Looking to purchase a Feelfree Kayak and need it shipped? Order direct from Feelfree using this link and support our page! www.feelfreeus.com/?ref=a_qil0o9xog
Nite Knight I know the feeling. I’ve bounced from sea ghost to big fish to pelican with hydrive and finally decided on the lure 11.5 . I’m 6’ 270# so I hope the lure works out. Got it for a helluva good price.
@@joshuaborchardt4355 how did you go with the lure 11.5? I got mine the other day, older one I think as it doesn't have a removable box for the fish finder and battery, it's just a sealed compartment, everything else is exactly the same though, im 6'4 and wondering how comfortable you are in yours? been pissing down with rain and windy since I got mine hahaha yet to get out on it
More people need to talk about the hull design as you have. Even most manufacturers don’t show them on their web site. Thank you, great info as always.
I bought my first Lure 11.5 in 2014. I liked it so much I bought a second one in ‘17 with the overdrive. The seat is all day comfortable and it’s very stable. Storage is excellent: I can store two 7’ rods in the hull if necessary. A rudder is a must. When pedaling normally I get almost 4 mph. Overall, a well thought out kayak and great ride. FeelFree’s customer service is awesome. They answer your emails and return your calls. If possible, go paddle before you buy, or at the very least, see them in person.
By FAR the best dang overview/comparison of features of any video on YT! Not just a quick blurb about what you like about them but actual in depth descriptions and comparisons to help people make a choice. Ultimately I went with the FeelFree Lure 13.5 because of the awesome features it has but also because I can upgrade it to the Overdrive in the near future.
I stalked Facebook marketplace for 4 months hoping for a Lure 11.5. One finally popped up and after a 2 hour drive I had my first kayak. Love the Lure, could not be happier, and I owe much of the decision to buy it to your videos! Thanks for the honest reviews and keep up the good work!
This was a good comparison review, Dan! Owning a Lure 11.5 for just a lttle over a year now, I'm pleased with it. The only [minor] drawback is with the proprietary gear track size, and having to use adapters. I use two of the Feelfree Uni-track devices, and find them sturdy, easy to attach/detach, and move fore/aft on the track. The included safety lanyard on the Uni device with the snap-in track attachment is a plus knowing the device won't be deep-sixed accidently. For my other track attachments I used the YakGear adapters to attach 4 Railblaza Starports (2 fwd, 2 aft), which I use for locating the camera boom in different positions on the kayak. The Wheel-in-the-Keel on the Lure makes it ideal for short trips from the truck to the water, on concrete/asphalt, or grassy areas. It doesn't fare well on gravel. For longer distances I use a Railblaza C-Tug. I have a short bed F150, so a BooneDox T-Bone works well in supporting the length of the Lure past the tailgate. I'm 65, so the ease of transport (weight factor) of the Lure is something I thought about when buying it. I did not demo the Lure 11.5 on the water, but did make a 2 hr trip to the Nashville area to the Hook 1 kayak store, and sat in the 11.5, and the Gravity Seat, Wheel-in-the-keel, (and other features) easily convinced me to order one. Checkout my channel if you get a chance to see a handy moveable storage cart I built to make loading/unloading the kayak into/out of my truck.
Love the video. I'm 71 yrs old and for me the stability of the Bonafide would make me more confident standing and the higher seat position should help my back so I don't get fatigued as easily.
First of all. You done a killer job of reviewing these products. I’m impressed. I’m leaning toward the Lure 11.5. I’ve never owned a kayak. I like the features of the lure along with the good amount of deck space and storage. I’ve been watching tons of videos about the stability. Seems like a great value. As soon as I save up enough funds, I’ll pull the trigger on one. Thanks for taking the time to do this awesome review.
As a lure owner, be sure to take into consideration that they use a proprietary rail system which requires a bunch of DIY or money to take advantage of. It's my biggest grip with feel free.
Dan after over one year looking for a kayak and demo some kayak the decision was made this weekend 8/10/19 for me It's stability is first and comfortably in the chair and height this is my first kayak I went with the Bonafide SS127 thank you for the videos and you did help, keep up the GOOD work you do, you do help the sport.
Really great review. I didn't see any bias, just the facts. I have the FeelFree Tandem (next to the lure) and my son in law has the Jackson Big Tuna. I think both are well made, stable, move well through the water and are fairly easy to upgrade. I don't like Feelfrees proprietary track system but bought the adapters you show for the cup holder I added, no big deal. The FeelFree is definitely heavier than the Tuna but both are manageable. The stern wheel on the FeelFree might work on smooth surfaces with no gear in the boat, otherwise it's useless (in my humble opinion). These look like all great kayaks and your review was one of the best I've seen! Great job!
Watching this again due to FOMO. I have had the lure 11.5 for 1.5 years and zero issues even in saltwater bays. However recent other videos say how feelfree brand is inferior to bonafide. Watching again and the things I like about my Lure11.5 are lesser on the Bonafide so loving my decision.
Nice video! Bought my wife the Bonafide SS107 and myself the SS127. Tested them next to the Wilderness Systems Radar 115 and the NuCanoe Frontier12. The Bonafide just felt more stable for me. I could stand up and fish the first day taking it out and this is my first kayak. It really is a great kayak and would recommend it to anyone in the market.
Got my feelfree lure 11.5 I honestly have nothing to complain about, comfortable, tracks like a champ, suuuuper stable even on choppy water haven't had my bow go under yet, it's just an all around fishing machine saltwater and freshwater.
Incredible video, especially the seats and hull design. I am still a bit torn between the lure and the ss107. The wheel in the keel might be the tipping point for me.
I promise you you get the lure 13.5 you will be more than incredibly happy If you're not planning on doing any big camping and don't mind losing some of the front storage the 12.5 would be also fantastic I've had me replacements and I need one I can get in and out of easily and it's incredibly stable my lure 13.5 is way better than I expected
I took a Bonafide out on the New River in Virginia and I will say it was cool, but when it's hot, the Black Hatch cover will become very hot! So keep that in mind....this is something that is never discussed.
Thanks, man. The FEELFREE has the most comfortable seat in the business. To this old war veteran, it is the best kayak in the business. I enjoy your videos, they’re great !!! Cheers from East Tennessee.
Hey Dan: Very thorough comparison! Thanks for sharing. My Tarpon 100 at 55lbs with seat is great for me because I'm 5'8" 130lbs. Can't stand up in it though. That's why I am attracted to the SS107. I wish they made an SS8 or SS9.
I’ve had the Lure for a year and a half. It’s a great boat for all the reasons you mentioned. The sonar pod seems fine to me, but I’m not comparing it to others like you did. Setting up my fish finder was a snap. The seat is awesome, probably the main reason I bought the boat. I have back problems and it’s height adjustability and comfort help. The track system is a bit annoying, with having to buy and use the adapters. One thing for sure is that this boat needs a rudder. I fish a relatively calm river, but a rudder is definitely on my list. Another plus for FeelFree; after about seven months, after a day on the water, there was about an inch of water inside my hull. FeelFree replaced my boat with a new one. I have enjoyed many of your videos.
Great video I have a lure 13 and a half awesome for fishing but it always seems to track to the left no matter what. Definitely built for comfort not for speed
I just called yesterday and had a talk with Josh, told him I was interested in the big Fish 120, now after this video I’m leaning towards the bonafide kayak, thanks Dan for this information, hope to see you guys soon so we can strike a deal on a yak.
I like the new high seat models I think it's a good idea to keep them in a paddle configuration because there are so many powerboats.that the shallow backwaters are where the fish are going.
I have chosen. Liska for me. Not just made in USA. Made in Tennessee. My home state. I like it so far but I am new to this hobby. Doesn't come with a lot of bells and whistles but you can add almost anything which is how I think they intended.
This makes me love the look of the vibe sea ghost 130 even more. Hours away from any place that will do a demo. I’m hoping I make the right choice! I go on a lot of river trips but I’m close to Sam Rayburn. I’d love to take it to Galveston also! This dude is awesome with his reviews!! Much appreciated!
Great video and tremendous comparison between the 3 yaks. for me the choice would be between the bona fide and the liska, with a bonafide likely winning out in the end. where has tracking would be a little bit of a concern for me with a bona fide, the height of the seat is beyond reproach. However, it is unfortunate that they did not include gear tracks on the sites of the stern. The feel free is a non-starter for me because of two things.. origin of the company being non U.S. and the requirement of purchasing adapters every time you want to use accessories on their proprietary track system
awesome video .. love the complete comparison . and that you also showed the bottoms . please do a complete review when you get the feelfree dorado in . especially the bottom
I need to figure out how to weigh my Lure 11.5, is has always seemed to be very heavy. My Lure 10 seems much lighter I think the specs are only about a 10lb difference. I love my lures but Bonafide has my full attention...
I'm leaning towards the Bonifide. It looks more stable than the others. I'm new to kayaking and was only planning on spending $ 500 but after your review I just might spend the money for a real good one. Thanks!
The 11.5 lure you can put the paddle on either side there is a stand up strap assist in front of the sonar pod and also the 3 circular areas on the bow areas for mounts altogether you have done a really nice video thanks
Awesome thorough comparison. I have a Jackson coosa fd for my big pedal kayak but I wanted a nice light paddle kayak as an adjunct. I went with the bonafide because of the stability and comfort. I also liked the rod staging area on the top of the hatch and the pod. I am really happy with it so far, my only real “complaint” is there is nothing in the back end with regard to tracks or flush mounted rod holders so I need to add either or both, otherwise I have nowhere to put my rods except if I bring my Hobie crate (which I have nothing to attach the crate to, except wrapping the bungees around it....). Although with the seat up, I can stage 3-4 rods resting on the seat base and hatch grooves and it is pretty sweet to have them all sitting right in front of me ready to go
I wish you would've highlighted the seat track on the liska. That's def a big feature imo if you are gonna carry a lot of weight in the back of the kayak. Awesome review though! I really like how thorough you are
Great review. I'm not doing big water so I'm choosing the Bonafide. I do like the hull shape of the Jackson and if I were 30 years younger I'd pick that one but a good salesman could probably talk me into either.
Dan, your content is fantastic. What an informative and in depth video! I’m still trying to pick my first kayak. I think stability and seat height would lean me toward the Bonafide. But, maybe I’ll try them and see! Thanks again.
Very Informative video, it may have just push me toward the Liska. I have a dealer here in town which will make it easy for purchasing and warranty if the need arises. Thanks for the video.
What ever Kayak I get will be powered. The SS107 would be my choice. Their all nice. I can add rod holders and I like the Electronics Box regardless of the work to set it up.
Love this video! Great review but still very much undecided between the lure and bonifide. So I thought I would ask to picture this.....North Carolina, generally light winds, flat waters with occasional river fishing, maybe even some intercostal waters. Which one would you recommend? Thank you...(Shopping for a yak)
Bonafide SS107 for the win! For the fishing aspect, stability and comfort is king and the Bonafide has it! There are a few things to make it your own, but that's the fun part! Awesome review man!
I have been deciding between the bonafide SS127 and Lure 11.5 and the only reason I’m really leaning to the Lure is the overdrive option. I’m a 240 pound guy that wants to stand up while fishing. Wanna stay American made just wish the Bonafide had a PDL
Between the two, which do you feel would be best suited for ocean fishing in San Diego, both in the Bay and off the coast in the kelp beds? The Lure 13.5 or the Bonafide SS127? I know they are not the subject of this review but I thought I would ask. Also, I think I would want a rudder, which is a negative against the Bonafide already. Thanks.
I've owned a dozen of the feel frees and they're a good boat. Very slow, I know they're not supposed to be fast, but I recently purchased a Wilderness Systems Radar 135 and it cruises down the river. Now I don't have to spend all day trying to keep up to my wife in her Pungo. No comparison. But the feel free is still a good boat, in fact i like my Moken 10 to camp out of more than any other boat, because of the front and back.
All three boats are very nice and would all be a nice buy. I really like the seat on the Lure, it's height adjustment is really cool. The Bonafied looks to have the nicest seat but I do not like what you have to do change the height. I think they need to work on a quicker setup, but the boat is incredibly stable so it may not matter. The Jackson looks very nimble and traditional. I will say I didn't like the hatch and electronics plastics on the Lure, they looked like something you would find on a $300 kayak imo. The Bonafied looked to have the best plastics overall but, and this is a big but, I can not believe the Bonafied doesn't have built in rod holders. That is absolutely mind boggling to me. I do not use a crate, I use a nice bag and cooler. And no way am I drilling holes in my yeti or gluing anything to it. I think they really need to take a hard look at that. If not for the rod holders the Bonafied would be an easy pick for me, but I think the Lure would have to be first just from that simple fact. Thanks for the great vids, very helpful what you cats do out there.
Great review! 1st time I’ve seen an in-depth comparison between the lure and the bonafide. While I love the stability and seat height (and height of the seat back) of the bonafide, the lure would be my choice as the basic boat can be retrofitted with pedal drive (and motor drive if I hit the lottery). Couldn’t see in the video but don’t the lures foot pegs adjust easily from the seat? If bonafide would do a pedal retrofit they’d get my money but... lol Thanks again and great job as always!
I'm a big guy and really like the Bonafide but I think I really want a pedal drive. Kinda torn between Jackson and Bonafide for getting into a fishing rig.
What are the weight capacities with each seat? Is there a cap? Bigger guys may be limited true? Not everyone is small or medium. Some of us are above 250 pounds. Weight capacity of each yak including the max weight for seat capacity is a deciding factor. I live in south east coastal Virginia and most of my kayaking is done in the salt water. Waves, tides, and wind are players. I have an old Ride 135 and feel as though the Lure would be my best option. I know Luther personally, but his kayak is, in my opinion, designed more for fresh water excursions. The Jackson will paddle like a barge. Thanks!
Hi Dan ... Just found this video clip, thanks for the info. ... Which kayak/hull design will choose for offshore work? Looks like the Bonifide has the higher sides compared to the others.
I bought a Cuda HD and put it this way. I LOVE the kayak. I really do however standing up in it is a complete joke. It's just not doable for me. It's too tippy. I wish i went with a Big Rig or the Bonafide SS127 myself. However i got a 2018 leftover model Cuda HD for a STEAL and i am very happy with the boat. It is pretty quick too. My next one will be a Bonafide though. I love the storage space and deck space that the boat has.
I have watched months of videos ... I favor the Bonafide ss 107 .... I am almost 70 and want the comfort.. It's light enough to load myself ... The replaceable skids ... I hear the wheel in the keel gets chipped up fast ... Love the front hatch better on the Bonafide... Just a better kayak for me
I was thinking about getting a (used) Bonafide SS107 for duck hunting. I'm a short and light guy and I usually go ultralight with a 60-pound lab. Any thoughts?
Hey Dan. Thanks for the info you put out in this video. I’m looking to get a kayak real soon as I’ve been researching which would suit me the best as I’m 6’4” at 280lbs. I’m leaning towards the Bonafide as you even said its the most stable. What are your thoughts on what I should get for my size. Thank you!!
Thank you for the video and going through the 3 boats. I am looking to buy my first kayak. I have been interested in getting a fishing kayak, but had some health issues that are hopefully in the rear view mirror. Again, thanks for going over the 3 kayaks. I am interested in the FeelFree Lure 11.5 and the Vibe Shearwater 125 and could use some insight on the two. The Lure looks incredible, has some internal storage and the very adjustable seat. The Shearwater seems to be really well thought out with internal access, storage areas galore, comes with a rudder and what also seems to have a very comfortable seat. Both are at the same price point, and can be retrofitted with a pedal drive. So, what am I missing? Which is better to paddle and which is more stable? Any insight or recommendations are appreciated.
Great video! I am so glad I grabbed 2 Lures from you guys. I was a little afraid that I would have buyers remorse after watching this video but for my personal needs I am more than ever convinced that the Lure for our family was the perfect choice! Thanks for a great review video Dan.
I am leaning on feel free but you open my eyes to the Bonafide I am looking for ocean stability for big game fishing. In its Limits of course which one is best for big water fishing
great video I have been looking to buy another kayak and have narrowed it down to a few and the bonofide and the feelfree are in the top 4 for sure just still not sure which one I want to go with.
If you had a choice between the feel free or the bonafide for everything from still small lakes to the Puget sound here in Seattle. Which one would you buy
If I was paddling the sound I would not pick either of them. Both are too slow and wide for open water use. I'd pick a Ocean Kayak Trident, or Wilderness Tarpon or something along those lines with speed and glide.
There are so many boats and so many options and sizes, how on earth can someone choose? What would be a good minimum kayak? Something with a raised seat, stable to stand, don’t need the bells and whistles. Just something that works well in a river or small lake? I have a used old town dirigo 10’, it works well but it’s sit in and doesn’t track real well. Also seems tough to paddle. Field and stream has an eagle for about $500 they also have a much nicer one for $799. The ability to add peddles long term might be worth it?
When buying a kayak you must consider how much energy is required to paddle it. Wide kayaks with high seating positions may be comfortable to sit in but try paddling them against a strong wind and/or tide. You will soon get tired trying to paddle these yaks any great distance.
Hi! I've watched alot of your videos trying to find a good kayak to fish from here in Europe where speed is a important factor. You seam to be the person who knows about kayaks and what you are talking about. I would like to see a video like this one, where you compare Feelfree lure 13.5 with a native, nucanoe and Jackson in the same price range. Thx from Sweden
As usual, thanks for the info my friend. I really wish the Feelfree boats would come in something other than the camo. Bit of a diva complaint but if they had colors like the Bonafides I'd be all about it. Also, if any one of these smaller boats had more horizontal rod storage (a la Nucanoe Pursuit - much bigger boat, I know) I'd buy it tonight.
Great review. Just picked up a lure V1 on clearance for $769. Arrives tomorrow. Already ordered the rudder kit. What are your thoughts on the PodMount trolling motor mounts they build for the lure? Worth the $150??
Hey Dan, did you ever get the Liska on the water? Curious about how the hull design performs, particularly on how much the standability hampers the speed. I realize there's always a bit of compromise on those two factors--your on-the-water review of Crescent Lite Tackle vs. Jackson Bite was informative. Def want to stand, but don't want a cumbersome super-slow yak. I'm 5'11" 170lbs, so don't need a big boat. Fish inshore saltwater in Florida.
Okay. Tired of researching. What would you recommend for a tandem (wife is tired of sitting on the shore with the dogs) fishing boat in the intermediate range? I've had a lot of back surgeries, so need a framed seat.
Loved the video, really liking the Liska. If you don't mind me asking do you guys still sell the Native Ultimate FX 13 propel? I'm very interested in that kayak after you did a viewers rig like a year ago, but I still haven't seen a more detailed breakdown of that boat.
Lots of great info. Thanks! Question pls... Which of the 3 is best for fishing/camping overnights (fish/camping gear, cooler)? MAX WEIGHT LIMITS BECOMES A HIGH CONSIDERATION FOR ME. I do have Ulta Light backpacking gear but would take a YETI 65 if it's a 2 or more day trip. I currently take my PELICAN MONACO DLX when fish/camp overnights. Its MAX WEIGHT LIMIT is 775 but hard going against the currents of a large lake's shoreline. Thanks, in advance, for your opinions.
I might stir up some emotions with this comment but I think that manufacturers of the pedal drives have them priced really high. They are complicated devices that are difficult and costly to manufacture. Kayak designs that make it easy and inexpensive to add a trolling motor may be a great option for consumers. This approach may be good for the consumer AND manufacturers. If no data but would guess they sell a pedal drive for every 4-5 kayaks they sell. Although the selling price of the pedal drive is almost as much as the boat, I'd guess the margins are greater on the boats. In other words, selling boats (not pedal drives) should be the focus. A boat designed to easily and inexpensively add a trolling motor may do VERY well. Your thoughts??
This seems to be a trend. Although companies like Native and Oldtown who have proven systems that have been around for a while are probably doing just fine with their systems. Innovation is expensive so if you can get some mileage out a product it becomes cheaper over time.
My only real issue with the FeelFree is the hull design seems like it could be hung up on rocks in class 1&2 shores. Get a little sideways and your getting wet. Do you have any experience with that happening?
Looking to purchase a Feelfree Kayak and need it shipped? Order direct from Feelfree using this link and support our page! www.feelfreeus.com/?ref=a_qil0o9xog
What's the most stable kayak under 1600 that I can use in saltwater fishing.
Thanks!
I fish saltwater with SS127 very stable paddles well
Bonafide SS127
Would u recommend the feelfree moken 12.5 v2 for off shore salt water fishing?
There needs to be only one kayak available so I can make a damn decision lol
Nite Knight I know the feeling. I’ve bounced from sea ghost to big fish to pelican with hydrive and finally decided on the lure 11.5 . I’m 6’ 270# so I hope the lure works out. Got it for a helluva good price.
Amen 🙏
@@joshuaborchardt4355 Summer's over, how'd it work out for ya?
@@joshuaborchardt4355 how did you go with the lure 11.5? I got mine the other day, older one I think as it doesn't have a removable box for the fish finder and battery, it's just a sealed compartment, everything else is exactly the same though, im 6'4 and wondering how comfortable you are in yours? been pissing down with rain and windy since I got mine hahaha yet to get out on it
@@xterrorx8376 how yah liking the lure?
Thank you for this video - I've yet to see such a well-done, in-depth overview comparison!
More people need to talk about the hull design as you have. Even most manufacturers don’t show them on their web site. Thank you, great info as always.
Thanks for discussing the hulls. One of the most important performance factors on the water. Great review!
I bought my first Lure 11.5 in 2014. I liked it so much I bought a second one in ‘17 with the overdrive. The seat is all day comfortable and it’s very stable. Storage is excellent: I can store two 7’ rods in the hull if necessary. A rudder is a must. When pedaling normally I get almost 4 mph.
Overall, a well thought out kayak and great ride. FeelFree’s customer service is awesome. They answer your emails and return your calls.
If possible, go paddle before you buy, or at the very least, see them in person.
By FAR the best dang overview/comparison of features of any video on YT! Not just a quick blurb about what you like about them but actual in depth descriptions and comparisons to help people make a choice. Ultimately I went with the FeelFree Lure 13.5 because of the awesome features it has but also because I can upgrade it to the Overdrive in the near future.
Much appreciated. Going to try and do more things like this.
Great video Dan. All 3 are amazing boats. SS107 for the stability and the high seat make it a winner for me.
I stalked Facebook marketplace for 4 months hoping for a Lure 11.5. One finally popped up and after a 2 hour drive I had my first kayak. Love the Lure, could not be happier, and I owe much of the decision to buy it to your videos! Thanks for the honest reviews and keep up the good work!
sciland1 that’s awesome to hear. Thanks man. Happy Paddlin
This was a good comparison review, Dan! Owning a Lure 11.5 for just a lttle over a year now, I'm pleased with it. The only [minor] drawback is with the proprietary gear track size, and having to use adapters. I use two of the Feelfree Uni-track devices, and find them sturdy, easy to attach/detach, and move fore/aft on the track. The included safety lanyard on the Uni device with the snap-in track attachment is a plus knowing the device won't be deep-sixed accidently. For my other track attachments I used the YakGear adapters to attach 4 Railblaza Starports (2 fwd, 2 aft), which I use for locating the camera boom in different positions on the kayak.
The Wheel-in-the-Keel on the Lure makes it ideal for short trips from the truck to the water, on concrete/asphalt, or grassy areas. It doesn't fare well on gravel. For longer distances I use a Railblaza C-Tug. I have a short bed F150, so a BooneDox T-Bone works well in supporting the length of the Lure past the tailgate. I'm 65, so the ease of transport (weight factor) of the Lure is something I thought about when buying it.
I did not demo the Lure 11.5 on the water, but did make a 2 hr trip to the Nashville area to the Hook 1 kayak store, and sat in the 11.5, and the Gravity Seat, Wheel-in-the-keel, (and other features) easily convinced me to order one.
Checkout my channel if you get a chance to see a handy moveable storage cart I built to make loading/unloading the kayak into/out of my truck.
Greg Jackson I’ll check it out
@@HeadwatersKayak: Thanks 👍
Love the video. I'm 71 yrs old and for me the stability of the Bonafide would make me more confident standing and the higher seat position should help my back so I don't get fatigued as easily.
First of all. You done a killer job of reviewing these products. I’m impressed. I’m leaning toward the Lure 11.5. I’ve never owned a kayak. I like the features of the lure along with the good amount of deck space and storage. I’ve been watching tons of videos about the stability. Seems like a great value. As soon as I save up enough funds, I’ll pull the trigger on one. Thanks for taking the time to do this awesome review.
As a lure owner, be sure to take into consideration that they use a proprietary rail system which requires a bunch of DIY or money to take advantage of. It's my biggest grip with feel free.
Dan after over one year looking for a kayak and demo some kayak the decision was made this weekend 8/10/19 for me It's stability is first and comfortably in the chair and height this is my first kayak I went with the Bonafide SS127 thank you for the videos and you did help, keep up the GOOD work you do, you do help the sport.
Really great review. I didn't see any bias, just the facts. I have the FeelFree Tandem (next to the lure) and my son in law has the Jackson Big Tuna. I think both are well made, stable, move well through the water and are fairly easy to upgrade. I don't like Feelfrees proprietary track system but bought the adapters you show for the cup holder I added, no big deal. The FeelFree is definitely heavier than the Tuna but both are manageable. The stern wheel on the FeelFree might work on smooth surfaces with no gear in the boat, otherwise it's useless (in my humble opinion). These look like all great kayaks and your review was one of the best I've seen! Great job!
As someone who is currently in the market for a kayak upgrade, this was an excellent review and comparison. Thank you!
Watching this again due to FOMO. I have had the lure 11.5 for 1.5 years and zero issues even in saltwater bays. However recent other videos say how feelfree brand is inferior to bonafide. Watching again and the things I like about my Lure11.5 are lesser on the Bonafide so loving my decision.
Very informative! Every Kayak Anglers looking into these three kayaks should watch this! Thanks Dan!
great comparison... super happy with my Jackson Liska.. great paddle and stability for lake use..
Nice video! Bought my wife the Bonafide SS107 and myself the SS127. Tested them next to the Wilderness Systems Radar 115 and the NuCanoe Frontier12. The Bonafide just felt more stable for me. I could stand up and fish the first day taking it out and this is my first kayak. It really is a great kayak and would recommend it to anyone in the market.
Got my feelfree lure 11.5 I honestly have nothing to complain about, comfortable, tracks like a champ, suuuuper stable even on choppy water haven't had my bow go under yet, it's just an all around fishing machine saltwater and freshwater.
Incredible video, especially the seats and hull design. I am still a bit torn between the lure and the ss107. The wheel in the keel might be the tipping point for me.
I promise you you get the lure 13.5 you will be more than incredibly happy
If you're not planning on doing any big camping and don't mind losing some of the front storage the 12.5 would be also fantastic
I've had me replacements and I need one I can get in and out of easily and it's incredibly stable my lure 13.5 is way better than I expected
I took a Bonafide out on the New River in Virginia and I will say it was cool, but when it's hot, the Black Hatch cover will become very hot! So keep that in mind....this is something that is never discussed.
Get a grip pard...
Thanks, man. The FEELFREE has the most comfortable seat in the business. To this old war veteran, it is the best kayak in the business.
I enjoy your videos, they’re great !!!
Cheers from East Tennessee.
Awesome review man, thanks! You should make another video like this one, but for the tandem kayak!
Hey Dan: Very thorough comparison! Thanks for sharing. My Tarpon 100 at 55lbs with seat is great for me because I'm 5'8" 130lbs. Can't stand up in it though. That's why I am attracted to the SS107. I wish they made an SS8 or SS9.
I’ve had the Lure for a year and a half. It’s a great boat for all the reasons you mentioned. The sonar pod seems fine to me, but I’m not comparing it to others like you did. Setting up my fish finder was a snap. The seat is awesome, probably the main reason I bought the boat. I have back problems and it’s height adjustability and comfort help. The track system is a bit annoying, with having to buy and use the adapters. One thing for sure is that this boat needs a rudder. I fish a relatively calm river, but a rudder is definitely on my list. Another plus for FeelFree; after about seven months, after a day on the water, there was about an inch of water inside my hull. FeelFree replaced my boat with a new one. I have enjoyed many of your videos.
Great video I have a lure 13 and a half awesome for fishing but it always seems to track to the left no matter what. Definitely built for comfort not for speed
I just called yesterday and had a talk with Josh, told him I was interested in the big Fish 120, now after this video I’m leaning towards the bonafide kayak, thanks Dan for this information, hope to see you guys soon so we can strike a deal on a yak.
Catch-N-Release559 yea you get a lot of yak with the Bonafide. Come demo both.
I like the new high seat models I think it's a good idea to keep them in a paddle configuration because there are so many powerboats.that the shallow backwaters are where the fish are going.
I have chosen. Liska for me. Not just made in USA. Made in Tennessee. My home state. I like it so far but I am new to this hobby. Doesn't come with a lot of bells and whistles but you can add almost anything which is how I think they intended.
The Liska is looking better and better for my needs...
Awesome video , I have been waiting for someone to do a comparison on all 3. I probably would have paid for this video if i had to...
Marland Martin haha well I’m glad I could help b
Disappointing that the Bonafide isn’t rudder ready/plumbed. Overall the feature rich FFL 11.5 represents the best value imo.
This makes me love the look of the vibe sea ghost 130 even more. Hours away from any place that will do a demo. I’m hoping I make the right choice! I go on a lot of river trips but I’m close to Sam Rayburn. I’d love to take it to Galveston also! This dude is awesome with his reviews!! Much appreciated!
Great video and tremendous comparison between the 3 yaks.
for me the choice would be between the bona fide and the liska, with a bonafide likely winning out in the end.
where has tracking would be a little bit of a concern for me with a bona fide, the height of the seat is beyond reproach.
However, it is unfortunate that they did not include gear tracks on the sites of the stern.
The feel free is a non-starter for me because of two things.. origin of the company being non U.S. and the requirement of purchasing adapters every time you want to use accessories on their proprietary track system
awesome video .. love the complete comparison . and that you also showed the bottoms . please do a complete review when you get the feelfree dorado in . especially the bottom
Adventures101 I already have a detailed walkthrough up over on my channel. Go check it out.
ua-cam.com/video/OyX30Onxsok/v-deo.html
I need to figure out how to weigh my Lure 11.5, is has always seemed to be very heavy. My Lure 10 seems much lighter I think the specs are only about a 10lb difference. I love my lures but Bonafide has my full attention...
I have 11.5 and I find it really heavy
dan, great video. i am new to the non-box store kayaks. based on the presentation I would opt for the bona fide.
can't wait to demo some of these.
Keep these type videos coming!! Feelfree cause the seat and the wheel
I'm leaning towards the Bonifide. It looks more stable than the others. I'm new to kayaking and was only planning on spending $ 500 but after your review I just might spend the money for a real good one. Thanks!
Love your Videos Dan , You know your stuff, Always good info ,,
The 11.5 lure you can put the paddle on either side there is a stand up strap assist in front of the sonar pod and also the 3 circular areas on the bow areas for mounts altogether you have done a really nice video thanks
Dan is such a nice guy he apologizes when bumping the camera :D
🤣
Best "in depth review I've seen as a "soon to purchase owner"...
Awesome thorough comparison. I have a Jackson coosa fd for my big pedal kayak but I wanted a nice light paddle kayak as an adjunct. I went with the bonafide because of the stability and comfort. I also liked the rod staging area on the top of the hatch and the pod. I am really happy with it so far, my only real “complaint” is there is nothing in the back end with regard to tracks or flush mounted rod holders so I need to add either or both, otherwise I have nowhere to put my rods except if I bring my Hobie crate (which I have nothing to attach the crate to, except wrapping the bungees around it....). Although with the seat up, I can stage 3-4 rods resting on the seat base and hatch grooves and it is pretty sweet to have them all sitting right in front of me ready to go
Really good review. Stability and comfort is what I'm most interested and would love to see you review the bonefide ss 107.
I wish you would've highlighted the seat track on the liska. That's def a big feature imo if you are gonna carry a lot of weight in the back of the kayak. Awesome review though! I really like how thorough you are
Great review. I'm not doing big water so I'm choosing the Bonafide. I do like the hull shape of the Jackson and if I were 30 years younger I'd pick that one but a good salesman could probably talk me into either.
Dan, your content is fantastic. What an informative and in depth video! I’m still trying to pick my first kayak. I think stability and seat height would lean me toward the Bonafide. But, maybe I’ll try them and see! Thanks again.
Like the shirt. Can't say it more. You do the best reviews.
Awesome video!! You answered many of my questions I had for all these kayaks! I think I’m going to buy the feel free!
Thanks for making the video too. A lot of great information
Very Informative video, it may have just push me toward the Liska. I have a dealer here in town which will make it easy for purchasing and warranty if the need arises. Thanks for the video.
What ever Kayak I get will be powered. The SS107 would be my choice. Their all nice. I can add rod holders and I like the Electronics Box regardless of the work to set it up.
I liked the practical details in your comparison, great review.
Love this video! Great review but still very much undecided between the lure and bonifide. So I thought I would ask to picture this.....North Carolina, generally light winds, flat waters with occasional river fishing, maybe even some intercostal waters. Which one would you recommend? Thank you...(Shopping for a yak)
Bonafide SS107 for the win! For the fishing aspect, stability and comfort is king and the Bonafide has it! There are a few things to make it your own, but that's the fun part! Awesome review man!
I have been deciding between the bonafide SS127 and Lure 11.5 and the only reason I’m really leaning to the Lure is the overdrive option. I’m a 240 pound guy that wants to stand up while fishing. Wanna stay American made just wish the Bonafide had a PDL
I’m trying to decide between the Bonafide and the feel free. I end up staring at the sea ghost the entire video.
For good reason. SeaGhost does everything well !
Wish your shop was on the east coast! Think I'm going to get the lure 11.5 . Doing more lake fishing. Enjoy your videos, Thanks
Between the two, which do you feel would be best suited for ocean fishing in San Diego, both in the Bay and off the coast in the kelp beds? The Lure 13.5 or the Bonafide SS127? I know they are not the subject of this review but I thought I would ask. Also, I think I would want a rudder, which is a negative against the Bonafide already. Thanks.
So which do you think is the best out of these 3? Including price and features. I’m really liking the Bonafide over the Lure, and Jackson.
Kinda really like that FeelFree. Be nice to be able to paddle them all around the lake first.
This was an excellent review.
I've owned a dozen of the feel frees and they're a good boat. Very slow, I know they're not supposed to be fast, but I recently purchased a Wilderness Systems Radar 135 and it cruises down the river. Now I don't have to spend all day trying to keep up to my wife in her Pungo. No comparison. But the feel free is still a good boat, in fact i like my Moken 10 to camp out of more than any other boat, because of the front and back.
All three boats are very nice and would all be a nice buy. I really like the seat on the Lure, it's height adjustment is really cool. The Bonafied looks to have the nicest seat but I do not like what you have to do change the height. I think they need to work on a quicker setup, but the boat is incredibly stable so it may not matter. The Jackson looks very nimble and traditional. I will say I didn't like the hatch and electronics plastics on the Lure, they looked like something you would find on a $300 kayak imo. The Bonafied looked to have the best plastics overall but, and this is a big but, I can not believe the Bonafied doesn't have built in rod holders. That is absolutely mind boggling to me. I do not use a crate, I use a nice bag and cooler. And no way am I drilling holes in my yeti or gluing anything to it. I think they really need to take a hard look at that. If not for the rod holders the Bonafied would be an easy pick for me, but I think the Lure would have to be first just from that simple fact. Thanks for the great vids, very helpful what you cats do out there.
I like the hull design of the Jackson.
Great review! 1st time I’ve seen an in-depth comparison between the lure and the bonafide. While I love the stability and seat height (and height of the seat back) of the bonafide, the lure would be my choice as the basic boat can be retrofitted with pedal drive (and motor drive if I hit the lottery). Couldn’t see in the video but don’t the lures foot pegs adjust easily from the seat?
If bonafide would do a pedal retrofit they’d get my money but... lol
Thanks again and great job as always!
Great video, thanks for the production!
I'm a big guy and really like the Bonafide but I think I really want a pedal drive. Kinda torn between Jackson and Bonafide for getting into a fishing rig.
bonifide for the true fisherman id go with one the stability and comfort first really wish it had the seat of the feelfree though
Excellent review of the kayaks. Thanks
What are the weight capacities with each seat? Is there a cap? Bigger guys may be limited true? Not everyone is small or medium. Some of us are above 250 pounds. Weight capacity of each yak including the max weight for seat capacity is a deciding factor. I live in south east coastal Virginia and most of my kayaking is done in the salt water. Waves, tides, and wind are players. I have an old Ride 135 and feel as though the Lure would be my best option. I know Luther personally, but his kayak is, in my opinion, designed more for fresh water excursions. The Jackson will paddle like a barge. Thanks!
Hi Dan ... Just found this video clip, thanks for the info. ... Which kayak/hull design will choose for offshore work? Looks like the Bonifide has the higher sides compared to the others.
I bought a Cuda HD and put it this way. I LOVE the kayak. I really do however standing up in it is a complete joke. It's just not doable for me. It's too tippy. I wish i went with a Big Rig or the Bonafide SS127 myself. However i got a 2018 leftover model Cuda HD for a STEAL and i am very happy with the boat. It is pretty quick too. My next one will be a Bonafide though. I love the storage space and deck space that the boat has.
Very professional and in formatted
I have watched months of videos ... I favor the Bonafide ss 107 .... I am almost 70 and want the comfort.. It's light enough to load myself ... The replaceable skids ... I hear the wheel in the keel gets chipped up fast ... Love the front hatch better on the Bonafide... Just a better kayak for me
I was thinking about getting a (used) Bonafide SS107 for duck hunting.
I'm a short and light guy and I usually go ultralight with a 60-pound lab.
Any thoughts?
Hey Dan. Thanks for the info you put out in this video. I’m looking to get a kayak real soon as I’ve been researching which would suit me the best as I’m 6’4” at 280lbs. I’m leaning towards the Bonafide as you even said its the most stable. What are your thoughts on what I should get for my size. Thank you!!
Bonafide has a 425lb weight limit. I have one and love it. I’m 6’3” and 235.
Thank you for the video and going through the 3 boats. I am looking to buy my first kayak. I have been interested in getting a fishing kayak, but had some health issues that are hopefully in the rear view mirror. Again, thanks for going over the 3 kayaks. I am interested in the FeelFree Lure 11.5 and the Vibe Shearwater 125 and could use some insight on the two. The Lure looks incredible, has some internal storage and the very adjustable seat. The Shearwater seems to be really well thought out with internal access, storage areas galore, comes with a rudder and what also seems to have a very comfortable seat. Both are at the same price point, and can be retrofitted with a pedal drive. So, what am I missing? Which is better to paddle and which is more stable? Any insight or recommendations are appreciated.
Great video! I am so glad I grabbed 2 Lures from you guys. I was a little afraid that I would have buyers remorse after watching this video but for my personal needs I am more than ever convinced that the Lure for our family was the perfect choice! Thanks for a great review video Dan.
I am leaning on feel free but you open my eyes to the Bonafide I am looking for ocean stability for big game fishing. In its Limits of course which one is best for big water fishing
I just picked out feelfree lure 10 for $699 can't wait-
Can you do a video on a feel free Dorado vs Hobie pro angler 12
Thomas Jacovitch I have a PA 14. I’ll be doing a Big Rig Hd vs Titan 13 vs Hobie PA vs Dorado video
What about the vibe SG130?
great video I have been looking to buy another kayak and have narrowed it down to a few and the bonofide and the feelfree are in the top 4 for sure just still not sure which one I want to go with.
If you had a choice between the feel free or the bonafide for everything from still small lakes to the Puget sound here in Seattle. Which one would you buy
If I was paddling the sound I would not pick either of them. Both are too slow and wide for open water use. I'd pick a Ocean Kayak Trident, or Wilderness Tarpon or something along those lines with speed and glide.
There are so many boats and so many options and sizes, how on earth can someone choose? What would be a good minimum kayak? Something with a raised seat, stable to stand, don’t need the bells and whistles. Just something that works well in a river or small lake? I have a used old town dirigo 10’, it works well but it’s sit in and doesn’t track real well. Also seems tough to paddle. Field and stream has an eagle for about $500 they also have a much nicer one for $799. The ability to add peddles long term might be worth it?
When buying a kayak you must consider how much energy is required to paddle it. Wide kayaks with high seating positions may be comfortable to sit in but try paddling them against a strong wind and/or tide. You will soon get tired trying to paddle these yaks any great distance.
Hi! I've watched alot of your videos trying to find a good kayak to fish from here in Europe where speed is a important factor. You seam to be the person who knows about kayaks and what you are talking about.
I would like to see a video like this one, where you compare Feelfree lure 13.5 with a native, nucanoe and Jackson in the same price range.
Thx from Sweden
For speed, you might look at a Jackson Kraken. The 15.7 is faster than the 13.5.
As usual, thanks for the info my friend. I really wish the Feelfree boats would come in something other than the camo. Bit of a diva complaint but if they had colors like the Bonafides I'd be all about it. Also, if any one of these smaller boats had more horizontal rod storage (a la Nucanoe Pursuit - much bigger boat, I know) I'd buy it tonight.
Great review. Just picked up a lure V1 on clearance for $769. Arrives tomorrow. Already ordered the rudder kit. What are your thoughts on the PodMount trolling motor mounts they build for the lure? Worth the $150??
Hey Dan, did you ever get the Liska on the water? Curious about how the hull design performs, particularly on how much the standability hampers the speed. I realize there's always a bit of compromise on those two factors--your on-the-water review of Crescent Lite Tackle vs. Jackson Bite was informative. Def want to stand, but don't want a cumbersome super-slow yak. I'm 5'11" 170lbs, so don't need a big boat. Fish inshore saltwater in Florida.
All around. One boat only. Lakes rivers bay. SeaGhost 130 period. Paddle Yak !!
Electric troller, SS127 hands down !
Okay. Tired of researching. What would you recommend for a tandem (wife is tired of sitting on the shore with the dogs) fishing boat in the intermediate range? I've had a lot of back surgeries, so need a framed seat.
Loved the video, really liking the Liska. If you don't mind me asking do you guys still sell the Native Ultimate FX 13 propel? I'm very interested in that kayak after you did a viewers rig like a year ago, but I still haven't seen a more detailed breakdown of that boat.
Lots of great info. Thanks!
Question pls... Which of the 3 is best for fishing/camping overnights (fish/camping gear, cooler)? MAX WEIGHT LIMITS BECOMES A HIGH CONSIDERATION FOR ME. I do have Ulta Light backpacking gear but would take a YETI 65 if it's a 2 or more day trip. I currently take my PELICAN MONACO DLX when fish/camp overnights. Its MAX WEIGHT LIMIT is 775 but hard going against the currents of a large lake's shoreline.
Thanks, in advance, for your opinions.
I might stir up some emotions with this comment but I think that manufacturers of the pedal drives have them priced really high. They are complicated devices that are difficult and costly to manufacture. Kayak designs that make it easy and inexpensive to add a trolling motor may be a great option for consumers. This approach may be good for the consumer AND manufacturers. If no data but would guess they sell a pedal drive for every 4-5 kayaks they sell. Although the selling price of the pedal drive is almost as much as the boat, I'd guess the margins are greater on the boats. In other words, selling boats (not pedal drives) should be the focus. A boat designed to easily and inexpensively add a trolling motor may do VERY well. Your thoughts??
This seems to be a trend. Although companies like Native and Oldtown who have proven systems that have been around for a while are probably doing just fine with their systems. Innovation is expensive so if you can get some mileage out a product it becomes cheaper over time.
Awesome videos. I learn a lot from watching them. Have you done a review or comparison video with a kaku kayak?
My only real issue with the FeelFree is the hull design seems like it could be hung up on rocks in class 1&2 shores. Get a little sideways and your getting wet. Do you have any experience with that happening?