"We Are One" (and John Lydon): Explanation and Analysis

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 вер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 58

  • @thinkabouteurovision2910
    @thinkabouteurovision2910 Рік тому +88

    I absolutely love how 50% of this video is talking about anything but the winning song

  • @escfan3878
    @escfan3878 Рік тому +61

    Jedward trying to be nice to John Lydon, while effectively saying his song was crap is one of the moments I will forever cherish as a Eurovision fan.

  • @naomileong6924
    @naomileong6924 Рік тому +35

    Knowing about the Swedish songwriter puts the We Are One the 2013 slogan jokes in perspective

  • @bacaliaros
    @bacaliaros Рік тому +20

    You just said everything in two lines: 'John Lydon doesn't seem to care about what his sex pistol fans want, and he doesn't seem to care about what eurovision voters want. He's just making the music that he wants to make. Wild Youth is making the music they think we want and doing a pretty bad job at it.'

  • @efraimgarcia7876
    @efraimgarcia7876 Рік тому +59

    Austria just revealed their song this morning, and I can't help but wonder how many requests you'll get for an episode on that one...

    • @overthinkingit
      @overthinkingit  Рік тому +33

      POE POE POE POE! (Not sure we're doing it yet but we sure do like it.)

    • @andrijacerinikolic7063
      @andrijacerinikolic7063 Рік тому +14

      What about Serbia? That is a material for overthinking it.

    • @robertlucchesi6947
      @robertlucchesi6947 Рік тому +4

      @@overthinkingit oh please do! There's some really interesting satire about the music industry, not to mention the way that it was leaked seems to have come from inside the house

    • @LeafHuntress
      @LeafHuntress Рік тому

      @@overthinkingit Do it! DOOOOOOOO IIIIIIIITTTTTTTT
      I'm Dutch so i naturally want you to cover our song for esc, but i'd like this more(or Czechia, Finland or Moldavia)
      Pretty please?
      I'll even forgive that you made that remark about the US metric system.

  • @draconiusultamius
    @draconiusultamius Рік тому +28

    Hawaii was a hot mess, but dang that nod to his wife with Alzheimer's is so sweet that it doesn't matter too much to me

  • @ChadIsYourDadlol
    @ChadIsYourDadlol Рік тому +8

    Serbia, Austria, and many others are bringing the overthinking it energy

  • @karagota
    @karagota Рік тому +3

    Looking from outside, this year's song of Ireland is refreshingly irish in accent and clothes of the artists, despite the generic swedish text and music. And the singer has some features which remind me Lord of the Dance's dancers. So I definitely like their song.

  • @jeffballmap616
    @jeffballmap616 Рік тому +46

    Classic OE; giving us an episode on a song nobody but they themselves asked for

    • @overthinkingit
      @overthinkingit  Рік тому +46

      Dude if we wanted to make POPULAR videos we'd do a lot of things differently.

    • @Lucian86
      @Lucian86 Рік тому +14

      ​@@overthinkingit lool..keep doing what you're doing. Love the content

    • @michaelkjellander9370
      @michaelkjellander9370 Рік тому +8

      ​@@Lucian86 Agreed, they got a loyal fanbase that love their content, even though the fanbase not that big. Keep it up!

  • @samthecloud2748
    @samthecloud2748 Рік тому +5

    PLEASE we need a Video of you about Austria and maybe Serbia? I think it would both of them fit perfectly here :)

  • @magnificentcatz1470
    @magnificentcatz1470 Рік тому +9

    Do one about FInland (cha cha cha) please.

  • @quaithe1
    @quaithe1 Рік тому +1

    I would really love to see you guys go back and do a video on Hatari. Nothing in Eurovision will ever be as punk again.

  • @Hitezaruki
    @Hitezaruki Рік тому +10

    I didn't know I need this video. Thanks! I didn't know a lot about John Lydon.
    I agree with the problem of Ireland's song, personally I like it, but it's just feel a song from the 2010's (which is good) but it has nothing special and it feels like a filler for the competition.
    But well, I liked more Brooke's song last year and SloMo was not my kind of song, but I think that one was better made to feel more unique and interesting.
    Well, I know you are busy overthinkers but I really looking foward for your next videos!! I would say this year we have a good amount of songs to overthink, so I want to see which ones are you choosing. 🙂

  • @fenzelian
    @fenzelian Рік тому +3

    That’s some real “tell don’t show” pluralism!

  • @arthurtyshchenko7336
    @arthurtyshchenko7336 Рік тому +4

    I hope you make a video about "Aijā"

  • @sophie3674
    @sophie3674 Рік тому +1

    I'm glad I ran into this channel, your videos are both informative and funny. I look forward your next videos, lot of good potential for overthinking this year!
    FYI you forgot to put the Croatian video in the 2023 playlist ;)

    • @overthinkingit
      @overthinkingit  Рік тому

      Thanks for the heads up Sophie. Lots more coming soon!

  • @rageguy311
    @rageguy311 Рік тому +2

    Whoa...
    So trips to Las Vegas for Irish butter?
    And what kind of omelettes? Denver? Spanish?

  • @annikania2682
    @annikania2682 Рік тому +4

    9:54 I adore how you already have decided that Croatia will win this year. I sure hope so, I love that thing and I am looking forward to vote for it (I don’t really believe they will win, but I sure hope so).
    So. About this song. I really don’t like it (which is critical, because my mom really likes it). It feels so. Sanitized. Like a middle grade book, easy to read for younger audiences - with a good message, but something that isn’t deep enough to work well for more mature people.
    And I don’t say a song has to be deep, necessarily. It helps, it distinguishes. But if the music is „good enough“ (in a very broad term), it doesn’t always need to be something you have to analyse first.
    But this song is BORING. It’s so… lackluster. It’s sad. It’s one more of the very mid-to-low songs this year. It’s the epiphany of non-offensive mid esc song.
    God, Blanka‘s song is more enticing, at least something is happening, baybah.

  • @rino09876
    @rino09876 Рік тому +2

    Wild should have won. Ireland should take an example from what Germany is doing this year and ensure that if they come last they do so with some dignity. Yes I've been mad about this for over a month.

  • @julesboag9927
    @julesboag9927 Рік тому +5

    Matt, It’s not offical, until it has been officially denied.
    GTPChat, what is the percentage of chance that you might have written this song for the Eurovision Song Contest?
    ‘As an AI language model, I do not have personal preferences or the ability to write songs. My responses are generated based on patterns and associations in the data I have been trained on. However, based on the language and structure of the song lyrics you shared, it is possible that I could have generated similar lyrics. Nonetheless, it is impossible to give a percentage or quantify the likelihood of me writing this specific song, as I am a machine learning model and do not have personal preferences or creative capabilities of my own.’

  • @nightmarecreature4489
    @nightmarecreature4489 Рік тому +1

    Can you do an analysis of Lord of the Lost's Blood & Glitter? Would love to see that

  • @maudzie93
    @maudzie93 Рік тому +2

    Someone's salty about a lack of salted butter

  • @aprilhoy4010
    @aprilhoy4010 Рік тому +4

    "...Lydon constantly strove to move beyond his punk roots." In turning into yet another tiresome old gammon I suppose he's achieved that much at least.

    • @LeafHuntress
      @LeafHuntress Рік тому +1

      I actually laughed out loud at that, scared the cat, if i had had one.

  • @TheSongwritingCat
    @TheSongwritingCat Рік тому +1

    The song was inoffensive. It's funny Jedward was judging as it sounded like something One Direction would have rejected. Glad you had an excuse to talk about John Lydon.

  • @patopaolo
    @patopaolo Рік тому +1

    I'm just afraid you guys will have to make a video afterwards apologizing to Ireland for underestimating them if they qualify.
    Yesterday at Barcelona Eurovision Party they did an excellent show.

  • @Dashew
    @Dashew Рік тому +1

    Please make one for Israel's entry. I keep finding new interpretations all the time :D

  • @proper_charlie2
    @proper_charlie2 Рік тому

    You could always switch to Country Life butter from Kerrygold - John Lydon advertised it on UK TV twenty years ago after all.

  • @Massev6871
    @Massev6871 Рік тому

    I'm Irish and I totally agree what you say about the Irish entry.

  • @jojoelio5537
    @jojoelio5537 Рік тому

    still one of my fave entries this year.

  • @escserg6731
    @escserg6731 Рік тому

    5:06 I'm very sorry for this completely off topic question, delete this comment right after answering (if you will), but maybe you know, does this video of Irish national final still exist somewhere? Seems like they deleted it from the official website.

    • @overthinkingit
      @overthinkingit  Рік тому +2

      Not off topic at all. I found the Jedward clip posted on a Jedward fan account! ua-cam.com/video/JEKpqAOXdAE/v-deo.html

    • @escserg6731
      @escserg6731 Рік тому +1

      @@overthinkingit Wow, huge thanks for answering! I thought you even had the full show but this is still at least something, it would've been really sad to lose that show completely, with so many ridiculous moments.

  • @fgb1929
    @fgb1929 Рік тому +3

    I‘m sorry Matt, but your british accent just sounds like an australian one…

  • @bi_smth
    @bi_smth Рік тому

    Well, what if peace *is* personal for Wild Youth?

  • @namenlos40
    @namenlos40 Рік тому

    Austria please

  • @martaschaper
    @martaschaper Рік тому +6

    Please react to Polish National final. Jann - Gladiator got robbed!

  • @andressac27
    @andressac27 Рік тому +2

    It made me feel like i was listening to One Direction!

  • @AngelGH_94
    @AngelGH_94 Рік тому +3

    I just have a question: Who The Hell Is Edgar? 🤔
    Please, overthink about Austria!

  • @EmoBearRights
    @EmoBearRights Рік тому +4

    Ireland should have picked the Enya type song that came second. Both Hawaii and We Are One are not good but then again I never liked Slo Mo.

  • @nsomandin5342
    @nsomandin5342 Рік тому +23

    How about making a video of the entire jann / poland drama, would be interesting to have a deep dive into that... thanks for your video's, you don't often find eurovision videos like yours :)

  • @CeeCee2960
    @CeeCee2960 Рік тому

    Long Live Johnny

  • @artemlyubchenko3022
    @artemlyubchenko3022 Рік тому

    Reminds me of a song by the youtuber Tantacrul combining the most common Eurovision cliches in one song, check it out, it's pretty hilarious