@@halodeer Well, IIRC, it was a self-insert fantasy in which he met his greatest hero, who showed him all the people he had beef with suffering eternally... Which isn't to say Dante is crap. Fanfic can be phenomenally well written.
I'll never understand why after basically getting rid of the incest plot line Cassandra Clare just felt the need to reintroduce it with her ACTUAL brother
I realize that the Shadowhunters have this weird thing against using mundane technology but a simple DNA test would have solved about 90% of Jace and Clary’s problems. And made the series about three books shorter.
The ships in these series are great if you ignore 1. the age gap 2. The incest (turned out not to be incest) 3. The harassment (turned out to be incest) 4. And the fact that Jace was very clearly meant to be with Simon. Otherwise amazing.
okay I wasn't expecting point 4 but you're like, absolutely right (as a Alec and Magnus shipper i am very used to ignoring the age, even though it is in fact, terrible)
@@Rat-ey It's a fantasy and fiction, it's okay to imagine things working out sometimes in fiction that maybe wouldn't work out or be possible in reality, and it's also involving a supernatural/fantasy creature that doesn't exist...he could be with a literal 100-yr-old grandparent and there would STILL be an insane age-gap present, technically! 😅😅🙃🫣😶🤭🤷🤷♀️🤷🏻♂️ Lol (Never mind the _looks_ that society would give that grandparent for being with this person they can't tell is an immortal 100+ yr-old warlock who only physically appears, like, 21 but sometimes slightly younger or older...depending on the day/moment.👀 😅 🤣🤣)
Jimon is such a good ship, like, they're so toxic to each other, but so passionate. I remember in the tv show there was a point where they were not exactly fighting and I was so sure they would kiss.
OMG when I read Simon and Jace chapters I was always like “he literally only respects Simon. Why can’t they just be together instead”. Lowkey least toxic pairing in this
The fact that Clary has 3 love interests and they are: 1) the best friend she grew up with, whom she sees as a brother 2) her adopted brother, with whom she actually ends up with 3) her actual brother Like that's a bit sus 😂
@@kodathepoet.if you recall in the first video, Cari said CC has a past fanfiction history? If I recall my history correctly, she wrote Harry Potter incest
And then like, when you get into the lady midnight, lord of shadows stuff, the main love interests are parabatai, which is kinda also incest in a way because parabatai with romantic love is wrong and shit
1:39:42 I'm only halfway in the video. And I think I knew where the Imogen-Jace storyline will end up from the dialogue. But this comment make me gasp. Cari already make a reference /hint 😭
Can we all appreciate the fact that I've read this saga like 3 or 4 times already and the moment Cari puts a video out I'm like "Well time to watch a 3 hour video about a story I already know😂😂"
2:13:57 “sebastian kisses teary-eyed Clary in front of the ruins of her house where her family was ripped apart and her brother was potentially killed” knowing who Sebastian really is,,, this scene was insane
I hope you do do books 4-6, because there are so many truly insane plotlines. I know theses videos are so much work but would love to hear your reactions
Clary being relieved that she hasn't been committing incest this whole time, only to instantly be told she in fact has still accidentally done the incest anyway, followed by Jace learning the truth about said not-incest because Sebastian wanted to clarify that he was not having an incestous relations with his father, but actually his sister which now makes it so Jace is in love with his sort of adoptive sister instead of blood sister, all while his adoptive brother from a different family is in love with him is so genuinely insane like.
to be fair, the parabatai bind is different than siblinghood; romance between parabatai is considered taboo, but not in a way that's necessarily healthy (the way it's healthy for incest to be taboo) - she actually explores this (parabatai romance) in one of the other shadowhunter series
PLEASE PLEASE do the next 3. Her books are so unhinged towards the end and your commentary is so perfect for the chaos. However, I feel like you can’t do the last 3 of TMI without doing infernal devices…it provides so much context for the 6th one lol
“I was never your friend, I loved you the whole time.” Ohhhh wow, that’s just… I’m assuming she was going for ‘romantic’ with that, but that’s just deeply, deeply sad. Imagine spending years thinking someone is your best friend, pretty much your only friend, like your whole life this one person is your constant rock. And then one day they turn around and go “nah actually, we were never friends, anyway, wanna make out?” I’d probably never trust anyone again after something like that tbh, that’s not something you just come back from.
Like, that first part, why would you say that... Why couldn't you her best friend and also in love with her, but like, in a way that you like her so much that you wanted to be around her, in no matter what capacity? Still unhealthy but so many people are in love with their best friends first. That just sounds heartless tbh
@@krussyarts he’s lucky he’s a genuinely fun character around the Clary Love stuff, because if he wasn’t busting out shit like “I have to buy you all Hanukkah presents anyway, it’s Jewish law. The god of the Jews is an angry god, and surprisingly gift-oriented” I’d have that boy burned at the stake. Still not ideal, but at least he gets over it relatively quickly. Glad ol’ Cassie knew not to let that thing linger
@@xLiLlyx98 I think that’s what’s getting me about it, yeah. “We were never just friends”, clearly you were from Clary’s perspective. Yeah, friends to best friends to lovers is a sweet progression, if it works out. But I’ve seen too many guys giving it the “oh my god, I acted like her friend for years and now she’s just slutting about with some guy, as if she’s not *mine*?” to find that behaviour cute or romantic, fictional or otherwise.
I kinda had this moment with a lot of my guy friends and it actually does burn. I used to have a lot of guy friends and would be friends with them for years and share secrets with them, then at one point or another a lot of them ended up confessing they were interested in me and after declining their feelings a few times they all kinda stopped talking to me. Now that I’m in a relationship of 5 years, none of my old guy friends talk to me at all. I recently had one guy check in and tell me I could always reach out to him, and then asked about my relationship. When I said my boyfriend and I were going great and went on to ask him about his life, I never got a reply. If I was in Clary’s position and had no girl friends to rely on I would have crumbled.
The Content Mother has delivered again. On another note, every character in the series encouraging a 17 year old to date a several-hundred year-old man is craaaaaazy
yess especially considering the fact that i started reading the books cuz of these videos. the actual actor for clary looks so much less like clary than cari does
I pictured Clary as having that more orange-ish-red hair (that I associate with the phrase "ginger," though that might just be me"), curly hair, and freckles. also a slightly wider/more oval face
I read these books ONCE in around 2014. I am surprised by how little I remember about the demon/shadowhunter plot, but how much I remember about the teenage drama, cringey one liners and overall emotional chaos.
My friend group split into parabatai pairs, we drew runes on our hands, we argued about shipping, and our names in the group chat were all characters from the mortal instruments universe for a hot minute. I barely remember any of the plot though.
opposite with me..i remember all the lore but complete forgot the plot..i did not even remember the incest-non-incest...my brain must have been trying to protect me
As someone who has read far, FAR too much marvel fanfiction, Jayce just absolutely smacks of discount dollar store Loki. And I mean that with every possible compliment and insult both
@maevem316 probably, lol. I really didn't mean to imply ms. claire had stolen the idea (the implied insults/compliments were towards the character), just that I was familiar with the character type and couldn't help thinking of Loki bc I'm a nerd
Blood is never kosher tho, it’s part of the horror and contradictions of being a jewish vampire, I don’t remember if that’s explicit in the books but I’m sure it was intentional since cassandra clare is jewish herself
@@camilafeitosa7743 that's really interesting! my family and i are not super strict about keeping kosher so i never knew that. also didn't know cassie clare is jewish!! still, for a jewish vampire, blood from kosher slaughter has to be a bit better than blood from non-kosher slaughter? or at that point would one just give up altogether?
@@camilafeitosa7743that is fascinating because blood and blood products are also forbidden for muslims to eat (in fact i live somewhere where often it’s easier for me to eat kosher than zabiha, the muslim equivalent, since kosher law covers more than zabiha covers) but we also have laws that state if it’s a life or death scenario, you must prioritize living over following zabiha eating. ie if you’re starving and the only option is, say, pork, you should eat the pork and live. ergo i always imagine if you were a muslim vampire and you would die if you didn’t drink blood, blood then becomes permissible for you to sustain yourself. are there similar permissibility “clauses” in jewish/kosher law?
I am so impressed how many cities of *insert word* the author came up with. Like imagine having to came up with different cool sounding cities for book titles and then also having to make that make sense in the plot
And then there's a prequel to "The Mortal Instruments" called "The Infernal Devices" and spin-offs called something like (iidrc) "The Unhallowed Relics" 'The Bad Thingumm-a-jigs" "The Deconsecrated Artifacts" etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc.
@@Mecharnie_Dobbsi like to imagine that cassie clare has a wheel she spins when she needs a new title and then she just bases the plot around whatever it lands on
I love that Cassandra Claire comes from the Bambi school of storytelling. Big dramatic, chase and the death of your mom-hard cut to 🎶lalalala don't worry🎶 singing birds and pretty flowers
As someone who read the first 3 books and couldn't stand to go on but still needs to know what happens in the rest of the series....please do the rest of the series this way, I love listening to it broken down like this!
PLEASEEEEEEEEEEE CONTINUE THE SERIES. the last 3 books are so unhinged theyre so fun. your reactions are so funny i love them and i wanna see u recap the plot!!
im glad u posted it because then i don’t actually have to read it which btw makes me so happy. i cannot read this whole big series, my mental capacity cannot handle them ❤
i don't think you understand how incredible these videos are and how fun you make them. I could watch a 10 hour video of you explaining the plotline of literally any book ever and i would live for it. Please never stop making these types of videos
1) I don't care what book you pick, just please keep making these multiple hour videos. It's the only thing that keeps me alive at work! I love these so much 2) everyone in this book needs a Dr cause it's not normal to black out this often 😂
I have no idea if they're canon straight, but Simon and Isabelle are so chaos bisexual coded 😆 Simultaneously accepting no bs and bringing tomfoolery to the story, love that
girl these are the FUNNIEST videos of all time WHY are you such a comedic genius. yeah please do continue with books 4, 5 and 6 because what else will entertain me. god's work for real bless you
I love how you pair Jace and Simon like the couple that never was through this video, anytime a love triangle becomes messy I also go, actually have we considered making the two love interests a couple
three and a half hours?? oh my god i can't wait to devour this video i appreciate the hard work you put in your videos so much, cari ❤ thank you for making this
I would love to see you complete the second half of the TMI series. Maybe even do the entire Shadowhunters universe so far (even though I know that will take you a WHILE!). Especially since Cassie overlaps plot points and characters A LOT with her series
@rica3947 yes of course, that why I said technically, but the rune should have hurt him and would problaby killed any other , I think it did not because of the angel blood he consumed in Jace's blood or because it was an special rune clary created for him
I’m cackling at the mental picture I have of Jace just being like “Gotta blast!” and yeeting himself out a window when the Lightwoods started asking how he jumped like that
i’m so sad you didn’t include jace’s line in the werewolf bar about wanting to be an angsty teen, it’s literally one of my favorite lines from the entire series
1:30:43 Valentine is obviously annoyed that Simon is alive, or that any vampire is, but then he realizes HOW Simon is alive, and he's unreasonably upset "Johnathan! You don't realize what you've done!" Erm, yeah, he's not the only one who doesn't.
Oh, please do continue. I think it's fascinating how Cari always manage to capture the essence of each character, especially Simon. This video alone ended my seasonal depression, i'm not even kidding. Now we just sit and wait for the other parts.
the jace edits tho ✨❤️ he’s killing with that sublimely androgynous look that dreams and aspirations are made of 👑 (and also his illegal amount of attitude lol)
I forgot how funny Magnus was. I remembered this series was high drama all the time and a bit unhinged but the meme choices and music make it so much better.
the herondales love confessions and way with words always get me in my feels like how they express about their love for someone is something i adore ALSO i would love for you to keep doing this like the whole saga if you enjoy it, it's so entertaining watching your commentary, doesn't matter how much it takes you 💗💗
The way Cassandra wrote that scene between Sebastian and clary with Sebastian knowing full well who clary was to him IS SO MESSED UP CASSANDRA WHY also i VERY MUCH hope you continue the series because i adore every one of these you make
I love these videos, because I haven’t read the books, but the Netflix Series is a guilty pleasure of mine, so I’m just sitting here like “Oh, I know what happens next!” Immediately followed by “WTF THEY DID THAT COMPLETELY DIFFERENTLY”
I loooove the show on Netflix but it's so incredibly inaccurate to the books they kind of feel like alternative universes 😂😂 both are still so fun and chaotic tho 10/10 would recommend
@@border_line.Much better!! You can see that her writing has improved and all the characters are generally a lot more loveable and as far as ik there’s no super weird plot lines
If you are willing to put in the work, I will totally watch you summarize the later books! This series is so nostalgic for me and I love these videos so much 😊 EDIT: Also my own out theory (aside from the fact that Cassie just hadn’t fully fleshed out parabatai) is that Alec’s unrequited crush on Jace hampered their bond because they weren’t on the same page. Parabatai are supposed to be in lock step, so when one of them is keeping this big secret from the other one, and their feelings for each other are mismatched, I could see that interfering with the soul binding a bit.
My favorite thing about these videos is Cari being an accidental cosplay of Clary 😂 i read these books as a teen and these recaps are hogwild thank you for blessing us all with this delightful content 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
The double incest plotline will always be wild to me. Also, do they not know about DNA test in this universe? Feels like it would solve a lot of their problems.
clary def would know of a dna test since she took her mom to a mundane hospital but im assuming the angel blood in them would mess up the results + it's technically against the law for shadowhunters to use human technology
Please continue, the rest of the series is so unhinged! Also, the rune(s) Clary changed in Valentine's summoning was the one binding/preventing the summoner from being smited. Love that for her.
So I think he was supposed to be a teenager, but funny enough that picture may still be pretty apt because I think it's Antonio Banderas in interview with a vampire where I'm pretty sure his character was supposed to be a teenager but was agreed up for the movie. Unless I'm completely misremembering it's been a while.
These videos give me LIFE!!! The editing, the scripting, all of it! Maryse as Moira from Schitts Creek is absolutely fantastic. And the insanity of books 4-6 need to be documented. *minor spoilers maybe??** The Sizzy stuff, Malec stuff, Sebastian’s weird ASS SHIT, and the connections to the other series are CRAZY, and they deserve their moment in a video. But only if your sanity can take it 🙏🙏🙏
i listen to these "forgot the plot" videos like audiobooks when i'm driving to work, and i JUST finished getting caught up on your acotar and crescent city videos. excited to relive the rest of this buckwild series!!!
I'm begging you to continue this series. I loved it as a teen and its just so unhinged and choatic in the last three. I'm living through listening to these and reliving all the moments
These videos are so fun! I love all your clips of Jamie❣️ I half expected you to add in those videos of him singing. 😂 have you seen him sing "Better Man" or "Waiting"?
Thank you for putting in the effort to make subtitles! I struggle to process spoken words without captions, so creators who put in the time to make good subtitles are my heroes
My honest hot take opinion here while I would enjoy another video I'd stop at the first trilogy your not missing out. The last two additions are just mediocre and forgettable and the final book in the saga is just bad. Its like a transformer movie but make it ya urban fantasy romance book.
Love these so much! ACOTAR was brilliant and hilarious, but this was even better. Am about to start reading Crescent City just so I can get the full effect of watching that one too. Can't imagine how much work goes into these - thank you.
Thank you for this, Cari! Unlike your Crescent City and ACOTAR videos (which I adore), this is a series I'm actually familiar with, and re-experiencing these books in this format was fantastic. I hope you do decide to finish the series!
cari, you HAVE to continue the series, please! I remember reading the books when I was younger but stopping at one point, and finally through your videos I got the motivation to pick them back up! Would be amazing if you covered as many books as possible (including the 'prequels' and so on! I love these videos so much, they make my days when you post
did i just finish a grueling 8 hour shift? yes. did i already watch part 1 to this video? yes. am i going to watch this 3.5 hr part 2 video? yes. will i be eagerly waiting for part 3? yes.
yessssss we’re eatin good tonight!! 🎉🎉 can’t get enough of this unhinged series 😅😅 2:04:05 ugh the missed opportunities for jace & simon 😩😩 2:20:49 “he has stapled an angel to the ground” was not a sentence i expected to hear in this video, or like, ever 💀💀 2:34:38 ngl, it was a pretty cool concept, if a bit predictable, to make the mirror actually a lake. from what i remember of the book, i actually liked the final battle that took place there. 2:38:48 simon coming out of left field & taking a big ole chomp out of sebastian was so satisfying 3:31:20 yes pleaseeee do books 4-6. i dropped off somewhere in the middle of book 5 bc it got so insufferable but i’m so curious about how the rest of the series ends.
i cannot stress enough how much theese books marked my teenage years and ive been wanting to reread them but was lazy cause remembered they kinda suck so thank you so much for this jasjsjajsjsajj i still absolutely love them
So excited for this one. Please keep doing these deep dive plot summaries! I love them and don't even care what book(s) you cover because I just know it'll be entertaining. 😂😂😂
If you’re able to do the second trilogy, I would be SO EXCITED! I’ve never been able to force myself to read them, but I want to know about them so badly 😭
You are doing such a service for those of us (me) who never finished this series but desperately need to fulfill their curiosity of how much worse Cassandra Clare can do
I'd love you to do the other books as well. I've read them all back in the day and loved them myself but I love the way you go over the plot. Very entertaining and fun! Shadowhunters will always hold a place in my heart
PLEASE keep going, your voice is so calming and I love these videos in the background while I do work, plus the way you joke and summarize these books is rlly funny
I cannot express to you how much I enjoy these plot recap videos. I ate them all up and your ability to summarize plots but also make me laugh out loud is truly amazing. I read all of TMI books on a whim over the span of a week a few years ago, and it's honestly such a blur so this is finally my chance to remember some of the story 😂 Please make more of these, you look like you're having so much fun making them and honestly, we need these good vibes videos ❤️✨
PLEASE CONTINUE THIS SERIES!!!!!! videos like this are my favourite to listen to at work 10/10 your voice and audio quality are also rlly good. this series was my life as a teenager.
I absolutely love your plot recaps! I've read the books 5+ times. I knew that Jace and Clary weren’t siblings since book 1, and waiting for the characters to realize it was pure torture! Knowing how evil Valentine was why did they believe him for even 5 minutes? 😂😂😂 also hearing the story explained outloud made me realize just how wild this series was.
PART THREE IS FINALLY HERE: ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
Thank you!!!
i love how the only scene transition cassandra clare can think of is to have a character pass out and then wake up in a different location.
I mean if Dante can do it in his Divina Commedia who are we to judge her 😂😂
@@camillatortorelli7986Dante walked so Cassie could run
@@ossswinfanfiction legends
@@camillatortorelli7986 not comparing the divine comedy to cassy clare LOL
@@halodeer Well, IIRC, it was a self-insert fantasy in which he met his greatest hero, who showed him all the people he had beef with suffering eternally...
Which isn't to say Dante is crap. Fanfic can be phenomenally well written.
That Jace fancam working overtime with different music to incapsulate the insane storyline is honestly giving me life!
Literally my fave parts of this video lmaoooo
[Jace does something insane]
🎶TEE-NAGE DREAM🎶
Loved it too! So funny!
i absolutely love it every single time it comes on!!
Period😂❤ super funny
I'll never understand why after basically getting rid of the incest plot line Cassandra Clare just felt the need to reintroduce it with her ACTUAL brother
:'''''')
"why not?" 😂
because she clearly has an incest fetiche
because she loves incest obviously. 🙃
For contrast-to illustrate the difference between the actual incest versus the thought-it-was--but-it-actually-wasn't. 🤷🤷♀️ 🤷🏻♂️
I realize that the Shadowhunters have this weird thing against using mundane technology but a simple DNA test would have solved about 90% of Jace and Clary’s problems. And made the series about three books shorter.
They have angel blood, so DNA results would be interesting.
@@mwont “Sir, why is your blood glowing?”
“…Aurora borealis.”
“In your blood?!”
“Yes.”
“……can I see?”
“…nnnnno.”
I KNOW, RIGHT?!!!!
The ships in these series are great if you ignore
1. the age gap
2. The incest (turned out not to be incest)
3. The harassment (turned out to be incest)
4. And the fact that Jace was very clearly meant to be with Simon.
Otherwise amazing.
okay I wasn't expecting point 4 but you're like, absolutely right (as a Alec and Magnus shipper i am very used to ignoring the age, even though it is in fact, terrible)
@@Rat-ey It's a fantasy and fiction, it's okay to imagine things working out sometimes in fiction that maybe wouldn't work out or be possible in reality, and it's also involving a supernatural/fantasy creature that doesn't exist...he could be with a literal 100-yr-old grandparent and there would STILL be an insane age-gap present, technically! 😅😅🙃🫣😶🤭🤷🤷♀️🤷🏻♂️ Lol
(Never mind the _looks_ that society would give that grandparent for being with this person they can't tell is an immortal 100+ yr-old warlock who only physically appears, like, 21 but sometimes slightly younger or older...depending on the day/moment.👀 😅 🤣🤣)
I remember being so flabbergasted about all that happened 😂
Jimon is such a good ship, like, they're so toxic to each other, but so passionate. I remember in the tv show there was a point where they were not exactly fighting and I was so sure they would kiss.
OMG when I read Simon and Jace chapters I was always like “he literally only respects Simon. Why can’t they just be together instead”. Lowkey least toxic pairing in this
The fact that Clary has 3 love interests and they are:
1) the best friend she grew up with, whom she sees as a brother
2) her adopted brother, with whom she actually ends up with
3) her actual brother
Like that's a bit sus 😂
3 is a pattern and I'm glad someone else sees it💀
@@kodathepoet.if you recall in the first video, Cari said CC has a past fanfiction history? If I recall my history correctly, she wrote Harry Potter incest
@@gracel2martYUP! she wrote a Ron/Ginny fic which was titled……..Mortal Instruments. not kidding
And then like, when you get into the lady midnight, lord of shadows stuff, the main love interests are parabatai, which is kinda also incest in a way because parabatai with romantic love is wrong and shit
It's Love square.
"Imogen as we will learn has a flair for the dramatic. Perhaps it runs in the family, I don't know" CARI 😭
To be fair every Herondale is insanely dramatic.
I came looking for this comment I'm SCREAMING
@@attystark9463that was my point lol
@@attystark9463 is that family a not so subtle jojo reference?
1:39:42 I'm only halfway in the video. And I think I knew where the Imogen-Jace storyline will end up from the dialogue. But this comment make me gasp. Cari already make a reference /hint 😭
Can we all appreciate the fact that I've read this saga like 3 or 4 times already and the moment Cari puts a video out I'm like "Well time to watch a 3 hour video about a story I already know😂😂"
lmao its an honor :')
Same ✨🙋🏻♀️
✨ Same ✨
💯 and I still listen to the audibooks😅
This is me!
Me, when Hodge dies: "Can't any of these goddamned people finish a sentence when telling Jace about his real identity" like for real
the jace fearless edits and the line "I've never been to England" made me full on burst out laughing. pure perfection.
The "speak now" bit too lmao
2:13:57 “sebastian kisses teary-eyed Clary in front of the ruins of her house where her family was ripped apart and her brother was potentially killed” knowing who Sebastian really is,,, this scene was insane
Right? 🫣
This is so f#cked 🙉
He was bold 🫡
@@CheesecakeIsLifee clearly 😭😭
This sentence itself was truly a ride as well...
I hope you do do books 4-6, because there are so many truly insane plotlines. I know theses videos are so much work but would love to hear your reactions
how did she think it was a good idea to keep going hahhaa
@@caricanreadcash grab 😅
Technically she’s still going with them. Weren’t we left on a major cliffhanger with Clary?
didn’t they literally have sex in hell at some point?? 😭😭
Yesssssss
You’re so right; Simon and Jace should have ended up together.
fr like what was that scene on the ship so hot for 🤨 lmao besides subverting tropes in the second book would’ve been so fun
Nice, ship all the boys except for the actual gay one 😂
My gay ass was EATING IT UP back in the day 😭😭
@@greenberry6019oh we ship them too👀
@@greenberry6019malec is a thing 😂
this video really opened my eyes to the untapped potential between jace and simon that went unnoticed in my youth and i thank you for that
im a big jamon shipper rn bc of this vid (never read the books, just knew of them and a little bit about them)
Dude! Sameee!!! For some reason I never noticed before😂
Clary being relieved that she hasn't been committing incest this whole time, only to instantly be told she in fact has still accidentally done the incest anyway, followed by Jace learning the truth about said not-incest because Sebastian wanted to clarify that he was not having an incestous relations with his father, but actually his sister which now makes it so Jace is in love with his sort of adoptive sister instead of blood sister, all while his adoptive brother from a different family is in love with him is so genuinely insane like.
to be fair, the parabatai bind is different than siblinghood; romance between parabatai is considered taboo, but not in a way that's necessarily healthy (the way it's healthy for incest to be taboo) - she actually explores this (parabatai romance) in one of the other shadowhunter series
Alex isn’t really in love with Jace so much as using Jace as a safe person to be in love with so he doesn’t have to find 6:33 a real love interest
@@annabelcrescibene4257 I don't know; Jace said that once but I think he was mostly saying that to hurt Alec.
You are doing god’s work with these plot explanations
we're trying :')
Surely it is Satan's work, though no less impressive for it lol
absolute poetry what@@CP-ll6qg
PLEASE PLEASE do the next 3. Her books are so unhinged towards the end and your commentary is so perfect for the chaos. However, I feel like you can’t do the last 3 of TMI without doing infernal devices…it provides so much context for the 6th one lol
I forgot the the second three grouping even existed omg Cari doing a forgot the plot would be perf
Infernal devices should be done first before second trilogy of TMI.
your wish is my command! ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
your simon/jace commentaries are SO right and true even tho i’ve not read this series
we were robbed of the best ship
She got me into this ship
“I was never your friend, I loved you the whole time.”
Ohhhh wow, that’s just… I’m assuming she was going for ‘romantic’ with that, but that’s just deeply, deeply sad. Imagine spending years thinking someone is your best friend, pretty much your only friend, like your whole life this one person is your constant rock. And then one day they turn around and go “nah actually, we were never friends, anyway, wanna make out?”
I’d probably never trust anyone again after something like that tbh, that’s not something you just come back from.
Yeah.. Unfortunately, looking back, Simon is suffering from nice guy syndrome
I like him, but Christ.
That line sounds so. Creepy. As well
Like, that first part, why would you say that... Why couldn't you her best friend and also in love with her, but like, in a way that you like her so much that you wanted to be around her, in no matter what capacity? Still unhealthy but so many people are in love with their best friends first. That just sounds heartless tbh
@@krussyarts he’s lucky he’s a genuinely fun character around the Clary Love stuff, because if he wasn’t busting out shit like “I have to buy you all Hanukkah presents anyway, it’s Jewish law. The god of the Jews is an angry god, and surprisingly gift-oriented” I’d have that boy burned at the stake.
Still not ideal, but at least he gets over it relatively quickly. Glad ol’ Cassie knew not to let that thing linger
@@xLiLlyx98 I think that’s what’s getting me about it, yeah. “We were never just friends”, clearly you were from Clary’s perspective.
Yeah, friends to best friends to lovers is a sweet progression, if it works out. But I’ve seen too many guys giving it the “oh my god, I acted like her friend for years and now she’s just slutting about with some guy, as if she’s not *mine*?” to find that behaviour cute or romantic, fictional or otherwise.
I kinda had this moment with a lot of my guy friends and it actually does burn.
I used to have a lot of guy friends and would be friends with them for years and share secrets with them, then at one point or another a lot of them ended up confessing they were interested in me and after declining their feelings a few times they all kinda stopped talking to me.
Now that I’m in a relationship of 5 years, none of my old guy friends talk to me at all. I recently had one guy check in and tell me I could always reach out to him, and then asked about my relationship. When I said my boyfriend and I were going great and went on to ask him about his life, I never got a reply.
If I was in Clary’s position and had no girl friends to rely on I would have crumbled.
2:16:52 “This is not her house. Those are not her plates.” you had me CACKLING the whole way through, thank you
The Content Mother has delivered again. On another note, every character in the series encouraging a 17 year old to date a several-hundred year-old man is craaaaaazy
no its okay alec is 18 💀💀💀
@@caricanread where does the “vampire bite” hickey fall on this timeline lol
just don’t think about it 😶😶
I think the whole are they siblings or not plot was worse💀🤡
@@v.a.l.i.awhat about the "dates and forgives their abuser" plot line in the second half of the series 💀
Please continue. The books just get more unhinged as they go on. It is beautiful.
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
Am I the only one who thinks that Cari looks exactly like how I pictured Clary while reading these books...?
honestly uncanny
What do you mean she's not cosplaying (heavy sarcasm)😂
My thoughts exactly. I love her copper colored hair!
yess especially considering the fact that i started reading the books cuz of these videos. the actual actor for clary looks so much less like clary than cari does
I pictured Clary as having that more orange-ish-red hair (that I associate with the phrase "ginger," though that might just be me"), curly hair, and freckles. also a slightly wider/more oval face
I love how simon’s storyline is “I love my girlfriend but she thinks we live in Alabama not New York”
I read these books ONCE in around 2014. I am surprised by how little I remember about the demon/shadowhunter plot, but how much I remember about the teenage drama, cringey one liners and overall emotional chaos.
My friend group split into parabatai pairs, we drew runes on our hands, we argued about shipping, and our names in the group chat were all characters from the mortal instruments universe for a hot minute. I barely remember any of the plot though.
opposite with me..i remember all the lore but complete forgot the plot..i did not even remember the incest-non-incest...my brain must have been trying to protect me
Who else can’t stop thinking about how her set up is behind camera? 🤣 I’m just glad she’s comfy lmao
exactly!!!
The pillow throne lmao
Can never unsee it now
Timestamp?
@@snowleopard064it's in the video before this one! there's a shot of her pillow setup in the intro.
As someone who has read far, FAR too much marvel fanfiction, Jayce just absolutely smacks of discount dollar store Loki. And I mean that with every possible compliment and insult both
I can honestly picture Jace having that massive grin that Loki always has and it’s sending me😂😂
If you’re talking about comic Loki then probably. MCU Loki didn’t come out until way after the first three books came out.
@@cindynguyen5661 i dont think they're saying cassandra copied marvel lol its just that they are similar characters
Considering he was (probably) based off the fanon version of Draco Malfoy, I guess it's just that bad boy archetype fandom loves in their dudes, lol
@maevem316 probably, lol. I really didn't mean to imply ms. claire had stolen the idea (the implied insults/compliments were towards the character), just that I was familiar with the character type and couldn't help thinking of Loki bc I'm a nerd
that blood they gave simon better have been from a kosher butcher shop. nothing but respect for my jewish vampire king
Blood is never kosher tho, it’s part of the horror and contradictions of being a jewish vampire, I don’t remember if that’s explicit in the books but I’m sure it was intentional since cassandra clare is jewish herself
@@camilafeitosa7743 that's really interesting! my family and i are not super strict about keeping kosher so i never knew that. also didn't know cassie clare is jewish!! still, for a jewish vampire, blood from kosher slaughter has to be a bit better than blood from non-kosher slaughter? or at that point would one just give up altogether?
I think they’d do that at least for a while but sometimes you gotta do what you gotta do probably
@@madie8769 Maybe, lol. Blood is "forbidden" to be consumed ordinarily tho, so I think we're gonna blow up trying to figure it out.
@@camilafeitosa7743that is fascinating because blood and blood products are also forbidden for muslims to eat (in fact i live somewhere where often it’s easier for me to eat kosher than zabiha, the muslim equivalent, since kosher law covers more than zabiha covers) but we also have laws that state if it’s a life or death scenario, you must prioritize living over following zabiha eating. ie if you’re starving and the only option is, say, pork, you should eat the pork and live. ergo i always imagine if you were a muslim vampire and you would die if you didn’t drink blood, blood then becomes permissible for you to sustain yourself. are there similar permissibility “clauses” in jewish/kosher law?
"The old incest distraction method" has me dying
WHY DIDN'T CLARY DRAW A PATERNITY TEST RUNE?!!!! Jk but actually they coulda solved this with modern medicine for like $130 USD
But they arent human 😂😭 i dont think they could just walk into a normal hospital lol
I am so impressed how many cities of *insert word* the author came up with. Like imagine having to came up with different cool sounding cities for book titles and then also having to make that make sense in the plot
And then there's a prequel to "The Mortal Instruments" called "The Infernal Devices" and spin-offs called something like (iidrc) "The Unhallowed Relics" 'The Bad Thingumm-a-jigs" "The Deconsecrated Artifacts" etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc etc.
@@Mecharnie_Dobbs This gave me the biggest laugh.
@@Mecharnie_Dobbsi like to imagine that cassie clare has a wheel she spins when she needs a new title and then she just bases the plot around whatever it lands on
This series is truly my barbenheimer 💛
😂🎀🖤
hey hi haha what does this mean
@@potatosack04like an event that changed their life other people say Roman empire or altered their chemisty etc
I love that Cassandra Claire comes from the Bambi school of storytelling. Big dramatic, chase and the death of your mom-hard cut to 🎶lalalala don't worry🎶 singing birds and pretty flowers
this is the best description of cassie clare’s writing 😆😆
poor Jace constantly being kept in suspense as everyone dies without fully telling him who he actually is LMAO
anyway I loved this so much!!
As someone who read the first 3 books and couldn't stand to go on but still needs to know what happens in the rest of the series....please do the rest of the series this way, I love listening to it broken down like this!
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
PLEASEEEEEEEEEEE CONTINUE THE SERIES. the last 3 books are so unhinged theyre so fun. your reactions are so funny i love them and i wanna see u recap the plot!!
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
im glad u posted it because then i don’t actually have to read it which btw makes me so happy. i cannot read this whole big series, my mental capacity cannot handle them ❤
❤❤❤
i don't think you understand how incredible these videos are and how fun you make them. I could watch a 10 hour video of you explaining the plotline of literally any book ever and i would live for it. Please never stop making these types of videos
1) I don't care what book you pick, just please keep making these multiple hour videos. It's the only thing that keeps me alive at work! I love these so much
2) everyone in this book needs a Dr cause it's not normal to black out this often 😂
I have no idea if they're canon straight, but Simon and Isabelle are so chaos bisexual coded 😆 Simultaneously accepting no bs and bringing tomfoolery to the story, love that
Don't tell me that I was literally wishing to watch the next video in this series this morning and it's here... thank you Cari T^T
your wish is my command :')
girl these are the FUNNIEST videos of all time WHY are you such a comedic genius. yeah please do continue with books 4, 5 and 6 because what else will entertain me. god's work for real bless you
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
I love how invested I am in this video series as if I haven’t been in this fandom for over a decade
I feel this!!
Sentences Cari has said: "He has stapled an angel to the ground."
I love how you pair Jace and Simon like the couple that never was through this video, anytime a love triangle becomes messy I also go, actually have we considered making the two love interests a couple
tehee 🤭 big supporter of just making it poly or making the love interests date each other instead of the mc
you would love the thieves series by Lexi Blake hahahahah
Yep! Ignore the axis!
the infernal devices ahaha
three and a half hours?? oh my god i can't wait to devour this video
i appreciate the hard work you put in your videos so much, cari ❤ thank you for making this
thank YOU!
I would love to see you complete the second half of the TMI series. Maybe even do the entire Shadowhunters universe so far (even though I know that will take you a WHILE!). Especially since Cassie overlaps plot points and characters A LOT with her series
Yes!! I def would love to see one for TID because will herondale has my whole heart
the way i would KILL to have a few shifts that i can kill just listening to cari talk about this
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
Should’ve had Clary create a rune to make Simon be fine in the sun. Would’ve been interesting development and practicing her powers
I think it would not work because clary(technically) can't put runes on anybody but a shadowhunter because It would hurt them and even kill them
@@jessicasanguino4814 in the end she does put a rune on Simon though, in order to keep Raphael from killing him, and it works
@rica3947 yes of course, that why I said technically, but the rune should have hurt him and would problaby killed any other , I think it did not because of the angel blood he consumed in Jace's blood or because it was an special rune clary created for him
@@jessicasanguino4814 3:09:30 since simon is a vampire, a type od downworlder, he can have runes on him
I’m cackling at the mental picture I have of Jace just being like “Gotta blast!” and yeeting himself out a window when the Lightwoods started asking how he jumped like that
i’m so sad you didn’t include jace’s line in the werewolf bar about wanting to be an angsty teen, it’s literally one of my favorite lines from the entire series
1:30:43 Valentine is obviously annoyed that Simon is alive, or that any vampire is, but then he realizes HOW Simon is alive, and he's unreasonably upset "Johnathan! You don't realize what you've done!"
Erm, yeah, he's not the only one who doesn't.
Oh, please do continue. I think it's fascinating how Cari always manage to capture the essence of each character, especially Simon. This video alone ended my seasonal depression, i'm not even kidding. Now we just sit and wait for the other parts.
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
would love to see books 4-6!! there are some absolutely insane storylines and would love to see your recaps!
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
the jace edits tho ✨❤️
he’s killing with that sublimely androgynous look that dreams and aspirations are made of 👑 (and also his illegal amount of attitude lol)
I forgot how funny Magnus was. I remembered this series was high drama all the time and a bit unhinged but the meme choices and music make it so much better.
I freakin LOVE how you refer to Jace as Simon's boyfriend😂
Clary:"His is my boyfriend Jace and my boyfriend's boyfriend Simon"
the herondales love confessions and way with words always get me in my feels like how they express about their love for someone is something i adore
ALSO i would love for you to keep doing this like the whole saga if you enjoy it, it's so entertaining watching your commentary, doesn't matter how much it takes you 💗💗
I'm so happy you briefly inserted the Taylor Swift song during the Fearless rune scenes Cari. Incredible editing as always!
The way Cassandra wrote that scene between Sebastian and clary with Sebastian knowing full well who clary was to him IS SO MESSED UP CASSANDRA WHY
also i VERY MUCH hope you continue the series because i adore every one of these you make
I love these videos, because I haven’t read the books, but the Netflix Series is a guilty pleasure of mine, so I’m just sitting here like “Oh, I know what happens next!” Immediately followed by “WTF THEY DID THAT COMPLETELY DIFFERENTLY”
I loooove the show on Netflix but it's so incredibly inaccurate to the books they kind of feel like alternative universes 😂😂 both are still so fun and chaotic tho 10/10 would recommend
the Netflix drama essentially took the characters some vague concepts from the book and ran with it and did their own thing still very entertaining
okay, hear me out everyone....
a plot summary of the infernal devices series 👀
also i love these videos so much😭💓 thank u for all ur hard work!!
That's what I said on the last video lol. I completely agree
Yesss!!!
I love TID so much ❤
are the infernal devices a lot better than this series? bc i was thinking of reading tid but am now…a tad bit unsure
@@border_line.Much better!! You can see that her writing has improved and all the characters are generally a lot more loveable and as far as ik there’s no super weird plot lines
If you are willing to put in the work, I will totally watch you summarize the later books! This series is so nostalgic for me and I love these videos so much 😊
EDIT: Also my own out theory (aside from the fact that Cassie just hadn’t fully fleshed out parabatai) is that Alec’s unrequited crush on Jace hampered their bond because they weren’t on the same page. Parabatai are supposed to be in lock step, so when one of them is keeping this big secret from the other one, and their feelings for each other are mismatched, I could see that interfering with the soul binding a bit.
I totally agree!
AGREED!
My favorite thing about these videos is Cari being an accidental cosplay of Clary 😂 i read these books as a teen and these recaps are hogwild thank you for blessing us all with this delightful content 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
The double incest plotline will always be wild to me. Also, do they not know about DNA test in this universe? Feels like it would solve a lot of their problems.
clary def would know of a dna test since she took her mom to a mundane hospital but im assuming the angel blood in them would mess up the results + it's technically against the law for shadowhunters to use human technology
Please continue, the rest of the series is so unhinged! Also, the rune(s) Clary changed in Valentine's summoning was the one binding/preventing the summoner from being smited. Love that for her.
Cari: Imogen, as we will see, has a flare for the dramatic
Me: well, she is a Herondale
Cari: perhaps it runs in the family
I'm crying at the photo of raphael 😂wasn't he supposed to look like 14-15? i love it
omg was he? hahhah i just thought of the older guy in the movie so i put him as an adult :''''')
@@caricanread yeah i think so, he was really young when he got turned
Yeah, came here to say this, I think he was 13. Should have been a pic of the boy from Stuart Little in that movie were he plays a child vampire
So I think he was supposed to be a teenager, but funny enough that picture may still be pretty apt because I think it's Antonio Banderas in interview with a vampire where I'm pretty sure his character was supposed to be a teenager but was agreed up for the movie. Unless I'm completely misremembering it's been a while.
@@mariaraquelfsthe little vampire. My sisters and I still joke about vampire cows. That movie was fantastic.
These videos give me LIFE!!! The editing, the scripting, all of it! Maryse as Moira from Schitts Creek is absolutely fantastic.
And the insanity of books 4-6 need to be documented.
*minor spoilers maybe??**
The Sizzy stuff, Malec stuff, Sebastian’s weird ASS SHIT, and the connections to the other series are CRAZY, and they deserve their moment in a video. But only if your sanity can take it 🙏🙏🙏
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
I looove these videos! You really have to do the next three, because years later I'm still not over JACE TAKING A CONDOM TO THE DEMON REALM, GIRL
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
@@caricanread!!!!!!!
52:37 'i am just a girl, standing in front of a camera, asking shadowhunter fans to be kind' the way i SCREAMED at that notting hill reference
i listen to these "forgot the plot" videos like audiobooks when i'm driving to work, and i JUST finished getting caught up on your acotar and crescent city videos. excited to relive the rest of this buckwild series!!!
I'm begging you to continue this series. I loved it as a teen and its just so unhinged and choatic in the last three. I'm living through listening to these and reliving all the moments
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
This is the one YA series I didn’t ever read that I always felt like I *should* read and I’m so glad you’re saving me from it
😊😊😊
A recap of the Infernal Devices would also be incredible!! Especially to give Brother Zachariah's backstory before City of Fallen Angels...iykyk 😭❤
Jace was sad so he tried to commit hate crimes against werewolves…. I swear to god Jace is the worst 😑
love yall!! also, im still working on the captions so only the first 40min are done sorry! I'm hoping to have them up by very early next week
I really appreciate you taking the time to ensure the captions are accurate!!! Thank you for doing them
These videos are so fun! I love all your clips of Jamie❣️ I half expected you to add in those videos of him singing. 😂 have you seen him sing "Better Man" or "Waiting"?
Thank you for putting in the effort to make subtitles! I struggle to process spoken words without captions, so creators who put in the time to make good subtitles are my heroes
My honest hot take opinion here while I would enjoy another video I'd stop at the first trilogy your not missing out. The last two additions are just mediocre and forgettable and the final book in the saga is just bad. Its like a transformer movie but make it ya urban fantasy romance book.
Love these so much! ACOTAR was brilliant and hilarious, but this was even better. Am about to start reading Crescent City just so I can get the full effect of watching that one too. Can't imagine how much work goes into these - thank you.
Thank you *so* much for this Cari!! Your hard work is sooo appreciated ❤️
❤❤❤
Thank you for this, Cari! Unlike your Crescent City and ACOTAR videos (which I adore), this is a series I'm actually familiar with, and re-experiencing these books in this format was fantastic. I hope you do decide to finish the series!
All of the Taylor Swift inclusions? Incredible. I absolutely adore your here's the plot videos!!
"I've never been to England" KILLED ME. fucking shot me dead the delivery on that was perfect
cari, you HAVE to continue the series, please! I remember reading the books when I was younger but stopping at one point, and finally through your videos I got the motivation to pick them back up! Would be amazing if you covered as many books as possible (including the 'prequels' and so on! I love these videos so much, they make my days when you post
did i just finish a grueling 8 hour shift? yes. did i already watch part 1 to this video? yes. am i going to watch this 3.5 hr part 2 video? yes. will i be eagerly waiting for part 3? yes.
yessssss we’re eatin good tonight!! 🎉🎉 can’t get enough of this unhinged series 😅😅
2:04:05 ugh the missed opportunities for jace & simon 😩😩
2:20:49 “he has stapled an angel to the ground” was not a sentence i expected to hear in this video, or like, ever 💀💀
2:34:38 ngl, it was a pretty cool concept, if a bit predictable, to make the mirror actually a lake. from what i remember of the book, i actually liked the final battle that took place there.
2:38:48 simon coming out of left field & taking a big ole chomp out of sebastian was so satisfying
3:31:20 yes pleaseeee do books 4-6. i dropped off somewhere in the middle of book 5 bc it got so insufferable but i’m so curious about how the rest of the series ends.
i cannot stress enough how much theese books marked my teenage years and ive been wanting to reread them but was lazy cause remembered they kinda suck so thank you so much for this jasjsjajsjsajj i still absolutely love them
I absolutely need this to be continued because these books are an absolute fever dream and I’m obsessed
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
So excited for this one. Please keep doing these deep dive plot summaries! I love them and don't even care what book(s) you cover because I just know it'll be entertaining. 😂😂😂
If you’re able to do the second trilogy, I would be SO EXCITED! I’ve never been able to force myself to read them, but I want to know about them so badly 😭
honestly you're missing out😭😭 it's some wild sh*t going on but like it's so good you can't stop reading them
honestly they're far better than the original saga!!
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
You are doing such a service for those of us (me) who never finished this series but desperately need to fulfill their curiosity of how much worse Cassandra Clare can do
I'd love you to do the other books as well. I've read them all back in the day and loved them myself but I love the way you go over the plot. Very entertaining and fun! Shadowhunters will always hold a place in my heart
Having not read these books in close to 10 years the amount of plot/lore I remembered SHOCKED me
Okay, haven't watched the whole vid yet but just want to reiterate that "forgot the Plot" is my absolute fave thing on booktube, ever ❤️❤️❤️
thank you :''''')
YES I NEEDED THIS SO BAD thank you so much for gracing us with this video series :,D
thanks for enjoying :'''')
PLEASE keep going, your voice is so calming and I love these videos in the background while I do work, plus the way you joke and summarize these books is rlly funny
I cannot express to you how much I enjoy these plot recap videos. I ate them all up and your ability to summarize plots but also make me laugh out loud is truly amazing. I read all of TMI books on a whim over the span of a week a few years ago, and it's honestly such a blur so this is finally my chance to remember some of the story 😂 Please make more of these, you look like you're having so much fun making them and honestly, we need these good vibes videos ❤️✨
PLEASE CONTINUE THIS SERIES!!!!!! videos like this are my favourite to listen to at work 10/10 your voice and audio quality are also rlly good. this series was my life as a teenager.
Truly the best Christmas present would be the continuation of this series! Love, love, love your plot summaries, so entertaining and hilarious
Carrie PLEASE continue the series! It really does get absolutely unhinged.
Here you go :) ua-cam.com/video/tq5mjahpl6Y/v-deo.html
I absolutely love your plot recaps! I've read the books 5+ times. I knew that Jace and Clary weren’t siblings since book 1, and waiting for the characters to realize it was pure torture! Knowing how evil Valentine was why did they believe him for even 5 minutes? 😂😂😂 also hearing the story explained outloud made me realize just how wild this series was.
YES PLEASE I'M WAITING FOR THE NEXT ONES 😭💗 your plot videos are insanely good! Can't live without them 🤞