Anatomy of a Great Actor

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 2 лют 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 3,5 тис.

  • @akanshapanwar9099
    @akanshapanwar9099 7 років тому +294

    Outstanding video!
    Can you please make a video on remarkable movies like "Before Sunrise" (Before- Trilogy)? The techniques used to create simplicity or simplicity used to create natural behavior on screen? Would love to see your input :) Great work.

  • @annyarun
    @annyarun 7 років тому +4433

    I feel with this video a new era of Indian youtube critic is born. The content quality and analogy is breathtaking.

    • @ajayvarghese1019
      @ajayvarghese1019 7 років тому +5

      Brahhhh 10000% agree!!!!!

    • @kharybdis
      @kharybdis 7 років тому +4

      Absolutely.

    • @kharybdis
      @kharybdis 7 років тому +42

      A critic and a reviewer are different. A reviewer needs to understand the audience and a critic, the art. A critic will always sound educated and intelligent. Arts courses don't teach you to make art but to talk about art intelligently as if you're 'critiquing', not just reviewing. I realised this in a college course on film and literature. So you're not half wrong.

    • @bhargavchavda1478
      @bhargavchavda1478 7 років тому

      unemployed singh rajput don't you have common sense??

    • @RaZa23796
      @RaZa23796 7 років тому

      Indeed

  • @TriedRefusedProductions
    @TriedRefusedProductions 7 років тому +1286

    LOVED THIS!

    • @AnimalLoversChiragBorawake
      @AnimalLoversChiragBorawake 7 років тому +39

      Tried&Refused Productions. Your videos are also very nice.

    • @vamshikrishna9964
      @vamshikrishna9964 7 років тому +45

      Cinema beyond Entertainment and Tried & Refused Productions are two channels criticising Bollywood Cinema reasonably and for good things to be done in near future
      Thank you both

    • @lentin30
      @lentin30 7 років тому +6

      Anmol 🔥❤️

    • @itsbonkerjojo9028
      @itsbonkerjojo9028 6 років тому +2

      Tried&Refused Productions. Love your channel

    • @shashidubey4882
      @shashidubey4882 6 років тому +5

      Tried&Refused Productions. I think AMIR khan is the leonardo dicaprio of india.

  • @neeleshsuteri7156
    @neeleshsuteri7156 5 років тому +766

    Showed varun dhawan when saying "Garbage".
    Instant subscription.

    • @enjoy-ug1gt
      @enjoy-ug1gt 4 роки тому +11

      He acted well at Badlapur that means he's a good actor but unable get a good script

    • @srivathsamarella7505
      @srivathsamarella7505 4 роки тому +29

      @@enjoy-ug1gt Watch the video again to understand.

    • @adityazagade7570
      @adityazagade7570 4 роки тому +43

      @@enjoy-ug1gt ya if acting good in 1 film out of 10 makes you a good actor then abhishek bachchan will be the greatest actor in the world

    • @Movieswod-v9f
      @Movieswod-v9f 4 роки тому

      @@adityazagade7570 😂😂

    • @consciousconsciousness7095
      @consciousconsciousness7095 4 роки тому

      @@adityazagade7570 😂😂😂😂

  • @BTECE_FARIZ
    @BTECE_FARIZ 7 років тому +1420

    u saying garbage and varun dhawan appearing
    that moment i liked the video

  • @suparnamaiti.
    @suparnamaiti. 6 років тому +1370

    As Indian audience, we have become habituated with mediocrity so much, that even an average performance is celebrated with much fervour. People don't watch movies with an unbiased opinion. They have built different cults. You can't criticise any a-lister actor, because then you will be ridiculed and bullied by his or her die hard fans. It's like we are ready to worship anything and everything.

    • @ozymandias2601
      @ozymandias2601 5 років тому +3

      Chhuti Maiti well said mate

    • @adnpro717
      @adnpro717 5 років тому +112

      Example - KGF
      the movie was not so good but people feel like its a legendary movie.. God I can't believe it

    • @prathamkumar5224
      @prathamkumar5224 5 років тому +32

      @@adnpro717 so true I can't believe saw that movie without watching it's trailer because critics said it was so good
      Pankaj tripathi and Nawaz Bhai rocks

    • @LoneWolf-tk9em
      @LoneWolf-tk9em 5 років тому +30

      @@adnpro717 ya man.. Got recommended by friends, but I find it so boring & lame..

    • @zeeb2455
      @zeeb2455 5 років тому +1

      Couldn't agree more

  • @NITAMKUMAR
    @NITAMKUMAR 5 років тому +313

    Irfan and Nawaz in front of each other .. then It's theatre... No need of camera, any angle audience can see performance.... That's magic of pure acting....

    • @navjotsidhu8437
      @navjotsidhu8437 4 роки тому +8

      RIP The Legend 💔

    • @mamamooscake
      @mamamooscake 9 місяців тому +2

      So true ! I loved both of them in The Lunchbox.

  • @mint139
    @mint139 7 років тому +766

    varun dhawan creepy entry when u say simply garbage :D

    • @yeshvendrapratapsingh2188
      @yeshvendrapratapsingh2188 7 років тому

      mayur reddy 😂😂😂

    • @AM-sp6je
      @AM-sp6je 7 років тому

      On point 😂

    • @stifler4eva1
      @stifler4eva1 7 років тому +22

      mayur reddy and entry of Salman khan and Shahrukh khan in bad actors 😂😂😂

    • @neerajpandey3154
      @neerajpandey3154 6 років тому +4

      watch october movie....varun dhawan was good in it.

    • @sheikhshahrukh4333
      @sheikhshahrukh4333 6 років тому +20

      @@neerajpandey3154 the movie was good.. not him

  • @sagnikchakraborty7637
    @sagnikchakraborty7637 7 років тому +392

    The fact that no one in the comments section is ranting against you for calling Aamir Khan just a normal actor, shows how mature your fanbase is!!!! And that is rare...

    • @saikatbandyo
      @saikatbandyo 7 років тому +51

      SAGNIK CHAKRABORTY yeah and somehow calling him average gives ourselves a sense of intellectualism, right you're.

    • @sy-en
      @sy-en 7 років тому +4

      Saikat Bandyo lol

    • @juliansam
      @juliansam 7 років тому +63

      Saikat : He is an average actor dude. I'm from Kerala and having watched the likes of Mohanlal, Mammootty, Kamal Hassan, Prakash Raj can easily say that Amir dosent even come close to any of these legends in terms of acting

    • @AN-NT557
      @AN-NT557 7 років тому +10

      Julian Sam Aamir is trash and so is Prakash Raj.lol

    • @Nina-oi1qk
      @Nina-oi1qk 7 років тому +43

      I think calling Aamir Khan an "average actor" is a bit harsh; actually I have always felt that Aamir becoming a Huge Star in the Bollywood system has limited him in his craft; despite this he has tried really hard to attempt different things;
      Overall unfortunately in all Film industries, there will always be better meatier roles for Character actors; look at the stuff Nawazuddin gets to do; does anyone think Aamir or Shahrukh will be allowed to try any roles like those? The studios will just not offer them these roles nor will they make any money. In the end, there are great actors and there are some HUGE money makers; very rarely they are the same performer. when they are , like a Brando or Day Lewis or yes an Aamir Khan, then we are lucky as the audience.

  • @muralikartik6813
    @muralikartik6813 3 роки тому +221

    Two thing I learnt here:
    - Great acting= reacting
    - Listening is important

    • @vansh4383
      @vansh4383 3 роки тому +16

      If you start listening believe me you will be better than 50% of the bollywood actors

    • @muralikartik6813
      @muralikartik6813 3 роки тому

      @@vansh4383 lol

    • @ronaldogoat1924
      @ronaldogoat1924 3 роки тому +1

      @@vansh4383 listening in the sense?? I am kind of coufuse can you explain. I just want to learn.

    • @vansh4383
      @vansh4383 3 роки тому +10

      @@ronaldogoat1924 listening means to listen and react to the person you are performing a scene with if you listen to the person and react (like in day to day life) you will look real infront on camera but it requires practice as you have to develop listening in a semse that while listening your mind is free of thoughts.

    • @dayyanahmad117
      @dayyanahmad117 3 роки тому +1

      And unpredictability also

  • @imviiku
    @imviiku 6 років тому +566

    That Rajkumar Rao Scene in Bareily ki Barfi was the Most Epic scene i have Ever seen as It took me by Surprise and The Theatre Erupted in Cheers n Whistles

    • @anshulsuri3769
      @anshulsuri3769 6 років тому +72

      When Theatres erupt in cheers it isnt a great scene. Great scenes make theatres silent!

    • @nik5129
      @nik5129 6 років тому +25

      Then you have not seen many good movies

    • @kashif2309
      @kashif2309 5 років тому +5

      @@anshulsuri3769 oh boy!

    • @akashdeep-db1ff
      @akashdeep-db1ff 5 років тому +12

      @@anshulsuri3769 Then almost every movie I watch at theatre is filled with great scenes and I watch evey movie.

    • @TashreefShareef
      @TashreefShareef 5 років тому +21

      @@anshulsuri3769 Depends on the scene. Raj Kumar Rao's scene is an ultimate one because it took the audience by surprise, which is an achievement for an actor.

  • @nehanez
    @nehanez 6 років тому +1520

    “Eccentricity in the name of acting “and ranveers entry😂🤣

    • @bantiray404
      @bantiray404 5 років тому +18

      @@aafiyatshaikh7244 you must be joking.

    • @swaroopboyina4236
      @swaroopboyina4236 5 років тому +73

      That's the best part after varun dhawan 's garbage appearance😂

    • @swaroopboyina4236
      @swaroopboyina4236 5 років тому +51

      @@aafiyatshaikh7244 seems like a fanboy got triggered 😂 Varun is a good actor? Okay !!

    • @bantiray404
      @bantiray404 5 років тому +10

      @@swaroopboyina4236 indeed

    • @swaroopboyina4236
      @swaroopboyina4236 5 років тому +40

      @@aafiyatshaikh7244 weird that you say you're not Varun's fan but defending him like one .. I'll be honest with you ..I haven't seen October but I have Badlapur which made me think he's not that bad of an actor but after I've seen some shitty films of him like Judwaa 2 , Badrinath ki dulhaniya ..I had a change of opinion , it's just plain overacting that's all ...maybe he can act , maybe if he does some experimental roles we can see his acting capability ...but God he sucked at his recent films like above mentioned and also pretty mediocre in sui dhaaga ..I'm sure in coolie no.1 also it's just cliched script and lame ass dialogues

  • @revzzrider
    @revzzrider 5 років тому +757

    Problem is Even Indian Audience think Overacting is Acting 😂😂😂 Example Mainstream Bollywood

    • @slaprakshas
      @slaprakshas 5 років тому +32

      Revzz Rider mainstream anywhere is overacting. Don’t undermine Indian films.

    • @bullykojima3232
      @bullykojima3232 4 роки тому +15

      @@slaprakshas It happens only in india . It needs to be bashed so that people like you can understand that we are watching shitty movies .

    • @slaprakshas
      @slaprakshas 4 роки тому +15

      @@bullykojima3232 have you watched “Hellaro”? I have spent many years in Europe... even 80% of French people have shitty commercial taste. Much more so in other countries

    • @jimmilton4543
      @jimmilton4543 3 роки тому +12

      @@slaprakshas Indians just love self hate and to act like anything which isn’t Indian is great without knowing a thing or 2 about it

    • @slaprakshas
      @slaprakshas 3 роки тому +17

      @@jimmilton4543 unfortunately so, I have observed that... a portion of people here are oblivious to cultures/films elsewhere and 99% of the rest who watch nothing but Hollywood absolutely try to bully the former for their taste. I actually prefer the former who are much more honest, innocent and unbiased.

  • @fa_cough
    @fa_cough 4 роки тому +311

    Paresh rawal as baburao. His acting with his body language was sometimes funnier than his dialogue delivery.

  • @randomrandom316
    @randomrandom316 7 років тому +546

    Though I have nothing to do with acting at all, the video kept me engaged all throughout, just goes to show how well the whole video has been put up, great effort, keep it up!!

  • @anonymoustruth995
    @anonymoustruth995 5 років тому +509

    Ayushmann Khurrana, Rajkumar Rao, Irfan Khan, Nawazuddin Siddiqui are born to be an actor. Hands down no one can even come closer in Bollywood in this generation !

    • @rahulr8595
      @rahulr8595 5 років тому +25

      I get what you are saying... but I would imagine that they have put a lot of hard work and effort to gain their current skills...

    • @RpLeoo
      @RpLeoo 5 років тому +70

      Wat about pankaj tirpathi brother

    • @meeradubey7018
      @meeradubey7018 5 років тому +13

      Nawaz is overrated af

    • @funnybones5926
      @funnybones5926 5 років тому +106

      @@meeradubey7018 Then you don't know what overrated means .

    • @jasper5016
      @jasper5016 5 років тому +14

      @@funnybones5926 Nawaz is really overrated. He has skills but certainly not that great.

  • @noonelikesmycomment3891
    @noonelikesmycomment3891 5 років тому +230

    I'm so glad finally these kind of quality content channel is coming into existence

  • @ashminbh05
    @ashminbh05 Рік тому +56

    Rest in Peace Vinit. I hope your legacy keeps on inspiring coming generations. ❤❤

  • @tylerdurden4187
    @tylerdurden4187 4 роки тому +55

    kate winslet is underrated like omg i saw her in steve jobs , reader just wow

    • @dayyanahmad117
      @dayyanahmad117 3 роки тому +7

      How is she underrated. She won oscar for the reader

    • @adwaitab.3622
      @adwaitab.3622 3 роки тому +3

      Her Mare of Eastown is brilliant

  • @Shashank147
    @Shashank147 7 років тому +174

    MAN, YOU ARE SERIOUSLY UNDERRATED !

  • @ishatyagi3371
    @ishatyagi3371 7 років тому +107

    I have been watching your videos ardently and even forced my friends to watch them. Every critique that you do strangely leaves me feeling good and self-contemplative. The fear of vulnerability is what stops us from doing most of the things we want to, and yet it is letting go, entering that space and being vulnerable that makes us grow and create something new. Vulnerability is natural in anything worth doing, not something to be cured or forcibly evicted from the thought process. Now, I just want to steal your bookshelf and read what you are reading :)
    I love your work. To quote a part from the cryptic preface of "The picture of Dorian Gray", whose meaning i am yet deconstruct in its entirety.
    "The artist is the creator of beautiful things.
    To reveal art and conceal the artist is art’s aim.
    The critic is he who can translate into another manner or a new material his impression of beautiful things."
    You Sir, are a "True Critic" with Oscar Wilde certification . Keep up the good work.

  • @mohitrawat5225
    @mohitrawat5225 3 роки тому +32

    parineeti chopra who doesn't know A of Acting said in an interview that 'Jo method acting karte hai woh acting hi nahi karte mein acting dhyaan se nahi dil se karti hu wahi acting hai'
    Jab tak Hindustan mein cinema hai log __________ bante rahenge.

    • @adwaitab.3622
      @adwaitab.3622 3 роки тому +1

      She pretty much represents most of the commercial actors

    • @rainachoudhary6861
      @rainachoudhary6861 2 роки тому +1

      Tbhi wo aaj ki date mai Kai nhi hai

    • @KrishanKumar-ec1ch
      @KrishanKumar-ec1ch 2 роки тому

      I disagree with her comment but acting dil se karte hai is important. If you will see actors they will say you need to be good human being,work from heart . Irrfan khan too said i had read method acting but it doesn't suit me ,when you will do things spontaneously then some different things you will see . So parineeti choices of words were wrong and stupid. I think naseeruddin Shah too not beleive in method acting

    • @KrishanKumar-ec1ch
      @KrishanKumar-ec1ch 2 роки тому

      @@rainachoudhary6861 Read my comment

    • @KrishanKumar-ec1ch
      @KrishanKumar-ec1ch 2 роки тому

      @@adwaitab.3622 Read my comment for different perspective

  • @natbiochannel
    @natbiochannel 5 років тому +144

    AWESOME CONTENT

  • @StephenGeorge
    @StephenGeorge 7 років тому +52

    Always appreciated Day-Lewis' work ethic, but hearing his different character voices side by side added a new level of respect.

    • @shiblishahrier9154
      @shiblishahrier9154 5 років тому +6

      Yes Stephen bro that's exactly how I think about Day-Lewis sir and undoubtedly, he is one of my favorite actors.

    • @johnrockyryan
      @johnrockyryan Рік тому

      Not just that its the details he adds to his character that gives his performances a new level of immersion

  • @anvitasingh5
    @anvitasingh5 5 років тому +381

    When people call Kajol the best actress I can't help but feel sorry for them. Great content !

    • @RahulKumar-ng2gh
      @RahulKumar-ng2gh 5 років тому +106

      I think tabu is the best actress of last two-three decades

    • @akashreddy3263
      @akashreddy3263 5 років тому +36

      Never understood why she is considered as a great. She openly admitted that she never wants go out of her comfort zone. I guess her being part of so many successful ventures that people think she is the best actress.

    • @abiromu
      @abiromu 4 роки тому +55

      She isn't great, but she isn't bad either. She is good. But there are several actors much better than her who deserved more attention. Tabu is one of the best examples of this. She was only held back because of her tall stature (sad).

    • @atgwiuz
      @atgwiuz 4 роки тому +18

      She's of the same sect of mainstream actors like SRK , whose performances have been overrated

    • @miscelaneas9532
      @miscelaneas9532 4 роки тому +9

      Konkona Sen Sharma is the best actress in India

  • @kokotootokok502
    @kokotootokok502 7 років тому +138

    I definitely agree the "GARBAGE" bit....👍👍👍👍😂😂😂

  • @vinaykumarsahu116
    @vinaykumarsahu116 7 років тому +61

    I really like your content of analysing great Indian Cinema. I happy that someone from India is doing analysis of Indian Cinema...

  • @ManjunathManja1227
    @ManjunathManja1227 4 роки тому +33

    That Lunchbox scene brings tears to my eyes every time.

    • @Sanjay_Singh_Bisht
      @Sanjay_Singh_Bisht 4 роки тому +3

      No that scene make me hollow.
      Make me thinks, seriously Nawaz doesn’t have any family member and Irfan is being awkward.

  • @vivekjha1185
    @vivekjha1185 6 років тому +300

    Yeh hain krantikari content.

    • @ashishshah6730
      @ashishshah6730 5 років тому +18

      @@aafiyatshaikh7244 bro you go watch Amit bhadana. That's your gold standard. And read it again carefully *your* gold standard (period).

    • @adventureofalifetime3019
      @adventureofalifetime3019 5 років тому +1

      @@aafiyatshaikh7244 would you like to explain why is this a shitty content?

    • @memeleo6486
      @memeleo6486 4 роки тому

      @@aafiyatshaikh7244 then everybody can be actor fucker go and act bollywood

    • @memeleo6486
      @memeleo6486 4 роки тому

      @@aafiyatshaikh7244 idiot if this a shitty content then u must be a boomer

    • @newgenerationanpanman7870
      @newgenerationanpanman7870 3 роки тому +1

      What happened in the replies?

  • @dvivek23
    @dvivek23 4 роки тому +135

    "I abandoned my child" still give heavy goosebumps... Art level infinity

    • @sushmita8824
      @sushmita8824 4 роки тому +15

      Same bro. I literally had goosebumps when the third time he says it and his voice breaks and I could feel the emotions he is going through at that point of time.

    • @mukeshaddagatla4934
      @mukeshaddagatla4934 3 роки тому +1

      @@sushmita8824 which movie is this from?

    • @VC-ps2vm
      @VC-ps2vm 3 роки тому +8

      @@mukeshaddagatla4934 there will be blood
      A modern day masterpiece

    • @gchudasamadarshit9111
      @gchudasamadarshit9111 2 роки тому +2

      There will be blood is one of the greatest movie ever made

    • @netaji-thebritishslayer
      @netaji-thebritishslayer Рік тому

      its a modern day masterpiece!!@@gchudasamadarshit9111

  • @versatile1684
    @versatile1684 3 роки тому +35

    For me if an actor is not versatile then he/she doesn't deserve to call himself/herself as an actor..If you are repeating the same type of roles over and over again that means you are not acting you are being yourself..

    • @raja-jl9os
      @raja-jl9os 3 роки тому

      Ajkal navaz bhi same lag rha h

    • @Tiedlux
      @Tiedlux 3 роки тому

      Although we all have a unique style of writing, speaking, walking ect. Everyone has some type of style even acting but yes even they seemingly have the same acting style for years that would really be a problematic problem for the actor

    • @KrishanKumar-ec1ch
      @KrishanKumar-ec1ch 2 роки тому +1

      Actually playing yourself is an part of acting. What will Tom cruise will do in mission impossible or his action movies it is more about him , sometimes it is about taking traits of an character. Like srk play himself in most of romantic movies ,action roles but with uniqueness

  • @umayrjaved
    @umayrjaved 6 років тому +93

    I like how you say “bad actors” when video was showing Salman Khan in HDDCS

  • @satarupamal1730
    @satarupamal1730 6 років тому +109

    I think the channel name, "Cinema Beyond Entertainment" truly justifies the videos you put up....!! Such a nice intellectual content..Love it..!

    • @pritamraghuvanshi450
      @pritamraghuvanshi450 5 років тому

      @jade ng just paint those white people black... Those acting skills are still brilliant.... Period.

    • @pritamraghuvanshi450
      @pritamraghuvanshi450 5 років тому

      @jade ng hm himdi me bhi yhi bat bolenge... Bihar se hai bhojpuri tk me yhi bat bolenge.... Or accent mera natural hai indian wala...
      To apna opinion dalo gaand me... 🙂

    • @pritamraghuvanshi450
      @pritamraghuvanshi450 5 років тому

      @jade ng you didn't get me i think... You just said that i try to immitate americans or their accent... But i said i don't and even in my laguage i will still say same...

    • @memeleo6486
      @memeleo6486 4 роки тому

      @@aafiyatshaikh7244 go and suck Ur self

  • @pratikrajendrajoshi4526
    @pratikrajendrajoshi4526 4 місяці тому +4

    Dear Vinith,
    whenever i feel low whenever i feel lost or clueless as an artist as well as an audience i come here and watch this video of yours....you are gone too far from this but your thoughts are still here making sense ❤

  • @Shinobi-sc6nm
    @Shinobi-sc6nm Рік тому +10

    One of my favorite video this man has produced. Rest in peace mate.

  • @rohitravi2989
    @rohitravi2989 Рік тому +8

    I come back to this video all the time. Today I rewatched it again and I cried. RIP Vinit❤

  • @livin_lino
    @livin_lino Рік тому +8

    Vinit Masram, thanks for leaving behind some outstanding perspectives and truths. R.I.P

  • @olddelhifilms
    @olddelhifilms 7 років тому +135

    Thank you for making this video.

  • @shivamrao8798
    @shivamrao8798 3 роки тому +73

    This guy can school Rajeev Masand on how to critic films.

    • @burntcookies8133
      @burntcookies8133 3 роки тому +2

      Rajeev Masand can have his candy floss with bollywood garbage

    • @user-fk8md4jn3i
      @user-fk8md4jn3i 3 роки тому

      Rajeev masand actually roasts mainstream crap alot

    • @rittamkhandai4201
      @rittamkhandai4201 3 роки тому

      @@user-fk8md4jn3i he called ranveer singh's garbage performance as khilji as 2019's best

    • @user-fk8md4jn3i
      @user-fk8md4jn3i 3 роки тому +1

      @@rittamkhandai4201 really??
      Thankyou for opening my eyes bro

    • @rittamkhandai4201
      @rittamkhandai4201 3 роки тому

      @@user-fk8md4jn3i also he has left film criticism permanently and has joined dharma productions,says a lot about him

  • @Ms.yaduvanshi10
    @Ms.yaduvanshi10 3 роки тому +9

    Rajkummar Rao is really an underrated actor in india.

  • @chiragojha7311
    @chiragojha7311 5 років тому +17

    I don't know if the viewers realise this but there has been an extremely high amount of research and content filtering that has gone into making this video. Really well done. I want to convey my thanks to everyone who worked on this video. Awesome work. Keep it up.

  • @abhijeet6164
    @abhijeet6164 7 років тому +59

    I know the word underrated is pretty overused these days but, you my friend really need to be recognised by the people. In a time where we are surrounded by garbage on UA-cam, this channel is consistently producing great content for the present and future generations of filmmakers. I hope you get the appreciation that you truly deserve.

  • @MindlessAthlete
    @MindlessAthlete 5 років тому +296

    This is brilliant work. People confuse eccentricity with fuckin good acting. Ranveer Singh is an example.

    • @mangala-ew4vm
      @mangala-ew4vm 5 років тому +8

      Bajirao mastani and Gully Boy are exceptions.

    • @mahmudtaher5472
      @mahmudtaher5472 5 років тому +49

      @@mangala-ew4vm there were Over eccentricity too. You can say lootera was the only perfect subtle performance given by him.

    • @mangala-ew4vm
      @mangala-ew4vm 5 років тому +14

      @@mahmudtaher5472 but I believe that eccentricity had to deal with the character. I felt that in those two movies Ranveer was totally in that character. He was different. Also Lootera. I forgot that. I agree with you on that.

    • @aftabeasty8577
      @aftabeasty8577 5 років тому +2

      Can someone explain what eccentricity is please??

    • @deepakraina6859
      @deepakraina6859 4 роки тому +20

      @@aftabeasty8577 I know it's probably late, but in terms of acting it means over-doing the emotions because you are not talented or trained enough to do it the right way. Lemme give you a brilliant example. Go to UA-cam and type L.A. Takedown diner scene. Then type Heat diner scene you will feel the difference.

  • @maverickjones1320
    @maverickjones1320 6 років тому +15

    Legend of Marathi cinema @6:27. I always adore his talent, the way he portrays any role by putting his soul into it. I take a bow to the great Ashok Saraf

  • @gost4812
    @gost4812 3 роки тому +15

    RAJAT KAPOOR.. ONE THE MOST UNDERRATED GEMS OF INDIAN CINEMA

  • @bhaveshyadav5580
    @bhaveshyadav5580 3 роки тому +40

    Who is here after Tried and Refused Productions?

    • @sanjitray1455
      @sanjitray1455 3 роки тому +4

      I have been here before also as again. Watching this for 7thbor 8th time

    • @bhaveshyadav5580
      @bhaveshyadav5580 3 роки тому +1

      @@sanjitray1455 me too bro

  • @geethum.j5429
    @geethum.j5429 7 років тому +26

    The reference on kapoor and sons is the apt one. It sad the indian film industry despite of of have really talented actors is obsessed with super star . A line of super star + itemsong+ unbelievable stunds+ non sense makes a success equation

    • @creamp2
      @creamp2 6 років тому +2

      Bollywood is obsessed with glamour n foreign chicks

    • @elhachem3625
      @elhachem3625 6 років тому +1

      @@creamp2 what about nepotism?

    • @KrishanKumar-ec1ch
      @KrishanKumar-ec1ch 2 роки тому

      Same with Hollywood Daniel day Lewis love by Americans but he doesn't have box office distribution like Tom cruise, Dwayne Johnson,will Smith . There flops film do collection in a high range . Being a superstar is also a quality with actor choices and you can't deny that

  • @MyTITIR
    @MyTITIR 7 років тому +430

    One day when i have my own money i will surely support your channel Vinit. Till then keep it up :)

    • @parulgusain9891
      @parulgusain9891 7 років тому +9

      Titir Dasgupta I second you.

    • @HimadriSekharGupta
      @HimadriSekharGupta 7 років тому +1

      And i fourth you

    • @sy-en
      @sy-en 7 років тому +2

      Sumit Pandya lol

    • @parbxi100
      @parbxi100 7 років тому +2

      I cant donate to this channel because i will be broke :-(

    • @miloblackmetalhate
      @miloblackmetalhate 7 років тому +2

      Titir Dasgupta erm, there's si many of us that if we all pitch in a bit we can come with something

  • @av1421
    @av1421 2 роки тому +3

    Nawaz talked about that Lunch box scene. He said in that scene, he was choking up, crying internally without a tear outside. Such a powerful scene.

  • @rohanbroach
    @rohanbroach 7 років тому +14

    I read an article of the the creators of 'Every Frame A Painting' (highly regarded as the best channel on film analysis). They said that the copyrights issues and fair use policies were such a mess that they couldn't create the content they wished to make. The channel eventually ended.
    Seeing the disclaimer, I feel so sad that so many content creators are limited for videos being made for Educational Purposes.
    I really appreciate the work you're doing. Your analysis and editing is improving with every new video.

    • @vinitchoudhari2617
      @vinitchoudhari2617 7 років тому +1

      No. Are you serious... Every frame a painting ended😨

    • @rohanbroach
      @rohanbroach 7 років тому

      Here's the link to the article. It's written by Tony (the creator of EFAP) himself: medium.com/@tonyszhou/postmortem-1b338537fabc

  • @raghurajrathore3337
    @raghurajrathore3337 5 років тому +35

    I have watched this an unhealthy amount of times.

  • @jayeshk.d.3429
    @jayeshk.d.3429 3 роки тому +76

    Another aspect is acting without any dialogue, with the silence - but still evoking enough emotion.
    Best example : SRK character's train sequence in Swades where he buys water from a kid.
    Just look at that scene, the eyes, his vulnerability, his realisation of his country's poverty situation -- absolute masterclass scene.

    • @ImtheIC
      @ImtheIC 2 роки тому +2

      Unfortunately this blind tried to show srk an average and one type of actor when rkr a versatile actor. Kid surly born after 2000 when srk got award for a villain character.

    • @ImtheIC
      @ImtheIC 2 роки тому +2

      @@divanshukumarmahajan4803 he's surely way more versatile than those actors you just named. To be exact, what role these amazing actors do play sounds very much similar each time, either funny or villain. On the other hand Srk felt so much different in pure negative role being the antagonist like in darr and anjam. Not gonna talk about his romantic drama, which are even different than his suspense romantic like Dil Se. On the other hand Dil Se, Raju Ban Gaya Gentle Man showed his natural direction. Devdas, k3, Rab Ne, Darr... showed the industry's most expressive face, even more than top actresses. What made him world's most unreal actor. Swades, Chak De was his classic cult being a stereo type drama. I think I don't need to mention everything. From those name, only Manoj ji was a theater actor still no to srk level. On the other hand srk was a full fledge theater performer, did series drama including series. He's top dancer and action hero with a crazy flexible body movements unlike most of heroes today. You can have your cause but I can show you thousand logics that srk is the most talented and skilled actor in the world. He's Mohammad Rafi saab in acting without any 2nd thoughts. Remember Irfan said once Hollywood doesn't have srk.

    • @ImtheIC
      @ImtheIC 2 роки тому

      @@divanshukumarmahajan4803 Dude you couldn't provide any facts but emotional talk. Come with facts we will talk. truthful portrayal a wide character just saying but showing technical abilities and facts.

    • @ImtheIC
      @ImtheIC 2 роки тому +1

      @@divanshukumarmahajan4803 I gave examples to indicate his technical aspects and acting skills in terms of versatility. But you failed to understand I won't blame you since you might not with media and journalism background. I've acted and directed several stage theaters during my thesis period. I had prepared a very reply for you from my course analysis but in the end, I deleted it because you won't understand those little.
      The point of view of general people and ours from a media background are not the same.

    • @ImtheIC
      @ImtheIC 2 роки тому

      @@divanshukumarmahajan4803 again you just wasted your full hours to write the same emotional cry that I ignored already once. I told you to come up with facts. Try again.

  • @anirbankar2840
    @anirbankar2840 7 років тому +41

    "or sell their eccentricities in the name of acting". There is no question to be raised about the content and quality of your videos. But we often fail to praise your use of Sarcasm. Being a student of English Literature I must say that your use of sarcasm is quite masterful.

  • @AlpaTyrant
    @AlpaTyrant 7 років тому +193

    You sir taken this to next level! More people see this more people will understand that Bollywood serving us same garbage year in year out! Thanks brother for this breathtaking work 😍

    • @Ozkan.619
      @Ozkan.619 7 років тому +4

      Avinash meghwansi did u see narrator mentioning Varun Dhawan as a garbage.lol. I think all of these commercial movies so called heroes are garbages.

    • @qwertassify
      @qwertassify 7 років тому

      can someone tell me the name of the actor who gave the last advice "live in front of people"

    • @spidaku2614
      @spidaku2614 7 років тому

      Sachin Yadav Harrison Ford

    • @AlpaTyrant
      @AlpaTyrant 7 років тому

      saurav mohapatra of course he is!

  • @prabhatsahani3154
    @prabhatsahani3154 4 роки тому +74

    This channel has done Great edit with his own voice over & the Celebs faces he have shown at the right timing.
    E.g 1 Varun dhawan's
    2 Salman khan
    3 Ranveer Singh

    • @tusharsaxena3981
      @tusharsaxena3981 3 роки тому +5

      Also srk at average actor

    • @Anna-bx2wm
      @Anna-bx2wm 3 роки тому +6

      @@tusharsaxena3981
      Hmmmm no
      Go watch Swades, My name is khan etc

    • @tusharsaxena3981
      @tusharsaxena3981 3 роки тому +1

      @@Anna-bx2wm 0:57 vineet said 🙄🙄
      Also srk fans accept that he has done only 3 or 4 good movies.
      Rest all are garbage wow we dont call that person a great actor.
      Just compare it with daniel day lewis.
      He has won all 3 oscars

    • @Anna-bx2wm
      @Anna-bx2wm 3 роки тому

      @@tusharsaxena3981
      Not interested

    • @p27_aryavardhansingh79
      @p27_aryavardhansingh79 3 роки тому

      @@tusharsaxena3981 SRK is a nice actor but DDL is one of the greatest of all times.

  • @litostic
    @litostic Рік тому +5

    Rest in Peace old friend. Your wisdom will be missed

  • @thusharpoovathur2166
    @thusharpoovathur2166 5 років тому +25

    ( MOHANLAL )Malayalam actor should also been included the LIVING LEAGENT actor of INDIAN CINEMA !!!!!💕💕

  • @a.a1633
    @a.a1633 5 місяців тому +2

    It's unbelievable how so many stars from the hindi film industry needs to watch this video

  • @Thetiruguy
    @Thetiruguy 7 років тому +16

    iam a film student and a film maker . let me tell u this your channel is one of the best film study channels on you tube today across the world. i love the way you construct your stuff . this is how a critique should be and sound like rather then people who think use of complicated English words is good critique. w

    • @nitinnishant7783
      @nitinnishant7783 6 років тому +1

      Dimple Orneel Why don't you collaborate with him? Would love to see enthusiastic film makers working with him.

    • @Thetiruguy
      @Thetiruguy 3 роки тому

      @@nitinnishant7783 if Destiny permits that will be a very good thing to do

  • @MiraasbyMariyamDawood
    @MiraasbyMariyamDawood 7 років тому +64

    Oh my god this video brought tears to my eyes. You called out actors like srk amir priyanka aishwariya ranveer kareena, pointed out that how bollywood is celebrating mediocrity and and hailing average actors as amazing ones where as some of the most amazing actors the great one like sanjay mishra, rajat kapur, ratna pathak, etc have been ignored for decades and even some new actors like zeeshan ayub are used in supporting roles. I am glad Rajkumar Rao finally getting the recognition he deserves. I know why you don't have many followers because people who love and enjoy mediocracy will never be able to hear this truth.

    • @CinemaBeyondEntertainment
      @CinemaBeyondEntertainment  7 років тому +11

      I am hopeful one day they will understand...

    • @nitinnishant7783
      @nitinnishant7783 6 років тому

      Cinema Beyond Entertainment Truth prevails. Just let it brew.

    • @rp1443
      @rp1443 5 років тому +2

      mariyam dawood he called aamir a good actor and others average....

    • @sejutisanyal6
      @sejutisanyal6 5 років тому +6

      @@johanawilson1889 Deepika was not even featured in this video..which maybe indirectly explains she doesn't even qualify for this!

    • @KrishanKumar-ec1ch
      @KrishanKumar-ec1ch 2 роки тому

      @@sejutisanyal6 what ? He didn't even put Amitabh Bachchan, Dilip Kumar,Nana patekar so you will think they are not qualified

  • @sadenb
    @sadenb 3 роки тому +6

    Nawazzuddin and Irfan khan on screen together was fantastic. Sadly we will never have it again.

  • @ujwalbasnet9444
    @ujwalbasnet9444 7 років тому +199

    You destroyed 3 khans with a single video. I truly respect you for saying that Aamir Khan is a average actor too. He hides behind physical transformation, change of looks and morally high ground characters.

    • @amansinha3629
      @amansinha3629 7 років тому +7

      Bifrost Bigfoot ur thoughts completely resonates with mine

    • @Arkaworldd
      @Arkaworldd 7 років тому

      so true

    • @apansinghal
      @apansinghal 7 років тому +2

      Check out this video from 32:20-37:00. ua-cam.com/video/-Huhzks6drY/v-deo.html

    • @nitinkulkarni6760
      @nitinkulkarni6760 7 років тому +2

      Verywell said about aamir khan.

    • @BTECE_FARIZ
      @BTECE_FARIZ 7 років тому +10

      Bifrost Bigfoot yeah he is just a good actor that picks really good stories.

  • @madhura4811
    @madhura4811 7 років тому +6

    This is great!! I'm so glad there's someone consciously analysing and understanding the entertainment "industry" which is going on a very scary and frankly miserable road now a days in india and not just passively consuming the "brainless" entertainment that's put out !!

  • @wasifw673
    @wasifw673 3 роки тому +8

    Nawaz is one of the best actor not just in india,i would say in the world.He is there with de niro,di caprio,tom hanks.
    I mean his expressions,depth in his eyes,and dialouge delivery is top notch.

    • @vansh4383
      @vansh4383 3 роки тому

      Dude many actors are better than dicaprio why are you guys so over obsessed with him?

    • @dayyanahmad117
      @dayyanahmad117 2 роки тому

      @@vansh4383 because he is the honey guy, I think?? 🤔
      But he's good

  • @Rushi_83
    @Rushi_83 7 років тому +13

    wow such an awesome details about actors and acting , majority of bollywood will never understand what real acting is,

  • @vihangN70
    @vihangN70 5 років тому +8

    Kudos to you for including a Marathi movie dialogue. Even a good comedy movie can showcase brilliant acting.

  • @Sohailkhan2001
    @Sohailkhan2001 3 роки тому +23

    08:50 Two Great Legends In Single Frame

  • @reetulsingh6637
    @reetulsingh6637 7 років тому +7

    Hands down, this is the best video on acting skills I have ever watched.

  • @amitgolani4494
    @amitgolani4494 6 років тому +163

    Watching this for the umpteenth time. Love how you have used the female as the generic gender when referring to an actor... 'Her' 'Herself' 'She'. The fact that this stands out is reflective of how one sided this choice has always been

  • @yoshitaarora4240
    @yoshitaarora4240 2 роки тому +9

    Wtf dude, why didn't I discover your channel earlier. This is so informational & intellectual! Subscribed and binge watching now! You go man! Keep up!

  • @ashishmishra2510
    @ashishmishra2510 5 років тому +97

    Vinit: Or simply garbage
    *Varun Dhawan emerges*

  • @vikaskale7786
    @vikaskale7786 7 років тому +9

    this is one of those videos you add in to playlist "Liked Videos" within a sec after finishing it..

  • @shubham-yy8tj
    @shubham-yy8tj 3 роки тому +6

    missing Irrfan Khan...after watching Sardar Udham.

  • @sushanshresthadxs
    @sushanshresthadxs 6 років тому +16

    he said 'Bad actor' and salman khan pops up ... smart :D

  • @CrickFreak_live
    @CrickFreak_live 6 років тому +74

    He said, Aamir is good actor, Srk is an avg actor.. I think he is right.
    He also mentioned at 9:11 that "The greatest talent of an actor lies in her choices" well that makes Aamir special. His filmography is superb.
    Even Naseeruddin shah praises Aamir for his film choices. I mean he is the only Mainstream cinematic star who atleast trying something different n creative.
    In the current lot of actors, Only Ranbir has that skills n choices which makes him a great actor n I think Vineet sir u will agree with me on this.
    And yes thank u for this amazing video..Keep doing the good work, make one video on "Life in a metro" movie.
    Thank you!

    • @amanoza9586
      @amanoza9586 5 років тому +1

      video itself shows ranbirs category .

    • @Gxzxmn
      @Gxzxmn 5 років тому +8

      ​@Shahjalal Khan Bro..you must be mistaking Ranbir for someone else or are blind if you dont see his range of emotions as well subtlety. Check out even a song - Kabira to see how much he emotes without even speaking. Sorry dude you got it wrong. Btw facial expressions are not the only way to guage emotions.

    • @mahmudtaher5472
      @mahmudtaher5472 5 років тому +6

      @Shahjalal Khan may b you are Ranveer singh fan
      Nd for your kind info Ranbir 's acting skills are damn high

    • @souravmondal5317
      @souravmondal5317 5 років тому +3

      If you are talking about choices..then yes..amir is doing good in choosing films. But if you are going to talk abour trying something different..then u have to agree that srk is doing a lot of different movies.. fan raees zero..these are perfect examples..even when Bollywood was about all love..srk did films like swades chak de ashoka. Some turn out to be great.. and some disaster. But srk is always trying different things

    • @slaprakshas
      @slaprakshas 5 років тому +9

      No. He meant SRK overacts. And Aamir Khan though not a bad actor chooses safe sympathetic roles. By choice he meant choice of portraying a particular character in a way.

  • @utsavlangaliya3
    @utsavlangaliya3 10 місяців тому

    By far the most interesting and apt video I have ever seen on UA-cam regarding Acting and performances. And the line that "by way of using their own personality into the personality of the character"...ooof the cherry on the cake. Its like the greatest actors have the different types of character played in their filmography and each of them stands out in their own perfect way and you remembers their certain lines, traits of personality, behaviors in your core memory. The only regret of mine is I fount this video very late in my life. truly some great analyzing and writing skills you have. Simply Majestic. Outstanding.

  • @ebutuoy123456798
    @ebutuoy123456798 7 років тому +42

    Let me tell you this. This is one of the best videos I have ever watched (and btw I watch dozens everyday). The analysis, choice of movie scenes and editing is near perfect. Summing everything up with the Lunchbox scene was just brilliant.
    Subscribed to you channel (the first Indian channel that I have subscribed to!!).

  • @persieprince9345
    @persieprince9345 7 років тому +31

    One of my favorite youtube channels, I'm following from Morocco, I love cinema and I want to be a good screenwriter

  • @sicklecuthammerfall
    @sicklecuthammerfall 5 років тому +4

    Big fan of the fact that Nawazuddin and Pankaj are getting more recognition. And love the content

  • @gaurangibhatnagar3730
    @gaurangibhatnagar3730 7 років тому +8

    I am speechless! Got to notice such beautiful nuances of so many great films and performances. Looking forward to more of such videos!!

  • @Swasti1
    @Swasti1 7 років тому +6

    I totally love what you're doing, please keep making such videos.

  • @litvoice9415
    @litvoice9415 3 роки тому +2

    This is what I call the hardwork with research and maturity. I want to give you a standing ovation for the way you have made this video.

  • @HarinderSingh-dy7pg
    @HarinderSingh-dy7pg 5 років тому +80

    Leo in wolf of wall street was truly amazing.

  • @rohitmenonmech
    @rohitmenonmech 5 років тому +5

    This channel made my day. I have been looking for detailed analysis like this from an Indian perspective! Thanks for all the videos. I have been binge watching all of them today.
    I truly appreciate the work that has gone behind every video, the breadth of content is amazing. And the analysis is not dumbed down and introduces you to new ways of thinking. Really impressive!

  • @shubhamnandeshwar999
    @shubhamnandeshwar999 2 роки тому +1

    In the past 4 years I have come back to this video like 100 times! Such a treat this is!

  • @crinspiration
    @crinspiration Рік тому +6

    Can’t believe he is no longer with us 😢

  • @pioneer3729
    @pioneer3729 6 років тому +15

    Great job bro. Just wanted to tell you that you are creating exceptional content. There are many analysis channels on UA-cam- ScreenPrism, Cinefix, Now you see it, etc to name a few. They make analysis videos of only western classics and dont give a dime about Indian classics (there are many but not as much as foreign classics). I always fear that indian classics like Guide, Jaane Bhi Do Yaron, A Wednesday, Haider, Aligarh, Shahid, Black Friday, Lagaan, Mother India, Udaan, Kagaz ke phool, Works of Satyajit Ray (he was the prime inspiration for Martin Scorsese), and many thousands others will be lost in time if not given enough appreciation. Our audience is gradually getting mature and it will become a pity to see our generation appreciate only Western classics. They need to be made aware of the treasure troves of the Indian Cinema not necessarily Bollywood. And u are the only youtuber (as seen from your videos) who has the calibre to take this responsibility of embracing World Cinema rather than saturating only towards only one section of World culture (which unfortunately others are doing). You have already impressed many by analysing movies like Swades, GOW, Rang De Basanti, etc. Also this will help you create your own Niche in this competitive market. High hopes from you.
    Great luck to your channel in the future.
    An Indian Film Aspirant

    • @syedmarwan8069
      @syedmarwan8069 6 років тому +1

      Indian classics also had - Maqbool,Swades,Anand,Bombay,Rockstar......etc

    • @KrishanKumar-ec1ch
      @KrishanKumar-ec1ch 2 роки тому

      @@syedmarwan8069 Well jaane bhi do yaaro,guide ,mother India are cult and big hits and people know about them . audience shouldn't have aware about them and lagaan is just 20 years old

  • @AthDanishKhan
    @AthDanishKhan 3 роки тому +8

    It's audience itself when they ignore Srk in Swades and love him in any masala average movie ..which in fact shows that even mainstream actors are good. But as mention in video they play safe. I hope in future we get more content orientated film and great acting.

    • @VC-ps2vm
      @VC-ps2vm 3 роки тому +4

      I don't agree that he was good in swades

  • @utkarshsanju10
    @utkarshsanju10 6 років тому +5

    My friend recommended me this channel and I must say that he was absolutely right! This channel is great! Keep up the great work man.

  • @KomalNirwan
    @KomalNirwan 7 років тому +6

    You make people hopeful for the Indian cinema. Thanks.

    • @FoodAndBeverageXplorer
      @FoodAndBeverageXplorer 7 років тому +2

      Dude Indian cinema is not just bollywood. There far more quality movies produced by other regional cinemas notably Marathi, Malayalam, Bengali etc

    • @KomalNirwan
      @KomalNirwan 7 років тому

      I count it in, plus something done good is meant to be acknowledged.

  • @sengarsumit
    @sengarsumit 2 роки тому +1

    I have always been thinking about this for so long in my head. For the first time saw someone articulating the nuances of a great actor so clearly. We only say "acting is great" but hardly analyse what traits actually "make it great". This is an exceptional video and a must watch

  • @AngelicFairyNeha
    @AngelicFairyNeha 6 років тому +17

    The way this video has been made, it kept me mouth-opened till the very end. Gud job 👍

  • @chanakyapendse7119
    @chanakyapendse7119 5 років тому +8

    I was so mesmerized watching this video ... I don't even remember when I clicked the like button

  • @RiyaGoala-j4s
    @RiyaGoala-j4s 7 місяців тому +2

    In the 90s, Indian audiance didn't have access to GREAT acting, so average acting was considered good. I'm happy that after seeing good movies and acting, our generation understands what good acting actually is. Happy to see the audience now accepts who the real A List actors are based on skills(like Rajkumar Rao, Nawazuddin Siddiqui, Irfan Khan, Ayushman Khurana, Manoj Bajpai) rather than still giving the titles to average actors like SRK, Amir, Salman Khan, Akshay Kumar and Hrithik Roshan. That's why the Indian audiance trolls star kids like Varun, Tiger, Ananya, Sara, Janhvi, Suhana, Khushi, Agastaya and etc etc for their acting skills and doesn't let them get away with it. Their problem is they still think they can get away with this kind of skill because the Indian audience are fools and will accept whatever they give in the name of 'acting'. I'm really proud we're evolving. Tollywood is way better than Bollywood and Hollywood acting is just way out of league for what Bollywood actors do

  • @kirtimanmishra8097
    @kirtimanmishra8097 7 років тому +6

    Please continue your work.I am not from a film background but your videos are a source of inspiration to me

  • @thatKaran
    @thatKaran 7 років тому +5

    I get a kick out of such deftly put together video essays. Keep'em coming Vinit!

  • @Vivek-hf7mx
    @Vivek-hf7mx 4 роки тому +7

    I like how, at the end of the video, he mentioned only those actors he considered good throughout the whole video

  • @subhasissaha8424
    @subhasissaha8424 6 років тому +6

    A few months back a stumbled across one of your videos "The Art of using Music". I found that video a true work of art but I didn't put the effort to dig deeper. Today I saw another one of your videos in my recommendation list and since then I have been binge watching all your videos.
    My thoughts? Damn! You are something else. You will go far.

  • @crazymaniac7474
    @crazymaniac7474 5 років тому +176

    I saw a indian acting class and they teach them to overact. 🤦‍♂️

  • @Yavanna16
    @Yavanna16 5 років тому +1

    I saw a Ted talk by Joseph Gordon-Levitt a couple days back. It is brilliant and I urge everyone to watch it, but primarily, I want to point out that around the 11 minute mark in that talk, he mentions how acting is just sincerely reacting to your co-actors in a scene, just like the second last point mentioned in this video. It is in a different context than here, but both mentions reaffirm each other.
    And this channel is producing unprecedentedly brilliant content, all my respect and admiration to the creator and his team!