I get that you normally would pretreat stains, but I can't tell you how many times I've pulled clothes out the dryer and realized I missed a stain. Also my teen child never catches the stains. So I personally would prefer the one that cleans best when we miss stains. I will always try to catch them and treat them, but that doesn't always happen.
There are only so many ingredients that can be used in the detergent market. Both brands fluctuate % of ingredient to stay competitive with each other. The only thing better about Tide is their marketing. Persil is the Tide of Europe and is the number one challenger to Tide in the US
Persil and a version of Tide (though usually not the original) are always the top 3 detergents in Consumer Reports testing. I don't like how strong Persil's fragrance is so I always get the winning Tide version but if you love fragrance, Persil is the obvious choice.
It would be interesting to test Tide Ultra Oxi powder. It has an oxygen bleach (color safe) along with an activator so it works in cold water (unlike oxyclean and other oxygen bleach products). Only powder detergents can contain bleach (it's not stable in liquid detergents) so it would probably perform better for stains.
I have the same type of washer. And I don’t use the precise feel because the water stops every time I lift the lid up. I like to add my detergent when the water is flowing as you did, so I choose what size load I’m doing so that the water is running and I can add immediately.
Right, I’m trying to use the precise fill option more to save on water but sometimes I’ve found it to use to little water. It’s really hit or miss sometimes. They’ll probably improve this feature as time goes on.
I've been a huge Persil detergent user. I gotta say Persil is the best detergent I've used gets out more stains and gets it more cleaner than tide. I've also used Oxiclean powder and clorox 2 liquid to boost the cleaning power even Lysol Laundry Sanitizer and scent booster beads to make my laundry smell good and sanitized.
Tests isnt comparing 1:1. That persil is like tide febreez. Regular persil is 1:1 to regular tide. Persil oxi to tide ultra oxi. Persil stain release to tide ultra stain release. I'm loving the format of your tests, but please compare the direct competitor for said detergent.
I see your point but I still consider this to be a 1:1 comparison because when you look at the ingredients for the Persil intense fresh & Persil original, the only difference are 2 ingredients. Persil original has sodium chloride which as the website says “may contribute to stability or modify viscosity” & a silicon emulsion which is as the website says “an antifoaming agent. Neither of those ingredients are significant enough to alter the results. The original contains the exact same surfactants & enzymes so their cleaning power are one in the same. If I was doing a scent comparison then I’d make it more of a point to pick the tide febreze. I could easily switch this & have tide frebreze vs persil original because just as the Persil, the tide original & tide febreze do not differ significantly formulation wise.
@@CelestialBreeze0325 That was the joke. Me pretending that it went over my head and I was correcting him. They literally put "Lol". That's why I mentioned both "tied" and "tide".
Great test. I only noticed water was added first to the cloth A before detergent. Water applied after on B. Almost forgot to add water first. I think maybe apply more water before pretreatments. To get the clth good and damp. Then try. Ha, Ha, rematch.😊
@@thecleanpsycho that will work. You can open the lid and get a direct read of the water temperature after it completes filling. That temperature will be the temperature it washes at since your machine has no internal heater.
Honestly yes, the only thing I don’t like is that you can’t wash like a comforter in it because it will mess it up. Like it chewed my comforter apart but as long as it’s not that it’s been really good. I like that it has an agitator and that you can pick the water fill level if you want. Also, the pre-soak option is amazing for more set in stains. I’d rate it a 8/10. We’ve had it for 4 years now and so it hasn’t had any issues thus far.
I have used numerous detergents including Tide, I was a Tide lover years ago, until I discovered Persil, Persil is much much better than Tide at cleaning clothes and taking away odors, love Persil ❤❤❤
There's always a version of Tide that's tied with Persil for #1 in Consumer Reports testing but it's never Tide Original. Currently Tide Ultra Stain Release is tied with Persil Proclean
Team Persil here!!! I do a lot of cooking. Oil stains are so difficult to get out, and Persil does the job!
We have the same washer and dryer. My husband likes buying simple appliances because then he can fix things himself when they need it.
I get that you normally would pretreat stains, but I can't tell you how many times I've pulled clothes out the dryer and realized I missed a stain. Also my teen child never catches the stains. So I personally would prefer the one that cleans best when we miss stains. I will always try to catch them and treat them, but that doesn't always happen.
There are only so many ingredients that can be used in the detergent market. Both brands fluctuate % of ingredient to stay competitive with each other. The only thing better about Tide is their marketing. Persil is the Tide of Europe and is the number one challenger to Tide in the US
Persil and a version of Tide (though usually not the original) are always the top 3 detergents in Consumer Reports testing.
I don't like how strong Persil's fragrance is so I always get the winning Tide version but if you love fragrance, Persil is the obvious choice.
It would be interesting to test Tide Ultra Oxi powder. It has an oxygen bleach (color safe) along with an activator so it works in cold water (unlike oxyclean and other oxygen bleach products).
Only powder detergents can contain bleach (it's not stable in liquid detergents) so it would probably perform better for stains.
You need to use Tide He ultra stain release. To make it equal to that Persil deep clean. To equal the enzymes.
I was gonna say, *this* is a very tasty rag. But then you got to transmission fluid 😂
For pretreatment, do a mix of water and detergent and put in spray bottle and just spray the stains and scrub. Saves a step.
Also your commenter is correct. For the machines that you add it into a detergent dispenser it dispenses after or during water fill.
I just started using Persil for my sons cloth diapers and it works so amazing for them
I myself use Tide ultra stain relief and it works like a gem
I have the same type of washer. And I don’t use the precise feel because the water stops every time I lift the lid up. I like to add my detergent when the water is flowing as you did, so I choose what size load I’m doing so that the water is running and I can add immediately.
Right, I’m trying to use the precise fill option more to save on water but sometimes I’ve found it to use to little water. It’s really hit or miss sometimes. They’ll probably improve this feature as time goes on.
Tide is my favorite
I've been a huge Persil detergent user. I gotta say Persil is the best detergent I've used gets out more stains and gets it more cleaner than tide. I've also used Oxiclean powder and clorox 2 liquid to boost the cleaning power even Lysol Laundry Sanitizer and scent booster beads to make my laundry smell good and sanitized.
Wow that’s a lot, I just add vinegar. Gets the smells right out.
@@2jcwardHow much vinegar?
Tests isnt comparing 1:1. That persil is like tide febreez. Regular persil is 1:1 to regular tide. Persil oxi to tide ultra oxi. Persil stain release to tide ultra stain release. I'm loving the format of your tests, but please compare the direct competitor for said detergent.
I see your point but I still consider this to be a 1:1 comparison because when you look at the ingredients for the Persil intense fresh & Persil original, the only difference are 2 ingredients. Persil original has sodium chloride which as the website says “may contribute to stability or modify viscosity” & a silicon emulsion which is as the website says “an antifoaming agent. Neither of those ingredients are significant enough to alter the results. The original contains the exact same surfactants & enzymes so their cleaning power are one in the same. If I was doing a scent comparison then I’d make it more of a point to pick the tide febreze. I could easily switch this & have tide frebreze vs persil original because just as the Persil, the tide original & tide febreze do not differ significantly formulation wise.
Tide all the way for me. I prefer the scent especially the botanical rain version.
And if there was an LA Awesome next to those, it would prob have don’t the same job! It’s blowing me away how equivalent it is.
Yes specifically the yellow bottle. I’m going to test the others as I go but the yellow bottle in my opinion has the best cleaning power.
Could you repeat the test please? This time do it the guy way: Throw the stuff in the washer without pretreating anything ever in your entire life.
What u mean the guy way ?
Rak bakal ilang mas nodane
They tide because Tide was there. Lol. Thanks for your time. I will give Persil a try.
They *tied and not "tide".
@@disguiseddv8ant486bro that pun went right over your head :/
@@CelestialBreeze0325 That was the joke. Me pretending that it went over my head and I was correcting him. They literally put "Lol". That's why I mentioned both "tied" and "tide".
Great test.
I only noticed water was added first to the cloth A before detergent.
Water applied after on B. Almost forgot to add water first.
I think maybe apply more water before pretreatments. To get the clth good and damp.
Then try.
Ha, Ha, rematch.😊
Great point!
👏👏👏
2:05 you're going to measure the temperature of your water? excellent. This will definitely help better explain results and verify claima
I am yes, I'm doing laundry tomorrow for myself, and I am going to note what it is.
@@thecleanpsycho how will you do it? Collect some water entering the machine with lid open and then use a food thermometer or something else
@@johndoe-vc1we I saw another person use a thermometer gun to see what the general temperature was, so I’m going to do the same.
@@thecleanpsycho that will work. You can open the lid and get a direct read of the water temperature after it completes filling. That temperature will be the temperature it washes at since your machine has no internal heater.
❤
Do you like your GE washing machine? Been looking at this model but not a whole lot of reviews on it
Honestly yes, the only thing I don’t like is that you can’t wash like a comforter in it because it will mess it up. Like it chewed my comforter apart but as long as it’s not that it’s been really good. I like that it has an agitator and that you can pick the water fill level if you want. Also, the pre-soak option is amazing for more set in stains. I’d rate it a 8/10. We’ve had it for 4 years now and so it hasn’t had any issues thus far.
I have used numerous detergents including Tide, I was a Tide lover years ago, until I discovered Persil, Persil is much much better than Tide at cleaning clothes and taking away odors, love Persil ❤❤❤
I 1000% agree. Persil is king but I need to test it against Ariel powder because I really like the results from that detergent as well.
@@thecleanpsycho I need to go check your video with Ariel, I used to use it years ago in Mexico but not here in the US.
Airel and persil are the best. They're practically equal
There's always a version of Tide that's tied with Persil for #1 in Consumer Reports testing but it's never Tide Original. Currently Tide Ultra Stain Release is tied with Persil Proclean
Can you do percil stain fighter vs tide plus ultra
I'll check my local store to see if they have it. Persil sells really quickly near me so I'll have to be on the look out.
persil did the better job
they both Tide lmao
PERSIL FOR ME