Why Snape Never Actually Died - Harry Potter Theory
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- Hey everyone,
Welcome to another installment of Harry Potter Theory. In this video, we’re going to be exploring the possibility that potions professor Severus Snape never actually died.
We see what we believe to be Snape dying in the Deathly Hallows, after Voldemort thinks that he needs to kill Snape in order to become the true owner of the elder wand. We of course later find out that Snape died in vain, as he was never the true owner of the elder wand at all - and was unnecessarily killed by Voldemort. However, what was always interesting about Voldemort killing Snape was that he didn’t do it himself-he used Nagini.
"The Elder Wand cannot serve me properly, Severus, because I am not its true master. The Elder Wand belongs to the wizard who killed its last owner. You killed Albus Dumbledore. While you live, Severus, the Elder Wand cannot truly be mine."
“My lord!’ Snape protested, raising his wand
‘It cannot be any other way’ said Voldemort. ‘I must master the wand, Severus. Master the wand, and I master Potter at last’.
And Voldemort swiped the air with the Elder Wand. It did nothing to Snape, who for a split second seemed to think he had been reprieved: but then Voldemort's intention became clear. The snake's cage was rolling through the air, and before Snape could do anything more than yell, it had encased him, head and shoulders, and Voldemort spoke in Parseltongue.
"Kill."
There was a terrible scream. Harry saw Snape's face losing the little color it had left; it whitened as his black eyes widened, as the snake's fangs pierced his neck, as he failed to push the enchanted cage off himself, as his knees gave way and he fell to the floor.
Nagini ‘killing’ Snape, rather than Voldemort using Avada Kedavra-which would surely end his life- does actually leave the door open a little bit. Particularly as it’s supposedly Nagini’s venom that ends up bringing Snape to his inevitable demise.
There are a couple of things that support the fact that Snape may not have actually died, watch the video to find out more!
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @harrypottertheory
Please LIKE / SUBSCRIBE / SHARE to support the channel
Leave your video ideas down below!
Thanks!
Instagram - / hptheory
Star Wars Channel - / starwarstheory
Music by Juan Naranjo - jp@naraudio.com
All content falls under fair use: any copying of copyrighted material done for a limited and “transformative” purpose, such as to comment upon, criticize, or parody a copyrighted work. Such uses can be done without permission from the copyright owner.
Alan Rickman was so perfect for Snape
He was a wonderful actor. I adored him as the Sheriff of Nottingham, Colonel Brandon, and of course as Professor Snape!
Sadly he died from cancer in 2016.
A great actor
Seriously
Snape escaped death and continued to live among muggles as an actor with alias of Alan Rickman
He had to "appear to die" as this would convince everyone that his role was done.....
Letting him free to take a vacation at Disney World
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
😂😂
😂😂😂😂
Noice
He deserves it.
I've never wanted a theory to be true more than this one...
Me too💕
Me to BUT YOU ONLY PUT ... IF ITS GONNA BE CONTINUED UGH..DUH I’m sorry I miss him to 😢 I’m pissed 😡 that he died 😭
Eh, for me personally Snape is my favorite character in the entire HP series and I am at peace with his sacrifice and death........at least he can see Lily again in the afterlife, maybe even make peace with the Marauders finally.
what if Alan Rickman didn't die....
Snape is my fave >:
In the end scene
Bang : voldemort dies
Snape : ah muggle weapon
Harry : your alive
Of course I'm alive I'm a potion master
This is from HISHE right?
@@smitaberde2978 uhhhh
@@smitaberde2978 yeeee nooooo yeeee nooooo yes yes it is
That is why I love the "How It Should Have Ended"
Snape says
"I'm alive, obviously!"
*Umbridge triggered*
I have a question... Why didnt Dumbledore appear in the forbidden forest when Harry used the resurrection stone?? Can someone answer me??
And why didn’t Snape as well? #justiceforsnape#justicefordumbledore
Because he saw Harry at King's Cross. Since Snape was neither at King's Cross, nor the Forbidden Forset when Snape used the resurrection stone... maybe he didn't die?
yesss this is what i was looking for before i commented it🤣
Also Dumbledore admitted Harry is like raising acpig for slaughter to Snape which upset Snape.
Oh I did not see your comment and I wrote almost the same😅
Why didn't Dumbledore become a ghost?
He certainly has lots of 'unfinished business'.
Unfinished Business is just a Myth for Ghosts. In Harry Potter, Dumbledore didn't fear death, and in Order of the Pheonix Harry asks Nearly Headless Nick about the process of how one becomes a ghost, and Nick explained that he was afraid of death, afraid of what happened after you die. Dumbledore didn't care whether he died or not, he was dying anyway, and when Snape told Dumbledore he had around a year left to live, the Book described as Dumbledore acting calm after hearing that News, like he was ready to die.
yeah. dumbledore accepted that he needed to die by snape's hand. or wand.
to gain big V's trust to snape.
he lived quite long and i'm sure he knew that sacrifices needed to be made. even if it means his death.
he did what he can to help harry. and he did accomplish so much during his life.
plus, it would be very tormenting to be stuck as a ghost for someone like dumbledore.
Because ghost suffer eternally and dumbledore welcomes death
Because if he was a "symbol of Death or DEATH itself" he needed to conclude his earthly life and be in the Eternal realm for Harry to meet later.. .probably why we didn't see him in the Forest as a ghost like the Others.🙂💞🌎
Katherine Gallagher actually they weren’t ghost they were memories
Can we take a moment to appreciate how beautifully he narrates the chapter quotes!!
Can we take a moment to appreciate that he misspelled “From”.
That is from the audiobook actually...it's stephen fry.
@@LordTimCahill IT IS STILL HIS VOICE, NOT STEPHEN FRY'S VOICE. YOU ARE TOO GULLIBLE
Wouldn't Snape be in his own portrait in the headmasters office?
Yes, he was after all a headmaster at Hogwarts
Rock Paper Scissors:
Nagini beats snape,
Snape beats Neville,
Neville beats Nagini
Snape does have a portrait in the castle but it isn't in the headmaster's office. He was , after all, a long time teacher at Hogwarts. He just wasn't a very popular one in either position. His time as headmaster was less than a year.
Yes Harry made sure that he remains in the Headmasters office as an portrait even after he didn't actually resigned from his post
The portraits do speak even if the person they are a copy of are still alive.
I could easily watch off snape as a lead rather than Harry.
This character is so well written and most importantly Alan Rickman played it so well that it is remembered forever
Agreed. It's like watching the Star Wars and realizing Obi Wan Kenobi is more interesting than Luke.
I never thought Snape deserved that hideous death. As an adult I found it horrifying, how do kids process it?
Kids be whoa cool .they like gory stuffs
I found it pretty sad tbh
We could kinda say we grew up along with the franchise and characters I kinda
Like how they went darker as the cast got older and so did The audience
They don't.
They internalize it, and talk about it years later, with their therapist.
Or so I've heard...
Rowling adepted her wrinting to follow the aging of the original fanbase and main characters. Around book 4starts to use teenager thematics and in the 7 young adults.
Wait, if we pretend that Snape was the actual owner of the Elder wand, wouldn’t Nagini be the true master of the Elder wand?
Heh
And then Neville for killing Nagini. Super Carlin Bros already covered that
@@oshersharaby lmaooo did they already? i havent watched them for a while now.
Voldemort was very mislead lmao
@@acouch5618 you did what you had to, to survive. but boy do i hate you still lmao
No matter how dark Snape was or tragic I will always love him as a character and Alan Rickman made it perfect rest in piece legend
𝓐𝓵𝔀𝓪𝔂𝓼
Snape died with heavy heart . He is labelled as killer and coward before he escaped after the duel between Minerva McGonagall . Students of Hogwarts need to know he just sacrificed his whole life for Potter . Rip the professor principal Snape . You are alive in our hear .
Snape was the Jesus of the story
Died in late 30's
Lived a life doing the right thing, not many liked his methods, but dam was he talented
Couldnt keep the one he loved in life
And sacrifices himself for everyone, even tho a lot of them hate him at the time
@@donovanulrich348 ok i dont think jesus took over a school and taught people to torture little children
but yeah i get the message
@@rarewubbox6413 Jesus didn't take over a school or the world
But then again Snape didn't ether, he just listened to Dumbledore
And both had a father figure that they strived to live up to
And if you consider Voldemort the church. . . . Then the parable comes full circle
Jesus/Snape didn't teach evil, they tried to defend the innocent from the real evil behind the screen
btw if Snape was at the forest, it would have been the most awkward moment as he has to stand before 'James' and Lily. that would be awkward.
I bet it would be. ;-)
I wanna see that 🤣😏
MolbotUK me too
I think Snape is still alive, or died just a year before Albus Severus Potter's birth. Anyways, he did not die in the wizarding war at Hogwarts.
Snape had better things to do in his life than die prematurely
Them: do you miss him Snape and Allan
Us: Always!
*Cries in Dumbledoor and Sirius*
*Alan
I really want to believe this theory but JK already confirmed that Snape died 😫
:’-(
I would say that his ghost could come back tho, and haunt the shrieking shack-he didn’t want to die, he feared death because he still wanted to bring down Voldemort? Idk
True but if it was true who would play snape like Alan did. R.I.P:(
She also co-wrote “The Cursed Child” so I mean 🤷♂️
Dont really care what she said ^^ For me Snape is alive
You also have to keep in mind that Snape might not choose to survive. He has the skill and I can see him making a snake venom antidote and I can even see him having it with him that night. I could see him prepared to take it right after the attack, as he had yet to tell Harry what he needed to know about Harry being the last horcrux. However, when Harry shows up right after the attack, he has the ability to pass on that information. He would know that he no longer has to protect Harry, as Harry's time has now come to meet his destiny. He can also no longer serve as a double agent because Voldemort has now seen the need for Snape to be dead. Snape's missions have been fulfilled. His one friend that truly saw him for who he was, Dumbledore, is no longer on the scene. There is literally nothing left for him that would draw him to want to remain. At this point, with everything accomplished, I think he would see it as a release to be able to let go and be reunited with Lily. So while he probably had an antidote, I can definitely see him choosing not to take that antidote, even if it were on hand.
I just hope Snape never died I love that character so much and how brave he was ....
Agree.
Rock Paper Scissors:
Nagini beats snape,
Snape beats Neville,
Neville beats Nagini
He's never really dead because he's alive in my heart
All of our hearts
Sorry to interrupt but...
He's physically dead anyway....
@@alchemist6819 obviously
That’s a bit cheesy...
snape died when rickman did... I miss that man a lot
Me today being a student at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry: "Professor Snape, you are still alive! After all these times"
Severus Snape: "Always"
Didn't Snape say he could put a stopper to death?
that was just a saying, no potion can actually do that
I'd count alchemy's philosopher stone as involving potions
The deepest part of me hopes and begs that this theory is true and Snape is still alive out there. He is my favorite character of the whole harry potter series...
I hope he only ran away or something :((
New ending: Snape decides to grow a garden, he still lives on the memory of lily potter. Severus decides to plant some lily plants. He wishes to keep then alive this time.
Snape isn’t meant to still be alive. His reward for everything he accomplished was to finally be at peace instead of living every day with his heart torn in two.
he absolutely had an army of demons. i can't imagine him living a normal life. he'd have wizard PTSD or something. probably be on magical antidepressants and be talking to a therapy witch every Tuesday afternoon.
Dude invented Sectum sempra
And made it to torcher himself instead of lashing out at the marauders
Notice he dosent need a counter to the spell, he just blocks his mind and pushes the spell off XD
But still goes on to invent a counter for others afflicted by his own spell
I couldnt agree more that this was Snapes reward and we the Snape respecters love him for it
He finnaly can be with his one true friend in death
And tell her he never forgot her and never will
And since theres no physical connection, there's no human jealously in death
Yes you are absolutely right. The Reason that Snape was able to protect Harry was because he looked like James and always remembered him for his father. He made Harry hate himself because he was actually trying to punish himself for the fate of their parents. And once Harry knew the Reality,he would never have taken any of Snape's talks and comments seriously and would've been a bit awkward for someone who hated you for 7 years,suddenly turns out to be your original undercover Guardian. It would really have felt differently. So I think it was better that Snape died and finally met Lily
@@sauhamvyas7361 He would have punished himself for the fate of Lily, but he didn't give a rat's ass about James OR Harry. Dumbledore was disgusted by this. When Snape went to 12 Grimmauld Place, he even took part of a letter that just said "Love, Lily" and tore a photo of Harry's parents in half, taking only the part with Lily, not with James OR Harry in it. Dumbledore used Snape's feelings for Lily alone to hold him to raising Lily's son, to make up for what he'd done.
I feel it would be possible that Snape survived, and I would imagine after he fulfilled his duty to Dumbledore to protect the boy who lived, that he probably would start a new life. The man suffered, why would he want to stay.
Severus snape is a beautiful character... r.i.p
0:11
Snape: *ahem* Defense against the dark arts professor...
Bruh He teaches Potions Too
He was teaching potions in 5 of the books while teaching DADA in only 1 book and headmaster in the last book.
He was basically potions Master for the whole franchise lol
Following the theory, as you mentioned, Snape would need to take the anti venom before Nagini attacked. Therefore, was Snape frequently ingesting anti-venom every time there was a possibility of danger? I think Snape would have the capabilities of producing a permanent anti-venom. (I don't want Snape to be dead). RIP Alan Rickman.
Pythons are not venemous
Unlees stated otherwise, snakes of that size arent venoumos, they curl around the victim and breaks its bones. Killing by afixia or internal blood loss.
@@yoyoabhishek777 Tell that to Arthur Weasley. Also, the anti-venom already existed because of one having to be found to cure Arthur.
Best channel on UA-cam so chill and easy to just sit here and enjoy
Hp theory please reply and make a video in this
Was Dumbeldore willingly going to sacrifice Harry in deathly hallows or he knew that Harry would survive killing curse
He knew as of Goblet of Fire since Voldemort used Harry’s blood in his resurrection process
@@brambleshadeofshadowclan4249 yes but he knew about the prophecy before even philosophers stone so before goblet of fire dumbeldore was planning it I think but I am not sure so only I wanted him to make a video on it
@@Harish-pt7jl Dumbledore was willingly going to sacrifice harry because when harry met him at kings cross he called harry a "brave brave boy" which implies that he was surprised by what harry did so yea
Dumbledore explains at "kings cross" that he knew harry would survive.
@@lukedeloop7284 I think it was more along the lines thought Harry would survive he could never be 100% sure if his theory was correct. Since Harry and Tom's connection is a new uncharted area in magic so no one could say for sure what was gonna happen
Real moment of grief silence when you realise Alan Rickman is no more.
Yeah Snape was pretty smart, you would think that he would know Voldemort would double cross him.
Or at least be aware of a such possibility.
I love this video! And yes. It is plausible that Severus did survive. I also have an idea for you. What if Nymphadora survived?
Um they saw her dead body
Just sayin
@@brambleshadeofshadowclan4249 An alternate take. She hadn't died.
Joshua Preston oh right 😂
“Don’t call her that”
Likely not much
Hey! That's a wonderful thought.
He didn't die because -
1. The verb 'knew' could indicate that Dumbledore and Snape are not headmasters anymore rather than taking the more obvious meaning that they both have died.
2. As he was a spy, he wanted to keep a distance from both the order and death eaters, hence, he didn't participate in the battle.
3. Although, he might not have had an antidote because of the possibility that dark lord might use Nagini instead of a killing curse are very rare, still Snape could have definitely done something to claim hia title the half-blood prince.
4. He must be secretly looking at Potter with his patronus over the years.
5. As you rightly pointed out, the man of his credentials cannot have such a tragic, unworthy and precedented death. The thought in itself is too weary.
6. He must have gone to a place for settling his thoughts and retiring with the best possible ways of living.
Thank you.
Its certainly possible Snape could be alive, he is certainly talented enough and cunning enough. As you state the specific spell created by Snape himself for counteracting blood loss and his potion prodigal skill, as well as his cunning nature could are all considerably significant points counted towards Snape surviving. These points you mention are very interesting and story wise would make a lot of sense as its content developed over several books that we know about the character which all point to his at ability and capability to have survived this scene.
Me after seeing the title: "Don't do that. Don't give me hope."
This was one of the only theories which I personally had theorised and thnx for confirming it in a way but I think he survived
Snape’s love for Lily is what made Snape keep on protecting Harry. Snape is quite the mysterious character but I know he’s well prepared for the worst. Snape is alive; the writer may do a plot twist to show us this in further sequels. I hope to see him reappear somewhere down the line.
Snape was prepared for Voldemort to try to kill him at some point, and he was also capable of defending himself like few others could. In the books only Dumbledore is better than Snape. We can imagine that Snape may be an actual match for Voldemort. Remember, the book notes he had raised his wand, ready to defend himself, but Voldemort then does the unexpected and attacks him in a way that he can't defend.
As great as it would be for him to be alive, he did die. And, the reason that he wasn't in the forest was that he truly hated Harry. He loved Lily. He risked and the sacrificed everything for her memory, but he treaded Harry as if he were an an abusive step-father, who loves the mother but not the son she had with someone else.
dude thats cope snape long dead, he was better than anyone in hogwarts except for dumbledor BUT voldemort was on equal footing with dumbledor, snape wouldnt have lasted long against him
What kind of potion master does not have an antidote to a snake when his master has a massive venomous beast, besides if JK wants him alive for story (money) reasons he can come back
Like a Beazor(?)🤣
@@katherinegallagher9081 no not like a Beazor exactly one of those
James fry she doesn't need money 💰 she has already much but ye he said the he cond stop death
Even if snape could save himself he wouldn’t, he wants to be with Lily.
She is with another..
@@StevenMichaelCunningham
Maybe things change in another demansion
@@mohmedhassan6875 I have a feeling that is exactly HOW Snape eluded captivation of any sort. The sheer amount of time he spent meditative concerning being glib & whiney about his being glib & whiney toward Potter's mother for example.....
Snape's Patronis is a Doe
Only because Lilly's was a Doe
Like Tonk's wolf to Lupin's
James was a bitch, just not "evil"
And if he didnt take Lilly, then only the Longbottoms would end up dying and Nevil is the chosen
@@mohmedhassan6875 Nope
Snape was the coolest character in the series!
I imagine he's dead, but I can also believe that Rowling might have been slightly ambiguous in case she ever wanted to write about him again. I don't think she will though, because Snape living diminishes his sacrifice, which is such a powerful part of the story.
Shape claimed he could "put a stopper in death" had access and knowledge of unicorn's blood and tears from a Phoenix as professor of potions. these supplies could have been acquired from the school's supply, Dumbledore's office or the dark forest. yet none of the people in Potter's team or Shape carried these life saving remedies.
To be honest that always just seemed like a dramatic statement he was making to first years as he swept in with his long black robes and intimidating nature. I think this was more generally referring to a variety of potions/remedies that can halt/reverse the progression of different causes of death, like bezoars for poisons or a snake anti-venom. If there was a potion that could literally stop death no matter the cause, then it must have ingredients that are nearly impossible to get or incredibly complex, one-mistake-and-you'll-no-longer-have-eyebrows-or-a-heartbeat steps to successfully make it. Otherwise, everyone would carry a vial or two and no wizarding community member would die. If such a complex, nigh impossible potion were to exist, yes Snape would probably be one of the most likely to have some, but I just don't think it's likely or wise as a plot device to introduce :) Have a great day!
No I think, by put a stopper, he meant that he would be able to make a potion that could kill. (A stopper is a cork-like thing)
Snape is dead, the idea that he survived to really devalue his sacrifice. It was his final act of ending the war and repenting for his sins.
His ultimate Love sacrifice for Lily and continual protection for Harry
This. It’s the prevailing theme of the entire series.
Eh, I think it would have been better for him to live and get a happy ending. For as much bullshit as he had to go through, even being forced to kill Dumbledore - dude deserved to settle down. Surprised they didn't give him a scene with the resurrection stone where he talks to Lilly, finally lets everything go, and settles down with some cute weirdo chick.
Agreed
He would have died of blood loss though
Well... There's a large side of wants to believe snape actually survived. Reasons
1. He was a great wizard and a potionsmaster. He is one of the only few characters in HP who could prevent voldermort reading his mind, who was one of the greatest legilimence.
2. Being a very good potions master he is bound to have emergency potion to survive any situation. Also,
If harry can summon firebolt from the gryffindor tower in goblet of fire, why cant snape summon a antidote for snake venom from his study if he's not carrying one.
Also there is mention of a possibility of snape can transfigure into animagus as a bat.(when he flees from the battle with minerva McGonigall).
There is a possibility when he was recovered from nagini's bite, already voldermort was defeated.
Snape had a thing with the potters and at the end of the deathly hallows, if he was alive, i can perfectly believe that he could have lived elsewhere instead showing himself to the wizarding world exactly like there is a fan theory saying newt scammander lived as buckbeak.
Snape grabbed the front of his robes and pulled him close “You have your mothers eyes”
Harry: Yeah what else is new
Lmfao
"turn to page 394"
Ur right
He should have held Harry and said "you know i cant forgive your father, but ill never forget your mother. Many say it, bit you remind me more of her then him. But that hair cut" an just ruin the suspense on a hair cut line, cuz we know Harry's hair stays the same
It felt completely different when Snape said it. Because it was at this very last moment that he sees Harry has his mother too inside him. He hated Harry all his life just because he looked like James,but after all it was Lily for which he was doing all this. So when he finally looked at his eyes,he realized that his job has done and now he can meet Lily with proud
I think it hit the hardest when snape said it because you wouldn't expect snape to say something like that. plus at that point, harry didnt know how close snape was to lily so he was probably confused why snape would say that.
My theory is that Fawkes would have appeared after the trio left the room and healed him... at least that's what I tell myself to give some hope for Snape, and perhaps Dumbledore as well - to show that he cared about him, that he wasn't just a pawn in his huge masterplan.
That would actually make the whole thing plausible. I don't buy any of the other theories
There is a statement that contradicts this.
Fawkes was never hogwarts possession he belonged to Dumbledore. During dumbledores funeral fawkes sang his lament. He subsequently left after the death of his master and his ties with the school was over. Perhaps after that he became a wild phoenix again ( prior to when Dumbledore owned fawkes was said to spend his life as a wild phoenix)
hermione granger I believe it depends on how you look at things. Dumbledore was an incredible man and his connection with Fawkes was very strong and Fawkes was loyal to him. In this theory, Fawkes came back on behalf of Dumbledore to atone for all the pain he caused Snape, and gave him a second chance.
To me, it makes sense. Snape was perhaps the greatest wizard of all time or well on his way to being so and it would make sense given his absolute thirst for knowledge that he would just like to disappear and study his magic in peace. It’s similar to what Voldemort did when he went missing for 10 years. I want so badly for it to be true that he lived because he was truly the most loving character. Alan Rickman, God bless him, played him perfectly, giving him the depth that he needed and deserved along with securing the strange affection we all felt for him without necessarily knowing why. Rowling worked with Alan to make sure that he portrayed Snape in a way to show his true colors even before they were revealed to us. It’s a brilliant character development, more so than even Harry.
I would very much like to think that Snape had survived. I agree that it seems unlikely that he would be prepared for every contingency. He was extremely observant and had a brilliant mind. I prefer to think that he seized the opportunity to leave his old life behind and slip into obscurity. It's not like he had anything to return to anyway. If I had played the double agent and been the personal counsel for two of the most powerful wizards in the wizarding world for 13 years, I'd certainly want to live out the rest of my life in peace and quiet.
I like to think that as Headmaster he became close to Winky like Harry did to Dobby, and that Winky got him out of the Shack and helped him recover.
@@katv1195I love this and it's already cannon in my mind 🙏🏾
Snape is the best profesor at hogwarts🖤💚🖤 i miss him so much
My favourite character 💚💚
Same!!!
my dear , harry didn't see professor dumbledore as well when he used the resurrection stone . please don't say he is alive as well .
I wish Snape and Alan Rickman were still alive😪. I also wish JK would write a prequel on the story of Snape growing up from his own perspective.
Y
E
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
S
that emoji is for sleeping lol
I wish Snape was alive because he ended up being my favorite! His protection and sacrifice tore at my heart strings. He had to pretend to harass Harry or Voldemort would have known and seen through it all. Snape couldn’t ever show his weakness. In privet during occlimancy classes he seemed to have been less guarded. It was always in Harry’s best interest Snape seem put off by Harry. But deep in his heart because of Lily, he had care and concern he could never show. Snape being in a portrait though makes me think too he died. How else would he end up in the portrait.
The portraits are make before the person they are a copy of dies. So one thing does not necessarily mean the other.
@@mangawithsilverninjaneko1024 🤔 I’m not sure I understand
I want to interview JK Rowling why she wants to kill everyone in the whole series after the. Boy who lived when he survived
I’d like him to live but Nagini is a Boa !!! She’s NOT a venomous species!!!!!
Elizabeth Callan Or maybe blood loss?
Snape could stop sectumsempra! What's a snake-byte to him? But well, nagini was a special snake, and he had not much else t to live for.. ☹️
It’s possible that Nagini’s venom was an ability given to her as a result of being a horcrux. Especially when in the fifth book when Arthur Weasley is getting treatment for Nagini’s bite, and St. Mungos is having trouble with coming up with an anecdote for the venom in the bite.
That's a movie mistake. In the books, she was venomous but her species was never mentioned. The movies should have portrayed her as a random venomous species.
I assume you are talking about Nagini in the movies.
If so the model looks more like Phyton than a Boa to me. Although Nagini is depicted way bigger than any Python or Boa in the real world is. Bigger as in heavier not longer percee although she totally is longer than most pythons. She could definitely be a part of that family of snakes if the appearance is anything to go by. However I don't know of any species of snakes that are as big as Nagine has been depicted in the movies. My point is even if in a movie something is inspired by real world animals doesn't mean they are that animal.
The books tell us that Nagini's poison is highly potent, very dangerous, deadly and possibly infused with dark magic. So that means that canonically she is venomous.
That said the Harry Potter canon is stil that the Harry Potter Canon who knows what JK will say next week. So yeah you could be right.
I'm a writer and I know everything in a movie or novel is there on purpose. When Snape's introduction mentioned "putting a stopper in death" had a purpose. I completely agree with you.
I think it's kind of pointless to theorise this. There was nothing left for Snape in the world. He had done all he had set out to do, and now was his time to rest.
Yeah, no I cannot get behind this theory (as much as I would have liked it to be true.) I confess that I wish there was a scene where Harry later returns to the forbidden forest and finds the resurrection stone simply to destroy it for good measure instead of leaving it to chance that no one stumbles on it accidentally (considering it still has the insignia on it that would identify it as the resurrection stone) A scene where Harry calls forth the spirit of Snape simply to say thank you. Even if it's a scene marred by undertones of continued contempt, a sort of echo of the long standing animosity. Maybe it could be the day/ week Albus was born. Though I suppose it's a good life lesson to say what you mean and mean what you say, because tomorrow is never a guarantee. Leave nothing meaningful unsaid lest you lose the chance forever.
Everybody hated him the whole series and at the end they love him. It hurts me in the beginning of the second book how ron was saying that maybe he got sacked since everybody hates him and it made me cry
we all agree that he still forever live in our heart
biggest sin of this movies is : they didnt find the actress with the same eye color like harry, sinse they say this thousend times true the series/ you have ur mothers eyes...NOOOO HE HAVENT
His mother in the movies had blue eyes from what I remember
@@myduckingself7938 adult have diferent eyes too
Adult Lilly did have blue eyes. Child Lilly unconsciously used magic to temporarily change her eye color to brown.
P.S.: Why didn’t they fix it in the DVD? What are they payed for?
I read online that the Actress that playd Lilly had the green eyes that she was supposed to have. And Daniel was supposed to use lenses to change his eye color to green. But he had an alergic reaction to them so he couldn't use them. So that's why they don't have the same eye color. But originaly she had green eyes. That's what i've read multiple times online so i don't know...
it`s magic dude, we muggles don`t see it but they are the same :)
I also believe that Snape's alive given the argument also think that what Snape told his students in his first class
I can teach you how to
Bewitch the mind and ensnare the senses
I can tell you how to bottle fame Brew Glory and even
Put a stopper in death
If he can teach 11 year olds to survive from near death its quite reasonable to think that he can do it himself
That would be pretty cool, but this isn't the MCU.
‘Put a stopper in death’ means put a lid on the potion bottle, not stop death.
To be honest, Snape got a portrait in the headmaster's room, so he's dead and it's proven.
@@LIAurora2267 He SHOULD have a portrait in the headmaster's office, but IIRC, it's never mentioned in the book, or shown in the movie.
@@PhilBagels then I just assume you didn't even read HP the cursed child
In orde of the phoenix, when Hagrid teached about Thestrals, he "sees 2 other thestrals coming". This means he has seen somebody been murdered, but who?
Hagrid was in the order of the Phoenix a long time ago before Voldemort vanished.
So it is likely that he saw someone die
@@itsrainstorm_ Also his father most likely. since it doesn't have to be murder.
But if you remember hagrid was in Hogwarts when his father died
When he was with the giants he saw several giants get killed.
One doesn't have to witness a murder to see thestrals, only see someone die. As a member of the Order of the Phoenix, Hagrid has probably wtinessed more than his share of deaths.
If Severus did survive, Harry should make Severus his son's Godfather.
I doubt Snape is gonna wanna look after another Potter boy lmao
@•Jaida Salem• True 😂
Personally I think Snape is, probably, still alive. I mean, there are clues in the first few moments of Snape's involvement with Harry Potter. Remember that he told his students on day 1: "There will be no foolish wand waving or silly incantations in the class. As such I don't expect most of you to appreciate the subtle science and exact art that is....potion making. But for the select few, who possess the predisposition....I can teach you how to bewitch the mind and ensnare the senses. I can show you how to brew Glory, bottle Fame, and even put a stopper....in Death!" (recited from memory by me) Was he just bragging? Or could he really reverse or "stopper" death, in certain circumstances?
I think it is entirely possible that Snape took an anti-venom specifically to guard against Nagini. As you pointed out, when he thought Voldemort was going to curse him directly, he raised his wand. Perhaps he thought that he'd found a way to negate the Killing curse as well? We know that is possible, because Dumbledore has done it. Perhaps Voldemort ALSO thought this likely, and didn't want to "risk" a duel with another of the most powerful Wizards alive; especially as his faith in the Elder Wand's power was shaken. Hence he struck through Nagini, rather than his preferred method of Avada Kedavra.
Hi who ever see’s this have a blessed day and the rest of your life
Bender
Thank you, you too!
Thanks don’t remind me about death ik it’s not you but I appreciate it
Thx ... same to you xx
Desperate for likes🙄
Video suggestion: What if James never saved Snape from Lupin?
Hey, Would you elaborate on that please? I haven't read the books. Was it shown in the movies?
@@ikaros9727 well, sirius told snape how to freeze the womping willow so he could go into it and find a werewolf lupin (ofc it was just a joke) because snape was very nosy about it. When James realised what sirius did, he went and saved snape before lupin could turn him into a werewolf but snape always thought that James potter only did it so that he would never get expelled.
Jvitesh Yup. Simpler, in fifth year, Sirius told Snape to go find Lupin and if he had he would’ve been killed by Lupin in his werewolf form, but James stopped him.
As you know, the Marauders continuously bullied Snape (most of the time for not reason at all) as a result, Snape started to spy on them, hoping to catch them breaking the rules (which the 4 did all the time) so that he could report them and eventually get them expelled.
As a result, the 4 bullied him some more, because they considered him a wet blanket, spoiling their fun.
At the day in question, he was following them again, ( he had observed their strange behaviour around full moon).
So, Sirius ( who even in adult life struck me as hotheaded and irresponsible) lured Snape into the passage towards the Shrieking shack where Lupin was transforming . Things could have got really bad for Snape- injured or killed.
At the last moment James realised S's death could get them into serious trouble , so he hurried to save him, at the same time threatening S into keeping quiet about the whole thing.
Snape never forgot the incident. It made him twice bitter 1. The 4 put his life in danger in the first place.
2. He loathed the fact that he owed his life to James- his worst enemy.
Snape would have died and James, Sirius, Lupin, and Wormtail would have most likely been expelled for it (and probably been sent to Azkaban for good measure). Lily and James don't get together, and thus Harry is never born. Voldemort reigns supreme (either that or Neville would be the Chosen One to deal with Voldemort instead).
I AGREE!! Kinda thought this all along. JK could do a follow-up book, putting the world back together.
everyone in the comments: first!!
me: *alright, you can't all be first...*
Fun fact: only 1% of ‘First!’ Comments are accurate.
DatNyanKittyKat so your telling me if there's 200 comments 2 people are first?
5monkey55 Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmnooooooooo🧐
FORTH REPLY!
Time turner says otherwise
I mean he *IS* the options master and he *IS* a slytharin so as a slytharin I'd ALWAYS have an anti venom especially when there's slytharins that I'm working with
Great video! I love how even Snape's death is enigmatic and open to debate. Such a brilliant character!!!
Let us also remember that the first encounter in the movie ( and book as well if i recall right ) with Snape in the class , he clearly states the following: " I can teach you how to bewitch the mind and ensnare the senses. I can tell you how to bottle fame, brew glory, and even put a stopper in death. "
So he basically states that he can cheat various deaths through probably very complex potions. I dont know about others but I personally would've kept such a life-saving vial with me in such dark times. Snape seemed to carry vials with him anyway, like the vertitaserum , after all he's a potion master.
No, no you are still holding on LET GO!
Let the past die! Kill it, if you have to.
Ren
I understood that referrence
NEVER
I think it would be really cool if Snape was still alive. It could make for some great stories. But alas, this is not the MCU.
Nagini having venom makes no sense to me considering she's a python, it probably bothers me more than it should 😂
I want him to still be alive, so yes. I agree that this is theory is very plausible! And, thank you for giving me back my favorite character! Now, he's not dead!
After this video, I think I can watch this movie series again.
When I thought Snape died, I was done with Harry Potter. Now with the thought of my FAVORITE character not perishing, just reignited the flame!!!!
Thank you!!!
I think he is alive
I think you are 🤡🤡🤡
I was willing to hear your argument, but when would've Snape taken the antidote. It looked like Snape expected Voldemort to kill him, not be bitten by the snake. However I will admit, that you convinced me that yes he MAY be alive.
Snape's attack wasn't the first time Voldemort used Nagini. So it's reasonable to believe Snape could have been dosing himself with anti-venom/poison prevention daily, weekly, or something similar.
It is feasible as you say he was smart always able to fool Voldemort and the death eaters consistently and as a potions master would have the stuff he need to meet any situation outside the killing curse they might throw at him! So there is a reasonable possiblity! Even I thought about that at times but never said anything! But it does hold a great deal of logic!
Hmm if I’d still alive, where would he be then? I’d think he’d live the rest of his life in the muggle would, or in the wizarding world as a different person. As I don’t think most of the society may not accept him due to his duties that he carried out as a death eater. I think harry would’ve been the only way Snape would’ve gotten out of serving time in Azkaban
I wonder if he would be recognized at other places in the world, since there are lots of other schools. he could be using his time to create new spells and new potions, and heck write a textbook under a different name that could be used at hogwarts, etc.
I think that if he was able to keep an eye on harry in some way, to see that he named his son after him, to see that harry's son became a slytherin, then that's enough for snape to live. I think he cared for harry, but he didn't want to say it to his face. plus he saw harry mature and defeat voldemort, so he probably had a new level of respect for him. the fact that harry went and sacrified himself to defeat voldemort. I bet it made snape proud in some way and realize he didn't remind him as much as james as he thought
I thought Snape didn’t appear in the forest for the same reason Dumbledore didn’t. Harry was close to them but not THAT personally
Actually 'HARRY POTTER AND THE CURSED CHILD' proves that Snape never died. It is when he was alive in the CURSED CHILD. This proves that snape was alive.
Pls like If you agree
I hate cursed child. It was a fan fic with many mistakes.then jk rowling made it canon
I agree
Is it true? Is snape alive in cursed child and profesor on the Hogwarts?
1st again how I’m confused. Hope your keeping well btw! :D
no your not
You're 8th
Snape also could've went into the forest to find the resurrection stone after the battle of hogwarts so he could see Lliy one more time. Also the tale of the 3 brothers refers to Harry Voldemort Snape and Dumbledoere being death. So when death took the 2nd brother for his own because he wanted meet the love of his life once again. And you all know what the 2nd brother did.
Alan Rickman really nailed that charecters. I can never think of a Snape other than him. The way he acted even in the first 4 movies,you can easily find out that though grudgingly he was trying to protect Harry. As it for the Theory,I feel like Harry must've gone to The Shrieking Shrak and had brought his body for a proper Farewell. One of my best charecters in this Franchise and I think of every single Franchises I've ever seen. Rest in Peace both the legends😔🙏
Why did Voldemort kill Snape? He could disarm him right? I mean, Harry became the owner because he disarmed Draco even when he was not using that the elder's one wand
Maybe Snape used his killing of Dumbledore to create his own horcrux. He had the knowledge and the ability.
Eh, whatever it entailed, it's so bad that Rowling won't even say what it is. And apparently plain old murder isn't enough. It's unlikely that Snape, especially post redemption arc Snape, would do something that horrible
Underrated comment . Why would he do that ? Snape did know how to create horacrux
@@yoyoabhishek777 Snape was a powerful and brilliant wizard... If anyone other than Voldemort knew how to create a horcrux it would be Snape. As for why? Fear of death, the same as Voldemort.
ua-cam.com/video/b5NDt8z69W0/v-deo.html
Heres a link to the video that explains it
I really disagreed here, at first because. Well he's dead and it seemed obvious. UNTIL you mentioned Harry not seeing his spirit with the others. THAT makes this really suspect and believable. Well done... I realize how you ended it but. I suspect it now lol.
Do you think he is
still... alive?😖😭👼🏻❤️🖤✨
(I hope so...😓💕)
If I was going to write fan fiction, this is what I would write about. I thought about all of the things mentioned here plus whether or not Snape could have made a horcrux after killing Voldemort. Lots of the most deadly snakes in the world will render human victims lifeless. I remember a true story of an man in India bitten by some terrible snake who silently prayed the doctors woudln't turn off the life support. He was in all ways dead but he began to recover the next day. So I would hope Snape went away and had a happier life. (I don't think it is part of the original series that Snape's picture was in the headmaster's office?)
Having Snape alive according to ur research would be very nice, yes. Sadly the actor Alan Rickman died. I love ur idea tho for it presented a loop hole :]
RIP alan rickman but that doesn't mean there can't be more snape. dumbledore was replaced with a new actor. there will never be another alan rickman version of snape because he was unique, but there are plenty of actors that can still bring snape back to life in their own way and it would be awesome to see this happen.
Omg arthur weasly also was saved by an anti venom when he was bit by nagini. Snape wud carry this venom because as u said he was in close proximity with voldemort.
The reason Rowling made Nagini kill snape instead of Voldemort killing him is that if Voldemort killed him, Harry wouldn't have been able to see his memories which were an important role in the story.
Voldemort was also afraid that a killing curse cast towards the (what he thinks) true owner of the elder wand could potentially rebound and hit him.
Once Nagini had killed Snape the wand would switch master (like it always has) to him naturaly!
Congratulations on successfully making me cry again
And I desperately want this theory to be true
No Snape died. To have survived goes against Jo’s theme of sacrifice.
Professor snape and the order of the phoenix knew an antidote to Naginis venom do exist ever since authur Weasleys return in the 5th book.
Always
Epic
i am the 3,458 viewer