Being a Chinese We used to Look Up to USA all the time. When I first went to USA to study for Master’s in 2004, I was shocked that every American family has cars, I was very envious. At that time, only Rich families in China could afford cars. Fast forward to 2024, now almost all Chinese families have cars, often more than 1. And we produce and export cars now more than anyone else. Now in Fortune 500 companies , USA has about 130, while China has more than 140. It’s nothing short of a miracle even for us Chinese.
i am nepali born in lucknow(11 GRRC) and raised in nepal...visited india countless times and visited china 7 times...they both have very different mindset...in china people are more responsible towards their society and they focus on that...in india they have mindset towards to criticize government but no one will raise hand to reform the society, same like us nepali...that's the difference..that's why india and nepal is poor..
China had to fight hard to get their great country back from foreign invaders. And China has done that many times in their 5000 years of civilization. India is not like that. India was not a country until the British came to annex all tribes. Basically india didn’t do anything themselves and didn’t fight hard to become a country, but let the British doing all the annexation, invasion and land grabbing from neighbouring countries like the McMahon map illegally taking land from China 🇨🇳 that led to today’s border dispute between China and India. China still has to face with unfair treatments, sanctions and oppression from western countries while India is still getting support from western countries. Like now western countries constantly accuse China for selling and buying from Russia and thus they sanction Chinese companies while the west allow India making huge profits from selling Russian oil to Europe. See the big difference? To sum it up, China has to do all the hard work fighting by themselves against the outside powerful forces while India doesn’t have to do that like China did and does while India still gets more help and support from foreign powers. And China is much more development when doing all the work by themselves. India getting all the help from foreign powers and gets favourable conditions and deal but still is lack of development. We have noticed that those countries got India’s cultural influences are lacking development and poor, and while those countries got China’s cultural influences are highly developed and richer. Let’s take a look at this. (The lack of development group) Nepal, Cambodia,Sri Lanka influenced by India vs. (The high development group) Korea, Japan, Vietnam influenced by China.
@@haniahannslew4108what fo you mean by british annexed all the tribes. India was not a tribal country infact it was the riches country until 18th century when british arrived and looted all our money. We were already rich
China does not want to compare itself with other countries, nor does it wish to interfere in the internal affairs of other countries; it just wants to live its own life well.
They do interfere. They have border problems with many countries and they claim sea too. So definitely they interfere. And don't forget debt trap which they use against poor countries.
Market economy is about competition. Competition is about comparing to others as motivation. Without competition for the ranking, Olympic athletes would not ran as fast as possible. It is the same for business world. Monopoly or harmony relationship among business is considered violation of antitrust law. The purpose of antitrust legislation is to keep business competing/comparing with other others to boost innovation and economic progress. Economist study indicates that harmony relationship and collectivism inhibit innovation; Individualism liberates innovation/creativity.
Chinese technology also dominates the world by controlling 37 fields, even beating the US and western countries which are increasingly weak and powerless in the field of technological innovation
hahahhaa they stole everything from the capitalist system of the USA! And now they have missed managed the economy, tell me, how is your housing market? hahahah FAILING!! thanks to your pathetic china’s socialist system with chinese characteristics, more like a dictatorship thats is failing hahahah
@@SamJonny-gc5rmHigh-speed rail technology. 5G communication technology. Quantum communication technology. UHV transmission technology. Bridge construction technology. Supercomputer technology. Artificial intelligence technology. New energy vehicle technology. UAV technology. Controlled fusion technology that has not yet been realized. Beidou satellite navigation technology. Mobile payment technology. 3D printing technology. Gene editing technology. Deep sea exploration technology. Aerospace technology. Big data technology. Cloud computing technology. Smart grid technology. Industrial robotics. Brain science and brain-like research techniques. New material technology. Biological breeding techniques. Virtual reality and augmented reality technology. Laser technology. Intelligent manufacturing technology. Blockchain technology. Network security technology. Vehicle driverless technology. Energy conservation and environmental protection technology. Electronic information industry technology. Superconducting technology. Smart City Technology.
All Han ethnic nations/regions are doing well under different systems, including taiwan, hong kong, singapore, macau, mainland, even oversea diaspora. As physician, we always try to connect dots to get a single diagnosis to explain all symptoms. Here is single most consistent factor obviously present in all those regions. It is also true for all highly developed nations, which often share one or two common factors. Long civilization is obviously not the answer for China achievement if you consider all other ancient civilizations.
@@alexoolau China had to fight hard to get their great country back from foreign invaders. And China has done that hard work many times in their 5000 years of advanced civilization. India is not like that. India was not a country until the British came to annex all tribes. Basically india didn’t do anything themselves and didn’t fight hard to become a country, but let the British doing all the annexation, invasion and land grabbing from neighbouring countries like the McMahon map illegally taking land from China 🇨🇳 that led to today’s border dispute between China and India. China still has to face with unfair treatments, sanctions and oppression from western countries while India is still getting support from western countries. Like now western countries constantly accuse China for selling and buying from Russia and thus they sanction Chinese companies while the west allow India making huge profits from selling Russian oil to Europe. See the big difference? To sum it up, China has to do all the hard work fighting by themselves against the outside powerful forces while India doesn’t have to do that like China did and does while India still gets more help and support from foreign powers. And China is much more development when doing all the work by themselves. India getting all the help from foreign powers and gets favourable conditions and deal but still is lack of development. We have noticed that those countries got India’s cultural influences are lacking development and poor, and while those countries got China’s cultural influences are highly developed and richer. Let’s take a look at this. (The lack of development group) Nepal, Cambodia,Sri Lanka influenced by India vs. (The high development group) Singapore, Korea, Japan, Vietnam influenced by China (including Taiwan Hong Kong and Macau).
hahahhaa they stole everything from the capitalist system of the USA! And now they have missed managed the economy, tell me, how is your housing market? hahahah FAILING!! thanks to your pathetic china’s socialist system with chinese characteristics, more like a dictatorship thats is failing hahahah
Shanghai was never a small village, it has always been the second city in china ...if you want to compare China's growth you need to compare Shenzhen in the 90s to Shenzhen now...
Hard-working and honest individuals, coupled with a government that is committed and responsible, alongside a united and supportive community. Aside from all the factors discussed in this video, there must be something particularly unique about the mindset of every Chinese individual. Any advanced society requires cooperation and collaboration among three key players: government, community, and individuals.
Note that China had to fight hard to get their great country back from foreign invaders. And China has done that hard work many times in their 5000 years of advanced civilization. India is not like that. India was not a country until the British came to annex all tribes. Basically india didn’t do anything themselves and didn’t do the hard work to become a country, but let the British doing all the annexation, invasion and land grabbing from neighbouring countries like the McMahon map illegally taking land from China 🇨🇳 that led to today’s border dispute between China and India. China still has to face with unfair treatments, sanctions and oppression from western countries while India is still getting support from western countries. Like now western countries constantly accuse China for selling and buying from Russia and thus they sanction Chinese companies while the west allow India making huge profits from selling Russian oil to Europe. See the big difference? To sum it up, China has to do all the hard work fighting by themselves against the outside powerful forces while India doesn’t have to do that like China did and does ,and India still gets more helps and supports from foreign powers. And China is still doing better and much more development when doing all the work by themselves. India is getting all the help from foreign powers and gets more favourable conditions and deal but still is lack of development. We have noticed that those countries got India’s influences are lacking development and poor, and while those countries got China’s influences are doing better and highly developed and richer. Let’s take a look at this. (The lack of development group) Nepal, Cambodia,Sri Lanka etc. influenced by India vs. (The high development group) Singapore, Korea, Japan, Vietnam influenced by China (including Taiwan Hong Kong and Macau)… and Laos and Cambodia are becoming more developed after joining China’s BRI.
hahahhaa they stole everything from the capitalist system of the USA! And now they have missed managed the economy, tell me, how is your housing market? hahahah FAILING!! thanks to your pathetic china’s socialist system with chinese characteristics, more like a dictatorship thats is failing hahahah
in year 1600s china was technology advanced and maybe the most civilized nation in the world. During that time, EU nations (US was not founded yet :)) sent many scholars and monks to the Beijing, capital city of chinese empire for the study of the astronomical, mathematical and engineering knowledge. They brought a lots of chinese literature back to europe and translated them into important local languages like French, German, Latin etc (English was back then only second or third tier of languages).
I'm sorry but India didn't technically open it's economy in 1991. It needed 2nd round of reforms which we never got. 1. Exclusive economic zones Missing in india. 2. Bureaucratic reforms never happened in India. 3. No judiciary reforms in India. 4. No push for manufacturing at all 5. Very bad focus on health, education and R&D in India. These 5 things China got it right
I think you left out private enterprises from the equation. The likes of Huawei, Tencent, BYD, Alibaba, etc are not SOE nor funded by FDI. In education, you fail to mention the focus on STEM which is the core of China's technology rise and is the reason it will surpass the west in technology in the future. The west cannot field the manpower needed to lead in the multitude of sectors of technology that China can. In fact, one of the reason for America's success in technology has been its attraction of the smartest Chinese, Indians, etal that migrated and become citizens of the US. Unfortunately that trend is diminishing and with the Chinese, there is a reverse brain drain. However, your points are very compelling to the reasons why China rose so fast. I would only add that the Chinese are willing to work hard and long hours that makes them competitive in almost all areas of business they choose to pursue. Everything from agriculture to restaurants, you will find Chinese working long hours and have created efficiency in their particular discipline. As the US is finding out, throwing money at a problem is not the total solution. It requires a dedicated and hard working workforce to compete on the world stage.
There are some obstacles that can deter a country's progress or even stall it from becoming an advanced economy even if it has good governance. These obstacles are beyond the control of the government. They include. 1. Frequent natural disasters 2. Unfavorable terrain eg. being too hilly or densely forested 3. Lack of natural resources, especially water and arable and habitable land 4. Being landlocked 5. Being surrounded by poor and unstable neighboring countries 6. Being too remote 7. Being too small in size 8. Crappy climate eg. being too hot, tropical or cold 9. Effects of global warming 10. Invasive plants, animals and insects Contrary to the belief of some classical economists, it's actually not possible for every country to become an advanced economy just like it's not possible for every person within an economy to be a millionaire.
Chin is an indepedence country ,Most of country it seemed it's indepenced but it's economy and finance ,media controled by west countrys,So china could decide how to develop
All the 3 factors stated in this video, namely FDI, Infrastructure and Education are being pursued in India, but India’s progress is nowhere as rapid as that of China. The makers of this video have omitted to mention an important factor and that is that the Chinese are not encumbered with the restrictions of democratic system of governance . They run a command economy under the dictatorship of the CPC. It appears that by and large this dictatorship has been benevolent and is working in the interest of the Chinese people. The Chinese have always been fiercely nationalistic and proud of their culture. In the Chinese culture the authority is respected and there is lack of questioning culture and of open discussion. India is exactly opposite. It is anarchic and always quarrelsome. There has always been the tradition of debate. This approach is well reflected in all the classical Indian discourses on religion and philosophy. There is no way Indians can be regimented. On top of this India has adopted the democratic form of governance. If a government proposes to do anything, there will always be objection on the environmental grounds or some other grounds. There will be court litigations and delays. The opposition parties capitalise on this descent to score political points. The questions that should therefore be asked are: Can a poor country like India afford the luxury of democracy in its present form? Is it right that just to satisfy a handful of chattering classes, the overwhelming number of poor Indians are condemned to live in subhuman conditions?
Well said 👏 I feel the same about my own country South Africa. I still believe with great minds like yours and analytical skills and ability to communicate clearly on problems identified there must something that can be done. I am pondering the same question myself on what I can do to help my country knowing the red tape challenges and including just to get access, be heard or come in close proximity to the people with the most power in government. The problem won’t solve its self unless someone does something about it.
The development of China is largely due to its ethnic culture. Chinese people are hardworking and hardworking, with a high pursuit of money. With the support of the government and a large influx of manufacturing capital after the reform and opening up, the competition in the huge market of 1.4 billion people has been fierce since they started school. Most of their middle class members have been attending extracurricular tutoring classes in addition to school since childhood, which has also created a large number of talented students and engineers in various fields~
Very good analysis. I have also studied China's economic progress over the past decade. Hard work and discipline has given the chinese people a monumental advantage which cannot be taken away by multilateral agreements in Europe.
China’s industrial might and advancements is due to its hardworking and diligent people. The Chinese always work and innovate. The world is a better place because of China.
Chinese hard working attitude coupled with their intelligence contribute to major economic growth. China does not spend time interfere in the internal affairs of other countries.
What I notice in Chinese people is that they are creative in simple things. All others try to create some very new complicated technology Chinese are also good at that but they also very good at finding out how to do a simple job faster
This video missing out most keypoints. Chinese culture which prioritise family is the key factor. CHeap labour is possible because grandparents willing to take care of grandchildren at hometown while young adults working in the city.
I am English and grew up near what was one of the first industrial cities in the world (1750), which is now old and ready to be demolished and hopefully then redeveloped. I worked in technology in the UK from 1966 (at age 19) and it is amazing to watch as technology has spread around the world from very humble beginnings. Soon even the remotest places on the planet will be highly technical, and I often wonder what will happen then.
I THINK ... 🤔💭 It Is Neither SOCIALISM Nor CAPITALISM Nor STATE CAPITALISM. OR Whatever You Want To Call It. It Is Just The Way Chinese DO THINGS. The Way Chinese WORK. Maybe We Can Come Up With A New Term, CHINA-ism. 😂 😊
Chinese by their dna always look to first improve themselves and their livelihood, often remembering their past humilation during the Japanese and western invasions. It has ever since become a very strong motivation to do well.
India has the same potential as China. Indians love their country, are honest, very hard working and excel at sciences and math. They've made great strides in improving their economy in the last 15 years and are part of BRICS which will help them rise further.. The things that go against India in its economic journey are its religious myopia and constant meddling in the internal affairs of its neighbors to destabilize them. If India were to embrace its religious minorities and the Kashmiris and stopped flexing its military muscle on its neighbors for at least 50 years, it will become unstoppable as an economy.
@@terrainofthought no Indian are lazy people. Do you know why iPhone manufacturers not succeed in India? As so many western companies? Indian ask for too much tea time.
In Asia, we looked up to the U.S. The U.S. is like another whole world. Even back then, Asia countries were very poor but thanks to outsider invasion, Asia countries have no choice but to rapidly improve and take whatever outside force have and copy it for themselves. I still remember how my family really wanted to move to the U.S. because of the "American Dream," and I honestly don't know where they even get that from, but that was the best decision my family ever made.
They developed not just their economy but their architecture and infrastructure in every city they have not just one or two city.. No countries is capable of doing what china did in this short period of time.. To be honest it's magnificent and they deserve the top without a dough..
@@keepingittight From 1980 to 2000, China progressed slowly, 2000 to 2008 it went a bit faster and after 2008, it sped up for 350km/hr. That was how fast the Chinese were. Right now, they're approaching 600km/hr. so cross Chinese railway tracks at your own risks. 😂😂😂😂😂
@@rayjohn-dl3ec hahahhaa they stole everything from the capitalist system of the USA! And now they have missed managed the economy, tell me, how is your housing market? hahahah FAILING!! thanks to your pathetic china’s socialist system with chinese characteristics, more like a dictatorship thats is failing hahahah
Brilliant Video! You can’t deny Chinas infrastructure is incredible, but at the cost of a controlling government. Still really want to Travel China tho, especially Chongqing.
Chinese have gungho spirit. Which can be find in another country that have deep root in China which is Japan and South Korea. Gungho is spirit to work and contribute to society, sacrificing personal liberty.
No. The special economic zone projects are like experiments in a small scale. Found issues to fix; when determined mature. then promote in larger area step-by-step, not like Soviet Union and eastern European countries, just listened to some western economists' proposals, then adapted wholesale, resulting in bad outcome.
China was managing world economy so got foreign investment. It worked as a broker so got richer by day .now india is managing world economy. Hope india will be developed as china soon.
It is not any one of the mentioned factors as much as culture. The one common denominator that defines the far eastern oriental races and separates them collectively from the rest of the world is culture. Whether within their original motherlands or as part of the great diaspora globally, the integrity in culture is maintained in all these races. And the essence of that culture has not only remained generally the same geographically but also through time. That is the only “secret”!
Consider all investments is not for profit..But for peoples well-being....That is ,I think the driving force of Chinese success....Long live China..❤❤❤❤ with love from India..❤❤❤.
When the roots of a plant are struggling to grow downward, no one will notice it. When the plant has a sufficient foundation and begins to grow branches and leaves, people will wonder why it grows so fast and so big. China's development in the past two or three decades has only been seen by people as the growth of branches and leaves.
A lot of careful govt planning , city planning , effective policies , long term goals etc. China had 3 legs - exports , infrastructure investments and property investment/urbanization. Ofc it had the workforce with 1.4B ppl. At the end of the day , credit must be given to the govt.
Ive always had this opinion about countries with one party system. You need to have a consistent form of government over a period to see remarkable growth in a country
Look at Middle East countries too. Over the past three decades, they are the ones who've seen the most rapid growth Unlike Democratic, or multy party where it's "Us vs Them" which prevents great policies from being implemented faster
It's not that there are those who developed so fast. It's just that subsequently, there were more effort, more output, hence healthy competition. But it's also that there are those who stayed developing the opposite speed. Less effort, less output.
Brother that's not the issue Britain's rule over india is the main problem. They set their own people on biggest posts to rule india even after independence. It was the biggest problem of India.
Being a Chinese We used to Look Up to USA all the time. When I first went to USA to study for Master’s in 2004, I was shocked that every American family has cars, I was very envious. At that time, only Rich families in China could afford cars. Fast forward to 2024, now almost all Chinese families have cars, often more than 1. And we produce and export cars now more than anyone else. Now in Fortune 500 companies , USA has about 130, while China has more than 140. It’s nothing short of a miracle even for us Chinese.
不，还有大量人没有汽车，你只是没去贫困山区看过而已，你就下此结论，你难道忘记了总理说的中国有6亿人月收入不足1000，9.65亿人月收入不足2000吗
@@johnbruce1775 这里的统计把不工作的老人和孩子也算上了 你看咨询能不能看准确点？一户人家这么算 人均不就少多了 现在极端贫困治理可不错 再去那些你觉得落后的地方看看吧
@@wang-ev7cb 我村子还没一家买得起汽车，山沟沟里的，只能种点菜还有粮食吃，水电也就前几年才通的
@@johnbruce1775那你更应该放下手机去努力工作，一个成年人应该努力让自己生活的更好，如果你贫穷，学历低，没有技能就少点抱怨努力工作吧，你会上网说明你会使用手机，还会看youtube，外卖软件你是会用的，什么都不会可以去送外卖，无论你在世界什么地方，天上都不会掉馅饼，如果你只会抱怨你要反思自己为什么穷！
@@johnbruce1775 我去过包括新疆西藏内蒙宁夏国内各个省份 看到的都是安居乐业 偏远山区也有汽车至少摩托车 我不相信 还有6亿人收入不到2000 老人小孩这些群体本身就没有收入或者只有退休金 到哪里几乎都没看到过流浪汉 大家都有体面的小康生活 大山深处 也有二维码支付 也有快递 也有5G
i am nepali born in lucknow(11 GRRC) and raised in nepal...visited india countless times and visited china 7 times...they both have very different mindset...in china people are more responsible towards their society and they focus on that...in india they have mindset towards to criticize government but no one will raise hand to reform the society, same like us nepali...that's the difference..that's why india and nepal is poor..
@@gobinlimbu8338 That was why the Indians talk and talk till the cows come home yet haven't finish talking. 😂😂😂😂
Government critics want to show others they have guts, yet most are just repeating what the opinion leaders say.
China had to fight hard to get their great country back from foreign invaders. And China has done that many times in their 5000 years of civilization. India is not like that. India was not a country until the British came to annex all tribes. Basically india didn’t do anything themselves and didn’t fight hard to become a country, but let the British doing all the annexation, invasion and land grabbing from neighbouring countries like the McMahon map illegally taking land from China 🇨🇳 that led to today’s border dispute between China and India.
China still has to face with unfair treatments, sanctions and oppression from western countries while India is still getting support from western countries. Like now western countries constantly accuse China for selling and buying from Russia and thus they sanction Chinese companies while the west allow India making huge profits from selling Russian oil to Europe. See the big difference?
To sum it up, China has to do all the hard work fighting by themselves against the outside powerful forces while India doesn’t have to do that like China did and does while India still gets more help and support from foreign powers. And China is much more development when doing all the work by themselves. India getting all the help from foreign powers and gets favourable conditions and deal but still is lack of development. We have noticed that those countries got India’s cultural influences are lacking development and poor, and while those countries got China’s cultural influences are highly developed and richer. Let’s take a look at this. (The lack of development group) Nepal, Cambodia,Sri Lanka influenced by India vs. (The high development group) Korea, Japan, Vietnam influenced by China.
@@haniahannslew4108what fo you mean by british annexed all the tribes. India was not a tribal country infact it was the riches country until 18th century when british arrived and looted all our money. We were already rich
100% bruh
China does not want to compare itself with other countries, nor does it wish to interfere in the internal affairs of other countries; it just wants to live its own life well.
They do interfere. They have border problems with many countries and they claim sea too. So definitely they interfere. And don't forget debt trap which they use against poor countries.
That's not true. China has been compare itself with British and USA from the get go.
@@dlf4298China can't compare with the ŰŠ UK propaganda machine. China can't compare to the ŰŠ UK jěnócïdę around the world.
@@dlf4298 CARE TO GIVE A FEW EXAMPLES???
😊
Market economy is about competition. Competition is about comparing to others as motivation. Without competition for the ranking, Olympic athletes would not ran as fast as possible. It is the same for business world.
Monopoly or harmony relationship among business is considered violation of antitrust law. The purpose of antitrust legislation is to keep business competing/comparing with other others to boost innovation and economic progress. Economist study indicates that harmony relationship and collectivism inhibit innovation; Individualism liberates innovation/creativity.
Chinese technology also dominates the world by controlling 37 fields, even beating the US and western countries which are increasingly weak and powerless in the field of technological innovation
Which field particularly, can you list few of them please...
hahahhaa they stole everything from the capitalist system of the USA! And now they have missed managed the economy, tell me, how is your housing market? hahahah FAILING!! thanks to your pathetic china’s socialist system with chinese characteristics, more like a dictatorship thats is failing hahahah
@@SamJonny-gc5rm应该39个了还有三个没有不难熔断全球
@@SamJonny-gc5rm高铁技术。5G通信技术。量子通信技术。特高压输电技术。桥梁施工技术。超级计算机技术。人工智能技术。新能源汽车技术。无人机技术。尚未实现的受控聚变技术。北斗卫星导航技术。移动支付技术。3D打印技术。基因编辑技术。深海勘探技术。航空航天技术。大数据技术。云计算技术。智能电网技术。工业机器人。脑科学和类脑研究技术。新材料技术。生物育种技术。虚拟现实和增强现实技术。激光技术。智能制造技术。区块链技术。网络安全技术。车辆无人驾驶技术。节能环保技术。电子信息产业技术。超导技术。智慧城市技术。
@@SamJonny-gc5rmHigh-speed rail technology. 5G communication technology. Quantum communication technology. UHV transmission technology. Bridge construction technology. Supercomputer technology. Artificial intelligence technology. New energy vehicle technology. UAV technology. Controlled fusion technology that has not yet been realized. Beidou satellite navigation technology. Mobile payment technology. 3D printing technology. Gene editing technology. Deep sea exploration technology. Aerospace technology. Big data technology. Cloud computing technology. Smart grid technology. Industrial robotics. Brain science and brain-like research techniques. New material technology. Biological breeding techniques. Virtual reality and augmented reality technology. Laser technology. Intelligent manufacturing technology. Blockchain technology. Network security technology. Vehicle driverless technology. Energy conservation and environmental protection technology. Electronic information industry technology. Superconducting technology. Smart City Technology.
Answer is simple :Smart plus hardworking.
Chinese people are the chosen ones, every great civilization that has fallen never got back up except for CHINA.
YEAH, WORK HARD ...
And Don't Think that the world owe us a living. Wanna live a Good Life, WORK FOR IT.
😊
@user-rk9it9hz6g If it wasn't for China there wouldn't be U S. Who gave the U S a head start? (the stuff u need to operate a fireweapon ring a bell)
@@asianconnection7701exactly
A lot of American companies moved to China back in 1990s to invest and make money In China
That’s how all the American companies got rich for example Apple company
According to the CWTS Leiden Ranking, China has about half of the world's top 50 universities in STEM.
Yes , the 5000-year journeys of historic sophistication definitely never lie , never .
All Han ethnic nations/regions are doing well under different systems, including taiwan, hong kong, singapore, macau, mainland, even oversea diaspora. As physician, we always try to connect dots to get a single diagnosis to explain all symptoms. Here is single most consistent factor obviously present in all those regions. It is also true for all highly developed nations, which often share one or two common factors. Long civilization is obviously not the answer for China achievement if you consider all other ancient civilizations.
@@alexoolau China had to fight hard to get their great country back from foreign invaders. And China has done that hard work many times in their 5000 years of advanced civilization. India is not like that. India was not a country until the British came to annex all tribes. Basically india didn’t do anything themselves and didn’t fight hard to become a country, but let the British doing all the annexation, invasion and land grabbing from neighbouring countries like the McMahon map illegally taking land from China 🇨🇳 that led to today’s border dispute between China and India.
China still has to face with unfair treatments, sanctions and oppression from western countries while India is still getting support from western countries. Like now western countries constantly accuse China for selling and buying from Russia and thus they sanction Chinese companies while the west allow India making huge profits from selling Russian oil to Europe. See the big difference?
To sum it up, China has to do all the hard work fighting by themselves against the outside powerful forces while India doesn’t have to do that like China did and does while India still gets more help and support from foreign powers. And China is much more development when doing all the work by themselves. India getting all the help from foreign powers and gets favourable conditions and deal but still is lack of development. We have noticed that those countries got India’s cultural influences are lacking development and poor, and while those countries got China’s cultural influences are highly developed and richer. Let’s take a look at this. (The lack of development group) Nepal, Cambodia,Sri Lanka influenced by India vs. (The high development group) Singapore, Korea, Japan, Vietnam influenced by China (including Taiwan Hong Kong and Macau).
Like explosives???
hahahhaa they stole everything from the capitalist system of the USA! And now they have missed managed the economy, tell me, how is your housing market? hahahah FAILING!! thanks to your pathetic china’s socialist system with chinese characteristics, more like a dictatorship thats is failing hahahah
Basically china invested in its country and the USA invested in its military instead of its country thats the difference
The US think invest in military can make fast money.
Shanghai was never a small village, it has always been the second city in china ...if you want to compare China's growth you need to compare Shenzhen in the 90s to Shenzhen now...
人家说的上海浦东，的确就是农村!
@@huiyuchina8594yes Pudong has developed a lot but still Shanghai was never a small village.
@@huiyuchina8594 你讲是对的
😊
No 1 biggest city in China
You are right, it was shenzhen that was once a small fishing village.
Hard-working and honest individuals, coupled with a government that is committed and responsible, alongside a united and supportive community.
Aside from all the factors discussed in this video, there must be something particularly unique about the mindset of every Chinese individual. Any advanced society requires cooperation and collaboration among three key players: government, community, and individuals.
And a very strong sense of collective unity. They focus on walking the walk, not talking the talk
You are quite right. We work hard for a better living
Note that China had to fight hard to get their great country back from foreign invaders. And China has done that hard work many times in their 5000 years of advanced civilization. India is not like that. India was not a country until the British came to annex all tribes. Basically india didn’t do anything themselves and didn’t do the hard work to become a country, but let the British doing all the annexation, invasion and land grabbing from neighbouring countries like the McMahon map illegally taking land from China 🇨🇳 that led to today’s border dispute between China and India.
China still has to face with unfair treatments, sanctions and oppression from western countries while India is still getting support from western countries. Like now western countries constantly accuse China for selling and buying from Russia and thus they sanction Chinese companies while the west allow India making huge profits from selling Russian oil to Europe. See the big difference?
To sum it up, China has to do all the hard work fighting by themselves against the outside powerful forces while India doesn’t have to do that like China did and does ,and India still gets more helps and supports from foreign powers. And China is still doing better and much more development when doing all the work by themselves. India is getting all the help from foreign powers and gets more favourable conditions and deal but still is lack of development.
We have noticed that those countries got India’s influences are lacking development and poor, and while those countries got China’s influences are doing better and highly developed and richer. Let’s take a look at this. (The lack of development group) Nepal, Cambodia,Sri Lanka etc. influenced by India vs. (The high development group) Singapore, Korea, Japan, Vietnam influenced by China (including Taiwan Hong Kong and Macau)… and Laos and Cambodia are becoming more developed after joining China’s BRI.
hahahhaa they stole everything from the capitalist system of the USA! And now they have missed managed the economy, tell me, how is your housing market? hahahah FAILING!! thanks to your pathetic china’s socialist system with chinese characteristics, more like a dictatorship thats is failing hahahah
The single party system is main reason that china develop so fast .
Viet？
@@晴天-k2t国家体量不一样啊，越南领土才多少？人口才多少
Spot on they will never admit that. Democracies are unstable and easily infiltrated by clandestine organisations like the CIA.
@@晴天-k2t 越南没有解决腐败问题，而且他们是军队腐败，这非常严重。
@@晴天-k2tvietnam is one of the best in south east asia
in year 1600s china was technology advanced and maybe the most civilized nation in the world. During that time, EU nations (US was not founded yet :)) sent many scholars and monks to the Beijing, capital city of chinese empire for the study of the astronomical, mathematical and engineering knowledge. They brought a lots of chinese literature back to europe and translated them into important local languages like French, German, Latin etc (English was back then only second or third tier of languages).
I'm sorry but India didn't technically open it's economy in 1991. It needed 2nd round of reforms which we never got.
1. Exclusive economic zones Missing in india.
2. Bureaucratic reforms never happened in India.
3. No judiciary reforms in India.
4. No push for manufacturing at all
5. Very bad focus on health, education and R&D in India.
These 5 things China got it right
Let's excuse. That's how we are doing.
Indian are intelligent people how did they not get it right?
Economic Liberalism happened during Narasimha Rao PM and Manmohan Singh's FM. Only Akand bhakth won't accept that
@@stevenlai1199i think you get the wrong information about IND people 😂😂😂🤡
India superpower 2047
Because China 🇨🇳 is world factory. China dont start wars it helps it people grows
@user-rk9it9hz6g你认为这些战争都是中国先发起的吗？？？
first look at your own country PAKISTAN
@user-rk9it9hz6gAmerican propagandised puppy 🐶
lies!
Slaves in china be like: 😢
India is still in the Stone Age.
first look at your own country PAKISTAN
You are just jealous of India's success 🤬🤬🤬
jealous of India becoming 3rd largest economy and we will progress in per capita in future and you can't digest that
it was usa who made china to grow fast now china is declining
@@Abdulo865jai hind
Future super power
Already a super power.
chine is the future.
first look at your own country PAKISTAN
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Jai hind @@njnikusha
the chinese are doing something right.
amen 8875
Using slaves? 😂
I think you left out private enterprises from the equation. The likes of Huawei, Tencent, BYD, Alibaba, etc are not SOE nor funded by FDI.
In education, you fail to mention the focus on STEM which is the core of China's technology rise and is the reason it will surpass the west in technology in the future. The west cannot field the manpower needed to lead in the multitude of sectors of technology that China can. In fact, one of the reason for America's success in technology has been its attraction of the smartest Chinese, Indians, etal that migrated and become citizens of the US. Unfortunately that trend is diminishing and with the Chinese, there is a reverse brain drain.
However, your points are very compelling to the reasons why China rose so fast. I would only add that the Chinese are willing to work hard and long hours that makes them competitive in almost all areas of business they choose to pursue. Everything from agriculture to restaurants, you will find Chinese working long hours and have created efficiency in their particular discipline. As the US is finding out, throwing money at a problem is not the total solution. It requires a dedicated and hard working workforce to compete on the world stage.
Chinese genome is of that of smartness, intelligent, resilent and very hard working.
With dedication and love for the country, with hard work, with education and honesty.
THE CHINESE PEOPLE HAVE A WORD FOR IT ...
为祖国贡献
😊
@@joyceching6487 translate into English please
And cooperation
chine too rich, smart and strong!
There are some obstacles that can deter a country's progress or even stall it from becoming an advanced economy even if it has good governance. These obstacles are beyond the control of the government. They include.
1. Frequent natural disasters
2. Unfavorable terrain eg. being too hilly or densely forested
3. Lack of natural resources, especially water and arable and habitable land
4. Being landlocked
5. Being surrounded by poor and unstable neighboring countries
6. Being too remote
7. Being too small in size
8. Crappy climate eg. being too hot, tropical or cold
9. Effects of global warming
10. Invasive plants, animals and insects
Contrary to the belief of some classical economists, it's actually not possible for every country to become an advanced economy just like it's not possible for every person within an economy to be a millionaire.
India govt need to follow similar policies for development!!
China has made rapid progress in tackling corruption. Those SOEs would not have survived if China was corrupt
They didn't. because of no election, there is not endless cycles of new officials for corruptions.
AMAZING !!
wow chine!
1.investment 2.education 3. technological progression.
Thank you
4. the most important: A sound and rational government structure and laws. A rational legal system.
5. Slaves
Thank you
Chin is an indepedence country ,Most of country it seemed it's indepenced but it's economy and finance ,media controled by west countrys,So china could decide how to develop
hahaha you sound so stupid!
All the 3 factors stated in this video, namely FDI, Infrastructure and Education are being pursued in India, but India’s progress is nowhere as rapid as that of China. The makers of this video have omitted to mention an important factor and that is that the Chinese are not encumbered with the restrictions of democratic system of governance . They run a command economy under the dictatorship of the CPC.
It appears that by and large this dictatorship has been benevolent and is working in the interest of the Chinese people. The Chinese have always been fiercely nationalistic and proud of their culture. In the Chinese culture the authority is respected and there is lack of questioning culture and of open discussion.
India is exactly opposite. It is anarchic and always quarrelsome. There has always been the tradition of debate. This approach is well reflected in all the classical Indian discourses on religion and philosophy. There is no way Indians can be regimented.
On top of this India has adopted the democratic form of governance. If a government proposes to do anything, there will always be objection on the environmental grounds or some other grounds. There will be court litigations and delays. The opposition parties capitalise on this descent to score political points.
The questions that should therefore be asked are: Can a poor country like India afford the luxury of democracy in its present form? Is it right that just to satisfy a handful of chattering classes, the overwhelming number of poor Indians are condemned to live in subhuman conditions?
Well said 👏 I feel the same about my own country South Africa. I still believe with great minds like yours and analytical skills and ability to communicate clearly on problems identified there must something that can be done.
I am pondering the same question myself on what I can do to help my country knowing the red tape challenges and including just to get access, be heard or come in close proximity to the people with the most power in government.
The problem won’t solve its self unless someone does something about it.
The development of China is largely due to its ethnic culture. Chinese people are hardworking and hardworking, with a high pursuit of money. With the support of the government and a large influx of manufacturing capital after the reform and opening up, the competition in the huge market of 1.4 billion people has been fierce since they started school. Most of their middle class members have been attending extracurricular tutoring classes in addition to school since childhood, which has also created a large number of talented students and engineers in various fields~
Very good analysis. I have also studied China's economic progress over the past decade. Hard work and discipline has given the chinese people a monumental advantage which cannot be taken away by multilateral agreements in Europe.
China’s industrial might and advancements is due to its hardworking and diligent people. The Chinese always work and innovate. The world is a better place because of China.
Chinese hard working attitude coupled with their intelligence contribute to major economic growth. China does not spend time interfere in the internal affairs of other countries.
What I notice in Chinese people is that they are creative in simple things. All others try to create some very new complicated technology Chinese are also good at that but they also very good at finding out how to do a simple job faster
Great anicent china 🇨🇳 ever great in the world 🌎 such as Hong Kong Taiwan Macau freedoms independence beautiful states in great china 🇨🇳❤
Thank you for investing so much time and resources to make this column so informative and factual. Keep up your good work. 🎉😂
As an Indian,
I agree that china is the king ok modern infrastructure.
First you are hating the china, and now after seeing china advanced development you are saying that china is good😏😏😏😏 never trust country like ind 😒
The pace, just unbelievable ✅👍
You don't know the Chinese.
They care about their people
This video missing out most keypoints. Chinese culture which prioritise family is the key factor.
CHeap labour is possible because grandparents willing to take care of grandchildren at hometown while young adults working in the city.
I am English and grew up near what was one of the first industrial cities in the world (1750), which is now old and ready to be demolished and hopefully then redeveloped. I worked in technology in the UK from 1966 (at age 19) and it is amazing to watch as technology has spread around the world from very humble beginnings. Soon even the remotest places on the planet will be highly technical, and I often wonder what will happen then.
Frankly....great China! All must admire what they did... incredible!
Socialism, the formula for success
nonsense
dumb
Combination of socialism-capitalism-communism-specail Chinese characteristics
I THINK ... 🤔💭
It Is Neither SOCIALISM Nor CAPITALISM Nor STATE CAPITALISM. OR Whatever You Want To Call It.
It Is Just The Way Chinese DO THINGS. The Way Chinese WORK.
Maybe We Can Come Up With A New Term, CHINA-ism. 😂
😊
amen 8232
There is no mystery , over 5000 yrs of history, hard working and smart.
Please do not compare India to China 'cuz China is not a toddy drinker. 😂😂😂😂😂
India is thi best
@@SathyaswamyS I know; best toddy drinker on planet earth. 🥳🥳🥳🥳🥳
@@SathyaswamySIndia is the best in boasting
😂😂😂 😂😂😂 😂😂😂 ...
When it comes to Indians and TODDY, They are almost Inseparable.
😊
Congrats to India for becoming the 'numba wan' country in term of Population 🎉
Chinese by their dna always look to first improve themselves and their livelihood, often remembering their past humilation during the Japanese and western invasions. It has ever since become a very strong motivation to do well.
How? By putting money back to the citizens, not to politicians, not to war and not to the people who control the government
India has the same potential as China. Indians love their country, are honest, very hard working and excel at sciences and math. They've made great strides in improving their economy in the last 15 years and are part of BRICS which will help them rise further.. The things that go against India in its economic journey are its religious myopia and constant meddling in the internal affairs of its neighbors to destabilize them. If India were to embrace its religious minorities and the Kashmiris and stopped flexing its military muscle on its neighbors for at least 50 years, it will become unstoppable as an economy.
@@terrainofthought no Indian are lazy people. Do you know why iPhone manufacturers not succeed in India? As so many western companies? Indian ask for too much tea time.
The Chinese have mastered economics and trade relationships like never seen before.
I love China!!! ❤❤❤
In Asia, we looked up to the U.S. The U.S. is like another whole world. Even back then, Asia countries were very poor but thanks to outsider invasion, Asia countries have no choice but to rapidly improve and take whatever outside force have and copy it for themselves. I still remember how my family really wanted to move to the U.S. because of the "American Dream," and I honestly don't know where they even get that from, but that was the best decision my family ever made.
Excellent talk.
They developed not just their economy but their architecture and infrastructure in every city they have not just one or two city.. No countries is capable of doing what china did in this short period of time.. To be honest it's magnificent and they deserve the top without a dough..
Simple; 'cuz the Chinese has high speed rails hence faster than everyone. 😂😂😂😂😂
@@keepingittight From 1980 to 2000, China progressed slowly, 2000 to 2008 it went a bit faster and after 2008, it sped up for 350km/hr. That was how fast the Chinese were. Right now, they're approaching 600km/hr. so cross Chinese railway tracks at your own risks. 😂😂😂😂😂
@@brianliew5901RIGHT, CHINA KEEPS MOVING ...
Progressively BETTER & FASTER.
😊
chine = $$$$
@@rayjohn-dl3ec hahahhaa they stole everything from the capitalist system of the USA! And now they have missed managed the economy, tell me, how is your housing market? hahahah FAILING!! thanks to your pathetic china’s socialist system with chinese characteristics, more like a dictatorship thats is failing hahahah
today chine is too rich, smart & powerful. chine is the future...
Brilliant Video! You can’t deny Chinas infrastructure is incredible, but at the cost of a controlling government. Still really want to Travel China tho, especially Chongqing.
Hard work and more hard work.
Great China 🇨🇳super power house of factories & infrastructure of world 🌎 so they did it ..will do more ,whole world 🌎 love China 🇨🇳 ever 👍
No cap in your analysis.
Chinese have gungho spirit. Which can be find in another country that have deep root in China which is Japan and South Korea.
Gungho is spirit to work and contribute to society, sacrificing personal liberty.
Japanese won’t be agree that. They think they are the best and superior in the world. It’s an insult to their Pride.
“The flame that burns Twice as bright burns half as long.” Lao Tzu, Te-Tao Ching
Interesting 🤔
Government investment, no neoliberal capitalist agenda, socialism wins
China system is the best, India should follow suit
Chinese worker works 12-14 hours a day ,7days a week with low salary. thats all reason.
Why isn't anyone talking about China being ruled by communism vs India a democratic nation where not a single govt project passes without opposition
Cool
India loves to eat curry everyday and China 🇨🇳 loves to eat mala hot spices meal.Fyi
No. The special economic zone projects are like experiments in a small scale. Found issues to fix; when determined mature. then promote in larger area step-by-step, not like Soviet Union and eastern European countries, just listened to some western economists' proposals, then adapted wholesale, resulting in bad outcome.
China was managing world economy so got foreign investment. It worked as a broker so got richer by day .now india is managing world economy. Hope india will be developed as china soon.
Answer to your question…. 1) By working Together COOPERATION,…. Not fighting for individual supremacy 2) By Great Leadership…
The Chinese people are maintaining their culture and are people are thinking out of the box
It is not any one of the mentioned factors as much as culture. The one common denominator that defines the far eastern oriental races and separates them collectively from the rest of the world is culture. Whether within their original motherlands or as part of the great diaspora globally, the integrity in culture is maintained in all these races.
And the essence of that culture has not only remained generally the same geographically but also through time. That is the only “secret”!
Consider all investments is not for profit..But for peoples well-being....That is ,I think the driving force of Chinese success....Long live China..❤❤❤❤ with love from India..❤❤❤.
I wonder if the Chinese characteristics of hard work, and follow the leadership are important?
When the roots of a plant are struggling to grow downward, no one will notice it. When the plant has a sufficient foundation and begins to grow branches and leaves, people will wonder why it grows so fast and so big. China's development in the past two or three decades has only been seen by people as the growth of branches and leaves.
A lot of careful govt planning , city planning , effective policies , long term goals etc. China had 3 legs - exports , infrastructure investments and property investment/urbanization. Ofc it had the workforce with 1.4B ppl. At the end of the day , credit must be given to the govt.
Immersive translate is also great for generating subtitles.
Plus China is relatively tough on corruption... something here in africa are struggling to deal with
Africa has great potential, but as far as I know, corruption is very serious in Africa
China agriculture value added more than USA .EU ,japan added ,it's manufacture value added just as USA and EU added ,China is a real super power
中国能有今天的成绩，全靠美国，是美国逼迫中国不断的前进，一旦中国在某个领域里落后的时候，美国就像老师惩罚不听话的学生一样，即使自己没有做到，也要激励中国超越自己。举个例子，当年美国的F22战斗机，声称升力系数能达到2.0，中国奋起直追，制造出了J20战斗机，达到了美国第五代战斗机的标准，结果美国的F22升力系数实际上是1.6，美国会把自己的梦想付诸在中国身上，不断的引导中国，让中国强大。
肯尼迪总统为了中国的原子弹事业甚至献出自己的生命。美国知道中国缺少技术，美国支援了大量的技术。为了发展中国的工业，美国不惜摧毁自己的制造业，也要把中国变成世界最大的工业国家。知道中国缺少能源，不惜阉割欧洲，也要把俄罗斯送给中国。知道中国产能过剩，带领盟友们退出俄罗斯的市场，如今美国甚至准备好了交出王座给中国，没有这么好的老师了。
India superpower 2000: ❌
India superpower 2020: ❌
India superpower 2030: ⏳
It's Saicagen from now on bcz. Volkswagen was owned of Chinese car companies from the Mainland of China
Maybe being a one party state also helps
Ive always had this opinion about countries with one party system.
You need to have a consistent form of government over a period to see remarkable growth in a country
Look at Middle East countries too.
Over the past three decades, they are the ones who've seen the most rapid growth
Unlike Democratic, or multy party where it's "Us vs Them" which prevents great policies from being implemented faster
China debt is 10% compared with US, incredible!
It's not that there are those who developed so fast. It's just that subsequently, there were more effort, more output, hence healthy competition.
But it's also that there are those who stayed developing the opposite speed. Less effort, less output.
India is not the only country that's fallen behind, check out my country, Nigeria, it's hell down here
7:14 I don't understand how female labor force participation decreases in both countries. Should not it be increasing in rate?
US Insane Military conspiracies theories
They will fall down at same speed if they didn’t respect neighbours …
五千年的底蕴 👍
So in Short NDA ( Non disclosure Agreement) doesn’t exist in China. Companies have to share their technologies with them to enter their market.
You call Shanghai in 1990 as a small village? Which village have 10 million people?
smart and hardworking
Your information is up to 2020, you should up date to 2024.China is more improved now. The last time I went to China was April 2024 .
How is the chinese housing market?
it's very bad. In 2021, I spent $70,000 to buy a house in our county, and now it has dropped to $40,000.
你可以了解深圳的发展历史，然后做一个关于深圳的节目。
Idk, maybe it’s because they aren’t colonized by the west 🤡
And now those cement buildings are ghost town 😢
Keep it in the cloud, when you looking back later on, you will appreciate
China was saved from the wrath of Islamic civlisation by the mighty Himalayas for centuries. We in India were not so lucky. China is bound to develop.
Brother that's not the issue
Britain's rule over india is the main problem.
They set their own people on biggest posts to rule india even after independence. It was the biggest problem of India.
I guess…the world should learn, from China. Including West, and US.
The author deliberately ignore the most and fundamental fact of Chinese fast development, or naive enough not seeing or realize it at all.
10 trillion investment of your technology advancement