Mark Kermode reviews The Quiet Girl (2021) | BFI Player
Вставка
- Опубліковано 12 січ 2023
- “…one of my favourite films of 2022, an Irish gem of breathtaking beauty…”
Watch The Quiet Girl on BFI Player (UK only): player.bfi.org.uk/subscriptio...
Subscribe: bit.ly/subscribetotheBFI
Claim an extended BFI Player Subscription free trial (UK only) - subscribe using code BFIUA-cam: theb.fi/player-subscription
Watch more on BFI Player: player.bfi.org.uk/
Like us on Facebook: / britishfilminstitute
Follow us on Instagram: / britishfilminstitute
Follow us on Twitter: / bfi - Фільми й анімація
Sometimes I feel very hardened to the beauty and emotional power of a film but I really cannot remember being so affected by a film. Just so utterly beautiful in every which way.
I saw this a few months back at a cineplex on a Sunday morning with 5 others in the theatre and it hasn’t left me since… there’s really nothing to it but yet it’s so human
The ending had me in bits
The ending could make Genghis Khan cry
Same here never seen a movie that had such an emotional impact during, the end and thereafter 😢beautiful film though
Only part of the movie I liked. The rest was just unrelentingly repetitive
@@jamesharris5707 If Putin saw it he would immediately return all of the kidnapped Ukrainian kids with a tearful apology letter.
I was blubbering and could hear the entire silent cinema sniffling!!
The little girl's acting was phenomenal, a great cast overall and totally heartbreaking.
My favourite film of the year, great choice.
A staggeringly beautiful film. The last scene is devastating.
Possibly my favourite film of all time, competing with Terence Davies’ Of Time And The City.
Every single shot in this film exudes a quality that other films have only hoped for.
The story is perfectly told and speaks an absolute truth about love and compassion.
It really is perfect.
Not to take anything away from the story and writing, it was brilliant, but the film was so well shot and the cinematography was so amazing that I could honestly watch this movie on mute, it was simply so aesthetically pleasing
There's an equally poignant Spanish film "Summer 1993" from a few years ago that's not dissimilar to to the "Quiet Girl" in terms of its themes and emotional impact. Its definitely worth seeking out if you've not seen it already.
If its even close in caliber to Quiet Girl, it will be worth watching. Thanks for the recommendation - I will look for this film.
There really is nothing like a good cry now and again.
Far and away the best film of 2022
Agreed. Just watched it today. Excellent film.
A great film, without recommendation from UK critics, I would never have heard of it where I am in the far east. There is meaning and emotion in every scene without much dialogue. The ending I will remember for a long time.
My fav film of the year. Fantastic acting. Loved it.
Upon seeing it for the first time, I knew the movie would jump into my top 100 movies list, and into a strong position in the relationship category in that list. Watching it for the second time was incredibly rewarding because I was able to savor all of the things that make this movie remarkable: the acting of the three main characters, the cinematography, the ability to speak volumes without a single word being said. Catherine Clinch was incredible, and I hope she realizes how incredible her portrayal was when she is in her 30's and 40's.
Wow, so simple, so real, that ending tough, was blubbering like a baby
What a movie it was. Wow. Could not leave until the ending credit finished.
Glad to see this making the award end of the Oscars. It's one of the most beautiful and poignant movies I've ever watched.
Just an outstandingly beautiful film. An ideal companion to Victor Erice's El Sur, which it visually references
What a beautiful masterpiece and destroyed me emotionally
Iontach maith gan dabht ar bith.
Just saw it at the theater. Brilliant!
Was just watching this video when An Ending (Ascent) started playing on Spotify and I just started crying my eyes out.
Such a beautiful film.
Amazing, heart wrenching film.
I haven't seen this film but just looking at the characters and set it seems like it could be very much like Ann of green gables.
It's heartwarming, it's heartbreaking, it's meaningful, but it never surprises you. You read the synopsis: "a neglected girl from a large family is sent to live with distant family over the summer, while her parents take care of their latest baby", and you know exactly what's going to happen. You can take that beginning of that story arc and plot it's course right to the end in your head without missing a beat along the way. It's a no doubt a very good film, but it's one that I'd watched through in my head 90 minutes before the credits rolled.
Yes true, it does play as you expect but the film is cheeky, the way it is shot (Cait in the long grass for example) and the subtlety in the script - the farm and its dangers, the well - moviegoers will probably expect a dramatic turn here or there but it doesn't happen. It isn't needed. The comedy of the neighbor spilling the most dramatic moment of the film. It is just a special treat.
I think that's kind of the point. It isn't a big dramatic film and it doesn't need to be. The ending feels completely inevitable, but that makes it even more poignant somehow. You know what's going to happen, but it still breaks you
I'm pretty sure it was intentional
That's why it's great, the plot is simple. There are no dramatic surprises.Yet It is a magical movie.
The play with light and shadows while journeying in the back of a car or placing the biscuit on the table are nuggets of cinematic gold.
The magic is real, because there are no tricks, no misdirection, it can only be real magic.
I love this film.
Great review of just a stunning film. Anyone know what is the name of the French cinema poet Mark refers to? (Am going to butcher the spelling: something like Celine Charmant?). Want to look him/her up and learn more about him/her.
Celine Sciamma, french director of films like 'Portrait of a lady on fire' or 'Petite Maman', which is the film that (I guess) Mark had in mind by mentioning her.
Thank you JordiTV79, for the response! It’s funny - Petite Maman has already come up with friends in discussing Quiet Girl. I just hadn’t known/committed to memory who the director was (of PM). Have watched a few interviews with the director of QG - amazing it is his first feature film. Now I will learn more about Celine, so thank you again.
scannán thar barr álainn é
A REAL Irish film, unlike that pretentious Banshees bollox. Should have been put in for the Oscar (main best picture) instead.
Why were the dialogues recorded in reverse? 😮
Racist much?
Copyright issues
"Иисус Христос неизменен: Он Тот же вчера, сегодня и вовеки. Иисус сказал: - Я есть путь, истина и жизнь. Никто не приходит к Отцу, как только через Меня. Я - дверь: кто входит через Меня, тот будет спасен. Здесь, на земле, у нас нет родины, и мы ожидаем будущего города. Наша же родина на небесах, и оттуда мы ожидаем Спасителя Иисуса Христа. (Флп 3:20) Будем через Иисуса постоянно приносить Богу жертву хвалы и благодарения, исходящую из уст, которые исповедуют Его имя.Благодарите Бога Отца, Который сделал вас достойными получить часть в наследии святых в Его Свете." (Евр 13:8,14-15)
Should’ve been a short film. This was so incredibly slow and tedious
Cheer up mate, Fast & Furious 10 drops soon. You'll love that!
@@neiljohnson5351 I actually love slow paced movies, especially Leave No Trace, A Ghost Story, The 400 Blows, Tokyo Story, Wild Strawberries, The Rules of the Game, Stalker, Amour, 45 Years, etc. The Quiet Girl just didn’t work for me, I thought the story was unnecessarily repetitive
@@neiljohnson5351 😂😂
The film is not that good.
Because we read the subs, we ourselves create the perfection of the delivery.
Anyone who has read the book will have to say, it's not that good. It could have done a lot of things much better.
But again, I think this is the same thing! It will never be as good as what we saw when reading that lovely, poem of a little book.
This movie is massively overrated , it's cold , shot like a documentary and I know it was designed to be just that but please don't say it's a masterpiece because it's not , the girl has three expression during the whole movie she is not a great actress she is just ok but no one is saying it because she is a child , the best acting in the movie was by the older women and the girls father they were very convincing, the story itself is nothing new nothing special , if you lie a movie with has a similar lost childhood tone to this watch Babyteeth
Like the old joke, everyone has an opinion.
Most people who have watched it wouldn't agree with any of that. Every film will have people who don't get it though.
@@alzer6467 it’s possible for people to get the film but still find it boring. I thought this was incredibly tedious. Should’ve been a short film
To me, it wasn't the overall story or the cinematography (although beautiful imo) that elevated this movie, but the quiet (no pun intented) way it showed how to show love and affection to a child. Not with grandiose words or long speeches about love, but through everyday acts of kindness... it was so beautiful. I guess it's not to everyone's taste though.
A masterpiece. An unassuming piece of cinematic art that devours the soul through the subtle and nuanced presentation of love. We now have it for eternity.