The History of Middle-earth Box Set 1 of 4 - REVIEW
Вставка
- Опубліковано 11 лип 2024
- Box Set 1
US: amzn.to/3GIPk3O
UK: amzn.to/3NnC2gE
Box Set 2
US: amzn.to/3uQ4cuf
UK: amzn.to/48dYK2M
00:00-00:33 Intro
00:33-02:26 Unboxing the Set
02:26-03:41 Reversible Covers
03:41-04:49 Comparing to Illustrated Editions
04:49-05:42 Comparing to 3-Vol Set
05:42-07:26 Should you buy it?
07:26-08:46 Why Silmarillion & UT?
08:46-11:52 Final Thoughts/Conclusion
#tolkien #historyofmiddleearth #books - Розваги
Upon review, the Great Tales books don't match up perfectly with these on the shelf, so maybe we will get new versions of those down the line? I would certainly love illustrated editions of those as well! What say you?
Just buy every single Tolkien book.
@@Nagy.Patrik that's my plan lol
I’m finding that I like to have two copies of Tolkien books: one to read and get thrashed up and bent, and one as a display piece that remains on the shelf! 💪
Got my eyes on the larger illustrated books. The ones with the writing on the pages.
@@D3A7HS7R1K3 i just got the Hobbit illustrated by the author and other artists, i was shocked how big it is because of the notes and artwork. Didnt expect a small book to be this big.
They also put the Silmarillion and unfinished tales in the box set so the references Christopher Tolkien makes to them throughout the history of middle earth match up. Without the original print the later illustrated versions don’t correspond.
Love the cut edge on the box - makes it easier to take the books out.
That's a great point! Hadn't even thought of that.
Mine are still pretty tight in there. But it's great. I also love the flip covers. The only other time I've seen this was Star Wars: Last Shot - A Han and Lando Novel by Daniel José Older. Del Rey gave you a Han Solo cover which you could flip into a Lando cover. That was pretty cool.
Yes! Very smart touch.
Beautiful box set by the looks of it. Love the reversible covers. Would definitely switch over to the darker sides!
As a professional driver, I listened to the Hobbit, LOTR trilogy and the SIlmarillion on audiobook. Here's hoping some of these other books become available on audiobook!
Great review, Matt! I loved how you showed the differences between all of them. That helps so much.
Cool! I'm really looking forward to getting this!
Might have to pick these up after a read through of the illustrator Hobbit I just picked up! Thanks for the vid!
Looks like a beautiful box set to add to the bookshelf!
These look so awesome! So happy these are coming out and excited for the whole collection to be released! Funny i just asked you on the 1 million livestream how to collect the history of middle earth!
This will be a great way to do that - especially if you like having books all matching in style and condition!
@NerdoftheRings Thanks so much for showing these off! You made me decide to wait it out now haha! I am not the biggest fan of mismatch or the risk of buying used books in unknown condition for Tolkien books. I look forward to your amazing videos as always as I continue my early journey of Tolkien and learning from you Master Nerd 🥰
The cover of the "Unfinished tales" has the same cover of the "Silmarrilion" in Greece! Very nice video! Your videos are the best!!!!!
Thank you for this amazing book review brother ❤
The history of middle earth ilustrad and silmarilion ilustrad is incredible 😍👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽
Very excited for these!!
This set, but illustrated, would be perfect. 👌 I've been trying to find this overseas, but no luck.
What a lovely box set!
Thanks for doing this! I have the old DEL REY paperbacks of BoLT vol 1&2, plus the set coming out in April. While I have the paperback and illustrated versions of the Silmarillion, I don't have UT.
Awesome bro u got me wanting to get that set I just re read all the lord of the rings books soo good!!
thank you for this in depth review :)
Amazing video ! I just bought 10 Tolkien book of some guy. My first book collection I've bought. Hobbit, LOTR (All 3), Silmarillion, Unfinished Tales, Children of Hurin, Tales from the Perilious Realm, Roverandom & his biography. Can't wait to read them this winter !
Congratulations. If you haven't read them before, you're in for a ride 😊(and, well, also if you have read them before)
I bet.. Thanks ! @@fgdj2000
Nice books 📚 ❤️❤️❤️❤️ I love your more history videos good work Boss⭐️✊️
This is a really beautiful set and I hope to pick it up, thanks for the review. How much will it cost and why does this whole particular set all have The Fall of Gondolin themed covers? They’re beautiful but I’m curious if there’s a specific reason. Personally my favorite edition of the Silmarillion is the Ted Nasmith edition. I really love the layout, art, and paper quality. It’s too bad this set only has art on the covers.
I don't own any of the books, but want them. I'm considering the 2020 illustrated set, along with the other illustrated books. There's also a new collectors edition of the Hobbit, LotR, and Silmarillion coming out this year that are looking nice. There's just so much, I don't know what to get. I probably should get something more affordable, but idk. I kept hearing "if you were only going to get one set get this one!"
If you don’t mind me asking, which UK store did you purchase the Harper Collins set?
Thanks and great review.
Totally agree on Illustrated versions of all 12 volumes. And they need to be on good paper with sewn bindings like Illustrated Unfinished Tales. I would buy all 12 for sure. Looks like this new set has cheaper paper and probably glued binding. And I probably will not get them for that reason even though I want to purchase all the History of Middle Earth volumes for the first time. We did not need inferior versions of Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales in these sets either.
Totally agree with you here!!!
The editions of The Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales included apparently replicate the text and pagecount from their first editions, which are referenced throughout the HoME volumes, hence their inclusion here (as other recent editions no longer match). I see it as a nice bonus. I already own a recent edition with tarniquetil as a cover which is my go-to-just for reading edition (matches the 2014 LOTR&Companion box set)
Think I can see a trip to waterstones on the horizon 😁
Wow, looks way better than my History of Middle-Earth omnibus, which have the 2 volumes in black. Will have to upgrade.
Hi , i love LOTR and the whole world of it but never had the chance to read more than just the LOTR Story & the Hobbit , would you reccomend these for someone new? also is there any books out which will not be covered by these 4 boxsets you would suggest getting so i can read all the lore and story. thanks
Thanks for the video! Nerd, please Upload a video with the soundtrack you put at the end of the channel's videos. This track is very beautiful and you would make many people's day happier by posting it in full for us to listen to. Thank you.
Totally agree with you. Obviously, all collector's items and wonderful reading of Tolkien ranging from the Beast to the individual books. I do think that having the "smaller" and "portable" versions of these will add a dimension of adding more, and even younger readers of Tolkien. In other words, when my nephews come over, I'd rather hand them a smaller version of my collection than the Beast, you know what I mean? lol
I may have missed it, but would someone guide me better concerning the digital copies? Good idea there, if we're sticking to the portability factor...
Just got my box set. Same thing with book of lost tales part 1 sleeve misalignment. It looks like it was folded incorrectly but can be adjusted with careful precision
Are there any compilation videos of the Robert E. Howard’s Kull, and Conan books? They’re my favorite fantasy books. And Robert E Howard was a crazy ass Texan.
I'd love to see new illustrations based on these.
Also, the books in this box set have Unique Barcodes so maybe HarperCollins decides to sell them separately for those that don't want to double dip(silmarillion and Unfinished tales).
They look really cool!
The page number references in HoMe to Silm/UT don't match the recent editions of these, but the versions in these box sets will have the same pagination as the original editions that Christopher used to reference.
If I were flush with cash I would be getting these in a flash, but I'm already 2/3 the way through getting the Howe cover paperbacks for HoMe, so will (for now) have to focus on getting those. And I already have three editions of the Silmarillion, so hard to persuade on this one!
OMG they’re so beautiful 😍, are there any paperback versions with these covers? I like paperback more than hardcover.
Twenty years ago, my Ballantine Books Darryl K Sweet cover editions were....twenty years old.
I literally bought them in 1982 or 83.
Already have the big 3-set of 'The History of Middle-Earth'. Really digging the art by Howe on the new versions, though.
I kinda wish it didn't include The Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales as I too already own the illustrated editions.
This is truly a holy collection.
You talk about the digital version of these. Is The History coming out on Kindle?
How do you keep your books when traveling with them without ruining them?
Personally I got some pocket versions that I bring with me but that also keeps me from reading these versions.
Hey great content 😊. I am interested in learning more about that Image with the black cat; what would be the best resource for this??? 👀👀
Tevildo - google him and be surprised.
I think for me, which books I bought would depend on how the paper and fonts compared between the books. Small type fonts anymore just give me a headache. As an aside I recall fondly how thrilled I was pre-ordering "The Silmarillion" when it was coming out. Then waiting in line at a bookstore to get my copy once it came in. Fond memories. I'd love to own fully illustrated versions of each book as an aside.
Hi could you resume the 'maps of middle earth' for third age? thank you❤
The HoMe illustrated hardcover sets is something I wish for intensely! I want to match it with my current illustrated Tolkien collection and feel the other HoMe boxsets don't match that vibe. Would you say this new set tries to fill that gap? And does it live up to it? Love your work, keep going. ❤
Would you ever do something like a chapter by chapter read along type thing? Like every week, you'd make a video summarizing what happened in a chapter (maybe 2-3 chapters) of one of tolkiens' books, and viewers can read along with you each week! And then watch your video to recap the chapter(s). Especially with some of the denser books, this could really help people (: just a thought!
I can't find that illustrated verion of Silmarillion to save my life. Is it still on sale?
I've recently bought the Hobbit and LoTR set, and this new set would match nicely with them on the shelf
where did you get it from? amazon us has it for 140$ which is a lot!
@@alpalcn891
Directly from the publisher, Harper Collins. I'm not in the US, but purchased it for the equivalent of $80-90
I hope the Book of Lost Tales is made available seperately, will look nice with the illustrated versions of the other 2 I already have
yeah then your page numbers won't match up.
@nerdoftherings ive been looking at getting the full sets so been planning on getting the illustrated ones, but now these new ones are coming out, im not sure what to get.
Can you do afull list of which books are in which collections? Thats if you know what the next 3 boxsets will include.
The illustrated books are nice books, but I would just go for the box sets initially, and if you are really into them, you could always get the illustrated editions afterwards for collection/display purposes...
The contents of the 4 Box sets were announced at the initial press release:
Box 1:
The Silmarillion
Unfinished Tales
The Book of Lost Tales Part One
The Book of Lost Tales Part Two
Box 2:
The Lays of Beleriand
The Shaping of Middle-earth
The Lost Road and Other Writings
Box 3:
The Return of the Shadow
The Treason of Isengard
The War of the Ring
Sauron Defeated
Box 4:
Morgoth's Ring
The War of the Jewels
The Peoples of Middle-earth
Index
These are already on my shelf. they're nice. tho it seems all of these were printed with the lost tales vol 1 noticeably off center on the spine. illustrated versions would be really nice and totally expected (gotta make that chedder!) but i really wish these at least had the bookmark ribbons...
I'd like to see a nice index for the three volume of history.
Simply magnificent.
Just this last Christmas I got the illustrated box set of The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings, and I think I might need to get these history of middle earth boxed sets. I’ve never read any middle earth books beyond the hobbit and LoTR. I only discovered these because I was looking to get a copy of The Silmarillion. I will probably get the boxes instead of just the illustrated Silmarillion because I’d prefer the slimmer book.
They look amazing but that price point....oooph.
I do hope they re-release the rest of Christopher Tolkien's History of Middle-Earth, books 6-12 in updated paperback forms as well
I will never tire of reading all of Tolkien's works
I have a question : they aren't expanded or have new material? So if I have a 12 volume set already I will only miss out on the artwork?
if by 'artwork' you mean the covers, then yes.
Please, can You tell us something about binding quality (sown or glued)? Thank You! 😀
It always amazes me that these collectors book reviewers talk all about the art and the content but never the actual binding of the book.
Heck yeh! Answer to both questions. 🤓
Do you have all 12 of the history of middle earth books
I’ve never read any of the history of middle earth books… which would you recommend reading first? I do own silmarillion and the children of Hurin. Haven’t read them yet… Let me know 😊 on second thought, is Children of Hurin actually considered part of history of middle earth?
I find myself referencing Peoples of Middle-earth pretty often. Maybe it would be worth looking at synopses for the books and picking whichever sounds most interesting? The nice thing about them is you don't have to go in order by any means.
That being said, if you haven't checked out any of the 3 great tales, Silmarillion, or Unfinished Tales - I'd definitely recommend starting with those.
Thanks brudda! Appreciate you and your hard work on this channel. Keep it up. If only Tolkien knew how expansive his following would later become!
Read The Silmarillion before HoME. HoME will make no sense to you if you haven’t read The Silmarillion.
The tale of the children of Húrin first appears as part of The Silmarillion. The Children of Hurin book is a much larger, expanded version of that story with commentary and notes. Personally, I'd start with The Silmarillion and then Unfinished Tales and then go from there depending on what you are most interested in.
Nice!
Do these have a sewn binding? Thanks
No
Hold up i need to get the two books of lost tales
Already got the others
MOTHER F*****R!!!! I only JUST finished collecting all of the History of Middle Earth in paperback!
The combined 12 volume has the leaf paper that like he said is often found in bibles
Cool
So, are you from UK?
Very nice
I have a question. If Sauron won, if he succeeded in conquering Middle Earth, would he have tried to free Morgoth? Did he still see himself as a servant of Morgoth? Or would have he have gone all Sith Lord and betrayed his master?
He absolutely wouldn't try to free him. The only reason he took up evil again is that he missed being in charge. He was a control freak
Part Two being ahead of Part One in that box is triggering my OCD man lol
I would like to see a boxed set of Tolkien's other works such as Farmer Giles of Ham, etc. Illustrated by Alan Lee or John Howe.
Check out a book called 'Tales From the Perilous Realm.'
@@insurrbution Thanks!!!
Watch out bro they might send Pinkerton agents to your house for those books
Does anyone know what the other 12 books be in the other sets will be?
From what I heard not all of them contain four books. The remaining books will be the other 10 history of Middle Earth books as well as a book for the index of the history of Middle Earth.
That's a boss collection
Does it mean we will get a new LOTR movie or Nerd of The Rings episode; Eldarion and Siblings and Entwives?
Hello, I hope you're well. I have a question to ask. With Christmas approaching, albeit a tad late for that occasion, my father's birthday is just around the corner in the following month. He possesses an ardent affection for the literature found within the pages of 'The Lord of the Rings.' To be precise, he cherishes his worn and weathered paperbacks that have been a constant companion since the 1990s. I am keen on gifting him a splendid edition of 'The Lord of the Rings' in a single, hardcover volume, preferably one adorned with illustrations. Might you have any recommendations in this regard? Your guidance would be greatly appreciated.
Definitely want to see an illustrated HoM-e set. It would be great, too, for a new artist to show off their interpretations (as much as I love the work of the og trinity).
Not possible. Why do you think The Nature of Middle-earth wasn't?
Can you please make a video on why Gandalf the grey became Gandalf the white?
I've never read the History of Middle Earth. Is it worthwhile?
I would really like a pocket edition of the silmarillion to go with the Lord of the Rings and Hobbit.
👍
I’m looking for a full set of all published Middle Earth books that all match each-other on the shelf, like a complete set. Can anybody in this great community recommend one? Thanks 🙏
The covers of the latest german publications of these books were prettier. But given the English conditions, they are of course above average.
So the illustrated editions are better, got it.
Seriously, I did not know there where this many books of Middle-Earth. I better start collecting 😁
Wasn't the Silmarillion the first edition text?
Illustrated HoMe!? Yes please. I can’t wait to get these sets and finally piece my library together.
I haven't got a VISA card, is there a site where you can buy them with normal bank card?
Amazon.
@@pridan94 only visa cards :(
one down, 3 to go.
Please make illustrated versions of each of the 12 books PLEASE!!! 🙏🙏🙏
I’m a fan of the BBC audio books myself , but no in-depth analyses or reviews though granted
At least you stopped taking Ad breaks in the middle of your long form Ads. Great content, you've fully evolved into a late-night Blade and Jewelry hawker....
I think these look good for a shelf, but I hope the mass market paperback box sets continue for History of Middle Earth because I think paperbacks are so much easier to read
Paperback editions have existed for years
I'll pass on this set. I have it all covered by other volumes plus I dig the illustrated books.
It hurt my soul watching you turn the slip cover inside out
😍😍😍👌