Ranking Every Mario Game From Worst to Best Reviewed
Вставка
- Опубліковано 22 лис 2024
- Hey guys welcome back to my channel where today I'm going to go through every single Super Mario games Metacritic score and putting them in order from where they rank in terms of review. I've seen alot of Mario ranking videos but none that do it in this specific way so if you enjoy the video please like, comment and subscribe!
Members tab is now live! Click to join for early videos and you'll be able to pick video ideas for me!
It really shows to the quality of Mario games when the lowest metacritic score is 75
Exactly lol.
The developers know what they are doing.
@@SmellinDSyrup For me is one of the worst Mario Games of all time... So BORING ! Hahahaha Combine that with Loot Boxes and you have a recipe for a bad game
@@SmellinDSyrup This video alone is why MK Tour is shit: ua-cam.com/video/Cqy1EKf2tRU/v-deo.html
Tbh mk tour is decent and good but IN APP PURCHASES MAN just like Plants Vs Zombies 2 a good game ruined by in app purchases
When the “worst” game has an average score of 75, you can tell that it’s a great series.
Sticker star should be waaay lower than 75 lmao
@@willcrabtree9561 I meant to say it’s a great series like the series has a great track record.
It’s the Nintendo boost reviewers give shitty Nintendo games a handicap
Ok fair enough I can agree with sticker star being the worst Mario game but come on guys it’s not that bad, it’s certainly not a amazing game but it’s playable same with color splash
@k ? Thousand Year Door is the best Paper Mario game by far.
I’m really glad odyssey is considered one of the best. As much as I love 64 and galaxy, Super Mario Odyssey is my personal favorite for the fun worlds and creative abilities. It’s just fun to move in that game!
Honestly I’ve played almost every Mario game odyssey is good but sometimes I feel like can be overrated it has great graphics and controls but other then that the game is just good the story isn’t great imo and the bosses are kinda mid it’s fun going around looking for stars but sometimes I felt frustrated and bored doing it I know there’s no point in making this comment since the original comment was made over 9 months ago but I still like to give my opinions anyways this is my opinion
I’ve heard that same thing said recently by ProJared
A year late lol but the only reason I prefer odyssey is movement. Galaxy and 64 will always be masterpieces but the movement always felt like it was fighting against you in those games.
Shame Super Mario Land 2 is so low, I can see why comparatively but I love how charming and genuinely weird it is. Not to mention, the worlds are beaten in a somewhat non-linear format, and centers around Mario working towards his own personal gain instead of someone else's(but still in a constructive way), which are two nice twists on the usual formula.
Copycat's videos feel so nostalgic. His style of video making feels like it came straight out of 2012. The good days. Love your videos by the way.
Right? They're relaxing and simple and free of cynicism in that sorta way.
Unless you’re old like me and 2012 sounds like it was three years ago.
2:15 I feel kind of guilty buying the full game now.
Same
I bought it too back then, I even one hundred percented it, and it was pretty fun honestly. It didn't stick with me tho
Neeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeennnnnnnnenen ene eneeenenneenneenenenneenneneneenenneneenen
@@lindasok7190 ?
Same
The DS new super Mario game was honestly so good. I have good memories of my childhood playing that game. It just exceeded my expectations.
I'm so glad to see Yoshi's world getting the love it deserves. It's my favorite 2d Mario game of all time
Some of these games deserve more Love, Right?!
Yes
definitely.
Wait Puzzles and Dragons Mario Edition gets a mention here? I never knew that the most forgettable and underrated Mario RPG would be noticed by someone that makes good content like this!
im pretty sure its not an rpg is it?
@@guthriebarrett it is. It shows health, you fight baddies in turns, it's an RPG.
@James Estes yeah not the best game ever, but for some reason I couldn't stop thinking about it.
@James Estes I agree.
Yeah exactly I like that game and the Z version bundled with it I have spent hours on. They're both quite fun. I love the enemy combos of the Mario version too, like Flutter and Flame Chomp or Bullet Bill and Goombas; there's something very charming about that! Also my favorite Z dragon is Thundra
I grew up playing snes, but Mario 64 blew my mind. It’s still incredibly fun to this day. However.... odyssey.... that’s the definition of fun. Such a fantastic game.
We deserve a sequel to odyssey. If they gave us that… I’d not ask anything more from Nintendo.
2:09 Switch Stop would like to know your location.
Thats what i was thinking lol
#Underveiwed
Weird that so many people actually know this guy
My top 5,
5. Super Mario World
4. Super Mario Bros 3
3. Super Mario Galaxy 2
2. Super Mario Sunshine
1. Super Mario Galaxy
Yes! Super Mario Galaxy is #1!
IM A CHUCKSTER
Valid top 5
no way sunshine is at number 2, 3d world, 64, odyssey are all better 3d games
@@kerestist These days I’d actually rank Sunshine at number 1. 3d World and 64 come at #6 and 7. And I don’t like Odyssey, that game sits at #14 for me.
Mario Maker: spend hours making and clearing your own levels that no one will play.
12:29 finally someone talks about super paper mario
I loved super paper mario
Mario Bros 3 is the best ever I’ve beaten it so many times and still play it over and over again
Super Mario 3D Land is my favorite of the main Mario games, I’m glad it was highly praised! It isn’t as amazing/perfect as it successors and predecessors (Galaxy 1 and 2, Odyssey, 3D World, Sunshine and 64) but I’m still glad it’s highly praised nether less but 3D Land to me I have always loved the most, I hope others get to play it.
Yeah, it is the most underrated mario game IMO
3D land was such a fun game my definite favorite
I never played 3D Land but I still play on my 3DS to this day even if I have a Switch
I am surprised by the really high score for Sunshine too. Having played it recently in 3D All-Stars, yeah, there are a handful of required Shines that are shockingly poorly designed, and the controls and physics are not what they should be. It may be cuz platformers were nearly non-existent in 2002, but it has aged much worse than Mario 64, despite the latter being six years older. It has the potential to be another masterpiece, but it was rushed a bit, and it shows by lacking the polish of most other entries.
What your favourite Mario game says about you:
Super Mario Bros: You love the classics.
Super Mario Bros The Lost Levels: You are a god of gaming.
Super Mario Bros 2: You can't beat The Lost Levels and think this is way better.
Super Mario Bros 3: You hate Super Mario World.
Super Mario Land: You are good at pronouncing difficult words.
Super Mario World: You hate Super Mario Bros 3.
Super Mario Land 2: You have very good taste in 2D platformers :).
Super Mario World 2 Yoshi's Island: You enjoy art.
Super Mario 64: You were blown away by the graphics back in the day.
Super Mario Sunshine: You like to be unique.
New Super Mario Bros: You were happy to see 2D mario games back when it first came out.
Super Mario Galaxy: You also have very good taste :).
New Super Mario Bros Wii: You love the Koopalings because you fight them a million times in this game.
Super Mario Galaxy 2: You have good taste. But you like something a bit more challenging.
Super Mario 3D Land: 2D plaformers are your thing but you like it when 3D games are based on them.
New Super Mario Bros 2: You love coins.
New Super Mario Bros U: You like to keep things the same.
Super Mario 3D World: You like catchy music.
Super Mario Run: You have no games consoles but wanted play a Mario game.
Super Mario Odyssey: You love good graphics.
This is all a joke btw. Please don't take this seriously.
Sunshine is criminally underrated. It deserves a hd remaster
It’s on 3D all starts but I love sunshine
I personally think that Galaxy should have been number 1 but Super Mario 3 is a fenomenal game
I’m so glad you didn’t forget to mention about Doki Doki Panic
I would love to see a version that is the Mario games ranked based on your opinion. Not what the critics think and the overall rating of the game. Don’t get me wrong I loved this video! I just think it would be cool to see what you think :)
New Super Mario Bros DS is one of the best Mario games. The mini games and vs mode was really fun and funny when playing with friends, and vs mode especially was competitive. The mini games were even fun to play alone, and so was the main story mode.
This actually turned out to be a really interesting video! I take back any minor doubts :)
Also, it's about time I subscribed!
Despite not being Copycat's ranking, it is still a ranking one and there were some opinions present. Also, I promised to put my ranking of the games included in my comment on the poll, so, here we go! (Time for another long comment...)
*ranking NOT final
24. Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars - Only played a little bit of this. It's fun so far, I'll have to come back to it sometime! ?/10
23. Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels - I have not made it past World 2! This game is very hard! It does like to troll you a lot with multiple paths, Hidden Blocks, crazy jumps and enemy placement, a deadly Mushroom, and "reverse Warp Zones" to take you BACK worlds. This all isn't necessarily a bad thing, but it can be at times. It could beat SML or SML2 in theory if I got further in this game, but not too likely. I don't dislike this game (so far) like some do though. ?/10*
22. Super Mario Sunshine - I've only played a few levels of this, enough to place it above Lost Levels, but that's it. It's fun so far though, and pretty unique too. I'm definitely going to play more of this in the future, and then we'll see how it truly ranks! ?/10* (Fav song: Delfino Plaza)
21. Super Mario Run - Yes, the story mode is short, but Remix 10 is pretty fun. Also, the Blue/Purple/Black Coins in levels provide some challenge. I've only played the first world as I haven't bought the full version. Toad Rally is fun too, and I like collecting parts to build my kingdom, and that there's no microtransactions. I really like it for a free Mario game! 7/10
20. Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island - This game is very pretty, charming, and innovative. I haven't made it through World 3 yet, but so far, I'm quite impressed. This game has the potential to be much higher than it currently is! 7.5/10* (Fav song: Athletic)
19. Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins - This game is quite unique. It's pretty easy, but the final level, Wario's Castle, comes out of nowhere with its difficulty. I haven't beat the final level yet, but I will try to soon. Despite being so low, this game is pretty good, and it could be a spot or two higher if I replay it someday. 7.5/10
18. Super Mario Bros. 2 - I never could make it past World 1 until recently. Now I've been to World 5. This game surprised me as to how fun it can be. It is very strange in level design and execution, which is what makes it good. It's also pretty difficult too. My only gripe is that the controls are very slippery and it's easy to fall off a platform or enemy and die simply because of this. Nevertheless, this game is fun and unique and if I ever finish it, it'll probably rise a spot or two! 7.5/10* (Fav song: Overworld)
17. Super Mario Land - Sorry guys, I actually like the original SML better than the second! I had fun playing this on my phone, learning the fidgety controls and weird level design. Sure, it's very short, but the strangeness alone makes me put it in this spot! It took me several runs to beat the game, as a few sections can be pretty tricky (looking at you, 4-2). Also, the music is quite catchy and pretty good for just being 4-bit. I have also truly 100% completed this game! 7.5/10 (Fav song: Birabuto Kingdom)
16. Super Mario Bros. - I must confess, I can't beat this game! Even with the warp to World 4, then the warp to World 8, 8-1 and 8-2 get me every time! I know you can hold A after a Game Over to retry the world, but no one did that back in the day, so it just feels like a cheap exploit. So I haven't beaten it or played all the levels, so if I ever get to do this it'll probably beat #15 (unless I play MM more). This is the true classic Mario game, the one that cemented him in our minds and put him on the podium! And it's still a fun adventure to this day! If you've never played this game, now's the time. Everyone should play this piece of history at least once! 8/10 (Fav song: Overworld)
15. Super Mario Maker - Sorry guys, I haven't played this one all that much. I've made a few levels, played some, and have enjoyed it, but my lack of experience with it means it won't be very high. This is my brother's favorite game though, so I do have a passive relationship watching him play it a lot. Just because I haven't played it much doesn't mean I don't like it much though. This lets you make your own levels and share them for crying out loud! 8/10*
14. Super Mario Bros. 3 - This one and SMW are both very innovative, complete, well-polished Mario games that have gone down in history as some of the best in the franchise. I haven't completed this game yet, as I'm currently in World 7 (this world is nuts), and even if I do finish it, I owe it a replay to cement my placement of it. It has been quite a fun adventure so far, aside from a couple levels that felt like trolls. Speaking of trolls, I have no idea why they thought it was a good idea to make the Mushrooms and Stars jump off the Blocks the opposite side you're on. This is infuriating at times, but it's just a nitpick more than anything. Just wanted to point that out as no one seems to mention it. Other than that, this is a great game and if you haven't played it already, what are you waiting for? The world's kingdoms are at stake! 8.5/10* (Fav song: Overworld)
13. Super Mario World - I have not finished this game yet, I'm currently on Wendy's Castle. This game really pushed the limits of what a Mario game can be, throwing in tons of unique level design, charm, and secrets, mashed with some quite challenging levels (like the aforementioned Wendy's Castle). While the Koopalings are easy, probably even more so than many of their fights in the Newer Series, they have much more unique patterns than in SMB3, which makes them more memorable. When I finally finish this game and play most of to all the levels, I can bet this will climb higher in my rankings, but for now, it's posted here. 8.5/10* (Fav song: Overworld)
12. New Super Mario Bros. U - This game has much more creativity than its 3DS counterpart, and more difficulty as well. Pretty much everything said about NSMBW applies here as well. The reason this one's lower is I haven't had the lots of nostalgia playing it when really young. Also, I've only played through this game once. After I do a no power-ups/checkpoints challenge, it might climb the rankings, but it's up against some stiff competition! I recommend getting this for the Switch, as it comes with Luigi U as well, which I enjoy just as much as this game! 8.5/10 (Fav song: Overworld)
11. Paper Mario - The first and currently the only Paper Mario game I've played. This game is fun, unique, innovative, has a great story, characters, battles, and puzzles. I haven't beat it yet, but I'm close. After completing this game, I may bump it up a spot or two, but it'll be hard to beat NSMB2 and the nostalgia and many hours associated with it. But this game really makes me want to play the other Paper Mario games, even Sticker Star. 8.5/10* (Fav song: Battle Theme)
Wow I got a "comment is too long" message! Check out the top 10 below:
10. New Super Mario Bros. 2 - Yes, it wasn't the most innovative game. Sure, most of its levels were easy. But I have had lots of fun with this game! Strangely, it has never been more fun to collect Coins, as having a universal Coin counter and a goal of 1 million (or 9,999,999) Coins helps make them much more fun to collect! And they're everywhere! After 100%ing the game, you get to visit Toad Houses to get infinite Gold Flowers, so you can use one on each level. I like keeping up with my Coin records on each level and replaying them and strategizing to see if I can beat my record. The DLC packs are fun too, and some, namely, Gold Classics and Mystery Adventures Packs, have some really cool and unique levels, and the Nerve-Rack Pack gives some of that difficulty back the main game was lacking. Also, just Impossible Pack. That's for everyone who says this game is too easy. Just try and beat Impossible Pack, good luck! Also, this was fun to replay with a no power-up/checkpoint challenge, and total my deaths. (I died 101 time total; I will replay again someday and try to beat that!) Also, I've 100%ed this game (except for Impossible Pack). So yeah, I understand if you don't really like this game, but I have lots of fun with it despite its few flaws. 8.5/10 (Fav song: Athletic)
9. Super Mario 3D Land - I like the idea of simple, linear levels turned into 3D form, especially for a handheld. This game was fun when I was young and still fun now. Many of the levels aren't very difficult, but the special worlds have their share of challenging levels, especially S8-Crown and S7-4. It also introduced the concept of remaking previous stages to make them harder, something which I enjoy if the remake is changed enough or a lot harder (like adding a Cosmic Clone, for example). I found it was quite fun to attempt to 100% this game again doing the no power-ups/checkpoints challenge, then totaling my death count. If you own a 3DS and don't have this game, why do you even have a 3DS? 9/10 (Fav song: Overworld)
8. Super Mario 64 - This is currently the Dark Horse in my rankings, making its way up the positions. I didn't get to play this game for the longest time, so by the time I got 3D All-Stars, I was more than ready to play this true classic! I haven't completed the game yet, and without nostalgic value, this game isn't nearly as high as many other's lists. But that's not to say I like this game any less than those people! I'd go through the strengths of this game, but that's already been stated a hundred times. Everything said applies here! The camera is annoying at times, but not awful. I can see this placing higher once I get all the Stars, and maybe replay it someday, but for now, it's 8th. 9/10* (Fav song: Dire Dire Docks)
7. New Super Mario Bros. Wii - One of my first Mario games and my first Mario platformer, NSMBW truly delivered! It improves on the DS version, adds 4-player support (which me, my bro, and my dad took advantage of), gives lots of fun levels, new power-ups, brings back Koopalings, some bopping music, and so on. I don't really have much else to say here except that it's a great game, and I can't wait to return to it yet again to do a no power-up challenge! 9/10 (Fav song: Overworld)
6. Super Mario Maker 2 - Now I'd probably have this game higher if I played it more, and even now this spot is not solid. I've played a decent amount of it, but since it has so much to offer, I don't think my opinion is solid yet. This is almost a direct upgrade to the original (except without Mystery Mushrooms sadly) where the creativity never ends! Build your own Mario levels in one of 5 styles, share them online, and play other's courses! Throw in Online Multiplayer, offline multiplayer, Endless Challenge, Story Mode, and Ninji Speedruns, and the fun never ends! 9/10
5. New Super Mario Bros. - The return to 2D Mario was well appreciated, and it started a great sub-series, too! We got 8 worlds of classic levels with new twists, power-ups, bosses, and music. Now in terms of just the main game alone, NSMB is actually my least favorite New Series game (not to say it's bad at all), but what really drives this one up the list for me is the Mario vs Luigi mode, which is some of the most fun I've ever had with any video game! It's a shame this hasn't made a return yet, but we can be thankful it exists in the first place! Only 5 stages, ruuuules are simple, but this mode is worth getting the game along, assuming you have someone like my bro to play with! But of course, even without this mode, this game is still a great one! 9/10 (Fav song: Overworld or Castle)
4. Super Mario 3D World - This game took what 3D Land did and made it even better! The levels are unique and fun, bosses are fun too (we even have a Boss Rush at long last), music is great, it's got that Mario charm, it has unique characters, and the challenge of getting all the collectables and completing every stage with every character. Some may complain about the generally easy story mode, but even easier Mario games have their challenges, especially when you do a no power-up/checkpoint challenge! Also, the special worlds say hi to your "easy difficulty" complaints! I'd love to play the Switch version with Bowser's Fury (which COULD bump this game up a place) so if I ever get it, I'll be sure to update this! 9.5/10 (Fav song: Super Bell Hill)
3. Super Mario Galaxy 2 - If Galaxy 1 didn't give that unique feeling, I'd be much more torn as to which to put higher. But that unique feeling of Galaxy 1 (which you'll see below) gives it the edge for me. But Galaxy 2 still invokes its own feeling. The levels are a bit different this time around, and (at least for me) are generally harder, which I like. Everything good about Galaxy is present in this game (except for the story) too. The Green Star postgame just adds even more to do into this game! Then you've got the Grandmaster Galaxy, which started the trend of Super Mario games (bar NSMBU, it had the crazy Challenge Mode instead) to make the very last level as insanely long and difficult as possible, to put your Mario skills to The Ultimate Test! (get it?) Amazing follow-up; would love to see a Galaxy 3 someday! 10/10 (Fav song: Main Theme/Sky Station Galaxy)
2. Super Mario Galaxy - What can I say that hasn't been said already? Well, aside from the amazing innovation, level design, soundtrack, story and background, charm, and challenges, Super Mario Galaxy seems to give a feeling that no other video game, not even Galaxy 2, does. It has a sort of open, mysterious feel of space, somewhat creepy and dangerous at times, but also relaxing and beautiful other times. Galaxies like Good Egg, Battlerock, Melty Molten, Matter Splatter, and Dreadnaught really drive the mysterious space-ness feeling home, while others like Honeyhive, Gusty Garden, and Beach Bowl give that more relaxing, welcoming feeling. Ah, I'm just rambling on about feelings that this digital piece of technology gives. But still, great game! 10/10 (Fav song: Good Egg Galaxy)
1. Super Mario Odyssey - This really is a near-perfect game. It is packed with charm, tons of innovation, secrets, awesome gameplay and level design, challenges, a stellar soundtrack, fun bosses, references, collectables, etc. Some don't like the sheer amount of collectables, but I think that adds to its replay value and just makes the game even better. You think you've scoured the entire kingdom when behold, there's a spot you missed, or a Moon hidden in plain sight! Also, gotta love the addition of 2 songs with lyrics, one being the game's main theme. This is something not seen in the Mario franchise and this really helps set Odyssey apart! 10/10 (Fav kingdom: Wooded, fav song: Jump Up, Super Star!)
Oh boy, that was long! Thanks for reading!
@@Wesley-76 Pretty solid ranking. My only disagreement is Land 2 being lower than 1, but I respect your opinion. =)
@@neypaz8054 Yeah that could change if I decide to play Land 2 again, it's not out of the picture! Maybe if I finally beat Wario's Castle I'll bump it above the first one
12:13 It definitely didnt help to make the WiiU stand out from the Wii.
Awesome list. Now let's see all of the main Sonic platformers ranked by their Metacritic scores! ;)
Dare you to make a video that has you rating every game to ever feature Mario as playable (so including Smash, Paper, & Luigi, etc...)
Yay! Nice job getting a weeks video done early!
the galaxy games are by far my favorite. First of all the music is amazing and the landscapes are beautiful. Its challenging but its done in a way that its not frustrating like some games. They are just great.
If you have them which galaxy game do you like better? I have 2 already and I’m contemplating buying 1.
@@egggamer1800 gotta say #1 is amazing. #2 is kinda just the same game but different at the same time.
@@mistymint_V alright thanks.
@@egggamer1800 ya welcome
TTYD is one of the greatest game I’ve ever played and I’d say it’s top 3
Suggestion: Put in your videos "In my opinion" because there are a lot of controversial things in the video, other than that, great job :)
But is is not in his opinion, it is based on meta critic.
Still understanding what you mean though
I hate when youtubers say “this is just my opinion” anyone with a brain can see that from watching the video I don’t need them spelling it out for me just so some people don’t get offended
Well there are some people who just have no brain cells to understand this, and sometimes youtubers say things that are so incorrect/controversial, they have to say "in my opinion" otherwise they will receive unnecessary hate.
If they're watching a yt video they should realize it's the creator's opinion...
Fantastic list, however, I would consider Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island as the first game in the yoshi series.
Odd that Paper Mario games and Yoshi's Island were considered as part of the rankable games, despite them not really being mainline Mario games.
The video title said every MARIO game (aka if it has mario in the title)
To be fair, if even the lowest rated games in the series are getting a 70-odd out of 100 rating, you're not doing too bad. Whatever you may personally think of them.
One thing you could have done is making the public opinion scores as tiebreakers, but besides that- nice video! 👀
Big fan Copycat! Love the content keep it up
I love Color Splash. I don’t get how it has “repetitive mechanics” any more than the other Paper Mario games. Well, I don’t know, it’s the only one I’ve played. I still need to play Thousand-Year Door, I wish they would port the first 3 Paper Mario games to Switch or something.
Personally, I have played the Wii U Virtual Console version of Paper Mario on N64; Super Paper Mario, which I first played as a young kid and couldn't figure out how to beat until years later; Color Splash, which I received for my 2017 birthday (along with Animal Crossing: amiibo Festival, ugh) and ended up 100% completing; and finally The Origami King, which I have probably completed about a quarter of since my 2020 birthday and haven't really played in a year or so. Out of those games, Super is the most nostalgic and my personal favorite, followed by 64 for being objectively the best after TTYD (which I haven't played), then CS, which has a flawed battle system and is really only saved by the music and writing, and last would be TOK, which I haven't felt much desire to revisit and honestly has an even worse and more confusing battle system.
As for the final thing you said, fortunately the original Paper Mario is going to be available on NSO + Expansion Pack. Less fortunately, we have no idea if/when GameCube or Wii games aside from Mario 3D All-Stars will be released on Switch.
Wow, this was pretty long for necroposting (replying to an old Internet comment), so I hope you appreciated it.
@@Griffintendo First off: Oh my god, I already forgot about N64 VC coming out lmao. Second: I've watched RTGame's video Super Paper Mario: A Love Letter since making that comment, and it looks so much better than Color Splash. Wow. Still really want TTYD on Switch, though.
I love super mario land because it was the first og gameboy I got when I started collecting 7 years ago
I had so much fun with Super Paper Mario. Admittedly it was my first Paper Mario game so maybe that’s why but I always have it much higher in these rankings than others do.
Both Super Mario RPG and The Thousand Year Door have been remade for the Switch. Nice to see Nintendo hasn't entirely forgotten those classics.
1 - Bowsers inside story
2 - The first one, I think it was SuperBean Saga
3 - Partners in Time, although I might be wrong, I didn’t care for the rest
Bro Ong bowsers inside story was the best
7:07 its actually my favorite in that series
I think its good, but its way to easy
With Super Paper Mario I enjoyed it more than I thought I would but I knew what I was getting into when I got it. Definitely not as good as the last one though.
The Mario Galaxy games are my favorite games, but Galaxy 1 is my favorite one ever!
To be honest. I loved Sticker Star
For me it was just simple. I didn't care that it wasn't super complex or didn't have a really deep story, I just kinda enjoyed it
That's just my opinion tho
Do this with Zelda next
Yes , he should do it for Zelda’s anniversary
Mario Odyssey DEFINITELY isn't the best 3d mario imo
@Work and Stuff it would be either galaxy 2 or 3dword. Both these games just have amazing level design. galaxy 1 would be my 3rd.
Sunshine was pog until i played the unforgiving levels xD. I didn't mind the plinko machine... but the other ones...
Super Mario 64 is better than Super Mario oddysey
my fave is 3D land
I completely agree, every time I play Mario Odyssey, I keep pointing out it’s flaws.
I personally disagree but I respect your opinion (Odyssey is at least top 3 for me, and I have 300+ hours in it)
I easily have put over 200 hours into super paper Mario between when I was a kid, replaying as a teenager, and replaying as an adult with my husband. I’d like to replay it again one day with my daughter as well. I don’t know why, but it’ll always be my favourite game
Paper Mario Sticker Star was honestly underrated. I liked the worlds, puzzles, stickers, and Kersti. Of course, there was no point to the battle mode if I’m being honest (outside of coins) but it was still fun to use the Things and the Stickers to battle
I LOVED paper Mario the origami king and I had a blast but I completely agree. The battle system gets so tedious and boring. But battling aside this game was great!
Nightmode for the metacritic score screenshots would have been nice
I’m surprised you didn’t mention hotel Mario and you should do this same sort of video on dr. Mario and Mario kart
I’ve been waiting on this video!
I feel like if you ranked games based on your opinion and not Metacritic I would have liked it better. Sure that's not as unique, but it would be more objective, as reviews are also largely impacted by the history. For example, you said that NSMB Wii was better than NSMB DS, but it was ranked higher, because the reviews at the time wouldn't hold up as well. I wouldn't rank Paper Mario 1 as high on this list, what with all the other games out there, (Thousand Year Door, *ahem*) but obviously it was the first of its kind when it was likely reviewed.
26: Run (2016)(Another console series to mobile game failure)
25: NSMB 2 (2012)(The “new” series isn’t so new anymore. Gimmicky!)
24: Lost Levels (1987)(A poison mushroom? Are you kidding me?!)
23: Mario Bros. (1983)(Games have gotten so much better)
22: Land (1990)(Might be higher if it were longer)
21: New Luigi U (2012)(Nothing more than bland NSMB DLC)
20: 3D Land (2011)(Not the 3D game we needed or asked for)
19: Maker/Maker 2 (2019)(An awesome idea with mixed execution)
18: Super Mario Bros. (1985)(A classic start to this long running franchise)
17: NSMB Wii (2009)(More not so new “new” games with sloppy multiplayer)
16: NSMB U (2012)(Does something interesting, but not much)
15: Super Mario Bros. 2 (1987)(A unique, refreshing sequel)
14: Land 2 (1992)(I miss when 2D Mario was still creative)
13: 64 DS (2004)(Adds so many cool things and so many issues)
12: NSMB (2006)(Back in my day, New Super Mario Bros. was actually new!)
11: Bowser’s Fury (2021)(A banger that would benefit from 2 or 3 more hours)
10: Yoshi’s Island (1994)(A delightful little game! Lovely!)
9: Super Mario Bros. 3 (1989)(The definitive Mario game)
8: 3D World (2015)(Looking back, this game rocks!)
7: 64 (1995)(Brought Mario into 3D very well, I’ll be it, flawed)
6: Galaxy 2 (2010)(Injects the OG game with more color and energy)
5: World (1992)(The SNES is a fantastic console with fantastic games)
4: Odyssey (2017)(The grandest Mario game since Galaxy)
3: Wonder (2023)(Mario on an acid trip! This game is wack!)
2: Galaxy (2007)(Puts the grand scale of space into perspective)
1: Sunshine (2002)(Is and always will be a Top 3 game ever for me)
I really wish there wasn't so much hate for color splash. I loved it!
Woo! Glad you chose to upload early!
They are right for Mario rpg having great graphics, when I first saw the game in a UA-cam video, I did not expect it to be from the snes
Wario earlier (SML2): Wahahaha I will attack Mario and have the all powers to control the mushroom kingdom, wahahah!!!
Wario now (WarioWare): Same but he instead of controlling Mushroom Kingdom he wants to control gaming industry
The forced perspective from the camera killed me so many times in 3D World. And there were several levels that were half-baked and level segments that were completely pointless.
That never happened to me, but rip
Weird, UA-cam un-subscribed me. I'm glad I saved this video to watch later, because I noticed that I needed to subscribe again. UA-cam is so weird sometimes.
4:54 missed an opportunity to show rocky wrenches
Overall, Im really satisfied and glad for this ranking :D
this is mostly the consensus and less of a ranking because hes using the metacritic scores
For me, of the ones I've played.
1. Odyssey
2. Galaxy
3. Yoshi's Island
4. Super Mario 64
5. Sunshine
6. Super Mario World
It's hard for people to really judge properly, particularly the older ones, since they were made such a long time ago. One forgets what a masterpiece they were. Also some people might play a game once and never get to take in the genius behind the game.
Sonic when he gets a 7/10- Let's go
Mario when he gets an 8.9/10- And I took that personally
Shout out to easy allies. (The guys at game trailers started easy allies when game trailers went down and then sold)
What do you mean Mario isn’t the focus in the Mario and Luigi series?
Both Mario and Luigi are the focus, not just Mario.
@@Ethan-gw6mi That’s like saying Mario, Luigi, Toad, and Peach are the focus in Super Mario Bros. 2 and 3D World and that they therefore shouldn’t be counted. That isn’t a good reason to exclude those games, especially when the other Mario RPGs were considered valid.
@@genericyoutubecommentchann7418 Those game have characters you choose. Mario and Luigi require you play as both characters, while the latter just haves them there if you want.
@@Ethan-gw6mi True, but it can also be said that you can play Super Mario Bros. 2 and 3D World without even using Mario at all. In those games he’s entirely optional. In Mario and Luigi it’s required to play as him even if it is simultaneously with Luigi. And once again, other Mario RPGs were included.
One of two focuses, technically.
I honestly thought GameTrailers went defunct. Nice to know IGN saved them.
I want them to make more paper Mario games without stupid gimmicks. I absolutely hate the origami king’s battle system but the world and story are good just give me the old battle system back.
If they made Mario run a game you can use Mario movement then it would be amazing
Edit: BRUH HOW DO THIS COMMENT GET LIKES!?
I tried playing a game that uses Mario movement on an emulator with a touch screen as the controller. It wasn't fun.
The first time I played sticker star I didn’t even realize how painfully bad it was. Years later I still kinda like it but opinions exist
Nobody says its painfully bad, just not that great for a mario game.
9:06 exist
Me who has a poster of that game:come HeRe YOU liL ShI-
Sticker star brought a lot new. The entire battle system (bad change), the art style leans much heavier on the paper aesthetic (great change), and the music style is also pretty different (good change). The battle style was what ruined the game for most.
While I understand that _Hotel Mario_ was probably excluded because it wasn't on a Nintendo console, and _Mario Bros._ because it's an arcade game, but why weren't _Mario's Time Machine_ and _Mario Clash_ included (besides being no-brainers for the bottom of the list)? Also, even though it's technically not a separate game per-say, I think _Bowser's Fury_ should've at least had an honorable mention.
Why isn't the Mario & Luigi series here if Paper Mario and Super Mario RPG are?
I’m assuming it’s because mario and luigi games are more about the bros as a pair instead of Mario as a character.
@@RainbowGalaxyAE yeah but yoshi island is here and you don’t even play as Mario
@@mooster4080 I mean... fair point.
I suppose the game is about rescuing Mario and bringing him and his brother to their rightful parents. Yes I know Luigi is the one who gets saved at the end of the game, but Mario literally lands on a Yoshi’s back...
@@RainbowGalaxyAE but Mario rpg is about the 4 main characters the game FORCES you to play as. JUST like the Mario and Luigi series. Copycat is full of shit
This was the video I was looking for ty!
I could probably just scroll through the metacritic but this is way more fun!
i love sticker star and color splash :'(
Me too :(
I don’t think people think it’s a horrible game. Just very mediocre compared to all the other mario games. So you shouldn’t feel bad 😊
@@The_Slickmeister yeah if you take the paper Mario out of it and make it A new series it probably rates higher. but the standard set by the first three games was just too high for the most recent 3.
@@The_Juice14 👏👏
@@The_Slickmeister thx :)
“Coming in at number nine is super mario sunshine.” Bro started spitting bars
6:38 I see most points people make as to why it’s not very good but I still love This Game something about just listening to the music Or seeing gameplay brings me joys Though it’s probably just because It was One of The first video games I every played And My first Or second Mario Game I’m not sure if it was New super Mario bros 2 Or Mario kart wii
yay so exited for this vid
out of interest dude where did you get the idea for "oh ye by the way my name is copycat"
coz its really cool
Your poll post reminded me of your new video, it's working! Lol
Damn I enjoyed sticker star
It was fun just not better than any other game
It's still a good game! A score of 75 is still a great score. It's just that comparatively, it's the worst game of the Mario franchise. But all Mario games are great, so you shouldn't feel bad for enjoying it! :)
Good
26:25 wait if the critic doesn’t think it’s perfect why’d he give it a 10/10
I was thinking the same thing
lol me too
Because 10/10 in video games doesn’t mean perfect because no game is perfect. It just means it’s really damn good.
If a game is 9.5 or better it would be rounded up not down
10/10 doesn’t mean perfect it just means the person had a really good time
So many games are missed out, such as yoshis island touch and go, new yoshis island, new super mario bros u deluxe, super mario 64 ds and much more, they may be remakes, but they are still their own games
Awww I personally give the color splash a 90/100 and or 9/10
I wish Nintendo would combine game mechanics, for example Super Mario Odyssey and Super Mario 3D World to make Bowser’s Fury where you had Cappy and you use power-ups where if you didn’t have a power-up you could capture enemies and if you had a Fire Flower Cappy would spit 1-5 Fire Flowers out in different directions depending on how many you have in your inventory
@serg snake Yeah I know I just wanted an example and for it to be an actual game
I'm sorry bro but I deadass busted out laughing when you said galaxy had tough bosses
I ALWAYS run in mario games so super Mario run is like a dream for me and a controller saver. I haven't played b/c im poor but when i can imma eat that game.
My own picks:
20: New Super Mario Bros 2 (7/10)
19: Super Mario Bros 2
18: Super Mario Bros USA
17: Yoshi’s Island
16: Super Mario Land (8/10 on IMDb)
15: Super Mario Sunshine
14: New Super Mario Bros
13: Super Mario 3D Land
12: New Super Mario Bros Wii
11: New Super Mario Bros U
10: Super Mario Bros
9: Super Mario 64 DS (9/10)
8: Super Mario Galaxy 2
7: Super Mario 3D World + Bowser’s Fury
6: Super Mario Land 2: Six Golden Coins
5: Super Mario Bros 3
4: Super Mario Galaxy
3: Super Mario World
2: Super Mario Odyssey
1: Super Mario All-Stars (10/10, though that’s really only for its version of Super Mario Bros 3)
Haven’t finished any of the RPG spin-offs except Legend of the Seven Stars (9/10)
Hello, I have a few things to say and forgive me for making this a long review but my Asperger's Syndrome and OCD are just part of my need to be thorough, first I think that given the fact that the actual "Super Mario Bros 2(Super Mario Bros: The Lost Levels)" is now available on the switch in both the SNES All Stars Version which is a game Playable on the SNES Gaming app of the "Nintendo Switch" and is also available on the NES Game app which is more true to the actual game than the SNES All Stars Version people should try playing it even if they do like I do and use the "Frame Rewind Function"(don't ask me to describe it exactly I just know that if you press and hold L&R on the switch controller you can reverse to a previous spot you were playing) to make the game easier by avoiding loosing a power-up or saving time on the maze mechanics(though I just looked up the right direction online through play-through videos), they might give the game a higher rating so you may want to at some point re-examine this category and even though you don't generally include the "Superstar Saga" and other various Mario Titles(one of which should be the Original Donkey Kong, as it was the first game Mario was in) especially as new Mario Games are made, and on that note you may want to do a video on Unique titles featuring Mario whether they be that Basketball Game that has Mario as a playable character, one from the aforementioned Superstar Saga, or even the "Mario and Sonic" at the Olympics games just to show how far Nintendo has tried to involve Mario in Gaming, second I understand that people were upset with some of the Mario Titles because the games were "Too Easy to start" but I think that for game player's like me who want to finish the game but don't want to rip there hair out because it is "Too Hard" that Nintendo should either resume releasing cheat devices like the old "Game-Shark" or the "Action Replay" which while sometimes causing glitches can make the game more fun as you now can do/have everything in it without driving yourself crazy trying to get it, which is especially good for people like me and for that matter for parents of young game player's who's kids start yelling at them because they can't "Win/Beat the Game" and don't want to see their kids break the expensive system or make them throw out the newly bought one, third I just want to remind you that one thing I'd love to see in your videos is a comparison of the various versions of the Mario Games, as in for example comparing the SNES and the Switch's NES version of "Super Mario Bros 2: The Lost Levels" to see the differences, whether they be graphics, music, or game-play itself in the 2 versions, just as I'd like you to do the same for the American version of "Super Mario Bros 2" from its original version of "Doki Doki Panic" to the NES version to the SNES version in "Super Mario All Stars" to the version for the "Gameboy Advanced" as there are several differences in both graphics and game-play in all 4 versions including in the case of World 5-3 the music played in certain spots, so please don't let me down and if you want I can write an article about this for "Pittverse Magazine" which I write for as it is for people like me who have Autism and that does get a lot of readers, one last thing I think that one thing you may want to make a video on is about the different TV/Movies made based on the Mario Character such as the Anime: "Super Mario Brothers: Peach-hime Kyuushutsu Daisakusen! English Subbed(www.thewatchcartoononline.tv/super-mario-brothers-peach-hime-kyuushutsu-daisakusen-english-subbed)" or the TV Series "The Super Mario Brothers Super Show" to the 1993 Movie with Bob Hoskins as Mario, John Leguizamo as Luigi and Dennis Hopper as Kopa, plus any other film releases ever made including live action and cartoons
Great video!
.. you showed Bowser's fury first yet didn't show it ???? It's seriously good
Its really just an extension to super mario world
I thought you would rank Mario karts to😂
I wanted to see Mario kart tour be at like a 40, then the second lowest at 75👀
CopyCat - love the content! I like how you match up the music with each game that is being talked about, simple editing like that is what makes great videos
Copycat: and a final boss in Wario who would never show up in a mainline super mario game
Super Mario 64 DS: Am I A Joke To You
Nice vid
Sorry if anyone criticizes me for posting a comment like this, but I really, really, really wish characters like Mallow and Geno were recurring characters like Luigi, Yoshi, Peach, Wario, Daisy, and Waluigi. I also wish there were somehow even more RPG games of Mario similar to Final Fantasy games. There is always another future after one. I just hope someday something will be confirmed. I wish it was not true if it is true something special will never, ever happen.