Regardless of how this case ends up, I can't stop thinking about how differently things would be if Johnny had lost the right for live trial streaming and we only had the mainstream media sources to rely on.. scary
I'm also shocked about how Johny Depp slams doors! losing his temper! was all in the headlines, but the whole rest of what everyone said was left out. I even saw an article completely defending Amber Heard and that everyone who said differently was misogynistic. I'm also very glad people can make up their own minds about this. Compilations about the trial tend to favor Johny Depp heavily, but then again Amber Heards lawyers really have nothing to work with (or are plainly rude to JDs witnesses, look how they treated his financial advisor Mr. White).
@@redpill1940 With some. With others, he's right. It'll follow him for the rest of his life. /he'll never be able to unring that bell with some people that seem to want to see him as a villain. It makes me so mad.
Yes. I have seen some articles from highly regarded sources that just... it's like "are you paying attention? Are you watching this? Are you being paid off?" Like one that talked about how the jury MUST have felt so bad for Amber when Camille was "badgering" her about not having photos of the injuries or medical records. Like no... most people will be thinking more like "yeah you told him not to make you prove it bc you had so much evidence and it was so well documented but where is the documentation?"
We all remember how horrific Rhianna’s face looked after her assault.. that was a 5 minute confrontation that started in a Moving vehicle- Yet Amber testified she was sliding on bloody broken glass , slung across the floor - she claims her hair was torn from her scalp- he head butted her - slammed her head against the wall - repeatedly punched her in a rage … yet those pics say otherwise
facts! not only that she would have scars from the broken glass she was sliding across. She would have required a hospital no question in regard to the sexual assault with the bottle. The woman is sick and crazy. The audio of her admitting to hitting him and the Dr telling the nurse that they have to get Johnny away from her after his finger was severed should be enough. She is guilty of perjury especially saying that the makeup compact she used to cover her bruises wasn't launched until 2017.
I am a registered nurse…and we ARE trained to assess all body systems and wounds and injuries…that was puzzling for me. She could have just said if there was injuries I would have documented them. If it’s not documented it didn’t happen, she def looked bad saying she wasn’t trained to look for those injuries. We as nurses look for objective info. Facts. Things we see.
Same I’m also an RN and worked in icu and imc. If the events she claimed happened happened, no competent health care worker would be able to ignore that extent of injury (concussion, broken nose, facial bruising, open cuts, imbedded glass, potentially a limp from vaginal injury etc)
@@dijolola3579 exactly…unless it didn’t happen, and there was nothing to document or asses because it wasn’t there….which I totally believe AH is lying. She’s in another world.
Same! The only thing I can think as to why she said that was scope of practice??? Idk... it's a stretch. Another thing that bugged me was the "frank blood" on AHs lip... so if she has "frank blood" am I crazy to question that wound being basically immediately before RN assessment - ie picking her lip right before RN arrived... did anyone else catch that as being questionable?
@@MM-wn9wu yes! Like what does that mean? What did it look like? Was it blood from a busted lip? Or blood from chapped lips? What was it! If you find things like that, you ask questions and you document!!
I hate when people say JD fans are Attacking her or don’t believe her. I hadn’t thought of him in years. I wouldn’t have called myself a fan but I know a liar when I see/ hear one!. It has nothing to do with being a fan.
Its funny how some of those in hollywood have a weird mentallity that we need to know everything about them, and how important they are.. (Jim Carrie's recent comments) Um...most of us have lives to get on with. some box office movies mean actors get insane pay...the amounts we can never dream of... Does their insane income mean they are "better" than joe average? Or that their word on global issues or pet causes, is what we should follow? No We are all born naked.. We all need to wee and poop... No one in this world is more important than anyone else I don't kowtow to celebrity culture nor wealth adoration I like many of JD s movies.. Who was AH again?... I didnt know much of JD,s life, except hes a great actor, and has had several celebrity relationships... What i have been gripped by, is the accusations... And i totally detest liars because of my own life experiences.... Its my belief, AH is a liar....
Same. Over 30 years ago I covered some exercise books with pictures of JD, but since then I'd just appreciated some of his movies. More recently I thought badly of both of them after the 'dog smuggling' incident in Australia. But my mind was blown when I started looking into this case. Everyday something new comes to light that shows AH outright lying, setting up a hoax to extort money or obviously being the aggressor in audio recordings.
Exactly ‼️ JD got the receipt s ‼️he's got the credibility of witnesses they all including three police officers saw no cuts bruises black eyes no hair pull out ‼️her makeup artist did her face again no marks none ‼️her own words I " hit u" she said she said that on tape nothing bout him hitting her ‼️,he gave u fame money luxury life u gave him hell embarrassed too his kids career but yet he stands tall looking so good that's not just a fan thing here he's got a better stronger more evidence case here
Regarding her feet being cut - there is a video of her rehearsing a dance scene for Danish Girl, supposedly days after the Australia incident and you see no cuts, bandages, etc on her feet AND she has NO problem dancing.
I stepped up small pieces of glass at home after dropping a glass. It hurt to walk for a week, even in tennis shoes. When I went into the studio to train, it was excruciating. It didn’t matter how I well I tried to protect the very minor injury. It didn’t matter if I was en pointe, wearing flats. I am used to my feet hurting but wow. If you step on a tiny piece of glass, it hurts. I don’t care who you are.
There is also audio recorded straight after the incident and you can hear her walking around in heels, and talking to a doctor, nurse and bodyguard, none of whom mention any injuries on her
😫 I wish someone would put together a timeline of what happened in sequence., with dates .. with all the extra footage.... like elevator footage and any public appearances that fits in .... its all so confusing .... if I could do this I would.... surely I can't be the only person finding it hard to keep track
AH’s claims are expansive, and her receipts are meager. I once worked for someone with an explosive temper who could be very verbally abusive. Being someone who normally doesn’t shrink from confrontation, I absolutely found myself fading into the woodwork to avoid him when he was in a bad mood. That’s why AH’s claims fall flat for me. If she were being viciously abused as she claims, I seriously doubt that she would have been taunting JD the way she did in those recordings.
Or dropping a grumpy on his bed. I don't know any victim of abuse who would go out of their way to antagonize their abuser in such a way. Even a non abusive person would be irate if that was done to them.
@@jenniferbestulic3579 Especially because it's so explicitly disrespectful. Abusers want control and nothing makes them lose it more than disrespect. I was viciously abused growing up and could barely breathe thinking about what would have happened to me had I ever done something like that to my abuser. He'd slap me across the face for looking him in the eyes he screamed at me and then grab me by the neck for 'ignoring him' by not looking at him as he screamed less than a minute later. I'd be dead if I did half of what she did in any 1 single recording
Exactly. Your survival and safety comes to depend on de escalation and placate g the bully or abuser . You font seek confrontation and instigate.. but Amber does because she is the aggressor itching fir a fight so she can release on JD
The differrence is you only worked with that kind of person, and Amber was married to one, meaning she wanted to have a functional relationship where her needs were met , too. So, it is not comparable situations of victimhood nor motives. You wanted to avoid as much as possible, she wanted to fix him, if one is to believe her case. I really don't think it is right to stereotype victims into how they should behave. If someone attacked me I would push back. Others would run. We are different in fight or flight situations. Thats why it is called fight or flight.
@@sB-wt5ov Abusers are rarely in a long term relationship with a person who would push back. Either because of what attracts them to a person to begin with, or because the relationship would not last with someone who won't tolerate abusive behavior and break up.
The horrific scenes she described being thrown across tables glass everywhere crawling through that constant punching in the face dragging across the floor punched against walls sexual assault and alot more .... I would have taught an ambulance would have been called for broken ribs bones etc blood gushing from nose n ears on deaths door not a picture of just bags under the eyes after few bottles of wine
Sounds as if she were beaten to a pulp. Concussion my butt. If this woman's walks out of this Scott free I will never believe in the law again. I know a couple of men going through the same think and felt all said who will believe me. At least in south africa you can divorce a person without spilling your guts. If you are such a abused man then rather get divorce and walk away. It'd better for a child to visit you in love a pease, that grow up in such toxic situations
I would have liked to have seen the Neuro Phyc testing to see if any real TBI lingering issues. I have not had the extensive head injuries due to beating BUT I have had concussions and deficits! I did not get it!
She made a recording right after this event you hear Jerry judge and her doctor and nurse talking about her when they get to the apartment. Its on UA-cam and disproves her whole story
On the Australia tape Jerry Judge says she has some self inflected scratches on left arm. Amber was stomping around in high heels you could hear it in the recording. Doubt if sexual assault happened, she wouldn't be stomping her feet in her heels.
@@al-dh5ju once the tape wasn’t allowed AH changed her story to JD cut his own finger. They tried ( but failed ) to get the doctors notes rejected because they reveal JD suffered a velocity fracture. 100% a compulsive truth manipulator.
You’re absolutely right! Her lawyer had to remind her what happened to her. That’s definitely leading! I just don’t believe her because I’m a victim of domestic violence and I’m not satisfied with how she testified.
That's a polite way of saying it. I'm sorry that happened to you btw. I will say she bullshitted from start to finish,ALL to ruin Johnny for dating to leave her. Psycho.
Same. I’ve been thru DV and although it’s a yucky feeling to say, bc of the “ believe all women” narrative, I don’t believe her either. Her story is non sensical, no supportive evidence and in stark contrast to other witnesses and evidence. I despise her bc she’s setting women back.
I am also a victim of violence, both domestic and otherwise, and there is no possible way I can speak about the incidents in the manner AH does. She's definitely not credible, based on my experience and observations of other victims of AB.
I don't think you can really say how a person is supposed to cry but there's something really odd about someone looking absolutely like they are trying to push a tear out and nothing comes out as long as she was talking.
There are physiological things that happen when you cry like your nose gets red and your face, your nose will start to water, it's biology. Not everyone cries out loud some cry softly but in both situations nose runs, tears come out of eyes face reddens eyes become puffy, it's how your body releases stress. That's why people are having a hard time believing her.
My mom and my sister were both victims of domestic violence and they never looked like Amber Heard's photos. They had bruises all over, black eyes, bleeding in the eyes, hair yanked out ect. If Amber Heard was violated the way she testified, she would look like Rhianna or Christine Mackinday. Amber Heard had access to doctors, nurses and bodyguards 24/7 and it doesn't matter who's paying their salary. They are obligated to report domestic and sexual violence. If Amber and Johnny wanted to settle their dispute in privacy or not press charges, it's their right, but LE would initially have been involved, if Ambers story were true. Amber also talks about a fight on a private chartered flight, where Johnny allegedly kicked her in the back and threw things at her. The security team would have restrained him and the pilot would have asked for permission to an emergency landing at the nearest airport. Neither the pilot or the security team would gamble with the lives of everyone on board that flight. Amber didn't seek medical attention and didn't document all her "injuries" like she documented Johnny's drunken sleep. She clearly knew how to snap a picture... BTW; Would a drunk and stoned Johnny remove all his chunky rings before having a go on Amber? NO WAY! English isn't my first language, so apologies for any grammar and spelling mistakes 😊
If johnny Depp was beaten her at the volume she said and she said he raped her with a wine bottle and she said blood was everywhere why didn't she take pictures of her injuries if he had beat her that bad she would have needed a ambulance to rush her to the hospital and she said he beather that bad u wouldn't be able to walk around and you would have had a concussion I said he must have beat her with SpongeBob square pants I am a survivor of domestic violence and abuse and the way she sets there saying that it just infuriating me u can tell she's a liar and that acting was awful I pray johnny Depp can clear his name and I hope they get her for lying under oath
My mom was a victim of DV too: face bruised, swollen scratches, broken ribs, etc. not a single pic, demonstrated by Heard and her team, look similar to those injuries. Bruises do not look like one dark spot as on those pictures of her leaving court after obtaining TRO. Broken nose, she claims? No way. Her eye area would be swollen due to that trauma. We all saw how she looked on that TV show. This is disgusting how she’s trying to pretend being a victim of DV.
If JD had been looking directly at AH while she testified, they'd say he was trying to intimidate her. No matter how he behaved during her testimony, they'd jump on it and point out what he did wrong.
I thought the exact same. He would be called out as intimidating her. I recall him looking at her intensely 1 time, and that was when she played the recording of him being suicidal, and you could see the utter disbelief and hurt in his face, even a tear, why did she record that anyway? She wasn't trying to help him, just words to make it sound like she was. You could see that he could believe she'd stooped to this level, even her lawyer awkwardly skipped by that. That was vile. And he held that look on her until she looked at him, then he looked away. That was too far. And honestly I thought it reflected on her character rather than his.
Johnny has never once made eye contact with her while she's on the stand or anywhere else in the court room. She keeps looking at him. It must be driver her crazy that he just sits there drawing or just looking away. He doesn't want to look at her anyways.
She testifies that when JD hit her it “changed her life” . She was arrested for DV against her former girlfriend. I don’t believe she’s never been in a physically abusive situation, it’s documented, and she was the aggressor!
What really bothers me is the "evidence" such as pictures and video really seem to be taken to actually humiliate him not proof of abuse. Especially after he lost his mother. So heartless. Worst kind of person
@@christinejones8717 That's absolutely what it was. Just like her PR statement, just like most of her testimony, & the audios she played. I think in her mind that she believes even if she loses, at least he's going to be too humiliated to show his face or get all the respect & adoration from fans he's gotten. Which shows just how freaking twisted she is.
Found your channel just as the trial started. You are an actual dream, explaining the legal aspects in such an interesting and simple way! Non biased and completely fascinating. 💯 the best legal commentary on social 🙌🏽
@@mzfreddie the hesitation right before he said it was even funnier 🤣 Bless poor Rotternborn he's career is over! Another life Amber ruined. She's pretty good at that.
I'm a dv survivor and had to stop watching her testimony live early on her first day because I felt so angry because it was so obviously false ... A lot of other survivors have said the same
Same for me on both aspects. I was beyond angry. Living through it myself, this woman mirrored my abuser in SO many ways...definitely not the other way around
I watched some of her testimony and felt like she was playing to the court room. If she had all of these injuries I’d want to see hospital records of them.
@also, maybe You're delusional. You've clearly not been listening to the audio or watching all the testimony that we have. Bc there's ABSOLUTELY no way that she was there victim. She was 100% the ABUSER! It's in every single word she says, in her every look glaring him down from the stand. & Daring him to look her in the eye. Or maybe you are 1 of her minions. But what actually happened is Depp covered for HER bc he didn't want her to get in trouble. She's admitted in her own voice on her own that SHE cut off his finger on Australia. There's so much evidence showing she's the abusive one, & absolutely NOTHING showing him as abusive. Also, aside from the ppl paid to do Johnny's bidding as you claim, she was working on a movie after being horrifically violated w\a bottle as well as choked, slammed against every hard object in the world & dragged over dozens of broken glass bottles naked, where all her body is shredded. That was HER description. Yet it was what the next day or the day after that we have video evidence of her dancing without ONE SINGLE INJURY on her body. & We can see a LOT of it. Specifically her uninjured feet!
And the Police Reports! It's my understanding, when an abused person arrives in the ER, doesn't the ER Staff contact Law Enforcement? It doesn't have to be done by the victim, family or friends.
@also, maybe he went to the hospital in Australia. When he was taken to the hospital she talked to his people and said she didn't mean to do it. She tells all this stories constantly changes what happened. No medical records no pictures. She talks about all the drugs she took. So she's no better. They obviously had an insane fight, together ruined the house and she went to far with that bottle. Ozzy was a mean insane drunk and I don't know how Sharon forgave him that's between them but it's not the same
when she described Bering backhanded , flying through the air and sliding on the wooden floor story , it's the scene from sleeping with the enemy even to the small injury on the head !! she's definitely watched that film .😢 funnily the characters name is Laura Nd she calls him the monster 😂
Doctor Curry explained Amber Heard's personality, then Amber got up there and proved her right. I'm an empathetic person, but I couldn't feel anything but contempt for her. 10 yrs I spent with an AH, and I've been mad crying due to true PTSD. Karma is coming for her.
I do believe that both psychologist stated that they did not support the theory of ‘mutual abuse.’ Neither do I and I hope that the jury caught this also when making a decision. Saying not nice things while being beat is not verbal abuse.
Yeah, I don't think anyone can make a reasonable argument that calling your spouse who abuses you, cheats on you, lies about you, etc, a "wh*re" is abuse.
Amber said how the nurse came to take her to another room and give her ambien, the nurse should’ve been cleaning her up, bandaging her feet and face and arms and ect but she didn’t mention the nurses doing any of that for her…? She must’ve forgot to add that part
I saw a video recently with audio from that night and the doctor told the nurse to give her seroquel. There wasn't even a mention about any injuries to her by her or the team of people who were there in crisis mode looking for his finger and trying to figure out what happened and what to do with her. I think it was on Incredibly Average's channel if you want to checkit out.
@@mzcytin that audio was unreal. The part where the doctor is talking about Amber flying back to LA and needing someone to go with her who wouldn’t be manipulated by her demonstrates how everyone around them knew she was insane.
The recording of the incident (not in evidence) also does not support her claim. Dr. Kipper and Nurse Debbie discuss giving her Senecol, but nothing about any injuries to her feet.
As an RN, I find it ludicrous that an RN would claim she was not trained to assess injuries especially knowing a woman, or man who claimed abuse, would not assess for injuries and/or document any injuries found on a victim. If one claims one's nose is broken, it is not only painful but possibly is interfering with breathing and it is obvious even for an untrained eye to see. I had a broken nose. It doesn't disappear overnight. Where did this nurse obtain her license?? Google University School of Medicine and Nursing? What an embarrassment🤬
@@brandydinsmore8214 as an RN; any RN seeing facial trauma would assess not only the injury but assess the head fully, any facial injury could result in head trauma. Remember a big part of tbi is the sudden stop that slams the brain against the skull.
Anyone else referring to Emily and this case so much people think she’s a family member or friend 🤣 my husband and I compare case notes thoughts and Emily’s law knowledge daily - ty for making this insane case bearable 👩⚖️love your channel !
At this point I'm surprised she hasn't testified that he just pulled out a gun and shot her in the chest. But you see she's got wolverine genes so she pushed the bullet out and healed too quickly to take a photo or go to the hospital. There's a faint red mark left where it happened so that's been submitted into evidence, naturally.
My undergraduate law professor said this case makes her upset...especially with all the objections and weird finessing of procedure they keep tryna do...and how the testimony is all over the place
@@fellowviewer1095 all the times Amber Heards lawyer tries to "lead" her into the answer her lawyer wants. Heards lawyer is a very notable lawyer here in VA and is a "super lawyer" a distingushment they give to very few...she knows procedure well enough to not do it as many times as she has but there isn't a counter case here...everyone deserves representation and they tried throwing it out but the judge dismissed it letting the hearings go on...my prof said if she were the judge she would have thrown it out after Deps testimony because she thinks they just want to air out dirty laundry at this point and it's waste of time...I mentioned that I learned a lot about procedure in this case and she said "a lot of awful procedure" with the caveat
@@stellaallbright4750 we talk about current events before lecture...since she is a family law attorney/general attorney (she also did minor contract disputes and tort law later on) who then earned her PhD later on...this class is related to torts so I brought it up...we also discussed will Smith and the slap...Jesus tht feels like a forever ago
Verbal abuse is abuse but if it was about verbal abuse there would be no article? As bad as verbal abuse is if everyone was put in jail the jails would be more crowed than they already are. This is because of the sexual and physical abuse allegations.
Good point. He certainly wouldn't have been cancelled over verbal abuse, especially after all of the recordings of her clearly verbally abusing him. I've never heard of an exparte for verbal abuse either.
@@emma2370 violence is abuse. but her lawyer is trying to claim that amber in the article was also talking about verbal abuse so because they got in to heated argument's they lawsuit should be dismissed which is b.s.
Kate Moss has always kept in touch with JD. Stayed good friends all these years. I have a feeling she’s going to testify that she was NEVER PUSHED down any stairs.
If they can prove AH doesn’t have first hand knowledge of the KM/stair incident , they might not call Moss. That would also mean AH can’t produce one of JD’s ex girlfriend to testify against him.
I don’t think they’d scramble to call and prep KM as a new witness during rebuttal, unfortunately. I do think her name dropping Kate gives way to Johnny’s team questioning AH about this name-dropping and her OWN past relationships during cross.
@@dmb6559 not sure about that, remember AH said she was told about the rumour & bringing KM on can’t disprove her story. KM could say it’s not true but the rumour would still stand. Personally I think AH made the whole thing up just like her other story’s.
I was a victim of someone's violent actions, no marks from Johnny's rings in the bruises, thats strange! I cannot believe AH has done what she has done. Her description just does not float with me.
As a survivor of child SA, DV in my first marriage and SA 2 years ago, she angers and triggers me so much. How can she put her head down on her pillow every night and sleep straight and soundly?? She has made a mockery of all true survivors and what we have been through.
I, also, am a child SA survivor and adult SA survivor. I feel for you and am familiar. She angers me and the way she talks about it or fakes recalling it, is no way how I’d share my experiences, even with my counselor. Also I can’t look or stare someone down talking about my trauma. It’s too painful to even want to recall and share, I don’t want to be seen or look into someone’s eyes as the hear what happened to me. It’s too disgusting and I feel so gross. I hope she is held accountable for lying sooooo freaking much. It’s so narcissistic.
She can because she’s a sociopathic narcissistic monster….Incapable of feeling for others or feeling empathy…Only concerned with how she can use & abuse other humans to get her own narcissistic needs met. She’s a recidivist perpetrator. She needs to be criminally prosecuted and imprisoned before she hurts new victims. I honestly believe that Johnny was lucky to make it out of the relationship alive. There are indications that she was planning on killing him and claiming it was in self defense (one reason why she was so concerned about not being in his will). Her own sister, Whitney, told her employer at the time, (whom she called her “chosen sister”) that she was worried that Amber was going to KILL Johnny! It’s the reason that Whitney moved out of the penthouses and moved in with her employer/“chosen sister.”
I just wanted to stop by and tell you I found your channel and I love your channel I worked the court system for 25 years & I love watching trials, I’m retired now so I can. I wanted to make a comment on everybody seems to think that Johnny Depp looking down and doodling instead of looking at Amber heard is weird but it’s not. during one of their fights or whatever you wanna call it he told her “I will never look at you again” and he’s not looking at her. it’s driving her crazy if you watch her on the stand she can’t stand it & she’s trying to get a reaction out of him.
Spot on! I'm sure you have noticed: as her emotions rise to crying, sobbing, heavy gasping sighs, she's definitely looking towards JD then at the jury, back and forth. Yet, no tears.
P.S. Oops, I didn't finish my comment (it's close to 2:30 a.m.). Anyway, the rising crescendo of AH's emotions during testimony, I believe, is AH doing her damndest to get a reaction out of Johnny! And, he is handling it all very well. He has kept himself in check; well done JD!!! I know from experience how difficult that is. God Bless Johnny & Team Johnny for the win!!!
And he should ‼️ he JD said I do cocaine,pills alcohol I abused myself no one else JD is more than proven his Innocence here ‼️ but Disney, Warner bros he will never go back too " Dior stuck by him years ago never drop him ever ‼️ look how they doing amazing$$$$$ many said he was guilty never " Dior so bleep all those who dropped him he will be bigger now than he ever was why" for believing in his self and wanting it on live stream on tv so all the world can see what really happened
I hope his career doesn’t continue to suffer because of these lies. However, no matter what comes in the future, it doesn’t change the nightmare she put him and his whole family through.
You've said everything I have been thinking, in particular about Amber Heard's testimony. As an abuse survivor, I'd be condemned by the survivor community too and that disturbs me almost more than Amber Heard's inconsistencies and apparent lies. We're not robots with identical personalities that think, feel and behave all the same. Our analysis of Amber needs to have depth and nuance. You've done just that, and I, as a survivor, thank you @ Emily D. Baker.
I don’t think people are saying the personalities have to be the same. It’s just for Amber you can tell certain things she’s making up. I believe some things she say & then there are things that’s she crazy lying about.
@@LexxJussMitee - I have listened to and read comments from people who have made comparisons between themselves and Amber because she's not apparently shedding tears and other forms of expression. They may be picking up on a real distinction but are talking about it with little if any insight into the real problem with Amber. In doing so, they themselves shame anyone who doesn't think, feel or behave as they do. The modern definition of personality is the sum total of how one thinks, feels and behaves. I don't think they are doing this comparison with malicious intentions, but the consequences of what they say is not good for anyone who isn't them, especially if they are young in their recovery from any form of abuse.
@@karenholladay2612 My doggie are ready for the excitement as well, can't wait to pop the popcorn 🍿 too!! 😃. I truly hope that Johnny gets justice ⚖️ and ATurd gets charges of perjury 🤞
Out of all the UA-cam channel's that I've seen grow...watching Emily's channel grow makes me the most happy. She deserves the best. I love you Emily!!!
Emily D Baker. Your wit and cleverness !.. My dad would’ve gotten a kick out of you and your commentary. He was “just a small country lawyer” in CT. Also, the most brilliant mind and kindest soul I’ve ever known. I miss him like crazy. I love listening to you. Thank you for sharing your massive talents to all of us wee folks out here on the interwebs 💜💜💜
@@susu_m very true, they don't. I think the incongruence here is that it's clear that "crying" is 100% what she's communicating to the court, but it's coming off as super overdone and inauthentic.
I wasn't aware that Johnny Depp was named in the original op ed and that his name was removed. I'm a Kiwi, up until recently not a JD supporter, saw Edward Scissorhands, that's it but when the op ed came out even I instantly I knew Heard was talking about Johnny. I dismissed it because I didn't believe her
Thank you for supporting the truth and Johnny. Yes according to the story about the Op-Ed, they wishy washed. First, they had JDs name in. Then they took it out. Then the ACLU writer wanted to put it back in to attract more readers because of JDs name.
Whawawahaaat?? I also didn’t know that!! And I’ve been following this since maybe week two(?) american and a Depp fan from “jump st” so to speak. But now I’m grown and don’t keep track of celebrities. Until this trial. This is fascinating. That’s a humungous deal his name in first copy of that article. Hmph! Geeze! Love to you Kiwi friend! 💜, 🗽ny
I've written everything she's said off as a lie. Even the things she has no need to lie about are soaked in lies. I'm just watching for feelings of increduloudness at this point.
I agree with this. Once a person has been shown to have lied (or embellished) on multiple subject/events, I cannot in good conscience believe anything else they say, unless there is absolute proof. I had the same reaction to Meghan Markle. Once you notice that a lot of her stories are either lies, exaggerations or that tbey make no logical sense, I cannot understand continuing to believe her. I feel like there is this whole wave now where anyone can say anything or accuse anyone of something and the burden of proof falls on the accusee. The accuser gets believed without evidence and the accusee needs to proof that the accuser is lying. It should be the other way around. God forbid I, as a third party, ask the accusee for any proof of statements made so I can made an informed decision on if a story is crecible, because that is apparently not the done thing anymore and people will verbally attack you online for doing so. The more accusers getting shown to be liars the more it actually impacts the real victims. Because of liars looking for attention or power the real victims suffer from public doubt when they accuse. These people make a mockery of someone else's real trauma and experiences to get attention or power and I find it very disrespectful and indecent.
I've been following multiple channels on the AH trial. From what I hear, JD's attorney was happy about the Kate Moss issue because past relationships abuse was excluded per the prosecution's request. AH bringing up Kate Moss allows Johnny's team to bring up the Tasha incidednt and AH getting arresting for DV.
It’s also being put about that KM was purposely mentioned so AH can bring in one of JD’s EX’s to testify against him. AH has already played down her DV arrest by lying about it in the UK trial. Although she shouldn’t get away with it in this trial .
@@thekitowl Jennifer grey? Haven’t seen anything suggesting AH purposely made that detrimental slip to open the door for JD’s team to bring up her prior relationships (DV arrest included) on cross so that her team could call one of JD’s ex’s last minute? Seems convoluted. More likely that AH’s thought processes were in overdrive trying to fabricate her testimony, and she slipped up with the Kate moss mention.
@@cutlass2523 you need to watch more channels covering this trial. AH does have one of JD’s ex’s on her witness list, a scorned one at that, who will claim JD threw a bottle at her proving JD can be violent to women & she’s not Jenifer Grey.
@@thekitowl That is stupid on AH's part since most of JD's ex's has publically come out and said that he is very protective and not known JD to raise a hand during the UK trial (Vanessa and Wynona) Kate Moss has come out and said she doesn't know what AH is talking about and confirms Vanessa and Wynona's sentiment.
@@nguyenkh2002 it’s possible this new witness could put doubt in the jury’s mind because as you say his other ex’s speak highly of JD. The judge might not see the KM mention as a reason to open the door because it’s only a story AH was told ( or made up ) I noticed in her UK testimony she played the DV arrest right down & didn’t answer when asked if she spent the night in jail , she also lied about why the charges were dropped. Be interesting to see which way this goes.
She's a liar and no one can tell me different. I've been through everything amber has described AND MORE and I'm a 5'9 280lb woman and believe me, I fought back and STILL ended up with black eyes, fat lips, a broken arm, sprained ribs multiple times, I have a permanent scar from my face smashed on a table with a coffee cup, etc. I've never been so disgusted with a person in my life, including my abuser. Amber Heard is done.
There is a recording where AH and JD are arguing. In one part of the argument you can clearly hear JD going away from AH to leave. You can hear her say “Johnny get off me!” When she says this JD is at the door already, so you can tell she is setting him up. Making it seem as if he was on top of her. He wasn’t. Question: How can you prove to a jury that he wasn’t on her, and how can you prove she was setting him up? Is there a way to?
people should listen to the recordings , these enough will tell you who lied and who didn't !! she literally told him that no one would believe him because she planned all that for 3 years , put on makeup and took photos and then she sent texts to her friends and parents so she would have proof of all that .i think that all of you should listen to that she outed herself and told him all of her plans , i was in shock she had the audacity or should i say the stupidity to say that. really hope that they'll play that record in court.
@@elainascott7496 last I heard, the Daily Mail still had links to the recordings on their site, other than that, there are a variety of yt channels that have them. Incredibly Average has posted a few and has also done some pretty impessive research on the case.
You're really good at explaining the trial. I liked how you broke things down. I watched the trial for hours and you were very succinct with key points & moments.
Hey there's a 4 hour uncut audio of Amber and Johnny discussing the relationship here on UA-cam - it's unnerving how the conversation goes nowhere and she starts yelling multiple times. Feels like Malcolm and Marie. In 4 hours of relationship discussion, at no moment she complains about him being violent - on the contrary - she admits that SHE starts the violent fights
May favourite part of that audio is when he says ‘I’m just being honest’ and then she immediately yells at him for calling her a liar. Like out of nowhere. And at the end she says that she was being so nice to him and never called him any names and he was insulting her the whole time. He never called her anything and she had called him a baby, an old man and suggested his body guard Travis should come in and suck him off
Thank you! :) An extra thank you for being the only person on UA-cam (that I've seen, and regarding this case) and in the trial to acknowledge that everyone responds to trauma differently, and that *not* everyone cries. I'm team Johnny, but I'm also so sick of hearing and seeing so many people say that IPV/DV victims *only* respond a certian way. ♡
After hearing her testify and all the contradictions...It feels like she's projecting SO much what she did to Johnny by saying that's what he did to her. We have literal proof that she hit him, berated him, insulted him, would prevent him from leaving but when she talked about things that happened she would say that Johnny was the one doing that! Just wild how her mind is flipping everything....
The “million dollars and a million alpacas” was his answer when someone asked him if he would go back to work for Disney if they asked him back AFTER they announced they were going a different way on PofC 6. They didn’t even do him the curtesy of informing him before putting out press. It had nothing to do with “creative differences”
As much as I do not believe she went through that level of abuse from johnny and I don't know her personally just what I see through out court and don't like what I see, but would be nice for her to get herself checked out and get the help she would need
I really appreciate you, I have been interested in this situation for a couple of years since hearing the leaked audio and realising Johnny at the time of the recording was in the position I had been in, in the past. I was nervous about being triggered especially when listening to Amber. You are like my comfort blanket through this . Just wish I could mute Amber and just listen to your commentary. Thank you for all that you do and for changing your flight and for the amazing community and the fantastic chatbox.
I just watched the Behaviour Panels analysis of parts of AHs testimony. I love them, they're so good and really know they're stuff. Really interesting to see their breakdown of her body language and spot on too.
My problem with her testimony is there any medical evidence. If he beat the crap out of her that many times there would be a lot of medical evidence. 40 years ago I was in abusive relationship. In one year I had to go to the emergency room six times. I had to have glass picked out of my skin. My nose was broken. The way she describes the violence there should’ve been some cracked ribs I know that’s what I experienced. If your nose was broken do you know when your nose is broken trust me. When you’re being backhanded and throwing around things break whether it’s a big toe or a finger something breaks. And you need medical attention. I don’t believe her I hate saying that but I don’t believe her. I’m not a fan of him he screwed up. I just don’t want to see when a woman comes forward then I believe because of this person lying it really breaks my heart. When I went to court 40 years ago things were quite different. I showed up with a broken arm choke marks around my neck and the judge asked me if I really wanted to break up my family over this. We’ve come a long way and I don’t wanna see this woman push us backI’ve never talked about any of this in public only in therapy. I’m sorry if my wording is wrong because I am not typing I’m using the microphone that types it for me.
As a nurse the first thing you do ALWAYS is the head to toe assessment. Geez I start it the moment they walk in saying hello. And yes, we notice bruising, scratches, bumps, lumps on exposed skin. Shit I notice dandruff, pet hair etc
I’m so glad I found your channel. Your are straight down the middle no bias from any of the videos I’ve seen I’ll be a supporter of this channel for sure
Emily, I am relatively new to your blog and I want to thank you for making it so clear and going step-by-step for us newbies. I have been trying to fit these pieces of the puzzle together with questionably results. Thank goodness I have found you‼️‼️‼️
Went to the garden center after work today and found myself drawn to the purple blooms. I was surprised at first because purple isn't normally a favorite, then I realised I've been watching Emily for a month! Love the purple, love your commentary 💜
After hearing her telling her harrowing Australia story and then seeing the pictures of her taken after, I totally laughed out loud! Her nose was NOT broken, ftr. I know what the after effects of a broken nose look like and I saw nothing. She had two TINY little discolourizations under her eyes that were extremely faint. I thought they could possibly have been photoshopped or it was done with makeup.
I have watched every live stream for the last week, and I find this round up very helpful. So much gets discussed, so it’s nice to be reminded of the major talking points. Your hard work does not go unnoticed Emily.
Your voice is so calming, and easy to understand. As someone who is hearing impaired, that's very important to me! You also give off a great vibe. I just subscribed! 🙂
I am an extremely sensitive empath. I watched a video from popcorn planet that was people who were abused telling their stories and in less than 5 minutes of the first story, I was in tears. 2 days of Herds testimony and all I felt was anger.
I know you do this primarily for the podcast, but thank you so much for providing even brief video/visual descriptions. As a blind person I really, really value this.
I love that you're a gamer at heart like me! It gives me validation to play games at 44 yrs old! And you're also my favorite UA-camr. I can't watch this trial without you, please don't leave again!!💕💕🎮
This has been a fascinating trip into the better side of the internet. Your commentary is clear and welcoming: you bring people into this process, making it accessible and human. Well done!
My mother was and is a severe narcissist and I have bpd due to it but I try my best to be a functioning empathetic mother not repeat in my traumatic past. We are impulsive etc but we are not like amber.
May God bless you in your journey. I survived a similar childhood with a mother who drove me through it but therapy and an amazing husband, I learned to love. Continued grace and wisdom to guide you!!
Yall! Same!!! I FINALLY at 35 got a doctor that thought my BPD was highly tied to CPTSD too and treated the CPTSD. I also got sober and AA is a lot about self awareness and behavioral mods like therapy so I did the work. I'm like a different person now, but at my W0RST, in horrible abusive relationships while high, I would FLIP if he or anyone else tried to leave me and all I did was harm MYSELF. I've never hurt anyone else. I'm too empathetic but I get the desperation and how much worse wine makes it. She needs to own it and accept some accountability.
Good for you. I think a very basic core difference is the acceptance of the issue. You have accept there is an issue before you can make a change. I work in an ER…I have seen so many totally destabilize people with BPD and I find most often they either dispute the diagnosis outright or they dismiss any misbehaviour and blame it on the BPD. That because they have BPD they are allowed to act the fool and OTHER people need to accommodate them. They treat it as disability. They are usually mostly being brought in for violence against 3rd parties and try to justify it or threats of suicide trying to manipulate partners into doing what they want. Generally to not leave. It’s a difficult diagnosis…and it’s good to hear that there are people that are putting in the work. Sometimes seeing only the worst I get disheartened.
I’ve watched each and every day, happy to have you there to explain things I don’t quite get. Love the commentary! Congrats on the increased traffic to your channel… well deserved! Been here since about 200k
Thanks Emily. Your insights are enlightening. Your summary of the case is so well done. Amber may not have written the heading. She provided details that led to the heading being written as is. With all the allegations she's making she can't claim she never mentioned sexual abuse. She also shared it and added a little commentary before posting. She endorsed it. If she didn't she's had years to correct the false impressions herself she chose not to. Everything was with her consent. If she had her way she would have added more specific and direct allegations. The OPED basically summarised all the allegations she's currently making in court. The door being opened may also have to do with the fact that Amber hired a renowed private investigator to dig up any past issues dealing with JD assualting a woman. He went back years before they even met and nothing came back. He instead found people who had issues with Amber's behaviour. Aside from asking her about her past domestic abuse arrest she may also need to answer about the findings of the private investigator. It will definitely be damaging to her when someone she paid couldn't find anything she needed to use to strengthen her case. She on the other hand has
Emily, found your channel very recently and I find you to be helpful to those of us who lack legal expertise. I am a Clinical Counselor Supervisor with over 30 years of experience, most with personality disorders (among other diagnosis) and I found your statements about never seeing someone break down and recover so fast etc… fascinating because in the mental health world, I see all these behaviors daily. Dr. Curry is spot on! I educate people with personality disorder traits so they can see them for themselves and then teach them skills to help them get their lives under control. Those who want to get better do and those who do not want this, stay the same. Chaotic lives of this nature are indescribably miserable for everyone involved. Thanks for helping others understand the legal system and the chaos that is this trial!
Hey Emily, have a few questions regarding this case that I'd appreciate if you could answer: How would you approach the Amica/Arnica snafu if you were Elaine while on direct with AH? Will she be able to correct/approach it while still maintaining some semblance of credibility? How would you approach the big promise they made about having AH testify to how she used makeup/mixed colors etc to hide bruises? What if any rebuttal/cross to this is possible for JD's team? (Would they be able to bring in a make-up specialist)? Can lawyers ask AH if she is currently under the influence of any medications/drugs that can affect her testimony/behavior while on the stand? Would this be a wise/appropriate line of questioning if allowed? When can we expect to hear the court's opinion on the motion for sanctions regarding metadata? Shouldn't her lawyers have filed a response by now? Still haven't seen a response to the motion from her team or an order from the judge in the public records yet.
Not Emily lol but can give my 2 cents. Elaine called Amber to the stand as”Laura Amber Heard” and called her own witness Dr. Hughes by Johnny Depps witnesses name “Dr. Curry”….. twice! She’s got bigger fish to fry than arnica cream lol! Makeup fiasco - they have enough time go get business records for the release of the palette from Milani and pull them into this trial. Would say you said you used THIS palette - but how did you do that if it didn’t exist? No they wouldn’t ask her if she’s under the influence on the stand. If they actually thought she was visibly impaired, it would be a side bar. The motion for sanctions is against amber Heard for not handing over evidence in discovery - Not metadata specifically. Emily mentioned it will be more than likely be brought up to the jury’s as a jury instruction when they go to deliberate - that Amber Heard failed to hand over evidence that could irrevocably hurt Johnnys case. It’s too late for them to hand the evidence over now.
@@jeanellephant Hey thank you for taking the time to answer my questions and sharing your thoughts!! I agree Elaine has definitely lost her credibility with the jury in my opinion given the various flubs, sighs, arguing with the judge about objections etc. In regards to makeup I wasn't sure if it mattered that it wasn't AH who mentioned it but rather Elaine in opening statements and as such AH can just testify no it wasn't me who said that. Or continue with the spin her PR team is trying to propogate in MSM about it only being a "demonstrative" to represent "something similar" even though she said it was this exact one.... smh In regards to the sidebar if they thought she was impaired, is that to prevent tainting the jury or having a mistrial etc? Ahhh thank you for the clarification!! I had heard that too but was wondering why the judge hasn't made a ruling yet given how important that could be or why AHs team hasn't filed a response to their motion either. Is this a typical thing to leave issues until they are forced to deal with them? Once again thank you for taking the time to answer and share your thoughts!!
Thank you for this video it gave me a good understanding of what happened. I appreciate you handling this case in a delicate manner, and warning watchers of triggering events. 💜💜💜
Listening to her telling these "stories," is mindboggling and highly disturbing. If she had been assaulted in the manner in which she claims, she would have needed medical attention. She has been widely photographed, not only by the paparazzi but by herself. She can not claim that makeup covers all of these bruises and swelling. It's not at all possible. We can only hope that the jury sees through all of this nonsense or Mr. Depp's team brings that home in cross and/or closing
You really give me a better understanding of some of this stuff. Just amazing to watch AH; I finally turned the volume off. I look forward to what you say about future testimony.
The nurse did check her head but didn’t find anything, then said if AH felt she had been so badly injured she should go to th ER or Urgent care to be checked more thoroughly out
Amber said she slid on the "parakeet" floor...if she read that word, she might mis-pronounce it, but if she used the work that she knew on her own, she would have known it was a "par-kay" (parquet) floor.
Exactly....she READ....”PARAKEET” from her SCRIPT!!! Remember, she didn’t finish high-school...who knows what her reading skills actually are. That slip was not only hilarious, it was QUITE A “TELL”
Emily D Baker.... I suddenly came across your streams - I appreciate your personality, the way you put yourself across, your sense of humour and of course your excellent experience and your great way of training us.... Yes, me one of those who want to talk to someone about this terrible trail.... I pray that Johnny's career takes off ... high in the sky off... because of this trial Now that will be a F/U straight into Amber's face !! Thanks for your wonderful work
As a person of past DV I felt very uneasy about AH testimony. Any DV survivor, there recollection of events never changes. they remember every detail. AH was all over the place & her reactions to events was difficult for me to believe. How could she have been beaten so bad as she said she was but the next to a couple days after she miraculously healed. nobody seen not 1 bruise, cut or swollen anything. let's not forget her shredded feet being cut with broken glass. Do u know how difficult it would have been for AH to walk let alone stand. I'm upset that she would say such things but say these things about a man who I feel didn't do what she has claimed.
Exactly! It's the bottle sa part for me. I have given birth, but if I were to violently experience the business end of that big old bottle like she said she did, I'd need medical attention and perineum stitches.
And to have no medical records of a doctor or nurse helping remove glass from the bottom of her feet afterwards, is she seriously expecting us to believe she managed to do a good enough job of that herself.
@@emmao6578 Incredibly Average has an audio on his channel from the night in Australia. You can hear the security, medical team, and house manager trying to assess what happened and how to fix it with her in the background saying she's sorry and that she doesn't want to leave because he'll never forgive her and it will be the end of the relationship. They discussed how hysterical she was and how they could calm her down so they could be free to find the finger and clean up the mess. The doctor told the nurse to give her a moderate dose of seroquel. He never said clean her wounds, didn't prescribe anything for pain or even a bandaid. No one in that whole audio, not even Amber, mentions anything about any injuries on her except a member of his security who, I think, said she a had a couple of surface scratches on her arm. You should hear that audio.
Regardless of how this case ends up, I can't stop thinking about how differently things would be if Johnny had lost the right for live trial streaming and we only had the mainstream media sources to rely on.. scary
I'm also shocked about how Johny Depp slams doors! losing his temper! was all in the headlines, but the whole rest of what everyone said was left out. I even saw an article completely defending Amber Heard and that everyone who said differently was misogynistic. I'm also very glad people can make up their own minds about this. Compilations about the trial tend to favor Johny Depp heavily, but then again Amber Heards lawyers really have nothing to work with (or are plainly rude to JDs witnesses, look how they treated his financial advisor Mr. White).
So true....
Whatever happens in this trial Johnny wins in the court of public opinion..
@@redpill1940 With some. With others, he's right. It'll follow him for the rest of his life. /he'll never be able to unring that bell with some people that seem to want to see him as a villain. It makes me so mad.
Yes. I have seen some articles from highly regarded sources that just... it's like "are you paying attention? Are you watching this? Are you being paid off?" Like one that talked about how the jury MUST have felt so bad for Amber when Camille was "badgering" her about not having photos of the injuries or medical records. Like no... most people will be thinking more like "yeah you told him not to make you prove it bc you had so much evidence and it was so well documented but where is the documentation?"
We all remember how horrific Rhianna’s face looked after her assault.. that was a 5 minute confrontation that started in a Moving vehicle- Yet Amber testified she was sliding on bloody broken glass , slung across the floor - she claims her hair was torn from her scalp- he head butted her - slammed her head against the wall - repeatedly punched her in a rage … yet those pics say otherwise
And no melanin to help hide a lick of it (must be that heavy makeup doing its job)... theres no way.
This is exactly what I thought of too when she testified
facts! not only that she would have scars from the broken glass she was sliding across. She would have required a hospital no question in regard to the sexual assault with the bottle. The woman is sick and crazy. The audio of her admitting to hitting him and the Dr telling the nurse that they have to get Johnny away from her after his finger was severed should be enough. She is guilty of perjury especially saying that the makeup compact she used to cover her bruises wasn't launched until 2017.
Anyone with eyes can tell. She’s a liar.
AH would have needed to be hospitalized if all that really did happen to her. She is such a dramatic LIAR!
I am a registered nurse…and we ARE trained to assess all body systems and wounds and injuries…that was puzzling for me. She could have just said if there was injuries I would have documented them. If it’s not documented it didn’t happen, she def looked bad saying she wasn’t trained to look for those injuries. We as nurses look for objective info. Facts. Things we see.
Same I’m also an RN and worked in icu and imc. If the events she claimed happened happened, no competent health care worker would be able to ignore that extent of injury (concussion, broken nose, facial bruising, open cuts, imbedded glass, potentially a limp from vaginal injury etc)
I (RN) fully agree.
@@dijolola3579 exactly…unless it didn’t happen, and there was nothing to document or asses because it wasn’t there….which I totally believe AH is lying. She’s in another world.
Same! The only thing I can think as to why she said that was scope of practice??? Idk... it's a stretch. Another thing that bugged me was the "frank blood" on AHs lip... so if she has "frank blood" am I crazy to question that wound being basically immediately before RN assessment - ie picking her lip right before RN arrived... did anyone else catch that as being questionable?
@@MM-wn9wu yes! Like what does that mean? What did it look like? Was it blood from a busted lip? Or blood from chapped lips? What was it! If you find things like that, you ask questions and you document!!
I hate when people say JD fans are
Attacking her or don’t believe her. I hadn’t thought of him in years. I wouldn’t have called myself a fan but I know a liar when I see/ hear one!. It has nothing to do with being a fan.
Same
Its funny how some of those in hollywood have a weird mentallity that we need to know everything about them, and how important they are..
(Jim Carrie's recent comments)
Um...most of us have lives to get on with.
some box office movies mean actors get insane pay...the amounts we can never dream of...
Does their insane income mean they are "better" than joe average?
Or that their word on global issues or pet causes, is what we should follow?
No
We are all born naked..
We all need to wee and poop...
No one in this world is more important than anyone else
I don't kowtow to celebrity culture nor wealth adoration
I like many of JD s movies..
Who was AH again?...
I didnt know much of JD,s life, except hes a great actor, and has had several celebrity relationships...
What i have been gripped by, is the accusations...
And i totally detest liars because of my own life experiences....
Its my belief, AH is a liar....
Absolutely agree!
Same. Over 30 years ago I covered some exercise books with pictures of JD, but since then I'd just appreciated some of his movies. More recently I thought badly of both of them after the 'dog smuggling' incident in Australia. But my mind was blown when I started looking into this case. Everyday something new comes to light that shows AH outright lying, setting up a hoax to extort money or obviously being the aggressor in audio recordings.
Exactly ‼️ JD got the receipt s ‼️he's got the credibility of witnesses they all including three police officers saw no cuts bruises black eyes no hair pull out ‼️her makeup artist did her face again no marks none ‼️her own words I " hit u" she said she said that on tape nothing bout him hitting her ‼️,he gave u fame money luxury life u gave him hell embarrassed too his kids career but yet he stands tall looking so good that's not just a fan thing here he's got a better stronger more evidence case here
Regarding her feet being cut - there is a video of her rehearsing a dance scene for Danish Girl, supposedly days after the Australia incident and you see no cuts, bandages, etc on her feet AND she has NO problem dancing.
I saw that video.
I stepped up small pieces of glass at home after dropping a glass. It hurt to walk for a week, even in tennis shoes. When I went into the studio to train, it was excruciating. It didn’t matter how I well I tried to protect the very minor injury. It didn’t matter if I was en pointe, wearing flats. I am used to my feet hurting but wow. If you step on a tiny piece of glass, it hurts. I don’t care who you are.
There is also audio recorded straight after the incident and you can hear her walking around in heels, and talking to a doctor, nurse and bodyguard, none of whom mention any injuries on her
😫 I wish someone would put together a timeline of what happened in sequence., with dates .. with all the extra footage.... like elevator footage and any public appearances that fits in .... its all so confusing .... if I could do this I would.... surely I can't be the only person finding it hard to keep track
@@crazyamericanredhead exactly! This! Broke a glass in my kitchen had to wear a band aid slipper for a week
You Fuckin Rock. You make the chaos of this trial palatable. Thank you from another Law Nerd.
Umm
"I would like to speak to the manager of the trial"
LOLOLOL this had me rolling
so true too, that was Dr Hughes' whole vibe
AH’s claims are expansive, and her receipts are meager.
I once worked for someone with an explosive temper who could be very verbally abusive. Being someone who normally doesn’t shrink from confrontation, I absolutely found myself fading into the woodwork to avoid him when he was in a bad mood. That’s why AH’s claims fall flat for me. If she were being viciously abused as she claims, I seriously doubt that she would have been taunting JD the way she did in those recordings.
Or dropping a grumpy on his bed. I don't know any victim of abuse who would go out of their way to antagonize their abuser in such a way. Even a
non abusive person would be irate if that was done to them.
@@jenniferbestulic3579 Especially because it's so explicitly disrespectful. Abusers want control and nothing makes them lose it more than disrespect. I was viciously abused growing up and could barely breathe thinking about what would have happened to me had I ever done something like that to my abuser. He'd slap me across the face for looking him in the eyes he screamed at me and then grab me by the neck for 'ignoring him' by not looking at him as he screamed less than a minute later. I'd be dead if I did half of what she did in any 1 single recording
Exactly. Your survival and safety comes to depend on de escalation and placate g the bully or abuser . You font seek confrontation and instigate.. but Amber does because she is the aggressor itching fir a fight so she can release on JD
The differrence is you only worked with that kind of person, and Amber was married to one, meaning she wanted to have a functional relationship where her needs were met , too. So, it is not comparable situations of victimhood nor motives. You wanted to avoid as much as possible, she wanted to fix him, if one is to believe her case. I really don't think it is right to stereotype victims into how they should behave. If someone attacked me I would push back. Others would run. We are different in fight or flight situations. Thats why it is called fight or flight.
@@sB-wt5ov Abusers are rarely in a long term relationship with a person who would push back. Either because of what attracts them to a person to begin with, or because the relationship would not last with someone who won't tolerate abusive behavior and break up.
The horrific scenes she described being thrown across tables glass everywhere crawling through that constant punching in the face dragging across the floor punched against walls sexual assault and alot more .... I would have taught an ambulance would have been called for broken ribs bones etc blood gushing from nose n ears on deaths door not a picture of just bags under the eyes after few bottles of wine
Sounds as if she were beaten to a pulp. Concussion my butt. If this woman's walks out of this Scott free I will never believe in the law again. I know a couple of men going through the same think and felt all said who will believe me. At least in south africa you can divorce a person without spilling your guts. If you are such a abused man then rather get divorce and walk away. It'd better for a child to visit you in love a pease, that grow up in such toxic situations
I would have liked to have seen the Neuro Phyc testing to see if any real TBI lingering issues. I have not had the extensive head injuries due to beating BUT I have had concussions and deficits! I did not get it!
She made a recording right after this event you hear Jerry judge and her doctor and nurse talking about her when they get to the apartment. Its on UA-cam and disproves her whole story
On the Australia tape Jerry Judge says she has some self inflected scratches on left arm. Amber was stomping around in high heels you could hear it in the recording. Doubt if sexual assault happened, she wouldn't be stomping her feet in her heels.
@@al-dh5ju once the tape wasn’t allowed AH changed her story to JD cut his own finger. They tried ( but failed ) to get the doctors notes
rejected because they reveal JD suffered a velocity fracture. 100% a compulsive truth manipulator.
You’re absolutely right! Her lawyer had to remind her what happened to her. That’s definitely leading! I just don’t believe her because I’m a victim of domestic violence and I’m not satisfied with how she testified.
That's a polite way of saying it. I'm sorry that happened to you btw. I will say she bullshitted from start to finish,ALL to ruin Johnny for dating to leave her. Psycho.
I felt like I was watching a comedy about a trial at moments.
It was like a Lifetime movie
Same. I’ve been thru DV and although it’s a yucky feeling to say, bc of the “ believe all women” narrative, I don’t believe her either. Her story is non sensical, no supportive evidence and in stark contrast to other witnesses and evidence. I despise her bc she’s setting women back.
I am also a victim of violence, both domestic and otherwise, and there is no possible way I can speak about the incidents in the manner AH does. She's definitely not credible, based on my experience and observations of other victims of AB.
I don't think you can really say how a person is supposed to cry but there's something really odd about someone looking absolutely like they are trying to push a tear out and nothing comes out as long as she was talking.
Like her face after she says “my dog stepped on a bee” lol
There are physiological things that happen when you cry like your nose gets red and your face, your nose will start to water, it's biology. Not everyone cries out loud some cry softly but in both situations nose runs, tears come out of eyes face reddens eyes become puffy, it's how your body releases stress. That's why people are having a hard time believing her.
@@yolandawilson9852 and for those of us who are as fair skinned as AH is, we get very very red nose, eyes, even across the neck and upper chest
It’s the voice for me. Your. Voice changes when you really cry. It’s not just tears. She isn’t the actress she thinks she is
@@helensmusings OMG Yes!
My mom and my sister were both victims of domestic violence and they never looked like Amber Heard's photos. They had bruises all over, black eyes, bleeding in the eyes, hair yanked out ect. If Amber Heard was violated the way she testified, she would look like Rhianna or Christine Mackinday.
Amber Heard had access to doctors, nurses and bodyguards 24/7 and it doesn't matter who's paying their salary. They are obligated to report domestic and sexual violence. If Amber and Johnny wanted to settle their dispute in privacy or not press charges, it's their right, but LE would initially have been involved, if Ambers story were true.
Amber also talks about a fight on a private chartered flight, where Johnny allegedly kicked her in the back and threw things at her. The security team would have restrained him and the pilot would have asked for permission to an emergency landing at the nearest airport. Neither the pilot or the security team would gamble with the lives of everyone on board that flight.
Amber didn't seek medical attention and didn't document all her "injuries" like she documented Johnny's drunken sleep. She clearly knew how to snap a picture...
BTW; Would a drunk and stoned Johnny remove all his chunky rings before having a go on Amber? NO WAY!
English isn't my first language, so apologies for any grammar and spelling mistakes 😊
Your English is perfect! I agree with you 100%
@@BeachGirl911 Thanks 😊
Great comment! Your English is perfect. Thanks for your insight.
If johnny Depp was beaten her at the volume she said and she said he raped her with a wine bottle and she said blood was everywhere why didn't she take pictures of her injuries if he had beat her that bad she would have needed a ambulance to rush her to the hospital and she said he beather that bad u wouldn't be able to walk around and you would have had a concussion I said he must have beat her with SpongeBob square pants I am a survivor of domestic violence and abuse and the way she sets there saying that it just infuriating me u can tell she's a liar and that acting was awful I pray johnny Depp can clear his name and I hope they get her for lying under oath
My mom was a victim of DV too: face bruised, swollen scratches, broken ribs, etc. not a single pic, demonstrated by Heard and her team, look similar to those injuries.
Bruises do not look like one dark spot as on those pictures of her leaving court after obtaining TRO. Broken nose, she claims? No way. Her eye area would be swollen due to that trauma. We all saw how she looked on that TV show.
This is disgusting how she’s trying to pretend being a victim of DV.
If JD had been looking directly at AH while she testified, they'd say he was trying to intimidate her. No matter how he behaved during her testimony, they'd jump on it and point out what he did wrong.
Have you seen the memes of JDs lawyer with his middle finger on his cheek while AH testifies? So so funny.
This, exactly.
I thought the exact same. He would be called out as intimidating her. I recall him looking at her intensely 1 time, and that was when she played the recording of him being suicidal, and you could see the utter disbelief and hurt in his face, even a tear, why did she record that anyway? She wasn't trying to help him, just words to make it sound like she was. You could see that he could believe she'd stooped to this level, even her lawyer awkwardly skipped by that. That was vile. And he held that look on her until she looked at him, then he looked away. That was too far. And honestly I thought it reflected on her character rather than his.
Johnny has never once made eye contact with her while she's on the stand or anywhere else in the court room. She keeps looking at him. It must be driver her crazy that he just sits there drawing or just looking away. He doesn't want to look at her anyways.
There's also a clip of Amber staring at Johnny and Ben Chew just staring back 🤣
She testifies that when JD hit her it “changed her life” . She was arrested for DV against her former girlfriend. I don’t believe she’s never been in a physically abusive situation, it’s documented, and she was the aggressor!
She is a fraud
What really bothers me is the "evidence" such as pictures and video really seem to be taken to actually humiliate him not proof of abuse. Especially after he lost his mother. So heartless. Worst kind of person
Shes sickening
@@christinejones8717 That's absolutely what it was. Just like her PR statement, just like most of her testimony, & the audios she played. I think in her mind that she believes even if she loses, at least he's going to be too humiliated to show his face or get all the respect & adoration from fans he's gotten. Which shows just how freaking twisted she is.
We KNOW.
Found your channel just as the trial started. You are an actual dream, explaining the legal aspects in such an interesting and simple way! Non biased and completely fascinating. 💯 the best legal commentary on social 🙌🏽
My favorite part was Amber's attorney objecting to himself!
I still laugh over that. You could see the immediate shame as soon as he said it 🤣
@@mzfreddie the hesitation right before he said it was even funnier 🤣
Bless poor Rotternborn he's career is over! Another life Amber ruined. She's pretty good at that.
@@jamall7003 AAAAAAAMEN!
Me too!!!!😆
That's been the funniest part of this trial. 🤣
I'm a dv survivor and had to stop watching her testimony live early on her first day because I felt so angry because it was so obviously false ... A lot of other survivors have said the same
I completely agree. And I'm sorry that happened to you.
Same for me on both aspects. I was beyond angry. Living through it myself, this woman mirrored my abuser in SO many ways...definitely not the other way around
I watched some of her testimony and felt like she was playing to the court room. If she had all of these injuries I’d want to see hospital records of them.
Yeah-I’m honestly shocked to learn that medical professionals were on the scene that day or within a week-and…nothing.
@also, maybe You're delusional. You've clearly not been listening to the audio or watching all the testimony that we have. Bc there's ABSOLUTELY no way that she was there victim. She was 100% the ABUSER! It's in every single word she says, in her every look glaring him down from the stand. & Daring him to look her in the eye. Or maybe you are 1 of her minions. But what actually happened is Depp covered for HER bc he didn't want her to get in trouble. She's admitted in her own voice on her own that SHE cut off his finger on Australia. There's so much evidence showing she's the abusive one, & absolutely NOTHING showing him as abusive. Also, aside from the ppl paid to do Johnny's bidding as you claim, she was working on a movie after being horrifically violated w\a bottle as well as choked, slammed against every hard object in the world & dragged over dozens of broken glass bottles naked, where all her body is shredded. That was HER description. Yet it was what the next day or the day after that we have video evidence of her dancing without ONE SINGLE INJURY on her body. & We can see a LOT of it. Specifically her uninjured feet!
And the Police Reports! It's my understanding, when an abused person arrives in the ER, doesn't the ER Staff contact Law Enforcement? It doesn't have to be done by the victim, family or friends.
yeah, like even the police saw there was no bruise .what a lying woman!! If you have been beat up that severe. girl you'll end up in the hospital!
@also, maybe he went to the hospital in Australia. When he was taken to the hospital she talked to his people and said she didn't mean to do it. She tells all this stories constantly changes what happened. No medical records no pictures. She talks about all the drugs she took. So she's no better. They obviously had an insane fight, together ruined the house and she went to far with that bottle.
Ozzy was a mean insane drunk and I don't know how Sharon forgave him that's between them but it's not the same
when she described Bering backhanded , flying through the air and sliding on the wooden floor story , it's the scene from sleeping with the enemy even to the small injury on the head !! she's definitely watched that film .😢 funnily the characters name is Laura Nd she calls him the monster 😂
😯
Oh you’re right!! Wtf?🤣
Oh gosh I had forgotten about that film
Jesus you’re right! I never made that connection and I love that movie. Seen it ten times.
And Elaine introduce her to the court as Laura! 😱🤣🤔🤣
Doctor Curry explained Amber Heard's personality, then Amber got up there and proved her right. I'm an empathetic person, but I couldn't feel anything but contempt for her. 10 yrs I spent with an AH, and I've been mad crying due to true PTSD. Karma is coming for her.
We’re Survivors.
Never Victims.
It took me over a year to get away. . . With all of their $$$,- she could have Easily walked right outta’ there.
I can’t even watch her testimonies in full tbh I just get too mad and sad
Omg same!!
@@TheDesudesudesudesu I feel incredibly sad for Johnny. It's heartbreaking 💔
My mom is like this, totally understand.
I do believe that both psychologist stated that they did not support the theory of ‘mutual abuse.’ Neither do I and I hope that the jury caught this also when making a decision. Saying not nice things while being beat is not verbal abuse.
100% agree with you
Yeah, I don't think anyone can make a reasonable argument that calling your spouse who abuses you, cheats on you, lies about you, etc, a "wh*re" is abuse.
Amber said how the nurse came to take her to another room and give her ambien, the nurse should’ve been cleaning her up, bandaging her feet and face and arms and ect but she didn’t mention the nurses doing any of that for her…? She must’ve forgot to add that part
I saw a video recently with audio from that night and the doctor told the nurse to give her seroquel. There wasn't even a mention about any injuries to her by her or the team of people who were there in crisis mode looking for his finger and trying to figure out what happened and what to do with her. I think it was on Incredibly Average's channel if you want to checkit out.
@@mzcytin that audio was unreal. The part where the doctor is talking about Amber flying back to LA and needing someone to go with her who wouldn’t be manipulated by her demonstrates how everyone around them knew she was insane.
@@mzcytin Seroquel is an antipsychotic med
Yes! And she was stomping around in the background…
The recording of the incident (not in evidence) also does not support her claim. Dr. Kipper and Nurse Debbie discuss giving her Senecol, but nothing about any injuries to her feet.
As an RN, I find it ludicrous that an RN would claim she was not trained to assess injuries especially knowing a woman, or man who claimed abuse, would not assess for injuries and/or document any injuries found on a victim. If one claims one's nose is broken, it is not only painful but possibly is interfering with breathing and it is obvious even for an untrained eye to see. I had a broken nose. It doesn't disappear overnight. Where did this nurse obtain her license?? Google University School of Medicine and Nursing? What an embarrassment🤬
Is she psychic though. If amber didnt mention being abused to the nurse, why would she have thought to examine her scalp.
@@brandydinsmore8214 as an RN; any RN seeing facial trauma would assess not only the injury but assess the head fully, any facial injury could result in head trauma. Remember a big part of tbi is the sudden stop that slams the brain against the skull.
every broken nose I've ever seen bled everywhere. swollen right away. and blackened both eyes over night. never able to cover it up with makeup
RN's are trained to assess the possibility of violence perpetrated upon their client.
Okay ! I am not an RN but I have seen RNs and they notice these things . How does that make sense ! lolll You are sooo funny lol
Anyone else referring to Emily and this case so much people think she’s a family member or friend 🤣 my husband and I compare case notes thoughts and Emily’s law knowledge daily - ty for making this insane case bearable 👩⚖️love your channel !
Yes!!!! My family are tired of well Emily said.
Why is there a lil gavel next to ur name?
Ya ! I always wonder what she will say !
Wait….Emily isn’t family??? As another California to the Midwest transplant I feel like we are 😂
oh yes. I tell everyone to watch Emily especially for this case
At this point I'm surprised she hasn't testified that he just pulled out a gun and shot her in the chest.
But you see she's got wolverine genes so she pushed the bullet out and healed too quickly to take a photo or go to the hospital. There's a faint red mark left where it happened so that's been submitted into evidence, naturally.
The fact that this statement actually could happen at this point… I can’t 😂
🤭🤣
I've been saying this. I fully expect her to say he killed her. Her story is escalating but her evidence is non-existent.
😂😂🤣
This made me laugh so hard I spit out my coffee 🤣🤣
My undergraduate law professor said this case makes her upset...especially with all the objections and weird finessing of procedure they keep tryna do...and how the testimony is all over the place
Which testimony, AH?
What do you mean by finessing of procedure?
@@fellowviewer1095 all the times Amber Heards lawyer tries to "lead" her into the answer her lawyer wants. Heards lawyer is a very notable lawyer here in VA and is a "super lawyer" a distingushment they give to very few...she knows procedure well enough to not do it as many times as she has but there isn't a counter case here...everyone deserves representation and they tried throwing it out but the judge dismissed it letting the hearings go on...my prof said if she were the judge she would have thrown it out after Deps testimony because she thinks they just want to air out dirty laundry at this point and it's waste of time...I mentioned that I learned a lot about procedure in this case and she said "a lot of awful procedure" with the caveat
@@stellaallbright4750 she was referring to the case in general...I think opinion wise she dislikes all of it lol
@@stellaallbright4750 we talk about current events before lecture...since she is a family law attorney/general attorney (she also did minor contract disputes and tort law later on) who then earned her PhD later on...this class is related to torts so I brought it up...we also discussed will Smith and the slap...Jesus tht feels like a forever ago
Verbal abuse is abuse but if it was about verbal abuse there would be no article? As bad as verbal abuse is if everyone was put in jail the jails would be more crowed than they already are. This is because of the sexual and physical abuse allegations.
Good point. He certainly wouldn't have been cancelled over verbal abuse, especially after all of the recordings of her clearly verbally abusing him. I've never heard of an exparte for verbal abuse either.
@@mzcytin yes
Yes. She claimed domestic violence and SA. That is different than abuse.
Good point!
@@emma2370 violence is abuse. but her lawyer is trying to claim that amber in the article was also talking about verbal abuse so because they got in to heated argument's they lawsuit should be dismissed which is b.s.
Kate Moss has always kept in touch with JD. Stayed good friends all these years. I have a feeling she’s going to testify that she was NEVER PUSHED down any stairs.
If they can prove AH doesn’t have first hand knowledge of the KM/stair incident , they might not call Moss. That would also mean AH can’t produce one of JD’s ex girlfriend to testify against him.
I don’t think they’d scramble to call and prep KM as a new witness during rebuttal, unfortunately. I do think her name dropping Kate gives way to Johnny’s team questioning AH about this name-dropping and her OWN past relationships during cross.
I agree. I bet she is a rebuttal witness!
@@dmb6559 not sure about that, remember AH said she was told about the rumour & bringing KM on can’t disprove her story. KM could say it’s not true but the rumour would still stand. Personally I think AH made the whole thing up just like her other story’s.
Watched the Behavior Panel today and ole Amber got toasted!! I only hope the jury is wise enough to figure out all the lies.
I was waiting for that to come out all week! So glad they called her out
I'm sure the Jury is feeling the same way!
I love being extra. I’m in the text crew and I have a custom ringtone set for the notifications. Just Emily going “Oh Shit”
This is amazing!
I need that ringtone. 💜
I need that ringtone!!!
Hi I'm new, how do u join the text chain? I clicked the link but it doesn't say to text "join" or anything! Thanks and sorry if u dont know
@cindy macdonald love this 🤣
I was a victim of someone's violent actions, no marks from Johnny's rings in the bruises, thats strange! I cannot believe AH has done what she has done. Her description just does not float with me.
As a survivor of child SA, DV in my first marriage and SA 2 years ago, she angers and triggers me so much. How can she put her head down on her pillow every night and sleep straight and soundly?? She has made a mockery of all true survivors and what we have been through.
I, also, am a child SA survivor and adult SA survivor. I feel for you and am familiar.
She angers me and the way she talks about it or fakes recalling it, is no way how I’d share my experiences, even with my counselor. Also I can’t look or stare someone down talking about my trauma. It’s too painful to even want to recall and share, I don’t want to be seen or look into someone’s eyes as the hear what happened to me. It’s too disgusting and I feel so gross.
I hope she is held accountable for lying sooooo freaking much. It’s so narcissistic.
She can because she’s a sociopathic narcissistic monster….Incapable of feeling for others or feeling empathy…Only concerned with how she can use & abuse other humans to get her own narcissistic needs met.
She’s a recidivist perpetrator. She needs to be criminally prosecuted and imprisoned before she hurts new victims.
I honestly believe that Johnny was lucky to make it out of the relationship alive. There are indications that she was planning on killing him and claiming it was in self defense (one reason why she was so concerned about not being in his will).
Her own sister, Whitney, told her employer at the time, (whom she called her “chosen sister”) that she was worried that Amber was going to KILL Johnny!
It’s the reason that Whitney moved out of the penthouses and moved in with her employer/“chosen sister.”
I just wanted to stop by and tell you I found your channel and I love your channel I worked the court system for 25 years & I love watching trials, I’m retired now so I can. I wanted to make a comment on everybody seems to think that Johnny Depp looking down and doodling instead of looking at Amber heard is weird but it’s not. during one of their fights or whatever you wanna call it he told her “I will never look at you again” and he’s not looking at her. it’s driving her crazy if you watch her on the stand she can’t stand it & she’s trying to get a reaction out of him.
I also think it may be therapeutic for him.
@@corrinabanks3567 agree. I thought same thing. It distracts him from the stressful situation.
hes reliving her terror over and over...
Spot on! I'm sure you have noticed: as her emotions rise to crying, sobbing, heavy gasping sighs, she's definitely looking towards JD then at the jury, back and forth. Yet, no tears.
P.S. Oops, I didn't finish my comment (it's close to 2:30 a.m.). Anyway, the rising crescendo of AH's emotions during testimony, I believe, is AH doing her damndest to get a reaction out of Johnny! And, he is handling it all very well. He has kept himself in check; well done JD!!! I know from experience how difficult that is. God Bless Johnny & Team Johnny for the win!!!
Shes stated at the beginning of her testimony that shes being sued for an oped she wrote
😂 good point
Trial should have ended after that statement lol
I think Dr Hughes’ Testimony will be bad for her future Expert Testimony Prospects
I hope so as her gender bias was so apparent
@@johannawigg6921 It was sooo obvious! I hope all those Committees, Bar Associations, Boards, Etc she sits on were paying attention.
Idk. Lots of shitty misogynists out there who need “experts” to defend them. I guess it have been a decent advertisement for them?
@@olhydra I don't follow - why would misogynist choose Dr. Hughes? I, however, think a misandrist would love Dr. Hughes.
@@olhydra u mean misandrists or i'm misunderstanding?
Robert Downey Jr., offered JD a big role in his next movie. JD is going to come out stronger than ever no matter what the outcome of this trial is.
And he should ‼️ he JD said I do cocaine,pills alcohol I abused myself no one else JD is more than proven his Innocence here ‼️ but Disney, Warner bros he will never go back too " Dior stuck by him years ago never drop him ever ‼️ look how they doing amazing$$$$$ many said he was guilty never " Dior so bleep all those who dropped him he will be bigger now than he ever was why" for believing in his self and wanting it on live stream on tv so all the world can see what really happened
HOORAY!!!
I really hope so. Robert Downey Jr. is one of my favorite actors. He has stood by his friend and kudos to him.
I hope his career doesn’t continue to suffer because of these lies. However, no matter what comes in the future, it doesn’t change the nightmare she put him and his whole family through.
You've said everything I have been thinking, in particular about Amber Heard's testimony. As an abuse survivor, I'd be condemned by the survivor community too and that disturbs me almost more than Amber Heard's inconsistencies and apparent lies. We're not robots with identical personalities that think, feel and behave all the same. Our analysis of Amber needs to have depth and nuance. You've done just that, and I, as a survivor, thank you @ Emily D. Baker.
I don’t think people are saying the personalities have to be the same. It’s just for Amber you can tell certain things she’s making up. I believe some things she say & then there are things that’s she crazy lying about.
@@LexxJussMitee - I have listened to and read comments from people who have made comparisons between themselves and Amber because she's not apparently shedding tears and other forms of expression. They may be picking up on a real distinction but are talking about it with little if any insight into the real problem with Amber. In doing so, they themselves shame anyone who doesn't think, feel or behave as they do. The modern definition of personality is the sum total of how one thinks, feels and behaves. I don't think they are doing this comparison with malicious intentions, but the consequences of what they say is not good for anyone who isn't them, especially if they are young in their recovery from any form of abuse.
I like how the uk and usa testimony by amber has changed
Natalie the Lawyer Chick has a video out and she discusses this issue. Great video if you haven't already seen it.
@@sharonlee6470 she did a great job !!
So looking forward to the cross examination!
My cat and I are waiting with our popcorn.
@@karenholladay2612 My doggie are ready for the excitement as well, can't wait to pop the popcorn 🍿 too!! 😃. I truly hope that Johnny gets justice ⚖️ and ATurd gets charges of perjury 🤞
Out of all the UA-cam channel's that I've seen grow...watching Emily's channel grow makes me the most happy. She deserves the best. I love you Emily!!!
Emily D Baker. Your wit and cleverness !..
My dad would’ve gotten a kick out of you and your commentary. He was “just a small country lawyer” in CT. Also, the most brilliant mind and kindest soul I’ve ever known.
I miss him like crazy.
I love listening to you. Thank you for sharing your massive talents to all of us wee folks out here on the interwebs 💜💜💜
Hey Common Sense--so sweet you have good memories of your dad and he would have loved Emily. What about the "cursey words"?😆😁😄
New here too Emily. So happy I found you. I love your calm voice. And ofc the jewels of wisdom which will help make me a law nerd.
Thank you so much Robyn!!
No, not all victims cry, but she really lays it on thick. Every time I hear her speak, it sounds like an audition.
A REALLY bad audition… and “We’ve gone with another Actor for the part!”
I saw a clip of her in Zombieland I think, describing a trauma as a character, and it's pretty damn similar.
you don't have to cry to show emotion so🤷♀️😬
@@susu_m very true, they don't. I think the incongruence here is that it's clear that "crying" is 100% what she's communicating to the court, but it's coming off as super overdone and inauthentic.
I wasn't aware that Johnny Depp was named in the original op ed and that his name was removed. I'm a Kiwi, up until recently not a JD supporter, saw Edward Scissorhands, that's it but when the op ed came out even I instantly I knew Heard was talking about Johnny. I dismissed it because I didn't believe her
Thank you for supporting the truth and Johnny. Yes according to the story about the Op-Ed, they wishy washed. First, they had JDs name in. Then they took it out. Then the ACLU writer wanted to put it back in to attract more readers because of JDs name.
Whawawahaaat?? I also didn’t know that!! And I’ve been following this since maybe week two(?) american and a Depp fan from “jump st” so to speak. But now I’m grown and don’t keep track of celebrities. Until this trial. This is fascinating. That’s a humungous deal his name in first copy of that article. Hmph! Geeze!
Love to you Kiwi friend! 💜, 🗽ny
Hey fellow kiwi 👋
@@loristoneking4536 I think it was Amber that wanted his name back in, no?
@@n.m.2174 Yes it was Amber that did. There are copies of the emails and the Lawyer Recounted Convos about how she did.
I've written everything she's said off as a lie. Even the things she has no need to lie about are soaked in lies. I'm just watching for feelings of increduloudness at this point.
Did you watch her 2016 deposition?!
Incredibly Average has them on his channel!!
I bet her dog didn't really step on a bee.
@@kristinhill4818 lol
It’s crazy that she can’t stop it’s like a compulsion
I agree with this.
Once a person has been shown to have lied (or embellished) on multiple subject/events, I cannot in good conscience believe anything else they say, unless there is absolute proof.
I had the same reaction to Meghan Markle. Once you notice that a lot of her stories are either lies, exaggerations or that tbey make no logical sense, I cannot understand continuing to believe her.
I feel like there is this whole wave now where anyone can say anything or accuse anyone of something and the burden of proof falls on the accusee. The accuser gets believed without evidence and the accusee needs to proof that the accuser is lying. It should be the other way around.
God forbid I, as a third party, ask the accusee for any proof of statements made so I can made an informed decision on if a story is crecible, because that is apparently not the done thing anymore and people will verbally attack you online for doing so.
The more accusers getting shown to be liars the more it actually impacts the real victims. Because of liars looking for attention or power the real victims suffer from public doubt when they accuse.
These people make a mockery of someone else's real trauma and experiences to get attention or power and I find it very disrespectful and indecent.
I've been following multiple channels on the AH trial. From what I hear, JD's attorney was happy about the Kate Moss issue because past relationships abuse was excluded per the prosecution's request. AH bringing up Kate Moss allows Johnny's team to bring up the Tasha incidednt and AH getting arresting for DV.
It’s also being put about that KM was purposely mentioned so AH can bring in one of JD’s EX’s to testify against him. AH has already played down her DV arrest by lying about it in the UK trial. Although she shouldn’t get away with it in this trial .
@@thekitowl Jennifer grey? Haven’t seen anything suggesting AH purposely made that detrimental slip to open the door for JD’s team to bring up her prior relationships (DV arrest included) on cross so that her team could call one of JD’s ex’s last minute? Seems convoluted. More likely that AH’s thought processes were in overdrive trying to fabricate her testimony, and she slipped up with the Kate moss mention.
@@cutlass2523 you need to watch more channels covering this trial. AH does have one of JD’s ex’s on her witness list, a scorned one at
that, who will claim JD threw a bottle at her proving JD can be violent to women & she’s not Jenifer Grey.
@@thekitowl That is stupid on AH's part since most of JD's ex's has publically come out and said that he is very protective and not known JD to raise a hand during the UK trial (Vanessa and Wynona) Kate Moss has come out and said she doesn't know what AH is talking about and confirms Vanessa and Wynona's sentiment.
@@nguyenkh2002 it’s possible this new witness could put doubt in the jury’s mind because as you say his other ex’s speak highly of JD.
The judge might not see the KM mention as a reason to open the door because it’s only a story AH was told ( or made up ) I noticed in
her UK testimony she played the DV arrest right down & didn’t answer when asked if she spent the night in jail , she also lied about why
the charges were dropped. Be interesting to see which way this goes.
She's a liar and no one can tell me different. I've been through everything amber has described AND MORE and I'm a 5'9 280lb woman and believe me, I fought back and STILL ended up with black eyes, fat lips, a broken arm, sprained ribs multiple times, I have a permanent scar from my face smashed on a table with a coffee cup, etc. I've never been so disgusted with a person in my life, including my abuser. Amber Heard is done.
The fact that we are referring to the 💩 as the grumpy cracks me up.
Yes, humans make grumpies and dogs make fun 😂 these are quality Deppisms.
There is a recording where AH and JD are arguing. In one part of the argument you can clearly hear JD going away from AH to leave. You can hear her say “Johnny get off me!” When she says this JD is at the door already, so you can tell she is setting him up. Making it seem as if he was on top of her. He wasn’t.
Question: How can you prove to a jury that he wasn’t on her, and how can you prove she was setting him up? Is there a way to?
Exactly he was trying too hide in bathroom then he was at the door soooooo set up tape
@@sharonthomas9357
Yeah, she’s set him up from day one.
I’m curious to know if there are ways to prove that in court 🤷🏻♀️. Seems almost impossible.
Lol at “can I speak with the manager of this trial?” 😂
That backbone product is one of the coolest sponsorships ever! Love seeing something new that I'm actually interested in getting. 🙌🏻
Same! Normally I skip through sponsor spots on YT vids. This one I actually stopped and looked at.
I love it when two of my favourite channels get together
Yeah I took a screenshot so I wouldn't forget it 🙂👍
For reeeeeal!
Thank you!!! It really is a lot of fun.
Johnny has been seen in Sussex this week .. about 3 hours from where Kate Moss lives in the Cotswolds.... interesting 🤔 lol
people should listen to the recordings , these enough will tell you who lied and who didn't !! she literally told him that no one would believe him because she planned all that for 3 years , put on makeup and took photos and then she sent texts to her friends and parents so she would have proof of all that .i think that all of you should listen to that she outed herself and told him all of her plans , i was in shock she had the audacity or should i say the stupidity to say that. really hope that they'll play that record in court.
I've heard chunks of the recordings. Do you have a link to all of them?
:)
@@elainascott7496 last I heard, the Daily Mail still had links to the recordings on their site, other than that, there are a variety of yt channels that have them. Incredibly Average has posted a few and has also done some pretty impessive research on the case.
The recording from Australia Blows her Fake Testimony Out of the Stratosphere!!
Check out YT channel *Incredibly Average* for a thorough timeline & audio recordings!!
I don’t think they can play alot of those sadly, because there are other people in the recordings that do not have a deposition
You're really good at explaining the trial. I liked how you broke things down. I watched the trial for hours and you were very succinct with key points & moments.
Hey there's a 4 hour uncut audio of Amber and Johnny discussing the relationship here on UA-cam - it's unnerving how the conversation goes nowhere and she starts yelling multiple times. Feels like Malcolm and Marie. In 4 hours of relationship discussion, at no moment she complains about him being violent - on the contrary - she admits that SHE starts the violent fights
May favourite part of that audio is when he says ‘I’m just being honest’ and then she immediately yells at him for calling her a liar. Like out of nowhere. And at the end she says that she was being so nice to him and never called him any names and he was insulting her the whole time. He never called her anything and she had called him a baby, an old man and suggested his body guard Travis should come in and suck him off
I PRAY the jury sees these points.
Thank you! :) An extra thank you for being the only person on UA-cam (that I've seen, and regarding this case) and in the trial to acknowledge that everyone responds to trauma differently, and that *not* everyone cries. I'm team Johnny, but I'm also so sick of hearing and seeing so many people say that IPV/DV victims *only* respond a certian way.
♡
Thank you for changing your flight plans to keep us informed. You’re the best!
After hearing her testify and all the contradictions...It feels like she's projecting SO much what she did to Johnny by saying that's what he did to her. We have literal proof that she hit him, berated him, insulted him, would prevent him from leaving but when she talked about things that happened she would say that Johnny was the one doing that! Just wild how her mind is flipping everything....
The “million dollars and a million alpacas” was his answer when someone asked him if he would go back to work for Disney if they asked him back AFTER they announced they were going a different way on PofC 6. They didn’t even do him the curtesy of informing him before putting out press.
It had nothing to do with “creative differences”
Thanks!
You bet!
Dr Dawn Hughes was giving big "I need to speak to your manager" energy. All she was missing was the haircut lol
I wonder: what is her best move
1. Accept she lied and invent whatever excuse and say she is ill
2. Continue to lie an lie and loose everything
3. ??
As much as I do not believe she went through that level of abuse from johnny and I don't know her personally just what I see through out court and don't like what I see, but would be nice for her to get herself checked out and get the help she would need
WOW, Emily, over 330k subscribers and it's only May! You didn't hit 200k until the beginning of this year if I recall correctly. This is SO COOL. 🥰♥️
Bless you for doing this LOL ! I can not endure listening to Amber Herd talk and tell lies!
Same
Me too!! Just too creepy!!
I really appreciate you, I have been interested in this situation for a couple of years since hearing the leaked audio and realising Johnny at the time of the recording was in the position I had been in, in the past. I was nervous about being triggered especially when listening to Amber. You are like my comfort blanket through this . Just wish I could mute Amber and just listen to your commentary. Thank you for all that you do and for changing your flight and for the amazing community and the fantastic chatbox.
When I feel down and like I'm not good enough and a bad person, I think to myself "it could be worse; I could be Amber Heard."
My favorite is still, "can we stop talking about the muffins."😂
I just watched the Behaviour Panels analysis of parts of AHs testimony. I love them, they're so good and really know they're stuff. Really interesting to see their breakdown of her body language and spot on too.
My problem with her testimony is there any medical evidence. If he beat the crap out of her that many times there would be a lot of medical evidence. 40 years ago I was in abusive relationship. In one year I had to go to the emergency room six times. I had to have glass picked out of my skin. My nose was broken. The way she describes the violence there should’ve been some cracked ribs I know that’s what I experienced. If your nose was broken do you know when your nose is broken trust me. When you’re being backhanded and throwing around things break whether it’s a big toe or a finger something breaks. And you need medical attention. I don’t believe her I hate saying that but I don’t believe her. I’m not a fan of him he screwed up. I just don’t want to see when a woman comes forward then I believe because of this person lying it really breaks my heart. When I went to court 40 years ago things were quite different. I showed up with a broken arm choke marks around my neck and the judge asked me if I really wanted to break up my family over this. We’ve come a long way and I don’t wanna see this woman push us backI’ve never talked about any of this in public only in therapy. I’m sorry if my wording is wrong because I am not typing I’m using the microphone that types it for me.
💖 thank you for sharing your thoughts, hope that you've had time to heal inside from that relationship and I'm sorry you went through that
A human actually asked you that question while seeing you broken? Made me tear up. I’m glad you made it past that relationship.
As a nurse the first thing you do ALWAYS is the head to toe assessment. Geez I start it the moment they walk in saying hello. And yes, we notice bruising, scratches, bumps, lumps on exposed skin. Shit I notice dandruff, pet hair etc
Agreed. I'm an nurse too and all nurses are trained to do a basic skin assessment for wounds and to ask where areas of pain are. It's nursing 101.
I’m so glad I found your channel. Your are straight down the middle no bias from any of the videos I’ve seen I’ll be a supporter of this channel for sure
She's the best by far.
Emily, I am relatively new to your blog and I want to thank you for making it so clear and going step-by-step for us newbies.
I have been trying to fit these pieces of the puzzle together with questionably results. Thank goodness I have found you‼️‼️‼️
Went to the garden center after work today and found myself drawn to the purple blooms. I was surprised at first because purple isn't normally a favorite, then I realised I've been watching Emily for a month! Love the purple, love your commentary 💜
Love your show (showing my age)! Also really love when you collaborate with the other LawTubers.
After hearing her telling her harrowing Australia story and then seeing the pictures of her taken after, I totally laughed out loud! Her nose was NOT broken, ftr. I know what the after effects of a broken nose look like and I saw nothing. She had two TINY little discolourizations under her eyes that were extremely faint. I thought they could possibly have been photoshopped or it was done with makeup.
its alleged she used an app to crop in bruises.. thsts why she wont give Metadata
Or Botox injections! I've had that happen.
@@erin4321 Wow! Excellent point!!!
I have watched every live stream for the last week, and I find this round up very helpful. So much gets discussed, so it’s nice to be reminded of the major talking points. Your hard work does not go unnoticed Emily.
Your voice is so calming, and easy to understand. As someone who is hearing impaired, that's very important to me! You also give off a great vibe. I just subscribed! 🙂
I am so grateful for your coverage and commentary on this lawsuit and many others.
I am an extremely sensitive empath. I watched a video from popcorn planet that was people who were abused telling their stories and in less than 5 minutes of the first story, I was in tears. 2 days of Herds testimony and all I felt was anger.
I feel the same exact way
I know you do this primarily for the podcast, but thank you so much for providing even brief video/visual descriptions. As a blind person I really, really value this.
I love that you're a gamer at heart like me! It gives me validation to play games at 44 yrs old! And you're also my favorite UA-camr. I can't watch this trial without you, please don't leave again!!💕💕🎮
This has been a fascinating trip into the better side of the internet. Your commentary is clear and welcoming: you bring people into this process, making it accessible and human. Well done!
My mother was and is a severe narcissist and I have bpd due to it but I try my best to be a functioning empathetic mother not repeat in my traumatic past. We are impulsive etc but we are not like amber.
Right! Enough therapy and self awareness and u may exhibit 1 symptom out of the 9 or like be in Remmision for a while all together...
May God bless you in your journey. I survived a similar childhood with a mother who drove me through it but therapy and an amazing husband, I learned to love. Continued grace and wisdom to guide you!!
Yall! Same!!! I FINALLY at 35 got a doctor that thought my BPD was highly tied to CPTSD too and treated the CPTSD. I also got sober and AA is a lot about self awareness and behavioral mods like therapy so I did the work. I'm like a different person now, but at my W0RST, in horrible abusive relationships while high, I would FLIP if he or anyone else tried to leave me and all I did was harm MYSELF. I've never hurt anyone else. I'm too empathetic but I get the desperation and how much worse wine makes it. She needs to own it and accept some accountability.
Very true. Stay strong ❤️
Good for you. I think a very basic core difference is the acceptance of the issue. You have accept there is an issue before you can make a change.
I work in an ER…I have seen so many totally destabilize people with BPD and I find most often they either dispute the diagnosis outright or they dismiss any misbehaviour and blame it on the BPD. That because they have BPD they are allowed to act the fool and OTHER people need to accommodate them. They treat it as disability.
They are usually mostly being brought in for violence against 3rd parties and try to justify it or threats of suicide trying to manipulate partners into doing what they want. Generally to not leave.
It’s a difficult diagnosis…and it’s good to hear that there are people that are putting in the work. Sometimes seeing only the worst I get disheartened.
I’ve watched each and every day, happy to have you there to explain things I don’t quite get. Love the commentary! Congrats on the increased traffic to your channel… well deserved! Been here since about 200k
Thanks Emily. Your insights are enlightening. Your summary of the case is so well done.
Amber may not have written the heading. She provided details that led to the heading being written as is. With all the allegations she's making she can't claim she never mentioned sexual abuse.
She also shared it and added a little commentary before posting.
She endorsed it. If she didn't she's had years to correct the false impressions herself she chose not to. Everything was with her consent. If she had her way she would have added more specific and direct allegations. The OPED basically summarised all the allegations she's currently making in court.
The door being opened may also have to do with the fact that Amber hired a renowed private investigator to dig up any past issues dealing with JD assualting a woman. He went back years before they even met and nothing came back. He instead found people who had issues with Amber's behaviour.
Aside from asking her about her past domestic abuse arrest she may also need to answer about the findings of the private investigator. It will definitely be damaging to her when someone she paid couldn't find anything she needed to use to strengthen her case. She on the other hand has
Emily, found your channel very recently and I find you to be helpful to those of us who lack legal expertise. I am a Clinical Counselor Supervisor with over 30 years of experience, most with personality disorders (among other diagnosis) and I found your statements about never seeing someone break down and recover so fast etc… fascinating because in the mental health world, I see all these behaviors daily. Dr. Curry is spot on! I educate people with personality disorder traits so they can see them for themselves and then teach them skills to help them get their lives under control. Those who want to get better do and those who do not want this, stay the same. Chaotic lives of this nature are indescribably miserable for everyone involved. Thanks for helping others understand the legal system and the chaos that is this trial!
The waiting theme is so groovy that it makes me wanna wait MORE
Reminds me of the small world ride at Disneyland, when the front of the ride starts going wonky.
Love seeing sponsors. Get that bag girl!
Hey Emily, have a few questions regarding this case that I'd appreciate if you could answer:
How would you approach the Amica/Arnica snafu if you were Elaine while on direct with AH? Will she be able to correct/approach it while still maintaining some semblance of credibility?
How would you approach the big promise they made about having AH testify to how she used makeup/mixed colors etc to hide bruises? What if any rebuttal/cross to this is possible for JD's team? (Would they be able to bring in a make-up specialist)?
Can lawyers ask AH if she is currently under the influence of any medications/drugs that can affect her testimony/behavior while on the stand? Would this be a wise/appropriate line of questioning if allowed?
When can we expect to hear the court's opinion on the motion for sanctions regarding metadata? Shouldn't her lawyers have filed a response by now? Still haven't seen a response to the motion from her team or an order from the judge in the public records yet.
Not Emily lol but can give my 2 cents.
Elaine called Amber to the stand as”Laura Amber Heard” and called her own witness Dr. Hughes by Johnny Depps witnesses name “Dr. Curry”….. twice! She’s got bigger fish to fry than arnica cream lol!
Makeup fiasco - they have enough time go get business records for the release of the palette from Milani and pull them into this trial. Would say you said you used THIS palette - but how did you do that if it didn’t exist?
No they wouldn’t ask her if she’s under the influence on the stand. If they actually thought she was visibly impaired, it would be a side bar.
The motion for sanctions is against amber Heard for not handing over evidence in discovery - Not metadata specifically. Emily mentioned it will be more than likely be brought up to the jury’s as a jury instruction when they go to deliberate - that Amber Heard failed to hand over evidence that could irrevocably hurt Johnnys case. It’s too late for them to hand the evidence over now.
@@jeanellephant Hey thank you for taking the time to answer my questions and sharing your thoughts!!
I agree Elaine has definitely lost her credibility with the jury in my opinion given the various flubs, sighs, arguing with the judge about objections etc.
In regards to makeup I wasn't sure if it mattered that it wasn't AH who mentioned it but rather Elaine in opening statements and as such AH can just testify no it wasn't me who said that. Or continue with the spin her PR team is trying to propogate in MSM about it only being a "demonstrative" to represent "something similar" even though she said it was this exact one.... smh
In regards to the sidebar if they thought she was impaired, is that to prevent tainting the jury or having a mistrial etc?
Ahhh thank you for the clarification!! I had heard that too but was wondering why the judge hasn't made a ruling yet given how important that could be or why AHs team hasn't filed a response to their motion either. Is this a typical thing to leave issues until they are forced to deal with them?
Once again thank you for taking the time to answer and share your thoughts!!
Thank you for this video it gave me a good understanding of what happened. I appreciate you handling this case in a delicate manner, and warning watchers of triggering events. 💜💜💜
Listening to her telling these "stories," is mindboggling and highly disturbing. If she had been assaulted in the manner in which she claims, she would have needed medical attention. She has been widely photographed, not only by the paparazzi but by herself. She can not claim that makeup covers all of these bruises and swelling. It's not at all possible. We can only hope that the jury sees through all of this nonsense or Mr. Depp's team brings that home in cross and/or closing
You really give me a better understanding of some of this stuff. Just amazing to watch AH; I finally turned the volume off. I look forward to what you say about future testimony.
I’m so glad I found you! Happy to have someone to watch with! 👏😘
The nurse did check her head but didn’t find anything, then said if AH felt she had been so badly injured she should go to th ER or Urgent care to be checked more thoroughly out
The nurse encouraged her to see Dr Kipper. His notes show an assessment on Dec 17, 2 days later, by a nurse practitioner showing no injuries.
Amber said she slid on the "parakeet" floor...if she read that word, she might mis-pronounce it, but if she used the work that she knew on her own, she would have known it was a "par-kay" (parquet) floor.
Spot on! I caught that as well.
Exactly....she READ....”PARAKEET” from her SCRIPT!!! Remember, she didn’t finish high-school...who knows what her reading skills actually are. That slip was not only hilarious, it was QUITE A “TELL”
'I want to talk to the manager of the trial!' :D Love that!
Emily D Baker.... I suddenly came across your streams - I appreciate your personality, the way you put yourself across, your sense of humour and of course your excellent experience and your great way of training us.... Yes, me one of those who want to talk to someone about this terrible trail.... I pray that Johnny's career takes off ... high in the sky off... because of this trial
Now that will be a F/U straight into Amber's face !! Thanks for your wonderful work
I'm so glad I'm all caught up! I can't wait for the live stream on monday!
As a person of past DV I felt very uneasy about AH testimony. Any DV survivor, there recollection of events never changes. they remember every detail. AH was all over the place & her reactions to events was difficult for me to believe. How could she have been beaten so bad as she said she was but the next to a couple days after she miraculously healed. nobody seen not 1 bruise, cut or swollen anything. let's not forget her shredded feet being cut with broken glass. Do u know how difficult it would have been for AH to walk let alone stand. I'm upset that she would say such things but say these things about a man who I feel didn't do what she has claimed.
Exactly! It's the bottle sa part for me. I have given birth, but if I were to violently experience the business end of that big old bottle like she said she did, I'd need medical attention and perineum stitches.
And to have no medical records of a doctor or nurse helping remove glass from the bottom of her feet afterwards, is she seriously expecting us to believe she managed to do a good enough job of that herself.
@@emmao6578 Incredibly Average has an audio on his channel from the night in Australia. You can hear the security, medical team, and house manager trying to assess what happened and how to fix it with her in the background saying she's sorry and that she doesn't want to leave because he'll never forgive her and it will be the end of the relationship. They discussed how hysterical she was and how they could calm her down so they could be free to find the finger and clean up the mess. The doctor told the nurse to give her a moderate dose of seroquel. He never said clean her wounds, didn't prescribe anything for pain or even a bandaid. No one in that whole audio, not even Amber, mentions anything about any injuries on her except a member of his security who, I think, said she a had a couple of surface scratches on her arm. You should hear that audio.