inaccurate or biased.
Almost thought you were oversimplified😂
I'll watch your videos until he drops part 3
" if i don't steal it ..someone else will ! " Jakob the Manhattan Jew
Guess you pissed the part about the JNF where it was legally purchased
13:12 ERROR HERE: the building with a golden dome is NOT the mosque. Everyone gets this wrong… the important mosque is a less imposing building near it, the thing with the gold on top (which is not actually gold by the way) is a just a shrine, and not the holy thing
It s not a shrine bitsh
Just a shrine?? 😂 it's holy as well why they built a dome in ur opinion
We build domes in our holy places if u didn't notice
@@AjejeB you will lose israel because of that dome
@@mesoiq I don’t question how important the golden building may be, but as far as I understand the building with the golden dome is not the one that is the third most important site for the religion, that one is another building (without gold) a few yards away, and lots of people confuse it with the golden one. Am I wrong?
@@AjejeB yeah true true
The video infers that Palestine was an Islamic place prior to the creation of the Jewish state. The Jews and Muslims lived in Palestine since the Romans
Since the Romans ???
Muslims didn’t exist during Roman times …….
Your misinforming Muslims only existed after Christian’s which is like 700 years later
Arabs came a lot later then Rome
Islamic is created in 610 ad ALMOST 200 YEARS AFTER THE WESTERN ROMAN EMPIRE FELL
Just 2 words - Free Palestine
Saying free palestine on youtube wont free palestine dude
@@Crashed_Byteit creates awareness like I’ve seen people start asking about it. Talking about something gains attention like that’s how trends start
@Moshmushh this comment has 16 likes ... 16 people are aware now that Palestine should be free? Read this sentence again. It's stupid
@@ekakshhanda2493 Those who seen it liked it and those who didn't liked it commented like you.
@@Crashed_Byteit shows support free palestine
I just got off warthunder and this is the first thing i see 59 seconds
Bro boutta be racism coated + 🙏
Ditto... but warthunder mobile
@@achour.falestinewtf, what connects war thunder and racism?
@@Parciwal_Gaming the community
@@Parciwal_Gaming heres a little game type the letter N in chat and watch the show
I've read 2 history Israeli books
3 palastineans history books
Like 30 random history articles
The full united nations history report of palastine between 1917
And i can tell you this video can be summarized into one word: facts
Far from it. More like "only the facts that support my narrative covered with negative opinions against the Jews"
Most the books I read abt the holocaust and their story had them talking about Palestine and moving there using the word Palestine. So they knew people still lived there and most the authors disagreed with the Zionism
I mean 3 minutes into the video and it's already wrong in the 1900s the idea of Jewish state was only brought up essentially never it was stated they wanted to take the land from the people who were tbh not there also there are no native people from palestine the place was called by the romes when they conquered kingdom of judea the "Palestinian people" are in reality settlers that most of them came in between 1915 to 1926 there was huge migration into that land to proof that there was a french journalist who visited the land in 1852 and said he saw nothing in the land from left to right basically no people no nothing Jerusalem and the golden heights were the only populated places at that time and you can guess who were in Jerusalem it were the jews
@@yanyannolife326 not true take a look at DNA on palestinians. its all israelites. the original jews all got converted or just don't live there anymore. most moved because they werent making profit from the land
@@yanyannolife326 seriously
I personally know 6 people who had who had records of there great grandparents from the 1850s
I spent alot of time verifying this
And each got an average of 10 kids
Each of those got an average of 7 kids and those now have kids
It's called population growth not by settlements and migration infact I would bet that between 1800 and 1930 more Palestines lift to other countries then the other way around
And for those who say "well gaza population is increasing since 1948 "
I will ask of them to search a simple thing
How many people were forced Into gaza since 1948 by is not ral
This Is a great explanation video!!!
Great job mate
2:56 wow my idea actually made it in the video :D
Nice
Excellent video.. I see it as accurate as it needed to be thanks for the hard work
Yall better enjoy this before it gets taken down
Same thing for part 2
Amazing well researched video bro, keep it up !!!
YOU EARNED A SUBSCRIBER , that was really good! quality content always wins
I really want to thank you for all this effort, and most importantly, telling the truth, unlike most channels that support the occupation.
What occupation Israelis own that land and it belongs to the Jews the “ native “ Palestines colonised and killed anyone who was Jewish after ottomans conquest
This is absolutely not the truth. It's the Palestinians narrative. Many of the "facts" are completely false
@@zvistachEven david ben-gurion admitted that zionists started the conflict.
It's very simple
European jews wanted to colonize palestina.
According to zionist historian Benny Morris, zionists chose to accept the 1937 partition plan, so they could eventually takeover all of Palestine
Excellent research. So nice to see a truly factual video. Thank you.
🇺🇦🐾🦘🐨🦘🐾🇵🇸
Pro israel
Close enough, welcome back, Oversimplified.
No it's not😢
It's not funny😢
Wow my dad was born in teera,haifa 1945 he told me all kinds of stories about what happened there and i was surprised that you mentioned the tying to convoys , thanks for this video btw my ancestors lived in palestine for 560 years i hope some day i can return ❤️
Is he a palestinien ?
@@Hassan-i7h yes we live in jordan now and i was born in jordan
@@abu7seen797 🇵🇸❤️❤️
@@Hassan-i7h ❤️❤️
This is an incredibly complex topic. Unfortunately, this video does not analyze this historical event from a neutral standpoint.
There are a bunch of statements that are not sourced because they are opinions, unfortunately. These opinions are stated as truths. A neutral analysis does not work this way.
I will show below the timestams when opinions or false information is stated as truths.
'There was no Jewish or British plan to expel Arabs from the proposed Jewish state' 20:05
'Not just people but Jews were hiring Jews. Also Arabs were hiring Arabs. That's not a big surprise. Although it is made to sound as if the British imposed segregation laws, which I could not find.' 16:38
'Well, it is the author's personal opinion to state that zionism is a colonial project.There are plenty of reasons why this can not be true.' 9:56
'While it is true that the British gave military assistance to the Palmach forces of the Haganah in 1942. It is not mentioned, however, that the British stopped doing so in 1943 and attempted to disarm the Haganah. Making it sound as if the British played the main role in building the Haganah.' 24:58
Let's also not forget things that were not included in this video, which could explain things that seemed a bit sketchy.
For example, the Jewish bitterness towards the British was not simply about restricting Jewish imagination. Jewish refugees during WW2 that fleed to the british mandate were intercepted by the royal navy and placed in concentration camps in Cyrus.
If it was mentioned what actually happened to Jewish refugees who tried to enter the British mandate, Lehi's sentiment would have made some logic.
finally someone said it, thank you.
@@shay-kg7ksYour welcome. It's important to expose such things early on before it is treated as factual.
nice comment
@@teze2284Thank you
Let’s say you’re 100% right. What does this have to do with what the Jews are doing to these people ?
Let's download this video before it's taken down by youtube. Then later we can reupload and spread this history forever! Everyone need to know the truth.
Amazing, best explanation I've ever seen 👏🏻
I got the popcorn for the comment section, who brought the drinks?
Bro used the wrong eagle to inpersonate austria. Before n4z1s there was no broken chain at the claws. After ww2 austrias eagle had them to show they finally are free again
the guy skipped 1929 hebron and safed pogrom(against 2 unarmed ,non zionist religious communities) and said 1921 riots were over a cloth in a muslim "religious site" -it wasnt in al aqsa but in the western wall,place that was never holy for the muslims. history is not his strong side
Ive seen more comments about how controversial the comment section will be than actual controversial comments 😂
Commenting for algorithm
Absolutely true vid. You just gained a sub.
my popcorn is ready.
THERE WAS AND WILL NEVER BE ISRAEL! FREE PALESTINE!
Why? What's wrong with the Jews having a country they earned through purchase and defensive wars?
Maybe the Palestinians should assimilate or migrate.
@muntTV not all the land purchased.
Zeev Jabotinsky said in 1921: "I don't know of a single example in history where a country was colonised with the courteous consent of the population".
Palestine has also been seen in europe so why dont they move there because the term Palestine was created by the romans which kinda means jewish land
We Palestinians don’t have to argue with racist westerners in a UA-cam comment section to prove our national identity.
Our country is our right and it is our right under international law to bear arms and resist the colonizers.
So raping and murdering innocents is resistance? Nah mate look what it caused 30 thousand Palestinians dead. Lay down your arms accept the jewish state and you'll get your own country in gaza and the west bank.
So get out you colonizers.
When abu bakr first entered Jerusalem he mentioned Jews in that land, while there still no Arabs there. All in thr last 3000 years, the Jews persist to present there. So logically its their land and u lot are occupiers.
No . Learn about the Arab conquest before talking
@@ahmadaltaher1524 lol, you Arabs are conguerors and colonizer of that land, return to ur ancestral land, lat the Jews back to their ancestral land as well
Wrong. You MIGHT have some rights to some of the disputed territories. Israel belongs to the Israelis. They built a country out of pretty much NOTHING. Palestinian Arabs are brainwashed by their disgusting murderous leaders that Israel actually belongs to them. Go for peace like decent humans and perhaps you'll have a state.
Amazing that this has not been deleted by our overlords
Free Palestine! No matter what, genocide is illegal.
Yes how dare Palestinians attack Israelis no matter their race, religion, or sex unprovoked while the west bank is just chilling
@@sirblank2384West Bank isn’t chilling it’s just silent. Search up the countless raids of the mosques every year in Gaza and the West Bank.
@Moshmushh they are not being attacked or bombed because they dont choose violence its plain and simple
@@sirblank2384 they are being attacked . are you an israeli? west bank recieves raids of their mosque every year for absolutely no reason. search it up
@@sirblank2384anti semitic alert
Hey so first of all love the new animation looks great now that you have your definite style great work. Also I have been getting replies on some comments I put on your videos and other commenters that say you’re spreading misinformation this happened during your Korean War two parter I love your channel don’t get me wrong but I worry that I’m spreading misinformation.
You should ALWAYS fact-check what anyone says! Whether it is me or other people. Use my videos as a starting point to learn more about all these topics! And never share information without checking it first. With that, you can rest assured you won't be spreading misinfo
@@ThingsICareAbout okay thanks I will view it like that and try to research it more in the way you suggest I’m sorry to trouble you with this it’s just been looming on my mind recently.
@@ThingsICareAbout i see in the comment that saying youre too biased to Palestinian, so i want to check your sources please
Mostly what he mentioned was actually true. If you want more details you can go to wiki or read the book about Palestine like the ethnic cleansing of Palestine by ilan peppe@@haikalmaulanapasha4676
@@haikalmaulanapasha4676the only ones saying he's biased towards Palestinians are zionists and most likely Israelis. It's like Americans saying that America isn't racist. You pretty much already know which groups of Americans would say that America isn't racist.
If you have a majority group facilitate the relations of two marginalized communities, it never ends well.
Especially if the major group was the reason the smaller ones were marginalized.
Fun fact:
Jordan was also used to be part of British Mandatory of Palestine. 1 year before the creation of the State of Israel, Transjordan had already declared independence.
Yeah, finally someone with common sense talking.
This narrator is very pro paliestinian
Was Britain also in Jordan?
20th Century British “Try not to Ruin Everything Challenge (Impossible)”:
21st century British - "hold my beer"..
Thank you for the informative video.
Bro even got the oversimplified background music💀
@@Goated_Trav I mean it is inspired by him
I appreciate this amount of Simplified...not too much under or Over.
This new animation is amazing
1:17 The ideas of Zionism predate Zionism by thousands of years
Yes, during the crusades
And even the Babylonian Exile where Jewish elites were allowed to return to the land by the Persian Emperor Cyrus the Great
Zionism is Asur אסור (Forbidden) for jews because The Moshia מושיע (savior/christus) is not come yet,
Israel is a secular/atheis country
Was watching over simplified and then this popped up noticeed a voice change and listened for awhile and now we are here
free palestine
And what does that mean? What's your idea of a free Palestine?
@@freddiemedley5580a land where the Palestinians are independent
Excellent video. props
As an Israeli Im glad that for once we can agree that the British are to blame
@@smilebro9999 next time please write "Palestinian" correctly please.
@@smilebro9999 I understand what you mean, doesn't mean I agree with it.
Arab and jew what comes to my mind is i think there should be more that we are agreeing.
I my self as a strict Muslim think that the Jews think that somehow we hate them because they are Jews.
As an Arab I am proud of my brother the children of ishaq AS the intelligent one in our family.
Don't you think that we could live together under one flag the flag of our father Ibrahim AS.
But i don't know how you all are Brain washed and you come over our house and stealing it even the Torah doses not allow it.
I am not saying it's you as individual jew
But the fact it's out of ordinary jew who follows Torah and Adonai commands it means someone really out of the boundary of this ibrahimic family is controlling things?
Who do you think that is ?
@@smilebro9999 it was literally said in the video that most of the arabs in that region didnt own the land that their houses stood apon.
How is it Britain's fault that the Israeli's got fucking greedy and decided to displace hundreds of thousands of Palestinians? 🤔
This channel is Oversimplified with an accent… and half the budget
Imagine a video calling ppl out for being racist while depicting the Irish people as leprechauns. It’s tragically delicious
Finally something did what oversimplified didn’t not dare to do. Chicken!!!
Free Palestine ✊🏽✊🏽✊🏽✊🏽✊🏽
Free jews for like 3 000 years of bad life (like how the heck has Jews always been treated so bad, Egypt, Europeans, NAZIS, Muslims)
Am sorry bro but you need a fact check. alot of what you presented is a twisted version of the truth or missing (out of context). For example Jewish ownership of Palestinian land by purchase never reached more than 10% all the rest was taken by force amongst others
Look around the sources he took from
All of those is most anti israel sources lmao
This video is BIG one sided
@@Shut_UpOnly from Ilan Pappé. The most factual historian alive.
(I'm completely sarcastic ofcourse.)
How about the simple fact that it shouldn't have happened in the first place? But one thing is true in every context, everywhere caucasians go. Death and destruction follow. They can't escape that. At first, it starts with the spreading of their Lord, Jesus Christ, with Christian or Catholic pilgrims. Then, traders, diplomats last it's the military No matter who they are, where they come from, their M.O. is the same. Conquer and expand No matter if they're European, German Irish, Russian, French, or American. In the modern day, you know them as the U.N. Which broke off and created its own subset. But this is nothing more than a ploy to capture Earth's natural resources for the wealthy. They have a subset within their own ranks to determine. Who is more worthy and pure from within the Caucasian ranks. What makes this more sad is the fact that all these other races, that are not Caucasian think they have a place at this table. And they don't. they use the people of these other countries. To gather up their natural resources and distribute them to other Caucasian nations so that they can become rich. While leaving the country that they got said riches from people broke in desolate, and this is, after they divided up the land and it's people between other Caucasian nations. And that's just the abridged version. Still factually, right.
great video. slight problem Alaqsa mosque is not the golden rock it's actually behind it. common confution. hope if more vids on this topic comes you will fix it. 😊
bro gives me Oversimplified vibes
and I love it
All i can say is thank You things i care about , people take for granted the impact colonialism and racism had on the events that led to WWI &II , the subjugation of the palestinian people and the creation of the state of Isreal....
I like the animation and all. Great Work! But I feel like your videos are a bit biased. This one was no exception. If being biased was never the intention, I highly recommend you do more research into topics like the Israel-Palestine conflict before uploading anything including part 2. It will take a little longer, but trust me it'll be worth it. You will likely get attacked by both sides, but that's a sign you've made improvement. And also a sign humans are idiotic creatures when someone disagrees with them.
Can you point out the biased part? I am curious
@@raihanaji7516 Watch his Korean War videos very closely and then do your own research on what he goes on about. That's all I can say.
@@CelticChu okay I will do that but, since I am usually a person who tends to miss some details, I would glady appreciate it if you point it out for me if you can. Thanks for your reply though.
Sorry for the high burden
Believe me I barely watch any videos about Israeli and Palestine conflicts the comments in those videos spew crap that’s not even in history
They weren’t called the Palestinians even in old Arab league document at a time it was known as northern Syria
What do you mean by northern syria? Are you serious? Palestine is south of syria and no they didnt, the land was called palestine for a long time and the people there started calling themselves palestinians even before the british came.
Literally read a book from 1940s and it mentioned Palestine multiple times