The CONTROVERSIAL Success of Lata Mangeshkar

Поділитися
Вставка

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,7 тис.

  • @vedantrusty
    @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +179

    Who is your fav female singer, and why?
    Also like the video, it really helps the channel out!

    • @itn0687
      @itn0687 6 місяців тому +18

      Ks chitra, alka yagnik, kavita krishnamurthy, shreya ghoshal, sunidhi

    • @amvmoon777
      @amvmoon777 6 місяців тому +11

      Lata ji, Alka yagnik, sherya ghoshal ,falguni pathak . Because I love there voice and versatility and personality. Who is your fav female singer ?

    • @bigbulk688
      @bigbulk688 6 місяців тому +10

      Prologue is 4 mins long. By the time I lost patience. Sorry dude, this is just completely nonsense format.

    • @os4879
      @os4879 6 місяців тому +8

      Lata Ji Geeta Dutt Ji and Asha ji.
      Do make a vedio on Guru Dutt Ji and Geeta Dutt ji

    • @rockstarby21
      @rockstarby21 6 місяців тому +4

      jonita gandhi and palak muchhal, shilpa rao, shreya ghoshal(for songs like bhalobashar morshum and chal rastaye saji tram line) note:I cannot tolerate shrill or sharp voices💀💀💀💀🤌

  • @shrinidhijoshi595
    @shrinidhijoshi595 6 місяців тому +1065

    I think you should edit the thumbnail a bit. It is a little misleading. The video is actually nice but thumbnail is like controversial
    Edit: I know what clickbait is, you can just add a question mark in the front of the bully, it still works.

    • @manasuniyal2897
      @manasuniyal2897 6 місяців тому +68

      Views ka chakkar hai BABAU BHAIYA . Content ki kami ki vajah se ye sab hota hai .

    • @ungnomeuser9624
      @ungnomeuser9624 6 місяців тому +1

      🤓

    • @rahulas8653
      @rahulas8653 6 місяців тому +8

      clickbait!

    • @musicpanditmoodle
      @musicpanditmoodle 6 місяців тому +7

      That's how marketing works :)

    • @vaibhavsingh8122
      @vaibhavsingh8122 6 місяців тому +9

      It's intentional, you probably would have never clicked on it, i certainly wouldn't

  • @prajwaldabbu
    @prajwaldabbu 6 місяців тому +146

    In video, it's been said she's not classically trained. But she was classically trained by her Father as her first guru and then when she moved to mumbai, she started taking further lessons in classical music from Ustad Aman Ali Khan of Bhendibazaar gharana. What she regretted was not pursuing a full fledged career in classical.

    • @manasuniyal2897
      @manasuniyal2897 6 місяців тому +12

      She started learning music since she was 6 . Kishore Kumar himself said in his interview that she was very skilled classical singer and he was not .

    • @prajwaldabbu
      @prajwaldabbu 6 місяців тому

      @@manasuniyal2897 Yes

    • @debjanibaisya7339
      @debjanibaisya7339 4 місяці тому

      This youtuber is such a jackass must say. Anything to garner likes and subscribers

    • @SingNostalgiaWithAmogh
      @SingNostalgiaWithAmogh 2 місяці тому

      ​@@prajwaldabbu
      Why do you even follow half cooked yt fake spreaders ☹️😊
      Always read books or authorized better reference pages on net for any knowledge, usually quora is the best ✌️☺️

  • @nevereverigoteyesonyou8377
    @nevereverigoteyesonyou8377 6 місяців тому +780

    1) i feel she knew her worth and asked for whatever she deserved in male dominated industry back then..... She was outspoken and aware of the love public had for her..... So obviously male composers must have been bitter about it..... But how is it her fault that movie producers wanted only her to sing for their movies???
    2) i understand the frustration of her female compititors and its surprising how no one questiones when kishore kumar, udit narayan, arijit were/are dominating the industry
    3) personally, i like Asha's voice and songs more so would have appreciated if there was variety in female playback singers during that era

    • @RajveerSingha1950
      @RajveerSingha1950 6 місяців тому

      You mean, she isn't a good woman (or rather a shady woman).

    • @vikashkumar5807
      @vikashkumar5807 6 місяців тому +40

      Even when Arijit Singh is dominating industry with so many songs, there are so many other singers too who gets good songs works hard. There are so many times it happened that, Arijit Singh himself sent directors to other singers, saying they can sing better than him.

    • @sushmitatiwari1307
      @sushmitatiwari1307 6 місяців тому +47

      ​@@vikashkumar5807even Lataji did that. She left so many songs due to lack of time and the style of the song that she thought others would sing better. And even in her era there were many other renowned singers too so?

    • @vikashkumar5807
      @vikashkumar5807 6 місяців тому +11

      @@sushmitatiwari1307 I wasn't comparing Lata ji with Arijit Singh. I have also said that he is dominating the industry but I was just saying that he don't do it forcibly or by politics. He respects the art and other artists.

    • @sushmitatiwari1307
      @sushmitatiwari1307 6 місяців тому +1

      @@vikashkumar5807 so does she doesn't she?

  • @vijaysingh-zz6cf
    @vijaysingh-zz6cf 6 місяців тому +673

    Apart from all the controversies her "Mere Vatan Ke Logo" is something which is out of this world🙌🙌

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +49

      100% true

    • @asianguy86
      @asianguy86 6 місяців тому +8

      Suman bahut achchi singer thi uska career barbad kr diya is lata ne 😢

    • @crazyadi6422
      @crazyadi6422 6 місяців тому +14

      To usko bolo khud ke style me kyu nhi gaya😂😂 sirf lata ki copy krti thi​@@asianguy86

    • @SudarshansMusicalworld
      @SudarshansMusicalworld 6 місяців тому +1

      That song was also selected for Asha Bhosale,but she cheated towards her own sister.

    • @asianguy86
      @asianguy86 6 місяців тому +2

      @@crazyadi6422 lata ki copy krti thi 🤦
      Taau sare lata ke fans ywhi nautanki karenge
      Lata se kai achchi singers thi in reality
      Suman aur anuradha ke sath jo bhosle mangeskar sisters ne kraa vph saff dikhta hain aise kao singers ko mauka nhi milna nhi diyaa

  • @Shivani-kw9kx
    @Shivani-kw9kx 6 місяців тому +473

    It was the fault of Directors, producers who wanted same kind of music and voice for their movies. We know that Lata Mangeshkar is legend with having melodius voice. But if there would have been diversities of melody then it would have been more beautiful to know about different different kind of voices and their uniqueness, their abilities like We see today

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +31

      sure

    • @udaybaviskar2422
      @udaybaviskar2422 6 місяців тому +19

      Everybody sang in that era...People loved and responded favorably to all good singers...Who did not get work...Suman, Hemlata, Vani, Anuradha, Runa Laila, nazia hassan etc etc etc.. all have songs recorded. But problem with them was that all wanted equal share or same position as Lata.. they were jealous of her supremacy....None of the abovementioned singers had that independent ability to make their songs hit for long or replace Lata.. Raj kapoor did experiments with other singers but did not work out.. What can Lata do for this...😁😁

    • @Shivani-kw9kx
      @Shivani-kw9kx 6 місяців тому +1

      @@udaybaviskar2422 i don't think so because Anuraadha and Suman Kalyanpur were doing so good... And i think they could have sung in better voice than Lata ji because They have young melodious voice but they didn't get any opportunity because of directors producers who wanted same voice for their movies... Everyone had unique voice but directors always wanted other singers to sing in Lata ji 's voice so their own unique voice kept hidden... Saat Samundar paar song was sung by other singer not lata ji still it got famous...

    • @udaybaviskar2422
      @udaybaviskar2422 6 місяців тому +14

      @@Shivani-kw9kx It is easy to cry victim and gain sympathy.. All have got bharooor opportunity and have sung good number of songs😀. But they have limitations in many ways.. they dont sound great nor creat the effect what Lata did!!
      After hearing Latas voice and gayaki ears dont agree with anybody else or anything less..

    • @NDver10
      @NDver10 6 місяців тому +1

      Exactly, same as Arijit Singh

  • @kamiltisekar259
    @kamiltisekar259 6 місяців тому +133

    Royalty is the correct issue.
    Singer must get royalty.

  • @Odyvers
    @Odyvers 6 місяців тому +54

    You can't underestimate her voice her voice is actually unique and skills

  • @duraiselvam
    @duraiselvam 6 місяців тому +371

    Until A.R. Rahman came and introduced a lot of singers to the industry, music directors were just repeating one or two singers for every era. Our people had such formulaic, herd mentality. The 50s, 60s and even the 70s predominantly belonged to Lata and Asha and that too Lata was reserved for the heroines and Asha for dance numbers. The 80s and 90s saw the likes of Anuradha Paudwal, Sadhana Sargam and Alka Yagnik sing for the leading ladies. Poornima and Hema Sardesai got very few songs, thanks to Anu Malik who thought a bit out of the box at least. The 2000s and 10s still had Sunidhi Chowhan and Shreya Ghoshal in the lead, but thankfully, the music industry turned into an even playing field in more recent years with innumerable number of singers getting opportunities to show case their talent, thanks to Rahman and Sanjay Leela Bhansali.

    • @drfeelgood7886
      @drfeelgood7886 6 місяців тому +24

      Now it’s Arijit n Arijit clones ? 😂

    • @hello.667
      @hello.667 6 місяців тому +37

      ​​@@drfeelgood7886 Arijit is only singing 1 or no song in movies. He has 1 song in Animal and no song in sam bahadur .Other songs are sung by other singers.
      While an old singer used to sing all 8-10 songs alone. That's why Lata Mangeshkar has 30000 songs, Mohammed Rafi sung 10000 songs, Kumar Sanu sang 5000 songs. But Arijit has only sung less than 900 songs in past 14 years.
      Arijit has now become more selectivve. He is just singing 2-3 songs in a month because now he is selecting best compositions with best lyrics like vida karo, terr hawaale, moh na laage.
      Talking about Arijit's clones , it is not his problem. There are many Kishore Kumar and Lata Mangeshkar clones available too.
      Kishore Kumar clones - Kumar Sanu ,Amit Kumar, Abhijeet Bhattacharya
      Lata Mangeshkar clones - Alka Yagnik, Suman Kalyanpur, Sadhana Sargam.
      Many Arijit's clones have slightly similar vocal texture but they can't copy his vocal abilties. For example , Darshan Raval has little similar vocal texture but he can't sing classical and all types of songs like Arijit. Darshan can't sing binte dil song of Arijit. I am not hating on Darshan .I am only writing truth.
      Popularity of Arijit in 21th century is like Kishore Kumar was in 20th century. That's why both singers have some clones.
      Fun fact : Arijit was born in 1987 i.e. the same year in which Kishore Kumar died.
      Only one reason why some buddhas have problem with Arijit : Because he is a singer of this generation who is better and more successful than most singers of their old generation . They can't get nostalgia after listening him because he is not their childhood singer. Ego of buddhas get hurt whenever they hear the name of Arijit.

    • @hello.667
      @hello.667 6 місяців тому +15

      True. There were monopoly among singers in old times. There was no internet so people didn't knew about many talented artists. Only connections with bollywood people were mattered in old times.
      We all know about monopoly of Kumar Sanu in 90's. By singing same type of simple flat slow repetitive romantic songs and copying Kishore Kumar from nose, he became the king of 90's music and continously won 5 filmfare awards. He sang 28 songs in 1 day due to monopoly in music industry in 90's. Has this so called melody king has sung anything other than 'hey hey la la' in his whole career?
      If internet was available at that time, then Kishore Kumar and Kumar Sanu also would have got many negative comments like Arijit. The problem with Arijit that he is unnecessarily hated by some haraami nostalgia merchants due to availability of social media. Different people have different opinions now on popular artists. Now anybody can talk about popular artists while sitting from their home.

    • @drfeelgood7886
      @drfeelgood7886 6 місяців тому +13

      @@hello.667 buddy i can understand you’re a Arijit fan bouy. But by saying Arijit’s name I don’t mean he’s singing in every film or doing 10 songs a film. Obviously you cannot compare with yesteryear’s musicians/film stars.
      But you’ll see in most of the big budget films there’ll be an Arijit number with formulated music tune which has a greater probability of becoming a hit. Music directors/ producers either want Arijit or Arijit sounding clones. These are not my words, there are plenty interviews by senior musicians on YT.
      Despite so many fans, in last few years we barely got to hear Late KK, Shaan, Sonu Nigam , Kunal Ganjawala, Mohit Chauhan. It’s not a rocket science to understand, more than art / faith in the artist, producers n record labels are following the market trajectories n economics. 😛

    • @hello.667
      @hello.667 6 місяців тому +2

      ​@@drfeelgood7886 I can see you are an egoistic ghamandi buddha who can't accept if a new generation singer is better than most singers of your generation. You said that I can't compare rijit with yesteryear's musicians? film stars. What a stereotypical and cheap thinking you have ! Shame on you buddhe. Arijit is new generation singer but it doesn't mean that he can't be better than any yesteryear's musician.
      You have written that musicians want Arijit's clones. But it was similar in 90's Musicians wanted Rafi and Kishore clones that's why Kumar Sanu (Kishore clone) ,Sonu Nigam (Rafi clone) and Alka Yagnik (Lata ji clone) became popular in 90's. You buddhas have too much ghamand for everything of their generation. You can't accept if something of this generation is better than most of your generation.
      Mohit ,Shaan, KK etc stopped getting work in 2010's decade because they don't have versatility and singing style like Arijit. They became outdated and irrelavent for modern generation just like Mohammed Aziz and Amit Kumar were outdated in 90's generation. It is just a game of time ,nothing else.
      Watch Sonu Nigam's interviews. Nowadays he is praising Arijit in his every new interview. He rated himself 5 and Arijit 7.

  • @mujjodlofiboy5909
    @mujjodlofiboy5909 6 місяців тому +68

    She came in my dream 15 days later after she passed away, she was sitting in farm house and i went near her and she given me an ashirwad for my music career it was vivid dream, i still remember that day when i woke up from it, may your soul rest in peace lata ma 🙏.

  • @aybexile
    @aybexile 6 місяців тому +365

    I didn't get why she was being referred to as a bully in the industry when the music directors themselves only wanted to work with her?

    • @farahyeasmin6230
      @farahyeasmin6230 6 місяців тому +15

      Bas limelight cahiye shasta

    • @ThinkingMonk000
      @ThinkingMonk000 6 місяців тому +14

      Because she was a bully

    • @vipulverma3597
      @vipulverma3597 5 місяців тому +7

      She did bully upcoming singers to maintain the number 1 tag.

    • @Ot4blink987
      @Ot4blink987 5 місяців тому +7

      ​@@vipulverma3597and she is still the biggest singer India ever had

    • @vipulverma3597
      @vipulverma3597 5 місяців тому +12

      @@Ot4blink987 ofcourse you'd be the biggest when you don't let upcoming artists to get work. Nobody denies her talent and hardwork and her soothing voice, but everyone has a grey/dark side, this was hers.

  • @rockstarby21
    @rockstarby21 6 місяців тому +102

    might sound controversial but i can't bear the sweetness of lata ji, I have my utmost respect for her and I don't think I can even praise her but I find asha ji better(again it's just my opinion) because she has been more experimental in her journey with song like khatuba etc etc.

    • @udaybaviskar2422
      @udaybaviskar2422 6 місяців тому +6

      Jao aur unkey 'gazal' suno pata chalega wo kya thi.

    • @vatsalsanwaria537
      @vatsalsanwaria537 6 місяців тому +8

      Yeah i can understand. It's a personal taste.
      e.g. i can't bear Death Metal growlers.

    • @udaybaviskar2422
      @udaybaviskar2422 6 місяців тому +9

      If Lata sang Asha style too then Asha would have had no space. A sis created a space for her Sis. Also it was an intelligent decision not to sing opposite character songs.. India celebrities tend to follow a specific line to fulfill the image in public. Lata gained a image/represented a voice of a mainstream Indian woman.. who does not have 'Disco, Jazzy tendency. That imageade her so so so big!!
      Not that she cannot sing what Asha sang. Thats Y lata even checked the words of the song, what is the scene of the song.. to avoid any anti-image element.

    • @nchamundi1
      @nchamundi1 6 місяців тому +2

      Just what I feel

    • @arifujjamansahake5371
      @arifujjamansahake5371 6 місяців тому

      @@udaybaviskar2422 😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘🥰

  • @swapnildalvi2975
    @swapnildalvi2975 6 місяців тому +159

    Misleading thumbnail...this is not bully or controversial, but she always worked on her own terms and conditions which is very commendable..no one can be like her..

  • @forexmage321
    @forexmage321 6 місяців тому +268

    Click bait 🤨

  • @sricharan_7402
    @sricharan_7402 6 місяців тому +172

    The legend. The best duo SP Balasubramaniam and Lata Garu...

    • @sbyoutube092
      @sbyoutube092 6 місяців тому +5

      nah ! u forgot Kishore Da & Lata didi combo💞

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +7

      ahhh!

    • @bharathumesh
      @bharathumesh 6 місяців тому +5

      Spb did the same in south Indian industry..

    • @vedantyadav00
      @vedantyadav00 6 місяців тому +2

      @sbyoutube092 oh C'mon man! Every single individual knows that The Great Mohammad Rafi Sahab and So-called Saraswati personified Lata Mangeshkar combo is the best of all the times! No one can replace 'em.

    • @Wihan4599
      @Wihan4599 6 місяців тому

      ​@@vedantrusty😅

  • @subhadityabasu9224
    @subhadityabasu9224 6 місяців тому +56

    You mentioned Devdas (1955) but the poster is of SRK's Devdas (2002)

  • @labi2999
    @labi2999 6 місяців тому +61

    I’m on Lata’s side. It’s sad that Asha Bhosle took her abusive husband’s side and didn’t even support her sister during the royalty situation esp after benefiting from her connections. Lata Mangeshkar was a force to be reckoned with. I think she understood that Asha Bhosle was trying to make a name of herself and did not have the influence and power to stand against other artists like her. Lata Mangeshkar will always be one of my idols.

  • @jawadsoomrotheboss
    @jawadsoomrotheboss 6 місяців тому +45

    Jab baat aati hai Royalties ki, I am neutral. I feel like Art shouldn't be treated like a business. However, there is also no issue with treating like a business. There is no right or wrong.
    1960's era was so full of Lata's songs. Then in late 90s, Alka Yagnik dominated the music industry. And now, I think Shreya Ghoshal will hold that crown till next decade.

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому

      hmmmmm

    • @boro3775
      @boro3775 5 місяців тому +3

      That is their bread and butter..they all don't have a proper job. Their voice will not always be like this or get stage shows. So it is for their financial stability.

  • @shashwatdeshpande9598
    @shashwatdeshpande9598 6 місяців тому +74

    I remember....there was a serial which used to air on &tv, 7-8 years ago, the plot of the serial was highly inspired by the controversial lives of Lata Mangeshkar and Asha Bhosle
    P.S.- the name of the show was "meri awaz hi pehchan hai"

  • @skk.782
    @skk.782 6 місяців тому +726

    Asha was able to get out of her sister's shadow but sadly other 2 sisters couldn't .

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +77

      Yup unfortunate

    • @snapp3256
      @snapp3256 6 місяців тому +31

      But asha was an equal selfish bully

    • @deeksha2943
      @deeksha2943 6 місяців тому +12

      Yes this I have heard from my father too that she tried ruining Asha bhosle's career too

    • @asianguy86
      @asianguy86 6 місяців тому +12

      Suman bahut achchi singer thi uska career barbad kr diya is lata ne 😢

    • @vedantyadav00
      @vedantyadav00 6 місяців тому

      @Newchannel-bl6bc true bhai! She's my favourite after Suraiya!

  • @undefeatableyt7
    @undefeatableyt7 6 місяців тому +167

    She is still a legend despite her controversies! 🐐🔥

    • @mazebankMK2
      @mazebankMK2 6 місяців тому +2

      😂😂 for people with terrible taste MJ, Metallica and beatles are more iconic than this terrible singer

    • @undefeatableyt7
      @undefeatableyt7 6 місяців тому +13

      @@mazebankMK2 Ek legend(Lata Ji) ko praise karne ke liye dusre legend(MJ) ki disrespect karna zaroori nahi hota 🤡

    • @undefeatableyt7
      @undefeatableyt7 6 місяців тому +15

      @@mazebankMK2 Also how is Lata a terrible singer, Lockdown kid hai kya love day?! 🤡

    • @JoseBio-jg6yw
      @JoseBio-jg6yw 6 місяців тому +1

      @@mazebankMK2 lol. dont compare lata with Beatles and MJ , she was a great legendary singer and mj and beatles were revolutionary and legendary , totally apples and oranges

    • @yashagrawal744
      @yashagrawal744 6 місяців тому

      Apne hi baap ka hain ki kisi USA vale kaa?​@@mazebankMK2

  • @mdebarshi
    @mdebarshi 6 місяців тому +29

    Many famous singers, who were colleagues of Lata Mangeshkar, got royalty because of Lata Mangeshkar; yet they criticized her.
    She was the boss... a true lone wolf...
    She fought alone against the establishment and everyone just enjoyed the fruits of her efforts, for free.
    Even the ones who opposed her when she wanted royalty, anyway took royalty when given!
    No wonder she was attacked and was made the villain, because she had the courage to challenge the industry and the order of power.
    For the same reason, there is propaganda against her even till this day.
    She is unique; she is a gem... more precious than the kohinoor and more beautiful than the Taj Mahal.
    Haters will have to live with this.
    ___________________
    All music directors wanted her to sing their songs...some even had gone on record saying that they composed keeping Lata's voice in their mind...
    Greats like bade Ghulam Ali, pt Bhimsen, Noor Jehan, mehdi Hassan praised her openly...
    Jagjit sing even composed 'sajda' iust for Lata Mangeshkar to sing fir him...
    People of India had great taste at some point in time, now mediocrity has been democratized. Sad and disgusting.

  • @amritrao882
    @amritrao882 12 днів тому +2

    Lata Mangeshkar and Asha Bhosle were a blessing and a bane at the same time. Lata Mangeshkar strangled the career of all her competitors.
    Many are mislead by Lata that the dispute between her and Rafi was over royalty. However insiders know that before public fall out over songs’ royalty, Lata was upset that Rafi was singing with singers other than Lata and Asha. Rafi declined to choke the careers of other singers. Rafi was a perfect gentleman. He didn’t interfere with the jobs of music director, lyricist and producer. The tension of Rafi’s refusal to facilitate Lata’s monopoly resulted in an eruption of her anger disguised as a policy differences over the royalty. We don’t know what Lata said to Rafi that made the otherwise cool Rafi so mad that he said that he wouldn’t sing with Lata going forward. Rafi and Asha both had the same stand on royalty yet Asha being Lata’s sister patched up with her but the duo ganged up against Rafi for rest of their lives. They kept denigrating Rafi’s singing. Asha ran away with Bhosle because Lata wouldn’t let her sing. Asha was determined to make her own career and she took a different path to accomplish her goal. She used men to further her career. She stole Asha’s manager Bhosle who had good industry connections and had marketed Lata well. He successfully launched Asha. After making her name she dumped Bhosle and patched up with Lata. She hooked up with OP Nayyar. Once Nayyar’s career was over she seduced RD Burman. She broke up with RD and started living separately when he didn’t have work. However upon his death she came to claim his property and royalty. She put RD’s mother into an old age home and took the ownership of SD Burman’s house and his songs’ royalty. She also kicked out her daughter in law and her granddaughter upon her son’s death and took over the house they were living in. Actress Sadhna had rented a house from Asha and was living there. When Sadhana was very old and could not afford to pay rent increase, Asha set upon her goons who shut down her water. Sadhana was alone and sick. She had lost her husband, had no children and was half blind at age 74 and was about to die but Asha had no mercy.
    Lata set up her monopoly over playback singing and like a gangster finished off her competition. To name a few Geeta Dutt, Mubarak Begum, Suman Kalyanpur, Sharda, Sudha Malhotra, Kanchan, Vani Jayaram, Sulakshna Pandit, Usha Timothy, Usha Mangeshkar, Meena Mangeshkar, Preeti Sagar fell victim to her. It’s a shame that amongst hundreds of crores of people India could not have another singer. Music lovers didn’t have a choice and were denied many good singers who could have enthralled them. Lata was a bully. She boycotted SD Burman, Sajjad Hussain, Jai Kishan, Raj Kapoor, Khemchand Prakash, Mohammed Rafi when they worked with other singers.

  • @bidsvon6379
    @bidsvon6379 6 місяців тому +101

    Veer Zara's song were so much better because it was her voice and that movie was released in 2000s.

    • @ratansoren365
      @ratansoren365 6 місяців тому +16

      Yes and becz of her voice Veer Zara songs r still memorized ❤❤

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +5

      hmmmm

    • @nilimat.1645
      @nilimat.1645 6 місяців тому +6

      Not at all.. there her voice already lost it all. Other young singers would have done justice to the song. I would consider that one in the list of ruined song. Her best time was 70 -80s.

    • @HritikGohil
      @HritikGohil 6 місяців тому +1

      Its only due to her voice the songs were remembered

    • @officially_nitin
      @officially_nitin 5 місяців тому +3

      ​@@nilimat.1645 the character Zara was also old, new voice would not do justice with her character.

  • @os4879
    @os4879 6 місяців тому +25

    Unhone Classical Music sekha apne Pitaji se lekin ek Performing Classical Vocalist nahi bani.
    Lekin unki Awaz me Raag Ras aur Rang Sabkuch hi Tha.
    Woh Sach much mein Sarawati Maa ka Bharat desh ko Vardan thi.
    Unke jitni achi awaz sirf Geeta Dutt ji aur Asha ji aur Begum Parveen Sultana ji ki hai

  • @Uzmi-Bitto
    @Uzmi-Bitto 5 місяців тому +3

    She was, is, and will always be remembered as a legend. Please don't disrespect her memory and eternal legacy by insinuating that she was a bully. Lata ji and Madam Noor Jahan are the indisputable melodic queens of the subcontinent. Their exquisite vocals continue to reign over our hearts.

  • @imrealtalk108
    @imrealtalk108 6 місяців тому +87

    Arijit voice also dont suit many heroz.
    Not a great play back singer imo.
    Actually playback singing died after 2003.

    • @hello.667
      @hello.667 6 місяців тому +1

      Arijit is great playback singer. You are an ignorant old fool. Shame on you haraami buddhe.
      Arijit's voice suits on new generation heroes like Ranbir Kapoor, Sushant Singh Rajput ,Kartik Aryan etc and many more.
      But you are judging him by his voice on old generation heros. He is most versatile singer. He can change his singing style and textures. For example - binte dil (arabic), chain of thoughts (western), main parwana (retro), vida karo (retro), hulchul (rock), gaaytri mantra jaap (classical), jhoome jo pathaan (pop), shanivaar raati (party). He is the only singer who can time travel though songs by singing both old and modern style songs.
      Shor Kumar sang in same style for different actors. He sounded same while singing for Amitabh Bachhan and Rishi Kapoor.
      Ranbir Kapoor, Sushant Singh Rajput, Kartik Aryan and many more actors suits a lot on Arijit's soulful voice.

    • @un-known1147
      @un-known1147 6 місяців тому +13

      Playback singing died just after Rafi sahab.
      Rest all singers be it Kishore kumar, Udit, Sanu, kk or Mohit Chauhan sings in their own styles which many times don't even suit many actors.

    • @imrealtalk108
      @imrealtalk108 6 місяців тому +3

      @@un-known1147 ...kishore kumar is no.1 artist 🔥.
      Dont b rafi chamcha

    • @un-known1147
      @un-known1147 6 місяців тому +9

      @@imrealtalk108Just say you are high on something. Sonu or Arijit stand ahead of Kishore.
      And my point still stands Except Rafi no singer actually did playback. Kishore had the same style for Amitabh and the same for Rishi. kapoor.

    • @imrealtalk108
      @imrealtalk108 6 місяців тому +6

      @@un-known1147 ...fully disagree.
      thr is No better artist then kishore kumat in playback + acting .
      Arjit n sonu are not even in top 5 .

  • @Plz.SILENCE
    @Plz.SILENCE 6 місяців тому +76

    Lata mangeskar is real feminist and for this reason I respect her, because she stands for his rights❤❤

    • @Rosee27
      @Rosee27 4 місяці тому +2

      Her rights

    • @soumilidasgupta7294
      @soumilidasgupta7294 4 місяці тому +2

      She was a bully and never let other good singers shine in the business. She ruined many people’s careers

  • @philosopher_sage_07
    @philosopher_sage_07 6 місяців тому +9

    Lata Mangeshkar was a staunch nationalist and a supporter of Savarkar. She also publicly appreciated the Ayodhya Ram Lalla Mandir judgement of 2020. Hence, the mudslinging by the leftist cabal. We are proud of Lata ji!

  • @DJMRAsingh
    @DJMRAsingh 6 місяців тому +3

    Lata Ji is a legend. Didn't know about her this side. Interestingly, I had made an AI cover of Ram Aayengey Bhajan in her voice which became mega viral and was loved by everyone. After a few weeks, I received a legal notice from her estate to delete or face legal charges.

  • @jyotiyangadmotghare1843
    @jyotiyangadmotghare1843 6 місяців тому +24

    No one is like Lata Mangeshkar

  • @prajjwaltiwari8644
    @prajjwaltiwari8644 6 місяців тому +35

    No way Lata Mangeshkar didn't know classical music.
    God had to nerf her down so that others can survive.☹️

    • @thepossessedseries9014
      @thepossessedseries9014 6 місяців тому +4

      She knew, her father was classical music, every kid of that family can sing, do you really think she doesn't know classical music?

    • @pradipshinde6598
      @pradipshinde6598 6 місяців тому

      She Was Old Era Prostitute No One Going to say this... In This Video Vedant Exposed Chapri Lata.. Kudos To Him

    • @prajjwaltiwari8644
      @prajjwaltiwari8644 6 місяців тому +6

      @@thepossessedseries9014 yeah, dude. The way she picked tunes, it's very hard to believe that she didn't have the classical knowledge.
      Someone like Kishor Kumar is very believable as you'll veryy rarely see him hitting complex sur or alaap.

    • @sudipabose8442
      @sudipabose8442 5 місяців тому

      You are mad!!

    • @asadazmat6957
      @asadazmat6957 4 місяці тому

      I agree , Lata voice was very depressing and straight like screaming

  • @Kushala_SD
    @Kushala_SD 6 місяців тому +83

    her 90's and 2000's songs are evergreen my most fav ❤️ her voice suited with every actress 🙏

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +12

      let's agree to disagree

    • @Vampress09
      @Vampress09 6 місяців тому +1

      True! I don't see a problem with it.

    • @Harsh12351
      @Harsh12351 6 місяців тому +3

      Her voice however beautiful it may be, always sounded like coming from an eloquent lady, not from a young beauty between 18-24 years old. Which created a dissonance. It suited the female characters of the 60s-80s, but with movies as the age of the female actresses dropped, the voice needed to be changed. For example, Shreya Ghoshal has a forever youthful voice, but still, for a younger, sultry character or wanting a rawer, huskier voice you have the talents of Shilpa Rao, Shalmali Kholgade and Parampara Tandon. The songs they sang would not have worked with Shreya Ghoshal's voice. Sunidi Chauhan is truly a more versatile singer but even she has limitations.

    • @itn0687
      @itn0687 6 місяців тому

      It wud have been better if sung by some else, popular those times rather than by a singer who sounded too old 😂

    • @Kushala_SD
      @Kushala_SD 6 місяців тому +4

      @@Harsh12351 if Latha madam had not sung those 90's 2000' songs those songs would had not become famous nor all time fav songs , We would had not know their names also. Whatever people say for many of us Latha madam 's voice suited for all generation. Without her voice those songs would had not become Evergreen songs .
      The new singers who you are mentioning except Shreya Ghoshal madam all those singers cannot create that charisma which latha madam had created through those songs

  • @zakikhatibi461
    @zakikhatibi461 6 місяців тому +1004

    Lata ruined 90's songs?!!! What were people smoking then?

    • @SapnaKumari-ui1ed
      @SapnaKumari-ui1ed 6 місяців тому +70

      I mean yes DTPH is still one of my favourite music albums from 90s

    • @beecool4686
      @beecool4686 6 місяців тому +15

      What,,,????really

    • @imrealtalk108
      @imrealtalk108 6 місяців тому +22

      Not really .
      But thr was no cover system Back then.

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +131

      they have a point though

    • @imrealtalk108
      @imrealtalk108 6 місяців тому +114

      I think 90s main female singer could have done better work in term of overall balance .
      As a 60 year old singing for 30 year old doesnt look best all the time in bollywood imo.

  • @alkasharma4701
    @alkasharma4701 6 місяців тому +10

    The one and only LATA MANGESHKAR will always be the greatest singer ever! Such a legendary voice is born once in a millennium years. With fame and success controversies come along. It is a shame to only pick on her how about the dominant male voice of Rafi. Why such questions are not raised about him.

  • @Odyvers
    @Odyvers 6 місяців тому +19

    Now day's ganjedi kid's of this generation will trying to question her success 😔🙏21:57 wow

  • @Max6850
    @Max6850 6 місяців тому +9

    70 to 90 is just sad era of Cinema and Music . Repetitive things
    Born In 93, All I remember Lata ji is from Rang de Basanti with AR Rehman for Luka Chuppi and it was magical

  • @adnanaliable
    @adnanaliable 6 місяців тому +94

    I don't think you need to bully people or play politics to get to the top when you have voice like LM, I mean have you heard her voice every time yashraj picture logo shows up, its like an angel is singing from the havens.

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +4

      yes that's the point of the video

    • @thesarasohrabi
      @thesarasohrabi 6 місяців тому +8

      You dont need to... but she did it anyways... that is the point...

    • @adnanaliable
      @adnanaliable 6 місяців тому +10

      @@thesarasohrabi Did you even watch the video, she actually didn't bully anyone, she even refused to accept any firlfare awards to give newcomers a chance.

    • @SVK1405
      @SVK1405 6 місяців тому +9

      ​@@thesarasohrabi she did not people are insane nowadays to accuse anyone anything

    • @asianguy86
      @asianguy86 6 місяців тому +2

      Dude you don't the reality shr ruined whole market controlled it infact

  • @KHEMRAJPARAJULI2002
    @KHEMRAJPARAJULI2002 6 місяців тому +7

    Ok so first of all - She's a goddess of music 🎶👑...
    And second of all - na lata maa se behtar koi tha na hai na koi hoga ❤❤❤.
    And last mein yahi kahunga jo log is devi ke baare mein galat sochte hai galat bolte hai...ganda arop lagate hai...un logon se zyada ghatiya log koi nahi hai... bhagwan maaf na kare inko ...chullu bhar paani mein dub mare ❤❤❤
    Because man ...not only a great singer she was but also a very inspiring personality, very kind, no egoistic. Jinke saath unhone kaam kiya sabko woh pyaar respect deti thi❤❤sabko pata hai unke simplicity k baare mein..no show off, no luxurious life style. Kitna mehnat kiya tha unhone male dominated industry mein apna naam banane k liye , kitne rejection mile yeh kehkar ki she had thin voice... unhone kya kya nahi kiya singers k liye... filmfare awards k liye awaaz uthayi & royalty k liye. Aur bhi bahut logon k liye bahut kuch kiya hai lata maa ne. Kitne hi concerts kiye funds k liye. She was first Indian artist who performed in the royal Albert hall. Lata maa ko respect dete huye bahut countries ne lata maa awards se nawaja hai. She had six doctorate degree 5 from Indias big universities and 6th one is from the York University Toronto.
    Aur log bolte hai she destroyed careers... like seriously 😤😒
    Why would she ? First of all woh industry mein late '40's thi jab suman kalyanpur ji, Anuradha ji, Hemlata ji ka existence nahi tha aur jab woh log aye the industry mein aaye the tab humari lata maa already bahut successful ho chuki thi then why would she need to destroy others careers. woh toh bas apna kaam kar rahi thi aur ha saare music directors, actors, producers jab chahte the ki sirf lata maa hi unke k liye gaaye jab woh hi unki pehli choice thi then lata maa thodi hi mana karengi unka request geet gaana yeh sochkar oh nahi mere gaane se dusro ko kam kaam milega. No right? Lekin murkh log is chiz ko negative way mein le lete hai aur is devi ke baare mein hatred, false rumours spread kar dete hai. Kitni dukh ki baat hai ki jis gayika ne apna pura Jivan sangeet mein samarpit mar diya, film industry ko saup Diya. Pure duniya Indian music ko pehchan dilaya usi devi ke upar gande arop lage hai 😢💔kuch toh bolte hai unhone apni beheno ko age badne diya 😢are bhai lata ji ne chhote umr se hi un sabko apne bachho ki tarah pala tha bada kiya ..woh aisa q karengi . Koi bhi nahi karta apne behno k saath 😢 grow up ppl. Aur agar kuch kiya hota asha ji kya itni badi gayika hoti aaj ...she equally big like lata maa ❤❤...so ppl Stop spread this false rumours.😢❤also some stpd ppl says she doesn't deserve bharat ratna. Bro listen she deserves more than Bharat Ratna..Aur ha khud bharat ratna ki izzat bad gayi uska naam the goddess lata maa k saath juda 😤😌👑🙏✨
    And listen bro video toh achha banaya hai but thoda aur research kiya karo..unka madan mohan ji ya Kishore da k saath kabhi jhagda nahi hua tha . matlab kuch bhi bolte ho. Aur hah 90s k actress k saath unka awaaz nahi jachta tha ...are sht up. Hume toh kabhi aisa nahi laga hume toh 90s k gaane bhi utne hi pasand hai jitne unke 50s60's k ...ya toh tum log behre ho jo lata maa ke awaaz pe question uthate ho. Grow up

    • @beautifulLife0_0
      @beautifulLife0_0 6 місяців тому +4

      Woww... Main jo kehna chah rahi thi... Woh aapne keh diya... 😊❤
      Yeh jo bhi lata ji ke baare mein anap sanap bolte hai. . Unko judge karte hai jaise ki woh koi bhagwan ho... Jhuthe afwaye failate hai... Unke charitra ke baare mein bura bolte hai.. Mai kahungi unse ghatiya log koi nahi hai... Ghatiya soch hai unki... Dharti ke boj hai sab... Kuch kaam toh hota nahi bs chale aate hai.. Humari devi maa सरस्वती ko bura bolne.

    • @KHEMRAJPARAJULI2002
      @KHEMRAJPARAJULI2002 6 місяців тому +1

      ​@@beautifulLife0_0💯🥰❤️

    • @hello.667
      @hello.667 5 місяців тому +1

      Lata Mangeshkar is overrated. Shreya better than her

    • @KHEMRAJPARAJULI2002
      @KHEMRAJPARAJULI2002 5 місяців тому

      @@hello.667 ok sir 🤦😂 bye.

    • @tusharyadav2000
      @tusharyadav2000 6 днів тому +1

      Me bolne hi wala tha par aap ne sab kuch bol diya bevkuf hai ye sab log

  • @cpol1146
    @cpol1146 6 місяців тому +89

    Lata Mangeshkar : GOAT of Indian Film Industry.

    • @aryantripathi6915
      @aryantripathi6915 4 місяці тому +1

      Can tell me the meaning of GOAT

    • @PriyaB-j2w
      @PriyaB-j2w 3 місяці тому

      ​@@aryantripathi6915greatest of all time

  • @Ayada_v
    @Ayada_v 6 місяців тому +61

    You should make video on the rise of writers in 70s-80s kader khan ,salim khan ,javed akhtar...

  • @diwakar9051
    @diwakar9051 6 місяців тому +9

    My favorite songs of her are from 'Aandhi'
    The duo of lata mangeshkar and Gulzar is the best for ever

  • @yashaswinikrishnan1878
    @yashaswinikrishnan1878 6 місяців тому +8

    There are confessions of many singers claiming that she bullied them and made directors make her sing. check it out. she's great, but there were more people

  • @biswasthapa1500
    @biswasthapa1500 6 місяців тому +5

    Lata ji sing in 90s era evergreen songs specially when she sings for yash raj film company and rajsri production .. that era was magical era .. i love and miss her so much respect u lata ji ❤bharat ratna...love from NEPAL🇳🇵🇳🇵till now all young generation love her voice ... i think that is not monopoly she ruled bollywood becoz all people love her voice crazily and undoubtedly all actrees and filmmaker film distributor musician lyricst want a sing song for them... that called stardom and successive career of magheskar sister not a monopoly😪😥😏
    So respect them 🙏🙌

  • @suryanshyadav4183
    @suryanshyadav4183 3 місяці тому +4

    Lata Mangeshkar is the greatest singer of all time... ❤️💛

  • @arijitawesome5750
    @arijitawesome5750 6 місяців тому +12

    When I was 3 or 4 years old, I used to hear Lata Mangeshkar's songs on the radio and sung by my grandmother herself. My grandmother came from a family of musicians; she was also a very good singer and would sing for me. At that time, I wasn't aware of music or had any knowledge about it, but it felt satisfying and made me happy. However, when I hear songs composed by Salil Chowdhury and sung by Lata Mangeshkar, it gives me another level of peace and touches my soul even today. I don't know what the connection is between those songs and me; sometimes it feels like it's from a previous life.

  • @SKcraftman
    @SKcraftman 6 місяців тому +30

    damn vedant is now consistent btw great video i personally think shreya ghoshal is the only female singer "now" who is very talented and is also loved by the audience but there is not beating late Lata mangeshkars voice

  • @protik007sbk
    @protik007sbk 6 місяців тому +4

    Nothing in this world can challenge the combination of talent and hard work and Lata was the example

  • @Rahul31129
    @Rahul31129 6 місяців тому +7

    0:03 The song lag ja gale is from the movie "woh kaun thi" The movie "woh jo haseena" has little same title lyrics which is "lag ja gale se aye tanhai...'

  • @rohitavhad2592
    @rohitavhad2592 6 місяців тому +4

    23:29 LataMangeshkar stood for genuine-feminism only by her hardwork

  • @professionaloutlook5960
    @professionaloutlook5960 6 місяців тому +12

    In the first place, why is this video made after Latajis's death? It's not fair when an artist who is virtually revered by all Indians including the Prime Minister of the country, should be shown as a controversial one. What you should acknowledge today is the vast collection of songs that she has left behind for all the students of music and musical orchestra singers for their livelihood. All the Musical Orchestra sustain only on the popular songs of her time which people love to hear even today. To blame her for singing maximum songs during her prime was not in her hands, it was the job of the music directors. Why this 'Only Lata' question not asked to any Music Director instead? Likewise Music Director Naushad always took Mohamed Rafi only as a male voice in all his songs, did anyone question that? So stop creating all this controversy now and keep listening to the golden voice which will never be born again.

  • @itn0687
    @itn0687 6 місяців тому +112

    15:50 Absolutely true, lataji's voice didn't suit any actresses from 90s and 00s. Its also true that her voice had become so mature by 90s that most songs wud have sounded better if sung by younger singers

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +37

      Yup, seemed to be a common understanding of that era

    • @ShubhamGhuleCodes
      @ShubhamGhuleCodes 6 місяців тому +10

      Definitely not!

    • @amvmoon777
      @amvmoon777 6 місяців тому +12

      Yah true bro. If you listen to lata ji's 70s and 80s songs then to 90s song then you can certainly note the change . And it would be better if young singer like alka or Kavita Krishnamurthy or someone else had sang the songs . But totally against that lata ji's voice ruined these songs.

    • @gauravjain7653
      @gauravjain7653 6 місяців тому +11

      I can’t seem to agree with you here. I think she did an amazing job singing for Yash Raj movies. I cannot fathom anybody else taking up that position.

    • @prathmeshgharat2873
      @prathmeshgharat2873 6 місяців тому +4

      Don't think so her voice was matured but on point in 90s

  • @skiyer10
    @skiyer10 4 місяці тому +1

    I always felt that Lata ji’s voice is the best. Dil to pagal hai, Ddlj, veer zara such movies would have been incomplete without Lata ji. This is my personal opinion that the directors wanted their movies and songs to be super hit and hence they choose Lata ji and Asha ji. Her voice for me and many other people is the sweetest and the best for every heroine and any song.

  • @kirtichandran8210
    @kirtichandran8210 6 місяців тому +41

    How is she not classically trained? You just mentioned she learnt from her father and then she had two more teachers..

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +7

      classical training is different from music training

    • @dddanie884
      @dddanie884 6 місяців тому +8

      ​@@vedantrustyshe was classically trained. Her father was a classical vocalist and she learnt from her. If she wasn't classically trained, she would not have been able to sing the highly classical based songs she sang in her long career-

    • @p..7163
      @p..7163 5 місяців тому

      She wasn't classically trained hindustani classical is way more harder and difficult but she nailed it without learning classical​@@dddanie884

  • @Thinkgood-c2q
    @Thinkgood-c2q 12 днів тому +1

    Laxmikant Pyarelal said "The Popularity and Fan following which RAFI Sahaab had no Singer had , not even LATA MANGESHKAR".

  • @Shivani-kw9kx
    @Shivani-kw9kx 6 місяців тому +95

    Composers deserves appreciation as singers... ..

  • @Avinashd22
    @Avinashd22 6 місяців тому +16

    11:01 its आनंदघन not आनंदघान , आनंदघन means a cloud raining rains of happiness or joy!

  • @IndiaExplained08
    @IndiaExplained08 6 місяців тому +41

    it doesnt matter whether you have praised her or not or what you have told about her in this video, but bro you have to change the thumbnail of ths video!!! cuz it sucks!!! its kinda demeaning the stature such an iconic and inspirational, respected and THE WORLDS GREATEST SINGER Lata ji

    • @krishnathakur7278
      @krishnathakur7278 6 місяців тому +2

      Agree

    • @vatsalsanwaria537
      @vatsalsanwaria537 6 місяців тому +4

      That's called Basics of UA-cam. They need it for u to click on this videos

    • @saroj1731
      @saroj1731 5 місяців тому

      Using her to sell ur video..come on pata kuch ghanta nahi hai lamba bio chhap dala

  • @Rohan20-d1w
    @Rohan20-d1w 13 днів тому +1

    If Music and Sur has another word then it will be LATA . The best Songs like Lag ja gale , ajeeb dasta hai ye , songs of silsila , veer zara and many more are the evidence that she is the best singer!❤ We love you lata ji!!!!!

  • @prazum
    @prazum 6 місяців тому +10

    I personally see mohd rafi ji as a fakir, unki soch waisi hi thi ekdum hi minimalistic insaan aur kafi achhe, and Lata ji ka point on royalty valid tha

    • @suryanshyadav4183
      @suryanshyadav4183 3 місяці тому +3

      But kuch log paise ke liye gaane gate the. Usise unka ghr chalta tha. Isliye royalty zaroori thi

    • @prazum
      @prazum 3 місяці тому +1

      @@suryanshyadav4183 wahi Maine bola ki Lata ji ka point royality pe valid tha

  • @tusharmahale3080
    @tusharmahale3080 9 днів тому +1

    Inspite of anything she is legend we can not compare her to others because not every people in this world are same. while growing up my grandfather show me the old
    Songs on tv there are lots of singers I have listen but my grand father is always say good things about lata didi and also told me that no one sing like lataji . me and my family always has respect towards lataji
    How can she bully yaar I don't know why people are thinking like this. Ok we assume that she is bully then what's the wrong in that every human being are trying to reach on first position. And she proved himself and reached on the top. She is always legend for me no one like her❤

  • @HassaanQ
    @HassaanQ 6 місяців тому +5

    Ah man I always thought why 90s songs were so off. You just proved my point. Lata’s never matched. Also the fact that how much of a clear line was in compositions between everyone else and Rahman’s composition just made 90s music it unbearable for me.
    Also the same mangeshkae monopoly is today as well that’s with Arijit Singh. I love his voice but he’s just annoyingly everywhere.
    Great work, takes guts to go after the other side of Lata. appreciate from Pakistan. 🇵🇰

  • @in.meraki
    @in.meraki 6 місяців тому +3

    Hi, A quick suggestion. There is lot of volume fluctuation, when playing on a low volume.
    The old videos are obviously in a very low volume, which could have been increased to match your own volume. Then your own volume also fluctuates.
    I'm watching this at midnight at a low volume, so I need to keep increasing and decreasing the volume.
    Otherwise great podcast. I'm subscribing. I'll watch it in day time, where I can watch in a high volume, Thanks.

  • @TanmoyDeb
    @TanmoyDeb 5 місяців тому +43

    Don't mislead people.

    • @anusuachanda7938
      @anusuachanda7938 3 місяці тому +2

      He is not 😊he is telling the truth only.

    • @AnshuSingh-w6r
      @AnshuSingh-w6r 9 днів тому

      Thumbnail dekh​@@anusuachanda7938

  • @jyotiyangadmotghare1843
    @jyotiyangadmotghare1843 6 місяців тому +25

    Yes in 90s her voice became matured that innocence was not seen there in her voice but no doubt before that no words are there to describe her voice. Scientists say that they have researched such voice will not be created after

    • @abhiishekk
      @abhiishekk 6 місяців тому +1

      which scientist where did they so research, ? :D

    • @faisalnazir9043
      @faisalnazir9043 4 місяці тому

      😂😂😂​@@abhiishekk

  • @VaibhavPatangiwar
    @VaibhavPatangiwar 4 місяці тому +1

    The moment you said "Is desh me koi insan nahi hoga jisne ye aawaz nahi suni hogi" , I knew the "Lag ja gale" song was coming. The young generation remembers only one song of Lata which is so disappointing.

  • @Beingvidarbha
    @Beingvidarbha 6 місяців тому +7

    Legend ek hi bar paida hota hai… bharatratna lata ji music industry ki legend thi.

  • @bandana_rathore
    @bandana_rathore 6 місяців тому +8

    Vedant brother one video on Jaya Bhaduri ji. She was so talented, eloquent and elegant. How life has changed her so much...

    • @manibun727
      @manibun727 6 місяців тому +1

      There's this interview of Amitabh and his whole family hosted by Simi. I don't remember the name of the show... rendezvous with Simi or something like that, you'll find it on UA-cam. You'll see Jaya wasn't particularly well respected by Amitabh during that interview.

    • @bandana_rathore
      @bandana_rathore 6 місяців тому

      @@manibun727 yes I have only seen snippets of that. Where she was saying that he thinks it's a waste of time to do romantic conversations with wife and he agreed to it. She was a very established actress and sophisticated, it can be seen in her old interviews.
      She became bitter because everyone always compared her with Rekha and as if she was the one who stood between her and Amitabh. Society never penalises the man in extramarital affairs, it's always the women who gets bitter end of the stick.

  • @dustudent1637
    @dustudent1637 6 місяців тому +12

    There can on;ly be one Lata Mangeshkar.
    ---------- VANI JAYARAM.

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +1

      indeed

    • @rajeshwarivasandani8305
      @rajeshwarivasandani8305 3 місяці тому +1

      If she really had the best voice, why the hell was she so insecure of suman kalyanpur and vanijayaram. Chor ke dadi mein tinka

    • @dustudent1637
      @dustudent1637 3 місяці тому +1

      @@rajeshwarivasandani8305
      It's a f;act she had best voice.
      Ask to south in;dian mus;ic compo;sers/sin;gers them;selves.

  • @tinklingcrystals6489
    @tinklingcrystals6489 6 місяців тому +4

    Lataji was fantastic till the end of 80s ..after that her voice started getting a weird timber which was slightly irritating to the ears... The same happened with Yesudas the singer of the south... After 85-86 his voice started sounding funny due to excessive stretching of vocal chords for his carnatic concerts...He too had pulled down a lot of vocal talents in the film industry and had become more of a business man rather than an authentic artist of his genre... He had even criticised and suggested that Lata ji stops singing coz she started sounding funny but perhaps its karma or something, the next year of his criticism on Lata , his voice too started sounding weird...But at the same time we cant ignore their precious contribution to Indian film music ❤

  • @samirkumarsaha7714
    @samirkumarsaha7714 6 місяців тому +6

    I don't appreciate the title and the thumbnail of this video. Don't call her a bully.
    My humble request.

  • @TheUnputdownables
    @TheUnputdownables 5 місяців тому +4

    I think you got the part wrong where you say that she should have taken a step back in the 90s to let others shine.
    In that decade she was extremely selective. Whereas singers like Alka ji, Anuradha ji , kavita ji and Sadhna ji were doing the majority of work.

  • @dddanie884
    @dddanie884 6 місяців тому +7

    The video is good but the part where you mention about Lata ji ruining 90s songs is just plain rubbish. My grandparents, parents and my whole family have been fans of her music and people who grew up listening to Lata ji would never agree with this above statement. She was already in her 60s in the 1990s but her popularity was still there. I remember my aunt who was in her 20s in the 1990s saying her favourite song was "jab se mile naina" from film "love letter" (1992). See, a woman in her early 20s grooving to the song sung by a 63 year old woman is just amazing! Moreover, the songs of HAHK (1994) were so popular upon its release that filmfare awarded Lata ji a special award (since she had already given up best singer award in 1970). She also let others grow in the 90s by singing less songs, which is evident from the fact that we see other singers like Alka Yagnik, Kavita Krishnamurthy etc. The Soundtrack album of DDLJ (1995) is one of the best selling albums of all time in India. If people of that time felt disconnected with Lata ji's voice, the album would have failed. Not only in Hindi but Lata ji was making her debut in Indonesian dangdut music in the 90s. Such was her voice's freshness. People commenting about her ruining 90s songs are either people who are jealous of her illustrious career or people who cant connect with her music.

    • @Manishrayyadav7
      @Manishrayyadav7 15 днів тому

      Yes right.. In fact Veer zara and DTPH Album is still my favorite affair ddlj

  • @vrushalidhongade5725
    @vrushalidhongade5725 5 місяців тому +2

    LataJi pushed aside all the bullies and producers who tried to control her. She was the first lady singer who became a super star on her own merit. So I'm on her Team.

  • @hanafromtunisia
    @hanafromtunisia 6 місяців тому +4

    Lata jee is a legend and so are you 🌺The research, delivery, themes, topics, titles and thumbnail designs 👏🏼love your channel. Keep shining

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому

      Thanks a ton

    • @hanafromtunisia
      @hanafromtunisia 6 місяців тому

      @@vedantrusty pleasure is all mine so well deserved

  • @sagayagambrun5149
    @sagayagambrun5149 2 місяці тому

    Success at whatever level attracts controversy and derisory. There is only one Sun capable of sustaining life on Earth.. There is always a special one. When the colonial countries around the World was in darkness where Indians forcefully and slavishly toiled the land for the greatest thieves on earth the voice of Lata lit their hearts with her silky and silvery voice. My mum survived the lost of my dad when she was only 27 years old and material hardship thanks to the presence of her songs! Thank you and blessings!

  • @antonettedsouza7529
    @antonettedsouza7529 6 місяців тому +38

    Lataji, is a legend. Why are you calling her a "Bully"?

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +21

      bhai ye hi to explain karne ke liye video banaya hai, dekh to le 😭

    • @GHOSTRIDER-nu6fb
      @GHOSTRIDER-nu6fb 6 місяців тому +6

      That is called click bait.

  • @samsungsam7670
    @samsungsam7670 5 місяців тому +2

    Bappi Lahiri could able to tabla at age of 4 . Lataji k gaane even small kids can sing in competitions. Lataji was lucky, God was always with her.

  • @theajpodcast
    @theajpodcast 6 місяців тому +4

    Hip Hop Culture vs Good Music
    her reply was very sweet: "Sur na ho to mujhe takleef hoti hai"

  • @VinayTiwari_27
    @VinayTiwari_27 6 місяців тому +2

    I was about to say you wrong words but thankfully I watched whole Video then.
    Lata Mangeshkar & Asha Bhosle are great institute of playback singing. They are Masters. Lata & Asha are Pride of Nation. Everyone listen their beautiful and immortal songs.
    No one can replace them.

  • @MusicalNight-pj2hy
    @MusicalNight-pj2hy 6 місяців тому +6

    1st thing no one can become lata mangeshkar because every person is only once when someone ask didi about compare with herself her answer was "" you consider my talent as 19 and someone copy me and show talent 20 but sometimes in me special no one beat that because everyone have own charm "" no one beat didi .
    2 . Please listen other singer live performance and listen sharply you definately find breathing but in lata mangeshkar concert no chance ,
    Especially listen her Royal albert hall concert 1974 without autotune and any technology she sounded like pure honey
    3. Who say didi not suitable for 90s without autotune
    Listen lekin album .
    4 . if didi was jealous person then why she stop her name being nominated in filmfare award
    Especially she fight for it to start category for singers
    5 . Once in EK SAFAR 1999 INTERVIEW Didi say that She not deserve such respect because she not do to much hardwork for this beside their are to many people much talented than me but god choice me
    I think it's her density and ashirwad by her father
    6- remember lata didi anyone always remember her in white saree and diamond
    She never ware other clothes in outdoor, her way of keeping Maharashtrian tradition
    7- besides film song she was 1st singer who record DYNESHWARI
    SHIVKAKYANRAJA
    BHAGWAT GEETA
    AND MORE
    I think her contribution are remember forever
    People who love her that it

  • @pallaviyadav2560
    @pallaviyadav2560 6 місяців тому +4

    In 90s lata and asha ji only sang 20 to 30 percent of all decade and those songs are perfect in all manner and result of determination of movies director and music composer for specific choice of singer and nothing is wrong in it. And once again all songs sung by lata ji in 90 are outstanding.

  • @user-rc4xq9jv4b
    @user-rc4xq9jv4b 6 місяців тому +10

    sorry to say but feels like arijit singh is also establishing monopoly for himself. singers like shaan, kumar sanu, abhijeet, kk, sonu nigam have better voice knows how to make the listeners feel the song. who knows why directors are only choosing arijit singh.

    • @vatsalsanwaria537
      @vatsalsanwaria537 6 місяців тому

      Correct

    • @hello.667
      @hello.667 5 місяців тому +3

      That is your personal opinion. But Arijit has better voice and versatility than those monotonous old singers. He knows how to make listeners feel the song. He is known as king of soulful voice. You can search on google. Listen to 'main phir bhi tumko chahunga' and 'uska hi banana' songs. These are legendary songs by him.
      Monotonous nasal overrated copycat Kumar Sanu established monopoly in 90's. We all know the monopoly of Shor Kumar in 70's. Arijit has better voice. Arijit is most versatile singer and he has sung all types of songs from classical (gaaytri mantra jaap), arabic (binte dil), retro (main parwana) to pop (shanivaar raati), western (chain of thoughts).
      Music directors are choosing Arijit because he did justice to every kind of song and he has most heart touching voice ever. Listen to 'vida karo' and 'main parwana' song it feels like Mohammed Rafi is singing. Listen to 'sajde' song it feels like Nusrat Fateh sahab is singing. Listen to 'Rishton ke saare manzar' song to feel Ghulam Ali vibe. Arijit was sounding like an arabic singer in 'binte dil' song.
      Listen to his new song 'satyanaas'. It is a fun track. Will you believe that he is the same singer who sang 'vida kar' song recently?
      Even Sonu Nigam gave Arijit more rating than himself. There is a reason for it.

    • @hello.667
      @hello.667 5 місяців тому +2

      @@vatsalsanwaria537 Not correct

    • @unnirajac8617
      @unnirajac8617 18 днів тому

      ​@@hello.667 I think he is right.Arijit is not a great technical singer. Like Shaan said his voice breaks often why singing the song. He is not restricted by any music directors to sing in the most correct and technical way possible because people love him for that. He sings through his heart and people adore that.

  • @Indian12023
    @Indian12023 4 місяці тому +1

    As the eldest (daughter) of five siblings , I totally understand why she said she doesn’t want to be reborn or if it happens she wouldn’t like to be lata mageshkar, the responsibilities and the ungrateful siblings and the pressure of parents over every one including themselves, it’s horrible!! I myself would never never want to be born again as an eldest of so many siblings. And it’s even harder to find a partner I’m 40 now in the struggle of bringing my siblings up I spent all my time and money. Now they all are settled and I am alone! Life is such!!! It’s a curse to be the eldest!!

  • @trigohotgaming9719
    @trigohotgaming9719 6 місяців тому +3

    your story-telling abilities, the research and the script, is what sets you apart....

  • @manasuniyal2897
    @manasuniyal2897 6 місяців тому +1

    LATA JI was literally GODESS of MUSIC in Hindi classicals and bollywood music.

  • @shubhamjagtap108
    @shubhamjagtap108 6 місяців тому +5

    Her success is fully deserved... Peace

  • @avikchakraborty6674
    @avikchakraborty6674 4 місяці тому +2

    Misleading thumbnail for sure. But yes the last question:if there would be another "Lata Mangeshkar"? The answer is NO. She is the reincarnation of Maa Saraswati herself. There cannot be another Lata Mangeshkar. When she sings, her voice percolates through all your senses and reaches at the depth of your heart. And you get swayed away with the emotions. I'm surprised why it wasn't declared a national mourning when she left us for the eternal abode. I took three days to come out of that. And every single day I celebrate her with her songs. Be at work or at home, her voice is beyond divine.

  • @melodiouskid
    @melodiouskid 6 місяців тому +7

    49 mins ago....bro consistency on peak

  • @chickenmomo4977
    @chickenmomo4977 16 днів тому

    My 90's are memorable because of Lata Mangeshkar ji's voice. I was quite young but I never felt her voice sounded old or odd for the actresses in 90's

  • @gypsymemoir6797
    @gypsymemoir6797 6 місяців тому +3

    Ralph Waldo Emerson famously said "To be great is to be misunderstood". Lata ruled the hearts of MILLIONS.
    Nobody will point out Asha's 90s song, Suresh Wadekar's voice not fit for many actors same applies for Nitin Mukesh etc (without questioning their singing abilities, which btw i am a fan of).
    So its common. Lata Mangeshkar is Great. Final Words.

  • @oopriyapriya
    @oopriyapriya Місяць тому +1

    Hello Vedant,
    I wanted to bring to your attention this very crucial piece of information..
    Lata Mangeshkar was introduced to the Indian Film Music Industry by the legendary music composer the late Mr. Dattatray Davjekar.
    Also known as Datta Davjekar.
    Popularly known as DD.
    He gave her her very 1st song ever 'Pa Lagu Kar Jori Re' in the film Aap ki Seva Mein.
    The year was 1947.
    This song is available on UA-cam.
    Please do check it out.
    DD not only supported her talent but also made her shine even in the Marathi film music industry.
    Kindly consider this information that people are unaware of..but need to know.
    Thank you.

  • @vishalmulik1981
    @vishalmulik1981 6 місяців тому +3

    Bhai, badhiya research and awesome video.Keep up the good work.

  • @samsonrao3793
    @samsonrao3793 4 місяці тому +1

    People used to wait for Lataji's songs. Bas Lataji ke naam par lakhon cassette bik jaate the. Why she needs to bully? Aise singer 1000 saal mein ek baar paida hoti hai❤

  • @fitedgemrr5041
    @fitedgemrr5041 6 місяців тому +4

    Great video bro ...I would like to see more videos on singer like Zubeen Garg who sang Ya Ali , Jaane Kya, etc and why he left bollywood

  • @vijayrajputbio
    @vijayrajputbio 5 місяців тому +1

    Explaining Lata Mangeshkar is not joke, because Lata is Lata.

  • @pratyushpavansaikia8161
    @pratyushpavansaikia8161 6 місяців тому +155

    Lata Mangeshkar didn't learn classical music😳😳😳 Damn 🤯

    • @shubhamshelke583
      @shubhamshelke583 6 місяців тому +48

      Her father was legendary classical singer and Sangeet Natak artist. So she inherited his singing in her childhood.

    • @vedantrusty
      @vedantrusty  6 місяців тому +19

      agreed

    • @princygoswami522
      @princygoswami522 6 місяців тому +11

      She's was classically trained singer

    • @SS-xj4fs
      @SS-xj4fs 6 місяців тому +9

      She definitely did learn as Pandit Dinanath Mangeshkar’s daughter, though maybe she didn’t perform it often. There is one rare recording of her Raag Malkauns khayal somewhere on UA-cam.

    • @pratyushpavansaikia8161
      @pratyushpavansaikia8161 6 місяців тому

      @@princygoswami522 it's said in the video that she regretted not learning

  • @shaktichauhan7128
    @shaktichauhan7128 6 місяців тому +2

    माँ सरस्वती जी का अवतार लता मंगेशकर जी सिर्फ़ और सिर्फ़ एक थीं। उनके जैसा न कभी कोई था, न कोई है और न कभी भी होगा।
    उनके जैसा होना तो बहुत दूर की बात, उनके आसपास भी कोई नहीं !

  • @thewhitewolf2641
    @thewhitewolf2641 6 місяців тому +3

    Lataji is goddess
    She is the living roop of devi Saraswati

  • @austinwolf6592
    @austinwolf6592 6 місяців тому +3

    Bhai lata jesa talent Kisi ke pas nahi hai unho ne Apne talent ke base pe yeh maqam hasil Kiya hai unki awaz unka Andaz unka Kamal Andaz unki kamyabi ke wajah bani