Rogue One: The Battle of Scarif - Data Vault Climb
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 жов 2024
- This is an alternate version of the data vault climb from Rogue One. In this scene, I replaced Michael Giacchino's overly repetitive score with the "Escape from Cloud City" cue by John Williams, from the Empire Strikes Back.
For more information on this fan edit, visit www.maple-films... or / maplefilms .
By far the best Star Wars movie in the new releases,they actually hired British army veterans to play the stormtrooper and rebel extras
The rebel uniform is base on the US military uniform use in Vietnam
@@franmadaraki616 its Russian army uniform. There some vietnam era flak jackets and some helmets but uniforms are Gorka. thesovietrussia.com/what-gorka-suit. Its afgan/russian war era.
@@moafu basically hodgepodge uniforms. Fitting for the rebels
@@pergys6991 yeah. But most of them have Gorka. On top of that is mix of gimme something that wil look cool.
@@moafu I think the gorka and Vietnam flak vest look is fitting; costume department did a great job
I was honestly shocked by how "easily" the Rebels were taken down.
And I mean, shocked in a good way, like "Wow, they actually show the Rebels struggling! Hello old days!"
Yes, a return to the Tantive at the beginning of Star Wars, when stormtroopers boarded the ship and decimated the rebel guards.
Yeah, just like the first scene of the first Star Wars movie ever.
Umm... the battle of hoth.
@@WeedShaggy oh yeah, can't forget that stomping.
@@WeedShaggy yeah but like everything in empire is great
I love how only 6 death troopers change the entire tide of a battle
Yeah proves how deadly they are
More like how shit the rebels are without plot armour/main characters. Kinda glad the MCs in this movie didn't have luke Skywalker level of plot armour.
Yes, idiot, they're highly skilled troopers and everyone are used to fear them the most. Sometimes, I really wonder how random people not knowing anything about star wars but just criticizing it(besides disney shit, we can all agree that it's shit) can be so stupid.
@@joshi2070 well aren't you a nice and civilised person.
@@joshi2070 So uncivilized.
they did a good job of showing just how brutal the war was for the average soldier
What if the us navy seals fought along the rebels
Darth Vitiate rofl 🤣
I agree and what i like is how no one is a hero there all just soldiers who are trying to save the ones they care about and just how hard they had to fight for. Such a small item
Ikr
@ Aidan J Lorenzana , the rebels are worse then the empire so
And people still say, stormtroopers can't shoot... Look at all those rebels without plot armor.
Thank you I completely agree
Too funny
The fact they survived at all is annoying. The moment those Death Troopers entered the fight, it should've been a wrap. These are the most experienced, elite, highly trained and funded soldiers in the galaxy during this era. They are basically the SAS being deployed against literal insurgents who are underfunded and under-equipped, yet somehow manage to pull through cause they have hope. Fucking Disney.
Not exactly. Baze and Chirrut are both believed to be empowered with the force to some degree during that scene, aka “the force wills it.” Do note that when the Death Troopers arrived, it was certainly a wrap. Every one of the rebels died as soon as they entered, except Baze and Chirrut because of the force. In the end, the Death Troopers were the end of the rebels and they did accomplish their goal. All of the rebels died in the end. Anyways, into the explanation
You can notice that the troopers were unable to shoot Chirrut while he was doing his chant and SLOWLY walking over to the switch, even though the rebel’s were running away and the Death Troopers were able to make their marks then. The force was likely making the Death Troopers miss as the force didn’t place any physical protection on Chirrut. Once the master switch was flipped, Chirruts role was complete and evidently the force let him die because immediately after a DT killed him.
The same thing happened with Baze. The force likely realized that if the DTs survived, they likely would have been the end of Jyn and Cassian before the plans could be sent. So, Baze was given the strength to press on and kill the DTs.
@@Slemoster What? they all died in scarif and the ones from space got attacked by vader's ship which made them lose a lot more rebels, what do you mean survived? did you watch the full movie or are you just a b*tch who hates disney's star wars?
The Death troopers made there enter like a boss
My theory is the death troopers are based off of the Nazi Einsatzgruppen. They would follow around superior SS officers and carry out war crimes, like executions etc. As you can see in the movies they do exactly the same.
@@granth9954 Navy Seals, not Nazi stuff like stormtrooper.
@@diddlypoop No, its based off of the Einsatzgruppen... George Lucas takes so much inspiration from World War 2, plus Navy Seals dont follow some high ranking official around
@@mh-60t Where is your proof? Because I got mine on several videos about the creation of the Death troopers.
@@diddlypoop www.history.com/news/the-real-history-that-inspired-star-wars
This movie made the Empire feel like an actual threat, a nice change of pace from Rebels
The Empire was always a threat. Rebels and those other shows dont exist to me. I prefer to have my imagination regarding side things of Star Wars.
@@Amp661 also the vader comics do the empire justice as well.
@@internetman- Crosshair and his new squad in Bad Batch were pretty badass as well.
Bad batch, OT (except ROTJ), the mandalorian, and R1 do a good job. Rebels on the other hand…..
@@OkIPullUp2915 In rebels they mugged stormtroopers too many times to count and the only death trooper action scene they get their ass handed to them.
Since the originals, I always felt the shots where the X-Wing pilots are screaming before their deaths extremely powerful. It shows that they are not robots, they are not spaceships; they are people, and they are going to die for what they believe.
And we really need the same thing for the imperial pilots too, they’re also people fighting for what they believed in
@Mark Omega Cow
@@moth8775 Only First Order troopers were trained from birth (or childhood), the Empire's Stormtroopers were mainly Conscripts and Volunteers that have the average training of a Soldier, not like the Clones in Kamino that are trained from birth, not the First Order who take children, brainwash them and train them, just ordinary volunteers like real soldiers.
ロマンナテ I don’t understand why some people in SW always judge people on what they believe especially people who believe the Empire you shouldn’t judge on who people believe in either if its beliefs or an country.
@@howardthealien2606 imperial Japan
If Director Krennic were a lifeguard during spring break: "Get that beach under control!!!"
DarthSquidward lol 😂😂😂
XD
Lol
Summer
I love the way when the death troopers arrive in the battle field they just casually walk off the ship. They're so baddass.
Can we get an F in the chat for the guy at 6:01? His name was Taidu Sefla and according to the Rogue One Visual Dictionary he was the highest ranking out of everyone in the group but let Cassian and Jyn have honorary rank over him. Then pinned down in blaster fire he was the first one to even attempt to get to the control switch,to even have the guts to face the most experienced soldiers in the Empire.
He even has a minifigure of him!
F
Wish they made a mini figure about melshi
F
F
When a spin-off is way better than the franchise.
@Diary of Deaths I think he refers to the sequels
Rogue one and Battlefront from EA are much MUCH militaristic and atmospheric than star wars shows and trilogies.
Diary of Deaths I like how you didn’t deny it you just stated fact lol
wayyyy better than the shitty sequels
@@timur5241 I've been really disappointed with Battlefront. I wanted a game as deep and complex as Battlefield. Despite DICE being involved, it's basically Star Wars Overwatch.
The Giacchino score is repetitive for a reason. It adds to the tension of the scene. I was literally on the edge of my seat during that part of the film, and the score had a big part in creating that mood. The repetition is meant to make the viewer feel anxiety and dread, and it worked perfectly.
Same here... I was so desperate at this point
It's similar to Dunkirk, that whole movie was so intense.
Do you think Giacchino will be able to do justice to other Star Wars soundtracks?
Both scores are repetitive; the runs are just faster on the Williams Score.
it's actually the notes of "dias Irea", which is usually used as musical shorthand to signify death. Michael Giacchino's score actually has a lot of meaning and importance behind it. see also; the main Rouge One title music uses the same notes as then normal Star Wars title music, but in different order
Some people say the Empire is weak but I am watching this and after the admiral says "take control of that beach" the stormtroopers start dropping and killing the rebel ground forces and taking out x wings. Also stormtroopers killed 2 rogue one members and the deathtroopers kill 2 as well
Yeah cause the rebels didnt have fuckin plot armor for once
jesus christ himself facts, the SW universe could be so much better if Plot Armor wasn’t a thing
@@confusedwhiteman7776 If it wasn't a thing then Leia, Luke, Han and Chewie would all die in ANH and that'd be the end of the SW universe.
Jovalin Yes.
@@jovalin5939 thats because they’re main characters, they need their plot armour until a certain point of the show, but the fact that most nowadays regular rebel soldiers have atleast the same amount of plot armour as darth vader really pisses me lmao
1:54 so cool how they insert the death troopers into battle
delta aron Except Baze.
@rapha7788 well if well armoured augmented men were flanking you would you turn to try and shoot them or run to escape even the ones trying to fight back were killed lol also edit they are behind cover firing in force while your forces are scattered in the open terrain they were attempting to run to the base so they could take cover
The thing that gets me is their body language as they’re about to be lowered into the battlefield. They’re utterly calm. Just standing in perfect formation like they’re on a parade ground, and they dismount like they haven’t a care in the world. Like it’s totally routine for them. Compare it to how the Rebels on the ground look even when they’re just changing position- hunched over, grim-faced, taut, clearly under the worst kind of stress imaginable. The Death Troopers are just...calm. Like they don’t even know to be afraid. It’s deeply unsettling.
@@_ArmIa good point and I agree...they probably have a high kill count being that calm lol
They didn't waste no time they was ready as soon as the door opened
1:17 I’ve always found it so menacing when the TIE Strikers sneakily form up behind Blue Leader. Even before they shoot him down, that shot fills you with dread as you realize how badly they caught him off-guard.
The original score is brilliant. If you don't get the suspense with the rebels being pinned down to the desperation in that data vault... you don't get it.
That's your opinion and you're welcome to have it. Personally I found the score in this scene to be obnoxiously repetitive. John Williams found a way to depict suspense and dread with only two notes in Jaws...Michael Giacchino does not fare as well here.
Maple Films you're one of the few people who think that way. It works for the scene.
It works for the scene...for you. It didn't for me, and that's why I made this fan edit. Some people that have watched the edit like the changes that were made to the music, and others like yourself do not. Regardless, it was a fun experiment on my part to try matching an existing track by John Williams to a scene that it was never intended to be scored to.
@@MapleFilms I liked having a different score for a change. John Williams is brilliant but Rogue One has a different genre and John Williams' standard Star Wars music doesn't fit or convey the scene. The music created for Rogue One was specifically designed to fit each scene while the Sequels just slap preexisting Star Wars trakcs onto each scene with slight edits. A different musician was a nice change of pace for Rogue One and really helped convey suspense.
It needed a good deal more work, yes. But some of these scenes do work REALLY well, all the same.
I often wondered as a kid why wasn't there a blue squadron, since it's my favorite color.
Nice to know they went down swinging and extracted the plans.
I now wonder where the other colored squadrons are.
I wonder if there's a Yellow squadron...
1:53 The sound of the ship is so badass.
yeah, I like the sound of the death troopers blasters
Ikr
1:47 respect that she probably steered into those troopers on purpose
After watching andor , melshi’s death hits harder
No lie, Death Troopers are the only infantry besides scout troopers in the empire that can aim for shit
Scout troopers can't aim according to the mandalorian
Lol, you haven’t seen the stormtroopers on Jedah in rouge one they cut down the rebels with ease and on Tantive 4 in a new hope
@@g59tothegrave exactly!!!
They can hit. They just always attack needed characters. Extras drop like flies.
@@g59tothegrave a bunch of inexperienced sailors against organized military. That scene doesn't show how good the stormtroopers are, they were basically going up against civilians lol
Just so people know, these rebels are the special forces, Imperial equivalents are death troopers. In fact most rebel troops we see aren't the rank and file soldiers but the best of the best. The soldiers on Hoth all have formal training and equipment, they are Rebel high commands personal honor guard, the infiltrators in Return of the Jedi are also special forces. So if you think the Stormtroopers are weak just remember you're looking at them fight the Rebel equivalent of Death Troopers.
And here we see how Death troopers stack up against Rebel Specforce operatives.... not much of a contest is it?
This was great. But I prefer the version from Rogue One. It perfectly fits the scene. John Williams was great, in in my opinion, Giacchino's score was amazing.
I totally agree with you all the way up until 6:00 minute mark. That song fits the scene really well and I would have like the original and this song in the movie as well personally
Ikr
True
Giacchino's score fits the more gritty tone of rouge one, John Williams sounds too fun and positive for a lot of the scenes, giacchino's is more reserved and its repetition matches the tension that the scenes have.
It’s repetitive for a reason. It’s the best fitting piece of music in a Star Wars film for me. The Empire music is just too serene. The Master Switch leaves you on the edge of your seat.
I like most of the changes you made. Well done. But I did miss Giacchino's score at the moment when the Death Troopers arrive on the battle field.
And when the TIE Reaper that transports them at 1:09.
Are they Death Troopers or Dark Troopers, or do both troopers have black armor?
Alpha Fairfoxs Death Troopers
It was one of the weaker scores, but it DOES have it's moments.
We need a series about a Deathtrooper Sergeant and his squad about how they kick Rebel scum‘s asses.
For real, everyone says they just want a Movie based on the Empire, or at least a show. Not like Rebels, they portrayed the Empire wrong. A show about a trooper and his friends in battle, or Elite Death troopers and the stuff they face. (Like republic commando) Or, just a game with a campaign that tells story’s of the Empire. But for some reason, we always get Rebels, it’s getting annoying. It’s so simple, people want stormtroopers, Disney has the money, but not the time. I hope they’ll make one in the future.
@@admiralpride7076 i know right its really annoying now, when i saw the battlefront 2 campaign i was so excited to see Empire protagonists, but then i was so disappointed later on...
@@cosmichorizon3273 “deceived by a lie,we all were!” But yeah, I was very disappointed when the campaign switched sides. Still a pretty “ok”campaign though.
@@admiralpride7076 agreed
Yes but Disney would never do that as it’s a good idea about Star Wars 🤣
2:21 "no good deed goes unpunished"
The score already fits the tone of the scene
i think the "repetitive" music conveyed the emotions of the battle the best... those desperate minor seconds repeating, heightening the feeling of despair and doom as the battle progresses and the rebels fight for their lives
It seemed perfect as it was in my opinion, the music fit the entire ordeal. I truly felt like the rebels were losing the battle and had no hope.
I came here to cure my eyes after seeing death troopers get massacred on star wars rebels
Well jedi make everything look like a joke.
@@internetman- nice excuse but still makes no sense. DEATH TROOPERS ARE LITERALLY SUPER SOLDERS.
@@paris5663 And Jedi are space wizards who can crush your organs with a thought.
@@ValentinoMarino11 and a funny child is able to knockout a full grown adult in armour with a rather light drop kick as he weights about what 120 pounds?
Repetitive or not, The Master Switch is a thrilling piece of music that adds so much suspense to that scene. It’s perfect.
We finally got to see what a Star Wars movie could be, since ROTJ. Well done, great choice for the plot, actually made the enemy formidable but not irrational. Made our heroes actually heroic.
I have to say I like the original better, especially the moment the door to the drop ship of death troopers shows up and the tone turns to one of likely doom.
In fact, the score was brilliant the entire battle, e.g.
1) The moment the X-wings show up to rescue those on the beach and kill the AT-ATs it sounds heroic and hopeful.
2) As more soldiers and X-wings die, however, it becomes more intense.
3) Once the Death Troopers show up, you feel a sense of desperation and imminent peril.
Funny, the windy data vault has a "Bespin-ish" feel to it. :)
We need actual WAR scenes in Star Wars Movies NOW a days
kyle price What do you think Rogue One is?
That one Asian anything to do with rebels is a terrorist attack, look at the battle of Mimban, that’s a real battle. But honestly, Rebels or Natives I don’t care, as long as a see troopers fighting for the Empire.
@@theshakespeareandoge2210 my favorite movie
The only star wars movie that shows how what happens on the battlefield you are NOT expected to live.
I think the original soundtrack of the film is *WAY* better.
Yeah
Yeah
Yeah
@@davindestroyer yo didn't expect to see you here
@@farrelariefatx554 hello there
5:53 "the switch is over at that console!" *soundtrack intensefies* goosebumbs
Honestly, I prefer the original. Its like a ticking clock, which was the point.
It got real when the deaths troopers showed and shit got serious at 2:21
I liked the music here. To me it gives you a sense of the hopelessness they are up against, yet they keep fighting. I thought it fit well with the scene.
The original, imo, feels a lot more tense as it should. It feels too serene in the edit. The music is repetitive to get the audience on edge, and it works
The fact you added the music to where Luke was hanging in cloud city was great
2:09 "when the Stormtrooper's use Hack for aim" DT: haha. hack..... hehe.....
I personally loved the music from the movie. It fit what was going on and it was reusing the same music over and over. It was original, just like the movie.
Anyone else thinks that the Scarif battle is just D-day but in Star Wars?
The Death Troopers were honestly one of my favorite things about this movie.
I love how powerful the death troopers are. Literally only 4 guys (Baze, Chirrut, Melshi, and Sefla) are even able to get to cover, all the other rebels die
What Disney used for this scene in terms of music really worked. It built up the tension in a major way. I bought the Rogue One soundtrack and have to give it a thumbs up.
Omg I am blown away with the John williams version matching so well. Truly a musical genius and proof that rogue one has the true feel of the original trilogy
I really believe that the editor(s) of Rogue One used Williams’s music as temp tracks. This one lines up too perfectly with the action to be a coincidence!
GREAT edit!
I like that Star Wars didn’t overuse the Force Theme the way marvels does with the Avengers theme
I really really love the score in the movie, the part where it gets repetitive sounds a lot like the dies irae over and over again which fits SO GOOD bc it comes right before lots and lots of death starts happening, I love it
In this battle scene, this just proves that experience beats training any day, I mean there were dozens of trained stormtroopers against only a handful of battle-hardened rebels, and yet the rebels were doing pretty well
Peake Performance you have to admit those death troopers were pretty badass
You forget the rebels have the special ability called plot armor though they were still perfecting it as the end of this movie shows
Rebels: uhm guys... what happend my plot armor? WHAT DO YOU MEAN ITS NOW REALISM?!
Bistan’s death always gets me. Hearing his little chirp as the ship goes down. Only 6 months in the alliance and he is killed.
You did really well AGAIN!
Well done!
You deserve it!
So much of this resembles the opening to the Saving Private Ryan intro…
And it’s badass!
The Cloud City music actually fits pretty well 👌
6:02 "IM GOIN" *proceeds to be instantaneously killed*
6:01 rebel hero wannabe
NaelDa Beast insted he got Rekt by a death trooper 😎
He thought he had plot armor! Empire will always win when rebels dont have plot armor
The king tried.
Gotta give him credit for atleast trying and volunteering himself while they were cornered
Dude thought he was Rey lmao
1:12 now, every time I defeat an enemy starfighter, I do a barrel roll through the cloud of smoke that came from the explosion of their ship in honor of General Merrick
Even though we knew the outcome this is still one of the most tense endings to a star wars movie
1:53 those TIE Reapers tho god damn
Looks like the Death troopers stoped working since Krennic dead 😐
Thanks for uploading this memorable scene. I agree with everyone who says the original score is designed to fit the scene. You can’t best serve the scene by injecting music that’s easier on your ears
I liked the U wing pilot I was sad to see her go but at least she went out like a champ and took a bunch of stormtroopers with her
The Master switch music creates such tension, it starts slow, just as the realisation that the rebels were losing, and created a more serious tone that there was an acfual threat instead of them having time to waste.
A civilization with ftl travel and their flash drives are the size of a baby
I feel like the Star Wars universe, for all its incredible advances in technology, must have missed the invention of the microchip processor or something.
Considering the vast amount of data stored on those drives...yeah I'd say it's reasonable. For example the Deathstar is a essentially a machine the size of a small planet. That's a bit of data to store.
Doesn't feel the same although the last one was repetitive yes I admit it's actually a common thing for composers to use a repitition device to build up tension within motifs. In this form it would be using the same note over and over but slowly increasing it with each moment. Think back to the classic jaws theme. It helps keep the audience in suspense because your prepared for something in your mind. The burst is coming because of the undertone of the music it also kind of makes you as a viewer dread whats coming and look forward to it at the same time so it keeps you gripped. The tensity of the two notes keeps you gripped and tensed for the scene but the buildup is really what your waiting for as a viewer. You can't wait to see whats next and thats how they get you hooked. Cloud city was a peaceful score because it was designed for different purposes. Every soundtrack drives its own narrative within the scene and a good composer appreciates this.
I love how Cassian looks absolutely terrified when Jyn’s about to jump. He really, really cares for her.
Always brings a tear to my eye seeing how many rebels readily laid down their lives in this mission, all of them knew the chance of making it out alive was slim anyway but it had to be done and it eventually saved the galaxy
Stormtrooper: *can’t shoot without aiming*
Death Trooper: Fine! I’ll do it myself!
Am I the only one that enjoyed watching that rebel general get wasted?
4:45 onwards....the music makes it all. Amazing!
4:52 - Good use of the original score there, the scene is almost reminiscent of ESB when there's air pressure outside of Bespin. Definitely like the Williams cues better here.
I like the original one personally.
Best Star Wars movie Disney has made by far, this is what happens when you but a real director on Star Wars
This star wars movie is the only one where all the new heroes die in 😢
Yeszzzzzzzz! Thank you! Seeing this only in 2024.
I will say the edited does fit very well and the swirling feel to John Williams song worked so well for that scene. And just the over all classic star wars songs mixed in felt really cool also applied appropriately.
I liked some stuff from the original. The silence at the one scene where we see the depth of the data room and hear the whirling wind.
I prefer the original...
Same
2:00 If The Empire used Death Troopers to serve in their military they could have ended the Rebellion in one night
Death troopers are commandos and probably wouldn't do so well on a battlefield
They actually hit their targets
Honestly, why would you replace the Giacchino score? Sure it's repetitive, it's supposed to be repetitive. Giacchino is reinforcing the DIES IRAE theme by repeating the first two notes of the theme while the Dies Irae ostinato is in the background. Giacchino uses the Dies Irae (the song of death) throughout the film. Jyn Erso's theme is literally the Dies Irae. Don't cut it! It's called foreshadowing!!!
06:00 so glad they used the same music as in "the empire strikes back"
I prefer the original music. The John Williams music doesn’t fit here because it doesn’t at all represent the chaos going on, and actually downplays the actions. Also the force theme playing just feels inappropriate
Favorite part
The second Death Troopers entered the battle should have come to a halt, they are elite and they highly trained, hell! They were drugged with fucking buffs to make them even harder to kill. No amount of force can stop 5-9 Death troopers lined up with you in there sights.
This is a masterpiece well done
Rise of Skywalker needed (among lots of other things) a massive battle scene like the battle of Scarif
This video still contains spoilers, as we see Stordan Tonc, Antoc Merrick, Taslet Colb, Laren Joma, Private Talwer, and Bistan die onscreen. In that order.
5:57 Jesus look at how many of these rebel elite Pathfinders got rekt by death troopers
4:15 I think John Williams music made his death more impactful
This feels like Vietnam. Half expected to hear Fortunate Son and Ride of the Valkries
1:13
RIP Blue 3 and Blue Leader
I think both scores work, however they convey different moods. The fighter scene for example has more of a dissonant serenity about it. Any idea when the full fan-edit will be out?
I love this rebellion spirit in this movie
Williams classic score fits well but I like the original. The first Star Wars film without Williams. They did well.