Bahco Laplander vs Silky Gomboy
Вставка
- Опубліковано 20 лип 2024
- A Bahco Laplander vs Silky Gomboy folding saw comparison. Both Bahco Laplander and Silky Gomboy are great folding saw options for the solo backpacker. So, come along with me on this folding saw comparison of the Bahco Laplander vs Silky Gomboy.
Video Timeline
00:00 - Intro
00:11 - Grip Profile
00:24 - Bahco Laplander Dead Limb Cut
00:46 - Silky Gomboy Dead Limb Cut
00:58 - Size and Blade Comparison
01:21 - Silky Gomboy vs Bahco Laplander Cutting
01:43 - Handle Comparison
01:52 - Silky Gomboy Large Diameter Cutting
02:19 - Bahco Laplander Green Limb Cut
03:08 - Silky Gomboy Green Limb Cut
04:02 - Locking Blade Comparison
04:28 - Striking Ferrocerium Rod Comparison
04:56 - Final Opinion
I provide content on camping, hiking, backpacking, bushcraft, leathercraft and miscellaneous outdoor activities. All the videos for this channel are shot outdoors.
▶ Subscribe: / @johnmillwoodoutdoors
▶ Instagram: / johnmillwoodoutdoors
The Silky came with a plastic sheath that is not shown in the video. I didn't like it because the saw rattles too much. I'll make a leather sheath. I hope you enjoy the video!
I have both but never carry the bahco any more. The blade design on the silky makes it so much more efficient. I have not had a problem with the silky opening in my pack. Thanks for the review!
The Silky cuts much better than the Bahco. I'll probably make a leather sheath for the Silky. That plastic sheath that came with it rattles too much. Thanks for watching and leaving a comment. I really appreciate it!
Good video. One thing that should be noted is that the Silky is designed to only cut on the pull stroke. Once I learned this and adjusted my sawing rhythm, I was able to cut through logs like butter without getting fatigued. I love my Gomboy. Looking forward to your next video.
Yes, you are right, it cuts on the pull. I did not mention that. The Gomboy is a fantastic saw. It can really chew up the wood. Thanks for watching and commenting. I hope to see you on the next one.
The Silky is a pruning saw for a nice relaxed sunny day in your garden. You can get different blades for different type of woods. Make a mistake and the blade snaps. The Bahco is more 'survival' orientated. One saw that does it all (even bone) in all circumstances. It will bend but not break.
Thanks for writing that information about the blade.
I have both of these saws. If I'm going to backpack a trail for a few days, I take the Silky. It processes firewood better. But for bush crafting, I like the Bahco, just because it's not as an aggressive cut. It just makes it a little easier for when you're trying to make things.
Thanks for taking the time to comment. Currently, I have the Silky in my pack, but I like the feel of the Bahco in my hand better than the Silky. Both of these saws get the job done for the tasks I do.
I've packed silkys of various lengths for 10 years. Never had a problem with them coming open when I didn't want them to. I learned cabinet making from my grandpa who always used Japanese pull saws. The silky feels natural and intuitive to use. Guess it comes down to preference. Both saws are superior to just about any other folder on the market.
Love your attitude and videos, please make more content.
Thanks for watching my videos! I will have another video out in the next couple of weeks. I'm trying to stay ahead on filming.
I LOVE YOUR REVIEWS…THE BEST IN DEPTH REVIEWS ON CAMPING GEAR ON UA-cam 👍 KEEP UP YOUR GREAT WORK 👍
Wow, thanks for that comment. I like being in the woods with gear. Thanks for watching! I hope to see you on the next one.
I carry the BigBoy 2000 or the F180 depending on the trip. Love Silky!!!
The Silky chews it up and spits it out. I really like the way it cuts. Good to hear from you! Thanks for commenting.
Great review thx for doing that for us
I'm glad you enjoyed the video. Thanks for watching and commenting!
Goood video John. You certainly have endurance. One of those cuts took a long time. I have a knock off Silky called a Gonic. Cuts good though! Good to you again. I think you have a great channel!
Thanks for commenting. That green cut got me breathing some. The Silky cuts great. The Bahco feels better in my hand. I like both saws and will be using both. Thanks for watching! I hope to see you on the next one.
Nice review, but it's fair to note that there is also a curved blade and handle version of the Gomboy. Both versions come with a nice case, although I've never been concerned about my straight Gomboy opening in my pocket or pack (I only own the straight). Silky also makes a more aggressive coarse blade for the Gomboy. The coarse blade is marketed as superior on dry wood, and the medium blade (on the one demonstrated in your video) is superior on damp wood. I can attest to the latter having used my Gomboy on a weekend backpacking trip a couple of days ago in freezing rain and wet snow. Would you consider a follow-up video comparing the Bacho and a few versions of blades on the Gomboy in both wet and dry conditions, thanks?
Thanks for adding more information about the Gomboy. I will be glad to do a follow up using different blades and weather conditions. I really do appreciate you watching and making suggestions!
Gomboy all day long! Great review 👍🏼
Thanks for watching and commenting!
Good video. Good review. God bless. From Glenn CATT in Massachusetts.
Thanks for watching and commenting Jennifer. I hope you enjoy the channel. God bless you too.
Thanks for putting this out there. Question for you…did the silky blade seem brittle to you? I’ve heard word of broken blades. The extra speed pales in comparison to a broken blade….curious of your impression.
Silky for weekends and fast. Bahco for Expeditions its gorilla proof and locks without anything extra to carry.
Thanks for posting a comment and watching my video.
Great video! What size gomboy are you using? And is it medium teeth or large? Thanks!
It's 210 mm with medium teeth. I like the way it cuts. A very good folding saw. I'm glad you enjoyed the video and found some value in watching. Thank you!
If the unsecured blade is the only downside, then a ranger band would fix that up pretty well.
I have some ranger bands. That's a great idea. I do like how the Silky cuts. You can't go wrong with this saw. Thanks for the comment. I really do appreciate it!
Good overview but you didn't mention that the Silky is just about twice the price. At least, it is in my country.
Good point. The Silky is more expensive.
hey is that a gomboy 210-10?
I have just two comments:
Why do you feel that the bade MUST be locked when it's folded? If you put the Silky into your pack tip first how will it open inside the pack? It certainly won't on taking it out. So, what's the problem?
Secondly, watching the sawing action, it is quite clear that the user is not using the approved technique for a Silky. As it is a pull stoke only tool, one should only apply pressure on the pull (cutting) stroke, and the release pressure on the return (push) stroke. This requires a slower more deliberate action. Also, the correct action will require far less energy expenditure, and allow some rest between cutting strokes. Even so, the Silky almost always outcuts the Bahco. Of course the Bahco needs no special skill to use, and is a very strong tool. The Silky is designed mainly for professional arborists and tree surgeons, but have become very popular for campers, outdoors folk, etc.
Note: the popular misconception is that Silky blade snap when being used. This is not true. People who use the wrong technique (as they would with a Bahco) sometimes do break blades. That's different from the blade breaking! It is a user problem, not a blade problem!
Thank you for taking the time to leave a comment and watching the video. I appreciate it.
cutting about the same.
Problem is with this comparison apples with oranges
Silky blade is a pruning wood saw blade it cuts wood ,wood and wood
The bahco is a hard point saw blade which cuts wood,
bone and plastic.
To get an apples with apples comparison
Compare a silky pruning blade with a bahco 396 jt pruning blade that only cuts wood ,wood and wood then you have a believable,factual comparison 😮 oh my why, why didnt you think if that
Because people learn from youtube videos and bushcraft UA-cam channels have just heard of "the Laplander", and it didn't occur to them that bacho has been making all sorts of saw blades for many decades.
But to that point, when camping, perhaps a woodsaw makes more sense? Do people need to cut bone and such hard materials all that often? Perhaps some old dry wood reclaimed from wooden buildings and such can pose a challenge, I don't know.
@pgpagaia you haven't replied why you still mistakenly compare a hard point laplander hard point saw with a silky pruning blade saw to the newbees as both brands are well known 🤔 tell the viewers as it as it is so why don't you compare a silky pruning saw with a bacho pruning saw blade,along with the laplander whats difficult about that bro telling viewers the fact's not misinformation
@@JohnT-wj5ru oh, I agree with you. I was being snarky. I am NOT the author or the video. I don't think the comparisons makes sense because they are of two different kinds.
But I guess the question that matters is: which kind is more useful for most people? I don't know... Cutting quick without using much energy is a great advantage. But then a dry piece of hardwood needs to be cut...
a good saw is not the one that cuts faster or better.
its the one most reliable and the silkys blade is to fragile it will break sooner or later (probably when need the most - believe me i've been there).
bahcos blade is flexible and won't snap if bent
i own Pocketboy, Gomboy and Corona. all three have the same blade that will snap if snagged. (and it will)
i carry and use the bahco and (pocketboy as secondary - still not used)
besides for the price of the silky gomboy you can buy 2 bahcos (2 is 1)
so in short :
silky cuts great but will break!!
Bahco Will Be there when needed
just my personal thought - good luck on your decision
I've used the Bahco for years and like that saw. The Silky is not bad, but I haven't abused it yet. Thanks for the information, it is helpful. I favor the Bahco because it feels better in my hand. Recently though, I've been packing the Silky.